4HE7ESTERN!PACHE(OME,ANDSCAPE-ANAGEMENTAND
&AILING%COSYSTEMS
3ETH0ILSK
$EPARTMENTOF&OREST2ESOURCES3AN#ARLOS!PACHE4RIBE3AN#ARLOS!:
*EANETTE##ASSA
%LDERS#ULTURAL!DVISORY#OUNCIL3AN#ARLOS!PACHE4RIBE3AN#ARLOS!:
!BSTRACTˆ4HETRADITIONAL7ESTERN!PACHEHOMELIESLARGELYWITHINTHE-ADREAN!RCHIPELAGO
4HENATURALRESOURCESOFTHEREGIONMAKEUPTHEBASISOFTHE!PACHEHOMEANDCULTURE0ROFOUND
LANDSCAPECHANGESINTHEREGIONHAVEOCCURREDOVERTHEPASTYEARS!SURVEYOFTRADITIONAL
7ESTERN!PACHEPLACENAMESDOCUMENTSMANYOFTHESECHANGES!NANALYSISOFTHEHISTORYAND
!PACHE PLACES IN THE 7HEATlELDS AREA IN SOUTHEASTERN!RIZONA ILLUSTRATES THE LOSS OF!PACHE
NATURALRESOURCES4RADITIONAL!PACHEELDERSATTRIBUTETHELOSSOFTHESERESOURCESTODISRESPECTFUL
LANDMANAGEMENTPRACTICESRESULTINGINDIRECTHARMTO!PACHECOMMUNITIES
)NTRODUCTION
&ORTHEPASTTHIRTEENYEARSTHEAUTHORSHAVEWORKEDEXTEN
SIVELYWITH!PACHEELDERSFROMTHE3AN#ARLOS!PACHE4RIBE
THE7HITE-OUNTAIN!PACHE4RIBETHE4ONTO!PACHE4RIBEAND
THE9AVAPAI!PACHE.ATION-UCHOFTHISWORKHASCENTERED
ONGATHERINGTRADITIONAL!PACHEINFORMATIONABOUTTHENATURAL
WORLD INCLUDING lELD WORK DOCUMENTING TRADITIONAL PLACE
NAMES AND PLANT USES4HE!PACHE INFORMATION INCLUDED IN
THISPAPERCOMESFROM!PACHEELDERSINTERVIEWEDDURINGTHE
COURSEOFTHISWORK
4HE TRADITIONAL 7ESTERN!PACHE HOME ENCOMPASSES A
LARGEAREAOFCENTRALANDEASTERN!RIZONASEElGURE4RADE
WARFAREANDCEREMONIALPRACTICESREQUIREDOCCASIONALTRIPSTO
THE2IO'RANDEANDEAST-EXICOTHE'ULFOF#ALIFORNIATHE
COASTOFSOUTHERN#ALIFORNIAANDTHE'RAND#ANYONNORTHWARD
!PACHESHAVELIVEDINTHISREGIONFORCENTURIESANDTRADITIONAL
KNOWLEDGEOFTHISREGIONISPROFOUNDINITSDEPTHANDSPECIlC
ITY-ANY!PACHESONGSANDSTORIESDESCRIBESPECIlCNATURAL
ELEMENTS AND PROCESSES IN THIS REGION FROM THE TIME BEFORE
HUMANSEXISTED0RIORTOTHEESTABLISHMENTOFTHERESERVATIONS
!PACHES DEPENDED TOTALLY ON THE NATURAL RESOURCES OF THIS
REGIONFORTHEIRLIVELIHOOD
.ATIVE!MERICANSHAVELIVEDINTHISREGIONFORTHOUSANDS
OFYEARSEXPLOITINGRESOURCESTOSURVIVE!PACHESDIDNOTLIVE
INAPRISTINELANDSCAPEUNALTEREDBYHUMANHANDS(OWEVER
!PACHES CONSCIOUSLY LIMITED THEIR IMPACT ON THE LAND IN
PRERESERVATION TIMES ATTEMPTING TO LIVE WITHIN TRADITIONAL
