Chapter 4 CLASSICAL ECONOMIC THOUGHT 2nd Semester, S.Y 2014 – 2015 Pangasinan State University Social Science Department – PSU Lingayen BACHELOR OF ARTS IN ECONOMICS Econ 126 – HISTORY OF ECONOMIC THOUGHT Chapter Outline A. B. C. D. E. F. What is Classical Economics? The Classical School of Economic Thought Origin and Timeline of Classical Economic Thought Legacy and Criticisms of Classical Economic Thought Economic Ideas and Principles of Classical Economic Thought The Classical Economic Thinkers and their Economic Thought Adam Smith David Ricardo Thomas Malthus John Stuart Mill Jean-Baptiste Say Jeremy Bentham Edmund Burke Alexander Hamilton Other Classical Economists Pangasinan State University Social Science Department – PSU Lingayen BACHELOR OF ARTS IN ECONOMICS Econ 126 – HISTORY OF ECONOMIC THOUGHT Classical Economics Classical economics is widely regarded as the first modern school of economic thought. Its major developers include Adam Smith, Jean-Baptiste Say, David Ricardo, Thomas Malthus and John Stuart Mill. Pangasinan State University Social Science Department – PSU Lingayen BACHELOR OF ARTS IN ECONOMICS Econ 126 – HISTORY OF ECONOMIC THOUGHT Classical Economics Classical economics is widely regarded as the first modern school of economic thought. It refers to work done by a group of economists in the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries. They developed theories about the way markets and market economies work. The study was primarily concerned with the dynamics of economic growth. It stressed economic freedom and promoted ideas such as laissez-faire and free competition. Economic thought until the late 1800’s. Adam Smith’s Wealth of Nations, published in 1776 can be used as the formal beginning of Classical Economics but it actually it evolved over a period of time and was influenced by Mercantilist doctrines, Physiocracy, the enlightenment, classical liberalism and the early stages of the industrial revolution. Pangasinan State University Social Science Department – PSU Lingayen BACHELOR OF ARTS IN ECONOMICS Econ 126 – HISTORY OF ECONOMIC THOUGHT Classical Economics Classical economics as the predominant school of mainstream economics ends with the ‘Marginalist Revolution’ and the rise of Neoclassical Economics in the late 1800’s. Famous economists of this school of thought included Adam Smith, David Ricardo, Thomas Malthus and John Stuart Mill. While Adam Smith would be regarded as the originator and leader of the school, David Ricardo should be credited with establishing the form and methods of the school. Pangasinan State University Social Science Department – PSU Lingayen BACHELOR OF ARTS IN ECONOMICS Econ 126 – HISTORY OF ECONOMIC THOUGHT Classical Economic Thinkers 1. Edmund Burke (1729–1797) 2. Jeremy Bentham (1748–1832) 3. Henry Thornton (1760–1815) 4. Jean-Baptiste Say (1767–1832), 5. Charles Hall (1740-1825) 6. William Godwin (1756-1836) 7. Henry Thornton (1760–11815) 8. James Mill 1773–1836) 9. Jean Charles Léonard de Sismondi (1773–1842) 10.Robert Owen (1771–1858) 11.David Ricardo (1772–1823) 12.Alexander Hamilton (1755–1804) Pangasinan State University Social Science Department – PSU Lingayen BACHELOR OF ARTS IN ECONOMICS Econ 126 – HISTORY OF ECONOMIC THOUGHT Classical Economic Thinkers 13. Henry Clay (1777–1852) 14. Mathew Carey (1760–1839) 15. Thomas Tooke 1774–1858) 16. Henry Charles Carey (1793–1879) 17. Johann Heinrich von Thünen (1783–1850) 18. Wilhelm Roscher (1817–1894) 19. Charles Gide (1847–1932) 20. Pierre-Joseph Proudhon (1809–1865) 21. John Stuart Mill (1806–1873 22. Frederic Bastiat (1801–1850) 23. George Wilhelm Friedrich Hegel (1770–1831) 24. Friedrich Engels (1820–1895) Pangasinan State University Social Science Department – PSU Lingayen BACHELOR OF ARTS IN ECONOMICS Econ 126 – HISTORY OF ECONOMIC THOUGHT Adam Smith FAST FACTS Career Scottish economist and social philosopher Born/Died June 5, 1723 – July 17, 1790 School of economic thought Classical School Notable Economic Thought Classical economics, modern free market, division of labor, the "invisible hand“, absolute advantage, paradox of value Magnum Opus An Inquiry into the Nature and Causes of the Wealth of Nations Influenced by Aristotle, Cantillon, Hobbes, Hume, Hutcheson, Locke, Mandeville, Petty, Quesnay Influences Engels, Friedman, Keynes, Malthus, Marx, Menger, Mill, Ricardo Pangasinan State University Social Science Department – PSU Lingayen BACHELOR OF ARTS IN ECONOMICS Econ 126 – HISTORY OF ECONOMIC THOUGHT Notable Economic Thought of Adam Smith Division of Labor Paradox of Invisible Hands Free Market Absolute Advantage Pangasinan State University Social Science Department – PSU Lingayen BACHELOR OF ARTS IN ECONOMICS Econ 126 – HISTORY OF ECONOMIC THOUGHT Adam Smith and The Wealth of Nations An Inquiry into the Nature and Causes of the Wealth of Nations, usually abbreviated as The Wealth of Nations is considered Adam Smith’s magnum opus and the first modern work of economics. It is a reflection on economics at the beginning of the Industrial Revolution and argues that free market economies are more productive and beneficial to their societies. Pangasinan State University Social Science Department – PSU Lingayen BACHELOR OF ARTS IN ECONOMICS Econ 126 – HISTORY OF ECONOMIC THOUGHT Theory of Invisible Hands Invisible Hand is a term coined by Adam Smith in his greatest work, Wealth of Nations. He said that if the government doesn’t do anything, there’s a controlling factor of people themselves who can guide markets. The theory of the Invisible Hand states that if each consumer is allowed to choose freely what to buy and each producer is allowed to choose freely what to sell and how to produce it, the market will settle on a product distribution and prices that are beneficial to all the individual members of a community, and hence to the community as a whole. The reason for this is that self-interest drives actors to beneficial behavior. Efficient methods of production are adopted to maximize profits. Low prices are charged to maximize revenue through gain in market share by undercutting competitors Pangasinan State University Social Science Department – PSU Lingayen BACHELOR OF ARTS IN ECONOMICS Econ 126 – HISTORY OF ECONOMIC THOUGHT Self-Interest Adam Smith's famous statement on self-interest is given below. "It is not from the benevolence of the butcher, the brewer or the baker, that we expect our dinner, but from their regard to their own self-interest. We address ourselves, not to their humanity but to their self-love, and never talk to them of our own necessities but of their advantages.