UNCTAD Multi-Year Expert Meeting on Commodities and Development 2013 Recent developments and new challenges in commodity markets, and policy options for commodity-based inclusive growth and sustainable development Room XXVI Palais des Nations Geneva, Switzerland Review and outlook for Copper, Nickel, Lead and Zinc Don Smale Secretary-General International Lead and Zinc Study Group International Copper Study Group International Nickel Study Group 20 MARCH 2013 This material has been reproduced in the language and form as it was provided. The views expressed are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the views of UNCTAD. Review and outlook for Copper, Nickel, Lead and Zinc Don Smale Secretary-General International Lead and Zinc Study Group International Copper Study Group International Nickel Study Group UNCTAD Multi-year Expert Meeting on Commodities and Development Geneva, 20-21 March 2013 1 International Copper Study Group Introduction Formally established in 1992, following a series of UNCTAD expert meetings on copper. Headquarters in Lisbon, Portugal. Co-located with International Lead and Zinc Study Group and International Nickel Study Group since 2006. The Group is an intergovernmental organization consisting of 23 member governments plus the European Union representing copper producing and using countries International Copper Study Group 2 ICSG - MEMBERSHIP Membership is open to any country involved in copper production, consumption or international trade. Last two countries joining in 2011/2012: Zambia and Iran Current members are: Australia, Belgium, Chile, China, Finland, France, Germany, Greece, India, Iran, Italy, Japan, Luxembourg, Mexico, Peru, Poland, Portugal, the Russian Federation, Serbia, Spain, Sweden, the United States, Zambia and the European Commission. Possible new Member Countries: Mongolia, Brazil and DRC International Copper Study Group 3 ICSG - MAIN OBJECTIVES & FUNCTIONS To conduct consultations and exchanges of information on the international copper economy. To improve statistics on copper. To increase market transparency. To undertake studies on issues of interest to the Group. To consider special problems or difficulties that exist or may arise in the international copper economy. ICSG endeavours to provide its membership with the most accurate, comprehensive and timely information on capacities, production, usage, trade, stocks, prices, technologies, research and development, and other areas that may influence the supply and demand for copper. International Copper Study Group 4 A FORUM FOR DISCUSSION • Markets: forecasts of supply and demand for metals a year ahead • Trade: monitoring of international trade in metals • Environmental policy: sharing information on approaches to regulation • Industry Advisory Panel: metals industry executives provide input to member governments • Invite observer countries, industry and observer organizations such as UNCTAD, World Bank, UNIDO, Common Fund for Commodities and metals associations International Copper Study Group 5 ICSG MAIN PUBLICATIONS/OUTPUTS Directory of Copper Mines & Plants (semi-annual): The Directory of Copper Mines and Plants highlights current capacity and provides a five year outlook of forecasted capacity for over 1,000 existing and planned copper mines, plants and refineries on a country by country basis, including separate tables for SX-EW plants. Salient details for each operation are included and the Directory separates operations between Operating & Developing and Exploration & Feasibility stages. Directory of Copper & Copper Alloy Fabricators - First Use (annual): This directory provides a systematic global overview of companies and plants involved in the first use of copper. First users are mainly semis fabricators that process refinery shapes into semi-finished copper and copper alloy products. The Directory covers wire rod plants, ingot makers (for castings), master alloy plants, brass mills, and electrodeposited copper foil mills. Publication prices refer to orders originating from institutions based in ICSG member countries International Copper Study Group 6 ICSG MAIN PUBLICATIONS/OUTPUTS Copper Bulletin (monthly): includes annual and monthly statistics, by country, on copper mine, smelter, refined and semis production, copper usage and trade, as well as stocks and exchange prices, providing a global view of supply and demand. Statistical Yearbook : As above, covering the past 10 years. Monthly Press Release on the state of the copper market (to be included in the email distribution list please contact mail@icsg.org) World Copper Market Forecast: Prepared twice a year for the following two years. Copper Factbook: The Factbook provides a broad overview of all facets of copper, from production to trade, usage, recycling and more. It is designed to promote copper and educate readers about the importance and contribution of copper to society. Available in ICSG Website, in PDF and in hard copies. Publication prices refer to orders originating from institutions based in ICSG member countries International Copper Study Group 7 World Copper Reserves 2011 Resources: about 3000 million tonnes (Mt) Reserves 690 Mt contained copper metal 2011 Mine Production 16.03 Mt Not to scale Sources: USGS 8 International Copper Study Group World Copper Reserves 2011 Breakdown Source: USGS • Despite increased consumption of copper produced from ore in recent years, increases in reserves have grown more, and there is more copper available to the world than at any other time in the past. Kazakstan 1% DRC 3% Canada 1% Other 12% Chile 28% Zambia 3% Poland 4% Indonesia 4% Russia 4% China 4% Peru 13% United States 5% Mexico 6% Australia 12% Mexico accounts for around 6% of World Copper Reserves reported by USGS 9 Average annual grow rate in the last century: 4% Average annual grow rate in the last decade: 2.1 % Average annual grow rate in the last 3 years: 1.2% Source:10 ICSG 2012/2014 Main Global Assumptions for Mine Production Mine production growth averaged a disappointing 0.9% growth in the period 20082011 (concentrate growth was flat) However smaller and medium size mine projects stared in 2012 and 2012 production recovered from 2011operational constrains Capacity expansions occurring in Chile, Mexico and Peru 20,000 18,000 16,000 Mine sx-ew world Concentrates world 14,000 12,000 '000t Cu The 2008 crisis had a severe impact on copper projects development and the postponement of many projects: no new major project until 2012. 10,000 8,000 6,000 4,000 2,000 - 2006 8% 6% The supply constraint factors that have been affecting the copper industry in the last few years will expected continue to impact supply. 