Terracycle Opportunities at UW - Stout A Feasibility Study Patrick Stariha Zach Renk Jon Hunter Table of Contents Background 2 Project Timeline 4 Project Proposals Walmart st 5 1 Congregational Church 7 Menomonie Food Co-op 9 UW – Stout 10 UW – Stout Pilot Implementation 12 UW – Stout Pilot Results 15 Terracycle Final Recommendations 16 References 19 Appendices A. Poster – Potential Collection Items 20 B. Poster – Final Collection Items 23 C. Terracycle In-Store Collection Methods 24 D. Key Contacts 26 E. E-Mail Trail 27 1 Description of Current Conditions Background: Terracycle is a small business which creates consumer products from pre- and post-consumer materials. Its purpose is to eliminate the idea of waste. This is done by creating national recycling systems for previously non-recyclable or hard-to-recycle waste. These recycling systems include brigades, groups of volunteers that collect and send waste to Terracycle. The waste is collected and converted to a wide variety of products and materials. To date, there are 2,176,013,042 people collecting trash; and 2,293,274,397 waste units have been collected. With the items collected, Terracycle then sends money to a charity of the collector’s choice. Terracycle has contributed over four million dollars to charity since the company was founded in 2001. This company is unique because it allows for people to set up brigades and send in collected items for free. Terracycle pays for shipping and postal costs (Terracycle: Outsmart waste, 2012). We believe the implementation of Terracycle could greatly benefit the Greensense organization at UW – Stout. Greensense is a student campus organization that is a collective group of individuals that try to raise awareness of the environment and sustainability through campus and community wide events. They are involved with creek clean-ups, Adopt-a-Highways clean-ups, Recyclemania, and Earth Week activities on campus. The implementation of a Terracycle collection program on campus could be a potential fundraiser for Greensense. Greensense would be the key stakeholder in this implementation, and could raise money for environmental projects on campus. Situational Analysis: Ink jet cartridges are difficult for people to recycle on campus. According to Sarah Rykal, UW – Stout Environmental Sustainability Coordinator, there is confusion about how to dispose of ink jet cartridges on campus. Because of her passion for the environment, Sarah currently mails cartridge recycling mailing bags to individuals who contact her. UW-Stout does not receive proceeds for recycling the inkjet cartridges. Each cartridge needs to be mailed individually in one of the designated bags (S. Rykal, personal communication, March 01, 2012). During a presentation to the Environmental Sustainability Steering Committee (ESSC), Camille Thorson stated that the University of Colorado Boulder has established a designated location for the collection of batteries and cell phones (C. Thorson, personal communication, April 13, 2012). She provided a photo to the ESSC to better illustrate the system (Figure 4). Discarded electronics and printer ink cartridges can have a hazardous long-term effect on the environment. The materials that house printer ink cartridges and the ink itself are potentially hazardous. The plastic material takes decades to decompose. Discarded electronics, printer ink cartridges, and their effects on the environment are important to understand. The environment is becoming contaminated with chemicals and non-biodegradable materials (The Effect of Discarded Printer Ink Cartridges on the 2 Environment, 2010). The ever-growing size of landfills continues to be a problem. Landfills are designed and built to store waste and are thought to be a safe containment of our garbage. However, there are countless hazardous wastes that are blended into the municipal waste stream – lead from batteries, mercury from light bulbs, heavy metals from TV and electronics, etc. When these hazardous waste streams find their way into municipal waste landfills, the contaminants can find their way into our drinking water. Also, land areas designated as landfills can pose serious damage to the soil for many generations, as that land cannot be used and converted into livable space. When waste is delivered to an incinerator it is usually sorted to remove recyclables from the waste stream. Even so, when the remaining municipal waste is incinerated, pollutants are emitted to the air. Typical emissions include CO2 (carbon dioxide), N2O (nitrous oxide), NOx (oxides of nitrogen) and NH3 (ammonia) (Johnke, 2010). Triple Bottom Line Analysis: Environmental – Extends the life of resources used. Terracycle creates items for consumers from the items collected and allows consumers to return these upcycled or recycled products at the end of their useful life. This closed loop system prevents items from being landfilled. The money generated from Terracycle will allow Greensense to fund environmental/sustainable projects on campus. Social - Boost economic need for shipping and jobs with Teracycle. More jobs can reduce the rate of unemployment and increase the quality of life for people. This can also provide an opportunity to educate the community on the importance of sustainability. Economic - This spurs the shipping economy, creates more job opportunities on Teracycle’s end, and extends the life of resources used. All proceeds would be sent to the nonprofit organization Greensense to be used exclusively for environmental/sustainable projects on campus. 