Alec Champbell, the last surviving Australian to fight at Gallipoli. 26Feb 1899-16 May 2002 Year 9 History, Semester 2- 2012 Depth Study 3: World War One (1914-1918) Students investigate key aspects of World War I and the Australian experience of the war, including the nature and significance of the war in world and Australian history. 1. An overview of the causes of World War I and the reasons why men enlisted to fight in the war 2. The places where Australians fought and the nature of warfare during World War I, including the Gallipoli campaign 3. The impact of World War I, with a particular emphasis on Australia (such as the use of propaganda to influence the civilian population, the changing role of women, the conscription debate) 4. The commemoration of World War I, including debates about the nature and significance of the Anzac legend. 1 2 Lesson-1 World War 1 Watch YouTube clip http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uP_0DkpFOKs Origins and major features of the war World War I is often said to have been caused by the assassination of Archduke Franz Ferdinand, heir to the Austro-Hungarian Empire, and his wife, Sophie, Duchess of Hohenberg, in the Bosnian city of Sarajevo. Their deaths occurred on 28 June 1914, and by 4 August all the great European powers were at war. The assassination was a trigger for the European powers to honour their alliances and look after their own interests. One by one they mobilised and prepared for war: the empires of Germany and Austria-Hungary on one side and those of Russia, France and Great Britain on the other. Other countries joined later. It was a war between empires because its roots were in nationalism and imperialism. The empires fought to gain a bigger empire or to preserve the empire that they had. As the war continued it became difficult to stop, as the idea of losing became unthinkable after so many resources had been invested and there was so much suffering. Australia will be there, but at what cost? Being part of the British Empire meant that Australia was committed to the war immediately. Men flocked to enlist, many fearful that they would miss out on a great adventure. As the war progressed, the horrors of Gallipoli and the Western Front changed people's perspective. Many soldiers who returned home were physically and mentally scarred after the war. Out of the suffering of this war arose the Anzac legend. The landing on the Gallipoli peninsula in 1915 was Australia's 'baptism of fire'. Throughout World War I, Australian soldiers demonstrated the same characteristics under fire that they showed at Gallipoli. The soldiers returned to a country that was proud of their achievements: Anzac Day had already been celebrated in 1916. The war had divided Australians and caused major political and social changes, which were exacerbated by the conscription plebiscites of 1916 and 1917. Optional – YouTube Rowan Atkinson Why did WW1 begin? Blackadder - How did the war start_ (eng sub) [www.keepvid.com].mp4 Task: Draw table of short term/long term causes for war. After watching YouTube clip, create small mind map with words that represent war to you Write 6 words that represent what it is to be an ANZAC (short discussion on how these words match or not with ideals of war Mindmap – Why did Australia become involved in WWI in 1914? Lesson-2/3 Learning intention-To gain an understand of conditions in Europe at this time in the lead-up to the assisination of Arch Duke Franz Ferdinand. PowerPoint – Causes of World War 1 i) Long Term Causes ii) Short Term Causes ..\Powerpoints\Causes of WWI.ppt 3 Schlieffen Plan In 1904 France and Britain signed the Entente Cordiale (friendly understanding). The objective of the alliance was to encourage co-operation against the perceived threat of Germany. Negotiations also began to addRussia to this alliance. As a result of these moves the German military began to fear the possibility of a combined attack from France, Britain and Russia. Alfred von Schlieffen, German Army Chief of Staff, was given instructions to devise a strategy that would be able to counter a joint attack. In December, 1905, he began circulating what later became known as the Schlieffen Plan. Schlieffen argued that if war took place it was vital that France was speedily defeated. If this happened, Britain and Russia would be unwilling to carry on fighting. Schlieffen calculated that it would take Russia six weeks to organize its large army for an attack on Germany. Therefore, it was vitally important to force France to surrender before Russia was ready to use all its forces. Schlieffen's plan involved using 90% of Germany's armed forces to attack France. Fearing the French forts on the border with Germany, Schlieffen suggested a scythelike attack through Holland, Belgium andLuxembourg. The rest of the German Army would be sent to defensive positions in the east to stop the expected Russian advance. When Helmuth von Moltke replaced Alfred von Schlieffen as German Army Chief of Staff in 1906, he modified the plan by proposing that Holland was not invaded. The main route would now be through the flat plains of Flanders. Moltke argued that Belgium's small army would be unable to stop German forces from quickly entering France. Moltke suggested that 34 divisions should invade Belgium whereas 8 divisions would be enough to stop Russia advancing in the east. On 2nd August 1914, the Schlieffen Plan was put into operation when the German Army invadedLuxembourg and Belgium. However, the Germans were held up by the Belgian Army and were shocked by the Russian Army's advance into East Prussia. The Germans were also surprised by how quickly the British Expeditionary Force reached France and Belgium. Task: On map provided, mark in the Schlieffen Plan and in your own word answer the following: 1. Why did Germany create this plan (objectives and why they felt it was needed)? 