AN ECONOMIC REPORT TO THE GOVERNOR OF THE STATE OF TENNESSEE THE STATE’S ECONOMIC OUTLOOK JANUARY 2016 AN ECONOMIC REPORT TO THE GOVERNOR OF THE STATE OF TENNESSEE Matthew N. Murray, Associate Director and Project Director Center for Business and Economic Research PREPARED BY THE Center for Business and Economic Research Haslam College of Business The University of Tennessee Knoxville, Tennessee IN COOPERATION WITH THE Appalachian Regional Commission Tennessee Department of Finance and Administration Tennessee Department of Economic and Community Development Tennessee Department of Revenue and Tennessee Department of Labor and Workforce Development THE STATE’S ECONOMIC OUTLOOK JANUARY 2016 CONTRIBUTORS An Economic Report to the Governor of the State of Tennessee AUTHORS UT Center for Business and Economic Research Matthew N. Murray, Associate Director and Project Director William F. Fox, Director Celeste K. Carruthers, Assistant Professor of Economics Lawrence M. Kessler, Research Assistant Professor Vickie C. Cunningham, Research Associate Mary Elizabeth Glenn, Graduate Research Assistant The Agri-Industry Modeling and Analysis Group Kimberly Jensen, Professor of Agricultural Economics Jamey Menard, Research Leader Burton English, Professor of Agricultural Economics Department of Agricultural and Resource Economics, The University of Tennessee Institute of Agriculture Andrew Griffith, Assistant Professor of Agricultural Economics Aaron Smith, Assistant Professor of Agricultural Economics Edward Yu, Associate Professor of Agricultural Economics PROJECT SUPPORT STAFF UT Center for Business and Economic Research Betty A. Drinnen, Administrative Specialist Carrie B. McCamey, Communications Coordinator The preparation of this report was financed in part by the following agencies: the Tennessee Department of Finance and Administration, the Tennessee Department of Economic and Community Development, the Tennessee Department of Revenue, the Tennessee Department of Labor and Workforce Development, and the Appalachian Regional Commission. This material is the result of tax-supported research and as such is not copyrightable. It may be freely reprinted with the customary crediting of the source. UT Publication Authorization Number R01-1493-295-002-16. ii | 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT PREFACE This 2016 volume of An Economic Report to the Governor of the State of Tennessee is the fortieth in a series of annual reports compiled in response to requests by state government officials for assistance in achieving greater interdepartmental consistency in planning and budgeting efforts sensitive to the overall economic environment. Both short-term, or business cycle-sensitive forecasts, and longer-term, or trend forecasts, are provided in this report. The quarterly state forecast through the first quarter of 2018 and annual forecast through 2025 represent the collective judgment of the staff of the University of Tennessee’s Center for Business and Economic Research in conjunction with the Quarterly and Annual Tennessee Econometric Models. The national forecasts were prepared by IHS Global Insight, Inc. Tennessee forecasts, current as of January 2016, are based on an array of assumptions, particularly at the national level, which are described in Chapter One. Chapter Two details evaluations for major sectors of the Tennessee economy, with an agriculture section provided by The Agri-Industry Modeling and Analysis Group at the University of Tennessee Institute of Agriculture. Chapter Three discusses Tennessee’s role in the international economy and presents the long-run outlook and forecast for the state. Chapter Four presents the background, early results, and challenges of Tennessee’s Drive to 55 program. The primary purpose of this annual volume—published, distributed, and financed through the Tennessee Department of Finance and Administration, Tennessee Department of Economic and Community Development, the Tennessee Department of Revenue, the Tennessee Department of Labor and Workforce Development, and the Appalachian Regional Commission—is to provide wide public dissemination of the most-current possible economic analysis to planners and decision-makers in the public and private sectors. Matthew N. Murray Associate Director and Project Director Center for Business and Economic Research 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT | iii CONTENTS CONTENTS EXECUTIVE SUMMARY....................................................................................................................................... viii CHAPTER 1: THE U.S. ECONOMY........................................................................................................................ 1 1.1Introduction........................................................................................................................................................1 1.2. The U.S. Economy: Year in Review....................................................................................................................2 Components of GDP.......................................................................................................................................2 1.3. The U.S. Forecast............................................................................................................................................10 1.4. Alternative Scenarios......................................................................................................................................17 1.5. Forecast Summary and Conclusions..............................................................................................................17 1.6.References......................................................................................................................................................18 CHAPTER 2: THE TENNESSEE ECONOMY: SHORT-TERM OUTLOOK.......................................................... 19 2.1. Introduction.....................................................................................................................................................19 2.2. The Current Economic Environment...............................................................................................................20 The Labor Market..........................................................................................................................................20 Income and Taxable Sales.............................................................................................................................23 2.3. Fiscal Update..................................................................................................................................................26 Federal Government......................................................................................................................................26 State Finances Across the Nation.................................................................................................................26 The Southeastern States and Tennessee.....................................................................................................27 2.4. Short-Term Outlook.........................................................................................................................................28 2.4. Tennessee Forecast at a Glance.....................................................................................................................33 2.5. Tennessee’s Agricultural and Forest Industries and Rural Economy..............................................................33 Introduction....................................................................................................................................................33 a. Agriculture and Primary Forestry..............................................................................................................33 b. Food, Fiber, and Forestry Manufacturing in Tennessee............................................................................38 c. Rural Economies and Well-Being.............................................................................................................40 d. Governor’s Rural Challenge......................................................................................................................41 Summary ......................................................................................................................................................42 References Used...........................................................................................................................................42 CHAPTER 3: THE TENNESSEE ECONOMY: LONG-TERM OUTLOOK............................................................ 45 3.1.Introduction......................................................................................................................................................45 3.2. Employment Outlook.......................................................................................................................................46 3.3.Unemployment................................................................................................................................................49 3.4.Population.......................................................................................................................................................52 3.5. Personal Income and Taxable Sales ..............................................................................................................53 iv | 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT CONTENTS 3.6. State Gross Domestic Product........................................................................................................................54 CHAPTER 4: TENNESSEE’S DRIVE TO 55: BACKGROUND, EARLY RESULTS, AND CHALLENGES LYING AHEAD............................................................................................................................... 57 4.1. Introduction and Key Points.............................................................................................................................57 4.2. The Landscape of College Progression in Tennessee....................................................................................58 4.3. Will “Free Community College” Make a Difference in Tennessee? Early Indicators........................................64 4.4. Challenges and Opportunities.........................................................................................................................65 Changing the Culture of College Aspirations.................................................................................................65 Undermatching..............................................................................................................................................66 Readiness and Research..............................................................................................................................67 The Other 45 Percent....................................................................................................................................68 4.5.Acknowledgements.........................................................................................................................................68 4.6.References......................................................................................................................................................69 APPENDIX A: FORECAST DATA.......................................................................................................................... 1 Quarterly History Tables...........................................................................................................................................2 Annual History Tables.............................................................................................................................................26 APPENDIX B: HISTORICAL DATA...................................................................................................................... 43 Quarterly Forecast Tables.......................................................................................................................................44 Annual Forecast Tables..........................................................................................................................................67 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT | v CONTENTS FIGURES AND TABLES CHAPTER 1: THE U.S. ECONOMY........................................................................................................................ 1 Figure 1.1: Inflation-Adjusted GDP Continued to Grow in 2015..............................................................................3 Figure 1.2: The Housing Sector Continues to Rebound, but Starts and Sales Remain Below Pre-Recession Levels............................................................................................................................5 Figure 1.3: Consumer Energy Prices Drop in 2015................................................................................................8 Figure 1.4: Unemployment Continues Dropping, but the Participation Rate Also Remains Low.............................9 Figure 1.5: The Federal Funds Rate Is Expected to Rise, Which Will Push Mortgage Rates Up..........................12 Figure 1.6: The Trade Deficit Is Expected to Continue as Import Growth Outpaces Export Growth.....................15 Figure 1.7: The Price of Crude Oil Will Begin Rebounding Mid-2016....................................................................15 CHAPTER 2: THE TENNESSEE ECONOMY: SHORT-TERM OUTLOOK.......................................................... 19 Figure 2.1: Over Eighty Percent of Tennessee Counties Experienced Job Growth in the Second Quarter Of 2015...........................................................................................................21 Figure 2.2: The Labor Force Participation Rate Remains Low in Tennessee and in the Nation............................22 Figure 2.3: Tennessee’s Monthly Unemployment Rate Is Near the Middle of the Pack Among Southeast States (December 2015)....................................................................................................22 Figure 2.4: Eighty-Seven Percent of Tennessee Counties are Reporting Unemployment Rates Above the National Average.................................................................................................................................23 Figure 2.5: Tennessee’s Per Capita Personal Income (in Current Dollars) is Slightly Below the Southeast Average, 2015Q3................................................................................................................................24 Figure 2.6: Per Capita Personal Income Is Lower Than the National Average in Most Tennessee Counties........24 Figure 2.7: Building Permits Are Still Well Below the Pre-Recession Peaks of 2005 ...........................................25 Figure 2.8: The Federal Deficit Will Increase Slightly in 2016................................................................................26 Figure 2.9: Tennessee Has Fourth Highest Growth Rate in Total Tax Revenues Among Southeastern States, Fiscal Year 2015 (July 2014–June 2015).................................................................................27 Table 2.1: Selected U.S. and Tennessee Economic Indicators, Seasonally Adjusted............................................29 Figure 2.10: Despite Recent Growth, U.S. and Tennessee Manufacturing Employment Are Well Below Pre-Recession Levels From 2008.....................................................................................................30 Figure 2.11: U.S. and Tennessee Manufacturing Output See Positive Growth .....................................................30 Figure 2.12: Tennessee’s Unemployment Rate Is Projected to Stay Above the National Rate Through 2018......31 Figure 2.13: Per Capita Personal Income in Tennessee Has Fallen Relative to the National Average..................32 Table 2.2: Tennessee Cash Farm Receipts and Share of Commodity Exports, 2010-2014..................................34 Table 2.3: Indicators of the Tennessee Farm Sector’s Financial Well-Being, 2010-2014.......................................37 Table 2.4: Tennessee Food, Fiber, and Forestry Manufacturing, 2013..................................................................39 Figure 2.14: Agri-forestry Products Manufacturing Value of Shipments, 2009–2013............................................39 Table 2.5: Household Income, Education Level, and Unemployment and Poverty Rates in Rural and Urban Areas of Tennessee....................................................................................................................40 Table 2.6: Scorecard Indicators of Positive Progress for Tennessee Agriculture...................................................41 vi | 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT CONTENTS CHAPTER 3: THE TENNESSEE ECONOMY: LONG-TERM OUTLOOK............................................................ 45 Table 3.1: Tennessee Nonfarm Employment by Broad Sector (Thousands of Jobs).............................................47 Table 3.2: Tennessee Manufacturing Employment by Sector (Thousands of Jobs)...............................................47 Figure 3.1: Nonfarm Employment Continues to Grow While Manufacturing Employment Reverts to Trend Contraction Over the Long-Term Forecast Horizon.............................................................................48 Figure 3.2: Total Covered Employment Growth.....................................................................................................48 Figure 3.3: In the Long-Run, Tennessee’s Unemployment Rate Will Trend Downwards but Remain Above the National Rate for Most of the Forecast Horizon.............................................................................49 Figure 3.4: Educational Attainment Levels in Tennessee Are Below the National Average ..................................50 Figure 3.5: Unemployment Rates in 2015 Are Comparable to their 2005 Counterparts in Most Tennessee Counties..............................................................................................................................................51 Figure 3.6: Tennessee Population Growth.............................................................................................................53 Table 3.3: Tennessee Inflation-Adjusted Gross Domestic Product by Sector........................................................55 CHAPTER 4: TENNESSEE’S DRIVE TO 55: BACKGROUND, EARLY RESULTS, AND CHALLENGES LYING AHEAD............................................................................................................................... 57 Table 4.1: Timely Student Progression Among 2007 and 2008 9th Graders.........................................................60 Table 4.2: High School Progression, Graduation, and College Enrollment Means by Cohort...............................61 Table 4.3: High School Graduates Who Do Not Go on to College: Workforce Participation, Earnings, and Industry by Cohort.................................................................................................................................61 Figure 4.1: College or Workforce Destinations the Year After High School Graduation, by Region.......................62 Figure 4.2: Seamless College Enrollment Rates by County of First High School.................................................63 Table 4.4: High School Dropouts: Workforce Participation, Earnings, and Industry Five Years After 9th Grade, by Cohort...............................................................................................................................................63 APPENDIX A: FORECAST DATA.......................................................................................................................... 1 Quarterly History Tables...........................................................................................................................................2 Annual History Tables.............................................................................................................................................26 APPENDIX B: HISTORICAL DATA...................................................................................................................... 43 Quarterly Forecast Tables.......................................................................................................................................44 Annual Forecast Tables..........................................................................................................................................67 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT | vii EXECUTIVE SUMMARY EXECUTIVE SUMMARY The U.S. Economy Early estimates indicate that U.S. gross domestic product (GDP) grew 2.4 percent in 2015 compared to 2.4 percent in 2014 and 1.5 percent in 2013. The last year started off slowly, with GDP growing by a meager 0.6 percent (on a seasonally-adjusted basis) in the first quarter of 2015 but rebounding in the subsequent quarters. This makes 2015 the sixth year of recovery since the recession. The continued U.S. recovery is an outlier in a global economy where many countries are experiencing economic slowdown or outright recession. The U.S. economy is predicted to sustain its stable growth through 2016 and 2017 and continue to be a global leader in growth. The most important milestone of 2014 was that it marked the first year that nonfarm payroll jobs finally reached their pre-recession level. In 2015, significantly more jobs were created and the unemployment rate dropped further. Total nonfarm payrolls increased by 2.9 million for a total of 141.9 million jobs. Unemployment continued to fall reaching 5.0 percent by the fourth quarter, the lowest since the first quarter of 2008. These positive labor market indicators, along with falling food and gas prices, led to increases in consumers’ inflation-adjusted disposable income. The same labor market factors led to consumption growing by a strong 3.1 percent, the highest growth rate since 2006. Nonresidential and residential investment also showed substantial gains and increased by 3.4 and 8.6 percent, respectively. This is a good sign for the housing sector, which experienced double-digit growth in 2012 and 2013 but only grew by 1.8 percent in 2014. Inflation was flat in 2015, and overall prices rose by only 0.2 percent. In less positive news, the government deficit was $438.9 billion, small when compared to the deficits run during the Great Recession, but 2015 marks the fourth year in a row that total U.S. federal debt was larger than U.S. GDP. The trade deficit widened in 2015, as exports grew minimally due viii | 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT to the global slowdown and an appreciating U.S. dollar, and imports grew faster due to increased domestic consumption. And despite the strength in many elements of the labor market, the low labor force participation rate and weak earnings growth remain causes of concern. Despite the global slowdown, the Fed was confident enough in the recovery to raise interest rates in December 2015. The Federal Funds rate rose from zero percent to 0.25 percent. Several subsequent 0.25 percentage point increases are expected in 2016. Other interest rates are also expected to rise. Despite these rising interest rates, rates remain low by historical standards and both residential and nonresidential investment are predicted to continue to grow. Recovering energy prices are expected to contribute to a slight rise in inflation in 2016. The Consumer Price Index (CPI) is expected to reach 1.2 percent. There are always reasons to be cautious about the next year, but so far the recovery has not been derailed and the U.S. economy has shown considerable resilience. The economy continued to grow last year and is expected to do so in 2016 and 2017 as well. GDP is expected to increase by 2.7 percent, and the unemployment rate is predicted to fall to 4.9 percent. The year is expected to have solid gains each quarter, with GDP increases of 3.0 percent, 3.0 percent, 3.3 percent, and 3.3 percent in the first, second, third, and fourth quarters respectively. Strong domestic demand will continue to be the major driver of these GDP increases. Expectations are that 2017 and 2018 will both register solid economic growth, 2.9 and 2.6 percent in 2017 and 2018, respectively. There are reasons to be concerned that the global slowdown could impact the U.S. economy, but overall U.S. economic indicators were positive throughout 2015. There are ample reasons to expect this recovery to continue and for there to be sustained and substantial growth in 2016 as well. EXECUTIVE SUMMARY The Tennessee Economy The Short-Term Economic Outlook The Tennessee economy continued to expand in 2015. Inflation-adjusted gross domestic product (GDP) grew by 2.4 percent for the year, matching GDP growth for the U.S., and nonfarm employment increased by 1.9 percent, representing an addition of 54,600 new jobs. Job growth in Tennessee was slightly slower than national job gains of 2.1 percent for 2015. The state unemployment rate fell from 6.6 percent in 2014 to 5.9 percent in 2015, but still rests above the national rate. Nominal personal income in Tennessee grew by 4.7 percent in 2015, outpacing the national growth rate of 4.5 percent. Nominal taxable sales continued to grow rapidly, increasing by 6.2 percent in 2015. This followed a 4.9 percent gain in 2014. Tennessee is projected to see slightly slower growth in 2016 and 2017. Inflation-adjusted GDP will rise by 2.3 percent in 2016 and 2.2 percent in 2017. Nonfarm employment should see 1.7 percent growth in 2016 and 1.3 percent growth in 2017. Leisure and hospitality, professional and business services, and natural resources, mining, and construction will experience the largest job gains in both 2016 and 2017. Manufacturing employment will continue to increase but at a slow rate of 0.7 percent in 2016 and 2017. Manufacturing employment growth will occur in the durable goods sector, expanding by 1.5 percent in 2016 and 2017. These gains will offset the losses in the nondurable goods manufacturing sector, where employment is projected to shrink by 0.7 percent in 2016 and 0.8 percent in 2017. The state unemployment rate will fall to 5.5 percent in 2016 and 5.4 percent in 2017. This would be the first time since 2007 that Tennessee’s unemployment rate fell below 6 percent. The number of unemployed people in Tennessee is projected to fall by 6.2 percent in 2016 and an additional 1.7 percent in 2017. However, Tennessee’s unemployment rate will remain above its national counterpart throughout the short-term forecast window. Nominal personal income will grow by 4.8 percent in 2016 and 4.7 percent in 2017. All components of personal income in Tennessee will enjoy healthy growth over the next two years. In 2016 wage and salary income will increase by the largest amount, expanding by 5.1 percent, followed by 4.3 percent growth in 2017. Proprietors’ income will increase by 5.0 percent in 2016 and 4.8 percent in 2017, while rent, interest, and dividend income will grow by 4.4 percent in 2016 and 5.2 percent in 2017. Transfer payments are also projected to increase by 3.7 percent in 2016 and 4.1 percent in 2017. On a fiscal year basis, nominal personal income is projected to rise by 4.9 percent in FY 2016 and 3.3 percent in FY 2017. Per capita personal income will increase by 3.7 percent this year and 3.6 percent in 2017. By 2017, per capita income in Tennessee will equal $44,695. However, this will equate to only 86.9 percent of the national average. Nominal taxable sales are projected to rise by 4.7 percent this year and 3.5 percent in 2017. On a fiscal year basis, nominal taxable sales will increase by 6.5 percent in FY 2016 and 3.3 percent in FY 2017. Long-Term Economic Outlook Tennessee’s long-term outlook is based on a trend forecast which focuses on factors of production such as population and labor force growth as well as productivity. The forecast presented in the body of this report extends out to 2025 and also takes a retrospective look at economic growth between 2005 and the present. One of the underlying assumptions of the trend forecast is that no recessions will occur within the next ten years, but a recession at some point during the long-term forecast horizon is possible if not likely. From 2005 to 2015, nonfarm employment in Tennessee expanded by only 0.5 percent (compound annual growth rate, CAGR). This was slightly slower than the 0.6 percent (CAGR) growth registered for the nation as a whole. Employment growth during this period was slowed due to the Great Recession, and stronger employment gains are expected over the next 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT | ix EXECUTIVE SUMMARY ten years. In Tennessee, nonfarm employment is projected to increase by 1.1 percent (CAGR) between 2015 and 2025. By comparison, national employment will expand by a slightly slower 1.0 percent compound annual growth rate. Tennessee’s manufacturing sector and other services sector will see a very slight contraction in employment over the next ten years, while all other sectors are projected to grow. Employment growth will be strongest in the professional and business services sector, followed by education and health services and natural resources, mining, and construction. Within the manufacturing sector, durable goods employment is projected to grow by 0.4 percent (CAGR) between 2015 and 2025 while nondurable goods employment will fall by 1.0 percent (CAGR). Tennessee’s unemployment rate has rested above the national rate for the last ten years, and a similar pattern is projected throughout most of the long-term forecast horizon out to 2025. However, both the state and national unemployment rates will trend downwards over the next ten years. Tennessee’s unemployment rate, which was 5.9 percent in 2015, will fall to 5.1 percent by 2025, while the national unemployment rate is projected to fall from 5.3 percent in 2015 to 5.0 percent in 2025. Despite the state’s declining unemployment rate, Tennessee labor force participation rate continues to fall. In 2005, Tennessee’s labor force participation rate was 62.0 percent and only slightly below the national participation rate of 64.5 percent. In 2015, the state’s labor force participation rate fell to 57.7 percent and is projected to fall even further to 55.1 percent by 2025. The national labor force participation rate has fallen as well and will rest slightly above 60 percent in 2025. Between 2015 and 2025, nominal personal income is projected to grow by 4.5 percent (CAGR) in Tennessee, outpacing the 3.8 percent x | 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT compound annual growth rate that was registered between 2005 and 2015. Per capita income in Tennessee was only 86.8 percent of the national average in 2015. From 2015 to 2025, per capita income growth in the state is expected to grow by 3.5 percent, but lag behind national per capita income growth of 4.0 percent. As a result, state per capita income will drop to 82.5 percent of the national average by 2025. State initiatives such as the Tennessee Promise, which offers two years of tuition-free community college or technical college to all Tennessee high school graduates, and the Drive to 55, with its goal of increasing the percentage of Tennesseans with a college degree or certificate to 55 percent of the Tennessee population by 2025, aim to increase the education status of the state. If the hoped-for gains are realized, this will support a stronger growth trajectory for the state economy. This could support stronger income growth and a narrowing of the gap between the incomes of Tennesseans and other Americans. Nominal taxable sales in Tennessee are expected to grow by 3.8 percent (CAGR) between 2015 and 2025. This is much stronger than the 2.5 percent compound annual growth rate that took place over the last ten years. Between 2005 and 2015, inflation-adjusted state GDP grew by a sluggish 1.1 percent (CAGR) in Tennessee, which was slightly slower than the 1.4 percent compound annual growth rate that inflation-adjusted GDP registered for the nation. Of course, this time period encapsulates the Great Recession which suppressed output growth in the late 2000’s. Looking ahead ten years, inflation-adjusted state GDP growth will accelerate to 2.2 percent (CAGR) between 2015 and 2025. This is slightly slower than the 2.4 percent compound annual growth rate projected for national GDP. EXECUTIVE SUMMARY Tennessee’s Drive to 55: Background, Early Results, and Challenges Lying Ahead Tennessee’s “Drive to 55” is an effort initiated in 2013 to have 55 percent of working-age Tennesseans hold a higher education credential by 2025. Tennessee Promise is one of the major prongs of this effort. Promise provides last dollar grants – covering tuition and required fees – for any high school graduate in the state who goes straight to a two-year higher education program. The program and its privately funded predecessors motivated similar proposals from several states, the White House, and presidential candidates. This chapter begins by situating Tennessee Promise in the recent history of student progression from high school to college. Among students who started 9th grade in 2008 or 2009, 54 – 55 percent of high school graduates went straight to college. For those who did not, typical earnings were well under the federal poverty line for a one-person household. Dropouts fared even worse. The second section reviews what we know about the impact of Tennessee Promise so far, as well as findings from a study by two CBER faculty on the impact of Knox Achieves – an earlier, very similar program limited to Knox County – on college enrollment. In the first year of Tennessee Promise, first-year college student enrollment rose 10 percent across two-year and four-year public systems. This echoes our estimated impact of Knox Achieves, whose participants were substantially more likely to enroll in college than similar students in ineligible counties. Last, we review some of the challenges and opportunities facing Tennessee Promise and the Drive to 55. Tennessee Promise has proven to be effective at changing the conversation about going to college, but this conversation need not start in twelfth grade. Free tuition will convince some would-be university freshmen to start at a community college (“undermatching”), and their ultimate success will test the state’s system of transfer pathways. Overmatching is potentially a bigger challenge: most two-year college students require remedial education and fewer than three in ten obtain a degree within six years. More high-quality research is needed to identify what programs or practices are pivotal in helping students through college. Research is also needed to identify factors of success for “the other 45 percent” without a college credential. 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT | xi xii | 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT The U.S. Economy | CHAPTER 1 CHAPTER 1: THE U.S. ECONOMY In this chapter— 1.1.Introduction 1.2. The U.S. Economy: Year in Review Components of GDP 1.3. The U.S. Forecast 1.4. Alternative Scenarios 1.5. Forecast Summary and Conclusions 1.6.References 1.1Introduction In 2015, the U.S. recovery from the Great Recession continued for its sixth year while many parts of the world continued reeling from the Great Recession or experienced setbacks related to China and its slowdown. U.S. gross domestic product (GDP) grew by a healthy 2.4 percent in 2015. For comparison, Canada, Japan, and China grew by 1.0 percent, 0.5 percent, and 6.8 percent, respectively. The U.S. was in many dimensions a global economic leader in 2015. The labor market continued a slow but steady recovery: 2014 was the first year that nonfarm payroll reached its pre-recession level, and in 2015 an additional 2.9 million jobs were created. Only one major sector is predicted to have lost jobs in 2015: natural resources and mining, which lost 66 thousand jobs due to falling energy and commodity prices and a subsequent reduction in drilling activity. In addition, the unemployment rate continued its drop to 5.3 percent for the year and 5.0 percent for the fourth quarter, and inflation- adjusted disposable income rose by 3.6 percent for the year. Moreover, the housing market recovered from the slow growth of 2014 and spending on residential investment grew by 8.6 percent in 2015. There were some weak spots in the nation’s housing sector, but generally the momentum was in a positive direction. Additionally, the economy experienced almost no inflation due to falling food and energy prices. All of this positive news culminated in the Federal Reserve signaling its confidence in the economy by raising the discount rate from 0.75 percent to 1.0 percent and the Federal Funds rate from the zero bound to 0.25 percent. These were the first increases in many years, driving home the Fed’s faith in the resiliency of the economy and their belief that the U.S. economy is stable enough to withstand rising interest rates and any modest, unforeseen shocks. The biggest drags and sources of caution were a combination of plummeting commodity and energy prices, an appreciating U.S. dollar, and the 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT | 1 CHAPTER 1 1.1. | The U.S. Economy Introduction, continued global slowdown (especially in China). Falling energy and commodity prices led to a contraction in the natural resources and mining sector and sharp curtailment of drilling activity. (Falling energy prices had a silver lining in the form of significantly lower gasoline prices which freed up purchasing power for other uses.) An appreciating dollar and the global slowdown contributed to a widening U.S. trade deficit. While none of these factors were enough to derail U.S. economic growth, their impact is expected to continue into the next year. 1.2. The U.S. Economy: Year in Review The last year was another stable year for the U.S. expansion. The year started off slow but gained momentum: GDP grew by 0.6 percent on a seasonally-adjusted basis in the first quarter. Afterwards, however, GDP grew by 3.9 percent and 2.0 percent in the second and third quarters; fourth quarter GDP grew at a disappointing 1.2 percent rate. This relatively strong growth for the year as a whole can be attributed to a slowly strengthening housing market, a solid labor market and employment outlook, and robust consumption spending (particularly of durable goods, including automobiles). The Federal Reserve’s December interest rate hike provided evidence of its confidence in the economy. A continuation of the stable growth seen in 2015 is expected for 2016. Both the labor and housing markets are expected to show sustained improvement and inflation is expected to remain benign. This favorable forecast comes with some caution. The global economy is not faring as well as the U.S. economy: much of the globe is experiencing a slowdown in growth, particularly in China, its trading partners, and other developing nations. This situation is expected to continue in 2016. The global slowdown and an appreciating U.S. dollar, in conjunction with strong domestic consumption, are likely to lead to a widening trade deficit. However, these threats are not viewed as significant enough to unsettle the U.S. economy’s current trajectory. 2 | A continuation of growth is expected in 2016. U.S. inflation-adjusted GDP is expected to grow by 2.7 percent, the economy is expected to create 2.4 million jobs, inflation-adjusted disposable income is expected to rise by 3.1 percent, and the global slowdown is expected to continue. Energy and commodity prices are expected to reach bottom in 2016 and affected economies are expected to begin stabilizing. The primary risk is a sharper slowdown in China and the global economy. 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT Components of GDP GDP is composed of personal consumption expenditures, investment, government purchases, and the balance of international trade (exports minus imports). Consumption Personal consumption expenditures are by far the largest component of U.S. GDP, accounting for 68.6 percent of spending in 2015. Consumption grew by 3.1 percent in 2015 compared to 2.7 percent in 2014 and 1.7 percent in 2013. This healthy consumer spending was a major driver of the economy. Increases in consumer spending accounted for 2.1 percentage points of the 2.4 percent growth in GDP in 2015. The strongest consumption growth was recorded in the second quarter, up 3.6 percent compared to 1.8 percent growth in the preceding quarter. The factors that typically help explain consumer spending include disposable income growth, consumer confidence, and the state of the labor market. Inflation-adjusted disposable income increased by 3.6 percent in 2015 compared to growing 2.7 percent in 2014 and falling 1.4 percent in 2013. Some of this disposable income growth was due to falling energy prices, particularly gasoline prices, freeing up income to be spent elsewhere. The unemployment rate and consumer sentiment index also moved in favorable directions. The unemployment rate fell to 5.3 percent for the year, The U.S. Economy 1.2. | CHAPTER 1 The U.S. Economy: Year in Review, continued the lowest the unemployment rate has been since 2007. The consumer sentiment index rose to 92.9, up from 84.1 in 2014. On top of these favorable indicators, inflation-adjusted household net worth grew by 3.2 percent compared to 4.8 percent and 12.7 percent in 2014 and 2013, respectively. Personal consumption has three components: services, nondurable goods, and durable goods. Spending on services is the least volatile of the three components and accounted for 65.5 percent of total consumption spending last year. Services spending grew by 2.7 percent in 2015, the most growth the category has experienced since 2006. Healthcare, transportation, and food services all saw substantial growth of 4.7 percent, 5.1 percent, and 4.5 percent, respectively. Nondurable goods are the second largest category of consumption with a share of 21.7 percent. Nondurable goods include food, beverages, clothing, medical products, gas, and other similar short-lived products. Spending on nondurable goods increased by 2.8 percent in 2015 compared to 2.1 percent in 2014 and 1.9 percent in 2013. The categories that account for the largest portions of nondurable goods spending are food and beverages (33.2 percent of total nondurable good consumption), clothing and footwear (14.8 percent), and pharmaceutical and medical products (16.1 percent). Pharmaceutical and medical products experienced strong growth with spending ticking up 4.6 percent. Clothing and footwear also grew 3.5 percent, but food and beverages spending flattened and increased by only 0.2 percent. Worth noting is that spending on tobacco products increased by 3.5 percent, the first time the category has grown since 2006. Personal spending on durable goods includes motor vehicles, furnishings, recreational goods, computers, and other household equipment. Spending on durable goods is by far the most volatile category of consumption. Spending growth on durables in the recovery has outpaced Figure 1.1: Inflation-Adjusted GDP Continued to Grow in 2015 5.0 4.0 3.0 GDP Growth (%) 2.0 1.0 0.0 -1.0 -2.0 -3.0 -4.0 Source: Bureau of Economic Analysis and IHS Global Insight, Inc. 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT | 3 CHAPTER 1 1.2. | The U.S. Economy The U.S. Economy: Year in Review, continued spending on nondurables and services, and this trend continued in 2015. Spending on durable goods typically sinks during recessions and increases more than any other category during periods of recovery or expansion to satisfy consumers’ pent-up demand. In 2015, durable goods made up 13.1 percent of total consumption spending, and spending on durable goods increased by 6.1 percent. This continues a pattern of strong growth in durable goods spending since the recession: spending on durable goods increased by 5.9 percent, 5.8 percent, and 7.4 percent in 2014, 2013, and 2012, respectively. Spending on computers and peripheral equipment increased by 15.6 percent in 2015, up from 8.1 percent in 2014 and 12.7 percent in 2013. Strong growth in vehicle purchases was one of the main drivers of durable goods consumption. Purchases of both used and new motor vehicles increased significantly for the year. Net used vehicle sales grew by 5.5 percent and new vehicles sales grew by 3.8 percent. This year marks a peak in both number of new vehicles sold and inflationadjusted spending on new vehicles: 17.4 million vehicles were sold and $254.2 million was spent in inflation-adjusted dollars. However, new vehicle sales growth belies a sharp division between the growth of new auto sales and light truck sales. New auto sales shrank by 8.0 percent, while new light truck sales rose 10.2 percent. Sales of domestic cars remained steady at 5.6 million units sold in both 2015 and 2014, while sales of foreign cars fell 6.4 percent from 2.1 million units in 2014 to 2.0 million units in 2015. Sales of domestic light trucks rose 9.3 percent in 2015 to 8.1 million units sold, and sales of foreign light trucks rose 29.7 percent to 1.8 million units sold. Investment Investment made up 17.5 percent of U.S. inflation-adjusted GDP and contributed 0.8 percentage points towards the total 2.4 percent GDP growth in 2015. Investment includes three subcomponents: nonresidential fixed investment, residential fixed investment (new housing), and the change in business inventories. All three categories contributed positively to GDP in 2015. (Note that 4 | 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT investment, as included in GDP, does not include financial instruments like stocks and bonds.) Nonresidential fixed investment, the largest component of investment spending, made up 77.8 percent of investment spending in 2015. It includes equipment purchases by firms, acquisition of non-tangible products such as software and licenses, and spending on structures. Nonresidential fixed investment spending grew by 3.4 percent in 2015 compared to 6.2 percent in 2014 and 3.0 percent in 2013. Spending on mining and petroleum structures fell by 34.7 percent, and spending on power and communication fell by 12.1 percent. On the other hand, manufacturing structures capacity increased dramatically with a 49.9 percent gain. This was the fourth year in a row to see an expansion in manufacturing structures. The second largest sub-component of investment spending is residential fixed investment, which accounted for 18.5 percent of investment spending in 2015. Residential fixed investment contributed 0.3 percentage points towards the 2.4 percent GDP growth in 2015. Residential fixed investment grew by 8.6 percent in 2015, a strong showing after growing only 1.8 percent in 2014. This makes 2015 the fifth consecutive year of growth in the housing market. Despite this consistent growth, residential investment remains substantially below its pre-recession peak. In 2015, inflation-adjusted residential investment increased to $528.4 billion in inflation-adjusted dollars, still only 65.5 percent of the level recorded in 2006. Housing is still trying to recover from the wrenching 24.0 percent, 21.2 percent and 2.5 percent setbacks recorded in 2008, 2009 and 2010. The number of housing starts grew by 10.9 percent to reach 1.1 million units in 2015 compared to 1.0 million units in 2014 and 928 thousand units in 2013. Nevertheless, 1.1 million housing starts is still significantly below the 1.8 million housing starts recorded in 2006. Sales of new homes increased by 12.7 percent in 2015 and reached 496 thousand units, the highest number since 2007. Sales of existing houses grew by 5.9 percent. The U.S. Economy 1.2. | CHAPTER 1 The U.S. Economy: Year in Review, continued House prices have kept their upward trend since 2012. Average and median prices of existing houses increased for the fourth consecutive year to reach $264 thousand and $220 thousand, respectively. The Federal Housing Finance Agency (FHFA) Housing Price Purchase-Only Index also increased for the fourth consecutive year. The housing market continued recovering in the spring and summer, despite stagnating home sales. As is the case for investment in general, interest rates are one of the key determinants of growth in the housing sector. Interest rates remained low throughout 2015, though many expected interest rate hikes to begin mid-year. The Fed did not raise interest rates until December 2015 because of the global slowdown and a weak Chinese economy. In December, the Federal Reserve announced that it would increase the discount rate from 0.75 percent to 1.0 percent and the Federal Funds rate from zero to 0.25 percent. The Federal Funds increase is expected to be the first of many small rate increases that will move the economy back to more typical interest rate levels in the years ahead. Because interest rates continued to be low in 2015, the 30-Year Fixed Mortgage Rate remained lower than its historical average, actually dropping from 4.2 percent in 2014 to 3.9 percent in 2015. The average before the recession was above 6.0 percent. The Federal Funds rate and 3-Month Treasury Bill rate both remained close to zero throughout 2015. Meanwhile, the 10-Year Treasury note yield fell from an average of 2.5 percent in 2014 to 2.1 percent in 2015. Changes in business inventory, the highlycyclical component of investment, contributed positively to GDP in the first two quarters of 2015 but came in negative in both the third and fourth quarters. The overall effect for GDP was slightly positive: changes in inventory accounted for 0.1 percentage points of the 2.4 percent growth in GDP. Typically, the change in inventories accounts for less than 3 percent of total investment (it 2.5 250.0 2.0 200.0 1.5 150.0 1.0 100.0 0.5 50.0 0.0 0.0 Sales of New Houses (Millions of Units) FHFA HPI - Purchase Only (1991Q1=100) New House Sales/Housing Starts (Millions of Units) Figure 1.2: The Housing Sector Continues to Rebound, but Starts and Sales Remain Below Pre-Recession Levels Housing Starts (Millions of Units) FHFA HPI - Purchase Only (1991Q1=100) Source: U.S. Census Bureau, FHFA, and IHS Global Insight, Inc. 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT | 5 CHAPTER 1 1.2. | The U.S. Economy The U.S. Economy: Year in Review, continued accounted for 3.1 percent in 2015), yet it can have a strong contribution to overall GDP growth in some quarters due to its cyclical nature. Inventory investment increased by 4.1 percent in 2015 compared to growing 3.1 percent in 2014. Both farm and nonfarm inventory investment increased steadily but not dramatically: farm investment grew by 3.2 percent and nonfarm investment grew by 4.2 percent. Government Purchases Government purchases, including federal as well as state and local spending, made up 17.5 percent of GDP in 2015. Federal purchases fell for the fifth consecutive year, down to $1.1 trillion in inflation-adjusted dollars. Federal purchases fell 0.4 percent compared to falling 2.4 and 5.7 percent in 2014 and 2013, respectively. Defense spending continued to fall but more slowly than in previous years: defense spending fell by 1.4 percent in 2015 compared to falling by 3.8 percent in 2014 and 6.7 percent in 2013. Federal nondefense spending grew by 1.2 percent compared to falling by 0.1 percent in 2014 and 4.0 percent in 2013. State and local purchases grew for the second year in a row and increased to $1.7 trillion in 2015, down from $1.8 trillion in 2010 in inflation-adjusted dollars. State and local spending grew by 1.5 percent compared to growing 0.6 percent in 2014 and shrinking 1.0 percent in 2013. This growth in state and local spending was spurred on by spending on investment: spending on construction increased by 5.6 percent (the first year of growth since 2006) and spending on software increased by 5.6 percent as well. State and local governments are still recovering from the trough of the Great Recession. The federal government’s deficit remains high at $483.9 billion (nominal dollars) but is small compared to the deficits run during the recession. Sequestration has helped rein in spending. Stronger income taxes and social insurance contributions counterbalanced lower corporate taxes. The total federal debt rose to $18.5 trillion nominal dollars, which makes 2015 the fourth year that federal debt was larger than 100 percent of GDP. Worldwide Recovery from the Great Recession Most recessions come and go without leaving a legacy in their aftermath. This was certainly not the case for the Great Recession where recovery has been prolonged and has varied significantly across the globe. For example, Korea’s unemployment rate in 2013 was 3.1 percent, 0.3 percentage points lower than its level in 2006. On the other hand, Spain’s unemployment rate more than tripled during that time period to 26.3 percent in 2013 from 8.6 percent in 2006. GDP growth has been equally divergent: in 2006, Spain’s GDP growth was 4.2 percent and South Korea’s was 5.2 percent. In 2013, Spain’s GDP shrank by 1.7 percent from the previous year, while South Korea’s grew 2.9 percent. What factors account for this uneven recovery? There are country-specific and region-specific factors at play, but there are also broad trends. Overall, developing nations did much better than developed nations at recovering from the recession. This may be because many developing nations are net exporters. China, with its insular markets, was not impacted by the Great Recession as much as many other large economies. Therefore, nations that exported to China were not impacted as severely by the Great Recession. In fact, Africa and Asia (excluding Japan and China and the Asian Tigers of Hong Kong, Singapore, South Korea, and Taiwan) had GDP growth of over 50 percent from 2009 to 2014. The Asian Tigers plus Japan and China, the Middle East, Latin America, and Oceania all recorded GDP growth of over 40 percent from 2009 to 2014 2014 (Arias & Wen, 2015). Unfortunately, this is also why many developing nations have experienced severe setbacks to growth as China’s growth slows. As a consequence, while developed nations’ contribution to global growth fell in the years following the Great Recession (2010 – 2014), it is predicted to have risen in 2015. continued on page 7 6 | 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT The U.S. Economy 1.2. | CHAPTER 1 The U.S. Economy: Year in Review, continued continued from page 6 Another important factor is whether a country used effective fiscal or monetary stimulus to respond to the recession. China used aggressive fiscal stimulus and used its state-owned enterprises to hoist up demand (Wen & Wu, 2014). European nations responded to the crisis with monetary policy and to varying degrees pursued fiscal austerity. Now, once we are at a vantage point to see the impact of those decisions, it appears that aggressive Keynesian government policy (i.e. deficit financed government spending) helped China weather the Great Recession, whereas the mixed fiscal and monetary policy actions of the U.S. were less effective, and the monetary actions of Europe were even less effective than that of the U.S. (Arais & Wen, 2015). Finally, the Great Recession began as a crisis in the financial sector. The more a nation’s financial market was integrated with global financial markets, the more exposed they were to the immediate financial crisis. Countries with insular and comparatively small financial markets may have been protected from the full ramifications of the financial crisis (Arais & Wen, 2015). The wilting financial markets had consequences for both the U.S. and European economies that may have made recovery more difficult. Europe, and especially a number of members of the European Union, had a particularly challenging time recovering from the Great Recession. In 2013, European GDP was the same as it was in 2012. Europe was so hard-hit because the recession launched a debt crisis, including a sovereign debt crisis for nation states. Five nations in the European Union (EU) required bailouts after the recession: Greece, Ireland, Portugal, Spain, and Cyprus. European nations trade heavily with each other, and membership in the European Union intensifies this interrelatedness. As Europe was attempting to recover from the recession, many of the EU member nations experienced crises that then impacted other nations. Further, the EU suffered from each of the factors listed above: (1) it is made primarily of developed nations, so it could not weather the Great Recession and its fallout through exports to China and other developing nations, (2) countries practiced monetary stimulus and in some cases even austerity measures in response to the recession, and (3) its financial markets are globally connected. Trade In 2015, the U.S. recorded a trade deficit of $525.4 billion (or 2.9 percent of GDP). Exports amounted to $2.3 trillion, while imports amounted to $2.9 trillion. Typically, purchases of foreign goods and services by U.S. consumers (imports) exceed sales of goods and services produced in the U.S. and sold to other countries (exports). After the recession, there was a three-year period from 2010 to 2012 when exports grew faster than imports. However, in 2015, import growth vastly outpaced export growth. Part of the explanation for this imbalance is the strength of the U.S. dollar. As the dollar strengthens, U.S. exports become more expensive and imports to the U.S. become less expensive. Imports increased in 2015 by 5.0 percent compared to rising by 3.8 and 1.1 percent in 2014 and 2013, respectively. Meanwhile, exports increased by just 1.0 percent compared to growing by 3.4 percent in 2014 and 2.8 percent in 2013. Imports of both goods and services grew solidly: imports of services grew by 5.7 percent and imports of goods grew by 4.9 percent. On the other hand, exports of goods fell by 0.3 percent, even as exports of services rose by 3.9 percent. Exports of vehicles and parts fell by 4.8 percent, the first time vehicle exports have fallen since 2009. Inflation and Prices The most popular measure of the aggregate level of prices in the economy is the Consumer Price Index or the CPI. As measured by the CPI, overall prices rose by only 0.1 percent in 2015 compared to 1.6 percent in 2014 and 1.5 percent in 2013. Low energy prices and low import prices (from a strong U.S. dollar) drove overall price indices downward. If energy and food are excluded, overall prices in 2015 still only rose by 1.8 percent. This rate is still below the Fed’s target range for inflation. Food prices rose by 1.9 percent, while 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT | 7 CHAPTER 1 1.2. | The U.S. Economy The U.S. Economy: Year in Review, continued energy prices fell by a staggering 16.7 percent, a much bigger drop than those recorded in 2014 and 2013. Producer prices (finished goods) fell by 3.4 percent in 2015, the first time the category has experienced a price decline since 2009. This decrease was mainly caused by falling energy prices (which impact both producers and consumers) and a huge reduction in crude material prices. Crude material prices fell by 24.2 percent in 2015, mostly driven by declines in the prices of fuels and power. Gas fuels, crude petroleum, and refined petroleum product prices fell by 45.5 percent, 50.8 percent, and 37.8 percent, respectively. The Federal Reserve is charged with maintaining both price stability and full employment. These goals can often be at odds: price stability requires some minimal level of inflation and some yield of interest on savings. Conversely, the Fed can stimulate demand (and thus hope to increase employment) by keeping interest rates low. This is what the Fed did in response to the Great Recession. The Federal Reserve kept the Federal Funds rate low (below 0.25 percent) for twenty-eight consecutive quarters by the end of 2015. Finally, in December 2015, the Fed raised the Federal Funds rate from zero to 0.25 percent. The Fed is predicted to slowly increase the Federal Funds rate until it returns to more normal levels. Expect the Federal Funds rate to exceed 1.0 percent by the end of 2016. As noted above, these anticipated increases are viewed by many economists as a signal of the Fed’s belief in the strength of the recovery as well as a necessary step to normalize rates. The Fed had maintained that interest rates would stay low until the unemployment rate was below 6.5 percent and labor market indicators improved. The unemployment rate in 2015 remained below that threshold and continued dropping from 5.7 percent in the fourth quarter of 2014 to 5.0 percent in the fourth quarter of 2015. The Fed previously announced that they would begin raising interest rates in mid-2015, but this did not happen until December 2015 because of the current Figure 1.3: Consumer Energy Prices Drop in 2015 Consumer Energy Prices (2009 = 100) 150.0 140.0 130.0 120.0 110.0 100.0 90.0 Year:Quarter Source: Bureau of Economic Analysis and IHS Global Insight, Inc. 8 | 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT The U.S. Economy 1.2. | CHAPTER 1 The U.S. Economy: Year in Review, continued global slowdown. The December hike was the first time the Fed has raised rates since 2006. There is some worry that rising interest rates will bolster an already strong dollar and lead to an even larger trade deficit in 2016. However, stronger global growth and rising interest rates in other countries will help temper these possible impacts. Although inflation is not an imminent concern for the U.S. economy, there are some signs that slightly higher prices are on the horizon. Wages are finally showing some signs of increasing, and the falling unemployment rate means additional tightening in the labor market. Moreover, energy prices have likely bottomed out and, as they recover, will add to inflationary pressures. There have been ongoing concerns since the end of the recession that deflation rather than inflation was a greater risk to the economy. Continued economic growth is reducing the likelihood of deflation. There is an excess of global capacity in the manufacturing and this is where ongoing downward price pressures are expected. The Labor Market The national unemployment rate continued falling for the fifth year, down to 5.3 percent for 2015 compared to 6.2 percent in 2014 and 7.4 percent in 2013. The unemployment rate’s descent has been slow but consistent. However, the labor force participation rate is well below relatively recent historical levels and is an ongoing cause for concern. The labor force participation rate held at 61.3 percent for 2015, the same as in 2014. For comparison, the labor force participation rate in 1996 was 65.0 percent. The labor force participation rate for those under 60 has fallen (down to 71.2 percent from 75.6 percent in 1996), while the participation rate for those 60 and over has risen (up to 18.3 percent from 11.5 percent in 1996). Some portion of the falling participation rate may be explained by (1) fewer people between the ages of 16-24 working because they are in school and (2) discouraged workers. A discouraged unemployed worker is one who stops looking for work and thus is technically no longer considered unemployed. Figure 1.4: Unemployment Continues Dropping, but the Participation Rate Also Remains Low 66.0 12.0 65.0 64.0 8.0 63.0 6.0 62.0 4.0 61.0 2.0 Participation Rate (%) Unemployment Rate (%) 10.0 60.0 0.0 59.0 Unemployment Rate Participation Rate Source: Bureau of Labor Statistics and IHS Global Insight, Inc. 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT | 9 CHAPTER 1 1.2. | The U.S. Economy The U.S. Economy: Year in Review, continued Discouraged workers imply that the relatively low participation rate in 2015 is part of the reason the unemployment rate is falling (since the unemployment rate only counts people without jobs who are actively seeking work). Many economists believed that once the recession was over, discouraged workers would re-enter the labor force, and the participation rate would bounce back up. Unfortunately, this has not happened. Janet Yellen, the Chair of the Fed’s Board of Governors, estimates that there are currently two million discouraged workers who are not employed in the current labor market but would be employed in a labor market with higher wages and less slack (Yellen, 2015). An additional concern is productivity, which has recently stagnated and increased by only 0.7 percent in both 2015 and 2014. Productivity increased significantly in the recession and its immediate aftermath: it rose by 3.2 percent in 2009 and 3.3 percent in 2010. Further, although 2008 experienced low productivity growth, productivity growth has traditionally been high in the modern U.S. economy. Since 1996, no year before the Great Recession had productivity growth of less than 1.6 percent. 1.3. The U.S. Forecast Even amidst uncertainty about the global economy, the U.S. is expected to continue on its trajectory of steady growth in 2016 and 2017. Inflation-adjusted GDP is expected to grow by a robust 2.7 percent in 2016, following 2.4 percent growth recorded in 2015. The fourth quarter of 2015 recorded annualized GDP growth of only 1.2 percent due to unexpectedly slow consumer spending. This followed strong GDP growth in the second and third quarters of 3.9 and 2.0 percent, respectively; growth in these quarters was driven by growing consumer spending. Calendar year 2016 is expected to have solid growth each quarter: 3.0 percent in the first and second quarters and 3.3 percent in the third and fourth. The factors contributing to this growth in the next year are primarily strong consumer spending, 10 | More encouragingly, the economy continued creating jobs in 2015, a positive indicator since the economy just reached its pre-recession level of jobs in 2014. The economy added 2.9 million nonfarm payroll jobs in 2015, a 2.1 percent increase. The total number of nonfarm payroll jobs reached 141.9 million, making 2015 the second year that post-recession nonfarm payroll jobs surpassed their pre-recession level. Most of the job gains came from the private sector, which added 2.8 million jobs. The public sector added 91 thousand jobs; 84 thousand of these jobs were added at the state and local level. Of the major sectors, professional and business services added the most jobs: 653 thousand jobs in 2015. However, both education and health services and trade, transportation, and utilities added large numbers of jobs, 584 thousand and 537 thousand, respectively. Notably, the construction sector continued to grow, adding 249 thousand jobs. The sector that did the poorest was natural resources and mining, the only sector to shed jobs, which lost 59 thousand jobs for a decline in employment of 6.6 percent. 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT continuing growth in residential investment, and a healthy pace of job creation. U.S. consumer spending is expected to rise by 3.0 percent, housing starts are expected to reach 1.3 million, and the economy is predicted to create 2.4 million jobs. The U.S. economy’s cornerstone of domestic demand will help shield it from many impacts of the global slowdown, but manufacturing as well as natural resources and mining will be impacted. Manufacturing is expected to continue to suffer from fallen global demand and an appreciating U.S. dollar. Low global commodity and energy prices will continue to depress growth in the natural resources sector. These same low prices will be a boon to consumers. Both U.S. fiscal and monetary policy are oriented for a year of robust growth. The Fed is expected to The U.S. Economy 1.3. | CHAPTER 1 The U.S. Forecast, continued continue increasing interest rates in 2016 following an increase at the end of 2015. U.S. federal purchases are predicted to rise for the first time since 2010 building on a bipartisan budget accord that was reached before the year’s end. The will help stabilize political influence on the economy through 2016. Consumption Consumer spending was strong throughout most of 2015, and that pattern is expected to continue into 2016 with an annual growth rate of 2.7 percent. This positive consumer spending depends on continued growth in inflation-adjusted income, automobile sales, and real estate, as well as continuing low inflation rates. Inflation-adjusted disposable income is expected to grow by 3.1 percent in 2016 compared to 3.6 percent in 2015. Inflation-adjusted household net worth is expected to grow by 3.4 percent in 2016 compared to 3.2 percent in 2015. Consumption growth in 2016 is expected to be relatively stable and grow 3.0 percent, 3.2 percent, 3.4 percent, and 3.4 percent for the first, second, third, and fourth quarters, respectively. Spending on durable goods should remain strong in 2016 as a result of the recovering economy and job market. Durable goods spending is expected to increase by 6.3 percent compared to increasing by 6.1 percent in 2015. Durable goods spending is expected to continue to outpace both services spending (expected to increase by 2.5 percent) and nondurable goods spending (expected to increase by 3.1 percent). While spending on new light trucks is expected to grow by only 4.0 percent compared to 10.2 percent in 2015, spending on recreational goods and vehicles is predicted to stay strong and increase by 11.2 percent. The Labor Market Employment growth is expected to remain solid and steady. The unemployment rate is expected to drop through 2016: it was 5.0 percent in the fourth quarter of 2015 and is expected to fall to 4.9 by the fourth quarter of 2016. Based on headline statistics like the overall unemployment rate, the labor market is getting close to full employment. Other measures—like counts of discouraged workers and the low labor force participation rate—suggest that significant underlying weaknesses remain in the labor market. The expected 1.7 percent rate of job creation is slower than the recorded rate for 2015 or 2014, which saw increases of 2.1 and 1.9 percent, respectively. Nevertheless, the economy is expected to add 2.4 million more jobs in 2016. The first quarter is expected to be particularly robust with 663 thousand jobs added. The sectors expected to experience the strongest growth are the education and health services sector as well as professional and business services, which are expected to add 600 thousand and 634 thousand jobs, respectively. Only one major sector is expected to cut payrolls: natural resources and mining, the same sector that shed jobs in 2015. Due to plummeting petroleum and natural gas prices, the natural resources and mining sector is expected to cut 93 thousand jobs. Productivity, which has slumped in recent years, is expected to grow by 1.5 percent in 2016. There is some evidence that productivity has slowed, including the disconnect between very strong rates of job growth and the more modest but still respectable rate of GDP growth. The lack of a rebound in productivity would translate into slower growth for the year. A major concern in recent years has been the decline in the labor force participation rate, i.e., the share of the adult population employed or unemployed and actively pursuing a job. From 2008 to 2011, the labor force actually shrank by 703 thousand workers. Labor force expansion has not reached 1.0 percent for any year since the recession, but in 2016 it is expected to reach 1.5 percent. This is close to the 1.7 percent rate of job creation expected in 2016. Investment and Interest Rates The housing sector is expected to continue its recovery, despite rising interest rates which increase monthly mortgage payments. Pent-up demand, low housing prices, and a healthy labor market will carry the housing market forward. Residential 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT | 11 CHAPTER 1 1.3. | The U.S. Economy The U.S. Forecast, continued fixed investment is expected to grow by 9.5 percent in 2016, marking its sixth year of growth. The first quarter is expected to be particularly strong, with an annualized growth rate of 11.2 percent. Housing starts are expected to increase to 1.3 million units compared to 1.1 million in 2015, notably still below the pre-recession level of 1.8 million in 2006. Sales of existing homes are expected to increase to 5.3 million units, 81.4 percent of their 2006 level. Housing prices are predicted to continue rising, with a 3.4 percent increase in average existing home prices expected in 2016. The average price of new homes is expected to rise much faster and increase by 7.1 percent, following a significantly smaller increase of 3.2 percent in 2015. The FHFA Purchase-Only Index is projected to rise by 4.8 percent in 2016, following increases of 5.6 percent and 5.5 percent in 2015 and 2014, respectively. The Fed finally began raising interest rates at the end of 2015. It is expected that the Federal Funds rate will reach 1.3 percent by the fourth quarter of 2016. The 3-Month Treasury Bill rate is expected to increase to 1.2 percent by the fourth quarter of 2016, and the 30-Year Fixed Mortgage rate is expected to increase to 4.6 percent. Some fear that rising interest rates could slow the housing market’s recovery, but the overall consensus is that the housing market has strengthened enough to withstand rising interest rates. The Fed’s interest rate hikes are already incorporated into market considerations. Nonresidential fixed investment is expected to grow by 5.0 percent in 2016 compared to 3.4 percent in 2015. Equipment investment is expected to account for most of the growth in nonresidential fixed investment, advancing 6.6 percent. Growing equipment investment is dependent on rising oil prices, the global economy gaining momentum, and exchange rates stabilizing. Structures investment is expected to grow by only 2.6 percent. Business inventory spending is not expected to grow as quickly as it did in 2015; the anticipated gain in 2016 is only 1.5 percent. The first sign of Figure 1.5: The Federal Funds Rate Is Expected to Rise, Which Will Push Mortgage Rates Up 8.00 7.00 7.50 6.00 Federal Funds Rate (%) 5.00 6.50 6.00 4.00 5.50 3.00 5.00 4.50 2.00 4.00 1.00 3.50 0.00 3.00 Federal Funds Rate Source: Federal Reserve Bank, Freddie Mac, and IHS Global Insight, Inc. 12 | 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT 30-Year Fixed Mortgage Rate 30-Year Fixed Mortgage Rate (%) 7.00 The U.S. Economy 1.3. | CHAPTER 1 The U.S. Forecast, continued a quickening global economy will be increased changes in inventory, rather than changes in the trade deficit. Federal Budget Because of a bipartisan budget agreement, the federal budget is expected to experience its first increase since 2010 and grow by 3.6 percent to $1.2 trillion. The deficit is projected to rise to $500.5 billion compared to $438.9 billion in 2015. Any deficit will add to the overall U.S. debt, which is predicted to hit $19.4 trillion in 2016. This would make 2016 the sixth year that U.S. federal debt has exceeded U.S. GDP. The Congressional budget deal includes an increase in defense and nondefense spending, as well as cuts to Medicare and Social Security benefits. Defense spending is projected to rise by 3.1 percent and nondefense spending by 4.4 percent. At the state and local level, spending is expected to grow by 1.5 percent. China’s Slowdown The economic situation in China is a major concern for the current global economy. The resolution of China’s economic slowdown or its continuance will impact worldwide growth in the coming year. China now has the largest economy in the world, with a purchasing power parity GDP of $17.2 trillion in 2014 (compared to $16.6 trillion for the U.S.), even though China’s GDP per capita was only $8 thousand in 2014 (compared to $55 thousand for the U.S.). It is unsurprising then that China’s slowdown and shift away from manufacturing and toward services should be felt throughout the world. On January 4, 2016, Chinese markets reopened for the year and subsequently shut down after a seven percent drop in the stock market. A repeat of this event happened on January 7. Clearly, the Chinese market will continue to contract in early 2016. What is causing this slowdown and how will it impact the U.S.? From 2002 to 2011, China enjoyed GDP growth of at least 9 percent per year including peaks of 14 percent. However, in 2012 growth fell to 7.7 percent and growth is expected to have fallen to 6.5 percent in 2015. A primary cause of this slowing growth is China’s aging population. China ascended to prominence in the global marketplace because of its large supply of labor and subsequently low manufacturing costs. Once the generation born under the One Child Policy matured, that labor supply became constrained. Now, with a more slowly growing labor force, wages are rising and a low-cost manufacturing model for China is no longer viable (Kessler & Murray, 2015). The Chinese government is aware of this and the economy is intentionally being shifted away from manufacturing to services. This shift is viewed by many as necessary to China’s economic development and is crucial to it transitioning to an economy fostered by domestic consumption and not by investment. The transition to a more consumption-dominant economy is already playing out: the International Monetary Fund estimates that in 2014 consumption contributed 0.1 percentage point more to China’s GDP than investment did (International Monetary Fund, 2015). Regardless of how necessary this transition may be, it remains a time of slowed growth and new vulnerabilities within the economy. The necessity of a lessening dependence on investment was made clear by the contraction of China’s real estate sector. China’s real estate bubble deflated and prices fell by 6 percent. The popping of the real estate bubble contributes to China’s economic slowdown on its own, but that is not where its impact on the slowdown stopped. China’s local governments had a large stake in real estate: they had been selling off local lands or leveraging them. Falling real estate prices also forced local governments to stop overleveraging and begin investing less, further contributing to the economic slowdown (Kessler & Murray, 2015). In addition to all of this, China devalued its currency twice in the past year: once in summer 2015 and again in early 2016. China is attempting to boost its faltering economy by depreciating its currency, like many other nations in the aftermath of the Great Recession. However, this has only increased market fragility, since investors now fear that the currency will be continued on page 14 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT | 13 CHAPTER 1 1.3. | The U.S. Economy The U.S. Forecast, continued continued from page 13 devalued further. The Chinese government is now faced with a slowdown with multiple causes. On a global stage, China’s slowdown is rippling through the world economy. The shift away from manufacturing has lowered demand for commodities and has exacerbated the drop in commodity prices worldwide. Further, the falling value of the yuan makes Chinese imports more expensive. Trading partners that China imports commodities from – Brazil, Canada, and Russia – are feeling the direct impact, contributing to recessions in these countries. It remains to be seen how China will affect the global economy in 2016 and 2017. On the positive side, the U.S. economy has limited direct exposure to China in terms of trade. In addition, falling commodity prices have translated into lower costs of production for producers and importantly lower gasoline prices for consumers. The downside risk depends on the degree to which China’s slowdown spreads through emerging markets and commodity-exporting nations. Some economies, like Japan, do have considerable direct exposure to the Chinese slowdown. The best bet at this time is a further slowdown in China, coupled with ongoing market instability, but sufficient global strength to ward off recession. International Trade The global economy is expected to continue to move at a sluggish pace, with recessions or slowdowns in many countries. Few of these nations are significant trading partners with the U.S., but the comparably robust U.S. recovery and U.S. dollar (which is expected to continue appreciating until mid-2016) mean that imports are expected to rise much faster than exports. In addition, the Chinese yuan was devalued again in early 2016, continuing its impact of driving down the cost of Chinese goods for exporters and driving up the cost for goods imported into China, including commodities and raw materials. Inflation-adjusted exports of goods and services are projected to grow by 2.3 percent in 2016 compared to 1.0 percent in 2015. Exports of capital goods excluding automobiles are expected to continue shrinking by 1.6 percent compared to a decrease of 2.8 percent in 2015. Imports are expected to record much faster growth than exports, 4.9 percent in 2016 compared to 5.0 percent in 2015. Imports of petroleum products 14 | 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT are expected to be particularly strong in the wake of low prices: petroleum product imports are expected to grow by 11.1 percent in 2016 compared to 2.1 percent in 2015. Inflation and Prices Inflation is expected to remain low in 2016 with consumer prices expected to increase by only 1.2 percent. This increase is higher than the low inflation of 0.1 percent experienced in 2015, but lower than in any other year since 2009. Consumer energy prices are expected to continue falling and decrease by 7.6 percent in 2016. Oil prices are expected to continue falling into the first quarter of 2016 to $38.48 per barrel but then bounce back and reach $55.52 per barrel in inflation-adjusted terms. By 2017, inflation is expected to reach 2.6 percent, hitting the Fed’s target range for the first time since 2012. Consumer energy prices are also expected to rise by 8.6 percent, ending a four-year period of price declines. The U.S. Economy 1.3. | CHAPTER 1 The U.S. Forecast, continued Figure 1.6: The Trade Deficit Is Expected to Continue as Import Growth Outpaces Export Growth 15.0 Import/Export Growth (%) 10.0 5.0 0.0 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 -5.0 -10.0 -15.0 -20.0 Exports Imports Source: Bureau of Economic Analysis and IHS Global Insight, Inc. Figure 1.7: The Price of Crude Oil Will Begin Rebounding Mid-2016 140.00 Brent Crude, Spot Price ($/bbl) 120.00 100.00 80.00 60.00 40.00 20.00 0.00 Year:Quarter Source: Commodity Research Bureau and IHS Global Insight, Inc. 