Enhancing Success and Safety in Schools Teaching Skills for Success Mission Statement Intervention Strategies Encouragement Strategies Conflict Resolution Function of Behavior Code of Conduct Research Intermediate Unit I One Intermediate Unit Drive Coal Center PA 15423-9642 Donna Whoric: 800 328 6481, ext. 238 whoricd@iu1.k12.pa.us CODE OF CONDUCT I participate in class activities. I use my cell phone for emergency purposes. I share information with the entire class. Challenge 100 YEARS FROM NOW… A Hundred Years From Now ...it will not matter what my bank account was, the sort of house I lived in, or the kind of car I drove... but the world may be different because I was important in the life of a CHILD. 2 Donna Whoric, Behavior Consultant, Intermediate Unit I POSITIVE BEHAVIOR SUPPORT Objectives 1. Participants will understand that appropriate behaviors must be taught. 2. Participants will identify key prevention strategies. 3. Participants will practice intervention strategies with respect and dignity. 3 Donna Whoric, Behavior Consultant, Intermediate Unit I PREVENTION STATATEGIES 4 KWL CHART K now W ant 5 L earned Donna Whoric, Behavior Consultant, Intermediate Unit I SYSTEMS OF BEHAVIOR SUPPORT Tertiary, Individual Student Systems for Students with High-Risk Behavior 1-7% Primary,Universal Supports Whole School, Classroom, and Non-Classroom Systems for All Students, Staff, & Settings Secandary,Group Interventions Specialized Group Systems for Students with At-Risk Behavior 5-15% 80-90% of Students Positive Behavior Support,University of Oregon 6 Donna Whoric, Behavior Consultant, Intermediate Unit I MYTHS OR FACTS? Myths or Facts about Discipline? 1. Punishment has power. “I can make you.” 2. Role bound authority has power. “Because I’m your mother.” 3. Emotional intensity has power. “I really mean it this time.” Randy Sprick, Safe and Civil Schools Historical Approach to Discipline A More Promising Approach to Discipline *Reactive *Negative *Exclusionary *Proactive *Positive *Instructional Discipline =? What is Positive Behavior Support? “Process for understanding the purpose of challenging behaviors and developing a plan that promotes the development of new skills while reducing the individual’s need to engage in challenging behavior.” Dunlap, Vaughn, & O’Neill, 1998 Nothing excuses inappropriate behavior! 7 Donna Whoric, Behavior Consultant, Intermediate Unit I Let’s Take a Look Randy Sprick BEHAVIOR SUPPORT ASSUMPTIONS Behavior Support Assumptions Assumption 1: There is no place for ridicule or humiliation of children in the process of managing behavior. Assumption 2: Inappropriate behaviors are learned and predictable. Assumption 3: A learner’s inappropriate behavior is his/her best effort to be successful in meeting his/her needs. Knoster, Timothy A Quick Glance: Establishing An Ecology of Behavior Support in Schools Pennsylvania Department Education 8 Donna Whoric, Behavior Consultant, Intermediate Unit I PROBLEM BEHAVIORS A Antecedent B Behavior C List Problem Behaviors Consequence COMMON INTERVENTIONS List Common Interventions to Inappropriate Behaviors 9 Donna Whoric, Behavior Consultant, Intermediate Unit I QUESTIONS: PAST… PRESENT 1. What were the issues in school? 2. Who were the delinquents? 3. What methods were used by students (with each other) for conflict resolution? 4. What were the drugs? 5. What were the headlines? 6. What were attitudes towards parents? Family Peers Student School Community 10 Donna Whoric, Behavior Consultant, Intermediate Unit I IDENTIFY NEEDS IDENTIFY BASIC NEEDS OF ALL PEOPLE IDENTIFY WHAT HAPPENS WHEN NEEDS NOT MET Abraham Maslow 11 Donna Whoric, Behavior Consultant, Intermediate Unit I BASIC NEEDS William Glasser The Quality School Fun Freedom Power, Achievement Belonging Survival Abraham Maslow’s Hierarchy of Needs Self-Transcending Self- Actualization Esteem Belongingness Safety Needs Physiological 12 Donna Whoric, Behavior Consultant, Intermediate Unit I THE FOUR GOALS OF MISBEHAVIOR Let’s Fight! Look at me! To Get/To Avoid Leave me alone! I’ll get even! Behavior is a choice! Rudolf Driekers, Children the Challenge 13 Donna Whoric, Behavior Consultant, Intermediate Unit I Cha l l e ngi ng Be ha vi or P e rsona l growt h i m prove s se l f c ont rol Im prove d qua l i t y of l i fe P e rc e pt i on of unm e t ne e ds Inc re a se i n opport uni t i e s for c onne c t e dne ss Re duc t i ons i n c ha l l e ngi ng be ha vi ors by l e a rni ng a l t e rna t i ve sk i l l s Knoster, Timothy A Quick Glance: Establishing An Ecology of Behavior Support in Schools Pennsylvania Department Education Me e t ne e ds i n a m ore soc i a l l y a c c e pt a bl e m a nne r . 14 Look t o unde rst a nd ne e ds a nd de ve l op hypot he se s De si gn a nd de l i ve r pre ve nt i on/ i nt e rve nt i on st ra t e gi e s ba se d on hypot he se s Donna Whoric, Behavior Consultant, Intermediate Unit I THE GOOD NEWS There are many schools that have well-managed classrooms and school buildings, regardless of: a. size b. socioeconomic influences c. student composition d. geographic setting NOT A PRODUCT OF CHANCE!!!! Punishing problem behavior without a school-wide system is associated with increased: a. aggression b. vandalism c. truancy d. tardiness e. dropouts Mayer & Sulzer-Azeroff Approaches that are effective include: a. social skills training b. academic/curricular restructuring c. behavioral interventions. Lipsey (1992), Tolan & Guerra (1994), Gottfredson AND... Classroom Management Wong, Brophy, Goodlad 15 Donna Whoric, Behavior Consultant, Intermediate Unit I VIOLENCE PREVENTION • Positive, predictable school-wide climate • High rates of academic & social success • Surgeon General’s Report on Youth Violence (2001) • Coordinated Social Emotional & Learning (Greenberg et al., 2003) • Center for Study & Prevention of Violence (2006) • White House Conference on School Violence (2006) • Formal social skills instruction • Positive active supervision & reinforcement • Positive adult role models • Multi-component, multiyear school-familycommunity effort INVITING SCHOOL SUCCESS Discussion: 1. Consider your perception of what an ‘inviting school’ would look like. Write down several specific aspects to discuss i n your group. 