Science Journal of Environmental Engineering Research ISSN: 2276-6324 http://www.sjpub.org/sjeer.html © Author(s) 2013. CC Attribution 3.0 License. Research Article Published By Science Journal Publication Volume 2013, Article ID sjeer-266, 10 Pages, 2013 Doi: 10.7237/sjeer/266 Sewage Technology in Nigeria: A Pragmatic Approach Sunday Adesogan Accepted 3rd July 2013 Federal University, Oye-Ekiti, Ekiti State Nigeria Abstract This report contains the inventory of sewerage technology in the urban cities of the country with their associated problems and recommendations on how to adopt a local technology that could meet the need of our society. Preliminary activities involved literature search to find out what has been done in this regard in the past. This was followed by training of the enumerators. Pilot study was undertaken during the training using the city of Ibadan as the focal city in the southwest geopolitical zone. This was done to ensure that when our enumerators are sent to the field, they will be able to replicate what they have done during the pilot study. Then the country was divided into six according to the geo-political zones. The study approach involved the use of survey instruments (questionnaires) to gather primary data relating to sewerage systems in Nigeria. The questionnaires were in two Parts, with the first part addressing general information while the second part was an interview guide used for collecting data from selected stakeholders. Facilities were surveyed in communities where they exist and determination of their coordinates was carried out by members of the project team with the aid of GPS units. During the field survey, photographs were taken and compiled. Data collected were classified, organised and analysed manually. Findings were represented graphically and it constitutes the bulk of this report. Keywords: Sewerage; Technology; Approach; Nigeria: Inventory Introduction Urban sewerage technology is an intricate issue of special concern to any nation in the world (Anonymous, 2008). Inventory of urban sewerage technology in Nigeria must be addressed in its entire ramification to ensure adequate sanitation and hygienic environment in the country. The problem posed by sewage to human health is an important issue globally (Koren, 1980). In developed countries urban households consider sanitation as a service and people are ready to pay for it as long as there are sound and reliable providers (Feachem et al, 2007). In order to gather baseline information on sewage technology, inventory of Sewerage Technology of the urban areas of Nigeria was embarked upon with the collection of the geographical coordinates of these sewer lines using Global Positioning System (GPS) units, wherever they are available. Among the characteristics of living things is excretion, which is basically the ejection of harmful waste products from the body. These waste products include sweat, urine and faeces. The last two could be termed as sewage, although sewage actually is the waste water of a community (Feachem et al, 2007). Everybody knows that the sight of sewage of a community is unbearable if proper disposal measures are not taken. In Nigeria people sometimes dispose their wastes into streams, a habit hazardous to human health. Sewage should be treated before its disposal in order to prevent pollution of the surface and groundwater’s, and to reduce the spread of communicable diseases caused by pathogenic organisms present in sewage (Ogedengbe, 2001). The treatment of sewage is mostly a combination of physical and biological processes and sometimes a chemical process is included when the sewage is very concentrated (e.g. sewage from residential and industrial buildings) or mixed with industrial wastes. The biological process involves the action of bacteria, protozoa and algae on sewage under ideal conditions. In a developing country like Nigeria with old cities and communities, wastewater or sewage generated are often discharged into pit latrines in rural areas while they are discharged into septic tanks, soakaways and cesspools in towns and cities. These systems are problematic as soils become saturated with pollutants and effluents with very high suspended and dissolved solids causing environmental pollution and even groundwater pollution in some cases. Environmental pollution from wastes generated by human activities has been a major challenge and problem to environmental engineers all over the world. Wastewater is defined as, “the spent or used water of a community or industry which contains dissolved and suspended matter” (American Society of Civil Engineers, 1982). The words wastewater and sewage are used interchangeably throughout this study. The pipes conveying the wastewater are referred to as sewers. Sewage or wastewater can be defined as the used water and added waste of a community which is carried away by drains and sewers. Sewage is created