UNIT REVIEW FOR 2012 Unit Name: Entomology Unit Head: Bruce Tabashnik Date of review: March 25, 2013 Important issues, concerns, and trends for the next 5 years Most recent budget cut: 20% of staff/operaQons (Total $ – faculty salary $) Past 16 years: 90% of staff/operaQons budget cut Our major challenge is to sustain excellence in the face of perennial budget cuts. We have a world‐renowned Department of Entomology. To maintain this excellence, resources are required to recruit and retain faculty and to sustain the Department’s infrastructure. The hiring of three outstanding, energeQc new faculty (Davidowitz 2009, Moore 2010, and Walker 2011) has substanQally bolstered the Department, improved morale, and posiQoned us to sustain excellence well into the future. ! ! !"#$%&'(#)*'!+$,-$.)'/,&.0! Important issues, concerns, and trends for the next 5 years 1#2.)!3#&!$,-$#&!,3,4,5+! 6,)#$-.6%4!+! Major resource: faculty are harmonious, collaboraQve, extremely producQve Faculty & other dept. members idenQfy strongly with Entomology Be`er support needed for faculty: space, tech support, infrastructure for grants, merit raises !"#$%&"'()! 5/(6%7"))0()(! *+,,-%."/01+2034! !(3()%8$$62+)39! ."2<%*+#,(! :")39"%;#<3()! =0"<>9#<%?0! @(<1-%:++)(! A+9<%!"$#BC+! :0>9"($%D0(9$(! &+C%EB039! !"3)0>0"%E3+>'! &)#>(%F"C"69<0'% G"39$((<%@"$'()! .0"<"%@9(($()! $8.5 million in new extramural funding 2011‐2012 CooperaQve Extension Total Extension FTE: 3.3 (23% of total faculty FTE) Millions of stakeholders benefit from our Extension programs every year: Urban IPM: Reduced pes<cide use in schools 71 to 93%, saving an average of $10,500 per school per year, and improving the health of school children in 55% of school districts in Arizona and a total of >2.7 million school children in 23 partner states. Co`on IPM: Reduced insec<cide use by 90% rela<ve to 1995; this has reduced risks to human health and the environment, saved AZ coPon growers $388 million since 1996 and preserved 9000 jobs and $700 million in annual contribu<on to the AZ economy. Vegetable IPM: Reduced use of broadly toxic pes<cides, improving health of millions of consumers na<onwide. Improved pest control boosted profits of ca. 700 growers in Arizona by >$1000 per grower per year. Insect Discovery and Insect FesQval: In 2012, Insect Discovery sparked interest in science in 3400 K‐12 students in Tucson, mostly from low income areas. The 2012 Insect Fes<val aPracted thousands of families to the UA campus to marvel and learn about insects. The Chronicle: Faculty Scholarly Productivity Index 3/25/13 7:48 AM Faculty Scholarly Productivity Index Home Facts & Figures Faculty Scholarly Productivity Index Top Research Universities Faculty Scholarly Productivity Index The 2007 index compiles overall institutional rankings on 375 universities that offer the Ph.D. degree. The Chronicle: Faculty Scholarly Productivity Index 2007 Or 3/25/13 7:48 Entomology AM Biological and Biomedical Sciences 2007 Go Choose an institution Go Entomology - 2007 Next Page >> << Prev Page Next Page >> << Prev Page Faculty Scholarly Productivity Index Home Facts & Figures Faculty Scholarly Productivity Index Faculty Scholarly Productivity Index Institution * Top Research Universities Faculty Scholarly Productivity Index The 2007 index compiles overall institutional rankings on 375 universities that offer the Ph.D. degree. 