Cabrillo Community College District Citizens’ Measure D Bond Oversight Committee Annual Report Letter from the Committee Chair Ninth Report to the Community on Measure D March 2005 through June 2013 INSIDE Committee Members2 About Prop. 39 Expenditures Projects 2 3-4 5 Issues & Conclusions6 It is my pleasure to share with you the Cabrillo College Citizens’ Measure D Bond Oversight Committee’s eighth report to the community. This has been an exciting year for Cabrillo College having completed the majority of the Facilities Master Plan projects. I encourage you to visit the campus and see the accomplishments made possible by your investment in our community college. In 1996, the college developed a comprehensive Facilities Master Plan which identified the educational programs that require expanded or upgraded facilities to support instruction. Measure C was approved by the voters in 1998 at $85 million and Measure D was passed in 2004 at $118.5 million. In addition, the college has been extremely successful in securing matching funds of $6.5 million from the Federal Economic Development Administration and $40 million from the state in order to maximize the benefit to our local community. The results: • The Solari Green Technology Center (GTC) The Solari Green Technology Center (GTC) opened in 2012. This Platinum Level LEED certified “green” building provides a unique learning environment focusing on career technical education at the former Watsonville Library site as part of Cabrillo’s Watsonville Center. • State-of-the-art teaching facilities State-of-the-art teaching facilities in the completely renovated Building 300 have been open for Business, English and Language Arts classes since spring 2011. • The new Chemistry/Biology lab in Building 600 will allow the college to offer more high demand science courses and is scheduled to come online spring semester 2014. The Dental Hygiene Program previously occupied the west end of building 600 prior to relocating to the new Health Wellness Building in 2010. This space will be designated as Biology and Chemistry classroom and laboratory space. • Two new Health & Wellness Buildings to house the Allied Health programs (Dental Hygiene, Radiologic Technology, Nursing, Medical Assisting and the Stroke and Acquired Disability Center) and the new Wellness Center opened in September, 2010. • Three Arts Education Classrooms for Visual, Applied and Performing Arts (VAPA) have been holding classes since fall of 2008, and the theater, theater arts classes, recital hall and music classrooms opened in fall 2009 for everyone to enjoy. • The new Barbara Samper Student Activities Center opened in 2007 and is a hub of activity with the considerably expanded campus bookstore, student assessment and orientation services, and expanded workspace for student government and clubs. • Bond funds have dramatically improved campus accessibility. New kiosks with campus maps as well as wayfinding signs have been installed to show building locations and wheelchair accessible routes. In addition, new seating in the football stadium has been installed to provide better access for individuals using wheelchairs. The annual audit for 2012-13 was performed by Vavrinek, Trine, Day and Co., LLP, and disclosed no instances of non-compliance with the terms of Proposition 39 or Measure D. The 2012-13 audit report was completed in December, 2013. Based on this report, the members of the Citizens’ Oversight Committee (COC) conclude that Measure D bond expenditures have been made in accordance with the California Education Code 15278 and exclusively for projects identified in the Bond Measure. The $118.5 million General Obligation Bond approved by more than 62 percent of the voters in March, 2004 has certainly upgraded and improved the campus facilities to better serve our students and community. The Citizens’ Oversight Committee looks forward to continuing to work with the Cabrillo staff in 2013-14 to assure compliance with Measure D and the completion of these projects which are a valuable resource for the Santa Cruz County community. Blaine Brokaw, Chair Measure D Bond Oversight Committee About a Proposition 39 Bond Measure Measure D Funded Facilities Master Plan Projects 2012-13 Kathy Blackwood Blaine Brokaw Bobby Buckter Ceil Cirillo Sharon Gray Ron Kaplan Brian Mathias Member at Large (Two-year term expires 8/14) Total Budget Measure D Projects in Progress Total Budget Measure D