“ Smith argued for a "system of natural liberty” where individual effort was the producer of social good. Smith believed even the selfish within society were kept under restraint and worked for the good of all when acting in a competitive market. Prices are often unrepresentative of the true value of goods and services. Pangasinan State University Social Science Department – PSU Lingayen BACHELOR OF ARTS IN ECONOMICS Econ 126 – HISTORY OF ECONOMIC THOUGHT Absolute Advantage: Examples A. Labor Requirement per unit of Production Country Pineapple Banana Philippines 3 workers/ton 7 workers/ton India 5 workers/ton 4 hours/ton B. Output per Labor Hour Country United States Wine 5 bottles United Kingdom 15 bottles Cloth 20 yards 10 yards Pangasinan State University Social Science Department – PSU Lingayen BACHELOR OF ARTS IN ECONOMICS Econ 126 – HISTORY OF ECONOMIC THOUGHT David Ricardo FAST FACTS Career English political economist and businessman Born/Died April 18 1772 – September 11, 1823) School of economic thought Classical School Notable Economic Thought Comparative advantage, Law of diminishing returns, Economic rent,Ricardian equivalence, Labour theory of value, Magnum Opus On the Principles of Political Economy and Taxation Influenced by Adam Smith, Jeremy Bentham Influences Ricardian Socialists, John Stuart Mill, Marx, Sraffa Barro Pangasinan State University Social Science Department – PSU Lingayen BACHELOR OF ARTS IN ECONOMICS Econ 126 – HISTORY OF ECONOMIC THOUGHT Notable Economic Thought of David Ricardo Labor Theory of Value Economic Rent Law of Diminishing Returns Ricardian Equivalence Law of Comparative Advantage Pangasinan State University Social Science Department – PSU Lingayen BACHELOR OF ARTS IN ECONOMICS Econ 126 – HISTORY OF ECONOMIC THOUGHT Principles of Political Economy and Taxation Ricardo's best known work is his Principles of Political Economy and Taxation (1817), which contains his critique of barriers to international trade and a description of the manner the income is distributed in the population. The book concludes that land rent grows as population increases. It also clearly lays out the theory of comparative advantage, which shows that all nations can benefit from free trade, even if a nation lacks an absolute advantage in all sectors of its economy. Pangasinan State University Social Science Department – PSU Lingayen BACHELOR OF ARTS IN ECONOMICS Econ 126 – HISTORY OF ECONOMIC THOUGHT Labor Theory of Value Ricardo opens the first chapter in his Principles of Political Economy and Taxation with a statement of the labor theory of value. Later in this chapter, he demonstrates that prices do not correspond to this value. The labor theory of value states that the relative price of two goods is determined by the ratio of the quantities of labor required in their production. His labor theory of value has the following several assumptions: 1. Both sectors have the same wage rate and the same profit rate; 2. The capital employed in production is made up of wages only; 3. The period of production has the same length for both goods. Pangasinan State University Social Science Department – PSU Lingayen BACHELOR OF ARTS IN ECONOMICS Econ 126 – HISTORY OF ECONOMIC THOUGHT Ricardian Equivalence Ricardian equivalence is an argument suggesting that in some circumstances a government's choice of how to pay for its spending (i.e., whether to use tax revenue or issue debt and run a deficit) might have no effect on the economy. It is an economic theory holding that consumers internalize the government's budget constraint: as a result, the timing of any tax change does not affect their change in spending. Consequently, Ricardian equivalence suggests that it does not matter whether a government finances its spending with debt or a tax increase, because the effect on the total level of demand in the economy is the same. Pangasinan State University Social Science Department – PSU Lingayen BACHELOR OF ARTS IN ECONOMICS Econ 126 – HISTORY OF ECONOMIC THOUGHT Ricardian Equivalence Ricardian equivalence can be demonstrated in its simplest terms: governments can raise money either through taxes or by issuing bonds. Since bonds are loans, they must eventually be repaid—presumably by raising taxes in the future. The choice is therefore "tax now or tax later.“ Suppose that the government finances some extra spending through deficits; i.e. it chooses to tax later. This action might suggest to taxpayers that they will have to pay higher tax in future. Taxpayers would put aside savings to pay the future tax rise; i.e. they would willingly buy the bonds issued by the government, and would reduce their current consumption to do so. The effect on aggregate demand would be the same as if the government had chosen to tax now Pangasinan State University Social Science Department – PSU Lingayen BACHELOR OF ARTS IN ECONOMICS Econ 126 – HISTORY OF ECONOMIC THOUGHT Ricardo’s Theory of Wages and Profits Some credit Ricardo with the concepts behind the so-called Iron Law of Wages, that wages naturally tend to a subsistence level. Ricardo believed that in the long run, prices reflect the cost of production, and referred to this long run price as a Natural price. The natural price of labor was the cost of its production, that cost of maintaining the laborer. If wages correspond to the natural price of labor, then wages would be at subsistence level. However, due to an improving economy, wages may remain indefinitely above subsistence level: In his Theory of Profit, Ricardo stated that as real wages increase, real profits decrease because the revenue from the sale of manufactured goods is split between profits and wages. He said in his Essay on Profits, "Profits depend on high or low wages, wages on the price of necessaries, and the price of necessaries chiefly on the price of food." Pangasinan State University Social Science Department – PSU Lingayen BACHELOR OF ARTS IN ECONOMICS Econ 126 – HISTORY OF ECONOMIC THOUGHT Comparative Advantage Ricardian equivalence is an argument suggesting that in some circumstances a government's choice of how to pay for its spending (i.e., whether to use tax revenue or issue debt and run a deficit) might have no effect on the economy. It is an economic theory holding that consumers internalize the government's budget constraint: as a result, the timing of any tax change does not affect their change in spending. Consequently, Ricardian equivalence suggests that it does not matter whether a government finances its spending with debt or a tax increase, because the effect on the total level of demand in the economy is the same. Pangasinan State University Social Science Department – PSU Lingayen BACHELOR OF ARTS IN ECONOMICS Econ 126 – HISTORY OF ECONOMIC THOUGHT Ricardian Distribution Theory Ricardo made a distinction between the workers, who received a wage fixed to a level at which they can survive, the landowners, who earn a rent, and capitalists, who own capital and receive a profit, a residual part of the income. Pangasinan State University Social Science Department – PSU Lingayen BACHELOR OF ARTS IN ECONOMICS Econ 126 – HISTORY OF ECONOMIC THOUGHT Ricardian Distribution Theory One of the first models of Ricardo used in Economics is aimed at explaining how income is distributed in society. This has the following assumptions: There is only one industry, agriculture; only one good, grain; There are three kinds of people or three factors of production. 