C/61 - 23 A SELECT BIBLIOGRAPHI ON CO*UNICATIONS AND POLITICAL DEVOPMENT Prepared by Jean Grossholts and ichard Hendrickson for the Social Science Research Council, Commttee on Comparative Politics Center for International Studies Massachusetts Institute of Technology Canbridge, Massachusette July, 1961 A SEIECTED BIBLIOGRAPH on COUNICATIONS AND POLITICAL DEVEIOPENT tele of the Mass Media in Political Develonent Ashford, Douglas E* "Patterns of Consensus in Developing Countries." 1, IV (April 1961), pp 7-10. Anlurian Bhairal S1is The major problem of coimensus formation in developing countries is to expend the world view of participant individuals to include the national scene. Creation of a "nationalistic fervor" by reference to an outside threat leads to instability and my hinder developmento Bruner, Jerome S. and Jeanette Sayre. "Short-wave Listening in an Italian Community." bp1g MinionQuarerly, V (Winter 1941), pp 640-56. A poll of a group of marginal Americans in Bostongs Italian north end furnishes a clue to the motivation and behavior of the recent iumigraot short wave listener. Eldersveld, Samel J. "Experimental Propaganda Techniques and Voting Behavior." American Political Scegge Review, 50 (March 1956), pp 154-65. Also in Eulau, .q. .1., Politica j3jgor eseargh, Glencoe, Ill., The Free Press, .a R .aggj4 1 , pp210-217. The effectiveness of techniques for getting out the vote varies with other considerations such as the type of campaign, personalities involved, etc. Personal contact seems the most effective technique for getting out the vote. Eulau, Heins and Peter Schneider. "Dimensions of Political Involvement." 02jg QuarerL, XI (Spring 1956), pp 128-42. Political involvement depends on relatedness to the political process. Sensitivity to politics is related to individual's perception of the role of citisen and his perception of the efficacy of political action. Hadsel, Fred L. *Propaganda in the Funnies." (December 1941), pp 365-68. Cgrret Bg2 I More people are reached by the comics than by any other part of the newspaper. Comics analysed as to content and function. 2 14 Role of the Mass Media ;n Plitical evelopmen, continued, Kirchheimer, Otto. "German Democracy in the 1950's" World Politics, 1III (January 1961), pp 254-66. External and internal problems of post war German devel opment. Good documentation of German political development and role of the mas media in this process. Klappar, Joseph T e "What we know about the Effects of Uass Communication: II (Winter 1957-8), The Brink of Hope,," _ubq Opinion Quarter1, pp 453-740 Summary of findings of mass media and mass communications research and disacusion of some generalizations about effects. Noelle-Neumann, Elisabeth. "Mass Communication Media and Public Opinion," 36 (Fall 1959), p 401 rery, J nl m Question of real function of the mass media in Western society People seek in the media confirmation for their analyzed. already existing opinions and philosophies. "The Lynakey Tribunal: The British Method of Robinton, Madeline B. Pealing with Political Corruption." Political Science uarterly, LXVIII (March 1953), pp 109-24. The Britiah method of holding open hearings with thorough press coverage, although destructive to some individuals without cause, did tend to rally public support for proceedings and led to a return of public confidence in the public administration. The mss media served as a means of insuring maintenance of the society9 s values. Simon, Herbert A. and Frederick Stern. "The Effects of Television upon Voting Behavior in Iowa in the 1952 Presidential election." American Politia1 Science Review, 49 (June 1955), pp 4.70-77. Also in _ cal Behavior: A Reader in The_ and eseareh,. pp 205-10, Television had no discernable effect on total participation or party division of the vote. Mass media had reachid a saturation point so that the addition of television makes no substantial difference In terms of evoking high inte:rest In a political campaign, Rot of the Mea MediainEoliticalLeve~lomeqi Stewart, Ponald H, ontinued "The Press and Political Corruption During The o1tIca1 Science QarL , IXVII pp 426-47 Federalist Administrotion." (September 1952), The newspapers pioneered in directing popular attention to gra~ft and corruption, pointing out land speculation deals, ote. Faults tended to be associated with Individuals rather than with abstract principles or inatitutions, Emphasis on the corruapton of the "ins" die, much to foster the growth of an opposition party, Wright, Charles P,,, "Functional Analysis and Mass Communication," b:;UC QpAnop Quartly, XXV (Winter 1960), pp 605-200 Kinda of factors involved in functional analysis of the role of the media end the formulation of hypotheses are discussed in terwm of the probleme involved in developing theory. 4 II. Communication Patterns Alisky, Marvin. "Growth of Newspapers in Mexico's Provinces." Jguurngles Quarterly, 37 (Winter 1960) pp 75-82. Discusses effect of the amazing growth of readership and influence of newspapers outside the national capital on local and provincial politics. They bring their readers into participation in local events and carry comment and criticism of national officials and policies0 At the same time they bring local political events to a wider audience and even to national attention. Cantwell, Frank V. "Public Opinion and the Legislative Process." American Politial Science Review, LV ( October 1946), pp 924-35. Also in Berelson, B. and Janowitz (eds.), Reader _n Pgb1g Opinion and Co ication, Glencoe, Ill., The Free Press, 1950, pp 121-31. Legislators wait for public opinion to shape itself before dealing formally with policy questions. Events play a more important role than Congress or the President in shaping public opinion. Public opinion seldom proposes a course of action and it always needs leadership. Damle, Y. B. Villages. 