HISTORICAL REVIEW OF URANIUM-VANADIUM PRODUCTION IN THE EASTERN CARRIZO MOUNTAINS, SAN JUANCOUNTY, NEW MEXICO, AND APACHE COUNTY, ARIZONA New Mexico Bureauof Mines and Mineral Open-file Report No. 193 by William L. Chenoweth with production statistics compiled by Elizabeth A. Learned March 1984 Resources CONTENTS Page Introduction.............................................. Early Prospecting Vanadium Mining 1 ......................................... ........................................... 2 4 U.S. Geological Survey Studies............................ 10 Manhattan Engineer District Activities.................... 10 ............................................ ............................................ ............................................. Uranium Mining 13 Summary....... 18 References... 20 FIGURES Figure 1. Mine Location Map, Carrizo Mountains Uranium Area, Apache County, Arizona, and San Juan In pocket County, New Mexico ........................ Figure 2. Uranium Productionin the Eastern Carrizo Mountains, San Juan County, New Mexico, and Apache County, Arizona......................... 22 TABLES Table 1. Details of Uranium/Vanadium Production in the Eastern Carrizo Mountains, San Juan County, New Mexico, and Apache County, Arizona 23 ............. Table 2. Vanadium Production 1942-1943, Lease 7 1-149-1ND-4225..............................-.. Table 3 . Table 4. Vanadium Production 1942-1947, VCA's East Reservation Lease, I-149-IND-5705 .............. 8 Location and Size of Plots, VCA's East Reservation Lease.......................................... 9 HISTORICAL REVIEW OF URANIUM-VANADIUM PRODUCTION I N THE EASTERN CARRIZO MOUNTAINS, SAN J U A N COUNTY NEW MEXICO, AND APACHE COUNTY, ARIZONA Introduction I n 1980, a r e p o r t w i t h t h e same t i t l e was o p e n - f i l e d b y t h e Grand J u n c t i o nO f f i c e Department of Energy (DOE) a s of t h e U.S. Technical Memorandum No. 210. S i n c et h i sr e p o r t was r e l e a s e d , c o n s i d e r a b l e amount of new i n f o r m a t i o n b e a r i n g on' t h e e a r l y of the Carrizo Mountains has mining history become a v a i l a b l e . T h e p r i n c i p a l s o u r c e o f new d a t a i s a d e t a i l e d r e p o r t prepared by t h eG e n e r a lS e r v i c e sA d m i n i s t r a t i o n (GSA), TrustAccountingDivisionfortheNavajo Thisdocument 1981) was a d m i t t e da se v i d e n c ei n (GSA, States, Docket NOS. Tribe vsUnited Tribe. C l a i m s Court,Navajo U.S. 69and Indian 299 (copper,vanadium, uranium,sand,rockandgravel!claims)heldinAlbuquerque, Mexico, February 24-March 4,1983. A copyof New t h e vandium and uranium s e c t i o n was obtain'ed for t h e N e w MexicoBureau and Mineral A of Mines Resources. review of t h e Vanadium CorporationofAmerica's 1947-1953 mill r e c e i p t s t o t h e (VCA) AtomicEnergyCommission (AEC), located i n t h e DOE a r c h i v e s a t Grand J u n c t i o n , added t o our knowledgeof the early the individuals mining, e s p e c i a l l y i n terms ofnames of who o p e r a t e d the VCA mines under contract. As this report deals only with historical production data, thereader Corey(1958), i s referred t o r e p o r t s byBlagbroughand Brown (1955), King (1951,1952),Mastersandothers(1955),and Stokes (1951,1954) for d e s c r i p t i o n s of thegeologyandore 1 deposits. A report by Albrethsen and McGinley (1982) gives the details of the AEC's uranium procurement program, and a report by of the mines. Anderson (1981) describes the current condition Figure 1 shows the locationsof the mines: the production is summarized in Table 1 and Figure 2. A DOE report (Chenoweth and Learned, 1980) covers the production and will Early history be of revised the in northern the near and western Carrizo Mountains, in Carrizo future. Prospecting Outcrops Mountains containing were uranium/vandium discovered minerals John Wade of Sweetwater, by the Arizona, around 1918. At that time the Navajo Reservationwas closed to 30, 1919, prospecting and mining. A Congressional Act of June opened the Navajo Reservation to prospecting claims inthe same manner as prescribed by and locating the United mining States Mining Law. This act allowed prospectors to enter the Reservation and stake a mining claim if their prospecting located promising mineralization. The locator of the claim then obtained a leaseon this land under terms that included escalating advance royalties and rentals, and annual work commitments. By 1920, Wade, operating as the Carriso Uranium Company, had located 40 claims the vicinity of astride the New Mexico-Arizona state line in 16. Milepost In April 1921 the area was examined W.byH. Staver, a consulting mining engineer. He noted that the company's holding consisted of the South Butte, Bluebell, North Star, and Hilltop n claim groups. The North Starclaims were astride the state line, with fiveinNew Mexico and six inArizona, and containedthe only development. Thirty-seven sacks of high-grade ore from these 1921). claims were stored at Beclabito Trading Post (Staver, He estimated that a total of 2,900 tons of probable ore could be developedon the property. The GSA (1981) could not locate the details of the Carriso Uranium Company's lease, except for the first year's rental on 