PARAMETERS GOVERNING THEIR OWN POPULATION SIZE HARVEST
INGOFWILDRESOURCESANDAGRICULTURALTECHNIQUES!PACHES
TRADITIONALLYUNDERSTOODTHENEGATIVECONSEQUENCESOFLIVING
BEYOND THESE TRADITIONAL PARAMETERS AND MISUSING NATURAL
RESOURCES
4HE ECOSYSTEMS OF THE 7ESTERN!PACHE HOMELAND HAVE
SUFFERED PROFOUND CHANGES SINCE )NAH %UROPEANS OR %URO
!MERICANSARRIVEDINTHESTOTRAPBEAVER$OBYNS
AND ESPECIALLY AFTER AS )NAH AGRICULTURAL AND MINING
PRACTICESALTEREDTHENATURALWORLDINAVERYSHORTPERIODOF
TIME .UMEROUS AUTHORS HAVE DESCRIBED THE ENVIRONMENTAL
IMPACTSOFTHISPERIODINCLUDING$OBYNS"AHRE
AMONGOTHERSAND0YNE!PACHEELDERSDESCRIBE
THISCHANGEASASERIESOFSPEEDYANDVIOLENTTRANSFORMATIONS
COMMONSCHANGINGINTORESTRICTEDLANDSWETLANDSCHANGINGTO
DRYLANDSWATERSOURCESDIMINISHINGORDISAPPEARINGALTOGETHER
THELOSSOFTOPSOILINGENERALTRANSFORMATIONOFGRASSLANDSINTO
WOODLANDSORSHRUBLANDSTRANSFORMATIONOFOPENFORESTSTO
CHOKEDFORESTSNONNATIVEPLANTSANDHUMANSDISPLACINGNA
TIVESANDNATURALPLACESTRANSFORMEDINTOINDUSTRIALORURBAN
SITES%LDERSSEETHISCHANGEINTERMSOFLOSTACCESSTOCULTURAL
RESOURCESASTHEPRE)NAHECOSYSTEMSHAVEALLBUTCOLLAPSED
4HEONGOING7ESTERN!PACHE0LACE.AMES0ROJECTHASTO
DATEIDENTIlEDOVERONETHOUSAND!PACHEPLACENAMESWITHIN
CENTRALANDEASTERN!RIZONASEElGURE4HESENAMESREmECT
AWEALTHOFKNOWLEDGEOFTHEREGIONINCLUDINGDESCRIPTIONS
OF THE LAND PRIOR TO )NAH ACTIVITIES AND SETTLEMENT /VER PLACESHAVEBEENDOCUMENTEDSOFARWHOSETRADITIONALNAMES
NO LONGER APTLY DESCRIBE THE LAND DUE TO SIGNIlCANT ALTERA
TIONORDESTRUCTIONBY)NAHACTIVITIES&OREXAMPLEC hichíil
Bi[dagoteel
h%MORY /AK &LATv AN IMPORTANT TRADITIONAL
ACORNGATHERING AREA IS NOW THE SITE OF THE INTERSECTION OF
(IGHWAYS AND SHOPPING CENTERS AND FASTFOOD IN
0AYSON!RIZONATee[H ach77
h2OWOF2ED#ATTAILSvWASA
WETLANDSWITHADENSEOFGROWTHOFTRADITIONALPLANTSONTHE
EASTERNBOUNDARYOFTHE3AN#ARLOS2ESERVATIONANDHASNOW
BEENPUMPEDDRYBYOFF2ESERVATIONFARMERSANDURBANUS
ERST][ichíog7h9ELLOW7ATER3PRINGvISASPRINGTHATFEEDS
0INTO#REEKNORTHOF3UPERIOR!RIZONANEXTTOATRADITIONAL
$ANCEGROUNDANDWILLSOONBEINTHEMIDDLEOFTHE#ARLOTA
#OPPER#OMPANYSPLANNEDOPENPITMINE
4HELANDALTERINGACTIVITIESOFTHELASTYEARSANDTHEIR
