Lesson Plan Course Title: Principles of Architecture and Construction Session Title: Career Discovery - Urban Design Performance Objective: After completing this lesson the student will be able to demonstrate basic awareness of the urban design concept and demonstrate an awareness of the job market for urban designers. Specific Objectives: The student will define various urban design concepts. The student will demonstrate proper internet research procedures including using advanced research tools. The student will define the attributes of an urban designer. The student will identify the skills and requirements needed to become an urban designer. The student will identify the job outlook for urban designers. The student will create an urban design preliminary plan sketch. Preparation TEKS Correlations: This lesson, as published, correlates to the following TEKS. Any changes/alterations to the activities may result in the elimination of any or all of the TEKS listed. 130.42.(c)(4)(B) .. read and understand industry-specific terminology 130.42.(c)(4)(D) .. use verbal or written processes to report key information 130.42.(c)(7)(A) .. confirm understanding of verbal and visual instructions 130.42.(c)(7)(C) .. perform assignments as requested 130.42.(c)(10)(C) .. evaluate feasibility of alternative suggestions 130.42.(c)(15)(A) .. search for information and resources 130.42.(c)(15)(C) .. select appropriate search procedures and approaches 130.42.(c)(15)(H) .. success commercial, government and education resources Copyright Texas Education Agency (TEA) 1 130.42.(c)(34)(E) .. identify job opportunities for the trade 130.42.(c)(34)(G) .. analyze potential growth of identified careers 130.42.(c)(34)(I) .. examine licensing, certification and credentialing requirements at the national, state, local level to achieve compliance 130.42.(c)(35)(A) .. research information to identify appropriate responsibilities and personal characteristics 130.42.(c)(35)(C) .. identify all critical functions Interdisciplinary Correlations: English: 110.31 (c)(21)(B) .. organize information gathered from multiple sources to create a variety of graphics and forms 110.31 (c)(22)(B) .. evaluate the relevance of information to the topic and determine the reliability, validity and accuracy of sources (including internet sources) by examining their authority and objectivity 110.31 (c)(23)(C) uses graphics and illustrations to help explain concepts where appropriate Teacher Preparation: This lesson is designed to introduce the student to the concept of Urban Design and to guide the student in determining the job aspects and credentialing process of the Urban Designer. This lesson requires the student to read and comprehend specific data (from data sheet supplied). This lesson is designed to guide the student in using internet research tools to gather specific information and apply the information in a guided exercise in Urban Design. References: Alan Jefferis and David Madsen, Architectural Drafting and Design, Delmar Publisher Teachers Guide, Career information, BLS Urban Design Group Gardnerville Plan for Prosperity, Gardnerville, CA North Old Town / Chinatown Redevelopment Strategy, Portland Development Copyright Texas Education Agency (TEA) 2 Commission , Portland, OR Urban Design Concepts, West Jordan Town Center, LMN Architects Urban Design Certificate Program, University of Washington Compact City and Sustainable Urban Form, Hideki Kaji, Keio University, Tokyo, Japan Instructional Aids: 1. Display for PowerPoint, websites 2. Reference books (current course text or architectural text) 3. Reference websites (Google Map) 4. Google Map and Google Earth Materials Needed: 1. Urban Design data sheet 2. Note pad or notebook paper 3. Vellum or tracing paper 3. Set colored pencils 4. Printer paper (teacher may supply printed project map, included or have students print from the internet Equipment Needed: 1. Method to display student activity results (optional) 2. Computers if using the internet research option for the student activity 3. Printer 4. Optional: Drafting template (rectangles & squares) and straight edge (triangle) Learner Preparation: 1. Discuss procedure for paginating a word document. 2. Discuss class rules for using the internet. 