177.45 acres paid in May1922. No production was recorded, and the disposition of the sacked ore at Beclabito is not known. TWO other companies acquired leases in the eastern Carrizos The Navajo Mining Company leased 80 during the early1920's. acres on April 6, 1921, effective May 10, 1921. The 80 acres 29 and 30, T. 13 N., included four contiguous claims in sections R. 5 W., Navajo Baseline and Meridian, in Apache County, Arizona. The four claims, Navajo Mining Claim, Navajo Mining Claims 1, 2, and 4, were covered by U.S. Mineral Survey Number 3643. appears that this lease was approximatelytwo miles westof Beclabito Trading Post in the vicinity of Milepost 12. (1981) report notes that1,500 pounds of ore lease in April1921. It The GSA was shipped from the This is the first recorded shipment of uraniferous material from the eastern Carrizo Mountains. The Value of the ore was listedas $68.33 (GSA, 1981). By 1922 the beginning to competitive radium decline with the industry as the newly in southwestern Colorado was carnotite ores nowere longer developed high-grade pitchblende in the Belgian Congo. A vanadium market never developed, as there was little demandfor domestic vanadium 3 due to imports from Peru. ore In spite of the lack of demand for carnotite ores, George 0. Williams and Nephi Johnson effective January22, 1924. leased 20.661 acres on June 8, 1923, This lease covered the Upper Bell Lode Claim of U.S. Mineral Survey Number1887. The only description of the location is in T. 11 N., R. 5 W., Navajo Baseline and Meridian,San Juan County, New Mexico. Since King Tutt Mesa is located in this north-central of part the township, it is very possible that the lease was located here. No production was located by the GSA (1981), but Office of Indian an Affairs memorandum of December4, 1936 (in GSA,1981) noted a 20ft-deep shaft, or hole, had been on dugthe claim, and about one ton of ore had been hauled to Durango, Colorado. On March 25, 1936, the Secretary of the Interior closed the Navajo Indian Reservation to claim location and for prospecting minerals until further authorization. In July, 1936, an application to prospect was made to the Executive Committee of the Navajo Tribal Council in the form of asking the council to pass a resolution requesting the Secretary of Interior to open the Navajo Reservation for mining to the applicant. The resolution was rejected by evidently did not want the Executive prospecting or Committee, mining on the which Reservation at that time. Vanadium Mining of By the late1930's, the mines in the carnotite region southwestern Colorado and southeastern Utah were being reopened for their vanadium content. At the same time, the Secretary of 4 the Interior Reservation The was being asked for prospecting Navajo Reservation to and open the Navajo by a Indian mining. was opened Congressional Act of May 11, 1938, but with new procedures. This act gave the Tribal Council the authority to enter into leases for the Reservation of the Interior. lands with approval of the Secretary Prospectors mining no claim longer under could enter regulations the Reservation and similar to those of the stake a United States Mining Law. The new mining regulations contained escalating annual rentals, a base royalty of 10% (mine-mouth value), bond requirements, acreage limitations, and a term of 10 years which couldbe extended Due to the vanadium for by uncertaintyof foreign war armaments, the Metals Reserve Company in 1942. purchasing ore. production. program and supplies federal and the government need for formed the The company beganan ore- increased the base price paid for vanadium At Monticello, Utah, the Defense Plant Corporation, a government agency, funded of a vanadium plantto construction the be operated by the Vanadium Corporation of America (VCA). Actual construction started in February, and on August 24, 1942, the first vanadium was produced. In April 1942, while construction was under ore-buying way, the Metals Reserve stationat Monticello and Company appointed (MRC) the established an United States Vanadium Corporation (USV) as its buying agent. All ore producers, independents and VCA, then sold ore to the MRC. MRC in turn had the ore milled by VCA or other mills. At Durango, Colorado, the Reconstruction Finance Corporation, a government agency, contracted with USV to convert 5 and operate an old lead smelterfor vanadium production. The vanadium was suppliedto Metals Reserve Company. United States Vanadium when operated the the government plant for the vanadium government purchasing until program early was 1944, terminated because of adequate vanadium stocks. U.S. Vanadium Corporation then purchased Corporation and the facilities operated from for the' them the Reconstruction production of Finance vanadium for commercial sales until August 31, 1945, when the plant was closed. The Metals Reserve's program was the stimulus to revive mining in the Carrizos. On April 5, 1940, effective May 9, 1940, John F. Wade, Thomas F. V. Curran, and H. R. Redington (d.b.a. Wade, Curran and CO.) leased 42.32 acres in the Carrizo Mountains. Their lease, I-149-IND-4225, covered the Syracuse Lode Claim near MP-16 and the Sunnyside Lode Claim in the western Carrizos. The lease was for a periodof five years. Production from the two claims isnot separated, butJohn Wade (pers. comm., 1955) stated the Syracuse was the first of the properties property to be mined. It was also one prospected by Wade's Carriso Uranium Co. in the 1920's. Shipments from Lease I-149-IND-4225 were recorded from May 1942 through October 1943. Details of the production are given below. 