AER 710 Aerospace Propulsion Introduction Propellers Internal Combustion Engines Gas Turbine Engines Chemical Rockets Non-Chemical Space Propulsion Systems Rolls-Royce 12-cyl. Merlin XX Caproni CA.36 using Isotta-Fraschini 6-cyl. V.4B Introduction to Internal Combustion Engines • In an IC engine, the fuel is burned in reacting with incoming air, within the engine, to produce the required heat energy • A number of different powerplants (sparkignition, compression-ignition, rotary) under the IC engine category that can be used for driving a propeller shaft • Each share the characteristic of intermittent combustion in their cyclic operation Spark-Ignition Engines • A conventional spark-ignition (SI) IC engine is commonly associated with a 4-stroke operational cycle, with reciprocating pistons in cylinders used to drive (rotate) the main driveshaft (crankshaft) that in turn rotates the propeller shaft (directly, or indirectly through a propeller speed reduction unit gear-box, if the driveshaft speed is too high) • Some variants may have fuel injection, and perhaps turbosupercharging, to improve performance Four-stroke operation of spark-ignited internal combustion engine (NASA report, 1985) Cross-section of four-stroke cycle SI engine showing engine components; (A) block, (B) camshaft, (C) combustion chamber, (D) connecting rod, (E) crankcase, (F) crankshaft, (G) cylinder, (H) exhaust manifold, (I) head,(J) intake manifold, (K) oil pan, (L) piston, (M) piston rings, (N) push rod, (0) spark plug, (P) valve, (Q) water jacket From: W.W. Pulkrabek, “Engineering Fundamentals of the Internal Combustion Engine”, 1997 Chair of Department Dr. Kamran Behdinan Dr. David Greatrix Dr. David Greatrix Assoc. Chair of Department Cutaway diagram of an in-line four-cylinder Chrysler 4-stroke sparkignition engine for automotive applications. A connecting rod connects the reciprocating piston (up-and-down motion) to the rotating crankshaft. The intake-compression-combustion-exhaust process is illustrated at the right In-line SI Piston Engine Configurations Radial V Horiz.-opposed From: W.W. Pulkrabek, “Engineering Fundamentals of the Internal Combustion Engine”, 1997 Schematic cutaway diagram of front view of Chevrolet Corvair horizontally-opposed “flat-six” turbosupercharged air-cooled six-cylinder engine, for automotive and aircraft applications. • present-day lighter aircraft are powered by two, four or six air-cooled cylinders in a horizontally opposed configuration for a given engine • lower-cost normally-aspirated engines likely using the older carburetion approach for fuel-air vapor delivery to the cylinders via a carburetor and intake manifold, versus fuel injection directly or almost directly into the cylinder • higher performance engines are likely turbosupercharged and fuel-injected Throat of carburetor with secondary venturi. The small secondary venturi gives a large pressure drop and good fuel flow control, while the larger primary throat offers less resistance to the main air flow. At higher altitudes, the venturi is susceptible to icing (not a good thing), thus the use of carburetor heating From: W.W. Pulkrabek, “Engineering Fundamentals of the Internal Combustion Engine”, 1997 • SI engines generally run on gasoline (automotive gasoline sometimes called mogas), and for aircraft piston engines, aviation gasoline (avgas), which has a higher octane level than mogas to prevent detonation (knocking) at higher cyl. pressures • Fuels are characterized in part by their flash point; the flash point is the lowest temperature at which they will ignite in air or oxygen under standard conditions • combustion process needs some fuel vapor present to proceed, i.e., some vapor pressure; the higher the volatility of the given fuel (i.e., its vapor pressure), the lower the flash point • Fuel is typically stored in the wing or in wing-tip tanks, for greatest safety in the event of a crash • Tanks can be constructed of aluminum, since that lighter metal does not chemically react significantly with aviation fuels. Synthetic rubber or nylon fuel bladders may be used for containing fuel in some applications, e.g., for tanks constructed of composite materials having micro-pores that would leak fuel, otherwise. Bladders, while adding weight to the aircraft (not a good thing), do provide additional safety in the event of a crash Thermodynamic