Haloselectivity of Heterocycles Baran Group Meeting Background SN(ANRORC) Addition of Nuclophile, Ring Opening, Ring Closure Polysubstituted heterocycles represent some of the most important compounds in the realm of pharmaceutical and material sciences. New and more efficient ways to selectively produce these molecules are of great importance and one approach is though the use of polyhalo heterocycles. Consider: Ar3 CO2Me Ar1 3 Suzuki Couplings N H Ar3 CO2Me Ar1 1 Triple Suzuki Coupling N H Ar3 CO2Me Ar1 NH3(l), 90% NH2 NH N CO2Me N NH N H Cross Coupling CO2Me Virtually all types of cross coupling have been utilized in regioselective cross coupling reactions: Kumada, Negishi, Sonogashira, Stille, Suzuki, Hiyama, etc. In all of these examples, the oxidative addition of the metal to the heterocycle is the selectivity determining steps and is frequently considered to be irreversible. This addition highly resembles a nucleophilic substitution and it frequently follows similar regioselectivities in traditional SNAr reactions. The regioselectivity of cross coupling reaction in polyhalo heterocycles do not always follow the BDE's of the corresponding C-X bonds. Nu Nu N X X N Nu 2nd Meisenheimer Complex 1st Br 83.2 SN(EA) O via: NaNH2, t-BuONa pyrrolidine N 87.3 THF, 40ºC OMe N SET Mechanism can also be operative (SRN1) + Nu HetX Het + X OK HetNu N N N + Nu Cl h!, NH3(l) 88% O N JOC 1981, 46, 294 HetNu + HetX HetNu + HetX 88.9 88.9 O Br 1st Merlic and Houk have determined that the oxidative addition in palladium catalyzed cross coupling reactions is determined by the distortion energy of the C-X bond (related to BDE) and the interaction of the LUMO of the heterocycle to the HOMO of the Pd species. N N HetX Br N + HetX + Nu 2nd Br Tetrahedron 1982, 38, 427 Het NH2 H SNAr or SN(AE) N H NH2 - Br Nucleophilic Substitution Br N NH2 N H Ar2 1 Triple C-H activation? N H Br Br NaNH2 CO2Me Ar2 1 Triple Halogenation N H Br N Ar2 3 Halogenations N H N Will Gutekunst JACS, 2007, 129, 12664; JACS, 2009, 131, 6632 Haloselectivity of Heterocycles Baran Group Meeting Predicting Reactivity Will Gutekunst Pyrroles can also be selectively monoarylated at C-2 under C-H activation conditions. The Handy Method Handy and coworkers disclosed an experimental method in 2006 for predicting the regiochemical outcome of multiply halogenated heterocycles using 1H-NMR of the dehalogenated substrate. The proton that displays the largest chemical shift implies it is attached to the most electron deficient carbon atom and, therefore, the preferred site of cross coupling. While this method is not foolproof (it does not take into account sterics, directing groups, or interactions noted by Merlic), it is a good start for predicting regioselectivities of cross coupling reactions. Ph2I+BF45% IMesPd(OAc)2 N Me rt, AcOH, 67% Ph N Me JACS 2006, 128, 4972 Chem. Comm. 2006, 299 Indole Pyrroles 2nd 7.55 7.00 - Due to the electron rich nature, SNAr reactions do not readily take place without strong EWGs. - Cross coupling reactions occur fastest at the 2/5 positions, in accord with chemical shift prediction. - Monocoupling in 2,5 dihalo substrates is difficult, but 3,4 dihalo substrates can be easily controlled on steric grounds. - 2nd 6.22 6.68 1st N H (CDCl3) 6.45 7.08 N H 7.40 last 7.27 - Like pyrrole, SNAr is very difficult without strong EWG's - Cross coupling occurs first at C-2, with C-4 to C-7 reacting before electron rich C-3. A C-2 vs C-4/7 has not been reported. 