2007 Or Biological and Biomedical Sciences 2007 Entomology Go Entomology - 2007 Next Page >> << Prev Page Next Page >> << Prev Page Institution * Faculty Scholarly Productivity Index Number of faculty Percentage of faculty with journal publication Citations per cited by another faculty work U. of California at Davis 1.87 18 - - 100% 12.39 94% 70.28 U. of Wisconsin at Madison 1.44 14 - - 86% 7.57 79% 42.43 3 U. of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign 1.36 22 - - 77% 5.86 77% 57.5 1.27 34 - - 91% 6.76 85% 32.09 47.52 5 U. of Arizona 1.23 27 - - 74% 4.22 67% 6 U. of Maryland at College Park 1.14 20 - - 85% 3.8 90% 30.8 7 Cornell U. 1.08 32 - - 69% 4.91 72% 30.88 8 North Carolina State U. 1.02 28 - - 79% 4.39 79% 25.71 9 U. of Kentucky 1 16 - - 81% 5.69 69% 26.25 23 - - 87% 4.61 74% New grants per faculty Total value of new grants per faculty Percentage of faculty with a journal publication Books per faculty Books per faculty Journal publications per faculty 2 of 10 U. of Minnesota-Twin CitiesPercentage .9 Percentage of faculty with a book publication Percentage of faculty with a journal publication 1 4Go U. of California at Riverside Choose an institution Number of faculty Percentage of faculty with a book publication Journal publications per faculty * Institution faculty with journal publication Citations per cited by another Citations per faculty work faculty Citations per paper Percentage of faculty getting a new grant Average amount of grant Percentage of faculty with an award 18.67 Awards per faculty 1 U. of California at Davis 1.87 18 - - 1 100% U. of California at 12.39 Davis 94% 70.28 70.28 4.76 33% .61 $251931 $412251 11% .17 2 U. of Wisconsin at Madison 1.44 14 - - 2 U.86% of Wisconsin at 7.57 Madison 79% 42.43 42.43 4.6 36% .5 $84327 $168654 7% .07 3 U. of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign 1.36 22 - - 3 5.86 77% U.77% of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign 57.5 57.5 7.57 41% .73 $50472 $69399 14% .41 4 U. of California at Riverside 1.27 34 - - 4 6.76 U.91% of California at Riverside 85% 32.09 32.09 3.74 21% .21 $27587 $133992 29% .35 5 U. of Arizona 1.23 27 - - 5 U.74% of Arizona 67% 47.52 47.52 8.67 37% .67 $139446 $209169 11% .19 6 U. of Maryland at College Park 1.14 20 - - 6 U.85% of Maryland at College Park 3.8 90% 30.8 30.8 6.29 40% .45 $44037 $97861 10% .1 7 Cornell U. 1.08 32 - - 7 Cornell 69% U. 4.91 72% 30.88 30.88 5.12 38% .63 $64851 $103761 19% .28 8 North Carolina State U. 1.02 28 - - 8 North U. 79% Carolina State 4.39 79% 25.71 25.71 4.53 21% .29 $55692 $194921 25% .39 9 U. of Kentucky 1 16 - - 9 U.81% of Kentucky 69% 26.25 26.25 3.96 25% .38 $66601 $177602 13% .19 .9 23 - - 10 U.87% of Minnesota-Twin 4.61Cities 74% 18.67 18.67 3.52 35% .52 $83278 $159615 4% .09 10 U. of Minnesota-Twin Cities Institution * Citations per faculty Citations per paper Percentage of faculty getting a new grant New grants per faculty 1 U. of California at Davis 70.28 4.76 33% .61 2 U. of Wisconsin at Madison 42.43 4.6 36% .5 3 U. of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign 57.5 7.57 41% .73 4.22 5.69 * Anvalue institution if the discipline related to more than one department. Total of may appear more than once Percentage of is Awards per new grants per Average amount faculty with an RELATED STORY: Faculty-Productivity Offers Surprises (November 16, 2007) faculty of grant award Index faculty $251931 $412251 How The Index Works 11% .17 The index examines faculty on a Ph.D. program's Web sites, and includes a total of 217,254 names. A professor listed in both history and $84327 $168654members who are 7%listed .07 American studies would be counted twice. But at the next level of aggregation (the humanities in this case), the professor would be counted only once. The index $50472 $69399 14% .41 Research Total Research FTE: 8.75 (58% of total faculty FTE) PublicaQons 2010‐2012 131 peer‐reviewed pubs indexed in Web of Science 5 peer‐reviewed pubs indexed in Web of Science per faculty research FTE per year Median impact for 86 Entomology journals: 0.9 Median impact factor for Ento faculty pubs: 4.7 (higher than 85 of 86 Ento journals) 15 high‐profile Entomology faculty publica<ons (Impact >9, PNAS = 9.7): Science 3, Nature Biotechnology 2, PNAS 3, Ecology Le6ers, PLoS Medicine, PLoS Pathogens 3, Annual Rev Entomol, Current Biology CitaQons (Web of Science) 2063 cita<ons in 2012 of all pubs produced by 15 current Entomology