3% 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 World concentrate production growth World SX-EW production growth 7% Major mine projects start by end 2013 and in 2014 boosting world production (eg. Oyu Tolgoi) 2007 5% 4% 2% 1% 0% -1% 2007 World copper mine production expected to -2% grow by around 6% in 2013, after a growth of about 3% in 2012 International Copper Study Group 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 Source: ICSG 11 Distribution of Copper Mine Production by Country Brazil , 0.4% Iran , 0.7% Others, 16.3% Kazakhstan , 3.4% Poland , 3.6% 1990 Chile , 17.2% China , 3.2% Peru , 3.3% 2014 Brazil , 1.7% Iran , 1.6% Others, 10.0% Kazakhstan , 2.0% Poland , 2.2% Chile , 29.3% Mexico , 3.6% Congo , 4.4% Mexico , 3.6% Congo , 3.9% Indonesia , 1.8% Canada , 8.6% Zambia , 4.6% United States , 17.2% Russian Fed. ,Australia , 3.5% 8.7% Indonesia , 3.4% Canada , 3.6% Zambia , 4.9% Russian Fed. , 4.0% Australia , 6.3% China , 8.9% Peru , 7.4% United States , 7.2% Chile to continue the biggest copper mine producer in the world United States loosing share and Peru increasing its share Mexico maintaining the same share at around 3.6% Source:12 ICSG 2012/2014 Main Global Assumptions for Refined Production 2013 world refined production recovering from extended maintenances occurring in 2012 Chinese refined production continuing its strong expansion Expected improved capacity utilization rates at Indian refineries. Two new refineries that started in Turkey and in Kazakhstan in 2011 bringing new supply in 2012/2013 Primary electrolytic refinery production to remain constrained by shortage of concentrates World secondary production expected to grow by 11% in 2013 and share in total output to be around 19% World copper refined production expected to grow by around 6% in 2013, after a growth of about 2% in 2012 International Copper Study Group '000t Cu 2012 Japanese refined production recovered from low 2011 levels. (earthquake) 24,000 22,000 20,000 18,000 16,000 14,000 12,000 10,000 8,000 6,000 4,000 2,000 - World Refined Production 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 18.0% World primary refined production growth 16.0% World secondary refined production growth 2012 2013 2014 14.0% 12.0% 10.0% 8.0% 6.0% 4.0% 2.0% 0.0% 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 Source: ICSG 13 Distribution of Copper Refined Production by Country Others, 23.7% China, 5.2% 1990 Chile, 11.1% Japan, 9.3% Mexico, 1.4% Peru, 1.5% Belgium, 1.8% China, 30.0% Spain, 2.0% Mexico, 2.0% Australia, 2.2% Zambia, 3.3% Spain, 1.6% Peru, 1.7% Belgium, 3.1% Australia, 2.5% Zambia, 4.1% Poland, 3.2% Korean Rep., 1.7% India, 0.4% 2014 Others, 16.2% Poland, 2.5% United States, 18.7% Germany, 4.9% Russian Fed., 7.4% Korean Rep., 2.9% India, 3.2% Germany, 3.1% Russian Fed., 4.0% Chile, 13.3% Japan, 6.8% United States, 5.3% Strong growth in Chinese refined production, up from 5% of world share in 1990 to 30% by 2014 United States and Japan loosing share Mexico growing from 1.4% to 2% Source:14 ICSG 2012/2014 Main Global Assumptions for Usage Copper consuming sectors growth linked to the performance of the world economy. World GDP should pick up gradually during 2013/2014 supporting global usage growth. However regional divergences occur with lower growth in some regions than others. Globally, the downside risk remains elevated Stimulus packs by some governments supportive of usage growth Improved outlook for the US economy, lower wirerod imports and new wirerod plant positive for usage in 2012-2014 Uncertainty on EU sovereign debt issues and economy contraction negatively impacting usage in 2012 with small recovery anticipated for 2013 and 2014 Japan’s usage is expected to remain practically unchanged in the period 2012-2014 Indian urbanization and industrialization should continue to boost copper usage and supporting growth in 2013 and 2014. Unstable political