1. Capitalists. They start the economic growth process by saving and investing. In return, they receive profits (P), which is what is left once wages and rents have been subtracted from the gross revenue. Capital can be divided into fixed capital (machines, for example) and working capital (wage fund, WF). Pangasinan State University Social Science Department – PSU Lingayen BACHELOR OF ARTS IN ECONOMICS Econ 126 – HISTORY OF ECONOMIC THOUGHT Ricardian Distribution Theory 2. Workers. They represent the labor force, in return for wages (w). 3. Landlords. They allow production(y) to take place in their lands in return for rent (R). Law of diminishing returns: affects labor (variable factor of production) and land (fixed factor). Principle of margin: marginal product of labor, which, along with the average product of land, is decreasing. Principle of economic surplus: profits are determined as a surplus of production. Pangasinan State University Social Science Department – PSU Lingayen BACHELOR OF ARTS IN ECONOMICS Econ 126 – HISTORY OF ECONOMIC THOUGHT Steady State Real wages will stagnate at subsistence level, the interest rate of capital will stay at 0 and rents will reach its maximum level. Ricardo explains how this steady state is painful, especially for the working class. However, this steady state can be delayed with technological progress or international trade, as is shown in Ricardian trade theory. Pangasinan State University Social Science Department – PSU Lingayen BACHELOR OF ARTS IN ECONOMICS Econ 126 – HISTORY OF ECONOMIC THOUGHT Comparative Advantage According to Ricardo's theory, even if a country could produce everything more efficiently than another country, it would reap gains from specializing in what it was best at producing and trading with other nations. Ricardo believed that wages should be left to free competition, so there should be no restrictions on the importation of agricultural products from abroad. The benefits of comparative advantage are both distributional and related to improved real income. Within Ricardo's theory, distributional effects implied that foreign trade could not directly affect profits, because profits change only in response to the level of wages. The effects on income are always beneficial because foreign trade does not affect value. Pangasinan State University Social Science Department – PSU Lingayen BACHELOR OF ARTS IN ECONOMICS Econ 126 – HISTORY OF ECONOMIC THOUGHT Comparative Advantage Ricardo argued that mutually gainful trade is possible even if one nation has an absolute disadvantage in the production of both commodities compared with the other nation. The less productive nation should specialize in the production and export of the commodity in which it has a comparative advantage. In comparative advantage, two countries will both gain from trade if, in the absence of trade, they have different relative costs for producing the same goods. Even if one country is more efficient in the production of all goods (absolute advantage) than the other, both countries will still gain by trading with each other, as long as they have different relative efficiencies Pangasinan State University Social Science Department – PSU Lingayen BACHELOR OF ARTS IN ECONOMICS Econ 126 – HISTORY OF ECONOMIC THOUGHT Assumptions of Comparative Advantage 1. The world consists of two nations, each using a single input to produce two commodities. 2. In each nation, labor is the only input (the labor theory of value). Each nation has a fixed endowment of labor, and labor is fully employed and homogeneous. 3. Labor can move freely among industries within a nation but is incapable of moving between nations. 4. The level of technology is fixed for both nations. Different nations may use different technologies, but all firms within each nation utilize a common production method for each commodity. Pangasinan State University Social Science Department – PSU Lingayen BACHELOR OF ARTS IN ECONOMICS Econ 126 – HISTORY OF ECONOMIC THOUGHT Assumptions of Comparative Advantage 5. Costs do not vary with the level of production and are proportional to the amount of labor used. 6. Perfect competition prevails in all markets. Because no single producer or consumer is large enough to influence the market, all are price takers. Product quality does not vary among nations, implying that all units of each product are identical There is free entry to and exit from an industry, and the price of each product equals the product’s marginal cost of production. 7. Free trade occurs between nations; that is, no government barriers to trade exist. Pangasinan State University Social Science Department – PSU Lingayen BACHELOR OF ARTS IN ECONOMICS Econ 126 – HISTORY OF ECONOMIC THOUGHT Assumptions of Comparative Advantage 8. Transportation costs are zero. Consumers will thus be indifferent between domestically produced and imported versions of a product if the domestic prices of the two products are identical. 9. Firms make production decisions in an attempt to maximize profits, whereas consumers maximize satisfaction through their consumption decisions. 10. There is no money illusion; that is, when consumers make their consumption choices and firms make their production decisions, they take into account the behavior of all prices. 11. Trade is balanced (exports must pay for imports), thus ruling out flows of money between nations. Pangasinan State University Social Science Department – PSU Lingayen BACHELOR OF ARTS IN ECONOMICS Econ 126 – HISTORY OF ECONOMIC THOUGHT Pangasinan State University Social Science Department – PSU Lingayen BACHELOR OF ARTS IN ECONOMICS Econ 126 – HISTORY OF ECONOMIC THOUGHT Comparative Advantage: An Analysis Suppose there are two countries of equal size, Country A and Country B, that both produce and consume two goods, food and clothes. The productive capacities and efficiencies of the countries are such that if both countries devoted all their resources to food and clothes production, output would be as follows: Country Country A Country B Food Production 100 400 Clothes Production 100 200 Country A has a comparative advantage in food production. Country B has a comparative advantage in clothing production Pangasinan State University Social Science Department – PSU Lingayen BACHELOR OF ARTS IN ECONOMICS Econ 126 – HISTORY OF ECONOMIC THOUGHT Let’s Check Your Understanding! Use the following information to answer the questions below. Country South Korea Taiwan Smartphones (in millions) 180 Digital Cameras (in millions) 60 60 30 1. Who has absolute advantage in producing smartphones? 