Why Study Burdens?
Medical Expenditure Burdens: The Impact
of Tax Subsidies, WithinWithin-Year Expenditure
Concentration, and More
Thomas M. Selden
Division of Modeling & Simulation
Center for Financing, Access and Cost Trends
Most families healthy in given year
Illness, however, is a fact of life
Medical bills pour in just when families
must grapple with illness, seeking care,
carecare-giving, and possibility reduced
earnings
Accurate burden measurement a key
ingredient for sound public policy
Conventional 20% Burden Measures
(OOPCare + OOPPrem > .2*Y
.2*YDisp)
Data
Medical Expenditure Panel Survey (03&04)
25
20.9
% of Population
<65 population
– Medicare Part D
All
20
0-100
100-200
200-300
300-400
400-600
>600
15
10
7.3
5
0
Poverty Level
*Essentially same as Banthin&Bernard (JAMA 06)
“Bill Problem”
Problem” Responses Might
Reflect Lower Thresholds
Annual 20% Burdens vs. SelfSelf-Reported
“Bill Problems”
Problems”
% of Pop .
% of Population .
Adults Age 1919-64 in 2003
50
45
40
35
30
25
20
15
10
5
0
MEPS
>20% Burden
Commonwealth
Fund
"Bill Problems"
50
45
40
35
30
25
20
15
10
5
0
MEPS
>40%
>15%
>5/10%
>20%
>10%
>5%
"Bill Problem"
1
3 Refinements
Impact of tax subsidies
IntraIntra-year burdens
Impact of Tax Subsidy
Burden of uncompensated care
None previously studied
Summary
Tax subsidies modestly reduce burdens
– Especially subsidies for premiums
The Impact of WithinWithin-Year Expenditure
Concentration
Lowers burden prevalence (7.3% to 6.2%)
Little benefit for poor
Peak Month as Percentage of Annual
Total, by Poverty and Expenditure
% of Total
40
30
20
70
60
50
40
30
20
10
0
% of Total
50
3
4
5
6
7
8
9 10 11 12
Total
Out-of-Pocket
0K
>1
2
0K
-1
5K
1
K
-5
1K
Poverty Level
0
70
60
50
40
30
20
10
0
K
<1
10
00
>6
0
60
040
0
40
030
0
30
020
0
20
010
00
<1
% of Annual Total .
WithinWithin-Year Family Expenditure
Concentration
Total Expenditure
Total
Out-of-Pocket
Ranked Months
Total
Out-of-Pocket
Note: Families with zero expenditures excluded
2
Precautionary savings are low
– 24% of bottom quintile have no liquid
assets
– Median among those with assets=$600
Earnings down when expenditures spike
WithinWithin-Year Burdens (20%)
% of Population .
IntraIntra-year Burdens?
50
45
40
35
30
25
20
15
10
5
0
42.7
36.3
25.7
20.5
15.5
6.3
1.1
ll
00
>6
0
60
040 0
40
030 0
30
020
0
20
010
0
10
0-
A
– Expenditure spikes play larger role
Annual
Quarterly
Monthly
Uncompensated Care
CWF “bill problem”
problem” includes inability to pay
UC can indeed be burdensome
Burden of Uncompensated Care
Medical debt
Credit problems
Access problems
Stigma
– All ignored by conventional burden analyses
–
–
–
–
Not observed, but…
but…
– WTP(avoid
WTP(avoid UC burden) < UC
Monthly Burdens (20%)
30
60
25
50
20
Upper Bound
Lower Bound
15
10
5
0
% of Population
% of Population
Bounding 20% Annual Burdens
for Uncompensated Care
40
Upper Bound
Lower Bound
30
20
10
0
LL
00
>6 00
6
040 400
030 300
020 00
2
010
00
<1
A
LL
00
>6 00
6
040 400
030 300
020 00
2
010
00
<1
A
3
UC Conclusions
Modest increase in prevalence
– Families “pay until it hurts”
hurts”
Concentrated among poor
Importance of measuring medical debt
Monthly UCUC-adjusted burdens approach
“bill problem”
problem” frequency
– 29% versus 32% among adults in 2003
Conclusions
Tax subsidies modestly reduce burdens
– Mostly among middle income
Narrowing “budget window”
window” increases burden
prevalence, especially among poor
UC modestly increases burden prevalence,
again mostly among poor
Refinements greatly increase regressivity
Type of Service Distribution in
HighHigh-Burden Month
100%
80%
HOSP
ER
AMB&OTH
DENT
RX
PREMIUM
60%
40%
20%
0%
00
>6 00
6
040 00
4
030 00
3
020 00
2
010
00
<1
LL
A
*Conditional on having 20% burden
4