2. Reflect on your experiences of the past few days. Identify any that you would classify as inviting or disinviting. 3. Pretend that you are a visitor to your school. After being in the building for 15 minutes, what initial impression do you think you would have of your school? What caused those perceptions? 4. Describe the characteristics of a student-teacher relationship that reflects mutual respect. What are specific ways to enhance this kind of relationship? Purkey, William, Inviting School Success 16 Donna Whoric, Behavior Consultant, Intermediate Unit I CODE OF CONDUCT 17 THE CODE OF CONDUCT The Code of Conduct 1. I am responsible. 2. I am safe. 3. I am respectful. ___Created by teacher and students. ___Written in the first person. ___Identifies the appropriate behavior. ___Taught to students. ___Used for self-evaluation ___Reviewed daily/weekly. ___Displayed in the classroom. ___Sent to parents. Albert, Linda; Cooperative Discipline Positive Behavior Support,University of Oregon 18 Donna Whoric, Behavior Consultant, Intermediate Unit I Panther PRIDE • P – Preparation • R – Respect • I – Integrity • D – Dedication • E - Excellence P.A.W.S. ________________was caught following the P.A.W.S. guidelines. P = Please listen A = Always be prepared W = Work/act responsibly S =Show respect Caught by: ________________ T-CHART Code: I am responsible Skill: Put away materials Looks like Sounds like 1. Materials on shelves 2. Labeled items 3. Turn taking 4. Clean area 5. Check-list/pictures of materials Code: Skill: 1. “Excuse me” 2. “Good job!” 3. Quiet voices 4. “It’s my turn” 5. ”I know where it is!” I am respectful Hand raising Sounds like Looks like 1. Hand raised in air 2. Seat on seat 3. Feet on floor 4. Material on desk 5. Pleasant expressions 1. Student asking/answering 2. Teacher asking/answering 3. “Nice hand raising!” 4. Smiles 5. One person talking at a time 19 Donna Whoric, Behavior Consultant, Intermediate Unit I PROCEDURES/ROUTINES Examples: •attendance/tardiness procedures •heading papers •assigning and collecting work •homework •procedures for when there are classroom visitors •transitioning individual to group work •lining up •attention signal •sharpening pencils •organizing desks/workspace •restroom breaks •preparing for and returning from recess/assembly •requesting assistance Additional: 20 Donna Whoric, Behavior Consultant, Intermediate Unit I T-CHART Code: Skill: Looks like Sounds like Positive Behavior Support,University of Oregon 21 Donna Whoric, Behavior Consultant, Intermediate Unit I THE EFFECTIVE TEACHER THREE CHARACTERISTICS 1. Positive Expectations 2. Classroom Management 3. Mastery Teaching How do positive expectations impact your role? Harry Wong, The First Days of Schools 22 Donna Whoric, Behavior Consultant, Intermediate Unit I Let’s Take a Look Harry Wong CLASS MEETINGS 23 THE CLASS MEETING THE BASICS ___Form a circle. ___Agenda setting. ___Set the code. ___Select partners. ___Pose the problem/question. ___Personal reflection. ___Signal for quiet. ___Partner talk. ___Whole group discussion. ___Close the meeting. WAYS TO CLOSE A CLASS MEETING 1. Review: If the meeting produced an agreement, review it. 2. Round the horn: “Let’s go around for final, brief comments: you may pass if you wish.” 3. Remembering: “What’s something somebody said that you thought was a good point, even if you didn’t agree with it? Take a moment to think . . .then share.” 4. Learning: “Think of something you learned from today’s meeting . . .” Then go around, or ask for volunteers. 5. Questions: “What’s a question that’s still on your mind?” 6. Complete the sentence: Invite all to complete a sentence starter (e.g., “At the end of this meeting, I think . . .” or, “I feel . . .” or, “I hope . . .”). 7. Partners: Students respond to any of the above, then share it with their class meeting partner (or change partners). 8. Future topics: “Suggested topics for our next meeting?” 9. Silence: “Take a minute to think about today’s meeting . . . a new idea you got . . . something you’ll do differently as a result of our discussion .. . Write it down or just keep it in mind.” 10. Evaluation: “What did you like about today’s meeting? What made it a good discussion? What could we do better or differently next time?” Thomas Lickona, Educating for Character 24 Donna Whoric, Behavior Consultant, Intermediate Unit I THE CLASS MEETING CLASS MEETING EVALUATION 1. Circle the word that best describes this class meeting: Excellent Very Good Good Fair Poor 2. Circle the word that describes what you think of this meeting: Wow So-so Yuk 3. Complete these sentences: a. This class meeting was ________________________________________________________________ b. In our meeting we decided ______________________________________________________ __________ c. I helped this meeting by ______________________________________________________ __________ d. I think the class meetings have helped ______________________________________________________ __________ e. Since we have class meetings, people have ______________________________________________________ __________ f. Our class meeting would be better if ______________________________________________________ __________ Thomas Lickona, Educating for Character 25 Donna Whoric, Behavior Consultant, Intermediate Unit I THE CLASS MEETING Compliments and Thank you’s 1. “I would like to compliment ___ for ____”. 