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT | 15 1.3. The U.S. Forecast, continued Inflation Expectations In the past year, the U.S. economy experienced very low rates of inflation. The Consumer Price Index (CPI), the most familiar measure of inflation, only rose by 0.1 percent in 2015. Core-CPI, which excludes energy and food prices (two sectors known to have price volatility), rose by 1.8 percent, still below the Fed’s benchmark of 2.0 percent inflation. Falling gasoline and commodity prices, low rates of wage increase, and a strong dollar are all contributing to these low inflation rates. How inflation behaves in the next year is dependent on all of these factors, and none of them have a clear-cut path. Gasoline prices are expected to continue falling in early 2016 but begin recovering mid-year. By 2017, gasoline prices are expected to be $58 per barrel compared to $54 per barrel in 2015. This rebound is contingent on increased oil demand (spurred on by low prices) outpacing supply. If this happens, prices will begin to increase so that the market can return to equilibrium. The ongoing global slowdown raises some question about the vitality of demand in the near term and whether prices will in fact tick back up. As this report goes to press, there is an increased likelihood of still lower gasoline prices. The path for commodity prices is also tricky since much of their fall has been caused by the global slowdown. As nations’ economies slow, they demand fewer commodities. Lower demand then drives prices downward. This situation is aggravated because supply had risen during recent years to match increased demand as China’s economy expanded at a booming pace each year. With a slowing Chinese economy, the commodities market faced a higher supply than usual and lower demand than anticipated, which led to commodity prices spiraling down to levels not seen since the Great Recession. The resolution or continuance of the global slowdown will determine how commodity prices behave in 2016 and beyond. The global slowdown is predicted to continue through 2016; likewise, commodity prices are predicted to remain depressed through 2016 as well. Low commodity and gasoline prices drive overall prices downward because they are such an important element of the costs of production. Additionally, as other economies slow and the U.S. economy expands, the U.S. dollar appreciates relative to other currencies. As the dollar strengthens, U.S. exports become more expensive and U.S. imports become less expensive. To exacerbate this state of affairs, many nations that are experiencing slowed growth are responding by devaluing their currency. This drives the U.S. dollar’s value up further in relative terms and makes imports from those nations even cheaper. These cheaper import prices also depress inflation. And, like low commodity prices, cheaper imports are expected to continue into 2016 as the global slowdown lingers. Finally, low levels of wage growth have put downward pressure on inflation by helping avert a wage-cost spiral. This low wage growth is tied to a labor market with slack and the low levels of productivity growth seen since the end of the Great Recession. In 2016, productivity is expected to increase by 1.5 percent compared to 0.7 percent in 2015. There is already small evidence of upward pressure on wages: hourly wages experienced higher growth rates at the end of 2015 than at its beginning. Lessening slack in the labor market will also help push inflation upward. In addition to all these factors, it is important to remember inflation expectations impact inflation itself. Inflation expectations can create environments where expectations become reality: if firms expect high rates of inflation in the next period, they may increase their current period demand in order to take advantage of relatively cheaper current period prices, which in turn will drive prices up. Consumer surveys in 2015 point to consumers’ inflation expectations falling as 2015 wound to a close. The Survey of Consumer Finances revealed that consumers’ three-year inflation expectations fell 0.1 percentage points to 2.8 percent from the October survey to the November survey (Sajdak, 2015). Janet Yellen, the Chair of the Fed’s Board of Governors, points out that short-run consumer inflation expectations are often responsive to current inflation levels (Yellen, 2015), and short-run business forecasts may be more indicative of future short-run inflation. Business inflation expectations (as computed by the Federal Reserve of Atlanta) increased a tenth of a percentage point from the November survey to the December survey. Surveyed businesses expect to see 1.9 percent inflation in 2016. Global Insight, Inc., predicts that the core-CPI will reach 2.0 percent by 2016, and overall CPI will reach 2.0 by 2017. This forecast is dependent on rising wages, rising gasoline prices, and the continuation of the global slowdown. 16 | 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT The U.S. Economy 1.4. • • • CHAPTER 1 Alternative Scenarios Rising employment and consumption were the basis for the U.S. economy’s strength in 2015. It is noteworthy that the national economy performed well in the face of strong headwinds from the global economy. Continued growth will depend on how the global slowdown plays out, commodity and gasoline price trends, the resilience of financial markets, and consumers’ responses to the aforementioned. In the pessimistic scenario (20 percent probability), the U.S. stock market weakens appreciably in 2016 and the global slowdown continues unabated. Foreign investors buy U.S. securities, driving up the value of the dollar further. The dollar’s appreciation makes U.S. goods more expensive and demand for U.S. manufacturing falls precipitously. These events drive down consumer 1.5. | and business confidence and thus job creation. The economy contracts and home sales decline. The Fed slows the rate at which it increases interest rates. In the optimistic scenario (15 percent possibility), the global slowdown relents. Demand for gasoline outpaces supply, thus driving up prices. Structural changes occur in other economies that improve the fundamentals of the global economy. In addition to these positive external events, the stock market recovers from its correction in 2015. Credit conditions soften, which leads to more residential and nonresidential investment. Consumer confidence and spending rise, and the economy speeds up the pace of job creation. The Fed quickens the rate at which it increases interest rates. Forecast Summary and Conclusions Inflation-adjusted GDP will grow at a healthy 2.7 percent rate in 2016, following 2.4 percent growth in 2015. The Fed will continue raising interest rates. The Federal Funds rate is expected to reach 1.3 percent by the fourth quarter of 2016, and the 30-Year Fixed Mortgage rate is expected to reach 4.6 percent. Consumer spending will continue to bolster the economy and grow by 3.0 percent in 2016 in response to growing disposable income and ongoing job creation. • • • Inflation will remain low at 1.2 percent, due to falling energy prices. The recovery of the housing market will continue and residential investment will increase by 9.5 percent. Exports and imports will continue diverging as the U.S. economy remains strong, the dollar appreciates, and the global economy stumbles. Exports are expected to increase by 2.3 percent while imports increase by 4.9 percent. 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT | 17 CHAPTER 1 | The U.S. Economy 1.6.References Arias, M. A., & Wen, Y. (2015). Recovery from the Great Recession has varied around the world. The Regional Economist: Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis, 23(4), 10-11. International Monetary Fund. (2015). IMF Country Report: People’s Republic of China. Retrieved January 13, 2016 from https://www.imf.org/ external/pubs/ft/scr/2015/cr15234.pdf. Kessler, L. & Murray, M. (2015). Domestic economy remains strong in the face of the global slowdown. Report for Tennessee Valley Authority. Sajdak, K. (2015) Consumers anticipate better labor market, mixed inflation outcomes. Liberty Street Economics: Federal Reserve Bank of New York. Retrieved January 12, 2016 from https://www.newyorkfed.org/ newsevents/news/research/2015/an151109. 18 | 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT Wen, Y., & Wu, J. (2014). Withstanding the Great Recession like China. Working Paper, Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis. Yellen, J.L. (2015). The economic outlook and monetary policy. Speech given for the Economic Club of Washington, D.C. Retrieved January 12, 2016 from http:// www.federalreserve.gov/newsevents/speech/ yellen20151202a.htm. The Tennessee Economy: Short-Term Outlook | CHAPTER 2 CHAPTER 2: THE TENNESSEE ECONOMY: SHORT-TERM OUTLOOK In this chapter— 2.1.Introduction 2.2. 2.3. The Current Economic Environment The Labor Market Income and Taxable Sales Fiscal Update Federal Government State Finances across the Nation The Southeastern States and Tennessee 2.4. Short-Term Outlook 2.4. Tennessee Forecast at a Glance 2.5. Tennessee’s Agricultural and Forest Industries and Rural Economy Introduction Agriculture and Primary Forestry Food, Fiber, and Forestry Manufacturing in Tennessee Rural Economies and Well-Being Governor’s Rural Challenge Summary References Used 2.1.Introduction Economic growth in Tennessee has been similar to that of the U.S. in recent years. Both the state and nation have now enjoyed more than six years of growth since the end of the Great Recession. In Tennessee, inflation-adjusted gross domestic product (GDP) expanded by 2.4 percent in 2015 and is projected to advance an additional 2.3 percent in 2016. Similarly, the U.S. economy grew by 2.4 percent in 2015 and growth is projected to accelerate to 2.7 percent in 2016. In the U.S. there were 292,000 new jobs created last December and 2.7 million new jobs for 2015 as a whole. This was below the 3.1 million new jobs created in 2014, but outpaced job creation for the three years prior (2011-2013). Significant employment growth can also be seen in the Tennessee labor market, where nonfarm employment increased by 1.9 percent in 2015, representing an additional 54,600 new jobs. Manufacturing employment also expanded by 1.9 percent in 2015, outpacing the 1.1 percent rate of growth seen in the nation. After recording a 6.5 percent unemployment rate during the first quarter of 2015, Tennessee’s unemployment rate finally fell below 6 percent during the second quarter – it had been seven years since the state last registered an unemployment rate under 6 percent (Tennessee’s unemployment rate was 5.7 percent during the first quarter of 2008.) In the second half of 2015, Tennessee’s unemployment hovered between 5.6 and 5.7 percent. The state unemployment rate is projected to fall to 5.5 percent for 2016 which is slightly above the nation’s 4.9 percent unemployment rate projected for 2016. In 2015, 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT | 19 CHAPTER 2 2.1. | The Tennessee Economy: Short-Term Outlook Introduction, continued nominal personal income in Tennessee grew at a faster pace than in the U.S., expanding by 4.7 percent compared to 4.5 percent growth for the nation. State personal income growth will accelerate to 4.8 percent in 2016, compared to only 4.2 percent growth projected for the nation. For nonfarm employees, the average annual wage 2.2. The Current Economic Environment The Labor Market Tennessee nonfarm employment grew at a healthy 1.9 percent rate during 2015. This was slightly slower than the 2.1 percent growth rate registered one year prior. Job growth in Tennessee was also slower than national employment growth of 2.1 percent for 2015. Tennessee nonfarm employment growth started off slowly in 2015, growing by only 0.5 percent in the first quarter before rebounding to 2.0 percent growth (on a seasonally-adjusted basis) for both the second and third quarters. Similar to what occurred in 2014, the slow start to 2015 was largely due to a cold and snowy winter. For the year, nonfarm employment totaled 2,870,733 which is only slightly above the pre-recession peak of 2,797,781 in 2007. It is rather remarkable that employment in 2015 was so close to the level seen eight years earlier. In 2015, nonfarm employment growth was led by the leisure and hospitality sector which grew by 3.3 percent. Employment in the natural resources, mining, and construction sector expanded by 3.2 percent, and job growth of 2.8 percent was seen in the professional and business services sector. Three sectors experienced job losses in 2015, including the information sector (-1.3 percent), other services (-1.0 percent), and the federal government (-1.1 percent). This marks the second consecutive year of job losses in Tennessee’s information sector, and the fifth straight year of federal government job losses in Tennessee. Manufacturing employment in Tennessee grew by 1.9 percent in 2015, outpacing the nation’s 1.1 20 | was $47,219 in 2015, representing a 3.1 percent increase over the previous year, outstripping the rate of growth in inflation. Nominal taxable sales in Tennessee expanded by 6.2 percent in 2015, and are projected to grow an additional 4.7 percent in 2016. 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT percent growth rate. This was the fifth consecutive year of manufacturing employment growth for the state following more than a decade of setbacks. Within manufacturing, employment in the durable goods manufacturing sector grew by 3.0 percent in 2015, while nondurable goods manufacturing employment grew by only 0.1 percent. Using the most recent data available, employment growth by county is presented in Figure 2.1. From June 2014 to June 2015, statewide employment grew by 2.8 percent. During this period there were 80 counties that reported employment gains, 44 of which outgained the state average of 2.8 percent. Among the counties to see employment growth, two enjoyed gains that exceeded 13 percent: Van Buren County reported employment growth of 15.3 percent and Pickett County experienced growth of 13.7 percent. By contrast there were 13 counties that faced employment contractions between June 2014 and June 2015. Job losses were the largest in Wayne County at -7.2 percent, followed by Lake County at -4.6 percent. Job growth was generally stronger in and around the state’s metropolitan areas. Tennessee’s civilian labor force, which includes employed people and unemployed people who are actively seeking work, increased by 2.3 percent in 2015. This was largely driven by a 3.1 percent increase in the number of employed people in Tennessee. The number of unemployed people also fell by 8.0 percent in 2015 and the labor force participation rate (i.e. the percentage of the adult population in the civilian labor force) grew The Tennessee Economy: Short-Term Outlook 2.2. | CHAPTER 2 The Current Economic Environment, continued Figure 2.1: Over Eighty Percent of Tennessee Counties Experienced Job Growth in the Second Quarter of 2015 (Year-Over-Year Growth in Total Covered Employment, June 2014- June 2015) Tennessee: 2.8% Employment Gain/Loss 0.0% or loss 0.1% to 2.7% 2.8% to 6.4% 6.5% or greater Source: U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, Quarterly Census of Employment and Wages. by 1.1 percent, indicating that more Tennesseans found jobs in 2015 than in 2014. This was the first time since 2010 that Tennessee’s labor force participation rate increased. However, at 57.7 percent, the low labor force participation rate is indicative of ongoing problems in the labor market, paralleling the situation for the national economy (see Chapter 1). Figure 2.2 shows that the labor force participation rates for both the state and the nation have been declining for the last decade, however this trend has been much more pronounced in Tennessee. These declines can be explained, at least in part, by an increase in retirees as the baby boom generation ages out of the workforce, but this number also likely encapsulates discouraged workers who have quit searching for a job. The more serious problem in Tennessee is likely tied to the fact that the state has a more poorly educated workforce than the nation as a whole, as well as a less healthy adult population. Both educational attainment and health status are correlated with labor market participation. It remains to be seen if the turnaround in the labor force participation rate in 2015 is part of a new trend. Tennessee’s unemployment rate averaged 5.9 percent in 2015, which is higher than the 5.3 percent unemployment rate for the nation. Between 2014 and 2015 Tennessee’s annual unemployment rate has fallen by 0.7 percentage points, while the U.S. unemployment rate dropped 0.9 percentage points. During the first quarter of 2015 Tennessee’s unemployment rate was pegged at 6.5 percent, but then dropped to 5.8 percent in the second quarter and 5.6 percent by the fourth quarter. This fourth quarter unemployment rate of 5.6 percent was Tennessee’s lowest unemployment rate since the fourth quarter of 2007. Figure 2.3 presents the seasonally-adjusted unemployment rates of all southeastern states for the month of December. Tennessee’s unemployment rate of 5.6 percent was slightly above the southeast average of 5.5 percent but was lower than 5 of the 12 southeastern states. The highest unemployment rate in the region was in Mississippi (6.4 percent), followed by West Virginia (6.3 percent); the lowest rate in the region was in Virginia (4.2 percent). Figure 2.4 presents non-seasonally adjusted county-level unemployment rates for November 2015. There were three counties that registered an unemployment rate above 9.0 percent – Hancock County (9.9 percent), Lauderdale County (9.4 percent) and Scott County (9.3 percent). While the unemployment rates in these counties were well above the non-seasonally adjusted state and national averages of 5.4 percent and 4.8 percent respectively, all three of these counties had reported unemployment rates above 10.5 percent one year prior so they are at least trending in the 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT | 21 CHAPTER 2 2.2. | The Tennessee Economy: Short-Term Outlook The Current Economic Environment, continued Figure 2.2: The Labor Force Participation Rate Remains Low in Tennessee and in the Nation 66.0 Labor Force Participation Rate (%) 64.0 62.0 60.0 58.0 56.0 54.0 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 TN U.S. Source: Bureau of Labor Statistics and CBER-UT. Figure 2.3: Tennessee’s Monthly Unemployment Rate Is Near the Middle of the Pack Among Southeast States (December 2015) 7.0% 6.4% 6.3% 6.2% 6.1% Unemployment Rate (%) 6.0% 5.0% 4.0% 3.0% 2.0% 0.0% Source: Bureau of Labor Statistics. | 5.3% 5.0% 5.0% 4.8% 4.2% 1.0% 22 5.6% 5.6% 5.5% 5.5% 5.5% 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT The Tennessee Economy: Short-Term Outlook 2.2. | CHAPTER 2 The Current Economic Environment, continued right direction. Conversely, there were 24 counties with unemployment rates below the state average of 5.4 percent. The lowest non-seasonally-adjusted unemployment rate in the state was in Williamson County (3.9 percent) followed by Rutherford County and Davidson County both at 4.2 percent. Each of these county’s rates were below the national average of 4.8 percent. Income and Taxable Sales Nominal personal income in Tennessee grew by 4.7 percent in 2015, which was slightly faster than the 4.5 percent growth rate registered for the nation. Personal income growth was driven largely by proprietors’ income which increased by 5.1 percent and wages and salary income which grew by 5.0 percent. Transfer payments were up 4.8 percent, and rent, interest, and dividend income increased by 4.1 percent. Nominal personal income per capita grew to $41,603 in 2015, representing a 3.6 percent increase over 2014. Figure 2.5 presents per capita personal income in current dollars for all southeastern states during the third quarter of 2015. At $42,215 per person, Tennessee ranked fourth among the 12 southeast states. Per capita personal income in Tennessee was slightly below the southeast average of $42,544 and well below the national average of $48,051. Among the southeastern states, Virginia had the highest per capita personal income ($52,498) and was the only southeastern state where per capita income was above the national average. Per capita personal income was lowest in Mississippi ($35,678) followed by West Virginia ($37,228). Figure 2.6 reports per capita personal income in current dollars across all Tennessee counties in 2014 (the most recent year for which data are available.) Williamson County continues to have the highest per capita personal income at $71,761 and eclipses per capita income in even the second highest county (Davidson County at $54,307). There were only four Tennessee counties with per capita income above the national average of $46,049 – Williamson, Davidson, Trousdale, and Fayette. Including the aforementioned, there were only four additional counties where per capita income was above the state average of $40,457 – Shelby, Hamilton, Knox, and Wilson. Conversely, per capita income was lowest in Bledsoe County at $21,432, which is less than 50 percent of the national average. Taxable sales continue to grow rapidly in Tennessee. Compared to a high base where taxable sales increased by 4.9 percent in 2014, taxable sales Figure 2.4: Eighty-Seven Percent of Tennessee Counties are Reporting Unemployment Rates Above the National Average (November 2015) Tennessee: 5.4% United States: 4.8% Non-Seasonally Adjusted Rate Less than 4.8% 4.8% to 5.3% 5.4% to 6.5% 6.6% to 7.7% 7.8% or greater Note: Not Seasonally Adjusted Source: U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics. 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT | 23 CHAPTER 2 2.2. | The Tennessee Economy: Short-Term Outlook The Current Economic Environment, continued Figure 2.5: Tennessee’s Per Capita Personal Income (in Current Dollars) Is Slightly Below the Southeast Average, 2015Q3 Virginia 52,498 United States 48,051 Florida 44,486 Louisiana 43,255 Southeast 42,544 Tennessee 42,215 North Carolina 41,114 Georgia 40,791 Arkansas 39,448 Kentucky 39,289 Alabama 39,115 South Carolina 38,265 West Virginia 37,228 Mississippi 35,678 $0 $10,000 $20,000 $30,000 $40,000 $50,000 $60,000 Source: Bureau of Economic Analysis. Figure 2.6: Per Capita Personal Income Is Lower Than the National Average in Most Tennessee Counties (2014 Per Capita Personal Income in Current Dollars) Tennessee: $40,457 United States: $46,049 Less than $27,000 $27,000 to $33,250 $33,251 to $40,450 $40,451 to $46,048 Greater than $46,048 Source: Bureau of Economic Analysis. 24 | 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT The Tennessee Economy: Short-Term Outlook 2.2. | CHAPTER 2 The Current Economic Environment, continued grew by an additional 6.2 percent in 2015. On a fiscal year basis, nominal taxable sales grew by 6.1 percent in FY 2015. For a second consecutive year taxable sales growth was strongest in the hotels and motels sector, expanding 12.1 percent in 2015. Light vehicle sales also showed very strong growth, as taxable sales from auto dealers grew by 11.3 percent in 2015. This is likely a continuation of consumer efforts to satisfy the pent-up demand for automobiles since the end of the Great Recession. Lower gasoline prices have also sparked resurgence in light truck sales. In the U.S., light truck sales reached 9.84 million in 2015, which was the first time in ten years that light truck sales surpassed 9.0 million units. Building permits (authorizing construction of new privately-owned housing units) in the U.S. and Tennessee continue to grow. For the U.S., building permits have now grown for five straight years (2010 through 2014,) while Tennessee has experienced three consecutive years of growth (2012 through 2014). However, permitting activity is still well below the pre-recession peaks for both Tennessee and the nation (see Figure 2.7). Figure 2.7: Building Permits Are Still Well Below the Pre-Recession Peaks of 2005 50,000 2,100,000 45,000 1,900,000 1,700,000 35,000 1,500,000 30,000 1,300,000 25,000 1,100,000 20,000 900,000 15,000 700,000 U.S. Total Permits Tennessee Total Permits 40,000 500,000 10,000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 TN U.S. Source: Census Bureau Building Permits Survey Data, U.S. Census Bureau. 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT | 25 CHAPTER 2 2.3. | The Tennessee Economy: Short-Term Outlook Fiscal Update Federal Government The federal budget deficit is expected to increase from $438.9 billion in 2015 to $500.5 billion in 2016 (see Figure 2.8). This will be the first time since 2011 that the deficit has grown. Despite this increase, the federal deficit is still less than half of its 2011 counterpart. The increased deficit is due to slightly higher government spending, largely attributable to increased Medicare and to a larger extent Medicaid spending. A bipartisan budget accord reached before the first of the year will lead to a larger deficit but reduce the likelihood of a crippling federal government shutdown. In 2015 the national debt was $18.5 trillion, which is projected to grow to $19.4 trillion in 2016. The amount of debt held by the public peaked at 75.2 percent of GDP in 2014, fell slightly to 74.4 percent of GDP in 2015, and is expected to rise to 74.8 percent in 2016. By comparison, this figure was only 54.4 percent in 2009 and closer to 35.0 percent in 2007. Growing national debt may hinder long-term economic growth by crowding out private sector investment and leaves policymakers with restricted options if faced with an unexpected economic downturn. State Finances Across the Nation States collected a total of $912.4 billion in tax revenues during fiscal year 2015 (July 2014 – June 2015), representing a 5.6 percent increase over FY 2014. All major tax revenue categories grew in FY 2015. Personal income tax revenues saw the largest growth, expanding by 9.0 percent over FY 2014. Corporate income tax revenues advanced 6.2 percent, sales tax revenues grew by 5.4 percent, and motor vehicle fuel tax revenues increased by 2.4 percent.1 State tax revenues grew in all regions of the nation in FY 2015. The Far West region experienced the strongest growth in FY 2015, with revenues expanding by 8.9 percent, followed by the Rocky Mountain region at 7.3 percent. Growth 1 Dadayan, Lucy & Boyd, Donald J. (November 2015). “Another Strong Tax Quarter for the States, But Less Promising Forecasts for Fiscal 2016.” The Nelson A. Rockefeller Institute of Government. Retrieved from http://www. rockinst.org/pdf/government_finance/state_revenue_report/2015-11-16SRR_101.pdf. Figure 2.8: The Federal Deficit Will Increase Slightly in 2016 4,500 4,000 3,500 3,000 2,500 2,000 1,500 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 Receipts *2016, 2017, and 2018 are projections Source: IHS Global Insights Inc. 26 | 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT 2011 2012 Deficit 2013 2014 Outlays 2015 2016* 2017* 2018* The Tennessee Economy: Short-Term Outlook 2.3. | CHAPTER 2 Fiscal Update, continued in the Far West region was primarily driven by large corporate and personal income tax gains in California which outweighed massive revenue losses in Alaska (73.4 percent decline in total tax revenues compared to FY2014) which relies heavily on oil and gas severance taxes. (Alaska is now discussing implementation of an income tax to help replace the revenue decline from oil and gas taxes.) Total tax revenue growth was the slowest in the Great Lakes region at 2.9 percent. Preliminary data on the third quarter of 2015 peg aggregate state tax revenue growth at 4.3 percent over the third quarter of 2014. This is well below the growth rates registered during the first half of 2015 (5.3 percent in the first quarter and 6.8 percent in the second quarter.) Personal income tax revenues grew by 6.1 percent in the third quarter and sales tax revenues grew by 3.4 percent, while corporate income tax revenues contracted 1.3 percent. The Southeastern States and Tennessee Total revenue collections in the southeastern states (Alabama, Arkansas, Florida, Georgia, Kentucky, Louisiana, Mississippi, North Carolina, South Carolina, Tennessee, Virginia and West Virginia) grew by 5.0 percent in FY 2015. This was slightly slower than the 5.6 percent rate of growth registered for all states. Tax revenue growth in the southeast was driven by an 8.3 percent increase in corporate income tax revenues and a 7.6 percent increase in personal income tax collections. Among the southeast states, Virginia led the way with an 8.5 percent increase in total tax revenues, followed by Mississippi at 7.6 percent. Louisiana saw the slowest rate of growth at 1.4 percent (see Figure 2.9). In Tennessee, total tax collections grew by 6.5 percent for the fiscal year.2 This was faster than both the national average of 5.6 percent and the southeast average of 5.0 percent. Among the 12 southeastern states, only Virginia, Mississippi, and Ibid. 2 Figure 2.9: Tennessee Has Fourth Highest Growth Rate in Total Tax Revenues Among Southeastern States, Fiscal Year 2015 (July 2014–June 2015) 9.0% 8.5% 8.0% 7.6% 7.0% 6.6% 6.5% 6.2% 6.0% 5.6% 5.0% 5.0% 5.0% 4.5% 4.0% 4.1% 3.1% 3.0% 2.8% 2.7% 2.0% 1.4% 1.0% Louisiana Florida West Virginia Arkansas South Carolina Kentucky Alabama Southeast United States Georgia Tennessee North Carolina Mississippi Virginia 0.0% Source: The Nelson A. Rockefeller Institute of Government. 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT | 27 CHAPTER 2 2.3. | The Tennessee Economy: Short-Term Outlook Fiscal Update, continued North Carolina enjoyed faster tax revenue growth than Tennessee As of December 2015, Tennessee Department of Revenue tax collections have totaled $5,113.5 million for the fiscal year-to-date (August 2015 – December 2015), representing a $377.4 million or 8.0 percent increase over last fiscal year-to-date. 2.4. Tennessee tax revenue growth has largely been driven by sales tax revenues which are up $222.9 million or 7.1 percent, and franchise and excise tax revenues (corporate income taxes) which have expanded by $146.3 million or 23.8 percent compared to last fiscal year-to-date. Short-Term Outlook The short-term economic outlook for Tennessee calls for solid growth over the next three years. Output and personal income should continue to post healthy gains. Nonfarm employment growth in Tennessee will mimic national employment growth throughout the short-term forecast horizon, while state manufacturing employment will see modest gains. Tennessee’s unemployment rate will continue to trend downwards but remain above the national unemployment rate throughout the short-term forecast window. Table 2.1 provides a summary of the shortterm economic outlook for Tennessee and the nation. Nonfarm employment in Tennessee is projected to increase by 1.7 percent in 2016 and 1.3 percent in 2017. Nonfarm jobs are expected to grow at a similar pace for the nation. Most broad sectors of the Tennessee economy are projected to see employment growth in 2016 and 2017. In 2016, nonfarm job growth will be driven by a 2.8 percent expansion in the professional and business services sector and a 2.6 percent increase in the natural resources, mining, and construction sector’s workforce. Both the information and other services sectors will experience job losses in 2016. The information sector will face a 2.0 percent employment contraction, and employment in the other services sector will fall by 1.1 percent. Manufacturing employment growth in Tennessee is expected to taper off in 2016. After increasing by 1.9 percent in 2015, manufacturing jobs will advance by 0.7 percent in both 2016 and 2017. As this report goes to press, there are signs of a deepening slowdown in the nation’s manufacturing sector that could ripple across the state. It is too early to tell whether this recent slowdown is a sign of a fundamental shift in prospects for the manufacturing sector or simply a short-term shock. Figure 2.10 shows that while manufacturing employment has grown since the Great Recession, employments levels are still well below those prior to the recession. Simultaneously, manufacturing output, as shown in Figure 2.11, has been trending upwards indicating that manufacturing productivity (output per worker) is on the rise. The number of manufacturing jobs in Tennessee will likely remain below pre-recession levels and revert to contraction before the end of the decade. Employment in durable goods manufacturing is projected to grow by 1.5 percent in both 2016 and 2017. Within durable goods manufacturing, the transportation equipment sector will see the strongest employment gains, growing by 3.7 percent in 2016 and in 2017. Wood products manufacturing will also see job gains of 1.9 percent in 2016 and 1.6 percent in 2017. Conversely, employment in nonmetallic minerals manufacturing will contract in both 2016 and 2017, and computers and electronics, and miscellaneous durable goods manufacturing will face job losses in 2017. Nondurable goods manufacturing will face job losses of 0.7 percent in 2016 and 0.8 percent in 2017. Among the broad sectors of nondurable goods manufacturing only food manufacturing and plastics and rubber manufacturing will avoid job losses over the next two years while the remaining continued on page 31 28 | 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT | The Tennessee Economy: Short-Term Outlook 2.4. CHAPTER 2 Short-Term Outlook, continued Table 2.1: Selected U.S. and Tennessee Economic Indicators, Seasonally Adjusted Table 2.1: Selected U.S. and Tennessee Economic Indicators, Seasonally Adjusted History 2015:3 2015:4 Forecast Data 2016:1 2016:2 2016:3 2016:4 2017:1 Annual 2017:2 2017:3 2017:4 2018:1 2014 2015 2016 2017 US GDP (Bil2009$) SAAR……………………………………………........................... 16414.0 16462.5 16586.4 16708.4 16844.5 16983.1 17096.3 17225.3 17338.9 17437.6 17567.0 15961.7 16346.8 16780.6 17274.5 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR……………………………………………………….................. 1.98 1.19 3.04 2.98 3.30 3.33 2.69 3.05 2.66 2.30 3.00 2.43 2.41 2.65 2.94 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………………………………… 2.15 1.93 2.53 2.29 2.62 3.16 3.07 3.09 2.94 2.68 2.75 2.43 2.41 2.65 2.94 US GDP (Bil$) SAAR……………………………………………....................................... 18060.2 18181.2 18391.4 18614.9 18860.4 19106.9 19318.4 19560.9 19794.5 20000.1 20259.9 17348.1 17951.1 18743.4 19668.4 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR……………………………………………………….................. 3.31 2.71 4.70 4.95 5.38 5.33 4.50 5.12 4.86 4.22 5.30 4.11 3.48 4.41 4.94 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………………………………… 3.07 3.21 4.20 3.91 4.43 5.09 5.04 5.08 4.95 4.67 4.87 4.11 3.48 4.41 4.94 TN PERSONAL INCOME (MIL2009$) SAAR…….................................. 254215 257680 260384 262090 263075 264591 266717 268147 269586 271585 273120 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR……………………………………………………….................. 2.55 5.56 4.26 2.65 1.51 2.33 3.25 2.16 2.16 3.00 2.28 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………………………………… 4.58 4.56 4.40 3.75 3.48 2.68 2.43 2.31 2.48 2.64 2.40 US PERSONAL INCOME (BIL2009$) SAAR…………............................. 14095 14224 14360 14435 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR……………………………………………………….................. 3.76 3.73 3.88 2.10 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………………………………… 4.41 3.98 3.61 3.36 14500 1.80 2.87 14604 2.90 2.67 14759 4.33 2.78 14879 3.28 3.07 14976 2.65 3.29 15100 3.35 3.40 15230 3.49 3.19 TN PERSONAL INCOME (MIL$) SAAR…………………….......................... 278958 282614 285656 288832 292132 295513 298903 302294 305795 309386 312604 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR……………………………………………………….................. 3.84 5.35 4.37 4.52 4.65 4.71 4.67 4.62 4.71 4.78 4.22 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………………………………… 4.85 4.89 5.27 4.52 4.72 4.56 4.64 4.66 4.68 4.69 4.58 242848 253482 262535 269009 2.28 4.38 3.57 2.47 2.28 4.38 3.57 2.47 13468 2.98 2.98 14036 4.22 4.22 14475 3.12 3.12 14929 3.14 3.14 264965 277316 290533 304095 3.74 4.66 4.77 4.67 3.74 4.66 4.77 4.67 US PERSONAL INCOME (BIL$) SAAR…………………….......................... 15468 15614 15750 15894 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR……………………………………………………….................. 5.09 3.84 3.52 3.70 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………………………………… 4.69 4.40 4.44 4.04 16073 4.59 3.91 16276 5.14 4.24 16502 5.67 4.77 16722 5.45 5.21 16933 5.14 5.35 17145 5.10 5.34 17390 5.84 5.38 14694 4.45 4.45 15360 4.53 4.53 15998 4.16 4.16 16825 5.17 5.17 TN NONFARM JOBS (THOUS)…………………………………….......................... 2874.9 2900.1 2906.8 2914.1 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR……………………………………………………….................. 1.97 3.57 0.92 1.01 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………………………………… 1.79 2.00 2.10 1.85 2921.4 1.01 1.62 2929.6 1.13 1.02 2940.2 1.45 1.15 2950.6 1.42 1.25 2961.5 1.49 1.37 2972.7 1.53 1.47 2982.4 1.30 1.43 2816.1 2.08 2.08 2870.7 1.94 1.94 2918.0 1.65 1.65 2956.2 1.31 1.31 US NONFARM JOBS (MIL)…………………………………………….......................... 142.2 142.9 143.6 144.1 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR……………………………………………………….................. 1.77 1.86 1.87 1.45 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………………………………… 2.05 1.90 1.81 1.74 144.6 1.39 1.64 145.1 1.32 1.51 145.6 1.42 1.39 145.9 1.01 1.28 146.4 1.20 1.24 146.8 1.28 1.23 147.2 1.14 1.16 139.0 1.93 1.93 141.9 2.10 2.10 144.3 1.67 1.67 146.2 1.29 1.29 TN MFG JOBS (THOUS)……………………………………………………................... 331.5 332.7 333.0 333.4 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR……………………………………………………….................. 1.00 1.53 0.37 0.41 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………………………………… 1.74 1.17 0.60 0.78 334.0 0.71 0.75 334.7 0.85 0.58 335.3 0.73 0.67 335.8 0.68 0.74 336.4 0.62 0.72 337.0 0.80 0.71 337.6 0.70 0.70 325.2 2.13 2.13 331.5 1.93 1.93 333.7 0.68 0.68 336.1 0.71 0.71 US MFG JOBS (MIL)……………………………………………………............................. 12.3 12.3 12.3 12.3 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR……………………………………………………….................. -0.05 -0.41 -0.51 -0.40 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………………………………… 1.04 0.35 -0.17 -0.34 12.3 0.10 -0.31 12.4 1.94 0.28 12.4 1.36 0.74 12.4 -0.02 0.84 12.4 0.80 1.02 12.5 1.11 0.81 12.5 0.71 0.65 12.2 1.41 1.41 12.3 1.12 1.12 12.3 -0.14 -0.14 12.4 0.85 0.85 TN UNEMPLOYMENT RATE (%)……………………………............................. 5.7 5.6 5.6 5.6 5.5 5.5 5.5 5.4 5.4 5.4 5.4 6.6 5.9 5.5 5.4 US UNEMPLOYMENT RATE (%)………………………………........................... 5.2 5.0 5.0 4.9 4.9 4.9 4.9 4.9 4.9 4.9 4.9 6.2 5.3 4.9 4.9 CHAINED PRICE INDEX, GDP (2009=100.0)……………...........................………..........………..........……….......... 110.0 110.4 110.9 111.4 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR……………………………………………………….................. 1.32 1.44 1.61 1.92 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………………………………… 0.91 1.25 1.62 1.57 112.0 2.02 1.75 112.5 1.93 1.87 113.0 1.76 1.91 113.6 2.00 1.93 114.2 2.14 1.96 114.7 1.88 1.95 115.3 2.23 2.06 108.7 1.64 1.64 109.8 1.04 1.04 111.7 1.70 1.70 113.9 1.94 1.94 US PERS CONSUMP DEFL (2009=100.0)…………….................................. 109.7 109.8 109.7 110.1 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR……………………………………………………….................. 1.28 0.11 -0.34 1.57 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………………………………… 0.27 0.41 0.81 0.65 110.9 2.75 1.01 111.5 2.18 1.53 111.8 1.28 1.94 112.4 2.10 2.08 113.1 2.43 2.00 113.5 1.69 1.87 114.2 2.28 2.12 109.1 1.43 1.43 109.4 0.29 0.29 110.5 1.00 1.00 112.7 1.97 1.97 CONSUMER PRICE INDEX, ALL-URBAN (82-84=1.000)……………………………......................................... 2.379 2.381 2.374 2.386 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR……………………………………………………….................. 1.58 0.33 -1.09 1.95 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………………………………… 0.14 0.43 0.94 0.68 2.409 4.03 1.28 2.427 2.94 1.94 2.435 1.44 2.58 2.452 2.69 2.77 2.471 3.24 2.57 2.483 1.98 2.33 2.501 2.95 2.71 2.367 1.61 1.61 2.370 0.13 0.13 2.399 1.21 1.21 2.460 2.56 2.56 3.8 4.0 4.3 4.5 4.8 5.0 5.3 5.5 3.3 3.3 3.9 4.9 FEDERAL FUNDS RATE (% per annum)…………………………….................... 0.137 0.152 0.483 0.787 BANK PRIME INTEREST RATE (%)………………………………...................... 3.3 3.3 3.5 1.037 1.290 1.533 1.787 2.037 2.290 2.533 0.089 0.131 0.899 1.912 4.4 4.5 4.6 4.7 4.7 4.8 4.9 5.0 4.2 3.9 4.4 4.7 TN TAXABLE SALES (MIL2009$)………………………………………................. 26228 26353 26392 26580 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR……………………………………………………….................. 9.46 1.91 0.59 2.88 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………………………………… 7.21 5.48 7.62 3.66 26635 0.83 1.55 26708 1.10 1.35 26795 1.31 1.53 26878 1.24 1.12 26954 1.14 1.20 27127 2.59 1.57 27230 1.52 1.62 97036 102746 106315 107755 3.41 5.88 3.47 1.35 3.41 5.88 3.47 1.35 TN TAXABLE SALES (MIL$)……………………………………………....................... 28781 28903 28953 29292 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR……………………………………………………….................. 10.84 1.70 0.70 4.76 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………………………………… 7.49 5.82 8.52 4.43 29577 3.95 2.77 29829 3.45 3.20 30028 2.70 3.71 30301 3.67 3.44 30575 3.67 3.37 30903 4.37 3.60 31167 3.45 3.79 105877 112414 117652 121807 4.89 6.17 4.66 3.53 4.89 6.17 4.66 3.53 TN AVG ANNUAL WAGE, NONFARM (2009$)…………….......................………..............………..............……….............. 43269 43666 43973 44087 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR……………………………………………………….................. -0.11 3.72 2.85 1.04 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………………………………… 3.46 3.10 3.64 1.86 44059 -0.26 1.82 44111 0.48 1.02 44274 1.48 0.68 44313 0.35 0.51 44347 0.30 0.65 44461 1.04 0.79 44544 0.75 0.61 41961 1.18 1.18 43161 2.86 2.86 44058 2.08 2.08 44349 0.66 0.66 TN AVG ANNUAL WAGE, NONFARM ($)………………............................. 47481 47891 48241 48586 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR……………………………………………………….................. 1.14 3.50 2.96 2.89 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………………………………… 3.73 3.44 4.51 2.62 48925 2.82 3.04 49266 2.82 2.87 49616 2.87 2.85 49956 2.77 2.82 50303 2.81 2.82 50649 2.78 2.81 50984 2.67 2.76 45782 2.62 2.62 47219 3.14 3.14 48755 3.25 3.25 50131 2.82 2.82 30-YEAR FIXED MORTGAGE RATE (%)………………………………............ 4.0 3.9 4.2 Center for Business and Economic Research, University of Tennessee Tennessee Econometric Model 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT | 29 CHAPTER 2 2.4. | The Tennessee Economy: Short-Term Outlook Short-Term Outlook, continued Figure 2.10: Despite Recent Growth, U.S. and Tennessee Manufacturing Employment Are Well Below Pre-Recession Levels From 2008 15.0 450.0 14.0 400.0 13.0 350.0 12.0 300.0 11.0 250.0 10.0 TN U.S. Source: Bureau of Economic Analysis and CBER-UT. Figure 2.11: U.S. and Tennessee Manufacturing Output See Positive Growth 2,000,000 50,000 45,000 1,800,000 1,700,000 40,000 1,600,000 1,500,000 35,000 1,400,000 1,300,000 30,000 1,200,000 1,100,000 25,000 Source: Bureau of Economic Analysis. 30 | 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT 1,000,000 TN U.S. U.S. Output (millions of 2009 dollars) TN Output (millions of 2009 dollars) 1,900,000 The Tennessee Economy: Short-Term Outlook 2.4. | CHAPTER 2 Short-Term Outlook, continued six broad sectors will experience contractions. Employment in plastics and rubber manufacturing will increase by 1.6 percent in 2016 and 1.5 percent in 2017, while food manufacturing employment will grow by 0.1 percent in both 2016 and 2017. By contrast, miscellaneous nondurable goods manufacturing will face the steepest job cuts, shrinking by 3.7 percent in 2016 and 5.6 percent in 2017. The textile mills and textile products manufacturing sector will also face significant jobs losses over the next two years, shrinking by 4.1 percent in 2016 and 5.0 percent in 2017. Tennessee’s unemployment rate is projected to remain at 5.6 percent for the first two quarter of 2016 and then fall to 5.5 percent during the second half of the year. In 2017, the state unemployment rate will drift slightly downward and is projected to average 5.4 percent for the year. The national unemployment rate will also continue its downward trend and as a result the state unemployment rate will remain above the national rate throughout the short-term forecast horizon (see Figure 2.12). In 2016, Tennessee’s civilian labor force will effectively remain unchanged, falling by a mere 0.1 percent. This slight drop in the civilian labor force will occur because of a 6.2 percent reduction in the number of unemployment people combined with a relatively small 0.3 percentage increase in employed people. As a result there will be roughly 3,000 fewer Tennesseans in the labor force in 2016 than there were in 2015. In 2017, the civilian labor force will grow by 0.6 percent as the number of unemployed people falls by 1.7 percent and the number of employed people grows by 0.8 percent. However, Tennessee’s labor force participation rate is projected to fall over the next two years, declining from 57.7 percent in 2015 to 57.0 percent in 2016 and 56.7 percent in 2017. By comparison, the national labor force participation rate is expected to hover between 61.6 percent and 61.8 percent over the next two years. Figure 2.12: Tennessee’s Unemployment Rate Is Projected to Stay Above the National Rate Through 2018 12 10 Rate (%) 8 6 4 2 0 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 TN U.S. Source: Bureau of Labor Statistics, IHS Global Insights Inc., and CBER-UT. 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT | 31 CHAPTER 2 2.4. | The Tennessee Economy: Short-Term Outlook Short-Term Outlook, continued Nominal personal income in Tennessee is forecasted to grow by 4.8 percent in 2016 followed by 4.7 percent growth in 2017. All components of personal income in Tennessee will enjoy healthy growth over the next two years. In 2016 wage and salary income will increase by the largest amount, expanding by 5.1 percent, followed by 4.3 percent growth in 2017. Proprietors’ income will increase by 5.0 percent in 2016 and 4.8 percent in 2017, while rent, interest, and dividend income will grow by 4.4 percent in 2016 and 5.2 percent in 2017. Transfer payments are also projected to increase by 3.7 percent in 2016 and 4.1 percent in 2017. Per capita personal income will grow by 3.7 percent in 2016 and 3.6 percent in 2017. By 2017, per capita income in Tennessee will equal $44,695, though this will equate to only 86.9 percent of the national average. This has become a growing concern as per capita personal income in Tennessee was equal to 90.7 percent of the national average in 2004 but has fallen relative to the U.S. average ever since (see Figure 2.13). The state’s education initiatives, including Tennessee Promise and the Drive to 55 should ultimately help turn this trend around. On a fiscal year basis, nominal personal income is projected to grow by 4.9 percent in FY 2016 and 4.7 percent in FY 2017. In Tennessee, nominal taxable sales are expected to increase by 4.7 percent in 2016 and 3.5 percent in 2017. All categories of taxable sales will see growth over the next two years. In 2016, taxable sales on miscellaneous durable and nondurable goods, auto dealer sales, other retail and service sales, and purchases from manufacturers will all increase by more than 5.0 percent. Taxable sales at hotels and motels will also see robust growth of 4.6 percent. In 2017, hotels and motels will continue to enjoy strong growth as taxable sales are projected to grow by an additional 6.2 percent. On a fiscal year basis, nominal taxable sales will rise by 6.5 percent in FY 2016 and 3.3 percent in FY 2017. Figure 2.13: Per Capita Personal Income in Tennessee Has Fallen Relative to the National Average TN Per Capita Income Relative to U.S. Average (%) 92.0 91.0 90.0 89.0 88.0 87.0 86.0 85.0 84.0 Source: Bureau of Economic Analysis, IHS Global Insights Inc., CBER-UT. 32 | 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT The Tennessee Economy: Short-Term Outlook 2.4. • • • • 2.5. | CHAPTER 2 Tennessee Forecast at a Glance In Tennessee, inflation-adjusted gross domestic product is projected to increase by 2.3 percent in 2016 and 2.2 percent in 2017, slightly below the 2.4 percent growth rate for 2015. Nonfarm jobs will grow by 1.9 percent in 2016 and 1.7 percent in 2017, as employment in the professional and business services, leisure and hospitality, and natural resources, mining, and construction sectors see healthy employment gains. Manufacturing employment will expand by 0.7 percent in 2016 and 2017. The state unemployment rate is projected to fall to 5.5 percent in 2016 and 5.4 percent in 2017. This would mark the first time since 2007 that the annual unemployment rate dropped below 6.0 percent. • • • Nominal personal income will grow by 4.8 percent in 2016 and 4.7 percent in 2017. Nominal taxable sales will expand 4.7 percent in 2016 and 3.5 percent in 2017. On a fiscal year basis, nominal personal income will increase by 4.9 percent in FY 2016 and 4.7 percent in FY 2017. Nominal taxable sales will grow 6.5 percent in FY 2016 and 3.3 percent in FY 2017. Tennessee’s Agricultural and Forest Industries and Rural Economy Introduction The impacts on Tennessee’s economy from agriculture and forestry are far ranging, from the farm and forest to food, fiber, and forest products manufacturing. The state’s diverse topography for producing food, fiber, and forestry products is reflected in its agri-forestry industrial complex. This section of the report focuses on economic indicators for three main areas related to the agri-forestry industrial complex1: a) primary agriculture and forestry, which includes farming and first-stage forestry; b) secondary agriculture and forestry, which includes manufacturing and processing facilities; and c) the rural communities that are so important to sustaining agri-forestry within the state. Indicators of progress toward recommendations made in the The Governor’s Rural Challenge are also discussed. 1 Defined as the primary industries typically associated with agriculture and forest operations such as growing crops, the breeding and feeding of livestock, and the management and logging of trees. Also included in the industrial complex were input supplying industries and value-added subsectors, which included food and beverage manufacturing, apparel and textiles, and forestry products manufacturing. a. Agriculture and Primary Forestry a.1. Agricultural Land Use and Farm Size In 2014, 10.9 million acres in Tennessee were designated as farming operations (USDA/NASS 2015a), constituting over 40 percent of the state’s nearly 27 million acres of land area. Of the land in farms, 5.3 million acres were in cropland and 2.9 million acres were in pasture (USDA/NASS 2012). Tennessee’s farming industry is characterized by two types of farming operations: larger farms that rely primarily on farm income, and small farms, many of which are operated by part-time farmers. Of Tennessee’s 67,300 farming operations, average farm size in 2014 was 162 acres, which is smaller than the average 218 acres of its neighboring states (USDA/NASS 2015a). Tennessee ranks only second to Kentucky among its neighbors in number of farms. a.2. Tennessee’s Crops and Livestock The 2014 value of cash farm receipts from crops and livestock was over $4.2 billion, with $1.8 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT | 33 CHAPTER 2 | The Tennessee Economy: Short-Term Outlook 2.5. Tennessee’s Agricultural and Forest Industries and Rural Economy, continued billion from animals and $2.4 billion from crops U.S. markets for these products. U.S. soybean (Table 2.2). Overall, Tennessee ranks 31st in the prices peaked in 2012/2013 at $14.40/bushel. U.S. in cash farm receipts. The top ten Tennessee strengthening of domestic crushwas and export smallest in half a century (USDA/NASS 2015b; USDA/ERS The 2015e). The recent decline in inventory agricultural products inconsecutive value of cash farmyears receipts markets helped increase the disappearance largely driven by three drought in the Southern Plains and the drought of 2012 that of negatively and oilseed production. Cattlesoybeans prices set in a record in 2014. However, latter are listed in impacted Table 2.2,grain along with the state’s ranking 2014/15 compared withthe 2013/2014 half of 2015 saw Tennessee cattle prices decline percent. The value of U.S. Tennessee broiler rose steadily for each product. In 2014, the largest value of 35 to 40(USDA/ERS 2014). cattle prices production rose from million in 2005 to over $598 million by 2014 (USDA/NASS 2015d). broiler cash farm receipts was$431 derived from soybeans, since 2010, with record retail beef U.S. prices in 2014. prices rose from 2010 through 2014. While U.S. broiler production held steady, broiler exports grew followed by cattle and calves. These were followed The U.S. cattle herd inventory declined steadily through 2014 (USDA/ERS 2015e). In 2014 the world’s largest poultry breeder discovered a fertility in magnitude by broilers, corn, cotton, wheat, dairy, between 2001 and 2014, and was 88.5 million in problem in a key rooster breed. The fertility issue resulted in fewer chicks hatching, which reduced hay, tobacco,inand vegetables and melons. The top poultry 2014, prices, the smallest halfbeen a century (USDA/NASS production 2014. Poultry exports, and consequently in 2015inhave negatively ten commodities in the state accounted for about 2015b; USDA/ERS The recent decline in impacted by Highly Pathogenic Avian Influenza (HPAI). The broiler industry was2015e). not significantly 86.7 percent of 2014 cash farm receipts. Tennessee inventory was largely driven by three consecutive impacted by HPAI, but its occurrence did result in a decline in exports. U.S. corn prices began declining, ranks the than top ten states in of cash farm droughtin years in the(USDA/ERS Southern 2015d). Plains and the fromin more $6/bushel in value 2013/2014 to less than $4/bushel 2014/2015 Higher production of corn relative to demands for fuel and feed uses and exports pushed prices downward receipts from tobacco and cotton. drought of 2012 that negatively impacted grain during period. production in 2013/2014 from 2012/2013 Table this 2.2 time shows cash U.S. farmcotton receipts over thewas downand oilseed production. Cattle(USDA/NASS prices set a record 2015c); however, total disappearance decreased sharply in that time period, primarily past five years. Cash farm receipts from soybeans, in 2014. However, the latterdue halftoofdecreased 2015 saw exports. Between 2013/2014 and 2014/2015, average U.S. cotton farm price declined from 82.5 cents Tennessee cattle prices decline 35 to 40 percent. cattle and calves, corn, wheat, and hay each per pound to 64.6 cents per pound (USDA/ERS 2015a). exhibited over 10 percent average annual growth The value of Tennessee broiler production rose from Exports 2010 toof2014. Only cotton cash farm $431 million in 2005 to with over the $598 million agricultural products from Tennessee werefrom valued at $1.7 billion in 2014, receipts experienced an overall decline during by 2014 (USDA/NASS 2015d). U.S. broiler prices majority of this coming from crops. Over 27 percent of the 2014 export value came from soybeans, followed by cotton at 8.4 percent, wheat at just under 8 percent, soybean meal at 6.3 percent, and corn this time period. The market for Tennessee crops rose from 2010 through 2014. While U.S. broiler at 5.4 percent. In 2014, major export destinations by product included soybeans – China, Mexico, and livestock is strongly impacted by trends in production held steady, broiler exports grew Indonesia, Japan, and Taiwan; cotton – China, Turkey, Mexico, Vietnam, Indonesia; wheat-Japan, Mexico, Brazil, Nigeria, and the Philippines; and corn – Japan, Mexico, South Korea, Columbia, and Egypt (USDA/FAS 2015). Table 2.2: Tennessee Cash Farm Receipts and Share of Commodity Exports, 2010–2014 Table 1. Tennessee Cash Farm Receipts and Share of Commodity Exports, 2010-2014 All Commodities Crops Animals & Animal Products Top 10 in 2014 Soybeans Cattle & Calves Broilers Corn Cotton Wheat Dairy Prod, Milk Hay Tobacco Vegetables & Melons a a 2010 3,084 1,746 1,337 Value of Cash Receipts (Million $) 2011 2012 3,290 3,743 1,881 2,225 1,409 1,518 499 545 476 272 332 52 151 82 99 69 471 588 454 418 311 104 175 91 96 48 575 746 436 532 357 147 157 102 111 41 Ranking and shares of exports are for vegetables only. Ranking and shares of exports are forand vegetables only. 2015f) (Sources: USDA/ERS 2015c USDA/ERS Sources: USDA/ERS 2015c and USDA/ERS 2015f. a 2 34 | 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT Avg. Annual Growth Ranking in U.S. (2010-2014) 2014 Share of Commodity Exports 2014 2013 4,091 2,541 1,550 2014 4,237 2,418 1,820 8.3% 8.8% 8.2% 31 26 33 85.3% 14.7% 815 626 576 573 284 227 163 119 111 54 834 825 598 454 239 215 192 126 115 76 15.2% 12.6% 6.9% 17.0% -7.0% 47.2% 6.8% 11.5% 4.1% 6.9% 15 23 16 20 10 18 30 n/a 3 24 27.2% 4.20% 4.3% 5.4% 8.4% 8.0% 1.6% n/a 4.2% 0.8% The Tennessee Economy: Short-Term Outlook | CHAPTER 2 2.5. Tennessee’s Agricultural and Forest Industries and Rural Economy, continued through 2014 (USDA/ERS 2015e). In 2014 the world’s largest poultry breeder discovered a fertility problem in a key rooster breed. The fertility issue resulted in fewer chicks hatching, which reduced production in 2014. Poultry exports, and consequently poultry prices, in 2015 have been negatively impacted by Highly Pathogenic Avian Influenza (HPAI). The broiler industry was not significantly impacted by HPAI, but its occurrence did result in a decline in exports. U.S. corn prices began declining, from more than $6/bushel in 2013/2014 to less than $4/bushel in 2014/2015 (USDA/ERS 2015d). Higher production of corn relative to demands for fuel and feed uses and exports pushed prices downward during this time period. U.S. cotton production was down in 2013/2014 from 2012/2013 (USDA/ NASS 2015c); however, total disappearance decreased sharply in that time period, primarily due to decreased exports. Between 2013/2014 and 2014/2015, average U.S. cotton farm price declined from 82.5 cents per pound to 64.6 cents per pound (USDA/ERS 2015a). Exports of agricultural products from Tennessee were valued at $1.7 billion in 2014, with the majority of this coming from crops. Over 27 percent of the 2014 export value came from soybeans, followed by cotton at 8.4 percent, wheat at just under 8 percent, soybean meal at 6.3 percent, and corn at 5.4 percent. In 2014, major export destinations by product included soybeans – China, Mexico, Indonesia, Japan, and Taiwan; cotton – China, Turkey, Mexico, Vietnam, Indonesia; wheat-Japan, Mexico, Brazil, Nigeria, and the Philippines; and corn – Japan, Mexico, South Korea, Columbia, and Egypt (USDA/FAS 2015). a.3. Commodity Market Trends and Outlook, Infrastructure, Agritourism and Direct Marketing Livestock, Poultry, and Dairy Outlook Meat protein and dairy product prices will be driven by export markets. Many industry experts attribute most of the 2015 declines in exports to the significant increase in the dollar’s value relative to other currencies. Meat proteins and dairy products will continue to find difficulty being absorbed in the world market the first half of 2016. Beef production will continue to increase, resulting in lower beef and cattle prices over the next several years. The pork industry will likely have strong 2016 production numbers, unless the Porcine Epidemic Diarrhea (PED) becomes an issue. Poultry production is likely to continue increasing, as well. Increased production will inherently result in increased exports, but prices for the three major meat proteins will likely decline from 2015 levels. U.S. dairy production will continue to increase in the first half of 2016, resulting in lower prices for the year. The export market and ability to move nonfat dry milk and whey will be critical factors for dairy markets in 2016. Incentives provided to producers through the Tennessee Agricultural Enhancement Program (TAEP) are targeted at increasing the quality and number of beef heifers statewide. Bringing quality bred heifers into production has represented a significant challenge to profitability of the state’s beef cattle industry. A private-public partnership among the Tennessee Department of Agriculture, the University of Tennessee Institute of Agriculture and the Tennessee Farmer’s Cooperative seeks to develop best management practices for bred heifers and to encourage their adoption by producers. Crops Outlook. In 2015, two important issues dominated Tennessee row-crop management and marketing. The Agricultural Act of 2014 (the Farm Bill) provided a new direction for domestic farm policy. For Title I (“Commodities”), Direct Payments, Counter-Cyclical Payments, and Average Crop Revenue Election (ACRE) programs were repealed and replaced with two new programs: Agricultural Risk Coverage (ARC) and Price Loss Coverage (PLC). Of the 2.06[2] million base 2 The Agricultural Act of 2014 converted 744,000 cotton base acres in Tennessee, into generic base acres. Generic base acres are not included in this estimate as a unique set of commodity program payment rules apply to generic base acres. Additionally, it should be noted that approximately 20 percent of planted acres in Tennessee have no base and as such do not qualify for commodity program payments. 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT | 35 CHAPTER 2 | The Tennessee Economy: Short-Term Outlook 2.5. Tennessee’s Agricultural and Forest Industries and Rural Economy, continued acres of cropland in Tennessee, 94 percent were enrolled in ARC and 6 percent in PLC (USDA/ FSA 2015a). Additionally, the Farm Bill increased emphasis on Title II (“Conservation”) and Title XI (“Crop Insurance”). The second major issue faced by row-crop producers in Tennessee was the continued decline in commodity prices. From their price peaks in 2012, corn, wheat, and soybean prices dropped 52 percent, 49 percent, and 36 percent, respectively, and cotton prices fell well below the cost of production resulting in planted acreage decreasing to an all-time low of 155,000 acres in 2015 (USDA/ERS 2015c). A bright spot for row-crop prices this spring was grain sorghum (milo). As a result of beneficial price incentives in the spring, Tennessee producers increased grain sorghum acreage from 33,000 in 2014 to over 120,000 acres in 2015 (USDA/FSA 2015b). Looking toward 2016, a strong U.S. dollar and record global supplies will continue to provide negative price implications for Tennessee row-crop producers. Barring a major production disruption at home or abroad, further reductions in prices should be anticipated. For the 2016 crop, current Tennessee farm-gate price estimates are: wheat – $4.30-$5.30; corn – $3.15-$4.20; grain sorghum – $3.00-$4.10; soybeans – $8.10-$9.60; and cotton – $0.62-$0.74. Infrastructure. An indicator of growth in onfarm infrastructure is grain storage capacity. In 2012, Tennessee’s on-farm grain storage capacity was 79.3 million bushels, while in 2007, it was 65.1 million bushels (USDA/NASS 2012). In 2013, a total of 17 grain and oilseed milling firms generated payroll of $132.7 million in Tennessee. Among the 17 firms, two were wet corn milling and two were soybean and other oilseed processing. In addition, six cotton ginning companies in Tennessee paid nearly $2 million in payroll. The demand for trucking in grain transportation has continuously increased over the past decade, while the modal share of rail for total grain shipment dropped to less than 30 percent nationwide in 2011. This trend implies 36 | 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT higher demand on local roads and bridges for the agricultural sector in Tennessee. In 2014, 181 projects in 62 counties were been approved by the legislature. An additional 765 projects identified by Tennessee Department of Transportation to address growth and safety in the infrastructure system were proposed in 2015. In addition, The American Society of Civil Engineering recommended expansion of the short-line freight service in rural areas. Since 2005, the TAEP has invested more than $123.4 million in 41,646 farm projects ranging from genetics and livestock equipment to commodity storage and specialty crops. For each dollar of TAEP investment, an estimated additional $3.89 is generated in local economic activity (Menard, Jensen, and English 2011). Two program areas have helped build on-farm investment for hay and grain storage. Cumulative (FY06 – FY15) TAEP payments for hay storage structures totaled $39.2 million while producer investments totaled an additional $77.3 million. For grain storage, cumulative TAEP payments totaled $10.5 million, while farmer investment was $33.8 million. Agritourism. Tennessee is uniquely positioned for growth in agritourism, building upon a welldeveloped tourism industry within the state and farming operations being located near or within tourism areas. The state had 616 agritourism operations with sales totaling over $11.9 million Agriculture (USDA/NASS 2012). Agritourism visitors were estimated to spend $34.4 million statewide in 2012, and with multiplier effects, the economic impacts from these expenditures were estimated at over $54.2 (Jensen, Bruch, Menard, and English 2013). The visitor expenditure impacts represent only a portion of the economic impacts resulting from these farms since many of the operators also rely on other sources of farm income. Provisions passed in 2014 to amend the “Right to Farm Act” have expanded the definition of agriculture to include certain entertainment activities. The Tennessee Economy: Short-Term Outlook | CHAPTER 2 2.5. Tennessee’s Agricultural and Forest Industries and Rural Economy, continued The net farm income ratio (net farm income/ Direct Marketing. The “local foods” movement, value of production) during 2010 to 2014 suggests along with technical and financial assistance about 15 to 30 percent efficiency in converting provided by USDA, TDA, UTIA, and other production to net farm income.[3] However, agencies, have helped increase direct marketing the interest expense ratios for the farming sector by farmers. An important component of direct reflect a low debt burden and interest payment marketing is sales through farmers markets. level relative to production. Times interest earned is Tennessee has seen a rapid expansion in the another measure of ability to cover debt payments, number of farmers markets with the number specifically interest payments. For all years, the rising from 99 to 119 venues between 2013 and values are greater than one, implying sufficient cash 2014 (USDA/AMS 2016). Current Agricultural to meet interest payments, and in 2014 the value a.4 Financial Indicators for Tennessee Farming Industries Marketing Service directory listings indicate 124 was 4.69. The state’s capital consumption ratio was farmers markets across the state. relatively low between ranging in between Several measures can be used to indicate the financial well-being of farms 2010-1014, and farm operators 0.10 and 0.20, suggesting only 10 to 20 percent Tennessee. Table 2 presents financial data from 2010-2014 for the Tennessee farming sector. Net cash of production is per needed to cover the sector’s capital income Indicators was just under $740 million in 2014, averaging $10,993 operation (USDA/ERS 2015b). a.4.farm Financial for Tennessee Farming Net cash farm income on a per acre basis was $67.87/acre. consumption. In 2014, the state’s farming sector Industries had an operating expense ratio of 0.65, suggesting 65 Several measures can be used to indicate the The net farm income ratio (net farm income/value of production) during 2010 to 2014 suggests about 15 of the value of production was used to financial well-being of farms and farmproduction operators to netpercent to 30 percent efficiency in converting farm income.[3] However, the interest expense cover operating expenses. in ratios Tennessee. 