1 "Gormunication of Modern Ideas and Knowledge in Indian Public Opinion Quarterly, XX (Spring 1956), pp 257-70. The influence of the social structure on the quality and quantity of the communications which are assimilated in seven villages at different distances and with differing contacts with urban center. Structural constraints whether natural or imposed render certain ideas and knowledge dysfunctional and lead to change. Davison, W. Phillips. "On the Effects of Communication." Quarterly, XXIII (Fall 1959), pp 343-60. Public Opinion Research must look deeper into the effects of communication on the arousal of human needs and how they are satisfied. In one sense the audience bargains with the message and vice versa. Deutschmann, Paul J. and Wayne A. Danieson. "Diffusion of Knowledge of the Major News story." Journalism Quarterly, 37 (Summer 1960), pp 345-55c Analysis of the diffusion process involved in dissemenation of three big news stories and the role of the 'opinion leader' in relaying additional information. This relay function is supplemental to the media and the reinforcement function, 5 I.Commun4eatiops- Patterns Glickmann, Harvey, "Viewing Public Opinion in Politics: A Common Sense Approach." Public Opinion Quarterly, XXIII (Fall 1959), pp 495-504. Considers the atomistic character of "public" and the influence of environmental factors and sub-publics on the articulation and aggregation problem. Horikawa, Naoyoshi. "Television in everyday life." Japanese Revgew, 1960, 10, pp 148-60. ournalism An inquiry into the change caused by television on the lives of women and children, Husain, Asad. "The Future of English Language Newspapers in India." Journaism Quarterly, 33 (Spring 1956), pp 213-219. The English language papers will maintain their prestige largely because the vernacular press has only a regional standing and the national language has not spread to dimensions necessary for a truly national press. English language speakers constitute only 8% of the populat on but they are spread all over India and the English papers have national coverage. Jennings, W. Ivor. "Universities in the Colonies." in Shannon, ed., New York, Harper, 1957, pp 114-119. Updordeeloped rea Discusses tha problem of education for life in the colonies versus the emphasir on examinations and English education. Kats, Elihu. "The Two-Step Flow of Communication: An Up to Date Report on An Hypothesis." Public .pinion Qurterly, XXI (Spring 1957) pp 61-78. Discuwsse character of opinion leader and source of his influence. Function of inter-personal relations. Lowe, Francia E. and Thomas C. McCormick, "A Study of the Influence of Formal and Informal Leaders in an Election Campaign." Public Oinion Quarterly, XX (Winter 1956), pp 651-662. Qualities of informal leaders and degree of influence relative to formal leaders noted, Finds citizen's political opinions relatively independent of those attributed to leader. 6 II. Compunication Patterns Mardin, Serif. "Some Notes on an Early Phase in the Modernization of Communications in Turkey." Comparative Studies in Socety nd History, III (April 1961), pp 250-271. The process of modernization in Turkey discussed in terms of Karl Deutsch's model in Nationalism and Social Cormncation. Concentrates on problem of language diversity and national assimilation. The building of national unity among the Turks had no relation to the assimilation of linguistic minorities by a linguistic majority that Deutach assumed, Park, Robert E. "Reflections on Communication and Culture." Ameriean Jpgurna.l of Sociolog, XLIV (1939) pp 191-205. Alvo in Reader n Publie Opinion and Communication -75 Communications "spin a web of custom and mutual expectation which binds together diverse social units." Two forms of organization involved, the familial and the communal. Pickerell, Albert G. "The Press of Thailand: Conditions and Trends." Journalsm _Quarterly, 37 (Winter 1960), pp 83-960 Paternalistic government, political apathy and other influences have shaped newspapers which are colorful but lack accuracy and responsibility. Trend toward more bluntness, more factual accounts, less carefree ways but problem of underdevelopment in media resources is major, Pye, Lucian W. "Communication Patterns and the Problems of Representative Government in Non-Western Societies." Public Opinn Quarterl XX (Spring 1956), pp 249-56, Traditional patterns of communication, changes wrought by urbanization and westernization and special problems of political communication inherent in character and culture of non-Western society. Ragsdale, Wilmott. "A Program for Developing the Media of Southeast Auia0o Journalism Qurterly, 37 (Spring 1960), pp 275-93 Report of the UNESCO Conference on Development of Information Media in Southeast Asia, Bangkok, January 18-30, 1960, Statistics on media available. Smith, 3ruce L. "Communications Research on Non-industrial Countries," PublIe Qpnion .Qartriy,, 16 (Winter 1952-3), pp 527-38 also in Shannon, JUnderdeveegg Areas., p 360-367, Outlines imin characteristics of these socielies wiTh emphasis on audlience charac teristicso 7 II. Communication Patterns Stycos, J. M. _Public , "Patterns of Comunication in a rural Greek Village." ion Quarterly, XVI (Spring 1952), pp 59-70. Investigates question: To what extent does 'opinion leader' hypothesis fit the comunication pattern of a relatively underdeveloped area? Finds that in an area with low literacy, low access to media, the importance of the opinion leader is enhanced and to some extent formalized. Also points to wthe information controllers" who because they own radios or newapapers can control the flow of news. Warner, Bob. "An Emerging Press: The African Story." 93 (August 27, 1960), p 120 Editor L Publisher, An examination of press conditions in the Congo Republic, Guinea, Somali, and Valagasy. 8 Illo Attitude Change. Social4sation and Personality, Struture Baur, E. Jackson. "Public Opinion and the Primary Group." Sociological Review, 25 (Arril 1960), pp 208-19. American Typical history of a public passes through stages characterized by mass behavior, public controversy between organised factions, and institutionalised decision making. In each stage primary groups perform generative and relay functions within larger structures. Breed, Warreno "Uass Communication and Socio-Culturel Integration." Sogal Force , 37 (December 1958), pp 109-116, Analyses mess media as an independent variable in normative integrtion in terms of publishing or not publishing material which may injure popular faith in the society or important parts of it. Power and close as structural strata are protected by media and the media do not reveal flaws in working of institutions or deviance from norms. Deutsch, Karl Wo "The Growth of Nations: Some Recurrent Patterns of Political and Social Integration." World Politics, V (January 1053), p 168-195o Defines comunity and people in terms of communications. Lists possible specific uniform ties in nation--building including the the growth of basic communicatlon gride. Concept