Norman Jewison: Commercial Success, Critical Failure An Honors Thesi s (1 D c199) by Ant.hnny Thes is Hall L. Beeson Di reel.or SUit.e Univprsit:,,- ('lune i e , I nd i ana February, f'>...;pec\.pd dat(~ 1987 of graduation: >Ja;.- 19M! Sc '2.0 \! ·1 ' ... 1he.:;i: J L.D . d\J·f2;'( ;;';;"1 I I QS7 Table of Contents , BJ.f4 In t roduc~ T Commen t a i. on .. 1':'>- F. i . ;:-; . on: r ..... . 6 .And Jusr.icp for Ai ]0 1:2 Thp f 0 \J Jewison r f, Lm s as a j n rom par j s r' n . riirertor. l ;) 1I Cone 1 us jon .•.• 1H R i. hI i og raph:v •. I~ Introduction The r-tlmost hCi n=~ for t. ~ () f I ms J tCO~'; in Ci '\ 0 r man of t.he Cill fi Ims been c.;llh.)(·et C I' j f I i son neg;-lt \\-P, n C Cl n thpy ha\e t)(~gan In 1::lt:i2 bf~en alsn from revIews !'-.()met JOlt'S h 11 i ] e t nl s t s . (1irr>ctin!:!, car'eer hhi('h successful, ni 1 (-h('> film rs . I-',pst h'o(~f, ra[lh~- reet.or, J) oid fn se(' t the al' the eno \ornan 1 ian t, but -j ons on Flddler' un ( Fin I p r, f i ! m S 0 \. t:'" r' s j at.ion. His ~1 i-~; ed i T. Joel F j J I.L e j' ilm revipws theme m n i l r,'t the i r' nt, SUb,jP(,T '~ j ) 0 j ThE-> '1 t tim f: s maLt.f~j', Jl aWl br i I- reducing ,he lie four tp{~hn of his Jl:OSt. i ea I expel't.i se hegR11 his variet.y ShOhS pro\.;pss as p t~c recent fiLms. in 1 he [1 rea of freC]llPfl t. mel\-l e- goer. a a tllr the riir'f"c-toJ' sc-ri pT shows \.;i t h h-ri t.Fr and He'tor anad 1811 Hroad('ast.l ng (:()rporjandf~rl him F1 'tour Hit val'i 9 i () n aga i surfaces p j In the hibil0g- in mind hhpre he st'veral I the in the one 1 Hb - tl:e significance. s i mr i,'t- Fl p r n ri u (, e in (,\1 0 cit z, \io r i t. z • papPI' • make no (' i aims of possess i ng 1n Toronto, 2 () 8 i hCit·]PS signifirnnce of Norm8n ,Jeh'lson and Rm ( - :.. 0 r mCi 'I ,J e his () n of tllis Rearing- this fi 1m, 2 (i tee h n i cal 1 ~l pro fie i his theIr sO('lHl In the Heat go unsC'athpd. not again: t. 0 stu d :.~ are a H];d as Harry 2 Garland, Danny Kaye, and Jackie Gleason. In 1962 Jel-lison Pounds of Trouble. more films directed his From there he has including: The first gone on Cincinnati Coming, tte Russians are Coming, The theatrical film, 40 to direct fifteen Kid, The Russians arc Thomas Crol-ln Affair, Jesus Agnes of God, and the four films which are the subject of this paper. (Finlor, 207-208) (Moritz, 188-191) 3 Rollerballc Rollerball is a postulation but A substance. no world corporations, for there are coalition of no nations, not by multi-national but by an all-powerful individual War, pc,verty, The future world is a Vtopia. ills of sickness, all anyone ... is run with style, corporations known as the "Majors:" transportation, food, energy, etc. cost of future world of a society have "All freedom. been eliminated, but at the (the it majors) asl~s not to interfere with management decisions." E., refuses of Thus, when the game's greatest star, Johnathon and management's decision making process, a begins questioning to retire showdown is set up between the corporation and the individual. As tte film progresses the dark underside of the corporation lS revealed. example, For it is discovered that Johnathon's first wife was taken from him by a jealous executive. example an executive at a party given in Johnathon's honor h'"hispers to another executive that "Evans is out." remark further illustrates crush individuals. or what he did the It is never wrong (if ability In another This offhand of the corporation to revealed what Evans' crime was, anything at all), the point is clear, individuals do not matter in this totalitarian regime. Utopian pleasure is purchased for the cost of individual freedom. At the party mentioned earlier an odd assortment of revelers leave the party in search of excitement. film's best scene, the decadent mob In what descends on trees (a symbol of liberty) and jubilantly attack I consider the a row of pine the trees Hith 4 a flame-thro~ing is clearly representative of The mob pistol. the corporation, destroying everything in their path, anything natural, singular, or individually beautiful. The film's focal point and central metaphor is the game of rollerball itself. The corporate not merely for cogs in designed the game continually of individual to represent easily rer:laced. to amusement, message of the futility meant only leaders have The players are effort. a machine, reinforce the cogs that are very t\evertheless, Johna thon E. emerges as a ,. star, .. an unanticipated symbol of the possibility of individual success. To further accentuate theme, director Norman ultramodern backdrop. spacious same; sloping curves. the Jewison of All and unimportance c lear l~- of the individual shot the film against a sleek, the offices corporate look the lit with