ANNEX A GSC6 RESOLUTIONS GSC6(00)49 RESOLUTION GSC 6/1 (Sapporo, Japan): International Mobile Telecommunications (IMT)-2000 and Beyond The Global Standards Collaboration 6 meeting recognizing a) b) c) d) that the World Telecommunication Standardization Assembly (WTSA)-2000 which meets in September 2000 will be agreeing on Resolutions which will have a significant impact on the effectiveness, efficiency and role of the ITU-T in the future; that the ITU Telecommunication Standardization Advisory Group (TSAG) has agreed to propose to WTSA-2000 an initial name and mandate for a group to work on “IMT-2000 and Beyond”; that the various initiatives on improving the ITU-T processes and working methods are anticipated to produce concrete benefits beginning immediately after the WTSA-2000; that the GSC Participating Standards Organizations (PSOs) and Liaison Organizations have a vested interest in the ongoing success of the ITU-T and in the harmonization and development of standards for global application, considering a) b) c) d) that a main objective of GSC is to support the interaction and coordination of the GSC PSOs and Liaison Organizations in support of ITU-T standards activities; that an ITU-T structure which reflects the key technology areas and functional skills of the ITU-T is desirable in terms of collaboration with the GSC PSOs and Liaison Organizations; that it is necessary that the ITU-T be able to work quickly, effectively and efficiently in response to dynamic industry needs and directions with respect to Third Generation Wireless Systems (IMT-2000 and beyond); that cooperation and coordination with other standards bodies, forums, consortia and, in particular Partnership Projects, are crucial to the success of the ITU-T, resolves that the PSOs (and through their Member States, where applicable) urge the ITU-T at WTSA-2000 to: 1) 2) 3) give careful consideration to the best organizational structure for a group to address “IMT-2000 and Beyond” based on the terms of reference agreed by TSAG; if agreed by WTSA-2000, to put the “IMT-2000 and Beyond” group into operation as soon as possible after WTSA-2000; and if agreed by WTSA-2000, to direct the “IMT-2000 and Beyond” group to develop a complementary program and strong cooperative relations with the 3G Partnership Projects. GSC6(00)49 ANNEX A GSC6 RESOLUTIOS RESOLUTION GSC 6/2 (Sapporo, Japan): Endorsement of ITU TSAG Proposal for WTSA-2000 The Global Standards Collaboration 6 meeting considering a) that many of the GSC Participating Standards Organizations (PSOs) and Liaison Organizations actively participate in the ITU Telecommunications Standardization Advisory Group (TSAG); b) that the package of draft new and revised Resolutions and Recommendations developed via the meetings and correspondence groups of TSAG reflects their interests; c) that many of the new and revised Resolutions and Recommendations developed by TSAG will improve the speed, efficiency and flexibility of the ITU-T; d) that ITU-T Member States and Sector Members may make additional or alternative proposals on matters prior to the World Telecommunication Standardization Assembly (WTSA)-2000 as they desire; resolves that, whilst noting considering d) above, proposals made by TSAG for WTSA-2000 consideration and approval should be supported by GSC PSOs and Liaison Organizations. -2- GSC6(00)49 ANNEX A GSC6 RESOLUTIOS RESOLUTION GSC 6/3 (Sapporo, Japan): ITU-T Reform The Global Standards Collaboration 6 meeting recognizing a) b) c) d) e) that the World Telecommunication Standardization Assembly (WTSA)-2000 which meets in September 2000 will be discussing aspects of ITU-T Reform which could have a significant impact on the effectiveness, efficiency and role of the ITU-T in the future; that the Working Group on ITU Reform (and its Ad-hoc Group 1 to address the creation of a new global standardization entity under the umbrella of the ITU) will meet next in October/November 2000 to continue discussion on ITU-T Reform; that the various initiatives on improving the ITU-T processes and working methods are anticipated to produce concrete benefits beginning immediately after the WTSA; that the GSC Participating Standards Organizations (PSOs) and Liaison Organizations have a vested interest in an ITU-T Reform which maintains the leadership role of the ITU in global standards development and increases the effectiveness of cooperation and coordination with the ITU-T; that reform of the ITU-T should reflect the leading role of the private sector in the telecommunications environment; considering a) b) c) the active participation by many of the GSC PSO members and Observer members in the WTSA and in the Working Group on ITU Reform; that a main objective of GSC is to support the interaction and coordination of ITU-T standards activities with the GSC PSOs and Liaison Organizations; that cooperation and coordination with other standards bodies, forums, consortia and in particular Partnership Projects are crucial to the success of the ITU-T; resolves that the PSOs, including their ITU-T members, consider and evaluate the proposals for ITU Reform, and as appropriate (and through their Member States and ITU-T members, where applicable), urge the ITU-T at WTSA-2000 and the Working Group on ITU Reform (and its Ad-Hoc Group 1) to reflect in their reform