4HE #RIMINAL !RUSHA
advertisement
#OLLOQUIUMOF0ROSECUTORSOF)NTERNATIONAL#RIMINAL4RIBUNALS\ 4HE#HALLENGESOF)NTERNATIONAL #RIMINAL*USTICE !RUSHA)NTERNATIONAL#ONFERENCE#ENTRE 4ANZANIA !PUBLICATIONOF4HE)NTERNATIONAL #RIMINAL4RIBUNALFOR2WANDA)#42 INCOLLABORATIONWITH 4HE)NTERNATIONAL#ENTERFOR%THICS *USTICEAND0UBLIC,IFEAT "RANDEIS5NIVERSITY53! #OLLOQUIUMOF0ROSECUTORSOF)NTERNATIONAL#RIMINAL4RIBUNALS\ 4HE#HALLENGESOF)NTERNATIONAL #RIMINAL*USTICE &OREWORD\ *OINT3TATEMENTOFTHE0ROSECUTORSOFTHE )NTERNATIONAL#RIMINAL#OURTTHE)NTERNATIONAL #RIMINAL4RIBUNALFORTHEFORMER9UGOSLAVIA THE)NTERNATIONAL#RIMINAL4RIBUNALFOR2WANDA ANDTHE3PECIAL#OURTFOR3IERRA,EONE\ #OLLOQUIUMOF0ROSECUTORSOF)NTERNATIONAL #RIMINAL4RIBUNALSONh4HE#HALLENGESOF )NTERNATIONAL#RIMINAL*USTICEv\ \2EPORTOF0ROCEEEDINGS )NTRODUCTION\ 7ELCOMEBY#HIEF0ROSECUTOR -R*USTICE(ASSAN"UBACAR*ALLOW\ +EYNOTEBY)###HIEF0ROSECUTOR -R,UIS-ORENO/CAMPO\ #HALLENGESOF#ONDUCTING)NVESTIGATIONSOF )NTERNATIONAL#RIMES\ 4HE#HALLENGESOF)NTERNATIONAL#RIMINAL 0ROSECUTION\ 3ERVICEOF3ENTENCEFOR)NTERNATIONAL #RIMES\ #HALLENGESOFTHE!DMINISTRATIONOF )NTERNATIONAL#RIMINAL4RIBUNALS\ #ONCLUDING3TATEMENTSOFTHE#OLLOQUIUM BY-R(ASSAN"UBACAR*ALLOW\ !PPENDICES\ &OREWORD\ & ORTHREEEXCITINGDAYSIN.OVEMBERTHE "YALLACCOUNTSTHE#OLLOQUIUMWASASUCCESSSOMUCH )#42/40)NTERNATIONAL#RIMINAL4RIBUNALFOR SOTHATWEDECIDEDWESHOULDBEMEETINGREGULARLY 2WANDAn/FlCEOFTHE0ROSECUTORWASHONOUREDTO TOSHAREEXPERIENCESANDIDEASONIMPROVINGTHE HOSTONITSPREMISESIN!RUSHA4ANZANIATHElRSTMEETING MECHANISMSOFINTERNATIONALCRIMINALJUSTICE-ANYPLAYED OFTHE0ROSECUTORSOF)NTERNATIONAL#RIMINAL4RIBUNALS AKEYROLEINTHISSUCCESSMYCOLLEAGUES0ROSECUTORS $UBBEDTHEh#OLLOQUIUMOF0ROSECUTORSvITBROUGHT #ARLADEL0ONTE)#49$AVID#RANE3#3,,UIS-ORENO TOGETHERTHE0ROSECUTORSANDTHEIRSENIOROFlCIALSASWELL /CAMPO)##ASWELLASTHEIROFlCIALSSTAFFINTHE/FlCE ASSCHOLARSANDPRACTITIONERSINVOLVEDININTERNATIONAL OFTHE0ROSECUTOR/40)#42ANDTHE4RIBUNALASAWHOLE CRIMINALJUSTICE WHOPREPAREDTHEGROUNDFORTHEMEETINGTHE/RGANISING #OMMITTEEOFTHE#OLLOQUIUMTHEPAPERPRESENTERS 4OGETHERWEREVIEWEDTHEPROCESSOFANDOUR THEPANELISTS*UDGE%RIK-SEAND!DAMA$IENG EXPERIENCESININTERNATIONALCRIMINALINVESTIGATIONAND RESPECTIVELY0RESIDENTAND2EGISTRAROFTHE)#42FORTHEIR PROSECUTION7EIDENTIlEDTHESUCCESSESANDCHALLENGES SUPPORTOFTHEINITIATIVE&INALLYTHE&ORD&OUNDATIONAND /UTOFTHISWEAGREEDONTHEDEVELOPMENTOFAh"EST THE/PEN3OCIETY)NSTITUTEWHOPROVIDEDTHEFUNDINGFOR 0RACTICES0ROGRAMMEvTHATWOULDPROVIDEAGUIDEFOR THEMEETING4OEACHANDEVERYONEWESAYTHANKYOU FUTUREPRACTITIONERSINTHISDIFlCULTTERRAIN"EYONDTHAT WEWEREUNITEDBYOURRECOGNITIONDRAWNFROMTHE 7EHOPETHE!RUSHA#OLLOQUIUMWASMARKEDAN EXPERIENCEOFTHEPASTDECADETHATDESPITENUMEROUS IMPORTANTCONTRIBUTIONTOTHEPERMANENTSYSTEMOF CHALLENGESTHEPROCESSOFINTERNATIONALCRIMINALJUSTICE INTERNATIONALCRIMINALJUSTICEANDTHATTHEPROCESSOF ISFEASIBLEITISEQUALLYDESIRABLEFORTHEMAINTENANCEOF CONSULTATIONBETWEENTHE0ROSECUTORSWILLCONTINUETO INTERNATIONALPEACEANDSECURITY4HEREISNONETHELESS PROVIDEVALUABLEINPUTTOSYSTEM ROOMFORIMPROVEMENTINTERMSOFEXPEDITINGTRIALSAND BRINGINGINTERNATIONALCRIMINALJUSTICETOWITHINREASONABLE LIMITS 4HE*OINT3TATEMENTOFTHE0ROSECUTORSHIGHLIGHTSOUR *USTICE(ASSAN"UBACAR*ALLOW MANYCONCERNSONWHATNEEDSTOBEACCOMPLISHEDBYTHE 0ROSECUTOR)#42 INDIVIDUALSTATESANDBYTHEINTERNATIONALCOMMUNITYIN ORDERTOPRESERVEANDSTRENGTHENTHISEMERGINGSYSTEM OFINTERNATIONALCRIMINALJUSTICE \ *OINT3TATEMENTOFTHE0ROSECUTORSOFTHE)NTERNATIONAL#RIMINAL #OURTTHE)NTERNATIONAL#RIMINAL4RIBUNALFORTHEFORMER9UGOSLAVIA THE)NTERNATIONAL#RIMINAL4RIBUNALFOR2WANDAANDTHE3PECIAL#OURT FOR3IERRA,EONE\ ! SINTERNATIONALPROSECUTORSWEHAVEBEEN .ATIONALLEGALSYSTEMSHAVEAVITALROLEINTHEPROSECUTION ENTRUSTEDWITHTHERESPONSIBILITYOFBRINGINGTO OFTHESEGRAVECRIMES)NTERNATIONALINSTITUTIONSNEEDTO JUSTICEINDIVIDUALSACCUSEDOFGENOCIDECRIMES STEPINONLYWHENNATIONALSYSTEMSLACKTHESTRENGTHOR AGAINSTHUMANITYANDWARCRIMES IMPARTIALITYTOHOLDTHEMOSTSERIOUSOFFENDERSTOACCOUNT #OMBINEDNATIONALANDINTERNATIONALEFFORTSWILLBEA 7EREPRESENTALLTHEREGIONSOFTHEWORLD/UR GUARANTEEOFIMPARTIALJUSTICE INSTITUTIONSWEREVARIOUSLYFOUNDEDBYTREATYBYTHE 5NITED.ATIONS3ECURITY#OUNCILORBYAGREEMENT 7EREAFlRMOURCOMMITMENTTOTHETASKTHATHASBEEN BETWEENTHE5NITED.ATIONSANDNATIONALGOVERNMENTS ENTRUSTEDTOUS7ECALLUPONALLNATIONALANDINTERNATIONAL AUTHORITIESTOSTRENGTHENTHEIRDEDICATIONTOJUSTICE (AVINGREVIEWEDTHECHALLENGESOFINTERNATIONALCRIMINAL JUSTICEWEHAVECONCLUDEDTHATTHEIDEALBEHINDTHE ESTABLISHMENTOFEACHOFOURINSTITUTIONSISTHESAME TOENDIMPUNITYFORTHEMOSTSERIOUSCRIMESTHATPLAGUE HUMANKINDANDTOCONTRIBUTETOPEACEANDTHEPREVENTION OFFUTURECRIMES 4HESETRIBUNALSHAVEMADEGREATPROGRESS(EADSOFSTATE ORGOVERNMENTHAVEBEENBROUGHTTOJUSTICE/THERMAJOR 7EBELIEVETHATTHEPEOPLEOFTHEWORLDAREENTITLEDTOA SYSTEMTHATWILLDETERGRAVEINTERNATIONALCRIMESANDHOLD TOACCOUNTTHOSEWHOBEARTHEGREATESTRESPONSIBILITY /NLYWHENACULTUREOFACCOUNTABILITYHASREPLACEDTHE CULTUREOFIMPUNITYCANTHEDIVERSEPEOPLEOFTHEWORLD LIVEANDPROSPERTOGETHERINPEACE 3IGNEDONTHISTHDAYOF.OVEMBER PERPETRATORSHAVEBEENINDICTEDARRESTEDANDTRIEDMANY HAVEBEENCONVICTEDTRIALSAREONGOING4HESEINSTITUTIONS HAVERECOGNIZEDTHATGENOCIDECANBECOMMITTEDTHROUGH ACTSOFSEXUALVIOLENCETHEYHAVEFOUNDTHATTHEUSE ,UIS-ORENO/CAMPO OFCHILDSOLDIERSISACRIMEAGAINSTHUMANITYTHEYHAVE 0ROSECUTOROFTHE)NTERNATIONAL#RIMINAL#OURT BROUGHTTHEWEIGHTOFLAWTOBEARONTHEEVILSOFETHNIC CLEANSING"UTBECAUSEMANYPEOPLECONTINUETOSUFFER FROMTHESECRIMESTHROUGHOUTTHEWORLDWEAFlRMTHAT ONLYASUSTAINEDCOMMITMENTTOACCOUNTABILITYWILLDETER THESEATROCITIES #ARLADEL0ONTE 4HEULTIMATESUCCESSOFTHESETRIBUNALSDEPENDSONTHE FORMER9UGOSLAVIA 0ROSECUTOROFTHE)NTERNATIONAL#RIMINAL4RIBUNALFORTHE CONTINUEDPOLITICALSUPPORTOFTHEINTERNATIONALCOMMUNITY 2ESOURCESCOOPERATIONANDASSISTANCEAREESSENTIALTO ENFORCETHEPRINCIPLEOFACCOUNTABILITYANDTHERULEOFLAW 4HERESOLVEOFTHEINTERNATIONALCOMMUNITYWILLALSO BEMEASUREDBYITSWILLINGNESSTODELIVERINDICTEESFOR TRIALEVENIFPOLITICALLYDIFlCULT)NTERNATIONALCRIMINAL (ASSAN"UBACAR*ALLOW 0ROSECUTOROFTHE)NTERNATIONAL#RIMINAL4RIBUNALFOR 2WANDA JUSTICEMUSTAPPLYTOINDICTEDFUGITIVESSUCHAS2ADOVAN +ARADZIC2ATKO-LADIC!NTE'OTOVINA&ÏLICIEN+ABUGA AND#HARLES4AYLOR4OPERMITINDIVIDUALSACCUSEDOFTHE GRAVESTOFCRIMESTOEVADEJUSTICEWOULDREINFORCETHE $AVID#RANE CULTUREOFIMPUNITYTHATFUELSCONmICTANDATROCITIES 0ROSECUTOROFTHE3PECIAL#OURTFOR3IERRA,EONE \ 2EPORTOF0ROCEEEDINGS\ #OLLOQUIUMOF0ROSECUTORSOF)NTERNATIONAL#RIMINAL4RIBUNALS ONh4HE#HALLENGESOF)NTERNATIONAL#RIMINAL*USTICEv )NTRODUCTION\ &ROM.OVEMBERTO.OVEMBERTHE E4OPROVIDEAVEHICLEFORENHANCINGTHE )NTERNATIONAL#RIMINAL4RIBUNALFOR2WANDA)#42HOSTED UNDERSTANDINGBYTHEINTERNATIONALCOMMUNITY ACOLLOQUIUMFORTHE0ROSECUTORSOFTHE)NTERNATIONAL REGARDINGTHEACHIEVEMENTSOFTHE)#42ASWELLAS #RIMINAL4RIBUNALSATTHE!RUSHA)NTERNATIONAL#ONFERENCE THECHALLENGESTHATTHETRIBUNALHASTOOVERCOMEFORA #ENTREIN4ANZANIA)TWASTHElRSTCOLLOQUIUM4HREE SUCCESSFULCOMPLETIONOFITSMANDATE INTERNATIONALCRIMINALCOURTSWEREREPRESENTEDBESIDES THE)#42THE)NTERNATIONAL#RIMINAL4RIBUNALFORTHEFORMER 9UGOSLAVIA)#49THE3PECIAL#OURTFOR3IERRA,EONE 3#3,ANDTHE)NTERNATIONAL#RIMINAL#OURT)##)N ADDITIONNATIONALPROSECUTORSINVESTIGATORSGOVERNMENT REPRESENTATIVESLEGALSCHOLARSDEFENCEATTORNEYSAND OBSERVERSENGAGEDINTHEINTERNATIONALCRIMINALJUSTICE SYSTEMFROMANUMBEROFCOUNTRIESWEREINATTENDANCE 4HESECOUNTRIESINCLUDED2WANDA4ANZANIA+ENYA3OUTH !FRICA#AMEROON.IGERIA4HE.ETHERLANDS'ERMANY "ELGIUMTHE5NITED+INGDOM!USTRALIAANDTHE5NITED 3TATES F4ODEVELOPWORKABLECOMMONSTRATEGIESANDA @"EST0RACTICEMODELGEAREDTOWARDSACHIEVINGTHE #OMPLETION3TRATEGIESOFBOTHTHE)#42ANDTHE)#49 G4OHIGHLIGHTACHIEVEMENTSANDFUTUREPLANSIN ORDERTOEXPLAINTHEMTOTHEINTERNATIONALCOMMUNITY THEREBYCREATINGABETTERUNDERSTANDINGOFTHETRIBUNAL ANDIMPROVEDSUPPORTFORITSWORK4HECONCRETE RESULTWILLTHEREFOREBEANINCREASEDAWARENESSBYTHE INTERNATIONALCOMMUNITYOFTHEWORKANDCHALLENGES OFTHE)#42ANDGREATERSUPPORTFORTHEWORKOFTHE TRIBUNAL H4OPROVIDEAFORUMFORTHEEXCHANGEOFIDEAS 4HEOBJECTIVESOFTHE0ROSECUTORS#OLLOQUIUMWERE A4OHOLDATHREEDAYCOLLOQUIUMASPARTOFTHE ONGOINGPROGRAMMETOCOMMEMORATETHETH ANNIVERSARYOFTHE2WANDANGENOCIDEOF B4OSHAREIDEASWITHPERSONNELFROMOTHER INTERNATIONALCRIMINALTRIBUNALSANDLEARNLESSONSONTHE CHALLENGESFACEDBYINTERNATIONALCRIMINALTRIBUNALSIN INVESTIGATINGANDPROSECUTINGVIOLATIONSOFINTERNATIONAL CRIMINALLAWASWELLASIMPRISONINGPERSONSCONVICTED BYTHETRIBUNALS ANDINFORMATIONONISSUESRELATINGTOTHEREFERRALOF CASESTOCOMPETENTNATIONALJURISDICTIONSANDTHE FORMALISATIONOFCONCRETEARRANGEMENTSTOACHIEVETHIS MANDATE I4OINITIATEAlRMERCOMMITMENTFROMTHOSE3TATES THATISCRITICALFORTHESUCCESSOFTHE)#424HISWILL ALSOGOALONGWAYTOWARDSASSISTINGTHETRIBUNAL TOSUCCESSFULLYCOMPLETEITSWORKANDACHIEVEITS MANDATEWITHINTHETIMELIMITSSETIN3ECURITY#OUNCIL 2ESOLUTIONOF C4OREVIEWTHEJURISPRUDENCEACHIEVEMENTSAND !GAINSTTHEBACKDROPOFBEAUTIFUL-OUNT-ERU CHALLENGESOFTHE)#42ANDIDENTIFYTHEUNDERLYING PARTICIPANTSGATHEREDIN!RUSHATODISCUSSINAFRANK CAUSESOFSUCCESSANDSETBACKSANDDOCUMENT ANDCONSTRUCTIVEMANNERTHECHALLENGESTHATCURRENTLY LESSONSTOBELEARNED FACETHEINTERNATIONALCRIMINALJUSTICESYSTEMANDIN D4OPROVIDEASPRINGBOARDFORREGULARINTERFACE PARTICULARTHEPROSECUTORIALDOMAIN4HISCOLLOQUIUM AMONGTHEINTERNATIONAL0ROSECUTORSANDSENIOR MANAGEMENTOFTHEVARIOUSTRIBUNALSTHATWILLBE REPRESENTEDATTHE#OLLOQUIUM WASTHERESULTOFTHETIRELESSEFFORTSBY)#42#HIEF 0ROSECUTOR-R(ASSAN"UBACAR*ALLOWANDHISSTAFF4HE ARRANGEMENTSFORTHE#OLLOQUIUMWEREmAWLESSWHICH ALLOWEDPARTICIPANTSTOCONCENTRATEFULLYONTHEIMPORTANT TOPICSADDRESSEDDURINGTHISINNOVATIVEANDSUBSTANTIVE MEETING \ 4HE#OLLOQUIUMCONSISTEDOFlVEFORUMSANDWAS B4HE$YNAMICSAND#HALLENGESOF)NTERNATIONAL ATTENDEDBYDELEGATESOBSERVERSAND 0ROSECUTION PARTICIPANTSALLFROMVARIOUSSTAGESOFTHEPROSECUTION C4HE3ERVICEOF3ENTENCEFOR)NTERNATIONAL#RIMES PROCESS!PANELOFDISTINGUISHEDPERSONSHEADEDEACH OFTHESEFORUMS4HEPANELSADDRESSEDISSUESRELEVANT TOTHETOPICDISCUSSED4HE0ROSECUTORSOFTHEVARIOUS 4RIBUNALSWHOWEREPRESENTMODERATEDTHESEFORUMSIN TURN4HETOPICSDISCUSSEDATTHESEFORAINCLUDED A4HE#HALLENGESOF#ONDUCTING)NVESTIGATIONSOF )NTERNATIONAL#RIMES \ D4HE#HALLENGESOF0ROPER)MPLEMENTATIONOFTHE #OMPLETION3TRATEGYAND E#HALLENGESOFTHE!DMINISTRATIONOF)NTERNATIONAL #RIMINAL4RIBUNALS 7ELCOMEBY#HIEF0ROSECUTOR-R*USTICE(ASSAN"UBACAR*ALLOW\ ) NHISWELCOMEANDOPENINGREMARKS#HIEF EXPERIENCEINTHECONDUCTOFINTERNATIONALINVESTIGATIONS 0ROSECUTOR-R(ASSAN"UBACAR*ALLOWNOTEDTHAT ASWELLASTHESELECTIONOFCASESFORPROSECUTIONTHE YEARSEARLIERTOTHEMONTHTHE5.3ECURITY#OUNCIL ESTABLISHMENTOFINTERNATIONALSTANDARDSFORFAIRTRIALAND ADOPTED2ESOLUTIONTHEREBYESTABLISHINGTHE)#42 THEENRICHMENTOFTHEJURISPRUDENCEOFINTERNATIONALLAW 3INCETHATTIMEONEMOREADHOCCRIMINALCOURTIE THE3PECIAL#OURTFOR3IERRA,EONEHASBEENCREATED -R*ALLOWSTRESSEDHOWEVERTHATTHE#OLLOQUIUM ASWELLASTHEPERMANENT)NTERNATIONAL#RIMINAL#OURT SHOULDNOTSERVEASANEXERCISEINSELFCONGRATULATION WHICHWASJUSTNOWBEGINNINGITSlRSTINVESTIGATIONS 0ARTICIPANTSMUSTBEBOLDANDCOURAGEOUSINIDENTIFYING 4HESECOURTSHAVEACOMMONMANDATETOCONTRIBUTE THESHORTCOMINGSOFTHEINTERNATIONALCRIMINALJUSTICE TOTHECONSOLIDATIONANDENHANCEMENTOFINTERNATIONAL SYSTEMSOTHATITCANCONTINUETOSTRIVEFORGREATER JUSTICEANDTHEINTERNATIONALRULEOFLAWBYBRINGINGTO EFlCIENCYANDEXPEDIENCEINTHEDELIVERYOFJUSTICE(E ACCOUNTINANINTERNATIONALFORUMTHOSEPERSONSBEARING REMINDEDTHEAUDIENCETHATNONATIONALLEGALSYSTEM THEGREATESTRESPONSIBILITYFORTHEMOSTEGREGIOUS ORANYLEGALTRADITIONCOULDCLAIMTOBEPERFECTEVEN VIOLATIONSOFINTERNATIONALHUMANITARIANLAW3INCESUCH THOUGHSOMEHAVEEXISTEDFORCENTURIES4HEINTERNATIONAL PERSONSAREALLTOOOFTENBEYONDTHEREACHOFUNWILLING CRIMINALJUSTICESYSTEMISBARELYADECADEOLDANDISSTILL ORUNABLENATIONALSYSTEMSOFJUSTICETHEREISANEEDFOR lNDINGITSWAY INTERNATIONALCRIMINALTRIBUNALSTOSHARETHEIREXPERIENCES ANDLEARNFROMONEANOTHERTHEREBYIMPROVINGTHE 9ETTHEPOWEROFTHISSYSTEMTOESTABLISHPEACEAND EFFECTIVENESSOFTHEINTERNATIONALCRIMINALJUSTICESYSTEM JUSTICEHASBEENDEMONSTRATEDTHROUGHTHEREACTIONS 4HEAIMOFTHISCOLLOQUIUM-R*ALLOWNOTEDISTO OFVICTIMSANDSURVIVORSIN2WANDAANDTHE"ALKANS IDENTIFYTHECONSTRAINTSANDCHALLENGESTHATINTERNATIONAL )TISCLEARTHATMANYOFTHEVIOLATIONSOFINTERNATIONAL CRIMINALCOURTSFACEININVESTIGATIONSPROSECUTIONAND HUMANITARIANLAWCOMMITTEDINTHESEPLACESCOULD ADMINISTRATIONASWELLASINTHEDETENTIONOFTHOSEWHO NOTHAVEBEENDEALTWITHEFFECTIVELYINNATIONALJUDICIAL AREULTIMATELYFOUNDGUILTYANDTOEXPLOREINTHELIGHTOF SYSTEMS4HEINTERNATIONALPENALOPTIONMUSTALWAYSBE EXPERIENCEHOWSUCHCHALLENGESCOULDBEEFFECTIVELY