of self-interest and the experience of self-awareness i part of the problem of social integration. Eisenstadt, S. No "Co micatlion Systems and Social Structures An Exploratory Comparative Study,," Public Qgipon Quarterly, XIX (Summer 1955), pp 153-67. Compares communio.system of underdeveloped countries with more urban-modern systemso Draws hypothesis as to how development takes place. Eisenstadt, S. N. "Conditions of Communicative Receptivity." opinion Quarterly, 17 (Fall 1953), pp 363- 74 Pbtlie Study of communication process of new immigrants in Israel, characteristics of "low communicants" and conditions which give rise to this. Finds that individuals need organization in a system and th.s organization determines his communication receptivity. Gempests, K. "The Relation of Empathy to Effective Communication," Journalism Quarterly, XXXVII (Autumn 1960), pp 533-46. Sunarises all writings on empathy- its nature, meaning and role in personality development, Draws some hypothesis about meaning in terms of communiation. 9. III. Attitude Change. Socialisation and Personality Structure. continued Geiger, Kurt. "Changing Political Attitudes in Totalitarian Society: A Case Study of the Role of the Family." (January 1956), pp 187-205. 2 Polits, VIII Interviews with refugees on parent-child relations vis-a-vis Soviets and religion. Conflict of values weakens family as unit of opposition. Golden, H. H. "Literacy and Social Change in Underdeveloped Countriea." RuCAI 9169, 20 (1955), pp 2-7. znds lIteracy correlates with industrialisation at .87 and at .84 with per capita income. Greenstein, Fred I. journa "Sex Related Political Differences in Childhood." Politics, 23 (May 1961), p 353 Review of findings on children's social development and report on New Haven study showing continuing sex differences in direction and degree of political attention and participation. as early as 9-10 years. Differences appear . "Children's Images of Political Authority." American Political Qo t evi, y LIV (December 1960), pp 934 New Haven study indicates grade 4 to 8 children have some perceptions of political letders and their roles and importance. Absence of political cynicism or skepticism at this age. Gulick, John. "Conservativisa and Change in a Lebanese Village." E B EUgt Jg _1 8 (Summer 1954), pp 295-307. Changes which have taken place as a result of contact with the West. What has changed: occupational roles, economics, religion, kinship structure, social behavior, localism. Guttman, Louis and Urill G. Foa. Attitude." Pu~bli "Social Contact and an Inter-Group Dinion Quarterl, XV (Spring 1951), pp 43-53. Survey of cross-section of Israeli population on attitude toward government civil servants. Amount of contact was not related to direction of intergroup attitude but was related to the intensity of that attitude, Kats, Daniel. "The Functional Approach to the Study of Attitudes," Public OApnn Quarterly, xxIV (Summer 1960), pp 163-204. Reasons for holding or changing attitudes are found in the functiona they perform for the individual, specifically the functions of adjustment, ego defense, value expression and knowledge. otivationa1 impact of other groups of variables considered. 10 III. Attitude Change, Socialization and Personality Structure, continued Klapp, Orrin E. "Social Types: Process and Structure." Sociological R~eve, 23 (December 58), pp 674-8. American Distinguishes between formal role structure and social typing. The later specify's much of the informal structure and special situations that develor for which no formal role exists. In a changing society social typing defines emerging roles and thus plays a role in the development of social structure. They give informal status, contribute to identity problems solutions in transitional societies. Meier, Dorothy and Wendell Bell. "Aunomie and Differential Access to Reig, 24 the Achievement of Life Goals." American So (April 1959), pp 189-202. rysfunction and communication problems. Nair, Le P. "Independent Religious Movements in Three Continents." I (January 1959),pp 113Comparative Studies i Society andHistory Reaction to opposition to established religious institutions appear similar: greater autonomy in achieving benefits or reinterpretation of the dogma and goals. Suggests political party or labor union organization may be similar, Patai, Raphael. "The Dynamics of Westernization in the Middle East." Middle East Journal, 9 (Winter 1955), pp 1What prevailed, means used by West, why some practices accepted easier than others, etc. Sees change as the development of mental attitudes in the direction of rational thinking. "The Concentration and Dispersion of Charisma." Shils, Edward. Politics, XI (October 1958), pp 1-19. World Charisma can be dispersed if individuals can find a way of breaking loose from habits of extended family without losing the basic organisational structure of personal life, By learning to use own capacity the individual gains in self respect but he must develop a basic structure to organise himself in relation with others, that is, develop a belief in his own charisma as well as charisma of those in authority. Tumin, Melvin U. "Some Disfunctions of Institutional Imbalances." Bqhavi2ra Sclenc . I (July 1956), pp 218-23. How does the economic structure--especially job recruitment, placement, performance, and reward--compare with the structure of kinship-role playing, and how do these structures interact? Ways in which institutions may become and be dominant and effect of imbalance which results particularly the imbalance in value attainment. 