activities the need to: 1) 2) 3) maintain the leadership role of the ITU-T, within its scope, in global standards development and harmonization; increase the effectiveness of cooperation and coordination with the GSC PSOs and Liaison Organizations, inter-PSO partnership projects and other telecommunications standards bodies, forums and consortia; and take into account the leading role of the private sector in developing technical telecommunications standards. -3- GSC6(00)49 ANNEX A GSC6 RESOLUTIOS RESOLUTION GSC 6/4 (Sapporo, Japan): ITU-T Relationship with the Standards Development Organizations of the 3GPPs The Global Standards Collaboration 6 meeting recognizing a) b) c) that regional Standards Development Organization (SDOs) have established Third Generation Partnership Projects (3GPPs) to produce specifications for IMT-2000 family members to be transposed into deliverables by the SDOs; that the ITU-T Telecommunication Standardization Advisory Group (TSAG) has produced a draft Resolution for the World Telecommunication Standardization Assembly (WTSA)-2000 which includes the activities in the ITU-T for producing Recommendations on IMT-2000 and Beyond; that TSAG has sent a liaison to the relevant SDOs on improving communications on this subject; considering a) b) c) that the establishment of good communications between the ITU-T and the SDOs of the 3GPPs is desired; that the close collaboration between the SDOs of the 3GPPs and the ITU-T on work program proposals to avoid duplication of technical work is desired; that the better understanding of the role of the ITU-T in providing the necessary Recommendations for interworking functions for global mobility between IMT-2000 family members is desired; resolves that the SDOs of the 3GPPs and the ITU-T should meet at the earliest opportunity to establish a framework agreement for cooperation and coordination, recognizing the results of the 3GPPs SDOs meeting with the ITU-R (September 99) and taking into account the ITU-T Recommendations A.4, A.5, A.6 and the ETSI/ITU-T Memorandum of Understanding. -4- GSC6(00)49 ANNEX A GSC6 RESOLUTIOS RESOLUTION GSC 6/5 (Sapporo, Japan): Internet Protocol (IP) The Global Standards Collaboration 6 meeting recognizing in regards to IP-Telephony and IP-Related Services a) that the ITU, GSC Participating Standard Organizations (PSOs), Internet Engineering Task Force (IETF), and other Standards Development Organizations (SDOs) have progressed the development of telecommunication-based technologies supported by Internet Protocol (IP); b) that many future networks will be based on IP, and will be designed to support existing services as well as new multi-media services; c) that interworking of networks based on IP and other networks using both IP and other technologies is a major requirement; concludes that harmonization of solutions is key to the deployment of IP-based activities, according to architecture principles supporting the requirements of public networks resolves to encourage the ITU-T, the IETF, and relevant PSOs, fora and consortia to harmonize their ongoing work in the area of integrating IP-based capabilities into telecommunication networks and services and pay specific attention to: a) development of an architectural framework to support telecommunication networks based on IP; b) underlying telecommunication network/protocol support for carriage of IP traffic, with particular attention to: IP over SDH IP over ATM IP over WDM; c) interworking between IP-based networks and telecommunication networks (e.g., Gateway Architectures for Voice Service Interworking, Interaction with SS7-based networks); d) naming, numbering and addressing; and e) other relevant areas where interactions and interworking between IP-based networks and other networks need to be defined. -5- GSC6(00)49 ANNEX A GSC6 RESOLUTIOS RESOLUTION GSC 6/6 (Sapporo, Japan): Collaboration Implementation of Meeting Results of GSC/RAST on The Global Standards Collaboration 6 meeting recognizing a) b) that GSC and RAST have contributed considerably in drawing out and addressing High Interest Subjects and other collaboration subjects for global standardization and promoting collaboration among Participating Standards Organizations (PSOs); that the follow-up of conclusions, resolutions, etc. reached at GSC/RAST meetings is highly desired; and further recognizing a) b) that the human resources for collaboration in global standardization are limited; that it would be desirable to improve the working methods in support of GSC/RAST collaboration; resolves 1) 2) 3) to strengthen the follow-up of conclusions, resolutions, etc. reached at the GSC/RAST meetings by introducing appropriate mechanisms to oversee the implementation; for each relevant resolution, to designate a rapporteur responsible to follow up and, if possible, to provide a status report at the next GSC/RAST meeting. Each PSO can nominate collaborators to assist the rapporteur, as appropriate; to further examine and develop, by correspondence, the details of a suitable improved collaboration mechanism based on contribution GSC6(00)09 from TTA, and to provide a report at the next GSC/RAST meeting for adoption. -6- GSC6(00)49 ANNEX A GSC6 RESOLUTIOS RESOLUTION GSC 6/7 (Sapporo, Japan): Identification of High Interest Subjects The Global Standards Collaboration 6 