3 Project Timeline Tuesday, February 14, 2012 Thursday, February 23, 2012 Tuesday, February 28, 2012 Thursday, March 01,2012 Thursday, March 01, 2012 Present overview of initial plan of attack to class/instructor Project work Project work Meet with Sarah Rykal and Juliana Lucchesi ‐ discuss opportunities on campus PROGRESS Report to class: how does the process currently work ‐ hand in draft overview Tuesday, March 06, 2012 Project work‐next steps: brainstorming and identifying possible solutions or changes to more sustainable practices. Determining a PLAN of action to examine feasibility/impacts of possible solutions. Thursday, March 08, 2012 Groups present overview of possible project proposals and plan to class/instructor Implement 1st collection bin in Jarvis Science Wing 360 Trash Blitz ‐ dumpster dive to compile data of potential Teracycle items in waste stream Project work Meet with Rob MacDougall ‐ discuss FCUCC opportunity for involvement PROGRESS Report to class: How feasible are the proposed solutions/changes? Determining focus. Hand in draft overview and basic analysis of proposals Group meetings with facilitator to discuss draft report and next steps Update instructors on recent and future actions Work on draft project report and documentation Meet with advisors to frame‐up final project Discuss/propose project to Environmental Sustainability Committee Project work/Present to Waste Reduction Work Group Hand in draft project report and partial documentation Host booth on campus for earth week Group meetings with facilitator to discuss draft report and final steps Project work Project work Hand in design project report and documentation Evaluate peers and individual contribution. STEM Expo presentation Possible date for final oral project presentations Tuesday, March 20, 2012 Wednesday, March 21, 2012 Thursday, March 22, 2012 Tuesday, March 27, 2012 Thursday, March 29, 2012 Tuesday, April 03, 2012 Thursday, April 05, 2012 Tuesday, April 10, 2012 Thursday, April 12, 2012 Friday, April 13, 2012 Tuesday, April 17, 2012 Thursday, April 19, 2012 Friday, April 20, 2012 Tuesday, April 24, 2012 Thursday, April 26, 2012 Tuesday, May 01, 2012 Thursday, May 03, 2012 Tuesday, May 08, 2012 Tuesday, May 08, 2012 4 Project Proposals Walmart Project Proposal Operational Details Present idea to Menomonie Walmart Use single store as a pilot trial for 4 weeks Provide collection bins Monitor and collect the items Sunday evenings at 7:00 PM Review and analyze data – push for a regional/statewide rollout if pilot trial proves beneficial Technical Factors Walmart’s willingness/ability to participate Bin separation – how would we do it? Bin location – around store? In entrance? Marketing/Awareness Resources Used Collection bins o Packaging student to build collection bins o Enough cardboard to build bins Shipping resources (shipping is free however resources are involved) o Ink, o Paper o Box to contain contents o Tape to close box Greensense Dale Buck – Shift Manager Terracycle Team Benefits of this location Walmart is one of the busiest places in Menomonie and the most popular place to purchase the products collected for Terracycle. With Walmart’s huge sustainable consciousness (Walmart Scorecard), this would be an ideal location for implementation. After a trial period at one location, there could be a possible nation-wide rollout, which could decrease the amount of material that goes into the waste stream/landfill. Results We contacted and met with the Shift Manager Dale Buck on Wednesday, February 22nd. Our ideas were proposed to him with a Power Point presentation asking if Walmart would have an interest in Terracycle. Dale requested more information, so we contacted Terracycle to figure out the logistics of implementing such a large scale brigade. Terracycle then provided us the illustrations in Appendix C. These show the 5 options that corporations are allowed to use to implement Terracycle collection at their site. This gave us a better understanding of the requirements, costs, and logistics of Terracycle. Due to the added cost to Walmart of implementing bins like those listed in Appendix C, Walmart is unable to participate. We tried to make contact with a corporate level employee, but were unsuccessful in that their e-mail system is an intranet and there are no employees at that level in Menomonie. Walmart was very reluctant to hand out any contact information that would have helped us. Due to rules within Walmart Corporation and the way Terracycle works, Walmart is unable to help us collect items. If Walmart were to put bins in their store, there would be a major cost associated with this – Walmart would have to pay Terracycle to help them pay for shipping and the upcycling of collected items. The way Terracycle receives funding is through companies that produce items they accept. For example, Frito Lay pays Terracycle millions of dollars so their chip bags can be sent in and upcycled into new products. Since this would be such a large scale operation, Walmart would have to sponsor this new brigade to cover the shipping and bin manufacturing (B. Stevens, e-mail, Feb. 23, 2012). Recommendations Dale was not able to make decisions and could not implement this into this one store. Those decisions need to be made from a corporate level. The implementation would start regionally to test feasibility for national roll out. We recommend not trying to implement Terracycle collection bins at Walmart unless a key corporate contact is identified. 