advertisement
MinutesofUniversityCouncil 2:30p.m.,Thursday,May21,2015 Neatby‐TimlinTheatre Attendance:J.Kalra(Chair).SeeAppendixAforlistingofmembersinattendance. Thechaircalledthemeetingtoorderat2:30p.m.,observingthatquorumhadbeenattained. 1. Adoptionoftheagenda WILSON/DICK:Toadopttheagendaascirculated. CARRIED 2. Openingremarks Dr.Kalraprovidedopeningremarks,notingtheimportantbusinessbeforeCouncilandsharingthe usualproceduresfordebateanddiscussionandtheprotocolformembersofthemedia.Elizabeth Williamson,universitysecretaryencouragedallmemberstoattendtheJuneCouncilmeetingto ensurequorumwouldbeattained. 3. MinutesofthemeetingofApril16,2015 BRENNA,B./KROL:ThattheCouncilminutesofApril16,2015beapprovedas circulated. CARRIED 4. Businessfromtheminutes Therewasnobusinessarising. 5. ReportofthePresident PresidentBarnhartexpressedthathewasfilledwithnostalgiaasherecalledthatitwasayearago todaythatthemediaannouncedhisappointment,andthatitwouldbeayeartomorrowsincehe firstmetwithCounciltoapplauseastheuniversity’sinterimpresident.Heconveyedthathestill perceivesagreatamountofsupportandthankedmembersfortheirsupportandforthewonderful year.HeconveyedthatapersonalhighlightforhimeachmonthinadditiontoattendingCouncil washavingbreakfastonceamonthwiththeCouncilchairandCouncilcommitteechairs. ThepresidentreportedthathehadreceivedanadditionalquestionaftertheMarchCouncilmeeting abouthowtheuniversitycommunicationsplanandplannedadvertisingwasassessedasto whetherornotitwassuccessful.HeadvisedthatinNovemberareputationalsurveyofthe universitywouldbeconductedbothwithinandoutsidetheprovince,andthatthesurveyresults wouldbeusedasoneindicatorofsuccessoftheadvertisingcampaign. ThepresidentrecalledtheactofvandalismthatoccurredintheSourisHallparkinglottwoweeks priorresultinginthewindowsof53vehiclesbeingsmashedinwhatthepolicehavetermedasa “smashandgrab”theftincident.Heacknowledgedthethreeseparateteamsofpeoplethat respondedseparatelytonewsoftheincidentundertheleadershipofsenioradministratorsGreg Fowler,PattiMcDougall,andBrianMuchmore,andtheteamsinvolvedleadingtothedevelopment ofaplantohavesecuritypresentonsitefromsunsettosunriseuntilmotionlightsandcameraswill Draft until approved at the meeting. beinstalledinthelotbythefall.Alsoacompensationplanisbeingputinplacetooffsetthe financialhardshipexperiencedbythosestudentsaffected.Thepresidentconveyedthatthe studentshaverespondedpositivelytowhattheuniversityhasbeenabletodo,andthusavery negativeeventwasturnedintoapositiveexperiencefortheuniversity. PresidentBarnhartcommentedontheresiliencyoftheuniversity,andnotedthatalthoughcampus wascalm,itwasnotcomplacent,andthatpositivechangewasoccurring,suchasthenew Indigenouslanguageoptionsbeingofferedandthebuildingofanewchildcarecentre.TheGordon OakesRedBearCentrewillopeninthefallandtheGraduationPowwowwilltakeplaceMay27in theBowl.ThePresident’sTourhassuccessfullyconcludedandalthoughtheexpectationwasthat donorcontributionswoulddropthisyear,infact,theoppositehasoccurred,anddonor contributionshaveincreased. ThepresidentconcludedhisreportbycongratulatingmembersofnewlyelectedGraduateStudents’ Association(GSA)andUniversityofSaskatchewanStudents’Union(USSU)executivesontheir