straight lines and gently The buildings are stately and magnificent, yet they are permeated with an odd dehumanizing aura. t\orman Jewison also uses various, more subtle, directing skills to create the proper mood for the film. of architecture has lighting coincides effect. already with the Jewison's choice been mentioned, but his choice of architecture to create the overall For instance, the office buildings and interiors are all extremely well lit. Combined with lighting a creates cold, foreboding Bartholomew's office, as an example, least bit cheerful. the smooth architecture, the atmosphere. is very bright, ;--lr. but not the As a contrast the rollerball track and arena are very dark with lots of shado~s. The track takes on a very r t. primitIve appearance. Th 1s "los t of t. f' n d ~, 1 () film's l s i 1 t e rail;.' a fi 1m r a i sed end the k ill hm,' insane the sit.uat.ion has bp('ome, not part behind anc goa I. The uses bali his name. nd i \'j t rn an film's theme Bnrl wR1'ning. One dUB t.he major OJ \\'hnt B (' r' i t He had violence, and in mind. but t.he his c U s p ri . t IH~ i ng t r a (' k frames, j (' ism S 0 f contt>:~t t. () this is not. in \-'tlich thRt· the violpnce do c h0 r j j :\ (0 t' 0 f t.h e U, :1 t 1."', "i 0 ]'mlUl t i 1m ('on1.Rins \'iCllenc~i' tha t is "ih n t not. U S out ,,,h i ('h t.lle h'FlS score sh()~"n he i s is tn t.o f i I m h' 0 I t e r h B the reaii7F'S t h c· t () h;l I I countf'J'pRrt purpose, r'ecogn i t i on , desensitiy.atlon the ]paves fi na I Thp problf.,m the spor1s 7: 0 t hp i i h about has the Obviousl;;:, .J PW j son he r n 11 n d h t ul'red focus, :t p S 1,-.' t'i n a lop P 0 n f' n t n i t. s i n tt~ n rl p d for' c h a 111 p i () n t h ens I.. a t fans chant:tng pmpha s i •J 0 h lW tho n. resemhling sport. the 1t y ear 1;.- f the future. inrli\'idualism triumphs. of anvthing (~i () r CJllR j p () i s pdt. () s t r i k Fan rl h i g h, s ha r p qui t e f i 1m g i vet h (' nigi1Lmarp ,'lsion of In n () t 1 S pIt.. f j lmf"(j h'8S cnntarni na.tl'·s contempOf'Hry filmgoers. A !", a inc ide n t s >; p () rl s () f r'isp () f ] i 1e1'B l 1 ,Ii haVE' "i () 1 en C P i n S i) () l' tin g quite spvprp. t.he fan In addit.ion, the most e vp n t s . grelv up Somp of in R ge n I" r violent te1p\1S1011 IH'()grRms t.h()\lsanos them ha\'t' R t j \J n the ~ere d(~at.h r () 11 t.i or a rH" a n rl ",ielpn" character'. effect, is a h"PIl "h i c- h S R \J in the hist,ory J)(~at.hs shoh's of numbi ng in thpse t;)h'?rds \-.IOU llP 1d (' h s v i o f amount fiJmgoer IS tame. To r t ~ 0 1 (' I, e nnd 0 j p 11 k e ep a t rae k film n C' p 1n futuristjr' 0 f !f fails. sport.s meant that so(-ipt;.' th(~ () n h'ouL.-l number (if the f11m is anything not Hnd f{ollf~rhall in thp f"frpet i vP, t ru 1;.' \.Jas s t. a tis t i (' S exposed to, he r: hat. the au die n (' p audif-'nep () f t fl p v i () J e n t i ng ] y -".Iso, (' Y'assness ,.: her' p IS s off. th~~ at lH . h a s po This the a s p () r t turned infuriat.ed h' fit. nf irna~(p \'isual to be morp film horrifying, lif\pd 1 s (·e~lt.ral the' spnse of ('onfliet r'ommon this bf,t,"f·en the .J Ph' i son good." The rna1n reHson ver;. film individu31 effer-tive is l.hp c\)rporHtp Hnd In ,)oilna1hon a ~"ho !linn SImple 11 himself, 18 that I lyeS his ><:iv('s in search, the society that h hoth fi 1m it.s he int.uiti\el': F. l~. i\n()l,J~.is in the C'orporat,e ,,'o,'ld Rnd insirjp powpr. F.I.S.T. Jn and F. I • S . T. a('('()un t. s :vmpa the t, i (' many ways is S () n of the /\mprir'an strllggJes g 1 luno r i 7.eri .\ 0 r man .J e \,' 1 to ()f PUl'P management's Jess shi f 1 S his earnera lahor mO\PIllf'nt hpl'oism, vIew. it the Thj s by but is a to f flO personal overa I j issue 1 Im i s n () 1, :1 means is it. film, and In of unIonism 7 than it is l,i th the relationship important role in the history of a of two friends who play an union very similar to the International Brotherhood of Teamsters. The film's theme centers around a question of ethics and This question is the morality, or do the ends justify the means? foundation upon which this film builds its story. The main character, Johnny Kovak is portrayed as a man who cares deeply about his fellow workers. some crates, Kovak is the men are pushed management. there to too far, man, help pick up the produce. Koval.. takes their When grievances to Interstate Truckers, F.I.S.T. After strike ends in the death of a friend and fellow union Kovak management decides of the that in local conditions for his men, push, or worker drops Eventually Kovak finds work as a union organizer for the mythical Federation of an aborted When a dock order to defeat the tyrannical trucking firm and gain decent working the union needs "push." He gets this power, from an unsavory