6 st 1 Congregational Church and Our Saviors Lutheran Church Project Proposal Operational details Provide bin to local churches Create awareness of project within congregations 2 options: o Greensense responsible for collecting bins, separation, and sending to Terracycle (proceeds go to Greensense) o Church sets up an account with Terracycle and operate independently Proceeds go to church We provide a bin for incentive or if needed Technical factors Church’s willingness to participate Determine which operational systems to use Resources required Collection Bins o Packaging student to build collection bins o Enough cardboard to build bins Shipping resources (shipping is free however resources are involved) o Ink o Paper o Box to contain contents o Tape to close box Greensense Contact at every church involved Benefits of implementing at churches Churches are very good at getting their congregations to donate for good causes. The participation rate amongst their congregations is typically quite high. Each member of the congregation more than likely has products that are being collected and would be more than willing to donate for Terracycle. In addition, the church itself uses a lot of ink printing bulletins and flyers and could contribute greatly. Since churches are non-profit organizations, they may want to pursue this initiative themselves if a partnership with UW – Stout does not work out or if they want to do it as a personal fundraiser. Results 1st Congregational Church was very receptive. Pastor Rob McDougal discussed Terracycle with his committee after meeting with Patrick who explained the logistics of Terracycle. They chose to use the first option in the operational details (work with Greensense). The Church congregation requested a bin and collected items for two weeks as an Earth Week activity. At the end of this event, many items were 7 collected and $29.28 was raised. However, one unforeseen problem was the amount of electronic waste that cannot be used for Terracycle (Table 1). Most of the non-Terracycle items that still worked were donated to the Goodwill. Broken items will be recycled at Best Buy, Inc. TABLE 1: TERRACYCLE ITEMS COLLECTED FROM THE 1ST CONGREGATIONAL CHURCH EARTH WEEK COLLECTION. Recommendations Our recommendation is that Greensense continue to work with 1st Congregational Church. In the future, the congregation should be better educated about the specific items that are accepted for Terracycle to reduce the amount of electronic waste that can’t be used for Terracycle. We also propose communicating with other community churches about participating with the Greensense Terracycle project. 8 Menomonie Market Food Co-op Project Proposal Operational Details Present idea to General Manager – Crystal Halvorson Provide bin for collecting items Monitor bin and collect items as needed Technical Factors Menomonie Market Food Co-op willingness/ability to participate Bin location – in store or entrance Marketing/Awareness Collection and separation of materials Resources Used Collection Bins o Packaging student to build collection bins o Enough cardboard to build bins Shipping resources (shipping is free however resources are involved) o Ink o Paper o Box to contain contents o Tape to close box Greensense Terracycle Team Benefits of this location Menomonie Market Food Co-op is known for marketing to and attracting environmentally conscious consumers. We have observed that their current efforts with #5 (Polypropylene or PP) recycling is very successful since the collection bin is typically overflowing. Results th We contacted the General Manager, Crystal Halvorson, Thursday, April 27 by email and phone. The Terracycle project was well received until the concern of space was discussed. Currently, due to the #5 recycling effort, there is additional space available for a Terracycle collection bin. Crystal mentioned that there are plans to increase store size in the future, however that timeframe is unknown. Recommendations Due to the current space constraints, Terracycle cannot be implemented at the Menomonie Market Food Co-op. However, Greensense should stay in contact with Crystal to help build Terracycle into the business model when the store size in increased. 9 Operational Details UW – Stout Project Proposal Create awareness among students and faculty about Terracycle and the items that can be collected o Campus life Today emails o An advertisement on http://www.uwstout.edu/sustainability/ o Create a “Green Week Go” video to add to the series Provide collection bins Krista James, professor in the biology department at UW – Stout, has communicated that we can implement a bin in Jarvis Science Wing room 360 and in the biology department office area. Professor James has confirmed that she will allow her contact information to be placed on the bins with instructions to call her when the bin becomes full. She will then contact the appointed Greensense representative to empty the bin, sort items, and send to Terracycle (K. James, personal communication, March 20, 2012). All proceeds will be sent to the nonprofit organization Greensense to be used exclusively for environmental/sustainable projects on campus Options: o Bins in Jarvis Science Wing room 360 and Science professor’s office area. o Bins at each of the resident hall’s front desks o Bins in all restrooms with showers of residential halls o Bins side by side with all other recycling bins on campus o One universal collection site on campus – Memorial Student Center (MSC) Technical Factors University’s willingness to provide locations to implement bins Student and faculty participation Clear marketing/instructions Resources Required Links on http://www.uwstout.edu/sustainability/ Bins Locations on Campus Greensense representative – Krista James Life Cycle Analysis The university produced 311 tons of landfilled waste in 2010 (Greenhouse Gas