WE CAN! LET’S GO! AND LET’S MOVE! Attempts at Moving the Needle on Childhood Obesity: A Trio of Case Studies Digital Strategies for Health Communication (HCOM512) Jasmine Hunt 7/15/12 We Can! is a national movement designed to give parents, caregivers, and entire communities a way to help children 8 to 13 years old stay at a healthy weight. Eating healthy, being physically active, and limiting screen time Target audiences: children, parents, and community partners 9 subpages •5,657 Likes •Posts include: healthy recipes, articles, ideas for physical activity (relevant for summer), and questions •Geared toward parents YouTube page has 12 videos, 71 subscribers PSAs, professionals talking about the program Sponsored video contest- only shows winner and runner-up Strengths Weaknesses •NIH is a large and reputable government •Facebook and all but one YouTube video are agency not available in Spanish •Initiative is in collaboration with NHLBI, •YouTube content bland and not engaging NIDDK, NICHD, and NCI •Change may be restricted by government •Website is available in Spanish bureaucracy •Comprehensive content •Social media use requires a disclaimer, •Attractive homepage privacy notice, and comment policy •Previous successes (since 2005) •Dense content •Research-based program •Complex and inconsistent navigation •Easy to “get lost” in subpages and links •Few Facebook “likes” and no Twitter account Opportunities Threats •General interest in health, nutrition, •Many other health organizations are and physical activity more engaging and visible in the public •Technologies can support the spread eye of information, access, and connection •Too many other things vying for to others parents’ attention •Other websites more frequented for health info •Funding issues •Belief that healthy food and exercise cost a lot •Some communities are not conducive to exercise or have access to healthy food Let’s Go! is a nationally recognized childhood obesity prevention program based in Maine. Main goal is to increase the proportion of youth, ages 0-18, at a healthy weight. And they seek to change policy and environments to support healthy eating and active living. 5-2-1-0 (5 or more fruits and vegetables, 2 hours or less of recreational screen time, 1 hour or more of physical activity, and 0 sugary drinks) Schools, after school programs, child care, worksites, and health care •1, 344 Likes •Posts include: pictures from events, questions, links to articles, and details on upcoming events. •One-sided (who is this for?) •56 followers, 96 tweets •Tweets include: links to relevant articles, few events, questions (no photos) •Not updated regularly (last updated over 2 months ago) •Branding Strengths Weaknesses •Collaboration with over 56 schools, 7 large workplaces, 34 child care programs, and 29 health care sites •Partnered with Maine State Parks and other community partners •Model has gained national support through the American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP) and the Let’s Move initiative • Memorable, consistent message (5-21-0) •Successful 5-year “demonstration project” •5-2-1-0 model picked up in other states •Recommendations based on medical research •Involvement in local, state, and national initiatives •Devoted staff and partners •Website, Facebook, Twitter, and YouTube videos are not available in Spanish •Only some documents available in other languages •YouTube content not aimed at children or parents •Website homepage is lackluster •Overall, website is a bit sparse for resources •Content for parents is difficult to find •Poor quality instructional videos •Social media use requires a disclaimer and comment policy •Few Facebook “likes” and few Twitter followers •Underdeveloped social media pages Opportunities Threats •General interest in health, nutrition, and physical activity •Technologies can support the spread of information, access, and connection to others •Other 5-2-1-0 initiatives across the nation have better web and social media strategies •Other organizations provide more and better quality information and resources for parents •Too many other things vying for parents’ attention •Funding issues •Some communities are not conducive to exercise or have access to healthy food •Belief that healthy food and exercise cost a lot Let’s Move! is a comprehensive initiative, launched by First Lady Michelle Obama, that is dedicated to solving the challenge of childhood obesity within a generation, so that children born today will grow up healthier and able to pursue their dreams. Helpful information for parents Environments that support healthy choices Healthier foods in our schools Access to healthy, affordable food More physical activity for kids Ex: Take a walk with your family after dinner: family calendar, families activities