THE CHRISTADELPHIAN EXPOSITOR It provides remarkable lessons. Its presence by an oasis, always denotes the proximity of water. It produces nourishing, health-giving fruit, whilst every portion of the tree is used in some way or other. As the palm stands erect above other trees (Jer. 10:5), so does the bnde above all others (Song 7:7). See notes on the Psalm in Romance For Ettrnity at Song 7:7. ' "And the boughs orthick trees" — Here the word for "boughs" is different to that referred to above. The Hebrew word is anaph signifying "to cover". Accordingly, worshippers, at the Festival of Tabernacles, Drougnt in their hands the symbols of fruit and of covering. The word "thick" is the Hebrew 'aboth, and signifies intertwined, thus referring to trees with a thick foliage, the very word used suggesting co-operation. Some render the expression as "thick-leaved trees", and identify it with the myrtle. Certainly branches of myrtle trees were used to make the booths during the Festival of Tabernacles (Nch. 8:15). The myrtle has been associated wiih the ideas Ol love, peace and immortality from ancient times. As thorns are symbolic of rebellious Israel (Hcb. 6:8). so the myrtle. of repentant and restored Israel (Isa. 41:19; 55;I3; 61:3). The mynle finds a place in the vision of Zechariah regarding the Millennium (Zech. 1:8), or the antitypical Feast of Tabernacles (Zech. 14:16). Ii is a large, evergreen shrub, growing over 18 ft. high, bearing beautiful white flowers that give forth an exquisite perfume, with leaves noted for their 'ragrance. It bears purplish black-berries, known as mursins, which have a medicinal value. Esther's first name Hadassah is the Hebrew title for the Myrtle. "And willows of the brook" — The Hebrew title 'arabim is from a root signifying "to braid, intermix, traffic, give pledge, or provide security". The willow is so named probably because of the excellent, all-embracing cover of its heavy foliage, providing a covering of security. See Isa. 44:4. Some identify the willow of this verse with the poplar, but the reference to the tree as providing foliage to "cover him about" (Job. 40:22) certainly indicates the willow's all-embracing foliage. It favours brooks, watercourses, or moist places, growing rapidly with an abundance of well-leafed boughs, and easily propagated by slip. Its leaves are pretty, us bark was used for medicinal 228 CHAPTER TWENTY-THREE purposes (salicin, a substitute for quinine is extracted from it), and its roots perform a useful purpose in binding the banks of rivers, keeping them from being washed away. The tree, therefore, symbolically provides an excellent example of the value of drinking deeply of the water of life; being beautiful in appearance, health-giving and useful. It is used in Scripture of Godly people who make quick progress in the truth (Psa. 1:3; Isa. 15:7; 44:4). "And ye shall rejoice before Yahweh seven days" — The word samach, "rejoice", signifies "to brighten up, to make blithe or gleesome" (Strong). The Festival was celebrated with great enthusiasm and joy; and certainly the trees listed in this verse would help to stimulate the feeling of pleasure. Consider them in the order of their listing. The goodly trees reminded Israelites of (he great privilege of their standing before God. The palm tree denoted usefulness and fruit, produced in the desert, reminding Israelites that they can produce fruit to the glory of God and the wellbeing of one another, even though they .might dwell in a spiritual wilderness. The boughs of thick trees called them to fellowship and cooperation. The willows of the brook witnessed to the source of true blessing: drinking deeply of the water of life so as to manifest ample, all-embracing growth, providing beauty, covering, and healing tolor others. With the harvest gathered in as a witness of Yahweh s goodness towards them, and with the ideals set before them as expressed in (he figurative meaning of the boughs of the trees that formed their covering during the Festival-,!/4 true Israelites rejoiced together in view or the great hope set before them. They could do so in anticipation of the great lime when "the sun shall not light onj them nor any heat" (symbols of persecu-£\ lion and trouble — Rev. 7:16), but when, in the covering provided of Yahweh, they would rejoice in the goodness of God (Rom. 11:22). VERSE 41 "And ye shall keep it a feast unto Yahweh seven days in the year. It shall be a statute for ever in your generations; ye shall celebrate it in the seventh month" — This command taught Israelites that they must ever keep in mind the goodness of Yahweh towards them, as a token of the greater goodness to be revealed at the i CHAPTER TWENTY-THREE Millennium. VERSE 42 "Ye shall dwell in