2. Who has absolute advantage in producing digital cameras? 3. What is the opportunity cost for each country producing smartphones? 4. What is the opportunity cost for each country producing digital cameras? 5. If these two countries were to engage in trade, which country should produce smartphones and who should produce digital cameras and why? Pangasinan State University Social Science Department – PSU Lingayen BACHELOR OF ARTS IN ECONOMICS Econ 126 – HISTORY OF ECONOMIC THOUGHT Ricardian Equivalence Ricardian equivalence is an argument suggesting that in some circumstances a government's choice of how to pay for its spending (i.e., whether to use tax revenue or issue debt and run a deficit) might have no effect on the economy. It is an economic theory holding that consumers internalize the government's budget constraint: as a result, the timing of any tax change does not affect their change in spending. Consequently, Ricardian equivalence suggests that it does not matter whether a government finances its spending with debt or a tax increase, because the effect on the total level of demand in the economy is the same. Pangasinan State University Social Science Department – PSU Lingayen BACHELOR OF ARTS IN ECONOMICS Econ 126 – HISTORY OF ECONOMIC THOUGHT Thomas Robert Malthus FAST FACTS Career English scholar and economist Born/Died February 14, 1766 – December 23, 1834 School of economic thought Classical School Notable Economic Thought Population theory Magnum Opus An Essay on the Principle of Population Influenced by David Ricardo, Jean Charles Léonard de Sismondi Influences John Maynard Keynes, Alfred Russel Wallace, Karl Marx Pangasinan State University Social Science Department – PSU Lingayen BACHELOR OF ARTS IN ECONOMICS Econ 126 – HISTORY OF ECONOMIC THOUGHT Economic Thought of Thomas Malthus Malthus argued that the human sex drive causes faster and faster expansion of the populace. Food production would not keep up because of the law of diminishing returns: as more people work on a fixed amount of land, less and less output is added. The result is an everwidening imbalance between the number of people and the supply of food. However, there is a counteracting force. Malthus saw that malnutrition and disease caused by a more limited food supply would lead to increased mortality and stop the imbalance from getting out of control. Less food to go around would also mean fewer children could be supported, and the birth rate would fall. This would lessen the pressure on land, restoring living standards. Pangasinan State University Social Science Department – PSU Lingayen BACHELOR OF ARTS IN ECONOMICS Econ 126 – HISTORY OF ECONOMIC THOUGHT Population Theory Malthus is best known for his hugely influential theories on population growth. Malthus was the first economist to propose a systematic theory of population. He argued that all government intervention would ultimately prove futile because of two factors, population growth and limited resources. He articulated his views regarding population in his famous book, Essay on the Principle of Population (1798), for which he collected empirical data to support his thesis. Malthus took into account two main assumptions: Food is an essential component for human existence. Humans have the basic urge to multiply. Pangasinan State University Social Science Department – PSU Lingayen BACHELOR OF ARTS IN ECONOMICS Econ 126 – HISTORY OF ECONOMIC THOUGHT Population Theory Malthus’ theory was based on the assumption that the power of population to multiply is much greater than the power of the earth to provide subsistence for man. In his own words ‘passion between the sexes is an inevitable phenomenon’, hence, when unchecked, population would grow at such a high rate that it would outstrip food supply. Malthus argued that because of the natural human urge to reproduce human population increases geometrically (1, 2, 4, 16, 32, 64, 128, 256, etc.). However, food supply, at most, can only increase arithmetically (1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, etc.). Therefore, since food is an essential component to human life, population growth in any area or on the planet, if unchecked, would lead to starvation. Pangasinan State University Social Science Department – PSU Lingayen BACHELOR OF ARTS IN ECONOMICS Econ 126 – HISTORY OF ECONOMIC THOUGHT Positive Checks This method results in increase in death rate. He described this as God’s way of restoring the Natural Order. Positive checks are those that increase the death rate. These include disease, war, disaster, and finally, when other checks don’t reduce population, famine. Malthus felt that the fear of famine or the development of famine was also a major impetus to reduce the birth rate. He indicates that potential parents are less likely to have children when they know that their children are likely to starve. Although positive Checks help in controlling the population growth, it brings with it widespread misery and pain. Hence, it is not regarded as an ideal solution to population problem. . Pangasinan State University Social Science Department – PSU Lingayen BACHELOR OF ARTS IN ECONOMICS Econ 126 – HISTORY OF ECONOMIC THOUGHT Preventive Checks This method refers to human effort in reducing the birth rate. It is more practically and logically applicable. Abortion, prostitution, postponement of marriage, birth control and celibacy are few measures that were advised to be strictly followed in order to help solve the problem. In his second edition of the same essay, Malthus laid more emphasis on moral restraint which is regarded as a universally applicable solution keeping up with the ideologies of virtue, economic gain and social improvement. According to this principle, one should refrain from marriage till the time he is capable of supporting a family with food, clothing and shelter. Until then he should follow strict celibacy. Pangasinan State University Social Science Department – PSU Lingayen BACHELOR OF ARTS IN ECONOMICS Econ 126 – HISTORY OF ECONOMIC THOUGHT Malthusian Trap Pangasinan State University Social Science Department – PSU Lingayen BACHELOR OF ARTS IN ECONOMICS Econ 126 – HISTORY OF ECONOMIC THOUGHT Jean-Baptiste Say FAST FACTS Career French economist and businessman Born/Died January 5, 1767 – November 15, 1832 School of economic thought Classical School Notable Economic Thought Say’s