11 III. AttitUde Chage. Socialisation and Personality Structure, continued Vickers, Geoffrey. "Is Adaptability Enough?" (July 1959), pp 219-234. Behavioral ienc, 4 Outlines a conceptual model for the adaptation of a system. Points out essential features of adaptation, problems raised. Society's regulatory process and how it reacts to changes. Control and conflict within the system. Walter, E, V. "Power, Civilisation and Psychology of Conscience." Amerigan Political Science Review LIII (September 1959), pp 641-61. Function of political power is to regulate, direct, coordinate, and control existing social relationships. To function properly it requires certain social and psychological conditions. Traditional societies differ in these conditions and change brin-s about crisis in political power. Wurfel, David. "Foreign Aid and Social Reform in Political Development: A Philippine Case Study 0 " American Political Science eie, LIII (June 1959), pp 456-82. American use of foreign aid to effect social reform, minimum wage act and encourage land reform, Social and political problems encountered in the processo 12 IV. Role of S'etfric Grous in Develommn Almond, Gabriel A, *A Comparative Study of Interest Groups and the LU (March Political Process." American Political §gAAMe Leud 1958), pp 270-2. Description of tho Committee on Comparative Politics of the SSTC its membership, orientation, objectives, and initial hypotheses. Rationale of interest group and functional approach. Ashford, Douglas E. "Labor Politics in a New Nation." Quarterly, XIII (June 1960), pp 312-331. ttgr Politis Study of U.U.T. labor movement in Morocco since independence. Example of a labor union becoming a well-organized and functionally specific interest group during the achievement of independence and then denying its union purposes in order to engage in politics and seek political influence. Blankaten, George I. "Political Groups in Latin America." Foltical Scine Reew, LIII (March 1959), pp 106-27. American Describes and classifies institutional, associational and non-associational groups in Latin American politics. Argues for the "group analysis" approach for an understanding of tatin American politics. Dubin, Robert. "Industrial Conflict and Social Welfere." Cflinct Renlgbuka, I (June 1957), pp 179-99, gIgg Role of conflict and response to same in social integration and social change. Social change is "hamered out" in the daily lives of citisens and their reference groups. The interplay and conflict over the ends of power seeking groups is the fund :ntal social process and the outcome of this conflict settles social policy questions. Eisenstadt, S. N. "Internal contradictions in Bureacratic Politics." Commarabie Stus g .glgtZ ajg MjigjgEZ, I (October 1958), pp 58-75c Punctional analysis of bureeataecies in pre-modern cultures. Shows that goals institutionalised by ruling elites who established centralised bureaucracies were eventually undermined by those recruited into the suprorting institutions. . "Political Struggle in Bureacratic Societies." II (October 1956), pp 15-36. World Politics, Political sphere of bureacracies is strongly goal oriented with goe' s distinct from those of other institutions or sub-groups in the society, Description of these socibes and social conditions which give rise to thes. 13 IV. R21e of Speeifie Group- in Develoment, continued Freedman, Maurice. "Immigrentaand Associations: Chinese in 19th Century Singapore," CoMarative Studies Ln Society and History, III (October 1960), pp 25 ff', Societies organised by Chinese created a sub-society during the 19th century, Secret societies insulated Chinese from other societies and provided consensus mechanism within the relatively closed society,. Friedmann, J. "Intellectuals in Leveloping Societies," Jyjlos (No. 4, 1960), pp 513-44. Modern intellectual must be ranged alongside the innovator in affairs of business as a principal agent in promoting economic growth. He mediates new values, formulates an effective ideology, etc. Hoselitz, B. F. "The Recruitment of White-Collar Workers in Underdeveloped Countries," International Sggil jSience Bulletin, VI (No. 3, 1954), pp 3-11. Also appears in Shannon, Underdeveloed Argj, pp 181-9. Character of the white collar worker and his recruitment on a personal, non-rational basis must be understood in terms of the development needs of underdeveloped countries. Kozicki, Richard J. "Indian Interest Groups and Indian Foreign Policy," Indian Journal of Political Scice, (July-September 1958), pp 219-27, Notes general absence of interest groups in India, But Federation of Indian Chambers of Commerce and Industry is active in foreign policy particularly discusses this group with respect to Indo-Burmese and IndoCeylon policies. Lerner, Daniel and Richard Robinson. "The Turkish Army as a Modernizing Force, World Pjltics, XIII (October 1960), pp 19-44. Role of military in spread of Westernization and Western values and in pressuring politicians to behave has been of great importance in Turkey. Contacts with West have been more intense historicalV and through U.S aid Lichtblau, George E. "The Politics of Trade Union Leadership in Southern Asia," W2rld Politics, VII (October 1954), pp 84-101. Unemployed intellectuals took over leadership of the labor movement to achieve social and political mobility otherwise denied them. Workers and leaders interests converged and were identified with nationalisa Political ambitions and personalized character of relationship converts unions into recruitment mechanism for political process and government takes over a protective role toward worker, 314 IV. Role of Specific Groups in Developsmnt, continued Liebman, Charles S. "Electorate Interest Groups and Local Government Policy," American Behavioral Scientist, IV (January 1961), pp 9 ff. Develops a model of policy formulation which assumes a complete separation of policy formulation and electoral activity. Voter decisions are entirely personality oriented and there is no expectation that particular policies will be realised because a particular candidate is elected. Thus elected officials are not bound by constituent demands. Rangnekar, r. K. "The Nationalist Revolution in Ceylon," LXII (December 1960), rp 361-74. Pagflc Affair., Peaceful transfer of power in Ceylon prevented the development of meass movement which might have served to unify the people. Bandaranaike aroused first nationalist spirit with appeals to politically alienated using socialism and nationalism0 Reed, Howard. "A New Force at Work in Democratic Turkey," Journal 7 (Winter 1953), pp 33-44. Mdde ,Ego Peasant has become target of political appeals and as prosperity and communication increase his demands become wider and more detailed, Fxample of broadening base of political power. Rudolph, Lloyd Iand Susanne H. Rudolph. "The Political Role of India's Caste Associations," Pacific Affairs, XXXIII (March 1960), pp 5-224 Caste associations as an example of indigenous forms of associations providing channels of communication and bases of leadership and organization to overcome "technical political illiteracy" handicaps of traditional elements and thus allow them participation in politics. Sakata, Yoshio and John Whitney Hall. "The Motivation of Political Leadership in the Meiji Restoration," Journal gf A8si