ENGINEER-ING TECHNICAL INFORMATION SYSTEM FIELD NOTESTECHNICAL REPORTS DATA RETRIEVALMANAGEMENT PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT NUMBER2 Notes Field Unified Rock Classification Clarification System and Amendments Forest Transportation Analysts Job Performance and Training Requirements The Use of Corrugated to Metal Culvert Liners Minimize Stream Bedload Effects Washington Office FOREST SERVICE News FEBRUARY U S U.S. DEPARTMENT OF AGRICULTURE 1979 US ENGINEERING FIELD NOTES 11 Number 2 Volume has been developed for of employees respon-sibility contained Information of United the for the The product of others that text in must not or service may be use the by as FSM except engineers and engineering intended The contractors its Department of Agriculture of this information by other than names use does not by the United in this publication an constitute is official States Department exclusively the represents publication be construed Service Agriculture-Forest guidance and its assumes no its own employees. for the information and endorsement or approval of Agriculture to the exclusion suitable. or policy not of and State agencies. interpretation or of the reader. Such convenience The publication of trade firm or corporation use of any this Department States Federal cooperating in recommended references. Because. technicians opinions personal or approved should of the read of the respective procedures of material type each issue FOREST SERVICE DEPARTMENT OF AGRICULTURE Washington D.C. 20013 in however for engineers. U.S. mandatory author and instructions the publication this publication all is Unified Rock article issue to Classification System--Clarification and listed on the cover as the first is printed last pages of this as the facilitate removal. fl Amendments ANALYSTS--JOB FOREST TRANSPORTATION PERFORMANCE AND TRAINING Victor REQUIREMENTS DeKaZb Engineer Chief Transportation Standards Consultation Trans-portation Transpor-tation WO Committee for Training Forest the Steering It included Analysts submitted its report to the Chief. for a and suggestions a listing of Job Performance Requirements Forest Forest Service-wide effort for training Analysts. Analysts are involved in long-range wide-area planning as The Job well as short-range specific project planning. reflect both must Requirements and the new training program these activities. Last September Perform-ance JOB PERFORMANCE REQUIREMENTS A draft of the Job Performance Requirements is being reviewed. They will be carried in a later issue of the Field Notes to permit from the field before they are put in the broadest possible comment Handbook. the FS Directive Ana-lysts co-operative TRAINING The PROGRAM current training program for Forest-level Transportation conducted at Richmond California through a is being with the University of California. agreement organiza-tion. a Service-wide training package and material Region 1 is preparing basis by means of to conduct the Richmond program on a continuing institution or other training with an academic a contract work to do in evaluating needs There is still considerable costs and opportunities before a final selection is made of the for the new courses. training institution and schedule developed A training modules. course consists of eight independent Analysis Course is provided here table Modules in Transportation can be included in a for your review. Any or all of the modules persons schedule as appropriate to meet the minimum requirements Analyst. for qualification as a Forest Transportation The 1 MODULES Number 1 2 3 Length days 22 22 22 IN TRANSPORTATION Prere- Description quisites - - - ANALYSIS COURSE Trainingq Traffic performance characteristics on Forest roads Itemize concepts and ground rules of which Transporations Analyst must be aware to feasible and desirable alternatives. Introduction to roading yarding standards logging systems Identify feasible and desirable logging system alternatives at level of detail a appropriate for forest planning. Traffic Compile necessary data for lyzing existing transportation conditions through inventory spec-ify and and ana-methods surveillance surveillance validation. 