df' ." "r'::_it._--: - Anorexia ;~crvosa 2nd Bulimarexl~: By .i 1!.' ~; i :; ::t;;;cie, - ) i .' j • (. t ("!' J:ldian~ DRn~erous Dietin~? ..... " · · .. em ... • - ,, When d O(~8 occupation? ;) fact C(:80(' to be a fno and turn .i n to a pre- Fow far will our society go in the pursuit of the body beautiful? In modern day America, the glorification of thinness has gone a bit too far. What started as a healthy concern for physical fitness seems to have blossomed into an all out obsession. Individuals are constantly bom- barded by the notion of the ideal body and what should be done to achieve it. Diets, exercise programs, and an unending number of fads proclaim the easy way to the perfect figurp. also extends this emphasis by images. pro~oting The media extremely conflicting Consumers see aDd hear that "thin i8 in," bu~ at the same time are overwhelr::ed with food commercials and acts to t.C'!1irt thcT:' ;l't!::,v from thjnncs~3. Tn reaLity, for r::o:-,t inJivld- uals, the two messages are not conpatible. What actually constitutes the ideal physique? An ultra- slim sleek aprearance is achieved only by precious few high fashion models. Why then are we so driven to reach this often unattainabJ e and unhealthy goal? completely clear, but this phenomenon so:r.c [~cr iOlls con~;equenc('s. - ~ay have brought about .Ao a 1 iX ely resul t of our soch' ty' s preoccupation with thinness, eating more and more prevalent. rrhis anrc;wer is not disord~rs are becoming It is of little wondpr that many have turned to food or its denial a3 a crutch. In rr.ar,y c2.ses, 1'-- - , 2 - these eating disorders are not merely an extreme form of dieting, but are often a manifestation of underlying emotional problems. Individuals affected with eating disorders involve food in their attr·mpt to solve problems. two such disorders that involve food as a means to solve problems, arl' Rnorexic) n crvosa and bul irnarexia. J~ 1_ thouC;h ev(~ry is distinct in its own way, many similarities and can be drawn. casC' ~Jarall cIs The signs, symptoms, treatments and prognoses surrounding these disorders will be pres~nted in ttis paper in an attcmrt to offer insi r;ht into pro1)lcms. Defininf thr disorders tiThe condition of self-inflicted starvation, without recognizable organic disease and in thE: midst of ample food is usually diagnosed as 8norexia nervosa. tI 1 There seems to be vast agreement that anorexia nervosa involves the willful and irrational starving of oneself. It is an extreme pursuit of weight Joss that often timeD becomes life ihrcateninr. This disorder, although receiving much recent attention, has in actL1 8li t:~T been in existence for many hundreds of years Dating fron almost 300 years ago, can finel various evidence we of the existence of 2.r..orexia nerVOS8. In 1629, an T'nglis>_ physician, l-:ic!:1ard j'orton, publishE:d a dissertation on .he termed "nervous consul.ption." 2 V/['cit VIi th his discri}Jtion of 3 emaciation, amenorrhea and other symptoms, one can now see that he was describing anorexia nervosa. The actual term "anorexia nervosa" originated in 1873. ately described tr]e symptoms of tne disorder "md so named l"t • 3 These early accounts were fairly accurate descriptions, even by today's standards. fairly accurate But while these citings were in their descriptions, these findings were considered very rare. In 1960, researchers Bliss and ranch defined anorexia ncrvosa as "a nonspecific diagnosis relatinc: to woight lOGS from any emotional cause.,,4 They believed that anorexia nervosa was a sysmptom of psychiatric disorrlers rather than a distinct disorder in itself. The patients in their studies had nothing ~ore in common than weight 10ss.5 After 1960, there was in increase in research :md mnterials put 1 1isi:C'd, prohabJ.y due to the frlct. th:Jt cn.;,('s of anorexia nervosa have been increasing in frequency. This in- crease SeeTllS to be linked with society's attitudes and t'1P ' u ro 1 e 0 f wo~cn t ouay. At thp present tiMe, it is est.imatpd /' t.hat as many as one in tvro ilw_dred fifty fern.a182 between -the ages of twelvE" 211d eighteen years of " 7 dlsorder.' ~~e 8[;e condition also occurs in olll'-tenth tile Crr'qucncy. vii 11 develop the ~a1es, but with only f~ Wi th the increase in roSC?rCll, the sY:l1ptorrs of anorexia - 4 - nervosa have noVl been better defined. In recent years, Hilde Professor of Psychiatry at Baylor College of r.ledicine, Pruch is one of the foremost authorities on anorexia nervosa. t!ot W1til her research, was anorexia nervosa considered a distinct disorder. 9 Now experts have agreed upon three major criteria for diagnosis which include: (1) loss of at least twenty-five percent of original body weight, (2) amenorrhea for at least three months and (3) a distorted body image. 10 The first characteristic, that of weight loss, is fairly self-explanatory. Original body weieht refers to weight before the illness and before any measurable loss. This loss of 25 per cent of the often is a result cf slim~ing pati~nts bcdy weieht most gone haywire. loss program, but as the anorectic finds that For the majority s~e is suc- cessful at losing weight, this in itself becomes reward eno;)~:h to continue lowering her weiE'ht to extremes. The second diagnostic characteristic, amenorrhea, occurs i.n virtually all aIlorectic patients.. This cessation of the menstrual cycle may well be linked to the loss of body fat. ~tudics have indicated that the beeinning of the menstrual cycle is most influenced by body-fat composition (often reflected in weight) rather than age, so in effect, .