Studieg, XVI (November 1956), pp 31-50. Analyses restoration in terms of the political agents who brought it about. Breakdown of equilibrium of three distinct political institutions and the development of a potential bargaining process as quid pro quols fluctuated. Significant in terms of imbalanees created during develorment and changes brought about through response to these imbalances. Sayeed, Kalid B, "Political Role of Pakistan's Civil Service," Affairs, XX (June 1958), pp 131-46. Pacific Civil Servant!s distrust of the politicisn and his ways and the strength of the civil service gives that group unnatural weight in political affairs, They are not responsive to needc and very slow to act, 15 IV. Role of S if Shils, Ed-card, World .Poli. roe Developmnt, continued "Intellectuals, Public Opinion and Economic Development," X (January 1958), pp 232-55o Finds that the intellectuals need to contact masesa with their vision, and me-s the preas as the chief organ of instructuared public opinion0 Generasl discussion of preas problems in underdeveloped countries, "The Intellectuals in the Political Development of the New o States " World Poljtics, XII (April 1960), pp 329-68& Changing roles of intellectuals in the process of political development Szigliano, Pobert Co "Political Parties in South Vietnam Under the Republic." argfiq Affairs, XXXIII (1ecember 1960), pp 327-346. Development of Vetnamese political parties as ins'trumnts for dealing with foreign rulers. Seek accomodation and a wider range of participation but miostly aimed at independence. "Patterns and Problems of Local Administration in Wickwer, W 11ardy. the Middle Easton Middle East Journal, 12 (Summer 1958), pp 249-60. Problem of decentralisation of administration and creation of viable political and administrative units at the local level. Use of Western institutions and the results, Socio-cultural factors inhibiting and enhancing development, Wright, Gordono "Peasant Politics in the Third' French Republie ' XX (March 1955), pp 7546. e.n!e Quaverl, Politics Role of peasants in development. They have tended to back reactionary forces and slor down social reform. 16 V, Cu;Ltral 'Faetors that Enhance or IMede Democratic DeveLo"2pment Bernstein, Marver. "Israel a Capacity to Govern." (Apiril 1959), pp 399-417, ol A2.Politijo, XI Analyzen the achievements and problems -the nation-building elite of Israel experienced in their development of a modern state0 Deals with orientations toward government, development of legitimy, etc. Brze'Anski, Zbigniew. "The Politics of Underdevelopment," IX (Oct&er 1956), pp 55-75, World Polities, Economic development requires totalitarian regimes, Foreign aid programs therefore, can not contribute to political and social change in the direction of democratic development,, Cook, Thomas 1o "Democratic Psychology and Democratic World Order," Worl Politics, I (July 1949), pp 553-564. Need to re-evaluate assumptions about political theory and psychology with a view to developing useful theoretical base for functicnal theory,, r. I "Tridonesis and the Commonwealth in Southeast Asiat A Reappraisal," International Affairs, 34 (October l58), pp 454-68 Cowan, C Description of events in Indonesia arising out of the 1.949 decision to change the constitution from a federal to a central unitary state. Notes the biggest problem in Indonesia is the failure to grasp the fundamental principle of Western parliamentary practice: the t governments succeed one another modifying each others programs as the pendulum swings f'rom one to another. Finaudi, Mario. "The Crisis of Politics and Government in France." Polit~ic TV (October 1951), pp 64-84c Worl Problems of parliamentary system in multi-party state. Does not generate spirit of compromise or acceptance of majority rule. How find the dividing line between party politics and government,, " A Meaning for Turnerls Frontier," PoliticL Science Quartrly, LUTY (September 1954) pp 321-353 and also U (December 1954) pp 565-602,, Elkins, Stanley and Eric MeYetriek. Political democracy is most obvious where there is r necessity to act that is, in the initial stages of seting up a new cor.runity where there Implies no clear diatInction is no struicture o' natural leedership. between rulers and ruled in this settinp 17 V0 Cultural Factors that Enhance or Impede Democratic Development Emerson, Rupert. "The Erosion of Democracy." Studies, XX (November 1960), pp 1 ff. The Journal of Asian Military take-overs in South East Asia raise the question of the suitability of Western evolved democracy for Asian environements. Griffith, Ernest S. and John Plamenats, J. Roland Pennock. "Cultural Prerequisites for Democracy." Aeica Political Science Review, 50 (March 1956), pp 101-37, A philosophical essay by each author on the requirements for democracy restricted to five highly industrialized countries. Hauser, Philip M. "Cultural and Personal Obstacles to Economic Development in the less Developed Areas." Huan Organisation, 18 (Sumer 1959), pp 78 ff . Elements of colonialism which impede economic development: truncated social orders, pluralistic societi.es, over-urbanisation, resurgent nationalism, mass disillusionment with respect to the timing of economic development0 Elements of indigenous culture which impede development: value systems which conflict with material aspirations, highly stratified socieities with a relatively small but powerful elite, etc. Hughes, Colin A. "Semi-Representative Government in the British West Indies." Political Science Quarterly, LXVIII (September 1953), pp 338-53o Two main tendencies in West Indian politics--lone wolf tradition of personality politics and over organization on paper which is ineffeative in terms of political organization. Transitional societies tend to have loosely organised politics at the same time that many opportunities exist to avoid accountability. This is crucial. Lane, Robert. "The Fear of Equality " LIII (March 1959), pp 35-51. American Political Science Review, Finds that working class Americans do not promote or hold to the ideal of equality. This value is promoted largely by intellectuals. Lipset, Seymour. "Some Social Requisites of Democracy: Economic Pevelopment and Political Legitimacy." American Political Science Ree LII (March 1959), pp 69-1050 Compares "democracies" nore or less democratic in terms of wealth, industrialization, education and urbanization0 Compares in terms of legitimacy and effectiveness