1 .%!23/54(3)$%0,!..).'345$9 3YRACUSE$EPARTMENTOF#OMMUNITY$EVELOPMENT 3OUTHEAST'ATEWAY#OMMUNITY$EVELOPMENT#ORPRATION &ACULTYOF,ANDSCAPE!RCHITECTURE 35.9#OLLEGEOF%NVIRONMENTAL3CIENCE&ORESTRY 3UMMER 0ROJECT4EAM (EATHER#ARRINGTON35.9%3& 0AUL3ALVATORE-ERCURIO35.9%3& 0ROFESSOR%MANUEL#ARTER35.9%3& -ICHELLE-IKE 3YRACUSE$EPARTMENTOF#OMMUNITY$EVELOPMENT +EVIN+OSAKOWSKI 3YRACUSE$EPARTMENTOF#OMMUNITY$EVELOPMENT 4HOMAS*OHNSON 3YRACUSE$EPARTMENTOF#OMMUNITY$EVELOPMENT 3TEERING#OMMITTEE 4WIGGY"ILLUE !LLIANCEOF#OMMUNITIES4RANSFORMING3YRACUSE -ARLANE"RYANT 3YRACUSE$EPARTMENTOF%CONOMIC$EVELOPMENT !LTHEA#HAPLIN 3OUTHEAST'ATEWAY#OMMUNITY$EVELOPMENT#ORPORATION ,INDA$ELANEY 3YRACUSE$EPARTMENTOF#OMMUNITY$EVELOPMENT 4hOMas&RANCIS 3YRACUSE-ODEL.EIGHBORHOOD#ORPORATION +ATHY'OLDFARB 4HE'IFFORD&OUNDATION 3HARON*ACK7ILLIAMS $UNBAR!SSOCIATION)NC 4ONY,ANEVE 3YRACUSE$EPARTMENTOF#OMMUNITY$EVELOPMENT 3TEVEN-UHAMMAD 3OUTHSIDE.EIGHBORHOOD!CTION'ROUP +ERRY1UAGLIA (OME(EADQUARTERS 6AN2OBINSON 3YRACUSE#OMMON#OUNCIL $AVID2UFUS 3OUTHEAST'ATEWAY#OMMUNITY$EVELOPMENT#ORPORATION 6ITO3CISCIOLI 3YRACUSE 4HOMAS3EALS 3YRACUSE#OMMON#OUNCIL /LIVE3EPHUMA #ENTRAL.EW9ORK#OMMUNITY&OUNDATION #HARLIE6INAL 3YRACUSE$EPARTMENTOF%CONOMIC$EVELOPMENT SYRACUSE NEAR SOUTHSIDE STUDY City of Syracuse Department of Community Development State University of New York College of Environmental Science and Forestry Summer 2004 2 4!",%/&#/.4%.43 )NTRODUCTION 0AGE 'OALS)SSUES/PPORTUNITIESAND#ONSTRAINTS ,AND5SE-AP 0AGE 0AGE 3TUDY!REA-AP 0AGE 3TUDY3ITE/NE -ARTIN,UTHER+ING'ATEWAY#ASTLE3TREET#ORRIDOR 3TUDY3ITE4WO 0AGE 0AGE 3EARS"UILDING4RIANGLE"USINESS)NDUSTRIAL0ARK 3TUDY3ITE4HREE 0AGE +IRK0ARK'ATEWAY 3TUDY3ITE&OUR "ILLINGS0ARK'ATEWAY 3TUDY3ITE&IVE 0AGE 0AGE 7ALLIE(OWARD0LAZA.EW!FRICA#ROSSROADS #ONCLUSION 0AGE4 SYRACUSE NEAR SOUTHSIDE STUDY City of Syracuse Department of Community Development State University of New York College of Environmental Science and Forestry Summer 2004 3 ).42/$5#4)/. 4HIS PROJECT IS A PLANNING STUDY FOR THE .EAR 3OUTHSIDE .EIGHBORHOODOF3YRACUSE.EW9ORK)TISINPARTAFOLLOWUPTO THE3OUTHEAST'ATEWAY5RBAN$ESIGN3TUDYTHEGEOGRAPHIC PARAMETERSOFWHICHWERE"URT3TREETONTHENORTH)NTERSTATE ONTHEEAST+ENNEDY3TREETONTHESOUTHAND#ORTLAND!VENUEON THE WEST 4HIS PROJECT FUNDED BY THE 3YRACUSE $EPARTMENT OF #OMMUNITY $EVELOPMENT HAS BROADER BOUNDARIES !DAMS 3TREETONTHENORTH)NTERSTATEONTHEEAST"RIGHTON!VENUEON THESOUTHAND/NONDAGA#REEKONTHEWEST 4HECLIENTSFORTHISPROJECTARETHE3YRACUSE$EPARTMENTOF #OMMUNITY $EVELOPMENT THE 3YRACUSE $EPARTMENT OF 0ARKS 2ECREATIONAND9OUTH0ROGRAMSTHE3OUTHEAST'ATEWAY#OMMU NITY $EVELOPMENT #ORPORATION AND THE PEOPLE OF THE .EAR 3OUTHSIDE.EIGHBORHOOD 4HEPURPOSEOFTHEPROJECTISNOTTODUPLICATETHEMANY HOUSINGANDCOMMUNITYREVITALIZATIONEFFORTSOFEXISTINGPUBLIC PRIVATE AND NOTFORPROFIT ORGANIZATIONS IN 3YRACUSE BUT TO ADDRESS ISSUES OF CONNECTIVITY COHERENCE AND FUNCTION IN THE COMMUNITYSLANDSCAPE4HESEISSUESWHICHARECURRENTLYLARGELY IGNORED HAVE INTERESTING IMPLICATIONS FOR THE FUTURE 4HEY ARE DEFINEDASFOLLOWS #ONNECTIVITY THE hGOODv NEIGHBORHOOD IS ONE THAT IS ATTACHEDTOADJACENTNEIGHBORHOODSINWAYSTHATENHANCEFUNC TION CIRCULATION ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT AND PUBLIC QUALITY OF LIFE #OHERENCETHEhGOODvNEIGHBORHOODHASASTRONGSENSE OF IDENTITY BASED ON THE SCALE FORMS PATTERNS COLORS MATERIALS DETAILING AND ORIENTATION OF STREETS BUILDINGS PUBLIC SPACES NATURALSYSTEMSSIGNAGEANDHUMANBEHAVIOR &UNCTIONTHEhGOODvNEIGHBORHOODDOESWORKPROVIDING PUBLIC WORKS HOUSING EMPLOYMENT RECREATION SHOPPING