by residential, institutional, commercial and industrial establishments (Anonymous, 2008). Raw sewage includes household waste liquid from toilets, baths, showers, kitchens, sinks and so forth that is disposed of via sewers. In many areas, sewage also includes liquid wastes from industry and commerce (Wise, 2009). According to West African Health Board (1991) some terms and terminologies include Interceptors, Mains, lateral, Relief Sewer, Rising Mains. Pressure Sewer system, Vacuum S c i e n c e J o u r n a l o f E n v i r o n m e n t a l E n g i n e e r i n g Sewers. Wetwells, Manholes, Diversion and Junction Chamber. The primary aim of this study is to carry out the inventory and current status of urban sewage technology in Nigeria. This study was undertaken as part of the ways to improving basic sanitation and hygienic practices nationwide in order to ensure achievement of the millennium development goals (MDG) target on sanitation. The overall objective of this study is to carry out an inventory of the existing technologies as a starting point for choosing best practices and innovative, adaptable and sustainable urban sewerage technologies. The study was Study Methodology R e s e a r c h ( I S S N : 2 2 7 6 - 6 3 2 4 ) P a g e |2 carried out in all the thirty six states in Nigeria, including Abuja, the Federal Capital Territory (FCT). The scope of this study is however limited to urban cities in Nigeria. The scope of the research include: (a) Identifying urban sewage technologies presently used in Nigeria. (b) Collecting information and data on design and status of the different technologies. The study area consists of all the urban cities in Nigeria. Figure 1 is a Map of Nigeria showing the six Geopolitical Zones. The country is bounded in the north by Niger Republic, the west by Benin Republic, the south by Gulf of Guinea and east by Cameroun Figure 1: Map of Nigeria Showing the Six Geopolitical Zones (Source: GNL, 2005) The research involves a purposeful survey of the sewage technology in Nigeria. The study adopted was the experimental action research which involved the use of structured questionnaire (Awoyemi, 2009). Preliminary activities involved literature search to find out what has been done in this regard in the past. Training of the enumerators and selection of various urban cities of the States in Nigeria were also carried out at the preliminary stage of the project. Pilot study was undertaken during the training using the city of Ibadan as the focal city in the southwest geopolitical zone. This was done to ensure that when our enumerators are sent to the field, they will be able to replicate what they have done during the pilot study. Then the country was divided into six according to the geopolitical zones. The study approach involved the use of survey instruments (questionnaires) to gather primary data Relating to sewerage systems in Nigeria. The questionnaires were in two parts with the first part addressing general information while the second part was an interview guide used for collecting data from selected stakeholders. Facilities were surveyed in communities where they exist and determination of their coordinates was carried out by members of the project team with the aid of GPS units. During the field survey photographs were taken and compiled. Data collected were classified, organised and analysed manually. Findings were represented graphically and it constitutes the bulk of this draft report. A reconnaissance survey of each zone was carried out with the field enumerators to acquit them with the study area. Thereafter, the area was broken into six sub-divisions, two persons to each division to carry out the survey. Available data in all the states were collected using photograph, focus group discussion, using GPS to get the co-ordinates of the treatment plants and interviews. How to Cite this Article: Sunday Adesogan, "Sewage Technology in Nigeria: A Pragmatic Approach" Science Journal of Environmental Engineering Research, Volume 2013, Article ID sjeer-266, 9 Pages, 2013. doi: 10.7237/sjeer/266 S c i e n c e J o u r n a l o f E n v i r o n m e n t a l E n g i n e e r i n g Administration of Questionnaire Questionnaires were administered to the operatives of the identified sewage treatment plant by direct interview and focus group discussion through our field enumerators in each of the selected urban cities in the country to collect information on: Type of sewerage technologies and authority responsible for the operation Sewerage technology in the urban city. Location of sewage treatment plant and functionality of the technology. Typical wastewater generated from each department. Quantities of wastewater generated per day. Methods of storage, collection, transportation and final disposal being used in managing wastes from the sewerage technologies stations. Authority responsible for wastes management. What is responsible for the