of government. Finds development problems of new states inherent in the requirements mentionedlevel of economic development and level of political effectiveness and legitimacy. V,, Cultural Factors that Enhance or Impd remocratic IDevelopment, .contInued' Folitic1 l Science Quartey Mershall, Jamese "The Nature of Democracy 0 " LXV (March 1950), pp 38=5.4o The measure of a people's democracy is the extent of its freedom from dependence, This is a sign of a political maturity, All modern Societes embody a degree of dependence those which try to decretve the level of dependence are democratie. If citizen is dependent he tan not relerse the aggrevsions and anxieties which society creates must rely on leaders, Democracy is a complex serise of human rdation ships a-nd e 4srative cultural relationshipo RosenbeJg, Uorris 0 "The Meaning of Politics In Mass Society." O2inon QuYtrleZjy, XV (Spring 1951), pp 5-15, Public iest8 three positive motivations to polilcal action and three obstructions to political action. Politics gives no immediate concrebe, gratification and thous rouses apathy 'but his allows people to accept political defeat of their candidates. Sayeed, Khalid Ben. "Collapse of Parliamentary Democracy in Pakistan." Middle East Journal, 13 (Autumn 1959), pp 389-406. Background of the situation, the division in leadership and the problems of the martial law regime in meeting demands of public opinion, Overall view of the problem of demoeratic development and social reform and difficulties of finding political solutions to social problems. Tambeah, S. J, and Bryce Ryan, oei, y " "Secularization o" Family Values in 22 (June 1957), pp 292-9. ,nfertility in ' ry'al Examines traditional ftmily values and Sinkalese communities. Different levels of urban contact, isolation other variables point out that harsh envircnmental conditions are not sufficient condition for modification of' value principles. yen der Kroef, Justus V. "Indonesilas Economic W'ture." Afaltra, 'XXI (March 1959), pp 46-72. Ilic Th politica of economic development rnd the problem of need for captel versus th'e ettitude toward foreign capital.. Traditional ways of complete representation and unanimity not conduelve to developMnt problem Solving, Mitual cooperation value places more coniern on ieology than on reconstr-uction o 19 VI. Theories and Models of Poltcal Systems Almond, Gabriel A.,, Taylor Cole and Roy C. Macridis. "A Suggested Research Strategy in Western European Government and Politics." AMIcan Pogli&col Scienge Rgyag, 49 (December 1955), pp 1042-49, Review of U.S. and European political theory and research and a suggested strategy for consensus among researchers as to the most urgent needs of the field, the best approaches and suitable methodolcgy. Almond, Gabriel. "Comparative Political Systems." Journal jffolitics, XVIII (August 1956), also in Eulau, et. al. Political Beavior:_ Ae der iI .Taggggq Rsarcgh. Formulation of the political culture model and the functional analysis of interest groups used in PolItie gf .he Deelojina Apter, David. "A Comparative Method for the Study of Politics." The American Jural of Sociolo"y, LXIV (November 1958), pp 221-237. Sets up three main dimensions-social stratification, political groups and government-in order to produce a manipulative theory out of comparative research. Outlines main components of each dimension and purports to show how each dimension interacts with the other two. . "The Role of Traditionalism in the Political Modernization of Ghana and Ugenda." WoQd Politics, XIII (October 1960), pp 45-68. _____ Compares Ghana and Uganda to shoe how their modern existence has been and is being shaped by the nature of their tradtions. Defines in terms of instrumental versus consummatory systems and the possibilities of innovation in each system. Berelson, Bernard. "Democratic Theory and Public Opinion." e 2nion Qarteri, 16 (Fall 1952), pp 313-330. Also appears in Eulau, j.t..j., Political Behavior: A Ragerg j g and Research. Discussion of the prerequisites of democracy as outlined by theorists and compared to what public opinion studies have shown to be the actual case about political behavior. Suggests points where theory is too gross and needs refinement. Sets up guidelines as to requirements of "democracy." Bretton, Henry Lo "Current Political Thought and Practice in Chana." AeLrin Poltical Science tA gs, 52 (March 1058), pp 47 ff. Attempts to isolate some of the problem areas and political characteristics implicit in behavior patterns of contemporary and future political systems in developing areas. Looks at practices and behavior of party organisation end the conduct of elections, parliamentary and administrative affairs. 20 V1. Theories and Models of PolitIeal Systems, continued Easton, Davido "An approach to the Analysis of Political Systems." Wrld olities, IX (April 1957), pp 383-400. Input-output systems model of political process0 Discusses the dynamic character of the process and the kinds of demands, channels, supports and outputs required to keep it operating0 Eiaenstadt, S. "Primitive Political Systems: A Preliminary Comparative Analysis,," American Anthropologist, LXI (April 1959), pp 200-20o Good description of the basic elements of a political system, Emerson, Rupert,, "Nationalism and Political Development." Journl 9f Polltics, 22 (February 1960), pp 3-28o Nationalism answers none of the practical problems of development or independence. Its contribution is of the spirit and psychology and it may even impede development i' used as a screen for domestic failures. Gyr, John W. "An investigation into and Speculations about, the formal nature of the problem solving process,' Behavioral Science, 5 ,Janlay 1960), pp 39-59. The process of a person fitting "guesses" about the environment to his experience in it, Need to consider such things as the succession of trials made by the subject in solving problems, information available to him prior to each trial, mechanism inside individual which might account for the specific linkages between information and trial and the control system within this process, Kahin, George McT., Guy Pauker, Lucian W. Pye, "Comparative Politics of Non-Western Countries," American Political Science Review, 49 (December 1955), pp 1022-41, A preliminary review and forecast of studies in comparative politics concentrating on problems of non-Western countries: the political process, groups and media of influence, dynamic