CMS Chronic Condition Data Warehouse June 4, 2007 Chronic Condition Data Warehouse Background • Medicare Modernization Act of 2003, Section 723, mandated a plan to “improve the quality of care and reduce the cost of care for chronically ill Medicare beneficiaries” • Essential component of plan was to establish a research database that contains fee-for-service Medicare claims data and assessments, linked by beneficiary, across the continuum of care • Claims and assessment data linked to Medicare eligibility/enrollment data 1 Chronic Condition Data Warehouse Population: 1999-2004 • Random 5% sample of Medicare beneficiaries (e.g., claims-based sampling methodology) • Eligible for and enrolled in Medicare on or after January 1, 1999 through the most current period • Health Insurance Claim (HIC) number where the eighth and ninth digits are in the set {05, 20, 45, 70, 95} • Qualified for 5% sample, therefore, remained part of the ongoing CCW sample (includes ever-qualifying beneficiaries from January 1, 1999 forward, i.e., an enhanced or person-based 5% sample) 2 Chronic Condition Data Warehouse Population: 2005 - Forward • 100% Medicare beneficiaries • Linked with historical data • Random 5% sample flags • Current data 3 Chronic Condition Data Warehouse Linkage Across the Continuum of Care • All CCW data files linked by assignment of a unique, unidentifiable beneficiary link key for ease of analysis across data files (unique link keys replace HIC numbers) • Allows for cross-sectional and longitudinal research from 1999 forward • Allows linkage across the continuum of care to construct patient-centric views of enrollment and service utilization • Link keys encrypted prior to delivery to the researcher, for privacy protection 4 Chronic Condition Data Warehouse Chronic Condition Categories Researchers may request data for 21 predefined chronic condition categories, allowing for timely data extraction: Acute Myocardial Infarction 5 Alzheimer's Disease, Related Disorders, or Senile Dementia Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease Congestive Heart Failure Diabetes Alzheimer's Disease only Glaucoma Atrial Fibrillation Hip/Pelvic Fracture Cancer, Breast Ischemic Heart Disease Cancer, Colorectal Major Depression Cancer, Prostate Osteoporosis Cancer, Lung Rheumatoid Arthritis/Osteoarthritis Cancer, Endometrial Cataract Stroke/Transient Ischemic Attack Chronic Kidney Disease Chronic Condition Data Warehouse Key Features • Patient-centric data files linked by unique beneficiary key, across the continuum of care (deidentified and encrypted prior to delivery to researcher) • Readily available chronic condition cohorts, customized cohorts (defined by researcher), and other categorization schemes • Beneficiary Summary File • Chronic Condition Summary File • Easy to use data files designed specifically for researchers (e.g., limited data set, SAS® input and label statements, frequency output, etc.) • Services from 1999 forward • Manageable 5% sample; 100% data for larger subsets or samples 6 Chronic Condition Data Warehouse www.ccwdata.org 7 Chronic Condition Data Warehouse Web Site – Statistical Summaries • Available to general public (pdf format) • Produced by IFMC staff • Resource for high level, summary statistics by segmentation variables (e.g., predefined CCW chronic conditions, utilization summary information, demographic, and/or enrollment factors) • Helpful for finding quick facts • Useful with exploring sample size options 8 Chronic Condition Data Warehouse Web Site – Statistical Summaries 9 Chronic Condition Data Warehouse Statistical Summaries – Beneficiary Demographics 10 Chronic Condition Data Warehouse Statistical Summaries – Population Statistics 11 Chronic Condition Data Warehouse Statistical Summaries – Assessment data 12 Chronic Condition Data Warehouse Data Files Available Upon Request from CMS • Enrollment/eligibility data • Administrative claims – Fee-for-service institutional claims for inpatient, outpatient, skilled nursing facility, hospice, and home health agency settings – Fee-for-service non-institutional claims for physician/supplier and durable medical equipment 13 Chronic Condition Data Warehouse Data Files Available Upon Request from CMS (cont.) • Assessment data – Minimum Data Set (MDS) - nursing facilities – Outcome and Assessment Information Set (OASIS) home health agencies – Inpatient Rehabilitation Facility Patient Assessment Instrument (IRF-PAI) – Swing bed data • • • • 14 CCW (CMS) Denominator (100% or 5% sample) Beneficiary Summary File Chronic Condition Summary File Medicare Current Beneficiary Survey (MCBS) Chronic Condition Data Warehouse Beneficiary Summary File • Annual beneficiary summary file containing demographic and enrollment data • Includes data for beneficiaries in the requested cohort or other specified population who were: – Ever part of the CCW 