AND SPACEFORNATURALSYSTEMSSUCHASWATERWAYSANDWOODLANDS 4HESE AFFECT AND ARE AFFECTED BY HUMAN BEHAVIOR 4HE INTENTION HERE IS TO HAVE THE LANDSCAPE OF THE .EAR 3OUTHSIDE #OMMUNITYREFLECTASENSEOFCONNECTIONTOANDPARTICIPATIONIN SUCCESSFUL CURRENTS THAT ARE UNDERWAY IN ADJACENT NEIGHBOR HOODSANDDISTRICTS 7ITH THE ABOVE IN MIND THIS REPORT ADDRESSES FIVE LOCA TIONSINTHE.EAR3OUTHSIDENEIGHBORHOOD -ARTIN,UTHER+ING'ATEWAY#ASTLE3TREET#ORRIDOR 3EARS"UILDING4RIANGLE +IRK0ARK'ATEWAY "ILLINGS0ARK'ATEWAY 7ALLIE(OWARD0LAZAAND.EW!FRICA#ROSSROADS SYRACUSE NEAR SOUTHSIDE STUDY City of Syracuse Department of Community Development State University of New York College of Environmental Science and Forestry Summer 2004 4 'OALS)SSUES/PPORTUNITIESAND#ONSTRAINTS '/!,3 4OCONTRIBUTETOTHEFUNCTIONALANDVISUALQUALITIESTHATMAKEUPAGOODNEIGHBORHOOD 4OENHANCETHECONNECTIONSBETWEENTHE.EAR3OUTHSIDEANDSURROUNDINGCOMMUNITIES 4OSTIMULATELOCALJOBSFORPEOPLEOFALLSKILLLEVELS 4OANNOUNCEANDCELEBRATETHE.EAR3OUTHSIDE 4OPROVIDENEIGHBORHOODACCESSTOFRESHFOODS 4OATTRACTCITIZENSFROMAVARIETYOFECONOMICBACKGROUNDS .%!23/54(3)$%!2%! )335%3 %MPTY,OTS6ACANT"UILDINGS "LANKWALLS ,OW0OPULATION$ENSITY 0OORPHYSICALCONNECTIONTO$OWNTOWN .OAPPARENTCONNECTIONTO5NIVERSITY(ILL /00/245.)4)%3 !CTIVECITIZENSANDCOMMUNITYORGANIZATIONS 7ELLARTICULATEDCOMMUNITYNEEDS #/.342!).43 0ERCEPTIONOFVIOLENCE ,ACKOFPUBLICSAFETY /LDERHOUSINGSTOCK "),,).'30!2+ )335%3 &EWTREESONSITE 0OORPEDESTRIANCONNECTIONS /00/245.)4)%3 (ISTORICCHARACTEROFPARK 'ATEWAYBETWEEN$OWNTOWN AND.EAR3OUTHSIDE #/.342!).43 4RAFFICJUNCTIONSALONG7ARREN3TREET AND3OUTH3ALINA3TREET +)2+0!2+ "53).%3342)!.',% )335%3 %MPTYLOTS 6ACANTBUILDINGS /00/245.)4)%3 ,OCATIONNEAR$OWNTOWNAND5NIVERSITY(ILL 0REEXISTINGINDUSTRIALZONE #/.342!).43 "ROWNFIELDSINNEEDOF2EMEDIATION /PPORTUNITIESFORSTREETSCAPE IMPROVEMENTS 7!,,)%(/7!2$0,!:! )335%3 0LAZAISACTUALLYAPARKINGLOT .OBUILDINGSHOLDTHECORNERSOF3OUTH3ALINA 3TREETAND"RIGHTON!VENUEINTERSECTION /00/245.)4)%3 'ATEWAYBETWEEN.EAR3OUTHSIDE AND"RIGHTON$ISTRICTS $UNK"RIGHTgSCOMMUNITYINVESTMENT #/.342!).43 0ARKINGNEEDSWITHINPLAZA "EAUTIFULHISTORICARCHITECTURE -,+0,!:! )335%3 3EWERTRUNKLINEINSTALLATION /00/245.)4)%3 /NONDAGA#REEKWALK !RBORETUMAND"OTANICAL'ARDEN 2EFORESTATION #/.342!).43 -AINTENANCEOFEXISTINGSUCCESSFULASPECTS OFTHEPARKIESPORTSPROGRAMSETC "LANKSWALLS )335%3 /NTRACK3TATION .OAPPARENTCONNECTIONBETWEEN.EAR 3OUTHSIDEAND5NIVERSITY(ILL -,+%LEMENTARY3CHOOLNEARBY /RANGEWALL /00/245.)4)%3 7EST#AMPUS%XPANSION0OTENTIAL #/.342!).43 4OPOGRAPHYCHANGE -AINTENANCEOFTRAFFICFLOW#ASTLE3TREET )&INEVIEW0LACE/NTRACK 5NDERUTILIZEDPARKS 5NSAFEPEDESTRIANCROSSINGS !UTOMOBILESCALEDFEATURES 392!#53%.%!23/54(3)$%345$9 #ITYOF3YRACUSE$EPARTMENTOF#OMMUNITY$EVELOPMENT 3TATE5NIVERSITYOF.EW9ORK#OLLEGEOF%NVIRONMENTAL3CIENCEAND&ORESTRY 3UMMER 5 6 7 -!24).,54(%2+).''!4%7!9#!34,%342%%4#/22)$/2 4HISAREAISABOUTCONNECTINGTHE.EAR3OUTHSIDE.EIGH BORHOODTO5NIVERSITY(ILL4HE3OUTHSIDE#OMMUNITYHASLONG BEENCUTOFFFROMTHEACTIVITIESOF5NIVERSITY(ILLANDTHUSCUTOFF FROMPARTICIPATINGINANDBENEFITINGFROMTHEUPLIFTINGACTIVITIES OF RESEARCH EDUCATION SOCIAL INTERACTION WITH PEOPLE FROM ALL OVER THE WORLD AND OTHER PURSUITS THAT HELP PROVIDE A SENSE OF FAITHINTHEFUTUREANDASENSEOFATTACHMENTTOTHESUCCESSESOF THEGREATER3YRACUSECOMMUNITY!DIRECTCONNECTIONTO5NIVER SITY(ILLISESPECIALLYIMPORTANTINANERAOFTHE#ITYSHISTORYWHEN EDUCATION AND MEDICAL RESEARCH AND CARE ARE THE DOMINANT ASPECTSOFTHEREGIONSECONOMICDEVELOPMENTANDIDENTITY 4HEBENEFITSOFTHEACTIVITIESON5NIVERSITY(ILLHAVEALWAYS FLOWED EAST TOWARD 