election,andwishingthemwellastheyrepresenttheinterestsofstudents. Commentsandquestionswereinvitedofthepresident.Amemberthankedthepresidentforallof hiseffortsoverthepastyear.Heindicatedthatanegativefactorpotentiallyaffectingthe recruitmentoffacultytotheuniversityandtheuniversity’sreputationisthatonly18%ofthe university’searly‐careerfacultymembersweresuccessfulthisyearinbeingawardedaNSERC DiscoveryGrant.ThesuccessrateisthelowestamongalluniversitiesacrossCanada,andpossibly overtherecenthistoryoftheuniversity.Heindicatedthathehadsimilarlyheardthatthenumber ofindividualsfromtheuniversityservingonselectioncommitteeswasalsodeclining,andthat thesetwodevelopmentsspeaktowhatishappeningtotheuniversity’sreputation. ThepresidentaskedKarenChad,vice‐presidentresearchtorespond.Dr.Chadannouncedthat ProfessorRonBorowsky,astheuniversity’snewNSERCleaderhasalreadyindicatedthatfocusing onnewinvestigatorswouldbeatoppriority.TheinternalreviewprocessimplementedforCIHR andSSHRCapplicantshasjustbegunforNSERCapplicants.Othersupportsystemsincludethe university’smentorshipprogramfornewresearchers.Sheacknowledgedtherecentstatisticsareof greatconcernandrecalledthatseveralyearsagotheuniversityhadthehighestsuccessrateofnew facultyawards.Suchperformancehighandlowsaretroublingwhenthedesireistoconsistently meetthenationalaverage.Dr.ChadindicatedthatanyadviceofferedbyhercolleaguesatCouncil onhowtocounterthemostrecentresultswouldbewelcomed,andthatherofficewasresponding totheresultsasapriorityitem. 6. ReportoftheProvost ErnieBarber,provostandvice‐presidentacademic,calledonPattiMcDougall,vice‐provostteaching andlearning,tomakeanannouncementonhisbehalfpriortothepresentationofhisreport. ProfessorMcDougallreportedthatProfessorJohnKleefeldoftheCollegeofLawwasthe university’smostrecentrecipientoftheBrightspaceInnovationAwardinTeachingandLearning, aninternationalawardthatrecognizesinnovationinpost‐secondaryteaching.Sheindicatedthat Dr.KleefeldjoinsProfessorsKenVanRees,SandraBassendowskiandJayWilsonasarecipientof theaward,andthattheuniversityhashadarecipienteveryyearsincetheawardwasfirst establishedfouryearsago. Dr.BarberindicatedthatthereportoftheacademicreviewoftheSchoolofPublicHealthwas availableontheInstitutionalPlanningandAssessmentwebsite.Thereviewwascommissionedin Draft until approved at the meeting. responsetotheCouncildecisionthattheschoolbereviewedaperiodoftimeafterits establishment.Dr.Barberbrieflyoutlinedthereviewprocessandtheopportunityfortheprovost andfacultyintheschooltorespondtothereviewers’report.Thereviewidentifiesthatthere continuestobearolefortheuniversityinpublichealth,inteaching,research,andinpracticebut comestotheoverallconclusionthattheambitionsoftheschoolareunabletobeachievedwiththe resourcespresentlyavailabletotheschool.Thereviewerssuggestthattheuniversityreviewits publichealthprogramming,inparticular,thetwolargelyparallelpublichealthstreamsandhow thesecontributetothevisionfortheSchoolofPublicHealth. Dr.BarberurgedCouncilmemberstoreviewthereportandresponses.Ataskforcewillbecreated whichwillworkonachievingconsensusbyOctober15thforaplanofactioninresponsetothe review.Dr.Barberreportedthathehaddiscussedthenatureofthereviewers’reportwiththe planningandprioritiescommittee.HecommittedtokeepingCouncilinformedandengaged