THE EMPLOYEE OFFICIAL MAGAZINE OF THE ASSOCIATION OF STATE CIVIL SERVICE EMPLOYEES OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK "With slight shades of difference, you have the same religion/ m a n n e r s , h a b i t s , a n d political principles. The independence and liberty you possess are the work of giant counsels and giant efforts, of common dangers, sufferings, and successes" GEORGE WASHINGTON "And having thus chosen our course, without guide and with pure purpose, let us renew our trust in God and go forward without fear and with manly hearts" ABRAHAM LINCOLN FEBRUARY, 1936 10 Cents per Copy VOL 5 Number 2 2 February THE STATE EMPLOYEE a 4 STAR HOTEL in N e w York * for BUSINESS...1 block from Times Square, 3 blocks from 5th Ave. 8 minutes t o Wall St. Underground passageway to all subways. "AT for DINING... 3 fine restaurants . . . t h e Coffee S h o p , t h e Tavern Grill a n d Bar, a n d t h e B L U E R O O M with dancing. Convenient Departures Dollar-Saving Fares tot • N E W YORK • SYRACUSE O ROCHESTER O B U F F A L O • NIAGARA FALLS GREYHOUND TERMINAL 1 4 0 0 large rooms...each with bath (tub and shower) Servidor and r a d i o . . .from $050 $050 Zmm SINGLE * for RECREATION...69 fine theatres within 6 blocks. 1 block from B r o a d w a y . . . 4 short b l o c k s t o Madison Square Garden. * for QUIET SLEEP...Our 32 stories of fresh air and sunshine assure you quiet rest. Simmons beds assure y o u comfort. 350 Broadway Tel. 4-6165 GREYyHOUND I \ J DOUBLE FRANK W. KRIDEL TWO-ROOM SUITES from $7.00 Managing Director JOHN T. WEST, Manager Special Rates For Longer Periods 74 c i i LINCOLN 44TH TO 45TH STREETS AT 8TH AVENUE • NEW YORK TFJ.F.PHONF FOR JERSEY 4..4.1£ft BORDEN BOULEVARD MILK and CREAM u An Unexcelled Combination of Service and Quality BORDEN BOULEVARD (B. F. P. Co. Inc.) 231 Third Street mm MILK CENTRAL DAIRY Albany, N. Y. Phone 3-0566 WALLPAPER-DURONT P A I N T J \ T 1 CEMTB.AL AVQ A 35 Anson / hornpsonlo. f \ ALBANY IX.I PHON& I 5-1613 > PATRONIZE OUR ADVERTISERS LOUIS J. BERBEN Dispensing Optician Oculists' Prescriptions Filled 36 MAIDEN LANE ALBANY, N. Y. 3 Doors Below No. Pearl St. THE STATE EMPLOYEE is published monthly except June, July, and August. Publication office 2 Norton St., Albany, N. Y. Editorial and executive offices Room 156, State Capitol, Albany, N. Y. 10c a single copy, $1.00 per year. Entered as Second-class matter, July 19, 1934, at the Post Office at Albany, N. Y., under the Act of March 3, 1879. Letters to the Editor, contributions, news items, applications for membership and application for advertising rates should be sent to Executive Headquarters, Room 156, State Capitol, Albany, N. Y. Members of the Association receive THE STATE EMPLOYEE upon payment of membership dues. THE STATE EMPLOYEE Official Publication of The Association of State Civil Service Employees of the State of New York Room 156, State Capitol, Albany, N. Y. Editor, CHARLES A. BRIND, JR. Business Manager, JOSEPH D. LOCHNER OFFICERS CHARLES A. BRIND, JR., President CHARLES L. CAMPBELL, Vice-President FRANK O. BAUER, Treasurer VOL 5. JOHN T. DEGRAFF, Counsel JAMES A. CONBOY, Secretary JOSEPH D. LOCHNER, Business Secretary FEBRUARY, 1936 NO. 2. Eight Hour Day The full import of the establishment of the maximum eight-hour day in State institutions is gradually permeating the atmosphere of these institutions and the departments having responsibility for the prison, mental hygiene, health and social welfare groups. Governor Lehman in inaugurating this reform has added new lustre to his progressive and humane record as Governor. Since this Association began its intensive work to have the long day abolished from State service, Governor Lehman has listened with an attentive ear to the many arguments presented by Committees of t h e . Association, which have visited him in regard to the matter. In the face of failure on the part of Governors White, Hughes, Dix, Sulzer, Glynn, Whitman, Smith, Miller and Roosevelt to establish a maximum eighthour day for State employees, Gov- ernor Lehman's conspicuous courage in adding this fine achievement to the many other vitally important political, economic and social reforms fostered by him, is but another proof of his truly great statesmanship. H e has honestly won a front rank position among great leaders of his time, and all informed people gladly and gratefully accord him this position. Unfamiliar with the Governor's thoroughness and constant efforts to deal with the very many problems that crowd upon him day by day, some individuals and groups were taken completely by surprise when the Governor's Budget revealed his decision to appropriate the very substantial sum of $2,500,000 to begin as of July 1st, next, the maximum eight-hour day plan. Some ridiculous statements questioning the eight-hour day program and indicating partizan or political bias have been made by certain individuals and groups among employees. These need not be taken seriously. The long day is gone forever, thanks to Governor Lehman and your Association. Assemblyman Ostertag's bill, Intro. No. 33, Print No. 708, providing a 48-hour week and 6-day week for State institutional employees and elevatormen in public buildings, passed the Assembly and is now in the Senate Labor Committee. Assemblyman M. B. Stewart's bill, Intro. No. 67, Print No. 558, and Assemblyman Ostertag's bill, Intro. No. 165, Print No. 165, both bills providing for a 48-hour week and a 6-day week for prison guards and prison employees passed the Assembly also, and are now in the Senate Penal Institutions Committee. Summary of Legislation Pending The following is a complete list of legislative measures introduced in both houses since publishing the January issue of this magazine, and which affect in some way the salaries, hours of work, pensions or civil service status generally of State employees, and are therefore of interest to them. SENATE Int. 426, Print 443, Senator Lee—Adds new Art. 3-a, Railroad Law, for transferring to public works dept. all the functions, powers and duties of public service dept. relative to highway railroad grade crossing elimination and alterations, outside New York City. Public Service Commission. Same as A. 395. Int. 487, Print 444, Senator Livingston— Adds new section 18-a, Labor Law, for grades and salaries of investigator and special social workers and appropriating $9,130. Finance Committee. Same as A. 478. Int. 433, Print 450, Senator Thompson— Extends for four years eligible lists of candidates for appointment as engineer of building on construction in public works department, engineering division. Civil Service Com. Same as A. 458. Int. 442, Print 450, Senator Nunan— Adds new sections 188 to 193, Labor Law, by providing no employee of any hospital shall be required to work more than 8 hours a day or 48 hours a week. Labor Com. Same as A. 550. Int. 443, Print 460, Senator Nunan— Amends Chapt. 798, Laws of 1931, relative to unemployment relief by providing no person receiving work relief or relief moneys shall be employed to perform duties of any em- ployee in a position subject to Civil Service Law. Relief and Welfare Com. Int. 445, Print 462, Senator Nunan— Adds new section 9-a, Civil Service Law, providing for automatic salary increment for State employees of $120 each year for five years following first year of service until such increment wll not exceed maximum salary for which employee is qualified or salary of $3600 and appropriating $2,400,000. Finance Committee. Int. 480, Print 501, Senator Crawford— Amends sections 62, 63, Civil Service Law, to permit retirement of members in State retirement system under certain conditions at age 55. Pensions Com. Int. 482, Print 503., Senator CrawfordAmends section 65-b, Civil Service Continued on Page 4 4 THE STATE EMPLOYEE February Summary of Legislation Pending Continued from Page 3 Law, relative to ordinary death benefit payable to beneficiary of State employees' retirement system by authorizing an additional amount equal to 50% of compensation where member dies with ten or more years' service. Tensions Com. Int. 483, Print 504, Senator CrawfordAmends section 14, Civil Service Law, by providing persons in labor class to permit promotion into competitive class must have served at least two, instead of three years in a similar position. Civil Service Com. Same as A. 722. Int. 500, Print 521, Senator Crawford— Amends subd. 3, section 07, Civil Service Law, by providing that revolving fund in State employees' retirement system in hands of comptroller shall also be used for immediate payment of expenditures for which the system will be reimbursed by the municipality for which expenditure is m a t e Pensions Com. Same as A. 631. Int. 533, Print 554, Senator McNaboe— Adds new section 14-c, Civil Service Law, providing oral examination shall mean a personal interview between applicant and examiner, no credit to be allowed or disallowed in compiling final average. Civil Service Com. Int. 534, Print 555, Senator McNaboe— Adds new section 14-b, Civil Service Law, providing no rules shall be made setting up 'educational requirements as condition taking civil service examination except in respect to professional and other positions for which requirements are expressly imposed by statute. Civil Service Com. Int. 550, Print 888, Senator Fearon— Amends Chap. 443, Laws of 1933, by providing definite reduction in salary of officer or employee made on accouut of emergency period shall not be considered a reduction for retirement purposes. 