situation in the Middle East and North Africa affecting usage in the region in 2011-2012 and only small growths expected for 2013-2014 Global green applications such as wind farms are a growing sector boosting world copper usage. Substitution remains a threat when copper prices remain high. In 2012, China apparent usage growth (+11%) inflated by high net cathode imports. However, anecdotal evidence suggests that the high imports were accompanied by an increase in inventories held in bonded warehouses. Chinese usage growth in 2013/2014 expected to be lower than in previous years. International Copper Study Group 15 Distribution of Copper Refined Usage by Country 1990 China , 5% Others, 26% United States , 20% Belgium , 1.3% Mexico , 1.5% Others, 15% Spain , 1.8% Turkey , 2.1% Belgium , 3.6% Mexico , 1.2% Spain , 1.3% Turkey , 0.9% Brazil , 1.3% Taiwan , 2.5% China , 42% Brazil , 2.1% Taiwan , 2.0% Germany , 9% Italy , 2.9% India , 3.3% Japan , 14.5% Italy , 4.4% India , 1.2% Russian fed. , 5.5% 2014 Korean Rep. , 2.9% Russian fed. , 3.1% Korean Rep. , 3.8% Japan , 4.6% United States , 9% Germany , 6% Strong growth in Chinese refined usage, up from 5% of world share in 1990 to more than 40% by 2014 United States share in world usage declining from 20% to 9% Mexico growing slightly from 1.2% to 1.5% Source:16 ICSG Major Uses of Copper: Usage by Region and End Use Sector, 2010 Basis: copper content, thousand metric tonnes Source: International Copper Association Europe 22% North America 10% Latin America 6% Building Construction 32% Equipment 54% Infrastructure 14% Asia 62% International Copper Study Group 17 ICSG World Copper forecast (Oct 2012) – summary table FORECAST TO 2013 REGIONS (1000 t) MINE PRODUCTION 2011 2012 REFINED PRODUCTION 2013 2011 2012 REFINED USAGE 2013 2011 2012 2013 Africa 1,306 1,396 1,712 961 1,064 1,326 281 256 262 N.America 2,150 2,244 2,536 1,706 1,701 1,886 2,202 2,241 2,340 Latin America 6,848 6,993 7,209 3,717 3,463 3,606 600 608 641 765 653 909 517 398 575 734 788 819 1,768 1,977 2,298 8,048 8,772 9,367 11,331 12,005 12,014 Asia-CIS 470 487 500 428 447 472 99 100 101 EU-27 788 804 814 2,716 2,768 2,790 3,295 3,137 3,207 Europe Others 832 853 870 1,080 1,049 1,095 1,202 1,120 1,173 Oceania 1,092 1,118 1,300 477 503 504 120 122 125 TOTAL 16,019 16,524 18,147 19,651 20,166 21,620 19,865 20,376 20,682 World adjusted 1/ 2/ 16,019 16,479 17,533 19,651 19,950 21,140 19,865 20,376 20,682 2.9% 6.4% 1.5% 6.0% 2.6% 1.5% -426 458 Asean-10 Asia ex Asean/CIS % change Refined Production - Usage Balance -214 1/ Based on a formula for the difference between the projected copper availability in concentrates and the projected use in primary refined production; 2/ based on average ICSG forecast deviations for pre-recession years 2003/2007. With production growth expected to exceed demand growth in 2013 and 2014, the market is foreseen to return to surplus after three years of consecutive deficits The International Copper Study Group recognized that numerous factors including a world economic slow down, European Union sovereign debt issues, political disturbances in the Middle East and North Africa, and market price volatility create significant uncertainty, and that the global market balances could vary from those projected 18 WORLD COPPER MINE CAPACITY BY REGION - 2012/2016 12,000 2012 10,000 10,263 2016 7,979 ('000t Cu) 8,000 5,892 6,000 3,699 4,000 4,133 3,938 2,190 1,976 2,225 2,000 3,043 1,254 1,494 0 Africa Asia Europe North America South America will remain the region