Click Here GEOPHYSICAL RESEARCH LETTERS, VOL. 35, L06102, doi:10.1029/2007GL032315, 2008 for Full Article Titan airglow spectra from the Cassini Ultraviolet Imaging Spectrograph: FUV disk analysis Joseph M. Ajello,1 Jacques Gustin,2 Ian Stewart,2 Kristopher Larsen,2 Larry Esposito,2 Wayne Pryor,3 William McClintock,2 Michael H. Stevens,4 Charles P. Malone,1 and Dariusz Dziczek5 Received 30 October 2007; revised 18 January 2008; accepted 6 February 2008; published 21 March 2008. [1] We present a spectral analysis of the far ultraviolet (FUV: 1150 – 1900 Å) disk airglow observations of Titan’s atmosphere by the Cassini Ultraviolet Imaging Spectrograph (UVIS). The FUV spectrum consists of emissions from the Lyman-Birge-Hopfield (LBH) band system of N2 excited by photoelectrons (a 1Pg ! X 1S+g ), N I multiplets from solar photodissociative excitation of N2, resonantly scattered solar H Ly-a and sunlight reflected by N 2 in the mesosphere-stratosphere and modified by aerosols (e.g., tholins) and hydrocarbon absorption. Below 1450 Å, the strongest emissions arise from H Ly-a with an intensity of 208 Rayleighs (R), LBH bands with an intensity of 43 R, and the N I multiplets with a combined intensity of 16 R. Above 1450 Å, most of the UVIS signal is due to reflected sunlight. Mixing ratios of tholins, C2H2, C2H4 and C4H2 have been derived from the reflected sunlight using a Rayleigh scattering model. The derived mixing ratios are in good agreement with Voyager infrared observations and with FUV photochemical models, assuming solar energy deposition above 1450 Å occurs near 250 km (Wilson and Atreya, 2004). We also present the first geometric albedo measurement of Titan from 1500 – 1900 Å. Citation: Ajello, J. M., J. Gustin, I. Stewart, K. Larsen, L. Esposito, W. Pryor, W. McClintock, M. H. Stevens, C. P. Malone, and D. Dziczek (2008), Titan airglow spectra from the Cassini Ultraviolet Imaging Spectrograph: FUV disk analysis, Geophys. Res. Lett., 35, L06102, doi:10.1029/2007GL032315. 1. Introduction [2] We have recently provided an analysis of the extreme ultraviolet (EUV) spectrum (900– 1150 Å) from the Ultraviolet Imaging Spectrograph (UVIS) on Cassini, hereafter referred to as Paper 1 [Ajello et al., 2007]. In the current paper we analyze the far ultraviolet (FUV) spectrum (1150 – 1900 Å) of the disk of Titan. The FUV spectral region is a probe of the stratosphere-mesosphere-thermosphere region from 200 to 1600 km [Wilson and Atreya, 2004]. For the 1 Jet Propulsion Laboratory, California Institute of Technology, Pasadena, California, USA. 2 Laboratory for Atmospheric and Space Physics, University of Colorado, Boulder, Colorado, USA. 3 Science Department, Central Arizona College, Coolidge, Arizona, USA. 4 Space Science Division, Naval Research Laboratory, Washington, D. C., USA. 5 Nicolaus Copernicus University, Torun, Poland. Copyright 2008 by the American Geophysical Union. 0094-8276/08/2007GL032315$05.00 first time, UVIS provides a spectrum of the FUV that bridges the gap between the EUV in Paper 1 and the middle ultraviolet (MUV) observations of the Titan albedo from International Ultraviolet Explorer (IUE) [McGrath et al., 1998]. Indeed, previous Titan FUV observations by Voyager 1 (VI) were poorly defined because of lack of instrumental sensitivity and resolution [Broadfoot et al., 1981] and did not allow an accurate analysis of the emission in this wavelength range. [3] McKay et al. [2001] and Cortin et al. [1991] have shown that in the UV (down to 2000 Å), the astronomically observed UV geometric albedo is determined by extinction properties of absorbing haze and intense Rayleigh scattering. The organic haze is