22 - and Planning process analysis for 5 4 and Become conversant with straints and powers concerning con-portatioh direc-tive re-organizing issues associated with transanalysis The 5 estimation con-organization Laws policies 4 J selecting planning and alternatives criteria that are transportation tained in Forest Service system. Develop technical skills quired to organize and design a transportation analysis effort properly including overall relations to forest planning process. alterna-and indi-7 ob-8 pre-test 6 45 10 network Transportation link analysis techniques Analyze transportation tives selected for study vehicle 456 analytical Funding 457 5 link alter-alternatives Techniques 5 using coding indices restrictions etc. such techniques as travel times cost of for evaluating and displaying results transportation introduction investments Evaluate transportation natives and documentation of study includes economic cators i.e. present worth effects and nonmonetary techniques. dis-play and Understand need format final study as process for taining funding for of implementa-budgeting un-derstand to programming and tion of study as wel. as other inventories and documents affected by study. The must pass pretests for the prerequisite modules before being considered or Forests also might want to administer the in any module. Regions modules planned for the employee to determine if the need for training is individual for training for any indicated. Analy-sis for 1980 and thereafter will course material being developed qualify specialists in the various phases of Transportation The course is performed at project area or Forest levels. designed for specialists who are at the GS-7 level and above have a background in Transportation Engineering and are or will be in Transportation Analysis and related planning working primarily and functions. Other specialists who have analytical experience for the course. will be considered as candidates training The January through May is the tentative. training schedule for 1980 Firm schedules and with the Western States as the chosen location. selection of the site will be announced by October. u C 4 THE USE TO OF CORRUGATED MINIMIZE STREAM CULVERT BEDLOAD THE LINERS EFFECTS HuZgc Engineer National Baker-Snoqualmie Robert Civil Mt. METAL D. Forest PROBLEM Baker-Snoqualmie in-stalled seasonal heavy rains and resulting high runoff conditions During mass bedload movements occur on numerous streams on the Mt. National Forest. In many instances the gravel bedload metal passing through the pipe drainage structures that are to transport streams under Forest Service roads causes As the material is rapid deterioration of the corrugated pipe. carried through the pipe it contacts the corrugations which are to the streamflow at relatively high velocities. perpendicular the Eventually are worn through and a venetian peak corrugations blind condition develops at the outlet extending back toward the inlet of the structure. If not detected at an early stage in road fills constructed of fine-grained materials this condition results in varying failure. degrees of road structure re-duce A SOLUTION liners were installed to Replaceable corrugated metal culvert the effect of deterioration and pipe wear on the segment of road involved. two such installations are functioning Presently National Forest. successfully on the Mt. struc-ture Baker-Soqu\lmie 1 a 58-inch typical installation figure by 36-inch arch is used 147.3 cm by 91.4 cm pip as a cross drain 48 inches wide and etal sections 12-gauge corrugated 117 inches long 121.9 cm b -95.2 and bolted overlapped line invert of the The inlet end of the together pipe arches. this liner assembly protrudes the pipe arch and is past the end of bolted to a prefabricated concrete slab the concrete acts as an When the bedload anchor holding the entire liner in place. causes the liner to wear out the bolts in the concrete can be removed the original liner assembly pulled out by a cable and a new liner installed. In a move-ment an-chor us-ing cm Even if wear the the concrete anchor slab is damaged