Guide to DSPS: A Primer Preface On behalf of the California Community Colleges Chancellor’s Office, we welcome you to Disabled Student Programs and Services (DSPS). As you begin your new role as DSPS Coordinator, you join this program at a time of great challenges with shrinking budgets and students with more complex disabilities and issues. However, this is also a time of opportunity to seek out ways to best serve the qualified students with disabilities utilizing your services. With 112 community colleges you will find there are many different ways to organize, lead and manage your program. This document is an attempt to lay out the basics of what DSPS does, the regulations that support your services, the criteria for determining eligibility, academic accommodations and fiscal reporting. The Chancellor’s Office DSPS staff, the Galvin Group, and most importantly, the staff at all 112 Community College programs are available to you with resources and a helping hand. We wish you every success in your new position and hope this document and our online training for DSPS Coordinators will help you on your way. Jan Galvin Bette McMuldren Richard Dunn Lucinda Aborn September, 2011 THIS REPORT IS FUNDED IN PART BY THE CALIFORNIA COMMUNITY COLLEGES CHANCELLOR’S OFFICE CONTRACT # 10-0345 Revised November, 2011 Guide to DSPS: A Primer Table of Contents Preface....................................................................................................................................... 1 Designing a DSPS Program ...................................................................................................... 4 Background ........................................................................................................................... 4 DSPS Director/Coordinator .................................................................................................. 5 State Funding ........................................................................................................................ 6 Qualified Students with Disabilities ..................................................................................... 7 Determining Eligibility for DSPS Services .......................................................................... 7 Determining Placement in a DSPS Reportable Category ..................................................... 8 Learning Disabilities Eligibility Determinations ................................................................ 15 Personnel Resources ........................................................................................................... 17 DSPS Student Record Forms .................................................................................................. 20 Application for DSPS Services ........................................................................................... 21 DSPS Release of Information Form ................................................................................... 21 Verification of Disability Status and Identification of Educational Limitations ................ 22 Student Educational Contract ............................................................................................. 24 Educational Accommodations ............................................................................................ 24 Student Rights and Responsibilities Form .......................................................................... 25 Student File Security ........................................................................................................... 25 Student Services ...................................................................................................................... 26 What Constitutes a DSPS Service Contact for MIS Reporting Purposes? ......................... 26 Student Contacts for MIS Reporting................................................................................... 26 Definitions of Services Commonly Provided and Service Contacts Associated with Each ... 28 Timely Service Delivery ......................................................................................................... 35 Intake Efficiencies .............................................................................................................. 36 Outreach and Transition ...................................................................................................... 37 Behavioral Issues ................................................................................................................ 38 Test Accommodations ........................................................................................................ 39 High Tech Center ................................................................................................................ 40 Alternate Media .................................................................................................................. 41 2 Guide to DSPS: A Primer Policies and Procedures .......................................................................................................... 43 Program Reviews and Program Plans ..................................................................................... 44 Budget/MIS Reporting ............................................................................................................ 45 Resources ................................................................................................................................ 47 3 Guide to DSPS: A Primer Designing a DSPS Program Background Disabled Student Programs and Services (DSPS) (Education Code, Section 84850 and Title 5, California Code of Regulations (5 CCR) Sections 56000-56076) were enacted in 1976 through the passage of Assembly Bill 77 (Lanterman), which funds support services and instructional programs for students with disabilities in the California Community Colleges. DSPS assists colleges by providing services and accommodations for students with disabilities. These services support student success and meet the requirements of federal and state nondiscrimination laws, including Sections 504 and 508 of the federal Rehabilitation Act, the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA), and state Government Code Sections 11135-11139.5. Operating DSPS is voluntary on the part of each college. Colleges are governed by the Title 5 regulations regarding DSPS only because they accept the DSPS funds allocated to them every year. A college could refuse the DSPS funds and not be subject to the requirements of Title 5 regarding DSPS. However, by refusing Title 5 funds, the college would not eliminate its obligations under state and federal law regarding the civil rights of people with disabilities and the need to provide services and accommodations to ensure that the college’s programs and services are accessible to, and usable by, students with disabilities. In fact, DSPS assists greatly in providing the funding and the mechanism through which the college meets these federal and state requirements. In many cases, it can be complicated to determine if a specific service is required by state and federal law since accommodations should be provided on an individualized basis, after engaging in an interactive process with the student with a disability. The critical requirement is that each individual student’s accommodation needs are met in order to provide equal access and eliminate discrimination. Your district is required to provide appropriate accommodations under the state and federal non-discrimination laws as requested by an eligible student or member of the public, regardless of funding available through DSPS to do so. If DSPS funds are insufficient to pay for the accommodation, such as the request for sign language interpreters, or it is an accommodation which cannot be funded by DSPS, the district will need to fund it from another source. If a resultant non-discrimination complaint or lawsuit was filed by a student, the budget of the entire institution compared to the cost of the accommodation would be taken into account. Whether or not the college had planned and budgeted for such expenditure would be irrelevant because of the legal requirement to provide the disability related accommodation. Further, DSPS may be providing services that are not required by state or federal non-discrimination laws, but are designed to meet the unique disability related educational needs of groups of students with disabilities. It is important to note that if 4 Guide to DSPS: A Primer such special services are not provided, then general services/activities of the college must provide needed accommodations unless, in instructional settings, they pose a fundamental alteration to the curriculum. If a student with a disability filed a complaint with the U.S. Department of Education, Office for Civil Rights, which is the entity that oversees compliance with Section 504 and the ADA in higher education, OCR would review the complaint and determine if the service reduction or elimination violated one of these federal laws. If it was found to do so, the entire institution would be held in violation of the relevant law. Title 5 states that programs receiving funds allocated pursuant to Education Code Section 84850 shall meet the requirements of this subchapter. Any support services or instruction funded, in whole or in part, under the authority of this subchapter must: (a) Not duplicate services or instructions which are otherwise available to all students; (b) Be directly related to the educational limitations of the verified disabilities of the students to be served; (c) Be directly related to the student’s participation in the educational process; (d) Promote the maximum independence and integration of students with disabilities; and (e) Support participation of students with disabilities in educational activities consistent with the mission of the community colleges as set forth in Education Code Section 66701. DSPS Director/Coordinator The DSPS Coordinator is the only required position for a DSPS program. Title 5 Section 56048 (b) states “Each district receiving funds pursuant to this subchapter shall designate a DSPS Coordinator for each college in the district. For the purpose of this section, the Coordinator is defined as that individual who has responsibility for the day-to-day operation of DSPS. The designated Coordinator must meet the minimum qualifications for a DSPS counselor or instructor set forth in Section 53414, (a) through (d), or meet the minimum qualifications for an educational administrator set forth in Section 53420. The Title 5 requirement for a DSPS Coordinator is in recognition of the specific nature and set of skills needed to deal with the variety and complexity of issues involved with providing services to students with disabilities. Specialized knowledge is needed in order for a college to comply with federal civil rights laws, state laws, and the Title 5 regulations. Each college needs to have qualified staff to conduct work related to the provision of accommodations and services to qualified students with disabilities. These responsibilities include, but are not limited to: 5 Guide to DSPS: A Primer interviewing students with disabilities; reviewing disability documentation and determining disability related functional limitations in the educational setting; working with the student to receive needed accommodations; coordinating and ensuring such accommodations are provided in a timely and effective manner; working with students with disabilities when they face various barriers to success or disability related issues related to college; and working with faculty and other college staff to answer their questions about accommodations and other issues related to students with disabilities, while staying within legal confidentiality requirements. Given the complexity of these tasks, it is highly recommended that each college have a DSPS Coordinator with 100% of their time dedicated to the DSPS program. When the current DSPS funding formula was adopted the intent of the base was to pay for a full-time DSPS Coordinator, along with clerical assistance for each college. In most cases, it is not feasible for someone to fully and effectively operate DSPS without spending their entire day dedicated to those pursuits. A part-time Coordinator, and especially one who is an administrator of multiple student service areas at the same time, is not achieving the goals behind the establishment of a DSPS Coordinator at each college. A related issue to keep in mind is maintaining the appropriate use of DSPS funds when assigning the DSPS Coordinator title to a position, and particularly when that assignment is made to a multi-program administrative position. Title 5 Section 56068, says that DSPS funds cannot be used for “…administrative salaries and benefits, with the exception of the DSPS Coordinator…” The intent of this statement is to ensure that DSPS categorical funds are not used to cover the costs of higher-level administrative positions. State Funding DSPS programs receive state funds based on the number of students served and types of disabilities these students have. These state funds are intended to cover ‘excess costs’ in serving students with disabilities. With or without state funding, students with disabilities still need to be served. Absent DSPS funds, the costs of providing and arranging for accommodations shift to the colleges/districts. 