2 presents financial data from for theTable farming sector reflect a low debt burden and interest payment level relative to production. Thedebt 2014 estimated market value of land and 2010-2014 for the Tennessee farming sector. Net to cover Times interest earned is another measure of ability payments, specifically interest buildings on farms was $39.2 billion or around cash farm income justthe under $740 payments. For allwas years, values aremillion greater in than one, implying sufficient cash to meet interest 2014, averaging operation (USDA/ payments, and$10,993 in 2014 per the value was 4.69. The state’s capital consumption ratio was relatively lowratios were USDA’s Economic Research definitions of farm sector financial used. A description of these can20 be percent found at http://www.ers.usda.gov/databetween between only 10 to of production is ERS 2015b).2010-1014, Net cash ranging farm income on 0.10 a perand acre0.20, suggesting products/farm-income-and-wealth-statistics/documentation-for-the-farm-sectorneeded to cover the sector’s capital consumption. In 2014, the state’s farming sector had an operating basis was $67.87/acre. financial-ratios.aspx#eff. 3 expense ratio of 0.65, suggesting 65 percent of the value of production was used to cover operating expenses. Table 2. Indicators of the Tennessee Farm Sector’s Financial Well-Being, 2010-2014 Table 2.3: Indicators of the Tennessee Farm Sector’s Financial Well-Being, 2010–2014 Value of Production Net Farm Income Interest Expense Market Value of Farmland, Buildings, and Equipment Capital Consumption Total Expenses Net Farm Income Ratio Capital Consumption Ratio Operating Expense Ratio Interest Expense Ratio Times Interest Earned 2010 2011 2013 2014 $4,343 2012 (Million $) $4,370 $3,764 $5,099 $4,916 $790 $260 $37,368 $1,180 $250 $37,908 $752 $240 $38,368 $1,414 $191 $38,913 $740 $201 $39,240 $408 $3,127 $427 $3,303 $697 $3,834 $920 $4,297 0.21 0.11 0.65 0.07 4.03 0.27 0.10 0.60 0.06 5.72 $637 $3,794 Ratios 0.17 0.15 0.67 0.05 4.13 0.28 0.14 0.58 0.04 8.40 0.15 0.19 0.65 0.04 4.69 Source: USDA/ERS 2015b. (Source: USDA/ERS 2015b) The 2014 estimated market value of land and buildings on farms was $39.2 billion or around 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT $583,061 per farm in Tennessee. The 2014 overall value is up from the 2010 value of $37.4 billion. Farms comprising the majority of sales have much larger land and building asset values than other | 37 CHAPTER 2 | The Tennessee Economy: Short-Term Outlook 2.5. Tennessee’s Agricultural and Forest Industries and Rural Economy, continued $583,061 per farm in Tennessee. The 2014 overall value is up from the 2010 value of $37.4 billion. Farms comprising the majority of sales have much larger land and building asset values than other farms. Farms with sales of at least $1 million had average market value of land and buildings of more than $7.3 million per operation and those with $500,000-$999,999 in sales had over $3.1 million in average market value of land and buildings per operation (USDA/NASS 2012). The 2014 average value of land and buildings among our neighboring states was $694,897 per farm. Tennessee’s farm structure is characterized by many small farming operations; however, a relatively few larger farms make up the majority of farm sales. About 69.8 percent of all farms have sales of less than $10,000. By contrast, 2,303 of the state’s farms accounted for 75 percent of the market value of agricultural products sold in 2012 (USDA/NASS 2012). Just under 42 percent of farmers in Tennessee cite farming as their principal occupation, highlighting the importance of other sources of rural income to economic sustainability of the agricultural sector. a.5. Primary Forestry in Tennessee In 2013, among the state’s 143 sawmill establishments, nearly 2,100 workers were employed with a payroll of close to $61.0 million (US Census Bureau 2013). Logging establishment numbers totaled 135 for the same time period, employing 728 workers with a payroll of close to $20.0 million. From 2009 through 2013, the average annual growth in the numbers of employees, payroll, and establishments for sawmills (NAICS 321113) were 3.1 percent, 7.9 percent, and -5.1 percent, respectively. For logging (NAICS 1133) in this same timeframe, the average annual growth values were 2.5 percent, 6.4 percent, and -1.3 percent, respectively, for employees, payroll, and establishments. According to the Forestry Inventory Analysis by U.S. Forest Service (USFS 2015), an estimated 1.4 billion board feet of sawtimber trees were removed from Tennessee (international ¼ inch rule). Between 2009 and 38 | 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT 2013, the average annual growth in sawtimber removals was -2.2 percent. Factors that influenced these trends in the primary forestry sector are: low new housing starts in 2009; slow recovery of new housing starts; and relatively flat U.S. demand for paper, paperboard, and pulp due to declining newsprint, printing and writing paper consumption (Howard and Westby 2013). b. Food, Fiber, and Forestry Manufacturing in Tennessee b.1. Value of Shipments, Number of Establishments, and Employees. As seen in Table 2.4, the state’s 1,591 food and fiber processing and manufacturing facilities employed 77,283 workers with a payroll of $3.2 billion in 2013. The value of shipments originating from these industries was $36.1 billion (US Census Bureau 2013). By comparison, the state’s overall manufacturing employments was 290,841 workers in 2013 and the value of shipments was $143.6 billion. This means that food and fiber related manufacturing employed more than 1 in 4 manufacturing workers and generated over 1 in 4 manufacturing shipment dollars. The largest percentage of the values of food and fiber-related manufacturing shipments, 51.3 percent, arose from food processing, followed by beverages at 17.1 percent. Figure 2.14 displays the growth in value of shipments from 2009 through 2013 for Tennessee’s food, beverage, and tobacco products manufacturing (NAICS 311 and 312 combined) and wood, paper, and furniture products (NAICS 321, 322, and 337 combined). Steady growth in food, beverage, and tobacco products manufacturing was primarily driven by growth in beverage and tobacco products (NAICS 312), which experienced an annual average growth of 7.2 percent from 2009 through 2013. Food processing (NAICS 311) experienced a 3.5 percent annual average growth over this time frame. Growth in forest products manufacturing was primarily driven by growth in wood products (NAICS 321) (8.6 trees were removed from Tennessee (international ¼ inch rule). Between 2009 and 2013, the average annual growth in sawtimber removals was -2.2 percent. Factors that influenced these trends in the The of Tennessee Economy: starts; Short-Term Outlook primary forestry sector are: low new housing starts in 2009; slow recovery new housing and relatively flat U.S. demand for paper, paperboard, and pulp due to declining newsprint, printing and writing paper consumption (Howard and Westby 2013). | CHAPTER 2 2.5.Forestry Tennessee’s Agricultural and Forest Industries and Rural Economy, b) Food, Fiber, and Manufacturing in Tennessee continued b.1 Value of Shipments, Number of Establishments, and Employees Table 2.4: Tennessee Food, Fiber, and Forestry Manufacturing, 2013a Table 3. Tennessee Food, Fiber, and Forestry Manufacturing, 2013a Employees (Number) Manufacturing Industry/NAICS Food (311) Animal Slaughtering/Processing (3116) Beverage & Tobacco Products (312) Textile Mills (313) Textile Product Mills (314) Apparel (315) Leather & Allied Products (316) Wood Products (321) Paper (322) Furniture & Related Products (337) Total a EstablishPayroll ments (Million$) (Number) Value of Shipments (Million $) 34,430 10,603 $1,446 $308 306 59 $18,530 $3,415 3,227 2,692 2,487 3,449 421 10,909 10,856 8,812 77,283 $190 $125 $81 $93 $12 $351 $599 $322 $3,218 91 55 138 94 27 461 124 295 1,591 $6,191 $987 $601 $354 D $2,169 $5,688 $1,614 $36,133 Values for animal slaughtering and processing are imbedded in food manufacturing (311) Values for animal slaughtering and processing are imbedded in food manufacturing (311) values D = values Data not disclosed Source: Census 2013. D =US Data notBureau disclosed a Figure 2.14: Agri-forestry 6Products Manufacturing Value of Shipments, 2009–2013 Food, Beverage & Tobacco Products Wood, Paper & Furniture Products $10.0 $26.0 $25.0 $9.0 Billion $ Billion $ $24.0 $23.0 $8.0 $22.0 $21.0 $7.0 $20.0 $6.0 $19.0 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 percent) and paper (NAICS 322) manufacturing (5.1 percent), with furniture and related products (NAICS 337) experiencing a 1.5 percent annual average growth. For all agri-forestry products manufacturing between 2009 and 2013, growth averaged 3.6 percent per year. Relatively flat annual average growth occurred for textile mills (NAICS 313) (0.01 percent), with textile product mills (NAICS 314) experiencing a 5.3 percent decrease 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 in value of shipments. Tennessee‘s share of the national value of shipments for food processing was 2.4 percent, beverage and tobacco products was 4.2 percent, textile mills was 3.2 percent, textile product mills was 2.6 percent, wood products manufacturing was 2.4 percent, paper manufacturing was 3.1 percent, and furniture and related products was 2.3 percent. 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT | 39 CHAPTER 2 | The Tennessee Economy: Short-Term Outlook 2.5. Tennessee’s Agricultural and Forest Industries and Rural Economy, continued Tennessee is a significant producer of ethanol in the Southeast U.S. Two major processors located in the state are Green Plains in Obion County and Tate & Lyle in Loudon County. The Energy Information Association lists capacity in Tennessee at 225 million gallons per year (EIA 2015). b.2. Economic Impacts from the Agri-forestry Industrial Complex In 2013, the agri-forestry industrial complex directly contributed (without multiplier effects) $49.0 billion in economic activity to the state’s economy, adding 179.7 thousand jobs (Menard, English, and Jensen 2016). The agri-forestry industrial complex contributed $13.9 billion in value-added. When accounting for multiplier effects, the agri-forestry industrial complex added $74.8 billion to Tennessee’s economy, or 12.8 percent of the state’s economic activity, and employed 349,398 individuals, or 9.4 percent of all workers. Agriculture, with multiplier effects, accounted for 9.0 percent of the state’s economy and generated $52.6 billion in output, employing c) Rural Economies Well-Being closeand to 254,000 Tennesseans, with 109,000 employed (both full- and part-time) in agricultural production. c. Rural Economies and Well-Being Rural communities and their resources are important contributors to the health of the agriforestry industrial complex. In 2014, about 22.8 percent of Tennessee’s population was classified as rural. Table 2.5 presents several indicators, including median household income, education level, unemployment rate, and poverty rate across rural and urban counties in Tennessee. The data reflect lower household income, lower percentage of college graduates, and higher unemployment and poverty rates in rural areas of Tennessee than in urban areas. Individuals 25 and over are about half as likely to obtain a college degree as urban individuals. Persons who are part of the rural labor force are nearly 30 percent more likely to be unemployed than persons who are part of the urban labor force. A person residing in a rural area is over 20 percent more likely to fall below the poverty level than a person residing in an urban area. Rural communities and their resources are important contributors to the health of the agri-forestry industrial complex. In 2014, about 22.8 percent of Tennessee’s population was classified as rural. Table 4 presents several indicators, including median household income, education level, unemployment rate, and poverty rate across rural and urban counties Table 4. Household Income, Education Level, and 2.5: lower Household Income, Education Level, and Unemployment and Poverty Rates in Rural in Tennessee. The Table data reflect Unemployment and Poverty Rates in Rural and household income, lower percentage of college and Urban Areas of Tennessee Urban Areas of Tennessee graduates, and higher unemployment and Rural/ poverty rates in rural areas of Tennessee than in Urban urban areas. Individuals 25 and over are about Measure Rural Urban Ratio half as likely to obtain a college degree as urban Median Household $31,998 $41,810 0.77 individuals. Persons who are part of the rural Income (2013$) labor force are nearly 30 percent more likely to 2009-2013 Education be unemployed than persons who are part of Level, Persons 25 and the urban labor force. A person residing in a Over (5-Yr Avg) (Percent) rural area is over 20 percent more likely to fall Not Completed 20.9 13.9 1.50 below the poverty level than a person residing in High School an urban area. Completed High 41.2 30.5 1.35 d) Governor’s Rural Challenge The Governor’s Rural Challenge set forward four major recommendations for Tennessee agriculture (TDA 2013). These recommendations were: 1. 2. 3. 4. School Completed College 2014 Unemployment Rates (Percent) 2013 Poverty Rate (Percent) 14.0 8.0 26.9 6.3 0.52 1.27 20.6 17.0 1.21 (Source: USDA/ERS 2015g) Source: USDA/ERS 2015g. Advance agriculture, natural resources, and rural infrastructure as Tennessee business priorities; Ensure a positive and predictable policy and regulatory environment; | 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT Expand market40 opportunities for Tennessee producers and encourage new production; and Increase the scope and depth of a skilled and educated workforce through career, technical, and higher education. The Tennessee Economy: Short-Term Outlook | CHAPTER 2 2.5. Tennessee’s Agricultural and Forest Industries and Rural Economy, continued toward the aforementioned recommendations. While the indicators were developed in 2013, The Governor’s Rural Challenge set forward four calculations for these indicator measures using major recommendations for Tennessee agriculture recent data can be used as baselines for future (TDA 2013). These recommendations were: growth. Notably, several of the “scorecard 1. Advance agriculture, natural resources, and indicators” exhibited positive movement toward rural infrastructure as Tennessee business their goals 2010-2014 in recent for years. Theseagriculture. are listed in Table priorities; earlier, the capital consumption ratio was relatively low between Tennessee TAEPainvestment assists farmers in expanding on-farm storage and building farm capital. TAEP 2.6. 2. Ensure positive and predictable policy and expenditures investing in productivity and infrastructure of the agricultural sector grew by 180.83 Several indicators of progress toward regulatory environment; percent from 2007 to 2012 (see Recommendation 2). Positive indicators of progress toward Recommendation 1 showedactivities positive progress. 3. Expand market opportunities for Tennessee Recommendation 3 include growth in economic activity from farming and associated in real indicators positive outcomes producers encourage new production; terms byand 14.91 percent between 2006 and 2011, andThe economic activityexhibiting from the food and beverage 2012, economic activity from farming during For a 5-year time span between agricultural and processing industries growing in real terms by 5.33 percent. and associated activities in real terms was $4.16 billion (36.71 percent greater than 2006) and economic censuses (2007 to 2012) included reduction in the 4. Increase the scope and depth of a skilled activity from food and beverage processing was $21.6 billion (19.46 percent greater than 2006). While percentage idle and cropland, growth in an and raw educated workforce through career, commodities exported out of state decreased, the inputs usedof in food beverageand processing index of major crop yields. These indicators technical, and higher imported from out ofeducation. state increased, but only by 1.5 percent. Under Recommendation 4, two two indicators reflect positive progress toward building a skilled and educated agricultural workforce. Educational suggest that less cropland is sitting idle and that Indicators were developed as part of the programs, such as Master Farmer and Master Gardener, saw over 12,574 Tennesseans participating cropland use is resulting in higher crop yields. strategic planning process to gauge progress d. Governor’s Rural Challenge from 2007-2012. Four-year agricultural degrees awarded annually increased from 516 in 2008/2009 to 621 in 2012/2013. The number of four year agricultural degrees awarded for the 2013-2014 year was 670. This is was 7.9 percent above the 2012-2013 year and 29.8 percent above the 2008-2009 year. Table 2.6: Scorecard Indicators of Positive Progress for Tennessee Agriculture Table 5. Scorecard Indicators of Positive Progress for Tennessee Agriculture Indicator Percent of Cropland that is Idled (%) Index of Crop Yield Per Acre (7 major crops)a Tennessee Ag Enhancement Program Expenditures (TAEP) (Million $) Inflation Adjusted Values by CPI (2007=100) Economic Activity from Farming and Associated Activities (Million $) Inflation Adjusted Values by CPI (2006=100) Economic Activity from Food and Beverage Processing (Million $) Inflation Adjusted Values by CPI (2006=100) Percent of Agricultural Commodity Exports to Out-of-State (%) Graduates of Master Farmer/Gardener Programs (Number in total) Four Year Agricultural Degrees Awarded (Number per Year)b Strategic Plan RecommPercent Change Goal endation -0.83% Decrease 1 2012 6.06% 2007 6.88% 120.60 100.00 20.60% Increase 1 $18.31 $6.00 205.14% Increase 2 $16.85 $6.00 180.83% Increase 2011 $3,870 2006 $3,044 27.14% Increase $3,498 $3,044 14.91% Increase $21,110 $18,114 16.54% Increase $19,079 $18,114 5.33% Increase 2011 55.10% 2008 59.30% -4.20% Decrease 3 2007-2012 12,574 2007-2008 5,826 115.83% Increase 4 2012-2013 621 2008-2009 516 20.35% Increase 4 3 3 Cotton, Hay, Sorghum, Soybeans, Tobacco, and Wheat 2012). Yieldfor ratios 2012 2007weighted for eachbycrop a Corn, Cotton,Corn, Hay, Sorghum, Soybeans, Tobacco, and Wheat (USDA/NASS 2012). (USDA/NASS Yield ratios of 2012 to 2007 eachof crop weretoshare 2012were acres of each crop. Source: Tennessee Department of Higher Education Fact Books http://www.state.tn.us/ thec/Legislative/Reports.html. a 9 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT | 41 CHAPTER 2 | The Tennessee Economy: Short-Term Outlook 2.5. Tennessee’s Agricultural and Forest Industries and Rural Economy, continued Data was available to calculate the yield index for 2013 and 2014, with these values being 147.57 and 138.62 respectively, again indicating a growth in yields compared with 2007. As noted earlier, the capital consumption ratio was relatively low between 2010-2014 for Tennessee agriculture. TAEP investment assists farmers in expanding on-farm storage and building farm capital. TAEP expenditures investing in productivity and infrastructure of the agricultural sector grew by 180.83 percent from 2007 to 2012 (see Recommendation 2). Positive indicators of progress toward Recommendation 3 include growth in economic activity from farming and associated activities in real terms by 14.91 percent between 2006 and 2011, and economic activity from the food and beverage processing industries growing in real terms by 5.33 percent. For 2013, economic activity from farming and associated activities in real terms was $4.1 billion (35.0 percent greater than 2006) and economic activity from food and beverage processing was $21.4 billion (18.0 percent greater than 2006). While raw commodities exported out of state decreased, the inputs used in food and beverage processing imported from out of state increased, but only by 1.5 percent. Under Recommendation 4, two indicators reflect positive progress toward building a skilled and educated agricultural workforce. Educational programs, such as Master Farmer and Master Gardener, saw over 12,574 Tennesseans participating from 2007-2012. Four-year agricultural degrees awarded annually increased from 516 in 2008/2009 to 621 in 2012/2013. The number of four year agricultural degrees awarded for the 2013-2014 year was 670. This is was 7.9 percent above the 2012-2013 year and 29.8 percent above the 2008-2009 year. These industries add $49 billion directly to the state’s economy and, with multiplier effects, $74.8 billion in total. About 1 in 4 manufacturing jobs are in food- and fiber-related manufacturing. The farming sector in Tennessee is quite diverse, which can help prevent large upswings and downswings due to market movements of one or two commodities. However, this diversity means that the state’s farming sector, by and large, is a market-follower at the farm-gate level, heavily impacted by market changes and policies at the national level. Furthermore, increasingly, export markets impact farm pocketbooks. The state’s farming sector is dual in nature, characterized with larger farms supplying the majority of sales and many smaller farms operated by part-time farmers who also rely on off-farm income. Building agricultural technology and infrastructure within the state to increase agricultural productivity and profitability will likely rely on increased rates of capital investment. Food and beverage manufacturing have sustained steady growth. These industries have proven to be fairly resilient to economic downturns, such as those experienced in the late 2000’s. The forest products sector has seen slower growth, with slowed domestic demands resulting in part from the economic downturn of the late 2000’s. Economic growth and an upward trend in new housing starts may place future positive pressure on the demand for forest products. Rural communities and counties are very important to the agri-forestry industrial complex, as is agri-forestry industrial complex to the rural economy within the state. However, gaps in income, educational attainments, unemployment, and poverty between rural and urban areas persist. Summary Howard, J. and R. Westby. 2013. U.S. Timber Production, Trade, Consumption and Price Statistics 1965–2011. USDA/USFS Forest Products Laboratory FPL-RP-676, http:// www.fpl.fs.fed.us/documnts/fplrp/fpl_rp676. pdf. The agri-forestry industrial complex encompasses industries that produce food and fiber and those adding value to these commodities. This industrial complex is important to the state’s economy, particularly to rural areas within the state. 42 | 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT References Used The Tennessee Economy: Short-Term Outlook | CHAPTER 2 2.5. Tennessee’s Agricultural and Forest Industries and Rural Economy, continued Jensen, K. M. Bruch, J. Menard, and B. English. 2013. “A Snapshot of Tennessee Agritourism: 2013 Update.” Available at http://aimag. ag.utk.edu/pubs/AgritourismJune2013.pdf. Menard, R., B. English, and K. Jensen. Economic Contributions of Agriculture and Forestry in Tennessee, 2013. Agri-Industry Modeling & Analysis group Report, Department of Ag. and Resource Economics, The University of Tennessee, Knoxville, forthcoming 2016. Menard, J., K. Jensen, and B. English. 2011. “An Analysis of the Economic Impacts from the Tennessee Agricultural Enhancement Program (TAEP).” Report to the Tennessee Department of Agriculture (TDA). Available at http://aimag.ag.utk.edu/pubs/ TAEPEconomicImpacts.pdf. Tennessee Department of Agriculture. 2013. Governor’s Rural Challenge a 10-Year Strategic Plan: Increasing Rural Tennessee’s Capacity to Produce. http://www.tn.gov/ assets/entities/ agriculture/attachments/ AgBusRuralChallenge.pdf. Tennessee Department of Higher Education. Tennessee Department of Higher Education Fact Books http://www.state.tn.us/ thec/ Legislative/Reports.html US Census Bureau. 2013. Annual Survey of Manufacturers, Geographic Area Statistics, Tennessee. http://www.census.gov/ manufacturing/asm/. U.S. Energy Information Administration (EIA). 2015. Tennessee State Energy Profile. https:// www.eia.gov/state/print.cfm?sid=TN. USDA/AMS. 2016. Farmers Markets and Directto-Consumer Marketing. Farmers Market Directory data https://apps.ams.usda.gov/ FarmersMarketsExport/ExcelExport.aspx. USDA/ERS. 2015a. Cotton and Wood Yearbook. http://www.ers.usda.gov/data-products/ cotton,-wool,-and-textile-data/cotton-andwool-yearbook.aspx. USDA/ERS. 2015b. Farm Income and Wealth Statistics-Farm and Wealth Indicators. http:// www.ers.usda.gov/data-products/farmincome-and-wealth-statistics/farm-financeindicators-state-ranking.aspx#P7026ab87f4204 60ebfb73e2a2d2739b4_4_186iT0R0x16. USDA/ERS. 2015c. Farm Income and Wealth Statistics-Cash Receipts. http://www.ers.usda. gov/data-products/farm-income-and-wealthstatistics/cash-receipts-by-commodity.aspx. USDA/ERS. 2015d. Feed Grains Yearbook. http://www.ers.usda.gov/data-products/feedgrains-database/feed-grains-yearbook-tables. aspx. USDA/ERS. 2015e. Livestock, Poultry, and Dairy Outlook. November. http://www.ers.usda. gov/media/1942630/ldpm257.pdf. USDA/ERS. 2014. Oil Crops Outlook. http:// usda.mannlib.cornell.edu/usda/ers/ OCS//2010s/2014/OCS-12-12-2014.pdf. USDA/ERS. 2015f. State Export Data. http:// www.ers.usda.gov/data-products/state-exportdata.aspx. USDA/ERS. 2015g. State Fact Sheets: Tennessee. http://www.ers.usda.gov/data-products/statefact-sheets/state-data.aspx?StateFIPS=47&Stat eName=Tennessee. USDA/FAS. 2015. Global Agricultural Trade System. http://apps.fas.usda.gov/gats/default. aspx. USDA/FSA. 2015a. ARC/PLC Election Data. http://www.fsa.usda.gov/programs-andservices/arcplc_program/. USDA/FSA. 2015b. Crop Acreage Data Reported to FSA. http://www.fsa.usda.gov/news-room/ efoia/electronic-reading-room/frequentlyrequested-information/crop-acreage-data/ index. USDA/NASS. 2012. Census of Agriculture, Tennessee. http://www.agcensus.usda.gov/ Publications/2012/. 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT | 43 CHAPTER 2 | The Tennessee Economy: Short-Term Outlook 2.5. Tennessee’s Agricultural and Forest Industries and Rural Economy, continued USDA/NASS. 2015a. Quick Stats. Tennessee Agricultural Overview. http://www.nass. usda.gov/Quick_Stats/Ag_Overview/ stateOverview.php?state=TENNESSEE. USDA/NASS. 2015b. Quick Stats. U.S. Cattle Inventory. http://quickstats.nass.usda.gov/. USDA/NASS. 2015c. Quick Stats. Cotton Planted Acreage-Tennessee. http://quickstats.nass. usda.gov/. 44 | 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT USDA/NASS. 2015d. “Poultry Production and Value 2014 Summary.” http://usda.mannlib. cornell.edu/ usda/current/PoulProdVa/ PoulProdVa-04-30-2015.pdf USDA/USFS. 2015. Forest Inventory Analysis. http://apps.fs.fed.us/fia/fido/index.html. The Tennessee Economy: Long-Term Outlook | CHAPTER 3 CHAPTER 3: THE TENNESSEE ECONOMY: LONG-TERM OUTLOOK In this chapter— 3.1.Introduction 3.2. Employment Outlook 3.3.Unemployment 3.4.Population 3.5. Personal Income and Taxable Sales 3.6. State Gross Domestic Product 3.1.Introduction Previous chapters focused on the short-term outlook (10 quarters ahead) using a cyclical forecast which concentrated on the ups and downs of the business cycle. This chapter provides a longerterm view (10 years ahead) of economic growth in Tennessee based on a trend forecast. Typically, the ups and downs of a business cycle have little impact on the long-term trend performance of an economy, although this was certainly not the case with the Great Recession. More generally, long-term growth is driven by growth in factors of production such as population and the labor force, productivity, human capital (i.e. knowledge, education, and on-the-job experience), private sector investments in productive inputs (equipment and structures), and public investments in infrastructure (from broadband to roadways). All else equal, growth in any of these inputs will stimulate economic growth for the state. Recessions and economic booms are not built into the trend forecast as they are unpredictable, but it is likely that both will occur at some point in the next decade. Between 2005 and 2015, inflation-adjusted state gross domestic product (GDP) in Tennessee grew at a compound annual growth rate (CAGR) of 1.1 percent. This was slightly slower than the 1.4 percent CAGR for the U.S., but both were largely affected by the Great Recession. By comparison, inflation-adjusted state GDP is projected to advance at a 2.2 percent CAGR between 2015 and 2025 and a 2.4 percent CAGR for the nation. Over the last ten years, Tennessee personal income grew by 3.8 percent (CAGR) and kept pace with national income growth. Looking forward ten years, personal income in Tennessee is expected to increase by 4.5 percent (CAGR) between 2015 and 2025, which is slightly slower than the 4.8 percent CAGR projected for the nation. As a result, Tennessee’s per capita nominal personal income is projected to fall from 87.2 percent of the national average in 2015 to only 83.2 percent by 2025. Due to the Great Recession, overall employment growth was slow over the last ten years in both Tennessee and the nation. Between 2005 and 2015, nonfarm employment in Tennessee expanded by only 0.5 percent (CAGR), and national employment growth increased by only 0.6 percent (CAGR). A more optimistic employment outlook is projected for the next ten years, as 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT | 45 CHAPTER 3 3.1. | The Tennessee Economy: Long-Term Outlook Introduction, continued Tennessee employment is forecasted to grow by 1.1 percent (CAGR) between 2015 and 2025 and slightly outpace national employment growth of 1.0 percent (CAGR). Despite these gains, manufacturing employment in Tennessee is still projected to fall over the next ten years, though by only 0.1 percent (CAGR), with some nearterm gains being overwhelmed by longer-term setbacks. This is much less severe than the 2.1 3.2. Employment Outlook Between 2005 and 2015 nonfarm employment grew by 4.7 percent in Tennessee, which is equivalent to a meager 0.5 percent CAGR. Employment growth was slightly faster across the nation where jobs expanded by 5.9 percent, yielding a 0.6 percent CAGR. Slow growth during this period was largely due to the Great Recession, but there were still some bright spots in Tennessee’s labor market. Employment in the education and health services sector grew by 24.1 percent, professional and business services employment expanded by 22.6 percent, and leisure and hospitality jobs grew by 16.7 percent. This was counteracted by an 18.9 percent reduction in manufacturing jobs, a 12.2 percent drop in information sector employment, and an 8.6 percent contraction in the natural resources, mining, and construction labor force. Table 3.1 provides a snapshot of Tennessee’s historical employment situation ten years ago as well as a projection of the state’s employment outlook ten years from now. Over the last ten years the manufacturing sector has suffered the largest losses, losing over 77,000 jobs and contracting by 2.1 percent (CAGR). Table 3.2 provides a more detailed look into the employment dynamics of the manufacturing sector. Between 2005 and 2015 employment in the durable goods sector fell by 1.8 percent (CAGR) or 42,900 jobs, while nondurable goods employment fell by 2.5 percent (CAGR) or 34,400 jobs. All subsectors within manufacturing were on the decline except for transportation equipment which grew by 0.5 percent (CAGR) 46 | percent (CAGR) contraction in manufacturing jobs that occurred in Tennessee between 2005 and 2015. Manufacturing output, on the other hand, is expected to grow as a result of productivity gains between 2015 and 2025. Subsequent sections of this chapter take a retrospective look at economic growth between 2005 and the present as well as the state’s longterm outlook through 2025. 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT or 3,600 jobs and in the beverage and tobacco sector where employment increased by 0.1 percent (CAGR). Employment in the furniture and printing and related support sectors saw the steepest declines, shrinking by 7.1 percent (CAGR) each. Looking ahead ten years, nonfarm employment in Tennessee is projected to grow by 12.1 percent between 2015 and 2025, representing a compound annual growth rate of 1.1 percent. This is slightly faster than the 10.3 percent growth rate expected for the nation (equivalent to a 1.0 percent compound annual growth rate). The manufacturing sector is expected to see a very slight contraction in employment over the next ten years, while all other sectors are projected to grow or remain stable. Employment growth will be largest in the professional and business services sector, followed by education and health services, and natural resources, mining, and construction. Within the manufacturing sector, durable goods employment is projected to increase by 0.4 percent (CAGR) between 2015 and 2025 while nondurable goods employment will fall by 1.0 percent (CAGR). Figure 3.1 shows state and national employment growth patterns over the long-term forecast period. Nonfarm employment growth in Tennessee closely mirrors the trend of the national economy, as both are expected to see positive growth throughout the forecast horizon. Of course, since this is a trend forecast the underlying assumption is that no recessions will occur within the next ten years, but a recession at some point during the long-term forecast horizon is possible if not likely. The Tennessee Economy: Long-Term Outlook 3.2. | CHAPTER 3 Employment Outlook, continued The outlook for manufacturing employment, on the other hand, is not as optimistic. For the nation, manufacturing employment growth will remain positive for most of the forecast horizon but trend towards zero. In Tennessee, manufacturing employment will see some positive growth over the next four years, and then revert to trend contraction in 2020 and throughout the rest of the long-term outlook. Figure 3.2 presents employment growth patterns Table 3.1:Table Tennessee Nonfarm Employment by Broad Sector (thousands of jobs) 3.1: Tennessee Nonfarm Employment by Broad Sector (Thousands of Jobs) Employment Total Nonfarm Natural Resources, Mining & Construction Manufacturing Trade, Transportation, Utilities Information Financial Activities Professional & Business Services Education & Health Services Leisure & Hospitality Other Services Government U.S. Nonfarm U.S. Manufacturing Growth Rate (%)* 2005 2,743.0 125.3 408.8 598.0 49.4 143.3 312.5 330.3 262.1 100.7 412.7 2015 2,870.7 114.5 331.5 607.5 43.4 144.8 383.0 409.8 305.9 104.8 425.6 2025 3,217.7 136.4 327.3 651.6 45.0 152.1 509.3 489.1 351.9 103.0 452.0 2005 to 2015 0.5 -0.9 -2.1 0.2 -1.3 0.1 2.1 2.2 1.6 0.4 0.3 2015 to 2025 1.1 1.8 -0.1 0.7 0.4 0.5 2.9 1.8 1.4 -0.2 0.6 134.0 14.2 141.9 12.3 156.5 12.9 0.6 -1.4 1.0 0.4 *Compound Annual Growth Rate *Compound Annual Growth Rate Source: Bureau of Labor Statistics and CBER-UT. Source: Bureau of Labor Statistics and CBER-UT Table 3.2:Table Tennessee Manufacturing Emplyoment by Sector (thousands of jobs) 3.2: Tennessee Manufacturing Employment Manufacturing Total Durable Goods Wood Products Nonmetallic Minerals Primary Metals Fabricated Metals Machinery Computers & Electronics Electrical Equipment, Appliances & Components Transportation Equipment Furniture Miscellaneous Durables Total Nondurable Goods Food Beverage & Tobacco Textile Mills, Textile Mill Products & Apparel Paper Printing & Related Support Chemicals Plastics & Rubber Miscellaneous Nondurable Goods 2005 408.8 254.6 17.7 15.9 12.0 42.6 33.9 10.4 23.5 63.9 19.2 15.3 154.2 34.3 5.4 18.0 18.9 18.8 27.2 29.3 2.3 Employment 2015 331.5 211.7 11.6 11.7 10.3 35.2 26.2 5.1 19.9 67.5 9.2 15.1 119.8 32.9 5.5 9.6 14.3 9.0 25.2 21.3 2.1 by Sector (Thousands of Jobs) 2025 327.3 219.3 12.1 11.2 10.1 34.2 25.8 3.7 21.2 78.4 7.9 14.8 107.9 31.8 4.8 6.4 11.8 7.7 22.2 21.7 1.5 Growth Rate (%)* 2005 to 2015 2015 to 2025 -2.1 -0.1 -1.8 0.4 -4.2 0.4 -3.0 -0.4 -1.5 -0.2 -1.9 -0.3 -2.5 -0.2 -6.9 -3.2 -1.6 0.6 0.5 1.5 -7.1 -1.5 -0.1 -0.2 -2.5 -1.0 -0.4 -0.3 0.1 -1.4 -6.1 -4.0 -2.8 -1.9 -7.1 -1.5 -0.8 -1.3 -3.1 0.2 -0.9 -3.3 *Compound Annual Growth Rate *Compound Annual Growthand Rate Source: Bureau of Labor Statistics CBER-UT. Source: Bureau of Labor Statistics and CBER-UT 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT | 47 CHAPTER 3 3.2. | The Tennessee Economy: Long-Term Outlook Employment Outlook, continued Figure 3.1: Nonfarm Employment Continues to Grow While Manufacturing Employment Reverts to Trend Contraction Over the Long-Term Forecast Horizon 4.0 2.0 0.0 Percentage change -2.0 -4.0 -6.0 -8.0 -10.0 -12.0 -14.0 TN Total U.S. Total TN Mfg 2025 2024 2023 2022 2021 2020 2019 2018 2017 2016 2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008 2007 2006 2005 -16.0 U.S. Mfg Source: Bureau of Labor Statistics, IHS Global Insight Inc., and CBER-UT. Figure 3.2: Total Covered Employment Growth (June 2005 to June 2015) Tennessee Average: 5.3% U.S. Average 5.9% Loss of 15.0% or more -15.0% to 0.0% 0.1% to 5.2% 5.3% to 15.0% 15.1% to 30.9% 31.0% or greater Source: Bureau of Labor Statistics, Quarterly Census of Employment and Wages. 48 | 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT The Tennessee Economy: Long-Term Outlook 3.2. | CHAPTER 3 Employment Outlook, continued across all Tennessee counties between 2005 and 2015. There were 36 counties that experienced employment contractions over the last ten years. Jackson County and McNairy County were hit hardest, contracting by 33.1 percent and 31.5 percent respectively. Conversely, there were ten counties which grew by at least 20.0 percent. Lake County saw the strongest employment gains, growing by an astounding 88.6 percent, though due to Lake County’s small size, this only represented an increase of 893 jobs. Williamson County came in second with employment growth of 54.4 percent, representing an additional 40,697 jobs, followed by Bledsoe County at 47.3 percent or 691 additional jobs. In addition, employment in Rutherford County grew by 22.0 percent or 20,878 jobs, Davidson County employment increased by 5.5 percent or 23,694 jobs, employment in Knox County expanded by 5.2 percent or 11,420 jobs, while in Shelby County employment fell by 2.2 percent or 11,081 jobs. 3.3.Unemployment Over the last ten years the state unemployment rate has generally rested slightly above the national rate. A similar pattern is projected for the next ten years as Tennessee’s unemployment rate will remain just above its national counterpart throughout most of the long-term forecast (see Figure 3.3). However, the state and national rate are both expected to trend downwards over the next ten years. Tennessee’s unemployment rate was 5.9 percent in 2015 and is projected to fall to Figure 3.3: In the Long-Run, Tennessee’s Unemployment Rate Will Trend Downwards but Remain Above the National Rate for Most of the Forecast Horizon 12.0 10.0 Rate (%) 8.0 6.0 4.0 2.0 0.0 TN U.S. US Source: Bureau of Labor Statistics, IHS Global Insight Inc., CBER-UT. 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT | 49 CHAPTER 3 3.3. | The Tennessee Economy: Long-Term Outlook Unemployment, continued 5.1 percent by 2025. The national rate is pegged at 5.3 percent in 2015 and is expected to fall to 5.0 percent by 2025. Tennessee’s labor force participation rate has been severely depressed in recent years, as currently almost half of the state’s adult population is not in the workforce. (The labor force is defined as the share of the adult population that is either employed or actively seeking employment.) In 2005, Tennessee’s labor force participation rate was 62.0 percent and only slightly below the national participation rate of 64.5 percent. In 2015, the state’s labor force participation rate fell to 57.7 percent and is projected to fall even further to 55.1 percent by 2025; the national labor force participation rate has fallen as well and will rest slightly above 60 percent in 2025. There are a number of reasons for this low participation rate in Tennessee. As was suggested in Chapter 2, poor health status and low educational attainment in Tennessee are two potential contributors to low labor force participation. Specifically, in 2013 Tennessee had the fifth highest adult smoking rate (24.3 percent in Tennessee compared to 19.0 percent in the U.S.) and fourth highest obesity rate in the nation (33.7 percent in Tennessee compared to 29.4 percent in the U.S.).1 Moreover, Tennessee’s average life 1 Center for Disease Control and Prevention, Behavior Risk Factor Surveillance System. expectancy (76.3 years)2 is the eight lowest in the nation and well below the national average of 78.8 years.3 Generally Tennesseans have poorer health status than their national counterparts. With regards to educational attainment, the percentage of Tennesseans with at least a high school degree (85.8 percent) is slightly below the national average (86.9 percent), but Tennessee has shown solid gains relative to the nation since 2010 (see Figure 3.4). More importantly, the percentage of Tennesseans with at least a Bachelor’s degree (25.3 percent) lags behind the national average of 30.1 percent and has not shown the same gains relative to the national average as has been the case with high school achievement. State initiatives such as the Tennessee Promise, which offers two years of tuition-free community college or technical college to all Tennessee high school graduates, and the Drive to 55, with its goal of increasing the percentage of Tennesseans with a college degree or certificate to 55 percent of the Tennessee population by 2025, aim to increase the education status of the state. If the hoped-for gains are realized, this will support a stronger growth trajectory for the state economy. This could support stronger income growth and a narrowing of the gap between the incomes of Tennesseans and other Americans. Measure of America 2013-2014. 2 Center for Disease Control and Prevention, National Center for Health Statistics. 3 Figure 3.4: Educational Attainment Levels in Tennessee Are Below the National Average High school graduates or higher Bachelor’s degree or higher 35.0 86.9 87.0 86.0 85.8 85.6 85.0 84.0 83.6 83.0 82.0 2010 2014 TN U.S. Source: U.S. Census Bureau. | 30.1 30.0 25.0 28.2 25.3 23.1 20.0 15.0 10.0 5.0 0.0 81.0 50 Percentage of the population aged 25 years and older Percentage of the population aged 25 years and older 88.0 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT 2010 2014 TN U.S. The Tennessee Economy: Long-Term Outlook 3.3. | CHAPTER 3 Unemployment, continued None of these explanations fully explain the labor force participation trends that have taken place in Tennessee and across the country. As the Great Recession unfolded and participation rates began to sag, there was speculation that a stronger labor market and better job opportunities would ultimately draw workers back into the labor force. To date this has not occurred. However, it remains a distinct possibility as labor markets in Tennessee and across the U.S. tighten further and job gains remain robust. Figure 3.5 reports non-seasonally adjusted unemployment rates across all Tennessee counties for November 2005 and November 2015. In November 2005, the unemployment rate in Tennessee was 5.3 percent (not seasonallyadjusted). There were 29 counties with an unemployment rate at or below the state average and 11 counties with a rate equal to or below the national average of 4.8 percent (not seasonallyadjusted). Among all Tennessee counties in 2005, Williamson County registered the lowest unemployment rate at 3.9 percent, followed by Rutherford and Cheatham Counties at 4.2 percent, and Knox County at 4.3 percent. Conversely, there were four counties with unemployment rates above 10 percent – Clay County (13.4 percent), Lawrence County (13.4 percent), Wayne County (12.6 percent), and White County (10.2 percent). By comparison, in November 2015 Tennessee’s unemployment rate was 5.4 percent (not seasonally-adjusted), which was slightly above the national rate of 4.8 percent (not seasonallyadjusted). There were 28 counties with an unemployment rate equal to or below the state rate and 12 counties equal to or below the national rate. Once again, the lowest unemployment rate was in Williamson County (3.9 percent), while Rutherford Figure 3.5: Unemployment Rates in 2015 Are Comparable to Their 2005 Counterparts in Most Tennessee Counties Tennessee: 5.3% United States: 4.8% November 2005 Less than 4.0% 4.0% to 5.3% 5.4% to 6.7% 6.8% to 7.9% 8.0% to 9.3% Tennessee: 5.4% United States: 4.8% November 2015 9.4% or greater Source: U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics. 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT | 51 CHAPTER 3 3.3. | The Tennessee Economy: Long-Term Outlook Unemployment, continued and Davidson Counties had the second lowest rate at 4.2 percent. Moreover, there were zero counties with an unemployment rate above 10 percent. Hancock County, with an unemployment rate of 9.9 percent, had the highest rate among Tennessee counties, followed by Lauderdale County at 9.4 percent. In comparing county-level unemployment rates between 2005 and 2015, there were 30 counties that saw their unemployment rate fall, six counties that reported no change, and 59 counties that experienced an increase in their unemployment rate. However, in 33 counties the rate change was less than 0.5 percentage points. Lawrence County saw the biggest drop in its unemployment rate, falling from 13.4 percent in 2005 down to 6.8 percent in 2015, an amazing 6.6 percentage point drop. Four other counties enjoyed unemployment rate drops in excess of 4.0 percentage points (Clay, Warren, Wayne, and White Counties.) Conversely, the largest rate increase was in Obion County where the unemployment rate increased from 5.3 percent in 2005 to 8.4 percent in 2015. Five additional counties saw their unemployment rate increase by 2.0 percentage points or more (Dyer, Hancock, Marion, McNairy, and Scott Counties) 3.4.Population Over the long-term, population changes will have a large impact on employment and economic activity in Tennessee since population directly affects the size of the state’s labor force. Between 2005 and 2015, Tennessee’s population grew by 12.4 percent, outpacing national population growth of 8.7 percent. These records equate to compound annual growth rates of 1.2 percent for Tennessee and 0.8 percent for the nation. Between 2015 and 2025 population growth for the state and nation are projected to slow down slightly, as Tennessee will see an 11.2 percent growth rate while the U.S. will see 8.1 percent growth. Figure 3.6 presents historical and projected population growth at the county level for 2005 to 2015 and 2015 to 2025. Between 2005 and 2015, Montgomery, Rutherford, and Williamson 52 | 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT Counties all saw spectacular population growth rates of 30 percent or higher. There were seven additional counties with growth between 20 and 30 percent (Fayette, Loudon, Robertson, Sequatchie, Sevier, Sumner, and Wilson County). Conversely, Clay, Grundy, Hardeman, Haywood, and Obion Counties all saw their populations decline. Between 2015 and 2025, Williamson County is projected to see the strongest rate of population growth, expanding by 33.7 percent equating to an additional 71,117 residents, followed by Rutherford County at 29.7 percent or 90,689 additional residents. Fayette, Montgomery, and Wilson Counties will also see population growth in excess of 20 percent. Projections indicate that Clay, Hardeman, Haywood, and Obion Counties will experience population contractions. The Tennessee Economy: Long-Term Outlook 3.4. | CHAPTER 3 Population, continued Figure 3.6: Tennessee Population Growth Tennessee: 12.4% United States: 8.8% 2005 to 2015 Less than 0.0% 0.0% to 4.9% 5.0% to 11.1% 11.2% to 17.3% 17.4% to 23.5% Tennessee: 11.2% United States: 8.1% 2015 to 2025 23.6% or greater Source: U.S. Census Bureau and CBER-UT. 3.5. Personal Income and Taxable Sales Between 2015 and 2025, nominal personal income is projected to grow by 4.5 percent (CAGR) in Tennessee, outpacing the 3.8 percent compound annual growth rate that was registered between 2005 and 2015. Income growth for the nation matched income growth in Tennessee between 2005 and 2015 but will surpass Tennessee income growth between 2015 and 2025. Long-term income growth in Tennessee will be driven by a 5.4 percent (CAGR) increase in proprietors’ income and a 4.8 percent (CAGR) expansion in rent, interest, and dividend income between 2015 and 2025. Wages and salary income will also grow by 3.8 percent (CAGR) over the next 10 years. Per capita income in Tennessee was only 86.8 percent of the national average in 2015. From 2015 to 2025, per capita income growth in the state is expected to grow by 3.5 percent, but lag behind national per capita income growth of 4.0 percent. As a result, state per capita income will drop to 82.5 percent of the national average by 2025. Because the state starts with a lower level of per capita income, it must actually realize stronger growth rates to ultimately catch up with the nation. As noted earlier, the state has embarked on a number of initiatives to improve the educational standing of the state’s workforce. If these investments are effective, they can mitigate or even reverse the trends that are projected here. 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT | 53 CHAPTER 3 3.5. | The Tennessee Economy: Long-Term Outlook Personal Income and Taxable Sales, continued Nominal taxable sales in Tennessee are expected to grow by 3.8 percent (CAGR) between 2015 and 2025. This is much stronger than the 2.5 percent compound annual growth rate that took place between 2005 and 2015. Taxable sales growth in Tennessee will be driven by hotel and motel sales which will increase by 5.0 percent (CAGR) over the next ten years, and stronger automobile dealer 3.6. State Gross Domestic Product Inflation-adjusted state gross domestic product (GDP) grew by only 0.7 percent in 2013 but then rebounded in 2014, growing by 2.3 percent. Growth of 2.4 percent is expected for 2015 and 2.3 percent growth is projected for 2016. Similar growth was seen in the nation as real GDP advanced 2.4 percent in both 2014 and 2015 but is expected to see a faster 2.7 percent growth rate in 2016. Over the long-run forecast horizon, output in Tennessee is expected to continue growing at a similar albeit slightly slower trend, averaging roughly 2.2 percent growth per year over the next ten years. Table 3.3 presents a summary of the longrun outlook for inflation-adjusted state GDP. Between 2005 and 2015, inflation-adjusted state GDP grew by a sluggish 1.1 percent (CAGR) in Tennessee, which was slightly slower than the 1.4 percent compound annual growth rate that inflation-adjusted GDP registered for the nation. Of course, this time period encapsulates the Great Recession which suppressed output growth in the late 2000’s. Over the last decade, production in the construction sector and other services sector were hit hardest, falling by a compound annual growth rate of 1.5 percent each. The manufacturing sector 54 | sales, which are projected to grow by 4.6 percent (CAGR) between 2015 and 2025, compared to only 2.2 percent (CAGR) over the last ten years. Purchases from manufacturers will also increase by 3.9 percent (CAGR) in the next ten years, compared to only 0.1 percent (CAGR) growth between 2005 and 2015. 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT grew by a sluggish 0.8 percent (CAGR) between 2005 and 2015, but production has nearly clawed back to the pre-recession peak levels registered in 2006. Conversely, service sectors such as professional and business services and education and health services saw output grow by more than 2.5 percent (CAGR) over the last ten years. Financial activities output also expanded by 2.5 percent (CAGR) and natural resources and mining production grew by 2.3 percent (CAGR). Looking ahead ten years, inflation-adjusted state GDP will grow by 2.2 percent (CAGR) between 2015 and 2025. This is slightly slower than the 2.4 percent compound annual growth rate projected for national GDP. In Tennessee, professional and business services output is projected to grow the fastest over the next ten years, expanding by 3.7 percent (CAGR), followed by natural resources and mining output at 3.4 percent (CAGR). State manufacturing output will advance 2.3 percent (CAGR), as durable goods manufacturing production increases by 2.8 percent (CAGR) and nondurable goods manufacturing output grows 1.5 percent (CAGR). It is notable that manufacturing output will expand while manufacturing employment is expected to contract. The Tennessee Economy: Long-Term Outlook 3.6. | CHAPTER 3 State Gross Domestic Product, continued TableInflation-Adjusted 3.3: Tennessee Gross Table 3.3: Tennessee GrossInflation-Adjusted Domestic Product by Sector Domestic Product by Sector Level (millions of 2009 dollars) State Gross Domestic Product Natural Resources & Mining Construction Manufacturing Durable Goods Nondurable Goods Trade, Transportation, Utilities Wholesale Trade Retail Trade Transportation & Utilities Information Financial Activities Professional & Business Services Education & Health Services Leisure & Hospitality Other Services Government Federal State & Local *Compound Annual Growth Rate *Compound Annual Growth Rate Analysis and CBER-UT Source: Bureau of Economic 2005 252,717 2,553 11,319 43,954 26,116 17,838 52,831 18,420 20,139 14,272 7,424 35,367 25,285 22,995 11,330 7,496 32,163 8,507 23,656 2015 281,548 3,216 9,756 47,428 27,410 20,017 52,904 18,933 19,590 14,382 9,068 45,432 33,169 29,853 11,960 6,477 32,285 7,582 24,704 2025 349,209 4,486 12,058 59,291 36,122 23,170 65,661 24,685 23,870 17,106 11,988 56,876 47,691 36,806 14,349 6,060 33,943 6,214 27,729 Growth Rate (%)* 2005 to 2015 1.1 2.3 -1.5 0.8 0.5 1.2 0.0 0.3 -0.3 0.1 2.0 2.5 2.8 2.6 0.5 -1.5 0.0 -1.1 0.4 2015 to 2025 2.2 3.4 2.1 2.3 2.8 1.5 2.2 2.7 2.0 1.7 2.8 2.3 3.7 2.1 1.8 -0.7 0.5 -2.0 1.2 Source: Bureau of Economic Analysis and CBER-UT. 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT | 55 56 | 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT Tennessee’s Drive to 55: Background, Early Results, and Challenges Lying Ahead | CHAPTER 4 CHAPTER 4: TENNESSEE’S DRIVE TO 55: BACKGROUND, EARLY RESULTS, AND CHALLENGES LYING AHEAD In this chapter— 4.1. Introduction and Key Points 4.2. 4.3. The Landscape of College Progression in Tennessee Will “Free Community College” Make a Difference in Tennessee? Early Indicators 4.4. Challenges and Opportunities Changing the Culture of College Aspirations Undermatching Readiness and Research The Other 45 percent 4.5.Acknowledgements 4.6.References 4.1. Introduction and Key Points Tennessee’s “Drive to 55” is an effort initiated in 2013 to have 55 percent of working-age Tennesseans hold a higher education credential by 2025. The initiative has three major branches. Tennessee Promise focuses on young adults at the cusp between high school and college, offering state-funded grants to cover the gap between other sources of financial aid and community college tuition and fees. The underlying message, “Free Community College,” has proven to be compelling, in many cases instantly transforming a young person’s view of college. But with around 90,000 18-year old Tennesseans in a given year, Tennessee’s working-age population of 3.5 million will not meet the 55 percent threshold in twelve years by focusing exclusively on young, traditional college students. With this in mind, the second branch of Drive to 55 applies to older adults who might like to go back to school: if so, Tennessee Reconnect grants offer them free passage through the Tennessee College of Applied Technology system, which provides laser-focused vocational programs. And to ensure that Tennessee Promise and Reconnect do not operate with blinders to actual job opportunities, the relatively newer Tennessee LEAP intends to identify skill gaps in the state and align them with college programs. Stepping back a moment, why 55 percent? Influential 2012 and 2013 Georgetown University studies projected that by 2020, 55 – 58 percent of Tennessee jobs would require at least some college training, or conversely, that a high school diploma 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT | 57 CHAPTER 4 4.1. | Tennessee’s Drive to 55: Background, Early Results, and Challenges Lying Ahead Introduction and Key Points, continued would suffice for only 42 – 45 percent of jobs. This study, alongside the Lumina Foundation’s claim that 60 percent of Americans should hold a postsecondary credential by 2025 (“Goal 2025”), are typically cited as motivating factors behind Governor Haslam’s choice of 55 percent. This is not as high as the Lumina Foundation’s national target, but higher than the target implied by the Georgetown studies, which considered postsecondary certificates as equivalent to “some college, no degree.” Regardless, the state’s goal to raise postsecondary attainment to at least 55 percent within twelve years is rightly called a “moon launch” given that the starting point was closer to 36 percent. This chapter focuses on the first branch of Drive to 55, that is, Tennessee Promise efforts that aim to increase the flow of young people into college and through college successfully. If Promise and affiliated programs are able to build and sustain higher rates of college enrollment and completion among traditional-aged students, Drive to 55 efforts will outlive 2025 as new waves of young adults build the base of college-educated workers with each passing year. Section 1 surveys the pre-Promise landscape of student progression into college or the workforce after high school. Section 2 reviews early evidence on the effect of Promise and its privatelyfunded predecessors on college enrollment and persistence. Section 3 highlights some of the challenges and opportunities lying ahead. Key findings and points of discussion include: • Prior to Tennessee Promise, 54 - 55 percent of high school graduates enrolled in college shortly after graduation. Those that did not go to college earned just $8,715 – 8,838 the 4.2. | • • The Landscape of College Progression in Tennessee Before turning to early indicators of success for Tennessee Promise, we first survey the prePromise landscape of student progression through high school and into college. These patterns, 58 • year after graduation, on average, if they worked at all. Dropouts earned even less. Knox Achieves, one of the privatelyfunded initiatives that served as a model for Tennessee Promise, is linked to a 2 – 3 percentage-point greater rate of college enrollment among typical high school senior classes and a 3 – 5 percentage-point gain in community college enrollment. Results imply that most – but not all – of the students whose college decisions were swayed by the program chose college over work rather than a two-year college over a four-year college. Results from Knox Achieves foreshadowed the first year of Tennessee Promise. Firstyear student enrollment rose substantially across Tennessee’s public higher education systems, but large growth in two-year programs were possibly offset to a degree by declines in four-year university enrollment. Going forward, one challenge for the Tennessee Promise branch of the Drive to 55 will be to ensure that transfer pathways between two-year and four-year college sectors are seamless. At the same time, high rates of remedial education in twoyear colleges and low rates of degree or certificate completion call attention to college readiness and persistence. The state has a rich history of education policy research: more is needed now to identify cost-effective policies and programs that help students meet their postsecondary goals. Finally, factors behind economic security and success for “the other 45 percent” warrant closer examination. 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT which closely reproduce similar data reported by the Harvard Strategic Data Project and the state Department of Education, offer a detailed view of the Drive to 55 starting point as it relates to Tennessee’s Drive to 55: Background, Early Results, and Challenges Lying Ahead 4.2. | CHAPTER 4 The Landscape of College Progression in Tennessee, continued traditional college students. The extent to which these patterns change in the coming years will be one measure of the success of Tennessee Promise and the Drive to 55 more broadly. Student progression is defined by the education choices students make after reaching the age when they can legally leave school (17 in Tennessee) as well as evident career readiness for students who do not pursue college. Here, we document trends in on-time high school progression, on-time regular high school graduation, seamless college enrollment, and for students who do not go on to college, first-year workforce outcomes. We include timely progression through high school alongside postsecondary benchmarks because over the coming years, student success in high school may reasonably be affected by policies that make college more feasible. More specific definitions for student progression outcomes are as follows: • On-time 10th grade: enrolling in 10th grade one academic year after starting 9th grade. • On-time 11th grade: enrolling in 11th grade two academic years after starting 9th grade. • On-time 12th grade: enrolling in 12th grade three academic years after starting 9th grade. • On-time regular high school graduation: obtaining a regular high school diploma (not a GED) within four academic years of starting 9th grade. • Seamless college enrollment: enrolling in any college by October 1st following high school graduation. • For high school graduates who do not enroll in college the year after high school (by March 1st of the year after graduation), we identify several workforce outcomes from the first calendar year (January through December) after graduation. o Labor force participation: having any record of earnings in the state Unemployment Insurance (UI) data files. Note that this will exclude out-of state work, self-employment, some agricultural work, and military enlistment. o For graduates in the UI workforce, January through December earnings. o For graduates in the UI workforce, the dominant industry of employment. o For dropouts, labor force participation and earnings five years after starting 9th grade. We identified students who enrolled in Tennessee public schools as 9th graders in 20072008 and 2008-2009. Longitudinal data allow us to follow these students as they progressed through high school and into college or the workforce. Data were combined from administrative records held by the Tennessee Department of Education (TDOE), the Tennessee Higher Education Commission (including college enrollment records from the National Student Clearinghouse), and the Tennessee Department of Labor and Workforce Development.1 Table 1 illustrates typical student progression patterns. From here on we refer to cohorts by the academic year they began high school (so, students entering in 2008-2009 represent the cohort of 2009 9th graders) or the academic year in which they graduated (students graduating in 2010-2011 represent the 2011 graduating cohort). Trends depicted in Table 1 take place during a truly unique time that encompasses the Great Recession and its immediate aftermath. Significant job losses occurred in 2008 and 2009 and significant job gains were not realized until 2011, when the cohort of 2008 9th graders were typically in 12th grade and 2009 9th graders were in 11th grade. The annual state unemployment rate in Tennessee peaked at 10.5 percent in 2009 while the national rate peaked in the following year at 9.6 percent. Significant changes in labor force participation rates and inflation-adjusted earnings also occurred over this period of time. Many of these changes had a disproportionate effect on lower skilled and younger workers. Such patterns may have affected decisions on programs of study, college choice, and the tradeoff between work, college, and unemployment. These dramatic changes in the economy and labor market are 1 We exclude students who transferred out of Tennessee public schools prior to high school completion or prior to dropping out, but we include students who transferred in to Tennessee schools after 9th grade. We omit students in alternative or vocational high schools. 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT | 59 CHAPTER 4 4.2. | Tennessee’s Drive to 55: Background, Early Results, and Challenges Lying Ahead The Landscape of College Progression in Tennessee, continued Table 4.1: Timely Student Progression Among 2007 and 2008 9th Graders Table 4.1: Timely student progression among 2007 and 2008 9th graders Grade Spring year 9th 2008 C08 2009 C09 2010 10th 11th 12th Post-secondary C08 C09 2011 C08 C09 2012 2013 C08 C09 C08 2007 cohort C09 2008 cohort 2014 an important backdrop to all of the descriptive statistics discussed below.2 Table 2 lists descriptive statistics for each progression outcome, along with sample size. High school progression outcomes follow the expected pattern, with on time graduation noticeably less likely than on time 12th grade, which is less likely than on time 11th grade, which is less likely than on time 10th grade. We find that 87 - 88 percent of 9th graders in these cohorts completed high school within four years.3 Among all high school graduates, including ontime and late graduates, 51 – 52 percent seamlessly enrolled in college (whether part-time or fulltime is not known) by October 1st of the year they graduated. Just over 1 in 3 graduates went to a four-year college or university and just over 1 in 6 went to a two-year community college or technology center.4 What happened to graduates who did not go straight to college? We find that 3 percent of graduates enrolled after a break from school but no later than March 1st of the year after graduation. The majority of late enrollees attended two-year institutions. For those who did not enroll in college at all the year after graduation, we can get a very short-sighted view of their career readiness by examining Tennessee workforce outcomes. Using statewide records on earnings reported to the 2 See Chapter 4 of Murray et al. (2015) for a detailed analysis of structural changes in the labor market over the arc of the Great Recession. 3 Not shown in Table 2: another 1 - 2 percent of students graduated one or two years later. 4 These figures include enrollment at in-state, out-of-state, public, and private institutions. College enrollment data are drawn from the National Student Clearinghouse, a non-profit organization that maintains enrollment records for (as of this writing) well over 90 percent of postsecondary students. 60 | 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT Unemployment Insurance system,5 we find that just 2 out of 3 graduates who did not go straight to college were in the Tennessee workforce the year after graduation (Table 3). Of those who were working, nominal first-year earnings averaged $8,715 for the 2008 cohort (who would have typically graduated in 2011) and $8,838 for the 2009 cohort.6 Note that these low average earnings typically reference 2012 and 2013 calendar years, and thus they must be considered alongside the Great Recession cycle and its uneven impact on younger, lower skilled, less educated individuals. Three-quarters of graduates who did not go straight to college were found working in one of three industries the year after graduation: food and accommodation services, retail, or business services.7 The “business service” category includes finance, accounting, insurance, real estate, and 5 First-year earnings are measured over January – December of the year after high school graduation. Again, we note that Unemployment Insurance records exclude earnings from self-employment, earnings from other states, some forms of agricultural or domestic pay, and some federal earnings (including military pay). 6 These earnings are not adjusted for inflation, which measured about 1 percent between 2012 and 2013 when, respectively, the 2008 and 2009 9th grade cohorts were typically out of high school and working. The 2008 cohort’s inflation-adjusted earnings of $8,802 were very similar to $8,838 average earnings among the 2009 cohort. We do not observe hours worked, so it is not possible to directly discern who was working part-time and who was working full-time. A very small share of students had earnings that would exceed full-time pay at the minimum wage. 7 Industry participation is assessed from NAICS codes reported by employers to the Unemployment Insurance system. Individuals can be associated with more than one industry in a given year or in a given quarter. These statistics refer to the primary, or most frequent, industry of occupation in the year after high school, allowing for ties between two or more industries. Accordingly, industry percentages add up to more than 100 percent. NAICS data do not allow identification of an individual’s occupation. The NAICS code that an individual is linked to may change because his or her firm opted to identify under a difference NAICS (following a merger or change in operational focus, perhaps), although these instances are likely rare relative to the more common occurrence of a worker’s movement into a different firm and industry. Tennessee’s Drive to 55: Background, Early Results, and Challenges Lying Ahead 4.2. | CHAPTER 4 The Landscape of College Progression in Tennessee, continued Table 4.2: HighTable School Progression, Graduation, and College Enrollment Means by Cohort 4.2. High school progression, graduation, and college enrollment means by cohort Ninth-grade cohort (spring year of ninth grade) High school progression On time 10th grade (%) On time 11th grade (%) On time 12th grade (%) On time regular graduation (%) Sample size for high school progression outcomes Initial college enrollment (among graduates) Seamless college enrollment (% by October 1 following graduation) Seamless two-year college enrollment (% in community colleges and TCATs) Seamless four-year college enrollment (%) Late college enrollment (% by March 1st of the following year) Samples size for college enrollment outcomes (equal to the number of HS graduates) 2008 2009 95.5 95.0 92.7 87.0 96.1 95.9 93.7 88.0 67,932 68,124 51.9 17.3 34.5 3.0 50.8 16.7 34.1 2.9 59,158 59,936 Table 4.3: High School Graduates Who Do Not Go on to College: Workforce Participation, Table 4.3: High school graduates who do not go on to college: Workforce participation, earnings, and industry by cohort Earnings, and Industry by Cohort Ninth-grade cohort (spring year of ninth grade) 2008 2009 Tennessee workforce participation In Tennessee UI-covered labor force in the year following graduation (%) 66.7 65.9 26,682 27,742 Earnings first academic year after graduation (Q1 - Q4, not including zeros) $8,715 $8,838 Food service and accommodation (%) 29.36 30.09 Retail (%) 25.29 25.17 Business services (%) 22.00 22.33 Manufacturing (%) 6.40 6.65 Health (%) 6.05 5.40 Other services (%) 5.69 5.36 Transportation (%) 3.60 4.54 Construction (%) 3.42 3.10 Wholesale (%) 1.91 1.95 Professional services (%) 1.34 1.58 Arts (%) 1.55 1.35 Education (%) 1.34 1.38 Public services (%) 1.26 1.25 Mining, forestry, agriculture (%) < 1.0 < 1.0 Utilities (%) < 1.0 < 1.0 Unknown industry (%) < 1.0 < 1.0 17,785 18,270 Samples size for graduates' workforce participation Earnings and primary industry of employment Samples size for wage and industry outcomes Notes: An individual’s primary industry is the one identified more frequently than any other over the course of the calendar year. Primary industry shares add up to more than 100 Notes: An individual’s primary industry is theprimary one identified percent because we allow for ties between two or more industries.more frequently than any other over the course of the calendar year. Primary industry shares add up to more than 100 percent because we allow for ties between two or more primary industries. office administration, but the majority of graduates in business services appear to be associated with temporary employment services or employment placement services. Figure 1 illustrates first-year destinations for all high school graduates in the 2008 and 2009 cohorts, by region. The standout observation from Figure 1 is that for all three regions of the state – East, Middle, and West – four-year colleges and universities were the most frequent destinations among graduates, with two-year colleges a distant second. After college enrollment, the next most 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT | 61 CHAPTER 4 4.2. | Tennessee’s Drive to 55: Background, Early Results, and Challenges Lying Ahead The Landscape of College Progression in Tennessee, continued frequent destination is the workforce, describing almost 40,000 students who we have categorized by primary industry of employment in Figure 1. Over 18,000 students from these two cohorts were not observed in college or in the Tennessee workforce. Across all three regions, the most popular industries for students who did not enroll in college, by far, were food and accommodation services, retail, and business services. Another observation from Figure 1 is that East Tennessee high schools sent a higher share of graduates to two-year colleges (22 percent) than Middle or West Tennessee schools (13 – 15 percent). That distinction is even clearer in Figure 2, which illustrates 4-year and 2-year seamless college enrollment rates by county of students’ last high school.8 The bottom portion of Figure 2 also illustrates that geographic proximity to a fouryear college or university is aligned with four-year enrollment rates. Spatial clusters of relatively high four-year enrollment coincide with the location of Tennessee’s major four-year public institutions in the northwest, southwest, northeast, east-central, and central north parts of the state. Last, what happened to students who did not complete high school? As we show in Table 4, less than half were found working in the Tennessee workforce five years after starting high school, and of those who were working, average annual 8 Figure 2 depicts college enrollment rates by geographic boundaries, not by school district boundaries. City school districts are included with their respective counties. Figure 4.1: College or Workforce Destinations the Year After High School Graduation, by Region Notes: The figure depicts the first-year destinations of 119,094 high school graduates from the two cohorts starting 9th grade in 2007-2008 or 2008-2009, by the region of students’ last high school. 62 | 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT Tennessee’s Drive to 55: Background, Early Results, and Challenges Lying Ahead 4.2. | CHAPTER 4 The Landscape of College Progression in Tennessee, continued earnings were just $6,000 – 6,100.9 It is worth noting that non-completers conceivably had more time to find employment and work toward pay raises than graduates, and yet dropout earnings were substantially lower at roughly the same point in time. And for both graduates and noncompleters, annual earnings of $6,000 - $8,838 are well below the federal poverty line for a oneperson household ($11,170 in 2012 and $11,490 in 2013). 