Exploring a topic through various genres Gloria Munson Grammar/Writing Coordinator English Language Institute University of Texas at Arlington gmunson@uta.edu • L2 writers are different from L1 writers • L2 writers already understand the academic expectations of universities in the U.S. • L2 writers need to be made aware how to write academic papers (Leki, 1995) • Write a 5,000 word research paper • Include a working bibliography • You must cite and document your sources in mla Did you understand to do research? • Did you merely the requirements? • Did you really final project? • Did you your drafts for the the teachers corrections? • Should certain kinds of ads be banned in the interest of health/morality/annoyance – alcohol, cigarettes, prescription meds, etc…? • Should the government use invasive pat-downs and body scans to ensure passenger safety or are there better methods? • U.S. companies that move factories to undeveloped nations barely pay employees enough to live on. Is it unethical to pay cheap wages or are companies doing those workers a favor? Write down three memorable events in your life that include the one or all of the topics you just wrote down. 1. A decision that changed you 2. A time when an adult did something unexpected during your childhood 3. An action that seemed threatening or dangerous 4. An unpredictable event that changed your life • • • • Why are the events significant? When did each one happen? How did each one change your life? What is the topic of this event (topic—not main idea)? Goal: generate cohesiveness and trust among classmates. Practice natural vocabulary about the topic. • What is it and what does it do? • How do you do it? The sequenced writing project is a series of written assignments on a single topic in order to allow students to develop expertise in a subject and to write with ease and confidence. (Leki, 1998) Personal Narrative Interview/profile Summary analysis Researched argument The Sequenced Writing Project Leki, Ilona. (1991-1992). Building expertise through sequenced writing assignments. TESOL Journal, 1(2), 19-23. Are your your connected to ? Which topics would you prefer to write about? A. Research topic from a list B. Research project you feel a personal connection with • experience • choice • background knowledge Choose a topic • Take a look at your three personal events that changed your life and are related to a topic that interests you. Share with others in a group. For example, I really like to ride my bike. – Terrible accident while riding my bike – I rode my bike alone through SE Asia – I attended Arlington City Council meetings in an attempt to support city funding for bike lanes The topic is your choice. However, you must select a topic that meets three requirements. 1. You must feel very interested in the topic and want to learn more about it, since you will spend several weeks writing about the same subject 2. You must already have had some personal experience with the topic you will write about. 3. This must be a topic that will allow you to do all four parts (Personal narrative, Interview Report, Summary Response Analysis, Argument). Topics Ideas used by Other Students • Obesity: student had gained 30 pounds since arriving in the United States. • Traveling alone: unusual for her Asian culture, student preferred traveling alone. • Technology creating social isolation: student’s marriage nearly failed due to his obsession with playing games on a smart phone. • In each case the student had already had some personal experience with the subject of their project before they wrote about it. • Students should choose carefully. They will write about the same topic in four different genres. Which topic could be written in all four genres? Personal Narrative Interview/profile Summary analysis Researched argument In the sequenced writing project, you may write on any topic you wish • All four papers will address the topic that you select. For example, I am a long-distance cyclist. • I wrote a narrative essay involving an accident that occurred on my longest ride (140 miles). It changed my life. • I interviewed a cyclist who attempted to ride across America in 11 days. He was featured in the award winning movie Bicycle Dreams. I wrote a profile essay about him. • In my summary analysis paper, I analyzed the elements of a chapter from Catfish and Mandala (autobiography of a Vietnamese American who cycled alone through Vietnam. • My fourth paper argued whether drivers who kill or injure cyclists should suffer the same consequences as they would when they kill or injure other drivers or passengers of cars. Portion of Timeline…. Date due Assignment Details Tuesday January 23 Topic Wednesday January 24 Outline narrative essay Thursday January 25 Rough draft narrative essay Thursday February 1 Final copy narrative essay due. Outline interview essay Approval by Gloria must be given Use appropriate format including thesis statement and complete topic sentences. Comments will be given for on-time assignments. Outside writing grade given. Tuesday February 6 Thursday February 8 Thursday February 15 Rough draft interview essay due. Final copy interview essay Use appropriate format including thesis statement and complete topic sentences. Comments will be given for on-time assignments. Outside writing grade given. (in class) Free-write on chosen topic Students complete an outline for the first assignment Check for • Thesis statement: Main idea and viewpoint • Clear organization – Topic sentences – Support – Detail Write the rough draft • Assign appropriate reading from text book After writing: peer response activity Topic: What is the story about? What does it reveal about the author? What do you think is important to the author? Does that come across in the narrative? First event: Second event Topic—what is the story about? Third event Details: 1. Details: What does it reveal about the author? 1. Details: 1. 2. 2. What do you think is important about this story to the author? 2.Does that come across? 3. 3. 3. Do you understand what happened in this story? Yes No What was your favorite part? (WARNING: students should not check grammar or spelling errors) Check to make sure the students completed their assignments and answer any questions Students write final drafts Teacher provides comments Students write final paper and turn it in for a grade on Students what they wrote Although written informally, the reflection paper should be as organized as any other type of formal essay. Include an • Introduction, describe your expectations before you began writing. • The body explain the conclusions you have come to and why, basing your conclusions in concrete details from your reading and experience. • End the paper with a conclusion that sums up what you learned or obtained from the writing experience. Reflection essay: Introduction I feel that the narrative essay is the hardest one to write compared to other types of essays. Usually, the narrative essay includes personal experience and viewpoint, so transferring personal thoughts to a formal essay is not easy. As I wrote about living with a pet, I held a stereotype. However, throughout my writing experience, I learned from that particular story. Through the writing experience, I realized my essay should have various descriptive words, organization, academic language, and many revisions. Reflection Essay: body If I were a reader and I had to read an article without enough detailed descriptive words, I might struggle with understanding the material. As same as this process, I have to have responsible for giving an interesting story to readers. When I look back at my essay, I realized that I did not satisfy this process. That was because I did not try hard enough. Next essay, I will. Reflection at the end of the project Self-reflection graphic organizer Comprehension And knowledge Past: I saw/remembered/felt/thought that……. Present: I see/ realize/know/recognize that…. Describe your expectations before you began working on the sequenced writing project (four essays: narrative, interview, summary/analysis and argument). Look at the final project. What are your feelings now? Recalling the first week of class when the sequenced writing project was announced, or before you began writing. Self-reflection graphic organizer Reflection (analysis/synthesis) Application/Evaluation I have come to understand that. . . OR I understand that my experiences have. . So that as I move forward in my life. . . I will / do / can. . . Write a conclusion that sums up what you learned or obtained from the writing experience. Discuss what you learned or obtained from the writing experience and how it will affect your future writing tasks. Steps for each genre (change #1 to suit) 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. Choose topics and share stories with classmates Free-write on chosen topic Complete an outline 1st rough draft Peer response activity Teacher checks students work/answers questions 7. Students write final drafts 8. Teacher gives comments 9. Students write final papers and turn them in 10.Students write reflection essay