1st (Acetone) S Br O Cl Cl 2.5 eq EtSH TEA, DMSO H 86% EtS H N Me Cl S N TBS N TBS 10% Pd(PPh3)4 Na2CO3, Tol/H2O reflux, 8 hrs 78% H N Me O Br Br O H B(OH)2 O Orthogonally, the 3-position could be selectively exchanged with t-BuLi. Tetrahedron 2005, 61, 5831 Br Br Br Br N Me Br Tet. Lett. 2009, 49, 1698 Cl Br Br B(OH)2 N Me 6% Pd(PPh3)4 K3PO4, Tol/H2O 90ºC, 12 hrs 71% t-BuLi, MeI Br Br N TBS Br -78º C, THF 81% N TBS Chem. Pharm. Bull. 1996, 44,1831 Cl The C-H activation conditions for pyrrole are also successful on indole and tolerates aryl bromides MeO MeO OMOM MeO B(OH)2 MeO MeO TfO MeO2C OTf N R CO2Me B(OH)2 2% Pd(PPh3)4 8% Pd(PPh3)4 aq. Na2CO3, THF reflux, 4 hrs 78% aq. Na2CO3, THF reflux, 20 hrs 58% Tet. Lett. 2003, 44, 4443 MeO OMe Br Ph2I+BF45% IMesPd(OAc)2 MeO OMOM MeO2C N R CO2Me N H 60º C, AcOH, 74% Br N H Ph Haloselectivity of Heterocycles Baran Group Meeting Will Gutekunst Much like the dibromo indole, after the first Negishi coupling, the lithium halogen exchange at C-3 is favored. Furan - Not as resistant as pyrrole, but SNAr reactions still do not readily take place without strong EWGs. - Cross coupling reactions occur fastest at the 2/5 positions, in accord with chemical shift prediction. - Halogenated furans have general stability problems, making cross couplings sometimes troublesome. 2nd 6.24 7.29 1st O (CDCl3) t-BuLi, MeI -78ºC, THF OMe OMe OMe Br OMe 54% O O Synthesis 2003, 6, 925 Br MeO2C Br Br Br O 4% Pd(PPH3)4 DMA, 90ºC, 79% MeO2C Thiophene SnMe4 5% [PdCl2(Po-Tol3)2] Br Bu3Sn O 7.18 1st S (CDCl3) 2 steps Synlett 1998, 11, 1185 MeO2C 64% O - A better substrate for SNAr than furan and two orders of magnitude more reactive than benzene, but not many examples of haloselective reactions. - Cross coupling reactions occur fastest at the 2/5 positions and the 3/4 much slower. Selectivity on 2,5 dihalothiophenes is scarcely obtained though some success has been seen with Sonogashira reaction and cases with substrate bias. 2nd 6.99 DMA, 90ºC, 70% O Br rosefuran Br 46% S Br BnNHCH3 O NBnMe O BnMeN S H O + H Br S 4:1 Furfural can be selectively arylated in the 5- position directly. H OMe Synlett 2000, 4, 459 PhBr O H O 10% Pd(OH)2, K2CO3 DMA, 130ºC, 75% O H O Ph Br Br JOC 2005, 70, 7578 7.63 7.23 6.76 last 7.30 7.51 O S 2.5% [PdCl2(dppf)] Et2O 63% S S Two more S Br cross-couplings 54% 7.78 - Like indole, SNAr is uncommon on benzofuran - Cross coupling also mimics indole first at C-2, with C-4 to C-7 reacting before electron rich C-3. Seems to follow Handy rules, though selectivity among C-4 through C-7 is unknown. st (acetone) 1 S ClZn Br BnZnBr Pd(PPh3)4 Br Br quant 52 - 57% S p-TolMgCl