18 July 2014
Practice Group(s):
Antitrust,
Competition and
Trade Regulation
Energy, Infrastructure
and Resources
Carbon Tax Repeal Places Spotlight on Price
Reductions
By Murray Deakin, Jenny Mee and Sylvia Ng
After months of delay, the Australian Government has passed legislation to repeal
Australia's carbon tax and introduce new sanctions against energy and gas refrigerant
entities that do not pass on cost savings arising from the repeal of the tax.
Among the package of amendments, the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (CCA)
has been amended to:
•
create a carbon tax price reduction obligation
•
impose a penalty on certain entities who fail to pass on carbon tax repeal cost
savings
•
require certain entities to substantiate that their cost savings have been passed
on to consumers
•
prohibit false or misleading representations about the effect of the carbon tax
repeal
•
give the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) price
monitoring and other powers to oversee the carbon tax repeal.
The new carbon tax price reduction laws principally apply to suppliers of natural gas and
electricity, bulk suppliers of synthetic greenhouse gases and suppliers of synthetic
greenhouse gas equipment (regulated entities).
The carbon tax repeal bills passed the House of Representatives for the third time and
then passed the Senate with the support of the Palmer United Party (PUP) alliance on 17
July 2014.
The legislation will apply retrospectively from 1 July 2014. The law is expected to
commence on the date it receives Royal Assent.
Energy Companies in the Frame
The carbon tax repeal will end carbon tax liabilities for approximately 371 entities that
were liable under the scheme, as well as end certain levies on liquid fuels and synthetic
greenhouse gases.
The Australian Government's recent amendments to the repeal bill, after negotiations
with the PUP alliance:
•
require an estimated 100 businesses comprised of natural gas and electricity
suppliers and bulk suppliers of synthetic gases used in refrigeration:
o
to comply with a carbon tax removal substantiation notice from the ACCC,
explaining and substantiating the effects of the carbon tax removal on costs
and prices
o
to produce within 30 days of Royal Assent, a carbon tax removal substantiation
statement estimating, on an annual percentage price basis or an average
Carbon Tax Repeal Places Spotlight on Price Reductions
annual dollar price basis, the costs savings in the 2014-2015 financial year that
will be passed on to each class of customer
•
require energy and gas suppliers to prepare statements for customers regarding such
estimated costs savings
•
impose on particular suppliers of electricity or natural gas, and bulk importers of
synthetic greenhouse gases, penalties of 250% of any savings which are not passed
through
•
exempt businesses that sell a small amount of refrigerant gases each day such as
vendors of fridges, air conditioners and cars.
In the lead up, the sticking point related to negotiations between political parties on the
amendments to the bill to guarantee that full savings from the carbon tax repeal, would
be passed on to consumers.
The Laws
Carbon Tax Price Reduction Obligation
The new Part V of the CCA prohibits carbon tax related price exploitation in relation to
the supply of regulated goods during the carbon tax repeal transition period (ie 1 July
2014 until 30 June 2015).
Under section 60C of the CCA, a regulated entity will engage in price exploitation in
relation to the carbon tax repeal if:
•
it makes a regulated supply
•
the price for the supply does not pass through all of the entity's cost savings
relating to the supply that are directly or indirectly attributable to the carbon tax
repeal.
In determining whether there has been a full pass through of the regulated entity's carbon
tax repeal cost savings, regard is to be had to a number of matters, including the relevant
cost savings, how they can reasonably be attributed to the entity's different supplies, the
entity's costs and other relevant matters that may reasonably influence price.
A regulated entity is a supplier of "regulated goods" which are defined as natural gas,
electricity, synthetic greenhouse gases and synthetic greenhouse gas equipment, and
any other goods prescribed by the Minister.
The ACCC will be able to issue written notices to:
•
an entity suspected of engaging in price exploitation in relation to the carbon tax
repeal, and the notice will be considered prima facie evidence that the price
charged for the supply did not pass through all of the regulated entity's relevant
cost savings
or
•
warn a regulated entity that supplies specified in the notice should not be made
above a maximum price (as otherwise, it could amount to price exploitation).
Those engaging in carbon specific price exploitation with respect to certain regulated
goods may be liable to pay penalties of up to a maximum of AUD1,100,070 (for
corporations) and AUD220,150 (for individuals). Additionally, remedies such as
damages, injunctions and orders limiting prices or requiring refunds could apply.
2
Carbon Tax Repeal Places Spotlight on Price Reductions
False or Misleading Representations Regarding the Effect of Carbon Tax
Repeal
The new Part V of the CCA will also contain a new provision that prevents any
corporation from making false or misleading representations about the effect of the
carbon tax repeal, in connection with the supply or possible supply of goods or services
during the carbon tax repeal transition period. This prohibition will apply to all goods and
services supplied, and not just the supply of "regulated goods".
Maximum civil pecuniary penalties of up to AUD1,100,070 (for corporations) and
AUD220,150 (for individuals) may apply.
Increased ACCC Monitoring Powers
The ACCC has now been formally provided with powers to monitor the prices from
electricity, gas and refrigerant gas industries and those with indirect carbon liabilities.
This is on top of the directive the Australian Government gave to the ACCC on
monitoring activities in February 2014.
The amendments provide new powers for the ACCC to monitor the prices of certain
"relevant goods" (including "regulated goods" and any goods specified by regulation) and
any goods supplied by a corporation that is on the Liable Entities Public Information
Database. Additionally, the ACCC will have information gathering powers to:
•
assess the general effect before and during the carbon tax repeal transition
period
•
assess compliance
•
assess the effect of the carbon tax repeal on prices.