meeting recognizing a) b) c) the importance of collaboration among Participating Standards Organizations (PSOs) in the High Interest Subjects (HISs), the continued relevance of many of the existing HISs for PSOs, that some HISs are recognized to be mature enough and may not be relevant to continue designation as an HIS resolves to keep one subject for a common HIS for GSC/RAST and four subjects as HISs of GSC as shown below to promote the collaboration among relevant PSOs and the information sharing among PSOs. Common High Interest Subject for GSC/RAST 1) Mobility/IMT2000 and Beyond High Interest Subjects for GSC 2) 3) 4) 5) Intelligent Network (IN)/Wireless IN (WIN)/Virtual Home Environment (VHE)/ Open Services Architecture (OSA) Telecommunication Management Network (TMN) Networks using IP (Internet Protocol) Bearer Independent Call Control (BICC) Brief description of each HIS is given in the Annex to this Resolution. -7- GSC6(00)49 ANNEX A GSC6 RESOLUTIOS Resolution 6/7 ANNEX 1 Brief description of High Interest Subjects identified for GSC/RAST 1) Mobility/International Mobile Telecommunications (IMT)-2000 and Beyond This subject includes: - Radio Transmission Technologies (RTTs), Transport technologies, Service control technologies, and Technologies for the evolution of IMT-2000 2) Intelligent Network (IN)/Wireless IN (WIN)/Virtual Home Environment (VHE)/Open Services Architecture (OSA) This subject includes: - Application of IN Technologies for emerging services/networks, including those for wireless networks and those for Voice over IP (VoIP) networks, - Technologies supporting Virtual Home Environment, and - Emerging Application Program Interfaces (APIs) related to those technologies identified above 3) Telecommunication Management Network (TMN) This subject includes: - Management of emerging networks, including VoIP networks, and - Emerging new technologies supporting TMN, including CORBA and tML 4) Networks using IP (Internet Protocol) This subject includes: 5) Technologies for VoIP, Technologies for efficient transport of IP traffic, Interworking with IP networks, and Technologies for managing IP network Bearer Independent Call Control (BICC) This subject includes: - Service control supported by BICC - Vertical interface between call control and bearer control - Interworking of BICC-related protocols -8- GSC6(00)49 ANNEX A GSC6 RESOLUTIOS RESOLUTION GSC 6/8 (Sapporo, Japan): Identification of Information Sharing Subjects The Global Standards Collaboration 6 meeting recognizing a) b) the need to initiate information sharing among Standards Development Organizations (SDOs) in the emerging technology areas; the work already underway in identified areas in some of the SDOs; resolves to create the following three subjects as new Information Sharing Subjects (ISS) for GSC, to assist in promoting the collaboration among relevant Participating Standards Organizations (PSOs): Information Sharing Subjects for GSC/RAST 1) Identification and Location Services; 2) Digital Subscriber Lines; and Information Sharing Subjects for GSC 3) Optical Transmission Network. Detailed description of each ISS shown above is given in the Annexes to this Resolution. further resolves to identify the following areas for information sharing: 4) Electronic Working Methods; 5) Intellectual Property Rights (IPR); and 6) User Interest in Standardization. -9- GSC6(00)49 ANNEX A GSC6 RESOLUTIOS Resolution 6/8 ANNEX 1 Identification and Location Services This activity will assist in promoting the collaboration among relevant PSOs to achieve a comprehensive framework outlining the general principles involved in the provision of user-friendly identification and location services. The need to provide user-friendly communications services has been recognized and the work already underway in this area in some PSOs (e.g., STF 157 in ETSI) An umbrella framework needs to be developed to: 1) separate and classify fundamental elements involved in the identification and location of entities; 2) facilitate the deployment of naming and addressing schemes without prejudice; and 3) permit the definition of new and interoperable services. - 10 - GSC6(00)49 ANNEX A GSC6 RESOLUTIOS Resolution 6/8 ANNEX 2: Digital Subscriber Line (DSL) Systems Interoperable DSL systems have now been standardized by the ITU-T and by a number of PSOs. In many countries, these systems will provide a major means of providing broadband access to public and private networks. PSOs are encouraged to share information about 1) 2) 3) Development of new DSL technologies and associated standards; Deployment of DSL systems in national copper access networks (covering spectrum management and deployment arrangements, including interaction of different DSL systems and other systems using shared cables); and Arrangements for customer equipment supporting DSL systems (covering deployment arrangements, including the arrangements necessary to maximise efficient use of available copper, and the impact on national regulatory arrangements). - 11 - GSC6(00)49 ANNEX A GSC6 RESOLUTIOS Resolution 6/8 ANNEX 3 Optical Transmission Networks Optical Transmission Networks (OTN) cover the use of optical technologies to form end-to-end transmission networks. Key issues for information sharing are: 1) definition of Optical Channel (OCh) overhead 2) so