Author: Jim Collins
Publisher: Collins Business
Type: Hardcover
Place of Publication: New York, NY
ISBN: 978-0066620992
Page: 300
Price: $ 27,50
Published in: 2001
Reviewer: Salih
Doğan*
“Good is the enemy of great…”
Jim Collins, Good to Great
This book, “Good to Great: Why Some Companies Make the Leap... and Others Don't” by Jim
Collins -co-author of the book “Built to Last: Successful Habits of Visionary Companies” with
Jerry I. Porras- was first published in 2001 and has sold millions of copies. It still sells more
than 300,000 copies every year. It ranks #66 in Amazon’s Book sales ranking and #1 in the
Management & Leadership category.
Collins and his team focused on eleven companies, selected among 1,435 companies,
including well-known ones such as Circuit City, Wells Fargo, and Gillette that were able to
renovate themselves and make the transition from ‘good’ to ‘great’. All these eleven
companies showed the following basic pattern: Fifteen-year cumulative stock returns at or
below the general stock market –where you cannot just be lucky for fifteen years- punctuated
by a transition point, then cumulative returns at least three times the market over the next
fifteen years. To reach the key findings and way to greatness, Collins and his 21-person
research team contributed 15,000 hours of work to the project, read and systematically coded
nearly 6,000 articles, generated more than 2,000 pages of interview transcripts, and created
384 million bytes of computer data in a five-year project.
*
Research Assistant, Department of Political Science and International Relations, Turgut Ozal
University, Ankara, Turkey. Email: sdogan@turgutozal.edu.tr
Most of the business books are analyzing the past successes or failures of the companies.
How did these companies succeed? Where did they make the mistakes? These are some of
questions that the authors were trying to answer. Jim Collins’ message is not solely for people
who are in business sector, but also to those who can apply what they learnt from the book to
their companies, social sector work, or at least to their own life. There is a focus on the values
and principles which were helpful in the past and will be helpful in the future in Collins’s
“Good to Great”.
The book consists of nine chapters that begin with “Good is the enemy of Great”. In this
first chapter, the author explains how he decided to work on such a huge project with a
research team of twenty-one people. Outlines of the project and previews of the key findings
are also described in Chapter 1. The process of transformation of the companies breaks down
into three broad stages: disciplined people, disciplined thought, and disciplined action. There
are also two key concepts within each of these three stages. These all six concepts are the
essence of “Good to Great” and he assigns a chapter for each of them, which are Level 5
Leadership, First Who… Then What, Confront the Brutal Facts, The Hedgehog Concept, A
Culture of Discipline, and Technology Accelerators.
In chapter 2, Jim Collins came up with a definition of Level 5 Leader – an individual who
blends extreme personal humility with intense professional will, and a definition of Level 5
Leadership - builds enduring greatness through a paradoxical blend of personal humility and
professional will. According to Collins, HUMILITY + WILL = LEVEL 5 (page 22) and this formula is
acceptable if we think humility as part of Personal Humility and will as part of “Professional
Will.” He should include the characteristics of the people in the formula; however, he might
have thought that humility and will are results of people’s characteristics to not to write same
thing again and again. Ambition (passion and energy should be a part of it) will drive a leader
to do what ever it takes to achieve his or her goals and get things done successfully. Loyalty is
the faith that leads level 5 leaders to stay with problems and get them fixed, instead of
remaining blind to troubles. Experience is another important factor of being a level 5 leader. It
takes time for people to practice and learn from their mistakes and it takes years for CEOs to
cultivate their mind and wisdom, to accumulate experiences and to learn right from
wrong. Therefore, no one is born to be a level 5 leaders without experiences.
In chapter 3, Collins clearly defines that during the transition from good to great,
companies should first have the right people on the bus (and the wrong people off the bus)
and then try to figure out where to drive it. Actually, this was not what they expected before
the project. They thought that the first step would be to set up a new direction, strategy, and
vision for the company. The truth is that if you get the right people on the bus, the right
people in the right seats, and the wrong people off the bus, they will drive the company
somewhere great.
“There is no worse mistake in public leadership than to hold out false hopes soon to be
swept away.”
Winston S. Churchill
Chapter 4 and Chapter 5 are about the second stage which is called “disciplined thought”
(confront the brutal facts and the hedgehog concept). The breakthrough between level 4 and
level 5 leadership appears in this stage. It is important for Good to Great companies to face
the brutal facts because that is the way to make the first step towards achieving greatness. A
cycle of good decisions is one of the key factors in the success of the great companies and the
author and his research team made a clear clarification of its process. The Hedgehog Concept
differentiates between CEOs. Collins has very appropriately included Isaiah Berlin’s essay, “The
Hedgehog and the Fox,” in which he refers to a Greek parable: “The fox knows many things,
but the hedgehog knows one big thing.” According to the results of the huge project, the
good-to-great companies were built by “hedgehogs” who were capable of focusing on one
important thing that carried their companies to greatness. There are three circles of the
Hedgehog Concept – what you are deeply passionate about, what you can be the best in the
world at, what drives your economic engine – and companies need all three circles in order to
have a fully developed concept.
In the part of “disciplined action” which covers chapters 6 and 7 (A Culture of Discipline
and Technology Accelerators), Collins makes a connection between the former chapters and
these two chapters. The good-to-great companies built steady systems with clear restrictions,
but they also gave people freedom and responsibility within the framework of a highly
developed system. This begins with the right people (chapter 3) who take disciplined action
and are consistent with the three circles of the hedgehog concept. There are two types of
individuals: those who see their job as a “responsibility” and those who see their job as a
“job”. The first type of people would take the company to greatness as their responsibility.
They “engage in disciplined thoughts and take disciplined actions” (page 142) to work out any
possibilities to help the company become the best in the world. Their own objectives and the
company’s objectives are parallel, so they believe that if they spend time on the company’s
objective, their own objective will become true automatically. Second type of people would
not pay attention much about responsibilities and disciplines. They just want to work to meet
the basic requirements and only expect to get their paycheck on time. The technology issue is
not one of the top factors in the transition, Collins’s study says. The good-to-great companies
used technology as an accelerator of momentum, not a creator of it; therefore, technology by
itself cannot be a main reason for either greatness or decline, and that’s why 80 percent of
good-to-great executives didn’t even mention technology as a top factor. No technology can
make people a level 5 leader, or turn the wrong people into right people. It is impossible for
technology itself to create a culture of discipline, or displace the need for deep understanding
of the three circles and the translation of that understanding into a simple Hedgehog Concept.
What Jim Collins says for the very first sentence of the book is “Good is the enemy of
great.” As a result of 5-years team project, Collins and his team accomplished a great work by
presenting this book to the business world. The findings and the discovery of “Good to Great”
would be helpful in every area of management in terms of strategy, mission, vision, and
practice. I believe Good to Great is one of those books that supervisors, managers, CEOs, and
CFOs will be reading for years.