EFFECTSON!PACHERESOURCESAREEASILYVISIBLEINTHEREGION
OF7HEATlELDSALONG0INAL#REEKJUSTWESTOF'LOBE!RIZONA
86'$)RUHVW6HUYLFH3URFHHGLQJV50563
&IGUREˆ7ESTERN!PACHE0LACE.AMES
IN!RIZONA
SEE lGURE 4HIS REGION KNOWN AS Tíiis Tseba h'RAY
#OTTONWOOD'ROWTHSvISATRADITIONALHOMELANDPERMANENT
CAMP AND FARMING AREA FOR THE Kíis C híintí7í4dn h!LDERS
*UTTING OUT 0EOPLEv, Ts8 Ts4h4skidn
h4REES ON A (ILLTOP
0EOPLEv, D zi[ Likesilan h-OUNTAINS IN A 2OW 0EOPLEv,
Tsebinastií
4h2OCK%NCIRCLED0EOPLEv,ANDTHEH ak2iy4h)NAH
5PWARDSv CLANS IN Tíiis Tseban THE 0INAL "AND COUNTRY
!PACHESLIVEDINTíiisTsebaINSIGNIlCANTNUMBERSWELLINTO
THESEVENTHOUGHMOST!PACHESHADBEENMOVEDONTO
THE2ESERVATIONBYTHEN
3ITUATEDATABOUTFEETTHERIPARIANAREASTILLCONSISTS
OFSOMECOTTONWOODWILLOWELDERBERRY4HEIMMEDIATESUR
ROUNDINGmATSARETHICKWITHMESQUITEANDCATCLAWORCLEARED
FARMLANDHOMESITESORINDUSTRIALSITES4HEUPLANDSREACHING
FEETINELEVATIONRANGEFROMUPPER3ONORANSCRUBTO
DESERT GRASSLANDS AND JUNIPER PINYON OAK WOODLANDS AND
CHAPARRAL
!CCORDINGTO!PACHEELDERSFROMTHESTHETíiis Tseba
OFCENTURIESAGOWAShxVACANTANDNEVERBEFOREOCCUPIEDBY
86'$)RUHVW6HUYLFH3URFHHGLQJV50563
!PACHE0LACESOBEAUTIFULTHAT;THEH ak2iy4=CLANMOVEDTHERE
INENTIRETYx'OODWINv7ITHINTHELASTTENYEARSELDERS
INTHEIREIGHTIESANDNINETIESHAVEREMEMBEREDTHETíiis Tseba
OFTHEIRYOUTHANDOFTHEIRELDERSMEMORIESDESCRIBINGTHEPRE
SETTLEMENTLANDSCAPEINSOMEDETAIL0INAL#REEKmOWEDYEAR
ROUNDWITHARELATIVELYNARROWANDDEEPCHANNEL4HEBANKS
WERECOVEREDWITHGRASSANDTHECROWNSOFTALLCOTTONWOODS
ANDWILLOWSONBOTHSIDESOFTHECREEKCONNECTEDTOFORMA
CLOSEDCANOPY
4HEmATSONEITHERSIDEOFTHECREEKWEREGENERALLYOPEN
ANDGRASSYWITHSOMEMESQUITESCOTTONWOODSBURROBRUSH
GRAYTHORNANDOTHERSHRUBS4HELOWERSLOPESONEITHERSIDE
OF0INTO#REEKWERECOMPOSEDOF3ONORANSCRUBSPECIESBUT
QUITEOPENWITHALMOSTALLOFTHESURFACECOVEREDWITHGRASS
4HEWOODLANDSWEREOPENANDCOVEREDWITHGRASSWITHOC
CASIONALPINYONJUNIPERSANDOAKS
-OSTPROMINENTINELDERSMEMORIESISTHEFORMERABUN
DANCEOFWATER.OTONLYWAS0INAL#REEKPERENNIALBUTSO
WERENUMEROUSSPRINGSINTHEREGION-OSTOFTHESESPRINGS
RANSTRONGANDSUPPORTEDLUXURIANTGROWTHATTHEIRSOURCES
ANDALONGTHECREEKSTHATRANFROMTHEM
4HETíiis TsebaREGIONWASRICHANDVARIEDIN!PACHERE