6 Guide to DSPS: A Primer Qualified Students with Disabilities Title 5 specifies what constitutes a qualified student with a disability who is eligible for services, in the following categories: 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. Physical Disability Communication Disability Learning Disability Acquired Brain Impairment (ABI) Developmentally Delayed Learner (now often called Intellectual Disability) Psychological Disability Other Disabilities Determining Eligibility for DSPS Services Prior to providing services or accommodations to a student, DSPS must determine that: 1. the individual requesting assistance is an individual with a qualifying disability; and 2. the disability can be verified by observation (e.g., a missing limb) or that documentation can be obtained from an appropriate professional (e.g., physician, audiologist, licensed clinical social worker); and 3. the disability can be appropriately placed in one of the seven DSPS reportable categories (e.g., physical disability, intellectual disability, ABI). It is critically important that the DSPS Coordinator be conversant with current federal and state disability law. The DSPS Coordinator is ultimately responsible for determining eligibility and the types of services or accommodations authorized for a student. While federal and state laws provide a broad foundation for decision-making, the Implementing Guidelines for Title 5 Regulations provide the specificity needed to determine DSPS eligibility and assignment of the disability to an MIS reportable category. A student who is auditing a class or who is taking community service classes is not eligible for services funded through the DSPS program. Although, the college should keep in mind that it has an obligation to provide services to students with disabilities in these and other instances in order to meet the requirements of Section 504 of the 1973 Rehabilitation Act (29 U.S.C. 794) and Assembly Bill 803 (Government Code Section 11135 et. seq.) and the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA). Q. Can a student with a disability utilizing DSPS services receive a full-time exception under financial aid regulations as an accommodation? A. No. The U.S. Department of Education defines full time for a standard semester term as at least 12 units, which can be found in Volume 3, page 4 of the 2009-10 Student Aid Handbook. Professional judgment cannot be used to change the definition of full time as 7 Guide to DSPS: A Primer defined in the same handbook in the Application and Verification Guide on page 105. The guide states that professional judgment can only be used to change data elements that lead to a change in the student’s EFC (Expected Family Contribution) or to adjust a student’s cost of attendance. Determining Placement in a DSPS Reportable Category Six of the seven reportable categories for DSPS services are straightforward and largely unambiguous (see Implementing Guidelines for Title 5, Article 3: Reports, Plans and Program Requirements). What follows is a summary of the placement criteria for six of the seven DSPS reportable categories: 1. Section 56032 defines a “physical disability” to include a visual, mobility or orthopedic impairment. Visual impairment includes but is not limited to the following conditions: o Blindness is visual acuity of 20/200 or less in the better eye after correction; or visual loss so severe that it no longer serves as a major channel for information processing. o Partial sightedness is visual acuity of 20/70 or less in the better eye after correction, with vision which is still capable of serving as a major channel for information processing. o Visual impairment does not apply where the loss or impairment is the result of a psychological condition or ABI. This disability can be verified by a physician, a licensed vision professional or through documentation from a referring agency relying upon verification from a physician or other licensed vision professional. Mobility impairment includes but is not limited to the following conditions: o impairments caused by congenital anomaly (e.g., clubfoot, absence of some member, etc.); o impairments caused by disease (e.g., poliomyelitis, bone tuberculosis, etc.); and o impairments from other causes (e.g., cerebral palsy, amputation, and fractures and burns which can cause contractures). Mobility impairment does not apply to mobility limitation due to seeing, hearing, or psychological limitations or mobility limitations resulting from ABI. 8 Guide to DSPS: A Primer Mobility impairments can be verified, if possible, by the personal observation of a DSPS professional staff member with the DSPS Coordinator review, by documentation from a physician, or by the documentation of the referring agency if a physician does the verification. 1) 2) 3) 4) 5) 6) 7) TITLE 5 DISABILITY CATEGORIES Physical Disability Communication Disability Learning Disability Acquired Brain Impairment Intellectual Disability Psychological Disability Other Disabilities When reporting disabilities in the statewide MIS system, the Title 5 category of “physical disability” is divided into two of the primary types of disabilities represented in this category, i.e., mobility impairment and visual impairment. For further review go to MIS data elements. 2. Section 56034 defines “communication disability.” Hearing impairment means total deafness or a hearing loss so severe that a student is impaired in processing information through hearing, with or without amplification. This disability can be verified by an appropriate hearing professional or through documentation from a referring agency that obtains its verification from a medical doctor or other licensed ear professional. This disability can be verified by a DSPS staff member only if that person has the appropriate license. Speech impairment is defined as one or more speech and language disorders of voice, articulation, rhythm and/or the receptive and expressive processes of language that limit the quality, accuracy, intelligibility or fluency of producing the sounds that comprise spoken language. Speech limitation is interpreted to mean impairment in the quality, accuracy, intelligibility or fluency of producing the sounds that comprise spoken language. Speech impairment does not apply to articulation with a foreign accent. It also does not apply to any limitation that is caused by a physical or hearing impairment, psychological disability, or ABI. This disability can be verified by a licensed speech professional or through documentation from a referring agency that obtains its verification from a licensed speech professional. This disability can be verified by a DSPS staff member only if that person has the appropriate license. When reporting disabilities in the statewide MIS system, the Title 5 category of “communication disability” is divided into two of the primary types of disabilities 9 Guide to DSPS: A Primer represented in this category, i.e. hearing impairment and speech/language impairment. For further review, click on MIS data elements. 3. Section 56036 defines “learning disability.” Learning disability is defined as a persistent condition of a presumed neurological impairment. This dysfunction continues despite instruction in standard classroom situations, to be categorized as having a learning disability, a student must exhibit: o o o o average to above-average intellectual ability; severe processing deficit(s); severe aptitude-achievement discrepancy(ies); and measured achievement in an instructional or employment setting. Learning disability does not apply to learning problems resulting from any physical, visual, or hearing impairments, psychological disability, or any health related disabilities. Learning disability can exist with other disabilities except ABI and DDL. This disability can be verified in one of the following ways: a learning disability professional using the California Community College Learning Disability Eligibility and Services Model. a DSPS Learning Disability Specialist may professionally certify if assessment documentation from a referring agency is deemed to meet the requirements in the California Community College Learning Disability Eligibility and Services Model. from documentation sent by an appropriate referring agency if its verification is done by an appropriately licensed professional. Title 5 category of “learning disability” is consistent with the statewide MIS system. 4. Section 56038 defines “acquired brain impairment (ABI).” ABI is defined as acquired brain impairment caused by external or internal trauma, resulting in total or partial functional limitation that adversely affects or limits a student’s educational performance by impairing: o cognition, information processing, reasoning, abstract thinking, judgment and/or problem solving; o language and/or speech; o memory and/or attention; o sensory, perceptual and/or motor abilities; o psychosocial behavior; or o physical functions. 10 Guide to DSPS: A Primer ABI does not apply to functional limitations resulting from brain trauma induced by birth, present at birth or that is progressive and/or degenerative in nature. ABI can be verified by an appropriately licensed professional, or by the documentation of a referring agency if its verification is done by an appropriately licensed professional. 5. Section 56040 defines “developmentally delayed learner (DDL).” DDL is defined as learning deficits resulting from below average intellectual functioning which adversely affects educational performance, existing concurrently with measurable potential for achievement in educational and/or employment settings. This category is often now referred to as Intellectual Disability, but Title 5 has not been updated. This disability can be verified by the DSPS Coordinator or a DDL Specialist using the documentation from a referring agency. The student is eligible by meeting one of the three standards described below: the student has an earned standards score less than or equal to 70 on the specified ability assessment procedure; or the student has certification from the Regional Center that the student’s earned standard score was less than or equal to 70 on an ability assessment procedure; or the student has an earned standard score between 71 and 80 and at least one of the seven following indicators is documented. For scores greater than 80, the assessment procedure’s standard error of measurement may be considered. o history of special education o history of sheltered or supported employment o history of unemployment or limited entry level employment o dependent/semi-independent living environment o client status with the state Department of Rehabilitation o client status with the Regional Center o academic skill deficiency NOTE: NEW REVISION 11/01/11 Learning Disability (LD) Specialists have been added to the approved list of verifiers on the Developmentally Delayed Learner (DDL) Verification Form. In 1999 the DDL Task Force published the criteria for the current DDL Verification Form. At the time, only DDL Specialists and DSPS Coordinators were permitted to sign the form in order to verify a student as qualifying for DDL. However, there are no current pathways to becoming certified as a DDL Specialist, nor have there been for the past eight years or so. As a result, very few colleges have DDL Specialists on staff, and many DSPS Coordinators have appointed 11 Guide to DSPS: A Primer Learning Disability (LD) Specialists to complete the form and then pass it along to DSPS Coordinators for their signature of approval. A person may be protected under Section 504 and the Americans with Disabilities Act because he or she has a history of disability or is perceived as having a disability. However, it is important to keep in mind that such individuals may not qualify for services from the DSPS program because (1) they do not have a current impairment or their impairment does not give rise to (2) an educational (functional) limitation. LD Specialists are trained in cognitive assessment and interpretation and are usually the ones conducting cognitive testing on campuses. In the process of this assessment they may determine that a student does not qualify for DSPS services under the category of LD, but does qualify under DDL. The LD Field Advisory group reasoned it would be more efficient if the LD Specialists could officially determine that DDL criteria are met at that time and be permitted to sign the verification form. This proposal was then vetted by the LD Specialists in their regional meetings and before the DSPS Regional Coordinators Advisory Group, which also approved the change. At the October 15, 2011 LD Field Advisory meeting, the group recommended the change to the Chancellor’s Office, which approved it and modified the DDL Verification Form to note the addition of LD Specialists to the approved signers list. Title 5 category of “developmentally delayed learner” is consistent with statewide MIS system. 6. Section 56042 defines “psychological disability.” Psychological disability is defined as a persistent psychological or psychiatric disorder, emotional or mental illness that adversely affects educational performance. Psychological disability is a condition that: is listed in the most current American Psychiatric Association Diagnostic and Statistical Manual (DSM) and is coded on Axis I or II as moderate to severe; reflects a psychiatric or psychological condition that interferes with a major life activity; and poses a functional limitation in the educational setting. The term psychological disability does not include: any condition designated by the most current DSM with a V Code signifying that it is not attributable to a mental disorder; 12 Guide to DSPS: A Primer The following conditions listed in the most current DSM are not included in the California Community College definition of psychological disability: transvestitism, transsexuals, pedophilia, exhibitionism, voyeur-ism, gender identity disorder not resulting from physical impairment, or other sexual behavior disorders; compulsive gambling, kleptomania, or pyromania; psychoactive substance abuse disorders resulting from current illegal use of drugs; and any conditions designated by the most current DSM as developmental disorders (mental retardation, pervasive developmental disorder, specific development disorders, or other developmental disorder), that is covered by another disability category. Recovering drug and alcohol abusers are considered psychologically disabled as long as they are in or have completed a recovery program and meet all other conditions for this disability category. A psychological disability can be verified by a professional with the appropriate license or by documentation of a referring agency if the verification was done by a professional with the appropriate license. This disability can be verified by a DSPS staff member only if that person is an appropriately licensed professional such as a licensed medical doctor, a licensed clinical psychologist or psychiatrist, a licensed Marriage, Family, and Child Counselor, or a licensed Clinical Social Worker. Title 5 category of “psychological disability” is consistent with the statewide MIS system. 7. Section 56044 defines “other disabilities.” While the previous six DSPS reportable categories have definite criteria and eligibility standards, much confusion exists about what qualifies as "other disabilities." If a student's disability can defined by one of the other six reportable categories (see Sections 56032, 56034, 56036, 56038, 56040, and 56042 above), then the student does not have an "other disability." Implementing Guidelines for Title 5 Regulations for DSPS define "other disabilities" as ". . . all other verifiable disabilities and health related limitations that adversely affect education performance but do not fall into any of the other disability categories."