RETAINEDURGED-R*ALLOW"UTFORTHISOPTIONTOWORK OVERCOME THEREMUSTBETHEFULLESTINTERNATIONALCOOPERATION INMATTERSRELATINGTORESOURCESINVESTIGATIONSTHE )TISANAPPROPRIATEMOMENTTOTAKESTOCKOFHOW APPREHENSIONANDTRANSFEROFFUGITIVESWITNESSPROTECTION INTERNATIONALCRIMINALCOURTSAREPERFORMINGNOTED-R ANDRELOCATIONANDEVENTUALLYTHETRANSFEROFAPPROPRIATE *ALLOW4HETWO5NITED.ATIONSADHOCTRIBUNALSARE CASESTONATIONALJURISDICTIONS4HECURRENTLEVELOF CURRENTLYIMPLEMENTINGCOMPLETIONSTRATEGIESANDTHE INTERNATIONALSUPPORTINTHESEMATTERSPOSESASERIOUS )##WILLSOONASSUMETHEMANTLEOFLEADERSHIPINTHE CHALLENGETOTHEWORKOFINTERNATIONALCRIMINALTRIBUNALS PROSECUTIONOFVIOLATIONSOFINTERNATIONALLAW0ARTICIPANTS WHICHISASUBJECTTHATPARTICIPANTSSHOULDCOLLECTIVELY AREENCOURAGEDTOLOOKATWHATTHE)#49AND)#42HAVE ADDRESSDURINGTHECOLLOQUIUMAMONGOTHERPRESSING ACCOMPLISHEDDESPITETHEFORMIDABLECONSTRAINTSTHEY ITEMS HAVEFACEDWHICHINCLUDEABSENCEOFJUDICIALMODELSTO FOLLOWALACKOFRESOURCESPROBLEMSOFLOGISTICSANDA JURISPRUDENTIALVACUUM-R*ALLOWSUGGESTEDTHATFUTURE OPINIONWOULDRECOGNISETHEIMPORTANTCONTRIBUTIONSTHE INTERNATIONALCRIMINALTRIBUNALSWILLHAVEMADEONSEVERAL FRONTS&OREXAMPLEINTHEELABORATIONOFRULESOFPRACTICE PROCEDUREANDEVIDENCETHEACQUISITIONOFSUBSTANTIAL \ +EYNOTEBY)###HIEF0ROSECUTOR-R,UIS-ORENO/CAMPO\ ) NHISKEYNOTEADDRESS#HIEF0ROSECUTOROFTHE ORPREJUDICE)TISYOURDUTYTOBUILDAPROSECUTION )##-R,UIS-ORENO/CAMPOACKNOWLEDGEDTHE SERVICETHATISANEFFECTIVEDETERRENTTOCRIMEAND SIGNIlCANTMILESTONETHATTHE)#42HASREACHEDWITH IS KNOWN TO DEMONSTRATE GREAT COMPASSION AND ITSYEARANNIVERSARY0ERHAPSMOSTIMPORTANTHE SENSITIVITYTOTHEPEOPLEITSERVES NOTEDISTHATTHEEXPERIENCEOFTHECOURTDEMONSTRATES THATALTHOUGHHUMANITYCANPERFORMTERRIBLEACTSITCAN 4HEPRIMARYAREASOFCONCERNFORTHE)##NOTED-R ALSOLEARNFROMTHOSEACTS3OMEOFTHELESSONSLEARNED /CAMPOAREHOWBESTTOINVESTIGATETHEKINDSOFCRIMES FROMTHEWORKOFTHE)#42ARETHATAHEADOFSTATECAN THATWILLCOMEBEFOREITHOWTOENSURETHEPROTECTIONOF BEARRESTEDINDICTEDANDCONVICTEDFORGENOCIDETHAT VICTIMSANDHOWSIMULTANEOUSLYTOACTINDEPENDENTLYAND THEACTOFRAPECANUNDERCERTAINCIRCUMSTANCESBE INTERDEPENDENTLY CONSIDEREDANACTOFGENOCIDEANDTHATTHOSEPERSONS WHOINCITEACTSOFGENOCIDETHROUGHTHEMEDIACANBE !LTHOUGHINSPIREDBYTHEEXCELLENTINVESTIGATIONSCARRIED HELDRESPONSIBLELIKEPOLITICALORMILITARYLEADERSFORTHE OUTBYTHE)#42IN2WANDA-R/CAMPONOTEDTHATTHE RESULTINGVIOLENCE )##WOULDFACESERIOUSCHALLENGESDURINGTHISPHASEOF ITSOWNWORK4HECOURTISBOUNDTOENCOUNTER3TATESTHAT -R/CAMPOEXPRESSEDHISWILLINGNESSTOLEARNFROMHIS AREUNABLEORUNWILLINGTOASSISTINTHEINVESTIGATIONOF FELLOWPROSECUTORSATTHIS#OLLOQUIUMFROM-R*ALLOW CRIMESCOMMITTEDONTHEIRTERRITORY4HE)##OFCOURSE WHOHASGREATLYEXPEDITED)#42PROSECUTIONSDURING HASNOPOLICEOFITSOWNANDNEITHERDOESITHAVEFORMAL HISMANDATEANDFROM-R#RANEOFTHE3#3,WHOHAS AUTHORITYOVERLAWENFORCEMENTBODIESINTHECOUNTRIES HADCLOSEINTERACTIONSWITHTHEVICTIMSOFTHECRIMESHE WHEREINVESTIGATIONSAREHELD4HE)##THUSREQUIRESTHE ISPROSECUTING-R/CAMPONOTEDTHATTHEADHOCAND VOLUNTARYCOOPERATIONOFMANYDIFFERENTENTITIESINORDER MIXEDTRIBUNALSHAVEGIVENTHE)##LEGALFRAMEWORKS TOINVESTIGATECRIMES)TMAYEVENSOMEDAYBECALLED THATITCANUSEANDABODYOFJURISPRUDENCETHATPUTS UPONLIKETHE3IERRA,EONECOURTTOINVESTIGATEASITTING SUBSTANCEWHERETHEREWEREONCEONLYBROADPRINCIPLES (EADOF3TATEWHOISUNLIKELYTOGRANTPERMISSIONFORAN 4HEINTERNATIONALCRIMINALJUSTICESYSTEM-R/CAMPO INQUIRYINTOHISOWNACTIONS3UCHASCENARIOPRESENTSA OBSERVEDISBUILDINGITSWAYTOWARDUNIVERSALPROCEDURES PROBLEMTOWHICH-R/CAMPOSTATEDHEHASYETTOlND THATNOLONGERRESPONDTOTHELABELSOFEITHERCOMMONOR ANANSWER CIVILLAW 9ETTHEPASTINVESTIGATORYWORKOFTHEADHOCAND 4HE#HIEF0ROSECUTORTHENNOTEDTHREEAREASOFCONCERN MIXEDTRIBUNALSSUGGESTSOMESOLUTIONS&OREXAMPLE THATHEHASIDENTIlEDASTHE)##TAKESITSlRSTSTEPSAS THEREISNOWABODYOFKNOWLEDGEABOUTAMMUNITION ANINSTITUTIONOFINTERNATIONALCRIMINALJUSTICE!LLOFTHESE DEALERSAROUNDTHEWORLDANDHOWTHEYTRANSPORTTHEIR ISSUESAREENCAPSULATEDINTHEFOLLOWINGQUOTATIONFROM GOODS3UCHKNOWLEDGEWILLHELPTHE)##TOFRAMEITS .ELSON-ANDELAONTHESUBJECTOFPROSECUTION INVESTIGATIONSOFCONmICTSANDHOWTHEYARESUPPLIED 4HE CHALLENGE FOR THE MODERN PROSECUTOR IS TO BECOMEALAWYERFORTHEPEOPLE)TISYOURDUTYTO BUILDANEFFECTIVERELATIONSHIPWITHTHECOMMUNITY AND TO ENSURE THAT THE RIGHTS OF THE VICTIMS ARE PROTECTED)TISYOURDUTYTOPROSECUTETHOROUGHLY ANDEFFECTIVELYINACCORDANCEWITHTHERULEOFLAW ANDTOACTINAPRINCIPLEDWAYWITHOUTFEARFAVOUR \ (OWEVERSUCHANINVESTIGATIONWILLNECESSITATETHE SHARINGOFINFORMATIONBETWEENNATIONALANDINTERNATIONAL PROSECUTORS4HE0ROSECUTORS#OLLOQUIUMWHICHHAS BOTHOFTHESEGROUPSINATTENDANCEREPRESENTSAN IDEALOPPORTUNITYTOBRAINSTORMOTHERSOLUTIONSTOTHE DIFlCULTIESOFINTERNATIONALCRIMINALINVESTIGATION 4HEPROBLEMOFVICTIMPROTECTIONISEQUALLYTHORNY!GAIN TRANSFORMALAWLESSSITUATIONINWHICHMASSIVECRIMES -R/CAMPONOTEDTHEEXCELLENTJOBTHATTHE)#42HAS HAVEBEENCOMMITTEDINTOONEWHERETHERULEOFLAWIS DONEINSETTINGNEWSTANDARDSFORTHETREATMENTOF RESPECTED!COURTCANNOTDOTHISALONE VICTIMSANDINlNDINGWAYSOFHELPINGTHEMTOCOME FORWARD-R/CAMPONOTEDTHATTHEVICTIMSOFMASSIVE 4HISISWHERETHECALCULUSOFINDEPENDENCEANDINTER CRIMESSUFFERTERRIBLYANDITISINCUMBENTUPONTHE DEPENDENCECOMESINTOPLAY)NTERNATIONALCRIMINAL INTERNATIONALJUSTICESYSTEMTHATTHEYNOTBETRAUMATISED TRIBUNALSMUSTBEINDEPENDENTINTHEWAYTHEYPERFORM FURTHER!TTHESAMETIMETHEYNEEDTOBEIDENTIlEDAND THEIRWORKFAITHFULTOTHEIRMANDATESANDIMPERVIOUSTO CONTACTEDFORTHEEVENTUALPROSECUTIONOFTHOSEMOST UNDUEOUTSIDEINmUENCE9ETTHEYMUSTALSOFOSTERINTER RESPONSIBLEFORTHECRIMESBEINGINVESTIGATED4HE)## DEPENDENCEWITHNATIONALENTITIESINORDERTOPERFORM ALSOHASANEWDUTYVICTIMSNEEDTOBEINFORMEDTHAT THEIRIMPORTANTWORK-R/CAMPOPOINTEDOUTTHATHE THEYCANPARTICIPATEINTRIALSANDSEEKCOMPENSATION HASAHUGEJURISDICTION(ECANINVESTIGATEANDPROSECUTE CRIMESCOMMITTEDINSTATESINTHEWORLD9ETINTHE 7HILETHISNEWROLEFORVICTIMSISAPOSITIVEDEVELOPMENT ABSENCEOFINTERDEPENDENCENONEOFHISWORKCANBE IN-R/CAMPOSVIEWITALSORAISESSOMENEWAND CARRIEDOUT CHALLENGINGQUESTIONS7HOCOUNTSASTHEVICTIMOFA CRIMEANDTHUSCANASKFORCOMPENSATION)SITONLY )NTERMSOFTHELEGACIESTOBELEFTBYINTERNATIONAL VICTIMSOFVIOLENCEORCANTHOSEDISPLACEDBYVIOLENCEBE CRIMINALTRIBUNALSALASTINGIMPACTINTHESOCIETIES COUNTEDALSO)FSOHOWCANTHEYALLBECOMPENSATED WHERECRIMESOCCURREDCANONLYBEACHIEVEDIFLOCAL 7HATABOUTTHEVICTIMSWHOSECASESWEREINVESTIGATE LEADERSANDINSTITUTIONSDOTHEIRPARTALONGSIDETHE BUTWHOSETESTIMONYISULTIMATELYNOTINCLUDEDINTHE COURTS0ROSECUTORSJUDGESANDLAWYERSHAVETHEIR PROSECUTORSPROCEEDINGS3HOULDTHEYBECOMPENSATED OWNPARTICULARMANDATETOFULlL)TISUPTOOTHERACTORS )FSOHOWCANTHEIRCOMPENSATIONBEDETERMINEDIFTHEIR TOREBUILDCOUNTRIES4HESELEGACIESARETHUSAJOINT CASESDONOTlGUREINTHETRIAL ENTERPRISEANDTHEYRELYONASPIRITOFINTERDEPENDENCE -R/CAMPOFEELSTHATCOURTSHAVETOEXPLAINTHISTOTHE -R/CAMPOWOULDLIKETOSEEACOMMUNITYSOLUTIONTO SOCIETIESWHERETHEYOPERATEANDTOTHEINTERNATIONAL THECOMPENSATIONPROBLEM)NOTHERWORDSINDIVIDUAL COMMUNITYATLARGE)NTHESAMEWAYNATIONSAROUNDTHE VICTIMSWOULDNOTBECOMPENSATEDBUTINSTEADLARGER WORLDNEEDTOUNDERSTANDTHATWITHOUTTHEIRCOOPERATION POPULATIONSTHROUGHTHEPROVISIONOFSCHOOLSHOSPITALS INVESTIGATIONSCANNOTTAKEPLACEARRESTSCANNOTBEMADE ANDOTHERNEEDEDRESOURCES)NTHISWAYJUSTICEWILLALSO ANDINDICTEDCRIMINALSCANNOTBEPROSECUTED)FNONE REINFORCEDEVELOPMENT OFTHISHAPPENSITWILLNOTBEAFAILUREOFTHECOURTSBUT INSTEADOFTHEGLOBALCOMMUNITYTHATHASNOTUNDERSTOOD 4HEPUSHFORINTERNATIONALCRIMINALCOURTSTOLEAVEBEHIND ITSOWNOBLIGATIONTOACTINTERDEPENDENTLY ALEGACYRESPONDSTOASIMILARQUESTIONWHATHAPPENS INPOSTCONmICTSOCIETIESAFTERJUSTICEISACHIEVED-R -R/CAMPOENDEDHISKEYNOTEADDRESSWITHSOMEASTUTE /CAMPOQUOTED5.3ECRETARY'ENERAL+OFl!NNANWHO OBSERVATIONSONTHEROLEOFINTERNATIONALJUSTICE7HEREAS SUGGESTEDTHATANYFUTURECRIMINALTRIBUNALMUSTCONSIDER PEACEAGREEMENTSWEREONCETHEDEFAULTMODEFOR ITSINTENDEDLEGACYINTHECOUNTRYCONCERNED4HISSETS ENDINGCONmICTSINTERNATIONALCRIMINALCOURTSHAVEhNOW VERYHIGHSTANDARDSINDEEDFORINTERNATIONALJUSTICE MADEJUSTICEANOPTIONv(EURGEDPOLITICALLEADERSTOTAKE REMARKED-R/CAMPO!CCORDINGTOTHISSCENARIOTHE NOTEOFTHISFACT4HEYACTEDTOCREATETHESETRIBUNALSAND EVALUATIONOFCRIMINALTRIBUNALSINCLUDINGTHE)##MAYNOT INSODOINGTHEYHAVESETNEWSTANDARDSFORTHEMSELVES BEBASEDONTHEIRPROCEDURESCONVICTIONSORDECISIONS BYAGREEINGTHATTHEREWILLBENOIMMUNITYFORTOPLEADERS ORONTHEIRABILITYTOINVESTIGATEANDPROSECUTEOREVENON IFTHEYHAVEPERPETRATEDCRIMESAGAINSTHUMANITY.OW THESKILLOFLEGALARGUMENTUSEDINTHECOURTROOM4HEY THEYHAVETOGETONBOARDANDPUTINTERNATIONALJUSTICEON MAYBEEVALUATEDINSTEADONTHEIMPACTTHEYLEAVEhON APARWITHNATIONALJUSTICEWHEREJUSTICEISNOTANOPTION THEGROUNDv BUTAMANDATORYRESPONSETOCRIME 7HILE/CAMPOISSYMPATHETICTOTHOSEWHOCALLFORALOCAL 4HECHALLENGEOFBRINGINGINTERNATIONALJUSTICEWORKTO IMPACTHETHINKSITISANUNDERSTANDABLEEXPECTATION DIVERSELOCALCOMMUNITIESWASALSORAISED%VENINTHE HEALSOCONSIDERSTHATSUCHANIMPACTISNOTNECESSARILY COURSEOFITSlRSTINVESTIGATIONOFCRIMESIN5GANDATHE THEWORKOFACOURT(OWCANAJUDICIALINSTITUTION )##HASENCOUNTEREDPERCEPTIONSOFJUSTICETHATDIFFER \ FROMTHOSEACCEPTEDINTHEINTERNATIONALCOMMUNITY -R/CAMPOCONCLUDEDBYNOTINGTHENEEDFORLOCALAND )NTHE7ESTAMNESTYSUGGESTSIMPUNITY"UTTOLOCAL GLOBALCOMMUNITIESTOBEBOTHSERVEDANDLINKEDTHROUGH LEADERSIN5GANDAEXTENDINGAMNESTYTOTHOSEWHO STANDARDSOFINTERNATIONALJUSTICE4HECASESPROSECUTED HAVEPERPETRATEDCRIMESAGAINSTTHEMWOULDSIMPLYMARK BYINTERNATIONALCRIMINALTRIBUNALSMAYSEEMREMOTEFROM THEENDOFTHE7ESTERNSOLUTIONANDTHEBEGINNINGOFA THEEVERYDAYEXPERIENCEOFCITIZENSLIVINGINDEMOCRATIC CUSTOMARYONEWHICHAIMSATTRUTHRECONCILIATIONAND ANDPEACEFULSTATES(OWEVERTHESECITIZENSNEED COMPENSATION3UCHATRADITIONALRESPONSE-R/CAMPO TOUNDERSTANDTHATTHEREISNOSAFEHAVENFORLIFEAND REMARKEDMAYAPPEARTOOhSOFTvBY7ESTERNSTANDARDS FREEDOMIFWEFAILTOPROTECTTHERIGHTSOFANYPERSONIN !TTHESAMETIMESOMENATIONALCOURTSMAYINSISTTHAT ANYCOUNTRYINTHEWORLD-R/CAMPOQUOTEDFROMTHE THEDEATHPENALTYISTHEONLYPROPERSENTENCEFORTHOSE PREAMBLETOTHE2OME4REATYWHICHUNDERSCORESTHE CONVICTEDOFCRIMESAGAINSTHUMANITYWHEREASTHE NEEDTOPUNISHANDDETERTHEMOSTSERIOUSCRIMESAND 7ESTERNSENTENCEMIGHTBESERVINGLIFEINAPROTECTED DECLARESTHATTHISMUSTTAKEPLACETHROUGHBOTHNATIONAL PRISONWITHMEDICALTREATMENTANDOTHERAMENITIES)NTHIS ANDINTERNATIONALACTIONANDCOOPERATION-R/CAMPO CASETHE7ESTERNRESPONSETOCRIMEISDEEMEDTOOLAX DECLAREDTHATTHISISOURCOMMONDUTYANDTHATTHE PROSECUTORSCOLLOQUIUMWILLALLOWTHOSEGATHEREDTOFULlL -R/CAMPOASKEDHISAUDIENCETOTHINKABOUTWHATA TRULYINTERNATIONALMODELOFJUSTICEWOULDLOOKLIKE(E URGEDHISCOLLEAGUESTOLOOKATASYSTEMLIKETHEGACACA COURTSIN2WANDAFROMWHICH7ESTERNERSHAVEMUCH TOLEARN'ACACAMAYNOTFULlL7ESTERNNOTIONSOFA FAIRTRIALBUTONTHEOTHERHANDITISNOTTRYINGTO-R /CAMPOCOMPAREDGACACATOAHUGECOMMUNITYPLEA BARGAINWHICHHElNDSITCOULDBEANEFFECTIVERESPONSE TOTHELARGENUMBEROFSUSPECTEDCRIMINALSCURRENTLY INDETENTION/NTHISPOINT-R/CAMPOCONCLUDEDBY NOTINGTHATVARIATIONSINHOWPEOPLEAROUNDTHEWORLD CONCEIVEOFJUSTICEGOFARBEYONDTHEMINORDIFFERENCES THATEXISTBETWEENCIVILANDCOMMONLAWSYSTEMS)F PRACTITIONERSOFINTERNATIONALJUSTICEWISHTOBETRULYINTER DEPENDENTTHEYSHOULDLEARNFROMLOCALCOMMUNITIESAND RESPECTTHEIRVIEWS \ THISDUTYMOREEFFECTIVELY #HALLENGESOF#ONDUCTING)NVESTIGATIONSOF)NTERNATIONAL#RIMES\ -ODERATOR -R(ASSAN"UBACAR*ALLOW0ROSECUTOR)#42 0RESENTERS -R"ERNARD-UNA&ORMER$EPUTY0ROSECUTOR)#42(ON.AVANETHEM0ILLAY!PPEALS*UDGE)##AND-S"INAIFER .OWROJEE,ECTURER(ARVARD,AW3CHOOLAND3ENIOR2ESEARCHER(UMAN2IGHTS7ATCH 0ANELLISTS -R2ICHARD2ENAUD#HIEFOF)NVESTIGATIONS)#42-R'AVIN2UXTON#HIEFOF0ROSECUTIONS)#49-R3ERGE"RAMMERTZ $EPUTY0ROSECUTOR)NVESTIGATIONS)##AND$R!LAN7HITE#HIEFOF)NVESTIGATIONS3,3# 0RESENTATIONS 4HISlRSTSESSIONOFTHE0ROSECUTORS#OLLOQUIUMADDRESSEDSOMEOFTHECOMMONCHALLENGESTHATARISEDURINGTHE INVESTIGATIONOFCRIMESBYINTERNATIONALCOURTSANDTRIBUNALS0ARTICIPANTSHADTHEOPPORTUNITYTOEXCHANGEEXPERIENCES ANDSUGGESTIONSFORIMPROVINGTHECRUCIALWORKTHATTHEYCARRYOUTINTHEINTERNATIONALJUSTICESYSTEM4HESESSION CONSISTEDOFTHREEPRESENTATIONSONTOPICSRELEVANTTOTHESESSIONTHEMEFOLLOWEDBYTHEREMARKSOFFOURINDIVIDUALS INTIMATELYINVOLVEDINTHEINVESTIGATIVEWORKOFTHEIRCOURTS h4HE%ARLY#HALLENGESOF#ONDUCTING)NVESTIGATIONSAND0ROSECUTIONSBEFORE)NTERNATIONAL#RIMINAL4RIBUNALSv PRESENTEDBY-R"ERNARD-UNA -R"ERNARD-UNABEGANBYNOTINGTHATADHOCTRIBUNALS THEADHOCTRIBUNALS4HECOMINGTOGETHEROFDIFFERENT WEREPOLITICALCREATIONSANDASSUCHRAISEDEXPECTATIONS LEGALSYSTEMSHASALSOCREATEDSOMEDIFlCULTIESFORTHE INTHEINTERNATIONALCOMMUNITYTHATWERENOTALWAYS )#420RACTITIONERSTRAINEDINDIFFERENTSYSTEMSMAY REALISTIC3PEEDYRESULTSWEREEXPECTEDBUTINVESTIGATIONS