SOURCESDUETOITSABUNDANCEOFWATERANDVARIEDECOSYSTEMS
4HEmATSALONG0INAL#REEKSUPPORTEDFARMSWHERE!PACHES
GREWTRADITIONALCROPSOFCORNANDSQUASH4HESURROUNDING
COUNTRY SUPPORTED NUMEROUS WILD PLANTS THAT PROVIDED TRA
DITIONAL FOOD AND ALL THE ELEMENTS OF MATERIAL CULTURE4HE
MANYWATERSOURCESSUPPORTEDPLENTIFULWILDGAME/NEELDER
ESTIMATEDTHATTHETíiis TsebaREGIONTRADITIONALLYSUPPORTED
AN!PACHECOMMUNITYOFAFEWHUNDRED%LDER84HIS
SAMEELDERREFERREDTOTHEREGIONOFTHATTIMEAShAN!PACHE
PARADISEv!LTHOUGH POPULAR )NAH WRITING HAS MADE MUCH
OF!PACHESASWARRIORSANDRAIDERSMOSTOFTHEIRTRADITIONAL
SUBSISTENCEWASOWEDTOAGRICULTUREANDWILDFOODHARVESTING
"USKIRK ESTIMATED THAT THE TRADITIONAL DIET OF MANY
7ESTERN!PACHEGROUPSWASCOMPRISEDOFUPTOWILD
ANDAGRICULTURALFOODSWITHONLYTHESMALLESTPORTIONMADEUP
OFPRODUCTSOBTAINEDINRAIDS
)NTHEMIDSWARSWITH)NAHBEGANINEARNESTANDBY
THEEARLYSMOSTOFTHE7ESTERN!PACHESHADBEENSUBDUED
BYTHE53!RMYANDCONCENTRATEDONRESERVATIONS4HE3AN
#ARLOS2ESERVATIONWASESTABLISHEDINANDTíiis Tseba
WASORIGINALLYINCLUDEDINTHE2ESERVATION!S)NAHFOUNDCOP
PERGOLDANDSILVERORESANDGOODGRAZINGLANDSONANDOFF
THE2ESERVATIONLARGETRACTSOFTHE2ESERVATIONINCLUDINGTíiis
Tseba,
WEREPLACEDBACKINTOTHEPUBLICDOMAIN!DETAILED
HISTORYOFTHE!PACHEWARSTHEESTABLISHMENTOFTHERESERVA
TIONSANDTHEREMOVALOFLANDSFROMTHE2ESERVATIONASTHEY
PERTAINTOTíiis Tseba,
CANBEFOUNDIN.EWTON
%XTENSIVE RANCHING AND MINING OPERATIONS IN THE Tíiis
TsebaAND'LOBE-IAMIREGIONSBEGANINTHEEARLYS!S
AN!PACHEELDERFROMTíiis TsebaTOLDUSh4HOSERANCHERS
THEYALREADYHADITlGUREDOUTWITHTHE!RMY4HE!RMYWOULD
COMEINANDTHERANCHERSWOULDSTARTUPRIGHTAWAYv%LDER
84OSUPPORTTHEFASTGROWINGPOPULATIONOFTHEAREA
NON!PACHEFARMSWEREESTABLISHEDINTHEmATSTHROUGHOUTTíiis
Tseba4HECOMBINATIONOFRANCHINGMININGANDAGRICULTURE
VERY QUICKLY IMPACTED!PACHE RESOURCES AND ACCESS IN THE
REGIONANDINTWENTYYEARSGREATLYALTEREDTHELANDSCAPE
%LDERSHAVETOLDUSTHATBYTHEBEGINNINGOFTHE4WENTIETH
CENTURY0INAL#REEKSTARTEDTOmOODMOREFREQUENTLYANDERODE
MORERAPIDLYGREATLYWIDENINGTHECREEKSCOURSE"YTHES
ORS0INAL#REEKmOWEDONLYWITHTHERAINS"YTHISTIME
CATTLEHADCLEAREDMUCHOFTOPLAYEROFVEGETATIONANDTOPSOIL