6 TABLE 2 Vanadium Production 1942-1943, Lease I-149-IND-4225, Wade, Curranand Co. Tons of "_ Year 1942 Pounds x225 1205 Ore 8.96 246 " 44,075 1943 720 - 40,343 Totals 966 4.37 84,418 Source: - Percent " 2.80 GSA (1981) Oreminedby Wade, Curranand Companywas and r a i l t o t h e mill a t Durango, Colorado.Lease shipped by t r u c k I-149-IND-4225 expired on May 9 , 1945. On April9,1941,theNavajoTribalCouncilrequestedthe t o the S e c r e t a r y of t h e I n t e r i o r t o l e a s e l a n d s f o r m i n i n g p u r p o s e s h i g h e s tb i d d e r .I no r d e rt ot a k ec a r eo ft h i ss i t u a t i o n ,t h e mining leases were written for large areas and subsequently of a s p e c i f i e d time period. r e d u c e di na c r e a g ea tt h ee n d The n e t e f f e c t of t h i s t y p e of l e a s e was t h a t a p r o s p e c t i n g p e r m i t was i s s u e d t o t h e h i g h e s t b i d d e r , who t h e n h a d t h e r i g h t t o up t o a maximum acreage. leaselandwithinthepermitarea On May t o r e q u e s t s by mining 29, 1942, i n r e s p o n s e companies, the O f f i c e ofIndianAffairsadvertisedanexploration l e a s e sale f o r c a r n o t i t e and r e l a t e d m i n e r a l s i n t h e e a s t e r n CarrizoMountains. The area o f f e r r e d was described as follows: "beginning a t a p o i n t on t h e New Mexico-Arizona S t a t e L i n e which i s approximately 8 1 / 3 miles s o u t h of t h e c o r n e r S t a t e s of Colorado,Utah, miles; thence south common t o t h e New Mexico, andArizona;thenceeast 1 2 miles; thence west 6 miles t o the Arizona- N e w Mexico s t a t e l i n e ; t h e n c e w e s t 3 1 / 2 m i l e s ; t h e n c e n o r t h 2 7 6 one mile: t h e n c e n o r t h miles: t h e n c e e a s t 1 0 miles: thence east 2 1 / 2 miles t o t h e Arizona-New Mexico s t a t e l i n e and i n t h e p o i n t ofbeginning." miles. The areacontainedapproximately104square This was t h e s e c o n dc a v n o t i t e The f i r s t was h e l d i n h e l d under thebiddingprocedures. November 1941 i n t h e n o r t h e r n lease s a l e for Navajolands and western Carrizo Mountains. Bids wereopenedonJune15, 1942, atwhichtimeVCAbid $7,600,andJohn $7,550 (GSA, F. Wade and Thomas F. V. C u r r a n ,p a r t n e r s ,b i d A s t h e b i d s were n e a r l ye q u a l , 1981, e x h i b i t 31). and s i n c e Wade and Curran offered t o pay$2,000overandabove h i g h e s tb i dr e c e i v e d ,t h eG e n e r a lS u p e r i n t e n d e n t S e r v i c e requested that the Commissioner of I n d i a n A f f a i r s make which was e x e c u t e d o n J u l y 1 4 , 1 9 4 2 , e f f e c t i v e J u l y 23, 1942, for a period of 1 0 years.Mining of t h a ty e a r of t h e Navajo VCA was a w a r d e d t h e l e a s e I- the d e c i s i o n t o a w a r d t h e l e a s e . 149-IND-5705, the and continuedthroughAugust were a l s o r e c o r d e d i n F e b r u a r y Lease I-149-IND-5705 ReservationLease"by VCA. 1945and commenced i n August 1944. S i n g l es h i p m e n t s i n J u l y 1947. was commonly r e f e r r e d t o as t h e " E a s t D e t a i l s of t h e vanadium p r o d u c t i o n are tabulated below. TABLE 3 Vanadium Production 1942-1947, V C A ' s East Reservation Lease Year 1942 1943 1944 1945 1946 1947 Tons of Ore "__ 2,063 7,082 1,056 15 0 15 P e r c e n t V2O5 Pounds x295 " " " 100,069 346,730 56,818 582 0 623 2.43 2.45 2.69 1.94 0 2.08 I _ 504,822 T o t a l s 2.47 10,231 8 Source: 1942-1945; GSA (1981) 1947; USGS memo datedJune 2, 1948 ( i n DOE f i l e s ) O n S e p t e m b e r 2 , 1 9 4 3 , t h e l e a s e was r e d u c e d t o a p e r m a n e n t 1 2 p l o t s (claims) t o t a l l i n g 436.79 a c r e s were o p e r a t i n gl e a s ea n d s e l e c t e d t o b er e t a i n e d .D e t a i l s of t h e s ep l o t sa r eg i v e n below. TABLE 4 Location and S i z e of P l o t s , V C A ' s East Reservation Lease Number Location Acres Name 1 RedWash 2 King T u t t P o i n t 3 Shadys i de 4 Williams Point 8.62 N. C e n t r a l King T u t t Mesa 5 Fissure 1.57 N. C e n t r a l King T u t t Mesa 6 Franks Point 6.23 NW King T u t t Mesa 7 Lower Oak Creek 8 Cottonwood B u t t e 9 Lone S t a r 6.20 E of MP-16 10 Oak Springs 5.53 Oak Springs 11 White Cap 20.66 S W of MP-16 12 Syracuse 4.13 Point Total 3.53 SE King T u t t M,esa 9.14 SW King T u t t Mesa 145.13 205.39 Oak C r e e k Canyon 20.66 Cottonwood Butte W of MP-16 436.79 a c r e s T h r e eo ft h ep l o t sn e a rM i l e p o s t covered the remainder C e n t r a l King T u t t Mesa 1 6 ( 9 , 11, and 1 2 ) of the area previously developed by the C a r r i s o Uranium Company on t h e i r North Star claims. The o r e from t h e E a s t R e s e r v a t i o n l e a s e 9 was t r u c k e d t o t h e m i l l a tM o n t i c e l l o ,U t a h ,u n t i l Later production in it c l o s e di nF e b r u a r y 1944. was shipped t o t h e Durango 1944and1945 t o VCA‘s vanadium m