with the largest copper mine installed capacity and is expected to bring to the market until 2016 an additional 2.3 Mt capacity. Asian and African copper mining capacity also increasing substantially. All together, these three regions represent 78% of the world additional copper mine production capacity to come on stream by 2016. South America Oceania GROWTH 2012-2016 Oceania South America North America Europe Asia Africa 0 500 1,000 1,500 2,000 2,500 Source: ICSG Directory of Copper Mines and Plants – February 19 2013 International Copper Study Group COPPER MINE PROJECTS (cap > 100Ktpy Cu) 600 550 500 Resolution Udokan 450 400 El Pachon Tampakan Las Bambas 350 Sentinel Michiquillay Cobre Panama 300 Toromocho Reko Diq Sierra Gorda Quellaveco Aynak 250 El Arco Galore Creek El Galeno Rio Blanco Mina Ministro Hales (Mansa Mina) Panantza Pebble Wafi Golpu Frieda River 200 150 La Granja El Relincho Deziwa & Ecaille C Agua Rica El Morro Qulong Tia Maria Caserones 100 King King Kamoa Altar Yandera Los Azules Junin Shaft Creek Cerro Casale 50 Total annual Capacity of Listed Projects : 9 Mt Cu 0 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 Source: ICSG Directory of Copper Mines and Plants – February 2013 International Copper Study Group 20 Projected Copper Smelter Production Capacity Increase by Country 2,000 1,750 Expected increase until 2016 1,500 1,250 ('000t Cu) 1,000 750 500 250 (1) Future possible new/expanded smelters in Mongolia, Egypt, Saudi Arabia , Brazil, Philipines, Indonesia and Tanzania Potential (1) Brazil Others Mexico Indonesia Zambia India Iran -250 China 0 China will continue to increase its smelting capacity through expansions and new projects. Some expansions, new projects occuring in other few countries Indonesi new mining law on banning ore exports leading to the development of new smelter projects in the country In August 2010 Grupo Mexico announced plans for a smelter/refinery project (Empalme) to start in Mexico in 2016 with a capacity of 350ktpy (development not yet confirmed) Source: ICSG Directory of Copper Mines and Plants – February 2013 International Copper Study Group 21 International Nickel Study Group An Autonomous International Governmental Organization Co-located in Lisbon, Portugal with International Lead & Zinc and Copper Study Groups, resulting in significant cost savings Enhancement of market transparency in the world nickel market Forum for discussions on nickel issues. INSG Member Countries Australia Brazil Cuba European Union Finland France Germany Greece Italy Japan Norway Portugal Russian Federation Sweden United Kingdom World Nickel Ore Production (2/2) in 1000 tonnes 2013 (f) (2154.7) 2003 (1257.3) Oceania 25% Europe 21% Africa 6% Asia 16% Africa 5% Oceania 19% Americas 32% Europe 18% Americas 23% Asia 36% (f) forecast October 2012; Asia adjusted in March 2013. World Primary Nickel Production (1/2) in 1000 tonnes (f) forecast October 2012; Americas, Asia and Europe adjusted in March 2013. World Primary Nickel Production (2/2) in 1000 tonnes 2013 (f) (1849.0) 2003 (1184.5) Americas 24% Asia 19% Africa 5% Oceania 15% Europe 37% Asia 41% Americas 18% Africa 3% Oceania 11% Europe 28% (f) forecast October 2012; Americas, Asia and Europe adjusted in March 2013. World Primary Nickel Usage (consumption) (1/2) in 1000 tonnes (f) forecast October 2012; Asia adjusted in March 2013. World Primary Nickel Usage (consumption) (2/2) in 1000 tonnes 2013 (f) (1755.2) 2003 (1218.6) Europe 41% Europe 21% Oceania 0.2% Oceania 0.2% Africa 2% Africa 3% Asia 