HAVEMARKEDLYDIFFERENTPERSPECTIVESONISSUESSUCH ENCOUNTEREDMANYOBSTACLESTHATDONOTEXISTIN ASSTATEMENTSBYTHEACCUSEDWHICHMAYULTIMATELY DOMESTICJURISDICTIONS-OSTOFTHOSESUSPECTEDOFMASS INmUENCEDECISIONSANDSENTENCES CRIMESHADmED2WANDAANDITWASNOTASIMPLETASK TOTRACKTHEMDOWN4HE)#42DOESNOTHAVEAPOLICE -R-UNABELIEVESTHATTHEACCUSATORIALLEGALSYSTEM FORCEANDTHUSHASTODEPENDUPONTHECOOPERATIONOF ISNOTASWELLSUITEDASTHEINQUISITORIALSYSTEMFOR NATIONALPOLICEFORCESANDENFORCEMENTSYSTEMS7HILE EXAMININGhTHECOLLECTIVERESPONSIBILITYOFAGOVERNMENT SOME3TATESCOOPERATEDINTHE)#42SINVESTIGATORY THATBECOMESAPREDATORONITSPEOPLEv4HEACCUSATORIAL WORKSOMEOTHERSDIDNOT)NCONTRASTTHE)#49HADAN APPROACHALSOMAYLEADTOLENGTHYPROCEEDINGSTHATMAY ADVANTAGEINTHATITHADTHEASSISTANCEOF.!4/FORCES RESULTINTAKINGUPALOTOFTIMEANDRESOURCES INLOCATINGANDARRESTINGSUSPECTS-R-UNAEXPRESSED THEHOPETHATTHE)##WILLRECEIVEMORECOOPERATION -R-UNASTRESSEDTHATTHEINTERNATIONALJUSTICESYSTEM FROM3TATESANDNATIONALSYSTEMSINTHEIRINVESTIGATIONOF MUSTPROMOTEACONSCIOUSNESSOFTHEIMPORTANCEOF CRIMINALS INTERNATIONALCOURTSEVENAMONGPOPULATIONSFARREMOVED FROMTHEKINDSOFCONmICTSEXAMINEDBYINTERNATIONAL 4HE)#42WASCREATEDINTHEIMAGEOFTHE5.'ENERAL CRIMINALCOURT(EREMARKEDh)FITISNOTOURTURNTODAYIT !SSEMBLY3TAFFSWERERECRUITEDFROMAROUNDTHEWORLD MIGHTBEOURSTOMORROWv 7HILESUCHGEOGRAPHICREPRESENTATIONSEEMEDLIKEA GOODIDEATHISDIVERSITYBROUGHTANUMBEROFCHALLENGES )THASBEENNOTEDTHATTHATTHE)#42HASYETTORESOLVEITS INTHECREATIONOFANINVESTIGATIONTEAMINCLUDING CREDIBILITYPROBLEMINTHEEYESOFTHE2WANDANPEOPLE THOSERELATEDTOLANGUAGECULTUREANDPROFESSIONAL 4HISISBECAUSETHETRIALSARETAKINGPLACEOUTSIDETHE TRAININGANDBACKGROUND)NCONTRASTTHE)##HASTHE TERRITORYINWHICHTHECRIMESWERECOMMITTED-R-UNA OPPORTUNITYTODRAWUPONAMOREEXPERIENCEDPOOLOF SUGGESTEDTHATCASESTHATREMAINAFTERTHETRIBUNALCLOSES STAFFASMANYPROFESSIONALSHAVEALREADYWORKEDWITH COULDBETRANSFERREDTOTHENEW!FRICAN#OURTFOR(UMAN AND0EOPLES2IGHTSASWELLASTONATIONALJURISDICTIONS \ h*URISPRUDENCEON3EXUAL6IOLENCEIN)NTERNATIONAL4RIBUNALSvPRESENTEDBY(ON*UDGE.AVANETHEM0ILLAY *UDGE.AVANETHEM0ILLAYBEGANHERPRESENTATIONBY WITNESSTESTIMONY4HISWASDUEINPARTTOINVESTIGATIONS NOTINGTHATASAJUDGESHECANNOTTELLPROSECUTORSHOW THATDIDPROVIDETHEEVIDENCETOSUPPORTACHARGEOF TOADVANCETHEIRINVESTIGATIONS3HESTRESSEDTHATJUDGES CRIMESOFSEXUALVIOLENCEINTHEORIGINALINDICTMENT!T NEEDTOBEBALANCEDSINCETHEYHEARCASESFROMTHEPOINT TIMESINVESTIGATORSHAVEALSOLACKEDAWARENESSOFTHE OFVIEWOFBOTHPROSECUTORSANDDEFENCE IMPORTANCEOFINVESTIGATINGTHESECRIMESANDSENSITIVITY INCOLLECTINGEVIDENCEABOUTTHEM *UDGE0ILLAYFEELSHOWEVERTHATONEAREAOFCRIMINAL INVESTIGATIONTHATHASNOTRECEIVEDSUFlCIENTATTENTION *UDGE0ILLAYPOINTEDOUTTHATJURISPRUDENCEFROMTHE ISTHATOFCRIMESOFSEXUALVIOLENCE#RIMESOFSEXUAL ADHOCTRIBUNALSHASINmUENCEDTHEDElNITIONSOFRAPE VIOLENCEREQUIREAPARTICULARAPPROACHSINCETHEYARE ANDOTHERSEXUALCRIMESANDCONSEQUENTLYTHENATURE SURROUNDEDBYFEELINGSOFSHAMEANDSTIGMAONTHEPART OFEVIDENCETHATHASTOBECOLLECTEDTOPROSECUTETHESE OFVICTIMS CRIMES3HECONCLUDEDBYASSERTINGTHATRAPEAND OTHERSEXUALCRIMESAREASSERIOUSASOTHERTYPESOF )NEARLY)#42CASESTHECHARGEOFRAPEWASSOMETIMES INTERNATIONALCRIME!SSUCHTHEYOUGHTTOBEACCORDED ADDEDATALATESTAGEOFTHEPROSECUTIONINRESPONSETO THESAMEATTENTION h7E#AN$O"ETTER)NVESTIGATINGAND0ROSECUTING)NTERNATIONAL#RIMESOF3EXUAL6IOLENCEvPRESENTEDBY -S"INAIFER.OWROJEE 4HECENTRALISSUERAISEDIN-S"INAIFER.OWROJEES s#AREFORTHEWELLBEINGSAFETYANDDIGNITYOFRAPE PRESENTATIONWASTHATTHEPROSECUTIONOFCRIMESOFSEXUAL VICTIMS4HISREQUIRESTHATSUFlCIENTINFORMATIONBE VIOLENCEHASNOTBEENASCONSISTENTORTHOROUGHASIT PROVIDEDTOVICTIMSTHATTHEYHAVETHEAGENCYTODECIDE COULDBEININTERNATIONALCRIMINALCOURTS-S.OWROJEE HOWTHEYWANTTOPROCEEDVISÌVISTHEJUDICIALPROCESS IDENTIlEDTHEFOLLOWINGMEASURESTHATCOULDBETAKENTO THATTHEYAREPROPERLYPREPAREDTOTESTIFYANDTHATTHEY ADDRESSTHEPROBLEM RECEIVEAPPROPRIATESUPPORTANDPROTECTIONSERVICES s#REATINGPOLITICALWILLONTHEPARTOFTHEPROSECUTOR s#REATINGANENABLINGCOURTROOMENVIRONMENTFORVICTIMS s$ESIGNINGAPROSECUTIONSTRATEGYFORRAPEATTHEOUTSET OFSEXUALCRIMES OFTHECOURTSACTIVITIES s4RAININGALLSTAFFSOTHATTHEYUNDERSTANDTHECOMPLEX ISSUESSURROUNDINGSEXUALCRIMESANDTHEIRINVESTIGATION s$EDICATINGASTAFFSPECIALISEDINTHEINVESTIGATIONOF SEXUALCRIMES \ -S.OWROJEECONCLUDEDHERPRESENTATIONBYPOINTINGOUT THATTHEEVIDENCENECESSARYTOPROSECUTEPERPETRATORS OFCRIMESOFSEXUALVIOLENCEEXISTS0ROSECUTORSNEEDTO IMPROVETHEIRMETHODSOFOBTAININGIT #OMMENTSBY0ANELISTS -R'AVIN2UXTON#HIEFOF0ROSECUTION)#49OBSERVED -R3ERGE"RAMMERTZ$EPUTY0ROSECUTOR)NVESTIGATIONS THATTHEREAREDIFFERENCESBETWEENTHENATUREOF )##ACKNOWLEDGEDTHATTHECHALLENGESCITEDBY-R INVESTIGATIONSIMMEDIATELYFOLLOWINGTHECREATIONOFTHE -UNASTILLEXISTTODAY4HE)##HASENCOUNTEREDSIMILAR )#49ANDTHOSETAKINGPLACEASITAPPROACHESTHEEND DIFlCULTIESINTHEMANAGEMENTOFEXPECTATIONSONTHEPART OFITSMANDATE)NVESTIGATIONSNOWSUPPORTTHEWORK OFTHEINTERNATIONALCOMMUNITYSPEEDYJUSTICE6ICTIMS OFPROSECUTORSINSTEADOFLEADINGTOINDICTMENTS(E ASSOCIATIONSMAYHAVEDIFFERENTEXPECTATIONSFROMTHE REITERATEDSOMEOFTHECHALLENGESLAIDOUTBY-R-UNAIN INTERNATIONALCOMMUNITYFULLJUSTICEANDYETNATIONAL THE)#42INCLUDINGTHELACKOFCOOPERATIONOF3TATESIN GOVERNMENTSHAVEDIFFERENTONESLOCALCAPACITYBUILDING INVESTIGATIONS/THERCHALLENGESFACINGINVESTIGATORSARE %FFECTIVECOMMUNICATIONCANHELPWITHEXPECTATION LACKOFFAMILIARITYWITHTHECONTEXTANDFACTSANDTHEFACT MANAGEMENT THATTHEEVIDENCEISCOLLECTEDLONGAFTERTHEEVENTSARE INVESTIGATED -R"RAMMERTZALSOSTRESSEDTHEDIFlCULTYOFINVESTIGATING CRIMES7HILETHEADHOCTRIBUNALSHAVERECOURSETO )TISALSOSOMETIMESDIFlCULTFORTHE/40TOKNOWWHEN 5.3ECURITY#OUNCIL#HAPTERPOWERSTHE)##DOES TOSTOPCOLLECTINGEVIDENCEORWHENACASEIShTRIAL NOT3UPPORTINGTHECREATIONOFTHE)##ISNOTTHESAME READYv,IMITEDRESOURCESSUGGESTTHATINVESTIGATORS THINGASSUPPORTINGITSWORKONADAYTODAYBASIS)## NEEDTOMOVEONTOANEWCASEWITHINAREASONABLE INVESTIGATIONSWILLALSOSOMETIMESBECARRIEDOUTIN AMOUNTOFTIME&INALLY-R2UXTONDESCRIBEDTHENEED DANGEROUSENVIRONMENTSSOMETIMESWITHCONTINUING TOhPACKAGEvCASESINSUCHAWAYTHATTHEYCANBEDEALT CONmICT7ITHREGARDTOCRIMESOFSEXUALVIOLENCEHE WITHREADILYBYOTHERJURISDICTIONSWHENTRANSFERRED EXPLAINEDTHATTHE)##HASASPECIALISEDUNITINTHE INVESTIGATIONDIVISIONRESPONSIBLEFORINITIATINGPOLICY $R!LAN7HITE#HIEFOF)NVESTIGATIONS3#3,SHAREDTHE CONDUCTINGTRAININGANDPLANNINGINVESTIGATIONSONGENDER BESTPRACTICESOFHISCOURT(EIDENTIlEDTHEFOLLOWING CRIMES hBESTPRACTICESv s!COURTNEEDSAWELLDElNEDMANDATESOTHAT INVESTIGATORSCANBEPROPERLYFOCUSED s'ENDERCRIMESWEREINCLUDEDINTHEINVESTIGATIONPLAN FROMTHEOUTSET -R2ICHARD2ENAUD#HIEFOF)NVESTIGATIONS)#42 STRESSEDTHEIMPORTANCEOFTHEFRANKCOMMENTSOFFERED DURINGTHESESSION7ITNESSESAREACRUCIALRESOURCEIN THEINTERNATIONALJUSTICEPROCESSANDSHOULDBETREATED ACCORDINGLY4HE)#42COULDALSOBENElTFROMhINSIDER s)NVESTIGATORSANDPROSECUTORSWORKEDSIDEBYSIDE WITNESSESv0LEABARGAININGASAMETHODFOREXPEDITING s4HE3#3,IDENTIlEDASTHEIRCLIENTTHEPEOPLEOF3IERRA THEJUDICIALPROCESSSHOULDBEEXPLOREDFURTHER-ANYOF ,EONEANDREACHEDOUTTOTHEMTHROUGHTOWNMEETINGS THECHALLENGESBROUGHTUPBY-R-UNAARESTILLRELEVANT SOTHATTHEYUNDERSTOODTHECOURTSMISSION -R2ENAUDNOTEDINPARTICULARTHENEEDFORCOOPERATION s4HERIGHTSTAFFSHOULDBEHIREDATTHEBEGINNINGOFTHE BY3TATESINTHEINVESTIGATIONPROCESS-R2ENAUDALSO COURTSWORK s7ITNESSESSHOULDBETAKENCAREOFBEFOREDURING ANDAFTERTESTIMONY4HE3#3,CREATEDAWITNESS AGREEDTHATTHETREATMENTOFGENDERCRIMESANDFEMALE WITNESSESISOFTHEUTMOSTIMPORTANCEANDTHATTHEREISA STRONGNEEDFORSPECIALISEDSTAFF MANAGEMENTUNITTOTHISEND s$ONORFATIGUEWILLQUICKLYENSUEIFTHEREISNOTA hPRODUCTv&OCUSEDWORKONINVESTIGATIONSWILLHELPIN COUNTERINGSUCHFATIGUE \ 0ARTICIPANTAND!UDIENCE-EMBER1UESTIONSAND#OMMENTS 4HEEXISTENCEOF3IERRA,EONEANSTAFFATTHE3#3, 4HE)##ISBASEDIN4HE(AGUEBUTHASWORLDWIDE HASMADEANENORMOUSCONTRIBUTIONTOTHEWORKOF JURISDICTION4HUSTHEJUDICIALPROCESSWILLOFTENBECARRIED THE0ROSECUTOR)NCONTRASTTHE)#42MADETHECHOICE OUTFARFROMTHELOCALITIESWHERETHECRIMESOCCURRED TONOTEMPLOY2WANDANSINTHE/40ANDHASNOTHAD 4HE)##WILLALSOFACECHALLENGESOFWITNESSPROTECTION COMPARABLEBENElTS,OCALSTAFFSHAVETHEADVANTAGEOF ESPECIALLYASITMAYTRYCRIMINALSASCONmICTCONTINUES KNOWINGTHECOMPLETECONTEXTOFTHECRIMESINVESTIGATED THELANGUAGEANDTHECULTURE3IERRA,EONEANSHAVEBEEN -ANYINTERNATIONALTRIBUNALSHAVENOhCOERCIVE PARTICULARLYUSEFULINGETTINGDIRECTTESTIMONYFROMSEXUAL POWERSvPOLICEFORCERIGHTTOSUBPOENAWITNESSESAND CRIMEVICTIMSINSTEADOFGOINGTHROUGHANINTERPRETER OTHERENFORCEMENTPOWERS4HEHYBRIDCOURTSHAVETHE ADVANTAGEOFBEINGABLETORELYONNATIONALENFORCEMENT 7ITHREGARDTOPROTECTINGWITNESSESIN2WANDAITIS SYSTEMS0ERHAPSTHE)##SHOULDHAVEINCORPORATEDA NOTPOSSIBLETOHAVEAWATERTIGHTSYSTEMOFWITNESS PROVISIONTHAT3TATESAREREQUIREDTOASSISTTHEPROSECUTOR PROTECTIONBECAUSEIDENTITIESOF2WANDANWITNESSES INTHEINVESTIGATIONANDPROSECUTIONPROCESS OFTENBECOMEKNOWNDESPITE)#42MEASURESTO ENSUREANONYMITY4HEVISIBILITYOF)#42INVESTIGATIONS 7HENTHE)#42/FlCEOFTHE0ROSECUTORWASESTABLISHED INTHELOCALITIESWHEREWITNESSESRESIDEREVEALSTHEIR THECONmICTIN2WANDAHADJUSTENDED)TWASUNCLEAR PARTICIPATION!SYSTEMOFWITNESSPROTECTIONSHOULD EXACTLYWHATROLETHE2WANDANNATIONALSSHOULDPLAYIN BERECONSIDEREDHAVINGWITNESSESKNOWNCOULDBEA THESTAFlNGOFTHE)#42!LTHOUGHITISEASYINHINDSIGHT BETTERGUARANTEEOFTHEIRSECURITYTHANTHEIRANONYMITY TOCRITICISESOMEOFTHEDECISIONSMADEBYTHE)#42THE )NTHECURRENTSYSTEMBOTHTHEPROSECUTIONANDDEFENCE POLICIESWEREMADEINGOODFAITH TEAMSKNOWTHEIDENTITYOFANONYMOUSWITNESSESAND THEPOSSIBILITYFORLEAKSOFTHISINFORMATIONCANNOTBE 3EVERALPARTICIPANTSNOTEDTHATEVENTHOUGHTHEMANDATE EXCLUDED)NSOMECASESWITNESSESHAVELOSTTHEIRLIVES OFTHE)#42ISCOMINGTOANENDITISNOTTOOLATETOMAKE PROCEDURALCHANGESTHATWOULDFACILITATEITSWORKAND 4HEACHIEVEMENTSOFTHE)#42ARENOTWIDELYKNOWN IN2WANDA4HISINFORMATIONSHOULDBEMADEAVAILABLE TOTHE2WANDANPOPULATIONSOTHEYSEETHATPROGRESS ISBEINGMADEANDTHATJUSTICEISBEINGPROVIDED)FTHE COURTPROCEEDINGSWERETAKINGPLACEWHERETHECRIMES OCCURREDASTHEYDOIN3IERRA,EONETHESUCCESSESOF THECOURTWOULDHAVEAHIGHERPROlLE \ MISSIONTOSERVETHE2WANDANPEOPLE 4HE#HALLENGESOF)NTERNATIONAL#RIMINAL0ROSECUTION\ -ODERATOR -R,UIS-ORENO/CAMPO0ROSECUTOR)## 0RESENTERS -R'AVIN2UXTON#HIEFOF0ROSECUTIONS)#49-R$AVID#RANE#HIEF0ROSECUTORFOR3#3,AND-R(ASSAN"*ALLOW #HIEF0ROSECUTOR)#42 0ANELLISTS -S&ATOU"ENSOUDA$EPUTY0ROSECUTOR)##-R,UC#OTÏ#HIEFOF0ROSECUTIONS3,3#AND-S-ELANIE7ERRETT #HIEFOF0ROSECUTIONS)#42 h4HE$YNAMICSAND#HALLENGESOF)NTERNATIONAL0ROSECUTIONvPRESENTEDBY-R'AVIN2UXTON )NINTERNATIONALCRIMINALJUSTICESYSTEMSTHEPROCESS 4HELENGTHOFTHECASESMUSTBEREDUCED!LTHOUGHTHERE FORFACTlNDINGISVERYDIFFERENTTHANINMANYDOMESTIC WEREREASONSFORESTABLISHINGMULTIPLECHARGESINAN SYSTEMSWHEREPOLICECONDUCTTHEFACTlNDINGANDTHEN EFFORTTOCREATEHISTORICALRECORDPROSECUTORSSHOULDNOW PASSITONTOTHE0ROSECUTORS)NTHE)#49-R2UXTON RESTRICTTHESCOPEOFWHATTHEYUNDERTAKETOPROVE-R NOTEDCASESEVOLVEFACTUALLYANDPROSECUTORSOFTENlND 2UXTONADDRESSEDTHEFOLLOWINGWAYSOFDEALINGWITHTHE THEMSELVESSCRAMBLINGFORINFORMATIONATTHETRIAL4HE EXCESSIVELENGTHOFCASES NEEDTOBEBETTERPREPAREDINADVANCEISAPPARENT-R 2UXTONSUGGESTEDTHATONEPOSSIBLESOLUTIONWOULDBETO 4HEREMUSTBEAWAYTOESTABLISHSOMECRIME DEVELOPMOREOFADOSSIER!LSOUSINGSYSTEMSSUCHAS BASEDISSUESSUCHASETHNICCLEANSINGIN"OSNIAOR #ASE-APISWORTHCONSIDERATION GENOCIDEIN2WANDAASASTARTINGPOINT4HEREISA TREMENDOUSAMOUNTOFTIMESPENTREPEATEDLYPROVING !NENORMOUSAMOUNTOFENERGYISDEDICATEDTOTHE THATTHATTHESECRIMESOCCURRED)NRESPONSETOTHE DISCLOSUREOFEXCULPATORYINFORMATIONINBIGCASES4HIS OVERWHELMINGAMOUNTOFEVIDENCEWITHSUCHCRIME ISDOCUMENTEDINTHElNALREPORTSATTHEENDOFTHE BASEDISSUESPROSECUTORSHAVEENCOURAGEDTHEUSE PROSECUTIONSCASEINTHE-ILOSEVICTRIAL4HE)#49ISNOW OFWRITTENSTATEMENTSOVERORALEVIDENCE(OWEVER MOVINGTOAN%LECTRONIC$ISCLOSURE3UITEANOPENBOOK SINCETHISMETHODPLACESMOREPRESSUREONSTAFFAND APPROACH7ITHTHISFORMATDEFENCECOUNSELSCANACCESS JUDGESTOPREPAREANDREADRESPECTIVELYITHASNOT BOTHTHEGENERALCOLLECTIONOFMATERIALSANDASECOND BEENENTHUSIASTICALLYADOPTED&URTHERMOREWRITTEN COLLECTIONTHATISSPECIlCALLYDEVELOPEDFORTHEIRCASE)T STATEMENTSWEREINCORPORATEDINTHE-ILOSEVICCASE ISDONEOVERTHE)NTERNET4HERULESHAVECHANGEDSOTHAT ANDBOTHTHEPRESSANDPUBLICWEREUNHAPPY-ANY ITISTHEPROSECUTORSOBLIGATIONTOPROVIDETHEDEFENCE WITNESSESHADTHEIRSTATEMENTSTENDEREDANDWEREONLY WITHANYEXCULPATORYMATERIALTHATIShWITHINOURACTUAL CROSSEXAMINED!LSOTHEPRESSANDSTAFFFOUNDITDIFlCULT KNOWLEDGEvATERMTHATMUSTBEDElNEDINTERNALLY TOFOLLOWTHETRIAL 0ERTHE3ECURITY#OUNCILRESOLUTIONSTHEREARENOW )NASYSTEMSUCHASTHE)#49ITISANENORMOUS