(emphasis added) A student should only be categorized under “other” if she/he (1) has a current verifiable impairment that meets the general definition of disability under Section 56002 and also has (2) an educational limitation as defined in Section 56004, but does not qualify in any of the disability specific categories. In short, to accurately apply the "other" category, the DSPS 13 Guide to DSPS: A Primer Coordinator would report a student as "other" after applying the "differential diagnosis” disability and verification is determined by using the medical model for a differential diagnosis. A selected list of disabilities that can qualify as "other" include: MIS DATA REPORTING DISABILITY CATEGORIES 1. Mobility Impaired 2. Visually Impaired 3. Hearing Impaired 4. Speech/Language Impaired 5. Developmentally Delayed Learner 6. Acquired Brain Injury 7. Learning Disabled 8. Psychological Disability 9. Other Disability o conditions having limited strength, vitality, or alertness due to chronic or acute health problems o heart conditions o tuberculosis o nephritis o sickle cell anemia o hemophilia o leukemia o epilepsy o acquired immune deficiency syndrome (AIDS) o diabetes o Lyme Disease Caveat: A person may be protected under Section 504 and the Americans with Disabilities Act because he or she has a history of disability or is perceived as having a disability. However, it is important to keep in mind that such individuals may not qualify for services from the DSPS program because (1) they do not have a current impairment or their impairment does not give rise to (2) an educational (functional) limitation. A disability in the “other disabilities” category must be verified by an appropriately licensed professional or through documentation from a referring agency that obtains its verification from an appropriately licensed professional. A DSPS staff member can verify this disability only if that person is an appropriately licensed professional. 14 Guide to DSPS: A Primer When reporting disabilities in the statewide MIS system, data element categories represent a further breakdown of Title 5 disability categories. The data elements in the MIS system use the following disability categories: 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. Mobility Impaired Visually Impaired Hearing Impaired Speech/Language Impaired Developmentally Delayed Learner Acquired Brain Injury Learning Disabled Psychological Disability Other Disability For further review click here: MIS data elements Learning Disabilities Eligibility Determinations As defined above, a learning disability is defined as a persistent condition of a presumed neurological impairment. This dysfunction continues despite instruction in standard classroom situations, to be categorized as having a learning disability, a student must exhibit: o o o o average to above-average intellectual ability; severe processing deficit(s); severe aptitude-achievement discrepancy(ies); and measured achievement in an instructional or employment setting. Learning disability does not apply to learning problems resulting from any physical, visual, or hearing impairments, psychological disability, or any health related disabilities. Learning disability can exist with other disabilities except ABI and DDL. This disability can be verified in one of the following ways: a learning disability professional using the California Community College Learning Disability Eligibility and Services Model. a DSPS Learning Disability Specialist may professionally certify if assessment documentation from a referring agency is deemed to meet the requirements in the California Community College Learning Disability Eligibility and Services Model. from documentation sent by an appropriate referring agency if its verification is done by an appropriately licensed professional. 15 Guide to DSPS: A Primer Expanding on these methods of eligibility determination, it is important to consider the responsibilities of Learning Disability Specialists. In addition to their role in assessing students’ eligibility for services as a student with a learning disability in the CCC system, LD Specialists are responsible for review of assessment results from sources outside the CCC. They review and evaluate outside assessments in terms of whether that assessment information meets specified system criteria for the definition of LD and to advise how the outside assessments relate to the student’s educational goals. With this information, they make recommendations for appropriate accommodations and compensatory strategies. An accurate and complete analysis of LD documentation is extremely important as students move through the higher education system. Students with documented learning disabilities make up the largest cohort of students with disabilities nationwide, as well as, the majority of students in DSPS programs and, therefore, generate a significant portion of the weighted student count. In addition, if Learning Disability Specialists are unavailable to perform testing to determine LD eligibility, only students who can afford to pay for outside LD testing would be able to receive disability related accommodations and services to support their student success. Based on the demographics of most California Community Colleges, these are not our typical students. Q. Are there any legal guidelines about the age of documentation that can be used in determining eligibility for LD services? We are counting many students with older records as “other,” rather than LD, due to staffing cutbacks that prevent us from conducting LD assessments needed to determine CCC LD eligibility. Some of these students with older LD documentation have adult testing, while others have assessments and IEPs from high school. A. Within the Department of Justice, there is new regulatory language for testing in ADA, Title III. § 36.309 Examinations and Courses. It says that considerable weight should be given to a history of previous accommodations and history of services that were provided under an IEP or 504 plan. If records from middle school show a history of accommodations being provided, accommodations are warranted. A testing entity should accept without further evaluation the accommodations that have been provided in the past. Considerable weight is particularly warranted when extra time and a quiet room for testing were provided and the student is seeking the same with another entity. The college should clearly grant the testing accommodation. This change indicates that standards don’t have to be as rigorous as have been observed in some settings. If you are short of resources, go with qualifying based on past documentation given the guidance from the ADA regulations. This new guidance highlights a difference between civil rights and state funding issues. The college may not be able to determine LD eligibility, but that doesn’t mean the student does not have a disability and is not entitled to accommodations. It may be appropriate to count the disability as “other” and change it later. This might be possible if the program 16 Guide to DSPS: A Primer can do an LD assessment or the student is able to bring in more documentation. In making the determination, engage the student in the interactive process and discuss changes that have occurred over the years, such as the services used, how they were used, changes in technology and how accommodations were provided. DSPS must use professional judgment in these decisions. Personnel Resources As outlined above, the only DSPS position required by Title 5 is a DSPS Coordinator. However, there is no legal requirement for a full-time DSPS Coordinator, despite the fact that having a less than 100% DSPS Coordinator raises inherent operational concerns. A college may move DSPS personnel into other positions within the college. However, a college cannot use DSPS funds to cover that individual’s salary and benefits, unless it is proportionate to the activities the individual undertakes to serve DSPS students with disabilities. Likewise, a college may not use Title 5 DSPS funds for any general college operations (Section 56064 & 56068). In order to meet the challenges of ongoing budget crises, continued cuts in staffing levels and increased DSPS student applications, DSPS activities need to be streamlined to ensure timely delivery of services. This includes finding ways to utilize staff time and expertise in the most efficient and effective manner. Not all tasks within DSPS have to be accomplished by faculty, there are many processes that can and should be completed by classified staff and student workers. Cross-training of all staff can help provide maximization of skills and abilities. Cross-training can also assist in the event of a staffing reduction. The ultimate responsibility for provision of services and accommodations rests with the district and/or college, not the DSPS program. It is not acceptable to tell students they have to wait to receive services. Timely delivery of services is critical. The date and time when a service request is made should be documented in the file. An effective approach is to triage the needs of incoming students. Continuing students asking for the same accommodations they have received in the past don’t need to see a Counselor immediately. New students can be given priority for counseling appointments and starting accommodations. In the case of new students, there may be a need for services to be provided on a temporary basis pending receipt of documentation. Legally, there is no requirement for an individual interview, so the process can be a paper process handled by DSPS Counselor or Coordinator. Remember that all requirements of documentation have to be met in order to claim the student for funding, but the college has an obligation under federal law to provide the services. 17 Guide to DSPS: A Primer While Title 5 requires oversight by DSPS It is important to recognize that the professional staff, paraprofessional DSPS ultimate responsibility for staff can take a significant role in provision of services and completing the intake procedure. For accommodations rests with the example, if a student comes in who has district and/or college, not the already registered with the college and has DSPS program. a completed DSPS application, along with disability verification and/or up-to-date LD assessment documentation, a DSPS paraprofessional staff member can schedule appointments with appropriate staff, and, in some cases, initiate services. The Coordinator/Counselor can review the file in a timely manner and sign the appropriate documentation. As part of a triage system, students without necessary documentation or with issues that only professional staff can resolve have priority for counseling appointments. Component 6 of the LDES Model states that the LD Specialist, upon review of documentation, determines whether the student is eligible for services as a student with learning disabilities. For students who are determined to be eligible for services, the Learning Disabilities Specialist identifies the student's educational limitations, develops the SEC and approves accommodations and recommends compensatory strategies. The DSPS Coordinator, Counselors and LD Specialist are all encouraged to become generalists, so that they can take turns staffing a drop-in hour to answer students’ questions. This will allow for sharing the responsibility of serving students. In addition, WorkAbility III staff may assist at the entry point for students, as Workability III clients are usually also DSPS students. If this is not the case, then all WorkAbility students should be enrolled in DSPS. WorkAbility III staff can help in triage activities and should document the contacts. Student workers can provide extra help and are essential for many programs. Student workers provide assistance with reception work and maintain the flow of paperwork. The development of job descriptions that outline responsibilities, the provision of initial training, and careful screening and ongoing supervision is very important. Student workers should be required to sign a confidentiality agreement. The presence of student workers also contributes to a welcoming environment in DSPS. But care should be given to ensure that confidentiality is maintained at all times and that they are educated about the critical importance of confidentiality. Q. Are shared education plans and/or shared schedules among DSPS, EOPS, CalWorks, and Counseling a breach of confidentiality for DSPS students? 