ITU-T Workshop on
Bridging the Standardization Gap
and Interactive Training Session
(Nadi, Fiji, 4 – 6 July 2011 )
Standardization roadmap
in Korea
Duck-joong Jeon
TTA
Nadi, Fiji, 4 – 6 July 2011
Outline
R & SD Policy
Overview about Standardization roadmap
in Korea
Case study : Green ICT Standardization
roadmap in Korea
Appendix : Application Map for Standards
Nadi, Fiji, 4 – 6 July 2011
2
Paradigm Shift of Standard
• Follow-up Strategy standard
• Leading & Advanced Strategy
• Supply-push(Provider oriented)
• Demand-pull (User Oriented)
• Technology Growth
• Leading for tech. Innovation
• Compatibility, Convenience
• Preoccupation for market
• Cost Saving, Quality Innovation
• Green Standardization
Globalization
Nadi, Fiji, 4 – 6 July 2011
3
Policies related with standard in the world
EU strategies for Action plan for European Standardization(‘05~’09)
- suggest the ICT area for embodiment i2010 & study for standardization
considering R&D in FP7
- Main areas : e-government, secure information infrastructure, e-health,
e-learning, interoperability platforms, broadband access, accessibility
Enhanced government role in standardization – utilization of standards in
government agency and monitoring standardization activities in private
sector (NTTAA, National Technology Transfer and Advancement Act ‘96)
strengthening the U.S voluntary standards system and fostering
government participation (USSS, United States Standards Strategy, ‘05)
ICT R&D and Standardization Strategy to enhance Japan’s International
Competitiveness(‘08.7) : ICT Standardization strategy map, establishment
of a center for ICT standardization and intellectural properties
10 Priority Areas in ICT R&D : NGN/IPTV, Radio & Frequency, ITS, 4G Mobile
Telecommunication,Security, ICT & Environment, Home network, Advanced
Broadcasting, Sound Image, Ubiquitous Network
Nadi, Fiji, 4 – 6 July 2011
4
Long term Trends – e.g GSC Case
1989 - 1992
1993 - 1996
1988 : CCITT-PA 1992
Melbourne Spirit ITU APP
WTSC 94
ITU-T TSAG
ITSC 1-3
(1990-92)
ISDN
OSI
B-ISDN
1997 - 2000
2001 - 2004
2005 -
WTSA-2000
GSC6
WTSA 96
GSC3
WTSA-2004
GSC9
GSC 1-8
GSC 9
(1994-99)
(2004)
WTSA-2010
GSC15
Future GSCs
Converging Tech.
Fixed Network Environment
NGN(GSC7,2001)
NGN Project in the ITU-T
GII (1995-)
FMC
Explosion of the Internet
IP as HIS
(1999-)
FMS
Explosion of Mobile Communications
GSC-Adhoc:
IMT2000(1998)
Fora & Consortia
Nadi, Fiji, 4 – 6 July 2011
ITU-T A.4(’96) A.5&6(’98)
5
R&SD general policy in Korea
Broadband IT Korea 2007
(Year 2003)
e-Korea Vision 2006
(Year 2002)
Cyber Korea 21
(Year 1999)
IT839
- 8 New Service
- 3 Infrastructure
- 9 New Growth Engine
-WiBro
-DMB
-Home
Net.
-Telemati
cs
-RFID
App.
-W-Bc
CDMA
N
-DTV
-US
-VoIP
N
-IPv
6
-4G Mobile Com.
-DTV/Broadcasti
ng
-Home Net.
-IT SoC
-Next Gen. PC
-Embedded SW
-Digital Contents
-Telematics
-Ubiquitous
Robotic
Companion
Year 2003
Nadi, Fiji, 4 – 6 July 2011
u-Korea
(Year 2006)
New IT
u- 8 New Service IT839
- 3 Infrastructure
- Convergence IT
- Problem Solver IT
- Advancing IT
- 9 New Growth Engine
-HSDPA/WCDMA
-WiBro
-BCS
-DMB/DTV
-u-Home
-Telematics/LB
S
-RFID/USN
-BcN
-IT Service
-USN
-Soft Infraware
-Mobile/Telematics
-Broadband/Home
Net.
-Digital
TV/Broadcasting
-Next Gen. Computing
-Ubiquitous Robotic
Companion
-RFID/USN
-IT SoC
-Embedded SW
-DC/SW Solution
Year 2006