ATTEMPTSTOCONTROLTHENUMBEROFINDICTEES-ANYJUDGES UNDERTAKINGFORANYSINGLEPERSONTORUNHISHEROWN WANTTODETERMINEWHICHCHARGESSHOULDBESUBJECTTO DEFENCE4HE-ILOSEVICCASEILLUSTRATESTHEDIFlCULTIES EVIDENCETHENUMBEROFWITNESSESANDDEADLINESFOR THATCANOCCURSUCHASWHENHEALTHISSUESINTERVENE THELENGTHOFCASES3ERIOUSATTEMPTSAREBEINGMADETO 4HETASKISCLEARLYBEYONDONEPERSONTODOITATCONSTANT HAVEPRETRIALJUDGESRESOLVEISSUESTHATCANBElXEDPRIOR SPEED TOTHETRIAL(OWEVERINCERTAINSITUATIONSTHISCANINTRUDE INTOTHEDISCRETIONANDINDEPENDENCEOFTHEPROSECUTOR -R2UXTONCONCLUDEDHISPRESENTATIONBYNOTINGAN ISSUETHATISSTILLTOHISDISMAYOPENFORDEBATEPROVING JOINTCRIMINALENTERPRISEBETWEENTOPLEADERS4HEISSUE RAISESMANYQUESTIONSESPECIALLYWHENTHOSEOFDIFFERENT MILITARYRANKSAREINVOLVED!TTHISPOINTHEEXPLAINED THERESHOULDBEARESOLUTIONTOSUCHAFUNDAMENTALISSUE \ h#HALLENGESIN0ROSECUTIONSBEFORETHE3PECIAL#OURTOF3IERRA,EONEvPRESENTEDBY-R$AVID#RANE )NDISCUSSINGHISPAPER-R#RANEFOCUSEDONTHE 7EST!FRICA7ITHTHESEPROGRAMMESTHE3#3,LEAVES LESSONSHEHASLEARNEDFROMTHE3#3,(EASSERTEDTHAT THEMESSAGETHATLAWISFAIRTHATNOBODYISABOVETHELAW THEMANDATEFORTHE3#3,ISBOTHPOLITICALLYANDLEGALLY ANDTHATTHERULEOFLAWISMOREPOWERFULTHANTHERULEOF ACHIEVABLETHATISTOPROSECUTEhTHOSEWHOBEARTHE THEGUN GREATESTRESPONSIBILITYvFORWARCRIMESCRIMESAGAINST HUMANITYANDOTHERSERIOUSVIOLATIONSTHATTOOKPLACE !SDEMONSTRATEDIN3IERRA,EONETRUTHCOMMISSIONS IN3IERRA,EONEAFTER.OVEMBER-R#RANENOTED AREIMPORTANTFORAJUSTANDSUSTAINABLEPEACE!LTHOUGH THATh4HOSEWHOBEARTHATGREATESTRESPONSIBILITYv THE#OURTCOULDNOTPROSECUTEPEOPLEITSCLIENTS INCLUDESLESSTHANTWODOZENINDIVIDUALS(OWEVERIF WEREASSUREDTHATITWOULDSEEKJUSTICE0EOPLENEEDED ONEWERETOCHANGEhGREATESTRESPONSIBILITYvTOhMOST AFORMALSETTINGWHERETHEYCOULDTESTIFYABOUTWHAT RESPONSIBLEvTHATWOULDINCLUDETOINDIVIDUALS HAPPENEDTOTHEM/VERPEOPLETESTIlEDBEFORETHE 'OONESTEPFURTHERMOVINGFROMhGREATESTvORhMOST 42# RESPONSIBLEvTOhTHOSERESPONSIBLEFORTHESEWARCRIMES ANDCRIMESAGAINSTHUMANITYvANDTHETRIALSWOULDGO )N-AYANACADEMICCONSORTIUMWASCREATED ONINDElNITELY!STHISILLUSTRATESITISVERYIMPORTANTTO BYUSINGLAWSCHOOLSFROMALLOVERTHEWORLDTOCREATE GETAMANDATEANDAMISSIONSTATEMENTTHATALLOWSTHE ANEDUCATIONPROGRAMFORLAWSTUDENTSTODIRECTLY ORGANISATIONTOACHIEVEITSGOALSINATIMEFRAMETHAT SUPPORTTHE0ROSECUTORSOFlCE)TWASANINCREDIBLE THEPEOPLETHEVICTIMSTHETOWNSANDTHEDISTRICTS EFFORTTHATPROVEDTOBEOFGREATBENElTFORALLPARTIES CANAPPRECIATE(EALSORECOMMENDSTHATAWARCRIMES 4HEINITIALINTENTWASTOSHOWLAWSTUDENTSTHATTHEY TRIBUNALDOESITSWORKINlVEYEARSORLESSOTHERWISEIT SHOULDCONSIDERINTERNATIONALCRIMINALJUSTICEASA CANBECOMEAPOLITICALPROBLEMFORTHEREGION FUTUREPROFESSION(OWEVERITALSOSAVEDTHECOURTA TREMENDOUSAMOUNTOFTIMEANDMONEYANDSTUDENTS #OURTSANDTRIBUNALSNEEDTOBELOCATEDINTHECOMMUNITY BENElTEDBYACTUALLYDOINGWARCRIMESWORK WHERETHECRIMESOCCURREDFORTWOMAINREASONS-OST IMPORTANTLYITALLOWSVICTIMSANDTHEIRFAMILIESTOSEE 4HEBIGGESTCHALLENGEFACINGTHECOURTISINTERNATIONAL JUSTICEINACTION3ECONDITFOCUSESTHEWORKOFTHECOURT INDIFFERENCE-OSTPEOPLEAREEITHERIGNORANTORDONOT REMINDINGALLWHYTHEYAREDOINGTHISWORK%VERYDAY CAREABOUTTHETRAGEDIESTHATHAVEOCCURREDIN7EST ONECANTASTETOUCHFEELANDSMELLTHEAGONYTHATTHE !FRICA4HEREFOREITISCRITICALTHATTHEINTERNATIONAL PEOPLEOF3IERRA,EONEHAVEEXPERIENCED COMMUNITYREALISESHOWTHESEEVENTSIMPACTTHERESTOF THEWORLD4HEYHAVEARIPPLEEFFECTANDWITH!L1UAEDA /UTREACHANDLEGACYPROGRAMMESAREKEYSTOSUCCESS (AMASAND(EZBOLLAHOPERATINGFREELYIN7EST!FRICA )N3IERRA,EONEASUCCESSFULOUTREACHPROGRAMPROVIDED EVERYBODYISVULNERABLE)FTHEINTERNATIONALCOMMUNITY THESTAFFWITHATRUEAPPRECIATIONFORWHATTOOKPLACEIN REMAINSINDIFFERENTTHESEGROUPSWILLRETURNANDWREAK h3ALONEv+RIOLANGUAGETERMFOR3IERRA,EONE-ORE HAVOC IMPORTANTLYITGAVEVICTIMSTHEOPPORTUNITYTOBEHEARDBY PROSECUTORSWHOWOULDINDICTTHOSEWHODIDSUCHTERRIBLE )NCONCLUSION-R#RANEEXPLAINEDTHECRITERIAFORTHE THINGS!TRIBUNALISFORTHEPEOPLEBEINGSERVEDAND SELECTIONOFTARGETSANDINDICTEES#RITERIAAREBASEDON THEREFORESOMETHINGOTHERTHANJUSTCONVICTIONSMUSTBE CASETHEORYANDADJUSTEDACCORDINGLYASNEWINFORMATION LEFTAFTERTHETRIALSARECOMPLETED4HEREMUSTBEALEGACY BECOMESAVAILABLE)NADDITIONTOSTANDARDPROCEDURES &OREXAMPLETHE3#3,WILLLEAVETHEREGIONWITHTRAINED SUCHASEXAMININGTHEFACTSANDLAWINTERVIEWING INDIVIDUALSTOCARRYONTHEWORKOFTHETRIBUNAL!LSOTHE VICTIMSANDCONSULTINGWITHALLSTAFFHEEMPHASISED TRIBUNALHASADUTYTOENSURETHESAFETYOFWITNESSESAND THATPROSECUTORSNEEDTOCONSIDERTHEDIPLOMATICAND VICTIMSWHICHINCLUDESPROVIDINGASSISTANCEFORTHEIR CULTURALASPECTSOFINDICTEES-R#RANECAUTIONEDTHAT PSYCHOLOGICALANDPHYSICALNEEDS,ASTLYPROPEROUTREACH BYNOTDOINGSOONECOULDDESTABILISEAWHOLEREGION)N ANDLEGACYPROGRAMMESPROVETHATTHELAWISTHE ADDITIONHENOTEDTHENEEDTOREACHOUTTOCIVILSOCIETYBY CORNERSTONEOFAPROPERDEMOCRATICANDPEACEFULFUTURE WORKINGWITH.'/S &ORDECADESTHELAWHASBEENATHREATTOTHEPEOPLEOF \ h4HE#HALLENGESOF)NTERNATIONAL#RIMINAL0ROSECUTIONWITH0ARTICULAR2EFERENCETO4HE)#42v PRESENTEDBY-R(ASSAN"*ALLOW -R*ALLOWHIGHLIGHTEDTHECHALLENGESANDCONSTRAINTS !TPRESENTMULTIPLEACCUSEDCASESAREPOSINGAGREAT THATTHE)#42HASFACED4HE)#42ONLYPROSECUTESTHOSE CHALLENGEFORTHECOURT4HEREFORETHE/40ISMOVING MOSTRESPONSIBLEFORSERIOUSVIOLATIONSOFINTERNATIONAL TOWARDSINGLEACCUSEDCASES%XISTINGMULTIPLE HUMANITARIANLAWIN2WANDAANDTHENEIGHBOURING ACCUSEDCASESHAVEBEENONGOINGFORYEARSANDREMAIN 3TATESDURINGTHESPECIlCPERIODOFST*ANUARYTO UNlNISHED)NSUCHCASESTHEREAREMULTIPLEDEFENCE ST$ECEMBER)THASSUCCEEDEDINPROSECUTING COUNSELSANDWITNESSES4HISOFTENLEADSTOMOREDELAYS THOSEWHOBORETHEGREATESTRESPONSIBILITYORENGAGED DUETOTHEABSENCEOFONEORMOREOFTHEACTORS INCOMMITTINGSERIOUSVIOLATIONSOFINTERNATIONAL HUMANITARIANLAW)NORDERTODEVELOPCRITERIATODETERMINE !SARESULTCURRENTPOLICYHASSHIFTEDTOTHESTRATEGY WHOMINTHEWORDSOF3ECURITY#OUNCILhPLAYEDALEADING OFSINGLEACCUSEDCASES3INGLEACCUSEDCASESTEND ROLEINTHEGENOCIDEOF2WANDAORWHOCOMMITTEDA TOPROCEEDMOREQUICKLY4HENEWINDICTMENTPOLICY SERIOUSVIOLATIONOFTHELAWvTHE)#42HELDAWORKSHOP ALSOREQUIRESTHATBEFOREANINDICTMENTISSUBMITTEDFOR OFSENIORTRIALATTORNEYS.EVERTHELESSWITHTHEDECISION CONlRMATIONALLSTEPSMUSTBETAKENTOENSURETHATTHE ONTHE#OMPLETION3TRATEGYBYTHE3ECURITY#OUNCIL)#42 CASEISTRIALREADYUPONCONlRMATION HADTOIN&EBRUARYFOCUSONTHEISSUEOFSELECTING CASESFORPROSECUTION )NORDERTOMAINTAINAUNIlEDCASETHEORYOFTHEGENOCIDE THE/40NEEDSTOIMPROVECOORDINATIONAMONGTRIAL /NCEFACEDWITHTHEDEADLINESTHE/40HADTO TEAMS7ITHNINETRIALTEAMSALLHEADEDBYENTHUSIASTIC CONSCIENTIOUSLYDETERMINEWHATCASESTORETAIN SENIORTRIALATTORNEYSTHISHASBEENACHALLENGE3TAFF PROSECUTETRANSFERORDISCONTINUE)TWASCONCLUDEDTHAT MUSTAVOIDTAKINGCONmICTINGPOSITIONSWITHREGARDTOTHE THREEFACTORSWERECRITICALTHESTATUSOFTHEACCUSEDIN OVERALLCASETHEORY4HEPOSITIONTAKENBYONETRIALTEAM 2WANDAATTHETIMEEGWHETHERHEWASSENIORMILITARY SHOULDNOTHURTANOTHER ORGOVERNMENTlGUREANDTHEEXTENTOFHISORHER PARTICIPATION'EOGRAPHICSPREADWASALSOESTABLISHEDAS )TISQUITEEASYTOFALLINTOTHEERROROFDEALINGWITHEACHOF ACONSIDERATIONSOASNOTTOEXCLUDECERTAINPARTSOFTHE THETRIALSATTHE)#42ASANISOLATEDCASEWHEREASINTRUTH COUNTRY4HATCOULDGIVERISETOISSUESOFDISCRIMINATORY THEREWASASINGLEGENOCIDE!LLTHECASESAREMERELY SELECTIONANDIMPEDETHEPROSPECTSFORNATIONAL INTENDEDTOESTABLISHTHEINVOLVEMENTOFEACHOFTHE RECONCILIATION!THIRDFACTORWASTHENATUREOFTHEOFFENCE ACCUSEDINTHATSINGLEEVENT)TISESSENTIALLYONECASEAND ITSELF/FFENCESOFSEXUALVIOLENCEORTHOSEDIRECTED THESEVERALTRIALTEAMSHAVETOBECONSCIOUSOFTHIS AGAINSTCHILDRENWOULDBEGIVENPRIORITYINPROSECUTION WHERETHEEVIDENCEANDLAWPERMITTED -R*ALLOWCONCLUDEDHISPRESENTATIONBYREITERATINGSOME OFTHECHALLENGESTHATTHE)#42SHARESWITHOTHERCOURTS 4HEPROLONGEDNATUREOFTHEINVESTIGATIONSONGOING SUCHASDISCLOSURESWITNESSPROTECTIONTRANSLATIONISSUES YEARSAFTERTHEEVENTANDDUETOCONCLUDEONLYBYENDOF ANDANOTHERCHALLENGEISINTERNATIONALCOOPERATIONAND POSEDACHALLENGETOPROSECUTION7ITHTHELAPSEOF INTERNATIONALSUPPORTWITHREGARDTORESOURCESPRODUCTION TIMEQUESTIONSASTOQUALITYOFRESULTSMAYARISE OFEVIDENCEAPPREHENSIONANDTRANSFEROFFUGITIVESAND THEACCEPTANCEOFREFERRALSFORPROSECUTIONATTHENATIONAL 5NLIKEINTHE)#49THE)#42"UREAUSHOULDNOTHAVEA LEVEL ROLEINDECIDINGWHETHERANINDICTMENTWILLGOFORWARD FORCONlRMATION4HE"UREAUDOESNOTHAVEACCESSTO 4HERULESPLACEDANONEROUSBURDENOFDISCLOSUREONTHE SUFlCIENTINFORMATIONSUCHASTHEENTIREDATABASEOF 0ROSECUTORWHICHCONTINUEDATALLSTAGESOFTHEJUDICIAL TARGETSTOENABLEITDETERMINEWHATCASESAREMORE PROCESSANDEVENWELLAFTERITSCONCLUSION$ISCHARGING SERIOUSTHANOTHERS/NLYTHE0ROSECUTORWHOISAWARE SUCHANOBLIGATIONREQUIREDBETTERORGANISATIONINTHE OFTHEENTIREDATABASEISINAPOSITIONTODOSO4HE ANALYSISCLASSIlCATIONANDACCESSTOTHEHUGEMASSOF ARRANGEMENTALSORAISESCONSTITUTIONALQUESTIONSRELATING MATERIALCOLLECTEDBYINVESTIGATORSOVERTHEYEARS4RIAL TOTHEEXERCISEOF0ROSECUTORIALDISCRETION ATTORNEYSWERESOMETIMESUNAWAREOFSOMEOFTHISDUE TONOFAULTOFTHEIRS \ 7ITNESSSECURITYWASBECOMINGAKEYISSUEATTHE4RIBUNAL 4HESUCCESSOFINTERNATIONALCRIMINALJUSTICEDEPENDED 3TATESUPPORTINPROVIDINGPROTECTIONANDRELOCATIONOF ONTHEONEHANDONTHEINTERNALEFFORTSOFTHETRIBUNALSTO WITNESSESANDINTHEAPPREHENSIONANDTRANSFEROFFUGITIVES EXPEDITETHEPROCESSOFDELIVERINGJUSTICEINANEFlCIENT WASWELLBELOWWHATWASREQUIRED4HEREFERRALOFCASESTO ANDFAIRMANNERANDONTHEOTHERTHEEFFECTIVESUPPORTOF NATIONALJURISDICTIONSFORTRIALWASAVERYIMPORTANTELEMENT THEINTERNATIONALCOMMUNITYFORTHETRIBUNALS!SCREATIONS OFTHE#OMPLETION3TRATEGYOFBOTHTHE)#49ANDTHE)#42 OFTHEINTERNATIONALSYSTEMNOTANCHOREDTOANYNATIONAL )NTHECASEOFTHE)#42VERYFEW3TATESHADDEMONSTRATED SYSTEMTHESETRIBUNALSDEPENDSIGNIlCANTLYMORETHAN AWILLINGNESSTOTAKEONSUCHCASES NATIONALINSTITUTIONSOREVENMIXEDTRIBUNALSONTHE INDIVIDUALANDCOLLECTIVESOLIDARITYOFMEMBERSTATES #OMMENTSBY0ANELLISTS -S-ELANIE7ERRETT)#42#HIEFOF0ROSECUTIONSNOTED -S&ATOU"ENSOUDA)##$EPUTY0ROSECUTORREmECTED THATMANYOFTHEISSUESTHATARISEINTHE)#42AND)#49 ONTHEUNIQUESITUATIONOFTHE)##)TISLIMITEDBYNEITHER AREBECAUSETHESETYPESOFTRIBUNALSEVENAFTER GEOGRAPHICNORTIMECONSTRAINTSTHUSACOMPLETION YEARSDONOTlTNEATLYINTOTHE5.SYSTEM3OMEOFTHAT STRATEGYISNOTANISSUE(OWEVERTHECOURTISFACED RESPONSIBILITYFALLSONTHECOURTS2ATHERTHANASKINGTHE WITHITSOWNISSUES#URRENTLYTHE)##ISINTHEPROCESS 5.h7HATTODOvTHEYSHOULDHAVESAIDh4HISISWHAT OFINVESTIGATING3UCHINVESTIGATIONSOFTENTAKEPLACE WEAREGOINGTODOv7ERRETTALSOADDRESSEDTHENEED UNDERDANGEROUSCIRCUMSTANCESWITHUNCOOPERATIVE FORhPROPERvRESOURCESINORDERFORCOURTSTOOPERATE GOVERNMENTSANDALONGSIDECONCURRENTPEACE EFFECTIVELY4HEREISASERIOUSNEEDFORMANYTYPESOF NEGOTIATIONS$EEPLYINVOLVEDINTHEINVESTIGATIONS TRAINING&OREXAMPLETHERETENDSTOBEADEHUMANISING PROSECUTORSSERVEASTEAMLEADERS4HE)##HASADUTYTO ATTITUDETOWARDTHOSEBEFORETHECOURTANDITMUSTBE INVESTIGATEBOTHINCULPATORYANDEXCULPATORYMATTERS)T ADDRESSED4HEREFORETRAININGMUSTINCLUDEEDUCATING CANNOTJUSTLATERDISCLOSEEXCULPATORYMATERIAL0ROSECUTORS STAFFONHOWTOTREATWITNESSESANDVICTIMSASPEOPLEAND HAVETHEDUTYTOPRESENTEVIDENCEOFAhUNIQUE NOTJUSTAShRESOURCESv INVESTIGATINGOPPORTUNITYvTOTHEPRETRIALCHAMBER4HERE AREALSOCLEARPROTOCOLSWITHREGARDTOHANDLINGWITNESSES -R,UC#OTÏ3,3##HIEFOF0ROSECUTIONSCOMMENTED ANDTHEACCUSED3HECONCLUDEDBYNOTINGTHATTHEJOINT ONSEVERALPOINTSMADEDURINGTHEPRESENTATIONS(E PROSECUTIONINVESTIGATIONAPPROACHISCRITICAL EXPLAINEDTHATTHESPECIlCITYOFTHE3#3,WHICHWAS CREATEDBYABILATERALTREATYBETWEENTHE5.ANDTHE -R'AVIN2UXTON)#49#HIEFOF0ROSECUTIONS 3IERRA,EONEGOVERNMENTMAKESITPOSSIBLEFORTHECOURT COMMENTEDONTHE)#49SINVESTIGATIONANDPROSECUTION TOBEINTHECOUNTRYWHERETHECRIMESWERECOMMITTED STRATEGIES7ITHCONSTANTMEDIAIMAGESANDINFORMATION (ENOTEDHOWEVERTHATITISNAÕVETOTHINKTHATTHISCAN IN%UROPETHE)#49HADTOGATHERWITNESSES4HEEARLY ALWAYSBEPOSSIBLEFORAVARIETYOFREASONSINCLUDING WORKWASEXPERIMENTALANDFOCUSEDONESTABLISHING CONTINUINGCONmICTANDTHEUNWILLINGNESSOFMANY THESTRUCTURESOFTHEMILITARYANDMILITIA%FFORTSWERE COUNTRIESTOSURRENDERSOVEREIGNTY CONCENTRATEDONTHEREGIONALANDNATIONALLEVEL)FLOWER LEVELPERPETRATORSlTINTOTHEPICTURETHEYWOULDBE -R#OTÏALSOADDRESSEDTHEISSUEOFLIMITINGTHENUMBER INDICTEDHOWEVERTHEFOCUSWASALWAYSONLEADERS OFWITNESSESWHICHWASRAISEDNUMEROUSTIMES(E 3INCEMUCHOFTHEINFORMATIONCOMINGOUTOFTHE"ALKANS NOTEDTHATTHISCOULDBEANISSUEBECAUSEPROSECUTORS WASNOTCREDIBLETHECOURTCAREFULLYCONSIDEREDTHEENTIRE OFTENDEVELOPPERSONALRELATIONSHIPSWITHPOTENTIAL PUBLICMATERIALANDMATERIALCOMINGFROMTHE3ERBSIDE WITNESSES)TCANBEHARDFORTHEMTOTHENEXPLAINTHAT ONESTESTIMONYISNOTULTIMATELYhNEEDEDv,ASTLYWITH -R2UXTONCONCLUDEDHISCOMMENTSBYNOTINGAN REGARDTOTHEPOLITICALREALITYFACINGTHEINTERNATIONAL