Lesson Plan Course Title: Graphic Design & Illustration Session Title: Propaganda Lesson Duration: Approximately one to two weeks [Lesson length is subjective and will vary from instructor to instructor] Performance Objective: Upon completion of this assignment, the student will use propaganda concepts to design an effective advertisement. Specific Objectives: 1. Define terms associated with the lesson. 2. Identify types of propaganda used in advertising. 3. Discuss words and strategies used in advertising based on target audience. 4. Compare various ads by the level of propaganda used. Preparation TEKS Correlations: 130.88(c) (1) The student applies academic knowledge and skills in art and design projects. The student is expected to: (A) apply English language arts knowledge and skills by demonstrating use of content, technical concepts, and vocabulary; using correct grammar, punctuation, and terminology to write and edit documents; and composing and editing copy for a variety of written documents such as brochures, programs, posters, flyers, and magazine covers. (2) The student understands professional communications strategies. The student is expected to: (A) adapt language for audience, purpose, situation, and intent such as structure and style; (C) interpret and communicate information, data and observations; (E) apply active listening skills; and (F) listen to and speak with diverse individuals. (8) The student applies ethical decision making and understands and complies with laws regarding use of technology in graphic design and illustration. The student is expected to: (E) analyze the impact of the advertising and visual communications design industry on society, including concepts related to persuasiveness, marketing, and point of view. (11) The student develops an increasing understanding of graphic design and illustration. The student is expected to: (C) interpret, evaluate, and justify design decisions; (D) conduct oral or written critiques of designs by: (i) applying a critical method of evaluation; (ii) communicating an oral or written defense; and (F) employ a creative design process to create original two– or three-dimensional projects by: AAVTC: Graphic Design & Illustration: Propaganda Copyright © Texas Education Agency, 2011. All rights reserved. 1 (i) creating designs for defined applications; (ii) applying elements of design; (iii) applying design principles and typography; and (iv) using good composition. Instructor/Trainer References: Lee, Alfred McLung, & Lee, Elizabeth Briant. 1939. The Fine Art of Propaganda. Harcourt, Brace, and Co. http://www.sourcewatch.org/index.php?title=Propaganda http://www.calvin.edu/academic/cas/gpa/ Instructional Aids: Propaganda Slide Presentation Propaganda Vocabulary Terms Organizer Propaganda Project Rubric Materials Needed: Magazines Pre-selected ads Movie advertisements Pencils Paper Dictionary Thesaurus Equipment Needed: Computer with software to project slide presentation Projector Learner Experience with basic design concepts; completion of the Focal Point in Advertising lesson would be beneficial (http://www.cte.unt.edu/arts/curriculum-graphic.html). Introduction MI Introduction (LSI Quadrant I): SAY: Words may encourage, incite anger, motivate, or offer joy and peace. We make numerous emotional connections with words. SAY: Words may be truthful. Words may be lies. Words are powerful tools. ASK: How many of you know what propaganda is? (wait for answers and discuss) ASK: What distinguishes propaganda from factual information? SAY: Today we are going to look in depth at what propaganda is and develop an advertisement using propaganda. AAVTC: Graphic Design & Illustration: Propaganda Copyright © Texas Education Agency, 2011. All rights reserved. 2 Outline MI Outline (LSI Quadrant II): Instructor Notes: Outline (LSI Quadrant II): I. Define terms associated with the lesson. A. From Merriam Webster Online – "the spreading of ideas, information, or rumor for the purpose of helping or injuring an institution, a cause, or a person, or ideas, facts, or allegations spread deliberately to further one's cause or to damage an opposing cause; also: a public action having such an effect." II. Identify types of propaganda used in advertising. A. Bandwagon – Very common, where the individual generally follows the crowd to become part of the “winning team.” B. Card Stacking – Only presenting information that supports a proposal and omitting other information. C. Glittering Generalities – (often political) Uses words associated with strong values, but that means different things to different people. D. Name Calling – (seldom used, political) Derogatory language or words often used to describe an enemy. E. Lesser of Two Evils – (often political) Convinces us to choose the less offensive option. F. Plain Folks – The views represented are those of the common people and everyone around him/her. G. Pinpointing the Enemy – (most often used during wartime) Pointing to one group of persons as the enemy (gays, Muslims, or some other group that is targeted for bias). H. Simplification – (similar to above) Eliminates important information and tries to make it a simple choice like stereotyping. I. Testimonials – Quotations or endorsements; in or out of context. J. Transfer – Linking two items together to try and make the viewer think of them in the same way. AAVTC: Graphic Design & Illustration: Propaganda Copyright © Texas Education Agency, 2011. All rights reserved. 