-Product-IT Convergence
-Process-IT Convergence
-Service-IT Convergence
-Green IT
-LED
-Health/Bio + IT
-Life + IT
-Semiconductor/Display
-Network/Mobile
Communication
-IT SoC & SW
Year 2008
6
Standardization Strategy in Korea
Global Standardization Leader
ICT Standard Development
ICT Standardization Activities
Development of New Driving Forces
(Strategic Technology)
Development of Standards
- Global Standards
- Public Standards, etc
Supporting Private SDO
CJK Standards Meetingg
- 4G, NGN, N-ID, etc
Collaboration with SDOs
- ITU, GSC, ETSI, ASTAP, etc
Nadi, Fiji, 4 – 6 July 2011
Organize Expert Pool
- About ICT Global 300 Experts
Educate Global Expert
4
Strategies
- How to write a Contribution,
- Negotiation Methods, etc
Advancing Standardization
Infrastructure
- Maintenance of Systems
& Law
Deployment Results
Through Standardization
Portal & Publication,
Various Training
7
What should we be prepared for the future?
“The best way to predict the future is to
create it”
Peter Ferdinand Drucker
Nadi, Fiji, 4 – 6 July 2011
Goals of SRM Development – Rolling Plan
Identifying standardization Needs in the national prospect
& Providing the guideline for Strategic Standardization Activities
Ministries
Coordination
&
Cooperation
SRM Development
Standardization Planning Committee
Guideline
ICT Industry Forum
Standardization Expert
Industry
Working Groups
University / Institute
Propose
the Standards
Standards Development linked with R&D  R&SD
Nadi, Fiji, 4 – 6 July 2011
9
Organization for SRM Development
Standardization Planning Committee
(R&D PD / PM)
Secretary : TTA
Working Group (1)
Editor
Co-editor
Working Group (n)
Reviewer
Editor
Co-editor
Reviewer
TTA Standardization Committee, Industry Forum, Standardization Experts (About 400 Experts)
Nadi, Fiji, 4 – 6 July 2011
10
Standardization Procedure for R&SD : SWOT
SRM
- Standard Development : Selection & Concentration Strategy
- Procedure : SWOT  Survey & Selection  Prioritization  Budget Allocation
Good ICT environment
lack of essential IPR
well-defined ICT standardization system
(Committees, Forum, Expert)
lack of global standardization
(mainly adopt to global-standard)
a world-class ICT infrastructure
such as broadband Internet &
mobile communications
lack of standardization expert
Increasing opportunity for launching
global-market
Rapid growth of ICT technology revolution
& IIC convergence
 Increasing needs for new standard
Increasing the fierce competition
to technology & standardization
Strengthen standardization & IPR protection
BRICs catch up with a developed country
Needs of cooperation among SDOs
Nadi, Fiji, 4 – 6 July 2011
11
Standardization Procedure for R&SD :
Survey & Selection
- Standard Development : Selection & Concentration Strategy
- Procedure : SWOT  Survey & Selection  Prioritization  Budget Allocation
Step 1 : Top-down Analysis
Analysis a major global SDO’s Items
such as ITU, JTC1, ETSI, IEEE, etc
Analysis domestic standardization plan
such as TTA committee, Forum, etc
Analysis domestic R&D plan
such as Policy, ICT Master plan, etc
Step 2 : Bottom-up Study
Study a requirement of users & industry
Questionnaire (Delphi Methods)
Step 3 : Expert Review by Master-PM
Select a technologies for growth engines
- Strategic priority
- a ripple effect on financial
Nadi, Fiji, 4 – 6 July 2011
6 Strategic Area