NiCl2(dppp) S S Tet. Lett. 1980, 21, 4017 OMe Again, Lithium Halogen Exchange shows a different regioselection Br OMe Br O S Eur. JOC 2008, 5, 801 Benzofuran 2nd Br Br ZnCl S OMe MgBr Br 5% [PdCl2(PPh3)2] 10% [NiCl2(dppe)] 10% [PdCl2(dppf)] THF, rt, 75% THF, rt, 86% Br MeZnCl THF, reflux, 93% OMe O Br S Br Thiophenes, pg 693 Br nBuLi, Et2O -78ºC; H2O 79% Br S Haloselectivity of Heterocycles Baran Group Meeting Benzothiophene 2nd 7.72 7.26 7.22 last 7.24 7.33 S 7.79 Will Gutekunst Attempts to displace the second chloride leads to mixtures with ring opened products. - SNAr occurs readily on benzothiophenes, but they have some strange reactions with nucleophiles. - Cross coupling also mimics indole: first at C-2, with C-4 to C-7 reacting before C-3. 7.70 7.56 Cl MeS S N NC 1st 1) 2 eq Na2S (CCl4) S NC 2) MeI + N Cl MeS SMe 7.58 NC CN Isoquinolin 7.85 SMe JOC 1964, 29, 660 NH NH Br S Pyrazole shows similar reactivity, with a bromide being displaces before an iodide. Br Br S 106ºC N S 200ºC 73% N Me N N Br JOC 1973, 88,1365 EtO2C MeO I OMe MeO S EtO2C Syn. Comm. 2008, 38, 674 Br Br Ethyl bromoacetate, rt 80% I Me N N S MeO B(OH)2 B(OH)2 EtO2C 1.2 eq Na2S, DMF, 100ºC; Ph S 3% Pd(PPh3)4 5% Pd(PPh3)4 Na2CO3, EtOH/DME Ba(OH)2, H2O/DME 95% 71% Br Ph S Synthesis 2002, 2, 213 Ph S N Br 4% PdCl2(PPh3)2 CuI, TEA/MeCN, rt 56% Br Ph N Br Br The remaining two bromides were unreactive in further Sonogashira couplings, even at higher temps 1,2-Azoles 1st Me N N 7.45 8.39 3rd 6.20 I Ph S 7.26 8.14 8.54 2nd N I Isothiazole (CCl4) Isoxazole (CS2) - Selective SNAr reactions are only known with EWGs on the 4-position, but strongly favors substitution at the 5-position over the 3. This can be rationalized by both innate electronics (seen by NMR) and conjugation to the EWG. - Cross coupling also follows Handy rules: first at C-5, then at C-2 and lastly C-3. Br Tribromopyrazoles also lithiate at the most reactive C-5 EtO S NC N Cl EtOH (xs) 94% N N S NC 2% PdCl2(PPh3)2 4% PdCl2(PPh3)2 CuI, TEA/MeCN, rt CuI, TEA/MeCN, 50ºC 45% (also 45% deiodo) 42% MeO Russ. Chem. Bull. 1998, 47, 537 Br Cl N Cl Ph MeO S N N 6.28 7.31 N-methyl pyrazole (CDCl3) 8.72 O Br Br Tetrahedron 2007, 63, 56 n-BuLi, -78ºC; Bu3SnCl 77% Bu3Sn N N Br Br S N Br Haloselectivity of Heterocycles Baran Group Meeting 1,3-Azoles 7.39 1st O 7.69 7.41 N N 7.98 2.5% Pd(OAc)2 2.5% Xantphos O I Thiazole (CDCl3) Oxazole (CCl4) N-methyl imidazole (CDCl3) 10% 8.88 N 3rd P S 7.95 7.09 N 7.01 Workers at Merck recently disclosed specific ligands to override and reinforce substrate bias in the 1,3-azoles in a screen of ~200 achiral phosphines. 