most likely formed in the 200– 500 km altitude region, initiated with the thermosphere photolysis of CH4 into CH radicals and photoelectron excitation of N2 into predissociating states yielding atomic N that diffuses to the stratosphere, where the dissociation products recombine as nitriles and hydrocarbons and eventually coagulate into tholin particles [McKay et al., 2001]. The attendant collisions result in a likely bimodal distribution with the small aerosol particles (average radius that is smaller than 200 Å) acting as an efficient UV absorber [Cortin et al., 1991]. Using the UV cross sections for extinction by aerosols computed by Khare et al. [1984] and assuming a mean particle radius of 125 Å, Liang et al. [2007] have analyzed a Cassini UVIS stellar occultation light curve over the range of 330– 970 km minimum ray heights and derived an altitude distribution of tholins. [4] The current state of the photochemistry of Titan’s atmosphere has been reviewed by Wilson and Atreya [2004]. Using a two-stream model algorithm to model the scattering contribution to the solar flux, they found that the solar flux between 1450 and 2000 Å reached altitudes between 200 and 350 km, where it is absorbed by molecules and aerosols [see Wilson and Atreya, 2004, Figure 3]. The airglow and reflected sunlight are produced at two different altitudes. The longer wavelength airglow emissions of the FUV (1450 – 1900 Å) are dominated by Rayleigh scattering produced in the stratosphere near 250 km compared to the shorter wavelength airglow emissions (1150 – 1450 Å) that occur higher in the thermosphere at 1100 km (Paper 1). This is the wide altitude range that we are probing. [ 5 ] The optically forbidden Lyman-Birge-Hopfield (LBH) band system of N2 (a 1Pg X S+g ) was observed by VI in the FUV and was the brightest N2 UV emission from the disk of Titan [Strobel et al., 1991]. The LBH intensities measured in 1980 by VI at solar maximum and in 2004 by UVIS at low solar activity track time changes in the solar XUV flux (0 to 450 Å). The VI observations did not L06102 1 of 5 L06102 AJELLO ET AL.: TITAN AIRGLOW SPECTRA FROM CASSINI UVIS resolve the LBH emissions from the Rayleigh scattered background. [6] The goal of this paper is to provide a spectral analysis of the FUV Titan airglow disk spectrum using a regression analysis on the three main N2 sources of the FUV airglow spectrum: (1) the LBH band system excited by photoelectrons; (2) the atomic N I lines produced primarily by photodissociative ionization (PDI) of N2 (Paper 1); and (3) solar UV emission scattered by the N2 atmosphere embedded with absorbing hydrocarbons and tholin absorbers. The FUV limb spectra analysis is the subject of a forthcoming paper. The limb spectra are complicated with a critical dependence on minimum ray height, dominated by solar reflectance at low altitudes and LBH airglow emissions in the ionosphere, near 1100 km. [7] We have discussed the geometry, performance and calibration procedures of the EUV channel in Paper 1. (See Ajello et al. [2007, Figure 1] for viewing geometry.) In brief, Cassini made its second close pass by Titan on 13 December 2004 (13Dec04) (11:36 UT DOY-348). The performance of the FUV channel is different than described in the instrument paper [Esposito et al., 2004] in two respects. The data pipeline includes a flat-field correction [Steffl et al., 2004] and takes into account the instrumental sensitivity variation with time. In flight calibrations using bright O-B stars (September 1999 – November 2007) have revealed that the FUV detector absolute sensitivity (l > 1600 Å) is slowly increasing with time. The uncertainty for the 13Dec04 