- this loss of body weieht causes something like a reversal of 5 - puberty.11 It is in tersting to note, however , that in ma."'1Y cases, the cessation of menstruation preceeds weight 108s_ And in many cases, even with weight gain, there may still be menstrual problems. 12 The third characteristic is a disorted body image. Hilde Bruch vms trw first to suggest that ih(~re is an identi- fiable disturbance in body image among anorectics. Since then, it has been accerted and is used as a major characteristic for l;ven ire ('xtreme cases, tho ;wlor,'ctic nati"Y't di[1c;no~3is. will deny that her state of emaciation is abnormaJ. Various studies, support tbe belief that anorecti cs bav,::' a deluded body conception. ~:ussC'11, OilS Using instruments designed by Slade and rCfJ"clrcllers h;lV(:' asked anorectiCE! to (,[;timate vc1ri- objects and body dimensions. It has generally been fc)und that anorectics overestimate body width, v.'hile they can fcli.rly accur2.tely estimate their height cmd widths of inanimate otjects~ It is true that all females in general overestimate lody width. The difference, however, lies in the dRcreo of overestimation and sl1bsefjuent denj.aJ of weir;ht -,.oss even 1 . ~ (' ponn, t ·nc 2'~ 0f . t· cmaCla' ,lnrl. 1) 'c':hile these three characteristics are 8grecd upon as di~g~ostic of anorexic nervosa, there are also other 0'ristics that t~ao - [iTe: c~ar~ct- useful in fnrther::1cfh:ihg thf; disorder. of resrarchrrs in St. LoUis, ;issouri furthered the definition in 19 7 2 with what are now teroed the Feighner 6 Criteria. F'sychiatrists l"eighner, ;\obins, and Guz(' produced a helpful guide for distinguishing cases of anorexia TIervosa from other disorders. 14 Cne ?Eig~~cr char2cteristic states that the onset of t}2C disorder nust is most likely due to the fact that girls of this age are concerned with fitting in with their peers. become weight ~onscious Teens often as they are very aware of their bodies and the changes occuring in them. bodies seems to be an easy \'JaY Forming their to self-improvement. Other characteristics di stinguish separate phases of fltti tud('s toward food and nutrition, and toward the handling of food itself. These attitudes include the denial of the experi- ence of hun.ger and the refusal to eat. Other 8.tti tudes to- ':lard food refer to ri tuals and behaviors concerninE preparation, eating, and hoarding of food~ The final Fci[hner character- istic states that there must be no other illnpss t1lat could DcC'olmt fnr !;~(; vf('j(~ht 1 r~ }O[;s. j T}'J's(' cri~.(,l'i;l "irq)]," to better (('fin (' the line between ?ctual (O~nor·::xia ~-'(rv(' nervosa amI other disorders. ts indicated earlier, certain physical characteristics serve as criteriR for c'-Ylorexia nervosa. such characteristic. Cth~r \:!eight Joss 18 onp physical characteristics also Rccompa.."1y the disorder, although they are hot necessarily diagnostic in nature as is weight - loss~ takes hold, the entire body is affected. When the disease Because of the 7 - extreme loss of body fat, the bones show through the surface of the skin, and the anorectic mny hav(! trouh Le 3 i ttinr~ or remaining in one position for any period of time, The skin becomes dry and develops an ashen yellow coloring. and nails become very brittle. The hair Low blood pressure and a d er. 16 · slow pu 1 se a 1 so accompany th e d lsor The second disorder that involves the use of food as a means of resolving problems is bulimare:da, also known as bulimia. Coined in 1974 by Harlene Boskind-Lode_hl, "bulirna- rexia" is a fairly recent term used to describe the practice of gorcing followed by fasting, vomiting, or purginc.17 While the Clllcient ter~ ~~OI:1C, is fairly new, the practice is not. [rU0sts and then continue to W:1S at In feasts would gorge thcr1[:;elv r-,;s, voni t, In e2~t. !~ome, prnctj('{,r1 rrc-dorninonUy by rnr'n, .. t 18 th 1 e prlTI:ary par t lClpans. 0 however, thj.s ri tuaJ 1:!hilr' today, WOr:1('n nT'(' inh . .1.• 1S prac tOO lce lS h~elnG used as 0 a means of weight control, mainly amone young wonen today. The number of p~rsons demonstrating bulimarectic weight con- trol is not accurately known, since patients with this disorder are typically very secretive e.bout their problem. studies, however, indicate that one out of every five college a p; e °t '0 1 mp n m(3 y (' x, ~ 1 tn· u 1 In arC' c t'1 0 W0 \ 0, J C 1) C h a vO lor I n \, ~) 0 met 1 0 rn c • 1CJ- Since the nature of bulimarexia is very secretive, it is diffic(ll t to pinpoint specific criteria. UYl~~iK (; 31'.orexia nervosa, there is not necessarily a marked weight loss to - 8 - signal the disorder. Some patients are only slightly under- weight, while most are of normal weight or slightly overweight. 