2nd Me N 6.86 Will Gutekunst Ph - SNAr reactions occur readily at C-2, though not very well at C-4/5 without assistance, and trends are not general among the series. - Cross coupling also does not follow the Handy rules, with usual order of cross coupling being 2>5>4, Also note that the relative order chemical shifts switches in oxazole. N O K3PO4, PhB(OH)2 THF, 64% N KCN, DMSO 18-crown-6 N Br N O2N Br N O2N N NaH, PhSH THF PhS N rt, 75% O2N N 80ºC, 85% Br Br OMe N PhB(OH)2 10% Pd(PPh3)4, Na2CO3 10% Pd(PPh3)4, Na2CO3 N PhH/MeOH/H2O 94% MOM N MeOH/NaOMe O2N N reflux, 40% MeO N Br Br N Br N N N SH EtO2C Br N I N n-BuLi, THF 33% S N S X OH Br N K2CO3, DMF 125-180ºC µw 51-84% Bioorg. Med. Chem. Lett. 2006, 16, 6078 N S S Br 1,3 azoles selectively C-H arylate at C-5 or C-2 N H S PhBr PdCl2(PPh3)2 CuI, TEA, THF 80ºC, 53-89% Ph S 10% Pd(OH)2, K2CO3 DMA, 130ºC, 82% N X N JOC 2005, 70, 7578 HN O O Br Me2N Heterocycles 2007, 72, 293 O X N S S Br MOM OMe EtO2C i-PrMgCl, THF -78ºC, 66% Heterocycles 2007, 72, 293 S Ph N PhH/MeOH/H2O 71% Br Br N Regioselective Mg-Halogen exchange was observed of this dibromothiophene. EtO2C Br Br Chem. Pharm. Bull. 1996, 44, 1831 Br J. Het. Chem 2000, 37, 119 EtO2C N B(OH)2 Br O2N Ph I Similar or better results were obtained for imidazoles, but selective C-4/C-5 over C-2 Suzuki couplings of dihalo thiophenes was not observed in any cases. No C-4 vs C-5 studies were undertaken. CN CN O K3PO4, PhB(OH)2 THF, 55% JOC 2010, 75, 1733 Br N 5% Pd(OAc)2 I I N S I O N N MeO OMe N Ph N N 5% Pd(OAc)2 Ph CuI, DMF, 140ºC 76% JOC 2005, 70, 3997, Eur. JOC 2006, 1379 MeO I 5% Pd(OAc)2 AsPh3, DMF, CsF MeO 140ºC, 46% N N Ph Haloselectivity of Heterocycles Baran Group Meeting Will Gutekunst Some Relative Rates of Azines (Joule and Mills 4th Edition) O For EtO- at 20ºC Cl Cl Cl N 1 Cl N N 1.7x102 7.3x103 X Cl 5.3x104 N N > X N 4 Cl 5.4x104 N Cl N N > N N X N N BnHN Ph 2nd 7.16 3rd 1st N (C6D6) X N - Pyridines readily undergo SNAr, usually faster at C-4 than C-2/6, but highly dependent on nucleophile and conditions. C-3/5 react much slower. - Cross coupling reactions occur fastest at the 2/6 positions followed by C-4 and C-3/5 much slower, much in accord with the Handy predictions. Mono substitution can usually be acheived with 2,6-dihalo and 3,5-dihalo pyridines. Cl OAr OH OR Cl Cl NH2 5% PdCl2(PPH3)2 CuI, TEA, 80ºC 90% Cl N Ph soft nucleophiles F Br OAr N NaH, DMSO Cl 130ºC, 85% N N Cl N Cl N 1:6 1:3 hard nuclephiles N Br cross coupling In, 4% Pd(PPh3)4 LiI, DMF, 100ºC Br + 61% F Tetrahedron 2005, 61, 2245 Cl NaH, THF + Br , then Br OR N 65%, one pot Br ACIEE 2002, 41,3901 OH Cl NH OH 1) o-tolMgCl 2) DDQ O O KOt-Bu, CuI, py 120ºC, 61% Cl NHtBu 98% KOt-Bu, DMA THF, 120ºC, 84% N Cl O N MeN O NHtBu Cl O NHtBu 100ºC, 97% N N MeN OPRD 2008, 12, 411 JOC 2006, 71, 2000 O OMe Cl N Ph Br OH N N JMC 2000, 43, 4288 7.55 N Cl Ph NH2 Pyridine 8.52 R = CH2CH2OPh > N NHR 140ºC, 93% Cl > BnNH2 NHR K2CO3, THF reflux, 61% Cl X > O O OL 2003, 5, 3131 1.3x108 5.8x10 N N X N > N N X N Cl N N PhB(OH)2 5% PXPd2 NHR Cl O PhB(OH)2 5% Pd(PPh3)4 K2CO3, THF reflux O OMe Ph N + Cl Cl 5:1 Usefully, Li-Halogen exchange is slow at 2/6 positions due to lone pair repulsion OMe N Ph n-BuLi, -100ºC; Br N Br D2SO4, 85% D N Br N Haloselectivity of Heterocycles Baran Group Meeting Quinoline/ Isoquinoline 7.73 Pyridazine/Pyrazine 2nd 8.05 7.46 7.65 N 8.05 Will Gutekunst 7.56 8.82 7.58 1st 1st 7.5 7.70 7.31 N 9.11 N 9.17 2nd 1st Isoquinoline (CCl4) 7.85 Quinoline (CCl4) 7.52 8.45 N N N - SNAr