3rd Reading. Int. 569, Print 603, Senator D o y l e Amends Section 22, Civil Service Law, relative to removals, to hearings and court review. Civil Service Com. Same as A. 122. Int. 594, Print 628, Senator Garrity— Adds new section 470-b, Correction Law, providing widow of retired guard or department employee shall be paid on his death one-half of retirement allowance. Pensions Com. Same as A. 574. Int. 595, Print 629., Senator Hanley— Adds new section 220-f, Labor Law, limiting hours of labor of employees in state institutions in mental hygiene department to 8 hours a day and 48 hours a week. Labor Com. Same as A. 025, S. 500. Int. 644, Print 688, Senator E g b e r t Adds new section 168, Labor Law, providing no person employed in a state hospital shall be allowed to work more than 8 hours a day and 8 consecutive hours shall constitute a days work and 48 consecutive hours a weeks work. Labor Com. Int. 657, Print 706, Senator Desmond— Amends section 25, Civil Service Law, by prohibiting any member of a state or municipal civil service commission from holding office in any political club, or association, serving as delegate to any political convention or as members of any political organization committee. Civil Service Com. Int. 658, Print 707, Senator Desmond— Amends section 13, Civil Service Law, by taking out of exempt class, secretary of a civil service commission. Civil Service Com. Int. 660, Print 709, Senator McNaboe— Amends section 31, Civil Service Law, by making provision relative to separation from service and reinstatement apply also to person holding position in non-competitive class or subject to a qualifying examination. Civil Service Com. Same as A. 1142. Int. 727, Print 777, Senator Howard— Amends subd. 4, section 220, Labor Law, by providing 4S hours shall constitute a legal week's work, eight hours a legal day's work and requiring one day rest in seven for all state employees employed by a State Department, board, agency or council or by any institution including those engaged in care and guarding of person and property or performing nursing, kitchen or other service and those in caring for public buildings and grounds. Labor Com. Int. 738, Print 802, Senator (Nunan— Adds new section lS-a, Labor Law, giving safety inspectors of construction and home work inspectors same rights and benefits of grades and salaries accorded to factory, mercantile, boiler, mine and tunnel inspectors. Labor Com. Same as A. 950. Int. 755, Print 818, Senator Coughlin— Amends section 22, Civil Service Law, by prohibiting removal of veteran nurses except for incompetency or misconduct shown after hearing, also giving preference in case of abolished positions, to veterans and exempt volunteer firemen and relative to certification for their transfer. Civil Service Com. Int. 769, Print 811, Senator Thompson— Adds new section 50-a, Civil Service Law, requiring comptroller to request opinion from attorney general on any determination made by him in administering State employees' retirement system when objected to by a person claiming benefits thereunder, any determination of comptroller to be subject of review by certiorari. Pensions Com. Same as A. 014. Int. 785, Print 857, Senator Crawford— Amends section 80, Civil Service Law, by providing no public or quasi-public organizations referred to in sections 75, 75-a, shall hereafter create any officers' or employees' retirement system. Pensions Com. Same as A. 553. Int. 786, Print 858, Senator Crawford— Amends section 05, Civil Service Law, relative to accidental disability retirement by striking out provision that if service of member is on other than full time basis allowance shall be equal to that which would be paid to member were he employed on full time basis. Pensions Com. Same as A. 032. Int. 787, Print 859, Senator Crawford— Amends subd. 2, section 02, Civil Service Law, by striking out exception to maximum compulsory retirement age provision, in favor of a member of system under age of 78, where continuance of such service would be advantageous to public service. Pensions Com. Same as A. 033. Int. 788, Print 860, Senator CrawfordAmends section 52, Civil Service Law, by excepting from membership in State employees' retirement system employees of State institutions reporting to state welfare and health depts. Pensions Com. Same as A. 557. Int. 789, Print 861, Senator CrawfordAmends section 05-a, Civil Service Law, relative to accidental death benefits by striking out last sentence referring to service of a member on other than full time basis and whose death was natural and proximate result of accident. Pensions Com. Same as A. 558. Int. 790, Print 862, Senator CrawfordAmends subd. 5, section 53, Civil Service Law, relative to persons with prior service credit who failed to become a member of state retirement system on first date of eligibility and who became member on or before January 1, 1936, by providing such member to secure prior service credit must render at least five years* additional service as a member after last becoming member of system Pensions Com. Same as A. 554. Int. 791, Print 863, Senator CrawfordAmends subd. 0, section 01, Civil Service Law, by providing members of state retirement system may borrow from "his funds" in the 'retirement system, instead of the retirement system as at present. Pensions Com. Same as A. 556. Int. 813, Print 891, Senator Kleinfeld— Amends section 2, Civil Service Law, by creating a personnel board for hearing all charges against an employee or officer for misconduct or dereliction of duty; employees may be represented by counsel and summon witnesses, all findings and recommendations as to penalties to be submitted to department head. Civil Service Com. Continued on Page 6 February THE STATE EMPLOYEE 5 New York City Chapter By Robert Axel, Chairman, Committee on Publicity The past month has witnessed increasing activity of the Chapter in fulfilling the aims and ideals of the Association—to extend and uphold the principle of merit and fitness in public employment, to maintain and promote efficiency in public service and to advance generally all interests of the Civil Service Employees of the State of New York. Two meetings of the Executive Committee of the Chapter have been held, on February 14 and 18, to take inventory and to discuss problems of vital concern to the entire civil service group. The first meeting dealt with an enumeration and discussion of the various abuses and evils which have become widespread under the Civil Service System. Consideration was also given to the lack of progress which was made in connection with the group health and accident insurance plan. Lack of participa'tion in group insurance has resulted in considerable adjustment of this plan. At present, negotiations are being held with the Continental Casualty Company to consider new proposals, the results of which will be announced at a later date. The meeting of the Executive Committee of the Chapter held on February 18, was a rather eventful one in view of the fact that much deliberation was given to bills introduced in the Legislature, and to other measures which are being instituted to facilitate and foster advancement and promotion within the state service. The following bills and other proposals contained in the report of the Legislative Committee of the Chapter, were approved by the Executive Committee: Salary increases. That a bill which has been drafted by the Legislative Committee be introduced which provides for a flat increase of $100.00 for each Civil Service Employee in the competitive service, whose annual salary is less than $2,500.00. This bill is of like pattern to the one which was successful in effecting similar increases in 1930. Restoration of full vacations. It was agreed, in accordance with the proposal of the Legislative Committee, that an effort should be made to secure the necessary cooperation from the Governor in restoring vacations to their former duration. Plans are being considered for the most effective means of accomplishing this result. Civil Service transfers and promotions. A thorough study of the Civil Service Law is at present being made by the Legislative Committee for the purpose of drafting such amendments as are necessary to insure promotions within the Department and to secure legislation which will facilitate the transfer of employees from one department to another. Such legislation would stamp out the "open competitive" evil. Amendment of Section 22 — Civil Service Law. The Committee is preparing an amendment to Section 22, Sub-division 2, of the Civil Service Law, which is designed to provide civil service employees with safeguards relating to the security of employment. Approved bills. Several bills have met with the approval of the Chapter. One group of bills aims to secure an eight-hour day for the employees in the state institutions. The other bills relate to the legal requirements of applicants for civil service examinations, extension of time for preferred lists, and to the undesirability of creating any new officers' or employees' retirement systems. Among the bills opposed by the Chapter are included those relating to the placement of certain positions in the exempt class and the continuance of the State Retirement Fund benefits upon the transfer of employees from the State to Federal service. The above are some of the activities with which the Chapter is immediately