FUV intensities is a root-sum-square error of 16% based on Poisson statistics (<5%) and calibration uncertainty (15%). The UVIS FUV line spread function was based on the near-Earth interplanetary Ly-a line. 2. FUV Solar Reflectivity From Rayleigh Scattering [8] We begin the problem by modeling the long wavelength portion of the FUV disk spectrum of Titan from 1500 to 1900 Å. This is the first step to provide one of the N2 input vectors to fit the entire FUV by regression analysis. To model the reflected sunlight from Titan, we use the LommelSeeliger (LS) law that includes multiple scattering and assumes a homogeneous atmosphere (refer to equation (47) of Wallach and Hapke [1985], applied to disc viewing geometry, i.e. pixels at the limb are excluded). We use the single scattering albedo in a gaseous mixture as defined by Gladsone and Yung [1983]. [9] The calibrated Titan FUV airglow spectrum that we analyzed is the sum of all the spatial pixels that intersect Titan’s disk (sum of all 1723 readouts). Since the incidence, emission and phase angles are generally very different for each pixel along the slit, we applied the reflectivity model to each individual pixel, computed an average spectrum, and weighted each spectrum by each pixel’s integrated intensity above 1500 Å (see Figure 1). The reflectivity calculated from the model above is then multiplied by a solar spectrum provided by the TIMED Solar EUV Experiment (SEE) [Woods et al., 2005], measured the same day as the observation. A least-square regression between the observed data and model is then applied, yielding the best-parameters, which are the mixing ratios of the absorbing components. L06102 [10] The main hydrocarbons in Titan’s atmosphere that have a significant absorption cross-section in the 1500– 1900 Å window are: C2H2, C2H4 and C4H2. With these hydrocarbons, we obtain a best fit shown in green in Figure 1, compared to the UVIS FUV disk spectrum in black. In this spectral window, the absorption cross-sections of these hydrocarbons decrease very steeply with increasing wavelength, which means that the more we add hydrocarbons, the larger is the discrepancy in the range 1650– 1850 Å. To improve the fit, we add an organic aerosol known as tholin, produced on Titan by photochemical reactions [McKay et al., 2001]. The mixing ratios of these four species are included in the single-scattering albedo calculation. We use tholins produced from N2/CH4 discharges, which have the required absorption cross-section dependence in this wavelength range [Liang et al., 2007]. The best-fit model with N2/CH4 tholins is greatly improved compared to the hydrocarbon-only fit, as seen in red in Figure 1. We find the mixing ratios of hydrocarbons relative to N2 to be: 2.4 106 for C2H2, 5.7 108 for C2H4, 1.2 108 for C4H2 and 2.4 1011 for 125 Å radius particle tholins. The quality of the fit shows these four species are sufficient to explain the observations. One UVIS reflection spectrum alone can not determine particle size; a similar fit is achieved with 25 Å radius particles by adjusting the tholin mixing ratio upward by a factor of 25. The exact optical properties for the type of tholin(s) present are unknown and LS results are a first order model of the FUV reflection spectrum. [11] The mixing ratio values we obtain characterize the atmosphere where the extinction optical depth is unity. The best-fit values are in excellent agreement with the hydrocarbon mixing ratios modeled by Wilson and Atreya [2004, Figure 10] and with the tholin mixing ratio modeled by Liang et al. [2007, Figure 2], by assuming that the bulk of sunlight is scattered near 250 km. These results are also consistent with Figure 3 of Wilson and Atreya [2004] which exhibits that the maximum solar scattering occurs between 200 and 350 km, and with a limb profile of the integrated 1500– 1900 Å band pass of the UVIS spectral intensities versus altitude (not shown) which exhibit an emission peaking around 250 km, that is 5 times more intense than the emission at 800 km. The mixing ratios also compare well with the VI infrared values [Hanel et al., 1981; Coustenis et al., 1991]. The best-fit model is used for the next step in the analysis. 