7ESTCOTT 3TREET AND NORTH TOWARD 'ENESEE 3TREET&ROMTHEGEOGRAPHICCENTEROF5NIVERSITY(ILL3ALINA3TREET ISASCLOSEAS7ESTCOTT3TREET4HE#ITYOF3YRACUSEWILLBESOCIALLY AND ECONOMICALLY HEALTHIER IF THE .EAR 3OUTHSIDE #OMMUNITY AND5NIVERSITY(ILLAREBETTERCONNECTED /UR PROPOSAL CALLS FOR NEGOTIATING THE ESCARPMENT THAT SEPARATES 5NIVERSITY (ILL FROM THE .EAR 3OUTHSIDE #OMMUNITY THROUGHTHEFOLLOWINGELEMENTS 4HEEXTENSIONOFTHERESIDENTIALELEMENTSOF5NIVERSITY (ILLnPERHAPSAhNEWVILLAGEvINCLUDINGHOUSINGFORUNDERGRADU ATEANDGRADUATESTUDENTSAT3YRACUSE5NIVERSITY35.95PSTATE -EDICAL 5NIVERSITY AND THE 35.9 #OLLEGE OF %NVIRONMENTAL 3CIENCE&ORESTRYnWESTTO&INE6IEW0LACE 4HEESTABLISHMENTOFAPUBLICPLAZAONTHEWESTENDOF THEhNEWVILLAGEvTHATLEADSTOAGRANDSTAIRWAYTHATDESCENDSTO ATERRACEONTOPOFTHENEWANDEXPANDED5NIVERSITY(ILLTRAIN STATION !NEWANDEXPANDED5NIVERSITY(ILLTRAINSTATIONTHAT INCLUDESACOMMUNITYMARKETPLACERESTAURANTANDOTHERACTIVI TIES !CONTINUATIONOFTHEGRANDSTAIRWAYFROMTHEROOFOF THE5NIVERSITY(ILLTRAINSTATIONTOGROUNDLEVELAT#ASTLE3TREET !COMMUNITYMARKETPLACEANDORFARMERSMARKETON THESOUTHSIDEOF#ASTLE3TREETNESTLEDBETWEEN)NTERSTATEAND THERAILLINE 4HE EXTENSION OF THE DESIGN VOCABULARIES ESPECIALLY LIGHTINGANDSTREETFURNISHINGSOFTHETRAINSTATIONMARKETPLACE COMPLEXALONG#ASTLE3TREETTOTHESCULPTED-ARTIN,UTHER+ING 'ATEWAYNEXTTOTHE-ARTIN,UTHER+ING3CHOOLATTHEINTERSEC TIONOF%AST#ASTLEAND3OUTH3TATE3TREETS 4HE FURTHER EXTENSION OF RELATED LIGHTING AND STREET FURNISHINGS ALONG #ASTLE 3TREET TO THE INTERSECTION WITH 3OUTH 3ALINA3TREET 4HEINTENTIONOFTHISCOMPLEXISTOCELEBRATETHECONNEC TIONBETWEEN5NIVERSITY(ILLANDTHE.EAR3OUTHSIDEBYEXTEND INGANDJOININGNEIGHBORHOODFUNCTIONSATTHEUNLIKELYLOCATION OF THE 5NIVERSITY (ILL AND h.EAR 3OUTHSIDEv TRAIN STATION 4HE CONNECTION SHOULD ALSO BE SYMBOLIC OF EDUCATIONAL PROGRAM MATIC AND ECONOMIC RELATIONSHIPS INCLUDING JOB OPPORTUNITIES ANDAPPROPRIATETRAININGBETWEENTHEINSTITUTIONSON5NIVERSITY (ILLANDTHELARGEPOOLOFASPIRATIONSENERGYANDTALENTTHATISTHE .EAR3OUTHSIDE#OMMUNITY SYRACUSE NEAR SOUTHSIDE STUDY City of Syracuse Department of Community Development State University of New York College of Environmental Science and Forestry Summer 2004 8 9 10 11 3%!23"5),$).'42)!.',%"53).%33).$5342)!,0!2+ 4HE3EARS"UILDING4RIANGLEISASIMPORTANTAS5NIVERSITY (ILLPERHAPSMORESO)FTHISASPECTOFTHEPLANISNOTREALIZEDTHE RESTOFTHERECOMMENDATIONSINTHISREPORTAREFORNAUGHT4HE .EAR3OUTHSIDE#OMMUNITY-534HAVEMOREPLACESFORWORKn TRAININGOPPORTUNITIESEMPLOYMENTOPPORTUNITIESANDENTREPRE NEURSHIP OPPORTUNITIES %SPECIALLY FOR THE YOUNG PEOPLE IN THE COMMUNITYITISIMPORTANTTHATLEGITIMATEEMPLOYMENTBEABUN DANTLYPRESENTANDVISIBLE /URRECOMMENDATIONSCALLFORTHEFOLLOWING 2ENOVATION OF THE FORMER 3EARS "UILDING AND THE RELATEDFORMERAUTOMOTIVEREPAIRCOMPLEXTHATFACESON#ORTLAND !VENUEANDTHEFORMERSUPERMARKETATTHEINTERSECTIONOF3OUTH 3ALINAAND4ALLMANFOROFFICEINDUSTRIALENTREPRENEURIALINCUBA TIONORTRAININGACTIVITIES #ONSTRUCTION OF UP TO FIVE NEW BUILDINGS WITHIN THE TRIANGLEFORTHEPURPOSESLISTEDABOVE 4HE DEVELOPMENT OF ONSITE PARKING FOR EMPLOYEES ANDACCESSFORTRUCKSENGAGEDINSHIPPINGANDRECEIVING !RETAILCOMPLEXATTHENORTHWESTCORNEROFTHEINTER SECTIONOF7EST#ASTLEAND3OUTH3ALINA3TREETS !DISTINCTIVESTREETSCAPETHATOFFERSANEWIDENTITYTO THISLOCATIONANDSOFTENSTHEIMPACTOFTHEBUSINESSANDINDUS TRIALPARKON#ORTLAND!VENUE3OUTH3ALINA3TREETAND7EST#ASTLE 3TREET 4HE PROPOSED BUSINESS INDUSTRIAL PARK WOULD HAVE STRONGURBANDESIGNIMPACTFILLINGINMAJORGAPSnARCHITECTURAL SOCIAL AND ECONOMIC ALONG 3OUTH 3ALINA 3TREET AND #ORTLAND !VENUEANDSPURRINGDEVELOPMENTINTHEIMMEDIATEAREAESPE