booths seven days" — The Hebrew word is suchah from whence the festival is given the title of Suchoth. The word denotes a hastily constructed and insubstantial, temporary shelter. Dwelling in these booths reminded Israelites of the nation's escape from Egypt (Exod. 13:20; Deut. 5:15). and in their prosperity to recognise, and thank Yahweh for His goodness towards them, thus instilling in them a humble and modest attitude. At the same time, they would be induced to look to the promised Millennium, when the temporary protection afforded Yahweh today will be replaced by one of permanency in the King.dom of God. "All that are Israelites born shall dwell in booths" — The "booths" in which Israelites kept the Festival, and the tents in which they dwelt during their sojourn in the wilderness, had this in common, that they were temporary places of abode: they belonged to the camp-life of a travelling community. The seven days of the Festival, therefore, was a fair symbol of the forty years of abode in tents in the wilderness, and were thus indicative of the state of believers prior to the setting up of the Kingdom: that of strangers ana sojourners in the world. The limitation of the command to "bom Israelites" is remarkable, particularly in view of the invitation to strangers to THE CHRISTADELPHIAN EXPOSITOR rejoice with Israelites (cp. Deut. 16:14). This provision of the Law was evidently designed to teach that the hope is Israelilish, and that a Gentile must become completely identified with the nation in order to partake of its benefits. If proselytes followed the example of the Kenites, they would have constantly dwelt in tents, indicative that the state of Israel, under the present dispensation is not that to which they are called, and which constituted the Kenites' hope (Jcr. 35). VERSE 43 "That your generations may know that I made the children of Israel to dwell in booths when I brought them out of the land of Egypt" — The Festival constantly recalled the separation of Israel from Egypt, and the temporary covering provided the nation in the wilderness until it entered the Land and the people dwelt in permanent dwellings. It thus pointed forward to the Millennium. The antitype is the temporary covering provided in Christ until the future age. "I am Yahweh your God" — This declaration authenticated ihe command to keep ihe Festival. VERSE 44 "And Moses declared unto the children of Israel the feasts of Yahweh" — The word "feasts" is tnowade, "the appointed times" of Yahweh. CHAPTER TWENTY-FOUR REQUIREMENTS FOR THE TABERNACLE This chapter continues instructions regarding service at the Tabernacle, particularly in regard to individual responsibilities thereto. It is divided into two parts: (I) Requisites for the Tabernacle supplied by the people; and (2) The penalty for blasphemy. A little thought will reveal that both sections are closely related. Requisites For The Tabernacle Supplied By the Tabernacle. The instructions for so doing are introduced at this place because the People — vv. 1-9 the provision of such represents the resThe people are commanded to make ponse of Israelites to the leaching of available oil and flour for the serviceofponseofIsraelitestotheleaching of 229 the THE CHRISTADELPHIAN EXPOSITOR CHAPTER TWENTY-FOUR Festivals. In supplying oil for the lamp, the people acknowledge their obligation to shine forth as witnesses of Yahweh; in providing flour for the shewbread, they acknowledge their obligations to dedicate the fruits of their labour to His service. a. Oil For Th« Lamps — w. 1-4 VERSE 1 ' "And Yahweh spake unco Moses, saying" — This is the re-occuring formula for introducing a sub-section.' VERSE 2 "Command (he children of Israel, that (hey bring un(o thee pure oil olive beaten Tor the light1' — As the command is to Israelites in general (see note Exod. 27:20-21), the oil was probably obtained at the public expense, rather than relying upon individuals to supply it. Beaten oil was the best quality. The berries were ripened by the influence of the sun to a purple colour — the colour of God manifestation. They were pounded in a mortar, and the juice extracted was then strained in order to ensure purity. This process illustrated the experience of every true Israelite then or now. It taught that true Israelites (represented by the berries) are brought to maturity by the strength of the Sun of righteousness (cp. Mai. 4:2); they are then subjected to trial and discipline (the pounding); are cleansed by the influence of the Word (John 15:3; Eph. 5:26); to finally produce the golden oil of faithful witness (see Psa. 43:3; Zech. 14:12-14; Phil. 2:15-16). See notes: Exod. 27:20; Rom. 11:17; Rev. 1:12-20. "To cause the lamps to burn continually" — In the Hebrew, lamps