3 An example of a glittering generality is the phrase “weapons of mass destruction.” An example of “Plain Folks” is the Republican Party’s reference to the “Average Joe” or “Soccer Moms” during the McCain/Palin campaign. There are numerous examples of testimonials and endorsements by prominent athletes and actors (clothing, insurance, food and beverages, utilities, online/cell phone service providers, etc.). Have students brainstorm examples of advertising testimonials. Ask: Have you ever been influenced to purchase a certain product based on an endorsement? III. Discuss words and strategies used in advertising based on target audience. A. ages 20-35 B. ages 40-55 C. ages 60 and older Ask: Why do advertisers shift strategies based on audience age groups? IV. Compare various ads by the level of propaganda used. A. Type of propaganda used B. Target audience C. Success of the message D. Application of design elements Application MI Guided Practice (LSI Quadrant III): Using one item, allow the class to create ads in any of the propaganda styles. Share ad ideas as a group and discuss the success of the design. NOTE: This is a classroom interactive experience MI Independent Practice (LSI Quadrant III): 1. Using a list of objects given to you, create ten slogans using Propaganda and directing five of the slogans toward adults. NOTE: Generate a list of items for the students to target for propaganda, or divide the class into two groups and have each group develop the list for the other group to target. 2. Take one slogan and address the following age categories using words directed toward their specific place in life: ages 20-35 ages 40-55 ages 60 and older 3. Develop the best slogan into a final advertisement. Summary MI Review (LSI Quadrants I and IV): Review different types of propaganda by identifying the following statements: Words can hit like a hammer. AAVTC: Graphic Design & Illustration: Propaganda Copyright © Texas Education Agency, 2011. All rights reserved. 4 Words can soothe like a balm. Words can encourage and entice, and offer truth or fiction. Remember: Awareness of word choice and their use can make a difference in product presentation, and sales. The way in which the words or ad are presented can influence the viewer...even if the message is false! Evaluation MI Informal Assessment (LSI Quadrant III): The teacher will monitor student progress and assess understanding during class discussions and independent practice. Individual redirection should be provided as needed. MI Formal Assessment (LSI Quadrant III, IV): Class critique and discussion of student-created advertisements. Use the rubric as the basis for discussion and for evaluation of projects. Extension MI Extension/Enrichment (LSI Quadrant IV): Students may bring in examples of propaganda for class discussion. Students may explore visual arts career opportunities associated with propaganda (research Song Byeok for an example of a Korean artist) Students interested in history may explore the United States Holocaust Memorial Museum website and consider the role of propaganda in the events leading up to WWII (http://www.ushmm.org/propaganda/). AAVTC: Graphic Design & Illustration: Propaganda Copyright © Texas Education Agency, 2011. All rights reserved. 5 Propaganda Vocabulary Terms Organizer Define, or provide an example of the following terms from the presentation/class discussion: 1. Bandwagon 2. Card Stacking 3. Glittering Generalities 4. Name Calling 5. Lesser of Two Evils 6. Plain Folks 7. Pinpointing the Enemy 8. Simplification 9. Testimonials 10. Transfer AAVTC: Graphic Design & Illustration: Propaganda Copyright © Texas Education Agency, 2011. All rights reserved. 6 Propaganda Project Rubric Criteria Completeness (30 pts) Design elements (10 pts) Propaganda (30 pts) Creativity (20 pts) Technical skill (10 pts) Exceptional Above Average Below Average Unacceptable 25-30 points 16-24 points 1-15 points 0 points All elements included (10 slogans, 3 design concepts, final advertisement). Final advertisement is complete, but slogans or design concepts are incomplete. Slogans and design concepts are complete, but final advertisement is incomplete. None of the parts of the project is complete. 9-10 points 5-8 points 1-4 points 0 points All design elements are appropriately applied. 3-4 design elements are appropriately applied. 1-2 design elements are appropriately applied. No evidence of application of design elements. 25-30 points 16-24 points 1-15 points 0 points Message is clear and appropriate for target audience. Message is clear but inappropriate for target audience. Message is appropriate for target audience but needs some clarification. Message is unclear and inappropriate for target audience. 18-20 points 10-17 1-9 Design ideas are original in thought and exceptionally creative. Design ideas are somewhat original and creative. Limited evidence of creativity and originality in thought. 9-10 points 5-8 points 1-4 points Professional project. Drawing level is appropriate and all products are neat and professionally presented. Drawing level is appropriate, but there are smudges or rough edges on the final products. Drawing level is inappropriate but the products are neat. Points 0 points No evidence of attempted creativity or originality in thought or execution of project. 0 points Project is unprofessional. Drawing level is inappropriate and there are smudges, stains, creases, torn edges, etc. on the final products. Total_______________ (Based on 100 pt scale) AAVTC: Graphic Design & Illustration: Propaganda Copyright © Texas Education Agency, 2011. All rights reserved. 7