as the liner sections both is far simpler and less costly than restoring fill material and replacing a conventional replacing eroded road drain-5 Field observation shows that the liners do not wear age structure. out as rapidly as conventional culverts because the corrugations are parallel to the stream flow. BENEFITS Three of the major benefits that result from use of the liners 1. Direct material and installation costs for the replacement wornout liner sections are only approximately 25% of the total cost of replacing an entire conventional culvert and the eroded road material. This cost difference probably will become much greater as labor and equipment rates continue to increase. of dis-ruption struc-ture fac-tor 2. of the corrugated metal culvert Replacement liners is a task that can be performed by relatively simple and straightforward Forest Service maintenance crews without specialized equipment. of only the liner assembly eliminates Replacement the traffic flow that occurs when the entire drainage is replaced and the roadbed must be reconstructed. This is more significant where the reconstruction must be made on the more permanent types of road surface such as asphalt concrete. 3. of in-corporated A Some concepts in RELATED DEVELOPMENT for the replaceable culvert developed liner were the modification of a downdrain accessory. an open rectangular downflume 24 inches 61.0 cm and 58 inches high 147.3 cm wide was lined with replaceable steel 12-gauge panels that were similar to the replaceable culvert The stream bedload moved in a high velocity streamflow liners. down a 67% slope causing rapid deterioration of the corrugated steel liners. The most severe deterioration of the downflume liners was observed at a particular section that measured 24 inches 61.0 cm wide by 120 inches 304.8 cm long. Previously struc-ture Lining the inside of the downflume with 10-foot 3.0 m sections of treated timber planking rather than the steel figure liners reduces replacement costs. Each 4-inch 10.2 cm by 12-inch 30.5 cm plank individually secured to the steel by bolts can be easily replaced as it wears out. 2 De-sign The replaceable liner described in this article was designed by Robert D. HuZet Civil Engineer and Robert G. Barnard C M National Superintendent Mt. Baker-Snoqualmie Forest and Earl Hanson District Engineer San Juan National Forest formerly National Engineer on Mt. Baker-Snoqualmie Forest. 6 View showing the inlet of the pipe arch concrete anchor stab and replaceable corrugated metal liner connection. View showing the position of the replaceable corrugated metal liner at the outlet end of the pipe arch. Figure 7 1 view o -F treated down flume with timber liner iris LaZ L-ation of fill slope Close up view of downflume showing in greater detail the treated timber planking Figure 8 2 from top WASHINGTON CONSULTATION Walter Assistant OFFICE AND NEWS STANDARDS Furen Director E. sched-ule AND STANDARD FS GENERAL PROVISIONS SPECIFICATIONS FOR CONSTRUCTION OF ROADS AND BRIDGES REPORT 1977 REVISION--STATUS The May 1978 issue of Field Notes explained the process and for planning the revision of the 1977 edition of the FS General Provisions and Standard Specifications for Construction of Roads and Bridges. The committee members working on the project were listed and suggestions from the field were solicited. Two questions were raised by the committee Re-gions 1. Have we 2. Is 1979 a had enough revision with experience the 1977 edition premature These to the questions were considered carefully in relation 1 and the received of about suggestions experiences year from all sources. It was soon determined that the following items should be accomplished errors 1. Correct 2. Standardize 3. Update 4. Eliminate 5. Simplify procedures 6. Reduce wording technical materials duplication problems in and ambiguities contract administration need and references for Regional preparation Specifications and 7. Reduce 8. Standardize and include Engineering Specifications for items such as Construction Staking. 