9 Non-completers’ primary industries of employment (not shown) followed a very similar pattern as that for graduates who did not go on to college (Table 3). Figure 4.2: Seamless College Enrollment Rates by County of First High School A. Two-year college and technology center enrollment rates 26.1 to 37.2% 19.2 to 26.1% 12.3 to 19.2% 3.7 to 12.3% Insufficient data B. Four-year college and university enrollment rates 36.6 to 65.5% 27.8 to 36.6% 19.1 to 27.8% 11.1 to 19.1% Insufficient data Notes: Seamless college enrollment is defined as attending college by October 1st after high school graduation. College enrollment includes attendance in any institution identified by the National Student Clearinghouse, including in-state, out-of-state, public, and private institutions. Color codes are aligned with standard deviations on college enrollment rates across counties. Table 4.4: High School Dropouts: Workforce Participation, Earnings, and Industry Five Years After 9th Grade, by and Cohort Table 4. High school dropouts: Workforce participation, earnings, industry five years after 9th grade, by cohort Ninth-grade cohort (spring year of ninth grade) In Tennessee UI-covered labor force five years after starting 9th grade (%) 2008 2009 47.7 48.9 Earnings five years after starting 9th grade (Q1 - Q4, not including zeros) $6,100 $6,000 Non-completer sample size 8,773 8,186 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT | 63 CHAPTER 4 4.3. | Tennessee’s Drive to 55: Background, Early Results, and Challenges Lying Ahead Will “Free Community College” Make A Difference in Tennessee? Early Indicators On January 9th, 2015, President Obama proposed “America’s College Promise,” a partnership between states and the federal government that would pay for two years of community college tuition for “everybody who’s willing to work for it.” The setting for this announcement – Pellissippi State Community College in Knoxville, Tennessee – coincided with the launch of Tennessee Promise. Nearly 58,000 students – the vast majority of eligible seniors – expressed interest in November 2014, and 31,000 were still active in the program as of April 2015. Prospective college students are not alone in their enthusiasm for Tennessee Promise. An astonishing 86 percent of registered voters approved of the initiative in a 2014 Vanderbilt poll. Will Tennessee Promise push more students into college and fundamentally change some of the patterns presented in the previous section? A CBER study by Celeste Carruthers and William Fox suggests it will. Tennessee Promise is a “last dollar” grant that covers the gap between state and federal scholarships (including “merit-based” Tennessee HOPE scholarships and “need-based” federal Pell grants) and the tuition and fees that students must pay to enroll. In a state where the median household income is $44,000 and 18 percent of the population lives below the poverty level, many students qualify for Pell grants that cover community college tuition, fees, and more. In-state tuition and fees for Tennessee community colleges amounted to $3,640 in 2013-2014, on average, while Pell grants were worth up to $5,645 in the same year. HOPE scholarships pay an additional $2,000 for eligible two-year students. Critics of last dollar programs are quick to point out that money does not actually flow to the neediest students, and moreover, that the cost of college does not stop at tuition. Books, supplies, transportation, child care, and living expenses are not covered by last dollar scholarships. This raises the question of why 58,000 students would sign up for financial aid that many of them will not receive. A strong and clear message – “Free Community College” – is surely one piece of that puzzle. 64 | 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT Students are not perfectly aware of their financial aid options, especially if they would be the first in their family to go to college. “Free Community College,” though not strictly correct (economists will tell you that nothing is free), is an attractive banner. In Tennessee, that message is paired with one-on-one mentoring throughout students’ senior year of high school. Mentors are unpaid volunteers from the community who guide students and their families through college and financial aid applications and help students plan for orientation, registration, and basic logistics. Mentors who have “been there” provide critical support and experience. Importantly, mentors alleviate the onerous federal financial aid process.10 The Free Application for Federal Student Aid (FAFSA) was never intended to be a college entrance exam, and yet for many students, it is just that because of its complexity. Researchers have found that helping students complete the FAFSA improves the chance they enroll. Driven by the first Promise cohort, dependent Tennessee students submitted 6.9 percent more FAFSAs in the first half of 2015 than they did in 2014. This was the largest yearover-year growth in the United States. The first wave of Tennessee Promise students – 16,291 ultimately enrolled, exceeding early expectations and pushing the freshman class up by 10 percent – are now in the midst of their second semester of college. It is too early to assess how many of those Promise students would not have been in college today without the program, or how long they will stay in college because of Tennessee Promise. But our study on the local initiative that inspired Tennessee Promise provides cause for optimism. Privately-funded Knox Achieves launched in 2008 to support Knox County high school seniors making a seamless transition into community colleges. After three years exclusively serving its home county, Knox Achieves took on the name Tennessee Achieves – and later, tnAchieves – and expanded eligibility to seniors in more than twenty 10 Within the largest Tennessee Promise partnering organization, tnAchieves, FAFSA guidance will shift from mentors to staff beginning with the 2015-2016 wave of Promise applicants. Tennessee’s Drive to 55: Background, Early Results, and Challenges Lying Ahead 4.3. CHAPTER 4 Will “Free Community College” Make A Difference in Tennessee? Early Indicators, continued counties throughout Middle and East Tennessee. We tested whether Knox County college enrollment rates changed after the introduction of Knox Achieves relative to college enrollment rates throughout East Tennessee and relative to Knox County’s own college enrollment rates prior to the class of 2009. Our major findings: • The share of Knox County high school seniors going straight to a community college (as opposed to work, the military, or a four-year college) rose 3 – 5 percentage points after Knox Achieves began. • College enrollment rates overall rose 2 – 3 percentage points, which means that most of the change in community college enrollment was coming from students who would not have gone to college otherwise. • Students who expressed interest in Knox Achieves were 24 percentage points more likely to go to college than similar students in other counties (who were not eligible) and 30 percentage points more likely to go to a community college. • Participants were also 5 percentage points less likely to enroll in a four-year college or university, and this finding was driven entirely by higher achieving and higher income students. Substituting away from four-year universities is concerning. Researchers have found that starting 4.4. | in a two-year college rather than a four-year college reduces the likelihood of completing a bachelor’s degree, even though most states have clearly defined transfer pathways between community colleges and universities. It is too early to tell how likely it is that Knox Achieves students will leave college with an associate’s or bachelor’s degree, or how quickly they will do so. Early signs are positive: participants earned 3 – 6 more college credits (equivalent to 1 – 2 additional classes) during the two years following high school. The Carruthers and Fox (2015) study suggests that the combination of a strong message, financial aid, and guided mentoring can increase college enrollment immediately after high school. This bodes well for Tennessee Promise as well as at least eleven similar proposals in other states. It is worth emphasizing that our work on Knox Achieves is, by necessity, non-experimental. Knox Achieves participants may have been intent on going to a community college in ways that we could not observe. This would tend to inflate our estimates of the program’s effect on college enrollment. Another caveat to keep in mind is that we focus on the classes of 2009 – 2011, who graduated in the midst of a slow economic recovery when job prospects were very limited for young people. For some, a more robust job market today may be a bigger draw than free community college. Challenges and Opportunities Section I documented baseline college enrollment rates and Section II discussed early results from a program much like Tennessee Promise. Here, we build on this context to point to challenges that may hinder Drive to 55 success as well as actionable policy opportunities that will get ahead of these issues. Changing the Culture of College Aspirations Janice Gilliam, Northeast State Community College president, was quoted in a recent Atlantic article about Tennessee Promise: “We have a lot of students who do not think about going to college. Some of their parents have not even finished high school. This is a huge step to break this cycle,” she says. “A lot of them don’t even know they have talent.” Local and national media stories about Promise students support Dr. Gilliam’s impression. “I didn’t think college was for me” is a common sentiment among Promise students, followed quickly by their story about how the promise of free community college reversed that notion. 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT | 65 CHAPTER 4 4.4. | Tennessee’s Drive to 55: Background, Early Results, and Challenges Lying Ahead Challenges and Opportunities, continued What many prospective Promise students do not realize, however, is that in reality the program provides a modest amount of aid, about $1,000 per student per year, typically, and that many of them could pay for community college tuition, fees, and more with federal and state grants and without a dollar from Promise. The high rate of federal Pell grant eligibility is the major reason that the Promise program can contain its cost to Tennessee taxpayers.11 One of the fundamental and underemphasized roles of Tennessee Promise, then, has been to offer a course correction for capable students who overestimate the cost of postsecondary education. The program has proven to be very successful at reshaping the college conversation that students have with their families, teachers, and counselors. Why wait until the senior year of high school to do this? If every high school freshman was more aware of the entry requirements for college – financial and scholastic – they would make more informed choices about life after high school graduation. And with a horizon that includes college, they might make better progress through high school coursework and ultimately require less remedial catch-up after enrolling in college. The widespread popularity of Tennessee Promise is already affecting the plans of younger students, but the program could go a step further and create an official point of contact prior to senior year. Bridging the information gap that students and families have about college readiness will help to raise college enrollment and smooth transitions into college. Undermatching In the same way that there is an information gap about college costs and admissions broadly speaking, students are often misinformed about their prospects at different types of colleges. A short time before the higher education policy environment was captivated by free community college, the issue du jour and focus of a January 2014 White House summit was “undermatching,” 11 This underscores one potential threat to the fiscal impact of Tennessee Promise. Federal changes to the generosity or scope of the Pell grant program will have a direct bearing on the typical size of Tennessee Promise grants. 66 | 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT that is, the idea that high achieving students are not best served by less selective colleges and universities. Undermatching can happen unintentionally if students are not aware of their admission and financial aid opportunities at more selective (and usually, costlier) schools. One study showed that merely providing students with this information increased the likelihood that they applied to and enrolled in public flagship universities or selective private universities, both of which tend to have more resources for students and higher graduation rates. Of course, undermatching may be deliberate on the part of students who have a strong preference for a particular school or region despite their prospects elsewhere. State policy may also play a role in undermatching. For some students, Tennessee Promise is certainly a nudge toward a community college rather than a four-year college or university. Although the 2015 freshman class was 10.1 percent greater in Tennessee public postsecondary institutions overall, large gains in two-year colleges and technology centers were offset to a degree by smaller freshman classes in some four-year universities. The 2015 entering class fell 13 percent at both the University of Tennessee-Martin and the University of Tennessee-Chattanooga. Early indications are that most of the students whose college choices are changed by Tennessee Promise are those who are unsure about going to college at all. For those who decide to start at a community college rather than a four-year college or university, however, a long line of research suggests that their likelihood of completing a bachelor’s degree is substantially lower. One study found that failure to transfer after accumulating 60 credits and the loss of credits upon transfer were two of the chief “choke points” that hindered community college students from attaining a bachelor’s degree. A broad structural solution to the undermatching problem, therefore, is to make the transition between two-year community colleges and four-year colleges and universities seamless for students who wish to attain a bachelor’s degree Tennessee’s Drive to 55: Background, Early Results, and Challenges Lying Ahead 4.4. | CHAPTER 4 Challenges and Opportunities, continued or greater. Tennessee already has a well-defined system of transfer pathways which are – in principle – the most cost-effective way for students to earn a bachelor’s degree in the state public postsecondary system. Whether this is true in practice, however, remains an open question, and more research and analysis is necessary in order to determine if there are unnecessary hurdles along these pathways. Another actionable policy response to undermatching is to ensure that Tennessee’s high school students are at least aware of their options in two-year and four-year college sectors. Tennessee already has two opportunities to do so. Tennessee is one of many states that aspires to have all high school students take the ACT. Test takers indicate up to four institutions to receive their official scores for free – additional score reports cost at least $12 and involve further action by students. Official ACT score reports serve as a formal channel between the ACT and college admissions offices, but also as a recruiting tool for colleges. The minor detail of how many schools a test-taker could list has had a remarkable effect on the quality of colleges that students ultimately choose. Tennessee’s ACT test-takers should be encouraged to send their scores to as many schools as they wish, and to include schools that they may incorrectly believe are out of their league. The second, newer opportunity to make students aware of their college options is a systemic part of Tennessee Promise itself. This initiative provides a new line of communication between students and state officials, partnering organizations, and volunteer mentors who all have the goal of helping more students get to college. This line of communication should include information about college options aside from those institutions eligible to receive Tennessee Promise students. The federal government has developed a valuable new tool for doing just that. The College Scorecard (https://collegescorecard.ed.gov/) allows prospective college students to quickly retrieve information describing U.S. colleges and universities, including costs, typical ACT or SAT scores of entering students, and even the typical post-college earnings of former students who – much like most Tennessee Promise students – received some form of federal financial aid. Readiness and Research Although undermatching is recognized as a nationwide issue that disproportionately affects lower-income high-achieving students, a far greater number of students find themselves overmatched when they enroll in a community college. In fact, the majority of two-year college students in Tennessee enroll unready for the challenges of postsecondary coursework: 59 percent require at least one remedial class and only 28 percent complete a degree within 6 years.12 The first year of Tennessee Promise has shown that it is remarkably easy to change the conversation about going to college, and student take-up in the program alongside their interest in college has exceeded expectations at each step. But elevating college readiness and the likelihood that students succeed in college will be harder and will require a closer examination of why students who earn a high school diploma and aspire to earn a two-year degree or more nevertheless struggle to do so. Innovative research is underway to test whether a dual-credit initiative in Tennessee can help students catch up before they leave high school. More research is necessary to identify impactful programs and policies that raise student persistence after enrolling. A wide and growing array of such interventions are already underway, including fresh approaches to mentoring and college coaching within Tennessee Promise partnering organizations, but to date, their effectiveness and cost-effectiveness are speculative. Tennessee has a strong history of improving on speculative hunches regarding educational practice. In the 1980s, there was considerable uncertainty about the benefits of smaller elementary classes, particularly when measured against the necessary costs of hiring more teachers to lead them. Determining if smaller classes benefitted students was complicated then, as now, by the fact that low student-to-teacher ratios do not arise by Tennessee Higher Education Fact Book: 2014-2015. 12 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT | 67 CHAPTER 4 4.4. | Tennessee’s Drive to 55: Background, Early Results, and Challenges Lying Ahead Challenges and Opportunities, continued chance. Smaller classes are often intertwined with other district and school advantages. Tennessee’s Project STAR experiment boldly tackled this problem by randomly assigning kindergarteners in 79 urban, suburban, and rural schools across the state to classes with 13 – 17 students or 22 – 25 students. This was one of the first large-scale field experiments in U.S. education, and despite imperfect execution, short-term and long-term results from Project STAR’s forerunning design inform education stakeholders to this day. A new generation of experimental research – this time, set in the state’s community college system – would go a long way toward identifying which higher education initiatives are pivotal in improving student retention and completion, and at what cost. The Other 45 Percent This chapter opened with an overview of the three branches of the Drive to 55. Aspiring to have 55 percent of working-age Tennesseans hold a postsecondary credential is a laudable goal and one that is supported by the best available research on the returns to higher education as well as the skill demands of the modern workforce. But a fourth branch, one that focuses on the other 45 percent, would provide a strong complement to the Drive to 55 strategy. A college degree is not the only path toward financial security and success for working-age adults. Some choose to enlist in the military after high school graduation; others choose to work in a skilled trade and earn industry certifications and licensures. There is abundant research on the payoff to enrolling in and completing college, but very little is known about the economic returns to credentials earned in the military or in work, nor is there a clear understanding of how the state and even the public higher education system can support the human capital development and career paths of individuals with no more than a high school diploma. Tennessee has a demonstrated interest in raising college and career-readiness throughout the state, and state agencies are well positioned to pursue and support research on open questions about workers who stop or fall short of a postsecondary certificate or degree. What are the factors behind financial security aside from college completion? Who succeeds outside of the college track, and why? What are the individual returns to military service? To industry licensure? To “sampling” a college program or enrolling in a MOOC (i.e. a massive, open online course)? Making headway on these and related questions will illuminate the other 45 percent of the Tennessee workforce and sharpen our understanding of success in and outside of college. 4.5.Acknowledgements The Section I analysis and discussion is drawn from a 2015 CBER report on student progression through high school and into college (Carruthers et al., 2015). That study was made possible by a contract with the Tennessee Consortium on Research, Evaluation, and Development (TNCRED) hosted at Vanderbilt University, and indirectly by Tennessee’s First to the Top award from the U.S. Department of Education. Portions of Section II review work by Carruthers and 68 | 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT Fox (2015), which was made possible by data from tnAchieves, the Tennessee Department of Education, and the Tennessee Higher Education Commission. The opinions expressed in this chapter do not represent those of the U.S. Department of Education or any Tennessee agency. Additionally, we are indebted to Antoniya Owens and others working with the Harvard Graduate School of Education Strategic Data Tennessee’s Drive to 55: Background, Early Results, and Challenges Lying Ahead 4.5. | CHAPTER 4 Acknowledgements, continued Project for many consultations regarding data processing. Their research on college-going in Tennessee has greatly informed our own. We are also grateful to staff members in tnAchieves, the Tennessee Department of Education, and the Tennessee Higher Education Commission for discussions related to data and policy. Jilleah Welch, Okila Elboeva, James Sheffield, and Marcus Bansah provided outstanding research assistance. 4.6.References Anderson, K. (2015). “Tennessee Promise ups enrollment at Chattanooga State, Cleveland State: University of Tennessee at Chattanooga enrollment declines.” Chattanooga Times Free Press. October 4th, 2015. Bettinger, E. P., Long, B. T., Oreopoulos, P., & Sanbonmatsu, L. (2012). The role of application assistance and information in college decisions: Results from the h&r block fafsa experiment*. The Quarterly Journal of Economics, 127(3), 1205-1242. Bound, J., Lovenheim, M. F., & Turner, S.. (2010). Why Have College Completion Rates Declined? An Analysis of Changing Student Preparation and Collegiate Resources. American Economic Journal: Applied Economics, 2(3), 129– 157. Carnevale, A. P., and N. Smith. (2012). A Decade Behind: Breaking Out of the Low-Skill Trap in the Southern Economy. Center on Education and the Workforce, Georgetown Public Policy Institute, Georgetown University. Carnevale, Anthony P., Nicole Smith, and Jeff Strohl. (2013). Recovery: Job Growth and Education Requirements through 2020. State Report. Center on Education and the Workforce, Georgetown Public Policy Institute, Georgetown University. Carruthers, Celeste K., Donald J. Bruce, William F. Fox, Matthew N. Murray (2015). Student Progression in the Wake of First to the Top. Prepared for the Tennessee Consortium on Research, Evaluation, and Development. Center for Business and Economic Research, University of Tennessee. Carruthers, C.K. and W.F. Fox (2015) “Aid for All: College coaching, financial aid, and postsecondary persistence in Tennessee.” Forthcoming in Economics of Education Review. Chetty, R., Friedman, J. N., Hilger, N., Saez, E., Schanzenbach, D. W., & Yagan, D. (2011). How does your kindergarten classroom affect your earnings? Evidence from Project STAR. Quarterly Journal of Economics 126: 1593-1660. Cook, Nancy. (2015). “The Power of Free Community College.” The Atlantic, September 5, 2015. Available online: http://www. theatlantic.com/business/archive/2015/09/ free-college-in-tennessee/403945/ Center for the Study of Democratic Institutions, (May 2014), “Ninth Vanderbilt University Poll.” Dynarski, D., S. Hemelt, N. Schwartz. (2014). “Dual Credit Courses and the Road to College: Experimental Evidence from Tennessee.” Grant No. R305H140028, Institute of Education Sciences, U.S. Department of Education. Dynarski, S., J. Scott-Clayton, and M. Wiederspan. (2013). “Simplifying tax incentives and aid for college: Progress and prospects.” National Bureau of Economic Research Working Paper No. 18707. Farmer, Blake. (2013). “Average Wage for TN High School Grads Drops $4,000 in Five Years; Governor Sees Moral Responsibility to Intervene.” WPLN Public Radio News Archive: September 4, 2013. 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT | 69 CHAPTER 4 4.6. | Tennessee’s Drive to 55: Background, Early Results, and Challenges Lying Ahead References, continued Federal Student Aid (2015). FAFSA® Volume Reports. U.S. Department of Education. Goodman, J., M. Hurwitz, and J. Smith (2015). “College access, initial college choice and degree completion.” National Bureau of Economic Research Working Paper No. 20996. House, E. (2015). “Tennessee Promise: Fall 2015 Update.” Tennessee Higher Education Commission Fall Quarterly Meeting: November 19, 2015. Hoxby, C. and S. Turner. (2013). Expanding College Opportunities for High-Achieving, Low Income Students. SIEPR Discussion Paper 12-014. Lee, Jessica A. (9/17/2105). “Rethinking community college to boost enrollment and completion.” Brookings Institution. Lumina Foundation. (2013). A Stronger Nation through Higher Education: Visualizing data to help us achieve a big goal for college attainment. Lumina Foundation for Education, Inc. Monaghan, D. B., & Attewell, P. (2015). The community college route to the bachelor’s degree. Educational Evaluation and Policy Analysis, 37(1), 70-91. Mosteller, F. (1995). The Tennessee Study of Class Size in the Early School Grades. The Future of Children Summer/Fall: 113-127. 70 | 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT Murray, Matthew N., and William F. Fox, Lawrence M. Kessler, Matthew C. Harris, Vickie C. Cunningham, and Mary Elizabeth Glenn. (2015). An Economic Report to the Governor of the State of Tennessee. University of Tennessee Center for Business and Economic Research. http://cber.bus.utk.edu/erg/erg2015.pdf Pallais, A. (2015). Small Differences That Matter: Mistakes in Applying to College. Journal Of Labor Economics, 33(2), 493-520. Smith, A. (2015). “Promise Provides Enrollment Boost.” Inside Higher Ed. November 24, 2015. Smith, J. and K. Stange. (2015). A New Measure of College Quality to Study the Effects of College Sector and Peers on Degree Attainment. National Bureau of Economic Research Working Paper No. 21605. SDP College-Going Diagnostic: Tennessee Department of Education (2015). Strategic Data Project, Center for Education Policy Research, Harvard University. Tamburin, A. (2015). “College enrollment jumps under TN Promise.” The Tennessean. September 12, 2015. Tennessee Higher Education Fact Book: 2014-2015. (2015). Tennessee Higher Education Commission. Forecast Data | APPENDIX A APPENDIX A: FORECAST DATA In this section— Appendix A: Forecast Data Quarterly Annual pages 2–25 (2015:4 to 2018:1) pages 26–40 (2015 to 2025) Quarterly Forecast Tables Table 1: Table 2: Table 3: Table 4: Table 5: Table 6: Table 7: Table 8: Table 9: Table 10: Table 11: Table 12: Table 13: Table 14: Table 15: Table 16: Table 17: Table 18: Table 19: Table 20: Selected U.S. and Tennessee Economic Indicators, Seasonally Adjusted......................................................................................................2 Selected Per Capita U.S. and Tennessee Economic Indicators, Seasonally Adjusted....................................................................................4 Tennessee Personal Income Components, Seasonally Adjusted (millions of 2009 dollars)...........................................................................5 Tennessee Personal Income Components, Seasonally Adjusted Annual Rates (millions of current dollars)..................................................6 Tennessee Nonfarm Employment by Sector, Not Seasonally Adjusted (thousands of jobs)...........................................................................7 Tennessee Durable Goods Manufacturing Employment, Not Seasonally Adjusted (thousands of jobs).........................................................8 Tennessee Nondurable Goods Manufacturing Employment, Not Seasonally Adjusted (thousands of jobs)...................................................9 Tennessee Nonfarm Employment by Sector, Seasonally Adjusted (thousands of jobs)...............................................................................10 Tennessee Durable Goods Manufacturing Employment, Seasonally Adjusted (thousands of jobs).............................................................12 Tennessee Nondurable Goods Manufacturing Employment, Seasonally Adjusted (thousands of jobs).......................................................13 Tennessee Average Annual Wage and Salary Rate by Sector, Not Seasonally Adjusted (2009 dollars)......................................................14 Tennessee Average Annual Wage and Salary Rate by Sector, Seasonally Adjusted (2009 dollars)............................................................15 Tennessee Average Annual Wage and Salary Rate by Sector, Not Seasonally Adjusted (current dollars)...................................................17 Tennessee Average Annual Wage and Salary Rate by Sector, Seasonally Adjusted (current dollars).........................................................18 Tennessee Civilian Labor Force and Unemployment Rate, Not Seasonally Adjusted..................................................................................20 Tennessee Civilian Labor Force and Unemployment Rate, Seasonally Adjusted.........................................................................................21 Tennessee Taxable Sales, Not Seasonally Adjusted (millions of 2009 dollars).............................................................................................22 Tennessee Taxable Sales, Seasonally Adjusted (millions of 2009 dollars)....................................................................................................23 Tennessee Taxable Sales, Not Seasonally Adjusted (millions of current dollars)..........................................................................................24 Tennessee Taxable Sales, Seasonally Adjusted (millions of current dollars)................................................................................................25 Annual Forecast Tables Table 1: Table 2: Table 3: Table 4: Table 5: Table 6: Table 7: Table 8: Table 9: Table 10: Table 11: Table 12: Table 13: Table 14: Selected U.S. and Tennessee Economic Indicators, Seasonally Adjusted....................................................................................................26 Selected Per Capita U.S. and Tennessee Economic Indicators.....................................................................................................................27 Tennessee Personal Income Components (millions of 2009 dollars)............................................................................................................28 Tennessee Personal Income Components (millions of current dollars).........................................................................................................29 Tennessee Nonfarm Employment by Sector (thousands of jobs)..................................................................................................................30 Tennessee Durable Goods Manufacturing Employment (thousands of jobs)................................................................................................31 Tennessee Nondurable Goods Manufacturing Employment (thousands of jobs)..........................................................................................32 Tennessee Average Annual Wage and Salary Rate by Sector (2009 dollars)...............................................................................................33 Tennessee Average Annual Wage and Salary Rate by Sector (current dollars)............................................................................................34 Tennessee Civilian Labor Force and Unemployment Rate............................................................................................................................35 Tennessee Taxable Sales (millions of 2009 dollars)......................................................................................................................................36 Tennessee Taxable Sales (millions of current dollars)...................................................................................................................................37 Tennessee Gross Domestic Product by Sector (millions of 2009 dollars).....................................................................................................38 Tennessee Gross Domestic Product by Sector (millions of current dollars)..................................................................................................40 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT | 1 January 2016 | Forecast Data 2016:1 2016:2 2016:3 2016:4 2017:1 2017:2 2017:3 2017:4 2018:1 2014 Annual 2015 2016 2017 US GDP (Bil$) SAAR………………………………18060.2 18181.2 18391.4 18614.9 18860.4 19106.9 19318.4 19560.9 19794.5 20000.1 20259.9 17348.1 17951.1 18743.4 19668.4 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………………………… 3.31 2.71 4.70 4.95 5.38 5.33 4.50 5.12 4.86 4.22 5.30 4.11 3.48 4.41 4.94 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………… 3.07 3.21 4.20 3.91 4.43 5.09 5.04 5.08 4.95 4.67 4.87 4.11 3.48 4.41 4.94 TN PERSONAL INCOME (MIL2009$) SAAR… 254215 257680 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………………………… 2.55 5.56 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………… 4.58 4.56 US PERSONAL INCOME (BIL2009$) SAAR…… 14095 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………………………… 3.76 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………… 4.41 14224 3.73 3.98 TN PERSONAL INCOME (MIL$) SAAR…………278958 282614 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………………………… 3.84 5.35 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………… 4.85 4.89 US PERSONAL INCOME (BIL$) SAAR………… 15468 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………………………… 5.09 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………… 4.69 15614 3.84 4.40 TN NONFARM JOBS (THOUS)………………… 2874.9 2900.1 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………………………… 1.97 3.57 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………… 1.79 2.00 260384 262090 263075 264591 266717 268147 269586 271585 273120 4.26 2.65 1.51 2.33 3.25 2.16 2.16 3.00 2.28 4.40 3.75 3.48 2.68 2.43 2.31 2.48 2.64 2.40 14360 3.88 3.61 14435 2.10 3.36 14500 1.80 2.87 14604 2.90 2.67 14759 4.33 2.78 14879 3.28 3.07 14976 2.65 3.29 15100 3.35 3.40 15230 3.49 3.19 285656 288832 292132 295513 298903 302294 305795 309386 312604 4.37 4.52 4.65 4.71 4.67 4.62 4.71 4.78 4.22 5.27 4.52 4.72 4.56 4.64 4.66 4.68 4.69 4.58 15750 3.52 4.44 15894 3.70 4.04 16073 4.59 3.91 16276 5.14 4.24 16502 5.67 4.77 16722 5.45 5.21 16933 5.14 5.35 17145 5.10 5.34 17390 5.84 5.38 2906.8 2914.1 2921.4 2929.6 2940.2 2950.6 2961.5 2972.7 2982.4 0.92 1.01 1.01 1.13 1.45 1.42 1.49 1.53 1.30 2.10 1.85 1.62 1.02 1.15 1.25 1.37 1.47 1.43 242848 253482 262535 269009 2.28 4.38 3.57 2.47 2.28 4.38 3.57 2.47 13468 2.98 2.98 14036 4.22 4.22 14475 3.12 3.12 14929 3.14 3.14 264965 277316 290533 304095 3.74 4.66 4.77 4.67 3.74 4.66 4.77 4.67 14694 4.45 4.45 15360 4.53 4.53 15998 4.16 4.16 16825 5.17 5.17 2816.1 2870.7 2918.0 2956.2 2.08 1.94 1.65 1.31 2.08 1.94 1.65 1.31 US NONFARM JOBS (MIL)……………………… 142.2 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………………………… 1.77 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………… 2.05 142.9 1.86 1.90 143.6 1.87 1.81 144.1 1.45 1.74 144.6 1.39 1.64 145.1 1.32 1.51 145.6 1.42 1.39 145.9 1.01 1.28 146.4 1.20 1.24 146.8 1.28 1.23 147.2 1.14 1.16 139.0 1.93 1.93 141.9 2.10 2.10 144.3 1.67 1.67 146.2 1.29 1.29 TN MFG JOBS (THOUS)………………………… 331.5 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………………………… 1.00 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………… 1.74 332.7 1.53 1.17 333.0 0.37 0.60 333.4 0.41 0.78 334.0 0.71 0.75 334.7 0.85 0.58 335.3 0.73 0.67 335.8 0.68 0.74 336.4 0.62 0.72 337.0 0.80 0.71 337.6 0.70 0.70 325.2 2.13 2.13 331.5 1.93 1.93 333.7 0.68 0.68 336.1 0.71 0.71 US MFG JOBS (MIL)……………………………… 12.3 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………………………… -0.05 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………… 1.04 12.3 -0.41 0.35 12.3 -0.51 -0.17 12.3 -0.40 -0.34 12.3 0.10 -0.31 12.4 1.94 0.28 12.4 1.36 0.74 12.4 -0.02 0.84 12.4 0.80 1.02 12.5 1.11 0.81 12.5 0.71 0.65 12.2 1.41 1.41 12.3 1.12 1.12 12.3 -0.14 -0.14 12.4 0.85 0.85 TN UNEMPLOYMENT RATE (%)……………… 5.7 5.6 5.6 5.6 5.5 5.5 5.5 5.4 5.4 5.4 5.4 6.6 5.9 5.5 5.4 US UNEMPLOYMENT RATE (%)……………… 5.2 5.0 5.0 4.9 4.9 4.9 4.9 4.9 4.9 4.9 4.9 6.2 5.3 4.9 4.9 (CONTINUED ON NEXT PAGE) Forecast Data US GDP (Bil2009$) SAAR……………………… 16414.0 16462.5 16586.4 16708.4 16844.5 16983.1 17096.3 17225.3 17338.9 17437.6 17567.0 15961.7 16346.8 16780.6 17274.5 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………………………… 1.98 1.19 3.04 2.98 3.30 3.33 2.69 3.05 2.66 2.30 3.00 2.43 2.41 2.65 2.94 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………… 2.15 1.93 2.53 2.29 2.62 3.16 3.07 3.09 2.94 2.68 2.75 2.43 2.41 2.65 2.94 | 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT History 2015:3 2015:4 APPENDIX A 2 Table 1: Selected U.S. and Tennessee Economic Indicators, Seasonally Adjusted Table 1: Selected U.S. and Tennessee Economic Indicators, Seasonally Adjusted History 2015:3 2015:4 January 2016 Forecast Data 2016:1 2016:2 2016:3 2016:4 2017:1 2017:2 2017:3 2017:4 2018:1 2014 Annual 2015 2016 2017 CHAINED PRICE INDEX, GDP (2009=100.0)……………...........................… 110.0 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………………………… 1.32 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………… 0.91 110.4 1.44 1.25 110.9 1.61 1.62 111.4 1.92 1.57 112.0 2.02 1.75 112.5 1.93 1.87 113.0 1.76 1.91 113.6 2.00 1.93 114.2 2.14 1.96 114.7 1.88 1.95 115.3 2.23 2.06 108.7 1.64 1.64 109.8 1.04 1.04 111.7 1.70 1.70 113.9 1.94 1.94 US PERS CONSUMP DEFL (2009=100.0)…… 109.7 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………………………… 1.28 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………… 0.27 109.8 0.11 0.41 109.7 -0.34 0.81 110.1 1.57 0.65 110.9 2.75 1.01 111.5 2.18 1.53 111.8 1.28 1.94 112.4 2.10 2.08 113.1 2.43 2.00 113.5 1.69 1.87 114.2 2.28 2.12 109.1 1.43 1.43 109.4 0.29 0.29 110.5 1.00 1.00 112.7 1.97 1.97 CONSUMER PRICE INDEX, ALL-URBAN (82-84=1.000)…………………… 2.379 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………………………… 1.58 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………… 0.14 2.381 0.33 0.43 2.374 -1.09 0.94 2.386 1.95 0.68 2.409 4.03 1.28 2.427 2.94 1.94 2.435 1.44 2.58 2.452 2.69 2.77 2.471 3.24 2.57 2.483 1.98 2.33 2.501 2.95 2.71 2.367 1.61 1.61 2.370 0.13 0.13 2.399 1.21 1.21 2.460 2.56 2.56 3.3 3.3 3.5 3.8 4.0 4.3 4.5 4.8 5.0 5.3 5.5 3.3 3.3 3.9 4.9 FEDERAL FUNDS RATE (% per annum)……… 0.137 0.152 0.483 0.787 1.037 1.290 1.533 1.787 2.037 2.290 2.533 0.089 0.131 0.899 1.912 30-YEAR FIXED MORTGAGE RATE (%)……… 4.0 3.9 4.2 4.4 4.5 4.6 4.7 4.7 4.8 4.9 5.0 4.2 3.9 4.4 4.7 TN TAXABLE SALES (MIL2009$)……………… 26228 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………………………… 9.46 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………… 7.21 26353 1.91 5.48 26392 0.59 7.62 26580 2.88 3.66 26635 0.83 1.55 26708 1.10 1.35 26795 1.31 1.53 26878 1.24 1.12 26954 1.14 1.20 27127 2.59 1.57 27230 1.52 1.62 97036 102746 106315 107755 3.41 5.88 3.47 1.35 3.41 5.88 3.47 1.35 TN TAXABLE SALES (MIL$)…………………… 28781 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………………………… 10.84 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………… 7.49 28903 1.70 5.82 28953 0.70 8.52 29292 4.76 4.43 29577 3.95 2.77 29829 3.45 3.20 30028 2.70 3.71 30301 3.67 3.44 30575 3.67 3.37 30903 4.37 3.60 31167 3.45 3.79 105877 112414 117652 121807 4.89 6.17 4.66 3.53 4.89 6.17 4.66 3.53 TN AVG ANNUAL WAGE, NONFARM (2009$)…………….......................………..... 43269 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………………………… -0.11 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………… 3.46 43666 3.72 3.10 43973 2.85 3.64 44087 1.04 1.86 44059 -0.26 1.82 44111 0.48 1.02 44274 1.48 0.68 44313 0.35 0.51 44347 0.30 0.65 44461 1.04 0.79 44544 0.75 0.61 41961 1.18 1.18 43161 2.86 2.86 44058 2.08 2.08 44349 0.66 0.66 TN AVG ANNUAL WAGE, NONFARM ($)……… 47481 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………………………… 1.14 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………… 3.73 47891 3.50 3.44 48241 2.96 4.51 48586 2.89 2.62 48925 2.82 3.04 49266 2.82 2.87 49616 2.87 2.85 49956 2.77 2.82 50303 2.81 2.82 50649 2.78 2.81 50984 2.67 2.76 45782 2.62 2.62 47219 3.14 3.14 48755 3.25 3.25 50131 2.82 2.82 Center for Business and Economic Research, University of Tennessee Tennessee Econometric Model Forecast Data | | 3 APPENDIX A 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT BANK PRIME INTEREST RATE (%)…………… January 2016 | Forecast Data 2015:4 2016:1 2016:2 2016:3 2016:4 2017:1 2017:2 2017:3 2017:4 2018:1 2014 Annual 2015 2016 2017 50944 1.16 1.39 50990 0.37 1.14 51270 2.21 1.70 51542 2.14 1.47 51857 2.46 1.79 52178 2.50 2.33 52420 1.87 2.24 52709 2.23 2.26 52950 1.84 2.11 53145 1.48 1.85 53432 2.18 1.93 49964 1.68 1.68 50787 1.65 1.65 51712 1.82 1.82 52807 2.12 2.12 US GDP ($) SAAR…………………………… 55712 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………………… 5.27 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………… 2.95 56053 2.47 2.31 56314 1.87 2.41 56849 3.86 3.36 57423 4.10 3.07 58063 4.53 3.59 58703 4.48 4.24 59233 3.66 4.19 59856 4.27 4.24 60449 4.02 4.11 60954 3.39 3.84 61623 4.46 4.03 54304 3.35 3.35 55771 2.70 2.70 57761 3.57 3.57 60125 4.09 4.09 TN PERSONAL INCOME (2009$) SAAR…… 37949 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………………… 4.14 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………… 3.39 38089 1.49 3.49 38509 4.47 3.47 38812 3.19 3.32 38966 1.60 2.68 39013 0.47 2.42 39137 1.28 1.63 39352 2.21 1.39 39462 1.13 1.27 39574 1.14 1.44 39767 1.96 1.61 39892 1.26 1.37 36816 1.20 1.20 38028 3.29 3.29 38982 2.51 2.51 39539 1.43 1.43 US PERSONAL INCOME (2009$) SAAR…… 43433 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………………… 2.22 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………… 3.50 43746 2.92 3.63 44058 2.89 3.18 44389 3.04 2.76 44530 1.27 2.53 44638 0.97 2.04 44868 2.07 1.84 45254 3.49 1.95 45529 2.45 2.24 45735 1.83 2.46 46021 2.52 2.57 46324 2.66 2.36 42157 2.23 2.23 43609 3.44 3.44 44607 2.29 2.29 45635 2.31 2.31 TN PERSONAL INCOME ($) SAAR………… 41512 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………………… 6.44 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………… 3.65 41797 2.77 3.77 42235 4.26 3.81 42579 3.30 4.18 42942 3.45 3.44 43322 3.58 3.65 43711 3.64 3.50 44100 3.61 3.57 44488 3.56 3.60 44889 3.66 3.62 45302 3.73 3.64 45659 3.19 3.53 40168 2.65 2.65 41603 3.57 3.57 43139 3.69 3.69 44695 3.61 3.61 US PERSONAL INCOME ($) SAAR………… 47512 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………………… 4.48 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………… 3.76 48007 4.24 3.91 48363 3.00 3.60 48684 2.69 3.60 49029 2.87 3.19 49482 3.75 3.07 50005 4.29 3.40 50597 4.82 3.93 51169 4.60 4.37 51711 4.30 4.50 52252 4.26 4.49 52893 5.00 4.54 45996 3.69 3.69 47720 3.75 3.75 49301 3.31 3.31 51434 4.33 4.33 TN TAXABLE SALES (2009$)……………… % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………………… % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………… 3852 18.31 6.59 3930 8.33 6.09 3938 0.86 4.38 3934 -0.44 6.51 3952 1.83 2.59 3950 -0.20 0.51 3951 0.07 0.31 3953 0.29 0.49 3956 0.22 0.09 3957 0.13 0.17 3972 1.56 0.55 3977 0.51 0.60 14710 2.32 2.32 15414 4.78 4.78 15786 2.42 2.42 15838 0.33 0.33 TN TAXABLE SALES ($)…………………… % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………………… % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………… 4214 20.93 6.86 4312 9.69 6.38 4319 0.65 4.72 4316 -0.33 7.40 4355 3.69 3.35 4386 2.89 1.71 4412 2.40 2.15 4430 1.66 2.66 4459 2.63 2.39 4488 2.63 2.33 4525 3.32 2.56 4552 2.42 2.75 16050 3.78 3.78 16864 5.07 5.07 17469 3.59 3.59 17903 2.48 2.48 Center for Business and Economic Research, University of Tennessee Tennessee Econometric Model Forecast Data US GDP (2009$) SAAR………………….…… 50798 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………………… 3.08 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………… 1.95 | 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT History 2015:2 2015:3 APPENDIX A 4 Table 2: Selected Per Capita U.S. and Tennessee Economic Indicators, Seasonally Adjusted Table 3: Tennessee Personal Income Components, Seasonally Adjusted Annual Rates (millions of 2009 dollars) History 2015:2 2015:3 January 2016 Forecast Data 2015:4 2016:1 2016:2 2016:3 2016:4 2017:1 2017:2 2017:3 2017:4 2018:1 2014 Annual 2015 2016 2017 TN PERSONAL INCOME…………...………252618 254215 257680 260384 262090 263075 264591 266717 268147 269586 271585 273120 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR……………… 5.23 2.55 5.56 4.26 2.65 1.51 2.33 3.25 2.16 2.16 3.00 2.28 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………… 4.47 4.58 4.56 4.40 3.75 3.48 2.68 2.43 2.31 2.48 2.64 2.40 242848 253482 262535 269009 2.28 4.38 3.57 2.47 2.28 4.38 3.57 2.47 WAGES AND SALARIES………………124682 125258 126977 128451 129300 129704 130334 131279 131841 132409 133239 133940 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR……………… 10.39 1.86 5.60 4.73 2.67 1.25 1.96 2.93 1.72 1.74 2.53 2.12 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………… 5.48 5.29 4.71 5.60 3.70 3.55 2.64 2.20 1.97 2.09 2.23 2.03 119019 124639 129447 132192 3.26 4.72 3.86 2.12 3.26 4.72 3.86 2.12 27846 1.30 3.13 28123 4.04 3.42 28407 4.10 4.02 28563 2.21 2.91 28654 1.28 2.90 28811 2.21 2.44 29041 3.23 2.23 29208 2.32 2.26 29365 2.16 2.48 29561 2.70 2.60 29715 2.10 2.32 27148 -2.03 -2.03 27759 2.25 2.25 28609 3.06 3.06 29294 2.39 2.39 PROPRIETORS INCOME……………… 33497 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR……………… 2.70 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………… 4.11 33913 5.07 4.93 34440 6.35 4.69 34721 3.31 4.35 35009 3.37 4.52 35158 1.71 3.67 35347 2.17 2.63 35655 3.53 2.69 35796 1.59 2.25 36004 2.34 2.41 36351 3.91 2.84 36635 3.17 2.75 32225 4.11 4.11 33781 4.83 4.83 35059 3.78 3.78 35952 2.55 2.55 RENT, INTEREST, DIVIDENDS……… 35625 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR……………… 4.24 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………… 3.64 35876 2.84 4.16 36259 4.34 4.19 36619 4.03 3.86 36802 2.02 3.30 36926 1.36 2.93 37203 3.03 2.60 37574 4.04 2.61 37857 3.05 2.87 38109 2.69 3.20 38441 3.53 3.33 38738 3.13 3.10 34428 2.64 2.64 35754 3.85 3.85 36888 3.17 3.17 37995 3.00 3.00 TRANSFER PAYMENTS……………… 52135 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR……………… -2.71 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………… 4.14 52411 2.14 3.72 53076 5.18 4.53 53500 3.23 1.92 53742 1.82 3.08 53907 1.24 2.86 54151 1.82 2.02 54482 2.46 1.83 54732 1.85 1.84 54944 1.56 1.92 55241 2.18 2.01 55415 1.26 1.71 50249 0.91 0.91 52529 4.54 4.54 53825 2.47 2.47 54850 1.90 1.90 LESS: PERS CONT FOR SOC INS… 19797 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR……………… 8.83 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………… 4.39 19829 0.66 4.29 19936 2.16 3.30 20054 2.40 3.47 20071 0.34 1.39 20028 -0.85 1.00 20013 -0.29 0.39 20075 1.24 0.10 20056 -0.37 -0.07 20020 -0.73 -0.04 20027 0.14 0.07 20107 1.62 0.16 19059 2.52 2.52 19736 3.55 3.55 20042 1.55 1.55 20045 0.01 0.01 RESIDENCE ADJUSTMENT…………… -1280 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR……………… 40.83 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………… 10.80 -1259 -6.30 9.00 -1259 -0.01 6.60 -1260 0.18 7.22 -1255 -1.45 -1.93 -1247 -2.67 -0.99 -1241 -1.96 -1.48 -1238 -0.99 -1.77 -1231 -2.00 -1.91 -1225 -2.05 -1.75 -1221 -1.30 -1.58 -1216 -1.67 -1.75 -1163 -5.89 -5.89 -1243 6.94 6.94 -1251 0.58 0.58 -1229 -1.75 -1.75 PER CAPITA PERSONAL INCOME ($)… 37949 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR……………… 4.14 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………… 3.39 38089 1.49 3.49 38509 4.47 3.47 38812 3.19 3.32 38966 1.60 2.68 39013 0.47 2.42 39137 1.28 1.63 39352 2.21 1.39 39462 1.13 1.27 39574 1.14 1.44 39767 1.96 1.61 39892 1.26 1.37 36816 1.20 1.20 38028 3.29 3.29 38982 2.51 2.51 39539 1.43 1.43 Center for Business and Economic Research, University of Tennessee Tennessee Econometric Model Forecast Data | | 5 APPENDIX A 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT OTHER LABOR INCOME……………… 27756 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR……………… 6.70 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………… 2.38 January 2016 | Forecast Data 2015:4 2016:1 2016:2 2016:3 2016:4 2017:1 2017:2 2017:3 2017:4 2018:1 2014 Annual 2015 2016 2017 264965 277316 290533 304095 3.74 4.66 4.77 4.67 3.74 4.66 4.77 4.67 WAGES AND SALARIES………………… 136391 137449 139264 140918 142493 144030 145565 147121 148630 150194 151784 153303 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………………… 12.83 3.14 5.38 4.84 4.55 4.38 4.33 4.34 4.17 4.27 4.30 4.06 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr………………… 5.75 5.57 5.05 6.48 4.47 4.79 4.52 4.40 4.31 4.28 4.27 4.20 129859 136360 143252 149432 4.73 5.01 5.05 4.31 4.73 5.01 5.05 4.31 OTHER LABOR INCOME………………… 30362 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………………… 9.05 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr………………… 2.64 30556 2.58 3.40 30845 3.83 3.75 31164 4.21 4.89 31477 4.08 3.67 31819 4.41 4.13 32178 4.59 4.32 32545 4.65 4.43 32928 4.78 4.61 33309 4.71 4.68 33676 4.48 4.65 34011 4.04 4.50 29620 -0.63 -0.63 30369 2.53 2.53 31659 4.25 4.25 33114 4.60 4.60 PROPRIETORS INCOME………………… 36642 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………………… 4.97 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr………………… 4.38 37214 6.39 5.21 37772 6.13 5.03 38091 3.42 5.22 38581 5.25 5.29 39041 4.85 4.91 39478 4.55 4.52 39958 4.95 4.90 40355 4.03 4.60 40840 4.90 4.61 41411 5.71 4.90 41932 5.13 4.94 35161 5.60 5.60 36957 5.11 5.11 38798 4.98 4.98 40641 4.75 4.75 RENT, INTEREST, DIVIDENDS………… 38971 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………………… 6.55 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr………………… 3.90 39368 4.13 4.44 39768 4.13 4.53 40173 4.14 4.73 40557 3.88 4.07 41005 4.49 4.16 41551 5.43 4.48 42108 5.47 4.82 42678 5.53 5.23 43228 5.25 5.42 43791 5.32 5.39 44338 5.09 5.30 37563 4.10 4.10 39116 4.13 4.13 40822 4.36 4.36 42951 5.22 5.22 TRANSFER PAYMENTS………………… 57031 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………………… -0.56 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr………………… 4.40 57512 3.42 3.99 58212 4.96 4.87 58692 3.34 2.77 59225 3.68 3.85 59862 4.37 4.09 60479 4.19 3.89 61056 3.87 4.03 61702 4.30 4.18 62323 4.09 4.11 62930 3.95 4.05 63426 3.19 3.88 54826 2.35 2.35 57466 4.82 4.82 59565 3.65 3.65 62003 4.09 4.09 LESS: PERS CONT FOR SOC INS…… 21656 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………………… 11.23 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr………………… 4.65 21759 1.93 4.57 21865 1.95 3.63 22001 2.51 4.33 22119 2.17 2.14 22240 2.21 2.21 22352 2.03 2.23 22498 2.63 2.26 22611 2.02 2.22 22709 1.75 2.11 22814 1.87 2.07 23014 3.55 2.29 20795 3.98 3.98 21592 3.83 3.83 22178 2.72 2.72 22658 2.16 2.16 RESIDENCE ADJUSTMENT……………… -1400 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………………… 43.94 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr………………… 11.08 -1382 -5.12 9.29 -1381 -0.22 6.95 -1382 0.29 8.12 -1383 0.35 -1.20 -1384 0.34 0.19 -1386 0.32 0.33 -1387 0.37 0.34 -1388 0.35 0.35 -1389 0.40 0.36 -1391 0.41 0.38 -1392 0.20 0.34 -1268 -4.55 -4.55 -1360 7.24 7.24 -1384 1.73 1.73 -1389 0.36 0.36 PER CAPITA PERSONAL INCOME ($)…… 41512 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………………… 6.44 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr………………… 3.65 41797 2.77 3.77 42235 4.26 3.81 42579 3.30 4.18 42942 3.45 3.44 43322 3.58 3.65 43711 3.64 3.50 44100 3.61 3.57 44488 3.56 3.60 44889 3.66 3.62 45302 3.73 3.64 45659 3.19 3.53 40168 2.65 2.65 41603 3.57 3.57 43139 3.69 3.69 44695 3.61 3.61 Center for Business and Economic Research, University of Tennessee Tennessee Econometric Model Forecast Data TN PERSONAL INCOME…………...……… 276341 278958 282614 285656 288832 292132 295513 298903 302294 305795 309386 312604 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………………… 7.56 3.84 5.35 4.37 4.52 4.65 4.71 4.67 4.62 4.71 4.78 4.22 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr………………… 4.74 4.85 4.89 5.27 4.52 4.72 4.56 4.64 4.66 4.68 4.69 4.58 | 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT History 2015:2 2015:3 APPENDIX A 6 Table 4: Tennessee Personal Income Components, Seasonally Adjusted Annual Rates (millions of current dollars) Table 5: Tennessee Nonfarm Employment by Sector, Not Seasonally Adjusted (thousands of jobs) January 2016 History 2015:3 2015:4 Forecast Data 2016:1 2016:2 2016:3 2016:4 2017:1 2017:2 2017:3 2017:4 2018:1 TOTAL NONFARM……………………………………………… 2869.0 2927.8 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr........................................... 1.90 2.01 2881.0 2919.4 2915.6 2957.6 2914.0 2956.0 2955.7 3001.1 2955.6 2.09 1.86 1.62 1.02 1.14 1.25 1.38 1.47 1.43 2014 Annual 2015 2016 2017 2815.4 2871.3 2918.4 2956.7 2.05 1.98 1.64 1.31 118.0 2.39 120.8 4.43 120.2 2.62 115.0 2.92 121.5 2.99 124.5 3.05 123.9 3.11 118.3 2.84 111.0 2.92 114.6 3.26 117.7 2.66 121.2 3.02 MANUFACTURING…………………………………………… 331.6 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr........................................... 1.71 333.8 1.21 332.1 0.60 333.1 0.77 334.0 0.75 335.8 0.59 334.3 0.68 335.6 0.74 336.4 0.71 338.2 0.71 336.7 0.70 325.2 2.14 331.5 1.93 333.8 0.68 336.1 0.71 DURABLE GOODS………………………………………… 211.8 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr........................................... 2.97 213.4 1.89 213.1 1.40 214.2 1.35 215.1 1.56 216.8 1.58 216.4 1.56 217.7 1.59 218.3 1.51 220.0 1.46 219.6 1.49 205.5 3.36 211.7 2.99 214.8 1.47 218.1 1.53 NONDURABLE GOODS…………………………………… 119.8 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr........................................... -0.44 120.4 0.03 119.0 -0.80 118.9 -0.25 119.0 -0.68 119.0 -1.17 117.9 -0.91 117.9 -0.81 118.1 -0.72 118.2 -0.67 117.0 -0.75 119.7 0.10 119.8 0.10 119.0 -0.73 118.0 -0.77 TRADE, TRANSPORTATION, UTILITIES………………… 610.0 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr........................................... 2.95 624.6 3.07 609.7 2.82 618.1 2.52 618.6 1.41 629.7 0.81 615.4 0.93 624.4 1.02 625.9 1.17 637.5 1.24 622.9 1.22 591.6 1.64 607.6 2.70 619.0 1.87 625.8 1.09 WHOLESALE TRADE……………………………………… 127.8 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr........................................... 3.20 130.1 4.41 129.0 3.86 130.2 3.54 130.5 2.16 130.4 0.21 129.5 0.40 131.0 0.59 131.6 0.82 131.7 0.99 130.8 0.96 123.3 1.18 127.0 3.01 130.0 2.42 131.0 0.70 RETAIL TRADE…………………………………………… 328.4 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr........................................... 2.56 337.3 2.59 326.6 2.30 332.4 1.77 332.3 1.19 340.2 0.86 329.8 0.95 335.6 0.97 335.9 1.08 343.9 1.09 333.1 1.02 320.5 1.76 327.9 2.32 332.9 1.52 336.3 1.03 TRANSPORTATION & UTILITIES……………………… 153.8 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr........................................... 3.59 157.2 3.01 154.0 3.09 155.5 3.27 155.8 1.25 159.1 1.21 156.1 1.33 157.8 1.46 158.3 1.66 161.9 1.78 159.0 1.86 147.9 1.76 152.8 3.28 156.1 2.19 158.5 1.56 INFORMATION………………………………………………… 42.9 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr........................................... -2.06 42.5 -4.35 42.4 -3.91 42.5 -2.78 42.1 -1.70 42.7 0.46 42.6 0.48 42.8 0.47 42.2 0.21 42.8 0.27 42.7 0.21 43.9 -0.30 43.3 -1.37 42.5 -2.01 42.6 0.36 FINANCIAL ACTIVITIES…………………………………… 145.4 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr........................................... 1.99 147.9 3.74 147.0 3.49 147.5 2.42 147.9 1.72 148.2 0.18 147.6 0.44 148.5 0.66 149.3 0.92 149.9 1.14 149.1 1.02 141.4 2.41 144.8 2.39 147.6 1.94 148.8 0.79 PROFESSIONAL & BUSINESS SERVICES……………… 382.8 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr........................................... 2.28 396.4 2.93 387.2 4.18 392.2 3.02 393.2 2.71 401.9 1.38 394.7 1.93 401.4 2.34 404.2 2.78 414.4 3.12 406.4 2.98 372.4 5.43 382.9 2.82 393.6 2.80 403.7 2.55 EDUCATION & HEALTH SERVICES……………………… 406.6 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr........................................... 1.30 416.5 1.68 414.4 1.68 416.4 1.89 416.4 2.42 424.5 1.91 422.2 1.86 424.2 1.88 424.3 1.88 432.8 1.94 430.1 1.88 402.8 1.09 409.8 1.75 417.9 1.97 425.8 1.89 LEISURE & HOSPITALITY………………………………… 316.7 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr........................................... 3.44 307.5 3.63 299.8 4.23 320.5 2.73 321.5 1.51 312.9 1.76 305.3 1.84 326.6 1.89 327.5 1.89 318.6 1.84 310.8 1.79 296.3 3.64 305.9 3.25 313.7 2.53 319.5 1.87 OTHER SERVICES…………………………………………… 105.4 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr........................................... -0.85 104.2 -0.86 103.2 -0.61 105.2 -0.57 103.6 -1.71 102.6 -1.53 101.5 -1.57 103.6 -1.52 102.5 -1.09 102.1 -0.56 101.5 -0.06 105.9 0.27 104.8 -1.00 103.6 -1.11 102.4 -1.19 GOVERNMENT……………………………………………… 412.0 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr........................................... 0.62 437.2 0.34 433.5 0.42 425.8 0.77 417.4 1.30 439.1 0.44 435.3 0.41 427.4 0.39 419.0 0.39 440.9 0.40 437.1 0.41 424.8 -0.07 425.9 0.26 429.0 0.73 430.7 0.40 47.6 0.71 47.8 0.84 46.5 -1.74 45.9 -3.65 46.8 -1.53 47.4 -0.83 46.0 -1.17 45.2 -1.45 46.1 -1.54 46.6 -1.56 45.2 -1.63 48.1 -2.65 47.6 -1.16 46.7 -1.93 46.0 -1.43 STATE & LOCAL…………………………………………… 364.4 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr........................................... 0.61 389.4 0.27 387.0 0.70 379.9 1.34 370.6 1.68 391.8 0.60 389.4 0.61 382.2 0.62 372.9 0.62 394.3 0.64 391.9 0.66 376.6 0.27 378.3 0.44 382.3 1.07 384.7 0.62 FEDERAL, CIVILIAN……………………………………… % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr........................................... | Center for Business and Economic Research, University of Tennessee Tennessee Econometric Model 7 APPENDIX A 111.8 1.10 | 117.1 1.91 Forecast Data 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT NATURAL RESOURCES, MINING & CONSTRUCTION… 115.7 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr........................................... 2.21 January 2016 | TOTAL DURABLE GOODS…………………………… 211.8 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………… 2.97 2016:1 2016:2 2016:3 2016:4 2017:1 2017:2 2017:3 2017:4 2018:1 2014 Annual 2015 2016 2017 213.1 1.40 214.2 1.35 215.1 1.56 216.8 1.58 216.4 1.56 217.7 1.59 218.3 1.51 220.0 1.46 219.6 1.49 205.5 3.36 211.7 2.99 214.8 1.47 218.1 1.53 11.8 3.22 11.8 2.92 11.6 2.23 11.8 1.82 12.0 1.87 12.0 1.68 11.8 1.66 12.0 1.60 12.2 1.51 12.1 1.44 11.9 1.43 11.2 3.45 11.6 3.41 11.8 1.90 12.0 1.55 NONMETALLIC MINERAL PRODUCTS………… 11.7 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………… -2.49 11.7 -1.68 11.5 -1.37 11.6 -0.85 11.7 -0.61 11.6 -1.10 11.4 -0.99 11.5 -1.00 11.5 -0.99 11.5 -0.90 11.3 -0.83 11.9 -1.92 11.7 -1.68 11.6 -0.98 11.5 -0.97 WOOD PRODUCTS……………………………… % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………… PRIMARY METALS………….…………………… % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………… 10.2 1.32 10.4 2.30 10.3 1.29 10.4 1.26 10.4 1.34 10.4 0.41 10.4 0.50 10.4 0.57 10.4 0.67 10.5 0.83 10.5 0.87 10.1 1.00 10.3 1.90 10.4 1.07 10.4 0.64 FABRICATED METAL PRODUCTS…………… % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………… 35.1 2.13 35.1 1.35 35.1 -0.56 35.3 0.45 35.2 0.29 35.4 0.98 35.4 0.86 35.5 0.53 35.4 0.46 35.5 0.03 35.4 0.02 34.4 1.35 35.2 2.28 35.3 0.29 35.4 0.47 MACHINERY……………………………………… % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………… 26.2 2.21 25.7 -2.90 26.2 -0.45 26.4 -1.36 26.0 -0.56 25.9 0.88 26.5 0.96 26.6 1.02 26.3 1.05 26.2 1.13 26.8 1.21 25.7 1.41 26.2 1.98 26.1 -0.38 26.4 1.04 COMPUTER & ELECTRONIC PRODUCTS…… % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………… 5.1 1.99 5.2 3.33 5.1 2.73 5.1 1.46 5.1 -0.99 5.0 -2.94 5.0 -2.71 5.0 -2.66 4.9 -2.61 4.9 -2.57 4.9 -2.46 5.0 -3.67 5.1 1.16 5.1 0.04 5.0 -2.64 ELECTRICAL EQUIPMENT, APPLIANCES & COMPONENTS…………..…………………… % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………… 20.0 2.39 20.1 2.55 20.0 1.44 20.1 1.75 20.4 2.00 20.4 1.48 20.3 1.38 20.4 1.31 20.6 1.22 20.7 1.52 20.6 1.52 19.4 4.49 19.9 2.58 20.2 1.67 20.5 1.36 TRANSPORTATION EQUIPMENT……………… % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………… 67.4 5.76 69.1 4.38 68.9 3.70 69.1 3.36 70.0 3.91 71.8 3.85 71.5 3.68 71.8 3.90 72.5 3.63 74.3 3.47 74.0 3.61 64.0 7.55 67.5 5.39 70.0 3.71 72.5 3.67 FURNITURE………………………………………… 9.2 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………… 1.85 9.2 1.47 9.2 0.87 9.3 1.28 9.2 0.43 9.2 0.17 9.3 0.88 9.4 1.21 9.3 0.92 9.3 0.62 9.3 -0.04 9.1 3.52 9.2 1.38 9.3 0.68 9.3 0.91 MISCELLANEOUS DURABLE GOODS………… % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………… 15.2 1.34 15.0 0.54 15.1 0.20 15.1 0.23 15.0 -0.89 14.9 -0.70 15.0 -0.72 15.1 -0.43 15.0 -0.10 14.9 -0.13 14.7 1.26 15.1 2.38 15.1 0.02 15.0 -0.49 15.1 1.34 Center for Business and Economic Research, University of Tennessee Tennessee Econometric Model Forecast Data 213.4 1.89 | 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT History 2015:3 2015:4 APPENDIX A 8 Table 6: Tennessee Durable Goods Manufacturing Employment, Not Seasonally Adjusted (thousands of jobs) Table 7: Tennessee Nondurable Goods Manufacturing Employment, Not Seasonally Adjusted (thousands of jobs) History 2015:3 2015:4 TOTAL NONDURABLE GOODS…………………… 119.8 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………… -0.44 January 2016 2016:1 2016:2 2016:3 2016:4 2017:1 2017:2 2017:3 2017:4 2018:1 2014 Annual 2015 2016 2017 120.4 0.03 119.0 -0.80 118.9 -0.25 119.0 -0.68 119.0 -1.17 117.9 -0.91 117.9 -0.81 118.1 -0.72 118.2 -0.67 117.0 -0.75 119.7 0.10 119.8 0.10 119.0 -0.73 118.0 -0.77 33.0 0.41 33.1 0.20 32.8 0.05 32.7 0.31 33.0 0.04 33.2 0.09 32.8 0.12 32.8 0.11 33.1 0.12 33.2 0.12 32.9 0.09 32.7 0.95 32.9 0.54 32.9 0.12 33.0 0.12 BEVERAGE & TOBACCO………………………… 5.5 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………… 0.00 5.5 1.85 5.4 0.90 5.5 0.67 5.5 0.02 5.4 -1.37 5.4 -1.14 5.4 -1.05 5.4 -0.94 5.4 -0.83 5.3 -0.85 5.4 1.88 5.5 0.77 5.5 0.05 5.4 -0.99 TEXTILE MILLS, TEXTILE MILL PRODUCTS & APPAREL……………………… 9.6 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………… -3.68 9.6 -2.71 9.3 -3.44 9.2 -3.59 9.2 -4.21 9.1 -5.12 8.8 -4.80 8.8 -4.93 8.7 -5.09 8.6 -5.17 8.4 -5.25 10.0 -4.54 9.6 -4.09 9.2 -4.09 8.7 -5.00 PAPER……………………………………………… 14.4 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………… -2.92 14.3 -2.06 13.9 -2.01 14.0 -1.68 14.1 -2.34 13.8 -3.09 13.6 -2.74 13.7 -2.51 13.7 -2.28 13.5 -2.05 13.3 -2.07 14.6 -0.51 14.3 -2.22 14.0 -2.28 13.6 -2.39 PRINTING & RELATED SUPPORT……………… 9.0 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………… -4.61 8.9 -4.63 8.8 -3.88 8.9 -2.24 8.8 -1.79 8.8 -1.03 8.8 -0.43 8.8 -0.52 8.7 -0.65 8.8 -0.76 8.7 -1.43 9.4 -1.73 9.0 -4.32 8.8 -2.25 8.8 -0.59 CHEMICALS………………………………………… 25.3 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………… -0.79 25.3 -0.39 25.1 -0.72 25.0 -0.59 25.0 -1.21 24.9 -1.57 24.8 -1.32 24.7 -1.16 24.7 -0.99 24.6 -0.90 24.5 -0.93 25.3 2.12 25.2 -0.39 25.0 -1.02 24.7 -1.09 21.3 1.59 21.5 1.74 21.6 1.56 21.6 2.55 21.6 1.54 21.7 0.86 21.8 1.20 21.9 1.47 21.9 1.64 22.1 1.73 22.2 1.62 20.7 2.40 21.3 2.90 21.6 1.62 21.9 1.51 MISCELLANEOUS NONDURABLE GOODS…… 1.8 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………… 30.95 2.2 36.73 2.0 -8.97 2.0 -1.72 1.9 2.50 2.1 -5.88 1.9 -5.70 1.9 -5.47 1.8 -5.62 2.0 -5.78 1.8 -6.18 1.5 -27.45 2.1 35.68 2.0 -3.84 1.9 -5.64 FOOD……………………………………………… % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………… PLASTICS & RUBBER…………………………… % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………… Center for Business and Economic Research, University of Tennessee Tennessee Econometric Model Forecast Data | | 9 APPENDIX A 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT January 2016 | TOTAL NONFARM………………………………… 2874.8 2900.1 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………… 1.94 3.57 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr………………… 1.79 2.00 2906.8 2914.1 2921.4 2929.6 2940.2 2950.6 2961.5 2972.7 2982.4 0.92 1.01 1.01 1.13 1.45 1.42 1.49 1.53 1.30 2.10 1.85 1.62 1.02 1.15 1.25 1.37 1.47 1.43 2014 2015 Annual 2016 2017 2816.1 2870.7 2918.0 2956.2 2.08 1.94 1.65 1.31 2.08 1.94 1.65 1.31 NATURAL RESOURCES, MINING AND CONSTRUCTION……………………… 112.9 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………… -5.03 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr………………… 2.08 115.7 10.55 1.91 116.3 1.87 1.10 117.1 2.78 2.39 117.9 2.76 4.43 118.8 3.09 2.62 119.7 3.07 2.92 120.6 3.04 2.99 121.5 3.02 3.05 122.5 3.33 3.11 123.1 1.97 2.84 110.9 2.87 2.87 114.5 3.20 3.20 117.5 2.63 2.63 121.0 3.02 3.02 MANUFACTURING……………………………… 331.5 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………… 0.81 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr………………… 1.74 332.7 1.53 1.17 333.0 0.37 0.60 333.4 0.41 0.78 334.0 0.71 0.75 334.7 0.85 0.58 335.3 0.73 0.67 335.8 0.68 0.74 336.4 0.62 0.72 337.0 0.80 0.71 337.6 0.70 0.70 325.2 2.13 2.13 331.5 1.93 1.93 333.7 0.68 0.68 336.1 0.71 0.71 DURABLE GOODS…………………………… 211.9 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………… 0.92 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr………………… 3.00 212.8 1.86 1.86 213.6 1.39 1.40 214.2 1.26 1.36 215.2 1.74 1.56 216.2 1.89 1.57 216.9 1.35 1.56 217.7 1.42 1.60 218.4 1.39 1.51 219.3 1.67 1.46 220.1 1.49 1.49 205.5 3.36 3.36 211.7 2.99 2.99 214.8 1.47 1.47 218.1 1.53 1.53 NONDURABLE GOODS…………………… 119.6 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………… 0.61 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr………………… -0.42 119.9 0.95 -0.02 119.4 -1.42 -0.81 119.1 -1.10 -0.25 118.8 -1.11 -0.68 118.5 -1.03 -1.17 118.4 -0.40 -0.91 118.2 -0.67 -0.80 117.9 -0.78 -0.72 117.7 -0.79 -0.66 117.5 -0.76 -0.75 119.7 0.09 0.09 119.8 0.10 0.10 119.0 -0.72 -0.72 118.0 -0.77 -0.77 TRADE, TRANSPORTATION, UTILITIES…… 610.9 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………… 5.27 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr………………… 2.85 615.9 3.34 3.06 616.9 0.65 2.82 618.3 0.87 2.52 619.5 0.80 1.41 620.9 0.94 0.81 622.7 1.13 0.93 624.6 1.21 1.02 626.8 1.42 1.17 628.7 1.22 1.24 630.3 1.03 1.22 592.1 1.71 1.71 607.5 2.60 2.60 618.9 1.88 1.88 625.7 1.09 1.09 WHOLESALE TRADE……………………… 127.3 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………… 5.75 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr………………… 3.02 129.9 8.42 4.42 130.0 0.09 3.86 130.0 0.16 3.54 130.1 0.21 2.16 130.2 0.39 0.21 130.5 0.84 0.40 130.8 0.93 0.59 131.1 1.12 0.82 131.5 1.07 0.99 131.7 0.74 0.96 123.3 1.22 1.22 127.0 2.99 2.99 130.1 2.42 2.42 131.0 0.70 0.70 RETAIL TRADE……………………………… 329.3 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………… 3.22 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr………………… 2.31 331.1 2.25 2.56 331.7 0.67 2.30 332.5 0.98 1.77 333.2 0.87 1.19 334.0 0.94 0.86 334.8 1.02 0.95 335.7 1.07 0.97 336.8 1.30 1.08 337.6 0.98 1.09 338.3 0.73 1.02 320.8 1.86 1.86 327.8 2.19 2.19 332.8 1.53 1.53 336.3 1.03 1.03 TRANSPORTATION & UTILITIES………… 154.3 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………… 9.42 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr………………… 3.86 154.9 1.56 3.02 155.3 1.09 3.09 155.8 1.22 3.27 156.2 1.14 1.25 156.7 1.38 1.21 157.4 1.59 1.33 158.0 1.73 1.46 158.8 1.94 1.66 159.5 1.86 1.78 160.3 1.92 1.86 148.0 1.81 1.81 152.7 3.15 3.15 156.0 2.19 2.19 158.4 1.56 1.56 INFORMATION………………………………… 43.2 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………… -3.91 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr………………… -1.52 42.4 -7.78 -4.36 42.4 0.39 -3.91 42.5 0.42 -2.78 42.5 0.45 -1.70 42.6 0.58 0.46 42.6 0.49 0.48 42.7 0.37 0.47 42.6 -0.60 0.21 42.7 0.81 0.27 42.7 0.26 0.21 43.9 -0.36 -0.36 43.4 -1.27 -1.27 42.5 -2.01 -2.01 42.6 0.36 0.36 FINANCIAL ACTIVITIES……………………… 145.1 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………… 2.90 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr………………… 2.06 147.5 6.68 3.68 147.5 147.6 147.6 147.8 148.2 0.04 0.21 0.12 0.35 1.07 3.49 2.42 1.72 0.18 0.44 (CONTINUED ON NEXT PAGE) 148.6 1.10 0.66 149.0 1.16 0.92 149.4 1.22 1.14 149.7 0.59 1.02 141.5 2.41 2.41 144.8 2.34 2.34 147.6 1.94 1.94 148.8 0.79 0.79 Forecast Data 2016:1 2016:2 2016:3 2016:4 2017:1 2017:2 2017:3 2017:4 2018:1 | 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT History 2015:3 2015:4 APPENDIX A 10 Table 8: Tennessee Nonfarm Employment by Sector, Seasonally Adjusted (thousands of jobs) Table 8: Tennessee Nonfarm Employment by Sector, Seasonally Adjusted (thousands of jobs) History 2015:3 2015:4 January 2016 2016:1 2016:2 2016:3 2016:4 2017:1 2017:2 2017:3 2017:4 2018:1 2014 2015 Annual 2016 2017 PROFESSIONAL & BUSINESS SERVICES… 384.0 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………… 2.65 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr………………… 2.13 390.7 7.20 2.95 391.8 1.09 4.18 393.0 1.27 3.02 394.4 1.41 2.71 396.1 1.74 1.38 399.3 3.32 1.93 402.2 2.92 2.34 405.4 3.16 2.78 408.4 3.08 3.12 411.2 2.75 2.98 372.6 5.54 5.54 383.0 2.80 2.80 393.8 2.81 2.81 403.8 2.55 2.55 EDUCATION & HEALTH SERVICES………… 409.0 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………… -0.26 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr………………… 1.41 412.8 3.84 1.67 415.0 2.09 1.68 417.0 1.94 1.89 418.9 1.84 2.42 420.7 1.78 1.91 422.7 1.89 1.86 424.8 2.01 1.88 426.8 1.85 1.88 428.9 2.02 1.94 430.7 1.64 1.88 402.6 1.05 1.05 409.8 1.78 1.78 417.9 1.98 1.98 425.8 1.89 1.89 LEISURE & HOSPITALITY…………………… 309.6 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………… 6.82 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr………………… 3.73 310.3 0.95 3.62 311.6 1.67 4.23 312.9 1.59 2.73 314.3 1.85 1.51 315.8 1.93 1.76 317.4 1.99 1.84 318.8 1.78 1.89 320.2 1.86 1.89 321.6 1.74 1.84 323.1 1.80 1.79 296.1 3.62 3.62 305.9 3.28 3.28 313.6 2.54 2.54 319.5 1.86 1.86 OTHER SERVICES……………………………… 105.2 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………… 2.71 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr………………… -0.47 104.6 -2.51 -0.85 104.2 -1.31 -0.61 103.9 -1.07 -0.57 103.4 -1.95 -1.71 103.0 -1.79 -1.53 102.6 -1.47 -1.57 102.4 -0.87 -1.52 102.3 -0.22 -1.09 102.4 0.34 -0.56 102.5 0.51 -0.06 105.8 0.21 0.21 104.8 -0.97 -0.97 103.6 -1.11 -1.11 102.4 -1.19 -1.19 GOVERNMENT………………………………… 423.5 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………… -1.68 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr………………… -0.18 427.5 3.83 0.32 428.0 0.54 0.42 428.6 0.49 0.77 429.0 0.39 1.30 429.4 0.36 0.44 429.8 0.42 0.41 430.2 0.40 0.39 430.7 0.39 0.39 431.1 0.39 0.40 431.6 0.46 0.41 425.2 0.00 0.00 425.6 0.10 0.10 428.7 0.73 0.73 430.4 0.40 0.40 FEDERAL, CIVILIAN………………………… 47.2 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………… -9.56 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr………………… -1.19 46.6 -4.45 0.58 46.6 0.07 -1.74 46.6 -0.33 -3.65 46.4 -1.34 -1.53 46.2 -1.70 -0.83 46.1 -1.33 -1.17 45.9 -1.45 -1.45 45.7 -1.66 -1.54 45.5 -1.80 -1.56 45.3 -1.62 -1.63 47.9 -3.33 -3.33 47.4 -1.06 -1.06 46.5 -1.95 -1.95 45.8 -1.43 -1.43 STATE & LOCAL……………………………… 376.3 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………… -0.64 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr………………… -0.05 380.8 4.91 0.29 381.4 0.60 0.70 382.0 0.59 1.34 382.5 0.61 1.66 383.1 0.61 0.60 383.7 0.63 0.61 384.3 0.63 0.62 384.9 0.63 0.63 385.6 0.65 0.64 386.2 0.71 0.66 377.3 0.44 0.44 378.2 0.24 0.24 382.3 1.07 1.07 384.6 0.62 0.62 STATISTICAL DISCREPANCY (% )……… -0.01 0.00 0.00 0.01 Tennessee Econometric Model Forecast Data | | 11 APPENDIX A 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT Center for Business and Economic Research, University of Tennessee | 2016:1 2016:2 2016:3 2016:4 2017:1 2017:2 2017:3 2017:4 2018:1 2014 Annual 2015 2016 2017 212.8 1.86 1.86 213.6 1.39 1.40 214.2 1.26 1.36 215.2 1.74 1.56 216.2 1.89 1.57 216.9 1.35 1.56 217.7 1.42 1.60 218.4 1.39 1.51 219.3 1.67 1.46 220.1 1.49 1.49 205.5 3.36 3.36 211.7 2.99 2.99 214.8 1.47 1.47 218.1 1.53 1.53 WOOD PRODUCTS……………………… 11.6 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..………… 1.54 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………… 3.26 11.7 2.39 2.90 11.8 1.63 2.23 11.8 1.71 1.82 11.9 1.75 1.87 11.9 1.62 1.68 12.0 1.57 1.66 12.0 1.45 1.60 12.0 1.40 1.51 12.1 1.36 1.45 12.1 1.50 1.43 11.2 3.44 3.44 11.6 3.40 3.40 11.8 1.90 1.90 12.0 1.55 1.55 NONMETALLIC MINERALS……………… 11.6 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..………… -2.02 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………… -2.47 11.7 0.98 -1.71 11.6 -1.31 -1.37 11.6 -1.03 -0.85 11.6 -1.07 -0.61 11.5 -0.98 -1.10 11.5 -0.89 -0.99 11.5 -1.07 -1.00 11.5 -1.02 -0.99 11.4 -0.60 -0.90 11.4 -0.62 -0.83 11.9 -1.94 -1.94 11.7 -1.68 -1.68 11.6 -0.98 -0.98 11.5 -0.97 -0.97 PRIMARY METALS………….…………… 10.2 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..………… 0.18 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………… 1.31 10.3 4.01 2.31 10.4 0.38 1.29 10.4 0.54 1.26 10.4 0.49 1.34 10.4 0.22 0.41 10.4 0.77 0.50 10.4 0.82 0.57 10.4 0.86 0.67 10.5 0.87 0.83 10.5 0.92 0.87 10.1 0.99 0.99 10.3 1.90 1.90 10.4 1.07 1.07 10.4 0.64 0.64 FABRICATED METALS………………….. 35.1 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..………… 0.99 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………… 2.16 35.1 -0.41 1.35 35.1 0.49 -0.56 35.2 0.73 0.45 35.2 0.37 0.29 35.4 2.35 0.98 35.4 0.00 0.86 35.4 -0.58 0.53 35.4 0.11 0.46 35.5 0.61 0.03 35.4 -0.06 0.02 34.4 1.35 1.35 35.2 2.28 2.28 35.3 0.29 0.29 35.4 0.47 0.47 MACHINERY………………………………… 26.3 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..………… -2.31 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………… 2.23 26.0 -4.64 -2.95 26.0 0.73 -0.45 26.1 0.89 -1.36 26.2 0.91 -0.56 26.2 0.98 0.88 26.3 1.07 0.96 26.4 1.11 1.02 26.4 1.05 1.05 26.5 1.29 1.13 26.6 1.38 1.21 25.7 1.44 1.44 26.2 1.94 1.94 26.1 -0.38 -0.38 26.4 1.04 1.04 COMPUTERS & ELECTRONICS………… 5.1 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..………… 7.23 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………… 1.96 5.2 5.23 3.37 5.1 -3.27 2.73 5.1 -2.91 1.46 5.1 -2.76 -0.99 5.0 -2.83 -2.94 5.0 -2.35 -2.71 5.0 -2.68 -2.66 4.9 -2.59 -2.61 4.9 -2.66 -2.57 4.9 -1.92 -2.46 5.0 -3.66 -3.66 5.1 1.16 1.16 5.1 0.03 0.03 5.0 -2.64 -2.64 ELECTRICAL EQUIPMENT, APPLIANCES & COMPONENTS…………..…………… 19.9 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..………… 0.95 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………… 2.40 20.0 2.43 2.54 20.1 1.86 1.44 20.2 1.78 1.75 20.3 1.92 2.00 20.3 0.35 1.48 20.4 1.48 1.38 20.5 1.49 1.31 20.5 1.57 1.22 20.6 1.54 1.52 20.7 1.50 1.52 19.4 4.49 4.49 19.9 2.58 2.58 20.2 1.67 1.67 20.5 1.36 1.36 TRANSPORTATION EQUIP……………… 67.6 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..………… 2.18 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………… 5.80 68.4 4.45 4.35 69.0 3.76 3.70 69.5 3.05 3.36 70.3 4.40 3.91 71.0 4.21 3.85 71.5 3.05 3.68 72.2 3.96 3.90 72.8 3.29 3.63 73.5 3.58 3.47 74.1 3.60 3.61 64.0 7.55 7.55 67.5 5.39 5.39 70.0 3.71 3.71 72.5 3.67 3.67 FURNITURE………………………………… 9.2 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..………… 4.64 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………… 1.94 9.3 2.60 1.41 9.3 -1.00 0.87 9.2 -1.01 1.28 9.3 1.16 0.43 9.3 1.55 0.17 9.3 1.85 0.88 9.3 0.27 1.21 9.3 0.03 0.92 9.4 0.33 0.62 9.3 -0.82 -0.04 9.1 3.50 3.50 9.2 1.38 1.38 9.3 0.68 0.68 9.3 0.91 0.91 MISCELLANEOUS DURABLES………… 15.0 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..