3. Spectral Analysis [12] The UVIS disk airglow spectrum over the spectral range of 1150– 1750 Å is shown in black in Figure 2. It is observed that there are about 20 well-defined emission features from the LBH bands of N2, atomic multiplets of N and H Ly-a from 1150– 1570 Å along with about a halfdozen solar chromospheric lines from 1570 – 1750 Å [Cohen, 1981]. Clearly identified in the airglow spectrum are the strong atomic lines of N I at 1200 Å, 1243 Å, and 1493 Å. The positions of weaker N I features are identified by tick marks. The strongest part of the LBH spectrum can be found between 1300– 1500 Å [Ajello and Shemansky, 1985]. Beyond 1500 Å, the spectrum is dominated by solar reflectance from Rayleigh scattering. 2 of 5 L06102 AJELLO ET AL.: TITAN AIRGLOW SPECTRA FROM CASSINI UVIS Figure 1. Fit to the UVIS dayglow FUV disk spectrum from 1500– 1900 Å with two models. The differences between the model in green (hydrocarbons only) and the model in red (hydrocarbons + tholins) show the importance of tholins to accurately model this portion of the FUV spectrum. The mixing ratio of C2H2 (the main absorbing hydrocarbon in this spectral region) is 10 times higher when tholins are not included. [13] The regression fit (orange) in Figure 2 consists of four independent spectra: (1) an optically thin 18 eV direct electron impact laboratory fluorescence spectrum (the N2 gas, rotationally cooled [Ajello et al., 1998], simulating the Titan airglow LBH spectrum) (red). The spectral fittings of both the FUV and EUV (paper 1) observations of UVIS at 5.6 Å FWHM are insensitive to variations in N2 rotational temperatures of laboratory spectra between 150– 300 K; (2) a PDI spectrum of N2 to produce the N I FUV emissions, based on the relative intensities given by Bishop and Feldman [2003] (purple); (3) the H I Ly-a emission line excited mainly by solar fluorescence at 1215.6 Å (green); and (4) reflected sunlight, calculated for the entire FUV using the mixing ratios obtained in Section 2 (blue). The best fit to the data from the regression in Figure 2 (orange) determines the contributions from the four components. [14] The medium resolution laboratory spectrum of electron-excited N2 (1.0 Å FWHM, prior to convolution with the Cassini line spread function) shows the presence of about 100 LBH spectral features over the FUV spectral range of UVIS. The strongest LBH features are the (2,0) + (5,2) and (3,0) + (6,2) bands at 1383 Å (5.5%) and 1356 Å (5.9%) [Ajello and Shemansky, 1985]. Based on the laboratory spectrum, the disk intensity of the LBH band system (1250 – 2600 Å) from Titan is 43 ± 7 R. The regression fit shows significant Rayleigh scattering background to the LBH system down to a wavelength of 1350 Å with an intensity of 458 R from 1350 to 1750 Å. Below 1350 Å the LBH, PDI and H Ly-a vectors include absorption by a slant column of CH4 of 3 1016 cm2. The model also places an upper limit of the slant column of C2H2 of 3 1014 cm2, which is consistent with the fact that the density of C2H2 is a factor of 100 below that of CH4 near 900 km [Shemansky et al., 2005]. L06102 [15] The N I features