i l l i n p l a n t , and the1947productionwent Naturita, Colorado. The Metals Reserve’s program t e r m i n a t e d i n March 1944, a t a l l b u t ceased in the Carrizo which time vanadiummining Mountains. GeologicalSurveyStudies U.S. A s p a r t of t h e U.S. GeologicalSurvey‘s (USGS) i n v e s t i g a t i o n s of c r i t i c a l war m a t e r i a l s , the uranium-vanadium d e p o s i t s of t h e C a r r i z o Mountains were examined during October and November 1942. The USGS g e o l o g i s t s examinedand mapped the e x i s t i n g mines, and acquired production history and statistics of t h e vanadium-ore reserves a l s o were o p e r a t o r s .E s t i m a t e s made. from t h e mine For t h ee a s t e r nC a r r i z oM o u n t a i n s ,t h e ya r ea sf o l l o w s : I n f e r r e d Ore Tons -% 2 V-” O Area - Indicated O r e Tons x2205 -- E a s t s i d e Mines25,000 2-2.5 5,000 1.5-2.5 Syracuse Mine 600 2-2.5 1,500 2.0-2.5 Horse Mesa 600 2-2.5 9,000 1.5-2.5 “zm Total The mines on, and 35,500 2 2 i n t h e v i c i n i t y o f ,King T u t t Mesa were referred to as theEastside Mines, anamestillusedinrecent USGS r e p o r t s . The d e t a i l e d r e s u l t s investigationsarein of t h e October-November1942 a r e p o r tb y 10 Duncan and Stokes (1942),which was s u b m i t t e d t o t h e ManhattanEngineer geologyandthedescription publishedby District. of t h e o r e d e p o s i t s The g e n e r a l was l a t e r Stokes ( 1 9 5 1 ) . ManhattanEngineer District A c t i v i t i e s formed t h e During World War 11, t h e Army CorpsofEngineers D i s t r i c t (MED) f o r t h e ManhattanEngineer development of atomic of weapons and a c q u i s i t i o n of raw m a t e r i a l s f o r t h e p r o d u c t i o n weapons. The Murray 1943, f o r t h e H i l l Area of MED was e s t a b l i s h e d o n J u n e 1 5 , majorpurpose m a t e r i a l s onwhich of e x p l o r a t i o n anddevelopmentof t h e e n t i r e Manhattan Project raw was dependent. Determination and e v a l u a t i o n of t h e uranium resources of t h e world was f i r s t undertaken,andtheprogram was l a t e r expanded t o includethoriumores. A c o n t r a c t , No. W-7405 Eng-78, made w i t h UnionMines s u b s i d i a r y ofUnion o u tt h e work.The DevelopmentCorporation (UMDC), a CarbideandCarbonCorporation,forcarrying c o n t r a c tp r o v i d e dt h a ta l lc o s t ss h o u l d reimbursed by the government, with UMDC e f f e c t i v e May 11, 1943, was be no f i x e d fee o r p r o f i t t o . On theColoradoPlateau, UMDC's i n v e s t i g a t i o n s were l i m i t e d t o the S a l t Wash Member of the Morrison Formation, EntradaSandstoneinthearea and t h e of t h e r o s c o e l i t e d e p o s i t s . Geologic s t u d i e s for t h e e a s t e r n C a r r i z o M o u n t a i n s a r e c o n t a i n e di n a report by Coleman (1944). A l l of the known o u t c r o p s of uranium/vanadiumminerals,prospects,andmines mapped anddescribedby UMDC g e o l o g i s t s . 11 were The g e o l o g i s t s mapped the Syracuse Mine of Wade, Curranand Co. and d e s c r i b e d s m a l l open p i t s andan a d i t s on V C A ' s P l o t s 9 and 1 2 , f i v e s m a l l on P l o t 7, two open c u t s and a n a d i t on P l o t 3,and onPlot adit a smalladit 1. O f t h e 128 uranium-vanadium-bearing outcrops examined by UMDC, 59 were on ground l e a s e d by VCA, and Wade, Curranand CO. The remaining 69 exposures were c o n s i d e r e d t o b e " r e l a t i v e l y unimportant andhave a poor prospectivevalue" (Coleman,1944, p. 19). A s p a r t of t h e i r i n v e s t i g a t i o n s , areasthatshouldbeacquired UMDC g e o l o g i s t s recommended by t h e F e d e r a l g o v e r n m e n t f o r t h e development of uraniumresources.IntheCarrizoMountains, s e l e c t e d 1 2 p l o t s fromexplorationlease CurranBrothersand UMDC I-149-IND-6197 issued t o Wade, w i t h 2 / 3 i n t e r e s t a s s i g n e d t o T h i sl e a s e ,c o n t a i n i n g USV. was 24 mileslong, 1 6 8 squaremiles, 7 miles wide, e a s t - w e s t w i t h t h e s o u t h e a s t north-south,and c o r n e rl o c a t e dn e a r Cove School(Fig. 1). Although Coleman (1944, p. 20) consideredtheSyracuse "tohavethebestprospectivevalue NavajoReservation," of anythingseen Mine on t h e it was n o t a c q u i r e d s i n c e t h e p r o p e r t y was locatedoutsidetheexplorationleaseboundary. Late in1942 andearlyin1943 the ManhattanEngineer District (MED) began a program t o o b t a i n uraniumfromdomestic sources.InJanuary vanadium (U-V) 1943, VCA agreed t o produce a uranium- sludge a t M o n t i c e l l o t h a t On a u n i t p r i c e b a s i s . was sold by The sludgecontained MRC t o MED 45 t o 50% u308 and about 25% V2O5 and was shipped t o t h e V i t r o M a n u f a c t u r i n g a t Canonsburg, Pennsylvania, Company for a d d i t i o n a p l r o c e s s i n gT . ailings 12 from the Monticello mill were considered by the in uranium for additional processing. closed the Monticello mill and MED to be too low In February 1944, MRC ceased production of both mill the fused oxide (~205)and U-V sludge. In 1945, Plant VCA Corporation leased and the Monticello purchased from MRC from the Defense remaining ore from other stockpiles. VCA processed the stockpiled ore