………… -1.09 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………… 1.32 15.2 3.79 1.34 15.1 -0.92 0.54 15.1 -0.87 0.20 15.0 -1.01 0.23 15.0 -0.75 -0.89 15.0 -0.17 -0.70 15.0 -0.93 -0.72 15.0 0.12 -0.43 15.0 0.60 -0.10 15.0 -0.31 -0.13 14.7 1.26 1.26 15.1 2.39 2.39 15.1 0.02 0.02 15.0 -0.49 -0.49 Center for Business and Economic Research, University of Tennessee Tennessee Econometric Model Forecast Data TOTAL DURABLE GOODS…………………… 211.9 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..………… 0.92 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………… 3.00 | 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT History 2015:3 2015:4 January 2016 APPENDIX A 12 Table 9: Tennessee Durable Goods Manufacturing Employment, Seasonally Adjusted (thousands of jobs) Table 10: Tennessee Nondurable Goods Manufacturing Employment, Seasonally Adjusted (thousands of jobs) History 2015:3 2015:4 January 2016 2016:1 2016:2 2016:3 2016:4 2017:1 2017:2 2017:3 2017:4 2018:1 2014 Annual 2015 2016 2017 TOTAL NONDURABLE GOODS………………… 119.6 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………… 0.61 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… -0.42 119.9 0.95 -0.02 119.4 -1.42 -0.81 119.1 -1.10 -0.25 118.8 -1.11 -0.68 118.5 -1.03 -1.17 118.4 -0.40 -0.91 118.2 -0.67 -0.80 117.9 -0.78 -0.72 117.7 -0.79 -0.66 117.5 -0.76 -0.75 119.7 0.09 0.09 119.8 0.10 0.10 119.0 -0.72 -0.72 118.0 -0.77 -0.77 FOOD……………………………………………… 32.9 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………… 1.18 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 0.40 32.9 -0.09 0.19 32.9 0.04 0.05 32.9 0.12 0.31 32.9 0.09 0.04 32.9 0.10 0.09 32.9 0.17 0.12 33.0 0.10 0.11 33.0 0.12 0.12 33.0 0.10 0.12 33.0 0.06 0.09 32.7 0.95 0.95 32.9 0.54 0.54 32.9 0.12 0.12 33.0 0.12 0.12 5.4 1.25 0.03 5.5 4.48 1.87 5.5 -1.72 0.90 5.5 -1.19 0.67 5.4 -1.37 0.02 5.4 -1.21 -1.37 5.4 -0.79 -1.14 5.4 -0.84 -1.05 5.4 -0.90 -0.94 5.4 -0.77 -0.83 5.4 -0.87 -0.85 5.4 1.89 1.89 5.5 0.77 0.77 5.5 0.05 0.05 5.4 -0.99 -0.99 TEXTILE MILLS, TEXTILE MILL PRODUCTS & APPAREL…………………… % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………… % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 9.5 -2.36 -3.66 9.5 -1.35 -2.76 9.4 -5.64 -3.44 9.2 -4.97 -3.59 9.1 -4.83 -4.21 9.0 -5.02 -5.12 8.9 -4.39 -4.80 8.8 -5.49 -4.93 8.7 -5.45 -5.09 8.6 -5.35 -5.17 8.4 -4.72 -5.25 10.0 -4.53 -4.53 9.6 -4.10 -4.10 9.2 -4.09 -4.09 8.7 -5.00 -5.00 PAPER…………………………………………… % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………… % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 14.2 -0.30 -2.89 14.3 0.24 -2.07 14.1 -3.55 -2.01 14.0 -3.07 -1.68 13.9 -2.93 -2.34 13.8 -2.81 -3.09 13.7 -2.13 -2.74 13.7 -2.16 -2.51 13.6 -2.03 -2.28 13.5 -1.88 -2.05 13.5 -2.20 -2.07 14.6 -0.53 -0.53 14.3 -2.23 -2.23 14.0 -2.28 -2.28 13.6 -2.40 -2.40 PRINTING & RELATED SUPPORT…………… 9.0 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………… -2.85 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… -4.61 8.9 -4.00 -4.63 8.9 -1.19 -3.88 8.9 -0.88 -2.24 8.8 -1.05 -1.79 8.8 -1.01 -1.03 8.8 1.24 -0.43 8.8 -1.23 -0.52 8.8 -1.59 -0.65 8.7 -1.41 -0.76 8.7 -1.47 -1.43 9.5 -1.73 -1.73 9.0 -4.32 -4.32 8.8 -2.25 -2.25 8.8 -0.59 -0.59 CHEMICALS……………………………………… 25.2 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………… 0.95 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… -0.79 25.2 -0.01 -0.40 25.1 -1.79 -0.72 25.0 -1.47 -0.59 24.9 -1.55 -1.21 24.8 -1.48 -1.57 24.8 -0.79 -1.32 24.7 -0.81 -1.16 24.7 -0.89 -0.99 24.6 -1.10 -0.90 24.5 -0.91 -0.93 25.3 2.12 2.12 25.2 -0.40 -0.40 25.0 -1.02 -1.02 24.7 -1.09 -1.09 21.3 5.00 1.52 21.5 3.86 1.75 21.5 0.54 1.56 21.6 0.87 2.55 21.6 0.91 1.54 21.7 1.14 0.86 21.8 1.88 1.20 21.9 1.94 1.47 22.0 1.60 1.64 22.1 1.50 1.73 22.1 1.45 1.62 20.7 2.39 2.39 21.3 2.90 2.90 21.6 1.62 1.62 21.9 1.51 1.51 MISCELLANEOUS NONDURABLE GOODS… 1.9 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………… -20.70 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 31.50 2.1 32.68 35.85 2.1 -5.85 -8.97 2.0 -5.80 -1.72 2.0 -6.21 2.50 2.0 -5.65 -5.88 1.9 -5.14 -5.70 1.9 -4.86 -5.47 1.9 -6.83 -5.62 1.9 -6.27 -5.78 1.8 -6.76 -6.18 1.5 -27.54 -27.54 2.1 35.66 35.66 2.0 -3.74 -3.74 1.9 -5.64 -5.64 PLASTICS & RUBBER………………………… % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………… % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… Center for Business and Economic Research, University of Tennessee Tennessee Econometric Model Forecast Data | | 13 APPENDIX A 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT BEVERAGE & TOBACCO……………………… % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………… % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… | January 2016 Forecast Data 2015:4 2016:1 2016:2 2016:3 2016:4 2017:1 2017:2 2017:3 2017:4 2018:1 2014 Annual 2015 2016 2017 43357 3.35 43262 3.11 44366 3.66 44004 1.86 44145 1.82 43704 1.02 44672 0.69 44229 0.51 44432 0.65 44050 0.79 44948 0.62 41973 1.20 43155 2.82 44055 2.08 44346 0.66 NATURAL RESOURCES, MINING AND CONSTRUCTION………………………… 49672 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 5.75 49815 7.83 50771 8.26 53788 8.91 51404 3.49 50503 1.38 51210 0.86 54121 0.62 51693 0.56 50885 0.76 51719 0.99 54548 0.79 47206 3.20 49911 5.73 51726 3.64 52104 0.73 MANUFACTURING……………………………… 52689 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 2.34 53229 3.83 53766 2.90 54469 8.57 54520 3.48 54549 2.48 54551 1.46 55048 1.06 54976 0.84 55037 0.89 55097 1.00 55471 0.77 51605 1.40 52464 1.66 54522 3.92 55039 0.95 DURABLE GOODS…………………………… 51051 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 1.14 51364 2.27 51833 0.94 52365 6.57 52332 2.51 52446 2.11 52380 1.06 52818 0.86 52719 0.74 52904 0.87 52935 1.06 53270 0.86 50494 2.00 50846 0.70 52381 3.02 52844 0.88 NONDURABLE GOODS……………………… 55594 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 4.47 56527 6.54 57212 6.30 58245 12.05 58469 5.17 58347 3.22 58511 2.27 59141 1.54 59144 1.15 58974 1.07 59130 1.06 59602 0.78 53509 0.60 55329 3.40 58393 5.54 59097 1.21 TRADE, TRANSPORTATION, UTILITIES…… 39131 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 2.27 39138 1.64 38861 -1.11 40211 3.11 39910 1.99 39960 2.10 39444 1.50 40675 1.16 40295 0.96 40415 1.14 39935 1.24 41108 1.06 38748 1.37 39032 0.73 39881 2.18 40330 1.13 WHOLESALE TRADE………………………… 59725 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 2.68 59131 0.33 59738 -0.83 60835 3.37 60521 1.33 60464 2.25 60701 1.61 61509 1.11 61066 0.90 61030 0.94 61304 0.99 62048 0.88 59172 2.55 59361 0.32 60630 2.14 61227 0.98 RETAIL TRADE…………………………………26647 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 2.10 26986 2.78 26637 -1.86 27743 4.85 27438 2.97 27487 1.86 26987 1.32 28040 1.07 27689 0.91 27813 1.19 27328 1.26 28331 1.04 26510 1.42 26683 0.65 27414 2.74 27718 1.11 TRANSPORTATION & UTILITIES…………… 49003 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 2.02 48479 1.23 48009 -0.78 49534 0.50 49402 0.81 49432 1.97 48657 1.35 50055 1.05 49825 0.86 49967 1.08 49273 1.27 50570 1.03 48242 0.33 48694 0.94 49256 1.15 49780 1.06 INFORMATION…………………………………… 56909 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 0.61 58773 3.84 58666 9.75 59235 3.89 59304 4.21 59875 1.88 59247 0.99 59567 0.56 59588 0.48 60342 0.78 59859 1.03 60058 0.82 55891 3.32 57841 3.49 59416 2.72 59839 0.71 FINANCIAL ACTIVITIES………………………… 64660 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 3.13 64744 3.67 65463 2.35 66457 4.28 66508 2.86 66344 2.47 66428 1.47 67131 1.01 67038 0.80 66907 0.85 67046 0.93 67566 0.65 63255 2.66 64649 2.20 66434 2.76 67030 0.90 PROFESSIONAL & BUSINESS SERVICES… 52018 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 8.87 50679 6.59 50169 6.89 51860 0.70 51482 -1.03 51502 1.62 50657 0.97 52194 0.64 51733 0.49 51819 0.62 51036 0.75 52507 0.60 47659 -1.55 51092 7.20 51375 0.55 51695 0.62 EDUCATION & HEALTH SERVICES………… 43759 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 2.31 44501 3.40 44188 4.28 44904 2.53 44998 2.83 45161 1.48 44551 0.82 45182 0.62 45206 0.46 45455 0.65 44910 0.81 45484 0.67 42791 0.55 44062 2.97 44904 1.91 45188 0.63 LEISURE & HOSPITALITY……………………… 21089 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 7.21 20653 5.27 21626 3.92 22500 6.14 21220 0.62 21254 2.91 22000 1.73 22762 1.16 21425 0.97 21500 1.16 22282 1.29 23014 1.10 20161 2.43 21141 4.86 21743 2.85 21992 1.15 OTHER SERVICES……………………………… 40132 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 5.62 40532 5.21 41232 3.91 41750 4.16 40884 1.87 41235 1.74 41427 0.47 41823 0.18 40922 0.09 41366 0.32 41654 0.55 42025 0.48 38855 4.37 40495 4.22 41324 2.05 41441 0.28 GOVERNMENT…………………………………… 39702 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… -0.23 40934 -0.28 39273 2.41 39816 2.16 40570 2.19 41267 0.81 39178 -0.24 39567 -0.63 40240 -0.81 40980 -0.69 38955 -0.57 39282 -0.72 39475 1.44 39721 0.62 40208 1.22 39936 -0.68 FEDERAL, CIVILIAN………………………… 74425 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 4.59 75277 4.06 75296 3.73 77526 4.16 78600 5.61 76563 1.71 75545 0.33 77465 -0.08 78409 -0.24 76465 -0.13 75530 -0.02 77346 -0.15 71511 8.59 74856 4.68 77059 2.94 76967 -0.12 STATE & LOCAL……………………………… 35290 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… -1.06 36451 -1.39 34762 1.72 35162 1.61 35858 1.61 36689 0.65 34682 -0.23 34972 -0.54 35608 -0.70 36481 -0.56 34532 -0.43 34770 -0.58 35381 0.03 35277 -0.29 35598 0.91 35398 -0.56 Center for Business and Economic Research, University of Tennessee Tennessee Econometric Model Forecast Data TOTAL NONFARM…………………………………… 43201 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 3.46 | 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT History 2015:2 2015:3 APPENDIX A 14 Table 11: Tennessee Average Annual Wage and Salary Rate by Sector, Not Seasonally Adjusted (2009 dollars) Table 12: Tennessee Average Annual Wage and Salary Rate by Sector, Seasonally Adjusted (2009 dollars) History 2015:2 2015:3 January 2016 Forecast Data 2015:4 2016:1 2016:2 2016:3 2016:4 2017:1 2017:2 2017:3 2017:4 2018:1 2014 Annual 2015 2016 2017 43973 2.85 3.64 44087 1.04 1.86 44059 -0.26 1.82 44111 0.48 1.02 44274 1.48 0.68 44313 0.35 0.51 44347 0.30 0.65 44461 1.04 0.79 44544 0.75 0.61 41961 1.18 1.18 43161 2.86 2.86 44058 2.08 2.08 44349 0.66 0.66 NATURAL RESOURCES, MINING AND CONSTRUCTION……………………… 50063 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………… 23.73 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr………………… 5.91 51066 8.26 7.96 51367 2.38 8.26 51699 2.61 8.91 51808 0.85 3.49 51770 -0.29 1.38 51811 0.31 0.86 52019 1.62 0.62 52100 0.62 0.56 52162 0.48 0.76 52326 1.26 0.99 52429 0.79 0.79 47214 3.24 3.24 49991 5.88 5.88 51772 3.56 3.56 52152 0.73 0.73 MANUFACTURING……………………………… 52672 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………… 22.74 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr………………… 2.32 53241 4.39 3.79 53900 5.05 2.91 54332 3.24 8.57 54501 1.25 3.47 54558 0.42 2.47 54689 0.97 1.46 54911 1.63 1.07 54956 0.33 0.83 55042 0.63 0.89 55240 1.45 1.01 55335 0.69 0.77 51603 1.41 1.41 52464 1.67 1.67 54520 3.92 3.92 55037 0.95 0.95 DURABLE GOODS…………………………… 51073 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………… 17.69 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr………………… 1.13 51311 1.88 2.23 51960 5.16 0.95 52259 2.32 6.58 52351 0.71 2.50 52389 0.29 2.10 52513 0.95 1.06 52711 1.52 0.87 52735 0.18 0.73 52843 0.82 0.87 53073 1.75 1.07 53164 0.69 0.86 50493 2.00 2.00 50844 0.70 0.70 52378 3.02 3.02 52841 0.88 0.88 NONDURABLE GOODS…………………… 55504 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………… 31.76 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr………………… 4.43 56665 8.63 6.53 57360 5.00 6.31 58047 4.88 12.05 58374 2.27 5.17 58489 0.79 3.22 58661 1.18 2.27 58943 1.93 1.54 59047 0.71 1.15 59117 0.47 1.07 59280 1.11 1.05 59405 0.84 0.78 53507 0.60 0.60 55333 3.41 3.41 58393 5.53 5.53 59097 1.21 1.21 TRADE, TRANSPORTATION, UTILITIES…… 39120 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………… 6.17 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr………………… 2.58 39083 -0.38 1.75 39405 3.33 -1.11 39737 3.42 3.11 39899 1.64 1.99 39903 0.04 2.10 39996 0.93 1.50 40196 2.02 1.16 40284 0.88 0.96 40357 0.73 1.14 40494 1.36 1.24 40624 1.30 1.06 38716 1.31 1.31 39037 0.83 0.83 39884 2.17 2.17 40333 1.13 1.13 WHOLESALE TRADE……………………… 59820 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………… 9.88 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr………………… 2.59 59333 -3.22 0.51 59834 3.42 -0.83 60397 3.82 3.37 60617 1.47 1.33 60670 0.35 2.25 60799 0.85 1.61 61067 1.77 1.11 61163 0.63 0.90 61238 0.49 0.94 61403 1.08 0.99 61602 1.30 0.88 59151 2.51 2.51 59353 0.34 0.34 60621 2.14 2.14 61218 0.98 0.98 RETAIL TRADE……………………………… 26636 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………… 9.18 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr………………… 2.51 26915 4.25 3.04 27124 3.14 -1.86 27321 2.94 4.85 27427 1.56 2.97 27415 -0.19 1.86 27481 0.97 1.32 27614 1.95 1.07 27677 0.93 0.91 27740 0.91 1.19 27827 1.26 1.26 27900 1.05 1.04 26483 1.36 1.36 26683 0.76 0.76 27411 2.73 2.73 27715 1.11 1.11 TRANSPORTATION & UTILITIES………… 48927 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………… 0.36 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr………………… 2.44 48343 -4.69 0.96 48732 3.26 -0.78 49128 3.29 0.50 49325 1.61 0.81 49293 -0.26 1.97 49390 0.79 1.35 49645 2.08 1.05 49748 0.83 0.86 49827 0.64 1.08 50015 1.52 1.27 50156 1.13 1.03 48212 0.28 0.28 48721 1.06 1.06 49284 1.16 1.16 49809 1.06 1.06 INFORMATION………………………………… 57039 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………… -0.15 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr………………… 0.68 58274 8.95 3.28 58842 3.95 9.75 59280 3.01 3.89 59440 1.08 4.21 59368 -0.49 1.88 59426 0.39 0.99 59612 1.26 0.56 59725 0.76 0.48 59830 0.71 0.78 60039 1.41 1.03 60104 0.43 0.82 55910 3.38 3.38 57804 3.39 3.39 59378 2.72 2.72 59802 0.71 0.71 FINANCIAL ACTIVITIES……………………… 64615 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………… 7.28 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr………………… 3.05 64863 1.54 3.59 65601 4.63 2.35 66209 3.76 4.28 66461 1.54 2.86 66466 0.03 2.47 66568 0.62 1.47 66879 1.88 1.01 66991 0.67 0.80 67030 0.23 0.85 67187 0.94 0.93 67314 0.75 0.65 63223 2.66 2.66 64642 2.24 2.24 66426 2.76 2.76 67022 0.90 0.90 (CONTINUED ON NEXT PAGE) | 15 APPENDIX A 43666 3.72 3.10 | 43269 -0.11 3.46 Forecast Data 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT TOTAL NONFARM………………………………… 43281 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………… 8.28 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr………………… 3.50 | Forecast Data 2015:4 2016:1 2016:2 2016:3 2016:4 2017:1 2017:2 2017:3 2017:4 2018:1 2014 Annual 2015 2016 2017 50530 -10.27 6.75 50914 3.07 6.89 51258 2.73 0.70 51383 0.99 -1.03 51350 -0.26 1.62 51408 0.46 0.97 51587 1.40 0.64 51634 0.36 0.49 51666 0.25 0.62 51793 0.99 0.75 51897 0.80 0.60 47621 -1.63 -1.63 51066 7.23 7.23 51350 0.56 0.56 51670 0.62 0.62 EDUCATION & HEALTH SERVICES………… 43698 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………… -0.39 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr………………… 2.34 44240 5.05 3.30 44580 3.11 4.28 44845 2.40 2.53 44936 0.81 2.83 44896 -0.35 1.48 44946 0.44 0.82 45123 1.59 0.62 45144 0.18 0.46 45188 0.39 0.65 45309 1.07 0.81 45425 1.03 0.67 42809 0.58 0.58 44065 2.93 2.93 44906 1.91 1.91 45191 0.63 0.63 LEISURE & HOSPITALITY…………………… 21606 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………… 25.95 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr………………… 7.12 21124 -8.63 4.98 21423 5.79 3.92 21647 4.25 6.14 21740 1.72 0.62 21739 -0.02 2.91 21794 1.02 1.73 21900 1.95 1.16 21951 0.93 0.97 21990 0.73 1.16 22074 1.53 1.29 22141 1.23 1.10 20158 2.45 2.45 21137 4.86 4.86 21730 2.81 2.81 21979 1.14 1.14 OTHER SERVICES………………………………40619 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………… 9.86 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr………………… 5.84 40596 -0.22 4.81 41102 5.08 3.91 41325 2.19 4.16 41379 0.52 1.87 41300 -0.76 1.74 41296 -0.04 0.47 41398 0.99 0.18 41418 0.19 0.09 41431 0.13 0.32 41523 0.88 0.55 41598 0.73 0.48 38866 4.44 4.44 40498 4.20 4.20 41325 2.04 2.04 41442 0.28 0.28 GOVERNMENT………………………………… 39444 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………… -0.32 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr………………… -0.25 39826 3.93 0.52 40161 3.41 2.41 40326 1.66 2.16 40306 -0.20 2.19 40149 -1.55 0.81 40064 -0.85 -0.24 40074 0.10 -0.63 39979 -0.95 -0.81 39870 -1.08 -0.69 39836 -0.35 -0.57 39786 -0.50 -0.72 39409 1.33 1.33 39726 0.81 0.81 40211 1.22 1.22 39940 -0.68 -0.68 FEDERAL, CIVILIAN………………………… 73296 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………… -5.14 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr………………… 1.95 75916 15.08 6.05 76920 5.40 3.73 77362 2.32 4.16 77409 0.24 5.61 77212 -1.01 1.71 77175 -0.19 0.33 77302 0.66 -0.08 77220 -0.42 -0.24 77113 -0.55 -0.13 77159 0.24 -0.02 77183 0.13 -0.15 71860 9.38 9.38 75100 4.51 4.51 77290 2.92 2.92 77198 -0.12 -0.12 STATE & LOCAL………………………………35100 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………… -0.17 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr………………… -0.75 35302 2.32 -0.74 35553 2.87 1.72 35683 1.47 1.62 35665 -0.20 1.61 35535 -1.45 0.66 35471 -0.72 -0.23 35489 0.21 -0.54 35416 -0.82 -0.70 35334 -0.92 -0.57 35317 -0.19 -0.43 35285 -0.36 -0.57 35292 -0.17 -0.17 35267 -0.07 -0.07 35588 0.91 0.91 35389 -0.56 -0.56 Center for Business and Economic Research, University of Tennessee Tennessee Econometric Model Forecast Data PROFESSIONAL & BUSINESS SERVICES… 51918 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………… 8.22 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr………………… 8.67 | 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT History 2015:2 2015:3 January 2016 APPENDIX A 16 Table 12: Tennessee Average Annual Wage and Salary Rate by Sector, Seasonally Adjusted (2009 dollars) Table 13: Tennessee Average Annual Wage and Salary Rate by Sector, Not Seasonally Adjusted (current dollars) History 2015:2 2015:3 January 2016 Forecast Data 2015:4 2016:1 2016:2 2016:3 2016:4 2017:1 2017:2 2017:3 2017:4 2018:1 2014 Annual 2015 2016 2017 48672 4.53 48493 2.61 49021 3.04 48811 2.87 50063 2.86 49861 2.82 50400 2.81 50181 2.81 51446 2.76 45795 2.64 47212 3.10 48749 3.26 50126 2.82 NATURAL RESOURCES, MINING AND CONSTRUCTION………………………… 54336 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 6.02 54664 8.12 55684 8.61 59009 9.83 56649 4.26 56081 2.59 57194 2.71 60652 2.78 58276 2.87 57720 2.92 58917 3.01 62434 2.94 51501 4.67 54603 6.02 57233 4.82 58891 2.90 MANUFACTURING………………………………… 57637 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 2.59 58410 4.10 58969 3.23 59756 9.48 60083 4.24 60574 3.70 60926 3.32 61690 3.24 61977 3.15 62429 3.06 62766 3.02 63490 2.92 56304 2.85 57400 1.95 60335 5.11 62216 3.12 DURABLE GOODS…………………………… 55845 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 1.40 56363 2.55 56848 1.26 57448 7.46 57672 3.27 58239 3.33 58501 2.91 59191 3.03 59432 3.05 60010 3.04 60302 3.08 60971 3.01 55093 3.45 55629 0.97 57965 4.20 59734 3.05 NONDURABLE GOODS……………………… 60814 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 4.73 62028 6.83 62748 6.65 63898 12.99 64435 5.95 64792 4.45 65349 4.15 66278 3.73 66676 3.48 66895 3.25 67360 3.08 68219 2.93 58381 2.03 60536 3.69 64618 6.74 66802 3.38 TRADE, TRANSPORTATION, UTILITIES……… 42806 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 2.53 42948 1.91 42621 -0.79 44113 3.97 43982 2.75 44374 3.32 44053 3.36 45584 3.33 45427 3.28 45843 3.31 45493 3.27 47051 3.22 42276 2.82 42701 1.01 44131 3.35 45587 3.30 WHOLESALE TRADE………………………… 65334 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 2.93 64887 0.60 65518 -0.50 66739 4.24 66696 2.09 67143 3.48 67795 3.47 68931 3.28 68842 3.22 69228 3.11 69837 3.01 71018 3.03 64560 4.01 64941 0.59 67093 3.31 69210 3.15 RETAIL TRADE………………………………… 29150 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 2.36 29612 3.06 29215 -1.54 30436 5.72 30238 3.73 30523 3.07 30141 3.17 31424 3.25 31215 3.23 31549 3.36 31131 3.28 32426 3.19 28924 2.87 29191 0.92 30335 3.92 31330 3.28 TRANSPORTATION & UTILITIES…………… 53605 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 2.27 53198 1.50 52654 -0.46 54342 1.34 54443 1.56 54892 3.18 54343 3.21 56095 3.23 56170 3.17 56678 3.25 56131 3.29 57881 3.18 52634 1.76 53269 1.21 54505 2.32 56268 3.24 INFORMATION…………………………………… 62253 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 0.86 64493 4.12 64342 10.10 64984 4.76 65355 4.98 66489 3.09 66171 2.84 66755 2.72 67177 2.79 68447 2.94 68191 3.05 68741 2.97 60978 4.79 63280 3.78 65750 3.90 67642 2.88 FINANCIAL ACTIVITIES………………………… 70732 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 3.38 71046 3.94 71797 2.68 72908 5.15 73294 3.62 73672 3.70 74191 3.33 75231 3.19 75575 3.11 75893 3.01 76378 2.95 77334 2.79 69014 4.12 70727 2.48 73516 3.94 75769 3.06 PROFESSIONAL & BUSINESS SERVICES…… 56903 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 9.14 55612 6.88 55023 7.24 56893 1.54 56735 -0.29 57190 2.84 56576 2.82 58492 2.81 58321 2.79 58779 2.78 58139 2.76 60097 2.74 51997 -0.15 55892 7.49 56849 1.71 58433 2.79 EDUCATION & HEALTH SERVICES…………… 47868 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 2.57 48832 3.67 48464 4.62 49262 3.38 49589 3.60 50150 2.70 49757 2.67 50634 2.78 50963 2.77 51560 2.81 51161 2.82 52060 2.81 46687 1.98 48204 3.25 49690 3.08 51080 2.80 LEISURE & HOSPITALITY……………………… 23069 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 7.48 22663 5.55 23718 4.25 24684 7.03 23385 1.37 23601 4.14 24571 3.59 25509 3.34 24154 3.29 24387 3.33 25384 3.31 26341 3.26 21996 3.89 23128 5.15 24060 4.03 24859 3.32 OTHER SERVICES……………………………… 43901 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 5.89 44477 5.49 45222 4.25 45802 5.03 45055 2.63 45790 2.95 46269 2.32 46870 2.33 46133 2.39 46922 2.47 47452 2.56 48100 2.62 42393 5.86 44302 4.50 45729 3.22 46844 2.44 GOVERNMENT…………………………………… 43431 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 0.02 44918 -0.01 43074 2.74 43680 3.01 44710 2.94 45825 2.02 43757 1.59 44341 1.51 45365 1.47 46484 1.44 44377 1.42 44961 1.40 43071 2.89 43456 0.90 44493 2.38 45142 1.46 FEDERAL, CIVILIAN…………………………… 81414 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 4.85 82604 4.33 82582 4.07 85050 5.04 86620 6.39 85020 2.92 84374 2.17 86813 2.07 88394 2.05 86735 2.02 86042 1.98 88527 1.97 78025 10.14 81893 4.96 85266 4.12 86996 2.03 STATE & LOCAL……………………………… 38604 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… -0.81 39999 -1.13 38126 2.05 38575 2.46 39517 2.36 40741 1.85 38735 1.60 39192 1.60 40142 1.58 41381 1.57 39338 1.56 39797 1.54 38604 1.46 38595 -0.03 39392 2.07 40013 1.58 17 Center for Business and Economic Research, University of Tennessee Tennessee Econometric Model APPENDIX A 47449 3.44 | | 47577 3.63 Forecast Data 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT TOTAL NONFARM…………………………………… 47258 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 3.72 January 2016 | TOTAL NONFARM……………………………………………….. 47346 47481 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………………………… 10.68 1.14 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………………….. 3.76 3.73 47891 48241 48586 48925 49266 49616 49956 50303 50649 50984 3.50 2.96 2.89 2.82 2.82 2.87 2.77 2.81 2.78 2.67 3.44 4.51 2.62 3.04 2.87 2.85 2.82 2.82 2.81 2.76 45782 47219 48755 50131 2.62 3.14 3.25 2.82 2.62 3.14 3.25 2.82 NATURAL RESOURCES, MINING & CONSTRUCTION…… 54764 56036 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………………………… 26.46 9.62 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………………….. 6.18 8.25 56338 56717 57094 57489 57866 58296 58734 59169 59609 60009 2.17 2.72 2.69 2.79 2.65 3.01 3.04 2.99 3.01 2.71 8.61 9.83 4.26 2.59 2.71 2.78 2.87 2.92 3.01 2.94 51513 54695 57291 58952 4.71 6.18 4.75 2.90 4.71 6.18 4.75 2.90 MANUFACTURING…………………………………………… 57619 58423 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………………………… 25.45 5.70 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………………….. 2.58 4.07 59116 59605 60062 60584 61081 61537 61954 62435 62929 63334 4.83 3.35 3.10 3.52 3.32 3.02 2.74 3.15 3.20 2.60 3.24 9.48 4.24 3.70 3.32 3.24 3.15 3.06 3.03 2.92 56302 57400 60333 62214 2.85 1.95 5.11 3.12 2.85 1.95 5.11 3.12 DURABLE GOODS……………………………………...... 55869 56305 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………………………… 20.29 3.16 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………………….. 1.39 2.50 56988 57331 57693 58176 58650 59072 59451 59941 60460 60849 4.94 2.43 2.55 3.39 3.30 2.91 2.59 3.34 3.51 2.60 1.28 7.47 3.26 3.32 2.92 3.04 3.05 3.03 3.09 3.01 55092 55627 57962 59731 3.45 0.97 4.20 3.05 3.45 0.97 4.20 3.05 NONDURABLE GOODS…………………………….. 60716 62180 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………………………… 34.67 10.00 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………………….. 4.70 6.82 62910 63681 64330 64949 65517 66055 66566 67057 67531 67993 4.78 4.99 4.14 3.91 3.54 3.33 3.13 2.98 2.86 2.76 6.65 12.98 5.95 4.45 4.14 3.73 3.48 3.24 3.07 2.93 58379 60542 64619 66803 2.03 3.71 6.73 3.38 2.03 3.71 6.73 3.38 TRADE, TRANSPORTATION, UTILITIES…………. 42794 42887 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………………………… 8.51 0.87 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………………….. 2.84 2.02 43218 43594 43970 44311 44670 45047 45414 45778 46130 46497 3.12 3.53 3.50 3.13 3.28 3.42 3.30 3.24 3.11 3.22 -0.79 3.97 2.75 3.32 3.36 3.33 3.28 3.31 3.27 3.22 42242 42707 44136 45592 2.75 1.10 3.35 3.30 2.75 1.10 3.35 3.30 WHOLESALE TRADE……………………………………. 65438 65107 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………………………… 12.31 -2.00 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………………….. 2.85 0.78 65624 66259 66802 67371 67904 68436 68952 69463 69949 70508 3.21 3.93 3.32 3.45 3.20 3.17 3.05 3.00 2.83 3.23 -0.50 4.24 2.09 3.48 3.47 3.28 3.22 3.10 3.01 3.03 64537 64934 67084 69200 3.97 0.61 3.31 3.15 3.97 0.61 3.31 3.15 RETAIL TRADE……………………………………………. 29138 29534 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………………………… 11.59 5.56 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………………….. 2.77 3.31 29748 29973 30226 30443 30692 30946 31202 31466 31700 31933 2.93 3.05 3.42 2.90 3.32 3.35 3.35 3.43 3.01 2.97 -1.54 5.72 3.73 3.07 3.17 3.25 3.23 3.36 3.28 3.19 28895 29193 30333 31329 2.80 1.03 3.91 3.28 2.80 1.03 3.91 3.28 TRANSPORTATION & UTILITIES…………………………… 53522 53048 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………………………… 2.58 -3.49 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………………….. 2.70 1.23 53448 53897 54358 54738 55162 55636 56083 56519 56977 57407 3.05 3.40 3.47 2.82 3.14 3.48 3.25 3.15 3.28 3.05 -0.46 1.34 1.56 3.18 3.21 3.23 3.17 3.25 3.29 3.18 52602 53300 54539 56304 1.71 1.33 2.32 3.24 1.71 1.33 2.32 3.24 INFORMATION…………………………………………………… 62396 63946 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………………………… 2.06 10.31 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………………….. 0.94 3.55 64536 65034 65505 65925 66370 66806 67331 67866 68396 68793 3.74 3.12 2.93 2.59 2.73 2.65 3.18 3.22 3.16 2.34 10.10 4.76 4.98 3.09 2.84 2.72 2.79 2.94 3.05 2.97 60999 63239 65708 67600 4.85 3.67 3.90 2.88 4.85 3.67 3.90 2.88 FINANCIAL ACTIVITIES…………………………………..... 70683 71177 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………………………… 9.65 2.82 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………………….. 3.31 3.87 71949 72635 73243 73807 74348 74950 75522 76033 76539 77045 4.41 3.87 3.39 3.12 2.96 3.28 3.09 2.73 2.69 2.67 2.68 5.16 3.62 3.70 3.33 3.19 3.11 3.01 2.95 2.79 68979 70721 73508 75761 4.12 2.52 3.94 3.06 4.12 2.52 3.94 3.06 (CONTINUED ON NEXT PAGE) 2014 Annual 2015 2016 2017 Forecast Data Forecast Data 2015:4 2016:1 2016:2 2016:3 2016:4 2017:1 2017:2 2017:3 2017:4 2018:1 | 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT History 2015:2 2015:3 APPENDIX A 18 Table 14: Tennessee Average Annual Wage and Salary Rate by Sector, Seasonally Adjusted (current dollars) Table 14: Tennessee Average Annual Wage and Salary Rate by Sector, Seasonally Adjusted (current dollars) January 2016 History 2015:2 2015:3 Forecast Data 2015:4 2016:1 2016:2 2016:3 2016:4 2017:1 2017:2 2017:3 2017:4 2018:1 PROFESSIONAL & BUSINESS SERVICES………………… 56794 55448 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………………………… 10.61 -9.15 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………………….. 8.94 7.04 55840 56232 56626 57021 57416 57813 58209 58605 59002 59400 2.86 2.84 2.83 2.82 2.80 2.79 2.77 2.75 2.74 2.72 7.24 1.54 -0.29 2.84 2.82 2.81 2.79 2.78 2.76 2.75 51957 55865 56824 58407 -0.22 7.52 1.72 2.79 -0.22 7.52 1.72 2.79 EDUCATION & HEALTH SERVICES……………………….. 47802 48546 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………………………… 1.81 6.37 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………………….. 2.59 3.57 48894 49198 49521 49855 50198 50568 50892 51257 51615 51992 2.90 2.51 2.65 2.73 2.78 2.98 2.59 2.90 2.82 2.95 4.62 3.38 3.60 2.70 2.67 2.78 2.77 2.81 2.82 2.81 46707 48207 49693 51083 2.02 3.21 3.08 2.80 2.02 3.21 3.08 2.80 LEISURE & HOSPITALITY……………………………………. 23635 23180 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………………………… 28.74 -7.48 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………………….. 7.39 5.26 23496 23749 23958 24140 24341 24542 24746 24944 25147 25342 5.57 4.36 3.58 3.07 3.37 3.35 3.36 3.24 3.29 3.15 4.25 7.03 1.37 4.14 3.59 3.34 3.29 3.33 3.31 3.26 21995 23125 24047 24845 3.92 5.14 3.99 3.32 3.92 5.14 3.99 3.32 OTHER SERVICES………………………………………….... 44433 44547 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………………………… 12.29 1.03 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………………….. 6.10 5.09 45079 45336 45601 45862 46122 46393 46692 46996 47302 47611 4.86 2.30 2.36 2.31 2.29 2.37 2.60 2.63 2.63 2.64 4.25 5.03 2.63 2.95 2.31 2.33 2.39 2.47 2.56 2.63 42406 44306 45730 46846 5.92 4.48 3.22 2.44 5.92 4.48 3.22 2.44 GOVERNMENT……………………………………………….... 43148 43702 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………………………… 1.89 5.23 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………………….. 0.00 0.79 44047 44240 44419 44584 44746 44910 45070 45226 45380 45538 3.20 1.76 1.62 1.49 1.46 1.47 1.43 1.39 1.38 1.39 2.74 3.01 2.94 2.02 1.59 1.51 1.47 1.44 1.42 1.40 42997 43461 44497 45146 2.78 1.08 2.38 1.46 2.78 1.08 2.38 1.46 FEDERAL, CIVILIAN……………………………………….. 80179 83305 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………………………… -3.04 16.53 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………………….. 2.21 6.33 84363 84871 85307 85741 86194 86630 87053 87470 87898 88341 5.18 2.43 2.07 2.05 2.13 2.04 1.97 1.93 1.97 2.03 4.07 5.04 6.39 2.92 2.17 2.07 2.05 2.02 1.98 1.97 78407 82162 85528 87263 10.94 4.79 4.10 2.03 10.94 4.79 4.10 2.03 STATE & LOCAL………………………………………….... 38396 38738 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………………………… 2.03 3.61 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………………….. -0.50 -0.48 38993 39146 39304 39460 39616 39771 39926 40079 40233 40386 2.66 1.58 1.62 1.60 1.59 1.58 1.56 1.55 1.54 1.53 2.05 2.47 2.36 1.86 1.60 1.60 1.58 1.57 1.56 1.55 38505 38582 39381 40002 1.25 0.20 2.07 1.58 1.25 0.20 2.07 1.58 Center for Business and Economic Research, University of Tennessee 2014 Annual 2015 2016 2017 Tennessee Econometric Model Forecast Data | | 19 APPENDIX A 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT | History 2015:3 2015:4 January 2016 2014 Annual 2015 2016 2017 3064 2.47 3042 0.62 3068 -1.21 3069 0.09 3067 0.13 3057 0.50 3087 0.62 3089 0.67 3090 0.74 3081 0.77 3011 -2.27 3065 1.76 3062 -0.10 3081 0.63 EMPLOYED PERSONS (THOUS)…………… 2883 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 2.78 2899 3.45 2875 1.61 2899 -0.93 2891 0.28 2905 0.21 2892 0.62 2921 0.76 2915 0.82 2930 0.87 2918 0.89 2811 -1.10 2884 2.62 2893 0.28 2915 0.77 UNEMPLOYED PERSONS (THOUS)………… 183 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… -13.89 164 -12.10 168 -13.83 169 -5.73 177 -2.88 162 -1.24 165 -1.58 165 -1.88 174 -1.80 160 -1.60 163 -1.33 201 -16.17 180 -10.21 169 -6.17 166 -1.72 PARTICIPATION RATE (PERCENT)…………… % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 57.7 0.41 57.5 1.26 56.9 -0.56 57.2 -2.36 57.1 -1.06 56.9 -1.02 56.5 -0.64 56.9 -0.51 56.8 -0.44 56.7 -0.37 56.4 -0.32 57.4 -3.43 57.7 0.55 57.0 -1.26 56.7 -0.49 UNEMPLOYMENT RATE (PERCENT)…………… 6.0 5.4 5.5 5.5 5.8 5.3 5.4 5.4 5.6 5.2 5.3 6.7 5.9 5.5 5.4 Center for Business and Economic Research, University of Tennessee Tennessee Econometric Model Forecast Data CIVILIAN LABOR FORCE (THOUS)……………… 3066 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 1.61 | 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT 2016:1 2016:2 2016:3 2016:4 2017:1 2017:2 2017:3 2017:4 2018:1 APPENDIX A 20 Table 15: Tennessee Civilian Labor Force and Unemployment Rate, Not Seasonally Adjusted Table 16: Tennessee Civilian Labor Force and Unemployment Rate, Seasonally Adjusted History 2015:3 2015:4 CIVILIAN LABOR FORCE (THOUS)………… % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………………… % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………… Forecast Data 2016:1 2016:2 2016:3 2016:4 2017:1 2017:2 2017:3 2017:4 2018:1 2014 Annual 2015 2016 2017 3058 -4.74 2.39 3062 0.42 2.63 3056 -0.79 0.61 3058 0.35 -1.21 3061 0.43 0.10 3065 0.52 0.12 3071 0.69 0.49 3077 0.83 0.62 3082 0.67 0.68 3088 0.73 0.73 3094 0.85 0.77 2993 -1.97 -1.97 3063 2.33 2.33 3060 -0.10 -0.10 3079 0.63 0.63 EMPLOYED PERSONS (THOUS)………… 2884 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………………… -4.22 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………… 3.40 2891 0.97 3.75 2885 -0.80 1.61 2888 0.42 -0.93 2892 0.56 0.28 2897 0.66 0.21 2903 0.83 0.62 2910 1.00 0.76 2916 0.80 0.82 2922 0.83 0.87 2929 0.94 0.89 2797 -0.84 -0.84 2882 3.05 3.05 2890 0.28 0.28 2913 0.77 0.77 174 -12.79 -11.83 171 -8.29 -13.30 171 -0.48 -13.83 170 -0.80 -5.73 169 -1.75 -2.88 169 -1.93 -1.24 168 -1.85 -1.58 167 -2.00 -1.88 166 -1.44 -1.80 166 -1.11 -1.60 166 -0.76 -1.33 197 -15.69 -15.69 181 -7.97 -7.97 170 -6.20 -6.20 167 -1.72 -1.72 57.5 -5.87 1.18 57.4 -0.77 1.41 57.1 -1.92 -0.58 57.0 -0.80 -2.36 56.9 -0.72 -1.05 56.8 -0.63 -1.02 56.8 -0.42 -0.64 56.7 -0.27 -0.51 56.7 -0.43 -0.44 56.6 -0.37 -0.37 56.6 -0.23 -0.32 57.1 -3.13 -3.13 57.7 1.12 1.12 57.0 -1.26 -1.26 56.7 -0.49 -0.49 5.7 5.6 5.6 5.6 5.5 5.5 5.5 5.4 5.4 5.4 5.4 6.6 5.9 5.5 5.4 UNEMPLOYED PERSONS (THOUS)…… % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………………… % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………… PARTICIPATION RATE (PERCENT)………… % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………………… % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………… UNEMPLOYMENT RATE (PERCENT)……… Center for Business and Economic Research, University of Tennessee Tennessee Econometric Model Forecast Data | | 21 APPENDIX A 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT | History 2015:2 2015:3 January 2016 2014 Annual 2015 2016 2017 25942 7.27 27861 5.41 24740 7.55 27009 3.65 26344 1.55 28236 1.35 25119 1.53 27313 1.13 26657 1.19 28680 1.57 25526 1.62 AUTO DEALERS………………………………… 2750 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 13.37 2870 12.91 2592 9.16 2717 7.13 2865 4.20 2953 2.88 2650 2.22 2805 3.26 2855 -0.36 2925 -0.94 2690 1.52 2900 3.39 9683 5.90 10748 11.00 11185 4.06 11275 0.81 PURCHASES FROM MANUFACTURERS…. % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 1100 9.19 1136 9.67 1311 5.12 957 8.26 1164 5.90 1149 1.17 1319 0.58 965 0.82 1180 1.36 1166 1.46 1341 1.66 981 1.66 4109 5.64 4431 7.84 4590 3.58 4652 1.36 MISC DURABLE GOODS……………………… % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 4547 7.15 4346 5.49 4478 5.83 3909 10.67 4688 3.10 4416 1.61 4527 1.11 3961 1.33 4750 1.31 4486 1.60 4606 1.73 4026 1.64 16103 3.01 16903 4.97 17540 3.77 17803 1.49 EATING AND DRINKING PLACES…………… 2833 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 8.68 2808 7.36 2768 6.00 2713 6.30 2918 2.98 2859 1.80 2812 1.59 2761 1.80 2967 1.69 2912 1.85 2870 2.07 2814 1.92 10260 4.35 10961 6.84 11301 3.10 11510 1.85 FOOD STORES………………………………… % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 2420 3.91 2457 3.83 2673 3.44 2370 2.57 2482 2.54 2480 0.94 2693 0.73 2380 0.41 2490 0.36 2489 0.36 2706 0.51 2388 0.33 9490 1.29 9861 3.91 10024 1.66 10065 0.41 LIQUOR STORES……………………………… % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 211 9.22 210 8.12 262 6.18 211 5.50 219 3.57 214 1.90 266 1.36 213 1.39 222 1.52 218 1.71 271 2.07 218 2.01 821 5.48 883 7.62 909 2.95 925 1.69 HOTELS AND MOTELS………………………… 801 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 12.38 832 13.97 757 12.88 636 10.66 827 3.20 827 -0.63 765 1.07 661 3.84 859 3.94 860 3.95 795 3.92 685 3.74 2647 12.27 2965 12.00 3055 3.03 3174 3.92 OTHER RETAIL AND SERVICE……………… % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 7789 6.24 7708 8.01 8946 4.73 7635 8.86 8122 4.27 7829 1.56 9121 1.96 7766 1.71 8254 1.63 7969 1.79 9290 1.86 7894 1.65 29923 3.84 31457 5.13 32707 3.97 33279 1.75 MISC NONDURABLE GOODS………………… 2134 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 4.37 2098 5.75 2518 5.83 2102 9.74 2236 4.80 2146 2.31 2555 1.47 2130 1.29 2265 1.29 2178 1.50 2597 1.65 2160 1.44 8297 2.66 8665 4.44 9040 4.32 9170 1.44 TRANSPORTATION, COMMUNICATION…… 1472 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 13.65 1476 1.21 1556 0.80 1491 0.36 1488 1.10 1471 -0.33 1529 -1.75 1477 -0.93 1471 -1.17 1454 -1.11 1513 -1.01 1460 -1.17 5786 -2.78 5989 3.51 5978 -0.17 5915 -1.05 3887 6.16 4164 4.32 3688 6.44 4016 2.58 3907 0.51 4177 0.31 3706 0.50 4020 0.10 3913 0.17 4199 0.55 3728 0.60 14721 2.39 15429 4.81 15786 2.31 15838 0.33 PER CAPITA ($)…………………………………… % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 3914 6.60 Center for Business and Economic Research, University of Tennessee 97118 102863 106329 107769 3.48 5.92 3.37 1.35 Tennessee Econometric Model Forecast Data TOTAL TAXABLE SALES………………………… 26057 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 7.72 | 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT Forecast Data 2015:4 2016:1 2016:2 2016:3 2016:4 2017:1 2017:2 2017:3 2017:4 2018:1 APPENDIX A 22 Table 17: Tennessee Taxable Sales, Not Seasonally Adjusted (millions of 2009 dollars) Table 18: Tennessee Taxable Sales, Seasonally Adjusted (millions of 2009 dollars) History 2015:2 2015:3 January 2016 Forecast Data 2015:4 2016:1 2016:2 2016:3 2016:4 2017:1 2017:2 2017:3 2017:4 2018:1 2014 Annual 2015 2016 2017 26580 2.88 3.66 26635 0.83 1.55 26708 1.10 1.35 26795 1.31 1.53 26878 1.24 1.12 26954 1.14 1.20 27127 2.59 1.57 27230 1.52 1.62 AUTO DEALERS………………………………… 2697 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………… 29.95 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 13.53 2754 8.67 12.79 2774 3.02 9.16 2706 -9.45 7.13 2810 16.28 4.20 2833 3.28 2.88 2836 0.39 2.22 2794 -5.71 3.26 2800 0.84 -0.36 2806 0.89 -0.94 2879 10.74 1.52 2889 1.43 3.39 9689 5.98 5.98 10751 10.95 10.95 11185 4.04 4.04 11279 0.85 0.85 PURCHASES FROM MANUFACTURERS…. % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………… % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 1081 8.58 9.28 1135 21.27 9.81 1144 3.23 5.12 1147 1.06 8.26 1145 -0.61 5.90 1148 1.03 1.17 1151 0.86 0.58 1156 2.02 0.82 1161 1.55 1.36 1165 1.41 1.46 1170 1.68 1.66 1176 2.02 1.66 4089 5.42 5.42 4420 8.09 8.09 4591 3.87 3.87 4652 1.33 1.33 MISC DURABLE GOODS……………………… 4252 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………… 34.98 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 7.15 4317 6.21 5.44 4352 3.30 5.83 4366 1.30 10.67 4384 1.66 3.10 4386 0.18 1.61 4400 1.31 1.11 4424 2.18 1.33 4442 1.58 1.31 4456 1.32 1.60 4476 1.83 1.73 4497 1.81 1.64 16089 2.96 2.96 16866 4.83 4.83 17537 3.98 3.98 17799 1.49 1.49 EATING AND DRINKING PLACES…………… 2741 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………… 15.86 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 8.64 2779 5.72 7.36 2796 2.46 6.00 2808 1.73 6.30 2823 2.06 2.98 2829 0.97 1.80 2841 1.61 1.59 2859 2.56 1.80 2870 1.62 1.69 2882 1.59 1.85 2899 2.51 2.07 2914 1.96 1.92 10259 4.35 4.35 10958 6.81 6.81 11301 3.13 3.13 11510 1.85 1.85 FOOD STORES………………………………… % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………… % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 2445 0.82 3.95 2483 6.40 3.83 2489 0.91 3.44 2503 2.24 2.57 2507 0.70 2.54 2507 -0.09 0.94 2507 0.08 0.73 2513 0.97 0.41 2516 0.48 0.36 2516 -0.08 0.36 2520 0.67 0.51 2522 0.26 0.33 9487 1.21 1.21 9858 3.91 3.91 10024 1.69 1.69 10065 0.41 0.41 LIQUOR STORES……………………………… % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………… % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 219 8.75 9.31 223 7.79 8.05 225 3.42 6.18 226 2.17 5.50 227 1.04 3.57 228 1.00 1.90 228 1.24 1.36 230 2.30 1.39 230 1.53 1.52 231 1.76 1.71 233 2.70 2.07 234 2.07 2.01 819 5.36 5.36 882 7.69 7.69 909 3.05 3.05 924 1.67 1.67 HOTELS AND MOTELS………………………… 737 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………… 37.30 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 12.32 771 19.59 13.88 765 -2.95 12.88 753 -5.90 10.66 760 3.85 3.20 766 2.81 -0.63 773 3.86 1.07 782 4.85 3.84 790 4.26 3.94 796 2.84 3.95 803 3.75 3.92 812 4.11 3.74 2642 11.91 11.91 2953 11.78 11.78 3053 3.37 3.37 3172 3.91 3.91 OTHER RETAIL AND SERVICE……………… 7832 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………… 20.96 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 6.23 8060 12.16 7.99 8058 -0.10 4.73 8130 3.62 8.86 8166 1.79 4.27 8186 0.97 1.56 8216 1.49 1.96 8269 2.61 1.71 8299 1.45 1.63 8332 1.60 1.79 8369 1.76 1.86 8406 1.78 1.65 29891 3.72 3.72 31419 5.11 5.11 32699 4.07 4.07 33270 1.75 1.75 MISC NONDURABLE GOODS………………… 2155 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………… 21.73 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 4.36 2209 10.46 5.70 2235 4.79 5.83 2251 2.92 9.74 2258 1.24 4.80 2260 0.36 2.31 2268 1.36 1.47 2280 2.23 1.29 2287 1.22 1.29 2294 1.19 1.50 2305 1.95 1.65 2313 1.41 1.44 8289 2.57 2.57 8650 4.36 4.36 9037 4.47 4.47 9167 1.43 1.43 TRANSPORTATION, COMMUNICATION…… 1483 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………… -3.32 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 13.72 1497 4.06 1.26 1514 4.60 0.80 1501 -3.60 0.36 1499 -0.42 1.10 1492 -1.72 -0.33 1488 -1.22 -1.75 1487 -0.34 -0.93 1481 -1.40 -1.17 1476 -1.50 -1.11 1473 -0.79 -1.01 1469 -0.99 -1.17 5782 -2.77 -2.77 5989 3.59 3.59 5980 -0.16 -0.16 5917 -1.05 -1.05 | PER CAPITA ($)…………………………………… 3852 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………… 18.31 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 6.59 3930 8.33 6.09 3938 0.86 4.38 3934 -0.44 6.51 3952 1.83 2.59 3950 -0.20 0.51 3951 0.07 0.31 3953 0.29 0.49 3956 0.22 0.09 3957 0.13 0.17 3972 1.56 0.55 3977 0.51 0.60 14710 2.32 2.32 15414 4.78 4.78 15786 2.42 2.42 15838 0.33 0.33 23 97036 102746 106315 107755 3.41 5.88 3.47 1.35 3.41 5.88 3.47 1.35 Center for Business and Economic Research, University of Tennessee Tennessee Econometric Model APPENDIX A 26392 0.59 7.62 | 26353 1.91 5.48 Forecast Data 26228 9.46 7.21 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT TOTAL TAXABLE SALES………………………… 25642 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………… 19.55 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 7.71 | History 2015:2 2015:3 January 2016 2014 Annual 2015 2016 2017 28466 7.56 30557 5.75 27142 8.45 29764 4.42 29253 2.76 31536 3.20 28150 3.72 30792 3.45 30237 3.36 32671 3.60 29216 3.79 AUTO DEALERS………………………………… 3008 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 13.65 3150 13.21 2843 9.51 2980 8.03 3158 4.97 3279 4.11 2959 4.09 3144 5.48 3219 1.93 3318 1.19 3064 3.55 3320 5.60 10565 7.42 11760 11.31 12376 5.24 12745 2.98 PURCHASES FROM MANUFACTURERS…. % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 1203 9.46 1246 9.96 1438 5.46 1050 9.17 1283 6.68 1276 2.38 1473 2.43 1081 2.99 1331 3.69 1322 3.64 1528 3.70 1123 3.83 4484 7.15 4849 8.14 5082 4.81 5262 3.54 MISC DURABLE GOODS……………………… % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 4974 7.42 4769 5.77 4911 6.17 4288 11.60 5167 3.87 4904 2.82 5057 2.97 4439 3.51 5355 3.64 5089 3.78 5247 3.76 4608 3.80 17572 4.49 18497 5.26 19415 4.96 20129 3.68 EATING AND DRINKING PLACES…………… 3099 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 8.95 3082 7.65 3036 6.34 2976 7.19 3215 3.74 3175 3.02 3141 3.45 3095 3.99 3345 4.02 3303 4.03 3270 4.11 3221 4.09 11195 5.84 11993 7.13 12507 4.28 13012 4.04 FOOD STORES………………………………… % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 2647 4.17 2696 4.11 2932 3.78 2600 3.43 2735 3.30 2754 2.15 3007 2.57 2667 2.58 2808 2.66 2823 2.51 3083 2.51 2733 2.47 10356 2.74 10789 4.19 11096 2.84 11381 2.57 LIQUOR STORES……………………………… % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 231 9.49 231 8.41 287 6.53 231 6.38 241 4.34 238 3.12 297 3.22 239 3.58 250 3.85 247 3.89 309 4.11 249 4.19 896 6.97 967 7.92 1007 4.17 1046 3.87 HOTELS AND MOTELS………………………… 876 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 12.66 913 14.28 830 13.25 698 11.59 911 3.97 918 0.56 854 2.92 740 6.08 969 6.33 975 6.18 905 6.00 785 5.95 2889 13.90 3245 12.31 3381 4.21 3589 6.15 OTHER RETAIL AND SERVICE……………… % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 8521 6.51 8459 8.30 9811 5.07 8376 9.77 8950 5.04 8693 2.78 10187 3.83 8703 3.90 9305 3.96 9039 3.97 10583 3.89 9035 3.81 32652 5.31 34421 5.42 36207 5.19 37631 3.93 MISC NONDURABLE GOODS………………… 2334 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 4.63 2302 6.03 2762 6.17 2306 10.66 2464 5.57 2383 3.54 2853 3.32 2386 3.47 2554 3.61 2471 3.68 2958 3.68 2473 3.60 9053 4.12 9482 4.73 10007 5.54 10369 3.62 TRANSPORTATION, COMMUNICATION…… 1610 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 13.94 1619 1.48 1707 1.13 1635 1.20 1640 1.85 1633 0.86 1707 0.05 1655 1.21 1658 1.10 1650 1.01 1724 0.97 1671 0.94 6313 -1.39 6552 3.79 6616 0.98 6687 1.07 4265 6.44 4566 4.66 4046 7.33 4425 3.35 4338 1.71 4665 2.15 4153 2.66 4532 2.40 4439 2.32 4784 2.56 4267 2.75 16063 3.85 16883 5.10 17474 3.50 17907 2.48 PER CAPITA ($)…………………………………… % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 4282 6.87 Center for Business and Economic Research, University of Tennessee 105976 112554 117695 121850 4.96 6.21 4.57 3.53 Tennessee Econometric Model Forecast Data TOTAL TAXABLE SALES………………………… 28505 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 7.99 | 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT Forecast Data 2015:4 2016:1 2016:2 2016:3 2016:4 2017:1 2017:2 2017:3 2017:4 2018:1 APPENDIX A 24 Table 19: Tennessee Taxable Sales, Not Seasonally Adjusted (millions of current dollars) Table 20: Tennessee Taxable Sales, Seasonally Adjusted (millions of current dollars) History 2015:2 2015:3 January 2016 Forecast Data 2015:4 2016:1 2016:2 2016:3 2016:4 2017:1 2017:2 2017:3 2017:4 2018:1 Annual 2015 2016 2017 105877 112414 117652 4.89 6.17 4.66 4.89 6.17 4.66 121807 3.53 3.53 2014 28953 0.70 8.52 29292 4.76 4.43 29577 3.95 2.77 29829 3.45 3.20 30028 2.70 3.71 30301 3.67 3.44 30575 3.67 3.37 30903 4.37 3.60 31167 3.45 3.79 AUTO DEALERS………………………………… 2950 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………… 32.82 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 13.82 3022 10.03 13.09 3043 2.81 9.51 2969 -9.35 8.03 3097 18.40 4.97 3146 6.47 4.11 3167 2.73 4.09 3131 -4.42 5.48 3157 3.26 1.93 3183 3.40 1.19 3279 12.65 3.55 3307 3.36 5.60 10572 7.49 7.49 11762 11.26 11.26 12378 5.24 5.24 12751 3.01 3.01 PURCHASES FROM MANUFACTURERS…. 1183 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………… 10.98 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 9.55 1245 22.79 10.10 1255 3.02 5.46 1258 1.17 9.17 1262 1.21 6.68 1275 4.15 2.38 1285 3.21 2.43 1296 3.42 2.99 1309 3.99 3.69 1321 3.94 3.64 1333 3.44 3.70 1346 3.96 3.83 4461 6.93 6.93 4836 8.39 8.39 5080 5.06 5.06 5258 3.51 3.51 MISC DURABLE GOODS……………………… 4652 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………… 37.96 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 7.42 4737 7.54 5.72 4773 3.09 6.17 4790 1.41 11.60 4832 3.52 3.87 4871 3.28 2.82 4915 3.67 2.97 4958 3.58 3.51 5007 4.02 3.64 5055 3.85 3.78 5100 3.59 3.76 5147 3.75 3.80 17555 4.44 4.44 18454 5.12 5.12 19407 5.16 5.16 20120 3.67 3.67 EATING AND DRINKING PLACES…………… 2998 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………… 18.42 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 8.92 3050 7.05 7.65 3067 2.25 6.34 3081 1.84 7.19 3111 3.92 3.74 3142 4.09 3.02 3173 3.98 3.45 3204 3.97 3.99 3236 4.06 4.02 3269 4.13 4.03 3303 4.28 4.11 3335 3.90 4.09 11194 5.84 5.84 11989 7.10 7.10 12506 4.31 4.31 13011 4.04 4.04 FOOD STORES………………………………… % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………… % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 2675 3.05 4.21 2725 7.74 4.11 2730 0.71 3.78 2746 2.35 3.43 2763 2.54 3.30 2784 3.00 2.15 2800 2.41 2.57 2817 2.35 2.58 2837 2.89 2.66 2854 2.41 2.52 2871 2.41 2.51 2886 2.16 2.47 10351 2.66 2.66 10785 4.19 4.19 11093 2.86 2.86 11377 2.57 2.57 LIQUOR STORES……………………………… 240 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………… 11.15 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 9.58 245 9.14 8.34 247 3.21 6.53 248 2.28 6.38 250 2.89 4.34 253 4.12 3.12 255 3.60 3.22 257 3.70 3.58 260 3.97 3.85 262 4.30 3.89 265 4.48 4.11 268 4.01 4.19 894 6.86 6.86 965 7.98 7.98 1006 4.24 4.24 1045 3.86 3.86 HOTELS AND MOTELS………………………… 806 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………… 40.33 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 12.60 846 21.10 14.18 839 -3.15 13.25 826 -5.80 11.59 838 5.75 3.97 850 5.99 0.56 863 6.28 2.92 877 6.29 6.08 891 6.76 6.33 903 5.41 6.18 915 5.55 6.00 929 6.09 5.95 2883 13.51 13.51 3231 12.09 12.09 3378 4.55 4.55 3586 6.15 6.15 OTHER RETAIL AND SERVICE……………… 8568 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………… 23.64 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 6.49 8845 13.57 8.28 8838 -0.30 5.07 8919 3.73 9.77 9000 3.65 5.04 9090 4.09 2.78 9176 3.85 3.83 9267 4.02 3.90 9356 3.89 3.96 9452 4.14 3.97 9534 3.52 3.89 9621 3.71 3.81 32614 5.20 5.20 34376 5.40 5.40 36186 5.27 5.27 37609 3.93 3.93 MISC NONDURABLE GOODS………………… 2357 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………… 24.42 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 4.63 2424 11.85 5.98 2451 4.57 6.17 2470 3.03 10.66 2489 3.09 5.57 2510 3.46 3.54 2533 3.72 3.32 2556 3.63 3.47 2579 3.65 3.61 2602 3.72 3.68 2626 3.71 3.68 2648 3.34 3.60 9044 4.04 4.04 9464 4.64 4.64 10001 5.67 5.67 10362 3.61 3.61 TRANSPORTATION, COMMUNICATION…… 1622 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………… -1.18 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 14.00 1643 5.37 1.53 1661 4.39 1.13 1646 -3.50 1.20 1652 1.40 1.85 1657 1.32 0.86 1662 1.08 0.05 1666 1.03 1.21 1670 0.97 1.10 1674 0.96 1.01 1678 0.93 0.97 1682 0.90 0.94 6308 -1.38 -1.38 6552 3.87 3.87 6617 0.99 0.99 6688 1.07 1.07 PER CAPITA ($)…………………………………… 4214 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………… 20.93 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 6.86 4312 9.69 6.38 4319 0.65 4.72 4316 -0.33 7.40 4355 3.69 3.35 4386 2.89 1.71 4412 2.40 2.15 4430 1.66 2.66 4459 2.63 2.39 4488 2.63 2.33 4525 3.32 2.56 4552 2.42 2.75 16050 3.78 3.78 16864 5.07 5.07 17469 3.59 3.59 17903 2.48 2.48 | Center for Business and Economic Research, University of Tennessee 25 APPENDIX A 28903 1.70 5.82 | 28781 10.84 7.49 Forecast Data 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT TOTAL TAXABLE SALES………………………… 28050 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………… 22.19 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 7.98 Table 1: Selected U.S. and Tennessee Economic Indicators, Seasonally Adjusted January 2016 | 2017 2018 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025 16780.6 2.65 17274.5 2.94 17728.6 2.63 18160.0 2.43 18600.2 2.42 19001.4 2.16 19410.7 2.15 19846.1 2.24 20292.1 2.25 20734.5 2.18 US GDP (Bil$) SAAR…………………………………………… Percentage change…………………………………………… 17951.1 3.48 18743.4 4.41 19668.4 4.94 20597.6 4.72 21531.1 4.53 22517.9 4.58 23499.8 4.36 24524.2 4.36 25592.8 4.36 26693.8 4.30 27826.3 4.24 TN PERSONAL INCOME (MIL2009$) SAAR……................. Percentage change…………………………………………… 253482 4.38 262535 3.57 269009 2.47 275712 2.49 282315 2.39 289062 2.39 295381 2.19 301349 2.02 307344 1.99 313789 2.10 320868 2.26 US PERSONAL INCOME (BIL2009$) SAAR………….......... Percentage change…………………………………………… 14036 4.22 14475 3.12 14929 3.14 15382 3.04 15819 2.84 16257 2.77 16662 2.49 17051 2.33 17449 2.34 17853 2.32 18267 2.32 TN PERSONAL INCOME (MIL$) SAAR…………………….... Percentage change…………………………………………… 277316 4.66 290533 4.77 304095 4.67 317862 4.53 331870 4.41 346797 4.50 362031 4.39 377731 4.34 394009 4.31 411133 4.35 429289 4.42 US PERSONAL INCOME (BIL$) SAAR…………………….... Percentage change…………………………………………… 15360 4.53 15998 4.16 16825 5.17 17707 5.24 18591 4.99 19505 4.92 20424 4.71 21375 4.65 22372 4.66 23394 4.57 24446 4.50 TN NONFARM JOBS (THOUS)………………………………… Percentage change…………………………………………… 2870.7 1.94 2918.0 1.65 2956.2 1.31 2997.7 1.40 3037.7 1.33 3070.0 1.06 3100.8 1.00 3130.1 0.94 3160.1 0.96 3189.6 0.93 3217.7 0.88 US NONFARM JOBS (MIL)……………………………………… Percentage change…………………………………………… 141.9 2.10 144.3 1.67 146.2 1.29 147.9 1.19 149.4 1.03 151.0 1.05 152.2 0.76 153.3 0.73 154.4 0.72 155.5 0.73 156.5 0.67 TN MFG JOBS (THOUS)………………………………………… Percentage change…………………………………………… 331.5 1.93 333.7 0.68 336.1 0.71 338.2 0.63 339.6 0.41 339.2 -0.13 338.0 -0.36 335.9 -0.60 333.7 -0.68 330.6 -0.92 327.3 -1.00 US MFG JOBS (MIL)……………………………………………… Percentage change…………………………………………… 12.3 1.12 12.3 -0.14 12.4 0.85 12.5 0.92 12.6 0.97 12.7 0.76 12.8 0.73 12.9 0.18 12.9 0.00 12.9 0.00 12.9 -0.03 TN UNEMPLOYMENT RATE (%)……………………………... 5.9 5.5 5.4 5.3 5.2 5.2 5.1 5.1 5.1 5.1 5.1 US UNEMPLOYMENT RATE (%)……………………………… 5.3 4.9 4.9 4.9 5.0 5.0 5.0 5.1 5.1 5.0 5.0 CHAINED PRICE INDEX, GDP (2009=100.0)……………..... Percentage change…………………………………………… 109.8 1.04 111.7 1.70 113.9 1.94 116.2 2.04 118.6 2.05 121.1 2.11 123.7 2.16 126.3 2.16 129.0 2.07 131.5 2.01 134.2 2.02 US PERS CONSUMP DEFL (2009=100.0)…………….......... Percentage change…………………………………………… 109.4 0.29 110.5 1.00 112.7 1.97 115.1 2.14 117.5 2.09 120.0 2.09 122.6 2.16 125.4 2.27 128.2 2.27 131.0 2.20 133.8 2.13 CONSUMER PRICE INDEX, ALL-URBAN (82-84=1.000)…… Percentage change…………………………………………… 2.370 0.13 2.399 1.21 2.460 2.56 2.526 2.68 2.591 2.54 2.655 2.50 2.724 2.58 2.798 2.72 2.874 2.70 2.947 2.56 3.018 2.41 BANK PRIME INTEREST RATE (%)…………………………… 3.3 3.9 4.9 5.9 6.3 6.3 6.3 6.3 6.3 6.3 6.3 FEDERAL FUNDS RATE (% per annum)……………………… 0.131 0.899 1.912 2.902 3.250 3.250 3.250 3.250 3.250 3.250 3.250 30-YEAR FIXED MORTGAGE RATE (%)……………………… 3.9 4.4 4.7 5.4 5.8 5.8 5.8 5.8 5.8 5.8 5.8 TN TAXABLE SALES (MIL2009$)……………………………… Percentage change…………………………………………… 102746 5.88 106315 3.47 107755 1.35 109560 1.68 111496 1.77 113387 1.70 115204 1.60 116993 1.55 118691 1.45 120455 1.49 122480 1.68 TN TAXABLE SALES (MIL$)…………………………………… Percentage change…………………………………………… 112414 6.17 117652 4.66 121807 3.53 126307 3.69 131066 3.77 136033 3.79 141197 3.80 146646 3.86 152158 3.76 157821 3.72 163864 3.83 TN AVG ANNUAL WAGE, NONFARM (2009$)……………... Percentage change…………………………………………… 43161 2.86 44058 2.08 44349 0.66 44652 0.68 44929 0.62 45141 0.47 45276 0.30 45354 0.17 45451 0.21 45592 0.31 45765 0.38 TN AVG ANNUAL WAGE, NONFARM ($)………………....... Percentage change…………………………………………… 47219 3.14 48755 3.25 50131 2.82 51477 2.68 52814 2.60 54155 2.54 55490 2.46 56848 2.45 58265 2.49 59733 2.52 61227 2.50 Center for Business and Economic Research, University of Tennessee Tennessee Econometric Model Forecast Data 2016 16346.8 2.41 | 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT 2015 US GDP (Bil2009$) SAAR……………………………………… Percentage change…………………………………………… APPENDIX A 26 Forecast Data 2019 2020 Table 2: Selected Per Capita U.S. and Tennessee Economic Indicators January 2016 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 TN GDP (2009$) SAAR………………………… Percentage change………………………… 42240 1.33 42745 1.20 43222 1.12 43719 1.15 44261 1.24 US GDP (2009$) SAAR………………….…… Percentage change................................ 50787 1.65 51712 1.82 52807 2.12 53762 1.81 TN GDP ($) SAAR……………………………… Percentage change………………………… 46690 3.13 48202 3.24 49652 3.01 US GDP ($) SAAR……………………………… Percentage change................................ 55771 2.70 57761 3.57 TN PERSONAL INCOME (2009$) SAAR…… Percentage change................................ 38028 3.29 US PERSONAL INCOME (2009$) SAAR…… Percentage change................................ Forecast Data 2020 2022 2023 2024 2025 44761 1.13 45297 1.20 45848 1.22 46395 1.19 46947 1.19 47550 1.29 54636 1.62 55522 1.62 56283 1.37 57058 1.38 57901 1.48 58766 1.49 59613 1.44 51154 3.02 52726 3.07 54309 3.00 56021 3.15 57816 3.20 59627 3.13 61486 3.12 63451 3.20 60125 4.09 62463 3.89 64778 3.71 67217 3.77 69607 3.56 72089 3.57 74667 3.58 77305 3.53 80002 3.49 38982 2.51 39539 1.43 40119 1.47 40676 1.39 41243 1.40 41741 1.21 42182 1.06 42621 1.04 43115 1.16 43691 1.33 43609 3.44 44607 2.29 45635 2.31 46647 2.22 47593 2.03 48528 1.96 49354 1.70 50120 1.55 50907 1.57 51703 1.56 52520 1.58 TN PERSONAL INCOME ($) SAAR………… Percentage change................................ 41603 3.57 43139 3.69 44695 3.61 46252 3.48 47815 3.38 49480 3.48 51159 3.39 52873 3.35 54638 3.34 56490 3.39 58453 3.48 US PERSONAL INCOME ($) SAAR………… Percentage change................................ 47720 3.75 49301 3.31 51434 4.33 53698 4.40 55932 4.16 58224 4.10 60497 3.90 62831 3.86 65270 3.88 67750 3.80 70284 3.74 TN TAXABLE SALES (2009$)………………… Percentage change................................ 15414 4.78 15786 2.42 15838 0.33 15942 0.66 16064 0.76 16178 0.71 16280 0.63 16376 0.59 16459 0.51 16551 0.56 16677 0.77 TN TAXABLE SALES ($)……………………… Percentage change................................ 16864 5.07 17469 3.59 17903 2.48 18379 2.66 18884 2.75 19409 2.78 19953 2.80 20527 2.88 21100 2.79 21685 2.77 22312 2.89 Center for Business and Economic Research, University of Tennessee Tennessee Econometric Model Forecast Data | | 27 APPENDIX A 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT 2021 January 2016 | 2017 2018 2019 TN PERSONAL INCOME…………...…………… Percentage change………………………… 253482 4.38 262535 3.57 269009 2.47 275712 2.49 282315 2.39 WAGES AND SALARIES…………………… Percentage change………………………… 124639 4.72 129447 3.86 132192 2.12 134946 2.08 OTHER LABOR INCOME…………………… Percentage change………………………… 27759 2.25 28609 3.06 29294 2.39 PROPRIETORS INCOME…………………… Percentage change………………………… 33781 4.83 35059 3.78 RENT, INTEREST, DIVIDENDS…………… Percentage change………………………… 35754 3.85 TRANSFER PAYMENTS…………………… Percentage change………………………… Forecast Data 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025 289062 2.39 295381 2.19 301349 2.02 307344 1.99 313789 2.10 320868 2.26 137561 1.94 139658 1.52 141457 1.29 143022 1.11 144684 1.16 146471 1.23 148304 1.25 29927 2.16 30459 1.78 30949 1.61 31355 1.31 31705 1.11 32057 1.11 32391 1.04 32759 1.13 35952 2.55 37039 3.03 37982 2.55 39398 3.73 40855 3.70 42211 3.32 43514 3.09 44930 3.25 46555 3.62 36888 3.17 37995 3.00 39208 3.19 40317 2.83 41392 2.67 42398 2.43 43305 2.14 44281 2.25 45350 2.41 46570 2.69 52529 4.54 53825 2.47 54850 1.90 55886 1.89 57238 2.42 58876 2.86 60456 2.68 62134 2.78 63711 2.54 65423 2.69 67331 2.92 LESS: PERS CONT FOR SOC INS………… Percentage change………………………… 19736 3.55 20042 1.55 20045 0.01 20087 0.21 20059 -0.14 20058 -0.01 20015 -0.21 19934 -0.40 19840 -0.47 19742 -0.49 19645 -0.49 RESIDENCE ADJUSTMENT………………… Percentage change………………………… -1243 6.94 -1251 0.58 -1229 -1.75 -1208 -1.68 -1184 -2.00 -1155 -2.48 -1124 -2.61 -1093 -2.76 -1063 -2.80 -1033 -2.76 -1005 -2.71 PER CAPITA PERSONAL INCOME ($)………… Percentage change………………………… 38028 3.29 38982 2.51 39539 1.43 40119 1.47 40676 1.39 41243 1.40 41741 1.21 42182 1.06 42621 1.04 43115 1.16 43691 1.33 Center for Business and Economic Research, University of Tennessee Tennessee Econometric Model Forecast Data 2016 | 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT 2015 APPENDIX A 28 Table 3: Tennessee Personal Income Components (millions of 2009 dollars) Table 4: Tennessee Personal Income Components (millions of current dollars) January 2016 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 TN PERSONAL INCOME…………...…………… Percentage change………………………… 277316 4.66 290533 4.77 304095 4.67 317862 4.53 331870 4.41 WAGES AND SALARIES…………………… Percentage change………………………… 136360 5.01 143252 5.05 149432 4.31 155575 4.11 OTHER LABOR INCOME…………………… Percentage change………………………… 30369 2.53 31659 4.25 33114 4.60 PROPRIETORS INCOME…………………… Percentage change………………………… 36957 5.11 38798 4.98 RENT, INTEREST, DIVIDENDS…………… Percentage change………………………… 39116 4.13 TRANSFER PAYMENTS…………………… Percentage change………………………… Forecast Data 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025 346797 4.50 362031 4.39 377731 4.34 394009 4.31 411133 4.35 429289 4.42 161706 3.94 167550 3.61 173373 3.48 179270 3.40 185479 3.46 191906 3.47 198412 3.39 34502 4.19 35805 3.78 37130 3.70 38430 3.50 39740 3.41 41095 3.41 42439 3.27 43827 3.27 40641 4.75 42702 5.07 44650 4.56 47269 5.87 50074 5.94 52911 5.67 55785 5.43 58869 5.53 62287 5.81 40822 4.36 42951 5.22 45203 5.24 47395 4.85 49660 4.78 51964 4.64 54282 4.46 56768 4.58 59419 4.67 62307 4.86 57466 4.82 59565 3.65 62003 4.09 64430 3.91 67285 4.43 70636 4.98 74097 4.90 77884 5.11 81677 4.87 85720 4.95 90083 5.09 LESS: PERS CONT FOR SOC INS………… Percentage change………………………… 21592 3.83 22178 2.72 22658 2.16 23157 2.20 23580 1.82 24063 2.05 24530 1.94 24986 1.86 25433 1.79 25866 1.70 26282 1.61 RESIDENCE ADJUSTMENT………………… Percentage change………………………… -1360 7.24 -1384 1.73 -1389 0.36 -1393 0.27 -1392 -0.08 -1385 -0.47 -1378 -0.51 -1370 -0.55 -1362 -0.59 -1354 -0.62 -1345 -0.65 PER CAPITA PERSONAL INCOME ($)………… Percentage change………………………… 41603 3.57 43139 3.69 44695 3.61 46252 3.48 47815 3.38 49480 3.48 51159 3.39 52873 3.35 54638 3.34 56490 3.39 58453 3.48 Center for Business and Economic Research, University of Tennessee Tennessee Econometric Model Forecast Data | | 29 APPENDIX A 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT January 2016 | 2016 2017 2018 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025 TOTAL NONFARM………………………………………………… Percentage change………………………………………… 2870.7 1.94 2918.0 1.65 2956.2 1.31 2997.7 1.40 3037.7 1.33 3070.0 1.06 3100.8 1.00 3130.1 0.94 3160.1 0.96 3189.6 0.93 3217.7 0.88 NATURAL RESOURCES, MINING & CONSTRUCTION…… Percentage change………………………………………… 114.5 3.20 117.5 2.63 121.0 3.02 124.1 2.49 126.2 1.75 128.7 1.93 130.9 1.73 132.0 0.87 133.3 1.00 134.9 1.16 136.4 1.14 MANUFACTURING……………………………………………… Percentage change………………………………………… 331.5 1.93 333.7 0.68 336.1 0.71 338.2 0.63 339.6 0.41 339.2 -0.13 338.0 -0.36 335.9 -0.60 333.7 -0.68 330.6 -0.92 327.3 -1.00 DURABLE GOODS…………………………………………… Percentage change………………………………………… 211.7 2.99 214.8 1.47 218.1 1.53 221.1 1.40 223.2 0.94 223.8 0.25 223.8 0.02 223.3 -0.23 222.6 -0.31 221.1 -0.68 219.3 -0.79 NONDURABLE GOODS…………………………………… Percentage change………………………………………… 119.8 0.10 119.0 -0.72 118.0 -0.77 117.1 -0.79 116.4 -0.60 115.4 -0.85 114.2 -1.08 112.6 -1.34 111.0 -1.41 109.5 -1.41 107.9 -1.42 TRADE, TRANSPORTATION, UTILITIES…………………… Percentage change………………………………………… 607.5 2.60 618.9 1.88 625.7 1.09 632.8 1.13 638.1 0.85 641.1 0.46 642.9 0.29 644.9 0.30 647.5 0.40 649.5 0.31 651.6 0.33 WHOLESALE TRADE……………………………………… Percentage change………………………………………… 127.0 2.99 130.1 2.42 131.0 0.70 132.1 0.86 133.2 0.83 134.2 0.72 134.7 0.42 135.0 0.23 135.4 0.29 135.7 0.20 136.2 0.36 RETAIL TRADE……………………………………………… Percentage change………………………………………… 327.8 2.19 332.8 1.53 336.3 1.03 339.4 0.94 342.1 0.78 342.5 0.13 343.0 0.14 343.5 0.14 344.2 0.21 344.7 0.15 345.2 0.13 TRANSPORTATION & UTILITIES………………………… Percentage change………………………………………… 152.7 3.15 156.0 2.19 158.4 1.56 161.2 1.77 162.9 1.03 164.4 0.92 165.2 0.48 166.3 0.71 167.8 0.90 169.1 0.72 170.2 0.70 INFORMATION………………………………………………… Percentage change………………………………………… 43.4 -1.27 42.5 -2.01 42.6 0.36 42.7 0.21 43.0 0.55 43.3 0.72 43.6 0.70 43.9 0.84 44.3 0.77 44.7 0.96 45.0 0.62 FINANCIAL ACTIVITIES……………………………………… Percentage change………………………………………… 144.8 2.34 147.6 1.94 148.8 0.79 150.3 0.99 151.8 1.03 151.7 -0.08 151.8 0.10 152.0 0.12 152.0 0.01 152.1 0.05 152.1 -0.02 PROFESSIONAL & BUSINESS SERVICES………………… Percentage change………………………………………… 383.0 2.80 393.8 2.81 403.8 2.55 416.0 3.01 429.5 3.26 442.8 3.09 455.9 2.97 468.6 2.78 481.9 2.83 495.7 2.87 509.3 2.74 EDUCATION & HEALTH SERVICES………………………… Percentage change………………………………………… 409.8 1.78 417.9 1.98 425.8 1.89 433.8 1.88 441.9 1.86 449.3 1.67 457.3 1.80 465.3 1.75 473.2 1.69 481.2 1.68 489.1 1.66 LEISURE & HOSPITALITY…………………………………… Percentage change………………………………………… 305.9 3.28 313.6 2.54 319.5 1.86 325.1 1.75 329.9 1.49 333.6 1.11 337.3 1.12 341.6 1.25 345.2 1.08 349.3 1.17 351.9 0.74 OTHER SERVICES……………………………………………… Percentage change………………………………………… 104.8 -0.97 103.6 -1.11 102.4 -1.19 102.6 0.18 102.7 0.11 102.7 0.00 102.8 0.05 102.9 0.17 103.2 0.29 102.9 -0.34 103.0 0.10 GOVERNMENT………………………………………………… Percentage change………………………………………… 425.6 0.10 428.7 0.73 430.4 0.40 432.3 0.42 434.9 0.61 437.8 0.67 440.2 0.56 442.8 0.59 445.7 0.66 448.8 0.69 452.0 0.71 FEDERAL, CIVILIAN………………………………………… Percentage change………………………………………… 47.4 -1.06 46.5 -1.95 45.8 -1.43 45.1 -1.65 44.4 -1.58 43.9 -1.09 43.3 -1.24 42.9 -0.89 42.7 -0.63 42.4 -0.62 42.1 -0.64 STATE & LOCAL……………………………………………… Percentage change………………………………………… 378.2 0.24 382.3 1.07 384.6 0.62 387.2 0.67 390.6 0.87 393.9 0.87 396.9 0.76 399.9 0.75 403.1 0.80 406.4 0.83 409.9 0.85 Center for Business and Economic Research, University of Tennessee Tennessee Econometric Model Forecast Data 2015 | 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT Forecast Data 2019 2020 APPENDIX A 30 Table 5: Tennessee Nonfarm Employment by Sector (thousands of jobs) Table 6: Tennessee Durable Goods Manufacturing Employment (thousands of jobs) January 2016 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 TOTAL DURABLE GOODS…………………… Percentage change………..…………… 211.7 2.99 214.8 1.47 218.1 1.53 221.1 1.40 223.2 0.94 WOOD PRODUCTS……………………… Percentage change………..…………… 11.6 3.40 11.8 1.90 12.0 1.55 12.2 1.29 NONMETALLIC MINERALS……………… Percentage change………..…………… 11.7 -1.68 11.6 -0.98 11.5 -0.97 PRIMARY METALS………….…………… Percentage change………..…………… 10.3 1.90 10.4 1.07 FABRICATED METALS………………….. Percentage change………..…………… 35.2 2.28 MACHINERY………………………………… Percentage change………..…………… Forecast Data 2020 2022 2023 2024 2025 223.8 0.25 223.8 0.02 223.3 -0.23 222.6 -0.31 221.1 -0.68 219.3 -0.79 12.3 0.79 12.3 -0.11 12.2 -0.34 12.2 -0.30 12.1 -0.31 12.1 -0.38 12.1 -0.29 11.4 -0.63 11.4 -0.16 11.4 -0.06 11.4 -0.06 11.4 -0.13 11.3 -0.34 11.3 -0.35 11.2 -0.91 10.4 0.64 10.5 0.91 10.6 0.90 10.6 -0.46 10.5 -0.53 10.5 -0.46 10.4 -0.69 10.3 -1.08 10.1 -1.48 35.3 0.29 35.4 0.47 35.5 0.16 35.7 0.67 35.4 -0.93 35.1 -0.85 34.8 -0.72 34.6 -0.70 34.3 -0.68 34.2 -0.57 26.2 1.94 26.1 -0.38 26.4 1.04 26.7 1.12 26.9 0.86 27.1 0.53 27.0 -0.44 26.7 -1.09 26.4 -0.96 26.1 -0.99 25.8 -1.14 COMPUTERS & ELECTRONICS………… Percentage change………..…………… 5.1 1.16 5.1 0.03 5.0 -2.64 4.8 -2.30 4.7 -3.35 4.5 -4.04 4.3 -4.10 4.1 -3.74 4.0 -4.20 3.8 -4.07 3.7 -4.15 ELECTRICAL EQUIPMENT, APPLIANCES & COMPONENTS…………..…………… Percentage change………..…………… 19.9 2.58 20.2 1.67 20.5 1.36 20.8 1.50 21.1 1.15 21.2 0.83 21.3 0.57 21.4 0.09 21.4 -0.05 21.3 -0.41 21.2 -0.48 TRANSPORTATION EQUIPMENT……… Percentage change………..…………… 67.5 5.39 70.0 3.71 72.5 3.67 74.9 3.23 76.3 1.87 77.4 1.43 78.2 1.09 78.7 0.64 79.0 0.43 78.8 -0.34 78.4 -0.52 FURNITURE………………………………… Percentage change………..…………… 9.2 1.38 9.3 0.68 9.3 0.91 9.3 -0.27 9.3 -0.63 9.1 -1.76 8.9 -2.62 8.7 -2.38 8.5 -2.30 8.2 -2.84 7.9 -3.25 MISCELLANEOUS DURABLES………… Percentage change………..…………… 15.1 2.39 15.1 0.02 15.0 -0.49 15.0 0.02 15.0 0.20 14.9 -0.63 15.0 0.12 14.9 -0.10 14.9 -0.03 14.9 -0.35 14.8 -0.23 Center for Business and Economic Research, University of Tennessee Tennessee Econometric Model Forecast Data | | 31 APPENDIX A 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT 2021 January 2016 | 2017 2018 2019 119.8 0.10 119.0 -0.72 118.0 -0.77 117.1 -0.79 116.4 -0.60 FOOD……………………………………………… Percentage change………..………………… 32.9 0.54 32.9 0.12 33.0 0.12 33.0 0.08 BEVERAGE & TOBACCO……………………… Percentage change………..………………… 5.5 0.77 5.5 0.05 5.4 -0.99 TEXTILE MILLS, TEXTILE MILL PRODUCTS & APPAREL…………………… Percentage change………..………………… 9.6 -4.10 9.2 -4.09 PAPER…………………………………………… Percentage change………..………………… 14.3 -2.23 PRINTING & RELATED SUPPORT…………… Percentage change………..………………… Forecast Data 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025 115.4 -0.85 114.2 -1.08 112.6 -1.34 111.0 -1.41 109.5 -1.41 107.9 -1.42 33.0 0.09 32.9 -0.40 32.7 -0.53 32.5 -0.60 32.3 -0.75 32.0 -0.71 31.8 -0.62 5.4 -0.89 5.3 -0.75 5.2 -1.57 5.1 -1.49 5.1 -1.38 5.0 -1.62 4.9 -1.75 4.8 -1.55 8.7 -5.00 8.3 -4.85 8.0 -3.57 7.7 -3.64 7.4 -3.82 7.1 -4.00 6.9 -3.86 6.6 -3.72 6.4 -3.27 14.0 -2.28 13.6 -2.40 13.4 -2.04 13.1 -2.00 12.8 -1.85 12.6 -1.84 12.4 -1.72 12.2 -1.64 12.0 -1.60 11.8 -1.54 9.0 -4.32 8.8 -2.25 8.8 -0.59 8.7 -1.52 8.6 -1.03 8.4 -1.97 8.3 -1.67 8.1 -1.62 8.0 -1.54 7.8 -1.93 7.7 -1.97 CHEMICALS……………………………………… Percentage change………..………………… 25.2 -0.40 25.0 -1.02 24.7 -1.09 24.4 -1.00 24.2 -0.92 23.9 -1.30 23.5 -1.51 23.2 -1.48 22.9 -1.42 22.6 -1.38 22.2 -1.62 PLASTICS & RUBBER………………………… Percentage change………..………………… 21.3 2.90 21.6 1.62 21.9 1.51 22.2 1.32 22.5 1.08 22.7 1.25 22.8 0.30 22.6 -1.02 22.3 -1.29 22.0 -1.34 21.7 -1.48 MISCELLANEOUS NONDURABLE GOODS… Percentage change………..………………… 2.1 35.66 2.0 -3.74 1.9 -5.64 1.8 -6.17 1.7 -3.23 1.7 -1.90 1.7 -2.05 1.6 -2.01 1.6 -2.08 1.6 -1.88 1.5 -2.07 TOTAL NONDURABLE GOODS………………… Percentage change………..………………… Center for Business and Economic Research, University of Tennessee Tennessee Econometric Model Forecast Data 2016 | 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT 2015 APPENDIX A 32 Table 7: Tennessee Nondurable Goods Manufacturing Employment (thousands of jobs) Table 8: Tennessee Average Annual Wage and Salary Rate by Sector (2009 dollars) January 2016 Forecast Data 2019 2020 2018 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025 44349 0.66 44652 0.68 44929 0.62 45141 0.47 45276 0.30 45354 0.17 45451 0.21 45592 0.31 45765 0.38 NATURAL RESOURCES, MINING AND CONSTRUCTION……………………… Percentage change………..……………… 49991 5.88 51772 3.56 52152 0.73 52564 0.79 52937 0.71 53223 0.54 53442 0.41 53667 0.42 53843 0.33 53983 0.26 54215 0.43 MANUFACTURING……………………………… Percentage change………..……………… 52464 1.67 54520 3.92 55037 0.95 55472 0.79 55749 0.50 56050 0.54 56195 0.26 56361 0.30 56717 0.63 56899 0.32 57077 0.31 DURABLE GOODS…………………………… Percentage change………..……………… 50844 0.70 52378 3.02 52841 0.88 53308 0.89 53596 0.54 53812 0.40 53902 0.17 54070 0.31 54332 0.48 54495 0.30 54627 0.24 NONDURABLE GOODS…………………… Percentage change………..……………… 55333 3.41 58393 5.53 59097 1.21 59559 0.78 59877 0.53 60388 0.85 60690 0.50 60903 0.35 61496 0.97 61753 0.42 62054 0.49 TRADE, TRANSPORTATION, UTILITIES…… Percentage change………..……………… 39037 0.83 39884 2.17 40333 1.13 40792 1.14 41238 1.09 41525 0.69 41801 0.67 41995 0.46 42212 0.52 42497 0.67 42877 0.89 WHOLESALE TRADE……………………… Percentage change………..……………… 59353 0.34 60621 2.14 61218 0.98 61845 1.03 62478 1.02 62735 0.41 63129 0.63 63209 0.13 63453 0.39 63985 0.84 64510 0.82 RETAIL TRADE……………………………… Percentage change………..……………… 26683 0.76 27411 2.73 27715 1.11 28022 1.11 28385 1.30 28692 1.08 28939 0.86 29191 0.87 29409 0.75 29610 0.68 29966 1.20 TRANSPORTATION & UTILITIES………… Percentage change………..……………… 48721 1.06 49284 1.16 49809 1.06 50346 1.08 50765 0.83 50860 0.19 51025 0.32 51124 0.20 51242 0.23 51441 0.39 51666 0.44 INFORMATION………………………………… Percentage change………..……………… 57804 3.39 59378 2.72 59802 0.71 60193 0.65 60385 0.32 60658 0.45 60855 0.32 61009 0.25 61114 0.17 61196 0.13 61434 0.39 FINANCIAL ACTIVITIES……………………… Percentage change………..……………… 64642 2.24 66426 2.76 67022 0.90 67485 0.69 67889 0.60 68196 0.45 68390 0.29 68477 0.13 68761 0.42 68995 0.34 69196 0.29 PROFESSIONAL & BUSINESS SERVICES… Percentage change………..……………… 51066 7.23 51350 0.56 51670 0.62 52043 0.72 52406 0.70 52766 0.69 53030 0.50 53289 0.49 53490 0.38 53760 0.51 54017 0.48 EDUCATION & HEALTH SERVICES………… Percentage change………..……………… 44065 2.93 44906 1.91 45191 0.63 45568 0.83 46026 1.01 46433 0.88 46733 0.65 46930 0.42 47088 0.34 47432 0.73 47756 0.68 LEISURE & HOSPITALITY…………………… Percentage change………..……………… 21137 4.86 21730 2.81 21979 1.14 22205 1.03 22371 0.75 22532 0.72 22578 0.21 22591 0.06 22588 -0.01 22689 0.45 22813 0.55 OTHER SERVICES……………………………… Percentage change………..……………… 40498 4.20 41325 2.04 41442 0.28 41671 0.55 41670 0.00 41405 -0.64 41122 -0.68 40808 -0.76 40499 -0.76 40220 -0.69 39979 -0.60 GOVERNMENT………………………………… Percentage change………..……………… 39726 0.81 40211 1.22 39940 -0.68 39706 -0.59 39465 -0.61 39201 -0.67 38884 -0.81 38529 -0.91 38169 -0.93 37827 -0.90 37506 -0.85 FEDERAL, CIVILIAN………………………… Percentage change………..……………… 75100 4.51 77290 2.92 77198 -0.12 77218 0.03 77314 0.12 77352 0.05 77323 -0.04 77202 -0.16 77062 -0.18 76962 -0.13 76907 -0.07 STATE & LOCAL……………………………… Percentage change………..……………… 35267 -0.07 35588 0.91 35389 -0.56 35230 -0.45 35062 -0.48 34849 -0.61 34587 -0.75 34276 -0.90 33952 -0.94 33646 -0.90 33358 -0.85 33 Center for Business and Economic Research, University of Tennessee Tennessee Econometric Model APPENDIX A 2017 44058 2.08 | | 2016 43161 2.86 Forecast Data 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT 2015 TOTAL NONFARM………………………………… Percentage change………..……………… January 2016 | 2017 2018 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025 47219 3.14 48755 3.25 50131 2.82 51477 2.68 52814 2.60 54155 2.54 55490 2.46 56848 2.45 58265 2.49 59733 2.52 61227 2.50 NATURAL RESOURCES, MINING & CONSTRUCTION… Percentage change………..…………………………… 54695 6.18 57291 4.75 58952 2.90 60598 2.79 62228 2.69 63852 2.61 65499 2.58 67268 2.70 69023 2.61 70728 2.47 72532 2.55 MANUFACTURING………………………………………… Percentage change………..…………………………… 57400 1.95 60333 5.11 62214 3.12 63951 2.79 65533 2.47 67243 2.61 68873 2.42 70645 2.57 72707 2.92 74548 2.53 76361 2.43 DURABLE GOODS…………………………………….... Percentage change………..…………………………… 55627 0.97 57962 4.20 59731 3.05 61456 2.89 63001 2.51 64558 2.47 66062 2.33 67773 2.59 69650 2.77 71398 2.51 73083 2.36 NONDURABLE GOODS…………………………….. Percentage change………..…………………………… 60542 3.71 64619 6.73 66803 3.38 68662 2.78 70385 2.51 72448 2.93 74382 2.67 76338 2.63 78835 3.27 80908 2.63 83020 2.61 TRADE, TRANSPORTATION, UTILITIES…………. Percentage change………..…………………………… 42707 1.10 44136 3.35 45592 3.30 47027 3.15 48475 3.08 49817 2.77 51232 2.84 52638 2.74 54114 2.80 55679 2.89 57363 3.03 WHOLESALE TRADE…………………………………… Percentage change………..…………………………… 64934 0.61 67084 3.31 69200 3.15 71298 3.03 73442 3.01 75264 2.48 77371 2.80 79228 2.40 81343 2.67 83833 3.06 86306 2.95 RETAIL TRADE…………………………………………… Percentage change………..…………………………… 29193 1.03 30333 3.91 31329 3.28 32305 3.12 33367 3.29 34422 3.16 35468 3.04 36589 3.16 37701 3.04 38795 2.90 40090 3.34 TRANSPORTATION & UTILITIES……………………… Percentage change………..…………………………… 53300 1.33 54539 2.32 56304 3.24 58041 3.09 59674 2.81 61017 2.25 62536 2.49 64081 2.47 65689 2.51 67397 2.60 69122 2.56 INFORMATION……………………………………………… Percentage change………..…………………………… 63239 3.67 65708 3.90 67600 2.88 69393 2.65 70983 2.29 72772 2.52 74584 2.49 76471 2.53 78344 2.45 80177 2.34 82190 2.51 FINANCIAL ACTIVITIES………………………………….... Percentage change………..…………………………… 70721 2.52 73508 3.94 75761 3.06 77800 2.69 79803 2.58 81814 2.52 83819 2.45 85830 2.40 88148 2.70 90396 2.55 92574 2.41 PROFESSIONAL & BUSINESS SERVICES……………… Percentage change………..…………………………… 55865 7.52 56824 1.72 58407 2.79 59997 2.72 61603 2.68 63303 2.76 64994 2.67 66794 2.77 68571 2.66 70436 2.72 72267 2.60 EDUCATION & HEALTH SERVICES……………………… Percentage change………..…………………………… 48207 3.21 49693 3.08 51083 2.80 52533 2.84 54104 2.99 55706 2.96 57276 2.82 58823 2.70 60364 2.62 62145 2.95 63891 2.81 LEISURE & HOSPITALITY………………………………… Percentage change………..