character named Vince Doyle and his gang cf mafia thugs. In exchange, Kovak and F.I.S.T. become indebted to Doyle's superior, Babe Milano. This "pact with the devil" creates a rift between Kovak and his best friend, Abe Belkin. to Kovak. Belkin is an interesting contrast They both yearn for better treatment for the truckers, but whereas Kovak will use any means necessary, Belldn remains staunchly idealistic. Unlike Rollerball, F.I.S.T. is shot in sharp focus to emphasize, particulary early in the film, a stark realism. Color 8 is used to enhance BroT"'n seems to be the the dreariness of the of also. this effect, primary color used and this symbolizes Even the actors seem to the working conditions faced by the men. exclusively wear almost clothing. brown and of shades brown In the scene There is, however, one vivid exception. in which Kovak angrily leaves the activities, he is bathed A senate hearings on union/ mob in bright sunlight and is greeted by a huge contingent of cheering lighter clothing. in their truckers who tribute through are wearing slightly symbolic use of light and color to the triumph of the union. Jewison makes frequent their relative use of For importance. positioning instance, executive sit in a section that is above track. and pit-like up at the ruling class. F.I.S.T. ~anagement of actors and in Rollerball the both the regular crOl.;d This lends itself to several shots looking Jewison uses the same technique in occupies a second story office where managers can literally look down on the common workers. As the film ends Je>-"ison shows a series of still shots of the truckers jubilantly cheering as they hearings. at the Senate Whatever the cost, Kovak had championed these people. On a more personal level, Rollerball. had been From what I have several heated read about this movie arguments among Jewison, actor Sylvester Stallone and co-writer Joe Ezterhas. those arguments r did not like F.r.S.T. as well as were about. It is not difficult to imagine what Stallone, perhaps 1n the interests of his career, seems to be pushing in this film for a completely 9 s~vmpat.hpt; probahl~ (' shooting .J i. mm:-- Horf;'i. fello~ his m \l C' I'P('11 1east j;'J heart. ~ n i e r pst. i n g c 0 1 J t~; produrt. id Film CiS The Jewison or;ginalJy made. ,,'CiS The studio ;1()s are left is fj()s t.(lO \1' l<i hat 10 AbP jncij\-jdual there is a. instanrp, action and is a ts length. jump from the the '!'oo many questions H elk i n inC a 1 j t' 0 r' n i a',> the mafia his ability el j r i t an emotional st.rang sense of tllerl' I shm<Js his Clgain rjghts a.nd the riignjr.,v of the COmllIOl'l m;ln. One of Jeh'ison's strengths is peop 1 p i n fin n I h'as the a t.herllm in Rnd s the origin"l of because sllorlen. h Cl. P pen P d I.J a C'e length. t. h p 011 that nevertheless, too t.he imp act oTlrp fo}' H 0 f fa short.er than ~-eal~s? (~(H1f'ern t.O sacri f j i s is mCirl\etahl e po",pr thp stCirri ng fOt, l\ 0 val\: . ~v is much no by S t. a I Lon e • iLl i ng sigrli f-icant right I\oval\: he1h'ppn he han .J 0 h n n now Jess gCiin relat.ioIlship t.he screen character depth. that. H ('omp I ete, lln:HlSh'Pf'ed: intprests of hpha \' i or The studio heads felt h'as prohah 1;.- the to t. fi 1m is t.O \<iouLd h 1-1 r act f' r it thF' het. t er act.or a greCiter forces played F' ha\'f~ personal "'ho for real-life of the to but need I,d h-a s .~nothpr aspeC't. of t.he Ag a in, closer I' .fimm:-' Hoffa dlCl snmeonp popu I a r i t ;.- h m0 r e t e t.o thp charaetpr t'H'oug;ht or rtl person,,: ,3. c· Eziprhas hTere and less-t.han-arlmi rahl e F. I . S , T . role, hovak, workers at resemhlancp what. (' h a r for a Like nnri ties hova i, . "in common va.lues ",onderi'lll to fi I TTl response. and seIlS i courtship sc'elle In 1 i \-} in h'llieh r.T.S.T. r.~-. For the hoval'; 10 character tries to make a good impression on the mother of a There is also a very poignant funeral for one of the young lady. early unien organizers who is killed by a mob of strikebreakers . ... And Justice for All is ... A~d Justice for All 1S addition exploration of inadequacies. The central a young idealistic lawyer named Arthur to regular legal system story an and its his law our current figure in the Kirkland. In practice he is a court appointed He defends both his paying clients and his less public defender. fortunate court appointees with equal vigor. The theme of ... And Are form of a question. Is there ideals? we living Justice for All? All may up to clear that, according to be stated in the our stated, lofty The answer is a resounding The screenplay by Valerie Curtin and "no~" it Justice for common folk, Barry Lcyinson makes Justice is not "for all," but for the fortunate few. The story centers on two of Kirkland's