CHAPTER 5 LINKAGE AND GENETIC MAPPING IN EUKARYOTES Copyright ©The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc. Permission required for reproduction or display INTRODUCTION Each species of organism must contain hundreds to thousands of genes Yet most species have at most a few dozen chromosomes Therefore, each chromosome is likely to carry many hundred or even thousands of different genes The transmission of such genes will violate Mendel’s law of independent assortment Copyright ©The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc. Permission required for reproduction or display 5-2 5.1 LINKAGE AND CROSSING OVER In eukaryotic species, each linear chromosome contains a long piece of DNA A typical chromosome contains many hundred or even a few thousand different genes The term linkage has two related meanings 1. Two or more genes can be located on the same chromosome 2. Genes that are close together tend to be transmitted as a unit Linkage influences inheritance patterns Copyright ©The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc. Permission required for reproduction or display 5-3 Chromosomes are called linkage groups They contain a group of genes that are linked together The number of linkage groups is the number of types of chromosomes of the species For example, in humans 22 autosomal linkage groups An X chromosome linkage group A Y chromosome linkage group Genes that are far apart on the same chromosome may independently assort from each other This is due to crossing-over A dihybrid cross studies crossing-over between two genes A trihybrid cross studies crossing-over between three genes Copyright ©The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc. Permission required for reproduction or display 5-4 Crossing Over May Produce Recombinant Phenotypes In diploid eukaryotic species, linkage can be altered during meiosis as a result of crossing over Crossing over Occurs during prophase I of meiosis replicated sister chromatid homologues associate as bivalents Non-sister chromatids of homologous chromosomes exchange DNA segments Figure 5.1 illustrates the consequences of crossing over during meiosis Copyright ©The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc. Permission required for reproduction or display 5-5 The haploid cells contain the same combination of alleles as the original chromosomes The arrangement of linked alleles has not been altered Figure 5.1 5-6 These haploid cells contain a combination of alleles NOT found in the original chromosomes These are termed parental or nonrecombinant cells Figure 5.1 This new combination of alleles is a result of genetic recombination These are termed nonparental or recombinant cells 5-7 Bateson and Punnett Discovered Two Traits That Did Not Assort Independently In 1905, William Bateson and Reginald Punnett conducted a cross in sweet pea involving two different traits This is a dihybrid cross that is expected to yield a 9:3:3:1 phenotypic ratio in the F2 generation Flower color and pollen shape However, Bateson and Punnett obtained surprising results Refer to Figure 5.2 Copyright ©The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc. Permission required for reproduction or display 5-8 Figure 5.2 A much greater proportion of the two types found in the parental generation 5-9 Bateson and Punnett Discovered Two Traits That Did Not Assort Independently They suggested that the transmission of the two traits from the parents was somehow coupled The two traits are not easily assorted in an independent manner However, they did not realize that the coupling is due to the linkage of the two genes on the same chromosome Copyright ©The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc. Permission required for reproduction or display 5-10 Morgan Provided Evidence for the Linkage of Several X-linked Genes The first direct evidence of linkage came from studies of Thomas Hunt Morgan Morgan investigated several traits that followed an X-linked pattern of inheritance Figure 5.3 illustrates an experiment involving three traits Body color Eye color Wing length Copyright ©The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc. Permission required for reproduction or display 5-11 Figure 5.3 5-12 P Males P Females Morgan observed a much higher proportion of the combinations of traits found in the parental generation Morgan’s explanation: All three genes are located on the X chromosome Therefore, they tend to be transmitted together as a unit Copyright ©The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc. Permission required for reproduction or display 5-13 Genetic maps allow us to estimate the relative distances between linked genes, based on the likelihood that a crossover will occur between them Experimentally, the percentage of recombinant offspring is correlated with the distance between the two genes If the genes are far apart many recombinant offspring If the genes are close very few recombinant offspring Number of recombinant offspring X 100 Map distance = Total number of offspring The units of distance are called map units (mu) They are also referred to as centiMorgans (cM) One map unit is equivalent to 1% recombination frequency Copyright ©The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc. Permission required for reproduction or display 5-45 Genetic mapping experiments are typically accomplished by carrying out a testcross A mating between an individual that is heterozygous for two or more genes and one that is homozygous recessive for the same genes Figure 5.9 provides an example of a testcross This cross concerns two linked genes affecting bristle length and body color in fruit flies e = ebony body color e+ = gray body color One parent displays both recessive traits s = short bristles s+ = normal bristles It is homozygous recessive for the two genes (ss ee) The other parent is heterozygous for the two genes The s and e alleles are linked on one chromosome The s+ and e+ alleles are linked on the homologous chromosome Copyright ©The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc. Permission required for reproduction or display 5-46 Chromosomes are the product of a crossover during meiosis in