…………………………… 23125 5.14 24047 3.99 24845 3.32 25599 3.04 26297 2.73 27031 2.79 27672 2.37 28317 2.33 28956 2.26 29727 2.66 30520 2.67 OTHER SERVICES………………………………………… Percentage change………..…………………………… 44306 4.48 45730 3.22 46846 2.44 48041 2.55 48982 1.96 49673 1.41 50398 1.46 51149 1.49 51917 1.50 52695 1.50 53486 1.50 GOVERNMENT……………………………………………… Percentage change………..…………………………… 43461 1.08 44497 2.38 45146 1.46 45774 1.39 46390 1.35 47029 1.38 47656 1.33 48292 1.34 48930 1.32 49560 1.29 50177 1.24 FEDERAL, CIVILIAN……………………………………… Percentage change………..…………………………… 82162 4.79 85528 4.10 87263 2.03 89019 2.01 90881 2.09 92799 2.11 94766 2.12 96766 2.11 98788 2.09 100833 2.07 102890 2.04 STATE & LOCAL………………………………………… Percentage change………..…………………………… 38582 0.20 39381 2.07 40002 1.58 40614 1.53 41214 1.48 41808 1.44 42389 1.39 42961 1.35 43524 1.31 44081 1.28 44628 1.24 TOTAL NONFARM……………………………………………… Percentage change………..…………………………… Center for Business and Economic Research, University of Tennessee Tennessee Econometric Model Forecast Data 2016 | 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT Forecast Data 2019 2020 2015 APPENDIX A 34 Table 9: Tennessee Average Annual Wage and Salary Rate by Sector (current dollars) Table 10: Tennessee Civilian Labor Force and Unemployment Rate January 2016 2015 2016 2017 2018 Forecast Data 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025 CIVILIAN LABOR FORCE (THOUS)………… Percentage change……………………… 3063 2.33 3060 -0.10 3079 0.63 3103 0.78 3124 0.66 3148 0.78 3170 0.69 3191 0.66 3209 0.57 3226 0.52 3243 0.51 EMPLOYED PERSONS (THOUS)………… Percentage change……………………… 2882 3.05 2890 0.28 2913 0.77 2938 0.89 2960 0.73 2985 0.84 3007 0.74 3028 0.70 3046 0.59 3063 0.56 3078 0.49 UNEMPLOYED PERSONS (THOUS)…… Percentage change……………………… 181 -7.97 170 -6.20 167 -1.72 165 -1.07 164 -0.61 163 -0.41 163 -0.14 163 -0.03 163 0.17 163 -0.11 165 0.95 PARTICIPATION RATE (PERCENT)……… Percentage change……………………… 57.7 1.12 57.0 -1.26 56.7 -0.49 56.5 -0.30 56.3 -0.41 56.2 -0.27 56.0 -0.34 55.8 -0.36 55.5 -0.43 55.3 -0.43 55.1 -0.39 UNEMPLOYMENT RATE (PERCENT)……… 5.9 5.5 5.4 5.3 5.2 5.2 5.1 5.1 5.1 5.1 5.1 Center for Business and Economic Research, University of Tennessee Tennessee Econometric Model Forecast Data | | 35 APPENDIX A 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT January 2016 | Forecast Data 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025 TOTAL TAXABLE SALES………………………… Percentage change………..………………… 102746 5.88 106315 3.47 107755 1.35 109560 1.68 111496 1.77 113387 1.70 115204 1.60 116993 1.55 118691 1.45 120455 1.49 122480 1.68 AUTO DEALERS………………………………… Percentage change………..………………… 10751 10.95 11185 4.04 11279 0.85 11615 2.98 11865 2.15 12159 2.48 12495 2.76 12841 2.78 13150 2.40 13453 2.31 13766 2.33 PURCHASES FROM MANUFACTURERS…. Percentage change………..………………… 4420 8.09 4591 3.87 4652 1.33 4729 1.66 4807 1.65 4899 1.90 4967 1.40 5040 1.46 5114 1.47 5186 1.41 5274 1.70 MISC DURABLE GOODS……………………… Percentage change………..………………… 16866 4.83 17537 3.98 17799 1.49 18085 1.61 18449 2.01 18828 2.06 19247 2.22 19687 2.29 20056 1.87 20471 2.07 20906 2.12 EATING AND DRINKING PLACES…………… Percentage change………..………………… 10958 6.81 11301 3.13 11510 1.85 11762 2.19 12057 2.51 12312 2.12 12605 2.38 12885 2.22 13180 2.29 13443 1.99 13786 2.55 FOOD STORES………………………………… Percentage change………..………………… 9858 3.91 10024 1.69 10065 0.41 10101 0.36 10209 1.06 10329 1.18 10414 0.82 10518 1.00 10654 1.30 10766 1.05 10917 1.40 LIQUOR STORES……………………………… Percentage change………..………………… 882 7.69 909 3.05 924 1.67 946 2.38 974 2.97 1001 2.71 1020 1.91 1041 2.03 1058 1.66 1079 1.96 1102 2.19 HOTELS AND MOTELS………………………… Percentage change………..………………… 2953 11.78 3053 3.37 3172 3.91 3299 4.02 3425 3.81 3497 2.10 3573 2.17 3648 2.10 3733 2.31 3836 2.78 3949 2.94 OTHER RETAIL AND SERVICE……………… Percentage change………..………………… 31419 5.11 32699 4.07 33270 1.75 33858 1.77 34432 1.70 34948 1.50 35363 1.19 35712 0.99 36041 0.92 36424 1.06 36869 1.22 MISC NONDURABLE GOODS………………… Percentage change………..………………… 8650 4.36 9037 4.47 9167 1.43 9310 1.57 9454 1.55 9599 1.53 9729 1.35 9846 1.21 9962 1.18 10091 1.29 10236 1.44 TRANSPORTATION, COMMUNICATION…… Percentage change………..………………… 5989 3.59 5980 -0.16 5917 -1.05 5854 -1.07 5823 -0.51 5814 -0.16 5792 -0.39 5776 -0.27 5743 -0.56 5706 -0.66 5675 -0.54 PER CAPITA ($)…………………………………… Percentage change………..………………… 15414 4.78 15786 2.42 15838 0.33 15942 0.66 16064 0.76 16178 0.71 16280 0.63 16376 0.59 16459 0.51 16551 0.56 16677 0.77 Center for Business and Economic Research, University of Tennessee Tennessee Econometric Model Forecast Data 2016 | 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT 2015 APPENDIX A 36 Table 11: Tennessee Taxable Sales (millions of 2009 dollars) Table 12: Tennessee Taxable Sales (millions of current dollars) January 2016 Forecast Data 2019 2020 2016 2017 2018 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025 TOTAL TAXABLE SALES………………………… Percentage change………..………………… 112414 6.17 117652 4.66 121807 3.53 126307 3.69 131066 3.77 136033 3.79 141197 3.80 146646 3.86 152158 3.76 157821 3.72 163864 3.83 AUTO DEALERS………………………………… Percentage change………..………………… 11762 11.26 12378 5.24 12751 3.01 13391 5.02 13947 4.16 14588 4.59 15314 4.98 16097 5.11 16858 4.73 17627 4.56 18418 4.49 PURCHASES FROM MANUFACTURERS…. Percentage change………..………………… 4836 8.39 5080 5.06 5258 3.51 5452 3.68 5651 3.65 5877 4.00 6088 3.59 6317 3.76 6556 3.78 6795 3.64 7056 3.85 MISC DURABLE GOODS……………………… Percentage change………..………………… 18454 5.12 19407 5.16 20120 3.67 20850 3.63 21687 4.02 22589 4.16 23590 4.43 24677 4.61 25711 4.19 26822 4.32 27970 4.28 EATING AND DRINKING PLACES…………… Percentage change………..………………… 11989 7.10 12506 4.31 13011 4.04 13560 4.22 14173 4.52 14771 4.22 15449 4.59 16150 4.54 16897 4.62 17613 4.24 18444 4.72 FOOD STORES………………………………… Percentage change………..………………… 10785 4.19 11093 2.86 11377 2.57 11645 2.35 12001 3.05 12392 3.26 12764 3.00 13183 3.29 13658 3.60 14106 3.28 14605 3.54 LIQUOR STORES……………………………… Percentage change………..………………… 965 7.98 1006 4.24 1045 3.86 1091 4.41 1145 5.00 1201 4.82 1250 4.11 1304 4.35 1356 3.97 1413 4.21 1475 4.35 HOTELS AND MOTELS………………………… Percentage change………..………………… 3231 12.09 3378 4.55 3586 6.15 3804 6.08 4027 5.85 4196 4.20 4380 4.38 4573 4.42 4785 4.64 5026 5.04 5283 5.11 OTHER RETAIL AND SERVICE……………… Percentage change………..………………… 34376 5.40 36186 5.27 37609 3.93 39033 3.79 40475 3.69 41928 3.59 43341 3.37 44763 3.28 46203 3.22 47723 3.29 49326 3.36 MISC NONDURABLE GOODS………………… Percentage change………..………………… 9464 4.64 10001 5.67 10362 3.61 10733 3.58 11114 3.54 11516 3.62 11923 3.54 12341 3.51 12771 3.48 13221 3.52 13695 3.58 TRANSPORTATION, COMMUNICATION…… Percentage change………..………………… 6552 3.87 6617 0.99 6688 1.07 6748 0.90 6845 1.44 6975 1.90 7098 1.76 7239 1.99 7363 1.70 7475 1.53 7592 1.56 PER CAPITA ($)…………………………………… Percentage change………..………………… 16864 5.07 17469 3.59 17903 2.48 18379 2.66 18884 2.75 19409 2.78 19953 2.80 20527 2.88 21100 2.79 21685 2.77 22312 2.89 Center for Business and Economic Research, University of Tennessee Tennessee Econometric Model Forecast Data | | 37 APPENDIX A 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT 2015 Table 13: Tennessee Gross Domestic Product by Sector (millions of 2009 dollars) January 2016 | NATURAL RESOURCES & MINING...................................................................................................... 3,216 3,343 3,468 3,594 3,721 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. 6.03 3.95 3.74 3.63 3.53 3,850 3.46 3,978 3.33 4,106 3.23 4,229 2.98 4,353 2.94 4,486 3.06 10,671 2.03 10,879 1.95 11,109 2.12 11,340 2.08 11,568 2.01 11,814 2.12 12,058 2.07 MANUFACTURING............................................................................. 47,428 48,617 49,807 51,005 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. 2.86 2.51 2.45 2.41 52,249 2.44 53,379 2.16 54,554 2.20 55,781 2.25 57,041 2.26 58,101 1.86 59,291 2.05 DURABLE GOODS........................................................................ 27,410 28,262 29,134 30,039 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. 3.63 3.11 3.08 3.11 30,971 3.10 31,773 2.59 32,629 2.69 33,532 2.77 34,465 2.78 35,245 2.26 36,122 2.49 617 1.50 625 1.27 633 1.34 1,057 1,061 1,065 Table 14: Tennessee Average Annual Wage and Salary Rate by Sector, Seasonally Adjusted (current dollars) WOOD PRODUCTS…………………………………………............. 575 583 591 600 608 History 1.01 Forecast1.29 Data Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. 1.49 1.37 1.48 2015:2 2015:3 2015:4 2016:1 2016:2 2016:3 2016:4 2017:1 2017:2 2017:3 2017:4 2018:1 NONMETALLIC MINERAL PRODUCTS…………………………….. 1,038 1,042 1,046 1,049 1,053 January 2016 642 651 1.41 Annual 1.40 2014 2015 1,066 2016 1,067 660 1.47 2017 1,070 TOTAL NONFARM……………………………………………….. 47346 47481 47891 48241 48586 48925 49266 49616 49956 50303 50649 50984 45782 47219 48755 50131 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. 0.49 0.36 0.42 0.28 0.35 0.40 0.39 0.33 0.12 0.10 0.23 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………………………… 10.68 1.14 3.50 2.96 2.89 2.82 2.82 2.87 2.77 2.81 2.78 2.67 2.62 3.14 3.25 2.82 % Chg Same METALS………….……………………………................. Qtr Last Yr……………………………….. 3.76 3.73 2.62 3.04 2.85 1,293 2.82 2.82 2.81 1,312 2.76 2.62 3.25 2.82 PRIMARY 1,240 3.44 1,2514.51 1,260 1,272 2.871,281 1,301 1,3233.14 1,330 1,341 change……………………………………………………………………….. 0.98 563380.93 0.67 57489 0.9557866 0.75 0.8859169 0.63 0.83 51513 0.84 0.55 58952 0.81 NATURALPercentage RESOURCES, MINING & CONSTRUCTION…… 54764 56036 56717 57094 58296 58734 59609 60009 54695 57291 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………………………… 26.46 9.62 2.17 2.72 2.69 2.79 2.65 3.01 3.04 2.99 3.01 2.71 4.71 6.18 4.75 2.90 FABRICATED METAL PRODUCTS………………….. 3,616 8.61 3,6439.83 3,677 3,701 2.713,743 3,711 3,6926.18 3,684 3,680 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………………….. 6.18 8.25 4.26 2.59 2.78 3,725 2.87 2.92 3.01 3,701 2.94 4.71 4.75 2.90 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. 2.09 0.75 0.94 0.63 1.14 -0.47 -0.39 -0.26 -0.24 -0.22 -0.11 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. 1.93 1.82 1.98 1.86 1.57 1.59 1.49 1.59 1.50 1.32 1.53 MANUFACTURING…………………………………………… 57619 58423 59116 59605 60062 60584 61081 61537 61954 62435 62929 63334 56302 57400 60333 62214 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………………………… 25.45 5.70 3.10 3.52 3.02 3,404 2.74 3.15 3.20 3,510 2.60 2.85 5.11 3.12 MACHINERY………………………………………………………… 3,119 4.83 3,1763.35 3,239 3,299 3.323,351 3,455 3,5631.95 3,610 3,665 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………………….. 2.58 4.07 3.24 9.48 4.24 3.70 3.32 3.24 3.15 3.06 3.03 2.92 2.85 1.95 5.11 3.12 DURABLE GOODS……………………………………...... 55869 56305 56988 57331 57693 58176 58650 59072 59451 59941 60460 60849 55092 55627 57962 59731 COMPUTER & ELECTRONIC PRODUCTS…………… 1,539 4.94 1,6262.43 1,710 1,799 3.301,895 2,102 2,3290.97 2,448 2,585 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………………………… 20.29 3.16 2.55 3.39 2.91 1,993 2.59 3.34 3.51 2,212 2.60 3.45 4.20 3.05 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………………….. 1.39 2.50 3.26 3.32 3.04 3.05 3.09 3.01 4.20 3.05 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. 5.73 1.285.667.47 5.17 5.22 2.92 5.32 5.20 3.03 5.47 5.22 3.45 5.310.97 5.09 5.58 NONDURABLE GOODS…………………………….. 60716 62180 62910 63681 64330 64949 65517 66055 66566 67057 67531 67993 58379 60542 64619 66803 ELECTRICAL EQUIPMENT, APPLIANCES % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………………………… 34.67 10.00 4.78 4.99 4.14 3.91 3.54 3.33 3.13 2.98 2.86 2.76 2.03 3.71 6.73 3.38 & COMPONENTS............................................................................. 3,218 6.65 3,283 3,452 4.143,539 3,711 3,9113.71 4,000 4,111 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………………….. 4.70 6.82 12.98 3,370 5.95 4.45 3.73 3,613 3.48 3.24 3.07 3,803 2.93 2.03 6.73 3.38 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. 2.51 2.03 2.65 2.44 TRADE, TRANSPORTATION, UTILITIES…………. 42794 42887 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………………………… 8.51 0.87 MOTOR VEHICLES, BODIES % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………………….. 2.84 2.02 2.52 2.08 2.71 2.50 12,269 12,764 13,264 13,805 43218 43594 43970 44311 44670 45047 45414 45778 46130 46497 3.12 3.53 3.50 3.13 3.28 3.42 3.30 3.24 3.11 3.22 -0.79 3.97 2.75 3.32 3.36 3.33 3.28 3.31 3.27 3.22 & TRAILERS, & PARTS............................................................................. 10,107 10,616 11,134 11,699 2.83 2.28 2.78 14,373 14,815 15,296 42242 42707 44136 45592 2.75 1.10 3.35 3.30 2.75 1.10 3.35 3.30 WHOLESALE TRADE……………………………………. 65438 65107 66259 66802 68436 68952 69949 70508 64934 67084 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. 6.12 656245.04 4.88 67371 5.0767904 4.88 4.0369463 3.92 4.08 64537 4.11 3.08 69200 3.24 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………………………… 12.31 -2.00 3.21 3.93 3.32 3.45 3.20 3.17 3.05 3.00 2.83 3.23 3.97 0.61 3.31 3.15 OTHER TRANSPORTATION EQUIPMENT……………………………………………………………………………………………………………… 385 -0.50 3924.24 401 408 3.47 416 421 3.10 428 435 3.974400.61 447 454 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………………….. 2.85 0.78 2.09 3.48 3.28 3.22 3.01 3.03 3.31 3.15 change……………………………………………………………………….. 2.12 297481.81 2.17 30443 1.8930692 1.87 1.3831466 1.61 1.48 28895 1.26 1.64 31329 1.51 RETAILPercentage TRADE……………………………………………. 29138 29534 29973 30226 30946 31202 31700 31933 29193 30333 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………………………… 11.59 5.56 2.93 3.05 3.42 2.90 3.32 3.35 3.35 3.43 3.01 2.97 2.80 1.03 3.91 3.28 FURNITURE…………………………………………………………….. 473 479 484 487 488 483 475 468 461 452 444 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………………….. 2.77 3.31 -1.54 5.72 3.73 3.07 3.17 3.25 3.23 3.36 3.28 3.19 2.80 1.03 3.91 3.28 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. 2.09 1.22 1.07 0.61 0.17 -0.89 -1.76 -1.52 -1.44 -1.98 -1.76 TRANSPORTATION & UTILITIES…………………………… 53522 53048 53448 53897 54358 54738 55162 55636 56083 56519 56977 57407 52602 53300 54539 56304 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………………………… 2.58 -3.49 3.47 2.82 3.48 2,402 3.25 3.15 3.28 2,588 3.05 1.71 2.32 3.24 MISCELLANEOUS DURABLE GOODS……………… 2,101 3.05 2,1713.40 2,222 2,274 3.142,329 2,496 2,6651.33 2,740 2,817 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………………….. 2.70 1.23 1.56 3.18 3.23 3.17 3.29 3.18 2.32 3.24 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. 2.02 -0.463.331.34 2.35 2.33 3.21 2.42 3.14 3.25 3.92 3.69 1.71 2.961.33 2.83 2.79 INFORMATION…………………………………………………… 62396 63946 64536 65034 65505 65925 66370 66806 67331 67866 68396 68793 60999 63239 65708 67600 NONDURABLE GOODS…………………………………. 20,017 3.74 20,3553.1220,673 21,278 21,925 22,576 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………………………… 2.06 10.31 2.93 20,966 2.59 2.73 2.65 21,606 3.18 3.22 3.16 22,249 2.34 4.85 3.6722,856 3.90 23,170 2.88 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. 1.82 10.101.684.76 1.56 1.42 2.84 1.49 1.54 2.94 1.47 1.48 4.85 1.473.67 1.24 1.37 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………………….. 0.94 3.55 4.98 3.09 2.72 2.79 3.05 2.97 3.90 2.88 FINANCIAL 70683 71177 72635 7,101 73243 73807 74950 75522 76539 77045 70721 7,812 73508 75761 FOODACTIVITIES…………………………………..... AND BEVERAGE & TOBACCO......................... 6,815 71949 6,966 7,233743487,371 7,470760337,562 7,652 68979 7,731 7,903 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………………………… 9.65 2.82 3.39 3.12 3.28 3.09 2.69 2.67 3.94 3.06 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. 2.46 4.412.213.87 1.94 1.86 2.96 1.90 1.34 2.73 1.24 1.19 4.12 1.032.52 1.05 1.16 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………………….. 3.31 3.87 2.68 5.16 3.62 3.70 3.33 3.19 3.11 3.01 2.95 2.79 4.12 2.52 3.94 3.06 (CONTINUED ON NEXT PAGE) Forecast Data CONSTRUCTION................................................................................ 9,756 10,036 10,248 10,458 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. 3.12 2.87 2.11 2.05 | 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025 GROSS DOMESTIC PRODUCT.......................................................................... 281,548 287,872 294,064 300,449 307,195 313,710 320,540 327,536 334,562 341,669 349,209 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. 2.40 2.25 2.15 2.17 2.25 2.12 2.18 2.18 2.15 2.12 2.21 APPENDIX A 38 Forecast Data Table 13: Tennessee Gross Domestic Product by Sector (millions of 2009 dollars) January 2016 Forecast Data 2015 2016 2025 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 GROSSTEXTILE DOMESTIC PRODUCT.......................................................................... 281,548 MILLS & TEXTILE PRODUCT MILLS 441 287,872 435 294,064 429 300,449 422 307,195 415 313,710 409 320,540 402 327,536 396 334,562 390 341,669 385 349,209 380 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. change……………………………………………………………………….. 2.40 2.25 2.15 2.17 2.25 2.12 2.18 2.18 2.15 2.12 2.21 Percentage -1.57 -1.49 -1.38 -1.63 -1.56 -1.59 -1.59 -1.47 -1.51 -1.40 -1.34 NATURAL RESOURCES & MINING...................................................................................................... 3,216 3,343 3,468 3,594 3,721 APPAREL & LEATHER PRODUCTS……………………………………………………………………….. 303 294 285 277 269 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. change……………………………………………………………………….. 6.03 3.95 3.74 3.63 3.53 Percentage -3.00 -2.95 -2.92 -2.91 -2.84 3,850 261 3.46 -2.84 3,978 254 3.33 -2.79 4,106 247 3.23 -2.68 4,229 241 2.98 -2.56 4,353 235 2.94 -2.42 4,486 230 3.06 -2.08 10,671 2,950 2.03 1.58 10,879 3,001 1.95 1.72 11,109 3,053 2.12 1.73 11,340 3,103 2.08 1.64 11,568 3,152 2.01 1.59 11,814 3,201 2.12 1.53 12,058 3,247 2.07 1.44 MANUFACTURING............................................................................. 47,428 PRINTING & RELATED SUPPORT……………………………………………………………………….. 1,158 48,617 1,155 49,807 1,153 51,005 1,152 52,249 1,153 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. change……………………………………………………………………….. 2.86 2.51 2.45 2.41 2.44 Percentage 1.55 -0.28 -0.19 -0.02 0.04 53,379 1,156 2.16 0.27 54,554 1,160 2.20 0.35 55,781 1,164 2.25 0.37 57,041 1,170 2.26 0.46 58,101 1,175 1.86 0.46 59,291 1,181 2.05 0.48 CONSTRUCTION................................................................................ 9,756 10,036 PAPER……………………………………………………………………….. 2,776 2,818 10,248 2,861 10,458 2,904 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. change……………………………………………………………………….. 3.12 2.87 2.11 2.05 Percentage 1.63 1.54 1.51 1.52 DURABLE GOODS........................................................................ 27,410 CHEMICALS……………………………………………………………………….. 6,157 28,262 6,328 29,134 6,494 30,039 6,634 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. change……………………………………………………………………….. 3.63 3.11 3.08 3.11 Percentage 2.65 2.79 2.61 2.16 30,971 6,783 3.10 2.25 31,773 6,978 2.59 2.87 32,629 7,163 2.69 2.65 33,532 7,355 2.77 2.68 34,465 7,557 2.78 2.75 35,245 7,705 2.26 1.96 36,122 7,876 2.49 2.22 WOOD PRODUCTS…………………………………………............. 575 583 591 600 PLASTICS & RUBBER……………………………………………………………………….. 1,939 1,931 1,924 1,917 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. change……………………………………………………………………….. 1.01 1.49 1.37 1.48 Percentage -0.46 -0.40 -0.37 -0.34 608 1,911 1.29 -0.31 617 1,907 1.50 -0.21 625 1,906 1.27 -0.07 633 1,906 1.34 0.00 642 1,909 1.41 0.13 651 1,915 1.40 0.36 660 1,923 1.47 0.41 NONMETALLIC MINERAL PRODUCTS…………………………….. 1,038 1,042 1,046 1,049 MISCELLANEOUS NONDURABLE GOODS………………429 428 427 426 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. change……………………………………………………………………….. 0.49 0.36 0.42 0.28 Percentage -0.35 -0.32 -0.23 -0.21 1,053 425 0.35 -0.15 1,057 424 0.40 -0.14 1,061 425 0.39 0.07 1,065 425 0.33 0.14 1,066 427 0.12 0.37 1,067 428 0.10 0.38 1,070 430 0.23 0.44 PRIMARY METALS………….……………………………................. 1,240 54,018 1,251 55,058 1,260 56,189 1,272 57,446 1,281 TRADE, TRANSPORTATION & UTILITIES………….....................……..................…….................. 52,904 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. change……………………………………………………………………….. 0.98 0.93 0.67 0.95 0.75 Percentage 4.33 3.71 3.09 2.88 2.51 1,293 58,646 0.88 2.22 1,301 59,970 0.63 2.00 1,312 61,303 0.83 2.00 1,323 62,635 0.84 2.10 1,330 64,095 0.55 2.00 1,341 65,661 0.81 2.44 3,711 22,020 -0.39 3.03 3,701 22,646 -0.26 2.84 3,692 23,302 -0.24 2.90 3,684 23,957 -0.22 2.81 3,680 24,685 -0.11 3.04 MACHINERY………………………………………………………… 3,119 19,981 3,176 20,359 3,239 20,784 3,299 RETAIL TRADE……………………………………………......................... 19,590 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. change……………………………………………………………………….. 1.93 1.82 1.98 1.86 Percentage 2.02 2.00 1.89 2.09 3,351 21,208 1.57 2.04 3,404 21,594 1.59 1.82 3,455 22,020 1.49 1.97 3,510 22,425 1.59 1.84 3,563 22,838 1.50 1.84 3,610 23,331 1.32 2.16 3,665 23,870 1.53 2.31 COMPUTER & ELECTRONIC PRODUCTS……………14,382 1,539 14,655 1,626 14,914 1,710 15,147 1,799 TRANSPORTATION & UTILITIES……………………………………………. Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. change……………………………………………………………………….. 5.73 5.66 5.17 5.22 Percentage 1.73 1.90 1.77 1.56 1,895 15,382 5.32 1.55 1,993 15,679 5.20 1.93 2,102 15,929 5.47 1.60 2,212 16,232 5.22 1.90 2,329 16,495 5.31 1.62 2,448 16,807 5.09 1.89 2,585 17,106 5.58 1.78 ELECTRICAL EQUIPMENT, APPLIANCES INFORMATION…………………………………………………….................................... 9,068 9,333 9,599 9,872 10,161 10,450 10,729 11,028 11,346 & COMPONENTS............................................................................. 3,218 3,283 3,370 3,452 3,539 3,613 3,711 3,803 3,911 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. 2.71 2.92 2.86 2.84 2.93 2.84 2.67 2.79 2.88 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. 2.51 2.03 2.65 2.44 2.52 2.08 2.71 2.50 2.83 FINANCIAL ACTIVITIES…………………………………............................ 45,432 46,518 47,644 48,773 49,958 51,017 52,190 53,401 54,581 MOTOR VEHICLES, BODIES Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. 2.53 2.39 2.42 2.37 2.43 2.12 2.30 2.32 2.21 & TRAILERS, & PARTS............................................................................. 10,107 10,616 11,134 11,699 12,269 12,764 13,264 13,805 14,373 PROFESSIONAL & BUSINESS SERVICES…………………………................. 33,169 34,390 35,679 37,064 38,483 39,965 41,456 42,960 44,451 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. 6.12 5.04 4.88 5.07 4.88 4.03 3.92 4.08 4.11 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. 3.99 3.68 3.75 3.88 3.83 3.85 3.73 3.63 3.47 OTHER TRANSPORTATION EQUIPMENT……………………………………………………………………………………………………………… 385 392 401 408 416 421 428 435 440 EDUCATION & HEALTH SERVICES………………………........................... 29,853 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. 2.12 30,561 1.81 31,251 2.17 31,929 1.89 32,606 1.87 33,245 1.38 33,940 1.61 34,636 1.48 35,322 1.26 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. 2.47 2.37 2.26 2.17 2.12 1.96 2.09 2.05 1.98 FURNITURE…………………………………………………………….. 473 479 484 487 488 483 475 468 461 LEISUREPercentage & HOSPITALITY……………………………………..................... 11,960 change……………………………………………………………………….. 2.09 12,311 1.22 12,514 1.07 12,737 0.61 12,951 0.17 13,182 -0.89 13,398 -1.76 13,612 -1.52 13,831 -1.44 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. 3.08 2.94 1.65 1.78 1.68 1.78 1.64 1.60 1.61 MISCELLANEOUS DURABLE GOODS……………… 2,101 2,171 2,222 2,274 2,329 2,402 2,496 2,588 2,665 OTHER SERVICES…………………………………………............................ 6,477 6,414 6,380 6,325 6,274 6,230 6,186 6,148 6,114 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. 2.02 3.33 2.35 2.33 2.42 3.14 3.92 3.69 2.96 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. -1.01 -0.97 -0.53 -0.85 -0.82 -0.70 -0.70 -0.61 -0.56 NONDURABLE GOODS…………………………………. 20,017 20,355 20,673 20,966 21,278 21,606 21,925 22,249 22,576 GOVERNMENT……………………………………………….............................. 32,285 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. 1.82 32,331 1.68 32,414 1.56 32,501 1.42 32,675 1.49 32,868 1.54 33,030 1.47 33,219 1.48 33,444 1.47 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. 0.02 0.14 0.26 0.27 0.53 0.59 0.49 0.57 0.68 FOOD AND BEVERAGE & TOBACCO......................... 6,815 6,966 7,101 7,233 7,371 7,470 7,562 7,652 7,731 FEDERAL.............................................…………………………………….. 7,582 7,450 7,274 7,087 6,910 6,771 6,625 6,505 6,403 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. 2.46 2.21 1.94 1.86 1.90 1.34 1.24 1.19 1.03 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. -1.82 -1.74 -2.36 -2.57 -2.50 -2.01 -2.16 -1.81 -1.56 11,671 4,000 2.87 2.28 55,689 2.03 14,815 46,074 3.08 3.65 447 36,018 1.64 1.97 452 14,090 -1.98 1.87 2,740 6,082 2.83 -0.52 22,856 33,682 1.24 0.71 7,812 6,304 1.05 -1.55 11,988 4,111 2.71 2.78 56,876 2.13 15,296 47,691 3.24 3.51 454 36,806 1.51 2.19 444 14,349 -1.76 1.84 2,817 6,060 2.79 -0.37 23,170 33,943 1.37 0.77 7,903 6,214 1.16 -1.43 27,378 2024 1.25 27,729 2025 1.28 STATE & LOCAL…………………………………………........................ 24,704 24,881 25,140 25,414 2015 2016 2017 2018 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. 0.60 0.72 1.04 1.09 Center for Business and Economic Research, University of Tennessee 25,765 2019 1.38 26,097 2020 1.29 26,405 2021 1.18 26,714 2022 1.17 27,040 2023 1.22 Tennessee Econometric Model APPENDIX A 39 3,725 21,373 -0.47 2.48 | | 3,743 20,855 1.14 2.95 Forecast Data 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT FABRICATEDTRADE……………………………………...................... METAL PRODUCTS………………….. 18,933 3,616 19,382 3,643 19,785 3,677 20,258 3,701 WHOLESALE Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. change……………………………………………………………………….. 2.09 0.75 0.94 0.63 Percentage 2.75 2.37 2.08 2.39 Table 14: Tennessee Gross Domestic Product by Sector (millions of current dollars) January 2016 Forecast Data | 5,916 7.12 6,335 7.08 6,777 6.98 7,220 6.53 7,677 6.34 8,167 6.38 13,216 3.93 13,719 3.81 14,294 4.19 14,890 4.17 15,502 4.11 16,154 4.20 16,800 4.00 MANUFACTURING............................................................................. 50,656 52,521 54,392 56,368 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. 4.08 3.68 3.56 3.63 58,408 3.62 60,323 3.28 62,374 3.40 64,538 3.47 66,782 3.48 68,963 3.27 71,316 3.41 DURABLE GOODS........................................................................ 27,815 28,980 30,190 31,496 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. 4.74 4.19 4.18 4.32 32,785 4.09 33,977 3.64 35,243 3.73 36,614 3.89 38,056 3.94 39,367 3.44 40,819 3.69 786 810 3.02 834 2.90 859 3.09 886 3.07 916 948 WOOD PRODUCTS…………………………………………............. 693 718 742 765 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. 2.82 Seasonally 3.52 Adjusted 3.40 (current 3.03dollars) 2.83 Table 14: Tennessee Average Annual Wage and Salary Rate by Sector, NONMETALLIC MINERAL PRODUCTS…………………………….. 1,096 1,109 1,125 1,141Forecast 1,157 1,186 1,203 History Data 1,172 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. 1.44 2015:4 1.222016:1 1.42 1.40 2016:41.44 1.25 2017:31.25 1.43 2015:2 2015:3 2016:2 2016:3 2017:1 2017:2 2017:4 2018:1 3.43 2016 3.46 January 1,218 Annual 1,232 1.202015 1.16 2014 2016 1,245 1.04 2017 TOTAL NONFARM……………………………………………….. 47346 1,344 47481 47891 48586 48925 49616 1,268 49956 50303 50649 1,235 50984 PRIMARY METALS………….……………………………................. 1,329482411,312 1,298 49266 1,282 1,249 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………………………… 10.68 1.14 3.50 2.89 2.82 2.82 2.77 2.81 2.67 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. -0.96 -1.17 2.96-1.24 -1.12 -1.182.87 -1.10 -1.522.78 -1.10 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………………….. 3.76 3.73 3.44 4.51 2.62 3.04 2.87 2.85 2.82 2.82 2.81 2.76 45782 47219 1,204 48755 50131 1,221 1,188 2.62 3.25 2.82 -1.11 3.14 -1.41 -1.38 2.62 3.14 3.25 2.82 FABRICATED METAL PRODUCTS………………….. 3,948567174,075 4,214 57866 4,347 4,498 NATURAL RESOURCES, MINING & CONSTRUCTION…… 54764 3,819 56036 56338 57094 57489 58296 4,425 58734 59169 59609 4,617 60009 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………………………… 26.46 4.57 9.62 2.17 2.69 2.79 2.653.17 3.01 1.80 3.04 2.991.633.01 2.64 2.71 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. 3.38 2.72 3.21 3.40 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………………….. 6.18 8.25 8.61 9.83 4.26 2.59 2.71 2.78 2.87 2.92 3.01 2.94 4,743 4,987 51513 54695 4,851 57291 58952 4.71 4.75 2.90 2.73 6.18 2.27 2.82 4.71 6.18 4.75 2.90 MANUFACTURING…………………………………………… 57619 58423 59116 59605 60062 60584 61081 61537 61954 62435 62929 63334 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. 3.49 3.35 3.74 3.60 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………………………… 25.45 3.51 5.70 4.83 3.10 3.52 3.323.27 3.02 3.43 2.74 3.153.333.20 3.48 2.60 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………………….. 2.58 4.07 3.24 9.48 4.24 3.70 3.32 3.24 3.15 3.06 3.03 2.92 56302 57400 60333 62214 3.47 1.95 2.89 3.47 2.85 5.11 3.12 2.85 1.95 5.11 3.12 DURABLE GOODS……………………………………...... 55869 1,383 56305 56988 57693 58176 59072 1,572 59451 59941 60460 1,650 60849 PRODUCTS............................................................................. 1,432573311,460 1,494 58650 1,534 1,613 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………………………… 20.29 3.16 4.94 2.43 2.55 3.39 3.30 2.91 2.59 3.34 3.51 2.60 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. 4.38 3.59 1.94 2.29 2.70 2.47 2.63 2.26 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………………….. 1.39 2.50 1.28 7.47 3.26 3.32 2.92 3.04 3.05 3.03 3.09 3.01 55092 55627 1,725 57962 59731 1,689 1,769 3.45 0.97 4.20 3.05 2.36 2.16 2.55 3.45 0.97 4.20 3.05 ELECTRICALGOODS…………………………….. EQUIPMENT, APPLIANCES NONDURABLE 60716 62180 62910 63681 64330 64949 65517 66055 66566 67057 67531 67993 Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………………………… 34.67 3,499 10.00 4.78 4.14 4,059 3.91 3.54 3.13 2.98 2.76 &%COMPONENTS............................................................................. 3,639 4.993,844 4,2853.33 4,495 4,7192.86 4,950 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………………….. 4.70 6.82 6.65 12.98 5.95 4.45 4.14 3.73 3.48 3.24 3.07 2.93 58379 60542 64619 66803 2.03 6.73 3.38 5,199 3.71 5,460 5,728 2.03 3.71 6.73 3.38 MACHINERY………………………………………………………… 3,338 3,454 3,584 3,713 3,834 3,965 4,097 4,240 COMPUTER & ELECTRONIC Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. 4.68 4.00 5.63 5.60 TRADE, TRANSPORTATION, UTILITIES…………. 42794 42887 MOTOR VEHICLES, BODIES & TRAILERS % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………………………… 8.51 0.87 Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………………….. 2.84 9,474 2.02 &%PARTS............................................................................. 5.56 4.90 4.98 4.90 43218 43594 43970 44311 44670 45047 45414 45778 46130 46497 3.12 3.53 3.50 3.13 3.28 3.42 3.30 3.24 3.11 3.22 -0.79 3.97 2.75 11,320 3.32 3.36 3.28 3.31 3.22 10,062 10,654 11,9573.3312,541 13,1643.2713,837 4,387 5.03 4,514 5.02 4,670 4.92 42242 42707 44136 45592 2.75 1.10 3.35 3.30 2.75 1.10 3.35 15,863 3.30 14,553 15,174 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. 7.05 65624 6.2166259 5.89 6.25 679045.63 4.88 694634.97 5.11 64537 5.18 4.54 WHOLESALE TRADE……………………………………. 65438 65107 66802 67371 68436 68952 69949 70508 64934 4.27 67084 69200 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………………………… 12.31 -2.00 3.21 3.93 3.32 3.45 3.20 3.17 3.05 3.00 2.83 3.23 3.97 0.61 3.31 3.15 OTHER TRANSPORTATION EQUIPMENT……………………………………………………………………………………………………………… 429 446 468 489 512 533 558 580 601 625 652 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………………….. 2.85 0.78 -0.50 4.24 2.09 3.48 3.47 3.28 3.22 3.10 3.01 3.03 3.97 0.61 3.31 3.15 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. 4.57 4.00 4.95 4.51 4.63 4.25 4.66 3.83 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. 3.98 2.71 2.62 1.77 2.13 0.16 0.16 -0.14 3.75 3.96 4.27 0.36 -0.47 -0.48 RETAIL TRADE……………………………………………. 29138 29534 29748 29973 30226 30443 30692 30946 31202 31466 31700 31933 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………………………… 11.59 5.56 2.93 3.42 2.90 FURNITURE…………………………………………………………….. 486 499 3.05 512 522 3.325333.35 3.35 533 3.435343.01 2.97 534 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………………….. 2.77 3.31 -1.54 5.72 3.73 3.07 3.17 3.25 3.23 3.36 3.28 3.19 28895 29193 30333 31329 2.80 3.91 3.28 536 1.03 533 530 2.80 1.03 3.91 3.28 TRANSPORTATION & UTILITIES…………………………… 53522 53048 53448 53897 54358 54738 55162 55636 56083 56519 56977 57407 MISCELLANEOUS DURABLE GOODS……………… 2,343 3.402,414 2,5583.48 2,662 2,7903.28 2,910 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………………………… 2.58 2,253 -3.49 3.05 3.47 2,484 2.82 3.14 3.25 3.15 3.05 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………………….. 2.70 3.74 1.23 -0.46 1.56 3.18 3.212.99 3.23 4.06 3.17 3.254.833.29 4.29 3.18 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. 3.98 1.34 3.01 2.90 52602 53300 54539 56304 3,025 1.33 3,133 3,239 1.71 2.32 3.24 1.71 2.32 3.24 3.93 1.33 3.59 3.38 INFORMATION…………………………………………………… 62396 63946 64536 65034 65505 65925 66370 66806 67331 67866 68396 68793 NONDURABLE GOODS………………………………….22,842 23,542 24,202 24,872 25,623 26,346 27,131 27,924 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………………………… 2.06 10.31 3.74 3.12 2.93 2.59 2.73 2.65 3.18 3.22 3.16 2.34 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. 3.06 4.76 2.81 2.77 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………………….. 0.94 3.28 3.55 10.10 4.98 3.09 2.843.02 2.72 2.82 2.79 2.942.983.05 2.92 2.97 60999 63239 65708 67600 28,726 29,596 30,497 4.85 3.67 3.90 2.88 2.87 3.67 3.03 3.04 4.85 3.90 2.88 FINANCIAL 70683 7,670 71177 71949 73243 73807 74950 9,208 75522 76033 76539 9,778 77045 FOODACTIVITIES…………………………………..... AND BEVERAGE & TOBACCO......................... 8,017726358,305 8,601 74348 8,935 9,509 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………………………… 9.65 5.60 2.82 4.41 3.39 3.12 2.963.88 3.28 3.06 3.09 2.733.262.69 2.83 2.67 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. 4.52 3.87 3.59 3.57 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………………….. 3.31 3.87 2.68 5.16 3.62 3.70 3.33 3.19 3.11 3.01 2.95 2.79 68979 70721 73508 75761 10,030 10,332 10,628 4.12 3.94 3.06 2.58 2.52 3.01 2.87 4.12 2.52 3.94 3.06 (CONTINUED ON NEXT PAGE) Forecast Data CONSTRUCTION................................................................................ 11,085 11,751 12,218 12,716 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. 6.04 6.01 3.97 4.08 | 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT NATURAL RESOURCES & MINING...................................................................................................... 4,021 4,466 4,806 5,157 5,523 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. 4.29 11.07 7.60 7.31 7.09 APPENDIX A 40 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025 GROSS DOMESTIC PRODUCT.......................................................................... 311,211 324,625 337,815 351,543 365,947 380,631 396,433 413,034 429,979 447,484 465,985 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. 4.22 4.31 4.06 4.06 4.10 4.01 4.15 4.19 4.10 4.07 4.13 Table 14: Tennessee Gross Domestic Product by Sector (millions of current dollars) January 2016 Forecast Data LEISURE & HOSPITALITY……………………………………..................... 13,245 FURNITURE…………………………………………………………….. 486 13,987 499 14,562 512 15,167 522 Percentage 5.12 5.61 4.11 4.16 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. change……………………………………………………………………….. 3.98 2.71 2.62 1.77 15,748 533 3.83 2.13 16,397 533 4.12 0.16 17,082 534 4.18 0.16 17,797 534 4.19 -0.14 18,537 536 4.16 0.36 19,341 533 4.34 -0.47 20,151 530 4.19 -0.48 OTHER SERVICES…………………………………………............................ 7,670 7,861 8,013 MISCELLANEOUS DURABLE GOODS……………… 7,560 2,253 2,343 2,414 2,484 Percentage 1.63 1.46 2.48 1.94 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. change……………………………………………………………………….. 3.74 3.98 3.01 2.90 8,171 2,558 1.98 2.99 8,349 2,662 2.18 4.06 8,534 2,790 2.21 4.83 8,733 2,910 2.34 4.29 8,940 3,025 2.37 3.93 9,146 3,133 2.31 3.59 9,367 3,239 2.41 3.38 GOVERNMENT……………………………………………….............................. 36,657 37,668 NONDURABLE GOODS………………………………….22,842 23,542 38,797 24,202 39,971 24,872 Percentage 2.02 2.76 3.00 3.03 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. change……………………………………………………………………….. 3.28 3.06 2.81 2.77 41,268 25,623 3.25 3.02 42,663 26,346 3.38 2.82 44,097 27,131 3.36 2.98 45,623 27,924 3.46 2.92 47,208 28,726 3.47 2.87 48,824 29,596 3.42 3.03 50,508 30,497 3.45 3.04 FEDERAL.............................................…………………………………….. 8,523 8,532 8,456 8,395 FOOD AND BEVERAGE & TOBACCO......................... 7,670 8,017 8,305 8,601 Percentage -0.16 0.10 -0.89 -0.71 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. change……………………………………………………………………….. 5.60 4.52 3.59 3.57 8,346 8,935 -0.59 3.88 8,333 9,208 -0.15 3.06 8,310 9,509 -0.28 3.26 8,322 9,778 0.14 2.83 8,357 10,030 0.42 2.58 8,386 10,332 0.36 3.01 8,419 10,628 0.39 2.87 STATE & LOCAL…………………………………………........................ 28,134 29,136 30,341 31,575 2015 2016 2017 2018 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. 2.70 3.56 4.13 4.07 32,922 2019 4.27 34,330 2020 4.28 35,787 2021 4.24 37,301 2022 4.23 38,851 2023 4.15 40,438 2024 4.08 42,089 2025 4.08 Center for Business and Economic Research, University of Tennessee Tennessee Econometric Model APPENDIX A 41 47,868 652 3.96 4.27 | | EDUCATION & HEALTH SERVICES………………………........................... 32,949 OTHER TRANSPORTATION EQUIPMENT……………………………………………………………………………………………………………… 429 34,300 446 35,640 468 36,983 489 38,391 512 39,762 533 41,246 558 42,791 580 44,379 601 46,044 625 Percentage 4.23 4.10 3.91 3.77 3.81 3.57 3.73 3.75 3.71 3.75 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. change……………………………………………………………………….. 4.57 4.00 4.95 4.51 4.63 4.25 4.66 3.83 3.75 3.96 Forecast Data 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025 GROSSTEXTILE DOMESTIC PRODUCT.......................................................................... 311,211 MILLS & TEXTILE PRODUCT MILLS 464 324,625 458 337,815 455 351,543 452 365,947 449 380,631 444 396,433 441 413,034 438 429,979 434 447,484 432 465,985 430 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. change……………………………………………………………………….. 4.22 4.31 4.06 4.06 4.10 4.01 4.15 4.19 4.10 4.07 4.13 Percentage -2.31 -1.23 -0.62 -0.77 -0.65 -1.00 -0.72 -0.61 -0.94 -0.57 -0.38 NATURAL RESOURCES & MINING...................................................................................................... 4,021 4,466 4,806 5,157 5,523 5,916 6,335 6,777 7,220 7,677 8,167 APPAREL & LEATHER PRODUCTS……………………………………………………………………….. 296 283 271 261 252 244 235 228 221 214 209 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. 4.29 11.07 7.60 7.31 7.09 7.12 7.08 6.98 6.53 6.34 6.38 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. -3.37 -4.28 -4.25 -3.77 -3.42 -3.40 -3.34 -3.26 -3.13 -2.96 -2.62 CONSTRUCTION................................................................................ 11,085 PAPER……………………………………………………………………….. 3,151 11,751 3,261 12,218 3,371 12,716 3,491 13,216 3,616 13,719 3,756 14,294 3,905 14,890 4,057 15,502 4,209 16,154 4,362 16,800 4,516 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. change……………………………………………………………………….. 6.04 6.01 3.97 4.08 3.93 3.81 4.19 4.17 4.11 4.20 4.00 Percentage 3.63 3.49 3.38 3.56 3.60 3.86 3.96 3.89 3.76 3.63 3.53 MANUFACTURING............................................................................. 50,656 52,521 54,392 56,368 58,408 60,323 62,374 64,538 66,782 68,963 71,316 PRINTING & RELATED SUPPORT……………………………………………………………………….. 1,099 1,104 1,099 1,097 1,098 1,101 1,104 1,108 1,113 1,118 1,124 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. 4.08 3.68 3.56 3.63 3.62 3.28 3.40 3.47 3.48 3.27 3.41 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. 2.92 0.47 -0.43 -0.16 0.04 0.25 0.35 0.34 0.44 0.47 0.50 DURABLE GOODS........................................................................ 27,815 28,980 30,190 31,496 32,785 33,977 35,243 36,614 38,056 39,367 40,819 CHEMICALS……………………………………………………………………….. 859 902 943 983 1,025 1,074 1,123 1,175 1,231 1,281 1,336 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. 4.74 4.19 4.18 4.32 4.09 3.64 3.73 3.89 3.94 3.44 3.69 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. 4.86 4.95 4.59 4.25 4.23 4.78 4.59 4.59 4.77 4.06 4.32 WOOD PRODUCTS…………………………………………............. 693 718 742 765 786 810 834 859 886 916 948 PLASTICS & RUBBER……………………………………………………………………….. 7,136 7,311 7,507 7,696 7,912 8,134 8,372 8,630 8,912 9,219 9,530 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. 2.82 3.52 3.40 3.03 2.83 3.02 2.90 3.09 3.07 3.43 3.46 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. 1.59 2.45 2.68 2.51 2.81 2.80 2.93 3.08 3.27 3.44 3.37 NONMETALLIC MINERAL PRODUCTS…………………………….. 1,096 1,109 1,125 1,141 1,157 1,172 1,186 1,203 1,218 1,232 1,245 MISCELLANEOUS NONDURABLE GOODS……………… 2,166 2,206 2,250 2,291 2,337 2,385 2,441 2,510 2,576 2,638 2,724 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. 1.44 1.22 1.42 1.40 1.44 1.25 1.25 1.43 1.20 1.16 1.04 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. 2.22 1.81 2.03 1.81 1.99 2.09 2.33 2.84 2.60 2.43 3.26 PRIMARY METALS………….……………………………................. 1,344 1,329 1,312 1,298 1,282 1,268 1,249 1,235 1,221 1,204 1,188 TRADE, TRANSPORTATION & UTILITIES………….....................……..................…….................. 59,227 61,691 64,147 66,823 69,726 72,730 76,055 79,534 83,067 86,829 90,844 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. -0.96 -1.17 -1.24 -1.12 -1.18 -1.10 -1.52 -1.10 -1.11 -1.41 -1.38 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. 4.18 4.16 3.98 4.17 4.34 4.31 4.57 4.57 4.44 4.53 4.62 FABRICATED METAL PRODUCTS………………….. 3,819 3,948 4,075 4,214 4,347 4,425 4,498 4,617 4,743 4,851 4,987 WHOLESALE TRADE……………………………………...................... 21,686 22,786 23,779 24,892 26,199 27,481 29,010 30,576 32,215 33,887 35,713 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. 4.57 3.38 3.21 3.40 3.17 1.80 1.63 2.64 2.73 2.27 2.82 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. 5.40 5.07 4.36 4.68 5.25 4.89 5.56 5.40 5.36 5.19 5.39 MACHINERY………………………………………………………… 3,338 3,454 3,584 3,713 3,834 3,965 4,097 4,240 4,387 4,514 4,670 RETAIL TRADE……………………………………………......................... 21,375 22,088 22,918 23,826 24,737 25,646 26,643 27,657 28,694 29,846 31,087 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. 3.51 3.49 3.74 3.60 3.27 3.43 3.33 3.48 3.47 2.89 3.47 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. 3.10 3.33 3.76 3.96 3.82 3.68 3.89 3.81 3.75 4.02 4.16 COMPUTER & ELECTRONIC TRANSPORTATION & UTILITIES……………………………………………. 16,166 16,817 17,450 18,105 18,790 19,602 20,402 21,301 22,158 23,096 24,044 PRODUCTS............................................................................. 1,383 1,432 1,460 1,494 1,534 1,572 1,613 1,650 1,689 1,725 1,769 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. 4.02 4.03 3.76 3.75 3.79 4.32 4.08 4.41 4.03 4.23 4.11 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. 4.38 3.59 1.94 2.29 2.70 2.47 2.63 2.26 2.36 2.16 2.55 INFORMATION…………………………………………………….................................... 8,975 9,191 9,414 9,645 9,889 10,117 10,329 10,569 10,823 11,061 11,311 ELECTRICAL EQUIPMENT, APPLIANCES Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. 1.80 2.41 2.43 2.45 2.53 2.31 2.10 2.33 2.40 2.20 2.26 & COMPONENTS............................................................................. 3,499 3,639 3,844 4,059 4,285 4,495 4,719 4,950 5,199 5,460 5,728 FINANCIAL ACTIVITIES…………………………………............................ 50,981 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. 4.68 53,525 4.00 55,905 5.63 58,290 5.60 60,777 5.56 63,198 4.90 65,862 4.98 68,675 4.90 71,509 5.03 74,315 5.02 77,316 4.92 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. 4.86 4.99 4.45 4.27 4.27 3.98 4.22 4.27 4.13 3.92 4.04 MOTOR VEHICLES, BODIES & TRAILERS PROFESSIONAL & BUSINESS SERVICES…………………………................. 35,854 53,107 14,553 56,011 15,174 59,129 15,863 62,339 & PARTS............................................................................. 9,474 37,853 10,062 40,074 10,654 42,410 11,320 44,829 11,957 47,458 12,541 50,226 13,164 13,837 Percentage 6.14 5.57 5.87 5.83 5.70 5.86 5.83 5.74 5.47 5.57 5.43 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. change……………………………………………………………………….. 7.05 6.21 5.89 6.25 5.63 4.88 4.97 5.11 5.18 4.27 4.54 42 | 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT Historical Data | APPENDIX B APPENDIX B: HISTORICAL DATA In this section— Appendix B: Historical Data Quarterly Annual pages 44–67 (2012:2 to 2015:3) pages 68–82 (2003 to 2014) Quarterly History Tables Table 1: Table 2: Table 3: Table 4: Table 5: Table 6: Table 7: Table 8: Table 9: Table 10: Table 11: Table 12: Table 13: Table 14: Table 15: Table 16: Table 17: Table 18: Table 19: Table 20: Selected U.S. and Tennessee Economic Indicators, Seasonally Adjusted....................................................................................................44 Selected Per Capita U.S. and Tennessee Economic Indicators, Seasonally Adjusted..................................................................................46 Tennessee Personal Income Components, Seasonally Adjusted Annual Rates (millions of 2009 dollars)...................................................47 Tennessee Personal Income Components, Seasonally Adjusted Annual Rates (millions of current dollars))..............................................48 Tennessee Nonfarm Employment by Sector, Not Seasonally Adjusted (thousands of jobs).........................................................................49 Tennessee Durable Goods Manufacturing Employment, Not Seasonally Adjusted (thousands of jobs).......................................................50 Tennessee Nondurable Goods Manufacturing Employment, Not Seasonally Adjusted (thousands of jobs).................................................51 Tennessee Nonfarm Employment by Sector, Seasonally Adjusted (thousands of jobs)...............................................................................52 Tennessee Durable Goods Manufacturing Employment, Seasonally Adjusted (thousands of jobs).............................................................54 Tennessee Nondurable Goods Manufacturing Employment, Seasonally Adjusted (thousands of jobs).......................................................55 Tennessee Average Annual Wage and Salary Rate by Sector, Not Seasonally Adjusted (2009 dollars)......................................................56 Tennessee Average Annual Wage and Salary Rate by Sector, Seasonally Adjusted (2009 dollars)............................................................57 Tennessee Average Annual Wage and Salary Rate by Sector, Not Seasonally Adjusted (current dollars)...................................................59 Tennessee Average Annual Wage and Salary Rate by Sector, Seasonally Adjusted (current dollars).........................................................60 Tennessee Civilian Labor Force and Unemployment Rate, Not Seasonally Adjusted..................................................................................62 Tennessee Civilian Labor Force and Unemployment Rate, Seasonally Adjusted.........................................................................................63 Tennessee Taxable Sales, Not Seasonally Adjusted (millions of 2009 dollars).............................................................................................64 Tennessee Taxable Sales, Seasonally Adjusted (millions of 2009 dollars)....................................................................................................65 Tennessee Taxable Sales, Not Seasonally Adjusted (millions of current dollars)..........................................................................................66 Tennessee Taxable Sales, Seasonally Adjusted (millions of current dollars)................................................................................................67 Annual History Tables Table 1: Table 2: Table 3: Table 4: Table 5: Table 6: Table 7: Table 8: Table 9: Table 10: Table 11: Table 12: Table 13: Table 14: Selected U.S. and Tennessee Economic Indicators......................................................................................................................................68 Selected Per Capita U.S. and Tennessee Economic Indicators.....................................................................................................................69 Tennessee Personal Income Components (millions of 2009 dollars)............................................................................................................70 Tennessee Personal Income Components (millions of current dollars).........................................................................................................71 Tennessee Nonfarm Employment by Sector (thousands of jobs)..................................................................................................................72 Tennessee Durable Goods Manufacturing Employment (thousands of jobs)................................................................................................73 Tennessee Nondurable Goods Manufacturing Employment (thousands of jobs)..........................................................................................74 Tennessee Average Annual Wage and Salary Rate by Sector (2009 dollars)...............................................................................................75 Tennessee Average Annual Wage and Salary Rate by Sector (current dollars)............................................................................................76 Tennessee Civilian Labor Force and Unemployment Rate............................................................................................................................77 Tennessee Taxable Sales (millions of 2009 dollars)......................................................................................................................................78 Tennessee Taxable Sales (millions of current dollars)...................................................................................................................................79 Tennessee Gross Domestic Product by Sector (millions of 2009 dollars).....................................................................................................80 Tennessee Gross Domestic Product by Sector (millions of current dollars)..................................................................................................82 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT | 43 January 2016 | Historical Data 2012:3 2012:4 2013:1 2013:2 2013:3 2013:4 2014:1 2014:2 2014:3 2014:4 2012 Annual 2013 2014 US GDP (Bil$) SAAR……………………………16227.9 16297.3 16440.7 16526.8 16727.5 16957.6 16984.3 17270.0 17522.1 17615.9 17649.3 17913.7 18060.2 18181.2 16155.3 16663.2 17348.1 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR……………………… 2.66 1.72 3.57 2.11 4.95 5.62 0.63 6.90 5.97 2.16 0.76 6.13 3.31 2.71 4.11 3.14 4.11 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 4.11 3.24 2.92 2.51 3.08 4.05 3.31 4.50 4.75 3.88 3.92 3.73 3.07 3.21 4.11 3.14 4.11 TN PERSONAL INCOME (MIL2009$) SAAR…237772 241833 236631 237037 237691 238407 240048 241798 243093 246452 249416 252618 254215 257680 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR……………………… 0.34 7.01 -8.33 0.69 1.11 1.21 2.78 2.95 2.16 5.64 4.90 5.23 2.55 5.56 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 3.45 4.95 0.68 -0.22 -0.03 -1.42 1.44 2.01 2.27 3.37 3.90 4.47 4.58 4.56 US PERSONAL INCOME (BIL2009$) SAAR… 13054 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR……………………… 0.22 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 2.29 13405 11.21 5.01 12962 -12.56 0.15 13073 3.46 0.20 13122 1.52 0.53 13154 0.98 -1.87 13298 4.44 2.59 13392 2.86 2.44 13500 3.28 2.88 13680 5.45 4.00 13861 5.38 4.23 13965 3.06 4.28 14095 3.76 4.41 14224 3.73 3.98 TN PERSONAL INCOME (MIL$) SAAR………252589 258288 253588 254303 256060 257738 260548 263843 266044 269426 271353 276341 278958 282614 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR……………………… 1.66 9.33 -7.08 1.13 2.79 2.65 4.43 5.16 3.38 5.18 2.89 7.56 3.84 5.35 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 5.07 6.80 2.21 1.09 1.37 -0.21 2.74 3.75 3.90 4.54 4.15 4.74 4.85 4.89 US PERSONAL INCOME (BIL$) SAAR……… 13867 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR……………………… 1.54 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 3.89 14317 13.62 6.86 13891 -11.37 1.68 14025 3.91 1.53 14136 3.21 1.94 14221 2.41 -0.67 14434 6.12 3.90 14613 5.06 4.19 14775 4.51 4.52 14956 4.99 5.17 TN NONFARM JOBS (THOUS)……………… 2718.8 2729.8 2739.6 2752.0 2761.6 2781.6 2790.5 2806.3 2824.2 2843.4 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR……………………… 0.87 1.63 1.45 1.82 1.40 2.93 1.29 2.29 2.57 2.76 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 1.75 1.73 1.47 1.44 1.58 1.90 1.86 1.97 2.27 2.22 15080 3.36 4.48 15277 5.33 4.55 15468 5.09 4.69 15614 3.84 4.40 2846.8 2860.9 2874.9 2900.1 0.47 2.00 1.97 3.57 2.02 1.94 1.79 2.00 238054 237442 242848 3.82 -0.26 2.28 3.82 -0.26 2.28 13112 3.03 3.03 13078 -0.26 -0.26 13468 2.98 2.98 252636 255422 264965 5.79 1.10 3.74 5.79 1.10 3.74 13915 4.98 4.98 14068 1.10 1.10 14694 4.45 4.45 2715.3 2758.7 2.00 1.60 2.00 1.60 2816.1 2.08 2.08 US NONFARM JOBS (MIL)…………………… 134.3 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR……………………… 1.23 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 1.65 134.8 1.74 1.66 135.5 2.10 1.57 136.1 1.65 1.68 136.6 1.60 1.77 137.3 1.94 1.82 137.8 1.60 1.70 138.6 2.33 1.87 139.4 2.16 2.01 140.2 2.46 2.14 141.0 2.24 2.30 141.6 1.74 2.15 142.2 1.77 2.05 142.9 1.86 1.90 134.1 1.71 1.71 136.4 1.71 1.71 139.0 1.93 1.93 TN MFG JOBS (THOUS)……………………… 315.1 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR……………………… 1.63 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 3.35 316.0 1.14 2.97 316.9 1.16 2.62 317.3 0.57 1.12 318.5 1.53 1.10 321.1 3.26 1.62 322.8 2.14 1.87 323.3 0.65 1.89 325.8 3.14 2.29 329.0 4.02 2.48 330.9 2.29 2.52 330.7 -0.29 2.28 331.5 1.00 1.74 332.7 1.53 1.17 313.4 2.94 2.94 318.4 1.61 1.61 325.2 2.13 2.13 US MFG JOBS (MIL)…………………………… % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR……………………… % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 12.0 0.98 1.69 12.0 -0.17 1.44 12.0 1.45 1.12 12.0 0.33 0.65 12.0 -0.02 0.40 12.1 2.04 0.95 12.1 1.75 1.02 12.2 1.30 1.26 12.2 1.51 1.65 12.3 2.31 1.72 12.3 1.60 1.68 12.3 0.30 1.43 12.3 -0.05 1.04 12.3 -0.41 0.35 11.9 1.71 1.71 12.0 0.78 0.78 12.2 1.41 1.41 TN UNEMPLOYMENT RATE (%)…………… 7.8 7.7 7.9 7.9 7.7 7.1 6.5 6.5 6.6 6.6 6.5 5.8 5.7 5.6 7.8 7.6 6.6 US UNEMPLOYMENT RATE (%)…………… 8.0 7.8 7.7 7.5 7.2 7.0 6.6 6.2 6.1 5.7 5.6 5.4 5.2 5.0 8.1 7.4 6.2 (CONTINUED ON NEXT PAGE) Historical Data US GDP (Bil2009$) SAAR……………………… 15380.8 15384.3 15457.2 15500.2 15614.4 15761.5 15724.9 15901.5 16068.8 16151.4 16177.3 16333.6 16414.0 16462.5 15354.6 15583.3 15961.7 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR……………………… 0.48 0.09 1.91 1.12 2.98 3.82 -0.93 4.57 4.28 2.07 0.64 3.92 1.98 1.19 2.22 1.49 2.43 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 2.39 1.28 1.09 0.90 1.52 2.45 1.73 2.59 2.91 2.47 2.88 2.72 2.15 1.93 2.22 1.49 2.43 | 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT 2015:1 2015:2 2015:3 2015:4 APPENDIX B 44 Table 1: Selected U.S. and Tennessee Economic Indicators, Seasonally Adjusted Table 1: Selected U.S. and Tennessee Economic Indicators, Seasonally Adjusted January 2016 Historical Data 2012:3 2012:4 2013:1 2013:2 2013:3 2013:4 2014:1 2014:2 2014:3 2014:4 2015:1 2015:2 2015:3 2015:4 2012 Annual 2013 2014 CHAINED PRICE INDEX, GDP ((2009=100.0)……………........................... 105.5 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR……………………… 2.37 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 1.71 105.9 1.49 1.95 106.3 1.50 1.79 106.6 1.10 1.62 107.2 2.00 1.52 107.6 1.79 1.60 108.0 1.48 1.59 108.6 2.23 1.87 109.0 1.59 1.77 109.1 0.12 1.35 109.1 0.11 1.01 109.7 2.12 0.98 110.0 1.32 0.91 110.4 1.44 1.25 105.2 1.84 1.84 106.9 1.63 1.63 108.7 1.64 1.64 US PERS CONSUMP DEFL (2009=100.0)… 106.2 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR……………………… 1.32 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 1.57 106.8 2.17 1.76 107.2 1.36 1.52 107.3 0.44 1.32 107.7 1.67 1.41 108.1 1.42 1.22 108.5 1.61 1.28 109.1 2.14 1.71 109.4 1.19 1.59 109.3 -0.43 1.12 108.8 -1.91 0.23 109.4 2.21 0.25 109.7 1.28 0.27 109.8 0.11 0.41 106.1 1.89 1.89 107.6 1.37 1.37 109.1 1.43 1.43 CONSUMER PRICE INDEX, ALL-URBAN (82-84=1.000)………………… 2.299 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR……………………… 1.77 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 1.68 2.314 2.64 1.91 2.322 1.38 1.69 2.321 -0.14 1.41 2.334 2.27 1.53 2.342 1.42 1.23 2.354 2.09 1.40 2.368 2.44 2.05 2.375 1.18 1.78 2.370 -0.85 1.20 2.352 -3.06 -0.10 2.369 2.98 0.04 2.379 1.58 0.14 2.381 0.33 0.43 2.296 2.08 2.08 2.330 1.46 1.46 2.367 1.61 1.61 3.3 3.3 3.3 3.3 3.3 3.3 3.3 3.3 3.3 3.3 3.3 3.3 3.3 3.3 3.3 3.3 3.3 FEDERAL FUNDS RATE (% per annum)…… 0.143 0.160 0.143 0.117 0.083 0.087 0.073 0.093 0.090 0.100 0.110 0.123 0.137 0.152 0.140 0.108 0.089 30-YEAR FIXED MORTGAGE RATE (%)…… 3.6 3.4 3.5 3.7 4.4 4.3 4.4 4.2 4.1 4.0 3.7 3.8 4.0 3.9 3.7 4.0 4.2 TN TAXABLE SALES (MIL2009$)…………… 22878 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR……………………… -1.93 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 0.93 23007 2.28 1.02 23361 6.30 -0.66 23472 1.91 2.10 23389 -1.41 2.23 23615 3.94 2.65 23780 2.81 1.79 23807 0.45 1.43 24465 11.54 4.60 24985 8.76 5.80 24523 -7.19 3.12 25642 19.55 7.71 26228 9.46 7.21 26353 1.91 5.48 92389 2.77 2.77 93837 1.57 1.57 97036 3.41 3.41 TN TAXABLE SALES (MIL$)………………… 24303 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR……………………… -0.64 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 2.51 24572 4.50 2.80 25035 7.75 0.85 25181 2.36 3.45 25196 0.23 3.67 25530 5.41 3.90 25811 4.47 3.10 25977 2.60 3.16 26775 12.87 6.27 27314 8.29 6.99 26679 -8.97 3.37 28050 22.19 7.98 28781 10.84 7.49 28903 1.70 5.82 98041 100943 105877 4.70 2.96 4.89 4.70 2.96 4.89 TN AVG ANNUAL WAGE, NONFARM (2009$)…………….................................. 41745 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR……………………… -2.20 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 0.60 42345 5.87 3.74 41492 -7.81 -0.74 41477 -0.15 -1.19 41449 -0.27 -0.71 41474 0.24 -2.06 41853 3.71 0.87 41816 -0.36 0.82 41824 0.07 0.90 42351 5.14 2.12 42429 0.73 1.37 43281 8.28 3.50 43269 -0.11 3.46 43666 3.72 3.10 41968 1.59 1.59 41473 -1.18 -1.18 41961 1.18 1.18 TN AVG ANNUAL WAGE, NONFARM ($)…… 44347 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR……………………… -0.91 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 2.18 45226 8.17 5.56 44466 -6.56 0.77 44498 0.29 0.11 44652 1.39 0.69 44837 1.66 -0.86 45427 5.38 2.16 45628 1.78 2.54 45772 1.27 2.51 46299 4.68 3.26 46160 -1.19 1.61 47346 10.68 3.76 47481 1.14 3.73 47891 3.50 3.44 44537 3.52 3.52 44613 0.17 0.17 45782 2.62 2.62 Center for Business and Economic Research, University of Tennessee Tennessee Econometric Model Historical Data | | 45 APPENDIX B 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT BANK PRIME INTEREST RATE (%)………… January 2016 | Historical Data 2012:2 2012:3 2012:4 2013:1 2013:2 2013:3 2013:4 2014:1 2014:2 2014:3 2014:4 2015:1 2015:2 2015:3 Annual 2013 2014 48777 49139 49964 1.47 0.74 1.68 1.47 0.74 1.68 US GDP ($) SAAR……………………………… 51270 51496 51623 51991 52168 52690 53320 53317 54115 54790 54987 55002 55712 56053 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR…………………… 3.01 1.77 0.99 2.89 1.37 4.06 4.87 -0.02 6.12 5.08 1.44 0.11 5.27 2.47 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr………………… 3.51 3.34 2.48 2.16 1.75 2.32 3.29 2.55 3.73 3.99 3.13 3.16 2.95 2.31 51321 52544 54304 3.34 2.38 3.35 3.34 2.38 3.35 TN PERSONAL INCOME (2009$) SAAR…… 36835 36769 37297 36398 36364 36368 36382 36536 36705 36805 37216 37565 37949 38089 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR…………………… 3.26 -0.72 5.88 -9.30 -0.37 0.04 0.15 1.70 1.87 1.09 4.54 3.81 4.14 1.49 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr………………… 2.91 2.35 3.84 -0.39 -1.28 -1.09 -2.46 0.38 0.94 1.20 2.29 2.82 3.39 3.49 36860 36378 36816 2.71 -1.31 1.20 2.71 -1.31 1.20 US PERSONAL INCOME (2009$) SAAR…… 41490 41423 42460 40992 41266 41334 41361 41745 41963 42214 42702 43195 43433 43746 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR…………………… 2.51 -0.64 10.40 -13.13 2.70 0.66 0.26 3.76 2.11 2.41 4.71 4.70 2.22 2.92 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr………………… 2.12 1.54 4.23 -0.59 -0.54 -0.22 -2.59 1.84 1.69 2.13 3.24 3.47 3.50 3.63 41653 41238 42157 2.27 -0.99 2.23 2.27 -0.99 2.23 TN PERSONAL INCOME ($) SAAR………… 39003 39060 39835 39007 39013 39179 39332 39656 40052 40280 40685 40869 41512 41797 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR…………………… 4.53 0.59 8.18 -8.06 0.06 1.71 1.57 3.34 4.05 2.30 4.09 1.82 6.44 2.77 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr………………… 4.73 3.95 5.67 1.12 0.03 0.30 -1.26 1.66 2.66 2.81 3.44 3.06 3.65 3.77 39118 39133 40168 4.66 0.04 2.65 4.66 0.04 2.65 US PERSONAL INCOME ($) SAAR………… 43931 44005 45349 43929 44272 44528 44715 45310 45789 46200 46683 46994 47512 48007 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR…………………… 3.76 0.67 12.80 -11.95 3.15 2.34 1.69 5.43 4.30 3.63 4.25 2.69 4.48 4.24 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr………………… 3.92 3.13 6.07 0.92 0.78 1.19 -1.40 3.14 3.43 3.75 4.40 3.72 3.76 3.91 44204 44362 45996 4.21 0.36 3.69 4.21 0.36 3.69 TN TAXABLE SALES (2009$)………………… 3565 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR…………………… -9.62 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr………………… 1.63 3538 -2.97 -0.14 3548 1.20 -0.05 3593 5.18 -1.71 3601 0.83 1.02 3579 -2.45 1.15 3604 2.85 1.56 3619 1.74 0.72 3614 -0.60 0.36 3704 10.37 3.51 3773 7.63 4.69 3693 -8.16 2.05 3852 18.31 6.59 3930 8.33 6.09 14306 14377 14710 1.68 0.49 2.32 1.68 0.49 2.32 TN TAXABLE SALES ($)……………………… % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR…………………… % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr………………… 3758 -1.69 1.42 3790 3.40 1.71 3851 6.61 -0.21 3863 1.28 2.35 3855 -0.82 2.58 3896 4.31 2.80 3928 3.37 2.01 3943 1.53 2.08 4054 11.69 5.15 4125 7.16 5.87 4018 -9.92 2.29 4214 20.93 6.86 4312 9.69 6.38 15181 15465 16050 3.59 1.87 3.78 3.59 1.87 3.78 3774 -8.51 3.43 Center for Business and Economic Research, University of Tennessee Tennessee Econometric Model Historical Data US GDP (2009$) SAAR………………….…… 48855 48808 48731 48881 48928 49184 49559 49364 49827 50246 50415 50414 50798 50944 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR…………………… 1.15 -0.38 -0.63 1.24 0.38 2.11 3.09 -1.57 3.81 3.40 1.36 -0.01 3.08 1.16 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr………………… 1.73 1.64 0.53 0.34 0.15 0.77 1.70 0.99 1.84 2.16 1.73 2.13 1.95 1.39 | 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT 2012 APPENDIX B 46 Table 2: Selected Per Capita U.S. and Tennessee Economic Indicators, Seasonally Adjusted Table 3: Tennessee Personal Income Components, Seasonally Adjusted Annual Rates (millions of 2009 dollars) January 2016 Historical Data 2012:2 2012:3 2012:4 2013:1 2013:2 2013:3 2013:4 2014:1 2014:2 2014:3 2014:4 2015:1 2015:2 2015:3 2012 Annual 2013 2014 TN PERSONAL INCOME…………..………237568 237772 241833 236631 237037 237691 238407 240048 241798 243093 246452 249416 252618 254215 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR……………… 4.37 0.34 7.01 -8.33 0.69 1.11 1.21 2.78 2.95 2.16 5.64 4.90 5.23 2.55 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………… 4.02 3.45 4.95 0.68 -0.22 -0.03 -1.42 1.44 2.01 2.27 3.37 3.90 4.47 4.58 238054 237442 242848 3.82 -0.26 2.28 3.82 -0.26 2.28 WAGES AND SALARIES………………114754 114363 116463 114532 114997 115321 116213 117642 118201 118966 121268 121639 124682 125258 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR……………… 3.65 -1.36 7.55 -6.47 1.63 1.13 3.13 5.01 1.92 2.62 7.97 1.23 10.39 1.86 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………… 3.84 2.34 5.48 0.71 0.21 0.84 -0.22 2.71 2.79 3.16 4.35 3.40 5.48 5.29 114827 115266 119019 3.59 0.38 3.26 3.59 0.38 3.26 28087 3.25 7.42 28240 2.21 7.00 27971 -3.76 2.65 27787 -2.60 -0.27 27602 -2.64 -1.73 27479 -1.77 -2.70 27288 -2.75 -2.44 27110 -2.57 -2.44 27001 -1.61 -2.18 27194 2.88 -1.04 27310 1.72 0.08 27756 6.70 2.38 27846 1.30 3.13 27860 7.11 7.11 27710 -0.54 -0.54 27148 -2.03 -2.03 PROPRIETORS INCOME……………… 29709 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR……………… 2.44 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………… 7.35 29757 0.65 5.73 29984 3.09 5.11 31182 16.96 5.59 30864 -4.02 3.89 30975 1.45 4.09 30792 -2.34 2.69 31512 9.68 1.06 32173 8.66 4.24 32319 1.83 4.34 32897 7.35 6.84 33274 4.67 5.59 33497 2.70 4.11 33913 5.07 4.93 29745 6.63 6.63 30953 4.06 4.06 32225 4.11 4.11 RENT, INTEREST, DIVIDENDS……… 33692 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR……………… 6.85 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………… 5.83 33702 0.11 4.99 35795 27.25 9.64 33232 -25.71 0.28 33493 3.19 -0.59 33750 3.11 0.14 33698 -0.62 -5.86 34096 4.80 2.60 34373 3.30 2.63 34443 0.81 2.05 34800 4.21 3.27 35257 5.36 3.41 35625 4.24 3.64 35876 2.84 4.16 34082 6.32 6.32 33543 -1.58 -1.58 34428 2.64 2.64 TRANSFER PAYMENTS……………… 48989 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR……………… 2.22 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………… -1.00 49198 1.72 0.92 49011 -1.52 -0.39 49435 3.51 1.47 49689 2.07 1.43 49880 1.55 1.39 50182 2.45 2.39 49629 -4.33 0.39 50061 3.52 0.75 50533 3.83 1.31 50774 1.92 1.18 52494 14.25 5.77 52135 -2.71 4.14 52411 2.14 3.72 48980 -0.83 -0.83 49797 1.67 1.67 50249 0.91 0.91 LESS: PERS CONT FOR SOC INS… 16323 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR……………… 1.16 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………… 1.13 16200 -2.97 -0.29 16458 6.51 3.02 18490 59.32 13.60 18571 1.77 13.77 18606 0.76 14.85 18699 2.02 13.62 18959 5.68 2.54 18965 0.12 2.12 19013 1.02 2.19 19299 6.16 3.21 19382 1.73 2.23 19797 8.83 4.39 19829 0.66 4.29 16314 1.07 1.07 18592 13.96 13.96 19059 2.52 2.52 RESIDENCE ADJUSTMENT…………… -1116 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR……………… 27.25 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………… 46.55 -1135 6.95 41.83 -1203 26.03 53.41 -1231 9.68 17.11 -1222 -2.78 9.49 -1231 3.05 8.48 -1257 8.76 4.56 -1159 -27.87 -5.84 -1155 -1.26 -5.48 -1155 0.06 -6.17 -1181 9.29 -6.06 -1175 -2.12 1.39 -1280 40.83 10.80 -1259 -6.30 9.00 -1126 45.87 45.87 -1235 9.70 9.70 -1163 -5.89 -5.89 PER CAPITA PERSONAL INCOME ($)… 36835 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR……………… 3.26 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………… 2.91 36769 -0.72 2.35 37297 5.88 3.84 36398 -9.30 -0.39 36364 -0.37 -1.28 36368 0.04 -1.09 36382 0.15 -2.46 36536 1.70 0.38 36705 1.87 0.94 36805 1.09 1.20 37216 4.54 2.29 37565 3.81 2.82 37949 4.14 3.39 38089 1.49 3.49 36860 2.71 2.71 36378 -1.31 -1.31 36816 1.20 1.20 Center for Business and Economic Research, University of Tennessee Tennessee Econometric Model Historical Data | | 47 APPENDIX B 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT OTHER LABOR INCOME……………… 27863 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR……………… 9.34 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………… 8.08 | Historical Data 2013:2 2013:3 2013:4 2014:1 2014:2 2014:3 2014:4 2015:1 2015:2 2015:3 2012 Annual 2013 2014 252636 255422 264965 5.79 1.10 3.74 5.79 1.10 3.74 WAGES AND SALARIES………………… 121507 121490 124387 122739 123373 124233 125635 127688 128977 130198 132573 132337 136391 137449 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………………… 4.92 -0.06 9.89 -5.19 2.08 2.82 4.59 6.70 4.10 3.84 7.50 -0.71 12.83 3.14 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………… 5.68 3.94 7.34 2.23 1.54 2.26 1.00 4.03 4.54 4.80 5.52 3.64 5.75 5.57 121860 123995 129859 5.55 1.75 4.73 5.55 1.75 4.73 OTHER LABOR INCOME………………… 29503 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………………… 10.68 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………… 9.99 29837 4.61 9.10 30162 4.43 8.88 29976 -2.45 4.21 29811 -2.17 1.05 29735 -1.02 -0.34 29707 -0.38 -1.51 29618 -1.19 -1.19 29582 -0.49 -0.77 29550 -0.43 -0.62 29729 2.44 0.07 29712 -0.23 0.32 30362 9.05 2.64 30556 2.58 3.40 29566 9.13 9.13 29807 0.81 0.81 29620 -0.63 -0.63 PROPRIETORS INCOME……………… 31458 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………………… 3.70 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………… 9.25 31612 1.97 7.39 32025 5.33 6.96 33417 18.56 7.20 33112 -3.60 5.26 33369 3.14 5.56 33289 -0.96 3.95 34203 11.44 2.35 35106 10.99 6.02 35370 3.04 6.00 35964 6.88 8.03 36201 2.66 5.84 36642 4.97 4.38 37214 6.39 5.21 31567 8.64 8.64 33297 5.48 5.48 35161 5.60 5.60 RENT, INTEREST, DIVIDENDS………… 35675 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………………… 8.16 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………… 7.70 35802 1.43 6.63 38230 30.01 11.57 35613 -24.70 1.80 35933 3.64 0.72 36359 4.83 1.55 36430 0.79 -4.71 37007 6.49 3.92 37507 5.51 4.38 37694 2.02 3.67 38044 3.76 4.43 38358 3.34 3.65 38971 6.55 3.90 39368 4.13 4.44 36172 8.34 8.34 36084 -0.25 -0.25 37563 4.10 4.10 TRANSFER PAYMENTS………………… 51872 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………………… 3.47 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………… 0.75 52264 3.06 2.50 52345 0.62 1.36 52977 4.92 3.01 53308 2.52 2.77 53735 3.24 2.81 54251 3.90 3.64 53868 -2.80 1.68 54625 5.74 2.47 55304 5.06 2.92 55507 1.48 2.32 57110 12.07 6.02 57031 -0.56 4.40 57512 3.42 3.99 51978 1.06 1.06 53568 3.06 3.06 54826 2.35 2.35 LESS: PERS CONT FOR SOC INS…… 17283 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………………… 2.40 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………… 2.92 17210 -1.69 1.27 17577 8.82 4.83 19815 61.49 15.33 19924 2.22 15.28 20044 2.44 16.47 20216 3.47 15.01 20579 7.38 3.85 20694 2.26 3.87 20808 2.23 3.81 21099 5.70 4.37 21087 -0.22 2.47 21656 11.23 4.65 21759 1.93 4.57 17313 2.99 2.99 20000 15.52 15.52 20795 3.98 3.98 RESIDENCE ADJUSTMENT…………… % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………………… % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………… -1182 28.81 49.14 -1206 8.36 44.05 -1284 28.76 56.11 -1319 11.17 18.89 -1311 -2.35 10.94 -1326 4.77 10.01 -1359 10.30 5.83 -1258 -26.71 -4.64 -1260 0.86 -3.86 -1264 1.26 -4.68 -1291 8.81 -5.00 -1278 -3.99 1.63 -1400 43.94 11.08 -1382 -5.12 9.29 -1195 48.63 48.63 -1329 11.18 11.18 -1268 -4.55 -4.55 PER CAPITA PERSONAL INCOME ($)…… 39003 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………………… 4.53 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………… 4.73 39060 0.59 3.95 39835 8.18 5.67 39007 -8.06 1.12 39013 0.06 0.03 39179 1.71 0.30 39332 1.57 -1.26 39656 3.34 1.66 40052 4.05 2.66 40280 2.30 2.81 40685 4.09 3.44 40869 1.82 3.06 41512 6.44 3.65 41797 2.77 3.77 39118 4.66 4.66 39133 0.04 0.04 40168 2.65 2.65 Center for Business and Economic Research, University of Tennessee Tennessee Econometric Model Historical Data TN PERSONAL INCOME…………..………… 251549 252589 258288 253588 254303 256060 257738 260548 263843 266044 269426 271353 276341 278958 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………………… 5.65 1.66 9.33 -7.08 1.13 2.79 2.65 4.43 5.16 3.38 5.18 2.89 7.56 3.84 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………… 5.86 5.07 6.80 2.21 1.09 1.37 -0.21 2.74 3.75 3.90 4.54 4.15 4.74 4.85 | 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT 2012:2 2012:3 2012:4 2013:1 January 2015 APPENDIX B 48 Table 4: Tennessee Personal Income Components, Seasonally Adjusted Annual Rates (millions of current dollars) Table 5: Tennessee Nonfarm Employment by Sector, Not Seasonally Adjusted (thousands of jobs) January 2016 Historical Data 2012:3 2012:4 2013:1 2013:2 2013:3 2013:4 2014:1 2014:2 2014:3 2014:4 2015:1 2015:2 2015:3 2015:4 2012 Annual 2013 2014 TOTAL NONFARM……………………………………………… 2712.2 2760.4 2711.9 2756.0 2753.6 2813.7 2765.8 2810.3 2815.6 2870.1 2822.1 2866.2 2869.0 2927.8 2715.0 2758.8 2815.4 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr......................................... 1.68 1.87 1.50 1.49 1.53 1.93 1.99 1.97 2.25 2.00 2.04 1.99 1.90 2.01 2.01 1.61 2.05 NATURAL RESOURCES, MINING & CONSTRUCTION…111.3 109.2 103.6 108.3 110.1 109.5 105.0 111.0 113.2 114.9 110.5 115.2 115.7 117.1 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr......................................... -1.62 -2.85 -1.96 -0.91 -1.08 0.21 1.42 2.43 2.78 4.96 5.24 3.84 2.21 1.91 108.9 107.9 111.0 0.19 -0.93 2.92 MANUFACTURING……………………………………………315.6 316.6 315.7 317.4 318.8 321.8 321.8 323.3 326.0 329.8 330.1 330.6 331.6 333.8 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr......................................... 3.28 2.96 2.69 1.13 1.02 1.64 1.93 1.86 2.25 2.50 2.56 2.26 1.71 1.21 313.4 318.4 325.2 2.94 1.61 2.14 DURABLE GOODS…………………………………………196.1 196.8 196.6 197.9 199.2 201.7 203.0 204.0 205.7 209.5 210.1 211.4 211.8 213.4 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr......................................... 5.96 5.17 4.10 2.03 1.56 2.52 3.26 3.08 3.26 3.83 3.53 3.61 2.97 1.89 193.9 198.9 205.5 5.56 2.54 3.36 NONDURABLE GOODS………………………………… 119.5 119.8 119.2 119.4 119.7 120.1 118.9 119.2 120.3 120.4 119.9 119.2 119.8 120.4 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr......................................... -0.83 -0.47 0.45 -0.33 0.14 0.19 -0.25 -0.17 0.56 0.25 0.90 -0.06 -0.44 0.03 119.5 119.6 119.7 -1.04 0.11 0.10 TRADE, TRANSPORTATION, UTILITIES………………… 574.2 588.8 572.7 578.5 580.9 596.3 579.6 588.4 592.5 606.0 592.9 602.9 610.0 624.6 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr......................................... 1.86 2.00 1.40 1.04 1.17 1.27 1.21 1.71 2.00 1.63 2.29 2.47 2.95 3.07 575.1 582.1 591.6 2.05 1.22 1.64 WHOLESALE TRADE…………………………………… 120.9 121.5 120.5 121.9 122.3 122.6 121.6 123.1 123.8 124.6 124.2 125.8 127.8 130.1 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr......................................... 2.05 2.07 1.37 1.05 1.13 0.88 0.89 0.93 1.23 1.69 2.19 2.19 3.20 4.41 120.5 121.8 123.3 2.22 1.11 1.18 RETAIL TRADE…………………………………………… 311.1 321.1 308.7 312.1 313.9 325.1 313.9 319.0 320.2 328.8 319.3 326.6 328.4 337.3 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr......................................... 0.88 1.36 0.43 0.10 0.90 1.22 1.70 2.20 2.02 1.14 1.72 2.38 2.56 2.59 312.8 314.9 320.5 1.18 0.67 1.76 TRANSPORTATION & UTILITIES……………………… 142.1 146.2 143.5 144.5 144.7 148.7 144.2 146.4 148.5 152.6 149.4 150.6 153.8 157.2 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr......................................... 3.90 3.39 3.56 3.14 1.81 1.69 0.44 1.29 2.63 2.65 3.63 2.89 3.59 3.01 141.8 145.4 147.9 3.87 2.53 1.76 INFORMATION……………………………………………… 42.7 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr......................................... -2.22 43.5 0.85 43.8 1.94 44.3 1.45 44.0 3.13 44.2 1.45 43.7 -0.15 43.8 -1.13 43.8 -0.53 44.4 0.60 44.2 1.07 43.8 -0.08 42.9 -2.06 42.5 -4.35 43.2 -1.26 44.1 1.99 43.9 -0.30 137.1 138.1 141.4 0.42 0.73 2.41 PROFESSIONAL & BUSINESS SERVICES……………… 339.3 349.3 340.7 348.7 352.4 371.1 359.9 370.4 374.3 385.1 371.7 380.7 382.8 396.4 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr......................................... 4.41 4.10 4.06 3.23 3.86 6.24 5.62 6.22 6.22 3.77 3.28 2.80 2.28 2.93 338.5 353.2 372.4 4.85 4.37 5.43 EDUCATION & HEALTH SERVICES……………………… 393.2 399.5 397.8 398.0 395.7 402.4 399.8 400.4 401.3 409.7 407.6 408.7 406.6 416.5 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr......................................... 2.25 2.27 1.87 1.54 0.65 0.73 0.51 0.62 1.42 1.81 1.95 2.06 1.30 1.68 393.8 398.5 402.8 2.47 1.19 1.09 LEISURE & HOSPITALITY………………………………… 283.9 277.5 270.8 291.8 294.6 286.5 280.0 302.5 306.1 296.7 287.6 312.0 316.7 307.5 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr......................................... 2.92 3.51 3.10 3.02 3.76 3.22 3.41 3.66 3.91 3.57 2.73 3.15 3.44 3.63 276.8 285.9 296.3 3.44 3.28 3.64 OTHER SERVICES………………………………………… 105.0 104.0 103.8 106.7 106.5 105.3 105.0 107.1 106.3 105.1 103.8 105.8 105.4 104.2 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr......................................... 1.97 1.79 0.97 1.52 1.40 1.25 1.16 0.31 -0.19 -0.19 -1.11 -1.18 -0.85 -0.86 104.2 105.6 105.9 2.15 1.29 0.27 GOVERNMENT……………………………………………… 409.8 434.7 427.0 424.6 411.5 437.0 431.6 422.2 409.5 435.7 431.7 422.5 412.0 437.2 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr......................................... -1.39 -0.18 -0.91 0.94 0.42 0.53 1.07 -0.56 -0.50 -0.29 0.02 0.06 0.62 0.34 424.0 425.0 424.8 -0.87 0.24 -0.07 50.2 -0.72 49.6 -0.93 49.6 -1.06 49.3 -1.46 49.2 -1.99 48.9 -1.48 49.1 -1.08 47.2 -4.26 47.4 -3.79 47.4 -3.14 47.6 -2.92 47.6 0.71 47.8 0.84 | Center for Business and Economic Research, University of Tennessee 49.5 -1.36 48.1 -2.65 373.9 375.6 376.6 -0.88 0.45 0.27 Tennessee Econometric Model 49 APPENDIX B STATE & LOCAL………………………………………… 359.7 384.5 377.4 375.0 362.2 387.8 382.7 373.2 362.2 388.4 384.3 374.9 364.4 389.4 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr......................................... -1.46 -0.11 -0.91 1.21 0.69 0.86 1.40 -0.49 0.01 0.15 0.43 0.46 0.61 0.27 50.1 -0.81 | FEDERAL, CIVILIAN……………………………………… 50.1 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr......................................... -0.86 Historical Data 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT FINANCIAL ACTIVITIES…………………………………… 137.2 137.1 136.0 137.7 139.0 139.7 139.3 141.3 142.6 142.6 142.0 144.0 145.4 147.9 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr......................................... -0.10 -0.24 -0.54 0.27 1.34 1.85 2.43 2.61 2.54 2.08 1.91 1.91 1.99 3.74 January 2016 | Historical Data 2012:3 2012:4 2013:1 2013:2 2013:3 2013:4 2014:1 2014:2 2014:3 2014:4 2015:1 2015:2 2015:3 2015:4 Annual 2013 2014 196.8 5.17 196.6 4.10 197.9 2.03 199.2 1.56 201.7 2.52 203.0 3.26 204.0 3.08 205.7 3.26 209.5 3.83 210.1 3.53 211.4 3.61 211.8 2.97 213.4 1.89 193.9 5.56 198.9 2.54 205.5 3.36 WOOD PRODUCTS……………………………… 11.3 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 2.74 11.0 0.91 10.7 -0.62 10.8 -2.11 10.9 -3.25 11.0 -0.30 11.0 2.49 11.1 2.77 11.4 4.59 11.4 3.94 11.3 3.34 11.6 4.19 11.8 3.22 11.8 2.92 11.0 2.24 10.9 -1.59 11.2 3.45 NONMETALLIC MINERAL PRODUCTS……… % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 12.7 5.83 12.6 4.70 12.4 2.48 12.2 -2.14 12.1 -4.99 11.9 -5.80 11.8 -5.11 11.9 -2.19 12.0 -0.28 11.9 0.00 11.7 -0.85 11.7 -1.68 11.7 -2.49 11.7 -1.68 12.5 5.80 12.1 -2.67 11.9 -1.92 PRIMARY METALS………….