cases. The first involves a young man who is originally stopped on the highway for having a broken taillight. Because he fits the description murderer, is the advice (not by young man Kirkland) he arrested plea of a and due to faulty legal bargains his way right to prison. When Kirkland is finally brought into the case, the evidence which proves the young man's innocence is ruled inadmissable by a certain judge named Fleming because it is brought in three days 11 late. Flpming .J udg p Accused ill sc1. his d fen s 1hpse anc1 nther injust,icps Kirkland \< I get e:>;plorles i n a h' a y h' i t, h t"lTl i ng to thf' i s i t. bo iIi n g po i n t. ,.; iii , h' hen gu i I t.:v and pnd of the fi 1m i\lrl,ianri ,:ha t of anrl fllry h i r 1\ 1 an ri t. () t,pns inn callspri h;\' The rpasons. cljent. significant. Fleming forces hrought is tha1' probably, othpr hirkland's .'"> polit.i(:al for p .' rape i n(' i ripnt., vicious 8 F~ ]' quite hf' has sppn and entlrf' jlldicial s y s t pm) i s For color. hllgp, () 11 t, this () for d p r ' " fi 1m .J p" i son uses most I y I ighting and Thf'rp arp t.wo significant s;\'mhols 1n this fj 1m. almost h p n c h wh p r p cartoon-likf'. t.IH~ Fleming gives lah'. ,If'wi son lISPS his views on prison. enclosed SHimming pooL ,J 11 d g f' anot.hf'r F J em i n g lit. ('. r a I I y symholic scenf' when "Prison shouid be scary. the prisoners create thf';r own Hel plastic natural The scene on 1S Fleming's shot. 1pt insiriE~ estate. a 1 tis Fleming's own views from his own microcosm. As the credits roll through the final bewi Idpreri int() is ama7.ed at. ... And Justice for Al I man approach t,o which Rj Ily, scenp, life one of is rrn7.Y overcrowded prison. qUI tf-' IS hI''' Kirkland s~arps has happened h'hat. a good example of Jewison's common II. ~or instance, hi rk I and J s un fortuna t.e for put.t i ng the 1S clients, ani n nor p n t, man a scene in s~atps in an that aLrpad~ 12 matter to the average person. the system works, and we go on this situation, but that does not As children we are believing that taught that way until we are and the ability of the rich to the injustices, plea bargaining, hire expensive lawyers ~ho Therefore, the proven wrong. can practically guarantee an acquittal for any crime just does not make sense to the average person. The problem I have with this film is the comedy clement. Some critics have described this film as a black comedy. The film is not that cynical. to disagree. is almost playful. experiences a As an nervous example, one breakdol,'n, suicidal character Along ~udge. as these A same true black violently merely a curiosity. Jewison adequately lines shaves his head, and ends up comedy would just a just sort of friend of Kirkland's is a a have portrayed this self-destructive. This is the comedy of Kirkland's associates He is not really crazy, throwing dishes at people. silly. In fact, I have In this film he is mild criticism. I believe made his point with strong social satire, but this film may have had a greater impact on audiences if it would have been a more cynical, black comedy. A Soldier's Story The most critically acclaimed of the four Jewison films I am examining is A Soldier's Story. Thematically, A Soldier's Story is an examination of the destructive power of prejudice. Fuller's excellent screenplay expounds not the overt violence of on this theme by showing white racism, but the less obvious 13 psychological effects of prejudice. The story centers on the investigation of the murder of the manager of a black baseball team/platoon in Sergeant Katers, the rural south of World II War America. to the a Howard University trained Captain Davenport, investigation is Assigned military lawyer who is sent from Washington to find the truth. Along the way Captain Davenport faces his share of obstacles from white soldiers and officers, his presence is particularly contested by Colonel Nivens who remarks, do in this part of the country is to pay too much attention to the death of a negro under the 1S prejudice more "the worst thing you can Most of mysterious circumstances." consisting mostly of reluctant subtle; salutes and condescending stares. The investigation ultimately Davenport leads to discover that the murder of Sergeant Waters was not committed by the Klan, nor was the crime carried out present the by two night of Water's slaying. white officers who were The murderer was a member of Water's own platoon and was in retaliation for Water's heinous the suicide involvement in out that Water's southern, rural black race. himself of another was black soldier. extremely It turns prejudiced towards blacks and meant to exercise their kind from the This is eerily ironic when considered in the context of World War II