SUNDAY, 9:30 A.M.--WHAT NOW? Honors Thesis (HONRS 499) by Laura I. Lewis Ball State University Muncie, Indiana May 1992 - Expected Date of Graduation May 1992 ..59~·,I! : r, ~, ., I ; " ~ Purpose of Thesis This thesis compares lessons Christian education from faults of merits and authority and activities, and the issues. guideline for - of In discussed addition, on the the version and of The basis of the there is junior high Sunday school a of the lesson proposal the Bible text age-appropriateness of aptness and relevance suggested essentials plan. each are interest level the and several Protestant denominations. readability suggested, and materials for junior high of a the topics lesson teachers which includes for lesson preparation and a sample lesson 2 Introduction In the junior high students, religious education of necessary to capture and hold each the same time fostering understanding, doctrine to qualified and prepared materials being used. For instance, appropriate. So, of the is fully failings in the materials may not be age materials available to decide materials and teaching strategies will be most successful class The the it is important that a teacher examine closely educational different a teacher there may be to teach, at It can be quite difficult Even when effectively. while and perhaps bE=lief, or teaching being presented. teach students interE~st student's it is which with a of junior high students before choosing what will be used. materials to be considered should include the version of the Bible text, activities. available lesson the topics and not only book text, Other considerations class activities. lesson time for issues, Teachers may by comparing suggested should include reading and and the the amount Bible text, participating in of discussing other relevant discover new strategies materials within their classtime for teaching denomination, also by examining the materials available from churches but of other denominations and from religious bookstores. Using the above criteria, I have examined compared several sets of junior high materials: (UMC, hereafter) materials, Cokesbury's older UMC Trek, divisions), David Nazarine, Lutheran, C. Cook's, and critically United Methodist Bible Adventures, Church of God (both younger and and Southern Baptist(also both 3 younger and older divisions). Version of Bible Text The selection of a specific version of the Bible text is an important aspect of any are religious instructional material. a variety of choices, James Version text ranging from the very traditional King to the modern Good for junior high students, News Bible. one should When selecting a consider the clarity and level of the language and whether the effort for sacrificed beauty, There impact, or, most important, clarity has authority or interpretation. Of the materials in texts I reviewed, modern language versions except the Southern Baptist (SBC, not specify a Bible text. of God, and (NIV) . The other lesson all favor for junior high Cook's UMC, the Nazarine, which is basically reader. sacrifices. for the most But, the changes For example, part, for students, New Revised Standard the King James Version with The language of the NIV easily understood some the Church International Version materials use the some slight alterations in the language. is clear and, of Bible hereafter) which does Lutheran lessons use the New Version (NRSV), the use words by a have caused young some poetic passages from the Psalms and the Song of Solomon have lost some of the aesthetic appeal which they have in the beauty but memorable. King James Version. also they seem to On the other hand, loses no beauty Not only have less have they lost poetic impact and are less the love passage in I Corinthians but becomes exceptionally clearer for the young 4 reader when the "love" in the NIV. "And King James In the King James the earth was without form, of the ~·1aters". becomes "\'I'as the NRSV (In moving".) In seems of God moved upon the face the only the N!V, the alteration is less the young memorable than "hovering" certainly does "Now the surface \01ith "surface", "void" with "empty" and "face" understood for urlloved" same passage reads, darkness was over simplifies the vocabulary of easily Genesis 1:2 reads, of God was hovering over the waters". of the deep and the Spirit By replacing the word and void; and darkness was upon and empty, the earth was formless NIV Version, of the deep. And the Spirit the face replaced by "charity" is the text, thus reader. But the the King James not have making it more NIV passage Version. the impact the The \'I'ord which the word "moved" does. Word choices variations in the King mother, sometimes interpretations. James Version and must respect his father. h ' S •• ~ "respect," while connotations connotations are in "Ye ~4hile shall today's to today's similar, and in Leviticus 19:3, fear every man his "each of you The \o10rds "fear" and have different language. reader ambiguities the NIV states, mother and father they are to For example, states, " open "Fear" that "respect" meanings and has negative does not have. While we are quick to say that one must respect one's parents, we do not wish to say that one should be afraid of one's parents, in the modern sense of the word. The NRSV uses the word "re\'ere" which has somewhat different connotations from both "respect" and ,-- 5 "fear". A teacher must attempt to decide which version seems to maintain the intent of the scripture and which is least likely to be misunderstood by youths. Thus, these factors all must be considered when deciding which versions of the Bible text to use. A the teacher must also consider how materials. The Nazarine, the Bible text is used in UMC, Cook and Lutheran materials large amount of reading directly from plan for a the May 17, instance, 1992, students read aloud John 20: the Bible. For lesson of the Nazarine materials has 1-8, The December 1, 24-29. 