Manual and Historical Documentation, 2011). Much of this waste includes materials and items that could potentially be collected for Terracycle (Appendix A). Results On April 13, 2012, Patrick Stariha gave a Terracycle project proposal presentation to the Environmental Sustainability Steering Committee (ESSC). Jeff Keenan, Stout Adventures Coordinator, raised the point that the current recycling and composting system on campus is very confusing. This lack of understanding is believed to reduce the degree of participation. When the proposed list of items was 10 displayed, Jeff recommended that we focus on a few higher valued items. The thought is that it would reduce confusion of what can be collected and could increase participation. He also said he would allow a bin in Stout Adventures and would call Krista James as needed for pickup (J. Keenan, personal communication, April 13, 2012). Patrick also presented to the Waste Reduction Work Group (WRWG) on April 17, 2012, and proposed implementing a collection bin in the Memorial Student Center (MSC) to collect the items listed in Appendix B. The idea was well received and Karen Lund, Interim Assistant Director of Operations and Services in the MSC, referred Patrick to Darrin Witucki, the Director of the MSC. A meeting was set up between Darrin, Patrick, and Sarah Rykal to discuss the opportunity for implementing a collection bin in the MSC. Darrin proposed we start with one bin on the lower level, located in a very visible area. He found a three slot container with side door key access in the Max R catalog and proposed that his office pay for the container since it’s important to maintain the professional image of the remodeled MSC. Greensense will be given a key to empty the bin as needed. Darrin will work on the wording and icons for the bin and will obtain the necessary approvals. The three slots would be for 1) ink jet cartridges, 2) all other items in Appendix B, and 3) battery recycling. Battery recycling is a possible new startup program that is unrelated to Terracycle. The proceeds earned from Terracycle will fund the battery recycling program (D. Witucki, personal communication, 1 May 2012). Greensense needs to follow up with Darrin Witucki at the beginning of the fall semester 2012 to learn of any progress Darrin made over the summer. Three cardboard Terracycle collection bins were implemented around campus: one in Stout Adventures, one in Jarvis 360, and one in the Biology Department office complex (Jarvis Hall Science Wing 331). These bins were designed and made by Jon Hunter in the packaging lab. Pictures and descriptions of acceptable items were glued to the top of the lids. Recommendations Keep current bins in Jarvis and at Stout Adventures. See final recommendations for more details on further implementation on campus. 11 UW – Stout Pilot Implementation Trial Campus Collection 1. Trash Blitz – On Wednesday, March 21st, Greensense organized an event called “Trash Blitz.” This event involved emptying the South Campus dorm dumpsters and separating trash from recyclables. This was an opportunity for us to help Greensense and our project by separating items that we can send to Terracycle. Throughout this three hour event there were multiple volunteers that helped the cause. Below is a picture of the volunteers (Figure 1). The original list of collectable items and the current collected items are listed in Appendices A and B, respectively. FIGURE 1: VOLUNTEERS SORTING RECYCLABLES AND ITEMS COLLECTED FOR TERRACYCLE AT TRASH BLITZ. 2. In-Class Bin – In Jarvis 360 we implemented a collection bin to collect the items listed in Appendix A. The main contributors to the collection bin were the students from our class and the Trash Blitz. The bin was made from C flute corrugated cardboard in the packaging lab on campus. The bin requires almost 15 square feet of corrugated (note these bins are temporary). Below are pictures of the collection bin in class and a layout of the design (Figures 2, 3). 12 FIGURE 2: COLLECTION BIN LOCATED IN JARVIS HALL 360 CLASSROOM WITH IMAGES AND DESCRIPTIONS OF WHAT IS BEING COLLECTED. 13 FIGURE 3: DRAWING OF CLASSROOM COLLECTION BIN WITH DIMENSIONS. THIS WAS THE MOST CONVENIENT SIZE FOR AREAS THAT DID NOT HAVE SPACE CONSTRAINTS. THIS DRAWING CAN BE USED TO REPLICATE THOSE BINS. THE BOARD WAS CUT AND SCORED ON THE KONGSBERG XL44 IN THE PACKAGING LAB. LAB ASSISTANTS ARE AVAILABLE DURING LAB HOURS TO CUT OUT DESIGNS. FILE FORMATS MUST BE PROVIDED IN .ACM FORM. 14 UW – Stout Pilot Implementation Results After collecting and sorting the items collected from the Trash Blitz and the class collection bin, the results and amount collected were recorded (Table 2). Product Quantity Price Total Cheese 23 $0.02 $0.46 Tortilla 2 $0.02 $0.04 Drink Pouch 8 $0.02 $0.16 $2.50 $0.00 $0.02 $1.80 $0.02 $0.00 1 $0.02 $0.02 99 $0.02 $1.98 4 $2.50 $10.00 23 $0.25 $5.75 Graphing Calc $2.00 $0.00 Cell Phones $0.01 $0.00 $0.02 $0.08 MP3 Player Candy Wrappers 90 Bear Naked Scotch Tape Chips Digital Cameras Ink Cartridge Beauty 4 Total $20.29 TABLE 2: THIS TABLE SHOWS THE RESULTS OF A 3 WEEK PILOT TRIAL. THIS DATA INCLUDES ITEMS FROM A CLASSROOM COLLECTION BIN AND SEPARATION OF TRASH FROM THE TRASH BLITZ. THE LIST OF THESE ITEMS CAN BE FOUND IN APPENDIX A. From collecting items in the classroom for 3 weeks and separating trash during Trash Blitz, about 4.5 pounds of acceptable items were collected to send to Terracycle. The only items gathered from the Trash Blitz were candy wrappers, chip bags, beauty products, cheese packaging, and drink pouches. After calculating the profit from each item collected, it is estimated that a total of $20.29 will be sent to Greensense from Terracycle. This data helped us understand that the majority of the funding came from the higher ticket items (Appendix B). These items, digital cameras, cell phones, ink cartridges, graphing calculators, and mp3 players, were collected in the classroom (360 Jarvis). This demonstrated that people will keep the environment in mind by saving these items for Terracycle. 