throughtheplanningandprioritiescommittee,asanyrestructuringoftheacademicunitsinvolved wouldproceedthroughthecommitteeandtoCouncilforapproval. ACouncilmemberindicatedthatwhatstruckhimaboutthereportwhichwasofconcernwasthe extenttowhichtheDepartmentofCommunityHealthandEpidemiologywassingledoutina villainousmanner.Inparticular,henotedthecommentarythatthedepartment’sintransigenceat notwantingtojointheSchoolofPublicHealthcreatedmanyissuesfortheschool.Heexpressedhis concernthattherecommendationsofthereportareverysignificant,andalthoughthedepartment isverymuchimplicatedintheserecommendations,thedepartmentitselfwasnotsingledoutfor review.HeaskedtowhatextentandunderwhatprocesstheDepartmentofCommunityHealthand Epidemiologywasconsultedaspartofthereview. Dr.Barberindicatedthathedidnotreadeitherthereportortheresponsefromthefacultyofthe schoolaspaintingtheDepartmentofCommunityHealthandEpidemiologyinavillainousway.He notedthereportexpressessomedisappointmentthattheschooldidnotcometogethermore whollyinasinglevision.Thereportalsomakesclearthatanumberofimportantrelationships externallyandinternallytotheuniversityrelatedtopublichealthandthescholarshipofpublic healthremainundeveloped.Dr.Barbercontemplatedthatinretrospectperhapsthereviewshould havefocusedonallofpublichealthoncampusaspartofasinglereview.Heconcludedthat nonethelesstheCollegeofMedicineandtheDepartmentofCommunityHealthandEpidemiology wouldbeverymuchinvolvedindiscussionsgoingforward,andthatthereportcontainedenough informationtowarrantanapproachinvolvingacollectiveofunits. Tofurtheremphasizehispoint,thememberreadanexcerptfromthereport,andindicatedthatthe reviewers’commentsonthedepartmentwereinviolationofthebestpracticesforaunitreview,as thisunitwasnotsingledoutforreview.Hesuggestedthatperhapsafirmresponsefrom administrationwasneededtothereviewersorthattheinstructionsgivenouttothereviewers wereunclear.Dr.Barberindicatedthathewouldtakethesecommentsunderadvisement. Asuggestionwasmadebyanon‐memberofCouncilthatthereviewoftheschoolpresentsthe opportunitytolookatpositioningIndigenouspublichealth,asastrongstreamwithintheschool. TheprovostagreedwiththeimperativetoengageinAboriginalpublichealth.Dr.Barberalsoasked thatrecognitionbeprovidedtoallfacultyandstaffintheschoolwhohavebeendoingtheirvery bestandhavemademanyindividual,strongaccomplishments. AformerCouncilmemberaddressedafollow‐upquestionfromthepreviousCouncilmeetingtoDr. Chad.HeindicatedhisquestionconcernstheTri‐agencyopenaccesspolicyonpublications,which Draft until approved at the meeting. requiresthatTri‐agencyfundedauthorseitherpublishtheirworkinopenaccessvenues,orplace thesepublicationsininstitutionalrepositorieswithinadefinedtimeline.Henotedthattheprevious week,theScholarlyPublishingandAcademicResourcesCoalitionpublishedanopenletterthatwas harshlycriticalofElsevier’snewopenaccessandsharingpolicy.ThegroupclaimsthatElsevieris creatingbarrierstoauthorscomplyingwithopenaccesspolicies,andforcesa“noderivativeuse” conditiononauthorswhoplaceworksintorepositories.Theletterwasco‐signedbyanumberof groups,includingtheConfederationofOpenAccessRepositories,theAmericanLibraryAssociation andtheAssociationofResearchLibraries.HeaskedDr.Chadtodescribethespecificsofhowher