1QQ? -----, lesson of the Cook UMC materials requires students to look up and read aloud John 8: - Exodus Isa. 7: 14 ; readings. The 3: 16 ; only the Micah Lutheran 1992, verse I 9 : 6; Micah 5 .• -, ? • and 53:5; Matthew 1:18-23; and lessons have Church only a Isa. text and Isa. Others denominations' September 1, how John aloud, providing ""eek. Isaiah 7:14; 58; 3:14 in the lesson activities. read 56, Luke 2:4-7 comparable in lists the of lessons provide shorter texts to of memory verse God's for the youth lessons week. For usually example, the lesson of the Church of God materials contains John 3:1 which students are to memorize for the Whichever materials are used, well acquainted the students the teacher must determine are with the Bible before the teacher can properly decide what amount of class time to spend on reading and/or memorizing the Bible text. Lesson Book Text A good teacher must also consider the lesson book text to be used by the students. Is the text written in understandable and 6 and are age-appropriate language, easily understood and followed? the directions Moreover, and questions does the text include Bible stories and/or modern stories to apply Biblical truths? All the lesson materials I reviewed are written clearly with the directions and questions easily also age-appropriate. But, division of the for December 1992, 8, Cook UMC lessons and lessons SBC sentimental the junior high lesson of understandable. were somewhat age students. the Cook Most are the younger simplistic and example, the For UMC materials begins as follows: Angels? Don't they sit on clouds and play harps? And they have wings Bible, and halos, right? Not exactly. angels were God's messengers. In the J4.ngels ,,,ere present when God created the earth and made Adam and Eve. Angels also knew about God's plan to send His only Son, Jesus, to earth. Today's story is told from the view of the archangel Gabriel. This passage insults teacher will he/she find that by will be believes in the offended the intelligence of the time by the of angels. in general, Bible texts which lack events in the Bible. For instance, in junior implication that wings and halo version divisions of the SBC lessons, paraphrasing of a child is the students. the Acts 16: 23-34. The lesson's high he/she still The are highly younger simplified adequate descriptions of October 13, 1991, retells part of the story of Paul and Silas in prison. text is A version gives lesson The Bible only the 7 basic actions that were do just as well to taken by the character. save the church A teacher would money and read rather than bother with a straight from the Bible, the account lesson which adds nothing towards understanding. The Cook UMC lessons, division of the Church of God Bible stories and also Bible the SBC The truths. paraphrase the lessons, younger lessons generally paraphrase include modern stories to help Nazarine and Lutheran Bible stories but rather move the Bible stories to analogous modern stories. lessons and the Older and the division of the the apply the lessons do not them directly from The Cokesbury UMC Church of God lessons do not employ Bible stories, but rather focus more heavily on modern Again, the teacher stories to illustrate Biblical truths. consider whether students need more Bible story review must or need more discussion of modern applications of the Biblical truths. Suggested Classtime Activities A teacher should readings which also consider are included activities other in lessons. These activities could include mental puzzles (such as mazes, crosswords, singing, teacher must and activities whether crafts. are The age-appropriate, supplies, space, or time have than the consider etc.), games, whether the sufficient variety, and are adequate to complete the activities in class. The activities in the lessons I reviewed are age-appropriate, neither too easy or too difficult, with the exception of the 8 the SBC lessons, younger division of For example, too simple. like "Acts questions older division of the but the October 6, is in lesson, difficult about person irritates with whether or one is that they are. student to strengthen the "list n student must answer a Christmas importance student, of your aspects that you can November 24, agree or in several disagree contemporary for every The activity provides no poor examples for with the personally the good which examples. date provides gift" or contrasts, ways that In the are asked to an "give a would greatly The C'hurch activity in which he/she elderly person's house" or "talk providing the October 6, "list some ways impact of the good same in some posi'tive with respect." the more difficult good Christians. contrast for the lesson comparison, to "list some story characters examples are behaving as "Get you, the students not lessc·n has simple In T your difficult person," and SBC lesson, 1991, For example, are asked students 1991, activities were much Church of God lessons asks treat your difficult person the the N more meaningful questions. 