18 Guide to DSPS: A Primer A. No, under FERPA certain educational records can be shared without breaching confidentiality. However, you are advised not to share diagnostic records. As an example of how a DSPS program utilizes their staff during intake, Mt. San Antonio College utilizes a screening at the front desk by classified staff. After a verbal explanation of the intake process, the student is given a folder containing forms. The folder includes an application, verification of disability and release of information, as well as the student handbook. When the student returns with their materials, the file is reviewed by a Disability Specialist who either signs off on the student’s eligibility or refers the file to the Program Coordinator, an LD Specialist or the Deaf/Hard of Hearing Counselor. After eligibility has been determined, the student is assigned to a caseload of one of the appropriately certificated staff members. For ongoing services, the student can see their assigned Counselor or may stop by during “drop-in” hours, when they may or may not see their assigned Counselor. It is also important for students to develop self-advocacy skills. A good way to start to develop these skills, is by giving them a checklist of what they need to do prior to receiving DSPS services. Here is an example of the steps that might be outlined: Step 1: Complete College Application for admission Step 2: Complete DSPS Application form Step 3: Submit Disability Documentation and Release of Information form Step 4: Take Placement Tests Step 5: Bring completed documents to DSPS Sacramento City and Foothill College have excellent checklists for new students. San Diego has an excellent one-page policy/procedure that describes paperwork requirements and service provision requirements and student responsibilities that the student is required to sign. The availability of video phone technology is a possible addition to a program’s resources for communicating with students who are deaf and utilize sign language. Video phone technology provides face to face video interaction with other deaf people or with a sign language interpreter. This technology allows the callers to view one another, thus enabling them to use direct sign language communication. Lake Tahoe has been successful in securing video equipment at their DSPS program and has found it to be very effective for counseling sessions and phone calls. The equipment is provided free of charge to the college through the Sorenson company. Another useful tool is a dual screen communicator such as Ubi-Duo or Interpretype. These devices allow for communication with students who are deaf, when no interpreter is available. The equipment provides for real-time communication via a keyboard and display. These devices can be used as a tool for short interactions, such as at the intake desk or 19 Guide to DSPS: A Primer admissions department, not as a replacement for an interpreter. A student must be comfortable with English, both expressive and receptive, in order to communicate via written English. DSPS Student Record Forms There are five required forms (which may be combined) for DSPS student records: Application for DSPS Services Release of Information Verification of Disability Status and Identification of Educational Limitations Student Educational Contract Educational Accommodations, Support Services, Documentation of Service Delivery, including Accommodations Provided Forms, like anything else, become cumbersome and outdated over time. We tend to forget why we designed a form in a particular way. For these reasons, it is important to review the forms used in the program on a regular basis to make sure they are meeting their intended purpose. Forms are used to provide information to the people providing the service. Forms are used to provide information to the people using the service. Forms are used to confirm information has been exchanged to protect the integrity of the service. Forms serve as a document of services provided and the date. Forms are helpful for program auditors to review compliance measures. Forms ensure that protocols have been met. A well-designed DSPS website could provide access to all forms and policies as well as staff contact information. Ease of access to this information benefits students and staff alike. Students can advocate for themselves by utilizing the web to learn more about DSPS and download forms. For staff, this would allow them to focus on other important front office duties. An important note to remember when designing DSPS forms: The vast majority of DSPS students have learning disabilities. The forms that are read and completed by these students should be simple, straightforward, and easy to read, with clear unambiguous instructions for completion. Be sure to include only the necessary information required. 20 Guide to DSPS: A Primer Application for DSPS Services Title 5- Section 56002, Student with a disability. This required form is simply a signed application for services and verification of enrollment in the college. The application can be a simple one-page application form which would include: date of application; name/address/email/phone number(s); student ID#; disability or diagnosis as self-reported by the student; how the disability impacts the educational process; and dated signature of both DSPS Specialist and student. Or a multipage form may be developed with other information included, such as: status as a client of Department of Rehabilitation; other colleges in District that the student has applied to or is attending; student’s highest level of education; It is important to review the forms used in voter registration the program on a regular basis to make sure assistance; and they are meeting their intended purpose. current work status. However, when deciding to add more questions, make sure it is for information truly needed in order to initiate the process. Students are required to complete a DSPS application acknowledging responsibility to provide appropriate verification of disability. Note: Many colleges include on the reverse side of the application a list of student rights and responsibilities and complaint process, which the student can initial after reading. The student then receives a copy of the signed form. Butte College has an excellent application form. DSPS Release of Information Form Title 5- Section 56008, Student Rights. A signed release of information form enables the college to verify the disability or obtain other types of records. The form should include: student name (including maiden name or other names used); date of birth; 21 Guide to DSPS: A Primer student ID#; student (or, if appropriate, parent/guardian) signature; and types of records identified for release. This form may also include a paragraph explaining the purpose of this form. Students must sign a release of information form. With the student’s permission, this form can be used by DSPS to obtain disability verification and/or to exchange disability related information with college personnel who have a “legitimate educational need to know.” For example, an instructor needs to be aware that a student with a print impairment should not be called on to read aloud in class. Some districts use forms that specify that information can be shared among the DSPS programs within that district. has a simple, easy to read and complete Release of Information form, Cuesta’s form is also excellent and covers more specifics. Moorpark College Verification of Disability Status and Identification of Educational Limitations Title 5- Section 56006, Determination of Eligibility; Section 56004, Educational limitation; Sections 56023-56044, Definitions of Specific Disability categories. This form should contain: student contact information; date of birth; student ID#; name, address and contact information of verifying professional; diagnosis (DSM Code and severity, if applicable); description of substantial limitations to learning and other major life activities; duration of disability; and signature and professional title License/Certification # and date. The student is required to submit documentation of their disability. This disability documentation can be provided by a professional who is qualified to make the specific diagnosis and is unrelated to the student: an M.D., licensed psychiatrist, clinical psychologist, speech pathologist, audiologist, LD Specialist, a Marriage, Family and Child (MFC) Counselor, licensed Clinical Social Worker, or by documentation from a referring agency that obtains its verification from an appropriately licensed professional. In some cases, such as with some mobility impairments, the first hand observation of a DSPS 22 Guide to DSPS: A Primer professional staff member with review by the DSPS Coordinator is sufficient to determine eligibility. The verification of disability should include the functional limitations resulting from the disability. A diagnosis alone is not sufficient to provide the necessary information to determine the educational impact of the disabling condition. The “educational limitations” that result from the stated “functional limitations” are determined through discussion between the student and the DSPS Specialist. The diagnosing professional who has signed off on the disability verification form is usually not familiar with postsecondary education requirements. Therefore, it is imperative that reasonable educational accommodations be determined by the DSPS professional in coordination with the student. DSPS is not required to provide all accommodations suggested by the diagnostician. For example, a physician may diagnose ADHD and recommend the student be excused from meeting timelines for assignments. This is not an appropriate postsecondary accommodation and there is no requirement to allow this. Although every effort should be made to encourage the student to obtain the necessary documentation prior to the initiation of services, in special circumstances, provisional services may be provided to the student while awaiting documentation. While possible, this is a situation best avoided because once services have started to be offered, terminating their delivery can be difficult. If provisional services are provided, the student should be informed that the services may change once the medical information has been received. Even though a student may be served, the program cannot claim funding for that student without appropriate documentation. An approach might be to steer the student toward a special class or lab rather than offering services and then having to withdraw those services if no documentation is forthcoming. Students need to be made aware that appropriate documentation must be provided for services to continue, that “provisional” is exactly that. Some colleges place a time limit; others have policies and procedures that spell out the process and timeline. Bottom line, it is ultimately the DSPS Coordinator’s responsibility to ensure appropriate disability verification documentation has been provided. The only time a student can be claimed as OTHER is if the student has a verifiable disability that does not fall into any other disability category or while awaiting documentation if the student has an observable disability or if the student is waiting for LD testing and/or has an IEP specifying a learning disability. has an excellent form with a second page which details documentation requirements for verification of disability. Cuesta College 23 Guide to DSPS: A Primer Student Educational Contract Title 5- Section 56022, Student Educational Contract; Title 5- Section 56026, Support Services; Title 5- Section 56028, Special Class Instruction; Title 5- Section 56029, Special Class Repeatability. The Student Educational Contract (SEC) should include: student name; contact information; student ID#; date of application for DSPS services; long-term educational goals, objectives, and activities; stated measures to be used in determining progress; and description of services to be provided. (see below) NOTE: The SEC should note the relationship between proposed educational activities and educational limitation(s). Note: Whenever possible, the SEC shall serve as the Student Educational Plan (SEP). The Student Educational Contract is required to be reviewed annually by DSPS staff. However, many programs review the SEC each term, as needed accommodations may change when courses change. If there are no changes to disability status or required accommodations, a classified staff member can meet with the student to obtain a signature. (This is one of those gray areas. It is not a perfect solution, but in these times can be utilized.) Moorpark College, Foothill College, Mt San Antonio and El Camino College all have excellent forms. Educational Accommodations Title 5- Section 56026, Support Services; Documentation of service delivery, including accommodations provided, in accordance with the Student Educational Contract for the student. The provision of DSPS accommodations must relate to the educational limitation(s) of the student. This is the most important requirement of eligibility and the provision of service. The presence of a disability doesn’t guarantee eligibility. The deciding factor is whether the student has a limitation in the educational environment as a result of the disability. Only qualified DSPS personnel may make the determination of the applicable accommodations. The form should include both the student’s signature and that of the DSPS professional. When this form is shared with the student’s instructor, it verifies that the request for accommodations is legitimate and approved by DSPS. 24 Guide to DSPS: A Primer The accommodations form, usually an extension of the SEC, lists the educational limitations and authorized accommodations/services. Usually this is a comprehensive list of all academic accommodations and/or support services offered by the program, with a place to identify those authorized for the student. Student Rights and Responsibilities Form Title 5- Section 56008, Student Rights; Title 5- Section 56027, Academic Accommodations: a signed acknowledgement that the student has been provided with information on and understands his or her rights and responsibilities with regard to DSPS services; Title 5- Section 56010, Student Responsibilities. This acknowledgement does not require a separate form; it can be part of the application form or the SEC/educational accommodations form. The essential component is that the student signs that they have read and understood their rights and responsibilities. Student File Security Documentation in files should be sufficient to allow a reviewer or other authorized person to determine that: Medical verification with a signature from the provider making the diagnosis; and Documentation showing that: the student was eligible to receive services; appropriate service planning was done; the student was fully informed about the process; services were delivered as planned; and the student’s rights were protected. The student record should also include documentation of: any abuse of DSPS service; code of conduct issues; academic standards issues, and/or; counseling notes or other service documentation. In addition, written notifications of accommodation or service problems encountered by the student may be placed in the file. All student records need to be kept in one secure location, any files taken out for review during the day should be placed back in the file cabinets, which should be kept secure at all times. 