OVERMOSTOFTHEHILLSANDTHEREWASLESSGRASSTOBEFOUND
-OSTIMPORTANTLYINTHEMEMORIESOFELDERSWASTHELOSSOF
MANYOFTHESPRINGSBYTHES!STHEYRECALLTHECOPPER
MINESESTABLISHEDAWATERDELIVERYSYSTEMFORTHEMINESTHAT
EFFECTIVELYDRIEDUPTHEMAJORSPRINGSINTHEAREAANDFURTHER
DIMINISHEDTHEmOWIN0INAL#REEK/THERSPRINGSHADBEEN
DYNAMITEDINANATTEMPTTOINCREASEmOWBUTHADRESULTEDIN
KILLINGTHESPRINGS
!NEXAMINATIONOF!PACHEPLACESINTHETíiisTsebaREGION
SEElGURECLEARLYILLUSTRATESTHECHANGEOFTHELANDSCAPE
ASWELLASTHELOSSOF!PACHERESOURCESN alee[iD anakaiy4
h$UCKS7ADDLE!ROUNDvWASINTHEEARLYPARTOFTHELAST
CENTURY A WETLAND NEXT TO 0INAL #REEK WITH STANDING WATER
YEARROUND!FAVORITESPOTTOCOOLOFFANDSWIMITWASKNOWN
ASAWATERINGHOLEFORANIMALSANDASOURCEFORIMPORTANTTRADI
TIONALPLANTS)TWASPUMPEDDRYBYTHEMINESINTHETEENSAND
THEWETLANDSDISAPPEARED4ODAYASEWAGETREATMENTFACILITY
STANDSONTHISSITE3IMILARLYTs4 L1tah T]
h7ATERON4OPOF
THE2OCKvWASASPRINGTHATHADASTRONGmOWOFCOOLWATER
YEARROUND WAS A SOURCE OF WATER FOR WILDLIFE PLANTS AND
!PACHESANDTHEIRFARMS4HEAREAAROUNDTHISSPRINGWASTRADI
TIONALLYONEOFTHEMOSTHEAVILYINHABITEDWITHAGREATNUMBER
OFFARMS4HESPRINGSITEISNOWSITUATEDINAROCKQUARRYAND
EVENTHOUGHTHESPRINGISGONETHEPLACEREMAINSWELLKNOWN
AMONGELDERSTHROUGHOUT7ESTERN!PACHECOUNTRY
T]Yadnlinh7ATER&LOWING$OWNvISAWASHTHATUSED
TORUNYEARROUNDBEFORETHEMINESCAMEBUTNOWRUNSONLY
OCCASIONALLYWITHHEAVYRAINS%LDERSTOLDUSTHATTHESPRINGS
NEARTHEHEADOFTHISWASHUSEDTOSUPPORTAN)NAHRANCHERS
FRUITORCHARDBUTTHESPRINGSmOWISNOWGREATLYREDUCEDAND
OFTENDRY4HECOTTONWOODSWILLOWSANDWALNUTSTHATUSED
TOBEABUNDANTALONGTHEWASHARENOWONLYSPORADIC,ARGE
DESERTWILLOWS #HILOPSIS LINEARIS HACKBERRIES MESQUITES
TURBINELLAOAKANDAFEWWALNUTSARENOWTHEDOMINANTTREES
N agoneltinh9ERBA-ANSAvISTHENAMEOFASPRINGANDWASH
THATWASATRADITIONALCAMPSITEFORGROUPSFROMTíiis Tseba
GOING OUT TO GATHER ACORNS AT THE NEARBY C hichíil da[kizh
h3POTTEDWITH%MORY/AKSv4HISSPRINGHASSINCEBEENDE
VELOPEDWITHAWINDMILLFEEDINGSEVERALPIPELINES4ODAYTHE
SPRINGSUPPORTSCOTTONWOODSWILLOWSANDREEDBUTTHEREARE
ENCROACHINGNONNATIVESSUCHAS!ILANTHUSTREESSPEARMINT
REDBROMEANDHOREHOUNDANDNONEOFTHEYERBAMANSAPLANTS