20 rrhe majority, howevl'?r, have had weight problems in the past. 21 As with anorexia nervosa, a preoccupation with food exists, but this preoccupation manifests itself in quite a different JT1rumer. rrhe bulimarectic does not decrease her intake of food, bqt rather will eatinE binges. a:r:r;:meJ~ to overeat in 3ecrpt She will then rid her body of the food by secretly vomiting or using laxatives. It is likely that most cases, therefore, go unnoticed because of this secrecy. The bulimarectic will veil her actions in secrecy because of and relatives then are often of little help in detecting the problem, since v/eight remains fairly constant and social ' b '1 t s may seem norma 1 • 22 · ea t lng ha In the late 1970's, there VIas an increase in the amount l' "'terf'p.t c, ~ of re. ~p-earch_ ~n.c! > 4L . th . e 0n 1 -J' e c SUI) Since that tine, three diagnostic r~\hc:Je drfinc tht' disorder. t 0 f b u l'1 mDT ex 1. a • 23 fe~tures h~ve criteric~ been used to arc (1) a powerful \lrr~(' to overeqt, (2) an attempt to compensate for overeating by vOfTlitin[; or 11.::C . ' t galn. . ';lslgn ,/;; In 1[·x~.t.i'!e3, and (3) 8 rror:olJ.Dced fC8r of . '-~, a study by Gcr21d cf Psychiatry of - of t~c po:\r~l v ~ • Russe]~, }'rep - of the Acqdcmic Dcpartmpnt l~oC"rl·tal uk" - .1'1" " '" lonnon .,_cc _., [>('tics dcscrih(c[ thf':lr po",!prfl:l ur[':c to ovprC!1t. ;~cvprrtl 9 - bulimarectics said th8t their thOllr:hts wprp C'o stantly Y1 food and some even had dreams abollt food. Oil \!!'lile thei:r thoughts were constantly about food, it was not because of hunccr. (ine p8.ti en t described her reasons for overea tir~[: cause of hunger, but to fill a void. and fill an emotional gap.25 !ating :0- not 8G to neet seem~d '1'0 the bulimarectic, any prob- lem or stressful situation could trigger an episode of binging. These bouts of binging seem to stem from a lack of impulse control. This lack of control can also manifest itself in other ways, such as kleptomania or alcoholism. 26 The binge, which is most often described as lIan action to fill an emotional gap", has many striking similari tif:'S between cases. The typical binge is always done while alone, although it is still not kept as secretive as the actual "'7 V-()'nl'+inrJ" .:: I· L -'- \......'"'. In a personal intcrvie 1:! v:i th"Carric" (fictitious name) char8.cteristi c binge. "I'::l typi cal hinge a1 way s tooi( rlacc when I was a1c,r'.e, and usually at home. pIa;} as mu ch as 8 Fany tinies, I \'!ouJd day at cad what I was goinG to eat. r~08t often, I ate things that were simp10 to make, Jiko to?st for example. Foods that need little or no preparation were what , I ate most •••• things like ice cream and junk food. 1I 28 Carrip's case is amazingly similar to those reported in the literature. - ------.-~---~~---~~.. . ...... ( 10 On other occasions, Carrie reported planning her route home from work in (lrd cr to stop at various fast food C'~ctabli shrlicn tc where she would consume whole dinners in the car. Once the tinging has taken place, the bulimarectic will then resort to the second of the diagnostic criteria, that of ridding herself of the binged food. In Carrie's case, this behavior was learned from peers as a means to prevent weight gain. To many, it initially seems to be an easy al ternati ve to dieting. In a study hy Suzanne F. Abraham anrl P. J. V. Beumont of the University of Sydney, Australia, 32 patients were studied with regard to thpir tinging and purging behavior. Out of those 32 patients, the majority re- ported use of laxatives at one time or another. ~ost often, these medications were taken in large amounts promptly after a binge. (f those who used varni t.inF': 83 {l rn('[1n~; of food elimination, one-half of the patients did so by simply contracting their stomach muscles. The remaining half had to use their fjngers or other objects to induce vomiting. 29 Again, it must be remembered that the major contributing factor in this cycle is the patients extreme fear of fatness. This pronounced fear of weight gain iE the third and final fe8tl.lre of the disorder. 'Phis is morc easily understood if one recalls that the vast majority of bulimarectics have had WRight problems and feel themselves to 11 - be over their desired weight. In bulimarexia, as with anorexj.a nervosa, v8Tious problems aCCOT'lpany the disorder. :ec2.use of the fr<"cuent vomiting "oehaviClr, problems w.tth the digE-;stivp E:ystem are' almost inevitable. In some casps, stomach acid fro~ the bouts of vomiting havf: hoem known to hurn th e f'f:orhar;us cHln other areas involved in the regurgitation process. This regurgitation of stomach acid 8.1so causes tooth decay, and "l:.l) can infect the salivary glands • ./ 'This vomiting behavior can even alter the patients ability to swallow properly. In a 1979 study of bulimarectic behaviors by Gerald Russell, it was concluded that in patients employing both vomi tine: nnd ttl e usc of 18xati V0S, vorrlJ. t i dangerous of the two. 31 n{~ was th p rnorr The resulting complications were of a more serious and harmful nature. Besides the comrlications associated with the actual dieestive processes, other very serious disorders have also been know:: to accollI)any the disorder. Potassium deficiency as weIJ. as other deficicnrj disorders, SiJ.C'" as aner:1.ia, often occur in the m2.jori-cy of LiuJimarectic patients. arp r:8SP9 fI'o a lesser ext~'ntt of }':J]!C'rtens.i on, rena] faUllr(' CJY1(] but worthy or note, ('vC'n ('pi] f'rtir: . 32 SPIzures. In both a~orexia nervosa and bulimare~ia, there tend to be very similar traits from one patient to another. mho typical anorectic is female and in her mid to late teens or - 12 - early twenties. 33 This seems logical because of the added pressures of adolescence a.Yld young adul theod. 