Law Magnum Opus A Treatise on Political Economy Influenced by David Ricardo, Adam Smith Influences John Maynard Keynes, Friedman Milton Pangasinan State University Social Science Department – PSU Lingayen BACHELOR OF ARTS IN ECONOMICS Econ 126 – HISTORY OF ECONOMIC THOUGHT Say’s Law Jean-Baptiste Say’s book, A Treatise on Political Economy contained a brief passage, now known as Say's Law of markets. Say argued that there could never be a general deficiency of demand or a general glut of commodities in the whole economy. People produce things, to fulfill their own wants, rather than those of others, therefore production is not a question of supply, but an indication of producers demanding goods. Say agreed that a part of the income is saved by the households, but in the long term, savings are invested. Investment and consumption are the two elements of demand, so that production is demand, so it is impossible for production to outrun demand, or for there to be a "general glut" of supply. Say also argued that money was neutral, because its sole role is to facilitate exchanges, therefore, people demand money only to buy commodities; "money is a veil". Pangasinan State University Social Science Department – PSU Lingayen BACHELOR OF ARTS IN ECONOMICS Econ 126 – HISTORY OF ECONOMIC THOUGHT Say’s Law To sum up these two ideas, Say said "products are exchanged for products". At most, there will be different economic sectors whose demands are not fulfilled. But over time supplies will shift, businesses will retool for different production and the market will correct itself. An example of a "general glut" could be unemployment, in other words, too great a supply of workers, and too few jobs. Say's Law advocates would suggest that this necessarily means there is an excess demand for other products that will correct itself. Pangasinan State University Social Science Department – PSU Lingayen BACHELOR OF ARTS IN ECONOMICS Econ 126 – HISTORY OF ECONOMIC THOUGHT Say’s Law of Market Say’s law is commonly summarized as ‘supply creates its own demand.’ This law, also referred to as Say’s ‘theory of markets’ or ‘law of markets,’ indicates that the act of producing aggregate output generates a sufficient amount of aggregate income to purchase all of the output produced. This principle indicated that excess production or insufficient demand for production was unlikely to occur, at least for any extended period. When combined with flexible prices and saving investment equality, Say’s law further implied that an economy would achieve and maintain full employment of resources. This law was singled out by John Maynard Keynes in his critique of classical economics, but remains relevant in current macroeconomic analysis, reflected in the circular flow model. Pangasinan State University Social Science Department – PSU Lingayen BACHELOR OF ARTS IN ECONOMICS Econ 126 – HISTORY OF ECONOMIC THOUGHT Supply Creates its Own Demand Pangasinan State University Social Science Department – PSU Lingayen BACHELOR OF ARTS IN ECONOMICS Econ 126 – HISTORY OF ECONOMIC THOUGHT Edmund Burke FAST FACTS Career Irish statesman, political theorist and philosopher Born/Died January 12, 1729 – July 9, 1797 School of economic thought Classical School Notable Economic Thought Magnum Opus A Thoughts and Details on Scarcity Influenced by Aristotle, Cicero, Richard Hooker, Edward Coke, William Blackstone Influences Robert Peel, Immanuel Kant, Lord Acton Pangasinan State University Social Science Department – PSU Lingayen BACHELOR OF ARTS IN ECONOMICS Econ 126 – HISTORY OF ECONOMIC THOUGHT Economic Thought of Edmund Burke Burke in his Thoughts and Details on Scarcity, he expounded "some of the doctrines of political economists bearing upon agriculture as a trade". Burke criticized policies such as maximum prices and state regulation of wages, and set out what the limits of government should be: That the State ought to confine itself to what regards the State, or the creatures of the State, namely, the exterior establishment of its religion; its magistracy; its revenue; its military force by sea and land; the corporations that owe their existence to its fiat; in a word, to every thing that is truly and properly public, to the public peace, to the public safety, to the public order, to the public prosperity. Pangasinan State University Social Science Department – PSU Lingayen BACHELOR OF ARTS IN ECONOMICS Econ 126 – HISTORY OF ECONOMIC THOUGHT Frederick Bastiat FAST FACTS Career French classical theorist, political economist Born/Died June 29,1801– December 24, 1850) School of economic thought Classical School Notable Economic Thought Opportunity cost Magnum Opus Capital and Interest and Economic Harmonies Influenced by Richard Cobden, Adam Smith Influences Ludwig von Mises Pangasinan State University Social Science Department – PSU Lingayen BACHELOR OF ARTS IN ECONOMICS Econ 126 – HISTORY OF ECONOMIC THOUGHT Economic Thought of Frederick Bastiat Bastiat is notable for developing the important economic concept of opportunity cost. His 1850 essay "That Which is Seen and That Which is Unseen" contains the famous Parable of the broken window. This demonstrates how opportunity costs, as well as the law of unintende consequences, affect economic activity in ways that are "unseen" or ignore. Bastiat asserted that the sole purpose of government is to defend and protect the right of an individual to life, liberty and property (statism). From this definition, Bastiat concluded that the law cannot defend life, liberty and property if it promotes socialist policies, which are inherently opposed to these very things. Pangasinan State University Social Science Department – PSU Lingayen BACHELOR OF ARTS IN ECONOMICS Econ 126 – HISTORY OF ECONOMIC THOUGHT Georg Wilhelm Friedrich Hegel FAST FACTS Career German philosopher Born/Died August 27, 1770 – November 14, 1831 School of economic thought Classical School Notable Economic Thought Absolute idealism Magnum Opus Influenced by Aristotle, Plato, Heraclitus, Neoplatonism, Anselm, Descartes, Goethe, Spinoza, Influences Adorno, Vygotsky, Bakunin, Barth, Bataille, Bauer Pangasinan State University Social Science Department – PSU Lingayen BACHELOR OF ARTS IN ECONOMICS Econ 126 – HISTORY OF ECONOMIC THOUGHT Henry Charles Carey Career American economist Born/Died December 15, 1793 – October 13, 1879 School of economic thought Classical School Notable Economic Thought Magnum Opus The Harmony of Interests: Agricultural, Manufacturing, and Commercial Influenced by Adam Smith, John Stuart Mill Influences Alexander Hamilton Pangasinan State University Social Science Department – PSU Lingayen BACHELOR OF ARTS IN ECONOMICS Econ 126 – HISTORY OF ECONOMIC THOUGHT Economic Thought of Henry Charles Carey Henry