plus ore sources again in and sold a U-Vsludge to the MED until the mill closed 1946. During the 1943-1944 period, USV constructed and operated a uranium-vandium sludge plant at the Durango site, under a costplus-fixed-fee agreement with the MED. Feed for the plant consisted of vanadium tailings from past and current operations. The sludge was shipped to a refinery at Grand Junction, Colorado, operatedfor the also to make the sludge MED by suitable USV, for where the further vanadium was removed refining to black oxide. Uranium Mining The Atomic Energy Commission was established by the Atomic Energy Act of August 1, 1946, in recognition of a need to provide for a civilian government development of atomic promote the research agency energy and for which could military development assure purposes necessary to the the and continued also utilization of atomic energy for peaceful applications. During World War 11, the Manhattan Engineer District (MED), under the Army of Engineers, Corps had been charged with the development of atomic weapons. Its activities included research and development, engineering and 13 design, the operation of f o r weapons m a t e r i a l s andcomponents,and production facilities weapons. of uranium for t h e p r o d u c t i o n o f n u c l e a r the acquisition A l l of t h e s e MED f u n c t i o n s , a n d t h e numerousgovernment- were owned f a c i l i t i e s i n which many of them were being performed, transferred to the AEC by E x e c u t i v e Order 9816, e f f e c t i v e a t midnight, December 31, 1946. An O f f i c eo f N e w York Directed Operations was e s t a b l i s h e d by the AEC onJune9,1947,and office supervised the procuring and processing that of uranium u n t i l t h e AEC's D i v i s i o n of Raw M a t e r i a l s was formed i n October 1947 t o direct t h o s e a c t i v i t i e s from t h e A E C ' s H e a d q u a r t e r s O f f i c e i n Washington, D.C. On t h e C o l o r a d o P l a t e a u , t h e AEC began a procurement program The f i r s t d o m e s t i cc o n t r a c t f o r uraniumconcentrate. was signed w i t h VCA on August 28, 1947, e f f e c t i v e May 20, 1947, t o purchase uranium concentrates Colorado. from the company's mill i n N a t u r i t a , The AEC a l s oc o n t r a c t e dw i t h VCA, e f f e c t i v e October 8, 1948, t o buy c o n c e n t r a t e s from t h e AEC-owned mill a t Durango, which VCA had l e a s e d w i t h a n o p t i o n t o S i n c e a m a r k e t haddeveloped, miningon beganfrom t h e i rE a s tR e s e r v a t i o n VCA began prospecting and Lease. t h el e a s e ,m a i n l yf r o mP l o t pers. comm.). P r o d u c t i o ni n c o n t a i n i n g 7,614pounds buy. I n March 1948,shipments 3 (PageEdwards,1955, 1948amounted u308 (Fig. t o 1,303tons 2). Durango m i l l i n March 1949 r e s u l t e d i n The reopening of the a shorter haulage for t h e mines i n t h e C a r r i z o Production increased in Mountains. 1949 with mining expansion on the ReservationLease,mainlyon P l o t 3 b u t a l s oo nP l o t s 14 East 1, 2, 4, 6 through 9, 11, and 12. differentiated the I t was n o tu n t i lJ u l y 1950 t h a t VCA numbers of t h e i n d i v i d u a l p l o t s r e c e i p t s t o t h e AEC. Hence, t h ee x a c ts o u r c e on o r e of t h e 6,758tons c o n t a i n i n g 29,786 pounds u308 l i s t e d as E a s t R e s e r v a t i o n Lease Also i n 1949, C a t 0 S e l l s made (Table 1) cannot be determined. i n i t i a l shipmentsfrommineralizedoutcropsnear Oak Springs, Arizona. I nt h ee a r l y1 9 5 0 ' s ,t h eN a v a j oT r i b a lC o u n c i la d o p t e d a series of resolutions dealing with uranium mining which approvedby t h e Commissioner of I n d i a nA f f a i r s . developed the r e g u l a t i o n s f o r p r o s p e c t i n g andmining o b t a i n permits for prospecting.Miningpermits were no l o n g e r t h e s u b j e c t These r e s o l u t i o n s permits, A l l prospectorsneeded miningleases,androyaltyschedules. t o Navajos, who c o u l da s s i g n were were g r a n t e do n l y them t o non-Navajos.Mining of c o m p e t i t i v e b i d d i n g , b u t negotiatedwiththeTribalCouncil, to leases were s u b j e c t t o approval by t h e Bureau of I n d i a nA f f a i r s .T h e s ea c t i o n s would g r e a t l yi n c r e a s e the Carrizo Mountains and throughout prospecting and mining in t h e NavajoReservation. During1950, VCA's o p e r a t i o n sc o n t i n u e d andat thecanyonview MineonPlot 7. t o expand on P l o t 3 A l s o , numerous smallnon- VCA o p e r a t i o n s commenced throughout the e a s t e r n C a r r i z o Mountains. Among t h ep r o p e r t i e st h a tc o n t r i b u t e ds i g n i f i c a n t l y t o theyear'sproduction were Cat0 S e l l s ' Upper Canyon Mine and Nakai Chee Begay's Red Wash O f t h et o t a l Reservation Lease. During t h a ty e a rp r o d u c t i o n t o n s of o r e c o n t a i n i n g reached a peakof5,089 (Fig. 2). Mine. uranium,73% 27,525pounds u308 came from t h eE a s t The 1950 p r o d u c t i o nr e p r e s e n t e dt h ea l l - t i m e 15 "~ yearly record for uranium produced in the eastern Carrizos. During May and June 1951, the AEC drilled 12 holes in vicinity of Nakai Chee Begay's Red Wash Mine,with allnegative results (Anderson