guide, tips on setting goals, and other helpful ideas •Dietary Guidelines for Americans •MyPlate •Front-of-Pack Labeling description •Doctors will prescribe simple ways to increase healthy eating •Eating healthy on a budget •97,460 Likes •Over 100 photos •Links to YouTube videos and blog posts •Links, events, colorful photos featuring the Obama family, celebrities, and happy children •10-50 Comments •Spokesperson YouTube ~100 videos, 675,334 views overall, 6,255 subscribers Michelle Obama in most of the videos Geared toward parents mostly Videos range from PSAs to White House events, to live cooking demonstrations with Bobby Flay, to the First Lady dancing with students in Iowa Twitter 42,070 followers and 958 tweets Tweets include upcoming events, such as those on Meetup, news and updates, contests, and healthy tips More useful info than their Facebook page More kid-friendly (healthy recipe contest, Disney Channel retweets) Other Meetup: 875 communities. Aims to spark face-toface meetings and activities locally and nationally. Flickr: fun and inspirational photos from events and other appearances Strengths •Backed by the power and legitimacy of the White House •Many community and national partners •Website is available in Spanish •Content is mostly clear •Attractive homepage and design •Sincere and intelligent spokesperson (Michelle Obama) •Great photo opportunities with the First Lady, the President, and other celebrities. •Ability to be wide-reaching •Well maintained and popular social media •Highly-visible brand, consistent, appealing Weaknesses •It does not appear that videos or social media is available in Spanish •Some of the website content is not organized in the best way for parents’ use. •Change may be restricted by government bureaucracy •Social media use requires a disclaimer, privacy notice, and comment policy Opportunities Threats •General interest in healthy living •Technologies can support the spread of information, access, and connection to others •Funding may be depleted by other more pressing issues. •If Obama does not get re-elected, program will likely stop. •Some communities are not conducive to exercise or have access to healthy food •Belief that healthy food and exercise cost a lot Comparison of Three Programs We Can! Let’s Go! Let’s Move! Nutrition, physical activity, screen time Nutrition, physical activity, screen time, sugary drinks Nutrition, physical activity Reach kids through Reach kids through parents and caregivers schools, after school programs, child care centers, worksites, and health care facilities Reach kids through parents, schools, local officials, community leaders, chefs, and health care providers Appealing colors, photos, dropdown menus---dense content, confusing layout Very visually appealing and interactive, difficult to find certain info, 5 simple steps Does not appeal to kids or parents, lack of materials for sectors, overwhelming links, cluttered Comparison of Three Programs We Can! Let’s Go! Let’s Move! Facebook, YouTube Facebook, YouTube, Twitter Facebook, YouTube, Twitter, Flickr, Meetup Redy mascot, cartoon graphics. and color palette is elementary Michelle Obama as a strong role model (kids, parents, passionate leader). Vibrant colors, happy children, fun! Branding and Tone: Diversity, unity, community, and family Recommendation for We Can! Website: Reorganize content and adjust navigation, consolidate materials Facebook: Consistent posts, interactive materials for target audience YouTube: Videos giving parents tips on healthy meals, portion sizes, and including children. Show families games to play indoors/outdoors. Use charismatic spokesperson to speak about limiting screen time. Videos in Spanish Twitter: Start one!....Quick tips, links to videos and other resources, promote events. Link to other accounts that parents follow Recommendation for Let’s Go! Website: Kid-friendly section, change layout, consistent branding, provide resources and tools for each sector, easy to find info Add more to community specific pages, news, events YouTube: Higher quality videos, stories from families in pilot, tips for other families, community partners reaching out to invite others to join the program, instructional videos of how to become a 5-2-1-0 school, etc. Cooking and physical activity how-to videos for parents and kids. YouTube and Twitter: Link to new videos, tips, update often, interactive Collaborate with other 5-2-1-0 programs in other states to increase visibility/unity of message and share resources. Recommendation for Let’s Move! Website: Restructure a little, more practical info upfront, change “Take Action” name. Facebook/Twitter: Incorporate more useful info for parents and kids (rather than just publicity), personal narratives, human interest stories Interlink social platforms