2. Compliments are given for: 2.Helpfulness 2.Accomplishments 2.Sharing 3. Just Say Thank you! QuickTi me™ and a decompressor are needed to see this picture. Thomas Lickona, Educating for Character 25 Donna Whoric, Behavior Consultant, Intermediate Unit I ENCOURAGEMENT STRATEGIES 26 THE 3’c OF ENCOURAGEMENT •Confidence Builders Capable •Acknowledge Achievement •Learning is Tangible •Make Mistakes O.K. •Success-Revisit It •Acceptance •Attention •Appreciation •Affirmation •Affection Connected •Students •The Class •The School •The Community •The Environment •The World Contributing Linda Albert, Cooperative Discipline 27 Donna Whoric, Behavior Consultant, Intermediate Unit I READING ABOUT THE 5 A’s Read 5 A’s Article Linda Albert, Cooperative Discipline Donna Whoric, Behavior Consultant, Intermediate Unit I APPLYING THE 3 C’s Time CAPABLE CONNECTED CONTRIBUTING Linda Albert, Cooperative Discipline 28 Donna Whoric, Behavior Consultant, Intermediate Unit I MISSION STATEMENT A Mission Statement should be that statement which says and documents what is most important to you, and guides your interactions with students, parents, staff, and community members. The mission statement also reflects your core values. It does not reflect the environment around you because that will change. It directs all your actions and reactions in a changing work environment. It is also the standard that you evaluate your daily performance. Adapted from Steven R. Covey, The 7 Habits of Highly Effective People 29 Donna Whoric, Behavior Consultant, Intermediate Unit I Let’s Take a Look Mr. Holland’s Opus INTERVENTION STRATEGIES “What am I going to do with this kid?” 30 DATA COLLECTION 31 Name______________________Dates ________ Setting ___________________________________ Time Antecedent Behavior 32 Consequence Donna Whoric, Behavior Consultant, Intermediate Unit I FUNCTION OF BEHAVIOR Attention Power Avoidance Revenge Communication Sensory 33 THE FOUR GOALS OF MISBEHAVIOR Let’s Fight! Look at me! Leave me alone! I’ll get even! Mistaken Goal Chart What’s the student message? “Look at me!” How do I feel? (Clue 1) What do I usually do? (Clue 2) What does the student do? (Clue 3) Irritated, annoyed Remind, nag, scold, rescue Stops temporarily Fight back, give in Continues, stops on own terms, “Let’s fight” Angry, frustrated “I’ll get even!” “Leave me alone.” Continues, intensifies, stops on own terms Anger, hurt, disappointed, sense of dislike Retaliate, punish severely, withdraw Professional concern, frustration Give up trying, refer student Linda Albert, Cooperative Discipline 34 Continues avoiding tasks Goal Attention Power Revenge Avoidance of Failure Donna Whoric, Behavior Consultant, Intermediate Unit I ATTENTION 35 ATTENTION Describe the student’s attention seeking behavior: Antecedent Behavior Consequence __________________________________________ __________________________________________ __________________________________________ Prevention Intervention Linda Albert, Cooperative Discipline 36 Donna Whoric, Behavior Consultant, Intermediate Unit I ATTENTION INSTRUCTIONAL STRATEGIES Notice Appropriate Behavior ___Use proximity praise. ___Use compliance praise. ___Make recordings. ___Give a standing ovation. Clarify Desired Behavior ___Use “when-then” statements. ___Use “target-stop-do”. Legitimize the Behavior ___Create a lesson. ___Go the distance. ___Have the class join in. ___Use a diminishing quota. Do the Unexpected ___Turn out the lights. ___Play a musical sound. ___Lower your voice. ___Change your voice. ___Talk to the wall. ___Use one-liners. ___Cease teaching briefly. Distract the Student ___Ask a direct question. ___Ask a favor. ___Give choices. ___Change the activity. Minimize the Attention ___Refuse to respond. ___Give “The Eye”. ___Stand close by. ___Use name dropping. ___Send a general signal. ___Send a secret signal. ___Give written notice. ___Use an “I message”. ___Consider seating arrangement. Linda Albert, Cooperative Discipline 37 Donna Whoric, Behavior Consultant, Intermediate Unit I ATTENTION: INTERVENTION Component Skills: •Moving •Scanning •Encouraging •Proximity praise with follow-up Characteristics of Effective Attention •Be sincere •Use eye contact •Make it descriptive •Vary the statements Research: Before grade 3: Attention for appropriate behaviors is evident. Beginning grade 3: More attention for inappropriate behavior 38 Donna Whoric, Behavior Consultant, Intermediate Unit I STOP AND THINK 1. Is there a problem? 2. Make a decision. Is it a Good choice or Poor choice? 3. Determine steps. Steps to Good Choices: 1.___________________________ 2. .__________________________ 3.___________________________ 4. Implement choices. Just Do It! 5. Evaluate. How did I do? .___________________________ .___________________________ George M. Batsche, University of South Florida 39 Donna Whoric, Behavior Consultant, Intermediate Unit I POWER AND REVENGE 40 DEESCALATION STRATEGIES 41 DEESCALATION STRATEGIES FIVE GUIDELINES TO AVOID AND DEFUSE CONFRONTATIONS 1. Focus on the behavior, not the student. 2. Take charge of negative emotions. 3. Avoid escalating the situations. 4. Discuss the misbehavior later. 5. Allow students to save face. PERSONAL SPACE Respectful Safe Nonthreatening PARAVERBALCOMMUNICATION Tone Volume Rate BODY LANGUAGE Theirs… Yours… Nonviolent Crisis Intervention 42 Donna Whoric, Behavior Consultant, Intermediate Unit I GRACEFUL EXITS State the message. Go! 1. ACKNOWLEDGE STUDENTS’ POWER A student refuses to complete an assignment. Teacher responds, “I can’t make you do the work, you have the assignment-it is your choice.” The expectation has not changed though the teacher has chosen not to fuel the confrontation and create a power struggle. 2. REMOVE THE AUDIENCE When a student demonstrates inappropriate behavior which does not require immediate action from the teacher, the intervention can be to remove the audience's attention. The teacher can make an important announcement or begin a new activity to redirect the attention of the class from the student. 3. TABLE THE MATTER A student has chosen to ‘push our buttons’. To deescalate the situation, the teacher may respond by discussing the matter at a later time or using the ‘gripe box’ in the classroom. The student is directed to write the complaint and place it in the “talk” box. 4. SCHEDULE A CONFERENCE Keep a clipboard handy with the time available for student conferences. When a student begins to challenge you, indicate that he may sign-up for a conference to discuss the issue. 43 Donna Whoric, Behavior Consultant, Intermediate Unit I GRACEFUL EXITS 5. AGREE WITH THE STUDENT A student states that you are the “worst teacher”. The teacher responds, You may be right, now let’s begin the lesson.” The student will realize that he is not able to engage the teacher in a power struggle that the teacher refuses to join. 6. CHANGE THE SUBJECT We can respond to verbal attacks by changing the subject. The student realizes the teacher will not argue with him. This does not condone the behavior: our goal is to end the misbehavior-and seek solutions later. 