can be identified from the work of Ajello and Shemansky [1985]. The strongest N I features in the FUV spectrum are 1200 Å at 6.8 R, 1243 Å at 0.6 R, 1493 Å at 3.0 R and 1743 Å at 1.6 R. The N I lines yield 16 R and the LBH N2 bands (1250 – 2600 Å) furnish 43 R. The H Ly-a feature dominates the intensity of the FUV at 208 R. The sources of H Ly-a, given by Strobel and Shemansky [1982], are due to resonance fluorescence in Titan’s atmosphere and background emissions from the local interstellar medium and particle excitation. [16] Tentative identification of atomic carbon airglow features are made from deficits in the regression fit compared to the UVIS FUV spectrum. These same C I features also occur in the solar spectrum [Prekke et al., 1991] and contribute to the reflection spectrum from Rayleigh scattering. The 31.4° ecliptic longitude difference between Cassini (Saturn) and SEE (Earth) contributes 2% uncertainty to the solar spectrum estimate at Saturn and to the tentative identification. The C I features are all identified in the figure caption and are located, also, by tick marks. The C I features are most likely due to electron-excited CH4 spectrum [Pang et al., 1987] with contributions from resonantly scattered sunlight and photoelectron excitation of atomic C. The strongest feature is 1657 Å followed by 1561 Å. Solar XUV photodissociative excitation produces a similar FUV spectrum of C I multiplets. One ‘‘mystery feature’’ at 1597 Å has not been positively identified. There are several candidate emission features at this wavelength. We have discounted the following because of lack of other supporting emissions: (1) CO A 1PX 1S (0,1) fourth positive Figure 2. Regression model fit to the FUV dayglow disk spectrum from 13Dec04 in black. The regression model (orange) includes four independent spectra: (1) LBH spectrum in red (see text); (2) PDI spectrum from solar photo-dissociative ionization of N2 in purple; (3) the solarscattered component described in Figure 1 in blue; and (4) the H Ly-a feature at 1216 Å in green. The C I airglow features (tentative identification) and ‘‘mystery feature’’ at 1597 Å are not included in the regression but are identified by tick marks. The C I multiplets are found at 1464 Å, 1561 Å and 1657 Å. Solar lines are found in the UVIS data from C IV at 1548 Å, C I at 1561 Å and 1656 Å, Fe II at 1686 Å, 1697 Å, 1702 Å, 1712 Å, and 1721 Å. 3 of 5 L06102 AJELLO ET AL.: TITAN AIRGLOW SPECTRA FROM CASSINI UVIS L06102 scattering spectral region. The major difference between the model and observed albedo curves is the presence of the C I multiplets from the upper atmosphere of Titan at 1561 and 1657 Å in the observed spectrum. The long wavelength value at 1850 Å joins smoothly on to the low wavelength IUE geometric albedo value of 0.028 at 2225 Å for the Faint Object Spectrograph (FOS) grating G270H. McGrath et al. [1998] also give a value of geometric albedo at 1800 Å of 0.02 for FOS grating G190H in agreement with our value. Further into the visible spectral region McKay et al. [2001] have noted that the haze extinction coefficient switches from mostly absorbing to mostly scattering. The general trend of the reddening of Titan was the original reason prompting tholin studies by Khare et al. [1984]. Figure 3. A plot of the geometric albedo of Titan from 1500 to 11000 Å, adapted from McGrath et al. [1998] for the FOS grating G270H (2200– 3300 Å) (red) for the MUV and McKay et al. [2001] (green) for the visible and near IR. The plot includes measured FUV values from 1500 – 1900 Å for the geometric albedo. Inset: The FUV model geometric albedo of Titan of the solar reflection (only) spectrum (blue) is compared to the observed UVIS data (black). 