In doing so, the ACCC has been given powers to monitor prices advertised, displayed
and offered. These powers are in addition to the ACCC's information gathering powers
under s 155 of the CCA.
Additionally, the ACCC has also been given information gathering powers to request a
person to produce specified information or produce documents containing information
relating to prices or the setting of prices, if it is reasonably believed to be information that
will be useful for the ACCC to monitor prices. It will be an offence to refuse or fail to
comply with such a request (a maximum penalty of AUD3,400).
Infringement Notices
The ACCC will be provided with powers to issue infringement notices for price
exploitation relating to the carbon tax repeal. The Explanatory Memorandum states that
the infringement notice is intended to provide an efficient and effective way for the ACCC
to tackle minor breaches by a person whom the ACCC considers has breached the new
prohibitions, without needing to apply to the courts for a civil pecuniary penalty. The
infringement notice amounts range from AUD102,000 for listed corporations, to
AUD10,200 for non-listed corporations to AUD2,040 for individuals.
Impact on Businesses
The amendments are likely to create practical challenges for affected businesses and
energy suppliers, especially in calculating the net direct and indirect cost savings derived
from the carbon tax repeal. Such difficulties may be further complicated by other
regulatory requirements, such as under certain energy legislation which prescribes how
3
Carbon Tax Repeal Places Spotlight on Price Reductions
and when price changes may occur. In this regard, the Australian Energy Regulator has
already issued a compliance statement in relation to its approach to standing offer prices
under the National Energy Customer Framework, stating its expectation for retailers to
publish prices immediately upon repeal.
The Explanatory Memorandum foreshadows logistical difficulties in ensuring consumers
reap the benefits of the repeal. It recognises the complexities of quantifying the specific
price changes as a result of the introduction of carbon tax in 2012, and that commercial
and contractual arrangements and other factors (eg supply chain absorption, inflation,
changes in the production cost base) may impact on the proportion of carbon tax that
may have been passed through or absorbed.
The ACCC has therefore been given new monitoring powers to enable it to monitor
pricing concerns and request information relating to regulated goods such as natural gas,
electricity, synthetic greenhouse gas, synthetic greenhouse gas equipment, goods
supplied by entities that have an entry in the Liable Entities Public Information Database,
and other goods listed by regulation. Regulated entities should therefore undertake a
carbon tax repeal cost savings analysis which would identify:
•
prices before the carbon tax
•
price increases (if any) since the introduction of the carbon tax
•
cost savings directly or indirectly attributable to the carbon tax repeal
•
net compliance cost savings.
Compliance Measures
The Explanatory Memorandum has envisaged that the ACCC will take a targeted
approach and will monitor around 500 businesses affected, including liable entities,
energy retailers and synthetic greenhouse gas importers and wholesalers.
The ACCC has indicated that it will engage with stakeholders to ensure that regulatory
obligations are understood. It has already issued a media release putting businesses on
notice about the carbon tax price reduction obligation, and has encouraged consumers or
businesses concerned that their suppliers are engaging in price exploitation to contact
the supplier to obtain information on the effect of the carbon tax repeal on the supplier's
prices. If consumers or businesses remain concerned, they have been advised to contact
the ACCC. It also proposes to issue guidance material.
Given the investigation and enforcement powers of the ACCC, it is important that
businesses undertake an appropriate carbon tax repeal cost savings analysis and
develop a compliance plan, so that they are in a position to justify their prices in response
to any price exploitation claims or notices.
Contact Us
We can assist regulated entities and other clients to comply with these carbon tax repeal
obligations, including advising on:
•
the net direct and indirect costs savings to be derived from the carbon tax repeal
•
the quantum and timing of any price adjustments and credits
•
substantiation carbon tax removal substantiation notices and other regulatory
reporting requirements
•
the content of statements for electricity and natural gas customers
4
Carbon Tax Repeal Places Spotlight on Price Reductions
•
other communications with customers and other stakeholders.
Additionally, we can advise businesses that are concerned their supplier might be
engaging in price exploitation.
Authors:
Murray Deakin
murray.deakin@klgates.com
+61.2.9513.2335
Jenny Mee
jenny.mee@klgates.com
+61.2.9513.2555
Sylvia Ng
sylvia.ng@klgates.com
+61.2.9513.2303
Anchorage Austin Beijing Berlin Boston Brisbane Brussels Charleston Charlotte Chicago Dallas Doha Dubai Fort Worth Frankfurt
Harrisburg Hong Kong Houston London Los Angeles Melbourne Miami Milan Moscow Newark New York Orange County Palo Alto
Paris Perth Pittsburgh Portland Raleigh Research Triangle Park San Diego San Francisco São Paulo Seattle Seoul Shanghai
Singapore Spokane Sydney Taipei Tokyo Warsaw Washington, D.C. Wilmington
K&L Gates comprises more than 2,000 lawyers globally who practice in fully integrated offices located on five
continents. The firm represents leading multinational corporations, growth and middle-market companies,
capital markets participants and entrepreneurs in every major industry group as well as public sector entities,
educational institutions, philanthropic organizations and individuals. For more information about K&L Gates or
its locations, practices and registrations, visit www.klgates.com.
This publication is for informational purposes and does not contain or convey legal advice. The information herein should not be used or relied upon
in regard to any particular facts or circumstances without first consulting a lawyer.
© 2014 K&L Gates LLP. All Rights Reserved.
5