Cycle, SI Engines • ideal air-standard (air as working medium) Otto cycle approximates the open-cycle performance of a spark-ignition IC engine • actual 4-stroke cycle, beginning with outward stroke 1 from TDC to BDC, one has a fresh fuel-air mixture being taken into the cylinder. Inward stroke 2 from BDC to TDC is compression of this gaseous mixture, followed by ignition via a spark and subsequent burning. Outward power stroke 3 from TDC to BDC results in the expansion of the hot combustion products as the net cylinder volume increases. Inward stroke 4 from BDC to TDC results in the exhausting of these products out of the cylinder • typically less efficient 2-stroke cycle combines the fuel-air intake and exhaust strokes from the 4-stroke case into a shorter transitional process near BDC. This process is called scavenging, and utilizes some variant of a pump/port mechanism to implement the intake of fresh fuel-air mixture and exhaust of combusted gas. One advantage of 2-stroke engines is that they do have a higher powerto-weight ratio, given the fact that intermittent power delivery is every driveshaft revolution, as opposed to every two driveshaft revolutions for the 4-stroke case Illustration of operational cycle of 2-stroke spark-ignition piston engine. Flapping reed or leaf valve commonly employed for intake of fresh fuel-airoil mixture from carburetor into cylinder. The schematic shows the finning about the cylinder walls and head, as an efficient means for dissipating heat from the metal structure (more surface area) in an air-cooling approach. Diagram courtesy of HowStuffWorks.com Common scavenging geometries for two-stroke cycle engines. (a) Cross scavenged with intake ports and exhaust ports on opposite sides of the cylinder. (b)Loop scavenged with intake ports and exhaust ports on the same side of the cylinder.(c) Through-flow scavenged, with intake ports in cylinder walls and exhaust valve in head. Other variations and combinations of these types exist, depending on the placement of slots and/or valves From: W.W. Pulkrabek, “Engineering Fundamentals of the Internal Combustion Engine”, 1997 Operations in a 2-cycle spark-ignition engine Thermal efficiency of Otto cycle: T4 1) mCv ( T4 T1 ) QH QL QL T1 T1 th 1 1 1 QH QH mCv ( T3 T2 ) T2 T3 ( 1) T2 ( Via observation of the two cycle diagrams: T1 1 th 1 1 rv1 1 1 T2 rv rv V1 / V2 V4 / V3 Thus, efficiency is a function of compression ratio; 7 to 9 is the typical SI detonation (knock) limit with avgas. Net ideal useful work as fcn. of mean effective pressure: wnet mep ( v3 v1 ) , Also: J/kg of air wnet q H q L th q H Ideal shaft power for 4-stroke cycle (1 power stroke every two engine shaft revolutions; 2-stroke cycle would change ½ to 1): 1 V h = head displacement PS ,i mep Vh ( N ) 2 Brake specific fuel consumption: BSFC m f PS Shaft power as a function of intake manifold air pressure (MAP; in inches of mercury, where 1 atm = 29.9 in Hg = 760 mm Hg) and engine shaft speed (rpm) at full and part throttle, at sea level. The data is representative of a small 4-stroke normally-aspirated carbureted sparkignition piston engine, the air-cooled horizontally-opposed four-cylinder Lycoming O-320-A2B Shaft power as a function of altitude and engine shaft speed at full throttle, Lycoming O-320-A2B. Corresponding dashed curves for MAP are also shown Fuel consumption rate in U.S. gallons per hour as a function of MAP and engine shaft speed, Lycoming O-320-A2B Compression-Ignition Piston Engines • For CI (diesel) engines, fuel injection (vs. carburetion) directly into the cylinder is required, and for higher performance for aircraft applications, turbosupercharging is also likely required • can operate at higher compression ratios of 15:1 up to 20:1, without too much concern about diesel fuel detonation (knock) • 2-stroke variant is actually more popular for aircraft, given the higher power-to-weight ratio discussed earlier Illustration of a turbosupercharged 160-hp two-stroke four-cylinder (V-4) DeltaHawk aircraft diesel engine (DH160A4/V4/R4). The engine can run on diesel or jet fuel. Diagram courtesy of DeltaHawk Engines, Inc. Illustration of internal workings of a 2-stroke compression-ignition piston engine. Diagram courtesy of HowStuffWorks.com 4-stroke diesel engine operations 2-stroke diesel engine operations Thermodynamic Cycle, CI Engines • ideal air-standard (air as working medium) Diesel cycle approximates the open-cycle performance of a comp.