the heterozygous parent Recombinant offspring are fewer in number than nonrecombinant offspring Figure 5.9 5-47 The data at the bottom of Figure 5.9 can be used to estimate the distance between the two genes Number of recombinant offspring X 100 Map distance = Total number of offspring = 76 + 75 542 + 537 + 76 + 75 X 100 = 12.3 map units Therefore, the s and e genes are 12.3 map units apart from each other along the same chromosome Copyright ©The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc. Permission required for reproduction or display 5-48 Alfred Sturtevant’s Experiment The first genetic map was constructed in 1911 by Alfred Sturtevant He was an undergraduate who spent time in the laboratory of Thomas Hunt Morgan Sturtevant wrote: “In conversation with Morgan … I suddenly realized that the variations in the length of linkage, already attributed by Morgan to differences in the spatial orientation of the genes, offered the possibility of determining sequences [of different genes] in the linear dimension of the chromosome. I went home and spent most of the night (to the neglect of my undergraduate homework) in producing the first chromosome map, which included the sex-linked genes, y, w, v, m, and r, in the order and approximately the relative spacing that they still appear on the standard maps.” Copyright ©The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc. Permission required for reproduction or display 5-49 Sturtevant considered the outcome of crosses involving six different mutant alleles All of which are known to be recessive and X-linked Mutant allele (Phenotype) Wild-type allele (Phenotype) y (yellow body color) y+ (gray body color) w (white eye color) w+ (red eye color) w-e (eosin eye color) w-e+ (red eye color) Alleles of the same gene Alleles of different genes that affect eye color v (vermillion eye color) v+ (red eye color) m (miniature wings) m+ (normal wings) r (rudimentary wings) r+ (normal wings) Alleles of different genes that affect wing length Therefore, his genetic map contained only 5 genes y, w, v, m and r Copyright ©The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc. Permission required for reproduction or display 5-50 The Hypothesis The distance between genes on a chromosome can be estimated from the proportion of recombinant offspring This provides a way to map the order of genes along a chromosome Testing the Hypothesis Refer to Figure 5.10 Copyright ©The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc. Permission required for reproduction or display 5-51 Figure 5.10 5-52 The Data Alleles Concerned Number Recombinant/ Percent Recombinant Total Number Offspring y and w/w-e 214/21,736 1.0 y and v 1,464/4,551 32.2 y and r 115/324 35.5 y and m 260/693 37.5 w/w-e and v 471/1,584 29.7 w/w-e and r 2,062/6,116 33.7 w/w-e and m 406/898 45.2 v and r 17/573 3.0 v and m 109/405 26.9 Copyright ©The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc. Permission required for reproduction or display 5-53 Interpreting the Data In some dihybrid crosses, the percentage of nonparental (recombinant) offspring was rather low For example, there’s only 1% recombinant offspring in the crosses involving the y and w or w-e alleles This suggests that these two genes are very close together Other dihybrid crosses showed a higher percentage of nonparental offspring For example, crosses between the v and m alleles produced 26.9% recombinant offspring This suggests that these two genes are farther apart Copyright ©The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc. Permission required for reproduction or display 5-54 To construct his map, Sturtevant assumed that the map distances would be more accurate among genes that are closely linked Therefore, his map is based on the following distances y – w (1.0), w – v (29.7), v – r (3.0) and v – m (26.9) Sturtevant also considered other features of the data to deduce the order of genes For example, Percentage of crossovers between w and r was 33.7 Percentage of crossovers between w and v was 29.7 Percentage of crossovers between v and r was 3.0 Therefore, the gene order is w – v – r Where v is closer to r than it is to w Copyright ©The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc. Permission required for reproduction or display 5-55 Sturtevant collectively considered all these data and proposed the following genetic map Do not have a JPG for this Sturtevant began at the y gene and mapped the genes from left to right Copyright ©The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc. Permission required for reproduction or display 5-56 A close look at Sturtevant’s data reveals two points that do not agree very well with his genetic map The y and m dihybrid cross yielded 37.5% recombinants But the map distance is 57.6 The w and m dihybrid cross yielded 45.2% recombinants But the map distance is 56.6 So what’s up? As the percentage of recombinant offspring approaches a value of 50% The likelihood of multiple crossovers increases Even numbers of crossover won’t be seen as recombination So the observed recombinations tend to underestimate the actual measure of map distance Refer to Figure 5.11 Copyright ©The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc. Permission required for reproduction or display 5-57 Figure 5.11 Multiple crossovers set a quantitative limit on measurable recombination frequencies as the physical distance increases A testcross is expected to yield a maximum of only 50% recombinant offspring Copyright ©The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc. Permission required for reproduction or display 5-58 Trihybrid Crosses Data from trihybrid crosses can also yield information about map distance and gene order The following experiment outlines a common strategy for using trihybrid crosses to map genes In this example, we will consider fruit flies that differ in body color, eye color and wing shape b = black body color b+ = gray body color pr = purple eye color pr+ = red eye color vg = vestigial wings vg+ = normal wings Copyright ©The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc. Permission required for reproduction or display 5-59 Step 1: Cross two true-breeding strains