1991, whose of God which the would rather d""· Christmas gift"; "clean an to a friend on the phone." Church making individual of God choices lesson more stresses the evident to the than the SBC lesson does. All the lesson plans have a degree of variety in activities. Usually the student materials selection of Bible-based mental provide only reading and a puzzles. The teacher's book then provides suggestions for object lessons, games, and Grafts. Only .- 9 suggest singing and provide the SSC materials The Cokesbury UMC interest-providing provide the lessons activities for vivid songs with music. greatest variety object lessons, and such as candle lightings to represent the "light of the world" and making to be passed out leaflets the Cook UMC lessons which games, but few give The else'.07here. least interesting is suggest leaving time practical suggestions, for crafts and leaving thus it entirely to the teacher to be creative or not creative. The lessons the availability I reviewed and expense of teachers the scissors, construction paper, most difficult to obtain UMC. These include supplies. books, lists in The all give adequate candles, other somewhat more expensive such as consideration to Most paper, include supply pencils, other inexpensive craft are those listed balls of string, items. glue, supplies. by the Cokesbury index The Cokesbury cards, and UMC lessons also require more planning ahead on the part of the teacher. Some of the activities cause space problems. UMC lessons require rooms the from different lesson For instance, require availability of where singing will plans could a few lessons from the Cook a kitchen; the not bother other SSC lessons classes; and older Church of God lessons require floor space for physical games. The time. lessons other Cokesbury UMC lessons give the best consideration of A well-prepared teacher could complete most of the object in fifteen activities. to twenty minutes, For example, the leaving class December 1, 1991, time for lesson .- 10 provides a plan for a five-minute object lesson The teacher merely pours water from effective. bowl while students watch and read a pitcher into a in aloud Philippians 2:5-11 of pride. which Christ "emptied himself" which is quite The idea is expressed orally and strongly reinforced visually. The Cook UMC and the Lutheran too short for the time provided, provide more than lesson activities are often while the Church of God lessons can be completed in class. example, For class could read through and complete the activities provided the December 1, 1991, lesson of the Cook UMC materials or more. This leaves in in about thirty minutes, while a typical class time at a local UMC is around forty-five minutes, a church the teacher with fifteen minutes or longer to occupy the students' interests. In contrast, the younger division of the Church of God lesson for December 1, 1991, exercise, a short story of two pages to read aloud and discuss, word-find puzzle, includes a an singing while walking exercise in which behavior of six hypothetical characters, self evaluation questions for are to be completed, discussion or prayer, be hard the teacher plan. But, students evaluate a the and a series of personal students to answer. with any extra .Fl.ll activities, of these such as in one hour. A teacher of this lesson would pressed to complete the students were slow or be, along in a circle activities in an hour. disorganized, could not If the as junior high students possibly complete the entire can lesson this is better than not having enough materials. 11 Time becomes a consider not must portion of an required major concern only lesson, individual teacher for time much ho~" A for a teacher. exposition is available but also and explanation teacher for each time is follo~"ed by interactive student activities to complete the learning process. the plans In spent I the largest revie~"ed, by the students reading aloud; by the teacher giving directions, lesson to students; student-input in The and the third puzzle best plans are Church of God, the other plans. the time that fifty to student plans allow for t1flenty to to n' . _l.SCUSSl.on. the older division of the discussion than of God plans allow compared to and explaining and least portion of time, allot more time to student the other minutes, leading prayers, activities and The Church time is the second largest is spent the Nazarine and which section of close to twice discussion-- forty twenty-five for to an hour lesson. Another consideration effectiveness of the for lessons. a teacher is the Colorfulness and visual variety spark interest better than drabness. The lessons both photographs exception, reviewed are and art~.,ork generally having photographs Lutheran I overlaid with full range of bright colors. The regular dull lessons are the most lesson printed on different . mostly colorful and blue Nazarine black and or red. attractive to the bright \¥ith lessons are an white text and Overall, the eye, ,,,i th each colored paper and with artwork in a 12 It only one church provided me too. But, thus I could make compare visual aids would be interesting to with visual aids, no comparisons. Remember though that good visual aids are a great plus The more in instruction. learning, senses employed in the more memorable the lesson is. Another consideration for a teacher is of continuity. be taken home All the lesson plans for the week. Nazarine plans The allow for part of than in class. called the Pix for home activities. The Cook the allow for the materials to Church of God plans and the lesson to be which the done at home UMC lessons include student to read, a leaflet contains a story and Most plans provide a memory verse to be learned for the