Charles Carey is best known for the book The Harmony of Interests, to compare and contrast what he called the "British System" of laissez faire free trade capitalism with the "American System" of developmental capitalism, through tariff protection and government intervention to encourage production. Carey, who had set out as an earnest advocate of free trade, accordingly arrived at the doctrine of protection: the coordinating power in society must intervene to prevent private advantage from working public mischief. He attributed his conversion on this question to his observation of the effects of liberal and protective tariffs respectively on American prosperity. Pangasinan State University Social Science Department – PSU Lingayen BACHELOR OF ARTS IN ECONOMICS Econ 126 – HISTORY OF ECONOMIC THOUGHT Charles Guide FAST FACTS Career French economist and historian Born/Died 1847 -1932 School of economic thought Classical School Notable Economic Thought Magnum Opus Revue d'économie politique Influenced by Leon Walras, David Ricardo Influences John Maynard Keynes Pangasinan State University Social Science Department – PSU Lingayen BACHELOR OF ARTS IN ECONOMICS Econ 126 – HISTORY OF ECONOMIC THOUGHT Economic Thought of Charles Guide Gide was a tireless champion of the cooperative movement: both agricultural and consumers' cooperatives during the first third of the 20th century. His book, Consumers' Co-operative Societies, which first appeared in French in 1904, and in English in 1921, is a classic in the field of co-operative economics, in the tradition of Cooperative Federalism. A founder of the Revue d'économie politique in 1887, Gide was a proponent of the French historical approach to economics. Gide was one of the few supporters of Leon Walras, as they shared a social philosophy, social activism, and disdain for the "Manchester-style" economics of the journalistes. Gide later resisted the influence of Keynesian economics in France Pangasinan State University Social Science Department – PSU Lingayen BACHELOR OF ARTS IN ECONOMICS Econ 126 – HISTORY OF ECONOMIC THOUGHT James Mill FAST FACTS Career Scottish historian, economist, and political theorist Born/Died April 6, 1773 – June 23,1836 School of economic thought Classical School Notable Economic Thought Unearned increment of land Magnum Opus Elements of Political Economy Influenced by Dugald Stewart, Jeremy Bentham Influences John Stuart Mill Pangasinan State University Social Science Department – PSU Lingayen BACHELOR OF ARTS IN ECONOMICS Econ 126 – HISTORY OF ECONOMIC THOUGHT Economic Thought of James Mill In 1814 he wrote a number of articles, containing an exposition of utilitarianism, for the supplement to the fifth edition of the Encyclopædia Britannica, the most important being those on "Jurisprudence," "Prisons" and "Government.“ His Elements of Political Economy followed up the views of Ricardo, with whom Mill was always on terms of intimacy. Among the more important of its theses are: that the chief problem of practical reformers is to limit the increase of population, on the assumption that capital does not naturally increase at the same rate; that the value of a thing depends entirely on the quantity of labor put into it; and that what is now known as the "unearned increment" of land is a proper object for taxation. Pangasinan State University Social Science Department – PSU Lingayen BACHELOR OF ARTS IN ECONOMICS Econ 126 – HISTORY OF ECONOMIC THOUGHT Jean Charles Léonard de Sismondi FAST FACTS Career Swish writer and economist Born/Died May 19, 1773 – June 25, 1842 School of economic thought Classical School Notable Economic Thought Economic cycle/business cycle Magnum Opus New Principles of Political Economy Influenced by Adam Smith Influences Robert Owen, John Maynard Keynes Pangasinan State University Social Science Department – PSU Lingayen BACHELOR OF ARTS IN ECONOMICS Econ 126 – HISTORY OF ECONOMIC THOUGHT Economic Thought of Jean Charles Léonard de Sismondi He published New Principles of Economic Philosophy, breaking ranks with Adam Smith by predicting that so-called general equilibrium would be marred by periodic economic crises, and calling for the state "to regulate the progress of wealth". he insisted on the fact that economic science studied the means of increasing wealth too much, and the use of wealth for producing happiness, too little. For the science of economics, his most important contribution was probably his discovery of economic cycles. Sismondi challenged the idea that economic equilibrium leading to full employment would be immediately and spontaneously achieved Pangasinan State University Social Science Department – PSU Lingayen BACHELOR OF ARTS IN ECONOMICS Econ 126 – HISTORY OF ECONOMIC THOUGHT Business Cycle The term business cycle (or economic cycle) refers to economy-wide fluctuations in production or economic activity over several months or years. These fluctuations occur around a long-term growth trend, and typically involve shifts over time between periods of relatively rapid economic growth (an expansion or boom), and periods of relative stagnation or decline (a contraction or recession) Business cycles are usually measured by considering the growth rate of real gross domestic product. Despite being termed cycles, these fluctuations in economic activity do not follow a mechanical or predictable periodic pattern. Pangasinan State University Social Science Department – PSU Lingayen BACHELOR OF ARTS IN ECONOMICS Econ 126 – HISTORY OF ECONOMIC THOUGHT The Economy is a Yo-Yo (Boom and Bust) Pangasinan State University Social Science Department – PSU Lingayen BACHELOR OF ARTS IN ECONOMICS Econ 126 – HISTORY OF ECONOMIC THOUGHT Jeremy Bentham FAST FACTS Career English jurist, philosopher, and legal and social reformer Born/Died February 15, 1748 – June 6, 1832 School of economic thought Classical School Notable Economic Thought Utility or greatest happiness principle Magnum Opus Fragment on Government Influenced by John Locke, David Hume, Hobbes Influences John Stuart Mill, Henry Sidgwick, John Austin, Robert Owen Pangasinan State University Social Science Department – PSU Lingayen BACHELOR OF ARTS IN ECONOMICS Econ 126 – HISTORY OF ECONOMIC THOUGHT Economic Thought of Jeremy Bentham Bentham stated that pleasures and pains can be ranked according to their value or "dimension" such as intensity, duration, certainty of a pleasure or a pain. He was concerned with maxima and minima of pleasures and pains; and they set a precedent for the future employment of the maximization principle in the economics of the consumer, the firm and the search for an optimum in welfare economics. Bentham rejected modern ideas of GDP and other metrics representing good measures of wellbeing or happiness, saying that money was not a good metric of people’s happiness. He called on politicians and moralists to discover a new metric of well-being, for the hopes of making morality an exact science were progressive. Bentham introduced the idea of compensation for labor being simply payment for the fact labor is ‘painful.’ Pangasinan State University Social Science Department – PSU Lingayen BACHELOR OF ARTS IN ECONOMICS Econ 126 – HISTORY OF ECONOMIC THOUGHT Jeremy Bentham and Utilitarianism Bentham’s main contribution to the fields of philosophy and economics was that of Utilitarianism. Utilitarianism was the principle that the greatest happiness or utility was the most important, most valuable, etc., furthermore, such a belief led that people would strive to maximize their net pleasure (or, spoken alternatively: maximize their pleasure while minimizing their pain) - a strong origin for the theories of maximization. Utilitarianism is heavily studied in the field of ethical philosophy striving to answer the question somewhat addressed by Adam Smith: if everyone strives to maximize their personal utility, will the general benefit be maximized? Pangasinan State University Social Science Department – PSU Lingayen BACHELOR OF ARTS IN ECONOMICS Econ 126 – HISTORY OF ECONOMIC THOUGHT Jeremy Bentham and Utilitarianism Utilitarianism is mainly characterized by two elements: happiness and consequentialism. Utilitarian happiness is the biggest happiness which every human being looks for. In utilitarianism everything useful to happiness is good. Therefore, the name of the doctrine is utilitarianism, based on the principle of utility. Utility is found in everything which contributes to the happiness of every rational being. The criterion of good and evil is balanced between individual’s happiness and the happiness of the community, ‘each counting in an equal way’. Consequentialism in utilitarianism is in the fact that an action must be judged for its consequences on the happiness of the largest number. That is: my search for happiness stops when it decreases the happiness of another individual or the happiness of the largest number, of the society or the community. Pangasinan State University Social Science Department – PSU Lingayen BACHELOR OF ARTS IN ECONOMICS Econ 126 – HISTORY OF ECONOMIC THOUGHT John Stuart Mill FAST FACTS Career British philosopher, political economist Born/Died May 20, 1806 – May 8, 1873 School of economic thought Classical School Notable Economic Thought Public/private sphere, hierarchy of pleasures in Utilitarianism, liberalism, early liberal feminism, harm principle, Mill's Methods, wage fund docrine Magnum Opus Principles of Political Economy Influenced by Aristotle, Locke, Hobbes, Smith, Ricardo Influences William James, John Rawls, Robert Nozick, Bertrand Russell Pangasinan State University Social Science Department – PSU Lingayen BACHELOR OF ARTS IN ECONOMICS Econ 126 – HISTORY OF ECONOMIC THOUGHT Economic Thought of John Stuart Mill Mill's famous formulation of utilitarianism is known as the "greatest-happiness principle". Mill is also credited with being the first person to speak of supply and demand as a relationship rather than mere quantities of goods on markets, reciprocal demand and the rejection of the wage fund doctrine. Mill promoted economic democracy in the capitalist economy whereby laborers would elect members of management. According to Mill, the ultimate tendency in an economy is for the rate of profit to decline due to diminishing returns in agriculture and increase in population at a Malthusian rate. Pangasinan State University Social Science Department – PSU Lingayen BACHELOR OF ARTS IN ECONOMICS Econ 126 – HISTORY OF ECONOMIC THOUGHT John Stuart Mill and Utilitarianism Mill's famous formulation of utilitarianism is known as the "greatest-happiness principle". It holds that one must always act so as to produce the greatest aggregate happiness among all sentient beings, within reason. Mill's major contribution to utilitarianism is his argument for the qualitative separation of pleasures. Bentham treats all forms of happiness as equal, whereas Mill argues that intellectual and moral pleasures are superior to more physical forms of pleasure. Mill distinguishes between happiness and contentment, claiming that the former is of higher value than the latter. Pangasinan State University Social Science Department – PSU Lingayen BACHELOR OF ARTS IN ECONOMICS Econ 126 – HISTORY OF ECONOMIC THOUGHT John Stuart Mill and Reciprocal Demand Ricardo expounded the theory of comparative advantage without explaining the ratios at which commodities would exchange for one another. It was J. S. Mill who discussed the problem of ratios in detail in term of his theory of ‘Reciprocal Demand’. The term ‘reciprocal demand’ was introduced by Mill to explain the determination of the equilibrium terms of trade. It is used to indicate a country’s demand for one commodity in terms of the quantities of other commodities it is prepared to give up in exchange. It is reciprocal demand that determines the terms of trade which in turn determine the relative share of each country. Equilibrium would be established at that ratio of exchange between the two commodities at which quantities demanded by each country of the commodity which it imports from the other should be exactly sufficient to pay for another. Pangasinan State University Social Science Department – PSU Lingayen BACHELOR OF ARTS IN ECONOMICS Econ 126 – HISTORY OF ECONOMIC THOUGHT Mill’s Theory of Economic Development Mill regarded economic development as a function of land, labor and capital. While land and labor are the two original factors of production, capital is "a stock, previously accumulated of the products of former labor." Increase in wealth is possible only if land and capital help to increase production faster than the labor force. It is productive labor that is productive of wealth and capital accumulation. "The rate of capital accumulation is the function of the proportion of the labor force employed ' productively. Profits earned by employing unproductive labors are merely transfers of income; unproductive labor does not generate wealth or income" . It is productive laborers who do productive consumption. Productive consumption is that "which maintains and increase the productive capacity of the community." Pangasinan State University Social Science Department – PSU Lingayen BACHELOR OF ARTS IN ECONOMICS Econ 126 – HISTORY OF ECONOMIC THOUGHT Mill’s Theory of Wage Fund According to Mill, the elasticity of supply is very high in response to high in wages. Wages generally exceed the minimum subsistence level. Wages are paid out of capital. Hence they are limited by existing fund of capital meant for paying