25 Guide to DSPS: A Primer Student Services Title 5 Guidelines: Section 56026 Notwithstanding current federal and state disability law, each college can determine which services they will provide students with disabilities. As DSPS has evolved, some services and approaches have developed as efficient and successful strategies to meet the legal requirements for providing accommodations and services based on student need. So, while there may be no direct legal or regulatory requirement to provide a specific service, there may be an institutional standard and general programmatic expectation that has developed regarding such services. These services have grown out of a long-standing and substantial history of serving the diverse needs of students with disabilities attending California Community Colleges. Examples of such services are Learning Disability Assessment, Special Classes and High Tech Center services. None of these three services is specifically required by state or federal law or regulation to be provided by colleges to students with disabilities, but the contribution they make to meeting student needs and to ensuring accommodations are provided in an effective manner is the key reason colleges choose to provide them. They provide the means to the end. Obviously, the issue of what is “mandated” is complex and therefore must always be addressed on an individual basis, in consultation with your administration, ADA Coordinator and if necessary district legal staff. It should be noted that colleges can establish DSPS service policies that outline student rights and responsibilities, such as notification requirements that apply when a student will be absent from class and thus not need a specific service, such as an interpreter. However, such policies must be reasonable and fair, be applied to all students, and be provided in advance to DSPS students in an accessible format. What Constitutes a DSPS Service Contact for MIS Reporting Purposes? Student Contacts for MIS Reporting Title 5- Section 56062, Provision of Support Services or Instruction Dates and nature of required student/DSPS contacts (at least 4 contacts per academic year are required) ". . . a student with a disability must be enrolled in either a special class or a regular class at the college. If the student with a disability is enrolled in a regular class, the student must receive four or more service contacts during the academic year. A service contact is defined as each time a service, as defined in Section 56026, is provided to the student. " A student who is auditing a class or who is taking community service classes is not eligible for services funded through the DSPS program. These are fee generating classes and it is 26 Guide to DSPS: A Primer advisable that the college keep in mind that it has an obligation to provide services to students with disabilities in these and other instances in order to meet the requirements of Section 504 of the 1973 Rehabilitation Act (29 U.S.C. 794) and Assembly Bill 803 (Government Code Section 11135 et. seq.) and the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA)." Definition of a service contact: A DSPS service contact is any DSPS service that is provided to a student related to the student’s educational limitation as caused by their primary and/or secondary disability. A DSPS service contact can involve tutoring, notetaking, registration assistance, counseling, interpreting services, etc. Each time a DSPS service is provided, it counts as a DSPS service contact for MIS reporting purposes. For example, if the DSPS program provides a tutor three times a week for 9 weeks, that would be a total of 27 service contacts. However, a student who comes in for a counseling session and talks about four different services they will receive during the semester has not received four services. They have received one service…counseling, which enabled them to plan for additional services to be received in the future. A service contact is: Meeting with a student to discuss classes, accommodations, etc.; Meeting with a student for an annual update of their SEC; An online or telephone conversation of substance or outcome-oriented. For example, an online ‘to and fro’ via email or other electronic means between a student and the Interpreter Coordinator regarding which classes the student is taking and the need for interpreters would be considered a contact. A telephone conversation regarding classes and accommodations between DSPS staff and student would be considered a contact. Training to use assistive technology. Students who attend an approved “Special Class” designed for DSPS students should receive four contacts reported in MIS. A service contact is not: A telephone call to remind the student of an appointment or letters/ newsletters sent out to students at home. 27 Guide to DSPS: A Primer Definitions of Services Commonly Provided and Service Contacts Associated with Each The primary focus of DSPS is to support students in mainstream classes. Title 5 Implementing Guidelines: Section 56026 states "A college will elect to offer services based on the population of students with disabilities served. All services addressed in Section 56026 are discretionary notwithstanding state and federal law. The college can determine which services are best provided by the DSPS office or by other departments on the campus." For questions about what constitutes mandated versus non-mandated services, it is recommended that you review the FAQ_Regarding_Students_with_Disabilities. The guidance provided in this section of this document was developed solely for use in the “Other Disabilities” research activity and should not be construed as a Chancellor’s Office directive. However, as participant colleges used these definitions, they expressed the sentiment that this type of guidance was helpful beyond the confines of the study. We, therefore, share this as a guide that may prove useful in building consistency both within and across programs. It is not intended or considered to be a final, comprehensive manual in determining service contacts or the definitive answer to questions of what constitutes a service contact and exactly how each should be counted. As always, when in doubt, present your questions to the experts at the Chancellor’s Office. Definitions of Data Elements For the purposes the “Other Disabilities” study the following definitions were applied: Academic counseling/advising – An interactive session between a student and a counselor (DSPS or college staff counselor assigned to students eligible for DSPS support) for the purposes of developing a Student Educational Contract, identifying and mapping classes for a major/minor, discussing academic progress, or any matriculation issue. In cases of distance education this does not necessarily mean a face-to-face session. Use of Skype, email or other forms of technology for an interactive counseling session can be recorded as a service contact. Adapted/Adjustable Furniture (AAF) – Any non-standard piece of classroom furniture (i.e., chair, table, or desk) that mitigates a student's functional limitation can be characterized as AAF. One service contact can be counted for each piece of AAF placed in a classroom or instructional activity (e.g., three pieces of AAF placed in three separate locations would constitute three service contacts). 28 Guide to DSPS: A Primer Adapted Physical Education (APE) – APE is designed for adults whose educational and functional limitations preclude them from fully participating in non-adapted physical education. APE is specifically designed to address a student’s educational and functional limitations that are directly related to their verified disability. Participation in each class the student attends is counted as a service contact. Alternate Media – Federal and state law require community colleges to operate all programs and activities in a manner that is accessible to students with disabilities. The terms “alternate media” or “accessible formats” are synonymous for the purpose of this definition and refer to methods of making information accessible to persons with disabilities. The most common types of alternate media are audio files, Braille, tactile graphics, taped tests, large print, and electronic text. Count as one service contact the production of each document created or produced by DSPS during a term. For example, if an authorized student requests three books in Braille, each book produced constitutes a service contact. If the book is produced in chapters over the course of a single term, only one service contact is counted for that book – e.g., although the book may have twenty chapters, twenty service contacts cannot be claimed – only one service contact can be counted for the production of one book. If, however, a student requests large print or Braille production for a class handout, a service contact can be counted for each handout produced in alternate media. See Guidelines for Producing Instructional and Other Printed Materials in Alternate Media for Persons with Disabilities for more details. Assessment – Assessment is the process by which functional educational limitations, academic readiness, and vocational interests, as well as verification of disability are assessed for a student with a disability. Any assessment conducted by the DSPS program must not replace or supplant existing general college assessment services. Each interactive session of a DSPS assessment can be counted as a service contact. For example, a student may require multiple sessions to complete a comprehensive assessment, such as separate sessions for math and English. Assistive Listening Devices (ALD) – Any device that helps a student overcome hearing loss. Usually the term ALD describes personal devices that transmit, process, or amplify sound. If an ALD is loaned to a student for a term, one service contact can be claimed for that term, regardless of the number of times the student uses the ALD. Assistive Technology (AT) – AT is any durable piece of equipment (i.e., keyboard, monitor, hardware) or software (i.e., screen reading technology, word prediction, print enlarger) that has been adapted or modified to mitigate the effects of disability. AT allows a student with a disability greater access and independence to information, word processing, college portals, library collections, course materials, and other formats. A CCTV would be covered in this category. If AT is loaned to a student for an academic term, one contact can be counted for each piece of AT loaned. If the AT is housed in a computer lab funded by DSPS (e.g., DSPS 29 Guide to DSPS: A Primer staff, DSPS equipment, DSPS programs), each time the student uses the AT in that lab can be counted as a service contact. Assistive Technology Training – Programs such as JAWS, Dragon, Inspiration, Kurzweil, etc. may require individual or small group training in order for the student to be an independent user. Each training session on a piece of Assistive Technology can be counted as a service contact. Calculator and Spell Checker – A calculator is a tool that assists a student in performing basic computations or logarithmic functions. Spelling is considered incidental to overall composition and it is not overtly taught in the college setting, except in the Spelling course. Therefore, it can be accommodated with appropriate tools (electronic spell checkers, computer spell checking functions, and/or hand-held spelling dictionaries such as the “Misspeller’s Dictionary”). Calculators and spell checkers may be provided by a student or DSPS. A single service contact can be counted for the authorization of a calculator or spell checker. (See Equipment Loan) If you need to advocate with an instructor for the use of a calculator or spell checker, this would also count as a service contact, as well. Computer Assisted Real-Time Transcription (CART) – CART (speech-to-text) uses a person specially trained to transcribe speech into viewable text, using a computer and an input device especially designed for this purpose. With CART, a student who is hard-ofhearing, deaf or has other disabilities can follow the text of what instructors or classmates are saying within a second or two of them speaking. CART also allows saving the transcribed text as a computer file that can be provided to the student for additional review. Each time CART is provided for during a term/semester counts as a service contact. (CART provided for a student fifteen times during a term/semester would count as fifteen service contacts.) Disability-related Counseling – An interactive session for the purpose of discussing the management of a student's disability (i.e., health care while attending classes, managing medications and nutrition, access to mental health services). Each counseling session can be recorded as a service contact. Distraction Reduced Setting – The use of noise canceling headphones or earplugs, a remote site from the classroom to allow the student to read a test aloud or verbalize answers prior to recording them, or any combination of services and accommodations that reduce visual or audible stimulation or allow a student to verbalize without causing a distraction to other students. The use of a distraction reduced setting for an instructional or testing session can be counted as a service contact each time it is used. Equipment Loan – Any piece of durable DSPS equipment loaned to a student during a term (i.e., recorder, spell checker, assistive listening device, calculator, motorized scooter, 30 Guide to DSPS: A Primer wheelchair). Each piece of equipment loaned to each student can be counted as a service contact for that term. However, if extra time is required in dealing with equipment loan issues, these can be counted as additional contacts. Extended Time on Quizzes, Tests, and Exams – Some students may be authorized an extended amount of time to complete in-class, on-campus or online exams because of the side effects related to medications, physical limitations associated with a disability, cognitive impairments, or a specific learning disability. A service contact can be recorded each time this service is used. Learning Disability Assessment (California Community College Learning Disability Assessment Eligibility and Services Model, re: LD Assessment) – The processes approved by the Chancellor’s Office is used for the identification of students with learning disabilities. Each session that the student participates in the LD Assessment model can be counted as one service contact. LD Eligibility Model Handbook Introduction and Overview Liaison/Referral to Instructors, College, and Community Resources – Referrals to oncampus offices (i.e., instructors, Financial Aid, Job Placement, EOPS) and community resources (i.e., Department of Rehabilitation, community shelter, social welfare agencies) are generally made during a personal counseling appointment and this service would usually be recorded as a part of the contact counted in a regular counseling session. However, if the referral includes walking the student over to the tutoring center or meeting with other personnel to introduce or discuss the referral, that activity would count as a service contact. Mobility Assistance- Physical assistance provided most often to a qualifying student directly related to their participation in an instructional activity (e.g., loan of a wheelchair or scooter, assisting with the changing of clothes for an adaptive physical education course, removing materials from a backpack and placement on a desk). A service contact can be counted each time mobility assistance is provided. Mobility and Orientation – A limited training to the campus emphasizing safety and effective travel provided to individuals who are blind, visually impaired, have difficulty ambulating, use a wheelchair for mobility, or have been diagnosed with an intellectual disability. The "mobility" piece generally assists the student in knowing how to get to