FORWHICHTHESPRINGWASNAMED/NCEPLENTIFULANDHIGHLY
VALUEDINHEALTHYWETLANDSYERBAMANSAISINCREASINGLYHARD
TOlNDIN!PACHECOUNTRY
4ODAY 0INAL #REEK AND ITS IMMEDIATELY ADJACENT LANDS
N alee[iD anakaiy4
Ts4 L1tah T]
ANDTHESPRINGATN agoneltin
ARE ALL PRIVATE HOLDINGS SURROUNDED BY 53 &OREST 3ERVICE
LANDS/FTENSIGNSAREPOSTEDONPRIVATEPROPERTYBOUNDARIES
WARNING TRESPASSERS TO KEEP OUT!PACHES ARE USED TO BE
ING LEGALLY SEPARATED FROM THEIR TRADITIONAL OFF2ESERVATION
PLACES AND THE TRADITIONAL RESOURCES THAT ARE FOUND THERE
/FTEN!PACHESMUSTSNEAKUNDERFENCESTOHARVESTTRADITIONAL
PLANTSANDTHEAUTHORSHAVESEENELDERSHIDEBEHINDBUSHES
ORINDITCHESSOTHATNOONEWILLSEETHEMGATHERINGIMPORTANT
RESOURCESEVENWHENPERFECTLYLEGALACCUSTOMEDASTHEYARETO
HARASSMENTBYLAWENFORCEMENTPERSONNELORLOCALCITIZENS
3EVERALYEARSAGOTHEAUTHORSSPOKETOANACCOMPLISHEDIzee
D ighinATRADITIONALHERBALISTWHOWASTHENINHISMIDNINE
TIESABOUTTHESTATEOFTHENATURALWORLD(ETOLDUSTHAThTHE
WORLDISDRYINGUP4HEWATERANDTHESPRINGSAREGOINGDOWN
AND THE MEDICINE PLANTS ARE PULLING BACK AWAY FROM USx
7EAREDISRESPECTINGTHELANDANDTHEPLANTSTHATSWHYxv
PERSONALCOMMUNICATION2ICHARD'ALSON4RADITIONAL
!PACHESRECOGNIZETHATEVERYELEMENTOFTHENATURALWORLDHAS
POWERANDTHATMAINTAININGAGOODRELATIONSHIPWITHEACHOF
THESEELEMENTSISCRUCIALTOONESABILITYTOUSETHESEPOWERS
FORSUSTENANCEANDHEALTH(URTINGANYOFTHESERELATIONSHIPS
BY DISRESPECT OR IGNORANCE CAN HARM ONESELF ONES LOVED
ONES OR THE COMMUNITY 4O TRADITIONAL!PACHES THE HOME
CONSISTSOFALLTHOSEWITHWHOMONESTRIVESTOMAINTAINGOOD
86'$)RUHVW6HUYLFH3URFHHGLQJV50563
&IGUREˆ4HE7HEATlELDS2EGION
86'$)RUHVW6HUYLFH3URFHHGLQJV50563
RELATIONSHIPSˆTHERELATIVESFRIENDSPLACESSPECIESANDNATU
RALELEMENTSTHATONEDEPENDSONTOBEHEALTHYANDHAPPY
%LDERSCONSIDERACTIVITIESTHATHARMTHENATURALWORLDSUCH
ASLARGESCALEMININGANDIRRESPONSIBLERANCHINGINHERENTLY
DISRESPECTFUL AND DANGEROUS!PACHE ELDERS ACKNOWLEDGE
THENECESSITYOFEXPLOITINGNATURALRESOURCESTOSURVIVEBUT
ARE CRITICAL OF DESTRUCTIVE EXPLOITATION (ARMING THE NATURAL
WORLDNOTONLYDESTROYSHABITATSFORNATURALRESOURCESTHEREBY
REMOVINGACCESSTORESOURCESBUTITBREAKSTHEFOUNDATIONOF
ONESHOMEEXPOSINGPEOPLEANDCOMMUNITIESTOTHEHARMFUL