choice of technology adopted? The status of the existing sewage technology. Design parameters for the existing sewage technologies. Field Study The sampling method of the survey was a purposeful survey based on the 2006 census of the country. An urban city is defined as a city with a population of 50,000 and above. Therefore 143 cities spread across the six geo-political zones were visited for sewerage treatment. The survey involve the use of personal observation In-depth interview of Key Personnel, Household Survey through the use of Questionnaire, researcher’s observation strategy and physical involvement in each of the urban cities. Data collected during survey included the functionality of the plant, the population to serve, source of sewage and method of treatment was collected particularly on existing sewage technology, sewage treatment facilities, functionality, utilisation and wastewater disposal in sewerage technologies stations. The primary facilities and the specialized services were based on the questionnaires and professional judgement of the project team based on the standard Sewage regulation and administration as obtained in the literatures. The logistics involved field visits for data acquisition. The country was divided into six zones, corresponding to the 6 geo-political zones and each zone was assigned a Zonal Leader. Each zonal leader appointed project supervisors (Enumerators) Corresponding to the number of political entities (States or FCT) in the zone. These zonal leaders supervised the state enumerators under them. Questionnaires were distributed to Health officers in the selected local government area (LGA) in the urban cities of Nigeria in order to extract relevant data on sewerage R e s e a r c h ( I S S N : 2 2 7 6 - 6 3 2 4 ) P a g e |3 technology within the LGA. It is assumed that the Health Officer would know what sewerage technology is used in his/her area of jurisdiction. Data collected at the LGAs was then correlated with similar information collected at the appropriate Ministries and Corporations of the political entity. Assessment of Existing Handling Methods The existing methods of handling each of the three key elements of sewerage technology (collection, disposal and treatment) were assessed to see if these meet the international standard of operations and in the case of treatment, the physical quality of the effluent were observed to see if there are any substantial improvement to the physical quality of the inflect . It was during this assessment that photographs were taken and compiled. From the assessment and evaluation, an option for a safe management of the sewage was developed. The survey served as a barometer to gage the best form of sewage treatment in some particular areas of the country Results and Discussion The research was limited to urban cities in the country. In 143 urban cities used as case study, the collection, disposal and treatment of sewage from residential and industrial sources were investigated. To facilitate the data collection procedure, this study brings to greater prominence the situation of Nigerian sewerage technology. Improved efficiency also has positive financial implications as it means less money will be wasted on valuable resources released to the environment. These simple and seemingly obvious facts raise the key question of why this is not occurring automatically in the industry without the stimulus of outside intervention. Sewerage Data in Various States of Nigeria As presented in Table 1, a total of twenty six Sewerage plants were evaluated in the urban cities of South-western Nigeria out of which four were not functioning. The table provides a summary that includes the location, functionality, method and level of treatment. The coordinates provided are for plotting purposes and correspond to the location of the treatment plant or the Agency responsible for the system where information about the system was obtained. Detailed description of each sewerage system is provided in this report, with photographs and drawings where available. Figure 2 shows the geographical spread of the 26 sewerage systems in the country. The figure shows the preponderance of sewerage technologies in the southern part as compared to other parts. Only Kaduna has a functional system in the north while Kano has a nonfunctional system. Similarly, the only functional system in How to Cite this Article: Sunday Adesogan, "Sewage Technology in Nigeria: A Pragmatic Approach" Science Journal of Environmental Engineering Research, Volume 2013, Article ID sjeer-266, 9 Pages, 2013. doi: 10.7237/sjeer/266 S c i e n c e J o u r n a l o f E n v i r o n m e n t a l E n g i n e e r i n g R e s e a r c h the middle belt is in the FCT while Benue has a nonfunctional system. Despite the preponderance of sewerage plants in the south, many of the southern States lack functional sewerage system or do not have at all these include