11.:3 ste. ted earlier, she is often at that point in her life when she wants to fi t in with her reers, and conformin,~ with her body is a way to do so. The typical anorectic is usually of middle or upper c 1 ass b ac k groun d , an d more 0 ft · en th an no t ,lS caucaSlan. . 34 In the past few years, however, the occurrence of the dis- ease has spread to a lesser extent to almost all socioe~o- nomic backgrounds. the anorectJc pati0nt iE; one wilo has been rrypicall~!, considered ~,~e 'rr:rfFct. chiJd.,,35 Eually of fairly intelliBsnc-, the t~haved, model stndeYlt. a~orectic is well ':"ten she is seen as an ~igh pretty, and a ove:!:'~H'hi',:vcr, and this overachievinr: is ol'ten fUE:lecl by parental pressure. family is DoSt often close knit. male. l;er Usually, there are two Dominant mothers and/or very authoritative parents ~ t ·e ro 1 . t ure. '1/ h seem t ·0 P 1 ay a GCIlnl e ·In th C PlC UnlikE' the anorectic patient, there is no detailed _1 • • pe:!:'sonality profile on the bulimarectic at this time. This may be due to the fact that the behavior is so secretive. In comparison to tl1 e anorecti c, hO\,lever, clew!:; 800m bnl.imarecti c to l)(~ more 300ial1y (1ctiv(' 8.nd outgoinC. =~7 while she is - tht:~ ~ore outEoinS, she hac 2 [),llt definite lack of splf 13 - esteem, as does the anorectic. Bulirnarcctics GcneralJy start late teens. 1,0 pat in binecs in their Vomiting behavior then usually one year later. around begin~ This vomiting behavior continues for the average duration of 4.5 years. r:[.1his duration of the illness is much loncer than that. or anorexi;} ncrvoS8, and when hr:·lp is sought, the prognosis is often not as promising. 38 As stated, most bulimarectics llRve had some type of weight problem in the past. This bulimarectic behavior may well then be [) result of frustration 8t ke('rint~ their vleigllt at their desired lpvel. UnderJ.ying lToblems severe weight loss, this weieht loss is only one of the problems. The underlying severity. '.Illile the typical anorectic viaS ini tially a model proble~s ~ay be of eve~ greater child, once the disease starts to take hold, there are mark0d c~1an8es in ~ler personali t2' as well as in bodily appearance. v:1thdravl frm rclationshil's and llsual activi tics 8.::d ber'orle unal}proachable in many cOD'JersatioY'.al 2reas. 'Ine underlying probler:-is are difficult to define. nervosa cannot be pinpointed to one specific cause. Anorexia Rathpr, - the r0asons behind anorexia nervosCl 8re nany C1.nrl v~Jrie(l. There are several typical underlying factors whict Gay have "'>:'9 (1) biolofical, (2) psychological, and (3) environr:lental bases./ Whereas psychological factors were once thought to be of sole or prir:1ary importance in the development of anorexia nervosa, now biologic factors are tensively. hein~ resc8rchcrt morc px- Studies now seem to support that there may be a hypothalamus/pituitary/ovary dysfunction. 40 The hypothalamus seems to regulate some basic behavors such as eating, ag. gresslon, 2.nd hypothalamus rl41 r100 __ S. It is now thoueht that perhaps the ~~:isreeulatinG hormones may be a rredetermining factor for a!'ore:-:ia nervosa. The dYGfunctioTI. of the hyroo I. I' type of rosc2rch i~ ctilJ in the (~~ly ste[Ps, so no dcfi- nite conclusions are available yet. }sycl!olorical factors do seen to play th e cl E:veloprTI(,n t of a~"-orexia nervo sa. 8. central rolf' i'1 en e con tribu ting fa(~tor mRy be the patient's self-p0rceived inability to live up to 11 er own expect~ltions or those of her authori tati.ve :par en ts w t'c 3 Such behavior seEDS logical, since the anorectic is often a hic:h achiever. ,:!i th - Cften hieh paTPntal ()Y.:l)cctatioD~j, couplc:d contiDual conrlicancc, lead her to feel totally inadequate. 15 -- In an attempt to overcome these feelings of inadequacy, the anorectic-to-be will start to diet as a means of conquering and controlling those feelings, givinG her a measure of indepenctenco in hcr own mind. Control itself, seems to be another important issue in the development of anorexia nervosa. 44 Eilde Bruch aCCl1rately expresses the dilemma of the anarectic in terms of "a sparrow in a golden cage".45 'rho anorectic has all of the luxuries and privileges she could "lant, but is deprived of the freedon to do 83 ste wishes. Fruch describes the anorectics whole life as an attempt to livp up to the f'xp(>cta" t lons i" 0_ ,ner Inml ~'l y. 46 As the model Child, always doing what she is told, anorectic behavior may well he an attempt to control something in her life. With weight control or reduction, shp can control her body, as well. those around ~er.47 form of a P01.'I'<T AD m8nirulat~ In a sense, her loss of weight, is a p1ay. 48 Another factor in the development of the disorder rnay be a major Ch2-Dge in the lifo of the anorectic. may be a bodil.y change such as puberty. 0_1 t.n.",. ~noY>.·. c<.• 00.1.:.1' r-t:o-np __ _ -, ~ 'cc(iini~c; a "ro-". "C,~_ ',1[0"';:1:1 it comes sCX0al feelines. t'''->l' nD' -t:., J.L. can be Also, A change in thp body aho1J+ thp fp"'r of' •. v .• _. ""0 _ ~~ heCOYnl' U,. 1 , ' _ n'T t. vcr;,' frtgh-Lenjnc, for vlLtn m~tur~tioo ~ith - This change ~ri~gs t~c with it lose of WGi II I I of .' 'eM - • 16 - this reversal of puberty ma~T he a vJay to dela:\c this matur8.