officewasworkingwiththelocalsubjectexperts,includingtheUniversityLibraryandcopyright office,tohelpauthorsoncampusadapttotheshiftingsandsofopenaccesspolicies. Dr.Chadthankedthespeakerforhisleadershipinposingthequestion.Sheclarifiedthatthepolicy referredtoisthenewTri‐agencyopenaccesspolicy.Althoughthepolicyhasbeenspearheadedby NSERC,theexpectationisthatCIHRandSSHRCwillfollowsuit.Thepolicyhastwocomponents:it requiresthosewhoaregrantrecipientsofNSERCfundingtohaveanypublicationsinpeer‐ reviewedjournalsarisingfromthisfundingtobefreelyavailablewithin12monthsofthe publication,eitherthroughon‐linerepositoriesoron‐linejournals.Inaddition,thespecificdata needstobefullyaccessibleandwithinthepubicdomain.Dr.ChadnotedthisisnotaUofSspecific issue,butanationalissue.Theissueraisedisonthevice‐presidentresearchagendaacrossthe countryandwillbeaddressedasatoppriorityitembythisgroupasacollective.Specificallyon campusthefollowingstepshavebeentakentoensurecompliancewiththepolicy:online repositoryfunctionalitywillbebuiltintotheUnivRSresearchadministrationsystem;andastudy willbeinitiatedtoproactivelyassistindividualstobeincompliancewiththepolicy.Dr.Chad concludedthatensuringpolicycompliancewasatoppriorityandthatmemberscouldlookforward toaquestionandanswerbriefingdocument,whichwouldsharethestepstakentoalleviateand mitigatecomplianceconcerns. Dr.BarberconcludedhisremarksbyexpressinghisregretthathewillbeunabletoattendtheJune Councilmeeting.HeofferedhisthankstoCouncilfortherespectfulanddeliberatedecisionsand debateoverthecourseoftheyearandthankedtheCouncilchairandvice‐chair,Councilcommittee chairs,andtheuniversitysecretaryandassociatesecretaryfortheircontributions.Counciljoined thechairinapplausetoacknowledgetheprovost’scontributions. 7. Studentsocieties 7.1 ReportfromtheUSSU GabeSenecal,vice‐presidentacademicaffairs,presentedaverbalreporttoCouncilonbehalfof JackSaddleback,USSUpresident.Mr.Senecalexpressedtheexcitementofthenewexecutiveto workwiththeuniversitycommunityandnamedthenewexecutivemembers.Sharedgoalsfor theyearincludementalhealth,sexualassault,studentengagement,andtuitionforecasting, amongothergoals.Duringthefirstfewweeks,theUSSUexecutivehasconnectedwith studentsregardingconcernsofsafety,security,residence,tuition,andconsultation.Mr. Senecalindicatedhelookedforwardtoworkingwiththeuniversitytocreateabetter experienceforstudents.Inturn,theCouncilchairexpressedthatonbehalfofCouncil,healso lookedforwardtoworkingwiththeUSSU. Draft until approved at the meeting. 7.2 ReportfromtheGSA RajatChakravarty,presidentoftheGSAprovidedaverbalreporttoCouncil.Mr.Chakravarty reportedthetwobroadgoalsoftheGSAaretoaddresstransparencyandtomodel collaboration.Tothatend,theexecutiveisconsideringaforensicauditofitsfinancesandhas givenitsfullcooperationtothepoliceinvestigationunderway.Newgoverningdocumentshave beenapprovedataspecialgeneralmeetingandtheGSAbudgetfortheyearhasbeen approved.Mr.ChakravartyreportedtheGSAistryingtoforgebondswithstakeholders,senior administration,theuniversitysecretary,andseekstopartnermeaningfullywiththeUSSU.The GSAhastriedtochannelthecarvandalismincidentintoameaningfuldiscussion.Aby‐election hasbeenheldandanewVPOperationselected.Withafullcomplement,theGSAexecutivewill nowsetitsspecificgoalsforthecomingyear.Mr.Chakravartythankedthoseinattendancefor hearinghisreportandexpressedthathelookedforwardtoparticipatingonCouncil. 