1 + band at 1597 Å [Beegle et al., 1999]; (2) the N++ 2 (D Su 1 + X Sg ) (0,0) and (1,1) transitions from 1587 – 1594 Å [Lilensten et al., 2005]; and (3) N+(3s 1Po3s 3P) between 1595 – 1598 Å (NIST http://physics.nist.gov/PhysRefData/ ASD/lines_form.html). [17] The nightglow spectrum (not shown) indicates a strong H Ly-a feature of about 80 R intensity and some weak N lines (1200 Å, 1243 Å and 1493 Å) each with an intensity <0.5 R. The LBH band system is not observed in the 13Dec04 nightglow spectrum. 4. Summary [18] We have modeled the FUV disk airglow spectrum of Titan from the upper atmosphere, probing altitudes between 200 km (reflected sunlight) and 1100 km (airglow). Our study of the UVIS FUV dayglow spectrum demonstrates that tholins are a key component of Titan’s atmosphere. The geometric albedo is a useful way for studying the nature of the haze [McKay et al., 2001]. In Figure 3 we show for the first time the FUV geometric albedo of Titan between 1500 – 1900 Å. Here, the observed albedo is the UVIS FUV disk-averaged surface brightness divided by the solar flux (4pIl/pFl) corrected for Titan distance as measured by TIMED SEE [Woods et al., 2005]. Our albedo results are compared to complementary results for the MUV from the IUE for phase angles of 1° to 5° [McGrath et al., 1998] and for the visible/near IR [McKay et al., 2001]. [19] The modeled albedo (blue, in Figure 3 inset, representing solar reflection from the lower atmosphere) and the UVIS observations of the FUV albedo (black, Figure 3 inset) indicate a value of 0.017 at about 1850 Å with a general trend to decline with decreasing wavelength. Superimposed on this trend are the molecular band features of the principal organic hydrocarbon absorber C2H2 in the Rayleigh [20] Acknowledgments. The research was carried out at the Jet Propulsion Laboratory (JPL), California Institute of Technology. The work was supported by the NASA Planetary Atmospheres Program and by the Cassini Project. M.H.S. was supported by the Office of Naval Research. References Ajello, J. M., and D. E. Shemansky (1985), A re-examination of important N2 cross sections by electron impact with application to the dayglow: The Lyman-Birge Hopfield band system and NI (119.99 nm), J. Geophys. Res., 90, 9845. Ajello, J. M., G. James, and M. Ciocca (1998), High resolution EUV emission spectroscopy of the N2 c0 v0 = 3 and 4 levels by electron impact, J. Phys. B At. Mol. Opt. Phys., 31, 2437. Ajello, J. M., M. H. Stevens, I. Stewart, K. Larsen, L. Esposito, J. Colwell, W. McClintock, G. Holsclaw, J. Gustin, and W. Pryor (2007), Titan airglow spectra from Cassini Ultraviolet Imaging Spectrograph (UVIS): EUV analysis, Geophys. Res. Lett., 34, L24204, doi:10.1029/ 2007GL031555. Beegle, L., J. M. Ajello, G. K. James, D. Dziczek, and M. Alvarez (1999), The emission spectrum of the CO (A 1P X 1S+) Fourth Positive System by electron impact, Astron. Astrophys., 346, 1. Bishop, J., and P. Feldman (2003), Analysis of the Astro-1/Hopkins Ultraviolet Telescope EUV-FUV nadir spectral radiance measurements, J. Geophys. Res., 108(A6), 1243, doi:10.1029/2001JA000330. Broadfoot, A. L., et al. (1981), Extreme UV observations from Voyager 1 encounter of Saturn, Science, 212, 206. Cohen, L. (1981), An atlas of solar spectra between 1175 and 1950 Å recorded on Skylab with the NRL’s Apollo Telescope mount experiment, NASA Ref. Publ., 1069. Cortin, R., R. Wagener, C. P. McKay, J. Caldwell, K. Fricke, R. Raulin, and P. Bruston (1991), UV spectroscopy of Titan’s atmosphere, planetary organic chemistry and prebiological synthesis, Icarus, 90, 