9 and origi-na There would be some advantage in waiting to gain more experience construction 1977 edition however it is believed the by using that the benefits derived by earlier improvements will outweigh other--and undetermined--possible advantages. Therefore it has been decided to proceed with the revision as outlined in our in com-pleted plan. The project is on schedule draft will be sent to a final review the Regions approximately May 1 1979 and the printing will be The package containing instructions by August 31 1979. and for of the 1979 edition of directions policy implementation the Specifications will be forwarded to all Regions by October 1 1979. CADASTRAL TRAINING Two new cadastral training programs in support of the expanding this winter. In January boundary survey program were developed about 25 Cadastral Surveyors from all Regions attended a 3-week course in Denver college quick covering boundary survey and the survey system in the United States. require-ments Boundary Survey Law course will be held at both Florida March 11-24 and Fresno State University April 2-13 University Both of these courses are for college for other Forest Surveyors. credit if all goes well they will be offered again next year. A 2-week FIELD TABLES The Engineering Field Tables EM 7100-10 book is being for reprinting we solicit any additions or corrections have. Please reply to WO Engineering no later than May 10 prepared you may 15 1979. Uni-fied Novem-ber UNIFIED ROCK CLASSIFICATION CLARIFICATION The AND SYSTEM AMENDMENTS changes listed below are intended to clarify the article Rock Classification System which was published in the 1978 FieZd Notes and the changes should be incorporated text as directed. re-printed the into 8 10 and 12. Each of these pages has been revised and Each revised page for direct insertion into the text. should be trimmed to size and stapled securely to its corresponding page completely covering the old page. Pages The of following changes should the original article. be made in ink directly on the pages In the first sentence of the paragraph the Page 11 paragraph B. words is present should be revised to read occurs. In the last sentence of paragraph the phrase maximum unit of weight should be revised to read maximum unit weight. B The following sentence should be inserted Page 13 paragraph C. between the last sentence of the paragraph and the one immediately it Dent Quality material produces fill that is not preceding free draining impervious and is not suitable for road aggregate material. pro-vided on-the-spot Page 16 last paragraph. In the next-to-last the words sentence a 150 pcf should be revised to read Rock less than Rock with 150 pcf. A reduced version of the table and text on pages and may be cut out and put into your Pocket reference. 11 8 and 9 are Handbook for ýrýf r.rr. CUT CUT SYSTEM URCS ROCK CLASSIFICATION ELEMENTS BASIC STRENGTH ESTIMATE UNIFIED ROCK MASS OF WEATHERING EFFECT WEATHERED SAND 1 SIZE SIZE STATE DECOMPOSED STATE PDS NON NON PLASTIC MINERAL C B A FRIABLE CRATERS SHEARS GRAIN E D 1000 7 3000 21 PSI 21 PLANAR IMPACT DO PITS TENSIONAL PQ. C B 8000 PSI 55 MPa to to AND ABSORPTION LINEAR 8000 55 REBOUNDS ELASTIC RO A 15000 PSI 103 MPa to to PSI 1500D 103 MPa ELEMENTS SOLID-PLANES TRANSMITS WATER NO YES DIMENSIONAL 2 OF SEPARATION NO DIMENSIONAL PLANES OF SEPARATION 3-D 2-D E D. LATENT PLANES OF SOLIDPREFERRED SEPARATION BREAKAGE SPB SRB C B A UNIT LESS 130 THAN 130 140 140 to lbs/ft3 lbs/ft3 2.10 2.10 Mg/m3 130 2.25J 2.25 D E K. VALUES and Peck R. 150 to 150 to 160 GREATER lbs/ft3 2.55 B. 2.55 /2.40Mto Mg/m3.40\ THAN 160 lbs/ft3 to M CONSISTENCY WEIGHT lbs/ft3 130 Terzaghi RANDOM BREAKAGE LPS ATTITUDE INTERLOCK 1 TO DENTS 3000 MPa to to WEIGHT BONDING COMPRESSIVE CQ MBL 1000 PSI 7 MPa UNIT RELATIVE REACTION MOLDABLE 3 MFS 1 REMOLDING YES VF S COMPARE To FRESH STATE PLASTIC FRESH STATE HAND LENS STATE STS D PLASTIC MICRO VISUALLY FRESH STAINED PARTLY E PLASTIC REPRESENTATIVE ALTERED GRAVEL COMPLETELY DECOMPOSED STATE COS rrrxr Mg/m3 //Ii r soil mechanics in 140 150 160 C B A Engineering Practice John Wiley and Sons Inc. 1948. 