is given in (he singular number, indicating that the various bowls were part of the multitudinous whole. The verb to burn is literally to cause to ascend. The oil of the lamp was replenished daily causing the light to shine continuously and brightly in the darkness of the Holy Place. This taught that believers should make daily contact with the Word of God that they might manifest the light of its teaching before men (Matt. 5:16). morning before Yahweh continually. It shall be a statute for ever in your generalions" — In this statement "congregation" is mowade, so that the reference is to the "tabernacle of meeting", or the dwelling of Yahweh in Israel to which the people should resort at the set times appointed of Him. To '"order" is from the verb 'arak and signifies "to arrange in order, to set in a row" as in v. 8 (see also Exod. 40:4; Lev. 1:7). The context suggests that it was the oil that was so ordered", the bowls being replenished one after the other each evening, so that there would be no danger of the light going out whilst all slept. In the morning, the various lamps were "ordered" (v. 4), or "dressed" (Exod. 30:7; 39:37), so that the light was always burning, and never went out, as Josepnus testifies (see Num. 8:3). VERSE 4 "lie shall order the lamps upon (he pure candlestick before Yahweh continually" — See note Exod. 27:21. The oil was replenished in the evening, and the wicks of the lamps ("candlestick" should be "lampstand' ) every morning. The trimming ot the wicks is suggestive of the pruning of the vine (John 15:1-2), the discipline that saints receive in life, and which has a salutary effect upon them in developing their characters. In that regard, the Lord showed infinite patience in his treatment of his fellowmen (cp. Matt. 12:20), and his followers are called upon to imitate him in that regard. They are to do so as Aaron was called upon to perform his duties; for all that he did, or supervised, had to be done "before Yahweh", in conscious acknowledgement of the divine presence. Believers need to replenish their oil, and to trim their wicks with the presence of Yahweh always in mind. VERSE 3 "Without the vail of the testimony, in the tabernacle of (he congregation, shaU Aaron order it from the evening unto the 230 b. Shewbread For The Tables — w. 59 VERSE5 "And thou shall take fine flour, and bake twelve cakes thereof" — The twelve cakes so provided, primarily represented the twelve tribes, and therefore were indicative of the Israelitisli nature of the hope (John 4:22; Acts 26:7; 28:20; Rom. 9:4). But, typically, the twelve cakes also point forward to the multitudinous Christ, the nucleus of whom is Christ CHAPTER TWENTY-FOUR himself. The symbolism is significant. The grain gave up its life, submitted to being bruised into flour, and was carefully silted for purity and consistency. It was then baleen into cakes, and so, by being subjected to heat, was brought to maturity. The application to Christ is obvious: "he learned obedience by the things that he suffered" (Heb. 5:8-9), and so must those who would be incorporated into the multitudinous Christ. As the "bread of life" he can feed and strengthen all spiritual life (see Psa. 104:15 and notes on Exod. 25:30). "Two tenth deals shall be in one cake" — The reference to two draws attention to the two families into which humanity is divided: Jew and Gentile. The word for "tenth" is asarah in Hebrew, from a root signifying to accumlale, to grow rich, and thereby suggesting the "riches of the glory of his inheritance in the saints" (Eph. 1:18; 4:13; Lev. 23:13). The cakes, or loaves of bread, were of considerable size, for the measure of flour indicated represents about 81b, or 8.400k. Josephus says that they were made of unleavened flour, baken flat and perforated. The "two tenth deals" formed "one cake", thereby suggesting the principle advanced by Paul (1 Cor. 10:17): "We being many are one bread" in Christ. It is significant that the material was the same, both in quality and in quantity, with that of each one of the wave-loaves of Pentecost (Lev. 23:17). The truth, as proclaimed on the Day of Pentecost, is the measure expected throughout the ages. VERSE 6 "And thou shall set them in two rows, six on a row, upon the pure table before Yahweh" — Six is the number of flesh, but when multiplied by two, makes twelve: the number of perfect government. The two rows of six cakes making twelve in all and placed in order "before Yahweh" suggest flesh disciplined and governed according to His will. VERSE 7 "And thou shall put pure frankincense upon each row" — The frankincense suggests prayer and communion with Yahweh. Josephus states that two cups, or vials, of it were placed upon the piles of flat cakes. "Thai It