15 Terracycle Final Recommendations University of Wisconsin – Stout Our recommendation is to establish a central collection station on the lower level of the MSC. Greensense students will be responsible for monitoring and emptying the bin, and mailing collection items to Terracycle. The Memorial Student Center (MSC) is the best location on campus due to the continuous flow of students, faculty, and staff walking through the building. Collecting high value and electronic items (digital cameras, cell phones, inkjet cartridges, graphing calculators, and MP3 players) will create the best funding option for Greensense campus sustainability initiatives. It also provides an opportunity to safely recycle potentially hazardous materials. We do not recommend installing new bins in other buildings. The estimated 540 pounds of potential items that could be collected does not justify increasing the number of collection bins across campus (Table 3). In addition, for permanent implementation, Karen Lund stated that the University would require the purchase of more aesthetically pleasing bins (K. Lund, personal communication, 1 May 2012). In addition to looking more professional, these bins would be more durable than corrugated cardboard bins. However, the permanent bin cost would outweigh the profits obtained from the program. Campus-wide Terracycle implementation could also prove difficult for Greensense members to monitor and empty collection bins. 5 dumpsters analyzed on the south campus residence halls Total per week Total estimate for one semester Total estimate for one year Items 251 x 4 Weight (lbs) 4.5 Estimate of all 20 residential dumpsters Items 1004 Weight (lbs) 18 x 15 weeks per semester 3,765 68 15,060 270 x 2 semesters per year 7530 135 30120 540 TABLE 3: THE ESTIMATED WEIGHT/NUMBER OF ITEMS THAT COULD BE COLLECTED FROM SOUTH CAMPUS RESIDENCE HALLS 16 To eliminate ink contamination, one bin should be used for inkjet cartridges and the other for electronic items. The appropriate marketing materials (visual aids and instructions) will be needed on the containers to inform participants of the rules (Figure 4). Ink Jet Cell phones, digital Cartridges players, and cameras, mp3 graphing calculators FIGURE 4: EXAMPLE OF PERMANENT COLLECTION BINS FOR INK CARTRIDGES, DIGITAL CAMERAS, GRAPHING CALCULATORS, AND CELL PHONES. The corrugated Terracycle collection bins currently located in Jarvis 360, the Biology Department office area, and Stout Adventures should remain in those locations. These areas are frequently visited by students and faculty that are conscious of recycling and aware of the Terracycle initiative. Krista James’ contact information will be applied to the bins. When notified that a bin is full, she will contact the appropriate Greensense representative to have the bin emptied. When funds are available for permanent bins we suggest using the same collection system as the MSC. A marketing program should be implemented that educates the campus community about the Terracycle program and the location of collection bins. Marketing could include, but is not restricted to Campus Life Today e-mails, Green We Go videos, and information posted on the Sustainability Stout Website. Greensense should set-up a separate bank account for Terracycle funds. In addition, Greensense should document the quantity of items collected and the amount of funds generated. Each fall and spring semester, this documentation should be presented to the Environmental Sustainability Steering Committee and the Greensense faculty advisors. 17 st 1 Congregational Church of Menomonie Continue working with the 1st Congregational Church to collect items during Earth Week. During the 2012 Earth Week collection, many items were collected and $29.28 was earned from Terracycle. However, one unforeseen problem was the amount of electronic waste that cannot be used for Terracycle (Table 1). In the future, the congregation should be better educated about the specific items that are accepted for Terracycle. Walmart It is our recommendation that Terracycle not be implemented at Walmart unless a corporate level employee is identified and is willing to propose the idea internally. All of the work and logistics should be carried out by Walmart Corporation in order to be successful. The Menomonie Market Food Co-op The Menomonie Market Food Co-op will not be able to participate in Terracycle due to space constraints. There has been talk of increasing store size, but until then Terracycle can’t be considered. Once the store expansion occurs, we recommend following up with the general manager to present the Terracycle project again. It would be a good idea to bring hard data to show the participation levels on campus and in the community. Shipping Collected Items When items are collected and sorted into their shipping containers, they are not able to be shipped by the United States Postal Service. They must be brought to a private industry drop off location, such as Marketplace Foods, Wisconsin Credit Union, etc. In addition, the shipping label must be taped or applied to the box prior to dropping it off. Non-Terracycled Electronic Waste We recommend that all collected electronic items that cannot be used by Terracycle be donated to charity (if they work) or taken to Best Buy, Inc for their e-waste recycling program. 