and others, 1952). After reaching a peak in 1950, production declined low to a of 1,504 tonsof ore containing 8,718 pounds u308 in 1952 (Fig. 2). This decline was largely dueto the fact that all of the exposed ore in outcrops and in the old mines was depleted and no exploration occurred. On January 7, 1952, the AEC opened an ore-buying station at Shiprock, New Mexico. This station provided a nearby market for independent producers in the Four Corners area. Also, during the first halfof 1952 the AEC conducted an extensive exploration drilling project throughout the eastern Carrizos. This drilling project discovered ore on King Tutt Mesa and in the Oak Springs area (Masters and others, 1955). In 1953, Walter Duncan, Jr. commenced mining at the Begay No. 1 Mine, which was discovered by AEC drilling (Garbrecht, 1954), and mining continued on Plot 3 where and AEC VCA drilling discovered additional ore. Mining resumed at the old Syracuse RFhR Mine. During the spring andsummer Mine and was renamed the of 1953, the AEC conducted two more drilling projects in the eastern Carrizos. These drilling projects discovered several small orebodies and the extension of others on Plot 3 and in the Oak Springs and Syracuse Mine areas (Blagbrough and Brown, 1955). On June 30, 1953, VCA exercised their option and purchased the Durango mill from the AEC. 16 the a t Cat0 Sells' Oak During1954,sustainedproductionbegan Springs Mine and a t V C A ' s P l o t 7. On November 1, 1954, t h e new Kerr-McGee O i l I n d u s t r i e s , Inc. m i l l a tS h i p r o c k , beganoperating and p u r c h a s i n g o r e N e w Mexico, fromindependentproducers. Operation of t h e ore b u y i n g s t a t i o n was taken over by Kerr-McGee. The o r e p u r c h a s e d b y t h e AEC a t t h e b u y i n g s t a t i o nwas subsequently sold t o Kerr-McGee a l o n g w i t h o r e from o t h e r AEC ore-buyingstations. Production from V C A ' s P l o t 1 0 Mine and Texas Mining Company's Tent Mine and Begay I n c l i n e began i n 1955. Ore p r o d u c t i o nd u r i n gt h a ty e a r 23,502 was 4,481tonscontaining pounds u308, t h e s e c o n d h i g h e s t y e a r f o r t h e e a s t e r n C a r r i z o s (Fig. 2 ) . A f t e r r e a c h i n g a peak i n 1955, p r o d u c t i o n g r a d u a l l y d e c l i n e d t o a low i n 1961, when only 324 t o n s of o r e c o n t a i n i n g 1 , 4 4 6 Poundsu308 were produced(Fig. 2). The d e p l e t i o no ft h e known orebodies was t h ec a u s e of t h i s d e c l i n e . decliningtrendseenin 1960 (Fig. 2 ) was due t o p r o d u c t i o n from P l o t 3. the new Lookout P o i n t I n c l i n e o n 1962 i n c r e a s e d t o 1,933tonscontaining8,124 P r o d u c t i o ni n poundsu308(Fig. Begay No. The anomaly i n t h e 2 ) a s DavisMining Co. commenced mining a t t h e 2 Mine t h a t hadbeendeveloped in the vicinity of e a r l i e r AEC o r e h o l e s . On March 1, 1963, VCA a c q u i r e d t h e Kerr-McGee mill a t Shiprockandclosed i t s Durango mill l a t e r t h a t month. eastern Carrizos, material uneconomicalbecause Inthe which was p r e v i o u s l y c o n s i d e r e d of t h e l o n g h a u l a g e t o mined. 17 Durango could now be A f t e r reaching a s m a l l peak i n 1962, p r o d u c t i o n g r a d u a l l y declinedto 1965(Fig. a low of 344 tonscontaining1,363pounds 2). Thisdropoccurredbecause was b e i n g d e p l e t e d a n d o t h e r u308 i n the Begay No. 2 Mine small o p e r a t i o n s were runningoutof ore. a t t h e Begay No. 2 The d i s c o v e r y of some a d d i t i o n a l o r e boosted the 1966 p r o d u c t i o n t o 964 t o n s c o n t a i n i n g u308 (Fig. 2). I n a f i n a lc l e a n - u pe f f o r ti n 740 t o n s of o r ec o n t a i n i n g 2,089pounds Begay 1, Begay 2, andNelsonPoint 4,215 pounds 1967, VCA produced u308 (Fig. 2 ) from t h e Mines. The f i n a l shipment was made i n August 1 9 6 7 . VCA merged with Foote Mineral Company onAugust Foote continued the Shiprock milling operation until 31, 1967. May 1968 when t h eo p e r a t i o n sc e a s e d . Summary Forty-nine properties in the eastern Carrizo Mountains have produced46,507tons of ore c o n t a i n i n g 217,839pounds averaging 0.23% u308 s i n c e 1948. contained2,263,758pounds I na d d i t i o n ,t h e s eo r e s V2O5 averaging 2.43% V2O5. interestingtonotethat 115,985pounds uranium produced i n t h e e a s t e r n C a r r i z o VCA's E a s t ReservationLease--landsthat J u l y 1942 f o r vanadium. onKing these plots p l u s the other approximately127,100pounds U308, Mountains, came from were a c q u i r e d i n of 1.4 square miles. mineson were l o c a t e d Productionfrom t h e mesa t o t a l e d u308, o r 58%of 18 It i s o r 53% o f t h e t o t a l S i x p l o t s of t h i s l e a s e T u t t Mesa, a na r e a U308 and t h er e g i o n ' st o t a l . On King T u t t Mesa, P l o t 3 , c o n t a i n i n g 145 acres,produced at l e a s t 72,400 pounds, o r 33% of t h e t o t a l i n the e a s t e r nC a r r i z o s . 