may be on the bread for ■ THE CHRISTADELPHIAN EXPOSITOR memorial, even an offering made by fire unto Yahweh" — See note Lev. 2:2. Dr. Young renders this as "it may be to the bread for a memorial . . . " Frankincense is a symbol of prayer, and bread speaks of the spirit word. By absorption of that word we partake ot Christ, the bread of life (John 6:51). The type taught that prayer should be added to the study of the Word. The frankincense was put into small gold cups, or vials (Exod. 25:29), and, most likely, was burnt upon the altar each sabbath. VERSE 8 "Every sabbath he shall set it in order before Yahweh continually" — There were important lessons taught by this provision of the Law. First, it drew attention to the day itself. The sabbath, as such, was the sign of the Covenant between Yahweh and Israel (Exod. 31:1617). Next, it illustrated the principle of "order" or "regularity" in divine service, for such is pleasing to God (1 Cor. 14:40; 16 : 2; Col. 2:5; Heb. 10:25). Finally, it emphasised the basis of fellowship: the hope of Israel. The shewbread was to be changed every sabbath, and the loaves, or cakes, that were removed were eaten by the priests in the holy place. Disciples of the Lord, are described as "priests of God". As such they enjoy fellowship with one another, and with God, by eating "bread" in the "holy lace" (their status in Christ, cp. Heb. 3:10). The bread, was used "as a memorial" in that the rank and Gle of Israel witnessed the priests engaged in the service of the bread each sabbath. The eating of it by the priests (who represented both Yahweh and Israel) was typical of Yahweh's acceptance of the nation. "Being taken from the children of Israel by an everlasting covenant" — As a form of meal offering, the twelve loaves symbolised the dedication of the nation's fruits of labour unto Yahweh. The sabbath represented the Millennium when the dedicated fruits of present labour in His service will find open approval by Him. Each cake represented a tribe. f VERSE 9 "And it shall be Aaron's and his sons" — In the service of the Temple, the preparation and arrangement of the cakes were committed to the Levites (1 Chron. 9:32; 23:27-29; 2 Chron. 13:11). 231 THE ChKlSTADELPHIAN EXPOSITOR CHAPTER TWENTY-FOUR "And they shall eat it in the holy place: for it is most holy unto Him of the offerings of Tire made by a perpetual statute" — See note Lev. 2:3. bances have been caused in the Ecclesias by some who have insisted on their "rights", whilst, at the same time, disobeying the marriage laws incidental to a proper walk in the Truth. The parentage of this trouble-maker indicated that such was the root cause of the problem. The Penalty of Blasphemy — w. 10-23 The method of execution relating to an offence of blasphemy has not previously been laid down. A case now arising, the matter is referred to Moses, and by him to Yahweh, mat the divine will in such cases may be made known. The punishment is threefold (a) The blasphemer is to be put to death (vv. 10-16); (b) The accused is lo be tried judicially (vv. 17-22); (c) The guilty party is to be publicly executed by being stoned by representatives of the whole nation (v. 23). (a) The Blasphemer To Be Put To Death — vv. 10-16 VERSE 10 "And th* son of an Israelilish woman, whose fat. r was an Egyptian" — As such he was a member of the mixed multitude that left Egypt in company with Israel (Exod. 12:38). Moses had trouble with those Gentiles from the beginning (Exod. 11:4); a warning to Gentile believers today. "Went out among the children of Israel" — The very way in which this is recorded suggests an act of defiance. The foreigner moved among the Israelites as though he were of equal status with them by birth, and hence failed to "remember" the privilege that he enjoyed by being separated from Gentilism, and incorporated into the Commonwealth of Israel (Eph. 2:11-13). Egyptians had to qualify for full entrance into the congregation of Israel; they were not permitted therein until the third generation (Deut. 23:8). Therefore, this person should have remained in the separate allotment of the camp that evidently was reserved for such as he. "And this son of the Israelitish woman and a man of Israel strove together in the camp" — The emphasis given to his mother suggests that he lay claim to being a full Israelite on the grounds of his relationship to her, whereas, in fact, her marriage had been a disgrace. The narrative does not record the cause of the strife, but Jewish tradition suggests, that he claimed the right to a position in the allotment of Dan, and that his insistence on this created the disturbance. Dislur- VERSE 11 "And the Israelitish woman's son blasphemed the Name of the Lord" — The addition of the Lord is not