factors to be considered by students in the field,, Kahl, Joseph A. "Some Social Concomitants of Industrialization and Urbanization," Organisation, 18 (Summer 1959), pp 53ff0 Good review of litereture on urbanization and Its effects on family structure, personal choices, attitudes toward life, etc, 21 VI. Theories and Models of Political Systes,. continued Rudolph, Susanne. "Consensus and Conflict in India." Worm (April 1961), pp 383-99. EgridB, lull Indian politics does not legitimise power or men who "live off" poelte. Discusses reasons for and results of this phenomena. Rustow, Dankart A., "New Horinns for Comparative Politics." Politics, IX (July ), pp 530-49c .Wggi Differences between comparattv ;titles of Western and non-Western world emphasise need for new concepts. Broad view of the situation shows similarities in experience. The constants have become variables and we need a more historical touch. Weiner, Nyron. ",*e Maint Power: Notes on Indian Political Behavior." WorlgPolitics, 'aI (April 1956), pp 392 ff. One prerequisite of a democratic system is a willingness of political groups to make political calculations ( e.g. compromises and *colitions) to increase their strength. This is lacking In lndia and leadero are not concerned for the political conequences of their acts. Indie attitudea toward power tend to place leaders outside of fcanal wae n their own organisation. 0 22 I. The Communications Process Bent, Silas. News er Crusaders: A Neglected Sto!Z* New iork: MCOraW-Hills 193 Bruce, John. Ga Years Ro Century: The StorY of San Francisco's Hundred ourna a Now orlic dom HI 194t Cater, Douglas. The Fourth Branch of Government. 14iflinp 19599 Boston: Houghton Do Fleur, Melvin and Otto N. Larsen. E.xprimnt in The Flow of InforMUtions An as Comunications. " YorkTHarper, 195 Hovland, Carl I. "Effects of Ass Iedia of Communication," Handbook of Social holo, II, G. Lindsey (editor). CambridLe: Addison-Wesley, 1954, pp 3. Hovland, Carl I., Irving I. Janis, and Harold H. Kelley. q m= and Persuasion. New Haven: Yale University Press, 1953. Hughes, Helen MnGill. News and the Human Interest Story. University of Chicago eis 959 ~ Janowits, M. The Commun Free Press,152 n an Urban Set ing on Chicago: encoot The Katz, Elihu and Paul Lasarafeld. "Personal Influence," in Eulau, et al., Political Behavior, Glencoe: The Free Press, 1956, pp '19-59. Lang, Kurt and Gladys E. "Mass Media and Voting," in Eugene Burdioik and Arthur J. Brodbeck (editors), American Voting Behavior Glencoas The Free Press, 1959. Lasewell, Harold D. "The Structure and Function of Communications in Society," in L. Bryson, The Communication of Ideas. Now York: Institute of Religion and Soe Studies,*1 S 23 I. The Communications Process, continued Lazarsfeld, Paul F., Bernard Berelson, and Hazel Gaudste The Peopie' Choice: How the Voter Makes U His Mind in a PresidentisTC, . Ner YrkTThiIe T w,[rntaiaFPeare # Lazarefeld, Paul F. and Robert K. Morton. "Mass Communcation, Popular Taste and Organized Social Action," in L. Bryson, The Communication of Ideas. New York: Institute of Religion and SociaTudiIes,9W. Lazarsfeld, Paul F. and Frank Stanton. Duell, Sloan and Pearce, 1944. Radio Research 191 2-3. New York: Lee, Alfred MClung. The DailyNewspaper in America: The Evolution of a Social Instruimet . ow York: am&Ul , 97. Merton, Robert K. "Patterns of Influence: A Study of Interpersonal Influence and of Commnication Behavior in a Local Community," in Lasarafeld, Paul F, and Frank Stanton, Communications Research 1948-9. New York: Harper and Brothers, 1949,~p" 85-0. Merton, Robert K. "The Sociology of Knowledge and Mass Communication," Part III of Social and Structure. Glencoe: The Free Press, 1959. Pool, Ithiel de Sola. Trends in Content Analysis. of Illinois Pres, 19 Urbana: Universdty Riley, John W., Jr. and 14. W. Riley. "Mass Communication and the Social Structure" in Merton, Broom and Cottrell, Sociology Tda. New York: Basic Books, 1959, pp 537-78. Rosten, Leo. The Washington Correspondents, Brace Company, Schramm, Wilbur (editor). Mass Communications. of Illinois Press, 1944e, New York: Harcourt, Urbana: University Schramm, Wilbur. Responaibility in Mass Communications. Harper and Brothers, New York: 0 24 I. The Cowmnications Process$ continued Schraum, Wilbur (editor). The Process and Effects of Mass Maieivr 1954 0 Communications . Urbana: Science Research Associates. ThedM Comics. January, 1956. Siebert, Fred S., T. B. Peterson, and Wilbur Schramm. Far Theories of the Press. Urbana: University of T1linois PressI19 6 . Sinclair, Upton. The Brass Chsc)o Pasadena: The Author, 1919. Waples, Douglas, Bernard Berelson, and F. R. Bradahaw. What ad of Evidence on the Social Effeci o Does to frgjs A S versity hicago: '(ioeai ro Readin and a Statmenft Williams, J. Go Redio Paris: UNESCO, 1950. n FundaMnal EAti URD _Undvn &31ea Wright, Charles R. Ction: CjOMMss A Sooiolotical Fersectiy New York: Random House (Paperback), 1960o 25 II. Attitude Change Socialisation and Personali Child, Irvin L. "Socialisation," in G. Lndsq, Hadbook of Social Psychology, II. Cambridge: Addison-es.e pp 655-09 Daedalus, 89 (Spring 60), "M4ass Culture and Mass Md Dood, Leonard Wo Am AP New Haven: Yale"nversAF'; Handlin, Oscar. The Uprootedo 1951 (paperbaw7 oMare Fipviliaed: na 90 New York: Grosset and Dunlap Publifhers, to 1 togant tri am Hays, Samuel P. The University of Chicago Press, 1957. 8 .n 9 Chicago: Heberle, Rudolf. Social Mavexents An IntrOductiont to Po~iial Sociology. New Yorks App1eTon-Ceu-rfts,15. Hoselits, Bert F. (editor). Socio Development. Glencoe: The F LAis ress, Hlyman, Herbert. Political Socialisation: A Stu MFrie of Political Be"TaivTO o Econom n the P Inkeles, Alex and David J. Levinson. "National Character: The Study of Modal Personality and Sociocultural Systems," in 0. Lindsey, Handbook of Social Psychology, II, Cambridge: Addison-Wesleys Kerr, Clark, John T. Dunlap, et al. Industr a Cambridge: Harvard University PresaZ 196 and Industrial Man. Kluckhohn, Clyde. "Culture and Behaviors" in 0. Lindsey, Handbook Cambridge: Addison-Wesley, 19!4""pl 1-76o of Social Psychology, II. Lipset, S. M., Paul F. Lasarafeld, A. H. Barton and J. Lins. "The Psychology of Voting: An Analysis of Political Behavior," Cambridge: in G. Lindsey, Handbook of Social Psychology, II. Addison-Wesley, 954s 1118E 0 U 26 II. Attitude Cha e Socialisation and Personalit , continued Mannoni, O. Po and Caliban: The Fsghro of