8. Planningandprioritiescommittee ProfessorDirkdeBoer,vice‐chairoftheplanningandprioritiescommitteepresentedthereportto Council. 8.1 Requestfordecision:NamechangefromDepartmentofNativeStudiestoDepartmentof IndigenousStudies ProfessordeBoermadeacorrectiontothemotion:tochangetheeffectivedateofthemotion fromJune1toJuly1,2015,andtoindicatewhenstudents’academicrecordswouldbe amended.Thekeypointinconsiderationofthemotionisthatconsultationandconsiderationof thenamechangebeganthreeyearsprior.Henotedthatithaslongbeenrecognizedthatthe term“native”isverybroadandimprecise,andtheterm“Indigenous”isfarlessambiguous. Manydepartmentselsewherecurrentlyusetheterminology“Indigenous”asitisfarmore inclusive.Extensiveconsultationregardingtheproposednamechangehasoccurredandthere iswidespreadsupportforthenamechange.TheprogramnamechangetoIndigenousStudies wasapprovedinJanuary2015. deBOER/KHANDELWAL:ThattheDepartmentofNativeStudiesberenamedthe DepartmentofIndigenousStudies,effectiveJuly1,2015,withallacademicrecords tobeupdatedSeptember,2015. CARRIED 9. Academicprogramscommittee ProfessorAlecAitken,vice‐chairoftheacademicprogramscommitteepresentedthereportsto Council. 9.1 Requestfordecision:CertificateofLeadershipinpost‐secondaryeducation ProfessorAitkenmadeacorrectiontothestartdateofthemotiontoreadMay1,2016,rather thanSeptember1,2015.Thenewcertificateprogramisintendedtomeettheneedsof practicingeducatorsandoffernewoptionstoundergraduatestudentsinthecollege.Further on,thenewcoursesofferedmayladderinortransitiontoamaster’sprogram. Draft until approved at the meeting. FLYNN/WILSON:ThatCouncilapprovetheCertificateofLeadershipinPost‐ SecondaryEducation,effectiveMay1,2016. CARRIED 9.2 Requestforinput:AcademicCoursesPolicy ProfessorAitkennotedthatpreviousversionsoftheAcademicCoursespolicyhavebeen submittedtoCouncilforinputastheacademicprogramscommitteeworksthroughpolicy revisions.Revisionstothepolicyincludechangestothesyllabussection,theweightingof courseactivities,thenatureofcontentofonlinecourses,examinvigilation,gradeconflicts,and theschedulingofmidtermsoutsideofnormalclasstime.Heinvitedmemberstoreviewthe proposedchangesandsubmitanycommentsbyemailtocommitteesecretaryAmandaStorey atamanda.storey@usask.ca. 9.3 Itemforinformation:ApprovaloftheMAProject–optioninPoliticalStudies,Revisionsto theProgramProposalForm ProfessorAitkenreportedontwoitemsforCouncil’sinformation. Theacademicprogramscommitteehasapprovedaproject‐basedmasterofarts(MA)within theDepartmentofPoliticalStudies,whichwillcomplementthedepartment’sMAthesis‐based program.Thenon‐thesisoptionwillincreasethenumberofgraduatestudentsintheprogram andmakethedepartmentmorecompetitivewithinitsU15peergroup.Theprogramis structuredtoencouragestudentstocompletetheprograminoneyear’stime. Therevisedtemplateforsubmissionofnewdegreeprogramsandothercurricularchangeshas beenrevisedbytheacademicprogramscommitteetobeasclearaspossibletoproponents submittingcurricularchanges,particularlywithrespecttothebudgetaryinformation requested. 