in the original. A reference to the Name was all-sufficient to indicate to a true Israelite what Name was referred to: the name Yahweh. It is this verse that the Jews use to justify their refusal to pronounce the name, and accordingly, the Hebrew nachav, which is correctly translated blaspheme is incorrectly rendered pronounced in the Septuagml, as though the blasphemy was in pronouncing the name. Why should this man of mixed parentage blaspheme? Perhaps he tried to force himself upon the Israelites as being of pure stock, and when reminded of the exclusiveness of the nation based upon the Name (Exod. 3:15), and the stigma of his parents' marriage, he was induced to blaspheme, if so', instead of acting in that way, he should have acknowledged a fault in the mixed marriage, and humbly submitted to Yahweh's requirements. But, whatever the circumstances, he added sin to sin by blaspheming the Name. The word nachav is from a root signifying "to pierce", and hence to violently set aside (it is rendered "pierce" in 2 Kings 18:21). It denotes to execrate, or to pierce one's character. He evidently spoke disrespectfully of the exclusiveness demanded by Yahweh. "And cursed" — The word signifies to treat lightly, dispose, revile. The Law pronounced the penalty of death upon one who cursed father or mother (Exod. 21:17), so there was little doubt as to the penalty of one who cursed God Whose status was that of Father to the nation. The doubt, in question, was as to the manner of execution. "And they brought him unto Moses" — The man was apprehended and taken before Moses in accordance with the instructions of Exod. 18:22. Moses, in turn, took the problem to God (Num. 27:5). "And hismother'snamewasShelomith, the daughter of Dibre, of the tribe of Dan" — Her name is recorded for some purpose. Possibly the reason is found in 232 CHAPTER TWENTY-FOUR the meaning of i t - "Shelomith" is the feminine form of Solomon, and signifies peacefulness. Her action in marriage suggests that she looked for peace at any price. "Dibre" signifies wordy; possibly, on her part, there was too much talk and not enough action. "Dan" denotes judge. But, in her marriage, she did not judge aright. VERSE 12 "And they put him in ward" — This is the first reference to a jail in Scripture. Young renders the plural they in the singular he, claiming that the Massorites altered it to they, perhaps because the use of the singular number would imply that Moses was in ignorance of what should have been done. "That the mind of Yahweh might be shewed them" — The margin renders this: To expound unto them according to the mouth of Yahweh. In support of the emendation, we point out that the word "mind" is peh in Hebrew, literally "mouth". "Shewed" is parish, "to separate, spread out" and hence to expound. The Berkeley Version gives the statement as "awaiting revelation of Yahweh's will . . . " with a footnote: "The man, half Egyptian and half Hebrew, obviously not well trained in Hebrew lore and worship, had spoken the Name insultingly. The Rabbis, when copying the sacred writings put Adonai instead of Yahweh to guard against further abuse of the Name, and so read it in the services." VERSE 13 "And Yahweh spake unto Moses saying" — Most likely Moses entered the Most Holy to receive this revelation (Num. 7:89). VERSE 14 "Bring forth him that hath cursed without the camp, and let all that heard him lay their hands upon his head" — There was a general assembly called that the lesson might be impressed upon all Israel. Then witnesses were required to step forth and lay their hands upon the head of the blasphemer. At least two witnesses were required for a conviction (Deut. 17:6), for the evidence had to be corroborated. They placed their hands upon the head of the reviler, not merely in endorsement of his guilt, but albo as an indication of the seat and source of sin. THE CHRISTADELPHIAN EXPOSITOR See Deut. 13:9; 17:7. "And let all the congregation stone him" — The word "congregation" is edah, "witness". The guilty party was to be executed by representatives of the nation, through whom it collectively witnessed to the justice of the penalty. VERSE 15 "And Ihou shall speak unto the children of Israel, saying. Whosoever curseth his God shall bear his sin" — Anybody making light of God shall be accounted guilty, and compelled to pay the prescribed penalty, whatever that penalty might be. However, there may be extenuating circumstances, allowing the offence to be purged by sacrifice. VERSE 16 "And he that blasphemeth the name of Yahweh, he shall surely be put to death, and all the congregation shall certainly stone him" — The deliberate blasphemer of the name was to be executed; there was no remitting of this extreme publishment in such