CIALLYALONGTHEEASTSIDEOF3OUTH3ALINA3TREET)TWOULDALSOBEA NODE WHERE LINKS TO THE LOWER 3OUTHSIDE VIA #ORTLAND !VENUE AND3OUTH3ALINA3TREETTHE3OUTHWEST#OMMUNITYVIA4ALLMAN !VENUE$OWNTOWNVIA3OUTH3ALINA3TREETAND5NIVERSITY(ILL VIA#ASTLE3TREETCOMETOGETHER-OSTIMPORTANTTHEPROPOSED COMPLEXWOULDBEASTATEMENTOFINTENTTOASSURETHEECONOMIC REVITALIZATIONOFTHE.EAR3OUTHSIDEANDSURROUNDINGNEIGHBOR HOODS 4HE LOCAL PRECEDENTS FOR THE DEVELOPMENT OF THIS PROPOSED BUSINESS INDUSTRIAL PARK INCLUDE THE %AST &AYETTE 3TREETBUSINESSPARKTHEALSOINCLUDESTHE3AMUEL7ILLIAMS"USI NESS#ENTERANDTHE%RIE"OULEVARD7EST"USINESS0ARKLOCATEDON THE FORMER 0ENN #ENTRAL RAIL YARDS BETWEEN %RIE "OULEVARD AND 7EST &AYETTE 3TREET $AVID -ICHEL #OMMISSIONER OF %CONOMIC $EVELOPMENT WAS THE LEAD PERSON IN DEVELOPING THE &AYETTE 3TREETAND%RIE"OULEVARDSITES(ESHOULDBEASKEDTOREPEATTHE PROCESSATTHE3EARS4RIANGLE4HE!)!5RBAN$ESIGN#ENTERISA GOODPLACETOSEEKSPECIFICIDEASFORTHEARTICULATIONOFBUILTFORM ONTHISSITE SYRACUSE NEAR SOUTHSIDE STUDY City of Syracuse Department of Community Development State University of New York College of Environmental Science and Forestry Summer 2004 12 13 14 +)2+0!2+'!4%7!9 4HE PURPOSE OF THE +IRK 0ARK 'ATEWAY IS TO CONNECT THE .EAR 3OUTHSIDE #OMMUNITY TO THE 3OUTHWEST #OMMUNITY AND BYEXTENSIONTOTHE3TRATHMORE#OMMUNITYTHROUGHTHE/NON DAGA"OTANICAL'ARDENAND!RBORETUM4HEORIGINALMASTERPLAN WHICH WAS FUNDED BY THE #ITY OF 3YRACUSE AND STRONGLY AUG MENTED BY FUNDING FROM #ONGRESSMAN *AMES 7ALSH FOR THIS FACILITYINCLUDED5PPERAND,OWER/NONDAGA0ARKTHE/NONDAGA #REEK #ORRIDOR INCLUDING THE WEST SIDE OF +IRK 0ARK SOUTH TO .EWELL 3TREET AND ALONG .EWELL 3TREET 6ALLEY $RIVE AND 'LEN WOOD!VENUETOANDINCLUDING%LMWOOD0ARK4HEDECISIONTO INCLUDEALLOF+IRK0ARKCAMEWITHTHEDELIVERYBY3ENATOR#LINTON OFAHOSTOFCHERRYTREESALONGTHESOUTHSIDEOF+IRK!VENUE4HE PLACING OF THESE TREES SPURRED THE CONSIDERATION OF OTHER PLANT EXHIBITS ALONG /NONDAGA #REEK AND AT THE -IDLAND !VENUE ENTRANCE TO THE PARK 4HIS MEANS THAT THE /NONDAGA "OTANICAL 'ARDEN!RBORETUMWOULDHAVEAPRESENCEANDANENTRANCEIN THE .EAR 3OUTHSIDE #OMMUNITY ALONG -IDLAND !VENUE AND WOULD EXTEND EAST ALMOST TO THE 3ALINA 3TREET (ISTORIC $ISTRICT 4HE/NONDAGA"OTANICAL'ARDEN!RBORETUMISPLANNED TOBEAMAJORREGIONALEDUCATIONALFACILITYCONTAINEDWITHINEXIST ING#ITYPARKSANDWITHOUTFENCINGORCHARGINGFORADMISSION)TIS INTENDED IN PART TO FOSTER EDUCATIONAL COOPERATION AMONG THE .EAR 3OUTHSIDE #OMMUNITY THE 3OUTHWEST #OMMUNITY THE 3TRATHMORE #OMMUNITY THE 35.9 #OLLEGE OF %NVIRONMENTAL 3CIENCE&ORESTRY#ORNELL#OOPERATIVE%XTENSIONOF/NONDAGA #OUNTY THE 3YRACUSE $EPARTMENT OF 0ARKS 2ECREATION 9OUTH 0ROGRAMSANDTHE3YRACUSE#ITY3CHOOL$ISTRICT!NASSUMPTIONIS THAT THE /NONDAGA "OTANICAL 'ARDEN !RBORETUMS ANNUAL CALENDAROFEVENTSWOULDKICKOFFWITHTHE#HERRY"LOSSOM&ESTI VALIN+IRK0ARK /URRECOMMENDATIONSINCLUDETHEFOLLOWING !NEXTENSIONOFTHELINEOFCHERRYTREESALONGTHEWEST ANDSOUTHENDSOFTHEATHLETICFIELDSANDREFORESTATIONALONGTHE /NONDAGA#REEK#ORRIDOR ! YETTOBE DETERMINED PLANT EXHIBIT AT THE -IDLAND !VENUEENTRANCE ! FORMAL GATEWAY AT THE EAST END OF THE PEDESTRIAN BRIDGEOVER/NONDAGA#REEKCONNECTINGTHEMAINBODYOF+IRK 0ARK TO THE WEST SIDE OF THE #REEK AND THE MAIN BODY OF THE "OTANICAL'ARDEN!RBORETUM 4HEGREENINGOF+IRK0ARKWILLMAKEANEWAESTHETICSTATE MENTANDALLOWTHEPARKTOBECOMEAMOREMULTIFACETEDFACILITY FORTHE.EAR3OUTHSIDE#OMMUNITYANDCONNECTTHE#OMMUNITY TO FUNDED EDUCATIONAL AND RECREATIONAL OPPORTUNITIES AVAILABLE FORTHE/NONDAGA"OTANICAL'ARDEN!RBORETUMANDADJACENT NEIGHBORHOODS)MPLEMENTATIONSHOULDBELEADBYTHE3YRACUSE $EPARTMENT OF 0ARKS 2ECREATION 9OUTH 0ROGRAMS !SSISTANCE SHOULDBEAVAILABLEFROM#ORNELL#OOPERATIVE%XTENSIONOF/NON DAGA#OUNTYANDTHE35.9#OLLEGEOF%NVIRONMENTAL3CIENCE &ORESTRY SYRACUSE NEAR SOUTHSIDE STUDY City of Syracuse Department of Community Development State University of New York College of Environmental Science and Forestry Summer 2004 15 16 17 "),,).'30!2+'!4%7!9 4HE"ILLINGS0ARK'ATEWAYWOULDCONNECTTHE.EAR3OUTH SIDE #OMMUNITY TO $OWNTOWN 3YRACUSE !DAMS 3TREET IS THE SOUTHERN BOUNDARY OF $OWNTOWN AND WHEN HEADING SOUTH ALONG3OUTH3ALINA3TREETTHERELATIVELYBARREN"ILLINGS0ARKTHE EMPTY FORMER #ENTRAL (IGH 3CHOOL AND THE EMPTY FORMER &OUR 3EASONS 0SYCHIATRIC #ENTER ARE A SORRY WELCOME INTO THE .EAR 3OUTHSIDE#OMMUNITY4HISISEXACERBATEDBYAMUCHTOOWIDE INTERSECTION OF 3OUTH 7ARREN AND 3OUTH 3ALINA 3TREETS SOUTH OF THEPARKnANINTERSECTIONTHATENCOURAGESVEHICULARSPEEDAND DANGEROUSPEDESTRIANCROSSINGS &ORTUNATELYTHEREISMOVEMENTTOWARDREOCCUPYINGTHE FORMER #ENTRAL (IGH 3CHOOL AS AN EDUCATIONAL FACILITY AND THE FORMER &OUR 3EASONS 0SYCHIATRIC #ENTER AS THE 3ALVATION !RMYS +ROC#ENTERnAPOTENTIALLYMAJORCOMMUNITYRECREATIONEDUCA TIONFACILITY4HESEWOULDBEWELCOMEANDWELCOMINGACTIVITIES ALONG 3OUTH 3ALINA AND 3OUTH 7ARREN 3TREETS ADDING PURPOSE HUMANPRESENCEANDANIMATIONTOTHISPOTENTIALLYMAJORURBAN GATEWAY /UR RECOMMENDATIONS FOR THIS GATEWAY ARE SIMPLE AND CALLFOR !NARROWINGOFTHE3OUTH7ARREN3OUTH3ALINA3TREETS INTERSECTION TO ENCOURAGE SAFE PEDESTRIAN CROSSINGS AND TO DISCOURAGEVEHICULARSPEED 4HEADDITIONOFATRAFFICLIGHTATTHEABOVEINTERSECTION TOASSISTINSAFERVEHICULARANDPEDESTRIANBEHAVIOR %STABLISHMENT OF NEW DENSE TREE LINES ALONG BOTH 3OUTH3ALINAAND3OUTH7ARREN3TREETSTOEMPHASIZEASENSEOF GATEWAYANDTOINTRODUCEASOFTERSTREETSCAPETHANISPOSSIBLEIN $OWNTOWN 4HE INTRODUCTION OF A RELATIVELY DENSE VEGETATION PATTERNIN"ILLINGS0ARKTOOFFERSTRONGERVERTICALDEFINITIONOFTHE PARKANDASHADEDRETREATFORTHESOONTOBEMANYUSERSOFTHE &ORMER#ENTRAL(IGH3CHOOLANDTHESOONTOBE3ALVATION!RMY +ROC#ENTER 4ALLVERTICALCOLUMNSWITHLIGHTSONTOPFLANKING3OUTH 3ALINA 3TREET JUST SOUTH OF !DAMS 3TREET AND OFFERING A STRONG SENSEOFGATEWAY 4HISINTERSECTIONHASTHEPOTENTIALTOBEONEOFTHEMOST VISUALLY INTERESTING AND ONE OF THE MOST ANIMATED IN 3YRACUSE 4HEINTENTISTOOFFERNOTONLYAWELCOMETOTHE.EAR3OUTHSIDE BUTALSOAPLACETHATOFFERSEMPLOYMENTOPPORTUNITIESIMPORTANT ACTIVITIESTHATSUPPORTTHELIFEOFTHE#ITYANDASENSEOFVITALITY ASSOCIATED WITH THE #OMMUNITY 0ROJECT ASSISTANCE SHOULD BE SOUGHT FROM THE .93 (ISTORIC 0RESERVATION /FFICE THE 3YRACUSE $EPARTMENTOF0ARKS2ECREATION9OUTH0ROGRAMSAND#ORNELL #OOPERATIVE%XTENSIONOF/NONDAGA#OUNTY SYRACUSE NEAR SOUTHSIDE STUDY City of Syracuse Department of Community Development State University of New York College of Environmental Science and Forestry Summer 2004 18 "ILLINGS0ARK%XISTING#ONDITIONS "ILLINGS0ARKISATTHETRANSITIONPOINTBETWEEN$OWNTOWN3YRACUSE ANDTHE.EAR3OUTHSIDE4HISPARKHOWEVERACTSMOREASAHIGHWAY DIVIDERTHANASAPUBLICGATHERINGPLACE4HEWIDENINGOF3ALINAAND 7ARREN3TREETSISLARGELYTHECAUSEOFTHISBUTVIGOROUSREFORESTATION COULDMAKETHISSITEMOREPEDESTRIANFRIENDLYAGAIN!NAXIALPATHWAY DIVIDESTHEPARKBUTTHISISMODELEDFOROUTDATEDPEDESTRIAN CIRCULATION4WOHISTORICMONUMENTSMARKTHENORTHERNANDSOUTHERN ENDSOF"ILLINGS0ARKBUTWITHOUTANYPEDESTRIANACCESSTOHIGHLIGHT THESEMONUMENTSBOTHAREOFTENOVERLOOKED4HEREAREMANY OPPORTUNITIESFORAPEDESTRIANTOACCESSBUTTHESTREETCROSSINGS AREVERYWIDEANDTHETRAFFICTHATSURROUNDSTHISPARKMOVES VERYQUICKLY 5LTIMATELYTHECHALLENGEPRESENTEDHEREISTORECLAIM"ILLINGS0ARK