2. What were the potential benefits of this plan? 3. What were the failings? (What did they overlook or miss judge?) 4. What was the outcome? The Schlieffen Plan YouTube clips http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lCbNE3ToePA http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lJXAcl8D51Y&feature=relmfu 4 Lesson-4 PowerPoint-Gallipoli Campaign W.W.1 lesson outline 2012\Gallipoli powerpoint.pptx http://www.anzacsite.gov.au/1landing/ (this site has an interactive website that allows students to look at a map of the landing) Task: Watch the following YouTube clip http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=E9A4ARtbmFk then read through the lyrics and in one paragraph outline the how war was portrayed in this song. When I was a young man I carried me pack And I lived the free life of the rover From the Murray's green basin to the dusty outback I waltzed my Matilda all over Then in 1915 my country said: Son, It's time to stop rambling, there's work to be done So they gave me a tin hat and they gave me a gun And they sent me away to the war And the band played Waltzing Matilda When the ship pulled away from the quay And amid all the tears, flag waving and cheers We sailed off for Gallipoli It well I remember that terrible day When our blood stained the sand and the water And how in that hell they call Suvla Bay We were butchered like lambs at the slaughter Johnny Turk, he was ready, he primed himself well He rained us with bullets, and he showered us with shell And in five minutes flat, we were all blown to hell He nearly blew us back home to Australia And the band played Waltzing Matilda When we stopped to bury our slain Well we buried ours and the Turks buried theirs Then it started all over again Oh those that were living just tried to survive In that mad world of blood, death and fire And for ten weary weeks I kept myself alive While around me the corpses piled higher Then a big Turkish shell knocked me arse over head And when I awoke in me hospital bed And saw what it had done, I wished I was dead I never knew there was worse things than dying Oh no more I'll go Waltzing Matilda All around the green bush far and near For to hump tent and pegs, a man needs both legs No more waltzing Matilda for me They collected the wounded, the crippled, the maimed And they shipped us back home to Australia The armless, the legless, the blind and the insane 5 Those proud wounded heroes of Suvla And when the ship pulled into Circular Quay I looked at the place where me legs used to be And thank Christ there was no one there waiting for me To grieve and to mourn and to pity And the Band played Waltzing Matilda When they carried us down the gangway Oh nobody cheered, they just stood there and stared Then they turned all their faces away Now every April I sit on my porch And I watch the parade pass before me I see my old comrades, how proudly they march Renewing their dreams of past glories I see the old men all tired, stiff and worn Those weary old heroes of a forgotten war And the young people ask "What are they marching for?" And I ask myself the same question And the band plays Waltzing Matilda And the old men still answer the call But year after year, their numbers get fewer Someday, no one will march there at all Waltzing Matilda, Waltzing Matilda Who'll come a-Waltzing Matilda with me? And their ghosts may be heard as they march by the billabong So who'll come a-Waltzing Matilda with me? Lesson-5/6 Movie-Gallipoli Task: Fill in the grid that is on the next page in your booklets Gallipoli (Peter Weir) Find examples of the following in the film. Describe what happens. 6 Australian’s enthusiasm to join the war. List all the reasons the film depicts. Australian’s attitude towards England. Australian’s attitude towards Germany. Australia is a long way from Europe Australian’s antiauthoritarianism. Australian mateship Training for the war. Conditions in the trenches 7 Lesson-7 The AIF served in Egypt, Palestine, the Gallipoli Peninsula and the Western Front. After the Gallipoli campaign, the Australian infantry divisions went on to fight some of the worst battles of the war, in France and in Flanders (Belgium). Between 1916 and late 1918, 295 000 Australian soldiers served in this area of the Western Front. The Battle of the Somme in France in 1916 and the Battle of Passchendaele in Flanders in 1917 are the two battles which most represent the needless slaughter of young Australian men on the World War I battlefields. Map of the Western Front – identify the numerous places Australian soldiers fought. http://www.bbc.co.uk/history/interactive/animations/western_front/index_embed.shtml