10. Scholarshipandawardscommittee ProfessorRaviChibbar,committeechair,presentedthereport. 10.1Itemforinformation:Year‐endreport ProfessorChibbarreportedthatoverthe2014‐15fiscalyeartherewere71newawardsfor undergraduatestudentsand28newawardsforgraduatestudentsestablished.Hehighlighted tomembersthesectiononAboriginalawardsinthereport,notingthatmuchworkisprojected fornextyear’scommitteeintheareaofAboriginalawards.Inclosing,hethankedWendy KlingenbergandherstaffwithinStudentandEnrolmentServicesandHeatherLukeyandher staffwithintheCollegeofGraduateStudiesandResearchfortheirsupportofthecommittee. 11. Nominationscommittee ProfessorEdKrol,chairofthenominationscommitteepresentedthecommitteereporttoCouncil. 11.1Requestfordecision:Committeenominationsfor2015‐16 Draft until approved at the meeting. Professor Krol indicated that the nominees to committees for 2015-16 were in the attached list before Council.InadditiontothenamespresentedintheCouncilpackage,ahandoutto addanadditionalmembertotheacademicprogramscommitteewasdistributedatthedoor. ThenominationscommitteereviewedthevacanciesontheCouncilcommitteemembershiplist andthecommitteesconstitutedunderthecollectiveagreement,andsolicitedvolunteersto thesecommittees.AnadwasplacedinOnCampusNews,andacallwassubmittedtodeansand departmentheads.Thenominationscommitteemetseveraltimesinthespringanddiditsbest topopulatethevaryingcommitteesstrivingforbalancebetweenthevariousdisciplines, degreeofexperienceandwithconsiderationofequityamongmembers. KROL/BRENNA,D.:ThatCouncilapprovethenominationstoUniversityCouncil committees,CollectiveAgreementcommittees,andothercommittees. CARRIED 12. Otherbusiness Thepresidentannouncedthathehadjustreceivedwordthattheprovince’snewMinisterof AdvancedEducationwouldbeScottMoe,agraduateoftheCollegeofAgricultureandBioresources, andthatthecurrentMinisterofAdvancedEducation,KevinDoherty,wouldbecomeMinisterof Finance. 13. Questionperiod Therewerenoquestions. 14. Adjournment Themeetingadjournedbymotion(MARCHE/ZELLO)at4:05pm. Draft until approved at the meeting. COUNCIL ATTENDANCE 2014‐15 Voting Participants Name Albritton, William Allen, Andy Arcand, Jaylynn Barber, Ernie Barnhart, Gordon Barrett, Jennifer Barth, Katrina Bartley, William Baxter‐Jones, Adam Bilson, Beth Bonham‐Smith, Peta Bradley, Michael Brenna, Bev Brenna, Dwayne Brown, William Buhr, Mary Butler, Lorna Calvert, Lorne Chakravarty, Rajat Chang, Gap Soo Cheng, Hongming Chibbar, Ravindra Crowe, Trever Day, Moira de Boer, Dirk D'Eon, Marcel DesBrisay, Gordon Dick, Rainer Dobson, Roy Eberhart, Christian Ervin, Alexander Findlay, Len Flynn, Kevin Freeman, Doug Gabriel, Andrew Gobbett, Brian Gray, Richard Greer, Jim Gyurcsik, Nancy Haines, Aleina Hamilton, Murray Harrison, Liz Havele, Calliopi Hayes, Alyssa Huywan, Zachary Iron, Monica Jamali, Nadeem James‐Cavan, Kathleen Johnstone, Jill Jones, Kirsten Jones, Marina Julien, Richard Kalagnanam, Suresh Kalra, Jay Kalynchuk, Lisa Sept 18 Oct 23 Nov 20 Dec 18 Jan 22 Feb 26 Mar 19 Apr 16 May 21 June 18 P P P P R R R R R P NYA P P P R P R P R P P A R P P P R P P R P R P R P P P P P R P R P P P A NYA NYA NYA A A A A A A NYA NYA NYA A A A A A A P P P A P P P R P P P P P P P P P P NYA R P P R P P R R P R R P P P P P R P A A A P