7. STATE BOTH VIEWPOINTS The outline for this technique is “To you_______, to me_______.” For example, “To you the science experiment seems foolish, to me it is an important concept that you need to know.” If the student continues to argue, specify the difference between understanding and agreeing. The student does not have to agree with our viewpoint-that would extend the power issue. 8. REFUSE RESPONSIBILITY When a student provides excuses for not meeting expectations, a comment such as, “I know you can figure it out” or “You are able to complete the assignment” does not provide the student with additional justification to argue. 9. DODGE IRRELEVANT ISSUES A student may begin arguing about an assignment and then include relevant issues to confuse the situation. Use a simple response, such as, “That is not the issue, the issue is ________.” 10. DELIVER A CLOSING STATEMENT his technique uses one-line statements to indicate to the student that the confrontation has ended for us. Sarcasm is not acceptable. An example is: “You’ve mistaken me for someone who wants to argue.” Linda Albert, Cooperative Discipline 44 Donna Whoric, Behavior Consultant, Intermediate Unit I GRACEFUL EXITS 1.I don’t know why I have to be in this dumb class anyway. ____________________________ ____________________________ 2. You’re the worst math teacher I’ve ever had. ____________________________ ____________________________ Graceful exit__________________ Graceful exit__________________ 3. Who ever told you that you knew how to coach? 4. I can’t learn anything the way you teach! ___________________________ ___________________________ Graceful exit__________________ ___________________________ ___________________________ Graceful exit__________________ 5. This sucks. __________________________ __________________________ 6.I can’t wait for the bell to ring. This place is driving me nuts! _________________________ _________________________ Graceful exit__________________ Graceful exit__________________ 7. Who needs to learn this stuff anyway? __________________________ __________________________ 8. You can’t make me do this. Graceful exit__________________ Graceful exit__________________ 9. You’re not being fair…no one else gives so much work. ____________________________ ___________________________ 10. I told you I am not staying after class. __________________________ __________________________ ____________________________ ___________________________ Graceful exit ___________ Graceful exit__________________ 45 Donna Whoric, Behavior Consultant, Intermediate Unit I POWER UNDERSTANDING-NOT EXCUSING THE HOSTILITY CYCLE Student Impulsive, Acting-Out, Refusal to Cooperate (Has a hostile world view) Teacher Teacher Feels more threatened (More fight or flight) QuickTime™ and a d eco mpres sor are nee ded to s ee this picture. Feels attacked (Fight-flight, accepts challenge) Student Accepts challenge from “Hostile Adult” (Increased Rage LAAD: ENDING THE HOSTILITY CYCLE L Listening “ You are upset, I’ll respect that.” This requires that the person receiving the message (teacher) hears the content and mood of the student and calmly restates that understanding to the student. A Acknowledging “ I hear you saying that you are not planning to do what was asked. Did I hear you correctly?” Acknowledge by verbal response or a head nod that you heard the student and redirect attention back to the lesson. A Agreeing “You are right, I cannot make you do things. The real question is whether you will make yourself do it.” This is very powerful because it shifts the responsibility back to the student. D Deferring “I am not sure why you said that in front of the class, let’s talk after class.” This option provides time to talk-without an audience. Richard Curwin, Allen Mendller, Discipline with Dignity 46 Donna Whoric, Behavior Consultant, Intermediate Unit I THE FOUR Rs OF PUNISHMENT RESENTMENT REVENGE REBELLION RETREAT 1. People adapt to punishment-needs to be more severe each time to be effective (can become neutral “So what?”or even reinforcing). 2. Punishment can lead to lying, sneaking, aggression toward others, avoidance or escape behavior, or the substitution of other behaviors. 3. Punishment often works only while punisher is present or during those exact conditions, and for a limited amount of time. 4. Inconsistency, variability, and delay between behavior and punishment decreases effectiveness. Alternative: Teach & strengthen acceptable behavior rather than attempting to punish unacceptable behavior. SOME PEOPLE BELIEVE THAT IN ORDER TO MAKE A CHILD BE “GOOD”YOU MUST MAKE HIM FEEL “BAD”. Becky Bailey, There’s Got To Be A Better Way, 47 Donna Whoric, Behavior Consultant, Intermediate Unit I SETTING LIMITS THE KEYS TO SETTING LIMITS 1. Explain exactly which behavior is inappropriate. Do not assume that the student knows which behavior is unacceptable. Be specific. 2. Explain why the behavior is inappropriate. Do not assume the student knows why the behavior is unacceptable. 3. Give reasonable choices and consequences. Present them in a positive context. 4. Allow time. If you do not allow time, it may be perceived as an ultimatum and the situation will escalate. 5. Enforce the consequences. Limits are most effective as a teaching tool when the consequences are followed through. Keep it simple, sweetie! How to Set Verbal Limits, Crisis Prevention Intervention 48 Donna Whoric, Behavior Consultant, Intermediate Unit I CONFLICT RESOLUTION 1. Define the Problem 2. Describe the Feelings 3. Declare the Needs 4. Discuss and Evaluate Potential Solutions Advantages Disadvantages 5. Decide on a Plan 6. Determine Effectiveness Signatures Date Review Date 49 Donna Whoric, Behavior Consultant, Intermediate Unit I REDIRECTING The Need for Prestige By Will Roy A m iddle school assistant principal asked me the following: ŅIÕmwalking around the cafeteria when I spot a milk carton on the floor. I say to the kid nearest to it, ŅHey, Tony, pick up that carton of milk.ÕTony answers, ŅIt ainÕ t mine and I ainÕtpicking it up.