Projects in Planning Total Budget Measure D Projects In Future Total Budget Measure D Projects Completed Unallocated Total Measure D Funding A member of the business community l An active member of a senior citizens organization l A member of a taxpayers association l An enrolled student active in a community college group l A member of a college support organization l Two members representing the community at large Committee members serve in an uncompensated capacity for terms of two years and may not exceed two consecutive terms. No District employee nor vendor, contractor, nor consultant to the District may serve on the committee. Business Representative (Two-year term expires 8/14) Senior Citizens Organization (Two-year term expires 8/13) Member at Large (Two-year term expires 8/14) Taxpayers Association (Two-year term expires 8/14) Previous Members Jack Baskin Member At Large 2004-06 Michael Bethke Taxpayer Association 2008-12 Rodney Brooks Member At Large 2004-08 Oleksii Chuiko Student 2011-12 Diane Craddock College Support Organization 2007-11 Leflora Cunningham Student 2007-08 Robert Dills Member At Large 2009-12 Harriett Duzet Senior Citizens Organization 2004-07 John U. Fry Business Representative 2008-12 Tila Guerrero College Support Organization 2004-07 Chloe LaFortune Student 2004-05 Leigh Ann Lively Student 2010-11 Nicole Moreno Student 2005-06 Gary Meyer Student 2008-09 Helen Palmer Member At Large 2008-09 Bob Petersen Member At Large 2006-10 Kris Reyes Business Representative 2004-08 Mike Siegel Student2006-07 Lou Tuosto Taxpayers Association 2004-08 Jeff Vella Student 2009-10 Bud Winslow Senior Citizens Organization 2007-11 (Schedule A) (Schedule B) (Schedule C) (Schedule D) $16,468,116 $750,000 $0 $108,204,411 $128,069,882 Measure D Funding Category Projects in Process Committee Meetings The COC met twice in the 2012-13 fiscal year. Meeting dates and minutes of prior meetings are available at the bond oversight web page at: http://www.cabrillo.edu/internal/facilities/measured/bond oversight/bondoversightDocs.html. For questions or comments about the committee and its activities, please call (831) 479-6406. All meetings are open to the public. Measure D Bond Issuance and Expenditures through June 2013 Allied Health Equipment Health and Wellness Building 300 Equipment Equipment Watsonville Green Technology Building Upgrades Watsonville Green Technology Equipment Amount Budgeted Paid to Date (thru 6/30/13) $1,105,493 $1,101,742 $931,000 $758,913 $7,148,000 $7,087,868 Equipment $400,000 $337,203 Campus Wide Signage ADA Accessibility $323,291 $275,093 Building 800 Moves/ Secondary Effects Building Upgrades $313,283 $308,373 Building 800 Renovation Building Upgrades $3,293,172 $1,964,941 VAPA Remediation Building Upgrades $395,605 $7,973 Smart Classrooms (2011-2013) Building Upgrades $323,587 $274,842 Building 600 Renovation Building Upgrades $1,500,000 $302,405 Building 100 Repairs Building Upgrades $734,685 $21,839 Total in Progress Schedule A $16,468,116 $12,441,192 S ched u l e B Measure D Funding Category Amount Budgeted Smart Classrooms ‘13 - ‘14 Building / Equipment $650,000 $0 Building 800 Move In Building Upgrades $100,000 $0 $750,000 $0 Project in Planning (none at this time) The Cabrillo Community College District issued the first series of Measure D Bonds, Series A, in the amount of $60 million, in May 2004. The District issued the second and final Series B in April 2007 in the amount of $58.5 million for a total Bond Offering of $118.5 million. Facilities projects are publicly bid as required by Contract Code and the District has endeavored to make qualified local contractors aware of the projects and to assist them with the public bidding process to facilitate work for local residents. Included in this Report are the Measure D funded projects that have been completed or were in progress as of June 30, 2013. Total in Planning Schedule B Paid to Date (thru 6/30/13) S ched u l e C Future Projects in Planning Schedule Reserve for Pending Projects None at this time Total Future Projects 1 2 2 Totals S ched u l e A College Support Organization (Two-year term expires 8/13) Student (Two-year term expires 8/13) $118,743,795 $9,326,086 $128,069,882 Measure D Funding summary Schedule l Members of the Citizens’ Oversight Committee As of June 30, 2013 Measure D Bond Sales Interest Through 6/30/13 Total Measure D Funding Supporters approved Cabrillo College Measure D under