a case. The Law, therefore, discriminated between "cursing" and "blaspheming". What is the difference? The former (qalul) denotes "to treat lightly", "to despise", as well as "to revile". A person could treat God lightly without going to the extreme of vocally blaspheming God. In such a case, his crime was judicially considered, and punishment administered accordingly. To blaspheme" is to deliberately and knowingly speak against God, and for that there was no forgiveness. See Christ's warning: Matt. 12:31. "As well the stranger, as he that is born in the land" — Foreigners when dwelling in the land governed by Israel must learn to respect Yahweh. "When he blasphemeth the name of hweh, shall be put to death" — Notice that the words of the Lord are in italics. The Hebew has only the Name, but every true Israelite knew what that term signified. For such an offence, the death penalty was exacted against foreigners as well as Israelites. b. All Executions To Be Done Judicially — vv. 17-22 VERSE 17 "And he that killeth any man shall surely be put to death" — The Hebrew 233 THE CHRISTADELPHIAN EXPOSITOR has nephesh adorn, or "soul of man". The margin renders: smitelh the life of a man. This describes not an accidental killing, but a deliberate murder. VERSE 18 "And he that killeth a beast shall make it good; beast for beast" — The word for "beast" in the latter two occurrences of the word is nephesh, "life". The party responsible for the death shall make it good, life for life, or value for value (see Exod. 21:23; Deul. 19:21, and note Christ's comment in Matt. 5:38). VERSE 19 "And if a man cause a blemish in his neighbour, as he hath done, so shall it be done to him" — In such a case, the guilty party shall make, or pay, adequate compensation (see note, Exod. 21:24-25). VERSE 20 "Breach for breach, eye for eye, tooth for tooth; as he hath caused a blemish in a man, so shall it be done to him again" — This does not mean that if a person knocked out a tooth of an enemy that he had a tooth of his own knocked out, but, as in our note on Exodus 21:24-25, proper compensation must be made for any hurt caused. This is shown by the legislation of v. 21. VERSE 21 "And he that killeth a beast shall restore it" — See note, Exod. 21:33-34. "And he that killeth a man, he shall be put to death" — There was judicial trial made, as in the case of the blasphemer referred to previously in this chapter, and if it were proved to be deliberate murder, the death penalty was imposed. See note Exod. 21:12-14. VERSE 22 "Ye shall have one manner of law, as well as for the strangers, as for one of your own country" — The blasphemer referred to earlier in this chapter, was not a true Israelite, and may have pleaded accordingly as extenuating circumstances in his case, but such a plea was to be refused. Anybody visiting Israel became subject to the law of Yahweh and was held accountable to its requirements. The listing of these laws in this place together with the extreme penalty to be imposed is thus shown to be appropriate. Indeed, CHAPTER TWENTY-FOUR the statement before us reveals the complete justice ot Yahweh's law, in contrast to those of other nations. British law is based upon the principle of a common law for both citizens and foreigners; Roman law was not: it gave preference to Romans, so that in some cases foreigners could not plead against such.- But Yahweh's law had to be administered properly. Notwithstanding the provocation offered, or the gravity of the offence, it must not be exercised in an unlawful manner, but in a way that witnessed to the righteousness of Yahweh. "For I am Yahweh your God" — The proper administration of God's law added to the dignity of His name, as well as to the authority of the decrees He pronounced. The Law elevated Yahweh in the minds of both citizens and foreigners. A pity that the law of the land today does not do so. c. The Blasphemer To Be Stoned — v. 23 VERSE 23 "And Moses spake to the children of Israel, that they should bring forth him that had cursed out of the camp, and stone him with stones" — This is the first penalty executed for blasphemy (cp. Exod. 20:7). Stoning was adopted as a mode of punishment because of its remoteness: the executors had no personal contact with the dead body, which would have been defiling. See note Exod. 19:1213. "And the children of Israel did as Yahweh commanded Moses" — The Scriptures record nine instances of stoning: The reviler of this chapter (Lev. 24:1123); the sabbath breaker (Num. 15:36); Achan and his family (Josh. 7:25); Abimelech (Jud. 9:53); Adoram (1 Kings 12:18); Naboth (1 Kings 21:13); Zechariah by Joash (2 Chron. 24:21); Stephen (Acts 7:58); Paul (Acts 14:19). Only in the case of Paul, was the action not fatal. 234