FROMTHEAUTOMOBILE4HISCANBEDONEFROMTWOAPPROACHESFIRSTBY MAKINGTHEPARKMOREACCESSIBLETOPEDESTRIANSANDSECONDBY MAKINGITAMOREWELCOMELOCATIONINWHICHTOLINGER 4HEABSENCEOFEASYPEDESTRIANACCESSANDADJECTENTSEATING ISOLATESTHESTATUARYIN"ILLINGS0ARK 3URFACEPARKINGANDARCHITECTURALSETBACKSMAKETHEWESTSIDE OF3OUTH3ALINA3TREETSEEMDISORGANIZED (EREBENCHESFORCEPEOPLEINTOONLYSELECTED SEATSEXCESSEXPOSURETOTHESKYMAKESTHEPARKFEELEMPTYAND THEMONUMENTBLENDSINTOTHESURROUNDINGSKYLINE 4HEJUNCTIONOF3OUTH3ALINA3TREEAND3OUTH7ARREN 3TREETISADANGEROUSAREAFORPEDESTRIANS 392!#53%.%!23/54(3)$%345$9 #ITYOF3YRACUSE$EPARTMENTOF#OMMUNITY$EVELOPMENT 3TATE5NIVERSITYOF.EW9ORK#OLLEGEOF%NVIRONMENTAL3CIENCEAND&ORESTRY 3UMMER 19 Billings Park Gateway PLAN Components of the Redesigned Billings Park: Placement of a dense line of street trees on either side of the South Salina Street corridor to tunnel views Narrowing of Warren Street to allow for a more comfortable pedestrian experience into and through Billings Park Expansion of sidewalks to incorporate "bump-outs" which would further improve pedestrian safety and provide traffic calming Placement of polished black granite columns on the SE and SW corners of Adams Street and South Salina Street to act as an announcement of a change in neighborhood Addition of a new traffic signal where South Warren Street separates from South Salina Street Reforestation of the park Provision of raised walls along walkways within the park to provide for additional seating Sout h Sa Enhancement of the WWI monument with seasonal floral displays for color and conifer plantings to frame views lina Stree t Enframement of historic monuments within Billings Park to be facilitated by breaking the street tree line along the east side of South Salina Street South Warren Street Retention of the historic aesthetic and circulation patterns of Billings Park PARK - PERSPECTIVE Lawn area for sun and warmth Raised seat-walls though park New Traffic Signal GATEWAY - SECTION Seating at Base of Column South Salina Street SYRACUSE NEAR SOUTHSIDE STUDY City of Syracuse Department of Community Development State University of New York College of Environmental Science and Forestry Summer 2004 20 7!,,)%(/7!2$0,!:!.%7!&2)#!#2/332/!$3 4HISLOCATIONATTHEINTERSECTIONOF3OUTH3ALINA3TREETAND "RIGHTON !VENUE IS PROPOSED AS A GATEWAY SIMILAR TO THAT AT "ILLINGS0ARKEXCEPTTHATTHISINTERSECTIONISACROSSROADSWITHINA DISTRICTRATHERTHANATRUESEPARATIONOFDISTRICTS4HEINTENTIONIS TO CELEBRATE THE POTENTIAL FOR A NEW COMMUNITY PARK ON THE 7ALLIE(OWARD0LAZASITEATTHENORTHEASTCORNEROFTHEINTERSEC TIONANDFORTHEPROPOSED.EW!FRICA0ROJECTALREADYINMOTION THAT WILL INCLUDE COMMERCIAL REVITALIZATION IN THE BLOCK OF 3OUTH3ALINA3TREETANDNEWHOUSINGPARKSANDAN)SLAMIC#ENTER IN THE BLOCK SOUTHWEST OF THE INTERSECTION THAT IS BOUNDED BY 3OUTH 3ALINA 3TREET 7EST "RIGHTON !VENUE 7EST ,AFAYETTE !VENUEAND#ANNON3TREET /URRECOMMENDATIONSCALLFORTHEFOLLOWING ! NEW PUBLIC PARK ON THE PARKING LOT OF THE 7ALLIE (OWARD0LAZATHATINCLUDESPEDESTRIANACCESSTOEXISTINGSTORES THERETENTIONOFEXISTINGSTORESAPARKPAVILIONANDTREESSHRUBS FLOWERINGPLANTSANDPARKFURNISHINGS ! NEW COMMERCIAL STRUCTURE AT THE SOUTH END OF THE PARKFACINGTHEINTERSECTIONOF3OUTH3ALINA3TREETAND%AST"RIGH TON!VENUE !NEWGROUPOFSTREETTREESINFRONTOF$UNK"RIGHT 6ERTICALCOLUMNSFLANKINGTHENORTHSIDEOFTHEINTER SECTIONWITHLIGHTSONTOPLIKETHOSEATTHE"ILLINGS0ARK'ATEWAY 4HE3ALINA3HOE3ALONNOWOPENANDOTHERRENEWED COMMERCIAL ENTERPRISES ALONG THE BLOCK OF 3OUTH 3ALINA 3TREET )N THE BLOCK SOUTHWEST OF THE