8 Revision CUT to November Field Notes 1978 CUT rrr.r ras a.r. CUT CUT I s ._ýr r Under URCS degree of weathering is restricted to The effect of weathering can be weathering. practically by determining the relative loss of the chemical defined the cohesion and the reduction of unit Five categories weight. are defined E--Completely Decomposed D--Partly State C--Stained State B--Visually Fresh State Decomposed State and A--Micro Fresh State. EFFECT 1 WEATHERED SAND 1 SIZE ALTERED GRAVEL COMPLETELY CONSISTENCY Terzaghi K. E--Completely pLASTIC STS NON VALUES and Peck R. B. FRESH Sgil mechanics Decomposed VFS MFS A TO WEIGHT UNIT STATE in Engineering State FRESH STATE HAND LENS B COMPARE PLASTIC MICRO FRESH STATE C NON PLASTIC I VISUALLY STATE D PLASTIC REPRESENTATIVE STAINED DECOMPOSED STATE PDS E 1 SIZE PARTLY DECOMPOSED STATE CGS WEATHERING OF RELATIVE Practice John Wiley and ABSORPTION Sons Inc. 1948. CDS. State is when the rock material Completely Decomposed all remoldable to sand silt or clay or mixtures of two The resulting remolded material is determined or more sizes. and Dry Strength Dilatency and to be plastic or nonplastic The in-place strength is tests are performed. Toughness estimated by consistency values The is 1. D--Partly Decomposed State PDS. deter-mined 1 State is when the rock material is Partly Decomposed and larger rock fragments with or remoldable to gravel-size without The relative percentage sand silt or clay mixtures. of rock fragments are estimated and the material is to be plastic The in-place strength is or nonplastic. estimated by consistency values or by size shape and graduation of remolded aggregate. The C--Stained State STS. The Stained State describes a condition when the rock material discoloration due to oxidation but shows partial or complete cannot be remolded. The rock material is usually shades of yellow or brown has a reduced unit weight and a higher 10 Revision LCUT to November Field Notes 1978 CUT ......CU CUT ul r r r Mineral Grain -Bonding or Specimen Strength -is defined as the cementation degree or adhesion between mineral grains that defines the fundamental strength of the rock mass independent of the and linear elements. For purposes of planar the limit of moldability is estimated at 1000 psi 7 MPa. There are four distinct reactions to impact loading by means of a 1-lb 450-g The reaction is ball-peen hammer. of the independent intensity of blow within limitations of the tool used and the investigators strength. The reactions are defined as Craters Dents and Rebounds. Based on these reactions plus the factor five moldability of categories specimen strength are denoted E--Moldable and A--Rebounds. D--Craters C--Dents B--Pits of classifi-cation Pits MINERAL 1 REMOLDING FRIABLE E D 1000 CONSISTENCY Terzaghi E--Moldable K. VALUES and Peck to 7 to R. B. Quality TO IMPACT DENTS PITS TENSIONAL COMPRESSIVE CQ MBL 1000 PSI 7 MPa BONDING REACTION CRATERS SHEARS MOLDABLE 1 GRAIN DQ PQ C 3000 MPa 3000 21 PSI 21 soil Mechanics-in to to RO A B 8000 PSI 55 MPa Engineering REBOUNDS ELASTIC 8000 55 Practice Co to John 15000 PSI 103 MPa Wiley and PSI 15000 103 MPa Sons Inc. 1948. MBL. Moldable Quality is present when the otherwise continuous and similar rock visually material can be remolded with finger indicates an estimated unconfined pressure. This compressive strength less than 1000 psi 7 MPa. Strength estimates are made by determining consistency values In all cases the material is examined and tested as a and a dual classification is given. the material Usually cannot be recovered core by diamond drilling and can be excavated by machinery. 1. soil D--Crater Quality Crater Quality reaction under CQ. rock material is as the term implies a point of impact producing a shearing and of mineral grains. upthrusting This has adjacent category an estimated unconfined from compressive strength range 1000 to 3000 psi 7 to 21 MPa. Usually The rock material can be recovered rock core during drilling operations has 12 Revision CUT to November Field Notes 1978 CUT UNIFIED ROCK MASS ROCK CLASSIFICATION STRENGTH ESTIMATE OF I SAND SIZE WEATHERING ALTERED GRAVEL SIZE STAINED VISUALLY E NON PLAST IL STS PDS D STATE iC MINERAL CRATERS SHEARS MBL 1000 PSI T MPa PSI 3000 to Dl to 21 PITS AND FIELD