wages. Thus wage per head can be derived at by dividing the total circulating capital by working population. Wages can increase by an increase in the aggregate fund of capital employed in hiring labor or by decrease in the number of the worker. If wages rise, supply of labor will be high. Competition among workers will not only bring down wages but also keep some laborers out of employment. This is based on Mill's notion that" Demand for commodities is not demand for laborers." It means income invested as advances of wages to labor creates employment and not income spent on consumer goods. Pangasinan State University Social Science Department – PSU Lingayen BACHELOR OF ARTS IN ECONOMICS Econ 126 – HISTORY OF ECONOMIC THOUGHT Mill’s Theory of Rate of Capital Accumulation Acccording to Mill the rate of capital accumulation depends upon: (1) "the amount of fund from which saving can be made" or" the size of the net produce of the industry "and (2) "the strength of disposition to save. "Capital is the result of savings, and the savings come from the "abstinence from present consumption for the sake of future goods". Although capital is the result of saving, it is nevertheless consumed. This means savings is spending. Since saving depends on the net produce of the industry, they increase with an increase in profits and rent which goes into making the net produce. Pangasinan State University Social Science Department – PSU Lingayen BACHELOR OF ARTS IN ECONOMICS Econ 126 – HISTORY OF ECONOMIC THOUGHT Pierre-Joseph Proudhon FAST FACTS Career French politician, philosopher and socialist Born/Died January 15,1809 – January 19, 1865 School of economic thought Classical School Notable Economic Thought Magnum Opus What is Property? Or, an Inquiry into the Principle of Right and Government Influenced by Hegel, Saint Simon, Charles Fourier, Victor Cousin, Rousseau, Cicero, Grotius Influences Karl Marx, Mikhail Bakunin, Déjacque, Édouard Depreux Pangasinan State University Social Science Department – PSU Lingayen BACHELOR OF ARTS IN ECONOMICS Econ 126 – HISTORY OF ECONOMIC THOUGHT Economic Thought Pierre-Joseph Proudhon Proudhon strenuously rejected the ownership of the products of labor by society or the state, arguing in What is Property? He argued that while society owned the means of production or land, users would control and run them (under supervision from society), with the "organizing of regulating societies" in order to "regulate the market". In the posthumously published Theory of Property, he argued that "property is the only power that can act as a counterweight to the State." Hence, "Proudhon could retain the idea of property as theft, and at the same time offer a new definition of it as liberty. There is the constant possibility of abuse, exploitation, which spells theft. At the same time property is a spontaneous creation of society and a bulwark against the ever-encroaching power of the State." Pangasinan State University Social Science Department – PSU Lingayen BACHELOR OF ARTS IN ECONOMICS Econ 126 – HISTORY OF ECONOMIC THOUGHT Thomas Tooke FAST FACTS Career English economist Born/Died February 28, 1774–February 26, 1858 School of economic thought Classical School Notable Economic Thought Magnum Opus History of Prices and of the State of the Circulation during the Years Influenced by David Ricardo, Robert Malthus, James Mill Influences John Fullarton and James Wilson, Robert Peel Pangasinan State University Social Science Department – PSU Lingayen BACHELOR OF ARTS IN ECONOMICS Econ 126 – HISTORY OF ECONOMIC THOUGHT Economic Thought Pierre-Joseph Proudhon Tooke is best known for his History of Prices and of the State of the Circulation during the Years 1703-1856. In the first four volumes he treats (a) of the prices of corn, and the circumstances affecting prices; (b) the prices of produce other than corn; and (c) the state of the circulation. The two final volumes, written with William Newmarch, deal with railways, free trade, banking in Europe and the effects of new discoveries of gold. The first two volumes dealt with the period from 1793 to 1837, and were published in 1838. His conclusions were that the high prices which, speaking generally, ruled between 1793 and 1814 were due to a relatively large number of unfavourable seasons, coupled with the obstructions to trade. Pangasinan State University Social Science Department – PSU Lingayen BACHELOR OF ARTS IN ECONOMICS Econ 126 – HISTORY OF ECONOMIC THOUGHT Wilhelm Roscher FAST FACTS Career German economist Born/Died October 21, 1817 – June 4, 1894 School of economic thought Classical School Notable Economic Thought Magnum Opus System der Volkswirthschaft Influenced by Georg Wilhelm Friedrich Hegel Influences Subsequent German economists Pangasinan State University Social Science Department – PSU Lingayen BACHELOR OF ARTS IN ECONOMICS Econ 126 – HISTORY OF ECONOMIC THOUGHT Economic Thought Wilhelm Roscher The main origins of the historical school of political economy may be traced to Roscher. Its fundamental principles are dated to his Grundriss zu Vorlesungen über die Staatswirtschaft nach geschichtlicher Methode (1843). Roscher tried to establish the laws of economic development by using the historical method from the investigation of histories legal, political, cultural and other aspects. Roscher developed a cyclical theory where nations and their economies pass through youth, manhood and senile decay. Pangasinan State University Social Science Department – PSU Lingayen BACHELOR OF ARTS IN ECONOMICS Econ 126 – HISTORY OF ECONOMIC THOUGHT William Godwin FAST FACTS Career English journalist, political philosopher and novelist Born/Died March 3, 1756 – April 7, 1836 School of economic thought Classical School Notable Economic Thought Magnum Opus Enquiry concerning Political Justice, and its Influence on General Virtue and Happiness Influenced by Edmund Burke Influences Robert Owen, Oscar Wilde, Peter Kropotkin Pangasinan State University Social Science Department – PSU Lingayen BACHELOR OF ARTS IN ECONOMICS Econ 126 – HISTORY OF ECONOMIC THOUGHT Economic Thought Wilhelm Roscher The main origins of the historical school of political economy may be traced to Roscher. Its fundamental principles are dated to his Grundriss zu Vorlesungen über die Staatswirtschaft nach geschichtlicher Methode (1843). Roscher tried to establish the laws of economic development by using the historical method from the investigation of histories legal, political, cultural and other aspects. Roscher developed a cyclical theory where nations and their economies pass through youth, manhood and senile decay. Pangasinan State University Social Science Department – PSU Lingayen BACHELOR OF ARTS IN ECONOMICS Econ 126 – HISTORY OF ECONOMIC THOUGHT