Ó What am I supposed to do, thereÕ s 135 kids watching me? Ó My reply: ŅThere are 135 kids watching Tony also; and there are 7 at his table taking side bets on who is going to win. Whose prestige is most at stake?Ó Both have the need to be in charge: both wan t to save face. While many adults might disagree, I believe that Tony is in the most precarious position. He has only two choices: The assistant principal has more options. HereÕ s the dilemma. If Tony decided to be defiant, there is r eally nothing that anyone can do to make him pick it up . At this point, Tony will risk any consequen ce. LetÕ s go backward a moment. How m ight we get the carton picked up? 1. Make a general announce ment abou t cleaning around oneÕ s table. 2. If any out side activity follows lunch, a choice can be provided: When the area is clean, we will be ready to go out. 3. Ask a student in a more respectful tone, ŅTony, please help out here. 4. Ask informal leaders to Ņplease make su re the areas gets cleaned up.Ó 5. Simply pick it up with or without commen t (if there is a commen t, it should not be sa rcastic). Suppo se we are already in the situation as was originally posed by the administrator? We now have all the possible negative options we can think ofÉdeten tion, report to the office, suspension, a call to parents, etcÉYe t, the milk carton remains on the floor. Sen sing a powe r struggle, we could simply pick up the carton and say, ŅNot yours Tony. I guess I can handle it.Ó There is no doubt that I ha ve Ōspit in TonyÕssoupÕ. He did not expect that response. I also pose this question: ŅIf a 40 year old man does not have the courage to pick up the carton; why is so much courage expe cted from a 13 year old?Ó Or, I c ould say, ŅIÕllget it Tony, a clean cafeteria is a r esponsibility that we all share. Maybe youÕ d be willing to help next time.Ó Keep it brief: donÕtlecture or moralize. A f inal commen t. Experience has proven that the next time I spot a carton of milk near Tony and s ay, ŅHey Tony, look at this. Ano ther carton. Whose turn is it?Ó ThereÕsa good chance heÕllpick it up. If not, I know I ha ve my work cut out to encourage him to become a contributing membe r of the school community. 50 Donna Whoric, Behavior Consultant, Intermediate Unit I ADDITIONAL INTERVENTIONS WHEEL OF CHOICE Count to ten and cool off Apologize Ask if there is a problem Select another activity Ignore Tell them to stop I Use an “I” message Walk away Try at least two, in case of an emergency, get an adult. Jane Nelsen, Positive Discipline 51 Donna Whoric, Behavior Consultant, Intermediate Unit I ADDITIONAL INTERVENTIONS CONSEQUENCES AND SOLUTIONS ___Reasonable ___Related ___Respectful ___Reliably Enforced ___Helpful: Solutions Advantage Disadvantage ____________________________________ ____________________________________ ___Reteach Appropriate Behavior ___Code of Conduct ___T-Chart ___Procedures/Routines ___Role Play ___Modeling by teacher/peers The “Rs” of RECOVERY ___Recognize the mistake with responsibility instead of blame. ___Reconcile by apologizing to those offended or hurt. ___Resolve the problem, when possible, by working together on a solution. I MESSAGES I Feel… When… Because.. What I need is … Jane Nelsen, Positive Discipline 52 Donna Whoric, Behavior Consultant, Intermediate Unit I POWER HIERARCHY Begin with the Least Intrusive Intervention, if necessary, proceed on the continuum. As you intervene with Power behaviors, employ the deescalation techniques to maintain the dignity of all. Least Intrusive Strategies: First Options: __Planned Ignoring __Acknowledge Appropriate Behavior: __Proximity Praise __Use Compliance Praise __Make Recordings (Posting of Positive Behaviors) __Give A Standing Ovation __Review Code of Conduct Successful intervention, no immediate action needed. Later, follow COPING during Therapeutic Rapport (CPI) If intervention not successful, Second Options: Graceful Exits: (Albert) __Acknowledge Student Power __Remove The Audience (their focus on the student) __Schedule A Conference __Agree With The Student __Change The Subject __State Both Viewpoints __Refuse Responsibility __Dodge Irrelevant Issues __Deliver A Closing Statement __Take Teacher Time-Out Successful intervention, no immediate action needed. Later, follow COPING during Therapeutic Rapport (NCI). 53 Donna Whoric, Behavior Consultant, Intermediate Unit I POWER HIERARCHY If intervention not successful, __Choose another graceful exit Successful intervention, no immediate action needed. Later, follow COPING during Therapeutic Rapport (CPI) If intervention not successful, Third Options: __Use an “I” message (Curwin and Mendler) “When________I feel________because________ So, what I need is________.” __Active Listening (LAAD) Successful intervention, no immediate action needed. Later, follow COPING during Therapeutic Rapport (CPI) If intervention not successful, Fourth Options: __Set Limits (NCI): __Clear __Enforceable __Reasonable __Use when-then statements: (NCI) " When you have _______, then you may ___________." __Give Limited Choices (Nelsen) __Wheel of Choice (Nelsen) __The Four Rs of Solutions (Nelsen) __Related-the solution is related to the behavior __Respectful-respect and dignity is maintained __Reasonable-not adding punishment __Revealed-students know solutions in advance __Positive Time-Out (Nelsen) __Ask the student if they need time to chill to feel better so that he/she will behave better __Use the Language of Choice: (Albert) __"You may sit quietly and not disturb instruction, or you may ___________. You decide." 