OVERSIGHTINTHECOLLOQUIUMSDISCUSSIONTHEAPPEARANCE JUSTICESYSTEM-R#OTÏCONTENDSTHATTRANSPARENCYIS OFINACTIVITY!LTHOUGHGAPSINTHECOURTSPROCEEDINGS ESSENTIALTHECHANGINGCRITERIAOFTHECOURTSCOMPLETION CANNOTALWAYSBECONTROLLEDTHEYDOPRESENTTHEPUBIC STRATEGIESSUCHASTHE)#42AND)#49SHOULDBEMADE WITHANEGATIVEIMAGE4OADDRESSTHISCRITICISMANDUSE PUBLIC THECOURTSMOSTEFFECTIVELYHEPROPOSEDTHATCOURTSBE CREATIVEINlLLINGTIMEWITHPRETRIALISSUES \ 0ARTICIPANTAND!UDIENCE-EMBER1UESTIONSAND#OMMENTS )NRESPONSETOTHEQUESTIONOFWHETHERTHE)#49COULD !SAFOOTNOTETO-R*ALLOWSCOMMENTSONGEOGRAPHICAL HAVEDEVELOPEDAWRITTENSTRATEGYINTHEBEGINNINGIT DISTRIBUTIONITWASNOTEDTHATTHE/40DIDAVERY WASNOTEDTHATITWOULDHAVEBEENVERYDIFlCULT%VENIF IMPORTANTJOBBYDRAWINGFROMDIFFERENTSECTORSOF ASTRATEGYHADBEENDEVELOPEDTHE4RIBUNALWOULDHAVE THE2WANDANPOPULATIONWHILEIDENTIFYINGTHOSEWHO DIVERTEDFROMITASEVENTSUNFOLDED PARTICIPATEDINTHEGENOCIDE-EMBERSOFTHEMILITARY POLITICIANSRELIGIOUSlGURESANDEVENMUSICIANSWHO 0ANELLISTSADDRESSEDQUESTIONSON)##PROVISIONSFOR WEREVERYGOODMOBILISERSDURINGTHETIMEOFGENOCIDE COMPENSATIONSTATINGTHATTHEREWILLBEATRUSTFUNDFOR HAVEBEENPROSECUTED COMPENSATIONOVERSEENBYANINDEPENDENTINTERNATIONAL PANELOFDIRECTORS!COMMUNITYAPPROACHWILLBEUSED 3OMEAUDIENCEMEMBERSNOTEDTHATINADDITIONTO TOMAKEDECISIONSWITHTHEJUDGESHAVINGTHElNALSAY INTERNATIONALINDIFFERENCETHEREISALSOANINTERNATIONAL ONWHORECEIVESCOMPENSATIONANDINWHATAMOUNTS INCOHERENCEOFPOLICIESRELATEDTOTHEWAYTHATSIMILAR 4HE'ENOCIDE3URVIVORS!SSISTANCE&UNDIN2WANDAWAS ISSUESAREADDRESSEDACROSSREGIONS!LTHOUGHTHE PROPOSEDASAWORKABLEMODEL INTERNATIONALCOMMUNITYISSPENDINGMANYRESOURCES ON2WANDAITISNOTADDRESSINGISSUESINTHE#ONGO 0ARTICIPANTSRESPONDEDTOAUDIENCEQUESTIONSABOUTTHE 4HESEARETWOVERYDIFFERENTAPPROACHESTOAVERYSIMILAR TRIBUNALSRATIONALETODRAFTINDICTMENTSWITHOUTSUFlCIENT PROBLEM EVIDENCE4HEYEMPHASISEDTHETREMENDOUSINTERNATIONAL PRESSURETOARRESTHIGHLEVELTARGETSWHOSEWHEREABOUTS 4HEEXCESSIVELENGTHOFTRIALSWASDISCUSSEDTHROUGHOUT WEREOBVIOUS)N.AIROBIGENOCIDESUSPECTSWERE THEPRESENTATIONS/NEPARTICIPANTPROPOSEDTHE WALKINGTHESTREETSANDTHEREWASPRESSURETOARREST FOLLOWINGISITPOSSIBLETHATBASINGDEFENCECOMPENSATION THEM!LTHOUGHCASESWERENOTREADYTHECOURTSHADTO ONTHEHOURSSPENTINCOURTROOMSWILLBEANINCENTIVEFOR STARTTHEPROCESSTOKEEPTHEINTERNATIONALCOMMUNITY hDELAYSv(EASKEDIFTHEREMIGHTBEANOTHERMETHOD COMFORTABLE!LSOINMANYCASESONCETHEREWASANY OFENSURINGFAIRREPRESENTATION0ARTICIPANTSNOTEDTHAT EVIDENCEAPERSONWASARRESTEDANDANINDICTMENTHAD THEREISANAPPROACHTHATGRADESTHECASESBYCOMPLEXITY TOBEPREPARED!FTERTHECONlRMEDINDICTMENTEVIDENCE ,AWYERSAREGIVENALUMPSUMPAYMENTACCORDINGTOTHE WASEXAMINEDTOASSEMBLEAMOREPROPERINDICTMENT COMPLEXITYOFTHECASE/NEPARTICIPANTNOTEDTHATPLEA #ASESWEREOFTENNOTREADYANDTHOUGHITDIDSEEM AGREEMENTSAREANOTHERSENSITIVEISSUEASTHEREISNO BACKWARDITWASAWAYTOESTABLISHCREDIBILITYWITH.'/S lNANCIALINCENTIVEFORTHEDEFENCE ANDTHEMEDIA #ONCLUSION )NCONCLUDINGTHESESSION-R/CAMPOCOMMENTED INNOVATIONTHE)##MUSTACTIVELYSEEKKNOWLEDGEFROM ONINDEPENDENCEINTERDEPENDENCEANDINNOVATION BOTHTHEINTERNATIONALANDDOMESTICSYSTEMS)NPARTICULAR (EEMPHASISEDTHENEEDFORTHE)##TOMAINTAIN ITSHOULDEXAMINETHEDEMONSTRATEDSUCCESSOFCREATIVE INDEPENDENCE!TTHESAMETIMEITISACOMPLEMENTARY APPROACHESINNATIONSSUCHAS!RGENTINAAND#HILEAND COURT4HEREFOREITHASANOBLIGATIONTOSUPPORTOTHERS ALTERNATIVESSUCHASGACACAIN2WANDA INTHEINTERNATIONALJUSTICESYSTEM7ITHREGARDTO \ 3ERVICEOF3ENTENCEFOR)NTERNATIONAL#RIMES\ -ODERATOR -R$AVID#RANE0ROSECUTOR3#3, 0RESENTERS $R*OHN(OCKING$EPUTY2EGISTRAR)#49AND-R,OVEMORE-UNLO$EPUTY2EGISTRAR)#42 h,ESSONS,EARNTON%NFORCEMENTOF3ENTENCES4HE)#49%XPERIENCEhPRESENTEDBY$R*OHN(OCKING $R(OCKINGHASBEEN$EPUTY2EGISTRARFORTHE)#42FOR 4HEREHASALSOBEENANEVOLUTIONINOTHERAREASSUCHAS ONLYTWOMONTHS(EWASPREVIOUSLY3ENIOR,EGAL/FlCER VICTIMANDWITNESSSUPPORTASWELLASINTERPRETATIONAND INTHE!PPEALS#HAMBERDEALINGWITHBOTH)#42AND TRANSLATIONOVERCOMINGTHEDIFlCULTIESOFTRANSLATINGLEGAL )#49APPEALS(ENOTEDTHATCOLLOQUIUMPARTICIPANTSARE CONCEPTSFROM%NGLISHINTO"OSNIAN3ERBIAN#ROATIANAND COMMEMORATINGAHORRIlCEPISODEINHUMANHISTORYTHIS &RENCH!NINTERNATIONALCRIMINALDEFENCEBARHASALSO BEINGTHETENTHYEARFOLLOWINGTHEGENOCIDEIN2WANDA BEENESTABLISHEDASWELLASASOLIDLEGALAIDSYSTEM (ECONTINUEDBYOUTLININGTHEIMPORTANTACHIEVEMENTSIN &INALLYTHEREARENOWSTATEOFTHEARTCOURTROOMSASWELL INTERNATIONALCRIMINALPROSECUTION ASADETENTIONFACILITY )THASBEENJUSTOVERYEARSSINCETHE)#49HASBEEN (OWDIDTHISALLCOMEABOUT)N$R(OCKINGSOPINION CREATED)THADBEENTHEDREAMOFINTERNATIONALLAWYERS ITWASDUETOTHECRITICALEFFORTOFKEYINDIVIDUALSSUCH AFTER.UREMBERGAND4OKYOTOCREATEANINTERNATIONAL ASTHE0ROSECUTORTHE2EGISTRARANDTHE0RESIDENTWHO CRIMINALCOURTANDITWASREALISEDWITHTHE)#494HIS REFUSEDTOGIVEUP7ITHINONEYEAROFITSESTABLISHMENT COURTPAVEDTHEWAYFORTHE)#423#3,%AST4IMOR THE)#49HAD2ULESOF0ROCEDUREAND%VIDENCEAN ANDITISHOPED#AMBODIAANDlNALLYTHE)##THElRST ARRESTANDITSlRSTTRIAL4ADIC(OWEVERALLOFTHESE PERMANENTINTERNATIONALCRIMINALCOURT ACCOMPLISHMENTSHAVEINVOLVEDAPROCESSOFLEARNINGAND STRUGGLE "YTHE)#49HADCOMPLETEDONETRIAL4ADICANDIT WASABOUTTOSTARTTHE#ELEBICITRIAL4HETRIBUNALHAD 4HE4ADICTRIALPLAYEDACRITICALROLEINTHEDEVELOPMENT JUDGES.OWITHASJUDGESANDRUNSSIXTRIALSEVERYDAY OFTHE4RIBUNALSINCETRIALSHAVEAMOMENTUMANDITIS INTHREECOURTROOMSONASPLITSHIFT4HOUSANDSOFVICTIMS IMPORTANTTOGETTHEMGOING4HEYARESTILLLEARNINGFROM HAVETESTIlEDANDNEARLYACCUSEDHAVEHADTHEIR TRIALSATTHE)#49ANDITISNOTPOSSIBLETOFORESEEALLTHE PROCESSESCOMPLETED PROBLEMSTHATWILLARISE)TISIMPORTANTTOGETTRIALSSTARTED WITHCOMMITMENTCREATIVITYANDmEXIBILITY 4HE)#49ALSOCREATEDTHElRSTINTERNATIONALCOURTOF CRIMINALAPPEALTHEREHAVINGBEENNOAPPEALSFROMTHE 4HE)#49AND)#42ARECRIMINALCOURTSSETUPWITHINTHE .UREMBERGOR4OKYO4RIBUNALS4HE!PPEALS#HAMBER 5.ADMINISTRATIVESTRUCTURE4HE5.HADNEVEROPERATED HANDLESCASESFROMBOTH)#49AND)#42,ASTYEAR ACRIMINALCOURTBEFORE!NEXAMPLEOFONEISSUETHATHAD ITDELIVEREDWRITTENDECISIONSONTOPICSSUCHAS TOBEOVERCOMEWASTODEALEFFECTIVELYWITHPROTECTED EVIDENCEJURISDICTIONPROCEDUREANDlNALAPPEAL WITNESSES3TATECOOPERATIONISALSOIMPORTANTINMANY JUDGEMENTSFROMJUDGEMENTSOFTHE4RIAL#HAMBERS AREASSUCHASINVESTIGATIONSARRESTSPROSECUTIONS RELOCATINGWITNESSESANDTHEENFORCEMENTOFSENTENCES 4HE)#49DETENTIONUNITWASESTABLISHEDASPARTOFTHE NORMAL$UTCHPRISONIN4HE(AGUE)TISAMODELPRISON WITHEDUCATIONPOSSIBILITIESFACILITIESFOREXERCISEAND MUCHELSE \ !RTICLEOFTHE)#493TATUTEGOVERNSINRELATIONTOTHE /NEFAILINGOFTHE)#49HASBEENTHEFAILURETOREACHOUT SERVICEOFSENTENCE4HETRIBUNALISENTIRELYDEPENDENT TOTHELOCALCOMMUNITY!N/UTREACH0ROGRAMMEHAS ONTHECOOPERATIONOF3TATESTOTAKEITSPRISONERS4HE BEENESTABLISHEDWITH%5FUNDING$R(OCKINGSHAREDAN )#49HASENTEREDINTOAGREEMENTSANDITHASNOTBEEN EXPERIENCEHEHADINRELATIONTOTHE/UTREACHINITIATIVE ANEASYTASK4HE)#49ISASKING3TATESTOTAKEPRISONERS /NEOFTHECRITICISMSOFTHE)#49HADBEENITSFAILURE CONVICTEDOFTHEMOSTSERIOUSCRIMESSUCHASGENOCIDE TOFOLLOWUPWITHWITNESSES/UTREACHANDTHE(ELSINKI CRIMESAGAINSTHUMANITYANDWARCRIMESWITHTHE #OMMITTEESTARTEDAPROGRAMMECALLEDh"RIDGINGTHE ONLYCOMPENSATIONBEINGTHEHONOUROFSERVINGTHE 'APvRELATINGTOTHE#ELEBICITRIAL INTERNATIONALCOMMUNITY 4HECAMPTHATWASATTHECENTREOFTHATTRIALISANHOUR 4HEREAREAGREEMENTSINPLACEALLWITH%UROPEAN ORSOFROM3ARAJEVO"OSNIAN3ERBSWEREHELDTHEREAS COUNTRIES5+$ENMARK'ERMANY3PAIN&RANCE PRISONERSBY"OSNIAN-USLIMFORCES)TWASAHORRIlC 3WEDEN!USTRIA.ORWAY&INLANDAND)TALY PLACE4HEREWEREMURDERSRAPESTORTUREANDVIOLENT ASSAULTSONPRISONERS0ERSONSFROMTHE)#49WHOHAD $OMESTICREGIMESAPPLYWITHRESPECTTOEARLYRELEASE WORKEDONATRIALWENTTOTHEPLACE)TWASCOLDSNOWING WHICHHASTOBEAUTHORISEDBYTHE0RESIDENTOFTHE)#49 ANDTHEHALLWASPACKED-OSTOFTHEVICTIMSHADCOMEIN AFTERCONSULTATIONWITHTHEJUDGES FROM2EPUBLIKA3ERPSKA&ROMAMUNTILPM THE)#49PEOPLESPOKEABOUTTHETRIALBEGINNINGWITHTHE 4WENTYFOURPERSONSHAVEGONETOSERVETHESENTENCESIN LEADINVESTIGATORWHOEXPLAINEDTHEINVESTIGATIONPROCESS PARTICIPATING3TATES4ENHAVECOMPLETEDTHEIRSENTENCES ANDWHYFOURPERSONSWEREINDICTEDWHILEOTHERSWERE &OURTEENARESTILLINDETENTION NOT4HEYMOVEDONTOTHETRIALITSELFSHOWINGTWOHOURS OFTRIALFOOTAGEINTERSPERSEDWITHCOMMENTSFROMTHOSE 0URSUANTTOTHECOMPLETIONSTRATEGYALLINDICTMENTSAT INVOLVED THE)#49MUSTBElNALISEDBY$ECEMBER4HERE AREFUGITIVESSTILLATLARGE4HEREAREABOUTACCUSED )TWASAMOVINGEXPERIENCE$R(OCKINGREMEMBERED INCUSTODYALTHOUGHSOMEAREONPROVISIONALRELEASE PARTICULARLYTHEREACTIONTOTHEVIDEOSHOWNOFTHECAMP )TISESTIMATEDTHATEACHOFTHE3TATESWHICHHAVE 4HREEELDERLYMENSITTINGATTHEFRONTNODDEDAGREEMENT AGREEMENTSWITH)#49MAYBEEXPECTEDTOTAKEONlVE WITHEVERYTHINGTHATWASSAID MOREPRISONERS 4HISWASTHElRSTCHANCEFORTHECOMMUNITYTOSEETHE )TISNOTEASYTOTAKEONTHESEPRISONERSWHOOFTENDO OUTCOMEOFTHETRIALANDTHEAPPEALANDTOKNOWTHE NOTSPEAKTHELANGUAGEOFTHE3TATEINVOLVEDANDWHOSE SENTENCE-OSTPEOPLECANNOTGETTO4HE(AGUETOWATCH FAMILIESAREFARAWAY4HE)#2#ORGANISESVISITSOFFAMILY TRIALS!FTERTHEYTESTIFYWITNESSESDONOTKNOWWHAT ANDFRIENDSTODETAINEDPERSONSBUTTHISISDIFlCULT COMESAFTERWARD4HISEXPERIENCEWASLIKECLOSINGTHE CIRCLEOFTHATTRIAL )#49WILLCLOSEINWITHTHELASTAPPEALS4HEREWILL HAVETOBERESIDUALPOWERSINSOMEBODYTHATWILLBE )NSOMECASESTHE)#49MAYHAVEFAILEDTOMEETTHE CHARGEDTOTAKEOVER4HISWILLREQUIREANAMENDMENTOF NEEDSOFVICTIMSWITNESSESANDCOMMUNITIES4HE THE3TATUTE ALTERNATIVEOFNOTHOLDINGATRIALATALLIN$R(OCKINGS VIEWWASNOTACCEPTABLE 0ARTOFTHECOMPLETIONSTRATEGYISTHEUSEOF2ULEBIS UNDERWHICHLOWANDMIDDLELEVELOFFENDERSAREHANDED BACKTOCOURTSINTHEFORMER9UGOSLAVIA4HEREISALSO ANOBLIGATIONTOHANDOVERTHEGREATEXPERTISETHATTHE )#49HASDEVELOPED$R(OCKINGFEELSTHATTHISISVERY IMPORTANT \ h4HE%NFORCEMENTOF3ENTENCESINTHE)#42vPRESENTEDBY-R,OVEMORE-UNLO -R-UNLOOPENEDBYPOINTINGOUTTHATTHEENFORCEMENT !RTICLEDEALSWITHCOMMUTATIONOFSENTENCEORPARDON OFSENTENCESATTHE)#42ISACHALLENGE4HE)#423TATUTE 4HISMATTERISREFERREDTOTHE0RESIDENTWHOMUST RESTRICTSTHEPOWERSOFTHE4RIBUNAL4HETRIBUNALHASNO CONSULTWITHTHE4RIAL#HAMBERTHATTRIEDTHECASEAND POLICEPOWERNOSOVEREIGNAUTHORITYANDNOTERRITORY OTHERSANDMAKEADECISIONWHICHMUSTALWAYSBEIN WHEREITCOULDTAKECONVICTEDPERSONS5NDERTHEHOST THEINTERESTSOFJUSTICE!GAINAFTERCOMPLETIONWHOWILL AGREEMENTIN4ANZANIAASSOONASAPERSONISCONVICTED PERFORMTHISFUNCTION-R-UNLOBELIEVESTHATTHE)#42 HEMUSTLEAVE4ANZANIAASSOONASPRACTICAL(OWEVER WILLHAVETODESIGNATEABODYTOCARRYONTHISWORK -R-UNLOASKEDhWHERESHOULDTHEYBETAKENv !LSOWITHRESPECTTOENFORCEMENTOFSENTENCESTHEREIS !RTICLEOFTHE)#423TATUTEGOVERNSTHESERVICEOF APROCEDURETOFOLLOWTOGETINTOUCHWITHACOUNTRYFOR SENTENCEANDPROVIDESFORTHESERVICEOFSENTENCEIN APOTENTIALTRANSFER4HE2EGISTRARWHOPROVIDESALLTHE 2WANDAORA3TATEWILLINGTOTAKETHECONVICTEDPERSON INFORMATIONRELATINGTOTHECONVICTEDPERSONMAKESINITIAL 4HEPROBLEMHOWEVERISTHATFEWCOUNTRIESWILLTAKE CONTACTSOTHATTHE3TATECANTAKEANINFORMEDDECISION )#42PRISONERS4HUSFARTHE)#42HASSUCCEEDEDIN )FTHEREISINTERESTTHENACOMPREHENSIVEMEMORANDUM GETTINGONLYSIXCOUNTRIESTOTAKEPRISONERS ISSENTTOTHE0RESIDENTCOVERINGMATTERSSUCHAS INTERNATIONALMINIMUMSTANDARDSSECURITYANDFREEDOM 4HE)#42HASAMODELAGREEMENTWHICHISSUBJECTTO TOMOVEWITHINCELLSEXERCISEFACILITIESANDSOON!LL MODIlCATIONDEPENDINGONTHEPARTICULARCOUNTRY)NORDER THEINFORMATIONONTHEPRISONINCLUDINGTHESITUATIONOF TOMAINTAINMINIMUMINTERNATIONALSTANDARDSTHE4RIBUNAL HISFAMILYHOWMUCHOFHISSENTENCEHASBEENSERVED MAYHAVETOHELPACOUNTRYTOMEETSUCHSTANDARDS ANDSOONISPROVIDEDTOTHE0RESIDENTWHOCONSULTS WITHTHE4RIAL#HAMBER2WANDAISALSOINFORMED4HE !RTICLEALSOSPEAKSABOUTTHERESPONSIBILITIESTHE REQUESTISTHENFORWARDEDTOTHE3TATECONCERNED)FTHERE ACCEPTING3TATEHASANDWHATISEXPECTEDFROMTHE)#42 ISAGREEMENTTHENTHE2EGISTRARANDTHETRANSFERSSIGN 4HE4RIBUNALHASONLYASUPERVISORYCAPACITYWITHTHE ACERTIlCATEMADE)TISALONGCOMPLICATEDPROCESS&OR GOVERNINGLAWBEINGTHATOFTHEHOSTCOUNTRY(OWEVER EXAMPLETHEHEALTHOFTHEACCUSEDISAPOTENTIALOBSTACLE WHOWILLHAVESUPERVISORYPOWERSAFTERTHE)#42S !COUNTRYMAYNOTWANTTOPAYFORTHECAREORCANNOT COMPLETIONSTRATEGYISSUCCESSFULLYCONCLUDEDIN OFFERACELLTHATCONFORMSTOTHENECESSARYSTANDARDS)N SUCHSITUATIONSTHE)#42HASTOASSIST 0ARTICIPANTAND!UDIENCE-EMBER1UESTIONSAND#OMMENTS -R$AVID#RANEOBSERVEDTHAT3#3,WASFACINGTHE -R2OLAND!MOUSSOUGASUPPORTED-R-UNLOS SAMEISSUESONSENTENCEENFORCEMENTTHATWEREBEING COMMENTSWITHRESPECTTOENGAGINGTHE5.4HEMODEL FACEDBY)#49AND)#424HE3#3,LEGISLATIONPROVIDED AGREEMENTTHATTHE/FlCEOF,EGAL!FFAIRS/,!HAD THATASENTENCECOULDBESERVEDIN3IERRA,EONEhOR SENTTO)#42HADBEENAMENDEDSINCEMOST!FRICAN ELSEWHEREv4HEYWEREPUTTINGMUCHEMPHASISON 3TATESWEREUNABLETOMEETTHEREQUIREDSTANDARDS hELSEWHEREvINANEFFORTTOPROTECTPRISONERS