faculty Mean cita<ons in 2012 = 236 per Research FTE (2063 total/8.75 Research FTE) Mean cita<ons in 2012 = 138 per faculty member (48 in 2007, #2 na<onally*) Mean cita<ons per paper (all years): 17 now (8.7 in 2007, #1 na<onally*) *2007 na<onal rankings of Faculty Scholarly Produc<vity for Entomology (see previous slide) hPp://chronicle.com/stats/produc<vity/ Research Total Research FTE: 8.75 (58%) Funding Grant proposals US federal agencies FY2012 NIH, NSF, USDA & EPA: 14 submiPed, 7 funded All FY2011‐FY2012 (UA Analy<cs): 68 submiPed, 50 funded, 6 pending Contracts & gihs 2012: Arizona CoPon Growers Associa<on, BASF, Bayer, CoPon Inc., Crop Protec<on Services (Yuma), D’Arrigo Bros. of California, Dow, DuPont, FMC, Gowan, JV Farms/SkyView Cooling, Marrone BioSciences, Monsanto, Lure Labs, Nichino Americas, Syngenta, Valent Total research expenditures for FY12: $3.8 million Federal: $1.8 million, State: $1.3 million, Gios/Local/Other: $0.6 million Non‐state spending = $0.24 million per Research FTE Total new extramural funding 2011‐2012: $8.5 million = $4.3 million per year Academic Programs Total Teaching FTE: 2.45 (17% of total faculty FTE) A. InstrucQon Total student credit hours taught by department: 1555 = 635 SCH per Teaching FTE B. Graduate Interdisciplinary Program in Entomology & Insect Science (EIS) 6 MS and 24 PhD students Graduate Chair: Hunter (Entomology Professor) 26 EIS graduate students mentored by core Entomology faculty 11 grad students mentored per Teaching FTE Doctoral Degrees Conferred 6 5 4 3 2 1 0 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 Masters Degrees Conferred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umber of undergraduate students in the unit involved in i. Research experiences: 53 ii. Internships: 1 Intellectual property data: 2010‐2012 Patents: 1 30 current EIS graduate students Mentors: 80% Entomology core faculty 86% Entomology core or adjunct faculty 100% Entomology core, joint, or adjunct faculty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ndustry InteracQons Support provided by: Companies: BASF, Bayer, Crop ProtecQon Services (Yuma), D’Arrigo Bros. of California, Dow, DuPont, FMC, Gowan, JV Farms/SkyView Cooling, Marrone BioSciences, Monsanto, Lure Labs, Nichino Americas, Syngenta, Valent Private donor: Lee LaRiever Industry OrganizaQons: Arizona Iceberg Le`uce Research Board, Arizona Co`on Growers Research & ProtecQon Council, California Melon Research Board, Co`on Inc. Classroom: Guest lecture by Dr. Jesse Richardson, Dow AgriSciences Other interacQons with organizaQons not listed above: Arizona Crop ProtecQon AssociaQon, Arizona Department of Agriculture, California AssociaQon of Pest Control Advisors, California Seed AssociaQon, Western Growers AssociaQon, Yuma Fresh Vegetable AssociaQon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esponses to implementaQon of performance‐based funding We can begin to plan effecQvely when we understand the rules. ABOR metrics: Undergrad: degrees, 6‐yr graduaQon, freshmen retenQon, enrollment Grad: MS and PhD degrees Research: expenditures, patents/income, startups Workforce & Community We encourage assessment of performance in terms of quality (not just quanQty) of all three of our major effort areas: research, extension and instrucQon. Our current strategy to sustain excellence in the face of perennial budgets cuts is to: 1) increase extramural support including grants, contracts and gihs; 2) base requests for addiQonal resources from CALS on our outstanding record of achievement and expected future producQvity; 3) retain flexibility to increase the number of student credit hours taught by faculty, if desired; and 4) augment our core of two full‐Qme office staff with part‐Qme assistants. Alumni and Development history and plan for CY13: Schlinger FoundaQon: $625,000 endowment for visiQng systemaQst CreaQng Entomology Advisory Board: 2012‐2013