54 Donna Whoric, Behavior Consultant, Intermediate Unit I POWER HIERARCHY Conflict Resolution (Albert) __Define the Problem __Describe the feelings __Declare the needs __Discuss/evaluate solutions __Decide on a plan __Determine effectiveness __The Rs of Recovery (Nelsen) __Recognize the mistake with responsibility/not blame __Reconcile by apologizing those offended or hurt __Resolve the problem, work on a solution Successful intervention, no immediate action needed. Following, use COPING during Therapeutic Rapport (NCI). If intervention is not successful, and instruction can not continue: Fifth Options: __Student is directed to go to _____. __If student refuses, the audience is removed to designated area. __Student remains in class with teacher or other staff __ Following, use COPING during therapeutic Rapport (CPI) __Employ previously stated consequences. Last Resort: Most Intrusive: __If the student becomes physically acting out at any time and is a danger to himself, students, or staff, NCI physical interventions are used by the team trained and certified by Nonviolent Crisis Intervention to ensure the care, welfare, and safety of all. 55 Donna Whoric, Behavior Consultant, Intermediate Unit I AVOIDANCE 56 AVOIDANCE OF FAILURE INSTRUCTIONAL STRATEGIES Modify Instructional Methods ___Use concrete learning materials. ___Use computer-based instruction. ___Teach one step at a time. ___Teach to the seven intelligences. Encourage Positive Self-Talk ___Post positive classroom signs. ___Require two “put-ups” for every put-down. ___Encourage positive self-talk before tasks. Reframe the “I Can’t” Refrain ___State your belief in students’ abilities. ___Stage an “I can’t” funeral. ___Teach students to set goals. Teach Procedures For Becoming Unstuck ___Brainstorm ask-for-help gambits. ___Use sequence charts. ___Provide tutoring. Linda Albert, Cooperative Discipline 57 Donna Whoric, Behavior Consultant, Intermediate Unit I ADDITIONAL RESOURCES 58 POSITIVE BEHAVIOR SUPPORT Enhancing Success and Safety in Schools PREVENTION STRATEGIES EDUCATOR’S MISSION STATEMENT _______________________________________________________________ _______________________________________________________________ _______________________________________________________________ _______________________________________________________________ _______________________________________________________________ THE CODE OF CONDUCT THE CLASS MEETING ___created by teacher and students. ___written in the first person. ___identifies the appropriate behavior. ___taught to students. ___used for self-evaluation ___reviewed daily/weekly. ___displayed in the classroom. ___sent to parents. ___Form a circle. ___Agenda setting. ___Set the code. ___Select partners. ___Pose the problem/question. ___Personal reflection. ___Signal for quiet. ___Partner talk. ___Whole group discussion. ___Close the meeting. ENCOURAGEMENT STRATEGIES HELP STUDENTS FEEL CAPABLE Make Learning Tangible ___“I-Can” cans. ___Accomplishment albums. ___Checklists of skills. ___Flowchart of concepts. ___Talks about yesterday, today and tomorrow. ___Organize materials, use subject folders. Recognize Achievement ___Select good citizen for the day/wk/mo. ___Applause and assemblies. ___Exhibits. ___Acknowledge student progress o parent. Make Mistakes Okay ___Talk about mistakes. ___Equate mistakes with effort. ___Minimize mistakes’ effects. ___Plan for the future. Build Confidence ___Focus on improvement. ___Notice Contributions. ___Build on strengths. ___Show faith in students. ___Acknowledge a task’s difficulty. ___Limit time on difficult tasks. Focus On Past Successes ___Analyze past success. ___Repeat past success. 59 Donna Whoric, Behavior Consultant, Intermediate Unit I HELP STUDENTS CONNECT Acceptance ___Accept students’ cultural differences. ___Accept students with disabilities. ___Accept students’ personal style. ___Accept the doer, not the deed. ___Celebrate diversity. Appreciation ___Appreciate the deed, not the doer. ___Use three-part appreciation statements. ___Give written words of appreciation. ___Teach students to give appreciation. Affirmation ___Be specific: affirm the doer, not the deed. ___Be enthusiastic. ___Acknowledge positive traits verbally and in writing, ___Teach students to be talent scouts: look for positive character traits. Affection ___Give affection with no strings attached. ___Demonstrate care when things are difficult. ___Show kindness, and it will multiply and be returned. ___Show friendship. ___Use high fives and handshakes. Attention ___Greet students. ___Listen to students. ___Teach students to ask for attention. ___Spend time chatting. ___Talk about life outside of school. ___Mention previous conversations. ___Eat with students. ___Attend school events. ___Complete a project with students. ___Schedule individual conferences. ___Join students on the playground. ___Chaperon school events. ___Recognize birthdays. ___Maker baby-picture bulletin boards. ___Send cards, messages to students. ___Show interest in students’ hobbies. ___Develop a coat of arms. ___Compile a class directory. ___Establish pen pals (e-mail, fax). HELP STUDENTS CONTRIBUTE Class ___Involve students in building the learning environment. ___Invite students’ help in daily tasks. ___Request students’ curriculum choices. ___Designate class liaisons. ___Conduct class meetings. ___Delegate responsibility for specific functions. ___Be a positive role model. School ___Create a Three C-Team to build a school-wide community. ___Schedule work service periods. ___Establish a “catch them being good” patrol. ___Complete special projects via an integrated curriculum. ___Recruit and train students as playground peer coaches. 60 Community ___Adopt a health care center. ___Adopt a zoo animal. ___Contribute to community drives. ___Promote volunteerism.. ___Acknowledge random acts of kindness. ___Visit, fax, write, or e-mail residents in nursing homes Environment ___Join and support worthy cause. ___Participate in school and community recycling, cleanup campaigns. ___Establish information/help centers for school and community. Donna Whoric, Behavior Consultant, Intermediate Unit I HELP STUDENTS CONTRIBUTE Other Students ___Create a circle of friends. ___Establish peer tutoring. ___Use students as cross-age tutors. ___Be a peer mediator. ___Teach peer recognition. ___Participate as a study buddy. INTERVENTION STRATEGIES ATTENTION-SEEKING Notice Appropriate Behavior ___Use proximity praise. ___Use compliance praise. ___Make recordings. ___Give a standing ovation. Clarify Desired Behavior ___Use “when-then” statements. ___Use “target-stop-do”. Legitimize the Behavior ___Create a lesson. ___Go the distance. ___Have the class join in. ___Use a diminishing quota. Do the Unexpected ___Turn out the lights. ___Play a musical sound. ___Lower your voice. ___Change