reactions occur readily at all of the positions. All sites are degenerate on pyrazine, and the 4-position is most activated for nucleophilic attack, despite NMR chemical shift. - Selective cross coupling reactions have not been well studied on pyridazine, but modest selectivity can be obtained from 3,6-dichloro compounds. Cl Cl MeO2C MeO2C HO ZnBr LiCl, DMF, rt 83% Cl N Cl Cl I aq. Me2NH EtOH, reflux I N N Cl Cl I N N 99% Cl Cl Chem. Eur. J. 2002, 8, 3448 N B(OH)2 N N SnBu3 N Cl Tetrahedron 2001, 57, 2507 N N Br B(OH)2 3% Pd(PPh3)4 CsF, DME 87% N N OEt 5% PdCl2(PPh3)2 80ºC, DMF 54% Tetrahedron 2001, 57, 2507 Cl 5% PdCl2(PPh3)2 80ºC, DMF 77% Cl Cl N N 4% [Pd(dba)2]PPh3 Tol reflux 80% S Me2N OEt O SnBu3 SnBu3 SnBu3 OMe OEt N Me2N JOC 1995, 60, 748 N Cl S Cl MeOH, NaOMe N Bioorg. Med. Chem. 2009, 17, 621 JOC 1999, 64, 453 60% N DMA, Na2CO3 74% N Pd(PPh3)4 THF 60ºC, 80% Cl Cl N N N CO2Me N N N NH Cl Cl HO Cl MeO2C ZnBr N Pyrazine (C6D6) Pyridazine (C6D6) - SNAr reactions of quinoline mimic pyridine largely, with C-4>C-2 generally preferred, but usually dependent on reaction conditions. Isoquinoline reacts fastest at C-1 followed by C-3 in SNAr. - Cross coupling reactions in quinoline strongly favor the 2 position followed by 4. Regioselection between the other positions has not been well investigated. Preference of 1 vs 3 is well established in isoquinolines, but other positions not as well. 8.6 4% Pd(PPh3)4 DMF, 100ºC 61% Br N OMe N Br N JOC 2002, 67, 9392 Br N TBS 10% Pd(PPh3)4 Na2CO3, MeOH/PhH 52% N N OMe NTBS Br Haloselectivity of Heterocycles Baran Group Meeting Pyrimidine 3rd Benzannelated Diazines 1st 8.78 N 7.36 9.26 N 2nd Pyrimidine (C6D6) - Pyrimidines readily undergo SNAr at the 2 and 4/6 positions. 4/6 being generally more reactive, but is very sensitive to reaction conditions. The 3position is greatly deactivated relative to the others. - Cross coupling reactions occur fastest at the 4/6 positions followed by C-2 and C-5 much slower, in direct contrast to the Handy predictions. N N H N Cl N HN Cl N N 86% N N 7.95 N 8.44 N OH Cl N TMS N -68ºC,-rt, 90% N Cl N PhB(OH)2 5% Pd(PPh3)4 Ph Cl N K2CO3, Tol/DMF Cl µw, 185ºC 10 min, 58% N N Cl N PhB(OH)2 5% Pd(Pt-Bu3)2 Ph Cl K2CO3, Tol/DMF Cl µw, 185ºC 10 min, 65% OTHP N Bu Br N N Cl 2% PdCl2(PPH3)2 CuI, TEA, rt 67% Acta Chem. Scand. 1996, 50, 914 N O Cl Et2O, -40ºC; then DDQ, 92% JMC 2008, 51, 2734 N N Cl EtOH, NaOEt 70ºC, 81% Me2N O S Et2O, -40ºC; then DDQ, 72%% Me2N S N N Me2N OTHP Bu Li SH N K2CO3, Tol/DMF Ph µw, 185ºC 10 min, 70% Lithium reagents can directly add into C-4/6, which can be oxidized back to aromaticity easily Me2N SMe N CuI, MeCN, TEA 60ºC, 56% Cl Li Cl Cl 7.5% Pd(OAc)2, PPh3 Br O N J. Chem. Soc. Perkin 1 2001, 978 N N N Cl Tet. Lett. 2006, 47, 4415 N HN MeCN, 130ºC 84% SMe N PhB(OH)2 5% Pd(PPh3)4 N 2nd 9.35 Quinazoline (CDCl3) JMC 1993, 36, 2196 N Chem. Soc. Perkin 2 1989, 1499; J. Het. Chem. 1994, 31, 989 Cl 8.06 Quinoxaline (CDCl3) NH2 OMe rt, 90% N 7.67 N SMe MeOH NaOMe 9.91 7.93 8.84 N Phthalazine (acetone) N n-BuLi, THF N Cl N 7.93 N TMS O 