concerned. An earnest effort is being made by the Chapter to develop a complete program of activities which would reach the entire body of state civil service employees in Greater New York. Such a program requires increasing participation by the officers, committees, and membership at large. All members who are employed in New York City should renew their membership in the Association as soon as possible through the New York City Chapter. Dues may be paid to Mr. Irving Siegel, Treasurer of the Chapter, Room 461, or to the department representatives. Hornell Dinner The Hornell District of the Highway Division of the Public Works Department held a dinner on February 24. Employees of this District and representatives of State employee groups in that section attended. President Charles A. Brind, Jr., of this Association was the principal speaker. Mr. Edward J. Hickey of the Credit Union Section, Washington, D. C , spoke as to the benefits of a credit union. Credit is due Mr. T. F. Nichols, Chairman of the Dinner, for this very successful affair. H.R.S.H. Credit U n i o n Members of the Employees' Association of the Hudson River State Hospital have now available to them a credit union. A successful party was held recently, the proceeds of which went towards organization expenses. Present officers of the Credit Union are: George G. Lozier, President; Otto V. Faust, Vice President; Sara Galbraith, Secretary; Margaret T. Olmstead, Treasurer. Mr. Lozier, Mr. Faust, Miss Galbraith, Miss Olmstead, A. H. Sullivan, Mary Benton, and Gladys Hand, constitute the Board of Directors. George Magee and John Livingstone make up the Credit Committee, while Mr. Lozier, G. Carlton Nuhn and Gertrude Flinn compose the Supervisory Committee. This Association wishes every success to this credit union. 6 THE STATE EMPLOYEE February Summary of Legislation Pending Continued from Page 4 Int. 843, Print 923, Senator CrawfordAmends section 61, Civil Service Law, for discontinued service allowance to a member of State retirement system who when discontinued from service has attained age of 45 and is then employed and for 20 or more years next prior thereto has been continuously employed as member or employee of legislature. Pensions Com. Int. 880, Print 961, Senator McNaboe— Adds new section 15-a, Civil Service Law, providing no state, county or city civil service committee shall appoint any person to any position for which there is a civil service list established. Civil Service Com. Int. 912, Print 1017, Senator E g b e r t Amends section 18, Civil Service ijaw, by providing removal of laborers or employees from labor class in cities shall be in inverse order of appointment, persons removed to be eligible for reinstatement in order of original appointment before certification of any other person. Same as 1048. Int. 915, Print 1020, Senator Garrity— Amends section 111, Correction Law, by providing principal keepers shall in addition to salary receive $2,500 in lieu of maintenance. Penal Institutions Com. Int. 916, Print 1021, Senator McNaboe— Adds new section 31-b, Civil Service Law, providing term of eligibility for reinstatement of person in labor class whose name is placed on preferred list shall be four years from date person was separated from service, also extending such term to person in labor class whose name was entered on preferred list on or after January 1, 1935, and prior to time section takes effect. Civil Service Com. Same as A. 1051. Int. 955, Print 10C9, Senator Twomey— Adds new section 18-aa, Labor Law, providing per diem officer or employee holding position in competitive, non-competitive or labor class may be granted sick leave with pay of not more than 30 days in each year. Labor Com. Int. 959, Print 1073, Senator B y r n e Adds new subd. 13-a, section 50, Civil Service Law, providing reduction in salary or compensation of member of retirement system during 1932, and other years of emergency period, shall not be considered a reduction so as to reduce his pension, allowance or privileges, contributions to continue on basis of undiminished compensation unless notice of election is filed on June 1 of each year. Pensions Com. Same as A. 1149. ASSEMBLY Int. 374, Print 377, Mr. Crews—Amends section 23, Civil Service Law, by providing employees unlawfully removed and reinstated by enactment of law shall receive compensation from date of such removal. Civil Service Com. Int. 376, Print 1251, Mr. Crews—Amends section 3I-a, Civil Service Law, by providing eligibility term for reinstatement of persons on preferred lists shall be eight, instead of four years, from date person was separated from service. Civil Service Com. Same as S. 194. Int. 382, Print 385, Mr. Farenga— Amends section 52-a, Civil Service Law, relative to status of members of state retirement system, when employed by federal government after December 1, 1933. Pensions Com. Int. 388, Print 391, Mr. Ostertag— Amends subd. 4, section 220, Labor Law, by providing that stationary firemen in State hospitals, employees in State institutions, except mechanics and engineers, electricians and elevatormen n public buildings division of public works dept. shall not be permitted to work more than 48 hours a week or six days in any one week. Labor Com. Int. 395, Print 1212, Mr. T h o m p s o n Adds new Art. 3-a, Railroad Law, for transferring to public works dept. all the functions, powers and duties of public service dept. relative to highway railroad grade crossing elimination and alterations outside New York City. Public Service Com. Same as S. 426. Int. 451, Print 464, Mr. Farenga— Amends sections 10, 14, Civil Service Law, by providing applicant for examination for position in competitive class must be a citizen of U. S. and have been a resident of State for one year immediately preceding date of examination. Civil Service Com. Int. 458, Print 471, Mr. Herman—Extends for four years eligible lists of candidates for appointment as engineer of building construction in public works dept., engineering division. Civil Service Com. Same as S. 433. Int. 462, Print 475, Mr. Robinson—Adds new section 31-a, Civil Service Law, by making six, instead of four years, emergency extension of term of eligibility for reinstatement of persons on preferred lists. Civil Service Com. Int. 473, Print 486, Mr. Crews—Amends section 161, Labor Law, by providing for one day of rest in seven for engineers and firemen employed in motion picture theatres. Labor Com. Int. 478, Print 491, Mr. Farrell—Adds new section 18-b, Labor Law, for Grades and salaries of investigator and special social workers and appropriating $9,130. Ways and Means Com. Same as S. 427. Int. 526, Print 540, Mr. Jarema—Amends section 6, Art. 5, Constitution, relative to merit and fitness examinations in civil service, by providing each resultant appointment shall be of the one standing highest. Judiciary Com. Int. 537, Print 551, Mr. E. S. Moran— Amends section 10, Civil Service Law by providing an appeal for review, alteration or re-rating of examination or physical test by applicant, shall be taken not less than 30 or more than 60 days after such examination or test. Civil Service Com. Int. 538, Print 552, Mr. E. S. Moran— Amends section 6, Civil Service Law, by providing a civil service commission shall not make any rule requiring payment of a fee in excess, of $1 to take an examination or receive an appointment. Judiciary Com. Int. 550, Print 568, Mr. Fitzpatrick— Adds new section 188 to 193, Labor Law, by providing no employee of any hospital shall be required tO' work more than 8 hours a day or 48 hours a week. Labor Com. Same as S. 442. Int. 553, Print 571, Mr. Potter—Amendssection 80, Civil Service Law, by providing no public or quasi-public organization referred to in sections 75, 75-a, shall hereafter create any officers' or employees' retirement system. Pensions Com. Same as S. 785. Int. 554, Print 572, Mr. Potter—Amends subd. 5, section 53, Civil Service Law, relative to persons with prior service credit who failed to become a member of state retirement system on first date of eligibility and who became member on or before January 1, 1936, by providing such member tosecure prior service credit must render at least five years' additional service as a member after last becoming member of system. Pensions Com. Same as S. 790. Int. 555. Print 573, Mr. Potter—Amends section 71-a. Civil Service Law. relative to suspending retirement allowances of members of state retirement system by making "pension" read "any retirement allowance" as used in section. Pensions Com. Int. 556, Print 574, Mr. Potter—Amends subd. 6, section 61, Civil Service Law, by providing members of State retirement system may borrow from "his funds in" the retirement system, instead of the retirement system, as at present. Pensions Com. Same as S. 791. Int. 557, Print 575, Mr. Potter—Amends section 52, Civil Service Law, by excepting from membership in the State employees' retirement system, employees of State institutions reporting to State welfare and health depts. Pensions Com. Same as S. 788. Third reading. Int. 558, Print 576, Mr. Potter—Amends section 63-a, Civil Service Law, relative to accidental death benefits by striking out last sentence referring to service of a member on other than full time basis and whose death was natural and proximate result of accident. Pensions Com. Same as S. 789. Third Reading. Continued on Page 14 February THE STATE EMPLOYEE Rochester Chapter Annual Dinner Feb.27 