AND)#42HADTOMEETCERTAINCOSTS4HE/,!AGREED TOTHEAMENDMENTBUTREFUSEDTHElNANCIALSUPPORT -R#RANECOMMENTEDTHATPARTOFTHE3#3,EXITSTRATEGY 4HE'ENERAL!SSEMBLYAPPROVEDTHE)#42REQUESTAND ADDRESSESWHATTODOWITHRECORDSCONVICTEDPERSONS MADETHEMONEYAVAILABLEBUTTHE/,!OPPOSEDTHE SERVINGSENTENCEANDOTHERMATTERS4HECOURTHAS EXPENDITUREOFTHEMONEYBYTHE)#42ONTHEBASISTHAT THOUGHTABOUTESTABLISHINGARESIDUALOFlCETHATWOULD ITWASNOTCOMPETENTTOSPENDTHEMONEY4HE)#42WAS DEALWITHRECORDSMONITORINDICTEESANDSOON(E BLOCKEDFORTWOYEARSANDONLYNOWHASAUTHORISATION(E SUGGESTEDTHATTHERECOULDBEAh5.WARCRIMESRESIDUAL CONCLUDEDTHATTHELONGTERMlNANCIALOBLIGATIONOFTHE OFlCEvWHEREINDIVIDUALSFROMTHEVARIOUSTRIBUNALS 5.INSENTENCEENFORCEMENTISASERIOUSISSUEFOR!FRICAN WOULDWORKANDWHICHWOULDHAVELIBRARIANSRECORDS COUNTRIES ANDOTHERFACILITIES4HETRIBUNALSOUGHTTOCONSOLIDATEAND WORKTOGETHERTOMAKETHISHAPPEN \ -R3AMUEL!KORIMOPOSEDTHEQUESTION7HATDIDWE -R2OLAND!MOUSSOUGADESCRIBEDTHEISSUERAISED AIMTOACHIEVEINTHEENFORCEMENTOFSENTENCES(E BY.GOGAAShVERYTOUCHYv4HE)#42WASBOUNDBY SPOKEABOUTTWOCRIMINOLOGICALTHEORIESOFPUNISHMENT INTERNATIONALCOVENANTTORESPECTMINIMUMSTANDARDS THECONSEQUENTIALISTTHEORYUNDERWHICHPUNISHMENT 4HEINTERNATIONALCOMMUNITYCOULDONLYHELP2WANDA ISTOLEADTOREFORMOFTHECONVICTANDHISREINTEGRATION TOIMPROVESTANDARDSANDTHEREWASAWAYTOGO(E INSOCIETYANDTHERETRIBUTIVETHEORYUNDERWHICH BELIEVEDASAHEADOFTHE)#42DELEGATIONTO2WANDA REGARDLESSOFTHERESULTPUNISHMENTMUSTOCCUR(E THATMANYOFTHEMINIMUMSTANDARDSWEREBEING SAIDHESUBSCRIBEDTOATHIRDTHEORYWHICHWASAHYBRID ACHIEVED7ITHREGARDTO()6THE)#42WASATTHE 0UNISHMENTSHOULDOCCURBUTSHOULDALSOBRINGABOUT FOREFRONTOFACTIVISMTOBRINGTHEPLIGHTOFVICTIMSIN REFORMANDLEADTOREINTEGRATION(EASKEDIFPARTICIPANTS 2WANDATOATTENTION4HE2EGISTRYHADPUTFORWARDA AGREEDWITHTHENEEDFORTHISTHIRDCATEGORY)TWOULD PROGRAMMETOHELPWITNESSESWITH()64HEYTOOKA ENSUREPUNISHMENTBUTALSOTOREINTEGRATEPERPETRATORS STEPFORWARDCREATINGATEAMWITHAGYNECOLOGISTA INTOTHECOMMUNITY PSYCHOLOGISTANDANURSE4HE)#42TRIEDTOGIVEEQUAL ASSISTANCETOWITNESSESANDTHEMONEYSPENTON $R*OHN(OCKINGEXPLAINEDTHATATTHE)#49ALLCONVICTED WITNESSESWASFARHIGHERTHANTHATSPENTONTHEACCUSED PERSONSSERVETHEIRTIMEINWESTERN%UROPEANPRISONS ALLOFWHICHHADPROVISIONSFOREARLYRELEASE4HEGENERAL -R"ERNARD-UNARAISEDACONCERNABOUTTHEPOLICY RULEWASTHATRELEASEWOULDOCCURAFTERTWOTHIRDSOFTHE OFREMISSIONOFSENTENCEWHICHSEEMEDTOHIMTOBE SENTENCEWASSERVED!LLPRISONERSCAMEBACKTOTHE ALMOSTAUTOMATICATTHE)#49(ESUGGESTEDTHERESHOULD 0RESIDENTWHENTHEYHITTHETWOTHIRDSMARK)TWASPRETTY BEANADDITIONALELEMENTCONCERNINGTHECONDUCTAND MUCHOFAGIVENTHATTHEYGOTOUTANEARLYRELEASE RECOGNITIONBYTHEPRISONERREPENTANCEABOUTTHE WRONGDONETOSOCIETY3OMEPRISONERSCOULDGOBACK -R-ARTIN.GOGAASKEDIFTHEMINIMUMSTANDARDSWERE TOTHEIRPARTICULARCOMMUNITYASHEROESHAVINGSPENT WRITTENDOWN&OREXAMPLEIN2WANDASNEGOTIATIONS TIMEINPRISONINDEFENCEOFTHEIRGROUP)TWOULDNOTHELP WITH)#42THE4RIBUNALSEEMEDTOBESETTINGITSOWN RECONCILIATIONTOGIVEONETHIRDREMISSIONOFSENTENCEAND STANDARDS)FTHESTANDARDSKEPTCHANGINGCOULDTHEYBE THENHAVETHEPERSONGOBACKASAHERO4HEPRISONERHAD APPLIEDEQUALLY(EALSORAISEDTHEQUESTIONOFHOWTHE TOACCEPTTHEREALITYOFWHATHEDID4HEREWASANEED ENFORCEMENTOFSENTENCESWASADVANCINGTHEGOALOF TOASSESSTHEATTITUDEOFTHEPRISONERSOTHATHEDIDNOT RECONCILIATIONIFTHECIRCUMSTANCESOFAN)#42CONVICTED AGGRAVATETHESITUATIONUPONHISRETURNTOSOCIETY PERSONWERETOBEDIFFERENTNOTONLYFROMTHOSEOF FELLOWPRISONERSIN2WANDABUTFROMTHOSEOFORDINARY $R(OCKINGAGREEDWITH-R-UNASPOINTEXPLAINING LAWABIDINGCITIZENS(EALSORAISEDTHEQUESTIONSABOUT THATTHEREWASNOTANAUTOMATICGRANTINGOFEARLYRELEASE STANDARDSFORVICTIMS0RISONERSWITH()6RECEIVECARE ALTHOUGHTHISMIGHTBESOINPRACTICE4HEPROCEDUREWAS WHILETHEIRVICTIMSARELEFTTODIE(EASKEDh(OWDID COMPLEX"EHAVIOURINDETENTIONDIDCOUNT(OWEVERTHE THISADVANCERECONCILIATIONv!LTHOUGHHERECOGNISES ISSUEOFREPENTANCEWASNOTTAKENINTOCONSIDERATIONAS THATTHEYCANNOTNECESSARILYPROVIDESIMILARCONDITIONS THISWASNOTTHEDOMAINOFTHE)#49 FORVICTIMS-R.GOGABELIEVEDTHATTHEYSHOULDHAVEA MINIMUMPOLICYFORSURVIVORS (ON*UDGE.AVANETHEM0ILLAYASKEDIF3TATESWOULD ACCEPTTHOSEWHOWEREACQUITTED3HEALSOASKEDIFTHE -R#RANESAIDTHISWASALSOCHALLENGEINTHE3#3,-ANY PLACEOFSERVICEOFSENTENCElGUREDONPLEABARGAINING THOUGHTTHATCONVICTEDPERSONSSHOULDBEEXECUTED4HIS WASNOTTHEINTERNATIONALSTANDARDBUTONEHADTOBE RESPECTFULTOTHELOCALCOMMUNITYWHILEEXPLAININGTHAT EXECUTIONWASNOTTHEINTERNATIONALSTANDARDANDTHAT THERULEOFLAWWASMOREPOWERFULTHANTHERULEOFTHE GUN7ITHREGARDTOVICTIMASSISTANCEHEAGREEDTHATIS NECESSARYBECAUSEIFTHISWEREMISSINGFROMTHEPROCESS VICTIMSWOULDBEREVICTIMISED4HOSEACCUSEDINTHE 3#3,WERELIVINGQUITEWELL7HEREASANORDINARYPERSON MIGHTEATJUSTONEMEALADAYDETAINEESRECEIVEFOUR 4HISBOTHEREDPEOPLEIN3IERRA,EONE \ $R(OCKINGSRESPONDEDNOTINGTHATBOTHTHE4RIAL -R!MOUSSOUGAADDEDTHATTHEISSUEOF3TATESACCEPTING #HAMBERSANDTHE!PPEALS#HAMBERHAVEACQUITTED ACQUITTEDPERSONSISTHEKEYCHALLENGEFACEDBYTHE)#42 SOMEPERSONSATTHE)#49!LTHOUGHITWASUNCLEARIF THATISNOTADDRESSEDINTHE3TATUTEORBYTHEINTERNATIONAL THEREAREPROBLEMSATA3TATELEVELITISVERYPOSSIBLE COMMUNITY!CQUITTEDPERSONSWEREUSUALLYREFUGEES THATTHEREWOULDBEPROBLEMSINTHELOCALCOMMUNITY&OR WITHNODOCUMENTATION#ONVICTEDPERSONSWHOHAVE EXAMPLE"LASKICSSENTENCEOFYEARSWASREDUCED SERVEDTHEIRSENTENCESBECAMEQUASISTATELESS-OSTOF TONINEYEARSONAPPEALANDHEGOTEARLYRELEASEALMOST THEMDONOTWANTTOGOBACKTO2WANDA IMMEDIATELY(EWENTBACKTOVISITTHEAREASWHERE THECRIMESHADBEENCOMMITTEDSAYINGHEWISHEDTO APOLOGISE(EWASRECEIVEDWITHVERYhMIXEDvFEELINGS 7ITHREGARDTO*UDGE0ILLAYSSECONDQUESTIONANDTHE )#49PLEABARGAININGWASANISSUEBETWEENONLYTHE PROSECUTIONANDTHEACCUSED4HE2EGISTRYWHICHWAS NOTINVOLVEDWASSOLELYRESPONSIBLEFORTRANSFERRING PRISONERSTO3TATES3INCETHE2EGISTRYHADNOCONTACT WITHTHE0ROSECUTIONONTHEPLACEOFSERVICEOFSENTENCE ITWASNOTPARTOFPLEADISCUSSION \ #HALLENGESOFTHE!DMINISTRATIONOF)NTERNATIONAL#RIMINAL4RIBUNALS\ -ODERATOR -R$AVID#RANE0ROSECUTOR3#3, 0RESENTERS (ON*UDGE%RIK-SE0RESIDENT)#42-R!DAMA$IENG2EGISTRAR)#42-R-ARTIN.GOGA$EPUTY0ROSECUTOR 'ENERAL2WANDAN'OVERNMENTAND-R,UIS-ORENO/CAMPO0ROSECUTOR)## h4HE)NDEPENDENCEOFTHE*UDICIAL/RGANOFTHE4RIBUNALvPRESENTEDBY(ON*UDGE%RIK-SE *UDGE-SEBEGANHISPRESENTATIONBYNOTINGTHAT ANDIMPARTIALTRIBUNALESTABLISHEDBYLAWv(ENOTEDTHAT SOMEMIGHTlNDhINDEPENDENCEOFTHEJUDICIALORGANv ITHASALWAYSBEENTHEINTENTIONTHATTHEJUDICIALBRANCH TOBEANUNNECESSARYTOPICFORDISCUSSION)SNOTTHE BEINDEPENDENT4HISFOLLOWSFROM5.HUMANRIGHTS INDEPENDENCEOFTHEJUDICIARYASELFEVIDENTPRINCIPLE)T CONVENTIONS!RTICLEOFTHECOVENANTGENERALCOMMENT ISSTATEDINALLHUMANRIGHTSCONVENTIONSANDALMOSTALL OFTHEHUMANRIGHTSCOMMITTEEANDALLTHEBASIC CONSTITUTIONS*UDGE-SEPRESENTEDTHREEEXPLANATIONS PRINCIPLESONTHEINDEPENDENCEOFTHEJUDICIARY FORWHYTHISTOPICWARRANTSDISCUSSION4HElRSTISTHAT EVENIFTHEIDEAISOLDITSIMPLEMENTATIONHASTOBE )N0ROSECUTORV+ANYABASHITHE!PPEALS#HAMBER STEADFASTLYCONTINUED4HEREISTHECONTINUOUSTASKOF FOUNDTHATTHEACCUSEDHASTHERIGHTTOBETRIEDBY MAKINGSURETHATINDEPENDENCEISSAFEGUARDEDINTHE ANINDEPENDENTANDIMPARTIALTRIBUNAL4HE!PPEALS DAILYACTIVITIESOFANYCOURT4HESECONDREASONISTHATTHE #HAMBERDISTINGUISHEDBETWEENTHECONCEPTOFJUDICIAL CHALLENGESFORANINTERNATIONALCOURTMAYWELLBEDIFFERENT INDEPENDENCEANDTHECONCEPTOFIMPARTIALITYSTATING FROMTHECHALLENGESOFANATIONALCOURT4HIRDLYTHERE h)NDEPENDENCECONNOTESFREEDOMFROMEXTERNAL MAYBEDIFFERENCESBETWEENINTERNATIONALTRIBUNALSTHE PRESSURESANDINTERFERENCEx)MPARTIALITYISCHARACTERISED CHALLENGESTOTHEINDEPENDENCEOFONEINTERNATIONAL BYOBJECTIVITYINBALANCINGTHELEGITIMATEINTERESTSAT CRIMINALTRIBUNALMAYWELLDIFFERFROMTHESITUATIONIN PLAYx4HETWOCONCEPTSARELINKEDv WHICHANOTHERTRIBUNALISOPERATING 4HISLINKBETWEENINDEPENDENCEANDIMPARTIALITYHAS "EFOREEXAMININGINDEPENDENCEFROMTHEPERSPECTIVEOF OFTENBEENSTRESSEDINHUMANRIGHTSCASELAW3TRASBOURG THE)#42*UDGE-SEEXPLAINEDTHATINDEPENDENCEOF CASESAREAPERFECTEXAMPLE7HENITCOMESTOTHECASE THEJUDICIALORGANCOULDBEDISCERNEDFROMTHETRIPARTITE LAWONTHEJUDICIALINDEPENDENCEANDIMPARTIALITYBYTHE STRUCTUREOFTHETRIBUNALWHICHINCLUDESONEDEPENDENT HUMANRIGHTSORGANSITHASBEENSTRESSEDTHATJUDICIAL ORGANANDTWOINDEPENDENT4HEREGISTRYBASEDIN INDEPENDENCEDESCRIBESANINSTITUTIONALAUTONOMYOF !RUSHAISINTHEHIERARCHYUNDERTHE5.3ECRETARIATAND JUDGES4HEPOINTISSEPARATIONFROMWHATINAMUNICIPAL THEREFOREDEPENDENT4HEBENCHANDTHEPROSECUTORARE LEGALSYSTEMWOULDBECALLEDEXECUTIVEPOWER4HAT INDEPENDENTORGANSCREATEDBYTHE3ECURITY#OUNCILTO CREATESAQUESTIONMARKFORTHOSEATTHE)#42BECAUSE ADHERETOTHEPRINCIPLESOFJUDICIALINDEPENDENCEAND THEYDONOTOPERATEATTHENATIONALLEVELBUTINSTEADAT PROSECUTORIALINDEPENDENCERESPECTIVELY4HETRIPARTITE THEINTERNATIONALLEVEL7HATTHENISTHEEXECUTIVEPOWER STRUCTUREISANECESSARYCONSEQUENCEOFTHEFORMOFTHE INTHEINTERNATIONALCONTEXT$OESITEXISTATALL4HISISA DECISIONTOSETUPTHETRIBUNALNAMELYTHE5.3ECURITY QUESTIONFORCONTEMPLATION #OUNCIL2ESOLUTIONUNDER#HAPTEROFTHE5.#HARTER )MPARTIALITYISASTATEOFMINDREALORPERCEIVEDOFTHE )NTHE)#423TATUTETHEREISNOREFERENCETOTHE JUDGE)TCOMPRISESBOTHOBJECTIVEANDSUBJECTIVEASPECTS INDEPENDENCEOFTHETRIBUNAL4HEREFORETHERIGHTTO /FCOURSETHEOBJECTIVEISWHATAREASONABLEOBSERVER BETRIEDBYANINDEPENDENTTRIBUNALISNOTAMONGSTTHE WOULDUNDERSTAND*UDGE-SENOTEDTHATWHENIT RIGHTSEXPLICITLYMENTIONEDINFOREXAMPLE!RTICLES COMESTOTHEISSUEOFTHEOBJECTIVETESTANDWHATA OR4HISISINSPITEOFTHEFACTTHAT!RTICLEOFTHE REASONABLEOBSERVERMIGHTPERCEIVEITISINTERESTINGIN )#423TATUTEISSOCLOSELYMODELLEDONTHECOVENANT ANINTERNATIONALTRIBUNALBECAUSEPEOPLECOMEFROMSO !RTICLEWHICHSTATESh%VERYONESHALLBEENTITLEDTO MANYDIFFERENTLEGALTRADITIONS.OTINGTHATWITHREGARD AFAIRANDPUBLICHEARINGBYACOMPETENTINDEPENDENT TOINDEPENDENCETHECHALLENGESATTHEINTERNATIONAL \ LEVELAREVERYDIFFERENTFROMTHENATIONALLEVEL*UDGE BOYCOTTORAGROUPBOYCOTTBYALLTHEACCUSEDORBYA -SEREDIRECTEDHISDISCUSSIONFROMAREVIEWOFGENERAL STRIKEONBEHALFOFTHEDEFENCECOUNSELSOMEORALL)T CONCEPTUALISSUETOANDEXAMINATIONOFTHESPECIlC MAYBEARGUEDTHATTHISISATHREATTOTHEINDEPENDENCEOF CHALLENGESFACINGHISTRIBUNAL THEINSTITUTION*UDGE-SENOTEDTHATMUCHDEPENDSON HOWTHE#HAMBERREACTSTOSUCHCHALLENGES)N!RUSHA (ESTARTEDWITHTHEESTABLISHMENTOFTHETRIBUNALASANAD THE#HAMBERSHAVEBEENlRMBUTREASONABLEINTHIS HOCTRIBUNAL4HEFACTTHATATRIBUNALLIKETHE)#49ANDTHE REGARDANDTHEPROCEEDINGSHAVECONTINUED4HEREHAS )#42ISANADHOCTRIBUNALISINITSELFACHALLENGE4HIS NEVERBEENANYACCEPTANCEOFBEINGHELDHOSTAGEWHICH INEVITABLYGIVESRISETOSUSPICION!LLEGATIONSALLOFWHICH COULDBESEENASANISSUEOFLACKOFINDEPENDENCE AREUNTRUEINCLUDEQUESTIONSABOUThVICTORSJUSTICEv ANDTHETRUEPURPOSEOFTHECOURT4HEWHOLENOTIONOF *UDGE-SETHENSPOKEABOUTMANAGEMENT)NA hADHOCvGIVESRISETOQUESTIONSTHATARERELATEDTOTHE NORMALNATIONALCOURTEVERYTHINGmOWSREASONABLYWELL ISSUEOFINDEPENDENCE4HESESUSPICIONSDONOTARISEIN (OWEVERININTERNATIONALANDADHOCSETTINGSTHEREARE ANATIONALCOURTANDPROBABLYARISELESSINATREATYBASED MANYINTERNATIONALPLAYERSANDMULTIPLE3TATESALLHAVING PERMANENTINTERNATIONALCOURT TOCOOPERATE4HUSTHEREAREMOREPOSSIBLEPROBLEMS BOTHEXTERNALANDINTERNAL4HISHASIMPLIEDTHATINORDER 7ITHREGARDTOTHEPERCEPTIONOFIMPARTIALITYTHETRIBUNAL TOSPEEDUPPROCEEDINGSTHEJUDGESMAYHAVETOBEMORE SHOULDBEVISIBLEIN2WANDATOEXPLAINITSMISSION PROACTIVEINTERMSOFPROBLEMRESOLUTIONTHANTHEYWOULD 0ROMOTINGUNDERSTANDINGOFTHE4RIBUNALSWORKCAN BEATTHENATIONALLEVEL7HENAJUDGEBECOMEAPROACTIVE CONTRIBUTETORECONCILIATION4HE2EGISTRYHASDONEAND ADMINISTRATIVEJUDGEFOREXAMPLEGETTINGINTOUCHWITH CONTINUESTODOALOTINCONNECTIONWITHITSOUTREACH ADMINISTRATIVEORFOREIGNAUTHORITIESCANITBEARGUED PROGRAMME4OTHEEXTENTTHEJUDGESGETMOREINVOLVED THATHISINDEPENDENCEISATSTAKE#OULDITBEARGUEDTHAT INTHISPROCESSTHE4RIBUNALWILLHAVEASTRONGERIMPACT THE)#42GETSTOOCLOSETODEPENDENCEONTHEEXECUTIVE (OWEVERASTHEJUDICIALBRANCHGETSMOREINVOLVED ORGANHEREBEINGREPRESENTEDBYOTHER3TATESORBY5. THEREISANINCREASEINTHERISKOFALLEGATIONSWITHREGARD HEADQUARTERS(ISANSWERTOTHISISTHATSUCHALLEGATIONS TOALACKOFINDEPENDENCEANDIMPARTIALITY&OREXAMPLE CARRYLIMITEDWEIGHT INSEVERAL4RIAL#HAMBERJUDGESIN!RUSHAMADE ANINSTITUTIONALVISITTO2WANDAANDMETWITH2WANDAN 4HE2EGISTRYHASTHEMAINRESPONSIBILITYOFTHEBUDGET)T AUTHORITIES)TWASNOTAJUDICIALVISITINCONNECTIONWITH ISACRITICALTOOLFORANYINSTITUTIONNATIONALORINTERNATIONAL APARTICULARCASE3HORTLYTHEREAFTERTHEACCUSEDINTHE 7HENJUDGESAREASKEDTHEYPROVIDEINPUTONTHEBUDGET -EDIACASECHALLENGEDTHEIMPARTIALITYOF*UDGE0ILLAY *UDGESAREUNIQUELYQUALIlEDTOASSESSTHENEEDSOFTHE *UDGE'àNEYAND*UDGE-SEBECAUSETHEYPARTICIPATED TRIALSANDTOOBJECTIVELYWEIGHTHECONCERNSOFALLPARTIES