…………………… 9.8 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 6.52 9.8 3.90 9.9 5.69 9.9 2.41 10.0 1.70 10.1 3.07 10.0 1.01 10.0 1.01 10.1 1.34 10.1 0.66 10.2 2.00 10.2 1.99 10.2 1.32 10.4 2.30 9.7 4.89 10.0 3.19 10.1 1.00 FABRICATED METAL PRODUCTS…………… % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 34.6 2.57 34.3 0.78 33.8 -1.65 33.9 -2.31 33.9 -2.02 34.0 -0.68 34.1 0.79 34.4 1.47 34.4 1.38 34.6 1.76 35.3 3.52 35.1 2.13 35.1 2.13 35.1 1.35 34.5 2.68 33.9 -1.67 34.4 1.35 MACHINERY……………………………………… 25.5 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 1.46 25.2 2.30 25.7 1.18 25.7 -1.40 25.2 -1.18 24.9 -1.32 25.4 -1.04 25.4 -1.17 25.6 1.72 26.4 6.30 26.4 3.67 26.7 5.11 26.2 2.21 25.7 -2.90 25.5 1.66 25.4 -0.69 25.7 1.41 COMPUTER & ELECTRONIC PRODUCTS…… 5.5 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… -2.35 5.3 -9.60 5.3 -8.62 5.3 -9.66 5.2 -6.02 5.1 -4.38 5.0 -5.03 5.1 -4.40 5.0 -3.21 5.0 -1.96 5.0 -0.66 5.1 0.00 5.1 1.99 5.2 3.33 5.6 0.60 5.2 -7.25 5.0 -3.67 18.0 0.94 18.1 1.87 17.8 0.38 18.3 2.23 18.9 5.19 19.2 6.07 19.5 9.16 19.0 3.83 19.5 3.17 19.6 2.08 19.7 1.37 19.8 4.04 20.0 2.39 20.1 2.55 17.9 1.65 18.6 3.48 19.4 4.49 TRANSPORTATION EQUIPMENT…………… 55.1 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 18.49 57.2 17.93 57.8 16.36 58.3 11.19 59.8 8.47 62.2 8.62 62.8 8.53 63.3 8.63 63.7 6.58 66.2 6.54 66.5 5.89 66.9 5.58 67.4 5.76 69.1 4.38 53.6 17.02 59.5 11.00 64.0 7.55 FURNITURE……………………………………… 8.8 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… -0.38 8.4 -2.69 8.6 0.00 8.8 -0.38 8.7 -1.14 8.9 5.93 9.1 5.43 9.1 3.02 9.0 3.83 9.1 1.87 9.2 1.10 9.2 1.10 9.2 1.85 9.2 1.47 8.7 -2.89 8.8 1.06 9.1 3.52 MISCELLANEOUS DURABLE GOODS……… % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 14.7 -2.86 14.5 -3.12 14.6 -2.01 14.6 -1.79 14.4 -2.04 14.4 -0.69 14.6 0.00 14.9 2.05 15.0 3.70 14.9 3.70 15.1 3.20 15.1 1.34 15.2 1.34 14.9 -2.30 14.5 -2.24 14.7 1.26 ELECTRICAL EQUIPMENT, APPLIANCES & COMPONENTS…………..………………… % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 14.9 -2.62 Center for Business and Economic Research, University of Tennessee Tennessee Econometric Model Historical Data TOTAL DURABLE GOODS………………………… 196.1 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 5.96 | 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT 2012 APPENDIX B 50 Table 6: Tennessee Durable Goods Manufacturing Employment, Not Seasonally Adjusted (thousands of jobs) Table 7: Tennessee Nondurable Goods Manufacturing Employment, Not Seasonally Adjusted (thousands of jobs) January 2016 Historical Data 2012:3 2012:4 2013:1 2013:2 2013:3 2013:4 2014:1 2014:2 2014:3 2014:4 2015:1 2015:2 2015:3 2015:4 TOTAL NONDURABLE GOODS…………………… 119.5 119.8 119.2 119.4 119.7 120.1 118.9 119.2 120.3 120.4 119.9 119.2 119.8 120.4 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………… -0.83 -0.47 0.45 -0.33 0.14 0.19 -0.25 -0.17 0.56 0.25 0.90 -0.06 -0.44 0.03 2012 Annual 2013 2014 119.5 119.6 119.7 -1.04 0.11 0.10 FOOD……………………………………………… 33.0 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………… -0.80 32.7 -2.29 32.1 -3.50 32.2 -2.72 32.5 -1.52 32.8 0.20 32.5 1.04 32.4 0.62 32.9 1.23 33.1 0.92 32.8 0.92 32.6 0.62 33.0 0.41 33.1 0.20 33.0 -0.25 32.4 -1.89 32.7 0.95 BEVERAGE & TOBACCO………………………… 5.2 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………… 1.97 5.3 3.27 5.3 3.27 5.3 2.58 5.3 3.23 5.3 1.27 5.3 1.27 5.4 2.52 5.5 2.50 5.4 1.25 5.4 1.25 5.4 0.00 5.5 0.00 5.5 1.85 5.2 3.50 5.3 2.58 5.4 1.88 TEXTILE MILLS, TEXTILE MILL PRODUCTS & APPAREL……………………… 10.7 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………… -0.92 10.7 -0.62 10.4 -1.26 10.4 -2.80 10.5 -1.86 10.5 -1.87 10.2 -2.24 10.0 -4.47 10.0 -5.38 9.8 -6.05 9.6 -5.88 9.6 -4.01 9.6 -3.68 9.6 -2.71 10.7 -0.08 10.5 -1.95 10.0 -4.54 PAPER……………………………………………… 14.9 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………… -3.88 14.7 -2.00 14.7 1.15 14.8 -0.45 14.7 -0.90 14.6 -0.45 14.4 -1.59 14.6 -0.90 14.8 0.68 14.6 -0.23 14.2 -1.39 14.3 -2.51 14.4 14.3 -2.92 -2.059 14.7 -3.76 14.7 -0.17 14.6 -0.51 PRINTING & RELATED SUPPORT……………… 9.6 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………… -2.04 9.6 -1.70 9.6 0.35 9.7 0.35 9.6 -0.35 9.6 0.00 9.5 -0.69 9.5 -1.72 9.4 -1.74 9.4 -2.77 9.2 -3.50 9.1 -4.56 9.0 8.9 -4.61 -4.626 9.6 -3.43 9.6 0.09 9.4 -1.73 CHEMICALS……………………………………… 24.4 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………… -1.08 24.5 -0.14 24.6 1.23 24.6 1.23 24.9 1.91 25.1 2.31 25.2 2.30 25.3 2.71 25.5 2.41 25.4 1.06 25.3 0.40 25.1 -0.79 25.3 25.3 -0.79 -0.394 24.4 -0.68 24.8 1.67 25.3 2.12 PLASTICS & RUBBER…………………………… 19.9 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………… 0.67 20.3 0.83 20.4 4.43 20.3 0.83 20.0 0.50 20.0 -1.48 20.2 -1.31 20.4 0.49 20.9 4.67 21.1 5.84 21.2 5.29 21.0 3.10 21.3 21.5 1.59 1.735 20.0 -2.44 20.2 1.04 20.7 2.40 MISCELLANEOUS NONDURABLE GOODS…… 1.9 2.1 2.0 2.1 2.2 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………… 12.00 26.00 17.31 12.50 16.07 Center for Business and Economic Research, University of Tennessee 2.2 1.6 1.6 1.4 1.6 2.2 2.1 1.8 2.2 4.76 -22.95 -25.40 -35.38 -25.76 42.55 31.91 30.95 36.73 1.9 2.1 1.5 14.65 12.33 -27.45 Tennessee Econometric Model Historical Data | | 51 APPENDIX B 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT APPENDIX B | | Historical Data Annual Historical Data 2012:3 2012:4 2013:1 2013:2 2013:3 2013:4 2014:1 2014:2 2014:3 2014:4 2015:1 2015:2 2015:3 2015:4 2012 2013 2014 2012:3 2012:4 2013:1 2013:2 2013:3 2013:4 2014:1 2014:2 2014:3 2014:4 201 TOTAL NONFARM………………………………… 2718.7 2729.7 2739.7 2752.1 2761.6 2781.4 2790.6 2806.4 2824.2 2843.3 2846.9 2861.0 2874.8 2900.1 2715.3 2758.7 2816.1 2781.4 1.60 2790.6 2.08 2806.4 2824.2 2843.3 284 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………… 0.86 1.62 1.48 1.82 TOTAL 1.38 NONFARM………………………………… 2.91 1.32 2.29 2.55 2.732718.7 0.522729.7 1.992739.7 1.942752.1 3.572761.62.00 Qtr SAAR………..…………… 2.55 2.73 0 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr………………… 1.75 1.73 1.48 1.44 1.58 % Chg 1.90Prev 1.86 1.97 2.27 2.22 0.86 2.02 1.62 1.94 1.48 1.79 1.82 2.00 1.382.002.91 1.601.32 2.082.29 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr………………… 1.75 1.73 1.48 1.44 1.58 1.90 1.86 1.97 2.27 2.22 2 NATURAL RESOURCES, MINING NATURAL RESOURCES, MINING AND CONSTRUCTION……………………… 108.50 107.77 107.90 107.77 107.50 108.17 109.33 110.27 110.57 113.57 115 114.33 112.87 115.73 108.92 107.83 110.93 AND CONSTRUCTION……………………… 108.17-0.99 109.33 2.87 110.27 110.57 113.57 1 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………… -2.42 -2.68 0.50 -0.49 -0.99 2.50 4.38 3.46 1.09 11.30108.50 5.14107.77 -2.30107.90 -5.03107.77 10.55107.500.17 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………… -2.42 1.09 11.30 5 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr………………… -1.72 -2.74 -2.12 -1.28 -0.92 0.37 1.33 2.32 2.85 4.99 5.18 -2.68 3.69 0.50 2.08 -0.49 1.91 -0.990.172.50-0.994.38 2.873.46 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr………………… -1.72 -2.74 -2.12 -1.28 -0.92 0.37 1.33 2.32 2.85 4.99 5 MANUFACTURING……………………………… 315.0 315.8 316.9 317.4 318.5 320.9 322.9 323.4 325.8 328.9 331.0 330.8 331.5 332.7 313.4 318.4 325.2 MANUFACTURING……………………………… 315.0 315.8 316.9 317.4 318.5 320.9 322.9 323.4 325.8 328.9 33 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………… 1.55 1.02 1.39 0.58 1.40 3.09 2.45 0.66 2.98 3.81 2.68 -0.30 0.81 1.53 2.94 1.61 2.13 Qtr SAAR………..…………… 2.98 3.81 2 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr………………… 3.35 2.95 2.63 1.13 1.10 % Chg 1.61Prev 1.87 1.90 2.29 2.47 1.55 2.53 1.02 2.28 1.39 1.74 0.58 1.17 1.402.943.09 1.612.45 2.130.66 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr………………… 3.35 2.95 2.63 1.13 1.10 1.61 1.87 1.90 2.29 2.47 2 DURABLE GOODS…………………………… 195.8 196.5 197.2 197.9 199.0 201.3 203.5 204.0 205.7 209.0 210.6 211.4 211.9 212.8 193.9 198.9 205.5 DURABLE GOODS…………………………… 195.8 196.5 197.2 197.9 199.0 201.3 203.5 204.0 205.7 209.0 21 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………… 3.89 1.33 1.46 1.39 2.44 4.68 4.35 0.97 3.41 6.49 3.22 1.45 0.92 1.86 5.55 2.54 3.36 Qtr SAAR………..…………… 3.41 6.49 3 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr………………… 6.05 5.15 4.05 2.01 1.65 % Chg 2.48Prev 3.21 3.10 3.34 3.79 3.89 3.50 1.33 3.63 1.46 3.00 1.39 1.86 2.445.554.68 2.544.35 3.360.97 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr………………… 6.05 5.15 4.05 2.01 1.65 2.48 3.21 3.10 3.34 3.79 3 NONDURABLE GOODS…………………… 119.2 119.4 119.8 119.5 119.5 119.6 119.4 119.4 120.1 119.9 120.4 119.4 119.6 119.9 119.5 119.6 119.7 NONDURABLE GOODS…………………… 119.2 119.4 119.8 119.5 119.5 119.6 119.4 119.4 120.1 119.9 12 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………… -2.16 0.52 1.26 -0.74 -0.30 0.47 -0.69 0.15 2.24 -0.66 1.75 -3.30 0.61 0.95 -1.04 0.11 0.09 Qtr SAAR………..…………… 2.24 -0.66 1 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr………………… -0.79 -0.48 0.38 -0.29 0.18 % Chg 0.17Prev-0.32 -0.10 0.54 0.25 -2.16 0.86 0.52 -0.02 1.26 -0.42 -0.74 -0.02 -0.30-1.040.47 0.11-0.69 0.090.15 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr………………… -0.79 -0.48 0.38 -0.29 0.18 0.17 -0.32 -0.10 0.54 0.25 0 TRADE, TRANSPORTATION, UTILITIES…… 575.4 578.6 580.2 580.4 582.2 585.7 586.5 590.3 594.0 597.6 600.0 603.1 610.9 615.9 575.1 582.1 592.1 TRADE, TRANSPORTATION, UTILITIES…… 575.4 578.6 580.2 580.4 582.2 585.7 586.5 590.3 594.0 597.6 60 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………… 0.86 2.27 1.11 0.09 1.29 2.40 0.55 2.64 2.51 2.47 1.59 2.08 5.27 3.34 2.05 1.22 1.71 Qtr SAAR………..…………… 2.51 2.47 1 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr………………… 1.91 1.84 1.40 1.08 1.19 % Chg 1.22Prev 1.08 1.72 2.02 2.04 0.86 2.30 2.27 2.16 1.11 2.85 0.09 3.06 1.292.052.40 1.220.55 1.712.64 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr………………… 1.91 1.84 1.40 1.08 1.19 1.22 1.08 1.72 2.02 2.04 2 WHOLESALE TRADE……………………… 120.7 121.2 121.3 121.6 122.1 122.2 122.4 122.8 123.6 124.4 125.1 125.6 127.3 129.9 120.5 121.8 123.3 WHOLESALE TRADE……………………… 120.7 121.2 121.3 121.6 122.1 122.2 122.4 122.8 123.6 124.4 12 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………… 1.00 1.56 0.44 0.99 1.54 0.44 0.66 1.09 2.74 2.72 2.27 1.39 5.75 8.42 2.21 1.09 1.22 Qtr SAAR………..…………… 2.74 2.72 2 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr………………… 2.11 1.99 1.36 1.00 1.13 % Chg 0.85Prev 0.91 0.93 1.23 1.80 1.00 2.21 1.56 2.28 0.44 3.02 0.99 4.42 1.542.210.44 1.090.66 1.221.09 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr………………… 2.11 1.99 1.36 1.00 1.13 0.85 0.91 0.93 1.23 1.80 2 RETAIL TRADE……………………………… 312.6 313.7 313.7 313.4 315.4 317.3 318.2 320.4 321.9 322.9 324.2 326.7 329.3 331.1 312.8 315.0 320.8 RETAIL TRADE……………………………… 312.6 313.7 313.7 313.4 315.4 317.3 318.2 320.4 321.9 322.9 32 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………… -0.34 1.42 0.00 -0.30 2.58 2.39 1.14 2.75 1.89 1.25 1.70 3.08 3.22 2.25 1.18 0.68 1.86 Qtr SAAR………..…………… 1.89 1.25 1 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr………………… 0.94 1.08 0.45 0.19 0.92 % Chg 1.16Prev 1.45 2.21 2.04 1.75 -0.34 1.90 1.42 1.98 0.00 2.31 -0.30 2.56 2.581.182.39 0.681.14 1.862.75 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr………………… 0.94 1.08 0.45 0.19 0.92 1.16 1.45 2.21 2.04 1.75 1 TRANSPORTATION & UTILITIES………… 142.1 143.8 145.2 145.3 144.7 146.2 145.9 147.2 148.5 150.3 150.6 150.8 154.3 154.9 141.8 145.4 148.0 TRANSPORTATION UTILITIES………… 146.2 2.54 145.9 1.81 147.2 148.5 150.3 15 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………… 3.45 4.77 4.14 0.18 -1.64 4.12 -0.82 & 3.71 3.67 4.94 142.1 0.80 143.8 0.53 145.2 9.42 145.3 1.56 144.73.89 Qtr SAAR………..…………… 3.67 4.94 0 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr………………… 3.95 3.38 3.57 3.12 1.83 % Chg 1.67Prev 0.44 1.31 2.65 2.85 3.45 3.27 4.77 2.47 4.14 3.86 0.18 3.02 -1.643.894.12 2.54-0.82 1.813.71 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr………………… 3.95 3.38 3.57 3.12 1.83 1.67 0.44 1.31 2.65 2.85 3 INFORMATION………………………………… 42.8 43.3 43.9 44.3 44.2 43.9 43.7 43.7 43.9 44.3 44.1 43.7 43.2 42.4 43.2 44.1 43.9 INFORMATION………………………………… 43.9 44.3 4 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………… -6.28 4.43 5.66 3.38 -0.90 -2.10 -2.11 0.31 1.53 3.69 42.8 -1.50 43.3 -4.16 43.9 -3.91 44.3 -7.78 44.2-1.3543.9 2.0843.7-0.3643.7 Qtr SAAR………..…………… 1.53 3.69 -1 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr………………… -2.21 0.54 2.09 1.68 3.11 % Chg 1.46Prev-0.46 -1.20 -0.60 0.83 -6.28 0.99 4.43 -0.15 5.66 -1.52 3.38 -4.36 -0.90-1.35-2.10 2.08-2.11-0.360.31 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr………………… -2.21 0.54 2.09 1.68 3.11 1.46 -0.46 -1.20 -0.60 0.83 0 FINANCIAL ACTIVITIES……………………… 136.8 136.8 137.1 137.7 138.6 139.3 140.3 141.3 142.2 142.3 142.5 144.1 145.1 147.5 137.1 138.2 141.5 FINANCIAL 139.3 0.78 140.3 2.41 141.3 142.2 142.3 14 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………… -0.68 0.00 0.78 1.86 2.64 2.13ACTIVITIES……………………… 2.71 2.98 2.57 0.19 136.8 0.75 136.8 4.47 137.1 2.90 137.7 6.68 138.60.45 Qtr SAAR………..…………… 2.57 0.19 0 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr………………… -0.07 -0.32 -0.53 0.49 1.32 % Chg 1.85Prev 2.33 2.61 2.60 2.11 -0.68 1.62 0.00 1.98 0.78 2.06 1.86 3.68 2.640.452.13 0.782.71 2.412.98 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr………………… -0.07 -0.32 -0.53 0.49 1.32 1.85 2.33 2.61 2.60 2.11 1 (CONTINUED ON NEXT PAGE) (CONTINUED ON NEXT PAGE) Historical Data 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT 52 Table 8: Tennessee Nonfarm Employment by Sector, Seasonally Adjusted (thousands of jobs) January 2016 Table 8: Tennessee Nonfarm Employment by Sector, Seasonally Adjusted (thousands of jobs) Table 8: Tennessee Nonfarm Employment by Sector, Seasonally Adjusted (thousands of jobs) January 2016 Historical Data 2012:3 2012:4 2013:1 2013:2 2013:3 2013:4 2014:1 2014:2 2014:3 2014:4 2015:1 2015:2 2015:3 2015:4 2012 Annual 2013 2014 PROFESSIONAL & BUSINESS SERVICES… 340.7 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………… 2.38 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr………………… 4.47 342.1 1.65 3.82 346.4 5.12 4.05 348.6 2.49 2.90 353.9 6.26 3.86 363.3 11.06 6.19 364.6 1.48 5.25 370.4 6.48 6.26 376.0 6.15 6.24 379.5 3.81 4.46 376.0 -3.60 3.13 381.5 5.91 2.99 384.0 2.65 2.13 390.7 7.20 2.95 338.6 4.82 4.82 353.1 4.26 4.26 372.6 5.54 5.54 EDUCATION & HEALTH SERVICES………… 394.6 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………… 1.67 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr………………… 2.16 396.5 1.97 2.16 398.4 1.86 1.82 398.6 0.23 1.43 397.5 -1.10 0.73 399.2 1.76 0.68 400.0 0.77 0.41 401.1 1.10 0.63 403.3 2.21 1.46 406.1 2.77 1.71 408.1 2.05 2.03 409.2 1.08 2.03 409.0 -0.26 1.41 412.8 3.84 1.67 393.8 2.44 2.44 398.4 1.17 1.17 402.6 1.05 1.05 LEISURE & HOSPITALITY…………………… 276.5 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………… 0.48 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr………………… 2.89 279.9 4.96 3.26 282.7 4.06 3.04 284.5 2.52 2.99 287.1 3.75 3.82 288.9 2.48 3.20 291.6 3.89 3.16 295.0 4.65 3.69 298.5 4.83 3.96 299.5 1.39 3.68 299.0 -0.71 2.51 304.5 7.66 3.24 309.6 6.82 3.73 310.3 0.95 3.62 276.8 3.40 3.40 285.8 3.26 3.26 296.1 3.62 3.62 OTHER SERVICES……………………………… 104.5 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………… 1.03 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr………………… 2.12 104.6 0.26 1.92 104.8 0.77 1.03 105.7 3.61 1.41 105.9 0.76 1.34 106.0 0.13 1.31 106.1 0.50 1.24 106.0 -0.38 0.25 105.7 -1.00 -0.19 105.5 -1.01 -0.47 104.9 -2.26 -1.16 104.5 -1.27 -1.38 105.2 2.71 -0.47 104.6 -2.51 -0.85 104.3 2.21 2.21 105.6 1.27 1.27 105.8 0.21 0.21 GOVERNMENT………………………………… 423.8 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………… 0.70 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr………………… -0.99 424.2 0.38 -0.41 421.4 -2.61 -0.98 427.2 5.69 0.99 426.1 -1.03 0.56 426.0 -0.13 0.43 425.5 -0.44 0.99 424.9 -0.56 -0.54 424.2 -0.66 -0.45 426.1 1.77 0.02 426.2 0.13 0.16 425.3 -0.90 0.08 423.5 -1.68 -0.18 427.5 3.83 0.32 424.1 -0.86 -0.86 425.2 0.25 0.25 425.2 0.00 0.00 FEDERAL, CIVILIAN………………………… 50.7 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………… 7.43 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr………………… -0.78 50.4 -2.35 -0.07 49.6 -5.95 -0.67 49.3 -2.66 -1.00 49.9 5.52 -1.45 49.5 -3.69 -1.79 49.0 -3.72 -1.21 48.6 -3.49 -1.42 47.7 -6.69 -4.41 46.4 -10.97 -6.27 47.5 9.83 -3.13 48.4 7.80 -0.41 47.2 -9.56 -1.19 46.6 -4.45 0.58 50.2 -0.45 -0.45 49.6 -1.23 -1.23 47.9 -3.33 -3.33 STATE & LOCAL……………………………… 373.1 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………… -0.18 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr………………… -1.02 373.8 0.75 -0.45 371.8 -2.16 -1.02 378.0 6.84 1.26 376.2 -1.86 0.83 376.5 0.35 0.73 376.5 0.00 1.28 376.4 -0.18 -0.42 376.5 0.14 0.08 379.7 3.48 0.85 378.8 -1.01 0.59 376.9 -1.96 0.14 376.3 -0.64 -0.05 380.8 4.91 0.29 373.9 -0.91 -0.91 375.6 0.45 0.45 377.3 0.44 0.44 STATISTICAL DISCREPANCY (% )……… -0.01 -0.01 0.01 0.01 -0.01 0.00 0.01 0.01 0.00 -0.04 0.03 0.01 -0.01 -0.01 0.00 0.00 0.01 Center for Business and Economic Research, University of Tennessee Tennessee Econometric Model Historical Data | | 53 APPENDIX B 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT January 2016 | 2012 Annual 2013 2014 196.5 1.33 5.15 197.2 1.46 4.05 197.9 1.39 2.01 199.0 2.44 1.65 201.3 4.68 2.48 203.5 4.35 3.21 204.0 0.97 3.10 205.7 3.41 3.34 209.0 6.49 3.79 210.6 3.22 3.50 211.4 1.45 3.63 211.9 0.92 3.00 212.8 1.86 1.86 193.9 5.55 5.55 198.9 2.54 2.54 205.5 3.36 3.36 WOOD PRODUCTS……………………… 11.1 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..………… 1.77 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………… 2.88 11.0 -5.02 1.05 10.9 -3.40 -0.80 10.8 -1.85 -2.16 10.8 -2.26 -3.14 11.0 6.84 -0.25 11.1 7.11 2.36 11.1 -0.32 2.76 11.3 5.29 4.69 11.4 3.85 3.95 11.5 4.32 3.26 11.6 3.36 4.20 11.6 1.54 3.26 11.7 2.39 2.90 11.0 2.25 2.25 10.9 -1.59 -1.59 11.2 3.44 3.44 NONMETALLIC MINERALS……………… 12.6 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..………… 5.05 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………… 5.95 12.6 1.50 4.70 12.6 12.2 -2.12 -12.01 2.34 -2.11 12.0 -6.33 -4.87 11.9 -2.66 -5.86 11.9 0.69 -5.19 11.9 -0.09 -2.14 11.9 1.33 -0.19 11.9 -2.11 -0.06 11.8 -2.65 -0.90 11.7 -3.08 -1.64 11.6 -2.02 -2.47 11.7 0.98 -1.71 12.5 5.80 5.80 12.1 -2.66 -2.66 11.9 -1.94 -1.94 PRIMARY METALS………….…………… 9.8 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..………… 4.22 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………… 6.51 9.7 -3.10 4.06 9.9 8.31 5.65 9.9 0.28 2.34 10.0 1.54 1.67 10.0 2.80 3.19 10.0 -0.82 0.94 10.0 0.52 1.00 10.1 2.99 1.36 10.1 -0.02 0.66 10.2 4.49 1.98 10.2 0.64 2.01 10.2 0.18 1.31 10.3 4.01 2.31 9.7 4.88 4.88 10.0 3.19 3.19 10.1 0.99 0.99 FABRICATED METALS………………….. 34.6 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..………… -1.00 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………… 2.63 34.3 -3.67 0.88 33.9 -4.19 -1.69 33.8 -0.60 -2.38 33.9 0.73 -1.96 34.0 1.54 -0.66 34.1 1.41 0.76 34.3 1.98 1.41 34.4 0.89 1.45 34.6 2.79 1.76 35.3 8.43 3.48 35.0 -3.24 2.13 35.1 0.99 2.16 35.1 -0.41 1.35 34.5 2.66 2.66 33.9 -1.67 -1.67 34.4 1.35 1.35 MACHINERY………………………………… 25.6 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..………… -3.63 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………… 1.53 25.6 -0.12 2.37 25.5 -0.38 1.08 25.4 -1.47 -1.41 25.3 -2.37 -1.09 25.2 -1.19 -1.35 25.2 0.58 -1.12 25.2 -1.41 -1.10 25.7 9.47 1.77 26.8 17.42 6.25 26.2 -9.04 3.62 26.5 4.67 5.18 26.3 -2.31 2.23 26.0 -4.64 -2.95 25.5 1.66 1.66 25.4 -0.70 -0.70 25.7 1.44 1.44 COMPUTERS & ELECTRONICS………… 5.5 5.3 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………-19.67 -12.78 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………… -2.40 -9.59 5.3 -3.24 -8.47 5.3 -2.26 -9.78 5.2 -5.71 -6.09 5.1 -6.00 -4.32 5.0 -5.71 -4.93 5.0 -0.34 -4.47 5.0 -0.97 -3.29 5.0 -0.40 -1.88 5.0 -0.81 -0.63 5.0 2.03 -0.05 5.1 7.23 1.96 5.2 5.23 3.37 5.6 0.58 0.58 5.2 -7.24 -7.24 5.0 -3.66 -3.66 ELECTRICAL EQUIPMENT, APPLIANCES & COMPONENTS…………..…………… 17.9 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..………… -2.13 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………… 0.96 18.0 3.41 1.90 17.9 -2.56 0.38 18.4 10.54 2.18 18.8 10.13 5.24 19.1 6.72 6.07 19.6 9.10 9.11 19.1 -9.34 3.84 19.4 7.55 3.22 19.5 1.87 2.03 19.8 6.37 1.39 19.9 0.52 4.04 19.9 0.95 2.40 20.0 2.43 2.54 17.9 1.65 1.65 18.6 3.47 3.47 19.4 4.49 4.49 TRANSPORTATION EQUIPMENT……… 55.2 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..………… 19.55 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………… 18.62 56.7 11.71 17.78 57.9 8.94 16.37 58.6 4.97 11.17 59.9 8.90 8.60 61.6 11.44 8.54 62.9 8.71 8.48 63.7 5.58 8.64 63.9 1.34 6.70 65.5 10.40 6.45 66.5 6.39 5.88 67.3 4.41 5.59 67.6 2.18 5.80 68.4 4.45 4.35 53.6 17.03 17.03 59.5 11.02 11.02 64.0 7.55 7.55 FURNITURE………………………………… 8.8 8.5 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..………… -1.57 -12.40 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………… -0.08 -2.69 8.6 6.21 -0.07 8.8 6.82 -0.55 8.7 -3.03 -0.92 9.0 14.40 5.92 9.1 3.87 5.33 9.0 -2.49 2.96 9.0 1.07 4.03 9.2 4.77 1.77 9.2 1.14 1.09 9.1 -2.60 1.06 9.2 4.64 1.94 9.3 2.60 1.41 8.7 -2.92 -2.92 8.8 1.06 1.06 9.1 3.50 3.50 MISCELLANEOUS DURABLES………… 14.8 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..………… -2.20 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………… -2.68 14.6 -3.38 -3.12 14.6 -0.25 -1.98 14.5 -1.68 -1.85 14.4 -2.79 -2.03 14.5 2.15 -0.66 14.6 2.45 0.01 14.8 6.53 2.03 15.0 3.67 3.69 15.0 2.29 3.72 15.1 0.46 3.21 15.0 -1.09 1.32 15.2 3.79 1.34 14.9 -2.30 -2.30 14.5 -2.25 -2.25 14.7 1.26 1.26 14.7 -2.07 -2.81 Center for Business and Economic Research, University of Tennessee Tennessee Econometric Model Historical Data TOTAL DURABLE GOODS…………………… 195.8 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..………… 3.89 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………… 6.05 | 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT Historical Data 2012:3 2012:4 2013:1 2013:2 2013:3 2013:4 2014:1 2014:2 2014:3 2014:4 2015:1 2015:2 2015:3 2015:4 APPENDIX B 54 Table 9: Tennessee Durable Goods Manufacturing Employment, Seasonally Adjusted (thousands of jobs) Table 10: Tennessee Nondurable Goods Manufacturing Employment, Seasonally Adjusted (thousands of jobs) January 2016 Historical Data 2012:3 2012:4 2013:1 2013:2 2013:3 2013:4 2014:1 2014:2 2014:3 2014:4 2015:1 2015:2 2015:3 2015:4 2012 Annual 2013 2014 119.4 0.52 -0.48 119.8 1.26 0.38 119.5 -0.74 -0.29 119.5 -0.30 0.18 119.6 0.47 0.17 119.4 -0.69 -0.32 119.4 0.15 -0.10 120.1 2.24 0.54 119.9 -0.66 0.25 120.4 1.75 0.86 119.4 -3.30 -0.02 119.6 0.61 -0.42 119.9 0.95 -0.02 119.5 -1.04 -1.04 119.6 0.11 0.11 119.7 0.09 0.09 FOOD……………………………………………… 32.9 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………… -4.74 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… -0.83 32.5 -4.87 -2.27 32.3 -2.84 -3.53 32.4 1.86 -2.69 32.4 -0.14 -1.53 32.5 1.98 0.19 32.6 0.46 1.03 32.6 0.34 0.66 32.8 2.06 1.21 32.8 0.78 0.91 32.9 0.57 0.94 32.8 -0.90 0.62 32.9 1.18 0.40 32.9 -0.09 0.19 33.0 -0.24 -0.24 32.4 -1.90 -1.90 32.7 0.95 0.95 BEVERAGE & TOBACCO……………………… 5.1 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………… -2.27 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 2.03 5.3 10.49 3.20 5.3 2.28 3.30 5.3 0.02 2.52 5.3 0.73 3.30 5.3 2.01 1.26 5.4 2.30 1.26 5.4 4.87 2.47 5.4 0.99 2.53 5.4 -2.88 1.28 5.4 2.10 1.23 5.4 -0.29 -0.04 5.4 1.25 0.03 5.5 4.48 1.87 5.2 3.51 3.51 5.3 2.59 2.59 5.4 1.89 1.89 TEXTILE MILLS, TEXTILE MILL PRODUCTS & APPAREL…………………… 10.6 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………… -3.21 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… -0.87 10.6 -1.12 -0.65 10.6 -2.01 -1.38 10.4 -4.46 -2.71 10.5 0.54 -1.78 10.4 -1.76 -1.94 10.3 10.0 -3.62 -12.11 -2.34 -4.36 9.9 -3.49 -5.33 9.8 -4.94 -6.11 9.7 -2.96 -5.95 9.6 -4.36 -3.94 9.5 -2.36 -3.66 9.5 -1.35 -2.76 10.7 -0.07 -0.07 10.5 -1.96 -1.96 10.0 -4.53 -4.53 PAPER…………………………………………… 14.7 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………… -3.80 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… -3.83 14.6 -1.02 -1.94 14.9 6.54 1.05 14.8 -3.29 -0.48 14.6 -5.17 -0.83 14.6 0.71 -0.40 14.6 1.13 -1.69 14.6 -0.17 -0.91 14.7 1.29 0.74 14.6 -3.04 -0.21 14.4 -3.79 -1.45 14.3 -4.36 -2.50 14.2 -0.30 -2.89 14.3 0.24 -2.07 14.7 -3.76 -3.76 14.7 -0.17 -0.17 14.6 -0.53 -0.53 PRINTING & RELATED SUPPORT…………… 9.6 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………… 1.04 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… -2.01 9.6 -1.06 -1.68 9.6 2.19 0.23 9.6 -0.36 0.45 9.6 -2.09 -0.34 9.6 0.33 0.01 9.6 -1.11 -0.81 9.5 -3.59 -1.63 9.4 -2.49 -1.73 9.3 -3.90 -2.78 9.2 -4.23 -3.56 9.1 -7.37 -4.52 9.0 -2.85 -4.61 8.9 -4.00 -4.63 9.6 -3.45 -3.45 9.6 0.08 0.08 9.5 -1.73 -1.73 CHEMICALS……………………………………… 24.4 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………… -0.04 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… -1.10 24.5 1.98 -0.13 24.6 2.45 1.22 24.7 0.70 1.27 24.8 2.41 1.89 25.1 3.75 2.32 25.2 2.23 2.27 25.4 2.60 2.75 25.4 1.04 2.40 25.3 -1.58 1.06 25.3 -0.50 0.38 25.2 -2.01 -0.77 25.2 0.95 -0.79 25.2 -0.01 -0.40 24.4 -0.68 -0.68 24.8 1.68 1.68 25.3 2.12 2.12 PLASTICS & RUBBER………………………… 20.0 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………… -1.82 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 0.75 20.3 6.19 0.89 20.4 3.41 4.24 20.2 -3.61 0.96 20.1 -3.70 0.48 20.0 -1.81 -1.47 20.1 3.64 -1.41 20.4 4.75 0.66 21.0 12.28 4.60 21.1 2.93 5.83 21.2 1.29 5.23 21.0 -2.99 3.23 21.3 5.00 1.52 21.5 3.86 1.75 20.0 -2.45 -2.45 20.2 1.03 1.03 20.7 2.39 2.39 MISCELLANEOUS NONDURABLE GOODS… 1.9 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………… 18.23 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 13.22 2.0 23.04 24.21 2.1 5.63 17.47 2.1 4.87 12.67 2.3 2.1 1.6 1.6 1.5 1.5 40.57 -26.92 -67.39 -6.11 -18.82 16.47 17.65 3.28 -23.01 -25.11 -34.72 -26.65 2.3 2.1 1.9 366.98 -30.68 -20.70 42.69 32.27 31.50 2.1 32.68 35.85 1.9 14.54 14.54 Center for Business and Economic Research, University of Tennessee 2.1 1.5 12.53 -27.54 12.53 -27.54 Tennessee Econometric Model Historical Data | | 55 APPENDIX B 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT TOTAL NONDURABLE GOODS………………… 119.2 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………… -2.16 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… -0.79 January 2016 | Annual 2012 2013 2014 41975 41476 41973 1.57 -1.19 1.20 NATURAL RESOURCES, MINING AND CONSTRUCTION……………………… 45180 44064 45129 47622 45052 44612 45684 48760 46969 46199 46897 49386 49672 49815 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr………………… -2.06 -1.26 4.46 -3.83 -0.28 1.24 1.23 2.39 4.26 3.56 2.65 1.28 5.75 7.83 45973 45742 47206 1.02 -0.50 3.20 MANUFACTURING…………………………… 53288 50255 51676 51249 50615 50846 50852 51414 51486 51268 52252 50170 52689 53229 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr………………… 6.22 -1.59 4.19 -0.43 -5.02 1.18 -1.59 0.32 1.72 0.83 2.75 -2.42 2.34 3.83 51672 50890 51605 1.83 -1.51 1.40 DURABLE GOODS………………………… 53801 49322 50848 49959 49263 49277 49527 49931 50474 50221 51352 49136 51051 51364 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr………………… 10.13 -1.00 3.76 -2.19 -8.43 -0.09 -2.60 -0.06 2.46 1.92 3.68 -1.59 1.14 2.27 51262 49507 50494 3.20 -3.43 2.00 NONDURABLE GOODS…………………… 52457 51785 53036 53378 52854 53456 53079 53945 53217 53056 53820 51982 55594 56527 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr………………… 0.59 -2.26 4.98 2.48 0.76 3.23 0.08 1.06 0.69 -0.75 1.40 -3.64 4.47 6.54 52342 53192 53509 -0.06 1.62 0.60 TRADE, TRANSPORTATION, UTILITIES… 38979 38487 38469 38416 38602 38370 37510 38925 38262 38506 39298 38999 39131 39138 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr………………… 1.13 -0.55 2.13 -1.89 -0.97 -0.30 -2.49 1.32 -0.88 0.35 4.77 0.19 2.27 1.64 38773 38224 38748 0.64 -1.41 1.37 WHOLESALE TRADE………………………58391 56984 61541 57278 58056 57634 57843 59347 58168 58938 60235 58850 59725 59131 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr………………… 1.80 -0.36 8.62 -1.73 -0.57 1.14 -6.01 3.61 0.19 2.26 4.14 -0.84 2.68 0.33 58800 57703 59172 2.48 -1.87 2.55 RETAIL TRADE………………………………27109 26636 25778 26518 26245 26376 25418 26546 26099 26255 27142 26461 26647 26986 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr………………… 1.82 -2.75 -2.54 -3.17 -3.19 -0.98 -1.40 0.11 -0.56 -0.46 6.79 -0.32 2.10 2.78 26727 26139 26510 -0.75 -2.20 1.42 TRANSPORTATION & UTILITIES…………48674 48688 47170 48170 48876 48108 47186 48659 48033 47892 48386 49287 49003 48479 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr………………… -1.22 1.07 0.75 -1.40 0.41 -1.19 0.03 1.01 -1.72 -0.45 2.54 1.29 2.02 1.23 48347 48085 48242 -0.37 -0.54 0.33 INFORMATION………………………………… 54425 55449 55942 53905 54646 54905 52932 56947 56566 56597 53456 57018 56909 58773 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr………………… 0.37 2.96 3.66 -1.35 0.41 -0.98 -5.38 5.64 3.51 3.08 0.99 0.12 0.61 3.84 55114 54097 55891 1.74 -1.85 3.32 FINANCIAL ACTIVITIES……………………… 64773 62827 64496 61642 61501 61126 62205 63905 62700 62454 63963 63729 64660 64744 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr………………… 10.75 3.20 7.12 0.74 -5.05 -2.71 -3.55 3.67 1.95 2.17 2.83 -0.28 3.13 3.67 63321 61619 63255 5.06 -2.69 2.66 PROFESSIONAL & BUSINESS SERVICES 47123 48785 49331 49718 48661 48549 46718 48376 47781 47545 46934 51501 52018 50679 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr………………… 1.35 5.76 11.60 0.96 3.26 -0.48 -5.30 -2.70 -1.81 -2.07 0.46 6.46 8.87 6.59 48621 48412 47659 5.38 -0.43 -1.55 EDUCATION & HEALTH SERVICES……… 42605 42975 42811 42581 42666 42978 42012 42982 42771 43038 42373 43798 43759 44501 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr………………… -1.76 -0.72 1.52 -0.84 0.14 0.01 -1.87 0.94 0.25 0.14 0.86 1.90 2.31 3.40 42834 42559 42791 -0.14 -0.64 0.55 LEISURE & HOSPITALITY…………………… 19717 19672 20121 20342 19197 19245 19945 20544 19670 19619 20810 21199 21089 20653 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr………………… 2.08 -1.63 1.57 -4.95 -2.64 -2.17 -0.87 1.00 2.47 1.94 4.34 3.19 7.21 5.27 20227 19682 20161 1.14 -2.70 2.43 OTHER SERVICES…………………………… 38018 37130 37470 37187 36508 37294 37921 39219 37997 38525 39681 40082 40132 40532 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr………………… 4.39 0.85 0.97 -0.52 -3.97 0.44 1.21 5.46 4.08 3.30 4.64 2.20 5.62 5.21 37500 37228 38855 0.81 -0.73 4.37 GOVERNMENT…………………………………39061 40783 38079 38805 38941 39804 38108 38707 39794 41047 38350 38975 39702 40934 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr………………… -1.34 1.15 -0.50 0.63 -0.31 -2.40 0.07 -0.25 2.19 3.12 0.64 0.69 -0.23 -0.28 39121 38914 39475 -0.23 -0.53 1.44 FEDERAL, CIVILIAN……………………… 67383 66795 65888 65516 65431 64778 67683 69951 71162 72342 72587 74426 74425 75277 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr………………… -0.60 -1.14 -2.79 -3.69 -2.90 -3.02 2.72 6.77 8.76 11.68 7.25 6.40 4.59 4.06 67023 65852 71511 -1.35 -1.75 8.59 STATE & LOCAL…………………………… 35229 37162 34446 35292 35437 36403 34353 34715 35669 36967 34175 34606 35290 36451 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr………………… -1.54 1.67 0.16 1.75 0.59 -2.04 -0.27 -1.63 0.66 1.55 -0.52 -0.31 -1.06 -1.39 35381 35371 35381 0.05 -0.03 0.03 Center for Business and Economic Research, University of Tennessee Tennessee Econometric Model Historical Data TOTAL NONFARM………………………………… 41938 41847 41875 41917 41417 41569 41000 42227 41757 41951 41958 42800 43201 43357 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr………………… 1.72 0.67 3.60 -0.76 -1.24 -0.66 -2.09 0.74 0.82 0.92 2.34 1.36 3.46 3.35 | 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT Historical Data 2012:2 2012:3 2012:4 2013:1 2013:2 2013:3 2013:4 2014:1 2014:2 2014:3 2014:4 2015:1 2015:2 2015:3 APPENDIX B 56 Table 11: Tennessee Average Annual Wage and Salary Rate by Sector, Not Seasonally Adjusted (2009 dollars) Table 12: Tennessee Average Annual Wage and Salary Rate by Sector, Seasonally Adjusted (2009 dollars) Historical Data 2012:2 2012:3 2012:4 2013:1 2013:2 2013:3 2013:4 2014:1 2014:2 2014:3 2014:4 2015:1 2015:2 2015:3 January 2016 2012 Annual 2013 2014 45915 45734 47214 1.09 -0.39 3.24 1.09 -0.39 3.24 MANUFACTURING……………………………… 53296 50341 51782 51066 50623 50896 50965 51261 51478 51296 52377 50042 52672 53241 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………… 16.96 -20.40 11.95 -5.42 -3.42 2.17 0.55 2.34 1.71 -1.41 8.70 -16.67 22.74 4.39 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr………………… 6.24 -1.66 4.18 -0.36 -5.02 1.10 -1.58 0.38 1.69 0.79 2.77 -2.38 2.32 3.79 51667 50887 51603 1.83 -1.51 1.41 1.83 -1.51 1.41 DURABLE GOODS……………………………53820 49385 50928 49812 49294 49288 49624 49811 50501 50190 51470 49035 51073 51311 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………… 24.98 -29.11 13.10 -8.48 -4.10 -0.05 2.75 1.52 5.66 -2.44 10.59 -17.62 17.69 1.88 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr………………… 10.19 -1.09 3.77 -2.14 -8.41 -0.20 -2.56 0.00 2.45 1.83 3.72 -1.56 1.13 2.23 51259 49504 50493 3.21 -3.42 2.00 3.21 -3.42 2.00 NONDURABLE GOODS…………………… 52448 51912 53185 53130 52823 53577 53221 53733 53147 53191 53957 51806 55504 56665 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………… 5.10 -4.03 10.17 -0.41 -2.29 5.83 -2.63 3.91 -4.29 0.33 5.89 -15.02 31.76 8.63 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr………………… 0.55 -2.28 4.94 2.57 0.72 3.21 0.07 1.13 0.61 -0.72 1.38 -3.59 4.43 6.53 52336 53188 53507 -0.05 1.63 0.60 -0.05 1.63 0.60 TRADE, TRANSPORTATION, UTILITIES…… 38870 38405 39147 37918 38480 38282 38188 38469 38137 38411 39848 38539 39120 39083 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………… 2.29 -4.70 7.96 -11.98 6.07 -2.04 -0.98 2.97 -3.41 2.90 15.83 -12.50 6.17 -0.38 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr………………… 1.10 -0.60 2.29 -1.90 -1.00 -0.32 -2.45 1.45 -0.89 0.34 4.35 0.18 2.58 1.75 38768 38217 38716 0.65 -1.42 1.31 0.65 -1.42 1.31 WHOLESALE TRADE……………………… 58505 57078 61693 56885 58199 57728 58000 58927 58310 59033 60332 58427 59820 59333 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………… 4.40 -9.40 36.48 -27.72 9.57 -3.20 1.90 6.54 -4.12 5.05 9.10 -12.04 9.88 -3.22 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr………………… 1.80 -0.42 8.70 -1.72 -0.52 1.14 -5.99 3.59 0.19 2.26 4.02 -0.85 2.59 0.51 58788 57703 59151 2.50 -1.85 2.51 2.50 -1.85 2.51 RETAIL TRADE……………………………… 27020 26511 26391 26095 26133 26248 26040 26187 25985 26122 27638 26058 26636 26915 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………… 0.99 -7.32 -1.80 -4.42 0.59 1.77 -3.13 2.28 -3.05 2.13 25.32 -20.98 9.18 4.25 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr………………… 1.77 -2.81 -2.27 -3.19 -3.28 -0.99 -1.33 0.35 -0.57 -0.48 6.14 -0.49 2.51 3.04 26719 26129 26483 -0.77 -2.21 1.36 -0.77 -2.21 1.36 TRANSPORTATION & UTILITIES………… 48398 48700 47969 47606 48607 48108 47993 48091 47761 47881 49116 48883 48927 48343 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………… 0.94 2.52 -5.87 -2.99 8.68 -4.05 -0.95 0.82 -2.72 1.01 10.72 -1.88 0.36 -4.69 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr………………… -1.20 1.02 0.76 -1.40 0.43 -1.22 0.05 1.02 -1.74 -0.47 2.34 1.65 2.44 0.96 48338 48078 48212 -0.38 -0.54 0.28 -0.38 -0.54 0.28 INFORMATION………………………………… 54592 55233 56244 53741 54687 54698 53213 56947 56652 56425 53617 57061 57039 58274 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………… 0.26 4.78 7.53 -16.65 7.23 0.08 -10.42 31.16 -2.05 -1.59 -18.47 28.28 -0.15 8.95 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr………………… 0.52 2.95 3.97 -1.49 0.17 -0.97 -5.39 5.97 3.59 3.16 0.76 0.20 0.68 3.28 55156 54085 55910 1.83 -1.94 3.38 1.83 -1.94 3.38 FINANCIAL ACTIVITIES……………………… 64915 63010 64653 61178 61501 61317 62353 63479 62700 62615 64098 63490 64615 64863 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………… 30.56 -11.23 10.84 -19.83 2.13 -1.19 6.93 7.42 -4.82 -0.54 9.81 -3.74 7.28 1.54 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr………………… 10.54 3.18 7.20 0.74 -5.26 -2.69 -3.56 3.76 1.95 2.12 2.80 0.02 3.05 3.59 63326 61587 63223 5.04 -2.75 2.66 5.04 -2.75 2.66 (CONTINUED ON NEXT PAGE) | 57 APPENDIX B NATURAL RESOURCES, MINING AND CONSTRUCTION……………………… 45249 45214 45743 45709 45289 45705 46233 46842 47267 47299 47447 47468 50063 51066 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..……………-17.31 -0.31 4.76 -0.30 -3.63 3.73 4.70 5.37 3.68 0.27 1.26 0.17 23.73 8.26 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr………………… -1.85 -1.16 4.35 -3.67 0.09 1.08 1.07 2.48 4.37 3.49 2.63 1.34 5.91 7.96 | 41968 41473 41961 1.59 -1.18 1.18 1.59 -1.18 1.18 Historical Data 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT TOTAL NONFARM………………………………… 41978 41745 42345 41492 41477 41449 41474 41853 41816 41824 42351 42429 43281 43269 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………… 1.69 -2.20 5.87 -7.81 -0.15 -0.27 0.24 3.71 -0.36 0.07 5.14 0.73 8.28 -0.11 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr………………… 1.70 0.60 3.74 -0.74 -1.19 -0.71 -2.06 0.87 0.82 0.90 2.12 1.37 3.50 3.46 January 2016 | 2012 Annual 2013 2014 48591 48410 47621 5.46 -0.37 -1.63 5.46 -0.37 -1.63 EDUCATION & HEALTH SERVICES………… 42493 42819 43131 42517 42598 42787 42345 42960 42700 42829 42749 43741 43698 44240 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………… -3.37 3.10 2.95 -5.58 0.77 1.78 -4.07 5.94 -2.40 1.21 -0.74 9.61 -0.39 5.05 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr………………… -1.89 -0.64 1.62 -0.80 0.25 -0.08 -1.82 1.04 0.24 0.10 0.95 1.82 2.34 3.30 42826 42561 42809 -0.11 -0.62 0.58 -0.11 -0.62 0.58 LEISURE & HOSPITALITY…………………… 20219 20198 19950 19483 19692 19747 19780 19725 20170 20123 20616 20395 21606 21124 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………… -5.10 -0.41 -4.81 -9.05 4.35 1.14 0.65 -1.11 9.35 -0.94 10.16 -4.22 25.95 -8.63 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr………………… 1.97 -1.59 1.82 -4.89 -2.61 -2.23 -0.86 1.24 2.43 1.90 4.23 3.40 7.12 4.98 20213 19675 20158 1.16 -2.66 2.45 1.16 -2.66 2.45 OTHER SERVICES………………………………38334 37308 37267 36820 36853 37494 37695 38800 38379 38732 39555 39675 40619 40596 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………… 14.82 -10.28 -0.44 -4.71 0.36 7.13 2.16 12.25 -4.27 3.73 8.78 1.21 9.86 -0.22 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr………………… 4.36 0.71 0.85 -0.57 -3.86 0.50 1.15 5.38 4.14 3.30 4.94 2.25 5.84 4.81 37485 37216 38866 0.77 -0.72 4.44 0.77 -0.72 4.44 GOVERNMENT………………………………… 38842 39438 39025 39326 38701 38441 39092 39259 39541 39619 39217 39475 39444 39826 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………… -2.14 6.28 -4.13 3.13 -6.21 -2.66 6.95 1.72 2.91 0.79 -3.99 2.66 -0.32 3.93 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr………………… -1.31 0.74 -0.28 0.70 -0.36 -2.53 0.17 -0.17 2.17 3.06 0.32 0.55 -0.25 0.52 39090 38890 39409 -0.26 -0.51 1.33 -0.26 -0.51 1.33 FEDERAL, CIVILIAN………………………… 67880 66004 65714 65560 65874 63999 67364 69808 71894 71585 74153 74269 73296 75916 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………… -2.16 -10.60 -1.75 -0.94 1.93 -10.91 22.75 15.32 12.50 -1.71 15.14 0.63 -5.14 15.08 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr………………… -1.05 -1.21 -3.43 -3.94 -2.96 -3.04 2.51 6.48 9.14 11.85 10.08 6.39 1.95 6.05 66962 65699 71860 -1.71 -1.89 9.38 -1.71 -1.89 9.38 STATE & LOCAL………………………………34971 35831 35429 35827 35159 35048 35378 35283 35366 35566 34952 35115 35100 35302 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………… -2.26 10.20 -4.41 4.57 -7.25 -1.26 3.81 -1.06 0.94 2.28 -6.73 1.88 -0.17 2.32 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr………………… -1.45 1.22 0.50 1.86 0.54 -2.18 -0.14 -1.52 0.59 1.48 -1.20 -0.48 -0.75 -0.74 35351 35353 35292 0.07 0.01 -0.17 0.07 0.01 -0.17 Center for Business and Economic Research, University of Tennessee Tennessee Econometric Model Historical Data PROFESSIONAL & BUSINESS SERVICES… 46989 48575 50369 48900 48675 48339 47725 47744 47777 47334 47630 50903 51918 50530 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..……………-11.40 14.20 15.61 -11.17 -1.83 -2.73 -4.98 0.16 0.27 -3.65 2.52 30.45 8.22 -10.27 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr………………… 1.38 5.70 11.90 0.97 3.59 -0.49 -5.25 -2.36 -1.85 -2.08 -0.20 6.62 8.67 6.75 | 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT Historical Data 2012:2 2012:3 2012:4 2013:1 2013:2 2013:3 2013:4 2014:1 2014:2 2014:3 2014:4 2015:1 2015:2 2015:3 APPENDIX B 58 Table 12: Tennessee Average Annual Wage and Salary Rate by Sector, Seasonally Adjusted (2009 dollars) Table 13: Tennessee Average Annual Wage and Salary Rate by Sector, Not Seasonally Adjusted (current dollars) January 2016 Historical Data 2012:2 2012:3 2012:4 2013:1 2013:2 2013:3 2013:4 2014:1 2014:2 2014:3 2014:4 2015:1 2015:2 2015:3 Annual 2012 2013 2014 48780 49204 51501 2.94 0.87 4.67 MANUFACTURING………………………………… 56424 53387 55192 54922 54301 54775 54975 55804 56180 56108 57123 54583 57637 58410 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………… 8.10 -0.05 6.02 1.09 -3.76 2.60 -0.39 1.61 3.46 2.43 3.91 -2.19 2.59 4.10 54834 54743 56304 3.76 -0.16 2.85 DURABLE GOODS……………………………… 56967 52396 54307 53539 52852 53086 53543 54195 55076 54963 56139 53457 55845 56363 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………… 12.08 0.55 5.58 -0.71 -7.22 1.32 -1.41 1.23 4.21 3.54 4.85 -1.36 1.40 2.55 54398 53255 55093 5.16 -2.10 3.45 NONDURABLE GOODS………………………… 55545 55012 56645 57203 56704 57587 57383 58552 58069 58065 58837 56554 60814 62028 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………… 2.37 -0.73 6.83 4.03 2.09 4.68 1.30 2.36 2.41 0.83 2.53 -3.41 4.73 6.83 55547 57219 58381 1.85 3.01 2.03 TRADE, TRANSPORTATION, UTILITIES…………41272 40886 41086 41169 41414 41335 40551 42249 41751 42141 42961 42428 42806 42948 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………… 2.92 1.01 3.92 -0.40 0.34 1.10 -1.30 2.62 0.81 1.95 5.94 0.42 2.53 1.91 41145 41117 42276 2.55 -0.07 2.82 WHOLESALE TRADE…………………………… 61828 60535 65728 61382 62285 62087 62533 64415 63471 64502 65850 64026 65334 64887 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………… 3.60 1.20 10.53 -0.23 0.74 2.56 -4.86 4.94 1.90 3.89 5.31 -0.60 2.93 0.60 62404 62072 64560 4.44 -0.53 4.01 RETAIL TRADE……………………………………28705 28296 27532 28418 28156 28414 27478 28813 28478 28734 29672 28788 29150 29612 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………… 3.63 -1.23 -0.82 -1.70 -1.91 0.42 -0.19 1.39 1.14 1.12 7.98 -0.09 2.36 3.06 28361 28117 28924 1.12 -0.86 2.87 TRANSPORTATION & UTILITIES……………… 51539 51723 50380 51622 52436 51825 51012 52814 52412 52413 52897 53622 53605 53198 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………… 0.53 2.65 2.52 0.10 1.74 0.20 1.25 2.31 -0.05 1.13 3.70 1.53 2.27 1.50 51303 51724 52634 1.53 0.82 1.76 INFORMATION……………………………………… 57628 58904 59749 57767 58626 59148 57223 61810 61723 61940 58439 62033 62253 64493 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………… 2.14 4.57 5.48 0.15 1.73 0.41 -4.23 7.00 5.28 4.72 2.12 0.36 0.86 4.12 58490 58191 60978 3.67 -0.51 4.79 FINANCIAL ACTIVITIES…………………………… 68585 66742 68884 66060 65981 65850 67248 69362 68417 68350 69925 69333 70732 71046 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………… 12.72 4.82 9.01 2.27 -3.80 -1.34 -2.37 5.00 3.69 3.80 3.98 -0.04 3.38 3.94 67200 66285 69014 7.06 -1.36 4.12 PROFESSIONAL & BUSINESS SERVICES…… 49896 51826 52688 53281 52206 52301 50506 52508 52137 52034 51309 56030 56903 55612 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………… 3.14 7.41 13.56 2.49 4.63 0.92 -4.14 -1.45 -0.13 -0.51 1.59 6.71 9.14 6.88 51599 52073 51997 7.40 0.92 -0.15 EDUCATION & HEALTH SERVICES………………45113 45653 45723 45632 45774 46299 45418 46652 46670 47102 46323 47650 47868 48832 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………… -0.02 0.83 3.30 0.66 1.46 1.41 -0.67 2.24 1.96 1.73 1.99 2.14 2.57 3.67 45455 45781 46687 1.75 0.72 1.98 LEISURE & HOSPITALITY………………………… 20877 20898 21490 21799 20595 20732 21563 22299 21463 21471 22750 23063 23069 22663 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………… 3.89 -0.09 3.36 -3.50 -1.35 -0.79 0.34 2.29 4.22 3.57 5.51 3.43 7.48 5.55 21464 21172 21996 3.06 -1.36 3.89 OTHER SERVICES………………………………… 40255 39444 40019 39852 39167 40177 40996 42568 41461 42162 43380 43608 43901 44477 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………… 6.23 2.43 2.75 0.99 -2.70 1.86 2.44 6.82 5.85 4.94 5.81 2.44 5.89 5.49 39795 40048 42393 2.73 0.64 5.86 GOVERNMENT……………………………………… 41360 43324 40670 41585 41777 42880 41198 42013 43422 44923 41925 42403 43431 44918 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………… 0.41 2.73 1.25 2.16 1.01 -1.02 1.30 1.03 3.94 4.76 1.77 0.93 0.02 -0.01 41515 41860 43071 1.66 0.83 2.89 FEDERAL, CIVILIAN………………………………71349 70958 70371 70210 70197 69784 73171 75924 77650 79172 79354 80972 81414 82604 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………… 1.16 0.41 -1.08 -2.23 -1.61 -1.65 3.98 8.14 10.62 13.45 8.45 6.65 4.85 4.33 71122 70841 78025 0.52 -0.40 10.14 STATE & LOCAL………………………………… 37302 39478 36790 37821 38018 39216 37138 37679 38921 40457 37360 37650 38604 39999 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………… 0.21 3.27 1.92 3.29 1.92 -0.66 0.95 -0.37 2.38 3.16 0.60 -0.08 -0.81 -1.13 37546 38048 38604 1.94 1.34 1.46 59 Center for Business and Economic Research, University of Tennessee Tennessee Econometric Model APPENDIX B NATURAL RESOURCES, MINING AND CONSTRUCTION…………………………… 47839 46810 48200 51034 48333 48060 49388 52924 51251 50561 51268 53729 54336 54664 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………… -0.33 0.28 6.30 -2.37 1.03 2.67 2.47 3.70 6.04 5.20 3.81 1.52 6.02 8.12 | | 44544 44615 45795 3.50 0.16 2.64 Historical Data 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT TOTAL NONFARM……………………………………… 44406 44455 44724 44921 44434 44781 44324 45834 45564 45912 45869 46564 47258 47577 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………… 3.52 2.24 5.42 0.74 0.06 0.73 -0.89 2.03 2.54 2.52 3.49 1.59 3.72 3.63 | 2012 Annual 2013 2014 44537 44613 45782 3.52 0.17 2.62 3.52 0.17 2.62 NATURAL RESOURCES, MINING & CONSTRUCTION… 47912 48032 48856 48985 48587 49237 49982 50842 51576 51765 51870 51642 54764 56036 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..………………………… -16.30 1.01 7.04 1.06 -3.21 5.46 6.19 7.07 5.90 1.47 0.82 -1.74 26.46 9.62 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………………….. -0.11 0.39 6.18 -2.21 1.41 2.51 2.30 3.79 6.15 5.13 3.78 1.57 6.18 8.25 48723 49198 51513 3.01 0.97 4.71 3.01 0.97 4.71 MANUFACTURING…………………………………………… 56433 53478 55305 54725 54310 54829 55098 55639 56172 56139 57260 54444 57619 58423 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..………………………… 18.39 -19.35 14.38 -4.13 -3.00 3.87 1.98 3.99 3.89 -0.24 8.23 -18.27 25.45 5.70 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………………….. 8.12 -0.12 6.01 1.16 -3.76 2.53 -0.37 1.67 3.43 2.39 3.92 -2.15 2.58 4.07 54829 54740 56302 3.77 -0.16 2.85 3.77 -0.16 2.85 DURABLE GOODS……………………………………...... 56988 52462 54394 53382 52884 53097 53647 54065 55106 54929 56268 53347 55869 56305 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..………………………… 26.51 -28.17 15.56 -7.24 -3.67 1.62 4.21 3.15 7.92 -1.28 10.11 -19.20 20.29 3.16 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………………….. 12.14 0.45 5.60 -0.66 -7.20 1.21 -1.37 1.28 4.20 3.45 4.88 -1.33 1.39 2.50 54394 53253 55092 5.16 -2.10 3.45 5.16 -2.10 3.45 NONDURABLE GOODS…………………………….. 55534 55147 56803 56938 56671 57717 57536 58322 57993 58213 58987 56362 60716 62180 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..………………………… 6.39 -2.76 12.57 0.95 -1.86 7.59 -1.25 5.58 -2.24 1.53 5.43 -16.65 34.67 10.00 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………………….. 2.33 -0.75 6.79 4.13 2.05 4.66 1.29 2.43 2.33 0.86 2.52 -3.36 4.70 6.82 55542 57215 58379 1.85 3.01 2.03 1.85 3.01 2.03 TRADE, TRANSPORTATION, UTILITIES…………. 41157 40798 41810 40635 41283 41241 41285 41755 41614 42037 43563 41929 42794 42887 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..………………………… 3.54 -3.45 10.30 -10.78 6.53 -0.41 0.43 4.63 -1.34 4.13 15.32 -14.18 8.51 0.87 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………………….. 2.89 0.95 4.09 -0.41 0.30 1.08 -1.26 2.76 0.80 1.93 5.52 0.42 2.84 2.02 41142 41111 42242 2.56 -0.08 2.75 2.56 -0.08 2.75 WHOLESALE TRADE……………………………………. 61948 60635 65891 60961 62438 62189 62703 63959 63626 64606 65956 63566 65438 65107 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..………………………… 5.68 -8.21 39.44 -26.73 10.05 -1.59 3.35 8.26 -2.07 6.31 8.62 -13.73 12.31 -2.00 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………………….. 3.60 1.14 10.62 -0.22 0.79 2.56 -4.84 4.92 1.90 3.89 5.19 -0.62 2.85 0.78 62393 62073 64537 4.45 -0.51 3.97 4.45 -0.51 3.97 RETAIL TRADE……………………………………………. 28610 28163 28187 27965 28037 28276 28151 28423 28354 28588 30215 28350 29138 29534 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..………………………… 2.22 -6.10 0.34 -3.12 1.03 3.46 -1.76 3.92 -0.97 3.35 24.78 -22.49 11.59 5.56 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………………….. 3.57 -1.29 -0.55 -1.72 -2.00 0.40 -0.13 1.64 1.13 1.10 7.33 -0.26 2.77 3.31 28353 28107 28895 1.11 -0.87 2.80 1.11 -0.87 2.80 TRANSPORTATION & UTILITIES………………………… 51246 51735 51233 51018 52147 51825 51884 52198 52116 52401 53695 53182 53522 53048 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..………………………… 2.18 3.87 -3.83 -1.67 9.16 -2.45 0.45 2.45 -0.63 2.21 10.24 -3.76 2.58 -3.49 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………………….. 0.55 2.60 2.54 0.09 1.76 0.17 1.27 2.31 -0.06 1.11 3.49 1.89 2.70 1.23 51296 51719 52602 1.52 0.82 1.71 1.52 0.82 1.71 INFORMATION………………………………………………… 57804 58675 60071 57592 58670 58925 57527 61810 61817 61752 58615 62079 62396 63946 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..………………………… 1.49 6.16 9.86 -15.51 7.70 1.74 -9.15 33.27 0.04 -0.42 -18.82 25.82 2.06 10.31 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………………….. 2.30 4.56 5.80 0.00 1.50 0.43 -4.23 7.32 5.36 4.80 1.89 0.44 0.94 3.55 58535 58179 60999 3.77 -0.61 4.85 3.77 -0.61 4.85 FINANCIAL ACTIVITIES…………………………………..... 68735 66937 69052 65562 65981 66056 67409 68901 68417 68527 70073 69074 70683 71177 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..………………………… 32.16 -10.06 13.25 -18.74 2.58 0.46 8.45 9.15 -2.78 0.64 9.34 -5.58 9.65 2.82 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………………….. 12.49 4.79 9.09 2.27 -4.01 -1.32 -2.38 5.09 3.69 3.74 3.95 0.25 3.31 3.87 67208 66252 68979 7.04 -1.42 4.12 7.04 -1.42 4.12 (CONTINUED ON NEXT PAGE) Historical Data TOTAL NONFARM……………………………………………….. 44448 44347 45226 44466 44498 44652 44837 45427 45628 45772 46299 46160 47346 47481 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..………………………… 2.94 -0.91 8.17 -6.56 0.29 1.39 1.66 5.38 1.78 1.27 4.68 -1.19 10.68 1.14 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………………….. 3.50 2.18 5.56 0.77 0.11 0.69 -0.86 2.16 2.54 2.51 3.26 1.61 3.76 3.73 | 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT Historical Data 2012:2 2012:3 2012:4 2013:1 2013:2 2013:3 2013:4 2014:1 2014:2 2014:3 2014:4 2015:1 2015:2 2015:3 January 2016 APPENDIX B 60 Table 14: Tennessee Average Annual Wage and Salary Rate by Sector, Seasonally Adjusted (current dollars) Table 14: Tennessee Average Annual Wage and Salary Rate by Sector, Seasonally Adjusted (current dollars) January 2016 Historical Data 2012:2 2012:3 2012:4 2013:1 2013:2 2013:3 2013:4 2014:1 2014:2 2014:3 2014:4 2015:1 2015:2 2015:3 2012 Annual 2013 2014 PROFESSIONAL & BUSINESS SERVICES…………………49754 51602 53797 52404 52221 52075 51595 51821 52132 51803 52070 55380 56794 55448 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..………………………… -10.31 15.71 18.12 -9.96 -1.39 -1.11 -3.64 1.77 2.42 -2.50 2.08 27.95 10.61 -9.15 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………………….. 3.17 7.35 13.87 2.50 4.96 0.92 -4.09 -1.11 -0.17 -0.52 0.92 6.87 8.94 7.04 51570 52074 51957 7.48 0.98 -0.22 7.48 0.98 -0.22 EDUCATION & HEALTH SERVICES………………………. 44994 45487 46065 45563 45701 46093 45778 46629 46593 46872 46734 47588 47802 48546 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..………………………… -2.19 4.46 5.18 -4.29 1.21 3.48 -2.71 7.65 -0.31 2.42 -1.17 7.51 1.81 6.37 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………………….. -0.15 0.92 3.41 0.71 1.57 1.33 -0.62 2.34 1.95 1.69 2.09 2.06 2.59 3.57 45448 45784 46707 1.78 0.74 2.02 1.78 0.74 2.02 LEISURE & HOSPITALITY…………………………………… 21409 21457 21308 20879 21126 21274 21383 21409 22009 22023 22538 22189 23635 23180 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..………………………… -3.94 0.90 -2.75 -7.81 4.81 2.82 2.08 0.48 11.69 0.25 9.69 -6.05 28.74 -7.48 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………………….. 3.78 -0.05 3.61 -3.45 -1.32 -0.85 0.35 2.54 4.18 3.52 5.40 3.64 7.39 5.26 21450 21165 21995 3.07 -1.32 3.92 3.07 -1.32 3.92 OTHER SERVICES…………………………………………... 40590 39633 39802 39459 39538 40391 40751 42113 41878 42388 43243 43164 44433 44547 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..………………………… 16.23 -9.10 1.72 -3.41 0.81 8.92 3.61 14.06 -2.22 4.97 8.31 -0.72 12.29 1.03 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………………….. 6.21 2.29 2.63 0.94 -2.59 1.91 2.38 6.73 5.92 4.94 6.11 2.49 6.10 5.09 39779 40035 42406 2.69 0.64 5.92 2.69 0.64 5.92 GOVERNMENT……………………………………………….. 41128 41896 41680 42145 41520 41411 42261 42612 43146 43359 42873 42947 43148 43702 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..………………………… -0.94 7.68 -2.05 4.53 -5.80 -1.04 8.47 3.36 5.11 1.99 -4.41 0.69 1.89 5.23 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………………….. 0.43 2.32 1.48 2.23 0.95 -1.16 1.39 1.11 3.92 4.70 1.45 0.79 0.00 0.79 41483 41834 42997 1.63 0.85 2.78 1.63 0.85 2.78 FEDERAL, CIVILIAN………………………………………. 71875 70117 70185 70258 70672 68945 72826 75769 78449 78343 81065 80801 80179 83305 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..………………………… -0.96 -9.43 0.39 0.41 2.38 -9.42 24.49 17.17 14.91 -0.54 14.64 -1.30 -3.04 16.53 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………………….. 0.70 0.33 -1.73 -2.49 -1.67 -1.67 3.76 7.85 11.00 13.63 11.31 6.64 2.21 6.33 71056 70675 78407 0.15 -0.54 10.94 0.15 -0.54 10.94 STATE & LOCAL…………………………………………... 37029 38064 37839 38394 37720 37757 38246 38297 38591 38924 38210 38203 38396 38738 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..………………………… -1.06 11.66 -2.34 5.99 -6.84 0.39 5.28 0.53 3.11 3.50 -7.14 -0.07 2.03 3.61 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………………….. 0.30 2.80 2.27 3.41 1.87 -0.81 1.07 -0.25 2.31 3.09 -0.09 -0.24 -0.50 -0.48 37515 38029 38505 1.96 1.37 1.25 1.96 1.37 1.25 Center for Business and Economic Research, University of Tennessee Tennessee Econometric Model Historical Data | | 61 APPENDIX B 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT January 2016 | Historical Data 2012:3 2012:4 2013:1 2013:2 2013:3 2013:4 2014:1 2014:2 2014:3 2014:4 2015:1 2015:2 2015:3 2015:4 Annual 2013 2014 3115 -0.39 3089 -0.05 3110 -0.25 3086 -1.06 3041 -2.37 3014 -2.45 3025 -2.72 3017 -2.22 2990 -1.69 3024 0.33 3105 2.64 3066 1.61 3064 2.47 3111 -0.62 3082 -0.93 3011 -2.27 EMPLOYED PERSONS (THOUS)………… 2871 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr………………… 0.54 2887 0.29 2833 -0.22 2862 -0.44 2844 -0.94 2830 -1.99 2807 -0.91 2828 -1.16 2805 -1.38 2803 -0.96 2829 0.78 2926 3.46 2883 2.78 2899 3.45 2868 0.64 2842 -0.90 2811 -1.10 UNEMPLOYED PERSONS (THOUS)……… 247 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………-12.41 228 -8.19 257 1.89 248 1.98 242 -2.36 211 207 197 212 187 -7.24 -19.44 -20.70 -12.12 -11.50 195 -5.84 179 183 164 -9.03 -13.89 -12.10 243 -13.52 PARTICIPATION RATE (PERCENT)………… 60.8 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr………………… -1.81 60.5 -1.56 59.9 -1.23 60.1 -1.42 59.4 -2.21 58.4 -3.51 57.7 -3.59 57.8 -3.87 57.4 -3.38 56.7 -2.86 57.2 -0.86 58.6 1.43 57.7 0.41 57.5 1.26 60.7 -1.81 59.5 -2.09 57.4 -3.43 7.3 8.3 8.0 7.8 6.9 6.9 6.5 7.0 6.3 6.4 5.8 6.0 5.4 7.8 7.8 6.7 UNEMPLOYMENT RATE (PERCENT)……… 7.9 Center for Business and Economic Research, University of Tennessee 239 201 -1.31 -16.17 Tennessee Econometric Model Historical Data CIVILIAN LABOR FORCE (THOUS)………… 3119 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr………………… -0.63 | 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT 2012 APPENDIX B 62 Table 15: Tennessee Civilian Labor Force and Unemployment Rate, Not Seasonally Adjusted Table 16: Tennessee Civilian Labor Force and Unemployment Rate, Seasonally Adjusted January 2016 Historical Data 2012:3 2012:4 2013:1 2013:2 2013:3 2013:4 2014:1 2014:2 2014:3 2014:4 2015:1 2015:2 2015:3 2015:4 2012 Annual 2013 2014 CIVILIAN LABOR FORCE (THOUS)………… 3092 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR…………………… 0.49 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr………………… -0.87 3091 -0.10 -0.65 3082 -1.18 -0.32 3067 -1.88 -0.67 3045 -2.89 -1.51 3020 -3.23 -2.30 3007 -1.72 -2.43 2997 -1.36 -2.30 2987 -1.32 -1.91 2983 -0.49 -1.22 3037 7.43 1.00 3096 7.94 3.30 3058 -4.74 2.39 3062 0.42 2.63 3091 -0.88 -0.88 3054 -1.20 -1.20 2993 -1.97 -1.97 EMPLOYED PERSONS (THOUS)………… 2852 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR…………………… 0.83 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr………………… 0.25 2852 0.06 -0.01 2838 -1.94 -0.38 2826 -1.67 -0.69 2812 -2.00 -1.39 2805 -0.96 -1.65 2811 0.78 -0.97 2802 -1.28 -0.87 2789 -1.80 -0.82 2786 -0.39 -0.68 2839 7.83 1.02 2915 11.14 4.05 2884 -4.22 3.40 2891 0.97 3.75 2850 0.28 0.28 2820 -1.03 -1.03 2797 -0.84 -0.84 UNEMPLOYED PERSONS (THOUS)…… 240 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR…………………… -3.47 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………-12.50 239 -2.02 -7.78 244 8.34 0.35 241 233 215 196 195 198 -4.25 -12.84 -27.66 -30.21 -2.48 5.69 -0.48 -2.98 -10.07 -19.43 -19.06 -15.06 197 -1.91 -8.35 198 181 174 171 1.99 -30.73 -12.79 -8.29 0.77 -7.49 -11.83 -13.30 241 -12.79 -12.79 PARTICIPATION RATE (PERCENT)……… 60.3 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR…………………… -0.69 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr………………… -2.05 60.1 -1.27 -1.83 59.7 -2.34 -1.49 59.3 -3.02 -1.84 58.7 -4.02 -2.67 58.0 -4.36 -3.44 57.6 -2.89 -3.57 57.2 -2.53 -3.45 56.9 -2.49 -3.07 56.6 -1.67 -2.39 57.5 6.16 -0.20 58.4 6.66 2.08 57.5 -5.87 1.18 57.4 -0.77 1.41 60.3 -2.07 -2.07 58.9 -2.36 -2.36 57.1 -3.13 -3.13 7.7 7.9 7.9 7.7 7.1 6.5 6.5 6.6 6.6 6.5 5.8 5.7 5.6 7.8 7.6 6.6 UNEMPLOYMENT RATE (PERCENT)……… 7.8 Center for Business and Economic Research, University of Tennessee 233 197 -3.27 -15.69 -3.27 -15.69 Tennessee Econometric Model Historical Data | | 63 APPENDIX B 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT January 2016 TOTAL TAXABLE SALES………………………… 23376 22622 24312 21915 23858 23108 24973 22314 24190 24183 26431 23004 26057 25942 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 2.74 0.72 1.15 -0.53 2.06 2.15 2.72 1.82 1.39 4.65 5.84 3.09 7.72 7.27 2013 2014 92342 93853 97118 2.70 1.64 3.48 AUTO DEALERS………………………………… 2222 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 7.26 2269 9.30 2037 3.25 2241 1.08 2309 3.93 2413 6.35 2180 7.01 2340 4.44 2426 5.04 2542 5.34 2375 8.92 2536 8.35 2750 13.37 2870 12.91 8745 8.16 9144 4.55 9683 5.90 PURCHASES FROM MANUFACTURERS…. 974 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… -2.00 929 -7.74 1119 7.77 806 0.39 989 1.57 968 4.18 1126 0.57 818 1.53 1007 1.79 1036 6.96 1247 10.83 884 8.03 1100 9.19 1136 9.67 3826 -0.78 3889 1.66 4109 5.64 MISC DURABLE GOODS……………………… 4078 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 2.53 3741 -2.95 3895 0.59 3491 -5.40 4181 2.52 3933 5.14 4027 3.39 3508 0.47 4244 1.51 4120 4.75 4231 5.07 3532 0.69 4547 7.15 4346 5.49 EATING AND DRINKING PLACES…………… 2460 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 5.51 2422 3.52 2385 3.73 2352 0.41 2552 3.74 2480 2.40 2448 2.64 2426 3.14 2607 2.16 2616 5.46 2611 6.66 2552 5.19 2833 8.68 2808 7.36 9610 5.27 9833 10260 2.32 4.35 FOOD STORES………………………………… 2253 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 2.98 2278 3.63 2459 1.68 2251 5.11 2326 3.24 2289 0.48 2504 1.84 2211 -1.79 2329 0.15 2367 3.39 2584 3.20 2311 4.52 2420 3.91 2457 3.83 9131 3.14 9369 2.61 9490 1.29 LIQUOR STORES……………………………… % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 183 9.56 174 4.99 219 4.23 178 3.52 184 0.57 187 7.28 230 4.94 186 4.62 193 5.32 195 4.02 247 7.47 200 7.36 211 9.22 210 8.12 747 6.78 778 4.10 821 5.48 HOTELS AND MOTELS………………………… 638 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 4.87 627 0.08 582 2.89 502 1.30 630 -1.28 626 -0.22 600 3.11 534 6.27 713 13.18 730 16.69 670 11.74 575 7.69 801 12.38 832 13.97 2343 4.44 2358 0.64 2647 12.27 OTHER RETAIL AND SERVICE……………… 7071 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 3.90 6790 1.83 7857 0.81 6703 0.15 7175 1.46 6877 1.28 8063 2.63 6913 3.14 7332 2.19 7137 3.77 8542 5.93 7014 1.46 7789 6.24 7708 8.01 MISC NONDURABLE GOODS………………… 1960 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 3.58 1872 2.00 2221 1.88 1893 0.62 1994 1.72 1910 2.04 2284 2.86 1889 -0.22 2045 2.53 1984 3.84 2379 4.17 1916 1.42 2134 4.37 2098 5.75 7934 3.46 8082 1.86 8297 2.66 TRANSPORTATION, COMMUNICATION…… 1536 1519 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… -10.46 -10.07 1539 -8.72 1498 -6.15 1519 -1.14 1424 -6.24 1510 -1.84 1489 1295 -0.57 -14.73 1458 2.36 1544 2.20 1485 -0.27 1472 13.65 1476 1.21 6190 -9.14 5951 -3.85 5786 -2.78 3750 0.08 3371 -1.59 3660 0.99 3536 1.07 3811 1.63 3396 0.75 3661 3.55 3991 4.73 3465 2.01 3914 6.60 3887 6.16 PER CAPITA ($)…………………………………… 3624 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 1.64 3498 -0.35 Center for Business and Economic Research, University of Tennessee 3672 0.33 15404 15632 16103 2.87 1.48 3.01 28411 28818 29923 2.96 1.43 3.84 14297 14378 14721 1.61 0.56 2.39 Tennessee Econometric Model Historical Data 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT Annual 2012 | | Historical Data 2012:2 2012:3 2012:4 2013:1 2013:2 2013:3 2013:4 2014:1 2014:2 2014:3 2014:4 2015:1 2015:2 2015:3 APPENDIX B 64 Table 17: Tennessee Taxable Sales, Not Seasonally Adjusted (millions of 2009 dollars) Table 18: Tennessee Taxable Sales, Seasonally Adjusted (millions of 2009 dollars) January 2016 Historical Data Annual 2012:2 2012:3 2012:4 2013:1 2013:2 2013:3 2013:4 2014:1 2014:2 2014:3 2014:4 2015:1 2015:2 2015:3 TOTAL TAXABLE SALES………………………… 22989 22878 23007 23361 23472 23389 23615 23780 23807 24465 24985 24523 25642 26228 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………… -8.65 -1.93 2.28 6.30 1.91 -1.41 3.94 2.81 0.45 11.54 8.76 -7.19 19.55 9.46 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 2.73 0.93 1.02 -0.66 2.10 2.23 2.65 1.79 1.43 4.60 5.80 3.12 7.71 7.21 AUTO DEALERS………………………………… 2155 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………… -10.37 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 7.84 2180 4.61 9.76 2194 2.64 2.49 2012 2013 2014 92389 93837 97036 2.77 1.57 3.41 2.77 1.57 3.41 2321 12.64 6.47 2337 2.79 6.51 2331 -0.91 4.38 2375 7.80 5.46 2441 11.57 5.21 2541 17.42 8.77 2526 -2.40 8.35 2697 29.95 13.53 2754 8.67 12.79 8743 8.02 8.02 9143 4.57 4.57 9689 5.98 5.98 PURCHASES FROM MANUFACTURERS…. 952 919 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………… 1.85 -12.84 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… -1.78 -7.20 995 957 37.21 -14.50 6.40 1.02 969 5.22 1.84 964 -2.11 4.84 988 10.52 -0.68 977 -4.39 2.14 990 5.12 2.11 1034 18.96 7.22 1088 1059 22.91 -10.17 10.10 8.40 1081 8.58 9.28 1135 21.27 9.81 3813 -0.94 -0.94 3878 1.70 1.70 4089 5.42 5.42 MISC DURABLE GOODS……………………… 3813 3711 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………… -26.03 -10.23 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 2.42 -2.64 3797 9.62 0.29 3892 10.34 -5.33 3908 1.67 2.50 3908 -0.03 5.30 3918 1.06 3.18 3914 -0.40 0.57 3968 5.65 1.54 4094 13.28 4.76 4112 3945 1.81 -15.31 4.96 0.79 4252 34.98 7.15 4317 6.21 5.44 EATING AND DRINKING PLACES…………… 2385 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………… -5.98 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 5.33 2392 1.22 3.74 2412 3.43 3.66 2433 3.51 0.47 2470 6.11 3.55 2455 -2.41 2.61 2474 3.21 2.56 2510 5.91 3.15 2523 2.08 2.15 2589 10.87 5.46 2638 7.82 6.62 2642 0.59 5.26 2741 15.86 8.64 2779 5.72 7.36 9611 5.29 5.29 9832 10259 2.29 4.35 2.29 4.35 FOOD STORES………………………………… 2272 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………… 0.24 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 2.96 2298 4.56 4.00 2290 -1.37 1.57 2382 17.13 4.90 2347 -5.73 3.30 2312 -5.91 0.61 2332 3.47 1.82 2336 0.81 -1.92 2352 2.72 0.20 2392 6.89 3.45 2406 2.44 3.19 2440 5.77 4.44 2445 0.82 3.95 2483 6.40 3.83 9131 3.19 3.19 9373 2.65 2.65 9487 1.21 1.21 LIQUOR STORES……………………………… % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………… % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 189 8.56 9.63 185 -7.12 4.91 188 5.65 4.29 191 7.40 3.42 190 -2.56 0.66 199 19.65 7.24 197 -3.06 4.96 200 5.64 4.53 200 0.96 5.46 207 12.90 3.94 212 10.89 7.49 215 4.86 7.30 219 8.75 9.31 223 7.79 8.05 747 6.93 6.93 778 4.06 4.06 819 5.36 5.36 HOTELS AND MOTELS………………………… 588 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………… -0.92 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 4.47 581 -5.09 0.46 587 4.57 3.23 595 5.39 0.90 580 -9.80 -1.44 580 0.55 -0.01 606 18.65 3.20 632 18.09 6.17 656 16.47 13.18 677 13.18 16.58 678 0.52 11.84 681 1.88 7.79 737 37.30 12.32 771 19.59 13.88 2345 4.74 4.74 2361 0.66 0.66 2642 11.91 11.91 OTHER RETAIL AND SERVICE……………… 7122 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………… -2.32 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 3.71 7095 -1.53 1.95 7063 -1.77 1.23 7148 4.88 -0.23 7217 3.92 1.33 7192 -1.35 1.37 7262 3.93 2.81 7360 5.50 2.97 7373 0.74 2.17 7464 5.02 3.78 7694 7468 12.94 -11.25 5.96 1.48 7832 20.96 6.23 8060 12.16 7.99 MISC NONDURABLE GOODS………………… 1982 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………… -6.09 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 3.29 1977 -0.97 2.00 1967 -1.91 2.04 2026 12.52 0.65 2014 -2.41 1.63 2015 0.20 1.92 2026 2.21 2.98 2023 -0.66 -0.18 2065 8.57 2.52 2090 4.98 3.72 2112 2051 4.29 -10.99 4.24 1.42 2155 21.73 4.36 2209 10.46 5.70 7939 3.51 3.51 8081 1.79 1.79 8289 2.57 2.57 TRANSPORTATION, COMMUNICATION…… 1532 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………… -15.37 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… -9.72 1540 2.07 -9.97 1513 -6.82 -9.70 1503 -2.55 -5.89 1524 1443 5.82 -19.69 -0.49 -6.28 1476 9.31 -2.46 1497 1304 5.91 -42.47 -0.41 -14.48 1479 65.49 2.46 1502 6.53 1.80 1495 -1.89 -0.13 1483 -3.32 13.72 1497 4.06 1.26 6182 -9.13 -9.13 5946 -3.81 -3.81 5782 -2.77 -2.77 PER CAPITA ($)…………………………………… 3565 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………… -9.62 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 1.63 3538 -2.97 -0.14 3548 1.20 -0.05 3593 5.18 -1.71 3601 0.83 1.02 3604 2.85 1.56 3619 1.74 0.72 3704 10.37 3.51 3773 7.63 4.69 3693 -8.16 2.05 3852 18.31 6.59 3930 8.33 6.09 3614 -0.60 0.36 28444 28818 29891 3.02 1.32 3.72 3.02 1.32 3.72 14306 14377 14710 1.68 0.49 2.32 1.68 0.49 2.32 Tennessee Econometric Model APPENDIX B 65 Center for Business and Economic Research, University of Tennessee 3579 -2.45 1.15 15433 15626 16089 3.15 1.26 2.96 3.15 1.26 2.96 | | 2252 3.45 4.52 Historical Data 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT 2233 7.43 0.84 January 2016 TOTAL TAXABLE SALES………………………… 24751 24032 25967 23485 25596 24894 26997 24220 26396 26466 28894 25027 28505 28466 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 4.56 2.30 2.93 0.98 3.41 3.59 3.97 3.13 3.12 6.32 7.03 3.33 7.99 7.56 2013 2014 98007 100972 ##### 4.62 3.03 4.96 AUTO DEALERS………………………………… 2353 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 9.16 2411 11.02 2176 5.07 2401 2.62 2477 5.30 2600 7.85 2357 8.32 2540 5.78 2647 6.84 2782 7.01 2596 10.14 2759 8.61 3008 13.65 3150 13.21 9279 10.19 9836 10565 5.99 7.42 PURCHASES FROM MANUFACTURERS…. 1031 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… -0.27 987 -6.29 1195 9.67 864 1.92 1061 2.91 1043 5.65 1217 1.79 888 2.83 1099 3.53 1134 8.66 1364 12.07 962 8.28 1203 9.46 1246 9.96 4062 1.08 4185 3.04 MISC DURABLE GOODS……………………… 4318 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 4.34 3974 -1.43 4160 2.36 3741 -3.97 4485 3.87 4237 6.62 4353 4.65 3807 1.76 4631 3.25 4509 6.42 4626 6.25 3843 0.93 4974 7.42 4769 5.77 16348 16817 17572 4.77 2.87 4.49 EATING AND DRINKING PLACES…………… 2605 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 7.38 2573 5.14 2548 5.56 2521 1.93 2738 5.11 2672 3.84 2647 3.90 2633 4.46 2845 3.90 2863 7.14 2855 7.86 2776 5.44 3099 8.95 3082 7.65 10198 10577 11195 7.24 3.72 5.84 FOOD STORES………………………………… 2385 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 4.80 2420 5.25 2626 3.47 2412 6.71 2495 4.60 2466 1.90 2707 3.08 2399 -0.53 2541 1.86 2590 5.04 2825 4.35 2514 4.77 2647 4.17 2696 4.11 9692 10080 10356 5.08 4.01 2.74 LIQUOR STORES……………………………… 193 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 11.50 185 6.64 234 6.07 190 5.09 197 1.90 202 8.80 248 6.22 202 5.96 211 7.12 213 5.67 270 8.68 217 7.61 231 9.49 231 8.41 793 8.77 837 5.51 896 6.97 HOTELS AND MOTELS………………………… 675 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 6.73 666 1.65 621 4.70 538 2.84 676 0.02 674 1.19 649 4.37 580 7.63 778 15.11 799 18.55 733 13.00 626 7.94 876 12.66 913 14.28 2486 6.36 2537 2.01 2889 13.90 OTHER RETAIL AND SERVICE……………… 7488 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 5.74 7214 3.43 8392 2.59 7183 1.67 7697 2.80 7409 2.70 8717 3.88 7503 4.46 8000 3.93 7811 5.42 9338 7.12 7631 1.69 8521 6.51 8459 8.30 MISC NONDURABLE GOODS………………… 2076 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 5.41 1989 3.60 2372 3.68 2029 2.15 2139 3.06 2058 3.48 2469 4.12 2050 1.06 2231 4.29 2171 5.49 2601 5.34 2084 1.66 2334 4.63 2302 6.03 8422 5.40 8695 3.24 9053 4.12 TRANSPORTATION, COMMUNICATION…… 1627 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… -8.87 1614 -8.66 1643 -7.11 1605 -4.72 1630 0.17 1534 -4.92 1633 -0.64 1617 1413 0.71 -13.28 1596 3.99 1687 3.35 1616 -0.04 1610 13.94 1619 1.48 6569 -7.41 6402 -2.54 6313 -1.39 PER CAPITA ($)…………………………………… 3838 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 3.44 3716 1.21 4005 1.84 3612 -0.09 3927 2.32 3809 2.49 4120 2.87 3686 2.04 4007 5.20 4363 5.91 3769 2.25 4282 6.87 4265 6.44 Center for Business and Economic Research, University of Tennessee 4007 2.04 4484 7.15 30158 31006 32652 4.89 2.81 5.31 15174 15468 16063 3.51 1.93 3.85 Tennessee Econometric Model Historical Data 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT Annual 2012 | | Historical Data 2012:2 2012:3 2012:4 2013:1 2013:2 2013:3 2013:4 2014:1 2014:2 2014:3 2014:4 2015:1 2015:2 2015:3 APPENDIX B 66 Table 19: Tennessee Taxable Sales, Not Seasonally Adjusted (millions of current dollars) Table 20: Tennessee Taxable Sales, Seasonally Adjusted (millions of current dollars) January 2016 Historical Data 2012:2 2012:3 2012:4 2013:1 2013:2 2013:3 2013:4 2014:1 2014:2 2014:3 2014:4 2015:1 2015:2 2015:3 TOTAL TAXABLE SALES………………………… 24342 24303 24572 25035 25181 25196 25530 25811 25977 26775 27314 26679 28050 28781 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………… -7.53 -0.64 4.50 7.75 2.36 0.23 5.41 4.47 2.60 12.87 8.29 -8.97 22.19 10.84 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 4.55 2.51 2.80 0.85 3.45 3.67 3.90 3.10 3.16 6.27 6.99 3.37 7.98 7.49 2343 4.87 4.29 2014 98041 100943 105877 4.70 2.96 4.89 4.70 2.96 4.89 2530 0.69 5.72 2592 10.11 7.26 2672 12.90 6.88 2778 16.91 9.99 2748 -4.27 8.61 2950 32.82 13.82 3022 10.03 13.09 9279 10.05 10.05 9836 6.01 6.01 10572 7.49 7.49 PURCHASES FROM MANUFACTURERS…. 