Trench warfare and living conditions W.W.1 lesson outline 2012\Trench warfare and living conditions.docx W.W.1 lesson outline 2012\Primary Source - accounts from the trenchesWhilst asleep during the night.docx Task: Students will take turns reading through the information below and then answer questions in their books. Trench warfare is a form of occupied fighting lines, consisting largely of trenches, in which troops are largely protected from the enemy's small arms fire and are substantially sheltered from artillery. It has become a byword for attrition warfare, for stalemate in conflict, with a slow wearing down of opposing forces. Trench warfare occurred when a military revolution in firepower was not matched by similar advances in mobility, resulting in a grueling form of warfare in which the defense held the advantage. In World War I, both sides constructed elaborate trench and dugout systems opposing each other along a front, protected from assault by barbed wire. The area between opposing trench lines (known as "no man's land") was fully exposed to artillery fire from both sides. Attacks, even if successful, often sustained severe casualties as a matter of course. 8 Rat Infestation Rats in their millions infested trenches. There were two main types, the brown and the black rat. Both were despised but the brown rat was especially feared. Gorging themselves on human remains (grotesquely disfiguring them by eating their eyes and liver) they could grow to the size of a cat. Men, exasperated and afraid of these rats (which would even scamper across their faces in the dark), would attempt to rid the trenches of them by various methods: gunfire, with the bayonet, and even by clubbing them to death. It was futile however: a single rat couple could produce up to 900 offspring in a year, spreading infection and contaminating food. The rat problem remained for the duration of the war (although many veteran soldiers swore that rats sensed impending heavy enemy shellfire and consequently disappeared from view). Frogs, Lice and Worse Rats were by no means the only source of infection and nuisance. Lice were a neverending problem, breeding in the seams of filthy clothing and causing men to itch unceasingly. Even when clothing was periodically washed and deloused, lice eggs invariably remained hidden in the seams; within a few hours of the clothes being re-worn the body heat generated would cause the eggs to hatch. Lice caused Trench Fever, a particularly painful disease that began suddenly with severe pain followed by high fever. Recovery - away from the trenches - took up to twelve weeks. Frogs by the score were found in shell holes covered in water; they were also found in the base of trenches. Slugs and horned beetles crowded the sides of the trench. Many men chose to shave their heads entirely to avoid another prevalent scourge: nits. Trench Foot was another medical condition peculiar to trench life. It was a fungal infection of the feet caused by cold, wet and unsanitary trench conditions. It could turn gangrenous and result in amputation. Trench Foot was more of a problem at the start of trench warfare; as conditions improved in 1915 it rapidly faded, although a trickle of cases continued throughout the war. 9 “Whilst asleep during the night, we were frequently awakened by rats running over us. When this happened too often for my liking, I would lie on my back and wait for a rat to linger on my legs; then violently heave my legs upwards, throwing the rat into the air. Occasionally, I would hear a grunt when the rat landed on a fellow victim.” (R L Venables) “If you have never had trench foot described to you, I will explain. Your feet swell to two to three times their normal size and go completely dead. You can stick a bayonet into them and not feel a thing. If you are lucky enough not to lose your feet and the swelling starts to go down, it is then that the most indescribable agony begins. I have heard men cry and scream with pain and many have had to have their feet and legs amputated. I was one of the lucky ones, but one more day in that trench and it may have been too late.” (Harry Roberts) “The water in the trenches through which we waded was alive with a multitude of swimming frogs. Red slugs crawled up the side of the trenches and strange beetles with dangerous looking horns wriggled along dry ledges and invaded the dugouts, in search of the lice that infested them.” (unknown journalist) “To get a ‘cushy’ one is all the old hands think about. A bloke in the Camerons wanted a ‘cushy’ bad! Fed up and far from home he was. He puts his finger over the top and gets his trigger finger taken off and two more besides. “I’m off to bonny Scotland!” he says laughing. But on the way down to the dressing station, he forgets to stoop low where an old sniper is working. He gets it through the head.” (Robert Graves) “We slept in our clothes and cut our hair short so that it would tuck inside our caps. Dressing simply meant putting on our boots. There were times when we had to scrape the lice off with the blunt edge of a knife and our underclothes stuck to us. “ (Elizabeth de T’Serclaes– a nurse on the front line) “No 1……2 Private A B; the Battalion (Pioneers) South Staffordshire Regiment was tried by FGCM on the