where they want to go and the "orientation" portion aids the student in knowing their location on campus. A service contact can be counted each time mobility and/or orientation to the campus is provided. Move Classroom – Notwithstanding federal or state laws, it is sometimes necessary to move the location of a classroom for reasons of accessibility. Any relocation that is advocated, 31 Guide to DSPS: A Primer initiated, and monitored by a DSPS staff member can be counted as a service contact for each student with a disability who requires specific access to that class. Notetaking/ Notetaking paper– The provision of notetaking services in the classroom includes notetaking assistance, or the manual manipulation of instructional materials, such as in-class completion of handouts or worksheets. A service contact can be counted each time the service is provided (i.e., notetaking/scribe services provided fifteen times during a term could be counted as fifteen service contacts). Notetaking paper is paper or a document that is used, primarily, for classroom notetaking purposes and provided by DSPS. Common notetaking papers include NCR (No Carbon Required), large-ruled paper for large print, and three-hole punched notebook paper. If notetaking is provided by another student taking the same course, the use of a copy machine may be authorized and counted as a contact. Scribe Services – Includes the services of a scribe writing student's responses (verbatim) when a student is unable to physically enter data during the class session and/or test. A service contact can be counted each time the service is provided. On-Campus Transportation – Any on-campus transportation (i.e., golf cart, paratransit bus, wheelchair [either motorized or pushed]) provided by DSPS to mitigate a disability associated with, but not limited to, ambulation, a pulmonary or cardiac condition, arthritis, cerebral palsy. Once authorized, on-campus transportation can be counted as a service contact each time it is used. Personal Counseling – Is an interactive session to assist a student resolve issues that may be preventing the full achievement of educational, social, or vocational/career goals. Issues may include study skills (i.e., enhancing memory, time management, academic coaching), personal behavior, substance abuse, mental illness, or any personal issue the student requests assistance resolving. While DSPS professionals can often assist the student in successfully resolving a personal issue, a session for personal counseling may result in a referral to college or community resource. A service contact can be counted each time a personal counseling session is held. Personal Locker – A sheltered space for a student to secure personal belongings or course materials while on campus. In order for a locker to be claimed as a service contact, it must (1) be authorized as a service or accommodation by DSPS and (2) it must be provided by DSPS. A locker in the college gym or music room, for example, cannot be counted as a service contact. Preferential Seating – A student may be authorized for preferential seating in a classroom or activity setting because of functional limitations imposed by a disability. Functional limitations may include, but are not necessarily limited to, deafness or hard-of-hearing, low 32 Guide to DSPS: A Primer vision, psychological disability (i.e., any anxiety disorder characterized by unexpected and repeated episodes of intense fear), and physical disability (i.e., irritable bowel syndrome, Crohn's Disease). For each setting in which preferential seating is provided during a term, a service contact can be recorded. Priority Registration – Granting a student permission to register for classes before the general student population in order to appropriately accommodate disability related issues. Priority registration is often used as a cost effective way to provide accessibility for students with disabilities. For example, allowance of lead time to secure the accommodation of the alternate text in a timely manner. One service contact can be claimed for each term/semester a student uses priority registration. Priority Registration FAQ Reader- A sighted individual who reads written materials for the benefit of a person who is unable to read print. The materials may be read and recorded or may be read in person. This service includes the coordination and provision of access to information required for participation in an instructional or testing activity if access is unavailable in other suitable modes (e.g., alternate media, audio file). A service contact can be counted each time a reader is provided to a student. Recorder – A recorder, either analog or digital, may be authorized for a student whose functional limitation, educationally, restricts, impairs, or prevents adequate notetaking, enhancing short or long-term memory, or aids in auditory processing. A service contact can be counted for each course for which a recorder is provided. Registration Assistance – Registration assistance is different from priority registration in that direct, personal assistance by DSPS or college staff is provided to a student to initiate and/or complete the registration process. The authorization for registration assistance can be counted as a service contact once each term/semester. However, there are instances where students (in particular those who are deaf or visually impaired) may return several times to obtain assistance adding or dropping classes, in which case, a service contact can be counted for each session required to complete the registration process. Service Animal –Beginning on March 15, 2011, only dogs (and miniature horses) are recognized as service animals under Titles II and III of The Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) . ". . . Service animals are defined as dogs that are individually trained to do work or perform tasks for people with disabilities.” Examples of such work or tasks include guiding people who are blind, alerting people who are deaf, pulling a wheelchair, alerting and protecting a person who is having a seizure, reminding a person with mental illness to take prescribed medications, calming a person with Post Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD) during an anxiety attack, or performing other duties. Service animals are working animals, not pets. The work or task a dog has been trained to provide must be directly related to the 33 Guide to DSPS: A Primer person’s disability. If a dog meets this definition, it is considered a service animal regardless of whether it has been licensed or certified by a state or local government or a training program. Dogs whose sole function is to provide comfort or emotional support do not qualify as service animals under the ADA. Please review the ADA Technical Assistance Brief on Service Animals and Policy and procedure guidance on service animals. If DSPS is involved in the authorization of a service dog (or miniature horse) or, more likely, involved in disputes or issues arising from a service dog, each interaction can be counted as a contact. Sign Language Interpreter (SLI) – In an educational setting, an SLI facilitates communication between a student who is deaf and instructors, classmates, and college staff (i.e., student services personnel, instructional support staff). Each time sign language interpreter services are used, a service contact can be recorded (e.g., three counseling office appointments, one meeting with financial aid officer, fifteen classroom sessions would total nineteen service contacts for the term/semester). Special Classes – Title 5 Implementing Guidelines, Section 56028, defines a special class as an activity which: Produces revenue in the same manner as other general college instructional activities; Has been approved through the normal curriculum review process; Is designed to overcome a student’s educational limitations or assist the student in acquiring skills necessary for completion of the goals set forth in the SEC; Is taught by specially trained instructors who hold the appropriate DSPS minimum qualifications; and Utilizes materials or instructional methods adapted to the disability related needs of the students. From an MIS perspective, DSPS will be deemed to have “provided support services or instruction” to a student with a disability, as required by Section 56060, if the student is enrolled in a special class. Speech Services- In order to be counted as a service contact, this service should supplement instructional activity and be provided in conjunction with participation in the educational offerings of the college. Speech therapy, like physical, music, recreation, and occupational therapy, cannot be funded by DSPS. When provided as a supplement or in conjunction with an instructional activity, one service contact can be counted each time speech services are provided. Special Parking (Handicapped Parking) – Parking facilities on campus should include adequate spaces for students with disabilities. Parking Requirements If DSPS is involved in the 34 Guide to DSPS: A Primer provision of special parking passes or involved in any issue regarding parking spaces, accessible route of travel, etc., a service contact can be recorded for each term/semester or issue. Transportation Assistance (off-campus) – Off-campus accessible transportation must be provided if the college provides transportation for non-disabled students. This requirement includes transportation for field trips and other instructional activities where transportation is provided for all students. DSPS is usually involved in working with instructors/facilities in ensuring accessible transportation is available. A service contact can be recorded each time a student is provided transportation assistance. A wait of more than a Tutoring Services – Under Section 504 of the 1973 month to see a Counselor Rehabilitation Act, students with disabilities must is not acceptable. have access to general college services. The DSPS program may offer specialized tutoring services but the tutoring services must be disability related rather than the general tutoring available to all students. A service contact can be recorded each time specialized tutoring is provided. NOTES: Co-curricular Activities—If a co-curricular activity is a requirement of a course in which the student is enrolled (e.g. class field trip, class visit to a museum), any service that is provided for that activity (i.e., mobility assistance, videography of an inaccessible site, paratransit vehicle) should be counted under the specific service. Equipment loan is counted as one service contact for the term/semester. However, if additional time is required with the student regarding use of the equipment, additional service contacts can be recorded. As always, rely on your professional judgment and experience in documenting eligibility for DSPS services, appropriate educational accommodations, and number of contacts counted for each student. Timely Service Delivery The most critical job of DSPS staff is to ensure the qualified student is provided with the most appropriate services and academic accommodations and that these are provided in a timely manner. First and foremost, it is important to recognize that the ultimate responsibility for provision of services and accommodations rests with the district and/or college, not the DSPS program. Remind the college administration that the proportion of cuts to DSPS has been greater than cuts in general funds of the college. Costs now are considerably less than lawsuits later. It is important to consider strategies when there is no funding available. It is not acceptable to tell students they have to wait to receive services. Think about triage; 35 Guide to DSPS: A Primer continuing students asking for the same accommodations they have received in the past don’t need to see a counselor. New students can be given priority for counseling appointments and starting accommodations. In the case of new students, start the services and do not wait until all the documentation is in. Legally, there is no requirement for an individual interview, so the process can be a paper process handled by DSPS Counselor or Coordinator. Remember that all requirements of documentation have to be met in order to claim the student for funding, but the college has an obligation under federal law to provide the services. Standardized forms should be developed for accessing alternate media requests, notetakers, and other classroom accommodations. Develop a clear procedure that students can follow to access services within the department. The procedure should be written and available for students to refer to either on the DSPS website or in a student handbook. All DSPS staff should understand that process as well. When classroom accommodations request forms are completed each term/semester by the student, classified staff may assist if necessary. Once approved, an authorization form is sent by DSPS to the instructor or carried to class by the student. Some colleges make use of an electronic notification system. An accommodations authorization form is generated online and sent by email to each instructor. Although the SEC is updated annually, accommodations may change each semester depending on class taken, text books required, examination formats, etc. It is the student’s responsibility to contact DSPS as early as possible regarding alternate text services, interpreter services and any other DSPS accommodations/services that require significant lead time for organization and/or set-up. In the case of alternate media, the student must purchase the required books prior to requesting the text in alternate media. Increasing the student’s responsibilities in the process of identifying, approving and notifying faculty regarding accommodations will help develop independence and self-advocacy skills that they will require throughout adulthood. Intake Efficiencies As stated earlier, a wait list to see a Counselor of more than a month is not acceptable. Programs need to be creative in finding ways to meet the needs of students in a timely manner. Group orientations or online orientations can be very helpful in avoiding a delay in service delivery. Group intake sessions of approximately 2 hours can also be utilized to ensure students are processed in a timely manner. In this scenario, student documentation would be submitted and reviewed in advance of this group intake. A group of 10 new-to-DSPS students would receive an overview of DSPS, learn which classes they should take, how to register for classes, access DSPS services and sign their student educational contract with DSPS. Brief 36 Guide to DSPS: A