week. The Cokesbury Church of God lessons provide readings. whether or not and whether they have a sense lessons are extended into the week rather that are UMC and the younger division of the lists of daily devotional Bible Work throughout the week should help students remember what they learned the week before. Other ways may be used to establish continuity throughout series of lessons. example, For the SSC lessons for establish continuity through the theme of witnessing. plans that relied more continuity by chronology heavily on Bible or by order of the a 1991 The lesson stories establish books of the Bible. Those that focused more heavily on modern stories do not maintain continuity from classtime to classtime. expectation of surprise to hold the students' Lesson Topics and Issues They rely more interests. on 13 Lastly, the topics and issues covered by the lessons teacher's greatest concern. main divisions of problems and the covered: the first such as loneliness, social other is The lessons I reviewed fall into two the topics issues concerns such as divorce, abortion, morality. issues, easily addressed with particular scriptures. address I plans include is personal greed,and witnessing; sexual ~.l are a discussion of and personal While these the emotions, they are not as emotionally charged as the subjects of the second division. Unfortunately such concerns are becoming more students. the and more the problems Of the lessons I reviewed, Church of God lessons and of younger and younger only the older divisions of the SBC lessons directly address these concerns and support statements with Bible texts. The September 8, immorality. helping It provides for personal or make materials, The abortion. and discussion of the subject, students to define their ot,.m decisions. texts 1991, Church of God lesson condemns sexual Unfortunately, particular to make their the moral lesson does not provide Bible suggestions Galatians the student although these are suggested in the teacher's guide. September 15, The lesson 1991, Church abortion, 1:15-16, Leviticus 24:17, of God lesson provides statistics on describes abortion procedures. against in based on Genesis fetal development Then it takes a moral stance Psalm 139:13-16, 9: 6 , and Matthew 1:18-20. condemns Exodus Jeremiah 1:4-4, Ex. 21:22, 20:13, 14 The older It bases its and condemns abortion also. Genesis 1:28a, 13-15, discussion and includes a lesson discusses decision on Psalm 139: 1:15-2:20, Matthew Exodus and Deuteronomy 14-19:14-15, 1991, division SBC January 19, 18:10a. 18:10, Matthew The lesson provides personal account and an address for where students can get more information on the topic. In addition, death of a personal texts, the December 15, loved one, illnesses. discussion time, and the Each lesson deals \.. ith lesson provides Bible I believe the older division Church of God lessons plans that I controversial 1992, and advice to help the students. older division effective SBC lesson deals with the and the March 22, debilitating Overall, 1991, of the SBC lessons reviewed. issues and Their are th·e best, most willingness to address their reliance on Biblical authority outweighs any drawbacks such as slightly more difficult language, limited activities and the lack of illustrative Bible stories. Finally, positions on lessons should not such contemporary understood by the youth, encourage student and and about living issues in order a but also be moral easily and incorporate as much variety to keep learning about God, as religious, reliable and readable Bible texts, participation, color possible, enthusiastic about have only provide Christian controversial issues requiring personal, students about in a interested and being a Christian, world with moral decisions. Proposal for the Rehoboth UMC Class many 15 To meet the needs of that the teacher of this Sunday school take design his/her own series of lessons, collected UMC from the Cook I am proposing these young students, the initiative and topics based on ideas lessons, other lesson available at local Christian bookstores, to materials and his/her own creative planning. Based on the plan to high above research, improve the religious Sunday school class I now would like education process for at my Methodist Church in Parker City, church, time every Sunday. is spent in school approximately 45 Approximately 15 receives and uses specific budget, for an minutes but Cook limited it United that adult and youth Sunday class UMC meets from minutes of opening program, for actual the basic Rehoboth grades 5-8; the sanctuary with all classes assembled the the junior Indiana. This class averages 5-6 students, 9:30 to 10:30 to propose a thus leaving time. The lessons. supplementary class There is no materials can be purchased upon request. Some flaws in the Cook UMC lessons the class presently uses include insufficient suggested activities classtime, few specific object lessons, ideas and and failure to fill the instructions for to address pertinent which more and more junior high students are facing. Some Essentials available crafts and social issues 16 Plan to Bible Text: use the NIV for in class reading and the King James Version for daily devotions. Lesson In addition Text: to NIV passages, tell modern stories which illustrate the NIV text used in the lesson. Include activities such as pencil puzzles such Activities: as crosswords and mazes, type crafts, and object lessons. usually should be used each week, A different but some large activities could be used during several class sessions. Lesson