the provisions of Proposition 39, which requires a minimum 55 percent approval by the electorate. Proposition 39 bonds also call for the appointment of an independent Citizens’ Oversight Committee within 60 days of election results certification. By statute, the committee must include: From left: Bobby Buckter, Graciano Mendoza, Dieter Schmidtmeier, Ceil Cirillo, Kathy Blackwood, Brian Mathias, Sharon Gray, Ronald Kaplan,Victoria Lewis, Joe Nugent. Not pictured: Blaine Brokaw 1, 2 Only Measure D funding is shown. Figures have been audited. Paid to Date $0 $0 $0 3 Measure D Funded Facilities Master Plan Projects (cont.) 1, 2 As of June 30, 2013 S ched u l e D Completed Projects Enrollment Center Faculty Offices Smart Classrooms Staff Offices Equipment Utility Relocation Project Southwest Power and Communication Southeast Perimeter Road Parking Lot R New Fire Water Line Building 100 Road and Utilities Building 100 Enrollment Center Building 400 Improvements Exterior Painting Buildings 100, 900,1000, 1500, 1550, 1300, 1400, & 1600 HVAC Buildings 400, 450, 500, 700 Building 900 Restrooms Building 400 Boiler Pipe Replacement 15 Smart Classrooms Building 2100 Upgrades Stadium Bathroom ADA Upgrades 2 (thru 6/30/13) $519,746 $1,350,053 $3,559,821 The new 14,000 square foot Solari Green Technology Center (GTC) opened in 2012. This Platinum Level LEED certified “green” building at the former Watsonville Library site provides a unique learning environment focusing on career technical education in construction, energy management, solar, and green building programs. The District purchased the library from the City of Watsonville in July 2008 and was awarded $3.4 million of grant funds from the Economic Development Agency to augment Measure D Bond funds specifically to build to the model Platinum Level LEED certified “green” building standard. The District also received a generous donation of $500,000 from the Richard and Mary Solari Charitable Trust and $100,000 from the Les and Jeane Ley Family Fund for construction that allowed the District to add back some of the items that were deferred due to budgetary constraints. Building 600 will be renovated for Biology and Chemistry classroom and laboratory space. The Dental Hygiene program previously occupied the west end of the building prior to relocating to the new Health and Wellness Building in 2010. This project is currently in the program planning and design phase. Building 300 Renovation Twelve new smart classrooms and ten offices in Building 300 for Business English, & Language Arts (BELA) and Human Arts and Social Sciences (HASS) classes opened in spring 2011. In addition to Measure D funds, state bond funds supported the renovation. ADA Access and Safety Allied Health Parking Structure Sheriff Office Relocation Allied Health Project Closed Portion $11,092,120 Building 800 Renovation SAC Student Services Student Services Project Now Closed $20,840,156 Arts Education Classrooms AEC Project $51,893,312 Arts Education Equipment AEC Project $1,126,453 Stadium Bathroom Renovation ADA Accessibility Allied Health Classroom Buildings Health and Wellness Building 300 Renovation Building Upgrades Bond Fee, Audits Fees The new state-of-the-art Jack and Peggy Baskin Technology Center for Engineering, Computing and Physics now offers classroom, laboratory and office space for Science, Technology, Engineering and Mathematics (STEM) programs in the 2013 fall semester. Cabrillo College was awarded a five-year federal Title III grant for the Science, Technology, Engineering, and Mathematics (STEM) fields in 2011 to increase the number of Latinos in the STEM fields. The Cabrillo College Foundation received $250,000 from the Monterey Peninsula Foundation to provide support for the construction costs to renovate the 800 Building and this also reduced the need for bond funds. In addition to the classroom renovation, the heating and ventilation systems and restrooms were repaired utilizing Measure D bond funds and funding from the Peggy and Jack Baskin Foundation to accomplish the renovation work not covered by the Federal STEM grant. Only Measure D funding is shown. Figures have been audited. 