37 technologies
SRM Ver.2011 - 37 Key Technologies
Ver.2011 37Key Technologies
Green ICT based
Green of ICT
Green by ICT
Green ICT
Green ICT
Mobile Comm.
4G/B4G, Smart Mobile Convergence, Gigabit
WLAN, WPAN/WBAN, VLC, Mobile Service,
Magnetic Communication
Future Network
FN Integrated Control, Future Internet, MoIP,
Smart IPv6 Networking, Integrated
Identification System, LAN/MAN
Digital Broadcasting
3DTV, UHDTV, NG DMB, NG IPTV
Knowledge/Security
IDMgt./PersonalSecurity, Validation/Authority
Mgt, Network/System Security, Application
Security/Verification, Biometric
ICT Convergence
e-navigation, Intelligent Robot, e-Health, uHome, Telematics, NG RFID, USN
DC/SW /Computing
Nadi, Fiji, 4 – 6 July 2011
Digital Contents, NG DRM, NG Web, Service
Oriented Computing(SOA, SaaS, SOiVA), NG
Mobile Interface & SW Platform, NG
Computing, Cloud Computing
Standardization Procedure for R&SD :
Selection Model –Key items
- Standard Development : Selection & Concentration Strategy
- Procedure : SWOT  Survey & Selection  Prioritization  Budget Allocation
Strategic Priority
Selection Area
Intention of Government & Industry
1.0
X Item 2
Publicity (User Convenience, etc)
Time to Market
Possibility of Tech. leading
Global Standardization Issue
+ Item 1
Strategic
Priority
Item 3
0.5
Item 6
Item 4
Item 5
A ripple effect on financial
0.0
Technical Importance (core technology)
Adoption to other technology
Commercial Possibility
Ripple Effect
Influence of future
0.0
0.5
a ripple effect on financial
1.0
Standardization Procedure for R&SD :
Positioning [Macro]
- Standard Development : Selection & Concentration Strategy
- Procedure : SWOT  Survey & Selection  Prioritization  Budget Allocation
Standardization
Stage
Publishing
/Revision
Standard settled
Technical immature
Standard &
technology settled
Final Review
Standards
Competition
Drafting
Work Item
Approval
New Work Item
Proposal
IPR
Acquisition
Non-standard
settled
Standard immature
Planning
Prototype
Design
Deployment
Verification
Product
Technology
Development
Phase
Standardization Procedure for R&SD :
Positioning [Macro]
- Standard Development : Selection & Concentration Strategy
- Procedure : SWOT  Survey & Selection  Prioritization  Budget Allocation
Competition Area
Technology
Strategy
Early stage of
standardization
- WPAN/WBAN,SOC, 3D TV, NG-Computing, Next Gen. DMB,
- UHDTV, Gigabit WLAN, , VnR, VLC, Emergency Telecom,
- TV WS Comm. e-Navigation, Future Internet, wired/wireless
Integration, Green ICT
- Support a global standardization activities
- Carry out R&D side by side for essential IPR
- 4G, NG Web, BcN(NGN), MoIP, NG-RFID, mobile S/W
platform, USN, u-Home, telematics, Intelligent Robot, NG
Web, NG IPTV, IT-SoC, Info/Security, IPv6, Integrated
Identification System
- Select global leading items
- Strengthen global standardization activities
- Strengthen a cooperation with SDOs
- Catch-up Strategy
Standard
Competition
Standard maturity
& R&D immaturity
- NG-DRM
Standard maturity
& R&D maturity
-
- Secure interoperability with global standard
- Develop killer-application
for revitalizing domestic-market
No Standard
& Tech.Competition
-
- Support Industry & Forum(de-facto Standard)
- Support R&D than develop standard
for essential IPR
- Support R&D & Adopt to a global standard
 Preoccupy global market
Vision and Goal of SRM Ver.2012
Smart
Service
Smart
Home/
Office
Smart
Transport
Smart
Edu./Ent.
Smart
Commerce
Smart
Public
Safety
User Oriented Service
Smart
Product
ICT Standardization
Media
Intelligent
Service SW
UHDTV, 3DTV,
mobile IPTV
Smart TV
Context awared SW
Cloud Computing,
mobile Platform
& application
Smart
Contents
ICT
Convergence
Social Contents
AR/VR
e-book
Telematics,
e-navigation
e-Health
Wired/wireless infrastructure
Security
High Speed, Low Power, Autonomy
NGN, Future Internet, 4G/B4G
IDMgt./PersonalSecurity, Validation/
Authority Mgt, Network/System Security,
Application Security/Verification, Biometric
SRM Framework
Part 1
Introduction
Part 2
Status Analysis
Part 3
Standardization Strategy
(Trend & Prospect)
1.1 Concepts
2.1 Market
3.1 SWOT Analysis
(Tool 1 : Matrix Model)
- International/Domestic Status
3.2 Select the key items for each Tech.
(Tool 2 : selection model)
1.2 SRM History
1.3 Vision & Effect
2.2 Technology
2.3 Standardization
3.3 Standardizations Strategy
(Tool 3 : Transition Diagram)
(Tool 4 : 5-Star Analysis Model)
3.4 Mid-Term (3 years) Strategy Map
Long-Term (decade) Strategy Map
Part I : Concept & Goal
Green ICT based Standardization
for Low Carbon, Green Growth
Green of ICT
Green by ICT
- Green of ICT about the IT product and Service lifecycle
- Green ICT based Standardization related with
Green by ICT in the view of Convergence
From Green ICT Standardization Roadmap v.2010
Part I : Vision & Effect
ICT와
환경 융합
기술분야 국제표준화
Phase
1 (’10)
Phase 2선도
(’15)및 핵심기술 확보
Phase 3 (’15 ~)
Ensure Infrastructure
for domestic standard
-Adapt Int’l Standard
-Develop Draft
of Domestic Standard
Reduce Total
Environmental
Cost
 Promote
Industry
Lead Int’l Standard
& Ensure IPR
in Green ICT Sector
Technical Effect
Economic Effect

