13.3 - Tools of Monetary Policy The Bank of Canada can conduct monetary policy in two different ways: 1. Open Market Operations (a signal of its intentions) 2. Target Overnight Rate Open Market Operations Recall: Bank of Canada sells and buys back federal gov’t bonds By selling and buying bonds, the Bank of Canada is able to influence the money supply and interest rates Open Market Operations: the buying and selling of bonds by the Bank of Canada in the open market. Bond Sales Process Bank of Canada sells $1000 bond to Bondholder A Bondholder A pays for it using a cheque from his account at Cartier Bank Bank of Canada sends the $1000 cheque to Cartier Bank Cartier Bank cancels cheque and reduces Bondholder A’s account by $1000 Cartier Bank pays the Bank of Canada for the cheque by having $1000 taken out of its Bank of Canada account Bond Sales Process The money supply now falls by $1000 Assuming a reserve ratio of 0.10, Cartier Bank’s excess reserves are cut by $900 – another reduction in the supply of money Cartier Bank has less money available to lend If the money multiplier is 10 (reciprocal of reserve ratio), a further decline in the money supply could be as much as $9000 (=900 x 10) Bond Sales Process cont’d Sales of bonds reduces the cash reserves of deposit-takers This cuts back on lending Decreases money supply By selling bonds, the Bank of Canada in engaging in Contractionary Monetary Policy Bond Purchases Bank of Canada buys back a $1000 bond from Bondholder B Bondholder B receives a cheque from the Bank of Canada She deposits cheque into her account at Cartier Bank Cartier Bank delivers it to the Bank of Canada and receives $1000 So buying bonds back allows the Bank of Canada to practice expansionary monetary policy Cash reserves increase, so increased lending Money supply expands Bond Purchases Cartier Bank’s cash reserves increase by $1000 If the bank has a reserve ratio of 0.10, then it only needs to hold back $100 The bank has excess reserves of $900 (= $1000 - $100) 𝟏 Now, the money multiplier = 10 (= ), creates a further 𝟎.𝟏𝟎 increase in the money supply of up to $9000 (= $900 x 10) The Target Overnight Rate The interest rate on overnight loans between financial institutions If the Bank buys bonds, this reduces the need for overnight borrowing If the Bank sells bonds, this increases the need for overnight borrowing If the change in the target overnight rate is substantial, primerate may be altered Prime Rate is the lowest interest rate charged by deposit-takers on loans http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KqI2HMlSTio Benefits of Monetary Policy Monetary Policy is the most important stabilization tool due to two main benefits: 1. Separation from Politics 2. Speed with which it can be Applied 1. Although the Bank of Canada is under the control of parliament, it is controlled by appointed officials 2. Recall that fiscal policy suffers from recognition, decision and impact While recognition delays may occur for monetary policy, decisions are done speedily Drawbacks of Monetary Policy 1. Weakness as an Expansionary Tool 2. Broad Impact 3. Potential conflict with the goal of financial stability Drawbacks of Monetary Policy 1. Weakness as an Expansionary Tool During a boom, the Bank sells bonds, decreasing the money supply, increasing interest and reducing spending During a recession/depression, the Bank buys bonds, but this won’t always increase the money supply If deposit-takers don’t lend the money and hold onto their cash reserves, the increase in money supply won’t occur 2. Broad Impact 3. Potential conflict with the goal of financial stability Drawbacks of Monetary Policy 1. Weakness as an Expansionary Tool 2. Broad Impact Fiscal policy can be focused on a particular region of the country Monetary policy affects every region If the interest rate increases, it increases for the whole country 3. Potential conflict with the goal of financial stability Drawbacks of Monetary Policy 1. Weakness as an Expansionary Tool 2. Broad Impact 3. Potential conflict with the goal of financial stability Extended periods of low interest rates (e.g. the decade before 2008 financial crisis), have serious effects on financial stability Low interest rates promote risky lending practices This can lead to more problems