- ~<J tion process. . I'~any of the preceeding psycholoGical factors sef?r2 to stem frorn an environnental basis. Although the anorectic's family life seems ideal on the surface, oftf?D there are underlying conflicts. As seen in the psychological factors, family pressures and the issue of control seem central to the disorder. So then, it appears, rsycholoEical factors and environmental factors almost SeE:~m to be one in the samo. The cause or etiological factors underlyinr bulimarexia Rgain seem to point to tile extreme feaT of \·!eigr.t 52-in. the of sa~e r~:arTi ~1ctly tine, however, several of the factors tiat contribute e, her llulil1areci: ie behavior \,/2.S as the rrofi 1e of the anorectic. as being lit 2.D a '!!?:,;l to control ':!i th Carrte, as well clel:lont of control, her binging and vomiting was a [loans of letting her ferlings And frustrations out. :~hr: had always complied ",!ith everyone's wishes and thus had nf:ver learned to express her oVln feelings. Eer binging and vomit- ing then, was Ila way to take out my frustrations. If I am mad at someone, it is easier to binge and Eet mad at myself instead of someone else. It's less of a threat to get mad at myself; it makes me take no chances. 1150 - « , 17 -- Thus it appears that the bulimarectic, like the anorectic, has 811 extreme lack of self esteem. The bulimarectie, however, has a much greater fear of becoming fat than does the anorectic. Again, this points back to the extreme fear of weight gain as the primary determinant of bulimarcctic behavior. Treatment Ju~t as the problems underlying eating disorders have a complex basis, the treatment must be focused on many levels. It is importcmt that the patient return to heal t!lY nutri tiona1 status, psychological lJ;roblems must be resolved, and ';1 family conflicts must he addressed.- }'irst and foremost, the patient's physical health f'!wst be upgraded. In some cases, the patient may be rear the point of death. In these very serious instances, the issue of saving her life comes first. In these, as well as the less serious instances, the anorectic vJill be easier to reason with once the body has returned to a somf"Vlhat heal th ipr state. ,~.J1orcctic patients are irrational in their thinkin/:, nnd until normal body processes are resumed, there will be little rrogress~ Weight cain seems to be agreed upon aE being the most urgent of tr~at~cnt procedures. ~here is a Ques~ion, how- ever, as to wrl ",ttl r:r this should be accompli shed through - '" _. 18 - hospi talization, or on an outpatient basis. therapy will clcIwnd 8. gr(~at reasons. h()spi Lal j y,(I '·/2.S Lion ('or lost. ':ost [;c'.ur(11 First, hospitalization allows for thorough physical assessment. from the r(~nuc'~;l rrode of deal upon the (}r;1ount of "/f'jrht lost and on the time period over "/hicn it rhysicians t('nri to ~'he Secondly, hospitalization removes the patient fa~ily setting. This is beneficial to both patient and family, because it helps to alleviate some of the stress encountered. Thirdly, hospitalization allows for the treat- ine; physician to for~ an understandin[~ rolationship with ') ') the patient. - ( Weight gain has been accomplished in illc'..IlY we_yS. DruGs are sometimes used to stimulate the 2norectic's appetite. other times, intravenous f&cding is implemented. of forty per v,ould ~pnt co~sti tl1te These body weight or lass of twenty-five to rri t0ri8 for intraverous fONline. '1'110 r.lost successful met.hod, however, is to encourage oreel feeding. 53 A lwl12.vior modification prograrr: can regard to eating habits. 11(, undertaken with Reinforcers or special privileees may be used to try to coax the patient to eat. In this way, the p2tient, unless near death, is allowed ,to feel in control of her eatine. With this method of treatment also comes the deemphasis on eating. With the focus taken off of the , PH' ." --------i-':; ~', i ,,·W1b ( 19 - patient t S eati:r:'g habits, trollinf~ not only lH'r Glee if allovled to feel slle is con- 1tlPiCJlt, hut (·v(·n tho;~p in chnrl~r'. S4 By gaining weight, the anorectic nay be alJowed visitinG privelezes or so~c similar reinforcement. Since the anorectic is usually extremely afraid of ar:d opposed to wei£ht gain, bargains can be made as to small amounts of weir;ht gain. }(eeping the amount of weight gain expected in small quanti ti es ',.Iill keep the anorectic t s distress to a minimum. Often times a "contract" can be aGreed upon by physicians and patients as to what behavior will receive rewards. Cne riust reRli z e, however, th at th ere \·!i11 rro ba bly be s etbad~ s in the treatrr:cnt of the Ci.llOrectic. i1osl'i t21i~('d patients or the ~morcctic Day ,,!eight in ordr'I' to be released frofl) trd? hospi tal Clnd then return to her previous behavior. Anorectics have also beEn kno1tm to hide or dispose of their food~ feli intr~-l.v('no11s1y, Sone, when beinG h::lVe evcfI disconnected their 1Vs. If there are others also suffering from anorexia nervosa ni='ar staff. These setbacks are normal, but it does not necessari- ly mean failure in the enrt. Recovery from anorf'xia nervosa is a slo\·/ process, and - it is impor-::;ant to rpalize that si!TiI'le wcigrt c8in does not ... .-,-~-- . "e -- -.- _. ". ". . • • . - "." . ......... I - ___ _ ttl ' ft' ! .