19 uraniumproduced References Albrethsen, Holger, Jr., and McGinley, F.E., 1982, Summary history of domestic uranium procurement under U.S. Atomic Energy Commission contracts, final report: U.S. Department of Energy, Report GJBX-220(82), 162 p. Anderson, 0. J., 1981, Abandoned or inactive uranium mines in New Mexico: New Mexico Bureauof Mines and Mineral Resources, Open-file Report 148,778 p. Anderson, A. H., Foster, J. R., and Hurley, D. B., 1952, Results Arizona: U.S. Atomic of preliminary drilling, Red Rock, Energy Commission, Report TM-39, 4 p. (open-filed 1979). Blagrough, J. W., and Brown, J. F., 1955, Diamond and wagon drilling in the east Carrizo area, Apache County, Arizona and San Juan County, New Mexico, Contracts No. AT(31-11-1364 U.S. Atomic Energy Commission, Report RMEand AT(05-1)-231: 83 (Pt. l), 19 p. (open-filed 1973). Chenoweth, W. L., and Learned, E. A., 1980, Historical review of uranium-vanadium production in the northern and western Carrizo Mountains, Apache County, Arizona: U.S. Department of Energy, Report TM-209, 19 p. Coleman, A. H., 1944, A reporton the geology and ore deposits of the B'Cla B'Toh (Beclabito) district, Carrizo uplift area, New Mexico-Arizona: Union Mines Development Corporation, Report RMO-469, 28 p. (open-filed by AEC 1957). Corey, A. S., 1958, Petrology of the uranium-vanadium ores of the Nelson Point No. 1 Mine, San Juan County, New Mexico: U.S. Atomic Energy Commission, Report RME-122, 30 p. (open-filed 1970). Duncan, D. C., and Stokes, W. L., 1942, Vanadium deposits in the Carrizo Mountains district, Navajo Indian Reservation, northeastern Arizona and northwesternNew Mexico: U.S. Geological Survey, Report RMO-28,32 p. (open-filed by DOE 1982). of mining methods on the outcome Garbrecht, Louis, 1954, Effects of small mines, Begay claim No. 1, King Tutt Mesa, east Carrizo area, New Mexico: U.S. Atomic Energy Commission, Report TM-51, 2 p. (open-filed 1979). General Services Administration, 1981, Navajo vanadium narrative in Accounting report on Navajo property, copper, missions, National Monuments, rightsof way, sand, rock, gravel, and vanadium, Dockets 69, 299, 353, volume1: General Services Administration, Indian Trust Accounting Division Report, p. 46-65, appendix 67 p. 20 King, J. W., 1951, Geological reconnaissance of King Tutt Mesa, east Carrizo district Arizona-New Mexico: U.S. Atomic Energy Commission, Report RMO-702, 16 p. (open-filed 1981). King, J. W., 1952, Geology of Horse Mesa, Arizona-New Mexico: U.S. Atomic Energy Commission, Report TM-20, 6 p. (open-filed 1979). Masters, J. A., Hatfield, K. G., Clinton, N. J., Dickson, R. E,, Maise, C. R., and Roberts, Lewis, 1955, Geologic studies and diamond drilling in the east Carrizo area, Apache County, Arizona, and San Juan County, New Mexico: U.S. Atomic Energy Commission, Report, RME-13 (Pt. l), 55 p. (open-filed 1973). Staver, W. H., 1921, Report on the Carriso Uranium Company's claims in the San Juan Indian Reservation: Unpublished consulting mining engineers report, 25 p. Stokes, W. L., 1951, Carnotite deposits in the Carrizo Mountains area, Navajo Indian Reservation, Apache County, Arizona, and San Juan County,New Mexico: U.S. Geological Survey, Circular 111, 5 p. Stokes, W. L., 1954, Some stratigraphic, sedimentary, and structural relationsof uranium deposits in the Salt Wash sandstone: U.S. Atomic Energy Commission, Report RME-3102, Technical Information Service, Oak Ridge, Tennessee, 50 p. 21 PZl Arizona E 3 New Mexico 35,000 Calendar Year Figure 2~ Uranium production, eastern CarrizoMountains, San Juan County, New Mexico,andApache County, Arizona. Page1 Detailsof Index No. Mine 59. Harvey Begay 3 60. Tony Tuc 61. of 5 TABLE 1 Uranium/Vanadium Production i n the Eastern CarrizoMountains, San JuanCounty, New Mexico and Apache County,Arizona (Revised9/1/83) Tons Ore - Pounds u3°8 Pounds v2°5 Periods o f Production/ Operator(s) % V2O5 Rose Mining Co. 21 49 0.12 407 1,379 0.17 26,074 Upper Red Canyon 26 134 0.26 1,695 62. King 6 54 114 0.11 773 63. Barton & Begay (BeclabitoLease) 254 740 0.15 11,311 2.23 1950Barton, Begay & Beyale 1950- Barton & Begay 1951- Lewis Barton 1953-Caylor 81 Neeley 64. Rocky F l a t s 1 , 2 (Rocky 1 , 2 ) 698 2,214 0.16 34,154 2.45 65. Canyon 1 111 237 0.11 4,6391 2~.09 66. John John1 25 97 0.19 1,392 2.78 1955John 67. King 2 557 1,761 0.16 31,424 2.82 1950-54- 68. Cottonwood Butte ( P l o t 8 ) ------- SeeFootnote 860 2.05 1956Troy 1 -- - 3.26 1950-1951 Lone S t a r ( P l o t 9 ) _"" See Footnotes 1and2 276 19503.05 16,852 0.33 1,814 - Tony Garnonez 0.72 1955,1957Troy ---- - 250 3.00 15,013 0.25 1,245 69. Charles Ashcroft/ 1956-57- T i t a 6 UranTummCorp. 1962- W.D. Tripp 1966- Sam Harvey 3.20 1953- ------ Rose Mining Co. 1950-52- Barton & Lee 1953,55- B a r r e t t Smith Mng.Co. 1 1950-51,1953- Pete A t c i t t y John Jimmie King 1949- VCA 1950-51 - Alfred Ne1 son 1954- VCA 1943,1949VCA Raymond Marshall 1950-51-Harrv Russell 1952-Leroy Pittigrew 1962- VCA Table 1 (continued) Page2 Index No. Pounds Tons Ore - m Mine -""- See Footnotes 1and2 225 0.27 1,203 2.96 13,321 70. Syracuse ( P l o t 12) 71. 1.88 Hazel 72. White Cap ( P l o t 11) 73. Syracuse (R, F, & R, Sam Harvey) 1,357 0.16 Val 1 75. ------- -- ----------- Periods o f Production/ Operator(s) 1943,1949- VCA 1950-52-Leroy Pettigrew 1955,1957- Leroy Pettigrew See Footnote 1 - SeeFootnote 3 - - --- ---- ------- 2.60 102,491 1949- VCA 1942-43- Wade, Curran & Co. 1954-56- Andrew A. Fry 1956-58- T i t a n Uranium Co. 1964-66- Sam Harvey 73 135 Upper Canyon & Lower 2,795 9,496 76. Leroy (MP-552) 25 96 0.19 2.46 1,230 77. Oak Springs (Gravel 5,1120.23 23,289 2.28233,362 1950,1954-59- Cat0 Sells 1962,1966- W.D.Tripp 0.24 9,389 11 1,458 2.82 1949,50-Cat0 S e l l s 1955-57- VCA 1957-58-Tanner & Thomas 7%. 