5% sample – Documented as being alive for some part of the reference year – Enrolled in Medicare Part A or B at some point during the reference year (may also have been enrolled in managed care) 15 Chronic Condition Data Warehouse Chronic Condition Summary File • Summary of a beneficiary’s chronic conditions (if any) by year • Flag indicator for presence of a CCW condition during that year • Includes beneficiaries in requested cohort (or other specified population) 16 Chronic Condition Data Warehouse Data Request Options • Standard (e.g., based on predefined chronic condition cohort criteria, entire 5% sample for a given year, etc.) • Custom (e.g., researcher-defined cohort based on demographic or clinical information such as diagnosis or procedure codes, etc.) • Finder file (e.g., based on known beneficiary identifiers, etc.) • Introductory pricing for 5% sample 17 Chronic Condition Data Warehouse Data Delivery Options • Data loaded to USB hard drive or DVD (no tapes!) • Flexible for use with different operating systems (e.g., Windows, Linux, etc.) • SAS read-in statements 18 Chronic Condition Data Warehouse Data Request Process 1. Researcher contacts Research Data Assistance Center (ResDAC) and/or IFMC for assistance with data request packet. 2. Researcher submits data request packet to CMS. 3. CMS approves data request, researcher submits payment to CMS, and and CMS forwards approval to IFMC as notification to fulfill request. 4. IFMC processes, encrypts, and delivers data package to researcher. 5. Copy of data package archived. 19 Chronic Condition Data Warehouse Considerations when Requesting CCW Data 1. Consider broad criteria for predefined chronic condition cohorts (indicating beneficiary probably has condition of interest); may require narrowing for analyses 2. Determine whether to restrict cohort based on Medicare coverage criteria 3. Decide whether to include a control or comparison group (chronic condition flags can make this simple) 4. Consider claims maturity 20 Chronic Condition Data Warehouse CCW Chronic Condition Flags For each chronic condition, an annual condition flag in the Chronic Condition Summary File includes the following values: 3 = Met full coverage criteria (Part A and B, no HMO) for entire look-back period (varies by condition) and claims diagnosis criteria 2 = Met full coverage criteria (Part A and B, no HMO) for entire look-back period (varies by condition) and did not meet claims diagnosis criteria 1 = Had intermittent coverage (any partial coverage combination of Part A or B, or HMO) for the look-back period and met claims diagnosis criteria 0 = Had intermittent coverage (any partial coverage combination of Part A or B, or HMO) for the look-back period and did not meet claims diagnosis criteria 21 Note: Coverage required only up to month of death. Chronic Condition Data Warehouse Defining CCW Cohorts: • Use CC Summary File flags Example: Study diabetes health services in 2005 with control group of non-diabetes health services - Cohort of CC diabetes flag = 3 - Control of CC diabetes flag = 2 • Use Beneficiary Summary File variables to further define (or supplement) cohorts using additional demographics, partial coverage options, HMO coverage, etc. Note: CCW does not contain managed care claims. 22 Number of Medicare Beneficiaries in 5% Sample for 2005 by Chronic Condition1 Number of Reference Period Chronic Condition Acute Myocardial Infarction Alzheimer's Disease Alzheimer's Disease and Related Disorders or Senile Dementia Atrial Fibrillation Cancer, Colorectal Cancer, Endometrial Cancer, Female Breast Cancer, Lung Cancer, Prostate Cataract Chronic Kidney Disease Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease Congestive Heart Failure Diabetes Glaucoma Hip/Pelvic Fracture Ischemic Heart Disease Major Depression Osteoporosis Rheumatoid Arthritis/Osteoarthritis Stroke/Transient Ischemic Attack None of the conditions 1Twenty-one 194,726 153,939 15,931 2,329 27,250 15,868 39,687 550,325 172,604 239,467 349,256 461,861 208,139 22,075 628,481 261,438 278,546 415,404 113,281 759,108 (in years)3 1 3 3 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 2 1 2 2 1 1 2 1 1 2 1 chronic conditions have been predefined by CMS for timely, efficient extraction of CCW data files. based on beneficiaries who were alive on January 1, 2005 and enrolled in Part A or Part B for at least one month during the reference year. 3Reference period represents the look-back time period during which a beneficiary qualified for a condition. 