3. Demonstrate sketching techniques needed for exercise 2. Introduction Introduction (LSI Quadrant I): (10-15 minutes) ASK: Does anyone know what urban design means? SAY: If you have been to a new modern shopping center with apartments or town homes nearby and have places for people to walk and gather, you have seen an example of urban design. SHOW: At appropriate times during the introduction and slide show pictures, illustrations or sketches of actual and/or proposed urban developments. ASK: Have you ever thought about what it takes to plan or design people places (places where people live, shop and recreate)? SAY : Urban design does not just happen. A lot of research, negotiating and planning among a large number of people and groups forms the nucleus of the model Urban Design. ASK: What is Urban Design and who are Urban Designers? SAY: Let's see if we can answer these questions and find out if urban design is in your future. Outline Copyright Texas Education Agency (TEA) 3 Outline (LSI Quadrant II): Instructors can use the PowerPoint presentation, slides, handouts, and note pages in conjunction with the following outline: MI Outline Notes to Instructor Part One --What is Urban Design? Summarize data sheet page 1 Urban Design is … . I. Community Character A. Reflect history B. Reflect town traditions C. Pride in ownership D. Pedestrian friendly E. Meets demand of contemporary automobile II. Mix-Use Places A. Planned development B. Mix-use places C. Horizontal development D. Vertical development III. Pedestrian Connections A. Safe and comfortable experiences B. Cluster interconnection should have ease of access C. Perimeter parking concept D. Inward parking concept IV. Traffic Calming A. Traffic management is a must B. Street-scaping C. Pedestrian friendly paving D. Dedicated pedestrian and bicycle paths V. Dimension of Sustainability A. Economic sustainability B. Environment sustainability C. Social sustainability VI. Protecting and Creating Economic Wealth A. Certainty for project developers B. Common expectation about quality C. Create and protect economic opportunities Part Two --What Is an Urban Designer? Urban designers are defined by… Summarize definition from data sheet page 2 I. What Is the Job Like? A. Determine city land use Copyright Texas Education Agency (TEA) 4 B. C. D. E. Deal with traffic and air pollution Plan for public accessibility Determine parking procedures Analyze statistics on street use, roadways, water consumption, sewers, schools, libraries, parks, museums etc. F. Develop and explain how new plans will address the community expectations II. How Do I Get Ready? A. B. C. D. E. III. College Apprenticeship Study computer science Study statistics Practice speaking and writing How Much Does the Job Pay? A. Entry level B. Experienced designers IV. How many Jobs Are There? A. B. C. D. V. 38,400 in 2008 Local government jobs Private architectural firms State governments What About the Future? A. Faster growth than the overall average B. Most growth tied to population growth C. Most future jobs in rapidly expanding communities VI. What Are Some Related Jobs? A. B. C. D. E. F. G. Verbal Linguistic Logical Mathematical Architects City managers Civil engineers Community development directors Environmental engineers Landscape architects Social scientists (geographers) Visual Spatial Musical Rhythmic Bodily Kinesthetic Intrapersonal Interpersonal Naturalist Existentialist Application Copyright Texas Education Agency (TEA) 5 Guided Practice (LSI Quadrant III): Teacher will demonstrate the criteria for completing the Urban Design lesson. Teacher will distribute the lesson data sheet and exercise 1 and 2 sheets. Teacher will demonstrate the procedure for competing exercises 1 and 2. Optional: Teacher will distribute the maps sheets if Google Earth is not available. Optional: Students may be divided into small groups for exercise 2. Independent Practice (LSI Quadrant III): Students will be given approximately 12-15 minutes to complete the criteria given in exercise 1. Students will be given approximately 15-20 minutes to complete the criteria given in exercise 2. Teacher should observe the students as they complete exercises 1 and 2 and document behavior using a camera and/or monitoring software if located in a lab environment. Summary Review (LSI Quadrants I and IV): Question: Was the organization of the information such that it was easy to comprehend? Question: Do you understand how accurate and complete information makes it easier to successfully complete a job? Evaluation Informal Assessment (LSI Quadrant III): Instructor should observe the students' independent practice time and note the issues or questions that arise. These should be brought up during summary time Formal Assessment (LSI Quadrant III, IV): Student should receive a grade for completing the research assignment. Research document should be turned in for evaluation. Student should receive a grade for active participation. Optional: Teacher will administer the "Urban Design Quiz" ( or use teacher written quiz) to check for understanding and as an evaluation tool for the independent exercises. Extension Extension/Enrichment (LSI Quadrant IV): This lesson could easily be expanded into a longer time frame project. Additional research points could be added as enumerated in the student data sheet. The Urban Design activity could first be done individually then randomly group students in groups of three. Each