plans: Provide ideas and instructions or information for weekday activities and community activities. Topics including, divorce, but issues: not envy, Address limited and euthanasia. loneliness, addition, and to social abortion, sexual Also address personal lack of faith and address basic Biblical topics, fall of humanity, topics and sin and salvation, lack issues, immorality, problems such as of commitment. In such as creation and the and the teachings of Christ. Sample Lesson Plan Preparation: Gather materials necessary to complete activities for class. For this lesson's activity, need scissors, glue, you will letter-size envelopes, and green and yellow chenille wire. Read through the lesson and make notes on points you wish to emphasize most in discussion. Pray for guidance in giving the lesson and pray for the needs of individual students. 17 Remember to remain flexible to the needs of the students. Sunday, 9:45: Class meets after Sunday School opening general assembly. Begin with prayer. Assign opening prayer to a different student each week for the following week, to encourage thoughtful prayer and to develop students' ability to speak in front of others. Introduce the lesson topic. For example, the topic may be "The Role of Money in Our Lives. Read aloud the Bible text, which could be Matthew 6:28-30 (NIV). Ask pertinent questions of the students in order to start them thinking critically on the subject. example, ask "Why do we need money?"; our lives be like without money?"; For "What would "What things in your life do you give more importance than money?" 10:00 Read the lesson. Allow students to read aloud giving prompting where needed. Remember students will recall the lesson better if they are forced into attention by reading it - . themselves . 18 Be willing to pause where students feel a need to discuss what they have read. 10:15 Begin the activity. Give instructions while passing out the materials. As the children work on the activity or craft, continue discussion on the lesson topic. Explain how the activity illustrates the points made in the lesson. For this lesson, the activity could be making paper lilies. Give students an envelope, a green chenille wire, and a yellow one for each lily they are to make. Instruct them to cut off each of the bottom corners of the envelope to make two triangles as large as can be cut from the envelope. Then, cut the very tip off the triangles and open to make them like funnels. angle. Place one inside the other at a right Next fold the yellow chenille wire in half. Make a small curl on each end. Wrap one end of the green chenille wire around the bend in the yellow wire. Then, Place a small drop of glue on the bend. draw other end of the green wire through the small hole of the envelope funnel so that the yellow wire sits in the cup of it. Curl the corners of the envelope around a pencil. ,,- 19 Bring out the points you wish to illustrate while the activity is in progress. For example, you could discuss how inexpensive it was to make the paper lilies, point out how God provides flowers at no expense to us, ask students if they can think of other things God provides for us. If no one mentions salvation, be sure to add that to their list. 10:25 Summarize the lesson. Answer any last minute questions. Give assignments for weekly readings, projects, and for next weeks prayer. For example, you could assign students to read William E. Barret's The Lilies of the Field, or the teacher might rent the film of the novel for the class to watch as a group. Also, the class might plant flowers for the church or for a group in the community such as the local nursing home. Tell the topic of next week's lesson, which could be Christ dying for our individual sins. Encourage students to think about how he died, he died, and how his death can enable us to become Christians. Encourage them to bring their thoughts and ,- questions to the next class meeting 10:30 Dismiss. why ,- 20 Works Consulted Dall, Jeanette, Nancy Hurst, Sharon K. Johnson, Lois Keffer, Lorraine Triggs, and Carol Watkins. Bible Adventures, Junior Creative Teaching Aids, Elgin: and Pix. Lorraine Triggs, ed. David C. Cook Publishing Co., 1991. Douglas, Jenni and Sally O. Langford. Trek Teacher Idea Book and Trek Student Leaflets. John O. Gooch and Janet E. Lowdermilk, eds. Nashville: Edwards, Rick, ed. Junior High. Cokesbury, 1991. Action/Reaction: Student Response Sheets-Kansas City: WordAction Publishing Co., 1991. Holy Bible Authorized King James Version. John D. Davis, G. Earnest Wright, Philadelphia: and Floyd V. Wilson, eds. Westminster Press, 1948. Holy Bible New International Version. Grand Rapids: Corporation, Zondervan 1983. Newell, Arlo F. Journey with the Word: Children III. Teacher book and student leaflets. Anderson: Warner Press, Inc., 1991. ----- Journey with the Word: Youth I. Teacher book and student leaflets. Anderson: Warner Press, Inc., 1991. New Oxford Annotated Bible with Apocrypha Revised Standard Version. Herbert G. May and Bruce M. Metzger, eds. New York: Oxford University Press, 1973. O'Connor, Bryan, Roger Sonneberg, and Tom Nummela. Our Life In Christ: Junior High Teachers Guide. Concordia Publishing House, 1991. Saint Louis: 21 Sunday School Board of the Souther Baptist Convention. Sunday School Youth. Nashville: Sunday School Board of the Southern Baptist convention, 1991. -----Children's Bible Study: Teacher. Nashville: Sunday School Board of the Southern Baptist Convention, 1991. Whelply, Hal Jr. Junior High Bible Study. Saint Louis: Concordia Publishing House, 1991.