* _cc ?O - mcc.n that the (-morcctic patient is cl)rcd. ':-v('n a ft0r fair- ly norMal ':!eicht and J'1.utri tion arC' rssuf1Pc'!, the l'1reoccu~ation fication is I'Iost successful when counled with psychological and far;1.ily therapy. To rcsolv() tllE' inner conflicts that overpowpr the ano- rectic, she must be made to feel in control of her life. Successful therapy must help the anorectic to mature emotionally and be able to understand and properly channel her feelines. This must aleo be coupled with ~hernpy to improve her self imace. 1'nc fOTldly of tll(> n.norf'ct.iei" cr.i.ticnl in h(lpi.nr~ v!jth this therapy. The family of the anorectic must be made to understand t~~ not only the patient has problpms. 56 Ano- re:xia is a lJroblem of the 1thole fal:"i ly, anr' a problerrJ that needs family 8~PTort. Therefore, the family support system must be strFllztliE.ned ;oJxtd reir:.forced. 2.. support 2yste~n Use of the fanil~r depeY1ds la,rgely on their ab-ili ty to as c}~2.nfc J\norc:xia Fcrvos8, by st",vC'rl J:evcnkron, the author provid ('s hasic behavi0Ts for parents copine: with an anorectic chi1d. One basic theme that runs throughout Levenkron' book is that of not ci.emandine; decisions of thp anorf?cti,c. Fewer choices forced upon the patient will ease her distress in copine with situations. - !tbove all, :rJPvenkron states tho n?;cd to 'ZOP c 21 - adopt a 11 nur turant yet authori tativel! l)osture toward their anorectic child. 57 In con tr8.ot to anorectics, bul5.rnar p ct1or.: eTe hard er to treat. With the extrAme secrecy surrounding the behavior, it is oftentimes hard to get thc bulimarectic to admit she proble~. has a Cnce the problem hac been discovered thouGh, treatment is usually the treatin~ u~dertaken of thes0 individuals, gins, and the' second is to 2re used, rlus c, p, treatment./ 2. t~e1'c chang('t)~c \'/81'd ('atiY'E ,,!lid V!eif:ht Gain. In on an outpatient hasis. 2re two pri~ary p8ti(onts 8ttit.udes to- rehavior modifj r:atioYl techniques ch8DgC in thinkinG is rCeJuired for full It takes a skilled thprapist to build trust and start to 1'pvcrse the cycle. At the onset of treatment, much is needed to help t1'ol the "nC'f'flv.ior. spelled out she eats. ~nd i11hc' COfl- r1FUlfc1's of thr: lwhnvior arf' oftcrt the patient is asked to record when 2nd ~lat In this manner, tbe doctor can exanine ca.tinES habits and attitudes about those pating hahits. The p8tipnt is instructed to only eat at certein times and ways to increase self-co~trol are discuss8ct, f'lent is the r::rcrd;ion of E: rccepti ur: Important in th0 treatenvi1'onl~'F:nt for recover:,'. 22 - cllanL~(:' ll(:r nti.ituc i C3 t(1\',r,rri,'ourl <Inri to\'/':rd !I('r'~-( If. c, Ci - }'rognosic Tr..e road to recovery from an one. e~tinE disorder is ::1, tou2~h It takes a great deal of time and patience on the part of the patient, and by all those around her. At the prespnt time, the mortali ty rate from anorl)xia ncrvosa ranees from flO six to fifteen per cpnt. John EopKins Univf'rsity statistics show thE't on(~-fourth treatment, oYle-r.alf of anorectics 2re not i~prove h(~lped by but 2r(' vulnerable to develop- inc future })roblems, nnd ()nly th" rcrrC'lininC one-fourtl1 rr'61 cover complctf?ly. :::t2tistics silow, hO\,lever, that the the chance for recovery. treat~~nt ~ fcv! satisfactor:,: rcport~o 67, of tulinarexia. / There have vIell-ciocUJl'1rntu.l, thcTP on the rr:> llc:~v('r;een incff('ctiv(- trF:atTJlents attempted, anci probler;1~ cocplicatect hy lack of trainpd therarists.64 )'[:''1{8 l:Jeen ~uccessful tr('a\1::C'nt {;('p(·nd~· on the pat.i.cnt'~~ rlbility La ;]('I~nO"ll('drl­ the problem 8nd want to chanGe. 65 ~\.t this point, only a limited prognosis can bp made hecause of tnt:' linitpd ar~ollnt of research 2vailable. -. It can be said that at this point in time, the treatment outco~e of tulimarexia is less favour2,[-le than that of anorexia nervosa. 3ulimarectic patients ·- are vcr:,' rcsisbu;t to trf';Jil'(Tlt:, Nl('Olmtf'T' cations, and Rre very prone to There is still much to be (inl~1 .. compli- rj'''"t'[,,0Tnllf' u; SU1Cldf'.lear~cd about eEtin~ disorders. VIi th Lil.1c B_wi patif'rlcc \t!ill ::Fly :.:::olutiOrl ever be reached. In the mcantime, ~owever, there are nation?l support groups as \'Jell as 10ra1 solI-help Groups. 'L'WO 2'.wh groups clTe trlc National Anorectic Aid Society in Columbus, C'hio, and thp -T ' +. l'. crvosa A SSOCla "lon . t . Amerlcan "u'!oreXla . T eance, k IT J erscy. 67 ln ~j ew Ifhese group:: can be contacted for information on v,here to ~he seek help. ~ating that first step, though, is just asking for hplp. disorders are a serious problem, and not somethine C2TI bf' overcome alone. 1. r.bsc['~::ion C c' loy' LL' s, 2?tin:'1 v!it-,-: foon, hoarri,-,r;., (;(JllP-i:inr f 0 0 d a cor' s t :'1. n t. ::: 1) i ~ j c c t (J _=- C () Y1 11 I" r - 7/. 4.~xcrciDjr[ 5. to extremcs Cr 2.:- e in personali ty 1 6. Above a.ll, j her to seek help. -- f someone :you knoVi does have a problen, lJrr-:e ~ating disorders are a s~rious problprn, and a problen that is increasine in frequency. tt present, we are far fror ' possessing All of thp; answers. \'!f' know thp.t , __ ~ ___ f ___ _____ d~~ ______________________________ __ ~~~~·.·~~~~~ ~ _ • • • _~ ___ • _ _ _ _ •• _ _ .~. 0 ______ ~!.~ __ -. ~~~'~'.~.~~.