8.11 N N OPRD 2006, 10, 921 N 9.60 8.00 9.29 HN Cl 8.13 2nd 7.86 7.77 - SNAr reactions occur readily at all of the heterocyclic positions. Behavior seems to be similar to the diazine counterparts, ie C-4 more reactive than C-2 in quinazolines, C-4>C-3 in cinnoline. - Cross coupling reactions have not been well studied on these systems, but the few examples mimic the corresponding diazines well. N NH N THF, -10 C to rt 92% Cl 1st 1st 8.01 8.18 Cinnoline (CDCl3) 4.2 eq Cl Will Gutekunst S N N Cl Haloselectivity of Heterocycles Baran Group Meeting Purine 8.83 3rd 8.72 Misc Examples 1st - Purines can participate in SNAr reactions at all carbon centers. For 9-H purines, the order of reactivity is 6>8>2. For substitution at 9, reactivity changes to 8>6>2. - Cross coupling reactions usually occur fastest at the 6 position, though C-8 becomes competitive in some cases. C-2 is slowest. N N 8.5 N N H 2nd Purine (D2O) Ph I N N N TEA, MeCN 95% I RHN N 5% PdCl2(PPh3)2 DCE, 75ºC 63% N THP N 120ºC, 89% N H N N CN NHBn N Sug MeS BnNH2 N N N N N N 50ºC, 95% MeS N N JMC 2009, 52, 655 N N Cl N DCM, Et2Ni-Pr 91% F SnBu3 S N HN KCN, DMSO F SMe UK-371,104 S N DCM, Et2Ni-Pr 86% Cl O NH2 OPRD 2008, 12, 575 Cl N N N N F HN CO, THF N Sug N NH2 N JMC 2010, 53, 52 1) K2CO3, MeOH, 100% 2) PdCl2(dppf)DCM HN Ph N N Cl Ph Ph Cl N Sug Ph Ph F NH2 Cl H2N N Will Gutekunst OEt Cl N THP N SNAr, Sonogashira Stille and Suzuki Cl N OEt N N N R Single regioisomer (no yields reported) Cl N N Cl Acta Chem. Scand. 1999, 53, 366 Tet. Lett. 2006, 47, 8917 C-8 can be directly functionalized to give highly flexible syntheses of trisubstituted purines N Cl N N Cl N MeMgCl Fe(acac)3 PhB(OH)2 5% Pd(PPh3)4 72% K2CO3, Tol 100ºC N Bn I N N 5% Pd(OAc)2 N N CuI, Cs2CO3 DMF, 160ºC 79% (two steps) Ph N N Bn Cl S B(OH)2 S PhB(OH)2 5% Pd(PPh3)4 5% Pd(PPh3)4 N Cl N N K2CO3, Tol Na2CO3, Tol/EtOH 100ºC, 98% 100ºC, 84% Ph OL 2007, 9, 4673 OL 2006, 8, 5389 OH Cl MeMgCl 30% Fe(acac)3 N N Cl N Synlett 2004, 6, 889 N THP NMP/THF 37% F OH Cl O N N O N N THP Br N N Br Ar NaHMDS THF, -10ºC 78% OPRD 2006, 10, 512 F O OH Br O OH Br OH O N N LiHMDS THF, -40ºC 60% HO N N Ar Baran Group Meeting Haloselectivity of Heterocycles Conclusions Selective reactions of polyhaloheterocycles has proven to be a very powerful method for synthesis of functionalized heterocycles. Frequently cross-coupling and SNAr are complementary methods, with C-H functionalization rapidly growing. While the prediction of regioselectivity is difficult to rationalize at times, common trends are seen in certain heterocyclic motifs and can be extrapolated to more complex situations, though, screening seems to still be needed for many cases. Future directions are in the ligand controlled cross coupling and further development of C-H activation reactions. Key References Cross coupling reviews: Tetrahedron 2005, 61, 2245 Chem. Soc. Rev. 2007, 36, 1036 Synthesis 2009, 9, 1405 Computational Analysis of Polyhalo Heterocycles JACS, 2007, 129, 12664 JACS, 2009, 131, 6632 Handy Predictions Chem. Comm. 2006, 299 Will Gutekunst