Naziism that was taking place in Germany. Sergeant Water's prejudice painful incident in World War I the black race in white was and a not merely for spite. strong desire A to elevate society provided strong motivational 14 reClson~, hi for sheris tClI",ar'ds h R s~:ed for v i (' t, i m i zed bv , t.hp t.he end of \\Rter's eruelt,\-, are Yet r t. inn s . nor Rrp they shed ppopiec;; all , fi 1m for the hRve ""hn for SergeRnr not are bJael\ \ormRn ,je""i son uses most 1 y i gh 1, in g. sout,hprn The rurRl I () cat. ion" ~-' i 1 min g in thp shRdows and Rut RS in other pmphasi7.p a t.o i nvo 1 \'ed 1 n d II r' i n g \\ 0 rid DR \'pn po r t. f t r 11 t. h i s 1 ~hen l.hRt II stRres 1Iy combined J e~' i son On p 0 to b P for 3 v e R J eo. \.J i t. h t,hf' film ends sh CH.JS Se f p War 1. a r~( p R n 1 10 H edt () i mprov j ng admirablp. t gently s i n i nth P (,.' 3 the h] :1.(,1\ mRn' s The hi 1 l i s fall ing creoits WR t. p r ' sam bit ion s 0 The hp,n:y in rreating an s r e n f' a i n \~ h i (' h window when the s r e n pin is of J(,h'i son so ft rain, blue light reflects the sero I I t h up ,~ s r rep II , ()f blacl{ soldiers marching over a hlll. compan:v j ms, fRre. thp Rno out j An 0 the r a a Davpnport~' sRdness on CRpt.a i n As r r'emorspfu I I y fj point. i.ghting 11 b:-.- "nn bolo colors Rrp part.icularl:,>T effecLi\'e wa s murder he bpen nRt.ura I was atmosphere sout,h. USPS dFl rkness and bo I d ro 1 () n:; a wf Rnci to, succumbed prejudire. For CaptR in race. 1'1 r h Rd i n b pen f', u r 0 pe • for t he b i a ('j{ so I rii p r s his mt" t. hod s A I tho II g h pos j t. ion 1.Jf'rp I,Tong, symbo I of prpjud i r('. hhen the soldiprs mRrch over thp crest they arp not oniy integrating the army, but Rlso American soriety. Onp of thp reasons t.h j s f i 1m ."as so critically sllccessful 1 ;) H CI S its S 11 b st.O r:--- 1 i n p It the other ~hrep truth h Cl s i (" t r il \ u min CI t ion of a nd p(~ hut ,Jeh'ison P,rhaps emotional is hTong. pre j u d i (" f> film arE" more ("omplpx than t.O hri ng is able Clgain, hack, harken "j1-h pn\.,JPl'flJl char'gpd t h: of this rna t. t. E" r t. films, I Ollt j 11 in which Da':enport. The scene is appeal. most. Quite simp]:--', highpr quality J e \, j son the to the scene and, it is of a thus, f jim . The four films in comparison The that t.oget.her Th d iff p r F 1~ 0 \l g h e Cl C n 0 f strong;, t. h p 8 e four fi 1ms hiQ;hly f c en t r al j indl\""ichwlis,ic g u res ,J e h' i 80 n is n (~e , through o h s t. i'l ("I e s dogged Though .Johnny hoval\ dies in learl of a inclusion 1S bonds most tn tlv, end t.O of E_ •. J.S.T___., helt.er pay 8nri ",orking ('ondit.ions for A.rthur hi rli 1 a.nd may (~()ntemrt· det.erm ina t ion for become, p r' b B I I the spirit of d isba t'red " s:--' s t pm" Fi na I 1:--, R0 1 I be t.hprp T his (' h a r a ole t~, tS his fellow ,,-orkers. aft.f·~r () f U1e aetion .iustice ill charaeter mn r e t h B nan y indi\-idw'll ism ann :lan'8 hjs effort.s havp 0 III ••• Anrl th;s c:ountr:--' ha.s of .)ohnat.rlon f'" in t. her, be s t p p] t. 0 m i z p s indomitable spirlt. 16 On the subject of traits. For style all instance, all four films of the share other common films use bold colors to emphasize an atmosphere of danger and foreboding. in particular of the Rollerball arena and Big I am thinking ~ary's saloon in A Soldier's Story. Jewison frequently has two opposing viewpoints argued by two people in a one on ono" confrontation In the four films. h'orks well ""hen used si tuations.. Bartholomew's orders, Bartholomeh" s persena] corpora t ic,n. context of individual versus group frequent clashes Jehnathon E. defies Mr. in the In their This these but Kishes. orders He represent represents more the than entire Similarly, Abc Belkin represents idealism in F.I.S.T., Judge Fleming stands for a pragmatic vieK of justice in . . . An d J 1.:,;.;:is::-t=--=i...::c'-'o"----=f'-'o"-'r~___"A~l::...::::..l , and Colonel Nivens represents racial prejudice in A Soldier's Story. Anoth er de\"ice authority above Jewison uses the common people. is As I s;rmbol ic placement of have mentioned earlier, examples cf this can clearly be found in the first three films. I have included a sentence or each film because the way JeKison twe concerning has chosen to end these four films re-amplifies the points made in the respective obscuring of the indi vidual, the ending of films: the the importance of the common ,,'o1'ker, the insanity of our judicial system, and the triumph of the black race over prejudice. 1 '/ Jewison as a director .J e ,.". 1 S Though 1'-ormrin riirectors; rihout, . i s r: he nevertheless Holl,v',,"oorl's mnsl I ,':3 fl one's at ten t. d0 p not 11 S t.