79. View % V705 112 1,9670.28 11,051 74. ey Pounds V705 % U30q of 5 Top) 1,979 Oak10) Springs (Plot Lower Oak Creek ( P7 )l o t " " " 21,014 3,870 0.09 2.29 3,338 1950-Cat0 0.17 1950,1955-56,1961- Cat0 S e l l s 1962-63- T r i p p Mining Co. 1963-64- W.D. Tripp 115,252 2.06 SeeFootnotes 1 and 2 - --0.27 171,268 ' Sells 1961- Davis Mining Co. ---- 1943-44,1948-50- VCA 1950-52Hosteen S.Begay 1950- Eugene Tapahanso 1951- Tom Jones, J r . 1954-57,1961-64- VCA 1955-59- Kennedy & McGee 1960- C.H. Corey, Jr. 1961- Will iam George Table 1 (continued) Page3 Pounds Tons Index No. Mine 80. S a l t Canyon 81. FranksPoint(Plot6) .82. Upper'& Lower a l t Rock0.17 1.93 S4,122 93 Pounds U?02 % U2Og 4,473 331 0.18 ------358 % V7O5 V705 2.41 -------- - SeeFootnote1 1950- Cat0 S e l l s 1953-Shorty & T u t t 1954-Hosteen S. Begay 1955- Kennedy & McGee 1949- VCA 1949- VCA . ~. 84. Sunnyside & Lookout Point 2.82 144,337 0.32 16,327 2,556 85. Lookout P o i n t I n c l i n e 86. Shadyside2 " " " 506 2,713 0..27 28,485 SeeFootnotes 1 and 2 6,183 3.76 66,842 0.35 87. Shadyside,ShadysideIncline -""3.14 108,589 0.26 8,8411,728 SeeFootnotes 88. Nelson Point SeeFootnotes1 3.94 211,347 0.25 " " " 13,364 2,684 Tent ------- See Footnotes and 12 " " " 809 89. Periods of Production/ Operator(s) 1950-51 - Eugene Tapahonso 1961-62- Davis Mining Co. 107 83. ~ 2.26 54,156 0.22 5,303 1.1 98 of 5 1 and 2 and2 - 2.81 - ----- ---- - - -- ------ . .. - " 1942, 1948. -50- VCA 1950- Billy,Peterson,&Shorty 1950- Billy & Shorty 1950-54-Paul Shorty 1956,1959- VCA 1960- C.H. Corey, Jr. 1960-61 - Will iam George 1942,1498-50- VCA 1951,1953-54-Harry 1954-55,1966- VCA Russell 1942,1948-50- VCA 1950- T u t t & Thomas 1950-51- T u t t & Tanner 1951-Harry Russell 1951 ,'53,'56,1964-65- VCA 1952-King T u t t 1942-43,1948-50VCA 1950-58,1961-Paul Shorty 1965-67- VCA 1955- Texas Mining Co. 1956-57- Eugene Tapahonso 1963- Hazel Bryant Table 1 (continued) Index No. Page 4 of 5 Tons Pounds Mine 0.20 Ore % u30q % v705 v705 Begay 190,638 2 91. Begay I n c l i n e 655 3,475 0.27 92. Carrizo 1 828 3,426 93. Begay 1 3,921 16,491 94. King T u f t P o i n t ( P l o2t ) -""2.5915,2220.32 1,900 294 95. King T u f f 1 96. Red Wash 97. Junction 18 38 0.11 153 0.43 1953-Walter 98. A1 ongo 27 76 0.14 76 0.14 1956- E.J. Alongo 99. RedWash 61 127 0.10 636 0.53 1952- Hosteen S. Begay 100. RedRock 22 65 0.15 1,001 2.25 1950-51-Leroy 101. Red Wash 27 137 0.26 1,176 2.19 1950-Leroy P o i n t ( P l o1t ) 4,515 Periods of Production/ Operator(s) 90. 1.42 18,450 Pounds u308 8,257 290 0.18 2.11 1962- Davis Mining Co. 1963-64- Hazel I . Davis 1965-66- Fritz-Ericson Co. 1967- VCA 38,215 2.92 1955-56-TexasMining 0.21 21,917 1.32 1956-58- Spafford & Sons 0.21 127,499 1.63 1953-54- Walter Duncan, Jr. 1966-67- VCA See Footnotes 1 and 2 --- ---- 1,060 Co. 1942, 1948-50- VCA 1950- John Joe 1950- Ray Marshall 1950- Leroy Petti grew 1951-Carl Thomas 1953,1956- VCA 1951,1953-Shorty & T u f f 1956- Sylvania Mining Co. 1958- Charles N. Pickens -""_ See Footnotes 1 and 2 2.9717,786 300 0.37 2,206 -- - ---- 1942,1948-50- VCA 1951-52- Sam Harvey 1952- Harry Russell Duncan Pettigrew Pettigrew Table 1 (continued) Page 5 of 5 Tons Index No. Mine 102. Upper Red Wash 103. Rocky Spring 5/ East Reservation Lease - Pounds Pounds " Ore .!a!?& ' I 338 10,002 0.24 1,610 11 3 311,503 6,7580.22 29,786 % u?oq 0.01 ~705 62 % V7Oq Periods of Production/ Operation(s) ' 1-48 1950-51- Nakai Chee Begay 1953- Pershing Mining Co. 0.28 1951- Jerome Chee 2.30 1948-50- VCA production shipped as East Reservation Lease, see Footnote5. During the period August 1942 through February1945, shipments from the East Reservation Lease totaled 10,216 tons o f ore averaging2.47% V2O5. Mining wason Plot 3 w i t h some production from Plots 1 , 2, 7, 9, and 12. 3/ During the period July 1942 t h r o u g h August 1943, a . t o t a l of 966 tons of ore, averaging 4.37% V205was shipped from the Syracuse and Sunnyside Mines (Sunnyside is i n the western Carrizos). -4/. An additional 410 tons of material was shipped from this property for which no payment was received f o r either uranium or vanadium. 5 / ' Early, 1948-50, production.from Plot 3, also includes minor production from Plots 1, 2 , 4, 6, 7, 9;-1-1,:and 12. 1/ Early 2/ Source: AEC production records, GSA report, AEC field notes, ' VCA mill receipts, and Bureau ofIndianAffairsrecords. LEGEND S.W. 114 F E N C E L A K E I:IOO,OOO S H E E T C O N T Q U R INTERVA,b =.20M E T E R S a t p 8, S T R I H E Y' FAULT 1 INFERRED " FAULT -I"-- . .-, . . ,' , . .. .. ! . I " . . .. - I . . . _ ! . ' . . . I I I . .. , !, I / . - .. -"" . 1 ... ' -I i: X I J . . ' . , , I . . !.. .. . F P . I .. I . . .. 1 . 1 , I ' c -_ : . . . - ... . . 4 : ! I ........ - .-. -,. .- -. - "- ,,.".. ___._ .., - - .,-.- ". ._. .... .", .... .I- a I.,. I1 . . . I _.. ,, , .,.,.,._ - ., -=...",., . ". ,"", ....... -- ""._ .-.- .- . , -. .."__..." . "". .,". "," -- .., . ~ "" _.I ~ , & ,I, - . - h - - . . I " " .- ' - ' I .-I i I . ' I "-., . . I - ._. ' . ,. 3. ' . =- . -