student presents his design then the students combine elements of each design to create a new design proposal. Groups or individuals could present their design concept which could be supported with independent or internet research. Copyright Texas Education Agency (TEA) 6 URBAN DESIGN --DATA SHEET What Is Urban Design? Urban Design is the study of the relationship among the components within a city and of the development of a design plan which will improve the quality of life within the city. It ranges in scale from parts of an environment such as streetscapes to the larger whole of districts, towns, cities or regions. Urban Design is manifest in all aspects of the physical environment including form, space movement, time, activity patterns and setting. Urban Design is concerned with the sensory and cognitive relationships between people and their environment. The urban plan will create a network of connected mix-use (commercial and residential) neighborhoods that are safe, pedestrian friendly, convenient and meet the needs of the populace. The urban design should provide direction for three clusters of opportunity sites where coordinated development can have the greatest positive impact. Community Character Urban Design concepts should reflect the history and traditions of the town. Pride in ownership is an important consideration as economic growth will respond to this context. The central plan should be pedestrian friendly with outlying areas providing the needs of contemporary demands of the automobile. Mix-use Places The modern urban plan utilizes planned developments that mix residential and commercial uses. These developments may be horizontal or stacked. The horizontal model has separated residential and commercial structures intermingled on the same site providing ease of access between the two. Stacked developments have both uses in the same structure. Commercial store fronts usually occupy the lower levels while residential areas occupy the upper levels. Pedestrian Connections One objective of urban planning is to design new projects that provide safety and comfort. The inter connection between use clusters should be planned for ease of access. One concept places parking on the perimeter with clusters inward. Another concept places clusters on the perimeter with parking inward. Both concepts should provide connecting sidewalks which promote access between clusters. Traffic Calming Urban planning must include managing automobile traffic. This includes streetscaping and paving materials that make it clear roadways are passing through pedestrian districts. Provision of on-street parking, designed widths and pedestrian amenities indicate cars are sharing neighborhood streets with pedestrians and bicycles. Copyright Texas Education Agency (TEA) 7 Dimension of Sustainability Economic Sustainability-Economic activities grow in stability by changing its structure to saving resources and energies. Environmental Sustainability-All the city activities work with zero emission to maintain safe and comfortable environment for urban residence. Social Sustainability-Social equity is achieved by equal distribution of social services. Protecting and Creating economic Value One of the benefits of a master urban plan is that it provides certainty for project developers and adjacent property owners. There is a common expectation about the quality and creation of shared addresses that creates higher values for land and existing and future buildings. The urban concepts should create and protect economic opportunities for the community and property owners. What Is An Urban Designer? A wide variety of people call themselves urban designers. In one sense anyone who is involved in making places, is active in urban design. Even if you take a college course in "urban design” what you learn will depend on which university you choose. Urban Design is a much diversified profession and not all universities have the same curriculum. Local institutions decide what an "Urban Design" curriculum should be and/or what expertise and knowledge you need to be able to practice as an urban designer. The American Planning Association (APA) is a professional organization which offers a certification program for the American Institute of Certified Planners (AICP). An urban designer needs a broad understanding of cities and towns and ways of making them work better. This involves understanding how the planning system operates, how developers make their costs add up, how to assess what makes a particular place special, how to make places easy to move around by foot and vehicle, how to bring life to places that have become run down, how to conserve historic buildings, how to make the most of landscape, how to think about the future of small and large development sites, how to involve local people, how to make sure projects actually