43% Americas 14% Asia 67% Americas 10% (f) forecast October 2012; Asia adjusted in March 2013. World Primary Nickel Balance annual in 1000 tonnes (f) forecast October 2012; Americas, Asia and Europe adjusted in March 2013. Primary Nickel Capacity by Country New committed developments: 0.5Mt 2011: 1.7Mt CANADA 10% BRAZIL 7% CHINA P.R. 9% COLOMBIA 3% AUSTRIA 0% AUSTRALIA 8% ZIMBABWE 1% CANADA 10% NORWAY 2% CHINA P.R. 8% GREECE 1% VENEZUELA 1% UK 2% UKRAINE 1% SOUTH AFRICA 3% SERBIA (KOSOVO) 1% BRAZIL 27% CUBA 3% DOM. REP. 2% FINLAND 3% FRANCE 1% FYROM 1% INDONESIA 2% JAPAN 10% RUSSIAN FED. 19% NORWAY 5% CUBA 4% NEW CALEDONIA 23% KOREA 2% NEW CALEDONIA 3% Note: excluding NPI. JAPAN 6% MYANMAR 4% MADAGASCAR 11% New producing countries KOREA 5% New Nickel Capacity on Stream / Ramp Up Project Name / Country Product Mode Estimated Production Projected Total Production Remarks Ambatovy / Madagascar Class I Ramp Up ≈ 35 000 60 000 Open market Tagaung Taung / Myanmar FeNi Ramp Up ≈ 10 000 22 000 China Koniambo / New Caledonia FeNi Start Up ≈ 16 000 60 000 Open market Onça Puma / Brazil FeNi Ramp Up ≈ 30 000 58 000 Open market Barro Alto / Brazil FeNi Ramp Up ≈ 27 000 36 000 Open market Goro / New Caledonia Semi / Class I Ramp Up ≈ 26 000 60 000 Australia & China Ramu / PNG Semi Ramp Up ≈ 13 000 30 000 China & Other Talvivaara / Finland Semi Ramp Up ≈ 18 000 35 000 Finland Raventhorpe / Australia Semi Ramp Up ≈ 33 000 39 000 Australia & Other Santa Rita / Brazil Conc. Ramp Up ≈ 23 000 25 000 Brazil & Finland Kevitsa / Finland Conc. Start Up ≈ 9 000 10 000 Open market Long Harbour / Canada Class I Start Up ≈ 10 000 50 000 Mainly replacement Taganito / The Philippines Semi Start Up ≈ 6 000 30 000 Japan Note: no Chinese NPI projects included. World Nickel Ore Production 2010 to 2013 (f) in 1000 tonnes Area 2010 2011 2012 % change % change 2013 (f) % change Africa 80.1 79.5 -0.8 89.5 12.5 101.0 12.9 America 367.2 482.7 31.5 488.1 1.1 490.0 0.4 Asia 504.8 662.4 31.2 732.5 10.6 780.0 6.5 Europe 325.4 361.5 11.1 343.5 -5.0 377.7 9.9 Oceania 298.4 346.1 16.0 375.8 8.6 406.0 8.0 Total 1575.8 1932.3 22.6 2029.4 5.0 2154.7 6.2 (f) forecast October 2012; Asia adjusted in March 2013. World Primary Nickel Production 2010 to 2013 (f) in 1000 tonnes Area 2010 2011 2012 % change % change 2013 (f) % change Africa 36.0 36.4 1.0 41.7 14.6 56.5 35.6 America 229.0 272.4 18.9 295.2 8.4 332.0 12.5 Asia 538.0 628.7 16.9 724.4 15.2 750.0 3.5 Europe 501.6 525.1 4.7 511.6 -2.6 509.0 -0.5 Oceania 141.4 150.2 6.2 176.5 17.5 201.5 14.2 Total 1446.0 1612.7 11.5 1749.4 8.5 1849.0 5.7 (f) forecast October 2012; Americas, Asia and Europe adjusted in March 2013. World Primary Nickel Usage 2010 to 2013 (f) in 1000 tonnes Area 2010 2011 2012 % change % change 2013 (f) % change Africa 24.0 23.9 -0.4 25.3 5.9 27.2 7.5 America 153.2 165.0 7.7 168.7 2.2 180.3 6.9 Asia 929.4 1050.6 13.0 1105.7 5.2 1170.0 5.8 Europe 355.9 364.5 2.4 359.3 -1.4 374.9 4.3 Oceania 2.7 2.7 0.0 2.7 0.0 2.8 3.7 1465.2 1606.7 9.7 1661.7 3.4 1755.2 5.6 Total (f) forecast October 2012; Asia adjusted in March 2013. The impact of Asia and China Nickel Usage (Consumption) tonnes 1,800,000 1,600,000 1,400,000 1,200,000 1,000,000 World ex-Asia 800,000 600,000 Asia ex-China 400,000 China 200,000 0 2005 Asia: 47% China: 15% 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 Asia: 66% China: 46% Nickel Product Substitution • Europe & North America: – Nickel scrap units are replacing primary nickel in not only stainless steel, but also in alloyed steel and high nickel alloys