-ignition IC engine • • Process 12 represents an isentropic compression of air as the piston moves from BDC to TDC. Process 23 is representative of heat being added at a constant pressure while the piston is moving downward from TDC to some intermediate point in the power stroke, until combustion is completed. In the actual case, one has fuel injection with subsequent, relatively slower burning (note: a glow plug heat source may be required for starting the engine initially, but thereafter would typically not be required for sustained operation), and further resulting pressurization. Process 34 represents an isentropic expansion, as the piston moves further downward until reaching BDC. Process 41 is representative of heat being rejected from the air and fresh air in turn being take in, while the piston is in the vicinity of BDC Thermal efficiency of Diesel cycle: T4 ( 1) 1 T th 1 1 1 T3 rv ( 1) T2 Net ideal useful work as fcn. of mean effective pressure: wnet mep ( v1 v2 ) Also: , J/kg (of air) wnet th q H q H q L On the negative side, higher diesel engine weights are required due to the higher operating cylinder pressures. On the other hand, BSFC is potentially quite low, on the order of 0.35 lb/hrhp (0.21 kg/hrkW) or less for existing aircraft diesels, thus there is some incentive to continue research and development on such items as lighter weight engine materials. Rotary Engines • Piston rotary approach used in the early 20th century, having the crankcase and cylinders in a radial configuration rotating in conjunction with the propeller, while the crankshaft was nominally fixed to the airplane; high roll torque and aerodynamic drag were undesirable characteristics Gnome 100-hp 9-cyl. piston rotary engine Fokker E.III Eindecker using an Oberursel U.I 9-cyl. 100-hp piston rotary engine • The most common pistonless rotary design is the Wankel engine, which uses an offset cam-shaped rotor (vane) rotating about a center output driveshaft, which also rotates in conjunction • Because their volumetric displacement versus total engine size is quite high relative to the reciprocating piston engines, the power-to-weight ratio, PS/WE , can be quite high, on the order of 1 to 3 hp/lb (as compared to 0.5 to 1 hp/lb for SI piston engines). These engines typically use spark ignition, with the intake, compression, ignition, expansion (power) and exhaust processes occurring smoothly in going around one cycle of the rotor • Sealing and maintenance are traditional design issues • Run at higher engine shaft speeds, likely necessitating a PSRU for the propeller 1. Engine inlet 2. Exhaust outlet 3. Housing 4. Combustion chambers 5. Stationary gear 6. Rotor 7. Internal gear 8. Eccentric shaft 9. Spark plug Wankel rotary engine schematic Photo at top left of opened rotary engine, courtesy of Mazda Motor Corporation. Photo at top right of AR731 air-cooled single-rotor 38-hp Wankel rotary engine for unmanned aircraft applications, courtesy of UAV Engines Ltd. Photo at bottom right of AR682 water-cooled twinrotor 95-hp Wankel rotary engine for unmanned aircraft applications, courtesy of UAV Engines Ltd. Illustration of internal operations of a Wankel rotary engine. Diagram courtesy of HowStuffWorks.com Turbosupercharging • performance of an IC engine (spark- or compression-ignition) can be enhanced by supercharging, i.e., compressing the air entering the intake • Superchargers are gear-driven off the main engine driveshaft, and as a result, their performance, while effective, is somewhat limited and inefficient Schematic diagram of conventional gear-driven supercharger setup Rolls-Royce Merlin 62, with two-stage (compressor), two-speed (gear-box), intercooled supercharger at rear of engine • To avoid the issue of bleeding off the main shaft’s power to run a front-end compressor, turbosuperchargers (TSCs) were introduced • TSCs employ a turbine in the exhaust stream, exploiting available energy that would otherwise be lost; the back-end turbine in turn drives a front-end compressor for mechanical air pressurization, and thus bypasses the need to extract power from the driveshaft • fuel-air detonation pressure limit in the downstream combustion chambers should not be exceeded; similarly, pressure on engine structure should not exceed allowed