By Leslie S. Wood As this issue goes to press, over 750 reservations have been received for the Annual Dinner of the Association, at the DeWitt Clinton Hotel, Albany, February 27th, at 7 P. M. Additional reservations cannot be accepted due to inability to secure accommodations. It will be the largest social event in the history of the Association, and the largest dinner ever to be held in the Capitol District. On January 9 the following departments were represented at a luncheon meeting, to consider the organization of a Rochester Chapter of The Association of State Civil Service Employees: Earle C. Pattison, Edward Brown, State Ins. Fund; H. H. Duncan, Agric. & Markets; John Burke, Harriet Dean, Employment Division; Mary L. Dawson, Compensation Division; Conrad O'Malley, Paul L. Ryan, Public Works; Ward C. Davis, Taxation & Finance; Leslie S. Wood, William F. Skuse, Rehabilitation Division. No definite decisions were made, but the various representatives expressed their views on the advantage of a local chapter. Mr. Wood was elected Chairman and the meeting was adjourned, to be called together in the near future. At the annual meeting of the N. Y. S. Rochester Employees Federal Credit Union, held at the Hotel Rochester on January 20, which was preceded by a dinner, the following Directors and Committees were elected: Board of Directors. Leslie S. Wood, 2 year term, Rehabilitation Division Ward C. Davis, 2 year term, Taxation and Finance; Fred Koerner, 1 year term, Public Works; H. S. Duncan, 1 year term, Agriculture and Markets; Grace Carroll, 1 year term, Compensation Division. Credit Committee. Conrad O'Malley, 2 year term, Public Works; John Burke, 2 year term, Employment Division; William F. Skuse, 1 year term, Rehabilitation Division; R. Quandt, 1 year term, Public Works; Grace Driscoll, 1 year term, State Insurance Fund. Supervisory Committee. Paul Smith, 1 year term, Employment Division; Wilmot Cook, 1 year term, Agriculture and Markets; Mary Dawson, 1 year term, Compensation Division. The Board of Directors have announced the following officers: Leslie S. Wood, President; Fred Koerner, Vice President; Ward C. Davis, Treasurer; Grace Carroll, Clerk. Large delegations from New York City, Buffalo, Brooklyn, Poughkeepsie, Saratoga Springs, Rochester, among other places, are going to attend. The program following the dinner, will begin by a brief word of welcome by Charles A. Brind, Jr., President of the Association. There will be a solo by Mrs. Betty A. Peyser of Brooklyn, whose singing has attracted wide attention in the Metropolitan area. The entertainment program, aside from dancing, will close with an address by Governor Lehman, in accordance with the custom of many years. Guests who have already accepted as this issue goes to press include: Governor and Mrs. Lehman, Mr. and Mrs. Charles Poletti, Mr. and Mrs. Walter Brown, Lieutenant Governor William Bray, Attorney-General John J. Bennett, Comptroller Morris S. Tremaine, Dr. and Mrs. Frank P. Graves. Department heads include Commissioners Weber, Rice, Osborne, Smith, Greene, Mulrooney, Ten Eyck, Andrews, Adie, White, Clark and Maltbie. Senators Byrne, Desmond, Fearon, Crawford, Graves, Ross, Twomey and Dunnigan have accepted. Assemblymen who will attend include, Corning, Hayes, Alterman, Todd, Byrnes. Legislative Correspondents signifying their intention to attend include Francis B. Cass, Samuel T. Coe, George M. Janvrin, Harold Keller, John Mooney, George R. Lories, Hollister Sturges, Jr., Kirkland King, Harold P. Jarvis, Wanter C. Wandell, George W. Herrick and Donald G. Coe. Thomas C. Stowell is Chairman of the Committee which will stage the stunt show. This committee's (OOCKTAIL Particularly THE cocktails served in the cozy environment of the new, enlarged MEZZANINE ILOUNGE The setting makes cocktails doubly appealing. Soft lights, sweet music, intimate table g r o u p i n g s . And t h e hors d'oeuvres are most tempting. So phone a friend or two to meet you here today. For this is the rendezvous every afternoon from 4 to 7. D E W I T T CLINTON a, l\nott hotel personnel includes; Walter Brown, Allan Reagan, John L. Halpin, Clarence H. Knapp, Howard E. Silberstein, John F. Tremain, Frederick Holowell, Foster Potter and Charles H. McTigue. Great credit is due Mrs. Hazel A. Ford, Chairman of the dinner, and her committee, as well as the committee arranging the entertainment, for what will prove to be one of the most successful affairs ever staged in this State. 8 T H E S T A T E EMPLOYEE February Editorial Page Back Again Legislation Under a somewhat new guise the old civil service raid bill to put the Alcoholic Beverage Control Division under the "spoils system" is back again. This time it is Lavery bill, Introductory No. 360. Although Governor Lehman rebuked attempts to turn the liquor law enforcement over to partizan administration on two occasions, the enemies of civil service and fair play and fair citizen opportunity to serve in public positions never give up. Selfishness is as old as wholesome honesty. The bill would give positions to those who could not or did not qualify in fair open competitive tests, and, of course, by doing so would deny to those who did observe the Constitution and the laws of the State their rightful appointment. We include in this issue a list of the members of the Legislature. We do this in order that members of the Association may familiarize themselves with the names of their Senator and Assemblymen. One of the functions of the Association is to protect the merit system and the retirement system from the inroads of new legislation which will tend to weaken or destroy either. At the same time adequate salaries are a prime objective of the Association. The other side of the story is, of course, the attempt of your officers and committees to secure needed legislation which will not only better the working conditions of State employees but will be beneficial to the entire State as a whole. Furthermore the officers, Counsel and committees must carefully examine every bit of legislation introduced, and determine its effect upon the welfare of State employees. At the present writing, there are over 150 measures pending action in the legislature, every one of which affect the salaries, pensions, hours of work or civil service status generally of State employees. Members of the Association can help greatly by calling the attention of their representatives in the legislature to this legislation by writing directly to them a record letter. We are sure that the members of the law-making body are desirous of knowing the attitude of their constituents upon matters affecting them. Whenever it occurs that appointing officers question the advisability of having positions in the exempt class or in the competitive class, they have the right to present the facts to the Civil Service Commission as the body created by the State to say whether the positions will be exempt or competitive. Why then these constantly recurring attempts to override the Constitution and to set aside the functions of a Department of State Government also constitutionally created? Let us hope that the Legislature of 1936 does not repeat the folly of 1934 and 1935 and give Governor Lehman the additional work of vetoing this bill. For the Injury of the Service Bills are in the Legislature which if adopted would result in the dismissal of two-thirds of the present comparitively small force of game protectors in the Conservation Department. Here is a body of State servants who by unanimous acclaim of those who actually know the facts about fish and game and good, clean sport, have done and are doing their work in as efficient and honest a manner as ever prevailed in any performance of duties, public or private. They are outstanding, and a grateful public has been particularly quick to say so on every appropriate occasion. But these bills would do harm in another destructive way. They would open wide the doors to despoilation of game birds and animals in this State, and create a system under which privilege and abuse would be rampant. The new bills would reward an army of irresponsible game protectors, so-called, by a percentage fee for finding a violator. What petty persecutions such a system would encourage, and what private privileges it could create, must give even a rapacious man pause! We would have the honest citizen going forth for a day's hunting or fishing, himself hunted, and the discredited speedtrap ideas of other days would be revived in another form and for new victims. The Association as well as other groups of informed citizens will oppose this attempt to discontinue a tried and proven service of great value. Special Privilege Every tenent of the merit system is degraded by attempts to secure special privileges through class legislation. The Berg bill which gives preference to disabled soldiers in retention and reinstatement, violates the fundamental principles of fair play. By the terms of this bill, the veteran has preference in reinstatement and retention if he had a disability at the time of original appointment, even though he has no disability whatever at the time of removal or reinstatement when the proposed preference would be accorded; also, a disabled veteran who might have served the State for less than a year is entitled to preference in retention over an employee who might have served for ten or twenty years, whether that employee was a veteran with long military or