INTERSECTION THE RESIDENCEFORMENTRANSITIONINGFROMINCARCERATIONTONORMALLIFE THROUGH A CULINARY ARTS PROGRAM ASSOCIATED COMMUNITY GARDENSANDASMALLFARMERSMARKETANEW)SLAMIC#ENTERWITH QUARTERS FOR THE )MAM AND HIS FAMILY AND A SMALL COMMUNITY PARK ,IKETHE3EARS"UILDING4RIANGLE"USINESS)NDUSTRIAL0ARK THIS7ALLIE(OWARD0LAZA.EW!FRICA#ROSSROADSHASTHEPOTEN TIALTOSTIMULATEECONOMICDEVELOPMENTANDPRIDEINLEGITIMATE WORK AND ENTREPRENEURSHIP )T WILL ALSO HAVE A STRONG URBAN DESIGNIMPACTINTHATITWILLBEANANIMATEDNEWCENTEROFCOM MERCIAL RECREATIONAL AND SOCIAL ACTIVITY EXPRESSED THROUGH NEW ARCHITECTURENEWPARKSANDGARDENSNEWSTREETSCAPESANDNEW ENERGY 3YRACUSES $EPARTMENTS OF #OMMUNITY $EVELOPMENT %CONOMIC$EVELOPMENTAND0ARKS2ECREATION9OUTH0ROGRAMS SHOULDTAKEANINTERESTINTHISAREA SYRACUSE NEAR SOUTHSIDE STUDY City of Syracuse Department of Community Development State University of New York College of Environmental Science and Forestry Summer 2004 21 7ALLIE(OWARD0LAZA%XISTING#ONDITIONS 7ALLIE(OWARD0LAZAHASTHE POTENTIALFORBECOMINGACOMMUNITY LANDMARKANDASOUTHERNGATEWAY ANNOUNCINGTHE.EAR3OUTHSIDEAREA )TCURRENTLYEXISTSASALARGEUNDERUTILIZED PARKINGLOTWITHAFEWSHOPSSETBACKFAR FROMTHESTREET4HEREISLITTLEGREENSPACE ANDTHEGREENERYTHATDOESEXISTSIS NEGLECTED4HEINTERSECTIONOF3OUTH 3ALINA3TREETAND"RIGHTON!VENUEHAS NOBUILDINGSATTHECORNERSGIVINGTHE AREAANEMPTYFEEL4HEPLAZAISALSO DOMINATEDBYTHENOISEANDTRAFFICOF BOTHSTREETS4HEPLAZAISALSOVISUALLY DOMINATEDBYTWOLARGEBILLBOARDS 4HEPLAZADOESHOWEVERSTILLHAVE POTENTIALTOBEMOLDEDINTOA NEIGHBORHOODGATHERINGSPACEANDA COMMUNITYIMAGEMAKER 4HEABSENCEOFSTREETTREESMAKETHEPEDESTRIAN EXPERIENCEALONG3OUTH3ALINA3TREETFEELVERY EXPOSEDTOTHENEARBYFASTMOVINGTRAFFIC 4HEREISMINIMALGREENSPACEIN7ALLIE(OWARD 0LAZA(ERESOMEOFTHEEXISTINGPLANTSARESEENTOBE POORLYMAINTAINED (EREONECANSEETHEEMPTINESSOF THEEXISTINGPARKINGLOT 4HEPLAZAISLEFTEXPOSEDTOTHEROADFROMBOTH SIDESWITHTWOLARGEAUTOMOBILESCALEBILLBOARDSDOMINATING THENORTHERNHALFOFTHESITE 4HISIMAGEISONEOFTHEFIRSTVIEWSONEENCOUNTERS WHENENTERINGTHE.EAR3OUTHSIDEFROMTHESOUTH#URRENTLY THEREEXISTSNOTHINGTOANNOUNCETHISCOMMUNITY 392!#53%.%!23/54(3)$%345$9 #ITYOF3YRACUSE$EPARTMENTOF#OMMUNITY$EVELOPMENT 3TATE5NIVERSITYOF.EW9ORK#OLLEGEOF%NVIRONMENTAL3CIENCEAND&ORESTRY 3UMMER 22 23 #/.#,53)/.3 4HERECOMMENDATIONSCONTAINEDINTHISREPORTARE PRIMARILYABOUTLANDSCAPESOFCONNECTION4HESEMUSTBE CONSIDEREDINTHECONTEXTOFSOMEOFTHEMANYINITIATIVES CURRENTLY UNDERWAY IN THE #ITY OF 3YRACUSE 4HE 35.9 #OLLEGEOF%NVIRONMENTAL3CIENCE&ORESTRYAND3YRACUSE 5NIVERSITY ARE INVOLVED IN PROJECTS THAT ASSIST THE #ITY IN AREAS SUCH AS ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT ENTREPRENEURSHIP THE REUSE OF VACANT AND THE REVITALIZATION OF /NONDAGA CREEKETC!LLOFTHESEPROJECTSHAVEGOODINTENTIONSAND SHOULD HAVE POSITIVE AND FARREACHING IMPACTS ON THE #ITYS FUTURE 4HE AUTHORS OF THIS REPORT HOPE THAT THE CURRENT MAYORAL ADMINISTRATION WILL CONNECT OUR RECOM MENDATIONSTOLARGERGOALSnESPECIALLYGOALSTHATAGGRES SIVELY ADDRESS HOUSING AND NEIGHBORHOOD RENEWAL AND EMPLOYMENTOPPORTUNITIES7ITHTHISINMINDWEOFFERTHE FOLLOWINGADDITIONALRECOMMENDATIONS 4HE #ITY MUST MAKE JOBCREATION IN THE 3EARS "UILDING4RIANGLEANDTHEREOPENINGOF#ENTRAL4ECHNICAL (IGH3CHOOL4(%3OUTHSIDEPRIORITIESDURINGTHENEXTFOUR YEARS 4HE #ITY MUST WORK WITH THE 5NIVERSITY (ILL #ORPORATION TO ESTABLISH COLLECTIVE AGENDAS AMONG THE HOSPITALS AND COLLEGES REGARDING GREATER TRAINING AND EMPLOYMENT OPPORTUNITIES FOR RESIDENTS FROM 3YRACUSES MOST CHALLENGED NEIGHBORHOODS 4HE INSTITUTIONS -534 BECONVINCEDTHATTHESEEFFORTSMAKETHEHOSTCOMMUNITY