Bayelsa, Ondo, Anambra, Ebonyi, Abia, Imo, Cross River and Akwa Ibom. Figure 4 shows the national distribution of the sewerage systems and the different types of treatment technologies used. Combining the Figure with Table 1, it becomes obvious that the four systems that are non-functional technologies are treated mechanically. These non-functional treatment plants are located in Markurdi Central, Kano Central, Ifruga Estate in Porthacourt, Rivers State and University College Hospital (UCH) Ibadan. All the eight (8) surveyed treatment treated through Biological Method are functional. These are the Sewerage Technologies located at Abakpanike Estate, in Enugu State, Etope Estate in Rivers State, Obafemi Awolowo University (OAU) Ife, University of Ibadan and University of Lagos. Others are the treatment plants at Abesan, Oke-Afa and Olusosun, all in Lagos. This observation would suggest that Biological methods are more sustainable than mechanical in the Nigeria environment. Coupled with most of the reasons provided as causes of nonfunctionality it will appear that maintaining a biological treatment plant is more cost effective than comparable mechanical treatment. The only Surveyed Sewerage Technologies that uses both Biological and Mechanical Methods was found at Afe Babalola University Ado-Ekiti. STATE F.C.T, Abuja Markurdi Kaduna Kano Enugu Edo Delta Rivers Lagos ( I S S N : 2 2 7 6 - 6 3 2 4 ) Biological Treatment Technologies Biological treatment is a more natural waste water treatment process than other waste treatment methods. Microorganisms feed on the complex materials present in the waste and turn them into simpler substances, preparing the water for further treatment. The point of this process is to reduce the Biological Oxygen Demand (BOD) level. Biological waste treatment also cuts costs because there isn't a great amount of energy that is needed for the process to be performed, thanks to the hard-working organisms Mechanical Treatment Technologies Mechanical systems utilize a combination of physical, biological, and chemical processes to achieve the treatment objectives. Using essentially natural processes within an artificial environment, mechanical treatment technologies use a series of tanks, along with pumps, blowers, screens, grinders, and other mechanical components, to treat wastewaters. Flow of wastewater in the system is controlled by various types of instrumentation. Sequencing batch reactors (SBR), oxidation ditches, and extended aeration systems are all variations of the activated-sludge process, which is a suspended-growth system. The trickling filter solids contact process (TF-SCP), in contrast, is an attachedgrowth system. These treatment systems are effective where land is at a premium. Table 1: Sewerage Technologies Captured in the Urban Area of Nigeria LOCATIONS OF SEWER LINES Wupa central Plant Markurdi central Nigerian Brewery, Kaduna Kano central Abakpanike Estate Nigerian Brewery, Benin NNPC, Warri Shell Petroleum Main Office and Staff Quarters Warri Ifruga Estate, Rivers Etope Estate , Rivers Chevron Office, Rivers Shell Petroleum office, Rivers Abesan Oke Afa Alausa Olusosun Nigerian Brewery, Lagos KIND OF TREATMENT Mechanical Mechanical LEVEL OF TREATMENT Complete Complete Biological Partial Mechanical Mechanical Complete Complete Mechanical Complete Mechanical Mechanical Complete Complete Mechanical Biological Mechanical Mechanical Biological Biological Mechanical Biological Mechanical Biological P a g e |4 Partial Partial Complete Complete Partial Partial Partial Partial Complete Partial LONGITUDE 7.380470 8.496710 LATITTUDE 9.021910 7.724560 STATUS Functioning Not Functioning Functioning 8.558002 11.984488 Not Functioning Functioning 6.334431 Functioning 5.515570 5.539423 4.779042 4.785990 4.786335 4.784149 Functioning Functioning 7.426657 7.523686 5.622182 5.740021 5.740724 7.009141 7.003762 7.005839 7.005724 3.292370 3.300730 3.352090 3.356550 3.364784 3.388970 10.508529 6.518289 6.591050 6.527210 6.623650 6.633710 6.480348 6.516493 Not Functioning Functioning Functioning Functioning Functioning Functioning Functioning Functioning Functioning Functioning How to Cite this Article: Sunday Adesogan, "Sewage Technology in Nigeria: A Pragmatic Approach" Science Journal of Environmental Engineering Research, Volume 2013, Article ID sjeer-266, 9 Pages, 2013. doi: 10.7237/sjeer/266 S c i e n c e Ekiti Oyo Osun Ogun J o u r n a l o f E n v i r o n m e n t a l University of Lagos ABUAD UCH University of Ibadan I.I.T.A Ibadan Nigerian Brewery, Ibadan OAU, Ile-Ife Nigerian Brewery, Ilesha Agbara Industrial Estate E n g i n e e r i n g R e s e a r c h ( I S S N : 2 2 7 6 - 6 3 2 4 ) P a g e |5 Mechanical and Biological Partial 5.223361 7.612281 Functioning Biological Mechanical Mechanical Partial Complete Complete 4.528612 4.785830 3.086104 7.516464 7.624270 6.505113 Functioning Functioning Functioning Mechanical Biological