Primer one-on-one appointments would follow to discuss remaining issues. Gavilan College and Diablo Valley College are possible resources for group registration procedures. DSPS Counselor drop-in times are also critically important to consider. The students who aren’t doing extensive education plans but just have quick questions can be taken care of during drop-in times. Some colleges have DSPS Counselors do only accommodation counseling and all academic counseling goes to General Counselors. If that were the case, a Counselor could do up to 5 intakes a day, 25 per week, and still have a little time for drop-ins related to accommodations. At West Valley, the DSPS program has utilized videos to showcase their services. Prior to meeting with the Accommodations Specialist, students are required to watch a video. The video offers visual introductions of the accommodations staff, including the Accommodations Specialist, the Mobility Specialist and the High Tech Center/Alt Media Specialist. Each describes the services they provide and explains the procedures. The program has found this added step to be invaluable as a time saver for staff. In the past, individual meetings with students where procedures and services were described and explained in detail resulted in significant duplication of effort for the accommodations staff. After viewing the video, the student meets with the Accommodations Specialist where required forms are completed. The student is then asked to submit their schedule along with accommodation requests. After data entry, instructors are notified of approved accommodations, either by email or hard copies of the accommodations form in their mailbox. Other service forms that may be required: Audio/Video Tape agreement Equipment Loan agreement Adaptive Furniture request form Service Animal form Good faith effort checklist for documentation in requesting course substitution or course waiver Referral forms within DSPS (to LD Specialist, to HTC, etc.) Outreach and Transition It is recommended that staff provide necessary application information to feeder high schools on the availability and eligibility for DSPS services. The staff should also meet with instructors on campus, as needed, to assist with the adjustment students are making to the college. 37 Guide to DSPS: A Primer Many colleges develop a transition guide for students and their families that addresses topics that may be confusing due to the difference in college accommodations. These transition guides may include an overview of the differences between open enrollment and benefitting from the classes and instruction. It might also include a discussion contrasting the mandated services in the K-12 system to those available in the college setting, as well as the selfadvocacy role that students need to assume when they attend college. Additionally, the status as “adult” at age 18 which shifts the responsibility for decisions from the parent to the student is typically addressed. Q. Can we provide priority registration for concurrently (high school) enrolled DSPS students? A. Yes. It is important to note that when provided as part of a disability accommodation, priority registration should not be limited to continuing students, but be available to new students, as well, if they have a disability related limitation in the educational setting where priority registration is used to enable the timely provision of an accommodation. For example, high school students with disabilities who need priority registration to ensure an accommodation based on their functional limitation(s) should be allowed to register in the spring priority registration period for the fall, rather than having to wait until registration opens up to other high school students. (Excerpted from the Priority Registration FAQ issued by the Chancellor’s Office in 2009.) Behavioral Issues There are occasions when faculty and staff around campus call on DSPS to handle behavioral issues with students who have disabilities. The call comes in that “one of your students” is creating a problem. It is important to remind others on campus that these are “our” studentsstudents of the college- and DSPS is not responsible for managing the behavior of students with disabilities at all times they are on campus. However, there are some times when DSPS will become involved, when your intervention can heighten awareness of disability issues. When concerning student conduct, an official college disciplinarian should be involved. Vice President of Student Services is often the college’s Judicial Officer whose responsibility is to investigate and ask questions and then will act according to law, i.e., follow due process. In these cases, it is important to determine if the student’s behavior is related to a disability. In the case of disruption in the testing process, determine the course of action through an interactive process with the student. Is there an accommodation to allow the student to use the testing process without disruption, such as taking a break? A common problem faced by DSPS programs is students who do not show at their assigned appointments, particularly when there is some lead time before the appointment occurs. This issue has been addressed at Mt. San Antonio College through a procedure that requires the 38 Guide to DSPS: A Primer student to come into the office and see the Coordinator after two no shows. If the student has a third no show, they are informed that they may lose priority registration as an accommodation, and they must come in to see the Coordinator or their Counselor within 14 days of being warned. When the student comes in to see the Coordinator or a Counselor, their rights and responsibilities are reviewed and in order to reinstate priority registration, they must sign a contract that outlines their commitment to attend scheduled meetings and classes. Additionally, there may be a request to suspend services because a student is not showing up for classes for which an interpreter is being provided. The courts say you really can’t terminate services in an arbitrary way; it must be the same for students with and without disabilities. It is recommended that you meet with the student and set conditions, such as, if student shows up 20 minutes late for class by habit; require that the student call within an hour of class to notify you that they will be in class. As another example, a student brings in psychological documentation that states he has been noncompliant with medications. This individual has identified as a student with a disability. The doctor’s disability verification says he has difficulty understanding rules, such as conduct. If the student is suicidal, an independent medical exam may be necessary. The student could be evaluated by their own therapist or in a hospital setting. It is probably in the best interest of the college to have a specialist conduct the evaluation, rather than a primary care physician. Test Accommodations Providing timely testing accommodations can be an issue. Exams must be delivered to DSPS and returned to the instructor in a timely manner. Many DSPS programs have difficulty gaining complete cooperation of faculty in this process. Consideration may be given to working out an arrangement with the campus Assessment Center for them to proctor all tests. DSPS staff should ensure Assessment Center staff understands the various types of test accommodations provided to students with disabilities, and DSPS staff could be assigned to cover various hours at the assessment center. Bakersfield College is an excellent resource for information about their use of the assessment center for test proctoring. Another option regarding testing accommodations is installation of video surveillance in the testing areas. The addition of these cameras not only makes the work of the person proctoring more efficient, but also colleges report that the very presence of cameras seems to reduce cheating. Q. What is the nursing/allied health program at a college required to provide as a reasonable accommodation in the following: Classroom exams 39 Guide to DSPS: A Primer Assessment of technical application ability, i.e., giving injections (time and ½?) A. In terms of in-class testing, students are entitled to extra time and other accommodations. In clinical application, a student may be entitled to certain accommodations, i.e., extra practice of tasks. However, when technical application of learning is being tested, a student would have to meet the same standards as other students. This is especially true if the skill involves a health and safety consideration. There may be different standards for different tasks. Assess if health and safety issues apply to the particular task. For example, a student may be granted extra time in relation to setting up their work area, but in performance of the technical activities, the student will need to meet the time requirements. Otherwise, this presents a fundamental alteration. Q. How many testing center hours for accommodations are reasonable? What are the rules for testing accommodation hours? A. The expectation is that students should be provided the opportunity to take their exam on the same schedule as their non-disabled peers. Ideally, testing accommodations should be offered in both evening and Saturdays to align with the regular class schedule. When an OCR complaint addressed this issue, particularly in terms of evening and weekend classes, OCR actually supported DSPS extending hours, in order to improve services. There may be circumstances where the college would allow for some flexibility in time; this would call for an interactive process to make adjustments. An example would be when two exams are given on the same day and the provision of extra time interferes with offering the test at the same time that the rest of the class is taking that exam. It would be advisable to have the instructor and student sign off on the schedule change. Also, it is not necessarily only a DSPS responsibility; there may be assistance available through the learning resource center or assessment center. Think creatively about who might be able to help you with proctoring. High Tech Center A computer lab dedicated to students with disabilities and operated by DSPS is commonly referred to as the High Tech Center. The purpose of the lab is to teach students to use assistive technology that may overcome educational barriers or limitations caused by their disability. Referrals to the HTC are one area where clear communication among staff is essential. The office may develop a referral form for Counselors to use in referring students to the HTC. Some Counselors and LD Specialists may not be fully conversant in the various technologies that may work for their students. Additionally, when referrals are made, those making the referrals do not always learn the disposition of the referral. To address this issue, hands-on training for the professional staff in the assistive technology that is available for 40 Guide to DSPS: A Primer students is a recommended approach. Utilizing a small portion of each staff meeting demonstrating and working with the software will better acquaint the staff to appropriately recommend Assistive Technology (AT) for students and will increase their comfort level of making referrals to the HTC. Alternate Media One of the biggest issues in the timely delivery of services to students with disabilities is the delivery of alternate media. It depends on numerous activities that have to come together. Alternate Media is any instruction- related material which is converted or altered from its original state into a different format so it is accessible and usable by people with disabilities. This may include, but is not limited to, Braille, ASCII text, large print, recorded audio, electronic text (e-text) formats, and video captioning. Community College Districts bear the ultimate responsibility under federal law for ensuring that they can respond to requests for materials in alternate media (e.g., ensuring an equal opportunity to participate in and benefit from an educational program and guarantee equal access to people with disabilities, as in State Government Code Sections 11135-11139.5, and the federal laws of Section 504 of the federal Rehabilitation Act and the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA). Providing materials in alternate media formats is a college-wide responsibility, because members of the public who have disabilities may need access to materials in your library or to college publications. Moreover, providing instructional materials in alternate media for students with disabilities in a timely and cost efficient manner is complex and demands the involvement and cooperation of all campus stakeholders. There are several considerations that must be taken into account in determination of appropriate alternate formats. The most significant of these considerations is the preference of the person/student making the request concerning the type of alternate format that will be most effective for their use. Section 35.160 of the regulations implementing Title II of the ADA specifically states: “When determining what type of auxiliary aid and service is necessary, a public entity shall give primary consideration to the requests of the individual with disabilities.” (28 CFR § 35.160(b) (2).) Thus, whenever possible, information should be provided in the alternative format preferred by the person making the request (i.e., Braille, audio tape, large print, electronic text). However, if it would be unduly difficult or expensive to provide the material in the requested medium by the time it is needed, the college may offer to provide it in another medium which would be equally effective given the needs of the person/student requesting the accommodation. To determine whether a proposed alternative format would be equally effective, the college should enter into an interactive process with the student with the disability. 