your voice. ___Talk to the wall. ___Use one-liners. ___Cease teaching briefly. Distract the Student ___Ask a direct question. ___Ask a favor. ___Give choices. ___Change the activity. Minimize the Attention ___Refuse to respond. ___Give “The Eye”. ___Stand close by. ___Use name dropping. ___Send a general signal. ___Send a secret signal. ___Give written notice. ___Use an “I message”. ___Consider seating arrangement. AVOIDANCE OF FAILURE Modify Instructional Methods ___Use concrete learning materials. ___Use computer-based instruction. ___Teach one step at a time. ___Teach to the seven intelligences. Encourage Positive Self-Talk ___Post positive classroom signs. ___Require two “put-ups” for every put-down. ___Encourage positive self-talk before tasks. Reframe the “I Can’t” Refrain ___State your belief in students’ abilities. ___Stage an “I can’t” funeral. ___Teach students to set goals. Teach Procedures For Becoming Unstuck ___Brainstorm ask-for-help gambits. ___Use sequence charts. ___Provide tutoring. 61 Donna Whoric, Behavior Consultant, Intermediate Unit I POWER AND REVENGE GRACEFUL EXITS ___Acknowledge student's power ___Table the matter ___Remove the audience ___Schedule a conference ___Agree with the student ___Change the subject ___State both viewpoints ___Refuse responsibility ___Dodge irrelevant issues ___Deliver a closing statement ___Take teacher time-out DEESCALATION STRATEGIES ___Revisit belief system ___Focus on the behavior-not the student ___Focus on the present ___Control negative emotions ___Discuss misbehavior later ___Allow students to save face ___Proxemics (personal space) ___Kinesics (body language) ___Paraverbal communication: ___Tone ___Volume ___Rate 6 D’s of CONFLICT RESOLUTION ___Define the problem ___Describe the feelings ___Declare the needs ___Discuss/evaluate solutions ___Decide on a plan ___Determine effectiveness CONSEQUENCES AND SOLUTIONS ___Reasonable ___Related ___Respectful ___Reliably Enforced ___Helpful: Solutions Advantage Disadvantage 3 “Rs” of RECOVERY ___Recognize the mistake with responsibility instead of blame. ___Reconcile by apologizing to those offended or hurt. ___Resolve the problem, when possible, by working together on a solution. ___Reteach Appropriate Behavior ___Code of Conduct ___T-Chart ___Procedures/Routines ___Role Play ___Modeling by teacher/peers ENDING THE HOSTILITY CYCLE ___Listening Calmly restate understanding that the student is upset. ___Acknowledging Acknowledge that student is heard and redirect back to the lesson. ___ Agreeing Agree with the student -keep responsibility with the student. ___Deferring Talk later-without an audience. ADDITIONAL INTERVENTIONS ___Wheel of Choice. ___Set limits. ___Student Conference. ___Student-directed plan. ___ “I” messages. ___Active listening. ___Team directed plan. ___Language of choice. 62 Donna Whoric, Behavior Consultant, Intermediate Unit I BIBLIOGRAPHY 63 REFERENCES AND ADDITIONAL RESOURCES Albert, L. (1996).Cooperative discipline. Circle Pines: American Guidance Service Inc. Anderson, J.L., Albino, R.W., Mesaros, R.A., Dunlap, G., & Morelli-Robbins, M. (1993). Issues in providing training to achieve comprehensive behavioral support. In J. Reichle & D.P. Wacker (Eds.), Communicative approaches to the management of challenging behaviors (pp. 363-406).Baltimore: Paul H. Brookes. Bailey, J.S., & Pyles,D.A.M. (1989). Behavioral diagnostics. In E. Cipani (Ed.), The treatment of severe behavior disorders: behavior analysis approaches (pp. 85-107). Washington, D.C.: American Association on Mental Retardation. Bambara, L., & Knoster, T. (1996). Guidelines on effective behavioral support. Pennsylvania Department of Education, Bureau of Special Education. Bambara, L., & Knoster, T. (1998). Designing positive behavior support plans. Washington, D.C.:American Association on Mental Retardation. Bambara, L., Knoster T., Lengyel, L., & Krueger, J. (1995). A five step planning process to design and deliver an effective behavioral support plan. Instructional Support System of Pennsylvania, Pennsylvania Department of Education. Bellanca, J., & Fogarty, R. (1991). Blueprints for thinking in the cooperative classroom. Palatine, IL: Skylight Publishing. Brophy, J. & Good, T. (1974). Teacher-student relationships: causes and consequences. New York: Holt, Rinehart, and Winston. Carr, E.G., Levin, L., McConnachie, G., Carlson, J.I., Kemp, D.C., & Smith, C.E. (1994). Communication based intervention for problem behavior: A year’s guide for producing positive change. Baltimore: Paul H. Brookes. Center for Systemic Educational Change. (1996). (videotape). Creating caring communities: A responsive classroom for urban children. District of Columbia Public Schools. Colvin, G., & Sugai, G. (1988). Proactive strategies for managing social behavior problems: An instructional approach. Education and treatment of children, 11, 341-348. Curwin, R.L. & Mendler, A.N. (1988). Discipline with dignity , Reston, VA: Association for Supervision and Curriculum Development. Dadson, S., & Horner, R.H. (1993). Setting events. Teaching exceptional children, 25 53-55. Donnellan, A.M., LaVigna, G.W., Negri-Shoultz, N., & Fassbender, L.L. (1988). Progress without punishment. New York: Teachers College Press. Donnellan, A.M., Mirenda, P.L., Mesaros, R.A., & Passbender, L.L. (1984). Analyzing the communicative functions of aberrant behavior. Journal of the association for persons with severe handicaps, 9, 201-212. 