following charges: “Misbehaving in such a manner as to show cowardice”. The accused, when proceeding with a party for work in the trenches, ran away owing to the bursting of a shell and did not rejoin the party. The sentence of the court was to suffer death by being shot." "We must looked out for our bread. The rats have become much more numerous lately because the trenches are no longer in good condition. The rats here are particularly repulsive, they are so fat the kind we call corpse-rats. They have shocking, evil, naked faces, and it is nauseating to see their long, nude tails." Erich Maria Remarque 10 Questions i) ii) iii) iv) How accurate is this description of trench warfare? How do we know these things really occurred in the trenches? What happened to the guy who wanted to get a ‘cushy’ exit back to Scotland? What is a ‘cushy one’? Why were the rats in the trenches often referred to as corpse-rats? Choose 6 words that describe conditions in the trenches Lesson-8 Working in pairs, research the following locations that Australians fought during WWI. Passchendaele, in Flanders Fromelles The Somme Sinai Palestine For each location, answer the following questions and record them in your books: i) ii) iii) iv) v) When did the battle/s take place, and how many Australian soldiers were involved? Who were the Australians fighting with and who were they fighting against at this location? What were the conditions of this location like (eg weather, food, etc)? How many Australians were killed and/or injured in this location? What was the outcome of the battle/s fought there? ASSESSMENT Historiography Task-Document Analysis Impact of war Lesson- 9 Explore the brief timeline of events in WWI http://www.timetoast.com/timelines/18-key-events-of-world-war-1 11 The enlistment dilemma Prior to 1915, the most dangerous activity for Australians had been working in the mining industry. This changed during World War I. As war casualty figures were published, people began to question their initial enthusiasm for war. Year Deaths 1915 8 474 1916 13 696 1917 21 736 1918 14 240 Source 10.1 Numbers of Australian servicemen who died in each year of the war Task: Explore the site below and create a graph using the statistics given for Australia, Great Britain and 3 other countries http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/World_War_I_casualties Propaganda A variety of propaganda campaigns and a reduction in the required physical standards of entry in 1915 contributed to increased enlistments. Until the middle of 1915 there had been no organised recruitment program; men joined in response to their own feelings or private pressures. The Australian government was forced into action because it had promised Great Britain more men than it was able to deliver. Men who had thought that they would not be needed came forward, along with those who had wanted to join but whose physical standard did not reach that required in 1914. From the middle of 1915, various patriotic ceremonies were organised to raise money for the war effort and to encourage enlistment. The new monuments erected to honour those killed in the war were popular sites for such ceremonies. The ceremonies were usually religious or nationalist in nature. One or more returned soldiers often participated, as the ceremonies were also aimed at recruitment. Posters encouraging people to enlist were also used to attract recruits. After July 1915, enlistment numbers declined again. Recruiting committees throughout Australia worked hard to get numbers up again at the beginning of 1916 but after an initial rise they began to decrease again. Division in Australian society Billy Hughes became Australia's seventh prime minister in October 1915. Like his Labor Party colleagues, he was against conscription (compulsory service in the armed forces). A visit by Hughes to Britain in early 1916 including a visit to Australian troops at the front. This visit convinced Hughes that the troops were doing a great job. He believed that the troops, and Britain, needed all the help that Australia could possibly give them to win the war. Britain had introduced conscription at the beginning of 1916 and Hughes believed that Australia should do the same. The War Precautions Act would have allowed the government to legislate to introduce conscription but Hughes was concerned that the Labor-dominated Senate might not pass the legislation. The alternative was a referendum on conscription: the people would decide and then that decision would be binding on all politicians. It would not be like a referendum to change the constitution. It would more correctly be called a plebiscite in which the people would vote directly on a matter of national importance; the result would give clear guidelines for the politicians to follow. Splits in Labor and Australia 12 The first referendum There were two referendums in Australia on conscription. The first was on 28 October 1916 (to give the government power to force men to serve overseas during the current war) and the second on 20 December 1917 (to give the government power to compel men to join the army to reinforce the AIF overseas). Both were narrowly defeated. The referendums split the country and destroyed, for over ten years, the chance of a Labor