("'h i ng i on . f 1 ,J e h i H Lnlike Im 1'1 s H I'll lows the rictors anrl S at least. son f i 1 m, mOI'e h0 one remalns This rsn he ntt.rihuted, st;;,'l e. f' S 0 h' r~, ". p prol ifil' of in prirt, t, h e d i no c tin g rl 0 e s not. g r a b notahle for his sereenl"ri tPl'S 0 wn t. alp n t. s . rlet,erml np the fnsiPHo, HOI~th IIp ot' his fi I ms. be(~ClUSe .TeL i son sudden 1,v- supeJ'lor <-l(:ting and '>.ls(), C'rpdi t.8 . IpHd!-:. H \or to anrl h:is fllms. dops he a hettel' d i rf'('tor, but bpe8.use of fine s('[·eenplriY. dops ,J Ph' j son hpcarne nnt li\-(' a 1i s 1 his nrime prominently 1n the flamboyant. 1 ifestyle. All of t.hi s 18 Conclusioq Perhaps, it lS not ~orman Jewison's competence as a director that makes him an important filmmaker. lighting, sets, casts, screenplays, nical in nature that sets him filmmaker, he may never apart. of his his choice of locations, or anything techAlthough he the quality that is a fine But the atsho~s through films and cements his importance in not only con- temporary cinema, but alse for people. is not be recognized as a master. tribute that docs set him apart, in all It ~orman contemporary society, Je~ison cares people ... and that is important. deeply about is his concern the dignity of i9 Bibl'lograph:v Rollerba Ii ----------~ A 1 Pf~rt, lis. Ho " F 11 t U r e .J 0 r h . " Hollis nelt.hf'r recommends t.he fi 1m, nor dise-T'edits i t , he mereiy points to the game as the fi 1m's major' flshT. The 11.urilPncp he saw t.he 1'i im h'it.h riisapp()intf~d him grent.ly b~' cheering the violent aot ion in the fj 1m as if they l,el~e 1-i81ching Cln act\lal sporting eVF~nt. ,. Sr' i - F i: F t'om Sports Canby, V i n(~en t. 29 .J un e I 9 7 ;), sec. 2: (j 2 1'0 Shs rks. ' In addition t.o his regular review, Canby hTote a srathing, satirir11..1 edit.orial on this film in \-.'h1ch hf~ arcuses !\orman Jewjson of having an imagination "the slzp of a six-pacl\: of heel' and 8 I arge bag of pret ze Is." Je\.;i son responded in t.hl" form of a let t e r (,,", e>J Yo t::'!i_I i me s, i 3 .J 11 I .v , 1 9 7 ;), s e (. • 2 : 1 1) i n h' h i c h hP refuterl Canby's argument. t.hat R()l.JS'rb~l.l was not. rea Ii st iC8 I 1~­ VIolent and ac~c~\lsed C:anb~' of possessing t.he saTTle ment.alit.y ClS th·' "Corporation" rieple-t.ed in the fi im. rocks, .Tay. ">.io Score." T i TTl e 7 .J u I ;.T 1 ~~ '/ ;) : '-I n Th is revi ewer gi ves t.he fi I m a script as "confusing." Forhps, Cheryl. "Rol]prbail To.0.9.L H Aug. 1:-1,"5: 18 ~vho poor gradp. \I; i 1 He rpfprs to thf' Fo 1 j m,?" This artie-Ie mprely outLines the plot. Gammon, l~,/f) i i \'e . >l4-4H C "Rollerhall ~ 1 Apr. This interest.ing articlp details the technical aspect of creat.ing t.ILe flC't.lt.iollS sport. of RoJ lerbai I for' t h f~ f i 1m. (}i J l1at.t., Penelope. "Skat es, Hi l\f~s, Sharks." 1~75:b'i-bH Gilliatt bemo8ns the fi 1m's lach of explaIned rules, "pol it.leally infnnt. ego," Hnd JR.f'\~ of intelligent. female roies. 20 "Dog Stanlpy. hi1uffmi1nn, JY75:20 pans the film as be i ng a s tel nda rd se I pnCf' h auf f man n cd so ref e r s to ,j e h~ i son's d ire (' t, i II gas This rpV1PlN" fictIon cl ~rhe. bping fTPdiocrp. ;'>]oses, I, Ovel'[l "Fe" " :'1 () vie T a I i\ • " Sam., [HOOP I,~ h~ gIves a po\)r rpvich tJ) the fi 1m. He STates, care h~hR 1. happens beT.\~pen the h~homps nnyhoh'. ,. f'los,'s i I I l--'oin1',g Siskel, G(~ne. "Rol1f'rbalL's Tlihune :::7 .Junp 1975, sec. 3 : :.S ]J1111 thp 1'1i nd ... Siskp dpjivprs i1noth.'r sC'i1t~hing rpvie,,' in ,,,hl('h hp atl',achS heing too soiemn and revejOpntii11. He aiso descl'ihes the fi 1m as the point of lhp film HS being too ohvious and moralizing. .'-ltPITi tt, Fll t .. Ro lip r ba 1 I - - \ i David. II rf~ .. , Christian ~.- the Sc~ienc(~ ! en t. , i"Ioraiisti<' ralf'" i'Ionitor 7 ,J II l:v 1 9 I fi : :.-: L 0 Onp of tilp few positi\p rpvieh's of the fi 1m, t'] n e a (' t. i n g . Stprritt, !)a\'id. [ n cl 11 S 1, Y';\' • Sterritt> ot ---~------~-----.--------~---~-~.- ":'-)o'vies as 'an Art l.oci;;p(j ~_b r j.-:c;,!,.t~~~~i e n~_~,'i0 n_it~().r: L 5 A 11 g • interviPHs Jpl·Jjson and dis('ussps thp Sterritt lip lRllds Inside an 1~J7:i:~2 fi 1m. F. I . S. T. Ansen, j)avicl. This its fatal old movie, "S,vlvpstpr Hoffa's int>elligent t'la~". not Ri~hard r('vie",' points to t,he film's direC'ts . . . as i f he Hel~p ".)PHison "staginess":ls rF'-('r(~ating ;In life." A. "Carhon ac("usps t. h e d fat her \-,' i t h rha ract.er f'xpl ora t ion. (~ 0 St.Ol',v." opies. ti i plot In \~ a 20 :vlay 1 ~J7 8: 4- ()8 0 f me reI y he i n g n (' 1 on P 0 f T IH' ri a t ion s a n d dis 1 i 1\ F' S t. h p i a r 1\ () f 21 Brill, steven. 