Ensure Capability for
Int’l Standard
- Develop Draft of
Int’l Standard
related with R&D
Social Effect
Core Technology in Green ICT Sector,
 Reduce total Cost
 Enhance national competitiveness
through Securing IPR
 Bring with synergy of R&D
 Prepared for Disaster
 Lead Green ICT Int’l Standard in
 Environmental Welfare
ICT/Environmental Convergence &
 with Core Technology
Reserve IPR
in Convergence Sector
- Achieved Clean Environment

Product
 Dev. Domestic
Standard
 Dev. International
Standard
People
 Human Resource
Development
 Train Experts of
Standardization
Partnership
 Strategic
Collaboration
Network&
Partnership
related to Global
Environment,
with other bodies
Promotion
 Promote Standard
 Strengthen
Capability
of Domestic and
Int’l
Standardization
2010.1 (Green ICTStandardization Roadmap)
Part II : Status & Analysis
[EU] “Strategic Energy Technology Plan”(‘08.1)
- 20% reduction of GHG emission by 2020, 60~80% by 2050,
compared with 1990
- Restriction of CO2 by Car : 125g/km by2015  95g/km by 2020
[Japan]“Fukuta Vision(‘07)
-14% reduction of CO2 by 2020 compared with 2007,
60~80% BY 2050
Cool Earth Energy Innovation Plan(‘08.5)
-suggest the 21 technologies roadmap for reducing CO2
[China]“National Climate Change
Programme” (‘07.6)
[US] Obama & Joe Biden's Plan(‘08.12)
- Growth of Alternative energy(3%15%) for
reducing 20% of gasoline consumption
- 80% reduction of GHG emission by 2050
[Germany] Energy & Climate
change Programme(’07)
-21% reduction of GHG emission
by 2012, 40% by 2020
-20% reduction of energy
consumption, 10% growth of
renewable energy per GDP
by 2010 compared with 2005
[Korea]“Basic Law for
Low Carbon -Green growth (‘09.
30% reduction of GHG emissi
2020, compared with 2005
Green IT National Strategy for Lo
Carbon & Green Growth(‘09.
Part II : Status & Analysis
FG on ICT&CC ‘08.7
FG on ICTs & CC was established by TSAG in July 2008 concluded with 4 Deliverables
Methodology, Gap analysis,Direct & indirect impact in March 2009
(Definition,
On-going symposia for promotion
Mandate of SG5 was expanded at the last TSAG
28-30 April 2009
• New SG5 title: Environment and climate change
• SG5 created 5 new and 1 revised Questions
• JCA-ICT&CC was established at the last TSAG
•
•
•
•
Kyoto (04.2008)
London (06.2008)
Quito (07.2009)
Seoul (virtual, 09.2009)
ISO/TC 207
- Environmental
Management
Review 4 drafts of National
Standards (2008.7)
Suggest the Technology Watch Activities &
“Green IT” Standardization
ISO/IEC JTC 1 Plenary, ’09.10
•
•
•
•
Study Group on Green ICT
Study Group on Energy Efficiency of Data Centers
Special Working Group on Smart Grid
Study Group on Cloud Computing under SC 38
ITU Kyoto Symposium (‘08.4),
ITU London Symposium (June
2008)
ICT & CC Advisory Group(’08, 12)
To study the terms,
energy efficiency assessment
definitions and impacts on
methodologies
study through NIPP for energy efficiency
ICTs and CC,
※ Network Interface, Power, and
–
To develop eco-friendly
Protection Committee(NIPP)
standards for ICTs in Korea
–
ISO/IEC JTC 1 Plenary, ’08.11