SIDEEFFECTSOFBROKENRELATIONSHIPS"ECAUSETRADITIONALPEOPLE
STILLHAVEANDMAINTAINTHESERELATIONSHIPSTHEDESTRUCTIONOF
HABITATSHURTSTHEMDEEPLYANDPROFOUNDLYASIFAFAMILYMEM
BERHASBEENHARMEDORKILLED4HEAUTHORSWEREPRESENTWHEN
AMEDICINEMANFROM#IBECUETEARFULLYTOLD&OREST3ERVICEAND
MININGREPRESENTATIVESTHATTHEIRPROPOSEDCOPPERMINEWOULD
hxTEAROPENTHEVEINSOF-OTHER%ARTHv%LDER94HIS
REmECTSACONSERVATIVEANDTRADITIONAL!PACHEVIEWOFCOPPER
ORE4HE AUTHORS HAVE OFTEN WITNESSED ELDERS IN TEARS WHEN
THEYHAVESEENADENIGRATEDPARTOFTHEIRHOME
!PACHE ELDERS BELIEVE THAT FORCED SEPARATION FROM TRADI
TIONAL PLACES THE DESTRUCTION OF TRADITIONAL PLACES AND THE
DESTRUCTIONOFNATURALRESOURCESPROFOUNDLYHARMSALLOFUS
ANDTHATTHISHARMMANIFESTSITSELFINAVARIETYOFINDIVIDUAL
ANDSOCIALILLSWHICHENCOURAGEDISRESPECTFULBEHAVIOR%LDERS
POINTOUTTHAT!GENCYANDPRIVATELANDMANAGEMENTPRACTICES
ANDTHEINDIVIDUALSRESPONSIBLEFORCARRYINGOUTTHESEACTIVITIES
HAVE DIRECTLY HARMED!PACHES AND THEIR RESOURCES!PACHE
ELDERSWANTLANDMANAGERSTOUNDERSTANDTHATWHATTHEYDOON
THELANDDIRECTLYAFFECTSTHEHEALTHANDWELLBEINGOFTHEENTIRE
!PACHECOMMUNITY!PACHEELDERSWANTALLOFUSTOMANAGE
THELANDTORESEMBLEASCLOSEASPOSSIBLEPRE)NAHSETTLEMENT
CONDITIONS
2EFERENCES
"AHRE#ONRAD*!LEGACYOFCHANGEHISTORICHUMANIMPACT
ONVEGETATIONINTHE!RIZONABORDERLANDS4UCSON5NIVERSITYOF
!RIZONA0RESSP
"AHRE#ONRAD*(UMANIMPACTSONTHEGRASSLANDSOFSOUTH
EASTERN!RIZONA #HAPTER )N -C#LAREN -6AN $AVENDER
42EDS4HEDESERTGRASSLAND4UCSON5NIVERSITYOF!RIZONA
0RESS
"USKIRK7INFRED4HE7ESTERN!PACHELIVINGWITHTHELAND
BEFORE.ORMAN5NIVERSITYOF/KLAHOMA0RESSP
$OBYNS(ENRY&&ROMlRETOmOODHISTORICHUMANDESTRUCTION
OF3ONORAN$ESERTRIVERINEOASES3OCORRO.-"ALLENA0RESS
P
'OODWIN'RENVILLE4HESOCIALORGANIZATIONOFTHE7ESTERN
!PACHE#HICAGO5NIVERSITYOF#HICAGO0RESSP
.EWTON6IRGINIA 4HE 3TATE 2OUTE ETHNOHISTORY PROJECT
7ESTERN!PACHE LAND USE IN CENTRAL!RIZONA 37#! #ULTURAL
2ESOURCE2EPORT.O3UBMITTEDTO!RIZONA$EPARTMENTOF
4RANSPORTATION AND4ONTO .ATIONAL &OREST 3ALT ,AKE #ITY 54
37#!)NCP
0YNE3TEPHEN*&IREIN!MERICAACULTURALHISTORYOFWILDLAND
ANDRURALlRE0RINCETON.*0RINCETON5NIVERSITY0RESSP
86'$)RUHVW6HUYLFH3URFHHGLQJV50563