P R P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P R R P P P P P R P P P R P R P P P R R P R P R R R P R R P P R R P P R P R P P P NYA NYA NYA NYA NYA NYA NYA NYA R P P P P P R R P A P P P P P R A P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P R P P P P P P R P P R P P P P P P P P P P P NYA P P P P P P R P P P P P R R R P P P P P P P P P P R P P P P P P P P A A A A A A A A A P P P P P P P P P R P P P P P P P R P R P A A A P P R P R R P R R R P R A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A P P P P P R A P P R P A R R R R R R R P P P R P P P P R A A A P R R R A R P P P A P R P P R R P R R P P P R P P A P R A A A A P A P P P P A P P A P P P A P A P A A P P P P P P P A P P P P P P R P R R P P R P P P R R R P P P P P P P P A R P R R P P P R A A A A A A A A A A A A A P P P A A R NYA NYA NYA P P P R P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P Name Khandelwal, Ramji Kipouros, Georges Klaassen, Frank Krol, Ed Kuhlmann, Franz‐Viktor Labrecque, Jamie Langhorst, Barbara Larre, Tamara Li, Wendy Lin, Yen‐Han Lindemann, Rob Makarova, Veronika Marche, Tammy Martz, Lawrence Meda, Venkatesh Muri, Allison Nickerson, Michael Noble, Bram Ogilvie, Kevin Paige, Matthew Parkinson, David Prytula, Michelle Pywell, Rob Racine, Louise Radomske, Dillan Rangacharyulu, Chary Robertson, Jordan Rodgers, Carol Roesler, Bill Sarjeant‐Jenkins, Rachel Senecal, Gabe Singh, Jaswant Smith, Preston Solose, Kathleen Soltan, Jafar Still, Carl Stoicheff, Peter Taras, Daphne Tyler, Robert Uswak, Gerry Van Kessel, Andrew Waldram, James Walker, Keith Walley, Fran Wang, Hui Wasan, Kishor Watson, Erin Williamson, Vicki Wilson, Jay Wilson, Ken Wotherspoon, Terry Yates, Thomas Zello, Gordon Sept 18 Oct 23 Nov 20 Dec 18 Jan 22 Feb 26 Mar 19 Apr 16 May 21 June 18 P P P P P P R P P P P R P P P P R R P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P R R P P R R R R R A P P P P P P P P R R P R R P R R R P R P P R P P P P A R R A A P P P P P R P A P A R R P A A A A A A A P A P P P P P A P P P P P P R P R P P P R P P P R P P R P P P P P A A P A P R P P P P P A P P A A A P A A P A P A P R A R R A A A A A A A A A A A A R P P P P P P A P P P R P P P P R R P A P P R P R R R P P P P P P P R P R P R P P P P P P A R R P P A P A A A P R A P R R R A A P P P P P P P P P P R P P P P P R P P P P R R R P A R R P R P P P P P P A P A P P P P P P P P P A R P P P R R P P P P P P R R P P P R P P P P P NYA NYA NYA NYA NYA NYA R P P R R P R P A R P P P R R P P P P R R P P P P P P P P P P P R P R P P P R R R R P P P P R A A A R A A A A A P P P R P P P P P P P R R P R R R P R P R P R R P P R A P P P P R A A A R ‐ R P P R P P R P P P P P P P P P R R P R P P P P P P P R P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P R P P P P P P R P R P P P P P P P P P P P P R P COUNCIL ATTENDANCE 2014‐15 Non‐voting participants Name Sept 18 Binnie, Sarah Chad, Karen Downey, Terrence Fowler, Greg Isinger, Russ Pulfer, Jim Saddleback, Jack Williamson, Elizabeth P P P P P P NYA P Oct 23 Nov 20 Dec 18 Jan 22 Feb 26 Mar 19 Apr 16 May 21 June 18 R P R P P P NYA P R P P P P P NYA P R R R P P P NYA P R P R P P P NYA P A P A P P P NYA P P R R P P P NYA P P P R R p p NYA p R P A P P P P P