Mechanical Mechanical Partial Partial Complete Complete 3.903897 3.901553 3.896732 3.969622 7.405737 7.433328 7.495748 7.397722 Not Functioning Functioning Functioning Functioning Figure 2: Status of Sewerage Technologies Surveyed in Urban Areas of Nigeria National Overview of Urban Sewage Technology The study showed that the majority of sewage disposal methods in the country are the septic tanks. This is graphically represented in Figure 3. There are also abundant pit latrines while sewer lines, though the primary concern of this study, are Minimal. The results show that although sewer lines are mostly used in southwest and north central (Abuja, in particular) old methods such as soil pit and defecating in the bush are still prominent, particularly in southwest, southsouth and north central geopolitical zones. How to Cite this Article: Sunday Adesogan, "Sewage Technology in Nigeria: A Pragmatic Approach" Science Journal of Environmental Engineering Research, Volume 2013, Article ID sjeer-266, 9 Pages, 2013. doi: 10.7237/sjeer/266 S c i e n c e J o u r n a l o f E n v i r o n m e n t a l E n g i n e e r i n g R e s e a r c h ( I S S N : 2 2 7 6 - 6 3 2 4 ) P a g e |6 Pit Latrine Septic Tank/Water Closet Sewer Line Bush Soil Pit Figure 3: Sewage Disposal Pattern in Urban Areasof Nigeria Figure 4: Methods of Sewerage Treatment Employed in Urban Cities of Nigeria. The survey revealed that virtually all urban sewages are not treated. The only places where sewerage technology is employed in the country are some selected institutions. These include University of Ibadan, which employs biological treatment method, International Institute of Tropical Agriculture, Ibadan in Oyo state, Obafemi Awolowo University, Ile-Ife in Osun State, Afe Babalola University, Ado-Ekiti in Ekiti State and Wupa sewage treatment plant in Abuja which uses mechanical treatment. There are some other place like estates where sewage are been treated in the urban areas of Nigeria. Examples are Agbara Industrial Estates in Ogun State, Abakpanike Estate in Enugu, Ifruga and Etope Estates, both in Portharcourt. Lagos State govt have three functional plants built recently-refer from the waste water office in Ikeja. It was discovered that industrial areas form the bulk of the places where sewerage technologies are located. These are places like Shell office in Portharcourt and Warri, Chevron office in Portharcourt, Nigeria National Petroleum Corporation (NNPC) in Warri, Nigeria Brewery at Kaduna, Benin, Ibadan, Lagos and Ilesa. How to Cite this Article: Sunday Adesogan, "Sewage Technology in Nigeria: A Pragmatic Approach" Science Journal of Environmental Engineering Research, Volume 2013, Article ID sjeer-266, 9 Pages, 2013. doi: 10.7237/sjeer/266 S c i e n c e J o u r n a l o f E n v i r o n m e n t a l E n g i n e e r i n g The majority of sewage disposal method in the country is water closet and septic tank followed by pit latrine. Some states had design of sewer lines for effective sewage treatment but due to the fact that water supply is grossly inadequate, coupled with the huge initial project costs, the proposal has not been implemented. For example, Oyo state had not implemented the design prepared several years ago. R e s e a r c h ( I S S N : 2 2 7 6 - 6 3 2 4 ) P a g e |7 Figure 3 shows the different kinds of sewerage treatment in Nigeria. It was discovered that majority (about 65%) of the sewerage technologies in the Urban Areas are treated mechanically of which most of it are located in the industrial areas. This is followed by Biological treatment method (about 31%). The treatment method whereby Biological and Mechanical methods are used is the least (about 4%) means of sewerage treatment in the country. 65% 31% 4% Biological Recommendations Mechanical Mechanical and Biological Figure 5: Relative Abundance of Sewerage Technologies in Urban Areas of Nigeria A few recommendations were made on the basis of observations made during the study and some of the results presented in the report. There is a need to review the status of those sewer lines that are non-functional with a view to determine the cost of rehabilitation as against reconstruction. The ultimate goal would be to make them functional while avoiding those factors that put them out of use. Such factors may include maintenance, foreign technology without appropriate adaptation and lack of resources (human, material, and financial). The concept of adopting adequate sewerage system (sewage collection and appropriate cost-effective treatment method) in relatively small but distinct concessions should be encouraged or even mandated. Such concessions would include Institutions of higher learning, military barracks, housing estates (Federal, State or private), etc. This would be the natural extension of the relative success of sewage systems in the FCT and the Southwest, some of which have been established for decades and are still