government at federal level in Australia. The second referendum After the loss of the first referendum, Billy Hughes was expelled from the Labor Party, taking 23 of the 65 Labor members with him. He retained the prime ministership and he and his followers initially formed the National Labor Party. This group then joined with the Liberals to form the Nationalist Party, with Hughes as leader, and won the 1917 general election. Conscription was not an issue in the 1917 election but, after the slaughter on the Western Front in 1917, Hughes tried a second referendum to compel troops to fight overseas and build up Australian numbers. He chose to do this by referendum even though he now had a Senate that would have supported the legislation. The country split into two camps over conscription—'Yes' and 'No'. Differences were bitter, as people felt strongly about their point of view. Differences between social classes and religions were heightened. Sectarianism (strong devotion to a particular religion) had been present in Australia since the first colonists arrived. Protestants viewed Catholics, who were predominantly of Irish background, as disloyal to Britain because of the Irish quest for Home Rule. Being against conscription became associated with Irish disloyalty to Britain. The Catholic Archbishop of Melbourne, Dr Daniel Mannix, spoke out strongly against conscription, particularly in 1917. He probably caused as many people to vote 'Yes' as 'No' because of the large number of issues underlying the debates. Speeches and posters were aimed at producing fear and guilt on both sides. Task: Answer questions in your book: i) What does ‘Sectarianism’ mean? ii) What you understand the term ‘home rule’ to mean? iii) Explain what role religion had in the debate on conscription iv) Why did Billy Hughes decide to call a referendum? v) What is a ‘plebiscite’ Lesson 10 Initial reactions to war The outbreak of war in August 1914 seemed to unleash a huge wave of enthusiastic support for Britain, and support for Australia’s part in the war. All major political parties, churches, community leaders and newspapers seemed to support Australia’s entry. It was seen as a moral and necessary commitment. There was a rush to the recruiting offices, and, at this stage, only the very fittest and healthiest men were accepted. Opposition to War Although it was evident that the majority of society was prepared to give its full support to the involvement of Australia in the War, there were also a few groups who were not. Out of fear of derision, among other reasons, these groups usually did not voice their opinions loudly until sometime into the War when doubt was beginning to emerge in society more generally as the real costs of war began to emerge. 13 Of the groups who did not support the War, there were 'conscientious objectors' who disagreed on going to war on the basis of moral grounds, as well as 'pacifists' who believed it was wrong to kill other people. Later on in the War a small number of Irish Australians also opposed Australia's commitment to the War. This opposition had little to do with Australia herself and more to do with being against the British mistreatment of rebels in Ireland in 1916. Some trade unions were opposed to the war in general out of concern that there would be a shortage of workers because they would be killed. The employers, however, would remain to make all of the money. In particular, the Industrial Workers of the World played a significant role in influencing others against the War. They also assisted in influencing political objectors who usually belonged to left-wing movements such as the Australian Labor Party. These two groups, in conjunction with Roman Catholic Church leaders, acted in concert on the issue, especially in the latter years of the War as the reality began to sink into Australian society. Task: Create a Venn diagram in your book, working in pairs brainstorm all the reasons for and against going to war. Once complete, groups will read out their findings. Any that reasons that are read out, that students do not have, can be added. Lesson 11 Teacher will model C.C.T.F on the board using a WWI propaganda poster. Task: i) Group work: supply each group with one of the conscription posters, have them do C.C.T.F. Present to class (2 minutes each) Year 9 Hist-NC. 2012\For Dan\WWI Posters.docx Lesson 12 Roles of Women http://www.dva.gov.au/commems_oawg/commemorations/education/Documents/DVA_Women_i n_War_part2.pdf Year 9 Hist-NC. 2012\For Dan\How Australian women were involved.docx Learning Intention- To look at the roles of women both in Australia and overseas. How were women portrayed? What were the expectations of women at home? How did the roles of women change? How Australian women were involved Australian women served in the Australian Army as nurses, and as other medical workers. There were also a number of Red Cross volunteers who provided comforts to the troops, and teachers and fundraisers. Nurses were expected to be single or widowed. Some married women got through the recruiting checks, and some married during their period of service. Of those who served overseas for whom there 14 are detailed statistics, seven were under 21 (though the official minimum age for enlistment was 25), 1184 aged 