where possible. • China PR: – Nickel Pig Iron (NPI) is replacing primary nickel and to some extent stainless steel scrap due to cost and easy availability. • India: – Nickel scrap units are increasing faster than primary nickel in stainless steel. • Conclusion: – The nickel market is changing all the time and currently nickel supply and demand is working differently around the world with China developing the usage of NPI and Europe, India & North America is going the scrap route more and more. Comments • What effect will the new nickel projects currently coming on stream and ramping up have on the market? • Nickel pig iron production and usage in China: – what effect would that have on the world nickel market, including ore availability, price and scrap? • Will nickel remain an attractive investment object and store of value in the future? ILZSG Overview Intergovernmental organization set up within the UN system Significant level of industry representation Established by UN in 1959 in New York Moved to London in 1977 From start of 2006 ILZSG, ICSG & INSG co-located in Lisbon, Portugal www.icsg.org www.insg.org 38 38 ILZSG Membership Membership open to any country involved in lead and/or zinc production, usage, or trade. 30 members (>85% of global lead/zinc industry): Australia Germany Morocco Serbia Belgium India Namibia South Africa Brazil Iran Netherlands Sweden Bulgaria Ireland Norway Thailand Canada Italy Peru United States China Japan Poland Finland Korea Rep. Mexico Portugal European Community France Russian Fed. 39 39 ILZSG Main Publications 50% Discount For companies based in member countries Lead and Zinc Statistics: ILZSG’s Monthly Statistical Bulletin Lead and Zinc New Mine and Smelter Projects 2013 Study on Chinese Zn First Use Market 2012 The By-Products of Copper, Zinc, Lead and Nickel Indian Lead Market 2012 The Market for Lead: Fundamentals Driving Change 2012 World Directory: Primary and Secondary Lead Plants 2011 Environment and Health Controls on Lead 2011 Environment and Health Controls on Zinc 2011 China Lead Acid Battery Market (prepared for ILZSG by BGRIMM) China Zinc Recycling Industry (prepared for ILZSG by BGRIMM) 40 World Zinc Reserves 2011 Resources: about 1900 million tonnes (Mt) Reserve Base 480 Mt Not to scale Reserves 250 Mt contained zinc metal Mine Production 13.0 Mt Sources: USGS, ILZSG 41 World Zinc Reserves 2011 Breakdown • Despite increased consumption of zinc produced from ore in recent years, increases in reserves have grown more, and there is more zinc available to the world than at any other time in the past. China 17% Australia 22% Source: USGS Peru 7% Kazakhstan 5% Mexico 7% Other 35% USA 5% Canada 2% Mexico accounts for 7% of World Zinc Reserves 42 Falling Lead and Zinc Mine Grades % Zn % Pb 7,5 2,8 Zn (LHS) 7,3 2,7 7,1 Pb (RHS) 2,6 6,9 2,5 6,7 6,5 2,4 6,3 2,3 6,1 2,2 5,9 2,1 5,7 Source: Wood Mackenzie, Macquarie Research 5,5 2000 2 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012f 43 Distribution of Lead Metal Supply 2011 2001 Other 13% Australia Korea 4% Mexico 3% China 15% 3% Japan 5% Europe 30% Europe Mexico Australia Korea 4% Japan 17% 3% 2% 2% Canada Other 3% 12% USA 13% USA 23% Canada 4% China 44% Source: ILZSG 44 Selected Lead Mine Openings/Expansions 2012 to 2014 (Committed* and Under Consideration) Source: New Mines and Smelters 2013 Report, ILZSG Mine Annual Capacity Open (Pb metal contained) George Fisher, Australia* Magellan, Australia* Potosi , Australia* Keke Tale, China* Kayar, India* Garpenburg, Sweden* Tala