happen, how to communicate effectively, how to negotiate and how to write design and guidance policy. This may sound like a lot of subjects, but they are all interconnected in urban designing. The urban designer is not expected to be expert in all of these areas but it is essential to see the interworking of them and to see the whole picture. What Is the Job Like? City planners figure out the best way to use the land in cities and neighborhoods. They report on the best location for houses, stores and parks. They try to solve many problems such as traffic increase and air pollution. Designers want to make sure Copyright Texas Education Agency (TEA) 8 people can get to where they need as easy as possible. They plan where people should drive cars, where to park, where to ride bicycles and where to walk. Designers are also concerned about saving the environment and providing schools, parks, roads and recreation centers. Before making plans for an urban development, urban designers need to know where everything is. They find out how many people use the streets, highways, water, sewers, schools, libraries, museums and parks. Designers listen to advice of people who live in the community. With these and many other facts, the urban designer develops a plan and explains the new plans. They also give an estimate of the cost of the changes. How Do I Get Ready? Most employers seek persons who have a master's degree in city planning or urban design. Sometimes employers will hire persons who have worked as a planner for a long time. A bachelor's degree is good to have when looking for the first job. Persons who are interested in becoming urban designers should take courses in computer science. To become an urban designer you should know how to use a computer. Classes in Architecture and Construction are also helpful. You must take the right amount of classes. Working in an office of a city planner is very helpful. Urban designers must be able to speak and write well and must pass a test for certification. How Much Does the Job Pay? In May, 2008, urban and regional planners had an average annual salary of $62,400. How Many Jobs Are There? Urban and regional designers held about 38,400 jobs in 2008. Most of them worked for local governments. Some designers worked for private architectural and engineering firms. Some worked for state governments. What About the Future? The number of jobs for urban designers is expected to grow faster than the average for all occupations through the year 2018. Most of their work will result from the population growth. Most jobs will be in rapidly expanding communities. What Are Some Related Jobs? Architects, City Managers, Civil Engineers, Community Development Directors, Environmental Engineers, Landscape Architects and Social Scientists (geographers). References: Alan Jefferis and David Madsen, Architectural Drafting and Design, Delmar Publisher Teachers Guide, Career information, BLS Urban Design Group Gardnerville Plan for Prosperity, Gardnerville, CA North Old Town, Chinatown Redevelopment Strategy, Portland Development Commission, Portland, OR Copyright Texas Education Agency (TEA) 9 Urban Design Concepts, West Jordan Town Center, LMN Architects Urban Design Certificate Program, University of Washington Compact City And Sustainable Urban Form, Hideki Kaji, Keio University, Tokyo, Japan American Planning Association, 1776 Massachusetts Ave. NW., Suite 400, Washington, DC 20036 (www.planning.org) Association of Collegiate Schools of Planning, 6311 Mallard Trace, Tallahassee, FL 32312 (www. Acsp.org) Additional Research: Bureau of Labor Statistics, Occupational Outlook Handbook, 2102-11 Edition (www.bls.gov/oco/ocos057.htm) Occupational Outlook Quarterly (www. Bls.gov/opub/ooq/2005/spring/art01.pdf) Copyright Texas Education Agency (TEA) 10 Urban Design Activity Sheet Activity 1 Research Instructions: Teacher: Each student should be given access to this document. Document may be modified to suit. Assign each student a specific search engine to use (teacher may modify list to suit) 1. Google.com 2. Yahoo.com 3. Ask.com 4. Bing.com 5. Other The teacher should be sure each student knows how to access the computer and use the advanced search options in each search engine. Student: Complete the Header of this document with the correct information. Procedure: Connect to the internet using your school procedure. Use the assigned search engine and *advanced search procedures for the following: 1. List the top three requirements for being hired as an urban designer (urban design jobs, qualifications for urban designers) a. b. c. 2. The three college courses an urban designer should take (urban design certification programs, colleges for urban design) a. b. c. 3. Locate three images of proposed or actual urban developments. List the name of the development below and copy and paste the images