64 REFERENCES AND ADDITIONAL RESOURCES Albert, L. (1996).Cooperative discipline. Circle Pines: American Guidance Service Inc. Anderson, J.L., Albino, R.W., Mesaros, R.A., Dunlap, G., & Morelli-Robbins, M. (1993). Issues in providing training to achieve comprehensive behavioral support. In J. Reichle & D.P. Wacker (Eds.), Communicative approaches to the management of challenging behaviors (pp. 363-406).Baltimore: Paul H. Brookes. Bailey, J.S., & Pyles,D.A.M. (1989). Behavioral diagnostics. In E. Cipani (Ed.), The treatment of severe behavior disorders: behavior analysis approaches (pp. 85-107). Washington, D.C.: American Association on Mental Retardation. Bambara, L., & Knoster, T. (1996). Guidelines on effective behavioral support. Pennsylvania Department of Education, Bureau of Special Education. Bambara, L., & Knoster, T. (1998). Designing positive behavior support plans. Washington, D.C.:American Association on Mental Retardation. Bambara, L., Knoster T., Lengyel, L., & Krueger, J. (1995). A five step planning process to design and deliver an effective behavioral support plan. Instructional Support System of Pennsylvania, Pennsylvania Department of Education. Bellanca, J., & Fogarty, R. (1991). Blueprints for thinking in the cooperative classroom. Palatine, IL: Skylight Publishing. Brophy, J. & Good, T. (1974). Teacher-student relationships: causes and consequences. New York: Holt, Rinehart, and Winston. Carr, E.G., Levin, L., McConnachie, G., Carlson, J.I., Kemp, D.C., & Smith, C.E. (1994). Communication based intervention for problem behavior: A year’s guide for producing positive change. Baltimore: Paul H. Brookes. Center for Systemic Educational Change. (1996). (videotape). Creating caring communities: A responsive classroom for urban children. District of Columbia Public Schools. Colvin, G., & Sugai, G. (1988). Proactive strategies for managing social behavior problems: An instructional approach. Education and treatment of children, 11, 341-348. Curwin, R.L. & Mendler, A.N. (1988). Discipline with dignity , Reston, VA: Association for Supervision and Curriculum Development. Dadson, S., & Horner, R.H. (1993). Setting events. Teaching exceptional children, 25 53-55. Donnellan, A.M., LaVigna, G.W., Negri-Shoultz, N., & Fassbender, L.L. (1988). Progress without punishment. New York: Teachers College Press. Donnellan, A.M., Mirenda, P.L., Mesaros, R.A., & Passbender, L.L. (1984). Analyzing the communicative functions of aberrant behavior. Journal of the association for persons with severe handicaps, 9, 201-212. 64 Durand, V.M. (1990). Severe behavior problems: A functional communication training approach. New York: Guilford. Evertson, C., & Harris, A. (1992). What We Know About Managing Classrooms: Synthesis of Research. Educational Leadership. 49 (7), 74-78. Evertson, C., & Harris, A. (1992, April). What we know about managing classrooms: Synthesis of research. Educational Leadership, 49 (7), 74-78. Forrest, M., & Pearpoint, J. (1992). “Common Sense Tolls: MAPS and Circles.” In J. Pearpoint, M. Forrest, & Snow, Eds. The inclusion papers: Strategies to make inclusion work. Toronto: Inclusion Press Contact: Inclusion Press, 24 Thome Cres., Toronto, ON M6H255. Foster-Johnson, L. & Dunlap, G. (1993). Using functional assessment to develop effective, individualized interventions for challenging behaviors. Teaching Exceptional Children, 25, 44-50. Glasser, W. (1986). Control theory in the classroom. New York: Harper & Row. Hamilton, R.W., Welkowitz, J.A., Mandeville, S.D., Prue, J.F., & Fox, T. (1994). Prevention, teaching, & responding: A planning team process for supporting students with emotional and behavioral difficulties in regular education. University Affiliated Program of Vermont Horner, F.H., Dunlap, G., Koegel, R.L., Carr, E.G., Sailor, W., Anderson, J., Albino, R.W., & O’Neill, R.E. (1990). Toward a technology of “nonaversive” behavioral support. Journal of the Association for Persons with Severe Handicaps, 15, 125-132. Horner, R.W., O’Neill, R.E., & Flannery, K.B. (1993). Building effective behavior support plans from functional assessment information. In M. Snell (Ed.), Instruction of Persons with Severe Handicaps (4th Ed.) (pp. 184-214). Columbus, OH: Merrill. Illinois State Board of Education, Tips for Teachers: Managing the Effective Classroom. March, 1994. Knoster, T. (1996). A quick glance at establishing an ecology of behavior support in schools. Instructional Support System of Pennsylvania: Pennsylvania Department of Education. Knoster, T. (1996). Program indicators for children with significant emotional/behavioral needs in general education settings. Instructional Support System of Pennsylvania: Pennsylvania Department of Education. for IEP teams. Knoster, T., Barbour, R., Boyle, R., & Hess, R. (1996). An LRE tool Instructional Support System of Pennsylvania: Pennsylvania Department of Education. Knoster, T., & Enggren, P. (1997). A quick glance at the concept of Least Restrictive Environment. Instructional Support System of Pennsylvania: Pennsylvania Department of Education. 65 Lewis, T.J., Scott, T.M., & Sugai, G. (1994). The problem behavior questionnaire: A teacherbased instrument to develop functional hypotheses of problem behavior in general education classrooms. Diagnostique, 19, 103-115. Lickona, T. (1991). Educating for character how our schools can teach respect and responsibility. New York: Bantam Books. Maslow, A. (1959) Creativity and self-actualizing people. New York: Harper and Row. McMullen, J. (1996). Strengthening community partnership for children and families. Tenth Annual Children’s Interagency Conference, State College, PA. Meyer, L.H., & Evans, I.M. (1989). Nonaversive intervention for behavior problems: A manual for home and community. Baltimore: Paul H. Brookes. Nelsen, J. (1987). Positive discipline. New York: Ballentine. O’Brien, J., & Mount, B. (1991). “Telling New Stories: The search for capacity among people with severe hanicaps.” In L. Meyer, C. Peck, & L. Brown, Eds. Critical issues in the lives of people with severe disabilities. Baltimore: Paul Brookes Publishing Co. O’Neill, R.E., Horner, R.H., Albino, R.W., Storey, K., & Sprague, J.R. (1990). Functional analysis of problem behavior: A practical assessment guide. Sycamore, IL: Sycamore Publishing. O’Neill, R.E., Williams, W., Leo, K., Hamilton, R.W., & Fox, T. (1994). A positive approach to understanding and addressing challenging behaviors. University Affiliated Program of Vermont. Purkey, W. (1984). Inviting school success, Belmont, CA: Wadsworth Publishing. Wayson, W., & Lasley, T. Climates for Excellence: Schools that Foster Self-Discipline. Phi Delta Kappa, 1984, 65, (6), 419-421. Wolfgang, C.H., & Glickman, C.D. (1986). Solving Discipline Problems: Strategies for Classroom Teachers. Boston, MA: Allyn and Bacon, Inc., Second Edition. Wong, H.K., & Wong, R.T. (1991). The first days of schools. Sunnyvale, CA: Harry K. Wong Publications. 66