MORE ATTRACTIVE TO PROSPECTIVE EMPLOYEES AND STUDENTS 4HEFUTUREQUALITYOFTHE#ITYWILLLARGELYBEDETERMINEDBY THERESIDENTIALCHOICESOFUNIVERSITYANDHOSPITALEMPLOY EES-UNICIPALPOLICIESREGARDINGHOUSINGANDNEIGHBOR HOODRENEWALMUSTBEADDRESSEDWITHTHEGOALOFATTRACT INGLARGENUMBERSOFTHESEEMPLOYEESTOLIVEINTHE#ITY ANDTOEDUCATETHEIRCHILDRENINTHE3YRACUSE#ITY3CHOOL $ISTRICT4HEHOSPITALSANDTHEINSTITUTIONSOFHIGHEREDU CATION MUST WORK DIRECTLY WITH THE #ITY IN WALKING THE EXTRAMILESTOMAKE3YRACUSEAPLACEOFCHOICEFORTHOSE WITH MANY CHOICES AND A PLACE OF OPPORTUNITY FOR THOSE WITHFEWERCHOICES,EGITIMATEEMPLOYMENTBASEDONREAL SKILLS MUST BE THE DOMINANT ACTIVITY IN 3YRACUSES CHAL LENGEDNEIGHBORHOODS4HESEDUCTIVEPOWEROFOPPORTU NITY EVIDENT ON 5NIVERSITY (ILL MUST SPILL OVER INTO THE 3OUTHSIDENEIGHBORHOOD 0ARTIALLYINPURSUITOFTHEABOVETHE#ITYSHOULD WORKWITHTHE3YRACUSE#ITY3CHOOL$ISTRICTTOREESTABLISH HIGHLY VISIBLE SPECIAL PROGRAMS HONORS PROGRAMS AND CONNECTIONS TO LOCAL AND REGIONAL UNIVERSITIES AND COLLEGES0ERHAPSEACHOFTHE#ITYSHIGHSCHOOLSCOULDBE hADOPTEDv BY 3YRACUSE 5NIVERSITY 35.9 #OLLEGE OF %NVI RONMENTAL3CIENCE&ORESTRY,E-OYNE#OLLEGEAND35.9 5PSTATE-EDICAL5NIVERSITY 4HERECOMMENDATIONSCONTAINEDINTHISREPORT MUSTBECOMPLEMENTEDBYANAGGRESSIVEANDINNOVATIVE APPROACHTOHOUSING4HE#ITYMUSTCONSIDERFOSTERINGTHE DEVELOPMENT OF A NEW OLD TYPE OF NEIGHBORHOOD )N 3ANTA 2OSA #ALIFORNIA THE COURTS RULED THAT ZONING THAT PREVENTED hGRANNY COTTAGESv WAS DISCRIMINATORY !!20 "ULLETIN 3EPTEMBER 3INCE THEN #OBBLESTONE (OMES HAS BUILT SINGLEFAMILY HOMES WITH GRANNY APARTMENTS)FTHE#ITYOF3YRACUSEWANTSTOOFFERTHEMOST DYNAMIC HOUSING CHOICES IN /NONDAGA #OUNTY THE #ITY SHOULDINVESTIGATETHEPOSSIBILITYOFCHANGINGITSZONINGTO ALLOW SINGLE FAMILY HOMES WITH GRANNY APARTMENTS 4HIS WOULDBEONEWAYOFACCOMMODATINGOURAGINGPOPULA TIONWHICHWILLBEAHUGECOHORTINTHENEXTYEARSAS BABYBOOMERS RETIRE AND ALLOWING OLDER CITIZENS TO LIVE WITH EXTENDED FAMILY WHILE MAINTAINING A DEGREE OF AUTONOMY4HISWOULDALSOWORKFORNEWLYWEDSSAVINGFOR AHOUSEORABETTERAPARTMENT4HE#ITYOF3YRACUSENEEDS ANINCREASEINPOPULATIONANDTHEBESTWAYTOGETITISTO OFFER MORE OPTIONS FOR MAINTAINING MULTIGENERATIONAL NEIGHBORHOODS 4HIS APPROACH COULD RESULT IN A INCREASEINNEIGHBORHOODDENSITYTHUSEQUALINGTHE PRESUBURBANIZATIONDENSITIESANDHENCEANINCENTIVEFOR NEIGHBORHOOD BUSINESS AREAS TO EXPAND 4HIS WOULD BE REVOLUTIONARYANDCOULDREALLYOFFERNEIGHBORHOODENRICH MENT4HESUBURBSWILLNOTTRYTOCOPYIT &INALLYTHE#ITYSHOULDWORKHARDTORESTAFFTHE 0LANNING$EVELOPMENTARMOFTHE3YRACUSE$EPARTMENT OF0ARKS2ECREATIONAND9OUTH0ROGRAMSWITHTHEINTENTION OFRESTORINGTRADITIONALFORESTANDGARDENLANDSCAPESTHAT COMPLEMENTACTIVERECREATIONFUNCTIONSANDOFFERENVIRON MENTALBENEFITSWHILERAISINGPROPERTYVALUESANDNEIGH BORHOODDESIRABILITY !LLOFTHERECOMMENDATIONSMADEINTHISREPORTARE BASEDONSOUNDCOMMUNITYDEVELOPMENTPRACTICESFROM AROUND THE 5NITED 3TATES AND IN MANY COUNTRIES ABROAD 4HE#ITYOF3YRACUSEHASTHEASSETSTOMOVEFORWARDINA BOLD WAY )T HAS INTERNATIONALLY RECOGNIZED INSTITUTIONS AND THE PEOPLE WHO MAKE THEM GREAT A HIGHLY SKILLED AND VARIED WORKFORCE EXCELLENT NATURAL RESOURCES AND IT HAS ENOUGH VACANCY TO ALLOW BOLD NEW APPROACHES TO NEIGHBORHOOD RENEWAL 0ERHAPS MOST IMPORTANT AT THIS TIMEISTHATTHE#ITYHASASECONDTERMADMINISTRATIONTHAT CANTAKERISKSANDINITIATEPOLICIESANDPROGRAMSTHATCOULD RESULTINAHISTORICALLYNOTEWORTHYLEGACY SYRACUSE NEAR SOUTHSIDE STUDY City of Syracuse Department of Community Development State University of New York College of Environmental Science and Forestry Summer 2004 24