INTHISVISIT7ITHREGARDTOTHEPERCEPTIONOFIMPARTIALITY INTHECOURTROOM3OMEBELIEVETHATTHISCOULDTHATBE THEJUDGESEMPHASISEDTHATEVERYEFFORTHADBEENMADE SEENASGETTINGTOOCLOSETOTHEEXECUTIVEBRANCH*UDGE TOCONDUCTTHEVISITINANOPENANDTRANSPARENTWAY)T -SECONTENDSTHATTHISISNOTTHECASEANDHEHASNEVER WASCONCLUDEDTHATTHEREWEREINSTITUTIONALREASONSFOR EXPERIENCEDITASAPROBLEM THEVISITTHATITWASTRANSPARENTANDTHATTHEREWASNOT BIASONBEHALFOFANYJUDGE)TISCOMPLICATEDBECAUSE *UDGE-SECONCLUDEDHISPRESENTATIONWITHABRIEF INSTITUTIONALJUDICIALVISITSSUCHASTHEONEINTHEEXAMPLE DISCUSSIONONCOMPLETIONSTRATEGIESANDTHEPERCEPTION MAYINCREASETHEUNDERSTANDINGOFTHEROLEOFTHECOURT THATSUCHSTRATEGIESMAYCONSTRAINTHEACTIVITIESOFA THEREBYMAKINGITEASIERFORTHEPROSECUTIONANDTHE TRIBUNAL"OTHADHOCTRIBUNALSHAVEACOMPLETIONSTRATEGY DEFENCETOOBTAINACCESSTOEVIDENCEANDTOWITNESSES ANDTHEQUESTIONARISESWHETHERTHEDEADLINESETBYTHE &URTHERMORESUCHVISITSCANCONTRIBUTETOJUDICIAL 3ECURITY#OUNCILPOSESATHREATTOTHEINDEPENDENCEOFAN INDEPENDENCE(OWEVERITISAVERYPRECARIOUSLINE ADHOC4RIBUNALBYCONSTRAININGITSACTIVITIES*UDGE-SE CONTENDSTHATTHE#HAMBERSWILLCONTINUETOPERFORM \ !NOTHERCHALLENGETHATMAYBEPERCEIVEDASRELATING THEIRFUNCTIONSINACCORDANCEWITHFAIRTRIALPRINCIPLES TOINDEPENDENCEISTHEQUESTIONOFNONAPPEARANCEOF IRRESPECTIVEOFANYDEADLINES)TISMOREAMATTEROFA THEDEFENCEINTHECOURTROOM4HEREHAVEBEENSEVERAL REASONABLEDIVISIONOFWORKBETWEENINTERNATIONALAND DIFFERENTSCENARIOSIN!RUSHAEITHERWITHANINDIVIDUAL NATIONALCRIMINALJUSTICETHANAMATTEROFINDEPENDENCE h4HE#HALLENGESOF!DMINISTRATIONOF)NTERNATIONAL#RIMINAL4RIBUNALSWITH3PECIlC2EFERENCETO)#42v PRESENTEDBY-R!DAMA$IENG -R$IENGBEGANHISPRESENTATIONWITHTHEASSERTION )NCLUDEDINADMINISTRATIONOFTHE4RIBUNALISTHE THATTHEREISAVASTDIFFERENCEBETWEENTHEWORKOFTHE MANAGEMENTOFWITNESSESANDVICTIMS4HISINCLUDES 2EGISTRYINANATIONALJURISDICTIONANDINANINTERNATIONAL BRINGINGWITNESSESANDPROVIDINGSUPPORTFORTHEDEFENCE JURISDICTION"OTHAREVESTEDWITHAMISSIONTOPROVIDE ANDPROSECUTION0ROTECTIVEMEASURESARETAKENFOR THECOURTANDTHELITIGANTSWITHADMINISTRATIVESERVICES VICTIMSANDWITNESSESANDTHE2EGISTRYMUSTPROVIDE THATARENECESSARYFORTHEFAIRANDPROMPTRESOLUTIONOF RELEVANTPHYSICALANDPSYCHOLOGICALSUPPORTINCLUDINGFOR CASES(OWEVERTHEREALDIFFERENCELIESINTHELACKOF RAPEVICTIMSASWELLASSUPPORTANDPROTECTIONFORLIFE APREEXISTINGADMINISTRATIVEAPPARATUSAGAINSTWHICH FAMILYANDPROPERTY INTERNATIONALJURISDICTIONMAYLEANBACKTOENSURETHEIR EFlCIENCY 4HEOTHERIMPORTANTASPECTOFTHE2EGISTRYSWORKISTHE MEDICALANDPSYCHOLOGICALSUPPORTTHATITPROVIDES)T 4HE2EGISTRYPROVIDESIMPARTIALFAIRANDTRANSPARENT FACILITATESACCESSTOEXTERNALMEDICALCAREANDPAYMENT SUPPORTTOALLPARTIESHARNESSINGINTERNATIONALPOLITICAL OFRELATEDBILLSANDPROVIDESINHOUSEMEDICALCARE ANDlNANCIALSUPPORT4HEROLEOFTHE2EGISTRYIS $URINGTHEGENOCIDEMANYWERERAPEDANDARENOW ALSOTOPROVIDELOGISTICALSUPPORTINCLUDINGOFlCE INFECTEDWITH()6!)$34HEPROVISIONOFMEDICALAND ACCOMMODATIONSANDHUMANRESOURCES0ROVIDINGHUMAN PSYCHOLOGICALCAREHASRAISEDSERIOUSCONCERNSASTO RESOURCESHASBEENCONTROVERSIALBUTTHE)##WILLNOT HOWFARCANTHE2EGISTRYGOINTOPROVIDINGPHYSICALAND HAVETHISPROBLEMBECAUSEITISCOMPLETELYAUTONOMOUS PSYCHOLOGICALREHABILITATIONUNDER2ULE&OREXAMPLE THE2EGISTRYESTABLISHEDAMEDICALUNITIN+IGALIWITHA 4HE2EGISTRYALSOPROVIDESSERVICING)NNATIONAL PSYCHOLOGISTGYNECOLOGISTANDANURSEPSYCHOLOGIST)T JURISDICTIONShSERVICINGvISUSEDTOREFERTOADMINISTRATIVE ALSOPROVIDES()6!)$3TREATMENT SERVICES(OWEVERINTHEINTERNATIONALSETTINGITMEANS SOMETHINGDIFFERENT4HE2EGISTRYPROVIDESINTERNALAND -R$IENGCONCLUDEDHISPRESENTATIONBYNOTINGTHATTHE EXTERNALCOMMUNICATION)NTERNALLYALLCOMMUNICATIONS 2EGISTRYHASMANYADDITIONALCHALLENGESTOOVERCOME FROMJUDGESANDPARTIESARECHANNELLEDTHROUGHTHE 4HESECHALLENGESAREINTIMATELYLINKEDTOTHE2EGISTRYS 2EGISTRY)TALSOPROVIDESINTERPRETATIONANDTRANSLATIONOF ABILITYTOCARRYOUTITSMANDATE4OADDRESSTHEMTHE PROCEEDINGS%XTERNALLYITKEEPSTHEPUBLICRECORDSAND 2EGISTRYMUSTREMAINIMPARTIALFAIRTRANSPARENTAND DOCUMENTS EFFECTIVEINTHEPROVISIONOFALLNECESSARYSUPPORTTOALL PARTIESINVOLVEDINTHETRIALPROCEEDINGS)TMUSTENLIST 4HE2EGISTRYALSOHANDLESTHEWORKOFPUBLICITYFORTHE SUPPORTTOTHEWORKOFTHE4RIBUNALESTABLISHCONDITIONS 4RIBUNALANDMANAGESITJUDICIALARCHIVESANDRECORDING OFACOOPERATIONFRAMEWORKHARNESSPOLITICALSUPPORT OFPUBLICHEARINGS!NEXTERNALRELATIONSECTIONHASBEEN FROMMEMBER3TATESANDMOBILISElNANCIALRESOURCES ESTABLISHEDTOHANDLERELATIONSWITHMEMBER3TATES &INALLYTHE2EGISTRYMUSTPROMOTEANDPUBLICISETHEWORK INTERNATIONALORGANISATIONSANDNONGOVERNMENTAL OFTHETRIBUNALIN2WANDAINTHE'REAT,AKESREGIONAND GROUPSANDTOSTRENGTHENCOOPERATIONWITHHOSTCOUNTRY THROUGHOUTTHEWORLDTHEREBYCONTRIBUTINGTOTHENATIONAL GOVERNMENT UNITYANDRECONCILIATIONPROCESSIN2WANDA \ h2WANDAYEARSAFTERTHE'ENOCIDE#REATING#ONDITIONSFOR*USTICEAND2ECONCILIATIONvPRESENTEDBY -R-ARTIN.GOGA -R.GOGABEGANHISPRESENTATIONBYDISCUSSINGTHELEGAL ENACTINGALAWTHATCOULDBEUSEDTOPUNISHTHECRIME SITUATIONIN2WANDABEFORETHEGENOCIDE(EDESCRIBED OFGENOCIDE7HETHERITCOULDAPPLYRETROSPECTIVELYWAS 2WANDAASHAVINGASYSTEMOFINSTITUTIONALISEDIMPUNITY ANOTHERQUESTION CREATEDBYAMNESTYLAWS)NMAJORMASSACRES IN2WANDACAUSEDAVERYBIGSECTIONOFTHEPOPULATION )N2WANDAESTABLISHEDASYSTEMTOADDRESSTHE TOmEETHECOUNTRY3OONAFTERINANAMNESTY CRIMESINACLASSICALWAY)TORGANISEDCRIMESOFGENOCIDE LAWWASPASSEDTHATGRANTEDAMNESTYTOEVERYONE ACCORDINGTOTHEFOLLOWINGFOURCATEGORIESPLANNERSAND INVOLVEDINTHEMASSACRES4HEREWASASECOND POSITIONSOFAUTHORITYNOTORIOUSKILLERSSEXUALTORTURE ROUNDOFMASSACRESIN4UTSINATIONALSINTHEHIGHER CRIMESLOOTERSANDOTHERPROPERTYCRIMES3ENTENCES LEARNINGINSTITUTIONSWERETHEMAINTARGETS,IKEBEFORE VARIEDACCORDINGLY ANAMNESTYLAWPASSEDINPARDONINGALLTHAT PARTICIPATEDINTHEVIOLENCEIN4HEREWEREMORE 7ITHDETAINEESINSUFlCIENTEVIDENCEANDPRISON MASSACRESINAFTERTHEINVASIONOF2WANDABYTHE FACILITIESILLEQUIPPEDTODEALWITHSUCHVASTNUMBERSTHE 20&4HOSEACCUSEDOFBEING20&ACCOMPLICESWERE GOVERNMENTHADTOlNDANADDITIONALWAYTOADDRESSTHE TARGETEDTORTUREDANDKILLED)MMEDIATELYFOLLOWINGTHERE CRIMES)NRESPONSEACONFESSIONPROGRAMKNOWNASTHE WASANOTHERAMNESTYLAWTHATPARDONEDEVERYBODYWHO /RGANIC,AWWASESTABLISHED)TALLOWEDFORAREDUCTION HADPARTICIPATED OFSENTENCEANDSUCCESSFULLYYIELDEDTESTIMONIESTHATHAD NOTCOMEOUTBEFORE4HECONFESSIONPROGRAMMEHELPED -R.GOGABELIEVESTHATIFTHEGENOCIDEHADNOT THEPROCESSGOFASTER"YTHEENDOFCASES STOPPEDIN2WANDAWOULDCURRENTLYHAVEANOTHER WERECOMPLETED!LMOSTOFTHEMINVOLVEDGUILTY AMNESTYLAW)NADDITIONTOTHEHISTORYOFAMNESTYLAWS PLEAS4HEREWEREGROUPCONFESSIONSANDTRIALSBECAUSE THEBEHAVIOUROFGOVERNMENTSTOWARDSINTERNATIONAL THEGENOCIDEWASABOUTAGROUPOFPEOPLEATTACKINGONE CONVENTIONSWASALSOANOTHERREmECTIONOFTHELITTLE PERSON)NSOMEINSTANCESTHEREWEREUPTOPEOPLEIN ATTENTIONTHATWASPAIDTOTHEMATTERSOFHUMANRIGHTS ONETRIAL 4HE'ENOCIDE#ONVENTIONOFWASRATIlEDBY 2WANDABUTWITHRESERVATIONSRELATEDTOPUNISHMENT)T !LTHOUGHTHECONFESSIONPROGRAMMEADDRESSED WASLIKESAYINGh7EACCEPTANDAGREETHATGENOCIDEIS CASESTHISWASSTILLASMALLNUMBERINLIGHTOFTHEREALITY ACRIMEBUTITDOESNOTDESERVETOBEPUNISHEDv4HATIS THATTHEREWEREOVERDETAINEESANDMANY CLEARLYONRECORD PERPETRATORSWERESTILLATLARGE4HEREWEREONLY SPECIALISED#HAMBERSINTHE2WANDA4RIBUNALOF&IRST 4HEGENOCIDECRIPPLED2WANDASJUDICIALSECTOR )NSTANCETODEALWITHDETAINEES!GAINTO "EFORETHEGENOCIDE2WANDAONLYHADMAGISTRATES ADDRESSTHEHUGENUMBERSTHEGOVERNMENTDECIDED PROSECUTORSANDSUPPORTSTAFF!PPOINTMENT TOPROVISIONALLYRELEASEDETAINEESWHOWERE TOTHEJUDICIALSECTORWHETHERASAMAGISTRATEORA EITHERELDERLYORSICK)TWASACONTROVERSIALDECISION PROSECUTORDIDNOTREQUIRELEGALTRAINING4HEREFORE AMONGSURVIVORS(OWEVERSINCETHEREISNOSTATUTEOF OFTHOSEINTHEJUDICIALSYSTEMWEREUNTRAINED!FTER LIMITATIONSONTHESECRIMESTHEGOVERNMENTRETAINSTHE THEGENOCIDE2WANDAFACEDALACKOFHUMANRESOURCES RIGHTTOPROSECUTEATALATERDATE INTWOREGARDS&IRSTONLYMAGISTRATESAND PROSECUTORSSURVIVEDTHEGENOCIDE3ECONDTHEMAJORITY "ECAUSEOFTHEHUGENUMBERSTHATCLASSICALCRIMINALLAW OFTHOSEWHODIDSURVIVEWERENEVERPROPERLYTRAINED)N SYSTEMCOULDNOTADDRESSTHEENORMITYOFTHESITUATION RESPONSETHEGOVERNMENTPROVIDEDTHEMAGISTRATES IN2WANDA)NRESPONSETHEGOVERNMENTDECIDEDTOLOOK WITHSIXMONTHSOFTRAINING TOATRADITIONALMEANSOFADDRESSINGCONmICT(ISTORICALLY THE2WANDANCOMMUNITYWOULDHAVEHADTHEIROWNWAY \ 2WANDAALSODIDNOTHAVEALAWTOPUNISHGENOCIDE OFSOLVINGTHECONmICTCALLED'ACACA'ACACAMEANING !LTHOUGH2WANDALOOKEDTOTHEINSTRUMENTSOFRATIlCATION hGRASSvIN+INYARWANDAISATRADITIONALDISPUTERESOLUTION OFTHE'ENOCIDE#ONVENTIONITQUICKLYDISCOVEREDTHAT MECHANISM)TWASMODIlEDTOMEETTHISBIGGERCHALLENGE ITCOULDNOTPUNISHTHECRIMEOFGENOCIDEUNDERTHOSE 4HE2WANDANGOVERNMENTDRAFTED'ACACALAWUSING INSTRUMENTS)NRESPONSETHEGOVERNMENTACTEDQUICKLY CATEGORISATION4HOSEINCATEGORYWENTTO'ACACA %LECTIONSAMONGhPEOPLEOFINTEGRITYvTRADITIONALLYCALLED CAUSEDPROBLEMSESPECIALLYWITHREGARDTORAPE)N INYANGANUGAYOWEREALSOORGANISED4HOSEELECTED RESPONSEPEOPLECANNOLONGEROPENLYSPEAKABOUTTHEIR TOOKPARTINTRAININGPROGRAMSTOPREPAREFOR'ACACA4HE INVOLVEMENTINSEXUALVIOLENCE MASSIVECONFESSIONPROGRAMMESALSOCONTINUED "Y'ACACAWILLBEFULLYOPERATIONALCOUNTRYWIDE )NORDERTOINITIATE'ACACACOUNTRYWIDEITWASSTARTED WITHABODYESTABLISHEDTOOVERSEESENTENCING/RIGINALLY INPHASES0HASEWASLAUNCHEDON*UNE ABRANCHOFTHE3UPREME#OURT'ACACAISNOWAN )TCONTINUEDTOBESETFORTHINSECTORSONEINEACH INDEPENDENTORGAN4HISWASESTABLISHEDAFTERAPROCESS PROVINCE/N.OVEMBERTHEPILOTPROGRAMME OFCONSTITUTIONMAKINGTHATINVOLVEDWIDECONSULTATION WASEXTENDEDTOSECTORS4HEPILOTPROGRAMSWELLED )NADDITIONTO'ACACATHE2WANDANGOVERNMENTISTRYING TOSUSPECTSASTHENUMBERSOFTHOSEWANTING TOINSTITUTIONALISETHERULEOFLAWBYCREATINGINSTITUTIONS TOCONFESSIN'ACACAGREW4OADDRESSTHISGROWTHA ANDLEGALSTRUCTURESSUCHASTHENEWCONSTITUTIONTHE CATEGORYWITHINCATEGORYCRIMESWASDEVELOPED!S #OMMISSIONOF5NITYAND2ECONCILIATIONSOLIDARITYCAMPS THEPROCESSUNFOLDEDAMENDMENTSWEREMADETOTHE ANDTHE(UMAN2IGHTS#OMMISSION LAW&OREXAMPLETHEFRANKNATUREOFTHECONFESSIONS h#URRENT)SSUESAND$EVELOPMENTIN)NTERNATIONAL#RIMINAL*USTICEhPRESENTEDBY-R,UIS-ORENO/CAMPO -R/CAMPORAISEDTHEFOLLOWINGQUESTIONATTHEONSET $IPLOMATICALLIANCESMUSTBEESTABLISHEDEVENWHILEONE OFHISPRESENTATIONh(OWCANWEHARMONISELEGAL MAINTAINSINDEPENDENCEASAPROSECUTOR)TISIMPORTANT STANDARDSv(EADDEDTHATTHISISSUECOULDONLYBE TOCOOPERATEWITHCOUNTRIESBYFOREXAMPLEGETTING ANSWEREDBYUNDERSTANDINGTHESTANDARDSFORTHECOURT NATIONALREFERRALS)NTHE)##ASEPARATEJURISDICTION ANDFORTHEPROSECUTOR,ATERINHISPRESENTATIONHE COMPLEMENTARITYANDCOOPERATIONHAVEBEENDEVELOPED ASSERTEDTHENEEDFORINDEPENDENCEANDCOOPERATION TOUNDERTAKEDIPLOMACY4HEDIVISIONASSESSESHOWAN WITHREGARDTOTHESESTANDARDS INSTITUTIONISWORKINGDECIDESWHENACOUNTRYISUNABLEOR UNWILLINGTOADDRESSASITUATIONLEARNSHOWTHEJUDICIARY 4OFULlLITSMISSIONTHE)##WILLHAVETOBEmEXIBLEAND ANDPOLICEAREWORKINGANDLEARNSTHEARMYISCONTROLLING COOPERATE)TISNOTAWORLDSUPREMECOURT)TEXISTS THETERRITORY TOHELPCOUNTRIESANDLOCALAUTHORITIESTODOTHEIRJOBS 4HE)##ISTHEGLOBALTESTTOAPPLYINTERNATIONALCRIMINAL 4OSUCCESSFULLYBEGLOBALINTERNATIONALJUSTICEMUST LAW)TMUSTBEUNDERSTOODTHATTHE)##ISWORKINGINAN REMAINSMALLANDLIMITED4HE)##HELPSGOVERNMENTS ENVIRONMENTTHATEMBRACES3TATESOVEREIGNTY BUTDOESNOTREPLACEGOVERNMENTS"YDOINGONLYAFEW CASESTHE)##DEMONSTRATESTHATITISNOTINCHARGEOF -R/CAMPOASSERTEDTHATALTHOUGHINDEPENDENCEIS EVERYTHINGTHEREBYMAKINGITCLEARTHATISNOTREPLACING OBVIOUSLYCRITICALFORTHEOPERATIONSOFTHECOURTITALSO NATIONALJUSTICESYSTEMS POSESAVERYREALPROBLEM0ROSECUTORSANDINVESTIGATORS MUSTDOTHEIRJOBSINANINANINDEPENDENTWAY(OWEVER !MISSIONOFTHE)##ISTOHELP3TATESAGREETOTHE TOACHIEVEITSGOALSTHECOURTMUSTSIMULTANEOUSLYBE GLOBALJUSTICESYSTEM4HISISACHALLENGEBECAUSEITIS INTERDEPENDENT(OWTOBEINTERDEPENDENTINSIDETHE ESSENTIALLYEXPORTINGTHEIDEAOFACRIMINALJUSTICESYSTEM STANDARDSOFTHEPROSECUTORWITHREGARDTOINDEPENDENCE FROMANATIONALTOAGLOBALSYSTEM(OWEVERUNLIKEIN ISACHALLENGETHATMUSTBEMASTERED(EOUTLINEDTHE THENATIONALSYSTEMTHEGLOBALSYSTEMDOESNOTHAVEA FOLLOWINGCHALLENGESANDWAYSTOACHIEVESUCCESS GOVERNMENTBECAUSETHEREISNO3TATE4HISCOMPLETELY CHANGESTHECRIMINALJUSTICESYSTEM7HEREASANATIONAL #OMPLEMENTARITYSHOULDBEENPERCEIVEDASANASSETNOT CRIMINALJUSTICESYSTEMISBASEDONCOMMANDANDCONTROL ARESTRICTION(YBRIDSANDALTERNATIVEWAYSOFADDRESSING THEGLOBALCRIMINALSYSTEMISBASEDONAGREEMENTANDCO CONmICTSHOULDBEENCOURAGED&OREXAMPLEAHYBRID OPERATION4HE)##WILLHAVETOLOOKTOOTHERCOURTSAGAIN TRIBUNALFOR3IERRA,EONEWASINLINEWITHTHEGOALOFTHE DEPENDINGONCOOPERATIONINORDERTOLEARNHOWTOBEST )##TONOTHAVECASES&ORTHE)##TOBEWITHOUTCASES FACETHISCHALLENGE WOULDMEANTHATEITHERTHEREISNOGENOCIDEORTHATTHE NATIONALSYSTEMSORTHEINTERNATIONALCOMMUNITYHAS