~,,_. ________ 24 - simply repairine; thehody 1~ not E'1!.Ol)f}l, hrt W'lat i,~ to be cione? As with eny problem, the best solution must stem fran the disorders, perhaps we should focus on the Bttitudes underlyin!3 t~e problcFls. }\norexia nervosa :mcl rmltrr:arcxj.8 arc only two more escape mechanisms in a long list. In a f30cif'ty with such other problems as alcoholism and drug abuse, would not the better solution be to teach people to cope? Before there will he any chanf~e, in the attitudes of our society. ther(' must lie a eh"nr~r; l!prhaps it is time that we try to break the myths that are starting to rule the lives of our younG, and in the words of :!ilde "Golden cacoll.69 :~~ruch, [Teak th:.1t ~ --._.....----------- , -'-~--~--- -_.- .-- -.- _ _~ _ _- - - '.........':...._~. (eM .1 •• ' .... -1Eruch, Eilde, UA.norexia Nervosa and its Differential Diagnosis," 'Ehe LTournal of Nervous and Iv1 ental Disease, 141, no. 5, 1966, p. 555. 2~acleod, Sheila, The Art of Starvation Schocken Books, 1981) p. 4. 3Pa~mer, 1 P •L• -" (New York: :uide for sufferers ttd. 1981) and their families p. 6. 4carfinkf'1, J)aul E., et al. "1'he Heterogeneity of Anorexia Nervosa, 11 j\.rchi ves of Gen eral "Psychiatry, vol. 37, September 1980, p. 1036. 5~-~ruch, Lilde, 11;'l.nor(!xia Nervosa and its DifferF:nti2.1 Diagnosis," p. 555. 6prucfl, ]!ilde, "Anorexia l'!ervosa: r~'hpTapy cmd ':::'heory," The Ameri can LlournaJ of Vsy chia try, 139, no. 12, Cecember 1982, p. 1531. 7(',-iulio, ?'2.Tbero, al"-c1 ,James I. Ch8rel, "Anorf?xia Fer'll(1 S!:t , 11 ~;ci('n('r-? r.uid~': TinivCTsit',T of !'jc'sollri- :-'nlllmlyi n \,icdiCcll ~':('tltcr, ~c:rics 1, no. 2: ,lune19b(), 1). -I. -~-f('alth ST'rlle>' I'lole'e IItl 110T'PXloa t 1 ('rvos3. II T:E:'r:~Llon"'c, c'lYld tn0ir l,~edical ::;,ip:l'l.ificance, vol. 18, no. r:-, !':overnbr:r7Dccernher 1976, p. 2~J. ..l...-)u .. l f - ' - L '-, ~ I· ........' _ C, ___ '_,_." ~l~ ... - ' - , _ 9carfinkpJ, p. 1036. 10Boyle, ])atricia r'1. p.t ale lI/\Sspssment and 1':ana~(.~mF'nt of Anorexia I'; prvosa, II r,Taternal- Child Hursing Journal, vol. 6, November/December, 1981,p. 412. 11 1~'a , 1 mer, P.! .• , p. 5R. 12~)inaikin, Phillip, "1'reatment of Anorex12, llervosa, Arizona Medicine, Vol. 39, no. 3, Parch 1982, p. 182 II 1 3TT F (' t b .'p l'SU, ..il.ic. ",eorge, II I s T'nere a 1\ J~lS llr. ance ll1 _;ody Ir.2.ge in Anorexia I'Tervosa?" The Journal of Eervous and Lental Disease, vol. 170, no. 5, 1982, p. 305-306 T ° 14}Jalmer, :po 14 - 15Giulio and Chap01, p. 1 16 Ferrar2, Corlpss ~ro"'m, "./I.l1oreyia IT erV0 sa: Choosinf, to ~~t('n'vf'," ,lollrnal of i:ursjnc: C:rlrc, If:::, ,T8.nU;1r:/ 1022,1'. 1r;. 25 ( .... _ _ _ . _ ..... ~ _ _ ~_:?_ . _ . : . , _ ....... _ _ _ •• _~~_.-L-,..;.,~~___----.;_ _ _._ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _---'............ .:.-....... _ _... , ......................_"...-.....d. . . . . . ._. '. . . . ._ - . . { 17Lucao, Alexander, "Bulimia and Vorni ting ~~yndrorne," New York state Journal of Medicine, vol. 3, I~arch 1982, p.398 18 Ibid ., p. 398 19"Anorexia: The'Starving Disease' r,;pidernic," and World Report, August 30 1982, p. 47. News 20Hussell, Gerald, "l:ulimia tl ervosa: An ominous variant of anorexia nervosa," Psychological r'iedicine, voL 9, 1979, p. 430 21 Halmi, Kath erine A., James R. }<'alk, and "::stelle Schwartz, IlBinge-eating and Vomiting: A survey of a colI e;~e popula tion, " Psychological f.:edicine, vol. 11, 1981, p. 703 22Fcdr1-'llrn, ('hristorner r.. [1)[C 1 h-,tf>r J. Cooper, lf~clr­ induced VOTIli_tinc; an.d bulir;!ia nervosa: an undetected problcIT., II 13rj_tish Ledieal Journal, vol. 284, ':pril 17, 1982, p. 1153. r) • ~ , ") ~ .....·)';·1 . }I:! j , ;'. t)t)'/. r. 43-1. "(: L:':_'c~spcr, !:ccina r;. ct 8.1. ".!::lJli!'lia: Its lncic!cnce em r ] Clinic2,1 Ir1pori;;:lnce iF Patients 1::i th. i'nore::d_a ::ervosa," Archivc2 of Seneral Psychiatry, vol. 37, Spptember 19 8 0, p. 1043 27pcbra!lal'1, :::uaznne l~. and P. J. V. T)eumon t, "Eo1t: pa ti CYl ts describe bulimi8 or binge eating,1! Fsychological Ledicin p , 12, 1982, p. 629. ?PJ'erson;:~l i r ltcrvlCw with (;arric (fictitLouf-i narnc) ?1 year old bulir1arectic-- Indianapolis, Indiana, ._Tune 1, 1983. 29Abr2ha~ and Bcumont, p. 631. 7.0 / russell, p. 438. 31 Ib'10. , p. 437. 3;',)~ b'Ie. j 33l'ruch, ') 4~: C;~l v!ab E', .:.\rth 11r lntc'rnri] i (r1 i cj nf', Sign i fie an c e , --! ---~ - .:. ,T J.. \.,n em 1. C , 35t1Anor8xia: II p. !) 7• 36ReccC', Foli('rt [~. tl1\norr-;::d 8 i;crr'02::o., II .t\r~r'ric;:]n i~r1mn~1 JOhy si ci an, vo 1. '1~";, n (). -1-, !\ Pl' i 1 1 q' (C, p. 1,-;:r.-'.=...::--.:.----..:...--"'- 37 .K. . . e urn 0 n t , .' ~l-' • J- • 'T\ ., u. "(~'~I "J~'. l..' r'eorp'e and T\ C'r'1 - C - , ......... '. .._' _c rt-. , I!Dieters and Vomiters a.nd rurgers in Anor8x:i8 '-ervClsa, Psycholoeical [~edicine, 6, 1976, r. (117. Cl • II 38 Bh 8.nji, S. and D. !~attingly, "Anorexia EenlOsa: Observations on ':0ietcrs' and 'Vomi ters' ," of Psychiatrl, 139, 19 8 1, p. 238. }~Ti ti8h ::":orlC Journal 39Ciulio and Chapel, p. 2. 40 Ibid • 41:palmer, p. 55 42Giulio and Chapel, p. 2. 43!"o'k I II\,r~ t · })a t·len t 1.1....,1 , .rene, .. ,.en th c jI.norpC1C You ••• II Nursinc;, December 1981, p. 47. l} Ch aengps 44pellmon.t, George, and Smart, p. 620. 4 5·n.brucn, , '.~1 ... 1 d e, C 1 d en f'" .:.'~1(~O University IJress, 19m p. 23. (Lassachusetts: ~iC3.rvard 46 11 '.-l .. n.lI. 117 , II Anorr'"l' .. ./. c",. ..... ~" q 'J~chwate, /1 The 'Starving Jiisease'::pidpITri,c ll , r. 4'1. p. 378. 