Longwood University Rubric for Ethics Audit
1. Clearly States the Ethical Dilemma……………………
1
Unable to identify ethical issue
2
3
4
5
Identifies the ethical issue and explains
the underlying principle being violated
5
Identifies stakeholders and describes
potential impacts
5
Uses multiple applicable but contrasting
theories
5
Provides adequate and detailed
description of ethical theory used
5
Provides realistic ramifications or each
possible choice
5
Is able to use values based logic to defend
position
5
Information in logical, interesting
sequence which reader can follow
5
Work ahs no spelling or grammatical
errors
5
Work displays a appropriate number of
references, written correctly
2. Identifies the Stakeholders Involved in an Ethical Issue
1
Unable to identify stakeholders
2
3
4
3. Evaluates the Issue from Multiple Ethical Perspectives
1
Unable to state ethical theory
2
3
4
4. Can State the Approach to Ethics Being Used……….
1
Unable to state ethical theory
2
3
4
5. Identifies the Ramifications of Various Solutions……
1
Unable to identify ramifications
2
3
4
6. Defends Chosen Solution……………………………..
1
Unable to give adequate reasoning
for ethical choice
1
Sequence of information is difficult
to follow
1
Work has four or more spelling
errors and/or grammatical errors
1
Work displays no references
2
3
4
2
3
4
2
3
4
2
3
4
7. Organization………………………………………….
8. Grammar and Spelling………………………………..
9. References……………………………………………
Total Points:_____________________________________
Comments:______________________________________________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________