CREATEDASOLUTIONTOTHEPROBLEM \ )NAGLOBALSYSTEMLITIGATIONMUSTBEFOCUSED -R/CAMPOCONCLUDEDBYRETURNINGTOTHENEEDFOR 4HEREFOREONLYTHOSEWHOBEARTHEGREATEST INCREASEDCOOPERATIONANDEXCHANGEOFINFORMATIONBETWEEN RESPONSIBILITYSHOULDBEPROSECUTED!SYSTEMTO INTERNATIONALCOURTSTOCREATEAGLOBALJUSTICESYSTEM4HIS ADDRESSTHISHASBEENDEVELOPED)TBEGINSWITHAN ISWHYHEPROPOSEDASTRATEGYFORTHE)##THATISBOTHVERY ANALYSISOFONLYTHEGRAVESTCRIMESANDTHENPROGRESSES OPENANDmEXIBLE.OTONLYWILLCOURTSLEARNFROMEACH 4HENTHEGROUPSCOMMITTINGTHEGRAVESTCRIMESARE OTHERSEXPERIENCESBUTALSOWITHANEFFECTIVEEXCHANGE IDENTIlEDASARETHEMOSTDANGEROUSINDIVIDUALSIN OFINFORMATIONCOURTSWILLHAVEANINCREASEDAWARENESSOF THESEGROUPS POLICIESANDACTIVITIESINOTHERCOUNTRIES&OREXAMPLETHE ARMSDEALERSWHOAREINVOLVEDINMASSACRESIN3IERRA,EONE AREPROBABLYDOINGBUSINESSINOTHERSITUATIONS 0ARTICIPANTAND!UDIENCE-EMBER1UESTIONSAND#OMMENTS -S"ARBARA-ULVANEY)#423ENIOR4RIAL!TTORNEYAGREED (ON*UDGE%RIK-SE)#420RESIDENTRESPONDEDTO WITHTHENEEDFORINCREASEDCOOPERATIONNOTINGTHAT COMMENTSMADEABOUTJUDICIALADMINISTRATIVEACTIVISM(E CURRENTLYTHEREISNOTEVENCOOPERATIONONLOGISTICS&OR NOTEDTHATITISSUBSIDIARYANDONLYCOMESINTOPLAYWHEN EXAMPLEGETTINGWITNESSESTOCOMETO!RUSHAANDTESTIFY THEREISBOTHADEADLOCKANDAPURPOSEOFBEINGEFlCIENT)T CANBEACHALLENGEBECAUSETHEREISNOUNIFORMSYSTEM ISAREMEDYTHATSHOULDBEAPPLICABLETOBOTHPARTIES 3HEAGREEDTHATGLOBALSTANDARDSPULLEDFROMVARIOUS TRADITIONSANDMUTUALLYAGREEDUPONMUSTBESETFORTHE -R#HARLES!DEOGUN0HILIPS)#423ENIOR4RIAL!TTORNEY )##TOOPERATEEFFECTIVELY ASKEDFORCLARIlCATIONON2WANDASMOTIVATIONTORECLASSIFY RAPEASA#ATEGORYOFFENCEWHENITWASORIGINALLYIN -R"ERNARD-UNA&ORMER$EPUTY0ROSECUTOR)#42 CATEGORISEDAS#ATEGORYUNDERTHE/RGANIC,AW EXPRESSEDHISCONCERNWITHTHETERMhGLOBALSTANDARDSv BECAUSEMANYDIFFERENTSOCIETIESWITHDIFFERENTBELIEFS -R-ARTIN.GOGA$EPUTY0ROSECUTOR'ENERAL2WANDAN ANDTRADITIONSAREINVOLVED)NSTEADHEARGUEDTHE 'OVERNMENTRESPONDEDBYEXPLAININGTHATTHEREWAS INTERNATIONALJUSTICESYSTEMSHOULDMOVETOWARDSASET EXISTINGJURISPRUDENCEFROMTHE)#42THATCLEARLYSTATED OFGLOBALVALUES4HESECOULDBEUSEDASAREFERENCEFOR THATRAPEISATOOLOFGENOCIDE)TWASAFUNDAMENTALERROR SOCIETIESASTHEYCREATETHEIROWNSTANDARDS TOHAVEEVERPLACEDTHECRIMEOFRAPEIN#ATEGORY4HE GOVERNMENTREALISEDTHATITWASUNDERMININGRAPEVICTIMS -R/CAMPORESPONDEDBYSUPPORTINGHISINITIAL BYPLACINGTHECRIMEIN#ATEGORY-R.GOGAALSO COMMENTSASSERTINGTHAThGLOBALVALUESvARENOTENOUGH BELIEVEDTHATINITIALLYTHEGOVERNMENTDIDNOTREALISEHOW 4HE)##NEEDShGLOBALSTANDARDSvBECAUSEhGLOBAL WIDESPREADTHECRIMEHADBEEN&URTHERMORETHEREWAS STANDARDSvIMPLIESAGREEMENT4HECOURTHASTORESPECT ALSOALOTOFPRESSUREFROM.'/SANDVARIOUSWOMENS UNDERSTANDANDLEARNFROMDIFFERENTTRADITIONS"YlNDING ORGANISATIONSWHICHAREVERYPOWERFULIN2WANDA4HE AWAYTODEVELOPACOMMONORGLOBALSTANDARDTHE)## NATIONHASTHELARGESTNUMBEROFWOMENINPARLIAMENT DEMONSTRATESTHATISITNOTJUSTA7ESTERNCOURT-ANY !LTHOUGHTHEGOVERNMENTCOULDNOTRESISTTHATPRESSURE PANELLISTSREITERATEDTHENEEDTOSTAYFOCUSED)TWAS ITALSOUNDERSTOODTHEMERITOFMAKINGRAPEA#ATEGORY NOTEDTHATTHISISALSONECESSARYTOPREVENTBECOMING CRIMEANDSOTHEAMENDMENTWASMADE OVERWHELMEDBYTHEENORMITYANDMASSNATUREOFTHE CRIMESBEFORETHECOURTS 4HEREWASANINTENSEDISCUSSIONONTHE20&SOLDIERS ANDTHECRIMESTHEYAREALLEGEDTOHAVECOMMITTEDTHE \ (OWEVER-R!DAMA$IENG)#422EGISTRARWAS PHILOSOPHYOFhVICTORSJUSTICEvANDTHESTEPSTAKENBY CONCERNEDWITH-R/CAMPOSASSERTIONTHATLITIGATION THEMILITARYJUSTICESYSTEMIN2WANDA3EVERALPANELLISTS MUSTBEVERYFOCUSEDFEARINGTHATLIMITINGINVESTIGATIONS ALSOCOMMENTEDONTHECOMPROMISESTHATWEREMADE MIGHTPRECLUDERECONSIDERINGACASEWHENNEW IN2WANDATOSTABILISETHESOCIETYANDTHEPROMINENTROLE INFORMATIONISUNCOVERED THAT.'/SPLAYEDINTHEAFTERMATHOFTHEGENOCIDE #ONCLUDING3TATEMENTSOFTHE#OLLOQUIUMBY-R(ASSAN"UBACAR*ALLOW\ 4 HE-ANDATEOFTHE4RIBUNALISTOPROSECUTE APPARENT)TISFORTHISREASONTHAT-R#RANESINVITATION PERSONSRESPONSIBLEFORGENOCIDEANDOTHER TOASSEMBLEINSIXMONTHSIN&REETOWN3IERRA,EONE SERIOUSVIOLATIONSOFINTERNATIONALHUMANITARIANLAW WASWARMLYACCEPTEDANDADOPTEDBYTHEDELEGATES COMMITTEDINTHETERRITORYOF2WANDA4HISCOLLOQUIUM )NADDITION-R*ALLOWEMPHASISEDTHENECESSITYTO COMMEMORATINGTHETHANNIVERSARYOFTHE4RIBUNALS NETWORKANDTOCREATEAFORUMWHEREPROSECUTORSCAN EXISTENCEPROVIDEDAFORUMFORTHEEXCHANGEOFIDEAS REGULARLYCONSULTEACHOTHERINBETWEENEVENTSSUCH ANDINFORMATIONONVARIOUSISSUES)TAFFORDEDARARE ASTHE#OLLOQUIUMWITHAVIEWTOCONTINUOUSLYIMPROVE OPPORTUNITYFORTHE)#42TOHIGHLIGHTITSACHIEVEMENTSAND THISINTERNATIONALCRIMINALJUSTICESYSTEM-R*ALLOWS MOREIMPORTANTLYLEARNFROMITSSETBACKS4HISALLOWED PROPOSALTOSETUPATASKFORCECOMPRISINGSTAFFTOBE FORALLINSTITUTIONSPRESENTTODEVELOPSTRATEGIESTHAT IDENTIlEDBYEACH0ROSECUTORANDWITHTHERESPONSIBILITY WOULDLEADTOAMOREEFFECTIVEANDCONSISTENTAPPROACHIN OFESTABLISHINGABESTPRACTICE0ROGRAMFORINTERNATIONAL THE0ROSECUTIONOF)NTERNATIONAL#RIMES!LLTRIBUNALSHAVE CRIMINALPROSECUTIONWASADOPTED4HISTASKFORCEWILL ACKNOWLEDGEDTHATATTHEIRINCEPTIONTHEYWERESAILING BERESPONSIBLEFORIDENTIFYINGINTERNATIONALSTANDARDSOF UNCHARTEDWATERS4HEVOICEOFINTERNATIONALCRIMINALLAW PRACTICEINTHEAREASOFINVESTIGATIONTRIALPRACTICEAND HADNOTYETBEENDElNED4HE#OLLOQUIUMALLOWEDFOR SPECIALSUBJECTAREASSUCHASVIOLENCEAGAINSTWOMEN ALLPARTIESCONCERNEDTOREDElNEBEARWITNESSTOAND DEPLOYMENTOFMINORSASSOLDIERSANDILLEGALIMPORTATION ENHANCETHEUNDERSTANDINGOFTHEINTERNATIONALCRIMINAL OFWEAPONSTONAMEBUTAFEW LAW 4HEMAJORCHALLENGEAHEADHOWEVERREMAINSFORTHE -R-ORENO/CAMPOINHISKEYNOTEADDRESSQUOTED-R )#49ANDTHE)#42REMAINSTHEPOSITIVECOMPLETIONOF .ELSON-ANDELASTATING THEIRMANDATES!S-R2UXTONSUGGESTEDEVERYTHING FROMNOWONMUSTPASSADOUBLETEST)TMUSTBOTH @4HE CHALLENGE FOR THE MODERN PROSECUTOR IS TO CONTRIBUTETOTHEMANDATEANDTHECOMPLETIONSTRATEGY BECOMEALAWYERFORTHEPEOPLE)TISYOURDUTYTO 4HE#OLLOQUIUMDEMONSTRATEDTHATEFFORTSHAVEBEENAND BUILDANEFFECTIVERELATIONSHIPWITHTHECOMMUNITY CONTINUETOBEMADETOFULlLTHEMANDATEANDTOENSURE AND TO ENSURE THAT THE RIGHTS OF THE VICTIMS ARE APOSITIVECOMPLETIONSTRATEGY(OWEVERTHEIMPLICATIONS PROTECTED)TISYOURDUTYTOPROSECUTETHOROUGHLY OFRUSHINGTHEWORKOFTHETRIBUNALSRISKSLEADINGTHE AND EFFECTIVELY ACCORDING TO THE RULE OF LAW AND QUALITYOFPROSECUTIONSASTRAY7HILSTCOMMITTEDTOTHE TO ACT IN A PRINCIPLED WAY WITHOUT FEAR FAVOUR OR DEADLINESSETBYTHE3ECURITY#OUNCILTHISSHOULDNOTBEAT PREJUDICE )T IS YOUR DUTY TO BUILD A PROSECUTION ANYCOST4OOMUCHHASBEENINVESTEDINTHETRIBUNALSTO SERVICE THAT IS AN EFFECTIVE DETERRENCE TO CRIME ALLOWTHEIRMOMENTUMTOBELOST AND IS KNOWN TO DEMONSTRATE GREAT COMPASSION ANDSENSITIVITYTOTHEPEOPLEITSERVES )NHISCLOSINGADDRESS-R*ALLOWTHANKEDTHE&ORD &OUNDATIONAND/PEN3OCIETY)NSTITUTEWHOSESUPPORT 4HE#OLLOQUIUMAFFORDEDTHEOPPORTUNITYTOEXPOUND HADBEENVITALTOTHE#OLLOQUIUMSINCEPTIONANDSUCCESS ONHOWTOFULlLTHISDUTYANDTHEREBYFULLYACHIEVED 4HElRST#OLLOQUIUMOF)NTERNATIONAL0ROSECUTORS THEOBJECTIVESESPOUSEDINITSPROPOSALTOTHEDONORS CONCLUDEDWITHTHEISSUINGOFAUNANIMOUSDECLARATION &ACEDWITHVARIOUSCONSTRAINTSANDTHEFULlLMENTOFA FROMALL)NTERNATIONAL0ROSECUTORSREAFlRMINGTHEIR COMPLETIONSTRATEGYITWASREAFlRMEDTHATTHETRIBUNALS COMMITMENTTOENDIMPUNITYFORTHEMOSTSERIOUSCRIMES MUSTNOTNEGLECTTHEIRDUTYTOTHEVICTIMS4HENEED THATPLAGUEHUMANKINDANDTOCONTRIBUTETOPEACEAND TOSHARECOMMONEXPERIENCESFEARSANDCONCERNSIN THEPREVENTIONOFFUTURECRIMES ACCOMPLISHINGTHISTREMENDOUSTASKBECOMESEVENMORE \ !PPENDICES\ !PPENDIX!,ISTOF0ARTICIPANTS !$ELEGATES "3PECIAL'UESTS s-R*USTICE(ASSAN"*ALLOW0ROSECUTOR)NTERNATIONAL s(ON*UDGE%RIK-SE0RESIDENT)NTERNATIONAL#RIMINAL #RIMINAL4RIBUNALFOR2WANDA 4RIBUNALFOR2WANDA s-R,UIS-ORENO/CAMPO0ROSECUTOR)NTERNATIONAL s(ON*UDGE!NDRESIA6AZ6ICE0RESIDENT)NTERNATIONAL #RIMINAL#OURT #RIMINAL4RIBUNALFOR2WANDA s-R$AVID#RANE0ROSECUTOR3PECIAL#OURTFOR3IERRA,EONE s(ON*UDGE.AVANETHEM0ILLAY!PPEALS*UDGE s$R3ILAS2AMAITE.ATIONAL$IRECTOROF0UBLIC )NTERNATIONAL#RIMINAL#OURT 0ROSECUTIONOF3OUTH!FRICA s-R!DAMA$IENG2EGISTRAR)NTERNATIONAL#RIMINAL s-R-ARTIN.GOGA$EPUTY0ROSECUTOR'ENERALOF2WANDA 4RIBUNALFOR2WANDA s-S&ATOU"ENSOUDA$EPUTY0ROSECUTOR0ROSECUTIONS )NTERNATIONAL#RIMINAL#OURT s-R3ERGE"RAMMERTZ$EPUTY0ROSECUTOR )NVESTIGATIONS)NTERNATIONAL#RIMINAL#OURT s-R"ERNARD-UNA"ARRISTERFORMER$EPUTY0ROSECUTOR )NTERNATIONAL#RIMINAL4RIBUNALFOR2WANDA s$R,EIGH3WIGART!SSOCIATE$IRECTOR)NTERNATIONAL #ENTERFOR%THICS*USTICEAND0UBLIC,IFE"RANDEIS 5NIVERSITY53! s-R'AVIN2UXTON#HIEFOF0ROSECUTIONS)NTERNATIONAL #RIMINAL4RIBUNALFOR&ORMER9UGOSLAVIA s-R+EN&LEMING1#"ARRISTERFORMER3ENIOR4RIAL 3IERRA,EONE s-R!LUTE-UGHWAI$EPUTYST3ECRETARYREPRESENTING -R"AHAME4OM.YANDUNGA0RESIDENT4ANGANYIKA s$R-ICHAEL"OHLANDER0ROFESSOROF,AW5NIVERSITYOF ,AW3OCIETY $URHAM s-S!LICE.AYEBARE,EGAL/FlCER%AST!FRICAN,AW s$R!LAN7HITE#HIEFOF)NVESTIGATIONS3PECIAL#OURTFOR 3OCIETY 3IERRA,EONE s-RS3YBILLE$ECARTIER"ELGIUM%MBASSY+IGALI s-S"INAIFER.OWROJEE,ECTURER(ARVARD,AW3CHOOL s-S3USANA3ACUTO$IRECTOR7AR#RIMES2ESEARCH AND3ENIOR2ESEARCHER(UMAN2IGHTS7ATCH s$R*OHN&REDERICK(OCKING$EPUTY2EGISTRAR !TTORNEY)NTERNATIONAL#RIMINAL4RIBUNALFOR2WANDA s-R,UC#OTÏ#HIEFOF0ROSECUTIONS3PECIAL#OURTFOR /FlCEAND0ROFESSORIAL,ECTURER7ASHINGTON#OLLEGEOF ,AW )NTERNATIONAL#RIMINAL4RIBUNALFOR&ORMER9UGOSLAVIA s-R!UGUSTINO3HIOREPRESENTING-R!NDREW#HENGE s-R,OVEMORE-UNLO$EPUTY2EGISTRAR)NTERNATIONAL !TTORNEY'ENERALOF5NITED2EPUBLICOF4ANZANIA #RIMINAL4RIBUNALFOR2WANDA s0ROF9EMI/SINBAJO!TTORNEY'ENERAL,AGOS3TATE s-R2OLAND!MOUSSOUGA#HIEFOF%XTERNAL2ELATIONS .IGERIA AND3TRATEGIC0LANNING3ECTION)NTERNATIONAL#RIMINAL s-S2UTH+OK$EPARTMENTOF#RIMINAL,AW3CHOOLOF 4RIBUNALFOR2WANDA s-S3IMON-ONASEBIAN0RINCIPAL$EFENDER3PECIAL s!DVOCATE,EONARD-C#ARTHY(EAD$IRECTORATEOF 3PECIAL/PERATIONS3OUTH!FRICA ,AW5NIVERSITYOF!MSTERDAM #OURTOF3IERRA,EONE \ #/BSERVERS s-R9VES3OROKOBI3POKESPERSON)NTERNATIONAL#RIMINAL #OURT s-R2ETY(AMULI0RESIDENTOFTHE!SSOCIATIONOF $EFENCE#OUNCIL)#42 $3TAFFOFTHE/FlCEOFTHE0ROSECUTOR)#42 s-R*USTICE(ASSAN"UBACAR*ALLOW0ROSECUTOR s-R3TEWART*AMES3ENIOR!PPEALS#OUNSEL s-S7ERRETT-ELANIE#HIEFOF0ROSECUTIONS s-S7ARREN-ARIA(EAD)NFORMATIONAND%VIDENCE s-R2ENAUD2ICHARD#HIEFOF)NVESTIGATIONS s$R!LEX/BOTE/DORA3PECIAL!SSISTANTTOTHE 3UPPORT3ECTION s-R7EBSTER$ON3ENIOR4RIAL!TTORNEY 0ROSECUTOR s-R7ALLACE+APAYA3ENIOR4RIAL!TTORNEY s-R!DEOGUN0HILIPS#HARLES3ENIOR4RIAL!TTORNEY s-R6AN!LPHONSE3ENIOR4RIAL!TTORNEY s-R!KORIMO3AMUEL#OMMANDER)NVESTIGATIONS s-S!DELAIDE7HEST4RIAL!TTORNEY s-S!RBIA3ILVANA3ENIOR4RIAL!TTORNEY s-S(OLO-AKWAIA4RIAL!TTORNEY s-R"A#IRE!LI3ENIOR4RIAL!TTORNEY s-R*USTUS"WONWONGA4RIAL!TTORNEY s-R%GBE7ILLIAM3ENIOR4RIAL!TTORNEY s-R#HEIKH4-ARA,EGAL!DVISOR s-R+ARYEGESA2ICHARD3ENIOR4RIAL!TTORNEY s-S!MANDA2EICHMAN,EGAL!DVISOR s-R+WENDE!LFRED#OMMANDER)NVESTIGATIONS s-R+HALED2AMADAN,EGAL!DVISOR s-R-OSES*ONATHAN3ENIOR4RIAL!TTORNEY s-S$IOR&ALL3OW,EGAL!DVISOR s-S-ULVANEY"ARBARA3ENIOR4RIAL!TTORNEY s-R(AMIDOU-AIGA)NVESTIGATOR s-R.GARUA0AUL3ENIOR4RIAL!TTORNEY s-R-OHAMMED,EJMI)NVESTIGATOR s-R.KOLE-AXWELL#OMMANDER)NVESTIGATIONS s-S3OLA!DEBOYEJO4RIAL!TTORNEY s-R3TEPHEN2APP3ENIOR4RIAL!TTORNEY \ -R"ERNARD-UNAFORMER$EPUTY0ROSECUTORASSISTED !PPENDIX" BY+ARYEGESA2ICHARD3ENIOR4RIAL!TTORNEY)#42 'UEST%DITORS s,EIGH3WIGART0H$!SSOCIATE$IRECTOR)NTERNATIONAL #ENTERFOR%THICS*USTICEAND0UBLIC,IFE"RANDEIS !PPENDIX# /RGANIZING#OMMITTEE)#42 5NIVERSITY53! s-ELISSA"LANCHARD#OMMUNICATIONS3PECIALIST )NTERNATIONAL#ENTERFOR%THICS*USTICEAND0UBLIC,IFE "RANDEIS5NIVERSITY53! s$R!LEX/BOTE/DORA3PECIAL!SSISTANTTOTHE 0ROSECUTOR#HAIRPERSON s-R7ALLACE+APAYA3ENIOR4RIAL!TTORNEY-EMBER s-S!DESOLA!DEBOYEJO4RIAL!TTORNEY-EMBER 2APPORTEURS s-S2ENIFA-ADENGA4RIAL!TTORNEY-EMBER s#HIEF2APPORTEUR$R!LEX/BOTE/DORA3PECIAL s-R$ENNIS-ABURA#ASE-ANAGERn-EMBER3ECRETARY !SSISTANTTOTHE0ROSECUTOR)#42ASSISTEDBY s-S"EATRICE-OUKAMBA+IMUNA!DMINISTRATIVE -S!DEBOYEJO!DESOLA4RIAL!TTORNEY)#42 !SSISTANT-EMBER s#HALLENGESOF#ONDUCTING)NVESTIGATIONSOF)NTERNATIONAL s-S,UCY-USSAU"I,INGUAL3ECRETARY-EMBER #RIMES&ORUM s-S&ATOUMATA4RAORE"I,INGUAL3ECRETARY-EMBER $R,EIGH3WIGART!SSOCIATE$IRECTOR)NTERNATIONAL #ENTERFOR%THICS*USTICEAND0UBLIC,IFE"RANDEIS 5NIVERSITY53!ASSISTEDBY-R3AMUEL!KORIMO #OMMANDER)NVESTIGATIONS)#42 s#HALLENGESOF)NTERNATIONAL#RIMINAL0ROSECUTIONS &ORUM -R7ALLACE+APAYA3ENIOR4RIAL!TTORNEY)#42 ASSISTEDBY-S&LORIDA+ABASINGA#ASE-ANAGER )#42 s3ERVICEOF3ENTENCEFOR)NTERNATIONAL#RIMES&ORUM *AMES3TEWART3ENIOR!PPEALS#OUNSEL)#42 s#HALLENGESOFTHE!DMINISTRATIONOF)NTERNATIONAL #RIMINAL4RIBUNALS&ORUM -R7ILLIAM%GBE3ENIOR4RIAL!TTORNEY)#42ASSISTED BY-S"INAIFER.OWREJEE,ECTURER(ARVARD,AW 3CHOOL s#HALLENGESOF#OMPLETION3TRATEGY&ORUM \