Colonisation. Translated byaml"osrado: ag,1 Public Public inion Quarterl XXII, Fall 1958, Daniel Lerner,(editor). titud earc n Modernising Areas." Qarter, XXIV, Suwmer 1960, Daniel Katz (editor). Slotkin, James S. From Field to Factory New Industrial EM o m (Research Centern Ecnio L~Delopuent'i"n lral =418ge University of Chicago) Glencoe: The Free Press, 1960. Smith, M. Brewster, Jerome S. Bruner and Robert W. White. and Personality. New Yorks John Wiley and Sons, Inc., nions Shils, Edward. "The Studr of the Primary Group," in Lerner and Lasell (editors), The P Sciences: Recent l in Sco and thod Stanford: Stnaford University Press, 1951. Spindler, G. D. Socio-Cultural and P choloical Proceses in Menomini Accul turaton. Berkey: versity of""a.11frnia Press, 1955. Thomas, William F. and Florian Zuaieki. The Polish Peasset in Europe and America. New York: Knopft, 1f. 1 0 27 III. Studies of Specific Grou and Case Studies of DevloMnt Apter, David, The Gold Coast in Transition. University 1re s","T7a. Princetons Princeton e in Morocco. pumTiished Ashford, Douglas., Political Cha University Press,$" 1,""Tio Princeton: Princeton Baileys F. G. Caste and the Economic Frontier: A 1 ie'useZ r UyPrisq , Oria Man. ssUF e in Highland 0. Bascom, Willia R. and Melville J. Herskovits (editors). Continu in African Cultures. Chicago s Chicago Unive and Chan Na ua act Coleman, Jwes So o a Berkele University of Ca~foindia Prs715"" Dore, R. P. .Cit Life in Japan: A S University o Ca3!oria s Dore, R. P. Land Reform in Ja national A r.ersity . of a Tolo Ward. London: Royal Institute of InterPress, 1959. Ehrman, Henry W. (editor). Interest Grou Pittsburgh: University of""tTTEE iri;g Emerson, Rupert* of Asian and Fallers, L. Be Berkeley: on Four Continents. 5. From fti5e to Nation: The Rise to Slf-Assertion a rid aa U es Ps Bantu B in the Poiiq W. Heffer adon, au O~~O ASuofIm tion and Conflict 0rA i9 Fisher, Margaret and Joan V. Bondurant. The Indian Democratic Elections. Berkeley: Univeerty ofC Ginsburg, N. and Chster Roberts. Washington Press, 1958, M noe with olifa 1756 Seattle: University of 28 III. Studies of Specific Groups and Case Studies of Development, continued Karpat, Kemal H. Turks 'a Politics: The Transition to a Multi-Party Sytm Princeton ncentoniver ty Press, 199. Kazuo Kawai. Jaan's American Interlude. Chicago Press, O. Kobre, Sidney. The Dev Colonial Pres,-19s. Mn Chicago: University of of the Colonial N aper. Pittsburgh: Lynd, Robert S. and Helen errili Lynd, Middletown in Transition: A Stu.d. in Cultural Conflicts. Ne York~Harcoir Bras i 'daqpany,937 Five Elections MacKensie, W. J. M. and Kenneth Robinson (editors). a in Africa: A Grou of El.ectoral Studies. Oxford: CI siide Marvick, 0. Glencoe: The Free Press, 1960. Political Decision-Makers. McKim, Marrialt (editor). Vil Community. Chicago: Universit India: Studies in the Little icg7rss I9 Park, R. and Irene Tinker (editors). Leadershi and Political rTiy Institutions in India. (Some papers from seinarT95T"Rnliefdnwinceton University Press, 1959. Redfield, Robert. The ittle Culture. Chicago: riliry Cammmni a and Peasant Societ rss 5" c" Rose, Saul. Socialism in Southern Asia. Press, 1957 New York: Oxford University Scott, Robert. Mexican Government in Transition. of Illinois Pr ,"I959 Shannon, Lyle (editor). and Underdeveloped Areas. Urbana: University New York: Harper, 1957. I * *A 29 III Studies of Specific Groups and Case S dies of Deelopmnt, continued inJa and Industrial Dnt Stanford: Stanford Uiversiy Smith, Thomas C. Political Chan 7e Goverment Enter 66. Press, 1955. Smythe, Hugh H. and label M. The New Nigerian Elite. Stanford University Press, Weiner, 1%rron. Par Press, 1957. o Modern Indonesian Eite Politics in India. Wolf, Charles, Jr. Fore Aid: Theo Princeton: kinceton U versity Wriggins, W. H. Celons University Press$ Stanfords : Its Implcations for United ncil on Fo reig1Tis a ) Social Cha in Latin America States . (ublished Of; New TorkiTllMer, 1960. Van Niel, Robert. The EmerE Chicago: QuadrangI 1166 s , Princeton: Princeton University and Practice in Southern Asia. T 60. of a New Nation, Zinkin, Maurice. Developmnt for Free Asia. Pacific Relations, 1956. Princeton: Princeton New York: Institute of 30 IV. Theories and Models of Political Systems Almond, Gabriel and James S. Coleman, et al. The Politics of the Develping Areas, Princeton: Princeton Unirsity Pires;""W O Banfield, Edward C. and Laura F. The Moral Basis of Socie Glencoe: The Free Preii I9$ Barnes, J. A. Politics in a Changing Society. Press, 19540 Backward New York: Humanities Dahl, Robert. "Hierarckl, Democracy and Bargaining in Politics and Economics," in Research Frontiers in Politics and Uovernment. Washington: Brookings Instils- 193I , pp 47-5. Ao appiars in Eulau, et al. Political Behavior, pp 83-90. Dahl, Robert and Charles E. Lindblom. New York: Harper, 1953. Politics, Economics and Welfare0 De Grasia, Sebastian. The Political Comuity: A Stud of Anomie. Chicago: University o Chicago 19ai yress, Eulau, H. et al. Political Behavior. Glencoe: The Free Press, 1956. Johnson, John J. Political Chan in Latin America: The Emergence of the Middle Sectors. in o : S-nfo'r' UVersityn3res, w Key, V. 0. Politics, Parties and Pressure Go Publishers, I8 Lasswell, Harold D. The An Approach. New yOrlIi Qxo Lasawell, Harold D. Company, 1948. New York: Crowell is of Political Behavior: An Enpirical niversty 1re1s Power and Personality. New York: N. W. Norton Latham, Earl, The Proup Basis of Politics: A Study in Legislation .thaca: ielfrUniversity Press, l'2Lerner, Daniel. M1iddle East. n Point The Passin of Traditional Societ : Modernising the 2nIs e"ree Press, 19 . 1 i 31 IV. Theories and Models of Political Syters continued Lipset, Seymour M. Political Man: Where, How and Works in the Moder World. Yor Dley Michels, Roberto Oligarchial Publisher, Political Parties: A Sociologcal Stu V onrne odern Democracy. Ne " Ince" "95"" Riesman, David et al. Press, 1950. Thr . Truman, David B. Ins. of the 9i Now Haven: Yale University Schapera, I. Government and Politics in Tribal Societies. Oxford University Pres 1 Tocqueville, Alexis de. University Press, 19l7. , in The Governmental Process. . London: New York: Oxford New York: Knopf, 1953. Translated and Weber, Max. From Max Weber: Esa ain Socipol Now York: Oxford sq Co iht ~ d edited by He.~1.'rW University Press, 1958. Wittfogel, Karl A. Power. Oriental p A niriyFrss2 ~Tel New Haven 57F. of Total -wmwWOSISaimmm