21–30, 947 aged 31–40, and 91 were 41+. Seven women received the Military Medal for bravery under fire, and several died of injuries or disease. More than 2300 members of the Australian Army Nursing Service (AANS) served overseas in war areas. These included: Egypt, Salonika, France, Belgium, Lemnos, India, off Gallipoli, Palestine, the Persian Gulf, Italy, Burma, Vladivostok and Abyssinia. Some nurses and women doctors paid their own way to be involved in medical service during the war. There were also masseuses (physical therapists), blood transfusionists, and other support medical occupations.Other women also performed valuable services. Vera Deakin set up the Red Cross Missing and Wounded Enquiry Bureau, which was instrumental in ascertaining information for families of the circumstances of those who were missing — through death, wounding or capture. Red Cross nurses, known as ‘Blue Birds’, served in French front line hospitals. Women such as Ranid MacPhillamy and Alice Chisholm set up canteens in Egypt, providing facilities for soldiers on leave. Key statistics 416,809 Australians enlisted in World War I, of whom 331,781 served overseas. 61,720 of these died during the war, and 137,013 were wounded. In all, 2139 women served with the Australian Army Nursing Service, and 130 worked with the Queen Alexandra Imperial Military Nursing Service. A further 423 nurses served in hospitals in Australia. Twenty-three of these women died in service during the war. Task: Places Worked Types of jobs and serviced performed 15 Formulating Ideas If you only had these images to form opinions about Australian nurses during the war, what could you say about them? ________________________________________________________________ ________________________________________________________________ ________________________________________________________________ ________________________________________________________________ ________________________________________________________________ ________________________________________________________________ 16 Study the sources below, which show a variety of experiences of Australian nurses during WW I. In the box after each source write individual words or short phrases that summarise your main ideas and reactions. One has been completed for you as an example. In India Sunday 25 April 1915 off Gallipoli Here I am on day duty, and Sister-in-Charge of two wards. Oh, these poor men from Mesopotamia! They are … only skin and bone (men from the Kut campaign). This is amoebic dysentery, and treated with hyperdermic injections of “Emetin” … most of the poor men are not long for this world … Oh, Pete, the men with dysentery would make one weep! Why are men allowed to suffer like this? And we hear folk in Australia and England talking about boys who have made the “Supreme Sacrifice”, and I suppose stone monuments etc, will be erected to their memory “of our glorious dead”. What about the living? The blind, crippled, disfigured and those poor mad men and women. … About 9am my first patients from battlefield commenced to pour in (We had gone in during night & anchored outside Dardanelles). We wakened up & could plainly hear sounds of guns. They came in an endless stream, some walking holding arms, hands covered with blood, some on stretchers with broken legs, some shivering & collapsed through loss of blood & some with faces streaming with blood … we went for the worst cases first & worked like fury while all the sound of firing was going on … we took on board 570 wounded … we filled every space, mattresses lying everywhere on deck … in my ward I had 118 patients (one Turk badly wounded) … we got to bed between 2 & 3 am. Matron Babs Moberly, February 1917, in Melanie Oppenheimer, Australian Women and War, Department of Veterans’ Affairs, Canberra, 2008 p32 Worked hard, witnessed great suffering, extreme workload, fatigue On Salonika Gertrude Moberley, reaction at the end of the war [Sister Gertrude Munro] was only ill for ten days … was put straight into hospital for sick sisters where she got the very best medical attention possible, and … one of her friends was constantly with her … She had a bad combination, Pneumonia and M.T. Malaria which is very hard to fight. Being a strong healthy woman we hoped against hope she might win through, but alas it was not to be … She is buried in a very pretty little Cemetery with some other Sisters and Soldiers who have given their lives for their country. Blood! Blood! I am very tired. Oh dear God, how dreadfully tired, and broken-hearted too. Jan Bassett, Guns and Brooches, Oxford University Press, Melbourne, 1992 p63 Jessie MacHardie White, 2 December 1918, Red Cross Wounded and Missing Enquiry Bureau files, AWM 1 DRL 428 On Lemnos Had a desperately hard time at Lemnos with food, tents, mud and sickness, as well as great troubles with Colonel Fiaschi, who treated Nurses shamefully — No consideration whatever … I believe the Hospital would have collapsed but for the Nurses. They all worked like demons … Letter from RHJ Fetherston in Jan Bassett, Guns and Brooches, Oxford University Press, Melbourne, 1992 p50 17 Lesson 13 Women at Home One way of exploring women’s roles and contributions in the war is to look at aspects of women’s activities in a country area during the war. One historian, John McQuilton, has studied an area in the north-east of Victoria. Here are some of his findings. Look at the list and identify the types of activities that women were involved in during the war — such as voluntary activities; fundraising; patriotic activities; political activities; employment activities. Write the type of activity beside each. Decide which of the activities might unite a community, and which might divide it. Write this in the numbered graph provided. Create a statement that summarises women’s activities and roles on the home front. How significant were women’s activities on the home front? You can consider their significance for the war effort, and also for the status of women in the community. 