2Counts 23 Beneficiaries2 27,209 91,626 Chronic Condition Data Warehouse Types of coverage used for these analyses: • Full 1YR (no break in coverage) Months PtA + Months PtB – Months HMO = 24 • Partial 1YR (minimal break in coverage) Months PtA + Months PtB – Months HMO 22 • January PtA & PtB & no HMO in January of reference year • July PtA & PtB & no HMO in July of reference year • Any At least one month PtA or PtB 24 Chronic Condition Data Warehouse Beneficiary Demographics by Type of Coverage in 2005* Age < 65 Full January July Any 249,063 254,887 261,077 270,580 349,167 16,048 21,328 17,220 48,265 107,316 66-75 675,756 684,816 700,203 692,055 911,322 76-85 498,175 503,731 512,023 494,859 634,288 > 85 183,263 185,461 187,348 172,573 230,435 July Any 65 Race Full Partial January White 1,386,624 1,408,142 1,427,028 1,425,827 1,870,224 Black 154,508 158,329 163,980 164,216 220,950 Asian 21,192 21,715 22,198 22,779 37,313 Hispanic 31,849 33,200 35,166 35,132 53,325 6,907 7,023 7,143 7,300 9,209 18,837 19,387 19,893 20,696 37,171 2,388 2,427 2,463 2,382 4,336 N Am Native Other Unknow n *Based on 5% Medicare sample. 25 Partial Chronic Condition Data Warehouse Number of Beneficiaries with Chronic Condition(s) in 2005* by Type of Coverage Number of Beneficiaries 800,000 600,000 400,000 200,000 0 0** 1 2-3 4+ Number of Chronic Conditions Full 1YR * Based July Any on 5% Medicare sample. coverage includes beneficiaries who may not have sufficient coverage to meet the chronic condition diagnosis criteria. **Any 26 Partial 1YR Chronic Condition Data Warehouse Number of Beneficiaries Number of Beneficiaries with Acute Myocardial Infarction in 2005* by Age and Type of Coverage 12,000 10,000 8,000 6,000 4,000 2,000 0 < 65 65 66-75 Age (in years) Full 1YR Partial 1YR *Based on 5% Medicare sample. 27 July Any 76-85 > 85 Chronic Condition Data Warehouse Number of Beneficiaries Number of Beneficiaries with Colorectal Cancer in 2005* by Age and Type of Coverage 7,000 6,000 5,000 4,000 3,000 2,000 1,000 0 < 65 65 66-75 Age (in years) Full 1YR Partial 1YR July *Based on 5% Medicare sample. 28 Any 76-85 > 85 Chronic Condition Data Warehouse Number of Beneficiaries Number of Beneficiaries with Diabetes in 2005* by Age and Type of Coverage 200,000 150,000 100,000 50,000 0 < 65 65 66-75 Age (in years) Full 2YR Partial 2YR Full 1YR *Based on 5% Medicare sample. 29 July Any 76-85 > 85 Chronic Condition Data Warehouse CCW Cohort Considerations: • Effect of coverage selections varies by: 1. Demographics (e.g., age) 2. Condition 3. Look-back period 30 • Equal opportunity for observing diagnosis of interest in control group as in cohort • ResDAC/IFMC Review Board can assist with refining selection criteria Chronic Condition Data Warehouse Total Medicare Payment ($ Billions) Total Medicare Payments ($275 Billion) in 2005 by Claim Type and Number of Chronic Conditions 180 160 140 120 100 80 60 40 20 0 0 1 2-3 4+ Number of Chronic Condition(s) DMERC Carrier Hospice Outpatient HHA SNF Inpatient *Includes total Medicare fee-for-service payments; extrapolated from 5% Medicare sample. 31 Chronic Condition Data Warehouse Percent of Medicare Payments* for Beneficiaries with Diabetes in 2005 by Claim Type Carrier 24% Percent of Claims* for Beneficiaries with Diabetes in 2005 by Claim Type Inpatient DMERC 1% SNF 1% 9% DMERC 4% Inpatient 46% HHA 1% Outpatient 13% Hospice <1% Hospice 2% Outpatient 12% HHA 5% SNF 7% Carrier 75% *Includes total Medicare fee-for-service payments/claims for beneficiaries identified as having diabetes; based on 5% Medicare sample. 32 Chronic Condition Data Warehouse Number of Medicare Beneficiaries* with Diabetes and Total Medicare Payment Amounts by Year $90.3 $102.2 $113.5 $120 $100 8 $80 6 $60 4 $40 2 $20 0 Total Payment Amount ($ Billions) Number of Beneficiaries (in Millions) 10 $0 2003 Number of Beneficiaries 2004 2005 Payment Amount *Includes total Medicare fee-for-service payments/claims for beneficiaries identified as having diabetes; based on extrapolation from 5% Medicare sample. 33 Chronic Condition Data Warehouse Research Potential Using CCW Data 34 • Supports increased need for chronic disease research as aging population increases • Allows longitudinal analyses of Medicare utilization, expenditures, quality of care, and health outcomes across continuum of care • Provides researchers with low cost, easy-to-use data files • Flexible data extract system allows researchers to request only minimum data needed for studies Chronic Condition Data Warehouse Potential Enhancements for CCW • Part D enrollment and drug event data (pending federal regulation) • Enhanced Summary Files: • 35 – Beneficiary Summary File – Chronic Condition Summary File – Condition-specific statistics in form of beneficiarylevel (deidentified) analytical file – Care setting/timeline summary file SAS code for deriving denominators Chronic Condition Data Warehouse Questions? Visit these web sites for additional information! Research Data Assistance Center www.resdac.umn.edu E-Mail: resdac@umn.edu Phone: 1-888-9-ResDAC or 1-888-973-7322 Iowa Foundation for Medical Care www.ccwdata.org E-Mail: ccwdata@ifmc.org Phone: 1-800-383-2856, ext. 8357 36 Visit us at AcademyHealth booth #305!