naval service or not. The State of New York at present accords preference to disabled veterans in appointment and promotion; in training and experience; on physical examinations in retirement and pension systems; and with reference to transfer and removal. With every regard for those veterans who have been rated at one time or another as showing disability, it is entirely without the sphere of justice to grant additional preferences. Every bit of preferential legislation in selecting public personnel is harmful whether it applies to veterans or others. It is absolutely foreign to the principles of the merit system. All bills of this type will be strenuously opposed by friends of civil service. February THE STATE EMPLOYEE 9 Editorial Page New York City Hotels Destructive of Morale For many months the advertisements of two hotels in New York City have been carried on the pages of this magazine, viz., the Hotel Lincoln and the Hotel Lexington. Not only do these hotels secure advertising space but they also give special consideration to State Employees and members of the Civil Service Association. If one wishes to be in the theatre area around Broadway, he is centrally located by stopping at the Lincoln which is on 44th to 45th Streets at Eighth Avenue. If his business is in the vicinity of Grand Central Station or subway connections from such station, he is excellently situated if he stops at the Lexington which is on 48th Street at Lexington Avenue. At either hotel he is assured a special welcome if he mentions the fact that he is a Civil Service Employee and a member of this Association. We state these facts, not at the request of the hotels but because members stopping there have told us how well pleased they were. The Association is opposing legislation which would permit the filling of competitive positions by persons who have not qualified through competitive examinations, or, unless there is direct action by the Civil Service Commission with reference to reclassification of the positions. Proposals to legislate individuals or groups into the competitive class of the civil service is not in accord with the State Constitution. Opinions of the Court of Appeals have plainly indicated that there must be proof of test of the merit and fitness of appointees. There is nothing in the present law which permits a person holding a position in the labor class to be transferred to the competitive class except through reclassification action by the Commission. The honorable way into public service is through open, frank, intelligent competitive examinations; only Santa Claus is entitled to use the chimney. More Opportunities Federal Civil Service The extension of eligible lists beyond two years as prescribed in the civil service law does not serve either the State in recruiting its personnel, or the civil service employee or other citizen anxious to advance in usefulness, and it does not aid the great objectives of the merit system. The Association has recorded itself against the measures in the legislature extending eligible lists and has stated its position that there should be no such extension unless for some sound reason satisfactory to the Civil Service Commission itself. Eligible lists as referred to here are not to be confused with continuance of eligibility of those civil service employees who through no fault of their own have lost their positions and await reemployment on suspended lists. From "America) ", 15 February, 1936, Pages 439, 440 The inconsistency which crops up now and then between the President and what we are wont to style "the Administration", is disconcerting. On four or five occasions, the President has expressed his approval of the system of appointing Government employees for merit alone, but on eleven occasions Congress has enacted, and the President has approved, bills which set the merit system aside. Evidently, the President and the Administration are at odds in this important matter. Room at the Top Yet since March, 1933, Congress has enacted eleven bills which exempted from the merit system 41,000 jobs. Between June, 1932, and June, 1933, the number of civil service positions declined by 12,000, although the number of Federal jobs increased by 237,000. Of these places, about one in every 107 was awarded under the merit system. The most vital need of government today is a well trained, vigorous and enthusiastic personnel, animated by patriotic chivalry, stimulated by good working conditions, and encouraged by an open road ahead to the highest positions of trust in the public service. We cannot expect the most valuable initiative and endeavor so long as we are half civil service and half "spoils". It is a reflection upon the intelligence of civil service employees to have the higher positions held in trust, so to speak, as political or other rewards. Let us be honest with the entire citizenry and give to all an equal chance to attain to the top on the basis of pure merit. This and this only is the merit system. That the matter is important is evident from a letter which the President addressed on January 30 to the Women Voters League. "There can be no question of greater moment or broader effect", wrote the President, "than the maintenance, strengthening, and extension of the merit system, established in the competitive principles of the Civil Service Act." What the singular merits of the individuals appointed to jobs, but exempted from the civil service examinations, may have been, the record does not show. Letters to Editor Always Welcome Most Intereting Ones Will be Printed 10 THE STATE EMPLOYEE February Members of Legislature—1936 Credit Union Growth SENATE Dist. Politics Name Address 1 R e p . George L. T h o m p s o n Kings Park 2 Dem. Joseph D. Nunan, J r 45 C e d a r St., N. Y. C i t y 3 Dem. F r a n k B. Hendel 67-19-79th St., Middle Village 4 D e m . P h i l i p M. Kleinfeld 122 E . 42nd St., N . Y. C i t y 5 Dem. J o h n J. Howard 453-55th St., B r o o k l y n 6 D e m . E d w a r d J . Coughlin 475 W a s h i n g t o n Ave., B r o o k l y n 7 Dem. Jacob J. Schwartzwald 66 C o u r t St., B r o o k l y n 8 Dem. J o s e p h E s a u i r o l 32 C o u r t St., B r o o k l y n 9 Dem. Jacob H. Livingston 67 B u l w e r Place, B r o o k l y n 10 D e m . J e r e m i a h F . T w o m e y 911 M a n h a t t a n Ave., B r o o k l y n 11 Dem. J a m e s J . C r a w f o r d 1476 B r o a d w a y a t 42nd St., N . Y. City 12 D e m . E l m e r F . Q u i n n 95 C h r i s t o p h e r St., N. Y. City 13 D e m . T h o m a s F . B u r c h i l l 7 W e s t 42nd St., N. Y. City 14 D e m . S a m u e l M a n d e l b a u m 277 B r o a d w a y , N. Y. City 15 D e m . J o h n L. B u c k l e y 20 E x c h a n g e Place, N. Y. City 16 D e m . J o h n J . McNaboe 242 E a s t 19th St., N. Y. City 17 R e p . J o s e p h C l a r k B a l d w i n 45 J o h n St., N. Y. City 18 D e m . J o h n T. McCall 342 Madison Ave., N . Y. City 19 D e m . D u n c a n T. O'Brien 15 W i l l i a m St., N. Y. City 20 D e m . A. Spencer F e l d 110 E a s t 42nd St., N. Y. City 21 D e m . L a z a r u s J o s e p h 1450 B r o a d w a y , N . Y. C i t y 22 D e m . J u l i u s S. B e r g 1650 B r o a d w a y , N. Y. City 23 D e m . J o h n J . D u n n i g a n 2382 G r a n d Concourse, N. Y. City 24 D e m . R a e L. E g b e r t P . O. Box 1, S t a t e n I s l a n d 25 R e p . P l i n y W. W i l l i a m s o n 115 B r o a d w a y , N. Y. C i t y 26 D e m . J a m e s A. G a r r i t y . . . . . 2 0 South Broadway, Yonkers 27 R e p . T h o m a s C. D e s m o n d 94 B r o a d w a y , N e w b u r g h 28 R e p . F r e d e r i c H . Bontecou 11 M a r k e t St., P o u g h k e e p s i e 29 R e p . A r t h u r H . W i c k s Kingston 30 D e m . W i l l i a m T . B y r n e Loudonville 31 D e m . Ogden J . R o s s 212 P a w l i n g Ave., T r o y 32 R e p . E d w i n E. Miller 251 S t a t e St., S c h e n e c t a d y 33 R e p . B e n j a m i n F . F e i n b e r g 85 M a r g a r e t St., P l a t t s b u r g 34 R e p . R h o d a F o x Graves Gouverneur 35 R e p . H a r r y F . D u n k e l 28 K i n g s b o r o Ave., Gloversville 36 R e p . W i l l i a m H . H a m p t o n 327 A r c a d e Bldg., Utica 37 R e p . P e r l e y A. P i t c h e r 620 W o o l w o r t h Bldg., W a t e r t o w n 38 R e p . George R. F e a r o n 930 U n i v e r s i t y Block, S y r a c u s e 39 R e p . W a l t e r W . Stokes Cooperstown 40 R e p . M a r t i n W . Deyo 508 S e c u r i t y M u t u a l B l d g . , B i n g h a m p t o n 41 R e p . C. T r a c e y S t a g g 220 N o r t h T i o g a St., I t h a c a 42 R e p . C h a r l e s J . H e w i t t Locke 43 R e p . E a r l e S. W a r n e r Phelps 44 R e p . J o e R. H a n l e y Perry 45 D e m . George B . K e l l y 967 H o w a r d St., R o c h e s t e r 46 D e m . N o r m a n A. O'Brien 37 R a i n i e r St., R o c h e s t e r 47 R e p . W i l l i a m H . Lee 28 L o h r m a n n Bldg., L o c k p o r t 48 D e m . D a v i d E . Doyle 22 H a w l e y St., Buffalo 49 D e m . Stephen J . W o j t k o w i a k 52 B u r g a r d P l a c e , Buffalo 50 R e p . Nelson W . Cheney Eden 51 R e p . L e i g h G. K i r k l a n d 59 F o r e s t P l a c e , F r e d o n i a ASSEMBLY Dist. Politics Name 1 2 3 Rep. Address ALBANY E r a s t u s C o r n i n g , 2nd Bethlehem John P. Hayes 30 W a l t e r St., A l b a n y S. E a r l M c D e r m o t t 288 S a r a t o g a St., Cohoes ALLEGANY W i l l i a m H . MacKenzie 33 W i l l e t t s Ave., B e l m o n t BRONX M a t t h e w J . H . M c L a u g h l i n . .410 E a s t 159th St., B r o n x D o r i s I. B y r n e 430 E a s t 140th St., B r o n x Carl P a c k 866 M a n i d a St., B r o n x Samuel W e i s m a n 601 E a s t 167th St., B r o n x Benjamin Gladstone 1106 W e s t F a r m s R o a d , B r o n x P e t e r A. Quinn 1651 Garfield St., B r o n x B e r n a r d R. F l e i s b e r 745 E a s t 178th St., B r o n x J o h n A. D e v a n y , J r 120 W e s t 183rd St., B r o n x BROOME E d w a r d F . Vincent Maine J a m e s E. H i l l 139 W e s t E n d Ave., B i n g h a m p t o n CATTARAUGUS J a m e s W . Riley 307 E a s t S t a t e St., Olean CAYUGA A n d r e w D. B u r g d o r f Martville Rep. Rep. L l o y d J . Babcock Carl E . D a r l i n g Dem. Dem. Dem. Rep. 1 Dem. 2 Dem. 3 Dem. 4 Dem. 5 Dem. 6 Dem. 7 Dem. 8 Dem. 1 2 Rep. Rep. Rep. 1 2 Rep. Rep. Rep. Rep. „ 1 2 Rep. „ Rep. „ Rep. Rep. CHAUTAUQUA l l W e l l m a n Ave., J a m e s t o w n 604 S w a n St., D u n k i r k CHEMUNG C h a u n c e y B. H a m m o n d R. D. No. 2 E l m i r a CHENANGO I r v i n g M. Ives Norwich „ „ CLINTON McKenzie B . S t e w a r t Mooers COLUMBIA F r e d e r i c k A. W a s h b u r n 103 N o r t h 5th St., H u d s o n CORTLAND Albert Haskell, J r 30 C h a r l e s St., C o r t l a n d „ DELAWARE E. Ogden B u s h DeLancey „ DUTCHESS H o w a r d N. Allen Pawling Emerson D. Fite V a s s a r College, P o u g h k e e p s i e Continued on Page 12 The Credit Union Committee of this Association under the leadership of Lewis S. Armento, reportsfurther progress in development and organization of Credit Unionsserving State Employees. There are now twenty-four credit unions,, and it is hoped that before the end of the year every employee no matter where located in the State wilt have the benefits of credit union membership brought to him. The following is the list of State Employee credit unions: 1. N. Y. State Albany Employees Credit Union, State OfficeBuilding, Albany, N. Y. 2. N. Y. State Centre St. Employees Federal Credit Union,. State Office Building, New York City. 3. N. Y. State Rochester Employees Federal Credit Union,. State Office Building, Rochester. 4. N. Y. State Buffalo EmployeesFederal Credit Union, State Office Building, Buffalo. 5. Buffalo State Hospital E m ployees Federal Credit Union,. Buffalo, N. Y. 6. Syracuse State School Employees Federal Credit Union, Syracuse, N. Y. 7. Brooklyn State Tax Employees Federal Credit Union, Brooklyn, N. Y. 8. N. Y. State Department of Public Works District 8, Employees Federal Credit Union, Poughkeepsie, N. Y. 9. N. Y. State Vocational School Employees Federal Credit Union, West Coxsackie, N. Y. 10. Hudson River State Hospital Employees Federal Credit Union, Poughkeepsie, N. Y. 11. Attica State Prison Employees Federal Credit Union, Attica, N. Y. 12. Auburn Prison Employees Federal Credit Union, Auburn, N. Y. 13. Matteawan State Hospital Employees Federal Credit Union, Beacon, N. Y. 14. Central Islip State Hospital Employees Federal Credit Union, Central Islip, N. Y. Continued on Page 12 February THE STATE EMPLOYEE WJFWl CJ milk has a definite alkaline effect! Drink a glass at n i g h t . . . another in the HI S I ™ / morning.. . and alkalize naturally! Milk works like a charm after overwork, over-indulgence, or loss of sleep. Brings you right back to par. There's nothing quite so soothing and refreshing as fresh, cool milk. And another thought, milk is one of today's most economical foods. Send for free booklet: "MILK—the Alkalizer." Write to The Bureau of Milk Publicity, Albany THE STATE OF NEW YORK 11 12 " THE STATE EMPLOYEE Members of Legislature—1936 Continued from Page 10 1 2 Rep. Rep. R ep. a4 Dem S Dem 0 Rep. 7 Rep. 8 Rep. Rep. Rep. Rep. Rep. Rep. Rep. Rep. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 Dem, Dem , Dem , Dem Dem Rep. Dem Dem Dem Dem , Dem , D-em , Dem Dem Dem Dem , Dem Dem. Dem. Dem, Dem, Dem, Dem, Rep. Rep. Rep. 1 2 3 4 5 Rep. Rep. Dem Rep. Rep. Rep. 1 2 Rep. Rep. 1 2 3 4 5 G 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 1G 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 Dem, Dem, Dem, Dem Dem, Dem Dem, Dem Dem Rep. Dem Dem . Dem Dem Rep. Dem Dem . Dem , Dem Dem Dem Dem Dem , 1 2 Rep. Rep. 1 2 3 D e m, Rep. Rep. 1 2 3 Rep. Rep. Rep. ERIK F r a n k A. G u g i n o 438 B u s t i Ave., Buffalo H a r o l d B. Elirlich 151 C l a r e m o n t Ave., Buffalo F r a n k X. Bernhardt 76 Goodell St., Buffalo A n t h o n y J . Canney 44 P a u l Place, Buffalo E d w i n L. K a n t o w s k i 499 F i l l m o r e Ave., Buffalo Fred Koehler 1217 F i l l m o r e Ave.. Buffalo A r t h u r L. S w a r t z 207 W a r r e n Ave., K e n m o r e R. F o s t e r P i p e r 50 W o o d v i e w Ave., H a m b u r g ESSEX T h o m a s A. L e a h y Lake Placid FRANKLIN J o h n H . Black Faust TULTON-HAMILXON D e n t o n D. L a k e 83 Second Ave., Glovcrsville GENESEE H e r b e r t A. R a p p Darien Center GREENE Paul Fromer Tannersville HERKIMER David C. W i g h t m a n 15 South Richfield St., M o h a w k JEFFERSON Russell W r i g h t 274 Ten E y c k St., W a t e r t o w n KINGS Crawford W. H a w k i n s 417 Pacific St., B r o o k l y n A l b e r t D. Schanzer 1255 E a s t 24th St., B r o o k l y n Michael J . Gill-en S0G H i c k s St., B r o o k l y n Bernard Austin 559 Bedford Ave., B r o o k l y n Charles R. McConnell 94G P u t n a m Ave., B r o o k l y n R o b e r t J . Crews 537 M a r c y Ave., B r o o k l y n William Kirnan 514 17th St., B r o o k l y n J a m e s Y. M a n g a n o G72 Union St., B r o o k l y n E d g a r F . Moran 447 81st St.. B r o o k l y n W i l l i a m C. McCreery 159 P r o s n e c t Place, B r o o k l y n Bernard J. Moran 121 South E l l i o t t Place, B r o o k l y n E d w a r d S. Moran, J r 27 P r o s n e c t P a r k W e s t , B r o o k l y n Ralph Schwartz 234 P o w e r s St., B r o o k l y n A a r o n F . Goldstein 144 Bedford Ave.. B r o o k l y n E d w a r d P . Doyle 723 H u m b o l t St., Brooklsm C a r m i n e J . Marasco 1079 71st St.. B r o o k l y n George W . S t e w a r t I l l Macon St., B r o o k l y n Irwin Steingut 70G E a s t e r n P a r k w a y , B r o o k l y n George K a m i n s k y 919 W i l l o u g h b y Ave., B r o o k l y n E u g e n e J . Iveogh 1247 H a n c o c k St., B r o o k l y n Charles H. Breitbart 714 E a s t 4th St., B r o o k l y n Clement A. Shelton 104 S h e p h e r d Ave., B r o o k l y n G. T h o m a s L o R e 2307 Dean St., B r o o k l y n LEWIS F r e d A. Y o u n g Lowville LIVINGSTON James J. Wadsworth Geneseo MADISON Wheel-er Milmoe Canastota MONROE Pritchard H. Strong 2700 E a s t Ave., R o c h e s t e r C h a r l e s R. H a g g e r t y 22 Beverly St., R o c h e s t e r E a r l C. L a n g e n b a c h e r 7 C a v u g a St., R o c h e s t e r H a r r y J. Gaynor 272 Spencer St., R o c h e s t e r Walter H. Wickins Scottsville MONTGOMERY L. J a m e s S h a v e r Canajoharie NASSAU Harold P. Herman GO Plainfield Ave., F l o r a l P a r k L e o n a r d W. H a l l 147 Anstice St., O y s t e r B a y NEW YORK J a m e s J. Dooling 40 F r o n t St., N. Y. City Nicholas A Rossi 225 Sullivan St., N. Y. Citv E u g e n e R. Duffy 440 W e s t 34th St., N. Y. City Leonard Farbstein 18 C o l u m b i a St., N. Y. Citv John F. Killgrew 325 W e s t 45th St., N. Y. City I r v i n g D. Neustein 441 E a s t 15th St., N. Y. Citv Saul S. S t r e i t 253 W e s t 72nd St., N. Y. City Stephen J. J a r e m a 129 E a s t 7th St.. N. Y. City I r a H . Holley 272 W e s t 90th St., N, Y. City H e r b e r t Brownell, J r 9 E a s t 8th St., N. Y. City P a t r i c k H . Sullivan 395 Riverside Drive. N. Y. City J o h n A. B y r n e s 235 E a s t 22nd St., N. Y. City W i l l i a m J . Sheldrick 420 W e s t 130th St., N. Y. City F r a n c i s J . McCaffery, J r 230 E a s t 71st St., N. Y. City A b b o t Low Moffat 125 E a s t 84th St., N. Y. City William S c h w a r t z 315 E a s t SSth St., N. Y. City Meyer A l t e r m a n 1274 F i f t h Ave., N. Y. City S a l v a t o r e A. F a r e n g a 218 E a s t 116th St., N. Y. City R o b e r t W. J u s t i c e 447 L e n o x Ave., N. Y. City Michael I. K e e n a n 79 E a s t 125th St., N. Y. City W i l l i a m T. A n d r e w s 405 E d g e c o m b Ave., N. Y. City Daniel F l y n n 403 W e s t 154th St.. N. Y. Citv W i l l i a m J . A. Glancy 1551 W e s t 109th St., N. Y. City NIAGARA F a y e t t e E. P e a s e Lockport, R. F . D. No. 4 H a r r y D. S u i t o r 215 4th St., N i a g a r a F a l l s ONEIDA P a u l B . Mercier 907 J o h n St., Utica W i l l i a m It. W i l l i a m s Cassville F r e d L. Meiss 701 C h a t h a m St., R o m e ONONDAGA H o r a c e M. Stone Marcellus George B . P a r s o n s 102 S t r a t h m o r e Drive, S y r a c u s e R i c h a r d B. S m i t h 411 E l m St., S y r a c u s e Continued on Page 15 February Credit Union Growth Continued from Page 10 15. Elmira Reformatory Employees Federal Credit Union, Elmira, N. Y. Gowanda State Hospital Em16. ployees Federal Credit Union, Gowanda, N. Y. 17. Marcy State Hospital Employees Federal Credit Union, Marcy, N. Y. 18. Newark State School Employees Federal Credit Union, Newark, N. Y. 19, Creedmoor State Hospital Employees Federal Credit Union, Queens Village, L. I. 20. N. Y. State Psychiatric Institute and Hospital Employees Federal Credit Union, New York City. 21 Rome State School Employees Federal Credit Union, Rome, N. Y. 22, Craig Colony, Sonyea, N. Y. 23. Utica State Hospital Employees Federal Credit Union, Utica, N. Y. 24. Wallkill Prison Employees Federal Credit Union, Wallkill, N. Y. Personnel Day The League of Women Voters