41 Guide to DSPS: A Primer As one of the steps required to achieve timely delivery of alternate media, faculty members must be urged to make textbook selections as far in advance as possible. Likewise, the bookstore needs to place orders as early as possible. Faculty should also be asked to provide syllabi, handouts and other materials as far in advance as possible and to utilize electronic text (e-text) when available. The student requiring alternate media as an academic accommodation is typically given priority registration in order to identify required texts with adequate lead time. Students must be registered in the course for which they are receiving alternate media. In most cases, materials will be delivered in one of the following manners: audio-taped textbooks through Learning Ally (RFB&D); the conversion of textbooks and handouts to CD (Daisy or MP3) or enlarged print text by DSPS; the conversion of textbooks and handouts to electronic textbooks (e-text) by DSPS; or the conversion of test and course materials into e-text by DSPS. Under the provisions of the Cooperative Agreement between the Department of Rehabilitation and the state Chancellor’s Office, students who are legally blind and clients of the Department of Rehabilitation will receive audio taped and Braille textbook services from that department. All other course handouts and/or materials are to be converted into accessible formats by DSPS. Students are an important link in achieving timely delivery of alternate media. Those utilizing alternate media services are responsible for providing the Alternate Media Specialist with course textbook information, a copy of the syllabus, and/or copies of the course handouts and materials for each class in which alternate media is requested. Eligible students are also encouraged to request all course materials, including handouts and tests, in e-text (on disk or via e-mail) from their instructors. Beyond a referral form, the Ventura Educational Assistance Center also has students sign a form that outlines their responsibilities in relation to Alternate Media requests. The High Tech Center Training Unit (HTCTU) and the Alternate Text Production Center (ATPC) provide a wealth of information on alternate media. The Distance Education Captioning and Transcription grant (DECT) provides California Community Colleges with funding for live and asynchronous captioning and transcription as a means of enhancing the access of all students to distance education courses. 42 Guide to DSPS: A Primer Policies and Procedures The District policy and procedures for academic accommodations must be made available to DSPS students. The vast majority of colleges put this policy on their website and in their student handbook. It may also be posted on the notice board. There is no requirement to give the student a hard copy of this document and it does not need to be in the student record. Q. What case law gives evidence to the fact that the college should not make a student take math 1-3 times and fail before they receive a substitution as an accommodation for a math LD? A. The OCR decision made at Mt. San Antonio College is the best response. If the purpose of having the student fail is the only way to evaluate that they have a math disability, this is not the right approach. The student should instead have a psycho educational assessment for a math disability. If a student takes the class once and fails, s/he should not be forced to repeat the class. However, if the student didn’t participate in the class and failed, not because of disability, but their behavior, then it is not disability related. To be practical, the student could be required to attempt the course one time, but not multiple times. The bottom line is that multiple failed attempts will only serve to discourage the student. In the case of a course that is a graduation requirement, investigate whether the college requirements are more stringent than the state requirements for graduation. If the college requirements are above the state minimum, then the college could grant a substitution or waiver. If the college requirements are in line with the state requirements for graduation and the state says the college can’t grant a degree without meeting this minimum, the college could raise the issue with the state or the student could file a complaint with the Chancellor’s Office. The question of what the student is trying to achieve must be considered. For example, if the student is a math or engineering major and can’t pass basic math, then the student needs to know this limitation. However, if the student is pursuing a major in art or many other areas, this student may not need algebra in their career or degree. There is a significant difference between a course waiver and a substitution. Waiving a requirement, if it’s an established academic requirement, may not be a reasonable accommodation. Determining whether to approve a substitution is an expertise question. If a DSPS professional evaluates the documentation and determines that the student probably won’t be able to pass, providing the substitution would be the appropriate course of action. As long as a diligent and reasonable process has been employed to determine the substitution, OCR would likely defer. 43 Guide to DSPS: A Primer Course Substitution Example: A student with limited use of her hands took an American Sign Language course. The first time she took the course, she passed; evaluation was based on only receptive skills. When she took a second course, she wasn’t successful because both expressive and receptive language were required. This is an example of a fundamental alteration question. Ultimately, one should check the course outline of record. If the course outline of record requires both expressive and receptive language skills, then modifying that is a fundamental alteration. In a case like this, there may be a concern that faculty are using different grading systems. If the institution can make a rational argument for why it’s necessary, OCR would likely defer. The important question is to determine why the student is taking the course. Is this course taken to meet the language requirement or does this student want to be an interpreter? Other policies and procedures that DSPS students need to know include: Emergency evacuation procedures (These should be in student handbook and on notice board.) Student Code of Conduct High Tech Center use Alternate Media requests Interpreting Services Policy Service Animal Personal Aide (Restrictions that apply) Examples of website- based policies and procedures and student handbooks are in the links provided at the end of this document. In addition, a faculty handbook is a very useful tool, especially as the number of adjunct faculty increases. This handbook would include all relevant laws and regulations with emphasis on classroom and test accommodations, styles for teaching, use of alternate media and contact information for DSPS. Program Reviews and Program Plans Title 5 requires that each DSPS program develop a Program Plan and that each program be reviewed every five years. Due to budget limitations, the Chancellor’s Office no longer conducts program reviews and as part of administrative relief, programs are no longer required to submit Program Plans at a scheduled interval before the college’s accreditation review. 44 Guide to DSPS: A Primer However, DSPS programs still need a Program Plan for the college’s accreditation and so it is strongly suggested that each DSPS Program prepare a plan and submit it to the Chancellor’s Office. This is an opportunity to link DSPS goals and objectives to the college’s mission and other institutional goals. By making the goals and objectives measureable, DSPS contributes to the college’s accountability for accreditation. Plans also include Student Learning Outcomes for the program and provide justification for future institutional support for the program. The minimum requirements for a program plan are included in Title 5, California Code of Regulations Section 56046(c) as follows: The program plan…shall contain at least all of the following: 1. 2. 3. 4. the long-term goals of the DSPS program; the short-term measurable objectives of the program; the activities to be undertaken to accomplish the goals and objectives; and a description of the methods used for program evaluation. Forms have been designed for DSPS programs to use and are available on the Chancellor’s Office website and the Galvin Group website. Budget/MIS Reporting It is of critical importance that the DSPS Coordinator learn the details of the District’s budgeting process and the DSPS budget in particular. Accurate reporting to the Chancellor’s Office and knowledge of what funds are available for program needs will enable the Coordinator to have more of a sense of control in these uncertain times. MIS (Management Information Systems) data is required to be submitted as a college/district. The data reported is used to determine DSPS funding. DSPS Coordinators are encouraged to work closely with their campus Information Technology Department. Reporting occurs two times each year: 1) The End of the Year report, for the college/district is the most important report which provides the Chancellor’s Office with information on FTES generated and expenditures and revenue services. This information is used with MIS data to determine the next year’s allocation. Deadlines are strictly enforced, so it’s important to work with the campus Fiscal/Business Office and Information Technology to ensure the accuracy of this input. The report requires signatures of the DSPS Coordinator, Vice President overseeing DSPS, Vice President of Fiscal Services and the President. 45 Guide to DSPS: A Primer 2) In the spring of each year, a second report is prepared to declare any unspent funds and to request additional funds. This report also requires signatures from the various high ranking college officials. Submitting timely and accurate reports is critical to all DSPS programs across the state for allocation purposes. A delayed report or inaccurate report can impact not only the campus/district that is late, but also others across the state. Note: The End of Year report (EOY) is undergoing revision. A new version was introduced in August 2011. Chancellor’s Office Webinars were offered to detail how to complete this report. It is expected that in the next several years this report will be fully automated under the Student Services Automated Reporting for Community Colleges (SSARCC). Q. With the budget cuts that programs are experiencing, is fundraising appropriate? A. Yes! Some ideas to get more money through collaboration are useful, so try these first. For example, programs can go to the district for basic skills funding (BSI), construction funds, or VTEA funds. Additionally, collaboration with faculty senate and partnering with other programs, such as EOPS or General Counseling, may help with DSPS students. Also, collaborate with community partners such as the Regional Centers and Department of Rehabilitation. VR Counselors can help with counseling and academic planning and disability issues on campus. Think creatively about where to find funds; establish a foundation for the department and do fundraising activities. Encourage community members, parents and students to advocate with the Board for the program and their needs. Likewise, students can file OCR complaints. If several students file for same issue, it will help to get a response. Be aware that OCR’s funding has been cut also. Offer sensitivity training on campus to develop a greater understanding of civil rights and legal responsibilities, so that consumers feel supported. 46 Guide to DSPS: A Primer Resources DSPS Online Resources These resources are made available in conjunction with the online training program for new DSPS Coordinators. They are continually updated as we discover new documents and links that can assist colleges in their ongoing efforts to provide equal access and opportunity of students with disabilities. Please visit us online at Galvin-Group.com to access these resources. The resources are organized in the following manner with sub categories under most headings: Section One - Chancellor's Office Resources Chancellor’s Office Links Selected Centers and/or Programs Funded Through the Chancellor’s Office Title 5 Regulations & Guidelines & California Code Sections Chancellor’s Office Legal Opinions Chancellor’s Office FAQs Chancellor’s Office Handbooks Chancellor’s Office Documents Related Documents and Resources Mental Health Services Selected College DSPS Websites Section Two - ADA/504 Compliance Relevant OCR Decisions and Lawsuits U.S Department of Education - 504 Links and Documents U.S. Department of Justice - ADA Links & Documents ADA & 504 Regulations ADA/504 Resources of Interest to Colleges Accessibility Checklists Section Three - Federal & State Laws, Compliance Regulations and Guidelines Federal Laws Documents & Resources Relating to Federal Laws Federal Agencies Links to Other Resources California State Laws and Regulations Documents and Links Relating to State Laws Chancellor's Office Legal Affairs 47 Guide to DSPS: A Primer Discrimination Section Four - DSPS Program Management Important Stuff- Program Management Documents Policies, Procedures and Forms Student Record Forms Program Plans & Program Reviews Student Learning Outcomes Special Classes and Course Outlines Universal Design in Instruction Job Descriptions Other Documents and Links of Interest Section Five - DSPS Services and Accommodations Deaf or Hard of Hearing Acquired Brain Injuries (ABI) Learning Disabilities Other Disabilities Blind and Low Vision Mobility Impairments Intellectual Disabilities Speech Impairments Psychological Disabilities Veterans Section Six - 508, Alternate Media, Distance Education & Assistive Technologies Section 508 and Web Accessibility Alternate Media Distance Education Captioning Assistive Technologies Section Seven - Faculty Resources Handbooks Fact Sheets and Information Training Programs Syllabus Disability Statements Tutoring 48 Guide to DSPS: A Primer Section Eight - Student Resources DSPS Orientation General Resources and Materials Student Handbooks Student Materials/Handouts Section Nine - Transition Resources Handbooks/Guides General Information for Parents and Students Orientation Information Transition Articles and Special Projects Section Ten - Budget/MIS Chancellor’s Office Documents Relating to DSPS Allocation Chancellor’s Office information on Deaf/Hard of Hearing Augmentation Chancellor’s Office FAQs and Legal Opinions Relating to Budget Chancellor’s Office Budget/MIS Links Section Eleven - Access, Security and Safety on Campus ADA/504 Barriers and Access Emergency Preparedness Crisis Intervention Section Twelve - Adapted Physical Education (APE) Section Fourteen - Working with Other Categorical Programs & Resources Section Fifteen - Bright Ideas for Keeping the Lights On NOTE: DON’T FORGET TO GO TO THE DSPS COORDINATOR TRAINING AT the Galvin Group website FOR MORE INFORMATION ON THIS PRIMER OR OTHER TECHNICAL ASSISTANCE ISSUES PLEASE CONTACT : Jan@galvin-group.com OR Bette@galvin-group.com T H E G A L V I N G R O U P, L L C 4 6 2 4 N O R T H B U C K S K I N WAY, T U C S O N , A Z 8 5 7 5 0 3146 W EST PA R ADI SE D R I VE PHOENI X, AZ 850 29 W W W. G A L V I N - G R O U P. C O M 49