Climate Change TF on ICTs
and Climate Change (‘08.2)
Part III : Standardization Strategy
Strength
Domestic
Competence
Factors
International
Environmental Factors
Market
Opportunity
- Environmental Issue of CO2
emission, according to expansion
of using IT
- Advent of ICT/environmental
Convergence Industry market
Weakness
Mar
ket
- beginning Stage of
ICT/Environmental Convergence
Industry & Market
Mark
et
-Domestic Market Related to Green ICT
has not formed
-Lack of Awareness & Response in Green
ICT Market
Tech
nolo
gy
- Excellence Competitiveness in
Original Technology in RFID/USN,
ITS, NGN, IPTV, etc
Tech
nolo
gy
-Lack of Self-developed product & Key
Source Technology in Green ICT
- Lack of interest in Cross-Correlation
Technology
Stan
dard
- Competitiveness in Korean
Standardization
stan
dard
- Lack of Awareness in Green ICT
Standardization
- Limited Infrastructure in Green ICT
Standardization (Manpower, Budget, etc)
Priority 1 (SO Strategy)
Priority 2 (WO Strategy)
-Rapid Response of standardization
for preoccupying Planning Phase
- Expand Domestic Industrial Participation
-Standardization with relating R&D
- Activate Domestic Forum, Workshop,
Expert Trainee Program for Infrastructure
Expansion
Threaten
Techn
ology
- mandatory about the quantities of
GHG in the company
Stand
ard
- Beginning stage of
Standardization
- High concerned about Int’l
standardization
market about the Convergence area
such like power, automobile, ship.
Etc
Market
- Uncertainty for Green ICT market
Priority 3 (WT Strategy)
Techn
ology
Priority 4 (ST Strategy)
- We need to take a time to get the
source technologies of Green ICT
- Train Experts of Int’l
Standardization forICT/Convergence
Tech.
-Achieve International Standardization
through Partnership with Leading
Countries
Stand
ard
- Developed Countries(U.S, Japan)
are competing to leading the Int’l
standardization
- Expansion of Green ICT Tech. &
Part III : Standardization Strategy
- Standard Development : Selection & Concentration Strategy
- Procedure : SWOT  Survey & Selection  Prioritization  Budget Allocation
Strategic Priority
Intention of Government & Industry
1.0
GHG Inventory Management
Tech. relating ICT Industries
Smart Grid Tech
Green IDC
X Green ICT Index/Evaluation
Realtime Energy
Monitoring & Ene
indicator
Efficient Tech. in ICT area
Smart Building Management Tech
Publicity (User Convenience, etc)
Time to Market
Possibility of Tech. leading
Global Standardization Issue
Strategic
Priority
0.5
A ripple effect on financial
0.0
Technical Importance (core technology)
Adoption to other technology
0.0
1.0
0.5
a ripple effect on financial
Commercial Possibility
Ripple Effect
Influence of future
2010.1 (Green ICTStandardization Roadmap)
Part III : Standardization Strategy
item
Contents of Standardization
- Green ICT Environment parameter
Green ICT Index/Evaluation - Green ICT Enterprise Evaluation Index & Evaluation Indicator
indicator
by ICT products
- Framework for monitoring of GHG
Real-time Energy
- Enhancement of Energy Efficiency for ICT equipment