threshold • An intercooling (aftercooling; charge air cooling) approach is sometimes used to enhance performance (via increased combustor intake air density), by using a heat exchanger to remove heat (cooling the air) that is leaving the TSC, prior to entering the combustion chamber Schematic diagrams of turbosupercharger setup Schematic diagrams of turbosupercharging setups Diagram courtesy of University of Notre Dame Front view of the Boeing B-17 Flying Fortress bomber of WWII fame. The three-bladed variable-pitch propeller in view (one of four) is being driven by a 1200-hp Wright R-1820 Cyclone 9 air-cooled spark-ignition piston engine (turbosupercharged; radial 9-cylinder arrangement). The General Electric designed turbosupercharger allowed the engine to maintain sea-level power up to 25000 ft in altitude. Radial engines always come in an odd number of cylinders (like 9) due to the alternate cylinder firing order sequence requirement (e.g., 1-3-5-7-9-2-4-6-8) Shaft power as a function of altitude and MAP at an engine shaft speed of 2700 rpm. The data is representative of a small 4-stroke turbosupercharged fuel-injected spark-ignition piston engine, the aircooled horizontally-opposed six-cylinder Teledyne Continental TSIO-520-WB Fuel consumption rate as a function of percentage of maximum rated shaft power (max. rated MAP = 39 in Hg), turbosupercharged Teledyne Continental TSIO-520-WB Note on Pulsejets and PDEs • The pulsejet engine can be considered a transitional development between the older reciprocating piston engines and the newer gas turbine engines • intermittent fuel-air burning cycle, as compared to the continuous burning seen with gas turbines • exhausting a hot jet to provide thrust (as opposed to using a propeller) • PJ has no mechanical compressor or turbine; constant-volume combustor (vs. constantpressure combustor of gas turbine) Photo of an American “copy” of a German pulsejet-powered V-1 “buzzbomb” cruise missile, reproduced in large measure from reverseengineering those seized by American forces towards the end of WWII, for post-war flight testing and technology demonstration by the USAF. Eventually, a lot of these copies were used, and destroyed, as target drones Schematic diagram of conventional valved pulsejet t cyc Illustration of operational cycle of conventional pulsejet 4 c / p a1 1 f cyc Illustration of representative wave activity in various locations of the pulsejet F Illustration of idealized (sinusoidal) combustor pressure, and corresponding thrust, as a function of time Fmax Valveless PJs • Valveless (aerovalved) PJ designs remove the need for a front-end combustor intake valve (valves tend to wear out quickly). These designs can vary, but typically depend on accurate tuning of the pressure wave passage in the applicable duct (combustion tube) system in order to operate efficiently. These designs allow for backflow of air out of the intake, which can be a problem if excessive, whereas the valved designs prevent backflow altogether with a mechanical valve • Valved or valveless, not much interest currently in direct usage of PJs as the principal propulsion system; elements of PJ technology, like wave rotors and PDEs, may have more promise Temperature distribution in one type of valveless pulsejet, V = 50 m/s Courtesy of Applied Energy Research Laboratory, North Carolina State University (Dr. William Roberts) Pulse Detonation Engines • PDE operation depends more on higher-speed, higherheat- input, higher-strength supersonic detonation waves moving downstream (rightward) in the intake/combustion/exhaust (detonation/combustion tube) duct system (flame front moves with the compression shock front), as opposed to weaker slightly supersonic compression and sonic rarefaction waves moving significantly faster than the subsonic deflagration front of the flame within the PJ combustor and tailpipe • Candidate propulsion system for high-speed flight applications (competing against more established ramjet, and scramjet, engines for consideration) Illustration of operational cycle of conventional pulse detonation engine. Diagram courtesy of Aerodynamics Research Center, University of Texas at Arlington (Dr. Frank K. Lu) Diagrams of p-v and T-s profiles for ideal Humphrey cycle, applicable to constant-volume combustor Thermal efficiency, Humphrey cycle T3 1 ( ) 1 T T th 1 1 { 2 } T3 T2 1 T2