celebrated January 29th, 1936 as "Personnel day." Luncheons at which civil service and the merit system were the topics of the day were held in all parts of the United States. In the evening there was a nation-wide broadcast. The program was arranged to bring to the public attention the urgent need for the elimination of the spoils system. The radio speakers were Secretary Roper, Mayor LaGuardia and Governor Fitzgerald of Michigan. A message from President Roosevelt was read. In part it said, "It matters not what political party is in power by the elective will of the people, the government functions for all; and there can be no question of greater moment, or broader effect than the maintenance, strengthening and extension of the merit system, established in the competitive principles of the Civil Service Act, whose fifty-third birthday is being celebrated this month." February THE STATE EMPLOYEE 13 Civil Service Appointments WHEN YOU The following is a list of appointments to positions in the State service, made since the publication of the January issue: Position Department Child Guidance Psychiatrist Pychiatrist Inst., N.Y.C. Leonard F. Horan Probation Examiner Correction Dept., Albany Frank McDonald Photographer Rockland State Hospital Charles Ginock Laundry Supervisor Mt. Morris T. B. Hospital Rose M. Fischette Asst. Type. & Tele. Oper..Mt. Morris T. B. Hospital Edward Holtz Asst. Physician Pilgrim State Hospital Robert C. Hunt Asst. Physician Rochester State Hospital Edward J. Humphreys....Asst. Physician Letchworth Village Betty R. Halperin Stenographer Brooklyn State Hospital Harold A. O'Connor Asst. Physician Creedmoor State Hospital Dr. Malwina T. Lemmle.. .Asst. Physician Binghamton State Hospital Stanley E. Targett Head Laundryman Woodbourne Inst, of Defective Delinquents Dr. James A. Taylor Asst. Physician Kings Park State Hospital Ann Sheriz Stenographer Brooklyn State Hospital Fred W. Hitchcock Steward Craig Colony Dr. Charles Kleinman Asst. Physician Marcy State Hospital James Gaetaniello Asst. Physician Harlem Valley State Hospital Donald W. Penley Teacher West Coxsackie Vocational Inst. Philip C. Heerdt Senior Messenger Labor, N.Y.C. Alexander Fisch Jr. Clerk Labor, N.Y.C. Isadore F. Andorsky Jr. Clerk Labor, N.Y.C. Alma Wiesner Employment Supervisor.. .Labor, Brooklyn F. Phvllis Reichler Jr. Clerk Labor, N.Y.C. Rose Peselnick Jr. Typist Labor, N.Y.C. Constance Ayer Placement Interviewer... .Labor, Buffalo Frank Brower Placement Interviewer... .Labor, N.Y.C. Samuel Flowerman Placement Interviewer... .Labor, Brooklyn Edith Abrahamson Placement Interviewer... .Labor, N.Y.C. Prank Pierce Placement Interviewer... .Labor, N.Y.C. Sylvia Weinstein Jr. Typist Labor, N.Y.C. Ruth Spitzberg Jr. Typist Labor, N.Y.C. Fannie S. Levine Asst. Steno Labor, N.Y.C. Marion J. Vosburgh Asst. Steno Labor, N.Y.C. Isabel Mory Placement Interviewer... .Labor, N.Y.C. Clifford A. Howell Placement Interviewer Labor, Buffalo Erma Goss Placement Interviewer... .Labor, Brooklyn William Pafkowitz Instructor in Drafting Wallkill Prison Lillian Caesar Clerk Public Service, N.Y.C. Clarence A. Rosecrans Guard Clinton Prison Joseph Kalish Bertillion Clerk Clinton Prison Francis D. Converse Asst. Bertillion Clerk Clinton Prison John F. Donovan Jr. Messenger Health, Albany Joseph B. O'Connell Jr. Messenger Health. Albany Norris R. Sutherland fiame Protector Conservation, Wayne County Mrs. Alice Truax Asst. Steno Conservation, Albany Milton Matz Jr. Agricultural Statistician Agricultural, Albany Elizabeth V. Fenn Jr. Clerk Education, Albany Rita E. O'Neill Asst. Steno Education, Albany Hilda Y. Smith Library Asst Education, Albany Edythe K. Salt Jr. Regents Examiner Education, Albany Celia Friedman Asst. Steno Education, Albany Clyde B. York Dairv & Food Inspector.. .Agriculture, Albany Frank M. Kirkland Guard Woodbourne Inst, for Defective Delinquents John C. McCarthy .Guard Woodbourne Inst, for Defective Delinquents Martin P. Lanahan Auditor Audit & Control, Albany Stephen W. Shanley Auditor Audit & Control, Albany Ernest W. Staub Safety Inspector State Insurance Fund, N.Y.C. Harrv W. Condon Investigator State Insurance Fund, N.Y.C. Samuel Burroughs Investigator A. B. C. Board, N.Y.C. Vincent J. Sabbatino Investigator A. B. C. Board. N.Y.C. Simon H. Goldstein Investigator A. B. C. Board. N.Y.C. Helen Minkoff Calculating Machine Oper.State Insurance Fund, N.Y.C. Oscar C. Sorenson Safety Inspector State Insurance Fund, N.Y.C. Tsidoro Siecel Addressograph Operator. .State Insurance Fund, N.Y.C. Isaac Kramer Jr. Clerk State Insurance Fund, N.Y.C. William Gottlieb Jr. Clerk State Insurance Fund, N.Y.C. Morris Koloditsky Jr. Clerk State Insurance Fund, N.Y.C. Edwin A. Davis Investigator State Insurance Fund, N.Y.C. Maria J. Jnknp Typist State Insurance Fund, N.Y.C. Isabel N. Malakoff Typist State Insurance Fund, N.Y.C. Lillian Raines Typist State Insurance Fund, N.Y.C. Joseph G. Cleary Underwriter Clerk State Insurance Fund, N.Y.C. Z. V. Antonsen Gas Meter Tester Public Service, Albany Cierald W. Vaillancourt.. .Principal Clerk Public Service, Albany Gladvs L. VanVleet ..Jr. Typist Health Laboratory. Albany Jeanette Goldflne Asst. Stenographer Social Welfare, Albany Irene M. McGowan Tr. Typist State, Albany Fred Fick Jr. Clerk State. Albany Jane A. Fitznatrick Asst. Statistical Clerk Social Welfare. Albany Loretta A. Mattimore Asst. Stenographer Health. Albany Morris Wolland Tr. Clerk State Insurance Fund, N.Y.C. Morton Price Jr. Clerk State Insurance Fund, N.Y.C. Doris L. Cohen Tr. Clerk ...State Insurance Fund, N.Y.C. R. Chase Horowitz Typist State Insurance Fund, N.Y.C. Ruth Berger Typist State Insurance Fund, N.Y.C. Lester I. Arnold Teacher Elmira Reformatory John B. Bvrne Medical Interne Rockland State Hospital Harry E. Winters Day Attendant Rockland State Hospital Truman E. Elethorp Day Attendant Rockland State Hospital Ronald Holt Day Attendant Rockland State Hospital Suzanne L. Zirkle Day Attendant Rockland State Hospital Lorraine Ahearn Day Attendant ..Rockland State Hospital Louise L. Wiener Special Attendant Teacher.Rockland State Hospital Name Donald W. Cohen WEEK END IN HewlfoeU N o w is the time to come to New York for a bright week end! See those brilliant n e w s h o w s . . . enjoy the g a y night life.. .visit all the sights you missed before. A n d w h e n y o u c h e c k in at t h e L e x i n g t o n y o u ' l l b e checking out all your cares. C o m f o r t a b l e r o o m s for as little as $3 single, $4 d o u b l e all with bath and radio. And four restaurants, including the famous SILVER GRILL w h e r e Ozzie Nelson's Orchestra plays nightly. The Lexington is just 4 short blocks from Grand Central and close to the theatres and shops. Garage accommodations! HOTEL LEXINGTON 48th St. at Lexington Ave., New York 801 R O O M S . . . F R O M $3 Charles E. Rochester, Manager National Hotel Management Co., Inc. • RalphHitz, President © February THE STATE EMPLOYEE 14 Summary of Legislation Pending Continued from Page 6 Int. 572, Print 590, Mr. Lavery—Adds new section 470-b, Correction Law, providing widow of retired guard of department employee shall be paid on his death one-half of retirement allowance. Penal Institutions Com. Same as S. 594. Int. 590, Print 609, Mr. Hamilton— Amends sections 14, 30, adds new 33, Civil Service Law, providing no person who is an appointive officer or employee of state, political subdivision or agency thereof, shall hold office on any political committee or in any club, principal activity of which is political, provison not to apply to those holding positions with tenure not exceeding four months a year. Civil Service Com. Int. 591, Print 610, Mr. H a m i l t o n Amends section 3, Art. 2, Constitution, by providing no person shall be deemed to have gained or lost a residence for purpose of voting by reason of presence or absence while employed in State service. Judiciary Com. Int. 625, Print 644, Mr. Ehrlich—Adds new section 220-f, Labor Law, by limiting hours of labor of employees in State institutions in mental hygiene dept. to eight hours a day and 48 hours a week. Labor Com. Same as S. 500, 595. Int. 631, Print 650, Mr. Potter—Amends subd. 3, section 57, Civil Service Law, by providing that revolving fund in State employees' retirement system in hands of comptroller shall also be used for immediate payment of expenditures for which the system will be reimbursed by the municipality for which the expenditure is made. Pensions Com. Same as S. 500. Third Reading. Int. 632, Print 651, Mr. Potter—Amends section Go, Civil Service Law, relative to accidental disability retirement by striking out provision that if service of member is on other than full time basis allowance shall be equal to that which would be naid to member were he employed on full time basis. Pensions Com. Same as S. 786. Int. 633, Print 652, Mr. Poter—Amends subd. 2, section 02, Civil Service Law, by striking out exception to maximum compulsory retirement age provision in favor of a member of system under age of 78 where continuance of such service would be advantageous to public service. Pensions Com. Same as S. 787. Int. 654, Print 673, Mr. Potter—Adds new section, 220-f, Labor Law, by limiting hours of labor of nurses and other employees in State hospitals to not more than eight hours a day, eight consecutive hours in any 24 to constitute a legal day's work. Labor Com. Int. 720, Print 749, Mr. Brownell— Amends section C, Article 5, Constitution, relative