1008 977 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………… 3.10 -11.69 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… -0.04 -5.75 1063 1025 40.19 -13.34 8.28 2.55 1040 5.68 3.19 1038 -0.48 6.32 1069 12.09 0.54 1061 -2.85 3.45 1080 7.37 3.86 1131 20.38 8.92 1190 1153 22.37 -11.89 11.34 8.65 1183 10.98 9.55 1245 22.79 10.10 4047 0.94 0.94 4172 3.09 3.09 4461 6.93 6.93 MISC DURABLE GOODS……………………… 4037 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………… -25.13 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 4.23 3943 -9.04 -1.12 4056 12.00 2.06 4171 11.84 -3.89 4193 2.12 3.86 4210 1.64 6.78 4236 2.49 4.44 4249 1.20 1.86 4330 7.91 3.28 4481 14.63 6.43 4496 4292 1.36 -16.93 6.14 1.02 4652 37.96 7.42 4737 7.54 5.72 16375 5.08 5.08 16810 2.65 2.65 17555 4.44 4.44 EATING AND DRINKING PLACES…………… 2525 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………… -4.83 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 7.20 2541 2.55 5.36 2577 5.68 5.48 2608 4.92 1.99 2649 6.58 4.92 2644 -0.79 4.06 2675 4.67 3.81 2724 7.62 4.47 2753 4.27 3.90 2833 12.19 7.14 2884 7.36 7.82 2874 -1.34 5.51 2998 18.42 8.92 3050 7.05 7.65 10200 7.28 7.28 10576 3.69 3.69 11194 5.84 5.84 FOOD STORES………………………………… 2406 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………… 1.47 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 4.78 2441 5.94 5.62 2446 0.77 3.35 2553 18.73 6.49 2518 -5.31 4.67 2491 -4.34 2.03 2521 4.94 3.07 2536 2.43 -0.67 2567 4.93 1.92 2618 8.17 5.10 2631 2.00 4.35 2655 3.75 4.69 2675 3.05 4.21 2725 7.74 4.11 9690 5.14 5.14 10083 4.05 4.05 10351 2.66 2.66 LIQUOR STORES……………………………… 200 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………… 9.89 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 11.57 197 -5.90 6.56 201 7.94 6.13 205 8.86 4.99 204 -2.13 1.99 214 21.64 8.75 213 -1.69 6.24 217 7.34 5.87 219 3.12 7.26 226 14.24 5.59 232 10.41 8.70 233 2.86 7.55 240 11.15 9.58 245 9.14 8.34 793 8.94 8.94 836 5.49 5.49 894 6.86 6.86 HOTELS AND MOTELS………………………… 623 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………… 0.29 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 6.32 617 -3.84 2.03 627 6.84 5.05 637 6.83 2.43 622 -9.40 -0.14 625 2.22 1.40 655 20.33 4.46 685 19.99 7.53 716 18.96 15.11 741 14.53 18.43 741 0.09 13.10 741 -0.07 8.05 806 40.33 12.60 846 21.10 14.18 2489 6.70 6.70 2540 2.04 2.04 2883 13.51 13.51 OTHER RETAIL AND SERVICE……………… 7541 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………… -1.12 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 5.55 7537 -0.23 3.55 7544 0.36 3.02 7660 6.30 1.28 7742 4.38 2.67 7748 0.30 2.80 7851 5.40 4.07 7988 7.19 4.29 8045 2.90 3.91 8169 6.27 5.43 8412 8125 12.45 -12.95 7.15 1.72 8568 23.64 6.49 8845 13.57 8.28 30184 4.96 4.96 31000 2.70 2.70 32614 5.20 5.20 MISC NONDURABLE GOODS………………… 2098 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………… -4.94 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 5.12 2100 0.34 3.60 2101 0.22 3.84 2171 14.05 2.18 2161 -1.98 2.97 2171 1.87 3.36 2190 3.66 4.24 2195 0.94 1.10 2253 10.90 4.27 2287 6.23 5.37 2309 2232 3.84 -12.69 5.41 1.66 2357 24.42 4.63 2424 11.85 5.98 8425 5.46 5.46 8693 3.18 3.18 9044 4.04 4.04 TRANSPORTATION, COMMUNICATION…… 1622 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………… -14.33 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… -8.12 1636 3.41 -8.57 1616 -4.80 -8.11 1611 -1.22 -4.46 1636 1555 6.28 -18.35 0.83 -4.96 1595 10.86 -1.27 1625 1423 7.62 -41.24 0.87 -13.02 1618 67.46 4.09 1642 6.06 2.95 1627 -3.77 0.11 1622 -1.18 14.00 1643 5.37 1.53 6560 -7.42 -7.42 6396 -2.49 -2.49 6308 -1.38 -1.38 PER CAPITA ($)…………………………………… 3774 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………… -8.51 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 3.43 3758 -1.69 1.42 3790 3.40 1.71 3851 6.61 -0.21 3863 1.28 2.35 3896 4.31 2.80 3928 3.37 2.01 4054 11.69 5.15 4125 7.16 5.87 4018 -9.92 2.29 4214 20.93 6.86 4312 9.69 6.38 15181 3.59 3.59 15465 1.87 1.87 16050 3.78 3.78 Center for Business and Economic Research, University of Tennessee 3855 -0.82 2.58 3943 1.53 2.08 Tennessee Econometric Model APPENDIX B 2526 4.25 7.81 | 2500 14.51 7.97 Historical Data 2417 3.91 5.90 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT 2394 8.90 2.37 67 2315 5.99 11.48 Annual 2013 | AUTO DEALERS………………………………… 2282 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………… -9.27 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr…………………… 9.75 2012 Table 1: Selected U.S. and Tennessee Economic Indicators, Seasonally Adjusted January 2016 | 2005 2006 2007 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 252717 0.97 258027 2.10 255313 -1.05 257567 0.88 247316 -3.98 251094 1.53 258257 2.85 266947 3.36 268707 0.66 274962 2.33 US GDP (Bil2009$) SAAR……………………………………… 13271.1 Percentage change…………………………………………… 2.81 13773.5 3.79 14234.3 3.35 14613.8 2.67 14873.8 1.78 14830.4 -0.29 14418.8 -2.78 14783.8 2.53 15020.6 1.60 15354.6 2.22 15583.3 1.49 15961.7 2.43 TN GDP (Mil$) SAAR……………………………………………. Percentage change…………………………………………… 206562 4.44 220573 6.78 228724 3.70 239395 4.67 243368 1.66 250402 2.89 247316 -1.23 253252 2.40 264022 4.25 279654 5.92 286908 2.59 298623 4.08 US GDP (Bil$) SAAR……………………………………………. 11510.7 Percentage change…………………………………………… 4.86 12274.9 6.64 13093.7 6.67 13855.9 5.82 14477.6 4.49 14718.6 1.66 14418.7 -2.04 14964.4 3.78 15517.9 3.70 16155.3 4.11 16663.2 3.14 17348.1 4.11 TN PERSONAL INCOME (MIL2009$) SAAR……................. Percentage change…………………………………………… 196674 1.84 203762 3.60 205807 1.00 212564 3.28 217676 2.40 220441 1.27 217358 -1.40 222615 2.42 229291 3.00 238054 3.82 237442 -0.26 242848 2.28 US PERSONAL INCOME (BIL2009$) SAAR………….......... Percentage change…………………………………………… 10838 1.67 11206 3.40 11504 2.66 12028 4.56 12358 2.75 12494 1.10 12095 -3.19 12274 1.48 12726 3.69 13112 3.03 13078 -0.26 13468 2.98 TN PERSONAL INCOME (MIL$) SAAR…………………….... Percentage change…………………………………………… 172239 3.86 182791 6.13 189889 3.88 201367 6.04 211376 4.97 220580 4.35 217354 -1.46 226302 4.12 238810 5.53 252636 5.79 255422 1.10 264965 3.74 US PERSONAL INCOME (BIL$) SAAR…………………….... Percentage change…………………………………………… 9491 3.68 10053 5.92 10614 5.58 11394 7.35 12000 5.32 12502 4.18 12095 -3.26 12477 3.16 13255 6.23 13915 4.98 14068 1.10 14694 4.45 TN NONFARM JOBS (THOUS)………………………………… Percentage change…………………………………………… 2662.6 -0.10 2705.6 1.62 2743.0 1.38 2782.9 1.46 2797.8 0.53 2775.4 -0.80 2619.3 -5.62 2615.5 -0.15 2661.9 1.78 2715.3 2.00 2758.7 1.60 2816.1 2.08 US NONFARM JOBS (MIL)……………………………………… Percentage change…………………………………………… 130.3 -0.24 131.7 1.09 134.0 1.72 136.4 1.80 137.9 1.12 137.2 -0.56 131.2 -4.34 130.3 -0.73 131.8 1.21 134.1 1.71 136.4 1.71 139.0 1.93 TN MFG JOBS (THOUS)………………………………………… Percentage change…………………………………………… 413.3 -3.56 411.8 -0.35 408.8 -0.74 399.4 -2.30 379.9 -4.87 360.9 -4.99 309.2 -14.33 299.0 -3.32 304.4 1.84 313.4 2.94 318.4 1.61 325.2 2.13 US MFG JOBS (MIL)……………………………………………… Percentage change…………………………………………… 14.5 -4.90 14.3 -1.34 14.2 -0.62 14.2 -0.49 13.9 -1.97 13.4 -3.42 11.8 -11.61 11.5 -2.69 11.7 1.71 11.9 1.71 12.0 0.78 12.2 1.41 TN UNEMPLOYMENT RATE (%)…………………………….... 5.6 5.4 5.5 5.2 4.7 6.8 10.6 9.6 8.9 7.8 7.6 6.6 US UNEMPLOYMENT RATE (%)……………………………… 6.0 5.5 5.1 4.6 4.6 5.8 9.3 9.6 8.9 8.1 7.4 6.2 CHAINED PRICE INDEX, GDP (2009=100.0)……………..... Percentage change…………………………………………… 86.7 1.99 89.1 2.75 92.0 3.22 94.8 3.07 97.3 2.67 99.2 1.93 100.0 0.79 101.2 1.23 103.3 2.06 105.2 1.84 106.9 1.63 108.7 1.64 US PERS CONSUMP DEFL (2009=100.0)……………......... Percentage change…………………………………………… 87.6 1.98 89.7 2.43 92.3 2.85 94.7 2.68 97.1 2.50 100.1 3.05 100.0 -0.06 101.7 1.65 104.1 2.46 106.1 1.89 107.6 1.37 109.1 1.43 CONSUMER PRICE INDEX, ALL-URBAN (82-84=1.000)…… Percentage change…………………………………………… 1.840 2.30 1.889 2.67 1.953 3.37 2.016 3.22 2.073 2.87 2.153 3.81 2.146 -0.32 2.181 1.64 2.249 3.14 2.296 2.08 2.330 1.46 2.367 1.61 BANK PRIME INTEREST RATE (%)…………………………… 4.1 4.3 6.2 8.0 8.1 5.1 3.3 3.3 3.3 3.3 3.3 3.3 FEDERAL FUNDS RATE (% per annum)……………………… 1.128 1.349 3.213 4.964 5.019 1.928 0.160 0.175 0.102 0.140 0.108 0.089 30-YEAR FIXED MORTGAGE RATE (%)……………………… 5.8 5.8 5.9 6.4 6.3 6.0 5.0 4.7 4.5 3.7 4.0 4.2 TN TAXABLE SALES (MIL2009$)……………………………… Percentage change…………………………………………… 89918 2.32 92218 2.56 95680 3.75 97860 2.28 98872 1.03 93182 -5.76 86223 -7.47 86956 0.85 89903 3.39 92389 2.77 93837 1.57 97036 3.41 TN TAXABLE SALES (MIL$)…………………………………… Percentage change…………………………………………… 78749 4.35 82725 5.05 88284 6.72 92705 5.01 95999 3.55 93236 -2.88 86219 -7.53 88395 2.52 93641 5.93 98041 4.70 100943 2.96 105877 4.89 TN AVG ANNUAL WAGE, NONFARM (2009$)……………... Percentage change…………………………………………… 38815 1.34 39485 1.73 39441 -0.11 40242 2.03 40847 1.50 40545 -0.74 40821 0.68 41444 1.53 41310 -0.32 41968 1.59 41473 -1.18 41961 1.18 TN AVG ANNUAL WAGE, NONFARM ($)………………....... Percentage change…………………………………………… 33993 3.35 35421 4.20 36388 2.73 38122 4.77 39664 4.04 40570 2.28 40822 0.62 42129 3.20 43022 2.12 44537 3.52 44613 0.17 45782 2.62 Center for Business and Economic Research, University of Tennessee Tennessee Econometric Model Historical Data 2004 250288 4.12 | 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT 2003 240376 2.34 TN GDP (Mil2009$) SAAR……………………………………… Percentage change…………………………………………… APPENDIX B 68 Historical Data 2008 2009 Table 2: Selected Per Capita U.S. and Tennessee Economic Indicators January 2016 Historical Data 2008 2009 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 TN GDP (2009$) SAAR………………………… Percentage change………………………… 41243 1.47 42514 3.08 42395 -0.28 42634 0.56 41561 -2.52 41406 -0.37 39356 -4.95 39661 0.77 40420 1.92 41335 2.26 41168 -0.40 41685 1.25 US GDP (2009$) SAAR………………….…… Percentage change................................ 45587 1.86 46887 2.85 48014 2.40 48830 1.70 49214 0.79 48633 -1.18 46878 -3.61 47673 1.70 48071 0.84 48777 1.47 49139 0.74 49964 1.68 TN GDP ($) SAAR……………………………… Percentage change………………………… 35441 3.56 37467 5.72 38370 2.41 39556 3.09 39616 0.15 40254 1.61 39356 -2.23 40001 1.64 41323 3.30 43303 4.79 43957 1.51 45272 2.99 US GDP ($) SAAR……………………………… Percentage change................................ 39540 3.89 41786 5.68 44167 5.70 46297 4.82 47903 3.47 48266 0.76 46878 -2.88 48255 2.94 49663 2.92 51321 3.34 52544 2.38 54304 3.35 TN PERSONAL INCOME (2009$) SAAR…… Percentage change................................ 33744 0.98 34611 2.57 34525 -0.25 35122 1.73 35434 0.89 35439 0.01 34589 -2.40 35162 1.65 35887 2.06 36860 2.71 36378 -1.31 36816 1.20 US PERSONAL INCOME (2009$) SAAR…… Percentage change................................ 37228 0.73 38147 2.47 38803 1.72 40188 3.57 40890 1.75 40972 0.20 39324 -4.02 39579 0.65 40728 2.90 41653 2.27 41238 -0.99 42157 2.23 TN PERSONAL INCOME ($) SAAR………… Percentage change................................ 29551 2.98 31048 5.06 31854 2.60 33271 4.45 34407 3.42 35461 3.06 34588 -2.46 35744 3.34 37376 4.57 39118 4.66 39133 0.04 40168 2.65 US PERSONAL INCOME ($) SAAR………… Percentage change................................ 32603 2.73 34222 4.97 35803 4.62 38071 6.34 39706 4.29 40998 3.25 39322 -4.09 40235 2.32 42419 5.43 44204 4.21 44362 0.36 45996 3.69 TN TAXABLE SALES (2009$)………………… Percentage change................................ 15427 1.45 15664 1.54 16051 2.47 16169 0.74 16096 -0.46 14981 -6.92 13721 -8.41 13735 0.10 14071 2.45 14306 1.68 14377 0.49 14710 2.32 TN TAXABLE SALES ($)……………………… Percentage change................................ 13511 3.46 14051 4.00 14809 5.40 15317 3.43 15627 2.02 14990 -4.08 13720 -8.47 13962 1.76 14655 4.97 15181 3.59 15465 1.87 16050 3.78 Tennessee Econometric Model Historical Data | | 69 APPENDIX B 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT Center for Business and Economic Research, University of Tennessee January 2016 | 2005 2006 2007 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 TN PERSONAL INCOME…………...……… Percentage change…………………… 196674 1.84 203762 3.60 205807 1.00 212564 3.28 217676 2.40 220441 1.27 217358 -1.40 222615 2.42 229291 3.00 238054 3.82 237442 -0.26 242848 2.28 WAGES AND SALARIES……………… Percentage change…………………… 104284 1.37 107774 3.35 109129 1.26 112922 3.48 115251 2.06 113521 -1.50 107965 -4.89 109400 1.33 110853 1.33 114827 3.59 115266 0.38 119019 3.26 OTHER LABOR INCOME……………… Percentage change…………………… 24968 6.51 26158 4.77 26715 2.13 25965 -2.81 26618 2.51 26803 0.70 25817 -3.68 25481 -1.30 26011 2.08 27860 7.11 27710 -0.54 27148 -2.03 PROPRIETORS INCOME……………… Percentage change…………………… 26618 -1.56 27967 5.07 26282 -6.02 27188 3.44 24205 -10.97 24017 -0.78 26095 8.65 26133 0.15 27896 6.75 29745 6.63 30953 4.06 32225 4.11 RENT, INTEREST, DIVIDENDS……… Percentage change…………………… 26736 0.15 26714 -0.08 27238 1.96 29476 8.22 31792 7.86 32598 2.53 30022 -7.90 30559 1.79 32056 4.90 34082 6.32 33543 -1.58 34428 2.64 TRANSFER PAYMENTS……………… Percentage change…………………… 32876 4.13 34138 3.84 35531 4.08 36559 2.89 39183 7.18 42789 9.20 46062 7.65 49595 7.67 49388 -0.42 48980 -0.83 49797 1.67 50249 0.91 LESS: PERS CONT FOR SOC INS… Percentage change…………………… 16506 1.61 16998 2.98 17219 1.30 17684 2.70 18051 2.07 17978 -0.40 17644 -1.86 17799 0.88 16140 -9.32 16314 1.07 18592 13.96 19059 2.52 RESIDENCE ADJUSTMENT…………… Percentage change…………………… -2302 1.76 -1991 -13.48 -1870 -6.09 -1861 -0.46 -1323 -28.93 -1309 -1.03 -958 -26.83 -753 -21.42 -772 2.58 -1126 45.87 -1235 9.70 -1163 -5.89 PER CAPITA PERSONAL INCOME ($)… Percentage change…………………… 33744 0.98 34611 2.57 34525 -0.25 35122 1.73 35434 0.89 35439 0.01 34589 -2.40 35162 1.65 35887 2.06 36860 2.71 36378 -1.31 36816 1.20 Center for Business and Economic Research, University of Tennessee Tennessee Econometric Model Historical Data 2004 | 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT Historical Data 2008 2009 2003 APPENDIX B 70 Table 3: Tennessee Personal Income Components (millions of 2009 dollars) Table 4: Tennessee Personal Income Components (millions of current dollars) January 2016 Historical Data 2008 2009 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 TN PERSONAL INCOME…………...……… Percentage change…………………… 172239 3.86 182791 6.13 189889 3.88 201367 6.04 211376 4.97 220580 4.35 217354 -1.46 226302 4.12 238810 5.53 252636 5.79 255422 1.10 264965 3.74 WAGES AND SALARIES……………… Percentage change…………………… 91328 3.38 96683 5.86 100686 4.14 106974 6.24 111913 4.62 113587 1.50 107961 -4.95 111211 3.01 115453 3.81 121860 5.55 123995 1.75 129859 4.73 OTHER LABOR INCOME……………… Percentage change…………………… 21866 8.62 23467 7.32 24646 5.02 24597 -0.20 25849 5.09 26819 3.75 25814 -3.75 25902 0.34 27092 4.59 29566 9.13 29807 0.81 29620 -0.63 PROPRIETORS INCOME……………… Percentage change…………………… 23310 0.39 25087 7.62 24254 -3.32 25754 6.18 23500 -8.75 24032 2.27 26099 8.60 26565 1.78 29057 9.38 31567 8.64 33297 5.48 35161 5.60 RENT, INTEREST, DIVIDENDS……… Percentage change…………………… 23414 2.14 23965 2.35 25134 4.88 27925 11.10 30876 10.57 32619 5.64 30017 -7.98 31066 3.49 33388 7.48 36172 8.34 36084 -0.25 37563 4.10 TRANSFER PAYMENTS……………… Percentage change…………………… 28792 6.19 30624 6.36 32780 7.04 34633 5.65 38051 9.87 42822 12.54 46064 7.57 50417 9.45 51434 2.02 51978 1.06 53568 3.06 54826 2.35 LESS: PERS CONT FOR SOC INS… Percentage change…………………… 14455 3.62 15248 5.48 15886 4.19 16752 5.45 17528 4.63 17989 2.63 17644 -1.92 18093 2.55 16810 -7.09 17313 2.99 20000 15.52 20795 3.98 RESIDENCE ADJUSTMENT…………… Percentage change…………………… -2016 3.78 -1786 -11.38 -1725 -3.43 -1763 2.22 -1285 -27.14 -1310 1.96 -958 -26.89 -765 -20.10 -804 5.11 -1195 48.63 -1329 11.18 -1268 -4.55 PER CAPITA PERSONAL INCOME ($)… Percentage change…………………… 29551 2.98 31048 5.06 31854 2.60 33271 4.45 34407 3.42 35461 3.06 34588 -2.46 35744 3.34 37376 4.57 39118 4.66 39133 0.04 40168 2.65 Center for Business and Economic Research, University of Tennessee Tennessee Econometric Model Historical Data | | 71 APPENDIX B 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT January 2016 | 2004 2005 2006 2007 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 TOTAL NONFARM………………………………… Percentage change………..……………… 2662.6 -0.10 2705.6 1.62 2743.0 1.38 2782.9 1.46 2797.8 0.53 2775.4 -0.80 2619.3 -5.62 2615.5 -0.15 2661.9 1.78 2715.3 2.00 2758.7 1.60 2816.1 2.08 NATURAL RESOURCES, MINING AND CONSTRUCTION……………………… Percentage change………..……………… 119.6 0.08 121.3 1.41 125.3 3.28 134.3 7.23 137.8 2.56 132.4 -3.90 109.9 -16.97 105.1 -4.37 108.7 3.43 108.9 0.17 107.8 -0.99 110.9 2.87 MANUFACTURING……………………………… Percentage change………..……………… 413.3 -3.56 411.8 -0.35 408.8 -0.74 399.4 -2.30 379.9 -4.87 360.9 -4.99 309.2 -14.33 299.0 -3.32 304.4 1.84 313.4 2.94 318.4 1.61 325.2 2.13 DURABLE GOODS…………………………… Percentage change………..……………… 250.9 -3.15 254.0 1.25 254.6 0.22 251.8 -1.11 237.1 -5.83 220.8 -6.85 181.8 -17.66 176.3 -3.04 183.7 4.21 193.9 5.55 198.9 2.54 205.5 3.36 NONDURABLE GOODS…………………… Percentage change………..……………… 162.4 -4.19 157.8 -2.82 154.2 -2.28 147.6 -4.25 142.8 -3.24 140.1 -1.91 127.4 -9.08 122.6 -3.72 120.7 -1.57 119.5 -1.04 119.6 0.11 119.7 0.09 TRADE, TRANSPORTATION, UTILITIES…… Percentage change………..……………… 578.7 0.30 587.8 1.58 598.0 1.73 607.4 1.56 610.7 0.54 600.3 -1.70 559.3 -6.82 555.0 -0.76 563.5 1.54 575.1 2.05 582.1 1.22 592.1 1.71 WHOLESALE TRADE……………………… Percentage change………..……………… 126.5 0.00 128.0 1.14 130.3 1.82 132.1 1.36 133.0 0.70 131.7 -1.00 120.7 -8.31 116.8 -3.26 117.9 0.96 120.5 2.21 121.8 1.09 123.3 1.22 RETAIL TRADE……………………………… Percentage change………..……………… 313.2 0.27 319.6 2.05 324.3 1.49 328.3 1.22 330.6 0.70 325.5 -1.55 306.9 -5.71 306.7 -0.06 309.2 0.81 312.8 1.18 315.0 0.68 320.8 1.86 TRANSPORTATION & UTILITIES………… Percentage change………..……………… 139.0 0.64 140.3 0.91 143.4 2.22 147.0 2.52 147.1 0.04 143.1 -2.70 131.7 -8.00 131.5 -0.12 136.4 3.75 141.8 3.89 145.4 2.54 148.0 1.81 INFORMATION………………………………… Percentage change………..……………… 51.2 -4.08 49.5 -3.31 49.4 -0.20 49.6 0.37 50.3 1.41 50.5 0.51 46.9 -7.27 45.0 -3.98 43.8 -2.74 43.2 -1.35 44.1 2.08 43.9 -0.36 FINANCIAL ACTIVITIES……………………… Percentage change………..……………… 139.8 1.15 141.9 1.46 143.3 0.99 143.6 0.20 144.8 0.89 145.1 0.18 140.5 -3.15 137.1 -2.45 136.5 -0.44 137.1 0.45 138.2 0.78 141.5 2.41 PROFESSIONAL & BUSINESS SERVICES… Percentage change………..……………… 287.3 -3.15 302.3 5.21 312.5 3.38 319.2 2.13 322.8 1.14 321.4 -0.43 293.6 -8.64 304.1 3.57 323.1 6.24 338.6 4.82 353.1 4.26 372.6 5.54 EDUCATION & HEALTH SERVICES………… Percentage change………..……………… 312.7 4.20 320.7 2.57 330.3 3.00 340.8 3.16 349.9 2.68 358.7 2.50 365.7 1.96 373.9 2.24 384.4 2.81 393.8 2.44 398.4 1.17 402.6 1.05 LEISURE & HOSPITALITY…………………… Percentage change………..……………… 246.7 2.81 253.6 2.82 262.1 3.34 270.1 3.07 276.2 2.23 273.7 -0.88 263.5 -3.73 262.0 -0.58 267.7 2.15 276.8 3.40 285.8 3.26 296.1 3.62 OTHER SERVICES……………………………… Percentage change………..……………… 102.3 0.62 101.7 -0.57 100.7 -0.99 101.7 0.99 104.0 2.33 104.5 0.42 102.0 -2.36 101.2 -0.82 102.0 0.85 104.3 2.21 105.6 1.27 105.8 0.21 GOVERNMENT………………………………… Percentage change………..……………… 411.1 0.20 415.0 0.96 412.7 -0.56 417.0 1.05 421.4 1.07 427.8 1.52 428.6 0.18 433.1 1.04 427.8 -1.22 424.1 -0.86 425.2 0.25 425.2 0.00 FEDERAL, CIVILIAN………………………… Percentage change………..……………… 51.2 -1.21 50.1 -2.23 49.2 -1.65 48.9 -0.64 48.8 -0.27 49.5 1.35 50.1 1.21 52.4 4.66 50.4 -3.77 50.2 -0.45 49.6 -1.23 47.9 -3.33 STATE & LOCAL……………………………… Percentage change………..……………… 359.9 0.41 364.9 1.41 363.4 -0.42 368.1 1.27 372.6 1.24 378.4 1.55 378.6 0.04 380.7 0.57 377.4 -0.87 373.9 -0.91 375.6 0.45 377.3 0.44 0.00 0.00 0.00 -0.01 0.00 0.00 0.01 0.00 -0.01 -0.01 0.00 0.01 | STATISTICAL DISCREPANCY (% )……… Center for Business and Economic Research, University of Tennessee Tennessee Econometric Model Historical Data 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT Historical Data 2008 2009 2003 APPENDIX B 72 Table 5: Tennessee Nonfarm Employment by Sector, Seasonally Adjusted (thousands of jobs) Table 6: Tennessee Durable Goods Manufacturing Employment (thousands of jobs) January 2016 Historical Data 2008 2009 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2011 2012 2013 2014 TOTAL DURABLE GOODS…………………… Percentage change………..…………… 250.9 -3.15 254.0 1.25 254.6 0.22 251.8 -1.11 237.1 -5.83 220.8 -6.85 181.8 -17.66 176.3 -3.04 183.7 4.21 193.9 5.55 198.9 2.54 205.5 3.36 WOOD PRODUCTS……………………… Percentage change………..…………… 16.7 -4.74 17.4 4.07 17.7 1.91 17.9 0.95 16.1 -10.14 14.3 -11.24 11.3 -20.84 10.9 -3.55 10.8 -1.07 11.0 2.25 10.9 -1.59 11.2 3.44 NONMETALLIC MINERALS……………… Percentage change………..…………… 15.6 2.94 15.7 0.64 15.9 1.73 16.1 1.05 15.5 -3.52 14.2 -8.38 11.6 -18.89 11.3 -2.05 11.8 4.20 12.5 5.80 12.1 -2.66 11.9 -1.94 PRIMARY METALS………….…………… Percentage change………..…………… 11.8 -6.74 12.1 2.90 12.0 -0.97 11.8 -1.55 11.7 -0.85 11.1 -4.97 9.0 -18.84 8.8 -2.68 9.2 4.66 9.7 4.89 10.0 3.19 10.1 0.99 FABRICATED METALS………………….. Percentage change………..…………… 41.4 -0.05 41.7 0.68 42.6 2.23 43.4 1.92 41.5 -4.46 39.7 -4.30 33.6 -15.37 33.0 -1.95 33.6 1.92 34.5 2.67 33.9 -1.67 34.4 1.35 MACHINERY………………………………… Percentage change………..…………… 33.2 -7.52 34.3 3.21 33.9 -1.16 33.2 -1.97 32.0 -3.69 31.2 -2.50 26.0 -16.63 24.8 -4.79 25.1 1.48 25.5 1.67 25.4 -0.70 25.7 1.44 COMPUTERS & ELECTRONICS………… Percentage change………..…………… 11.7 -9.59 11.3 -3.39 10.4 -7.48 9.3 -11.27 8.1 -12.55 7.4 -8.27 6.2 -16.07 5.6 -10.58 5.6 0.44 5.6 0.58 5.2 -7.24 5.0 -3.66 ELECTRICAL EQUIPMENT, APPLIANCES & COMPONENTS…………..…………… Percentage change………..…………… 23.6 -5.65 23.1 -2.22 23.5 1.65 23.2 -1.36 22.1 -4.66 20.6 -6.94 17.8 -13.52 16.9 -5.00 17.7 4.51 17.9 1.65 18.6 3.47 19.4 4.49 TRANSPORTATION EQUIPMENT……… Percentage change………..…………… 60.2 0.28 62.9 4.53 63.9 1.59 63.7 -0.27 58.6 -7.99 52.5 -10.46 40.4 -22.96 40.5 0.03 45.8 13.20 53.6 17.03 59.5 11.02 64.0 7.55 FURNITURE………………………………… Percentage change………..…………… 19.9 -6.59 19.6 -1.34 19.2 -2.04 17.7 -7.71 16.0 -9.72 14.2 -11.08 10.8 -24.26 9.7 -10.21 8.9 -7.73 8.7 -2.92 8.8 1.06 9.1 3.50 MISCELLANEOUS DURABLES………… Percentage change………..…………… 16.8 -1.76 15.9 -5.22 15.3 -3.83 15.3 0.16 15.4 0.18 15.5 0.98 15.0 -2.99 14.9 -0.68 15.2 1.83 14.9 -2.30 14.5 -2.25 14.7 1.26 Center for Business and Economic Research, University of Tennessee Tennessee Econometric Model Historical Data | | 73 APPENDIX B 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT 2010 January 2016 | 2005 2006 2007 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 162.4 -4.19 157.8 -2.82 154.2 -2.28 147.6 -4.25 142.8 -3.24 140.1 -1.91 127.4 -9.08 122.6 -3.72 120.7 -1.57 119.5 -1.04 119.6 0.11 119.7 0.09 FOOD……………………………………………… Percentage change………..………………… 35.9 -0.43 34.8 -3.04 34.3 -1.38 34.0 -0.97 32.7 -3.84 32.5 -0.62 32.3 -0.46 32.6 0.80 33.1 1.62 33.0 -0.24 32.4 -1.90 32.7 0.95 BEVERAGE & TOBACCO……………………… Percentage change………..………………… 6.1 -3.77 5.8 -6.12 5.4 -5.79 5.2 -4.31 5.1 -2.56 5.1 0.14 5.1 0.16 5.0 -1.64 5.0 0.18 5.2 3.51 5.3 2.58 5.4 1.88 TEXTILE MILLS, TEXTILE MILL PRODUCTS & APPAREL…………………… Percentage change………..………………… 21.3 -12.94 19.4 -8.85 18.0 -7.37 16.1 -10.55 15.1 -6.37 14.8 -2.09 12.6 -14.93 11.5 -8.35 10.7 -7.20 10.7 -0.07 10.5 -1.96 10.0 -4.53 PAPER…………………………………………… Percentage change………..………………… 19.6 -4.02 18.8 -3.92 18.9 0.72 18.3 -3.23 17.4 -5.06 17.2 -1.02 16.2 -6.13 15.7 -2.94 15.3 -2.53 14.7 -3.76 14.7 -0.17 14.6 -0.53 PRINTING & RELATED SUPPORT…………… Percentage change………..………………… 19.9 -3.16 19.6 -1.20 18.8 -4.32 17.8 -5.39 17.0 -4.51 15.7 -7.53 13.3 -15.27 11.4 -13.96 10.0 -12.93 9.6 -3.45 9.6 0.08 9.5 -1.73 CHEMICALS……………………………………… Percentage change………..………………… 28.6 0.36 27.6 -3.29 27.2 -1.76 26.3 -3.14 26.9 2.34 27.5 2.20 25.8 -6.17 25.0 -3.26 24.6 -1.63 24.4 -0.68 24.8 1.68 25.3 2.12 PLASTICS & RUBBER………………………… Percentage change………..………………… 28.2 -6.14 28.9 2.59 29.3 1.46 27.6 -5.76 26.6 -3.64 25.4 -4.39 20.4 -19.81 19.9 -2.49 20.5 2.90 20.0 -2.45 20.2 1.03 20.7 2.39 MISCELLANEOUS NONDURABLE GOODS… Percentage change………..………………… 2.8 -10.49 2.8 0.06 2.3 -20.22 2.3 3.32 2.1 -8.57 2.0 -9.00 1.8 -9.44 1.6 -10.87 1.7 4.82 1.9 14.67 2.1 12.41 1.5 -27.57 TOTAL NONDURABLE GOODS………………… Percentage change………..………………… Center for Business and Economic Research, University of Tennessee Tennessee Econometric Model Historical Data 2004 | 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT Historical Data 2008 2009 2003 APPENDIX B 74 Table 7: Tennessee Nondurable Goods Manufacturing Employment (thousands of jobs) Table 8: Tennessee Average Annual Wage and Salary Rate by Sector (2009 dollars) January 2016 Historical Data 2008 2009 2006 2007 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 39441 -0.11 40242 2.03 40847 1.50 40545 -0.74 40821 0.68 41444 1.53 41310 -0.32 41968 1.59 41473 -1.18 41961 1.18 NATURAL RESOURCES, MINING AND CONSTRUCTION……………………… Percentage change………..……………… 41700 0.85 41541 -0.38 42264 1.74 44071 4.27 45329 2.86 45128 -0.44 44526 -1.33 45426 2.02 45418 -0.02 45915 1.09 45734 -0.39 47214 3.24 MANUFACTURING……………………………… Percentage change………..……………… 45856 1.63 46892 2.26 46605 -0.61 47371 1.64 48006 1.34 48163 0.33 48923 1.58 51200 4.66 50738 -0.90 51667 1.83 50887 -1.51 51603 1.41 DURABLE GOODS…………………………… Percentage change………..……………… 45284 0.91 46069 1.73 45774 -0.64 46584 1.77 47071 1.04 47379 0.66 48242 1.82 50335 4.34 49667 -1.33 51259 3.21 49504 -3.42 50493 2.00 NONDURABLE GOODS…………………… Percentage change………..……………… 46742 2.74 48219 3.16 47976 -0.50 48721 1.55 49551 1.70 49402 -0.30 49884 0.97 52453 5.15 52365 -0.17 52336 -0.05 53188 1.63 53507 0.60 TRADE, TRANSPORTATION, UTILITIES…… Percentage change………..……………… 36969 0.91 37525 1.50 37797 0.72 38337 1.43 38926 1.54 38008 -2.36 37815 -0.51 38270 1.20 38519 0.65 38768 0.65 38217 -1.42 38716 1.31 WHOLESALE TRADE……………………… Percentage change………..……………… 51712 2.08 53743 3.93 54161 0.78 56196 3.76 57141 1.68 56361 -1.37 55941 -0.74 56904 1.72 57355 0.79 58788 2.50 57703 -1.85 59151 2.51 RETAIL TRADE……………………………… Percentage change………..……………… 26656 0.30 26489 -0.63 26583 0.36 26659 0.29 27206 2.05 26281 -3.40 26401 0.46 26841 1.67 26925 0.31 26719 -0.77 26129 -2.21 26483 1.36 TRANSPORTATION & UTILITIES………… Percentage change………..……………… 46786 0.52 47872 2.32 48297 0.89 48367 0.15 48796 0.89 47789 -2.06 47801 0.02 48376 1.20 48520 0.30 48338 -0.38 48078 -0.54 48212 0.28 INFORMATION………………………………… Percentage change………..……………… 46609 1.28 48212 3.44 48521 0.64 52767 8.75 52342 -0.81 51111 -2.35 51533 0.83 52405 1.69 54163 3.35 55156 1.83 54085 -1.94 55910 3.38 FINANCIAL ACTIVITIES……………………… Percentage change………..……………… 54730 5.52 56157 2.61 54620 -2.74 57508 5.29 58928 2.47 57322 -2.73 57385 0.11 60363 5.19 60287 -0.13 63326 5.04 61587 -2.75 63223 2.66 PROFESSIONAL & BUSINESS SERVICES… Percentage change………..……………… 39828 0.91 40484 1.65 40405 -0.20 41932 3.78 43665 4.13 44569 2.07 46282 3.84 46898 1.33 46076 -1.75 48591 5.46 48410 -0.37 47621 -1.63 EDUCATION & HEALTH SERVICES………… Percentage change………..……………… 40127 0.57 41473 3.35 42147 1.62 42295 0.35 42744 1.06 42642 -0.24 43665 2.40 43532 -0.30 42873 -1.51 42826 -0.11 42561 -0.62 42809 0.58 LEISURE & HOSPITALITY…………………… Percentage change………..……………… 19556 0.85 19545 -0.05 19397 -0.76 19858 2.38 20195 1.69 19686 -2.52 19666 -0.10 20077 2.09 19982 -0.47 20213 1.16 19675 -2.66 20158 2.45 OTHER SERVICES……………………………… Percentage change………..……………… 35909 2.17 37014 3.08 36314 -1.89 37234 2.53 36543 -1.85 36437 -0.29 37018 1.60 37008 -0.03 37199 0.52 37485 0.77 37216 -0.72 38866 4.44 GOVERNMENT………………………………… Percentage change………..……………… 37683 2.14 38100 1.11 38110 0.03 38495 1.01 38989 1.28 38902 -0.22 39122 0.57 39028 -0.24 39191 0.42 39090 -0.26 38890 -0.51 39409 1.33 FEDERAL, CIVILIAN………………………… Percentage change………..……………… 60785 4.50 63097 3.80 63215 0.19 63610 0.62 64920 2.06 63166 -2.70 64208 1.65 65783 2.45 68125 3.56 66962 -1.71 65699 -1.89 71860 9.38 STATE & LOCAL……………………………… Percentage change………..……………… 34395 1.71 34671 0.80 34709 0.11 35156 1.29 35593 1.24 35731 0.39 35805 0.21 35362 -1.24 35327 -0.10 35351 0.07 35353 0.01 35292 -0.17 75 Center for Business and Economic Research, University of Tennessee Tennessee Econometric Model APPENDIX B 2005 39485 1.73 | | 2004 38815 1.34 Historical Data 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT 2003 TOTAL NONFARM………………………………… Percentage change………..……………… Table 9: Tennessee Average Annual Wage and Salary Rate by Sector (current dollars) January 2016 2007 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 TOTAL NONFARM……………………………………………….. Percentage change………..……………………………… 33993 3.35 35421 4.20 36388 2.73 38122 4.77 39664 4.04 40570 2.28 40822 0.62 42129 3.20 43022 2.12 44537 3.52 44613 0.17 45782 2.62 NATURAL RESOURCES, MINING & CONSTRUCTION… Percentage change………..……………………………… 36519 2.86 37263 2.04 38995 4.65 41749 7.06 44020 5.44 45155 2.58 44523 -1.40 46175 3.71 47298 2.43 48723 3.01 49198 0.97 51513 4.71 MANUFACTURING…………………………………………… Percentage change………..……………………………… 40160 3.65 42067 4.75 42999 2.22 44875 4.36 46615 3.88 48192 3.38 48934 1.54 52048 6.36 52839 1.52 54829 3.77 54740 -0.16 56302 2.85 DURABLE GOODS……………………………………...... Percentage change………..……………………………… 39659 2.92 41328 4.21 42231 2.19 44128 4.49 45705 3.57 47412 3.74 48252 1.77 51167 6.04 51724 1.09 54394 5.16 53253 -2.10 55092 3.45 NONDURABLE GOODS…………………………….. Percentage change………..……………………………… 40936 4.78 43260 5.68 44266 2.33 46156 4.27 48119 4.25 49426 2.72 49896 0.95 53325 6.87 54531 2.26 55542 1.85 57215 3.01 58379 2.03 TRADE, TRANSPORTATION, UTILITIES…………. Percentage change………..……………………………… 32376 2.91 33663 3.97 34872 3.59 36317 4.14 37796 4.07 38030 0.62 37816 -0.56 38903 2.87 40116 3.12 41142 2.56 41111 -0.08 42242 2.75 WHOLESALE TRADE……………………………………. Percentage change………..……………………………… 45288 4.11 48212 6.46 49972 3.65 53236 6.53 55483 4.22 56395 1.64 55941 -0.81 57846 3.41 59732 3.26 62393 4.45 62073 -0.51 64537 3.97 RETAIL TRADE……………………………………………. Percentage change………..……………………………… 23344 2.30 23762 1.79 24525 3.21 25255 2.98 26417 4.60 26298 -0.45 26402 0.40 27285 3.34 28043 2.78 28353 1.11 28107 -0.87 28895 2.80 TRANSPORTATION & UTILITIES………………………… Percentage change………..……………………………… 40974 2.51 42943 4.81 44556 3.75 45819 2.84 47379 3.40 47815 0.92 47802 -0.03 49176 2.87 50528 2.75 51296 1.52 51719 0.82 52602 1.71 INFORMATION………………………………………………… Percentage change………..……………………………… 40816 3.28 43247 5.96 44752 3.48 49988 11.70 50817 1.66 51141 0.64 51535 0.77 53268 3.36 56408 5.89 58535 3.77 58179 -0.61 60999 4.85 FINANCIAL ACTIVITIES…………………………………..... Percentage change………..……………………………… 47931 7.61 50379 5.11 50399 0.04 54482 8.10 57219 5.02 57358 0.24 57388 0.05 61370 6.94 62787 2.31 67208 7.04 66252 -1.42 68979 4.12 PROFESSIONAL & BUSINESS SERVICES………………… Percentage change………..……………………………… 34880 2.91 36314 4.11 37273 2.64 39723 6.57 42403 6.75 44594 5.17 46283 3.79 47673 3.00 47982 0.65 51570 7.48 52074 0.98 51957 -0.22 EDUCATION & HEALTH SERVICES………………………. Percentage change………..……………………………… 35143 2.57 37206 5.87 38886 4.52 40065 3.03 41506 3.60 42670 2.80 43666 2.33 44252 1.34 44652 0.90 45448 1.78 45784 0.74 46707 2.02 LEISURE & HOSPITALITY…………………………………… Percentage change………..……………………………… 17126 2.85 17532 2.37 17896 2.07 18812 5.12 19610 4.24 19698 0.45 19666 -0.17 20409 3.78 20811 1.97 21450 3.07 21165 -1.32 21995 3.92 OTHER SERVICES…………………………………………... Percentage change………..……………………………… 31446 4.18 33199 5.57 33504 0.92 35272 5.27 35482 0.60 36458 2.75 37021 1.54 37619 1.61 38739 2.98 39779 2.69 40035 0.64 42406 5.92 GOVERNMENT……………………………………………….. Percentage change………..……………………………… 33000 4.16 34178 3.57 35159 2.87 36467 3.72 37858 3.82 38925 2.82 39120 0.50 39672 1.41 40817 2.88 41483 1.63 41834 0.85 42997 2.78 FEDERAL, CIVILIAN………………………………………. Percentage change………..……………………………… 53231 6.58 56597 6.32 58318 3.04 60258 3.33 63034 4.61 63202 0.27 64209 1.59 66876 4.15 70947 6.09 71056 0.15 70675 -0.54 78407 10.94 STATE & LOCAL…………………………………………... Percentage change………..……………………………… 30121 3.72 31103 3.26 32021 2.95 33304 4.01 34562 3.78 35753 3.45 35803 0.14 35946 0.40 36793 2.36 37515 1.96 38029 1.37 38505 1.25 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT Center for Business and Economic Research, University of Tennessee Tennessee Econometric Model Historical Data 2006 | 2005 | 2004 APPENDIX B 76 Historical Data 2008 2009 2003 Table 10: Tennessee Civilian Labor Force and Unemployment Rate January 2016 Historical Data 2008 2009 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 CIVILIAN LABOR FORCE (THOUS)………… Percentage change……………………… 2912 0.18 2880 -1.11 2901 0.73 3032 4.52 3062 0.97 3052 -0.32 EMPLOYED PERSONS (THOUS)………… Percentage change……………………… 2748 -0.29 2726 -0.81 2740 0.54 2874 4.89 2916 1.46 UNEMPLOYED PERSONS (THOUS)…… Percentage change……………………… 164 8.81 154 -6.01 161 4.17 158 -1.86 PARTICIPATION RATE (PERCENT)……… Percentage change……………………… 63.8 -0.73 62.4 -2.18 62.0 -0.66 5.6 5.4 5.5 UNEMPLOYMENT RATE (PERCENT)……… Center for Business and Economic Research, University of Tennessee 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 3050 -0.05 3088 1.23 3118 0.99 3091 -0.88 3054 -1.20 2993 -1.97 2845 -2.46 2727 -4.14 2790 2.32 2842 1.85 2850 0.28 2820 -1.03 2797 -0.84 145 -7.93 207 42.71 323 56.11 298 -7.95 276 -7.13 241 -12.79 233 -3.27 197 -15.69 63.7 2.78 63.3 -0.70 62.2 -1.67 61.4 -1.22 61.6 0.32 61.6 -0.06 60.3 -2.07 58.9 -2.36 57.1 -3.13 5.2 4.7 6.8 10.6 9.6 8.9 7.8 7.6 6.6 Tennessee Econometric Model Historical Data | | 77 APPENDIX B 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT January 2016 | Historical Data 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 TOTAL TAXABLE SALES………………………… Percentage change………..………………… 89918 2.32 92218 2.56 95680 3.75 97860 2.28 98872 1.03 93182 -5.76 86223 -7.47 86956 0.85 89903 3.39 92389 2.77 93837 1.57 97036 3.41 AUTO DEALERS………………………………… Percentage change………..………………… 10769 4.67 10529 -2.23 10224 -2.90 9911 -3.06 9788 -1.24 7935 -18.93 6724 -15.27 7546 12.22 8094 7.26 8743 8.02 9143 4.57 9689 5.98 PURCHASES FROM MANUFACTURERS…. Percentage change………..………………… 4490 5.59 4626 3.02 5205 12.52 4940 -5.10 4888 -1.06 4495 -8.04 3491 -22.33 3595 2.96 3850 7.09 3813 -0.94 3878 1.70 4089 5.42 MISC DURABLE GOODS……………………… Percentage change………..………………… 14719 3.00 15810 7.41 17170 8.60 18165 5.80 17964 -1.11 16339 -9.05 13748 -15.86 14258 3.71 14961 4.93 15433 3.15 15626 1.26 16089 2.96 EATING AND DRINKING PLACES…………… Percentage change………..………………… 7896 3.28 8309 5.24 8627 3.83 8935 3.56 9144 2.35 8968 -1.92 8841 -1.42 8909 0.78 9128 2.45 9611 5.29 9832 2.29 10259 4.35 FOOD STORES………………………………… Percentage change………..………………… 8966 -3.55 8849 -1.31 8884 0.40 8887 0.04 8992 1.17 8592 -4.44 8822 2.68 8740 -0.93 8849 1.24 9131 3.19 9373 2.65 9487 1.21 LIQUOR STORES……………………………… Percentage change………..………………… 495 4.10 510 3.20 536 5.09 578 7.76 612 5.86 636 3.89 657 3.37 673 2.48 699 3.75 747 6.93 778 4.06 819 5.36 HOTELS AND MOTELS………………………… Percentage change………..………………… 2079 0.51 2096 0.81 2215 5.66 2342 5.73 2425 3.56 2312 -4.66 2038 -11.84 2033 -0.25 2239 10.13 2345 4.74 2361 0.66 2642 11.91 OTHER RETAIL AND SERVICE……………… Percentage change………..………………… 26505 3.32 27074 2.15 27970 3.31 28642 2.40 29151 1.78 28220 -3.19 26806 -5.01 26871 0.24 27611 2.75 28444 3.02 28818 1.32 29891 3.72 MISC NONDURABLE GOODS………………… Percentage change………..………………… 7128 -1.69 7269 1.98 7613 4.72 7698 1.12 7990 3.79 7780 -2.63 7364 -5.34 7521 2.13 7670 1.98 7939 3.51 8081 1.79 8289 2.57 TRANSPORTATION, COMMUNICATION…… Percentage change………..………………… 6870 3.10 7146 4.02 7237 1.27 7763 7.27 7919 2.01 7905 -0.17 7731 -2.20 6808 -11.94 6803 -0.08 6182 -9.13 5946 -3.81 5782 -2.77 PER CAPITA ($)…………………………………… Percentage change………..………………… 15427 1.45 15664 1.54 16051 2.47 16169 0.74 16096 -0.46 14981 -6.92 13721 -8.41 13735 0.10 14071 2.45 14306 1.68 14377 0.49 14710 2.32 Center for Business and Economic Research, University of Tennessee Tennessee Econometric Model Historical Data 2004 | 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT 2003 APPENDIX B 78 Table 11: Tennessee Taxable Sales (millions of 2009 dollars) Table 12: Tennessee Taxable Sales (millions of current dollars) January 2016 Historical Data 2008 2009 2004 2005 2006 2007 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 TOTAL TAXABLE SALES………………………… Percentage change………..………………… 78749 4.35 82725 5.05 88284 6.72 92705 5.01 95999 3.55 93236 -2.88 86219 -7.53 88395 2.52 93641 5.93 98041 4.70 100943 2.96 105877 4.89 AUTO DEALERS………………………………… Percentage change………..………………… 9431 6.74 9444 0.14 9429 -0.16 9389 -0.43 9503 1.21 7938 -16.47 6725 -15.28 7672 14.07 8431 9.90 9279 10.05 9836 6.01 10572 7.49 PURCHASES FROM MANUFACTURERS…. Percentage change………..………………… 3933 7.69 4150 5.52 4803 15.73 4679 -2.58 4745 1.41 4497 -5.22 3491 -22.37 3654 4.68 4009 9.72 4047 0.94 4172 3.09 4461 6.93 MISC DURABLE GOODS……………………… Percentage change………..………………… 12892 5.06 14183 10.02 15845 11.72 17208 8.60 17440 1.35 16347 -6.27 13747 -15.90 14494 5.43 15583 7.52 16375 5.08 16810 2.65 17555 4.44 EATING AND DRINKING PLACES…………… Percentage change………..………………… 6915 5.34 7454 7.80 7960 6.79 8464 6.34 8880 4.91 8973 1.06 8840 -1.48 9057 2.45 9508 4.98 10200 7.28 10576 3.69 11194 5.84 FOOD STORES………………………………… Percentage change………..………………… 7852 -1.64 7937 1.09 8196 3.26 8419 2.72 8731 3.70 8601 -1.49 8821 2.57 8885 0.72 9217 3.74 9690 5.14 10083 4.05 10351 2.66 LIQUOR STORES……………………………… Percentage change………..………………… 433 6.17 458 5.71 495 8.10 548 10.63 594 8.51 636 7.05 657 3.32 685 4.17 728 6.31 793 8.94 836 5.49 894 6.86 HOTELS AND MOTELS………………………… Percentage change………..………………… 1821 2.50 1881 3.27 2044 8.67 2218 8.55 2355 6.15 2313 -1.78 2038 -11.87 2067 1.40 2333 12.85 2489 6.70 2540 2.04 2883 13.51 OTHER RETAIL AND SERVICE……………… Percentage change………..………………… 23213 5.37 24286 4.62 25806 6.26 27134 5.15 28304 4.31 28237 -0.24 26806 -5.07 27316 1.90 28758 5.28 30184 4.96 31000 2.70 32614 5.20 MISC NONDURABLE GOODS………………… Percentage change………..………………… 6243 0.27 6521 4.45 7024 7.72 7293 3.82 7758 6.38 7784 0.34 7364 -5.39 7646 3.82 7989 4.49 8425 5.46 8693 3.18 9044 4.04 TRANSPORTATION, COMMUNICATION…… Percentage change………..………………… 6016 5.15 6410 6.55 6682 4.23 7353 10.05 7689 4.57 7910 2.87 7729 -2.29 6921 -10.45 7085 2.37 6560 -7.42 6396 -2.49 6308 -1.38 PER CAPITA ($)…………………………………… Percentage change………..………………… 13511 3.46 14051 4.00 14809 5.40 15317 3.43 15627 2.02 14990 -4.08 13720 -8.47 13962 1.76 14655 4.97 15181 3.59 15465 1.87 16050 3.78 Center for Business and Economic Research, University of Tennessee Tennessee Econometric Model Historical Data | | 79 APPENDIX B 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT 2003 Table 13: Tennessee Gross Domestic Product by Sector (millions of 2009 dollars) | 2,333 14.70 2,676 14.70 2,575 -3.77 2,451 -4.82 2,313 -5.63 2,838 22.70 3,033 6.88 11,112 -2.59 10,171 -8.47 9,066 -10.86 8,995 -0.78 9,157 1.80 9,525 4.02 9,297 -2.39 9,461 1.77 MANUFACTURING............................................................................. 39,647 44,681 43,954 45,674 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. 3.78 12.70 -1.63 3.91 43,772 -4.16 42,827 -2.16 38,639 -9.78 39,488 2.20 41,425 4.91 44,136 6.54 44,914 1.76 46,110 2.66 DURABLE GOODS........................................................................ 22,702 25,103 26,116 27,090 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. 10.88 10.58 4.04 3.73 24,479 -9.64 24,898 1.71 20,627 -17.15 20,498 -0.63 23,023 12.32 25,302 9.90 25,593 1.15 26,450 3.35 WOOD PRODUCTS…………………………………………............. 622 655 705 730 History Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. -11.27 5.31 7.63 3.55 814 809 603 611 663 660 560 Table 14: Tennessee Average Annual Wage and Salary Rate by Sector, Seasonally Adjusted (current dollars) 2015:2 2015:3 January 2016 Forecast Data Annual 11.51 -0.61 -25.46 1.33 8.51 -0.45 -15.15 2015:4 2016:1 2016:2 2016:3 2016:4 2017:1 2017:2 2017:3 2017:4 2018:1 2014 2015 2016 569 1.59 2017 NONMETALLIC MINERAL PRODUCTS…………………………….. 1,547 1,675 1,497 1,335 1,332 1,112 875 959 1,068 1,089 1,030 1,033 PRIMARY METALS………….……………………………................. 990 1,134 1,121 1,075 853 848 767 875 993 1,159 1,219 1,228 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. 7.37 12.91 -4.09 7.15 -2.56 -13.03 -9.54 6.35 -3.36 2.34 -6.25 1.84 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. 6.02 -4.85 15.10 -6.93 -13.30 17.95 -23.60 -5.90 7.85 -8.89 17.90 1.67 TOTAL NONFARM……………………………………………….. 47346 47481 47891 48241 48586 48925 49266 49616 49956 50303 50649 50984 45782 47219 48755 50131 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. 14.09 1.14 8.27 -21.312.81 9.60 11.37 2.621.973.14 -5.42 0.31 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………………………… 10.68 3.50 -10.63 2.96 -10.82 2.89 2.82-0.22 2.82 -16.52 2.87 2.77 2.78 2.67 3.25 2.82 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………………….. 3.76 3.73 3.44 4.51 2.62 3.04 2.87 2.85 2.82 2.82 2.81 2.76 2.62 3.14 3.25 2.82 NATURAL RESOURCES, MINING & CONSTRUCTION…… 54764 56338 -1.15 56717 57094 57866 58296 59169 14.08 59609 60009 54695 57291 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. -19.905603614.55 -4.1057489 -20.65 -0.59 58734 -9.55 13.49 51513 16.72 5.18 58952 0.73 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………………………… 26.46 9.62 2.17 2.72 2.69 2.79 2.65 3.01 3.04 2.99 3.01 2.71 4.71 6.18 4.75 2.90 FABRICATED PRODUCTS…………………..3,965 4,601 2.59 4,483 3,5272.92 3,751 3,625 4.71 3,7106.18 3,478 3,542 % Chg Same QtrMETAL Last Yr……………………………….. 6.18 8.254,477 8.61 4,294 9.83 4.26 2.71 3,899 2.78 2.87 3.01 2.94 4.75 2.90 MANUFACTURING…………………………………………… 57619 58423 59116 59605 60062 60584 61081 61537 61954 62435 62929 63334 56302 57400 60333 62214 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………………………… 25.45 4.83 3,797 3.35 3.10 3.32 3,614 3.02 2.74 3.20 2.60 5.11 3.12 MACHINERY………………………………………………………… 3,467 5.703,299 3,534 3.52 3,064 2,7613.15 2,598 2,802 2.85 2,5531.95 3,010 3,060 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………………….. 2.58 4.07 3.24 9.48 4.24 3.70 3.32 3.24 3.15 3.06 3.03 2.92 2.85 1.95 5.11 3.12 DURABLE GOODS……………………………………...... 55869 56305 56988 57331 57693 58176 58650 59072 59451 59941 60460 60849 55092 55627 57962 59731 COMPUTER ELECTRONIC PRODUCTS…………… 2252 3.16 2868 2302 3.392752 40723.34 1210 1176 3.4512780.97 1,385 1,455 % Chg Prev Qtr&SAAR………..…………………………… 20.29 4.94 2561 2.43 2.55 3.30 3897 2.91 2.59 3.51 2.60 4.20 3.05 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. 95.15 2.5027.351.28 -10.70 19.55 4.493.03-70.28 -2.81 3.458.670.97 8.37 5.07 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………………….. 1.39 7.47 -10.11 3.26 3.32 2.92 41.61 3.04 3.05 3.09 3.01 4.20 3.05 NONDURABLE GOODS…………………………….. 60716 62180 62910 63681 64330 64949 65517 66055 66566 67057 67531 67993 58379 60542 64619 66803 ELECTRICAL EQUIPMENT, APPLIANCES Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………………………… 34.67 10.00 4.78 4.99 4.14 3.54 3.33 3.13 2.86 2.76 6.73 3.38 &%COMPONENTS………….………………… 2,590 2,583 2,828 3,090 3.91 2,487 3,088 2,9092.98 2,536 2,696 2.03 3,4843.71 3,070 3,139 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………………….. 4.70 6.82 6.65 12.98 5.95 4.45 4.14 3.73 3.48 3.24 3.07 2.93 2.03 3.71 6.73 3.38 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. 8.87 -0.27 9.49 9.26 -19.51 24.17 -5.80 -12.82 6.31 29.23 -11.88 2.24 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. 19.66 21.59 16.70 20.85 -24.94 -17.21 -55.23 143.37 42.34 21.64 8.40 5.89 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. -6.93 33.08 5.94 -14.90 -6.71 -15.98 -32.96 17.02 9.09 -15.74 -18.90 2.18 TRADE, TRANSPORTATION, UTILITIES…………. 42794 42887 43218 43594 43970 44311 44670 45047 45414 45778 46130 46497 42242 42707 44136 45592 MOTOR VEHICLES, BODIES & TRAILERS % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………………………… 8.51 0.87 3.12 3.53 3.50 3.13 3.28 3.42 3.30 3.24 3.11 3.22 2.75 1.10 3.35 3.30 &%PARTS………………………………… 4,127 2.025,018 7,077 3.32 5,312 1,9693.31 4,792 6,821 2.75 8,2971.10 8,994 9,524 Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………………….. 2.84 -0.79 5,856 3.97 2.75 3.36 4,398 3.33 3.28 3.27 3.22 3.35 3.30 WHOLESALE TRADE……………………………………. 65438 65107 65624 66259 66802 67371 67904 68436 68952 69463 69949 70508 64537 64934 67084 69200 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………………………… 12.31671-2.00 893 3.21 3.93 3.32 3.20 3.17 2.83 3.23 3.31 3.15 OTHER TRANSPORTATION EQUIPMENT……………………………………………………………………………………………………………… 946 805 3.45 751 631 3.054233.00 495 540 3.97 4550.61 369 377 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………………….. 2.85 0.78 -0.50 4.24 2.09 3.48 3.47 3.28 3.22 3.10 3.01 3.03 3.97 0.61 3.31 3.15 RETAIL TRADE……………………………………………. 29138 29534 29748 29973 30226 30443 30692 30946 31202 31466 31700 31933 28895 29193 30333 31329 FURNITURE…………………………………………………………….. 1,028 5.56 990 905 849 2.90 826 651 3.354713.43 423 404 2.80 4261.03 456 463 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………………………… 11.59 2.93 3.05 3.42 3.32 3.35 3.01 2.97 3.91 3.28 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. -7.80 3.31 -3.70 -6.19 3.07-2.71 -27.653.36-10.19 -4.49 2.805.451.03 7.04 1.63 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………………….. 2.77 -1.54 -8.59 5.72 3.73 3.17 -21.19 3.25 3.23 3.28 3.19 3.91 3.28 TRANSPORTATION & UTILITIES…………………………… 53522 53448 1,606 53897 54358 55162 55636 56519 2,248 56977 57407 53300 2,022 54539 56304 MISCELLANEOUS DURABLE GOODS……………… 1,443530481,511 1,69254738 1,805 1,951 56083 2,250 2,235 52602 2,191 2,060 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………………………… 2.58 -3.49 3.05 3.40 3.47 3.14 3.48 3.25 3.28 3.05 2.32 3.24 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. 3.07 4.71 6.29 5.35 2.826.68 8.09 15.333.15 -0.09 -0.58 1.71 -1.971.33 -7.71 1.86 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………………….. 2.70 1.23 -0.46 1.34 1.56 3.18 3.21 3.23 3.17 3.25 3.29 3.18 1.71 1.33 2.32 3.24 NONDURABLE GOODS…………………………………. 16,94563946 19,578 18,58465925 19,293 18,012 18,402 60999 18,834 19,660 INFORMATION…………………………………………………… 62396 6453617,838 65034 65505 66370 17,929 66806 67331 6786618,990 68396 68793 6323919,321 65708 67600 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. -4.4310.3115.54 4.18 2.593.82 0.463.22 5.43 -3.10 4.852.353.67 2.59 1.75 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………………………… 2.06 3.74 -8.89 3.12 2.93 2.73 -7.07 2.65 3.18 3.16 2.34 3.90 2.88 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………………….. 0.94 3.55 10.10 4.76 4.98 3.09 2.84 2.72 2.79 2.94 3.05 2.97 4.85 3.67 3.90 2.88 FOOD AND BEVERAGE & TOBACCO......................... 5,388 6,014 5,938 6,585 7,369 6,779 6,912 7,120 6,761 6,769 6,501 6,652 FINANCIAL ACTIVITIES…………………………………..... 70683 71949 -1.26 72635 73243 74348 74950 76033 76539 70721 73508 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. -3.427117711.62 10.9073807 11.91 -8.01 75522 1.96 3.01 77045 -5.04 689790.12 -3.96 75761 2.32 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………………………… 9.65 2.82 4.41 3.87 3.39 3.12 2.96 3.28 3.09 2.73 2.69 2.67 4.12 2.52 3.94 3.06 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………………….. 3.31 3.87 2.68 5.16 3.62 3.70 3.33 3.19 3.11 3.01 2.95 2.79 4.12 2.52 3.94 3.06 (CONTINUED ON NEXT PAGE) Historical Data CONSTRUCTION................................................................................ 11,484 11,434 11,319 11,407 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. -1.50 -0.44 -1.01 0.78 | 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT NATURAL RESOURCES & MINING...................................................................................................... 2,409 2,449 2,553 2,697 2,034 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. 9.00 1.66 4.25 5.64 -24.58 APPENDIX B 80 January 2016 Historical Data 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 GROSS DOMESTIC PRODUCT.......................................................................... 240,376 250,288 252,717 258,027 255,313 257,567 247,316 251,094 258,257 266,947 268,707 274,962 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. 2.34 4.12 0.97 2.10 -1.05 0.88 -3.98 1.53 2.85 3.36 0.66 2.33 Table 13: Tennessee Gross Domestic Product by Sector (millions of 2009 dollars) 27,151 5.83 4,398 25,606 -5.69 1,969 26,821 4.74 4,792 27,840 3.80 6,821 30,019 7.83 8,297 30,649 2.10 8,994 31,896 4.07 9,524 change……………………………………………………………………….. -6.93 11,341 33.08 11,330 5.94 11,608 -14.90 LEISUREPercentage & HOSPITALITY……………………………………..................... 11,047 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. 3.80 2.66 -0.10 2.45 FURNITURE…………………………………………………………….. 1,028 990 905 849 -6.71 11,606 -0.02 826 -15.98 11,020 -5.05 651 -32.96 10,285 -6.67 471 17.02 10,541 2.49 423 9.09 10,936 3.75 404 -15.74 11,292 3.26 426 -18.90 11,260 -0.28 456 2.18 11,602 3.04 463 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. 3.07 31,023 4.71 32,163 6.29 32,082 5.35 GOVERNMENT……………………………………………….............................. 30,991 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. -3.17 19,578 0.10 17,838 3.67 18,584 -0.25 NONDURABLE GOODS…………………………………. 16,945 6.68 30,235 -5.76 19,293 8.09 32,123 6.24 17,929 15.33 32,417 0.92 18,012 -0.09 30,570 -5.70 18,990 -0.58 31,473 2.95 18,402 -1.97 32,517 3.32 18,834 -7.71 32,264 -0.78 19,321 1.86 32,279 0.05 19,660 change……………………………………………………………………….. -3.42 21,778 11.62 23,656 -1.26 23,586 10.90 STATEPercentage & LOCAL…………………………………………........................ 21,412 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. -3.98 1.71 8.62 -0.30 11.91 21,778 -7.67 -8.01 24,264 11.42 1.96 24,627 1.50 3.01 22,832 -7.29 -5.04 23,826 4.35 0.12 24,944 4.69 -3.96 24,388 -2.23 2.32 24,556 0.69 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. 19.66 22,963 21.59 22,995 16.70 23,497 20.85 23,665 -24.94 25,297 -17.21 26,373 -55.23 26,477 143.37 27,224 42.34 27,967 21.64 EDUCATION & HEALTH SERVICES………………………........................... 21,501 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. 3.50 6.80 0.14 2.18 0.71 6.90 4.25 0.39 2.82 2.73 OTHER TRANSPORTATION EQUIPMENT……………………………………………………………………………………………………………… 671 893 946 805 751 631 423 495 540 455 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. -7.80 -3.70 -8.59 -6.19 OTHER SERVICES…………………………………………............................ 7,366 7,526 7,496 7,544 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. -2.96 2.17 -0.40 0.64 MISCELLANEOUS DURABLE GOODS………………1,443 1,511 1,606 1,692 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. -4.43 15.54 -8.89 4.18 FEDERAL.............................................…………………………………….. 9,579 9,245 8,507 8,496 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. -1.32 -3.49 -7.98 -0.13 FOOD AND BEVERAGE & TOBACCO......................... 5,388 6,014 5,938 6,585 Center for Business and Economic Research, University of Tennessee -2.71 7,201 -4.55 1,805 3.82 8,457 -0.46 7,369 -21.19 6,860 -4.74 1,951 -7.07 7,859 -7.07 6,779 -27.65 6,524 -4.90 2,250 0.46 7,790 -0.88 6,912 -10.19 6,479 -0.69 2,248 5.43 7,738 -0.67 7,120 -4.49 6,529 0.77 2,235 -3.10 7,647 -1.18 6,761 5.45 6,771 3.71 2,191 2.35 7,573 -0.97 6,769 8.40 28,398 1.54 369 7.04 6,608 -2.41 2,022 2.59 7,876 4.00 6,501 5.89 29,134 2.59 377 1.63 6,543 -0.99 2,060 1.75 7,722 -1.95 6,652 Tennessee Econometric Model APPENDIX B 81 25,656 1.11 5,312 | | PROFESSIONAL & BUSINESS SERVICES…………………………................. 24,214 25,269 25,285 25,374 MOTOR VEHICLES, BODIES & TRAILERS Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. 3.96 4.36 0.06 0.35 & PARTS………………………………… 4,127 5,018 5,856 7,077 Historical Data 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT January 2016 Historical Data 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 MILLS & GROSSTEXTILE DOMESTIC PRODUCT.......................................................................... 240,376 250,288 252,717 258,027 255,313 257,567 247,316 251,094 258,257 266,947 268,707 274,962 TEXTILE PRODUCT MILLS……………………………..675 725 618 668 582 615 421 369 295 332 455 448 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. 2.34 4.12 0.97 2.10 -1.05 0.88 -3.98 1.53 2.85 3.36 0.66 2.33 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. -6.38 7.41 -14.76 8.09 -12.87 5.67 -31.54 -12.35 -20.05 12.54 37.05 -1.46 NATURAL RESOURCES & MINING...................................................................................................... 2,409 2,449 2,553 2,697 2,034 2,333 2,676 2,575 2,451 2,313 2,838 3,033 PAPER……………………………………………………………………….. 2,285 2,402 2,462 2,746 2,348 2,385 2,590 2,709 2,452 2,610 2,683 2,731 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. 9.00 1.66 4.25 5.64 -24.58 14.70 14.70 -3.77 -4.82 -5.63 22.70 6.88 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. 1.78 5.12 2.50 11.54 -14.49 1.58 8.60 4.59 -9.49 6.44 2.80 1.79 CONSTRUCTION................................................................................ 11,484 11,434 11,319 11,407 11,112 10,171 9,066 8,995 9,157 9,525 9,297 9,461 PRINTING & RELATED SUPPORT……………………………………………………………………….. 1,211 1,233 1,256 1,304 1,276 1,237 1,093 1,064 1,041 995 1,121 1,140 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. -1.50 -0.44 -1.01 0.78 -2.59 -8.47 -10.86 -0.78 1.80 4.02 -2.39 1.77 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. 6.88 1.82 1.87 3.82 -2.15 -3.06 -11.64 -2.65 -2.16 -4.42 12.66 1.72 MANUFACTURING............................................................................. 39,647 44,681 43,954 45,674 43,772 42,827 38,639 39,488 41,425 44,136 44,914 46,110 CHEMICALS……………………………………………………………………….. 3,535 5,506 4,218 4,604 4,781 4,337 4,557 5,198 5,622 5,740 5,852 5,998 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. 3.78 12.70 -1.63 3.91 -4.16 -2.16 -9.78 2.20 4.91 6.54 1.76 2.66 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. -17.64 55.76 -23.39 9.15 3.84 -9.29 5.07 14.07 8.16 2.10 1.95 2.49 DURABLE GOODS........................................................................ 22,702 25,103 26,116 27,090 24,479 24,898 20,627 20,498 23,023 25,302 25,593 26,450 PLASTICS & RUBBER……………………………………………………………………….. 2,451 2,509 2,280 1,932 2,121 1,919 1,757 1,894 1,749 1,782 1,957 1,948 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. 10.88 10.58 4.04 3.73 -9.64 1.71 -17.15 -0.63 12.32 9.90 1.15 3.35 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. 1.49 2.37 -9.13 -15.26 9.78 -9.52 -8.44 7.80 -7.66 1.89 9.82 -0.47 WOOD PRODUCTS…………………………………………............. 622 655 705 730 814 809 603 611 663 660 560 569 MISCELLANEOUS NONDURABLE GOODS……………… 1,020 841 768 505 586 415 -25.46 470 395 275 397 -15.15 432 430 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. -11.27 5.31 7.63 3.55 11.51 -0.61 1.33 8.51 -0.45 1.59 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. 15.38 -17.55 -8.68 -34.24 16.04 -29.18 13.25 -15.96 -30.38 44.36 8.82 -0.37 NONMETALLIC MINERAL PRODUCTS…………………………….. 1,547 1,675 1,497 1,335 1,332 1,112 875 959 1,068 1,089 1,030 1,033 TRADE, TRANSPORTATION, UTILITIES………….....................……..................…….................. 48,398 50,717 52,831 54,084 53,733 52,319 47,471 49,142 49,883 50,770 50,708 51,765 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. 14.09 8.27 -10.63 -10.82 -0.22 -16.52 -21.31 9.60 11.37 1.97 -5.42 0.31 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. 6.09 4.79 4.17 2.37 -0.65 -2.63 -9.27 3.52 1.51 1.78 -0.12 3.20 PRIMARY METALS………….……………………………................. 990 1,134 1,121 1,075 853 848 767 875 993 1,159 1,219 1,228 WHOLESALE TRADE……………………………………...................... 16,648 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. -19.90 17,765 14.55 18,420 -1.15 19,025 -4.10 19,537 -20.65 19,414 -0.59 16,467 -9.55 16,740 14.08 16,876 13.49 17,612 16.72 17,935 5.18 18,426 0.73 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. 7.32 6.71 3.69 3.28 2.69 -0.63 -15.18 1.66 0.81 4.36 1.83 2.74 FABRICATED METAL PRODUCTS…………………..3,965 4,477 4,294 4,601 4,483 3,899 3,527 3,751 3,625 3,710 3,478 3,542 RETAIL TRADE……………………………………………......................... 18,926 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. 7.37 19,307 12.91 20,139 -4.09 20,156 7.15 19,928 -2.56 18,871 -13.03 18,229 -9.54 18,805 6.35 18,909 -3.36 19,184 2.34 18,864 -6.25 19,202 1.84 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. 7.40 2.01 4.31 0.08 -1.13 -5.30 -3.40 3.16 0.55 1.45 -1.67 1.79 MACHINERY………………………………………………………… 3,467 3,299 3,797 3,534 3,064 3,614 2,761 2,598 2,802 2,553 3,010 3,060 TRANSPORTATION & UTILITIES……………………………………………. 12,824 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. 6.02 13,645 -4.85 14,272 15.10 14,903 -6.93 14,268 -13.30 14,034 17.95 12,775 -23.60 13,597 -5.90 14,098 7.85 13,974 -8.89 13,909 17.90 14,137 1.67 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. 2.72 6.40 4.60 4.42 -4.26 -1.64 -8.97 6.43 3.68 -0.88 -0.47 1.64 COMPUTER & ELECTRONIC PRODUCTS…………… 2252 2868 2561 2302 2752 3897 4072 1210 1176 1278 1,385 1,455 INFORMATION…………………………………………………….................................... 6,339 6,897 7,424 -10.11 8,033 8,532 8,808 8,330 8,516 8,359 8,395 8,583 8,828 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. 95.15 27.35 -10.70 19.55 41.61 4.49 -70.28 -2.81 8.67 8.37 5.07 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. 4.53 8.80 7.64 8.20 6.21 3.23 -5.43 2.23 -1.84 0.43 2.24 2.86 ELECTRICAL EQUIPMENT, APPLIANCES FINANCIAL ACTIVITIES…………………………………............................ 36,980 & COMPONENTS………….………………… 2,590 35,988 2,583 35,367 2,828 36,027 3,090 37,767 2,487 38,658 3,088 39,929 2,909 41,490 2,536 42,980 2,696 43,242 3,484 43,188 3,070 44,311 3,139 Percentage 0.42 -2.68 -1.73 1.87 4.83 2.36 3.29 -12.82 3.91 3.59 0.61 -11.88 -0.12 2.60 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. change……………………………………………………………………….. 8.87 -0.27 9.49 9.26 -19.51 24.17 -5.80 6.31 29.23 2.24 January 2016 | NATURAL RESOURCES & MINING...................................................................................................... 1,796 2,098 2,150 2,369 2,097 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. 17.54 16.82 2.48 10.19 -11.48 2,590 23.51 2,676 3.32 2,894 8.15 3,297 13.93 3,135 -4.91 3,811 21.56 3,855 1.17 10,956 3.64 10,030 -8.45 9,066 -9.61 8,832 -2.58 9,123 3.29 9,767 7.06 9,867 1.02 10,454 5.95 MANUFACTURING............................................................................. 36,987 41,192 41,088 42,256 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. 5.11 11.37 -0.25 2.84 40,282 -4.67 40,068 -0.53 38,639 -3.57 38,898 0.67 40,805 4.90 45,296 11.01 46,913 3.57 48,671 3.75 DURABLE GOODS........................................................................ 22,764 25,800 26,011 23,410 Table 14: Tennessee Average Annual Wage and Salary Rate by Sector,25,106 Seasonally Adjusted (current dollars) 23,536 20,627 -12.36 19,878 -3.63 21,865 10.00 24,753 13.21 25,418 26,555 January 2016 2.69 4.48 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. 12.43 10.29 2.76 0.82 History -10.00 0.54 Forecast Data Annual WOOD PRODUCTS…………………………………………............. 893 2016:1 942 2016:2907 887 2017:1 8342017:2 603 631 2018:1 626 2014 664 654 2015:2 735 2015:3 2015:4 2016:3 2016:4 2017:3 2017:4 2015 2016 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. -6.37 21.50 5.49 -3.72 -2.21 -5.98 -27.70 4.64 -0.79 6.07 -1.51 674 2017 3.11 TOTAL NONFARM……………………………………………….. 47346 47481 47891 48241 48586 48925 49266 49616 49956 50303 50649 50984 45782 47219 48755 50131 NONMETALLIC MINERAL PRODUCTS…………………………….. 1,316 2.821,307 999 2.62 1,0603.14 1,055 1,080 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………………………… 10.681,283 1.14 1,401 3.50 1,333 2.96 2.89 2.82 1,039 2.87 2.77 8752.81 929 2.78 2.67 3.25 2.82 % Chg Same Qtr change……………………………………………………………………….. Last Yr……………………………….. 3.7611.66 3.73 9.20 3.44 4.51 2.62 2.87 -20.50 2.85 2.82 2.81 2.76 3.25 2.82 Percentage -4.85 -1.28 3.04 -0.68 -15.782.82 6.17 7.53 2.626.113.14 -0.47 2.39 NATURAL RESOURCES, MINING & CONSTRUCTION…… 54764 892 56036 1,305 56338 56717 574891,401 57866 58296 59169 1,105 59609 60009 54695 1,376 57291 58952 PRIMARY METALS………….……………………………................. 1,433 57094 1,672 1,410 58734 767 1,437 51513 1,484 1,357 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………………………… 26.46 9.62 2.17 2.72 2.69 2.79 2.65 3.01 3.04 2.99 3.01 2.71 4.71 6.18 4.75 2.90 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. -21.13 46.30 9.81 16.68 -16.21 0.64 -45.60 44.07 30.05 3.27 -7.28 -1.35 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………………….. 6.18 8.25 8.61 9.83 4.26 2.59 2.71 2.78 2.87 2.92 3.01 2.94 4.71 6.18 4.75 2.90 FABRICATED METAL PRODUCTS………………………… 3,474 60062 3,706 3,356 61954 3,527 3,361 56302 3,623 3,652 MANUFACTURING…………………………………………… 576193,016 58423 3,462 59116 59605 605843,696 61081 61537 62435 3,491 62929 63334 57400 3,503 60333 62214 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. 0.35 3.106.68 3.52 -0.27 -9.20 -3.72 2.857.801.95 -3.31 4.26 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………………………… 25.45 5.71 5.70 14.79 4.83 3.35 3.32 3.02 2.745.103.15 -1.02 3.20 2.60 5.11 3.12 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………………….. 2.58 4.07 3.24 9.48 4.24 3.70 3.32 3.24 3.15 3.06 3.03 2.92 2.85 1.95 5.11 3.12 MACHINERY………………………………………….……………………… 3,107 2,857 3,359 3,116 2,746 3,234 2,761 2,483 2,651 2,530 3,121 3,225 DURABLE GOODS……………………………………...... 55869 5.29 56305 -8.05 56988 57331 58176-11.87 58650 59072 59941 -10.07 60460 60849 55627 23.36 57962 59731 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. 17.57 57693 -7.23 17.77 59451 -14.63 6.77 55092 -4.56 3.32 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………………………… 20.29 3.16 4.94 2.43 2.55 3.39 3.30 2.91 2.59 3.34 3.51 2.60 3.45 0.97 4.20 3.05 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………………….. 1.393,655 2.50 4,245 1.28 3,515 7.47 3.26 2.92 4,010 3.04 3.05 3.09 3.01 4.20 3.05 COMPUTER & ELECTRONIC PRODUCTS…………… 2,866 3.323,086 4,0723.03 1,178 1,105 3.45 1,1870.97 1,297 1,325 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. -17.20 64330 -18.46 29.94 665661.55 -6.20 583797.42 9.27 66803 2.14 NONDURABLE GOODS…………………………….. 6071675.13 62180 16.14 62910 63681 64949 7.68 65517 66055 67057 -71.07 67531 67993 60542 64619 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………………………… 34.67 10.00 4.78 4.99 4.14 3.91 3.54 3.33 3.13 2.98 2.86 2.76 2.03 3.71 6.73 3.38 ELECTRICAL EQUIPMENT, APPLIANCES % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………………….. 4.70 6.82 6.65 12.98 5.95 4.45 4.14 3.73 3.48 3.24 3.07 2.93 2.03 3.71 6.73 3.38 & COMPONENTS........................................................ 2,169 2,118 2,358 2,636 2,211 2,829 2,909 2,470 2,593 3,558 3,203 3,343 TRADE, Percentage TRANSPORTATION, UTILITIES…………. 42794 5.70 42887 -2.35 43218 43594 44311-16.12 44670 45047 45778 -15.09 46130 46497 42707 44136 change……………………………………………………………………….. 11.33 43970 11.79 27.95 454142.83 4.98 42242 37.22 -9.98 45592 4.36 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………………………… 8.51 0.87 3.12 3.53 3.50 3.13 3.28 3.42 3.30 3.24 3.11 3.22 2.75 1.10 3.35 3.30 MOTOR VEHICLES, BODIES & TRAILERS % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………………….. 2.84 2.02 -0.79 3.97 2.75 3.32 3.36 3.33 3.28 3.31 3.27 3.22 2.75 1.10 3.35 3.30 & PARTS.................................................................................................................................... 6,188 66802 6,673 3,775 68952 1,969 5,945 64537 7,541 8,850 WHOLESALE TRADE……………………………………. 654384,983 65107 5,734 65624 66259 673714,877 67904 68436 69463 4,463 69949 70508 64934 8,264 67084 69200 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. 7.92 3.327.84 3.45-26.91 -47.843.00126.66 33.21 3.97 26.850.61 9.59 7.09 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………………………… 12.3116.86 -2.00 15.07 3.21 3.93 3.20 -22.60 3.17 3.05 2.83 3.23 3.31 3.15 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………………….. 2.85 0.78 -0.50 4.24 2.09 3.48 3.47 3.28 3.22 3.10 3.01 3.03 3.97 0.61 3.31 3.15 OTHER TRANSPORTATION EQUIPMENT……………………………………………………………………………………………………………… 581 790 862 754 709 596 423 494 545 470 392 410 RETAIL TRADE……………………………………………. 29138-3.17 29534 35.97 29748 29973 30443 -5.97 30692 30946 31466 16.78 31700 31933 29193 -16.60 30333 31329 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. 9.11 30226 -12.53 -15.94 31202 -29.03 10.32 28895 -13.76 4.56 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………………………… 11.59 5.56 2.93 3.05 3.42 2.90 3.32 3.35 3.35 3.43 3.01 2.97 2.80 1.03 3.91 3.28 FURNITURE…………………………………………………………………… 818 773 3.73729 3.07 734 578 3.23 4713.36 405 386 2.80 4231.03 453 468 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………………….. 2.77 895 3.31 -1.54 5.72 3.17 3.25 3.28 3.19 3.91 3.28 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. -8.30 -8.60 -5.50 -5.69 0.69 -21.25 -18.51 -14.01 -4.69 9.59 7.09 3.23 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. 3.50 2.42 5.39 4.67 7.33 6.78 20.00 -0.93 -0.54 -0.18 -5.11 3.44 TRANSPORTATION & UTILITIES…………………………… 53522 53048 53448 53897 54358 54738 55162 55636 56083 56519 56977 57407 52602 53300 54539 56304 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………………………… -3.49 1,483 3.05 1,563 3.40 3.47 3.14 1,875 3.48 3.25 3.28 3.05 2.32 3.24 MISCELLANEOUS DURABLE GOODS………………2.581,448 1,636 2.821,756 2,2503.15 2,229 2,217 1.71 2,2131.33 2,100 2,172 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………………….. 2.70 1.23 -0.46 1.34 1.56 3.18 3.21 3.23 3.17 3.25 3.29 3.18 1.71 1.33 2.32 3.24 INFORMATION…………………………………………………… 62396 63946 64536 65034 65505 65925 66370 66806 67331 67866 68396 68793 60999 63239 65708 67600 NONDURABLE GOODS…………………………...…………………. 14,223 16,245 2.59 16,872 18,0123.2219,020 20,5433.6721,495 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………………………… 2.06 10.31 16,086 3.74 15,288 3.12 2.93 2.73 16,532 2.65 3.18 3.16 18,940 2.34 4.85 3.90 22,116 2.88 Percentage -4.96 6.26 3.09 3.86 -2.02 -0.42 4.858.463.67 4.63 2.89 % Chg Same Qtr change……………………………………………………………………….. Last Yr……………………………….. 0.94-4.82 3.55 13.10 10.10 4.76 4.98 2.84 2.72 2.798.952.94 5.60 3.05 2.97 3.90 2.88 FINANCIAL ACTIVITIES…………………………………..... 706834,642 71177 5,010 71949 72635 738076,060 74348 74950 76033 7,010 76539 77045 70721 6,932 73508 75761 FOOD AND BEVERAGE & TOBACCO......................... 5,036 73243 5,442 6,052 75522 6,912 6,503 68979 7,019 7,263 % Chg Prev Qtr SAAR………..…………………………… 9.65-4.80 2.82 7.93 4.41 3.87 2.96 3.28 3.09 2.69 2.67 3.94 3.06 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. 0.52 3.398.06 3.1211.36 -0.13 14.212.73 1.42 -7.23 4.127.932.52 -1.24 4.78 % Chg Same Qtr Last Yr……………………………….. 3.31 3.87 2.68 5.16 3.62 3.70 3.33 3.19 3.11 3.01 2.95 2.79 4.12 2.52 3.94 3.06 (CONTINUED ON NEXT PAGE) Historical Data CONSTRUCTION................................................................................ 8,132 8,719 9,581 10,571 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. 3.11 7.22 9.89 10.33 | 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT Historical Data 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 GROSS DOMESTIC PRODUCT.......................................................................... 206,562 220,573 228,724 239,395 243,368 250,402 247,316 253,252 264,022 279,654 286,908 298,623 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. 4.44 6.78 3.70 4.67 1.66 2.89 -1.23 2.40 4.25 5.92 2.59 4.08 APPENDIX B 82 Table 14: Tennessee Gross Domestic Product by Sector (millions of current dollars) Table 14: Tennessee Gross Domestic Product by Sector (millions of current dollars) January 2016 Historical Data 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 250,402 572 247,316 421 253,252 369 264,022 332 279,654 358 286,908 486 298,623 475 2.89 -26.40 -1.23 -12.35 2.40 -10.03 4.25 5.92 2.59 4.08 3.44 7.83 35.75 -2.32 2,590 2,676 2,894 3,297 3,135 3,811 3,855 239 212 235 203 206 316 306 23.51 3.32 8.15 13.93 -4.91 21.56 1.17 3.46 -11.30 10.85 -13.62 1.48 53.40 -3.06 10,030 9,066 8,832 9,123 9,767 9,867 10,454 2,171 2,590 2,806 2,537 2,693 2,925 3,040 -8.45 -9.61 -2.58 3.29 7.06 1.02 5.95 6.42 19.30 8.34 -9.59 6.15 8.61 3.94 40,068 38,639 38,898 40,805 45,296 46,913 48,671 1,222 1,093 1,039 973 922 1,040 1,068 -0.53 -3.57 0.67 4.90 11.01 3.57 3.75 -6.50 -10.56 -4.94 -6.35 -5.24 12.80 2.67 23,536 20,627 19,878 21,865 24,753 25,418 26,555 548 470 521 551 848 785 820 0.54 -12.36 -3.63 10.00 13.21 2.69 4.48 -33.25 -14.23 10.85 5.76 53.90 -7.43 4.41 834 603 631 626 664 654 674 3,983 4,557 5,205 6,089 6,624 6,927 7,025 -5.98 -27.70 4.64 -0.79 6.07 -1.51 3.11 0.53 14.41 14.22 16.98 8.79 4.57 1.41 1,039 875 929 999 1,060 1,055 1,080 1,745 1,757 1,835 1,752 1,873 2,084 2,119 -20.50 -15.78 6.17 7.53 6.11 -0.47 2.39 -8.06 0.69 4.44 -4.52 6.91 11.27 1.69 1,410 767 1,105 1,437 1,484 1,376 1,357 50,336 47,471 49,691 51,450 53,880 54,604 56,848 0.64 -45.60 44.07 30.05 3.27 -7.28 -1.35 -0.16 -5.69 4.68 3.54 4.72 1.34 4.11 3,356 3,527 3,491 3,361 3,623 3,503 3,652 18,063 16,467 17,137 17,679 19,024 19,551 20,575 -9.20 5.10 -1.02 -3.72 7.80 -3.31 4.26 2.51 -8.84 4.07 3.16 7.61 2.77 5.24 3,234 2,761 2,483 2,651 2,530 3,121 3,225 18,647 18,229 18,950 19,436 20,249 20,108 20,732 17.77 -14.63 -10.07 6.77 -4.56 23.36 3.32 -3.59 -2.24 3.96 2.56 4.18 -0.70 3.10 4,010 4,072 1,178 1,105 1,187 1,297 1,325 13,626 12,775 13,604 14,335 14,607 14,945 15,541 29.94 1.55 -71.07 -6.20 7.42 9.27 2.14 1.27 -6.25 6.49 5.37 1.90 2.31 3.99 83 STATE & LOCAL…………………………………………........................ 16,890 18,060 20,381 21,192 2003 2004 2005 2006 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. -0.46 6.93 12.85 3.98 Center for Business and Economic Research, University of Tennessee 20,411 2007 -3.69 23,562 2008 15.44 24,627 2009 4.52 23,442 2010 -4.81 24,914 2011 6.28 26,564 2012 6.62 26,628 2013 0.24 27,394 2014 2.88 Tennessee Econometric Model APPENDIX B 8,817 3,343 2.90 4.36 48,619 4.81 8,850 7.09 33,779 5.80 410 4.56 31,611 4.21 468 3.23 12,599 5.21 2,172 3.44 7,439 1.54 22,116 2.89 35,930 2.10 7,263 4.78 8,537 -0.32 | 8,568 3,203 3.02 -9.98 46,390 2.46 8,264 9.59 31,928 3.57 392 -16.60 30,334 2.69 453 7.09 11,975 2.32 2,100 -5.11 7,326 0.34 21,495 4.63 35,192 1.67 6,932 -1.24 8,564 6.38 | 8,317 3,558 0.53 37.22 45,276 3.33 7,541 26.85 30,826 9.25 470 -13.76 29,538 4.65 423 9.59 11,703 7.16 2,213 -0.18 7,301 6.49 20,543 8.46 34,615 4.77 7,019 7.93 8,051 -0.90 Historical Data 2016 TENNESSEE ECONOMIC REPORT 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 GROSS DOMESTIC PRODUCT.......................................................................... 206,562 TEXTILE MILLS & TEXTILE PRODUCT MILLS.................................................................. 609 220,573 645 228,724 576 239,395 636 243,368 553 Percentagechange……………………………………………………………………….. change……………………………………………………………………….. 4.44 6.78 -10.70 3.70 4.67 -13.05 1.66 Percentage -13.25 5.91 10.42 NATURAL RESOURCES & MINING...................................................................................................... 1,796 2,098 2,150 2,369 2,097 APPAREL & LEATHER PRODUCTS……………………………………………………………………….. 415 371 311 246 231 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. 17.54 16.82 2.48 10.19 -11.48 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. -18.79 -10.60 -16.17 -20.90 -6.10 CONSTRUCTION................................................................................ 8,132 8,719 9,581 10,571 10,956 PAPER…………………………………………………………………………..... 1,857 1,894 1,971 2,334 2,040 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. 3.11 7.22 9.89 10.33 3.64 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. -2.26 1.99 4.07 18.42 -12.60 MANUFACTURING............................................................................. 36,987 41,192 41,088 42,256 40,282 PRINTING & RELATED SUPPORT……………………………………………………………………….. 1,192 1,203 1,258 1,350 1,307 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. 5.11 11.37 -0.25 2.84 -4.67 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. 6.33 0.92 4.57 7.31 -3.19 DURABLE GOODS........................................................................ 22,764 25,106 25,800 26,011 23,410 CHEMICALS……………………………………………………………………….. 727 690 860 651 821 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. 12.43 10.29 2.76 0.82 -10.00 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. 38.48 -5.09 24.64 -24.30 26.11 WOOD PRODUCTS…………………………………………............. 735 893 942 907 887 PLASTICS & RUBBER……………………………………………………………………….. 2,694 4,216 3,367 3,806 3,962 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. -6.37 21.50 5.49 -3.72 -2.21 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. -16.00 56.50 -20.14 13.04 4.10 NONMETALLIC MINERAL PRODUCTS…………………………….. 1,283 1,401 1,333 1,316 1,307 MISCELLANEOUS NONDURABLE GOODS……………… 2,087 2,057 1,909 1,780 1,898 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. 11.66 9.20 -4.85 -1.28 -0.68 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. -0.67 -1.44 -7.19 -6.76 6.63 PRIMARY METALS………….……………………………................. 892 1,305 1,433 1,672 1,401 TRADE, TRANSPORTATION, UTILITIES………….....................……..................…….................. 41,117 44,015 47,012 49,584 50,417 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. -21.13 46.30 9.81 16.68 -16.21 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. 6.09 7.05 6.81 5.47 1.68 FABRICATED METAL PRODUCTS………………………… 3,016 3,462 3,474 3,706 3,696 WHOLESALE TRADE……………………………………...................... 13,433 14,777 15,722 16,806 17,620 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. 5.71 14.79 0.35 6.68 -0.27 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. 6.21 10.01 6.40 6.89 4.84 MACHINERY………………………………………….……………………… 3,107 2,857 3,359 3,116 2,746 RETAIL TRADE……………………………………………......................... 16,634 17,306 18,478 19,034 19,342 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. 5.29 -8.05 17.57 -7.23 -11.87 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. 6.76 4.04 6.77 3.01 1.62 COMPUTER & ELECTRONIC PRODUCTS…………… 3,655 4,245 3,515 2,866 3,086 TRANSPORTATION & UTILITIES……………………………………………. 11,050 11,932 12,812 13,744 13,455 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. 75.13 16.14 -17.20 -18.46 7.68 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. 4.95 7.98 7.38 7.27 -2.10 ELECTRICAL EQUIPMENT, APPLIANCES INFORMATION…………………………………………………….................................... 6,812 7,357 7,722 8,220 8,614 8,801 8,330 8,464 8,273 & COMPONENTS........................................................ 2,169 2,118 2,358 2,636 2,211 2,829 2,909 2,470 2,593 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. 4.35 8.00 4.96 6.45 4.79 2.17 -5.35 1.61 -2.26 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. 5.70 -2.35 11.33 11.79 -16.12 27.95 2.83 -15.09 4.98 FINANCIAL ACTIVITIES…………………………………............................ 33,976 33,843 33,976 35,388 37,774 39,067 39,929 41,778 43,818 MOTOR VEHICLES, BODIES & TRAILERS Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. 3.04 -0.39 0.39 4.16 6.74 3.42 2.21 4.63 4.88 & PARTS.................................................................................................................................... 4,983 5,734 6,188 6,673 4,877 3,775 1,969 4,463 5,945 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. 16.86 22,162 15.07 22,784 7.92 23,695 7.84 25,012 -26.91 26,784 -22.60 25,606 -47.84 26,957 126.66 28,216 33.21 PROFESSIONAL & BUSINESS SERVICES…………………………................. 20,394 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. 5.33 8.67 2.81 4.00 5.56 7.08 -4.40 5.28 4.67 OTHER TRANSPORTATION EQUIPMENT……………………………………………………………………………………………………………… 581 790 862 754 709 596 423 494 545 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. -3.17 19,716 35.97 20,348 9.11 21,316 -12.53 22,356 -5.97 24,393 -15.94 26,373 -29.03 27,077 16.78 28,225 10.32 EDUCATION & HEALTH SERVICES………………………........................... 17,900 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. 6.83 10.15 3.21 4.76 4.88 9.11 8.12 2.67 4.24 FURNITURE…………………………………………………………………… 895 818 773 729 734 578 471 405 386 change……………………………………………………………………….. -8.30 -8.60 -5.50 10,303 -5.69 10,737 0.69 10,524 -21.25 10,285 -18.51 10,542 -14.01 10,921 -4.69 LEISURE Percentage & HOSPITALITY……………………………………..................... 8,898 9,339 9,705 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. 5.34 4.96 3.92 6.16 4.21 -1.98 -2.27 2.50 3.60 MISCELLANEOUS DURABLE GOODS……………… 1,448 1,483 1,563 1,636 1,756 1,875 2,250 2,229 2,217 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. 3.50 2.42 5.39 4.67 7.33 6.78 20.00 -0.93 -0.54 OTHER SERVICES…………………………………………............................ 5,803 6,116 6,339 6,639 6,595 6,533 6,524 6,649 6,856 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. -0.19 5.39 3.65 4.73 -0.66 -0.94 -0.14 1.92 3.11 NONDURABLE GOODS…………………………...…………………. 14,223 16,086 15,288 16,245 16,872 16,532 18,012 19,020 18,940 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. -4.82 26,016 13.10 28,019 -4.96 29,054 6.26 28,528 3.86 31,276 -2.02 32,417 8.95 31,470 5.60 33,038 -0.42 GOVERNMENT……………………………………………….............................. 24,747 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. 0.86 5.13 7.70 3.69 -1.81 9.63 3.65 -2.92 4.98 FOOD AND BEVERAGE & TOBACCO......................... 4,642 5,010 5,036 5,442 6,060 6,052 6,912 7,010 6,503 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. -4.80 7.93 0.52 8.06 11.36 -0.13 14.21 1.42 -7.23 FEDERAL.............................................…………………………………….. 7,857 7,956 7,638 7,862 8,117 7,714 7,790 8,028 8,124 Percentage change……………………………………………………………………….. 3.81 1.26 -3.99 2.93 3.24 -4.96 0.98 3.06 1.20