Designing an EVS hardware management
system
Paul Burt
Senior Learning and Technology Adviser
Centre for Educational and Academic Development (CEAD)
University of Surrey – key facts
circa 12K students
four faculties:
Faculty of Arts and Human Sciences
Faculty of Engineering and Physical Sciences
Faculty of Health and Medical Sciences
Faculty of Management and Law
single compact campus in Guildford
3
EVS ownership
the university purchased 1000 TurningPoint RF handsets in
2006
a further 1500 purchased in 2007
45 USB receivers owned
EVS Pilot 2006-2007
aimed to learn how lecturers approach using EVS
varying class sizes (40 – 200) and levels
focused on those lecturers willing to use it regularly
frequent session observations, supported by ongoing dialogue with
CEAD staff
different handset distribution models trialled
loan for semester (admin by lecturer/department)
distributed by lecturer at each session
distributed by CEAD staff at each session
Pilot findings – hardware management
student attitude towards handsets
low perceived monetary value = little care taken
if students had handsets for extended duration then many returned
‘dirty’ from being in bottom of bags/pencil cases
manual loan system
difficulty of documenting handset codes
deciphering handwritten names
greater losses than per session distribution
distribution per session
only really manageable in small cohorts (<30)
difficulty of dealing with latecomers/early leavers
difficulty of dealing with multiple room exits
Objectives – hardware management
maximise use and availability of a limited resource to support
widespread usage
many of the distribution models trialled in the pilot were not
sustainable in terms of requiring staffing resource to implement
not financially possible to sustain regular handset losses
want to encourage regular, rather then infrequent, EVS usage
unlike in pilot, high probability of having in-range sessions operating
simultaneously and therefore need to avoid radio interference by
using unique RF channels
Solution – hardware management
students:
borrow an single handset each via Library
staff:
attend “Using an Electronic Voting System to Support Active
Learning” three hour course
fill in web form to request to teach with EVS
once request approved, are lent USB receiver
(paper loan form used)
receivers all programmed to unique RF channels
given a slide to append to presentations that shows channel number
given leaflets to pass onto students
Setting the channel on your voting handset
This session is on channel XX
1. Press GO
(light flashes red/green)
2. Enter the two-digit channel number
3. Press GO (light goes green)
Important: if the light does not end on green
you have not successfully changed the
channel and need to try again
8
9
Student buy-in leaflet
Solution – Library handset loans
led to the following challenges:
convincing Library colleagues to take on responsibility
individual handsets needed to be available on shelves
lack of physical space on handset to attach TALIS compatible
barcode
need to prevent theft of handsets from library
desire to raise perceived value of handsets
desire to offer physical protection to handsets
need to provide handset instructions (channel reprogramming)
Solution – handset cases
students use self-issue
facility to borrow
handset
handset is in a case
which can only be
unlocked by decoupler
in Library foyer
channel reprogramming
instructions on rear of
case
Handset cases – in detail
small lockable cases imported from Hong Kong
foam inserts designed in-house and made by foam specialist
paper sleeves designed in-house and printed/die-cut
handsets etched using ‘Selectamark’
temp staff employed for assembly (approx four people/two
weeks)
Reflections and evaluation*
pros:
zero financial loss over 2.5 years of operating
loan system (approx three students have
paid for replacements)
students now unquestioning of method
cons:
not ideal for staff new to EVS to experiment
semester long loan prevents maximising
usage when staff don’t commit to using EVS
regularly
students forgetting handsets
* student employed to evaluate system 2008