called “digital wrapper," 3) "protection and restoration mechanisms," and 4) the architecture and Wave Division Multiplexing (WDM) Wavelength Allocation. Work on these issues, ongoing in ITU-T SG15, ETSI TC TM, T1X1, etc., is focused on phase 2 compatibilities (due late 2000 / early 2001) with subsequent work planned to cover optical layer survivability and other extensions. PSOs are encouraged to share information about: 1) 2) Harmonization of optical network architectures, and Alignment of requirements for extensions of OTN compatibilities. - 12 - GSC6(00)49 ANNEX A GSC6 RESOLUTIOS RESOLUTION GSC 6/9 (Sapporo, Japan): User Interest in Standardization The Global Standards Collaboration 6 meeting recognizing a) b) c) d) e) that it is essential that the needs and input of users be recognized when defining specifications for telecommunications products and services; that language, cultural, and regional barriers exist and must be addressed; that it is difficult to recruit and maintain users to participate in the standards development process; that users find it difficult to understand the implications of proposed standards; that a properly researched and unified user input would strengthen the global standards development process making it more responsive to end users’ needs. resolves 1) 2) 3) 4) 5) 6) 7) for all the issues identified by the User Working Group, Participating Standards Organization (PSOs) should collaborate to nominate a champion per issue; that the use of the ETSI-provided exploder forum, gsc-user@list.etsi.fr, be used for discussion of provided input; that each PSO appoint a point of contact or coordinator to facilitate communication with PSO taking responsibility for the progress of the identified issues, the use of GSC exploder and user web page; that PSOs circulate to other PSOs user groups within each region or country to encourage liaison between these groups; to invite PSOs to identify collectively and flag user issues in standards development that should be addressed by the standards development community; to encourage PSOs to support liaison among user advocacy organizations with an eye toward more unified input into the global standards development process; to require the User Working Group Chair to liaise with Working Group members and convene meetings to address proposed issues as necessary; and further resolves 8) 9) 10) that user participants be invited to attend the next Users Working Group meeting; to encourage hosts of subsequent GSC meetings to hold User Workshops, which should precede Users Working Group meetings; and to request PSOs to identify to the User Working Group Chair issues that the User Working Group should examine. - 13 - GSC6(00)49 ANNEX A GSC6 RESOLUTIOS RESOLUTION GSC 6/10 (Sapporo, Japan): Intellectual Property Rights The Global Standards Collaboration 6 meeting recognizing a) that the ITU-T has a well-established policy and guidelines for patents, and is in its final phase of developing a policy for software copyright; b) that some Participating Standards Organizations (PSOs) have a requirement to distribute, as part of their standards, the software codes included in ITU-T Recommendations; c) the value of continued information exchange among the PSOs on Intellectual Property Rights (IPR) issues; considering a) that database information on IPR declaration should be updated in a more efficient manner and shared among PSOs and the ITU as much as possible; resolves 1) to encourage all PSOs and the ITU to find and implement a practical means, e.g., using web pages, to update IPR holder’s contact information, together with a further view towards agreeing on more harmonized forms of the IPR declaration and database; 2) to support the TTC’s proposal to improve the draft ITU-T policy on software copyright to let the copyright holder to grant not only the ITU but also recognized regional/national SDOs a royalty-free license for publication and distribution; and 3) to continue the exchange of information on IPR matters among the PSOs and the ITU utilizing the exploder (gsc-ipr@ttc.or.jp) of the GSC IPR WG more effectively, as well as to ask the hosting organization of the next GSC meeting to consult with the PSOs about the need for an IPR WG meeting by July 2001. - 14 - GSC6(00)49 ANNEX A GSC6 RESOLUTIOS RESOLUTION GSC 6/11 (Sapporo, Japan): Handling Methods Electronic Document The Global Standards Collaboration 6 meeting recognizing a) that considerable progress in the use of electronic tools for standards development and dissemination has now made Electronic Document Handling (EDH) a commodity rather than high tech; b) the continuing need to improve speed to market of telecommunications standards; c) the on-going development of electronic tools; d) the need to increase the use of electronic collaborative tools in standards development; resolves 1) to encourage each Participating Standards Organization (PSO) to exchange information on their EDH activities using the GSC E-mail reflector (GSC-EWG@LIST.ETSI.FR) on an ongoing basis; 2) that GSC EWG members provide information to the ITU-T to assist in the development of electronic document handling tools; and 3) that GSC EWG initiate and guide decisions leading to selection of the proper tools and encourage their use for collaborative activities among GSC members. - 15 -