43. Coustenis, A., B. Bezard, D. Gautier, and A. Marten (1991), Titans atmosphere from Voyager 1 observations, III. Vertical distribution of hydrocarbons and nitriles near Titan’s north pole, Icarus, 89, 152. Esposito, L., et al. (2004), The Cassini Ultraviolet Imaging Spectrograph investigation, Space Sci. Rev., 115, 299. Gladsone, G. R., and Y. L. Yung (1983), An analysis of the reflection spectrum of Jupiter from 1500 to 1740 Å, Astrophys. J., 266, 415. Hanel, R., et al. (1981), Infrared observations of the Saturnian system from Voyager 1, Science, 212, 192. Khare, B. N., C. Sagan, E. T. Arakawa, F. Suits, T. A. Callicott, and M. W. Williams (1984), Optical constants of organic tholin produced in a simulated Titanian atmosphere: From x-ray to microwave frequencies, Icarus, 60, 127. Liang, M. A., Y. Yung, and D. E. Shemansky (2007), Photolytically generated aerosols in the mesosphere and thermosphere of Titan, Astrophys. J., 662, L19. Lilensten, J., O. Witasse, C. Simion, H. Soldi-Lose, O. Dotuit, and R. Thissen (2005), Prediction of a N++ 2 in the upper atmosphere of Titan, Geophys. Res. Lett., 32, L03203, doi:10.1029/2004GL021432. McGrath, M., R. Courting, T. E. Smith, P. Feldman, and D. F. Strobel (1998), The ultraviolet albedo of Titan, Icarus, 131, 382. McKay, C. P., A. Coustenis, R. E. Samuelson, M. T. Lemmon, R. D. Lorenz, M. Cabane, P. Rannou, and P. Rossart (2001), Physical properties of the organic aerosols and clouds on Titan, Planet. Space Sci., 49, 79. Pang, K. D., J. M. Ajello, B. Franklin, and D. E. Shemansky (1987), Electron impact excitation cross section studies of methane and acetylene, J. Chem. Phys., 86, 2750. 4 of 5 L06102 AJELLO ET AL.: TITAN AIRGLOW SPECTRA FROM CASSINI UVIS Prekke, P., O. Kjeldseth-Moe, J.-D. F. Bartoe, and G. E. Brueckner (1991), An ultraviolet atlas of a sunspot and an active region 1190-1730 Å, Astrophys. J. Suppl. Ser., 75, 1337. Shemansky, D., I. Stewart, R. West, L. Esposito, J. Hallett, and X. Liu (2005), The Cassini UVIS stellar probe of the Titan atmosphere, Science, 308, 978. Steffl, A. J., A. I. F. Stewart, and F. Bagenal (2004), Cassini UVIS observations of the Io plasma torus. I. Initial results, Icarus, 172, 78. Strobel, D. F., and D. E. Shemansky (1982), EUV emission from Titan’s upper atmosphere: Voyager 1 encounter, J. Geophys. Res., 87, 1361. Strobel, D. F., R. R. Meier, M. E. Summers, and D. J. Strickland (1991), Nitrogen airglow sources: Comparison of Triton, Titan and Earth, Geophys. Res. Lett., 18, 689. Wallach, D., and B. Hapke (1985), Light scattering in a spherical exponential atmosphere, with application to Venus, Icarus, 63, 354. Wilson, E. H., and S. K. Atreya (2004), Current states of modeling the photochemistry of Titan’s mutually dependent atmosphere and ionosphere, J. Geophys. Res., 109, E06002, doi:10.1029/2003JE002181. L06102 Woods, T. N., F. G. Eparvier, S. M. Bailey, P. Chamberlin, J. Lean, G. J. Rottman, S. Solomon, W. K. Tobiska, and D. L. Woodraska (2005), Solar EUV Experiment (SEE): Mission overview and first results, J. Geophys. Res., 110, A01312, doi:10.1029/2004JA010765. J. M. Ajello and C. P. Malone, Jet Propulsion Laboratory, California Institute of Technology, Pasadena, CA 91109, USA. (joseph.m.ajello@jpl. nasa.gov) D. Dziczek, Nicolaus Copernicus University, ul. Gagarina 11, 87-100 Torun, Poland. J. Gustin, L. Esposito, K. Larsen, W. McClintock, and I. Stewart, Laboratory for Atmospheric and Space Physics, University of Colorado, Boulder, CO 80303, USA. W. Pryor, Science Department, Central Arizona College, Coolidge, AZ 85228-9778, USA. M. H. Stevens, Space Science Division, Naval Research Laboratory, Washington, D. C. 20375, USA. 5 of 5