ITU Forum on Smart Sustainable Cities, Abu Dhabi, 3-4 May 2015
Key Performance Indicators for Smart
Sustainable Cities
Ziqin Sang, Vice Chairman
ITU-T Focus Group on Smart Sustainable Cities
KPIs deliverables of ITU-T FG-SSC
– KPI definitions
–
–
–
–
[ITU-T L.KPIs-overview], Technical Specifications
[ITU-T L.KPIs-ICT], Technical Specifications
[ITU-T L.KPIs-impact], Technical Specifications
[ITU-T L.KPIs-Supp], Technical Report
• KPI metrics and evaluation
– under development
Overview
ICT
Impact
Definitions
Intention of KPIs
•
•
•
•
Publish the criteria to evaluate ICT in SSC
Enhance cities and municipal administrations
Assist evaluation and ranking agencies
Facilitate development and operation
organizations of SSC
• Encourage communications with city residents
and non-profit organizations
3
General principles to select KPIs
•
•
•
•
•
•
Comprehensiveness
Comparability
Availability
Independence
Simplicity
Timeliness
4
Dimensions of KPIs
Statistic of Indicators
Dimension
Number of
Indicators
[L.KPIs-ICT]
Number of
Indicators [L.KPIs- subtotal
impact
Information and
communication technology
(ICT)
11 indicators
0 indicators
11
Environmental sustainability
3 indicators
10 indicators
13
Productivity
8 indicators
7 indicators
15
Quality of life
7 indicators
3 indicators
10
Equity and social inclusion
6 indicators
4 indicators
10
Physical infrastructure
13 indicators
6 indicators
19
30
78
subtotal 48
Sub-dimensions of ICT
Dimension
label
D1
Dimension
Information and
communication
technology
Sub-dimension
label
Sub-dimension
D1.1
Network and access
D1.2
Services and
information platforms
D1.3
Information security
and privacy
D1.4
Electromagnetic field
Indicators of ICT
indicators
mayor
policy
online
survey
planning
EMF
protection
certificate
12315
hotline
civil affairs
survey
city planning
comm
infrastructure
utilities
ICT
public health
data sources
public safety
COP
cyber
security
economy information
public info
security
computer
and tablet
feedback
WIFI
fixed
broadband
subscription
wireless IoT
broadband
subscription
network
security
privacy
protection
Sub-dimensions of Environment
Dimension
label
D2
Dimension
Environmental
sustainability
Sub-dimension
lebal
Sub-dimension
D2.1
Air quality
D2.2
CO2 emissions
D2.3
Energy
D2.4
Indoor pollution
D2.5
Water, soil and noise
Indicators of Environment
indicators
agri
mitigation
industry
mitigation
carbon
trade
policy
GHG
meteor
indoor
pollution
landscape
garden
data sources
energy
environmental
sustainabillity
safety
supervision
urban
governance
healthcare
waterworks environment
protection
PM2.5
dust
PM10
water source
quality greenland
waste water source
coverage
recycle monitoring
noise
control
industry energy
saving
renewable
energy
ratio
energy safety
climate
change
quality
management
health
alert
family
energy
saving
environment
perspection
soil
pollution
poisonous
air
real time
monitoring
Sub-dimensions of Productivity
Dimension
label
D3
Dimension
Productivity
Sub-dimension
label
D3.1
Capital investment
D3.2
Employment
D3.3
D3.4
Inflation
Trade
D3.5
Savings
D3.6
Export/import
D3.7
Household
income/consumption
D3.8
Innovation
D3.9
Knowledge economy
Sub-dimension
Indicators of Productivity
inflaction
knowledge intensive
e-commerce
import/export
ICT R&D
intensity
indicators
knowledge
intensive
investment
ICT
patent
intellectual
property
edudation
commerce
family
income
remaining
saving
rate
employment
bank
productivity
data sources
finance
economy
family ICT
expenditure
public ICT
expenditure
R&D investmt ICT
exployee
ratio
ratio
science &
technology
graduates
employmnet
knowledge
service intensive
industry employment
rate
industry
GIS
big data platform
ICT
cloud
company computing platform
ratio
platform
traditional
industry
ICT R&D SSC projects imprvmt
investment
Sub-dimensions of Life Quality
Dimension
label
D4
Dimension
Sub-dimension
label
Sub-dimension
D4.1
Education
D4.2
Health
D4.3
Safety/security
public place
D4.4
Convenience and
comfort
Quality of life
Indicators of Life Quality
HLY
health
records
medical
records
indicators
student ICT ICT training
use of
capability facilities
e-learning
telemedical
medicine
resource
sharing
food & drug
trace-back
education equity
industry
education
epidemic
prevention
utilities
healthcare
Quality
population of life
civil affairs
control
data sources
community disaster
alert
event
disaster
relief
safety
city
digital
learning
public
safety
facilites for
disabled
public
facilities
developmt convenience
chance
dwelling
innovation
dwelling satisfaction
convenience
cost
emergency
anti-terrorism
census response
child
protection
Sub-dimensions of Social Equity
Dimension
label
Dimension
Sub-dimension
label
D5.1
D5
Equity and
social
inclusion
D5.2
D5.3
D5.4
Sub-dimension
Inequity of
income/consumption
(Gini coefficient)
Social and gender
inequity of access to
services and
infrastructure
Openness and public
participation
Governance
Indicators of Social Equity
social
city info e-govrnmt
satisfactory open
public service
online
citizen
engagement
new
info
immigrant rules and
improvemt
regulations
help
on ICT literacy
indicators
legal affairs
social insurance
mass media
survey
equity and
social inclusion
data sources
efficiency
industry
utilities
emilating support people
with special
poverty
needs
gendar
income
equity
gini
coefficients
taxation
economy
civil affairs
sector
income
equity
public
facilities
managemt
social
resouce
integration
social info
sharing
Sub-dimensions of Infrastructure
Dimension
label
D6
Dimension
Physical
infrastructure
Sub-dimension
label
D3.1
D3.2
D3.3
D3.4
Piped water
Sewage
Electricity
Waste management
D3.5
D3.6
D3.7
D3.8
D3.9
D3.10
D3.11
Knowledge infrastructure
Health infrastructure
Transport
Road infrastructure
Housing – building materials
Housing – living space
Building
Sub-dimension
Indicators of Infrastructure
indicators
sewage
system
water
water recycle saving
facilities
drainage household
system sanitation
coverage
456.78
water supply
system monitorging
data sources
waterworks
999.97
smart
meters
renewabl reliable power
supply
e facility
coverage
urban governace
electricity
healthcare
for the
aged
community
healthcare
public
transport
smart
sensor
lighting
installati
on
traffic
info
smart
parking
environmt
building undermaterials ground
pipelines
public
buildings
integrated
mangement
poison tracing
facilities
waste
recycle
waste
clasification
culture &
sporting
public construction
transport
smart station
water leckage
rate
city planning
physical
infrastructure
health care
smart
meters
cultrure
facilities
auto
energy
efficiecy
waste
disposal
sporting
facilities
*
metrics and evaluation of SSC
•
•
•
•
•
•
step 1, assessment model selecting
step 2, objectives of assessment determining
step 3, metrics of indicators and data collecting
step 4, data processing and normalizating
step 5, index of SSC calculating
step 6, evaluation of SSC reporting
Thank you
The Technical Specifications and Technical Report are
available on the ITU website at
http://www.itu.int/en/ITUT/focusgroups/ssc/Documents/Approved_Deliverables/TS-OverviewKPI.docx
中文版本
Espanol
contact: tsbsg5@itu.int