1983 51 ;jruc~),Feelin.gs ano their Fodical Significanc p , p. 31 52c:' ,--,lnal'k'J.n, p. 183. r) '.I, . "Jbid. 54Zeller, Clifford, tlTreatment of Sgo J)eficits in Anorexia Hervosa,11 American Journal of Orthopsychiatry, 52, no. 2, April 1982, p. 358. .- 27 - 55ruSik, p. 47 56 Reece, p. 125 57 Levenkron, Steven, rrrf~atinfT and Ovprcomin. Nervosa (New York: Charles • 58pairburn, p. 710. 59 Ibid • 60 Reece, p. 125. 61 !I HnoreXla: fI . 62 r~he I Starving Disease 'r~pictemic," P. 48. Reece, p. 125. 63pairburn, p. 707. 64JJllcas, p. 399. ir l'usse l~.1, 00·· C7, , 1,11 eel S , p. 68"Anorexia: -'('C) ').1 '11he 'StarvinE DisC'(~sc' h9-~l_rucu, h ' ' 'J.n ' e G ~ . o.Id pn Cage, p. 1 c..:.O /. 28 :·;pio.f'r:de,lI p. ~(.:. , -_.-- BIBI.:ICGRJ\H~Y Ab r ah am , S u. Z 8...11 n e F. and P. J • V. Be\) rn 0 n t • describe bulimia or "binge eating." [V;edicine, 12, 1982, (;25-G35. "!~ow :patients Psychological "Anorexia: 'l'he 'Starving Disease'~'~pidemic, World Report, August 30, 1982, 47-48. f'!evls and fl Beumont, P.J.V., G.C.\'I. George, and D.E. Smart. TlDieters and Vomiters and Purgers in Anorexia Nervosa.1! Psychological Gedicine, 6, 1976, 617-622. ~;ome Bhanji, S. and D. T';attingly. "Anorexia Nervosa: Observations on 'Dieters' and ''lomiters','' British Journal of Psychiatry, 139, 1981, 238-241. I~oy1e, Yatricia T.l. et ale .\noY'f':\j:, vol. £), i'I('r'.lt)~n.11 1I,~,ssessment clOd j.:.qn2{!c])!ent of ~~l'J'rn~II-('fliJrJ i': ov cr:1 bl'I' /Deccml.'er 1 9bi, r!llr~)jnL. ,1nur'nal, 41 2-ZL18. })ruch, Iljlrlp, "-;'.norpxi'1. i<f:Tvc'sa. lIi"pplin~E' and their ['pdiccll ~iGnjT~i(,8nc(', yo], 1£', no. (-:, t:ovpmtier/DecPI'J,er 1976, 29-'0;1) • Eilcif. I I /J10 rE'xia ~:r;rvosa ar:j its Differenticd l}iaZnosis. 11 "'!'(' Journal of;ervou~ ,\On r'-pntril l,i [(,;:130, 14'1, no. ~~ (1 91 t, ), 5=5- 55t',. ~(ruch, 'Erucl:, :-:i1de. TI:~norexia liervosa: ~neI'2py and '2.'heory. II 'l'he Mnerican ,Journal of Tsyr:hiatry, 130, no. 12, "r,cem1)('r 1Clef) r, '-\8 " .t., 1r,_, "il-1 . /. ~r\) ch, ~=ild e. "'anager'lcnt of ]\norexia ~l erVOS2. r r 1 -I', r rJ • at"..d ('c t a.>.+' 1~ rh _' y S 1'C.1 an, J~, I) gus +v 1. 07 J 0, n II "cesj d 81: t fJ,ruch, IHlcle. r:'hp. Colden Cage. r"assachusetts: };arvard University Press, 1978. Casper, T~etin3 C. et a1. 111~lJlimia: Its Incidence and Clinical Import,U1cr: in J'aticnts ;,./ith j\norexia iiervosa. 11 lTchives of General Tsychiatry, vol. 37, ~pptember 1980, 1030- 1035. - Fairburn, Christopher. 11 A coe;ni ti vo behavior8,1 approach to the treatment of buLimi8." Psychological :pciicine, vol. 11, 1981, 707-711. fairburn, (lf1J'1stopher C;. rind l'ci,r'l' ,1. ::oopr·.r, 1':;1'] f'-indl](;('ri vomiting and bulimia nerYosa: an undetected problem. 11 British IIedical Journal, vol. 284, April 17, ~982, 1153-1155. Ferrara, Corl ess :;]ro\'m, It Anorexia Ii crvosa: Choosing to starve. II Journal of HursinE) 1~12re, 15, January 1982, 14-16. ·t~~. ct al. "The l!etf:roeenei ty of An.o:rexia Archives of General Fsychiatry, vol. 37, Garfinkel, Paul ~;ervoi3a.11 September 1980, 1036-1040. Cui.lio, }lc:rhc·:l'o, ;lflC1 ,)nillf'C I. CJ1;1rw I. IIf,n('1'I'.:d:l IJ('rV()f"~I." lTcaltl; ~>'i('n('c[;,:ui,dr': Univ('r~:1t' o,~' riSSOllr1-(lollJ"!'hj~1 Falmi',l:aHc(Tin? ;'., ulaticn." ,];<~~cs .:'~ l:Sll, }.L. r:.:corCf:. ;:tnd '!Orrl tEll': :118 r~'~~(Ore j\rorcy-ial!CrVosn,?lI T~c !ljsp;=>sc, vol. 1'/0,1'10. Levcnkron, ~'t('vcn. t,norf'yi.r1 Fall~, ~nd 2tc11 c ::C i'I:.'2.rt7. oJ' a colJ P[!f' ]'n}'I'sycLoloCiceJ 1:c:'rIicirJ', vol. 11, 19'~1, G97-706. !IJ'lnr.:c-ec'tln[~ a ,,:,;ur'.j('j' ~;i::;tllrc2,nc(' ,'I 0 ur"-, ,,:,} of' inody Ini2r':p Ln 1:''I'VOll~ ~lil(i ;'('Y1t81 Sf 10(')2, 305-307 nf ('11l r1 (v('r('01l\'; n::" /'n OreX1.R I': (TVa ~;-). Fcw \01'1\: {"nnrJf';l :'cri1 ncr'r. ,(:on:', (:-'1'1' .'rt j ,:f'J'VOSFi.. 1982. Lohahl, rarlene ::':oskind, clIJd i:lilliam f;. l!1hi teo "rr1 he Definition and Treatment of Rulimarexi in CollcEc Women./\. pilot study. .Journal of the Americ:an College Eealth Association, vol. 27, October 1978, 84-86. TJucas, Alcxander. IIF,ulimia ar.d I,romi ting Syncirorre. II 1; ('w York >:t;:1tr ,TournaI of f"('rlicine, vol. 3, [;.arch 1982, 398-'3 cI9. Macleod, Sheila. l)ooks, 1981 The Art of starvation. fic;j k, 'j ret'!'. 1I~','h('n trw :'l]'orf'ctic I ,~llJf'nt l!ursj,rl,,,w , December 1981, A6-49. jO - Hew York: "hcllJ('nC('f~ Schocken VUll ••• 11 - raImer, H.:L. Anorexia l!crv(~sa-i\ guide for sufferers and their fa!"1ilies. Great Britain: chauc~r Press ltd. 1981 Eeece, Hobr:rt :'. "Anorexia Ferv·llS8." !'~merican Family Physician, voL 13, no. 4, J\pril 1976, 121-126. Hussell, Gerald. "?ulinia i'i crVOScl: fir" ominou s varian t of ciDorexia nervosa." 1~svchoJoP'ical r-edicine, vol. 9, 19 7 9, !l29-~4f~. "'= Sch'tJabe, Artfwr D. et ale "knorpxi::>, ~Tervosa. II Annals of . \-, 1 0c I n t erEa 1 T-,. e d·lClne, VO 1 • q4 ~ , no. 3 ,,"[ arC1' _ <.) 1 , . /"::('(1 - :7"0 ;0. ~jinclikin,I'!lillip. l1'l'r ..';} Lmcnt of /morcxia [!prvosa." II!edi cine, vol. 39, no. 3, 1'-1arch 1982, 182-185. /,r:l70na Zeller, Clifford. "'fTPatf.' en t of Iceo Defici ts in "~.norexia IJPI'vosa. 11 Anerican Journal of rrthopsychiatry, 52, no. 2, April 1982, 256-359. J\PF?lTDIX Information on eating disorders Rnd support groups caD he obtained from the National Aid Society, Inc., }.0. Box 294(;1, r;oJ 111lhlS (\;1 ~ 3229 and the f.nl('I'i(~a,n /,norc:xio tir'rv03<l AssoC:iation, Inc:., 133 C~edar Tane, ':'r8.nr'CK ii,} 0766f.. 31