18 References Johnke, B. (2010). Emissions from waste incineration . 455-468. http://www.ipccnggip.iges.or.jp/public/gp/bgp/5_3_Waste_Incineration.pdf Terracycle: Outsmart waste. (2012, April 19). Retrieved from http://www.terracycle.net/en-US/ The effect of discarded printer ink cartridges on the environment. (2010, October 23). printer ink catridges, http://www.printerinkcartridges.com/articles/the-effect-of-discarded-printer-ink-cartridges-on-theenvironment.html 19 Appendices Appendix A. Poster – Potential Collection Items: Materials accepted for Terracycle: The following poster can be used to applied to collection bins to advertise what is being collected. Materials Accepted for Terracyle Any brand and any size plastic tape dispensers and cores $0.02 each Any brand of used cheese packaging. Examples: string cheeses packages, individual singles wrappers, singles packages, shredded cheeses packages and all plastic cheese packaging $0.02 each Any empty brand or size chip bag $0.02 each Only Bear Naked® brand packaging which includes: Bear Naked granola bags, Bear Naked trail mix bags, Bear Naked Granola cookie boxes $0.02 each All brands or sizes of used cell phone; No house/portable phones, phone chargers or loose batteries are accepted through this program $0.01 each Any brand inkjet cartridges $0.25 each 20 Any brand or size MP3 player $2.50 each Any brand and size of: lipstick cases, mascara tubes, eye shadow cases, shampoo bottles, conditioner bottles, bronzer cases, foundation packaging, body wash containers, soap tubes, soap dispensers, lotion dispensers, shaving foam tubes (no cans), powder cases, lotion bottles, chap stick tubes, lotion tubes, face soap dispensers, face soap tubes, face lotion bottles, face lotion jars, eyeliner cases, eyeliner pencils, eye shadow tubes, concealer tubes, concealer sticks, lip liner pencils, hand lotion tubes, hair gel tubes, hair paste jars. No hair spray cans, nail polish bottles, and nail polish remover bottles accepted. $0.02 each Any brand and size candy wrappers. No candy boxes or gum packaging. $0.02 each Any kind of brand of drink pouches. We do not accept juice boxes at this time. $0.02 each Any brand of digital cameras $2.50 each All brands and styles of graphing calculators are acceptable $2.00 each We accept any tortilla and tostada packaging $0.02 each 21 This Brigade accepts any brand of tortilla and tostada packaging: tortilla plastic bags, tostada cello bags, tortilla plastic packaging $0.02 each We accept any brand and any size cereal bag. We do NOT accept cereal boxes or the plastic cereal lining found inside cereal boxes. $0.02 each The monetary value for each unit collected is paid to Greensense environmental club by Terracycle. All proceeds will be used solely for the investment of renewable energy sources on UW-Stout campus. 22 Appendix B. Poster – Potential Collection Items: Materials Accepted for Terracycle: The following can be used as a poster above or applied to collection bins telling people what is being collected. Materials Accepted for Terracycle All brands or sizes of used cell phone; No house/portable phones, phone chargers or loose batteries are accepted through this program $0.01 each Any brand inkjet cartridges $0.25 each Any brand or size MP3 player $2.50 each Any brand of digital cameras $2.50 each All brands and styles of graphing calculators are acceptable $2.00 each The monetary value for each unit collected is paid to Greensense environmental club by Terracycle. All proceeds will be used solely for the investment of renewable energy sources on UW-Stout campus. 23 Appendix C. Terracycle In-Store Collection Methods: The following are potential collection bins that can be utilized for collecting Terracycle items at Walmart. 24 25 Appendix D. Key Contacts Krista James Professor jamesk@uwstout.edu Martha Daines Professor dainesm@uwstout.edu Sarah Rykal Environmental Sustainability Coordinator rykals@uwstout.edu Juliana Lucchesi Student Sustainability Senator luchessij@my.uwstout.edu Greensense Key stakeholder organization greensense@uwstout.edu Dr. Rob MacDougal Pastor – First Congregational United Church of Christ robucc@wwt.net Terracycle (866) 967-6766 customersupport@terracycle.net Dale Buck Shift Manager – Walmart Dwbuck.s01819@stores.usa.walmart.com (715) 235-6565 Crystal Halverson Menomonie Food Co-op (715) 231-3354 26 Appendix E. E-Mail Trail: ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ Terracycle In-Store Collection Sent: Thu 2/23/2012 1:19 PM To: Stariha, Patrick Hi, Based on our conversation, you would be looking at either Option #1 or #6, which is where the store would oversee and manage the program. This deck is normally geared toward our brand partners, but in this case you'd be gearing it directly to the retailer. Terracycle would produce and ship the bin to the store (with a pre-paid return shipping label on the back of it), and there is a cost associated with each bin. What you would need to do is identify a sponsor for this program to cover that cost. Best, Brett Stevens Director, Retail Activation Terracycle, Inc. +1(609)393-4252 x3106 www.TerraCycle.net 121 New York Avenue Trenton, NJ 08638 ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ RE: Teracycle discussion Hi everyone, Can we move the 1:30pm Thursday meeting location to 225 Administration Building? We can meet in my office’s conference room. Thanks, Sarah Sarah Rykal Environmental Sustainability Coordinator University of Wisconsin-Stout 715.232.5254 www.uwstout.edu/sustainability 27 ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ From: Stariha, Patrick Sent: Thursday, February 23, 2012 11:03 AM To: Rykal, Sarah Cc: Renk, Zachary; Hunter, Jonathan Subject: FW: Teracycle discussion Hello Sarah and Juliana, My name is Zach Renk I’m currently in the Sustainability Capstone course. My partners and I have selected “Teracycle” as our semester project. I believe that Krista or Martha informed you that we would like to meet and go over the feasibility of implementing Teracycle on campus. If both of you are free today around 4:40pm to meet and discuss Teracycle that would be very much appreciated. If not could you please let us know your next available time to meet? Thanks for your time, Zachary Renk B.S. Packaging University of Wisconsin - Stout 1107 8th St E Menomonie, WI. 54751 (608) 220-7102 Email: renkz@my.uwstout.edu ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ Sent: Tue 3/20/2012 4:42 PM From: First Congo (Rob) To: Stariha, Patrick Patrick, Thanks for the info. We talked about your project at our church council meeting and they assigned a couple of people to work on this with you. Is there a time when we could get together to figure out what is possible for our involvement? What might be a time in your schedule between Tues - Fri next week? I usually just go by "Rob" so feel free to address me that way. Rob ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ From: Patrick Stariha To: First Congo (Rob) Cc: Hunter, Jonathan ; Renk, Zachary Sent: Tuesday, March 20, 2012 11:09 AM Subject: Terracycle Hello Dr. Reverend Rob MacDougall, 28 I just wanted to follow up with our previous conversation regarding the exciting opportunity with Terracycle. Attached is a document of all the materials that we are collecting. I hope this clears up any questions. If you have any questions or concerns I would be happy to answer them. Best regards, Patrick Stariha 218.341.1257 Thank you Sue! Hello Dr. Reverend Rob MacDougall, I am excited to be working on Teracycle for my capstone in Sustainability. Teracycle is an opportunity to: collect items that are not typically recyclable, save them from the landfill, and have them up-cycled or recycled into new products. An example is Capri Sun pouches that are made into purses, wallets, or bags. Another great aspect is that there are proceeds for each item collected. The proceeds go to a nonprofit organization or charity. I was wondering if you think the United Church of Christ Congregationalist may be interested in participating as a collection site? Greensense would manage the logistics of the collection: making the bin, sorting, and shipping when bin is full. If you think there may be an interest in the congregation, would you like to meet and discuss this exciting opportunity? Best regards, Patrick Stariha 218.341.1257 ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ From: Foxwell, Sue Sent: Thursday, March 01, 2012 8:23 AM To: Stariha, Patrick; James, Krista; First Congo (Rob) Cc: Hunter, Jonathan; Renk, Zachary Subject: RE: Terracycle Hi Patrick and all, I’m copying Dr. Reverend Rob MacDougall on this e-mail. As the minister of the church he would be a good one to initiate the discussion with. I am no longer the Moderator but I do believe that this is a project that the 1st Congregational Church would be interested in exploring with you. Rob can hook you up with the appropriate folks. Thanks so much for doing this---it’s a great idea!! Sue Sue Foxwell Research Administrator 29 152 Vocational Rehabilitation Bldg. University of Wisconsin-Stout Menomonie, WI 54751 715-232-2477 phone 715-232-1479 fax foxwells@uwstout.edu ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ From: Stariha, Patrick Sent: Wednesday, February 29, 2012 7:51 PM To: Foxwell, Sue; James, Krista Cc: Hunter, Jonathan; Renk, Zachary Subject: RE: Terracycle Hello Sue, I am excited to be working on Teracycle for my capstone in Sustainability. Teracycle is an opportunity to: collect items that are not typically recyclable, save them from the landfill, and have them up-cycled or recycled into new products. An example is Capri Sun pouches that are made into purses, wallets, or bags. Another great aspect is that there are proceeds for each item collected. The proceeds go to a nonprofit organization or charity. I was wondering if you think the United Church of Christ Congregationalist may be interested in participating as a collection site. Greensense would manage the logistics of the collection: making the bin, sorting, and shipping when bin is full. If you think there may be an interest in the congregation, would you like to meet and discuss the feasibility? Thank you for your time, Patrick Stariha 218.341.1257 From: Foxwell, Sue Sent: Wednesday, February 29, 2012 6:57 PM To: James, Krista; Stariha, Patrick Subject: Re: Terracycle Hello Krista and Patrick--I'm glad to help. Please let me know what you need. Sue Sent via BlackBerry by AT&T 30 ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ From: "James, Krista" Date: Thu, 1 Mar 2012 00:22:58 +0000 To: Stariha, Patrick Cc: Foxwell, Sue Subject: RE: Terracycle United Church of Christ Congregationalist Church. I’m ccing Sue Foxwell on this email. She’ll be able to help you connect with the right person. She works at Stout (Research Services), but is also on the Church board. Sue, Patrick is working on a senior capstone project to develop a feasibility study for Terracycling in Menomonie. This is a link to the Terracycle program: http://www.terracycle.net/en-US/ Krista C. James Environmental Science Applied Science Program Biology Department 327 Jarvis Hall Science Wing University of Wisconsin-Stout