to civil service appointments and promotions of vet- erans, preference however not to be accorded in any promotion and making other changes. Judiciary Com. Int. 722, Print 751, Mr. Caaney—Amends section 14, Civil Service Law, by providing persons in labor class to permit promotion into competitive class must have served at least two, instead of three years in a similar position. Civil Service Com. Same as S. 483. Int. 786, Print 823, Mr. Hamilton—Adds new section 25-a, Civil Service Law, prohibiting a person holding position in classified service of state or any civil division or city from holding office on any political committee or in any club or organization, principal activity of which is political, nor shall he serve as delegate to any political convention. Civil Service Com. Int. 833, Print 873, Mr. Ostcrtag— Amends subd. 4, section 220, Labor Law, by making 48 hours a legal week's work for all classes of State employees whether employed by a department, board, commission, agency, bureau or council or by an institution including those caring for persons and property, or performing nursing and other service, eight consecutive hours in any 24, shall constitute a legal day's work. Civil Service Com. Int. 872, Print 924, Mr. Crews—Adds new section 9-a, Civil Service Law, prohibiting a public officer or employee from performing service of motion picture operator or stage hand in connection with performance given by or for inmates of any state institution unless civil service employees are by occupation or vocation motion picture operators or stage hands. Civil Service Com. Same as S. 213. Int. 900, Print 953, Mr. Crews—Amends section G, Civil Service Law, by providing no rule shall be made prescribing any educational requirements as condition to examination or appointment of applicant for civil service position except with respect to professional and other positions for which requirements are expressly provided. Civil Service Com. Int. 922, Print 974, Mr. Schwartz—Adds new section 11-a, Civil Service Law, prohibiting any rule of civil service commission which provides for certification or appointment of any person from an eligible list to a grade lower than grade for which such person has qualified. Civil Service Com. Int. 948, Print 1015, Mr. M o r r i s Amends section 68-a, Civil Service Law, to permit on or before January 1, 1938, instead of 1936, as at present, optional retirement before age of GO, of members of State retirement system. Civil Service Com. Same as S. 358. Int. 950, Print 1017, Mr. Ostertagr—Adds new section 18-aa, Labor Law, giving safety inspectors of construction and home work inspectors same rights and benefits of grades and salaries accorded to factory, mercantile, boiler, mine and tunnel inspectors. Labor Com. Same as S. 738. Int. 1051, Print 1139, Mr. H e r m a n Adds new section 31-b, Civil Service Law, providing term of eligibility for reinstatement of person in labor class whose name is placed on preferred list shall be four years from date person was separated from service, also extending such term to person in labor class whose name was entered on preferred list or on after January 1, 1935, and prior to time section takes effect. Civil Service Com. Same as S. 916. Int. 1119, Print 1221, Mr. A u s t i n Amends section 23, Civil Service Law, by providing officers and employees unlawfully removed or suspended and reinstated by court order or voluntary act of removing or suspending officer, shall be entitled to receive compensation from date of removal or suspension. Civil Service Com. Int. 1142, Print 1244, Mr. Wadsworth— Amends section 31, Civil Service Law, by making provision relative to separation from service and reinstatement apply also to person holding position in non-competitive class or subject to a qualifying examination. Civil Service Com. Same as S. GOO. Int. 1149, Print 1259, Mr. Ostertag— Adds new subd. 13-a, section 50, Civil Service Law, providing reduction in salary or compensation or member of retirement system during 1932 and other years of emergency period, shall not be considered a reduction so as to reduce his pension, allowance, or privileges, contributions to continue on basis of undiminished compensaton unless notice of election is filed on June 1, of each year. Civil Service Com. Same as S. 959. The Newly Remodeled Y. W. C. A. CAFETERIA Extends a special and cordial invitation . . . to all State employees . . . to become regular patrons of the distinctively different meeting and eating place. LUNCHEON DINNER 11:45 to 2:00 5:30 to 7:00 Food Excellent — Lowest Prices 5 LODGE STREET February THE STATE EMPLOYEE Members of Legislature—1936 1 2 1 2 3 4 5 6 1 2 1 2 1 2 1 2 1 2 1 2 1 2 3 4 5 Continued from Page 12 ONTARIO Rep. Harry R. Marble Holcomb ORANGE Rep. Lee B. Mailler Cliffside Park, Cornwall Rep. Rainey S. Taylor 14 Wickham Ave., Middletown ORLEANS Rep. John S. Thompson 216 Park Ave., Medina OSWEGO Rep. Ernest J. Lonis Hannibal OTSEGO Rep. Frank G. Sherman 41 Grove St., Oneonta PUTNAM Rep. D. Mallory Stephens Brewster QUEENS Dem. Mario J. Cariello 25-55 32nd St., L. I. City Dem. George F . Torsney 40-01 50th Ave., L. I. City Dem. Peter T. Farrell 27-58 Curtis St., Corona Dem. Daniel E. Fitzpatrick 82-09 Surrey Road, Jamaica Estates, Jamaica Dem. Maurice A. FitzGerald 129-16 134th St., S. Ozone Park. Long Island Dem. James L. Dixon 117-14 Union Turnpike, Kew Gardens RENSSELAER Dem. Philip J. Casey 50 Ida St., Troy Rep. Maurice Whitney Berlin RICHMOND Dem. Charles Bormann 89 Broad St., Stapleton, S. I. Dem. Herman Methfessel 71 Midland Road, Great Kills, S. I. ROCKLAND Rep. Laurens M. Hamilton Sterlington ST. LAWRENCE Rep. W. Allan Newell 415 Caroline St., Ogdensburg Rep. Warren O. Daniels Parishville SARATOGA Rep. William E. Morris 108 Third St., Waterford SCHENECTADY Rep. Oswald D. Heck 749 DeCamp Ave., Schenectady Rep. Harold Armstrong: 759 Curry Road, Schenectady SCHOHARIE Dem. William S. Dunn Schoharie SCHUYLER Rep. Floyd E. Meeks Montour Falls SENECA Rep. James D. Pollard Box 359, Seneca Falls STEUBEN Rep. Wilson Messer 238 Wall St., Corning Rep. J. Austin Otto Atlanta SUFFOLK Rep. John G. Downs Cutchogue Rep. Hamilton F. Potter Smithtown Branch SUL.LIVAN Rep. J. Maxwell Knapp Hurleyville TIOGA Rep. Frank G. Miller Apalachin TOMPKINS Rep. James R. Robinson 313 East Court St., Ithaca ULSTER Rep. J. Edward Conway 30 Fairmont Ave., Kingston WARREN Rep. Harry A. Reoux Warrensburg W ASHING TON Rep. Herbert A. Bartholomew Whitehall AVAYNE Rep. Harry L. Averill Palmyra WESTCHESTER Rep. Herbert R. Smith 23 Sturgis Road, Bronxville Rep. Ralph A. Gamble 18 Linden Ave., Larchmont Dem. Hugh A. La very Croton Ave., Ossining Rep. Jane H. Todd 41 North Broadway, Tarrytown Rep. William T. Grieve 11 Stone St., Yonkers WYOMING Rep. Harold C. Ostertag Penn Yan YATES Rep. Fred S. Hollo well Attica Join or Renew After You Have Tried For Real Value Try Others HOTEL CAPITOL GREEN ST. OFF STATE TAP ROOM TODAY! 15 Albany Basket Ball League The basketball league composed of State employees in Albany and sponsored by the Adult Recreation Bureau of the Education Department of the City of Albany, in cooperation with the Association of State employees, reports the following standing as of February 11th. W L Pet. Audit & Control 9 1 .900 Public Works 7 3 .700 Health Lab 5 6 .455 Tax & Finance 4 6 .400 Agriculture & Markets 4 7 .364 State 2 8 .200 Bowling Contest The State Comptrollers bowling team, leaders in the State Employees' Civil Service Association League of Albany, recently traveled to Poughkeepsie and defeated the State Insurance Fund bowling team of New York City by a three game total of 2636 to 2608. The victors enjoyed a party at the Elks Club in Poughkeepsie at the expense of the New York team. Bowling with the Albany team were, Price, Clark, Conley, Lanahan and Burgess and with the New York team, Moore, Jones, Gorman, Gray and Meyerson. Buffalo Hospital Credit Union The Buffalo State Hospital Employees Federal Credit Union held their first annual meeting on January 20th last. The officers and committees were re-elected for the ensuing year. In operation for only three months, the progress of this Credit Union reflects great credit on those connected with its promotion and management. Total loans issued $1,932. Total membership 229. A successful dance was held the early part of February, the proceeds of which went towards organization expenses and reserve funds. ORGANIZATION—complete and active-is as essential to your welfare as a state civil service worker as insurance is to yourself or your family. THE ASSOCIATION serves you whether you are a member or not. The only difference is that when you are a member you bear your share of the work. Is there any worker anywhere who deliberately shirks his common duty? We think not. GOOD INTENTIONS as to membership are not sufficient... an application card is followed quickly by a membership card. YOUR MEMBERSHIP CARD is a reference and a recommendation. It indicates loyalty and good judgment. ^ cog ^ p 03 i> cfCQ 3 CD 3 M w Print Last Name Above Residence Work Address Dept. Employed sip: p First Name Title. Institution or Div T H E ASSOCIATION OF STATE CIVIL SERVICE EMPLOYEES OF T H E STATE OF NEW YORK ROOM 156, STATE CAPITOL, ALBANY, N. Y. Membership Application Dues to Dec. 31, 1936 — $1.00 $.50 of which is for a year's subscription to "The State Employee" <$ to There is only o n e highway to success — The cooperative way of organization. ef • O CQ e| OH