1978:85 "The Facts Behind 'F. I.S. T'" Esquire 23 ~lay Brill is an expert on the Teamsters and is disappointed in the film. ~ot because it is historically inaccurate, but because the film trivializes a much more complex story. Canby, Vincent. " 'F. I . S. T. ' 1978:210-211 Delivers." New York Times 14 May The same Vincent Canby who so viciously attacked Rollerball, writes a quite good review for this film. Canby praises the emotional power projected in the film. Gilliatt, Penelope. "Warlords." New Yorker 8 May 1978:121-123 Gilliatt accuses the film of being overtly '·right-~.;ing·' Hi th a somewhat xenophobic streak in which unions are considered nothing but Bolshevik agitators. Haskell, Nolly. "Camera Obscura." Neh' Yorh: 8 Ma:r 1978:74-78 Haskell states that she enjoyed this films simple charm, but nevertheless derides its lack of authenticity. Hatch, Robert. "Films." The Nation 3 June 1978:675-676 The reviewer praises Stallone's performance. Kauffmann, Stanely. May 1978:24-25 Rod Steiger's "Onward to the Past!" small role, but pans The ~eh- Republic 20 Kauffmann praises Stallone's performance and the film's 30s style. Kauffmann also finds other critics' penchant for lambasting this film's old-fashioned romanticism amusing. He states, "what h-as ... holy in 1938 is sin in 1978, even among those who mourn the changes of time." Lownsbough, John. "~.I.S.S.E.D." MacLean's 15 May 1978:86-87 This review complains that the film never makes "connection" with the audience and describes the main problem as being lack of character depth in the starring role. 2, :2 Schickp.I, lCichard. \)a y 19'( H : '( 4 The Lt.le of this artictf': p:'(p1ains thp. rpvipwpr's attit.llde. S chi c J~ p I f () 1] n d t h p f j 1III b 0 ring and R co III P Lp t p fail 11 r e . He s UH Eo S t hat. S 1. al . 0 n p , s a c t. i n g i S 11 t t p r I y I" ron g for t h plio f fa - i ~ k e chRract.pr and tabs .lewison's dirpct,ing as being "V8guP and distant." (} p rlf~ . " R p P p t i t jon h 0 's 'F. I • S . T . ' Trjbl:!JI£:' L({qpr. 197H, sec. 3::l Sis k pi, ~1 p 5 S Rg P • " Siskpj is lmprpsspd h1'ith thp. serollri ha]f of thp film anrl it,s depiet.inn of a :'iUs SenAte heAring. Ypt 0\'p1"a11 hp found t.hf' fi 1m "lifeless" Rnd bpI jpvps A r(~-erlit.ing might. hf·lp the fi 1m. St.ein, :'-1.1" ","orman .jPl.Jlson: ' I WAnt F.l.S.T. N p '''_)~() r 1,--,[ i!l1£ s 7 Ma~' 1 9 I R , SPC. :2: 1 '/ , :2 H t.o Peoplp. , .. I n t h i s i n t e r \' i p I'; J Ph' i son e:'( po 11 n d s o n f i J III mR k j n g a n rl t~~ s ~J_-,- s p e c i f i cal I y . Thp f i 1m d ire C tor R 1s n di s c 11 sSP S t h p d i 1 em mao f mR ld n ,S{ q 11 a I i r y r'i 1 III S t. hat, at. t. h p sam e tim P, S II C e p (' d R t t_ h e box _. 0 f fi c e . H p a Iso tal k s abo 11 ,t his up com i n g f i I III (._,-,--'-:...~,IJQ .J u s tic e _fs2.,l=-6JJ..l "h i (' h h pea I j s "a b 1 a. c k co III e d y a b () u t I a,,, y p r s . l' Sterritt, David. "Stal1on~~'s LRtpSt. Proves He's a Ch..r..i.§j, i ~, Sc,i pW:f 1"15]n U.:.Q.t::. 2.f Apr. I 97 H : 1 H liP11l1ine Star." Hords for and the Sterri tt has nothing hut" kind Sta 1 lone fi 1m. In U'le rpvipw SUlJ lone 15 prnispd YOl' his "pl'ofes~ionalism" and ,/pwison for his "so('iai \iallp~', .Ipan. !'Sta1lonp's Latest" Fight." 82 This arti('lp chroniclps thp trials and tribulRtions lJl',·oi\-(·d Hit h t ~ h p ma lei n g 0 f t h p f.i ) III • Inc I II d f'd i s the s tor y () f h () H St 011 onp rph'l'ot PUlP s('ri pt and rpmadp the hO\'ol{ chara\;t,,~r . .. . And ,Just,lcp for All ------------'--------- \dlpr, Rpnata. "ExasperRtion." Th is rev i p,,'pr f i I man d p" i n t. S 01] t Nph' Yorker 22 Oct. 1979:17J-;Hi fInds lack of RlJ1,hpnticit~- pVf>r;.-lJhprp spvpra j J PgR I f 1 8.HS in thp plot. 1 n t hf': <\nsen, DavHi. "Disordpr 1~79: 102.1U4 the In ~2 \eh'Sh'peh. Court ()('t,. t.he f j 1m ,. t. hem 0 s t i n t ere st. i n g f i J m .J e \" i son h 8 S Ansen c:a 11 s film s1.raining made in .vears" ;:)Tld I'll t.hough he fillds part.s of the impressed with the sincere feelings c: red i b il i t. y, 0 ye r a I 1 he 1 s e';pr('s~~"d by t.he aetors. ( an by, \,i i nc<~n l\eh' York t • --~--- rimes --------------~------ 19 (Jet. 1979:119 (anby strite's that the film is h;vstf'rical. :\or. hyst.er](;all:, funn:-, j\l>d ilystpriral. flf~ ronteTlcis that. this "satirizps not.hing, having no oirect.ion and no pOInt of vleF." "J)i sorder .Jlld- tho Crist, in the CO\lrt." 1 ~}7 ;)0 Pius dec'. "---------- --- ~: 5b-:::! ( . r i st. hT i t. e s a n ext rem e I :-positive reVlew in whieh she praises Pacino's sincprity as an aet.or and Jewison's attention to ,. e\.-eryday clet.R i 1 • ,. Denhy, \ 0 Ua\--d. "Ahbott and Costello r 1\ :~ 9 Of't. 1 9 7 (~ : H5 ThlS re\.-ipHel~ finds fauLt, ere d i h i lit.