jamesk@uwstout.edu https://bluedrive.uwstout.edu/users/facultystaff/jamesk/wwwroot/index.htm 715-232-1557 ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ From: Stariha, Patrick Sent: Wednesday, February 29, 2012 5:17 PM To: James, Krista Subject: Terracycle Hello Krista, What was the name of the church that was mentioned during the Greensenes officers meeting on Monday? I would like to get in touch with them to discuss the opportunity of a collection bin there. Hope all is well, Patrick Stariha 31 ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ Sarah, Patrick Stariha, one of the students in the Sustainable Design and Development Capstone course, would like to present to the ESSC about Terracycle. He is requesting feedback from the committee about how to make sure the project is sustainable (after they graduate). He’s also looking for practical feedback about implementation. Will you please add Patrick’s presentation to the meeting agenda? I’m ccing Patrick and his other project team members on this email. Thanks! Krista C. James Environmental Science Applied Science Program Biology Department 327 Jarvis Hall Science Wing University of Wisconsin-Stout jamesk@uwstout.edu https://bluedrive.uwstout.edu/users/facultystaff/jamesk/wwwroot/index.htm 715-232-1557 ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ Sent: Tue 4/10/2012 2:21 PM From: Renk, Zachary To: mhendrickson@oslme.com Cc: Hunter, Jonathan; Stariha, Patrick Hello Pastor Hendrickson, My name is Zach Renk, and my group members and I are currently working on a senior capstone project to develop a feasibility study for Terracycling in Menomonie. Teracycle is an opportunity to: collect items that are not typically recyclable, save them from the landfill, and have them up-cycled or recycled into new products. An example is Capri Sun pouches that are made into purses, wallets, or bags. Another great aspect is that there are proceeds for each item collected. The proceeds go to a non-profit organization or charity. I was wondering if you think the Our Savior’s Lutheran Church may be interested in participating as a collection site. My team and I would manage the logistics of the collection: making the bin, sorting, and shipping when bin is full. For more information this is a link to the Terracycle program: http://www.terracycle.net/en-US/ If you think there may be an interest in the congregation, would you like to meet and discuss the feasibility? 32 Please let me know if you have any questions or concerns, Zachary Renk B.S. Packaging University of Wisconsin - Stout 1107 8th St E Menomonie, WI. 54751 (608) 220-7102 Email: renkz@my.uwstout.edu ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ From: Rykal, Sarah Sent: Monday, April 16, 2012 10:54 AM To: Stariha, Patrick Subject: RE: Waste Reduction Work Group Hi Pat, We’ll be meeting in the Glass Lounge at Price Commons. Do you want to limit the presentation to the first 15 minutes? We have other things to discuss that we need to get to. Thanks! Also, do you need a projector? Thanks, Sarah ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ Sent: Tue 4/17/2012 5:04 PM From: Rykal, Sarah <rykals@uwstout.edu> To: Stariha, Patrick <starihap@my.uwstout.edu>; Witucki, Darrin <WituckiD@uwstout.edu> Hi Darrin, We discussed this with Patrick at the Waste Reduction Work Group meeting today (Karen Lund was present) and the consensus of the group was very favorable. There was a lot of interest in implementing a couple bins to collect ink jet cartridges and some of the personal e-waste Patrick describes below. Would this be of interest to you? Thanks, Sarah ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ 33 From: Stariha, Patrick Sent: Tuesday, April 17, 2012 11:36 AM To: Witucki, Darrin Cc: Rykal, Sarah; Renk, Zachary; Hunter, Jonathan; James, Krista; Daines, Martha Subject: Opportunity for Electronic Waste Receptacle in MCS Hello Darrin, My group members and I are currently working on a senior capstone project to develop the feasibility of Teracycle on campus and in Menomonie. Teracycle is an opportunity to: collect items that are not typically recyclable, save them from the landfill, and have them up-cycled or recycled into new products. An example is Capri Sun pouches that are made into purses, wallets, or bags. Another great aspect is that there are proceeds for each item collected. The proceeds go to a non-profit organization or charity. We have signed Greensense up as the non-profit to receive the proceeds and the proceeds will be used exclusively for sustainable projects on campus that the University won’t/can’t fund. We were wondering if there would be an opportunity to have a bin in the MSC that specifically collects digital cameras, graphing calculators, mp3 players, and potentially one more for inkjet cartridges. We figure the MSC is a great hub that would be easy to create awareness/market. As the bins become full, a Greensense representative would be called to empty the bins and handle the logistics from there. An example of what this could look like is below but with the respective marketing information. The image below is from University of Colorado Boulder. Best regards, Patrick Stariha 34 Sources Johnke, B. (2010). Emissions from waste incineration . 455-468. http://www.ipccnggip.iges.or.jp/public/gp/bgp/5_3_Waste_Incineration.pdf Terracycle: Outsmart waste. (2012, April 19). Retrieved from http://www.terracycle.net/en-US/ The effect of discarded printer ink cartridges on the environment. (2010, October 23). printer ink catridges, http://www.printerinkcartridges.com/articles/the-effect-of-discarded-printer-ink-cartridges-on-theenvironment.html 35