Hamza, Algeria Admiral Bay, Australia Browns Oxide Project, Australia Browns Sulphide Project, Australia McArthur River (expansion), Australia Mount Isa Super Pit, Australia 120,000t 85,000t 14,000t 15,000t 15,000t 50,000t 36,000t 350,000t 70,000t 150,000t 93,000t 200,000t 2012 (36kt expansion) 2013 (reopening) 2012 (new) 2012 (new) 2013 (new) 2012 (20kt expansion) 45 Zinc Mine Supply 1963-2013f '000 tonnes 14000 12000 10000 8000 6000 4000 Source: Wood Mackenzie, Macquarie Research 2000 1963 1968 1973 1978 1983 1988 1993 1998 2003 2008 2013f 46 Distribution of Zinc Mine Supply 2011 2001 Europe 12.0% Mexico 4.8% India 2.4% Peru 10.3% Other 34.8% Australia Australi 13.7% China 20.1% Europe 8.0% Other 26.3% Mexico 4.9% India 6.4% Australia 11.4% Peru 9.7% China 33.3% Source: ILZSG 47 Selected Zinc Mine Openings/Expansions 2012 to 2014 (Committed* and Under Consideration) Mine Annual Capacity Source: New Mines and Smelters 2013 Report, ILZSG George Fisher, Australia* Perkoa, Burkina Faso* Bracemac-McLeod, Canada* Keke Tale, China* Valardena, Mexico* Garpenburg, Sweden* Tala Hamza, Algeria Admiral Bay, Australia Dugald River, Australia McArthur River (expansion), Australia Mount Isa Super Pit, Australia Panorama, Australia Gamsburg, South Africa Ozernoye, Russia Open Zn Metal contained 215,000t 95,000t 90,000t 40,000t 90,000t 50,000t 164,000t 450,000t 200,000t 380,000t 300,000t 185,000t 350,000t 350,000t 2012 (64kt expansion) 2013 (new) 2013 (new) 2012 (new) 2013 (reactivation) 2012 (20kt expansion) 48 World Lead Demand Forecast Annual Change 7.0% ILZSG Forecast 6.0% 5.0% • 2012 3.4 % 4.0% 3.0% • 2013 3,3% 2.0% 1.0% 0.0% 2009 2010 2011 2012f 2013f Source: ILZSG 49 World Lead Mine Supply Forecast Annual Change 12.0% ILZSG Forecast • 2012 10.9 % • 2013 2.8% 10.0% 8.0% 6.0% 4.0% 2.0% 0.0% 2009 2010 2011f 2012f 2013f Source: ILZSG 50 World Lead Metal Supply Forecast Annual Change 8.0% ILZSG Forecast 7.0% 6.0% 5.0% • 2012 • 2013 2.9 % 4.0% 3.0% 3,8% 2.0% 1.0% 0.0% 2009 20103 2011f 2012f 2013f Source: ILZSG 51 Lead Metal World Balance 200 '000 tonnes 150 100 50 0 -50 -100 -150 -200 Source: ILZSG -250 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012f 2013f 52 Zinc Stocks and Prices Oct 2006 – Oct 2012 2200 '000 tonnes US $ per tonne monthly average 2000 1800 5000 4500 4000 1600 3500 1400 3000 1200 2500 1000 2000 800 1500 600 400 1000 200 500 Source: ILZSG / LME 0 Oct-06 0 Oct-07 SRB+SHEFE Oct-08 Oct-09 Producers+Consumers+LME Oct-10 Oct-11 Oct-12 Zinc LME Cash Settlement Price 53 World Zinc Metal Demand Forecast Annual Change ILZSG Forecast • 2012 • 2013 –0.3 % 3.8% 14.0% 9.0% 4.0% -1.0% -6.0% 2009 2010 2011f 2012f 2013f Source: ILZSG 54 World Zinc Mine Supply Forecast Annual Change 7.5% ILZSG Forecast 5.0% • 2012 5.0 % 2.5% • 2013 2.7% 0.0% -2.5% 2009 2010 2011f 2012f 2013f Source: ILZSG 55 World Zinc Metal Supply Forecast Annual Change ILZSG Forecast 14.0% 12.0% 10.0% • 2012 –2.0 % 8.0% 6.0% 4.0% • 2013 4.8% 2.0% 0.0% -2.0% -4.0% -6.0% 2009 2010 2011f 2012f 2013 Source: ILZSG 56 Zinc Metal World Balance 400 '000 tonnes 300 200 100 0 -100 -200 Source: ILZSG -300 -400 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012f 2013f 57 Next Study Group Meetings in Lisbon, Portugal ● 22-23 April 2013 International Nickel Study Group ● Morning 24 April 2013 International Lead and Zinc Study Group ● 2.00pm 24 April 2013 Joint Study Groups Seminar “Financial Aspects of the Metals Industry: Price Volatility, Investor Activity and Project Financing” ● 25-26 April 2013 International Copper Study Group 58