below (urban design images, urban design projects). a. b. c. 4. Print your document using class print procedures. *Use quotes before and after multiple word searches (“urban design”) *Use a colon and specific location after the search word(s) to specific limit the search to the specified area (“urban design jobs”:TX). *Use the “advanced search” feature of the search engine. Copyright Texas Education Agency (TEA) 11 Urban Design Activity 2 Requirements: 1)Access to computers and 2) Google Earth. If Google Earth is not available you may use the attached printed maps. (Copy attached Google Earth Maps to document, enlarge to fit page and print one map for each student 3) Colored pencils or markers. Teacher: Assign each student a specific location from the list below (substitute areas may be used). Substitute areas should be zoomed to an altitude of 200 ft. Student: Use the assigned link below. Study the area shown on the map. Note the location of buildings, vegetation (landscape). Save the map as a bitmap then change the color to “Washout”. Print the map using school print procedures. Use the printed map or the one furnished for the following exercise. Procedure: Connect to the internet using your school procedure. Using the assigned link below examine the listed areas. Assume the listed area is scheduled for redevelopment. You have been given the job to come up with a proposal for the redevelopment. Use the images from Activity 1 and the attached sample as reference. Follow the criteria below for your development. Use colored pencils or markers to illustrate the different types of buildings, parking, walks, bike paths, parks, etc. 1. Use existing streets as shown on map 2. Lots may be combined 3. Use existing buildings and/or create new ones or use a combination of new and current structures. Use different colors for different types of buildings (shops, restaurants, theaters etc.) 4. Identify parking areas, walking paths, parks, pavilions, water features etc. 5. Any building may be removed by drawing new feature over it. 6. Interior streets may be blocked off, designated as one way or converted to walkway, bike path etc. 7. Boundary streets must stay as is but may be designated as one way to accommodate traffic flow. Copyright Texas Education Agency (TEA) 12 Area One: New Braunfels Re-development Project This area of the city scheduled for re-development is bounded by Frostwood Dr. on the west, Riverside Dr. on the east and Summerwood Dr. on the north. Click on the link below to see the map. Use Google Earth to view current buildings and landscape. Use colored pencils or markers to draw off and color in the features of your proposal. Be sure to include a legend to identify the colors used for different structures, roads, paths, etc. <http://maps.google.com/maps?hl=en&ie=UTF8&ll=29.709319,98.104056&spn=0.00534,0.006673&t=f&z=17&ecpose=29.70918723,98.10405598,746.92,0.011,1.517,0> Area Two: Abilene Re-development Project This area of Abilene is scheduled for re-development. The new development will be between Interstate 20 on the north, South 3rd St. on the south , Meander St. on the east and Amarillo St. on the west. Click on the link below to see the map. Use Google Earth to view current buildings and landscape. Use colored pencils or markers to draw off and color in the features of your proposal. Be sure to include a legend to identify the colors used for different structures, roads, paths, etc. http://maps.google.com/maps?hl=en&ie=UTF8&t=f&ecpose=32.44816278,99.74535542,901.99,0,5.296,0&ll=32.448474,99.745355&spn=0.003074,0.004608&z=18 Area Three: McKinney Re-development Project This area of McKinney is to be re-developed. The new development will include a multi-story hotel. The area is bounded on the north by US 380, on the south by W. Pearson Avenue and by Sherman St. and Coleman St. on the west and east, respectively. Click on the link below to see the map. Use Google Earth to view current buildings and landscape. Use colored pencils or markers to draw off and color in the features of your proposal. Be sure to include a legend to identify the colors used for different structures, roads, paths, etc. http://maps.google.com/maps?hl=en&ie=UTF8&t=f&ecpose=33.2130801,96.61914519,604,0,5.3,0&ll=33.213427,96.619145&spn=0.003047,0.004608&z=18 Copyright Texas Education Agency (TEA) 13 Sample Project: Your project should be color coded for features, structure s and landscap ing. Include labels and color code legend. Copyright Texas Education Agency (TEA) 14 Optional Maps if internet or Google Earth is not available New Braunfels Google Earth Map Copyright Texas Education Agency (TEA) 15 New Braunfels Google Map Copyright Texas Education Agency (TEA) 16 Abilene Google Earth Map Copyright Texas Education Agency (TEA) 17 Abilene Google Map Copyright Texas Education Agency (TEA) 18 McKinney Google Earth