4 Building Upgrades and Classroom and Lab Upgrades Paid to Date Building 600 Biology/Chemistry Classroom Renovation Project Building 100, 900, 1100 ADA Access Stair Replacement Parking Lots E, F, and G Upper Campus Land Bridge Safety Phones Parking Structure Building 100 Plaza Total Completed Schedule D 1 Measure D Funding Category Solari Green Technology Center (Watsonville Library Acquisition) $1,135,675 $225,359 $15,072,637 $1,116,963 $272,117 $108,204,411 Smart Classrooms In an effort to provide state-of-the-art educational facilities, classrooms throughout the District were identified in need of technology, furniture, carpet and paint upgrades. Smart classrooms are utilized in each of the Instructional Divisions. Measure D funds were used for upgrades in the following classrooms this year: 1606, 1112A, 450, 607. Health and Wellness Classrooms and Parking The 55,000 square foot Health and Wellness classroom facility opened in fall 2010. This new facility brought together healthrelated disciplines that include Nursing, Dental Hygiene, Medical Assistant, Radiologic Technology, the Stroke and Acquired Disabilities Learning Center, Health Science, and a new Wellness Center. The adjacent Health and Wellness Facility parking structure opened in fall 2008. The parking structure provides 510 parking spaces in the northeast corner of the campus for those students attending classes on the upper campus. Arts Education Classrooms The Arts Education Classrooms project consists of five buildings totaling 122,300 square feet, and includes a 581-seat theater, a 369-seat music classroom and recital hall, a building dedicated to two-dimensional art, one building for three-dimensional art, and one building for general instruction and offices. Fifteen music practice rooms are available for students, four music rehearsal spaces, an acting studio, five drawing and design studios, and an experimental theater classroom. Three of the buildings opened for classes in fall 2008; the Crocker Theater and the Music Recital Hall were opened in August 2009. Some aspects of the construction contracts between the trade contractors and the District were disputed by the parties which resulted in mediation. The mediation process resulted in a settlement of outstanding issues. The settlement in the amount of $1.6 million was reached in March 2011 and finalized in August 2011. 5 Student Activities Center Examination of Expenditures The Barbara Samper Student Activities Center, a 50,000-square foot, two-level building located in the very center of the Aptos campus on Soquel Drive, opened in fall 2007. The new center provides a gateway to the Aptos campus and houses the campus bookstore, student assessment and orientation services, student government, student activities and club space, and related student services programs and offices. The project includes three new elevators which significantly improve accessibility on campus to and from Soquel Drive. Covered parking on the ground level provides access to the bookstore and to enrollment services. The college received a certificate of completion from the Division of the State Architect (DSA) in March 2011. Cabrillo College staff provides the Citizens’ Oversight Committee with the monthly Facilities Master Plan Status Reports which are submitted to the Cabrillo College Governing Board for review. A comprehensive update is provided to the Citizens’ Oversight Committee and formally approved by the Governing Board annually. Aptos Campus Signage A signage plan for the Aptos campus, prepared by Kate Keating Associates of San Francisco, has been completed. Handicap accessible routes are now clearly identified, and updated map kiosks and wayfinding signs have been installed on campus to assist new students, staff, and visitors. Replacement building identification signs have also been installed and will continue to be updated as construction projects in progress become finalized. 6 Overcoming Challenges The Citizens’ Oversight Committee continues to observe the California Division of the State Architect (DSA) required approval process delay design and construction schedules resulting in potential additional project costs. The Citizens’ Oversight Committee strongly supports any changes which would streamline the construction approval process and reduce overall project costs. The COC also encourages District personnel to continue to evaluate college projects using the industry best practices in construction and design-bid cost alignment to ensure maximum utilization of Measure D bond funds. Conclusions The Citizens’ Oversight Committee finds that Cabrillo College has complied with requirements of state law in accounting for and expending public bond funds.