that differ with regard to three alleles. Do not have a JPG for this Female is mutant for all three traits Male is homozygous wildtype for all three traits The goal in this step is to obtain F1 individuals that are heterozygous for all three genes Copyright ©The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc. Permission required for reproduction or display 5-60 Step 2: Perform a testcross by mating F1 female heterozygotes to male flies that are homozygous recessive for all three alleles Do not have a JPG for this During gametogenesis in the heterozygous female F1 flies, crossovers may produce new combinations of the 3 alleles Copyright ©The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc. Permission required for reproduction or display 5-61 Step 3: Collect data for the F2 generation 5-62 Analysis of the F2 generation flies will allow us to map the three genes The three genes exist as two alleles each Therefore, there are 23 = 8 possible combinations of offspring If the genes assorted independently, all eight combinations would occur in equal proportions It is obvious that they are far from equal In the offspring of crosses involving linked genes, Parental phenotypes occur most frequently Double crossover phenotypes occur least frequently Single crossover phenotypes occur with “intermediate” frequency Copyright ©The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc. Permission required for reproduction or display 5-63 The combination of traits in the double crossover tells us which gene is in the middle A double crossover separates the gene in the middle from the other two genes at either end Do not have a JPG for this In the double crossover categories, the recessive purple eye color is separated from the other two recessive alleles Thus, the gene for eye color lies between the genes for body color and wing shape Copyright ©The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc. Permission required for reproduction or display 5-64 Step 4: Calculate the map distance between pairs of genes To do this, one strategy is to regroup the data according to pairs of genes From the parental generation, we know that the dominant alleles are linked, as are the recessive alleles This allows us to group pairs of genes into parental and nonparental combinations Parentals have a pair of dominant or a pair of recessive alleles Nonparentals have one dominant and one recessive allele The regrouped data will allow us to calculate the map distance between the two genes Copyright ©The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc. Permission required for reproduction or display 5-65 Parental offspring Gray body, red eyes (411 + 61) Black body, purple eyes (412 + 60) Total Nonparental Offspring Total 472 Gray body, purple eyes (30 + 2) 32 472 Black body, red eyes (28 + 1) 29 944 61 The map distance between body color and eye color is Map distance = 61 944 + 61 X 100 = 6.1 map units 5-66 Parental offspring Gray body, normal wings (411 + 2) Black body, vestigial wings (412 + 1) Total Nonparental Offspring Total 413 Gray body, vestigial wings (30 + 61) 91 413 Black body, normal wings (28 + 60) 88 826 179 The map distance between body color and wing shape is Map distance = 179 826 + 179 X 100 = 17.8 map units 5-67 Parental offspring Red eyes, normal wings (411 + 28) Purple eyes, vestigial wings (412 + 30) Total Nonparental Offspring Total 439 Red eyes, vestigial wings (61 + 1) 62 442 Purple eyes, normal wings (60 + 2) 62 881 124 The map distance between eye color and wing shape is Map distance = 124 881 + 124 X 100 = 12.3 map units 5-68 Step 5: Construct the map Based on the map unit calculation the body color and wing shape genes are farthest apart The eye color gene is in the middle Do not have a JPG for this The data is also consistent with the map being drawn as vg – pr – b (from left to right) In detailed genetic maps, the locations of genes are mapped relative to the centromere Copyright ©The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc. Permission required for reproduction or display 5-69 To calculate map distance, we have gone through a method that involved the separation of data into pairs of genes (see step 4) An alternative method does not require this manipulation Rather, the trihybrid data is used directly This method is described next Copyright ©The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc. Permission required for reproduction or display 5-70 Phenotype Number of Observed Offspring Gray body, purple eyes, vestigial wings 30 Black body, red eyes, normal wings 28 Gray body, red eyes, vestigial wings 61 Black body, purple eyes, normal wings 60 Gray body, purple eyes, normal wings 2 Black body, red eyes, vestigial wings 1 Single crossover between b and pr 30 + 28 = 0.058 1,005 Single crossover between pr and vg 61 + 60 Double crossover, between b and pr, and between pr and vg 1+2 = 0.120 1,005 = 0.003 1,005 Copyright ©The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc. Permission required for reproduction or display 5-71 To determine the map distance between the genes, we need to consider both single and double crossovers To calculate the distance between b and pr Map distance = (0.058 + 0.003) X 100 = 6.1 mu To calculate the distance between pr and vg Map distance = (0.120 + 0.003) X 100 = 12.3 mu To calculate the distance between b and vg The double crossover frequency needs to be multiplied by two Because both crossovers are occurring between b and vg Map distance = (0.058 + 0.120 + 2[0.003]) X 100 = 18.4 mu Copyright ©The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc. Permission required for reproduction or display 5-72 Alternatively, the distance between b and vg can be obtained by simply adding the map distances between b and pr, and between pr and vg Map distance = 6.1 + 12.3 = 18.4 mu Note that in the first method (grouping in pairs), the distance between b and vg was found to be 17.8 mu. This slightly lower value was a small underestimate because the first method does not consider the double crossovers in the calculation Copyright ©The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc. Permission required for reproduction or display 5-73