NOTATION In 6000 55 to 1A000 103 103 both under the letter symbol the letter. For BCAD A SRB C B D3 D 130 B--Visual fresh state C--Dents with hammer blow A--Solid with random breakage and D--unit weight 130 to 140 pcf 2.10 to Explanation PSI MPa ELEMENTS LINEAR includes written VFS Mg/m3 2.25 SOLID-PLANES TRANSMITS notebook A 1SOOT PSI MPa to classification Field RE B 8000 PSI MPa The ELASTIC PQ I ý\J/ REBOUNDS TENSIONAL 55 e IMPACT C 3000 MPa to to A E 0 the field the notation and the abbreviated basis example ABSORPTION O TO PREDQ PLANAR WATER break-LESS No YES 2 DIMENSIONAL PLANES LATENT PLANES OF 2-D E D UNIT THAN 130 to UN /f t3 IAN for RANDOM BREAKAGE BREAKAGE LPS SPB SRN C B A then design values can the intended purpose. Notes 1. AAAA ATTITUDE INTERLOCK Mg/m 2.10 SOLID- PREFERRED OF SEPARATION SEPARATION 3-D 130 The No DIMENSIONAL OF SEPARATION 140 TeZaEh and K. Peck R. to 50 150 to /2.25 J to ED GREATER 1bs/ft3 2.40 M9/m3 I 2 .4 160 140 150 0160 C B A B. NOnhnnln to EoAUn000E q John Wiley and Sons Inc. EEEE LAAA. 0 O 2. of the four major elements are not Design values even though the same letter notation equivalent might apply. 1948. 8 ALONG 9 THIS LINE material requires the most design evaluation. 00 CUT this P9/m3 2.55 / D sov. requires the least design evaluation. for MPa bs/ft3 2.55 to M9/m3 established be Some combinations do not occur for example Decomposed State and Greater than completely Solid with random 15000 psi 103 age and Greater than 160 pcf 2.55 Mg/M3 THAN 130 E VALUES O WEIGHT 1bN/ft3 2.05 M9/m3 CONSISTENCY 140 /f t3 to /2.10 0130 1 AND NOTATIONS WEIGHT BONDING GRAIN D E 3 RELATIVE DENTS LOM SS IVE N FRIABLE YES UNIT STATE REACTION MOLDABLE I 000 SYMBOLS letter design symbols of the four major element classes are grouped in a four-letter notation that can together be read at when a glance placed on maps sections or on The four letters are in caps and drilling logs. are The letter denotes that the least design while tion is required denotes the most design evaluation is required. in sequence means no determination made. A lower-case after a letter indicates estimated value. The A TO FRESH LENS MFS B COMPARE PLASTIC 1 REMOLDING Z VFS C NON ptpST PLASTIC FRESH STATE HAND STATE DECOMPOSED COS MICRO FRESH PARTLY OE COMPOSED Q REFRESENTATIVE STATE COMPLETELY STATE O O under-lined. evalua-WEATHERED EFFECT - SYSTEM URCS BASIC ELEMENTS - CUT ALONG THIS LINE INVITATION TO READERS OF FIELD NOTES Every reader a potential is you would of an article for Field Notes. author If we you have a news item or ac-curate short article Material to share with Service engineers you invite Field Notes. in publication like submitted to the Washington Office for should publication send to be reviewed it for by the Washing-ton Regional respective Office to that see the information is current timely technically to Forest Service Engineers FSM 7113. The length of from several short sentences to several may vary typewritten pages however short articles or news items are preferred. All material submitted to the Office should be typed double-spaced and ideally all illustrations should be informative material and of interest submitted original drawings Field Notes is or negatives. prints glossy distributed from the Washington Area Headquarters mailing list ask your Office Coordinator to increase the also to their should retirees. Manager or the Regional number of copies sent to available from the Washington Field personnel Office directly and Forest Service Forests submit If to you all your not Station currently Technical Engineering office. Regional are Data Systems Copies of back issues are Office. material for publication or questions concerning Field Notes Coordinators Regional R-1 Melvin Dittmer R-4 Ted Wood Royal M. Ryser R-9 Fred Hintsala R-2 R-5 Walt Weaver R-10 F. R-3 Juan R-6 Kjell Bakke Gomez should direct questions concerning problems to Forest Service Engineering - USDA RP-E Bldg Rome L. P.O. Box 2417 Telephone format editing Staff Attn Gordon Washington WO Bob Bowers R-8 Coordinators and on the D.C. Editor 20013 Area Code 703 235-8198 W. Baxandall Al Colley publishing dates and other