Monitoring & Energy
Efficiency Tech. in ICT area - Guideline for using Alternative Energy in stead of ICT
Green IDC
Smart Building
Management Tech.
- Guideline for constructing the Green Data Center
- Evaluation Model and Index for Green Data Center
- Energy management for building and Home
GHG Inventory
- Evaluation for GHG emission of Enterprises
Management Tech. relating - Guideline for inventory Design of GHG in the ICT area
ICT Industries
- Network Platform for Next electric power grid
- Access tech. for connecting among electric power grid &
Smart Grid Tech.
Legacy Network
Part III : Standardization Strategy
Selected Standardizations
items
SDO
Company in
Korea
Standardization
States
ETRI,NIA, KEA,
Samsung, LG
New Work item
Proposal
ETRI, Echo
Sense
Some
Work item approval
International
Green ICT Index/Evaluation
indicator
Real-time Energy Monitoring &
Energy Efficiency Tech. in ICT
area
ISO/IEC JTC1
ITU-T SG5
IEC TC111
ATIS, ETSI
Green IDC
ITU-T SG5
ISO/IEC JTC1 ETSI
KT, NIA, ETRI,
SKT
Smart Building Management
Tech.
ITU-T SG5
ISO/IEC JTC1
MKE, KCC
GHG Inventory Management
Tech. relating ICT Industries
ITU-T SG5
ISO/IEC JTC1
ISO TC 207
ETRI, Echo
Sense
Smart Grid Tech.
ITU-T SG5
ISO/IEC JTC1
IECTC 111
ETRI, Echo
Sense
New Work item
Proposal
2010.1 (Green ICTStandardization Roadma
Part III : Standardization Strategy
 Real-time Energy Monitoring & Energy Efficiency Tech (example).
Importance Domestic Dev. Host
Publishing
S /Revision
T
A
N
Final
D Review
A
R
D
S
Drafting
S
T
A Work item
T Approval
E
S
New Work
Item
Proposal
IPR
Risk
12
13
★★★
★★
★
International
SDO
Standards. Technology
Dev.
Dev.
11
★★★
10
09
TTA
ETRI
Forum
ETRI
12
11
ISO/IEC JTC1
ITU-T SG5
IETF
6LowPAN
ATIS
ETSI
NOTE
10
09
08
09
07
: International present States
: states transition for Standard. In Domestic
: states transition for Standard. In international
09
Planning
: Domestic present states
Prototype
Design
Deployment
Verification
Technology Dev. Level
Product
: Technology Dev. After Standardizations)
 : Standardardizations go with technology Dev.
: Standardizations After Technology Dev.
Part III : Standardization Strategy
 Real-time Energy Monitoring & Energy Efficiency Tech(example).
Part III : Standardization Strategy
Classific
ation
Before 2009
2010
2011
2012
After 2013
Standardizati
on Goal

Green of
ICT


(2007)
(2014
)
●
Green ICT Index/Evaluation indicator
(2013
)
●
Real-time Energy Monitoring & Energy Efficiency Tech. in ICT area

(2008)
Green IDC
(2014
●

)

Smart Building Management Tech.

◑
Collaborate
/
Compete
with Int’l
Standard
Rev.2
Green by
ICT
(2006)

GHG Inventory Management Tech. relating ICT Industries
●


●
Smart Grid Tech.
Note

: Korea Standard Dev.
: Korea Technology Dev.


(2014
)
: Complete Int’l Standard Dev.
priority : ● (high) - ◑ (Mid) - ○ (Low)
: Complete Int’l Technology Dev.
Application Map for Standardization
Download : www.tta.or.kr
VINAKA VAKALEVU!
(vee narka vakalevoo)!
Contact : jooniii@tta.or.kr
Cyberjaya, Malaysia, 29 June – 1 July 2010
31