Map Copyright Texas Education Agency (TEA) 19 McKinney Google Map Copyright Texas Education Agency (TEA) 20 Urban Design Reading Questions and Quiz Part 1 --Reading assignment Directions: Read the Urban Design Data sheet and complete the following. Fill in the blank with the word or phrase from the reading assignment that best completes the statement. ______ 1. Urban designers are concerned with creating plans that improve the __________ of life within the city. ______ 2. The urban plan will create a network of connected ________ neighborhoods. ______ 3. Urban plans should provide _________ and comfort for pedestrians. ______ 4. Urban designing must include a method for managing ________. ______ 5. Planners are concerned about saving the _________. ______ 6. Economic, environmental and social _________ is a critical element of urban design. ______ 7. Urban designers make _______ and _______ work better. ______ 8. Urban designers must also estimate the total ______ of the project. ______ 9. A master urban plan provides ______ for developers and land owners. ______ 10. Urban designers must know where _______ is. ______ 11. Anyone who is involved in ________ places is involved in urban designing. ______ 12. A ________ is good to have when looking for your first job as an urban designer. ______ 13. Urban designers must know how to use a _____________. ______ 14. The number of jobs for planners is expected to _________. Copyright Texas Education Agency (TEA) 21 Urban Design Reading Questions and Quiz Part 2 --True or False Quiz Directions: Read each statement carefully. If the statement is completely true place a printed, capital "T" in the blank to the left of the statement. If any part of the statement is false, place a printed capital "F" in the blank to the left of the statement. Use standard block lettering. ______ 1. Urban designers are concerned only with the environment. ______ 2. The central plan should be pedestrian friendly. ______ 3. On-street parking should be avoided at all costs. ______ 4. Urban designers rely on managers and others for negotiating and writing policy. ______ 5. City planners figure out the best way to use the land in cities and neighborhoods. ______ 6. Urban designers must be knowledgeable in a wide range of subjects. ______ 7. Urban design is not an exact or narrowly defined occupation. ______ 8. Persons interested in urban design should take courses in computer science and statistics and classes in Architecture and Construction. ______ 9. Most urban design jobs are with small architectural firms. ______ 10. Urban designers need to know where everything related to city life is. ______ 11. The future of urban design is directly related to the growth and expansion of communities. ______ 12. Urban designers are not generally concerned with the preservation of existing old buildings. ______ 13. Mix-use concepts use the "stacked" and/or the "horizontal" structure concept. ______ 14. The horizontal structure always places parking on the perimeter with shops in the middle. ______ 15. Streetscaping and landscaping are vital part of the urban development plan. Copyright Texas Education Agency (TEA) 22 Answers to Urban Design Reading Questions and Quiz Part 1 1. quality Part 2 1. F 2. mix-use 2. T 3. safety 3. F 4. traffic 4. F 5. environment 5. T 6. sustainability 6. T 7. cities, towns 7. T 8. cost 8. T 9. certainty 9. F 10. everything 10. T 11. making 11. T 12. degree 12. F 13. computer 13. T 14. increase 14. F 15. T Copyright Texas Education Agency (TEA) 23 Urban Design Rubric Task Statement: Urban Design Task Assignment: _______________________________________ Criteria Concepts/Skills to be Assessed Novice 1 Criteria Categories (Novice to Exemplary) Developing Accomplished 2 3 Exemplary 4 Demonstrate understanding of Urban Design Concept No understanding Some understanding Good understanding Fully understands (Possible 8 points) (1-2 points) (3-4 points) (5-6 points) (7-8 points) Identifies types of mix-use places (buildings) Unable to identify Able to identify one type Identifies each type in some cases (Possible 8 points) (1-2 points) (3-4 points) (5-6 points) Identifies each type in most cases (7-8 points) Navigate advanced search procedures (Possible 8 points) Unable to use advanced search feature (1-2 points) Improperly uses advanced search features (3-4 points) Sometimes uses advanced search features (5-6 points) Accurately and effectively uses advanced searches (7-8 points) Utilizes research data to solve design problem Does not use research data Applies research data inappropriately Utilizes some date appropriately Uses data appropriately (Possible 16 points) (1-4 points) (5-8 points) (9-12 points) (13-16 points) A = 31-40 points; B = 21-30 points; C = 11-20 points; D = 6-10 points Maximum points = 40 Copyright Texas Education Agency (TEA) Total Points: Points Earned