18 Women were active in both the pro- and anti-case during the bitter conscription campaigns of 1916and 1917. 1. Some women were thrust into public roles during the war. 2. Some women broke gender employment barriers, by replacing enlisted men in such areas as bank teller and shire clerk. 3. Most women had not changed their occupational status at the end of the war, and continued to be employed in traditionally female occupations. 4. Women formed Red Cross branches and worked tirelessly in voluntary activities to support the soldiers. The volume of goods produced and the personal efforts involved ‘beggar the imagination’. One example — by the war’s end the Red Cross society of Rutherglen had forwarded 1233 shirts, 8512 pairs of underpants, 1233 pairs of pyjamas, 2405 pairs of socks, 76 sheets, 776 pillow-cases, 455 bed screens, 391 handkerchiefs and ‘numerous other items’. The shirts, underpants, socks and pillow cases alone accounted for 30,100 hours of work. 5. Red Cross and other volunteers packed billies for soldiers at Christmas time, met troop trains with sandwiches and tea for the travelling soldiers, baked cakes for local training camps and hospitals. 6. Women organised fundraising activities. 19 They organised touring concert parties to raise funds —the ‘Royal Patriots’, the ‘Win-the-War-Girls’, the ‘Advance Guard’, and ‘Our Girls at Home’. 8. Some women put great pressure on men to enlist, and refused to go out with eligible men who had not volunteered. 9. Some women sent white feathers, the symbol of cowardice, to local men in the community. One man wrote in a letter to the local newspaper that ‘Some old tart … has posted me some White Leghorn Plumage. Little does she know that I have been turned down for various defects including hammer toe and varicose veins.’ 10. Some women were pressured to force their men to enlist, to ‘send their sons, brothers and sweethearts to war and to shun the shirker and poltroon’ [those who were too scared or not noble enough to volunteer]. 11. Some women encouraged their men not to enlist. The most common stereotypes of ‘the patriotic woman’ were those women who worked tirelessly for nation and Empire, the nurse at the front, and the soldier’s mother. 12. One woman committed suicide when her son returned from the war physically and mentally maimed. 13. School girls were encouraged to raise money for patriotic funds — they raffled geese, sold pet lambs, gathered and sold vegetables from their gardens, knitted and made cakes. 14. School boys and girls were used in patriotic processions. 20 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 Lesson 14 Interment Camps in Australia during WWI Internees and other German-born Australians The majority of Australia's 33 381 German-born residents at the 1911 census lived in Queensland and South Australia. At the beginning of the war these people had to register at local police stations. Australians had little or no ill-feeling towards these citizens in 1914 but increasing casualty rates, reports of German atrocities against civilians in Belgium and other strong antiGerman propaganda changed this situation. Action taken against German-born Australians included exclusion from employment opportunities and some physical attacks. Throughout Australia, but mainly in South Australia, places with German names were renamed with English or Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander names. Some people of German background showed sympathy for the German cause in the war. They were placed in internment camps, often established in old jails. Approximately 4500 people were interned during the war, 15 per cent of whom were naturalised Australians. The internees lived as normal a life as possible while confined in the camps, allowing for the prison environment and presence of guards. They played various sports, primarily football (soccer), and were able to pursue such cultural pursuits as drama and music. The internees also undertook physical work associated with the camps or for the community. 