~! an (1 a Iso its use () f t. ragedy . Hatch, Rlchard. "Noyies." ~leet (as others ha\.'e) h h' ide ext rem e s S \l C The Gation ~7 Hat.eh calls the film "poh'erful' red i h i 1 i t ~T Ln R n .v 0 n e () f 1. h e sub P lot s , knowledge cOllcerning jegal qllPst~i()ns. (~ Fr-ank. Rich, f. ranld urte;." Felix j n g p r, h·it.h the films of comf'dy Rnd Uct. 19i~:,i12 and but admits finds no a loss ()f laC'k or "hangal"OO Court I?if'h contenos that. hy pxaggf'rating the lpgi'll an i TIC red i b I p dpgree, t.he sa tire lS i nf:ffec t i ve. fault wii.h the film's h'ilri emotionFd s\.Jings . S c h 1e s \~eh' Art h u r .J I' • .. ..l.. n d .J us tic e for ~0 S:istem to sllC'h II e a Iso fin d s n e ... De'~' 197~~:4K This r-eview statf'S that the fi 1m is out ot C'ontrol and lacks of rI good sRt.i.rf" sUf'h as Paddy (hR;.'efsky's 'i~_:t\,;,0J'tL H(n';F~ver, Schlesinger rlirl enjo;.- i-'acino's performant'e anrl believes the fi 1m makes an important point anout the Jurlif'ial system. :-lisl<;pl, Cpne. "'.Justiee' Perpetrat.es a Travest,v." (:J:llca~!L<2 Tribune I~ Oet. 1979, SPf'. 3:3 Siskel finds pverything in the fi 1m overdone and aCf'uses .Jel..:ison of taking a superior st,anf'e anrl morali?;ing to a fall!t. Hp also found Pa(~ino t.o be bori.ng in the lead role. Railey, Ppter. "Int.rodll('ing: Caesar. " Ado!ph Fbi2~ l)e(' . 1~84:G(),62 Tn this article the impact of the Sergeant Waters rolp explorerl hy the man who played him on stage anrl ln the fi 1m. Reale, Lewis. Stor.\', ,.. lS "The St.ruggle, Sacrifice and Hope Behind 'Soldier's ~ hiCago II:LbJ:!.n~ 7 Oct.. J 9~H, se(~. l:l: :"i-h This articJe concerns the making of t.he fi 1m ,"Ind, in the difficult.;,' Jt~wison nad in getting financial backing for the film. Inh~,'estingl,\" .Jel,ison C,n (.:'i.fXf'l' make the f': 1m, he> h'as hi 11"Flg to dirt'ct tht' fi 1m r'OI' l)() pi\~'. Tic" Direetr.r's Gui Id fOj'('ed him t(, charge sr:;u,(J()(J, (1Ii.s norTllni f p' (> i s s 1 • L;) m', J I i I) n . part.i(~lJiar. Remrose, .John. Sept,. 198,+:7~ 13 e m r 0 se Billingsle~·, ~ ()(' t . The "people" pffeC'ts. R l' pia u d s Lloyd. H 4- : 1 1 2 t h F' t'i n f' S "A, Sol d j p Cooper ('omment.s act,ors. PRllljne. J' , on s P n p I a:v and f> '( C' '1;)c'I,('B n e I I p nt R C' t i I 11 s g . r 's S tor :-- . " revi Ph'er finds sppC:'lal a ,VPHr so (iolTJinaiJ'd Ca ro I. " , So I die 19H4-:1i-19,'i'b hap], cor p 11'1 'oope I', h'nnks ... in Story' pleasure 1 n th is fi I IT) ab'-Jut by S(' i en('p fiction ;lnd spP('ial Saiutf:." of qu:~ I i t:-' f i 1 ms for h I Rei, h a e I e x p () 11 n d s o n t t l e d iff i c' 11 1 t, ips 0 f ser'pen and apYl I HUrls .]e\vi son' s pff()l~ts, () f t h (' f l I man d I 1 S 0 (, (";1 s ion R I h 1 1m () t' pI'ai spn for thpi l~ work, bringing a play to the ~he liked his pacing hi g Kauffmnnn, 1 :1 H 4 : :~ "FH i 1 StRneJ:--:, 4 The , ae t () r s n r' f~ I:\'oundup. " The 1"(,\-IP\;P1' likps the film, but fp]t the flashback here somf'hha t pnOl i -:.- hmH1 J 0d , Tllf~ revi Ph'er a I so fe Jr. t 11a t R,ollins \,a~;; nd', lwa!'ly as good ae; Sidney Poit~ier "as 111 fie R r,---.J:>J~,-I'l.p N i g h t . tiroll, Vs. Jac!~. 1 ~ H4 : n I s () Vs. Hlack scpnes t/Oh'a I'd l!,L-.!t,_~:~ ]() hhite." ~f'pt. '~:=i Kroll gives the fi 1m a good re\'iew, but h'i th i.he 1"(,:s(,1"vatlon thaT he did not I ike the rhanged ending (the pIa:,' entis tragiraJ Iyl and felt 1he 5t-yle h'as too rc'minisePllt Df In inp t/E'at o f ....t.t~_-':.j'-E,ht_. O'Brien, Tom. ":'Ioza r This revlewcr ()' Bf'i en found t hem t'i 1m ) s c () n ti n ui t. y , ~ t i\illrde r finds ovel~ I y t' a ( ommom..:ea 1 I i, long Sis k e 1, (; p n e , .. B 1 Cl (' l, R0 1 P S UL!__S~ilQ_-'-:[L__ib Ul}~ L H S P pt .. this \l " h' and i t. h I ~ t. h e l l S P ch~st.r\lcti\·e Help Enrich j~H~, Sf~('. 1~ 8 (Jc 1. 0 in 4: ;-;:i k f] B S h hac I~ s . f terms of the ',4. 7:5 Sisl;;el praises the qual ity and variety 1i 1m, espeeia11;,-- 1.he'\(joi ph CaeS:lI' perforrnarH'p as Serge:ln: Waters. Siater, j ~~ from Van JELck. Sled,pr's arti(~jp Paul Poherson In Gejdpl~, Lssen('p ... IS a ('hronology of bJark mBlf'" roles to the act.orsin this LJ'!lj)el:g_!~_.J:gJ..1£':..~ l.ahTenre. "I-'i 1m: 14 sept. 1~1i::i4, sec. :~:~i A 1'1 f' 11 "HollYhlood's ,\ OY • 4 : ~: 2 - h 4 , 1 3 H , i 4 1 P()~,itIve ,}pl-Jison's 'Soldier"s Story,'" \Ph rev i P\.!, \ Rn {ielder p r a i s e s t . :l!~ part,in ('xp8nding t.he play to tilE' srrppn. in f i 1 rn f'i 1m. l 0 r'l~ ---~---- - 'J' 1 m(:':" -~----- arring and Finipr, Rn ~:. ,Joe1 CJ J\ s, I ~ K ;) :-;~j(l()ts Horhota, C;c·orgp. ",jPl,json 0(' t.. I ~ 7 ~J : b - K I,yon, (hri~::;tophpr, Filmmakprs ~1 () r i t. 7:, (h H rip s . Ynrh: il. h. ~ ('-d. vols. pd ., p t hilson, Thp nt p i. h i cag'): 8 I. l~jH(J for rhe tlq Trtlth." L, ~, 0 1I a I D1(~ tJ.~)r~Cl,l':V~_ J.~Lr~LL'!l:;-;. C\ lid :-,t • •lamps Prf~ss, i ~K..J:. YO l . L r'n1'1 t i Llll~.L~D.L Ii L()"g r 1'1 pI2.Y. Ju~<:trJ}C~oi\. l:~ 7 ~J •