operational. The individual systems can later be integrated if the need arises. The innovative improved septic tank system used in Enugu State deserves some special attention. It is surprising that it has not been introduced to other States, particularly in the southeast geo-political zone, despite its efficiency and ease of maintenance. Apart from being introduced to other geopolitical zones, it is being recommended that the system should be studied in a few Universities of Technology with a view to document its characteristics and improve on its performance. It is a valuable technology that can be introduced to other developing countries, if encouraged. The design of treatment plant in form of improved septic tank system could be in the form of sewage treatment seen in Enugu State Housing Estate Abakpanike, Enugu. How to Cite this Article: Sunday Adesogan, "Sewage Technology in Nigeria: A Pragmatic Approach" Science Journal of Environmental Engineering Research, Volume 2013, Article ID sjeer-266, 9 Pages, 2013. doi: 10.7237/sjeer/266 S c i e n c e J o u r n a l o f E n v i r o n m e n t a l E n g i n e e r i n g R e s e a r c h ( I S S N : 2 2 7 6 - 6 3 2 4 ) P a g e |8 DESIGN LAYOUT Operations Figure 6: Suggested Improved Septic Tank Sewage Treatment Method Each house is designed in such a way that they must be connected to the main pipe for water supply and human waste carrier pipe. The main sewage pipe is connected to the control pipe that run through each street to the main central treatment tank and Reserve tanks. When the main tank is filled up, this process, the main sewage tank is treated with weeds. This process continues until the tank is filled up with total solid from the faces and the tank is sealed up ready for evacuation. In the process of evacuating the main tank, the reserve tank is open up for use. It is suggested that the federal government should adopt a policy where cities are Laid down with layout/design as shown in above. Finally, one should not overlook the inter-relationship of infrastructural development of the nation. For example, the success of any sewerage system and it’s functionality at any instance is dependent on availability of water supply. In many cases in Nigeria, there would be adequate water reservoirs and appropriate distribution systems but no electricity to pump the water. Hence, recommendations include provision of mini-water schemes whereby the government looks for sources of raw water that could be harnessed separately for mini-water works and which will meet the city’s ultimate demand if integrated together. How to Cite this Article: Sunday Adesogan, "Sewage Technology in Nigeria: A Pragmatic Approach" Science Journal of Environmental Engineering Research, Volume 2013, Article ID sjeer-266, 9 Pages, 2013. doi: 10.7237/sjeer/266 S c i e n c e J o u r n a l o f E n v i r o n m e n t a l E n g i n e e r i n g R e s e a r c h ( I S S N : 2 2 7 6 - 6 3 2 4 ) P a g e |9 The government should also look into the issue of formulating and enforcing sewerage legislations both at the State and Federal levels with respect to the level of sewerage treatment to be embarked upon in the country. This should include enforcement of quality standards for discharge into the waterways of the country. It should also come with some incentives for industries that comply. References 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. American society of Civil Engineers (ASCE), (1982) Gravity Sewer Design and Construction ASCE MOPS 50 (WEF MOP FD5) Reston, VA: American Society of Civil Engineers Anonymous, (2008) Sewage Technology http:// www.en.wikpedia.org/wiki/sewage_collection_and_disposal Anonymous, (2008) International Source Book on Environmental Sound Technology for Waste Water and Storm water Management http://www.unep.or.jp/ietc/publications/Tech publications/Techpub-15/3-Afrca/1-2-3, asp Awoyemi, A.E (2009) “Perception of Students in Tertiary Institution of Poverty as an Index Intellectual Dwarfism” An Unpublished Ph.D Thesis in the Department of Statistics, Faculty of Science, University of Ibadan. Feachem, R. McGarry, M. and Mara, D, (2007): Water, Wastes and Health in Hot Climate. John Wiley and Sons, Chichester. Koren, H, (1980): Handbook of Environmental Health and Safety. Pergamon Press, Paris. Ogedengbe, M.O., (2001) Waste Management Systems Potential impacts, Paper presented during a course on Environmental Impact Assessment by National centre for Technology Management, OAU, Ile-Ife West African Health Examination Board,(1991). Waste Disposal and Environmental Hazard Control .Clarerianium Press, Ibadan. Wise, A. F. (2009): Water, Sanitary and Waste Services for Building. B. T. Batsford Limited, London . How to Cite this Article: Sunday Adesogan, "Sewage Technology in Nigeria: A Pragmatic Approach" Science Journal of Environmental Engineering Research, Volume 2013, Article ID sjeer-266, 9 Pages, 2013. doi: 10.7237/sjeer/266