21 Task: In pairs, students will research one of the following Internment camps (teacher to assign), You will include the following. Pictures, numbers of people interned, nationality, when opened/closed, any personal stories a map, conditions at the camp, escapes etc. This should be saved as a word doc and printed out to be put into your books. You will also write in your books your personal feeling on were internment camps a necessary thing? Berrima, New South Wales Bourke, New South Wales Enoggera (Gaythorne), Queensland Holsworthy (Liverpool), New South Wales Langwarrin, Victoria Molonglo, Australian Capital Territory Rottnest Island, Western Australia Torrens Island, South Australia Trial Bay, New South Wales Bruny Island Internment Camp, Tasmania Fort Largs Internment Camp, south Australia Garden Island Interment Camp, Western Australia Lesson 15/16 Charles Bean Making of the ANZAC Legend Look at the short YouTube clip on Charles Bean. Explain that Bean was a war correspondent. Short discussion on what a ‘war correspondent’ was and why they would be needed. Why was there role so important at this time? Brainstorm on board what their duties might be and, how a war correspondent could greatly influence the understanding of people back home Brief overview, who was Charles Bean, what did he do and how did he go about it? http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ytK0gkRV7ZY Read through the short account below of Bean and then watch ‘Gallipoli- Untold Stories’ on DVC and Answer the questions Bean accompanied two Australian brigades during an unsuccessful and costly attack at Cape Helles two weeks later. He was recommended for the Military Cross for the help he gave to wounded men under fire on the night of 8 May but as a civilian was ineligible so was mentioned in dispatches. His bravery was well known and he was the only correspondent to stay on Gallipoli from April until 22 December, despite being hit by a bullet in the right leg on 6 August 1915. Instead of being evacuated to a hospital ship he lay in his dugout until 24 August having the wound dressed each day until he was able to go out and watch the fighting again. After the evacuation of Gallipoli Bean edited The Anzac Book (London, 1916) which he compiled from drawings and writing by the soldiers. The seeds of the official history series were sown when he was in France in 1916–18 with the AIF. Conscious of his responsibilities to the men, he decided that: The only memorial which could be worthy of them was the bare and uncoloured story of their part in the war. [Charles Bean, quoted in B Nairn and G Serle (eds), Australian Dictionary of Biography, Volume 7, Melbourne University Press, 1979, p 227] Even earlier, at Gallipoli, Bean had noticed the Australians avidly collecting battlefield relics and it occurred to him that there should be a war museum in Australia. Questions: (Answer in your books) 1. How did the account of the ANZAC landing by general sir Ian Hamilton differ from differ from other reports and also that of Charles Bean? 2. How did what Australians first heard about the ANZAC landing differ from the reality? How was this accounted for? 3. How did Bean feel about the conditions of the wounded? Give an example of his thoughts. 4. What was Beans thought on how the British were coordinating and handling the Gallipoli campaign? 5. Who received Australia’s first V.C (Victoria Cross) and who was the man with the donkey and how did he die? 6. How did the Australians go about organising the armistice to bury the dead 7. Who was Alec Campbell? 8. What was significant about him? 9. What did Bean think that the ANZAC and the Turks would come to think of each other? 10. Why did the army wish to ban Bean and other war correspondents to Lemnos, do you think that the timing of this was significant seeing as Bean had just had his first report printed in Australian newspapers? 11. What impression to you get of Beans opinions of the men who fought? 12. Bean went on to do what? 23 Lesson 17 Bean was the only Australian war correspondent to remain on the Gallipoli Peninsula for the entire campaign and the only consistent Australian front line reporter. He brought a deep sense of responsibility to his craft: “The war correspondent is responsible for most of the ideas of battle which the public possesses ... I can't write that it occurred if I know that it did not, even if by painting it that way I can rouse the blood and make the pulse beat faster-and undoubtedly these men here deserve the people's pulses shall beat for them. But war correspondents have so habitually exaggerated the heroism of battles that people don't realise that real actions are heroic.” Charles Bean Task: Re-write this in your own words. Explain what you think Bean meant by this. Group discussion: 1. Who has been to an ANZAC ceremony? 2. What is the point? 3. Do you agree with the digger at the end of the documentary that said “you should never go to war to fight for someone else’s country, should only go to defend your own country”? 4. Do having these services glorify war? 5. What should they achieve? 6. Is there a better way to mark this occasion? 7. Should these ceremonies be sombre or festive? 8. Should they exist at all 9. Why do you think the British sought to make people believe that at first that Gallipoli was a success? 10. Alec Campbell said, not long before his death, that we should not make a celebration out of what happened at Gallipoli, that it was nothing more than a mistake and a bloodbath lead by the British “whatever you do, don’t turn it into a shrine”. With that in mind, what are your thoughts on the growing number of Australians that are going to Gallipoli each year for ANZAC Day and that the dawn service from there is now televised? 24