Innovating Solutions to Nonpoint Source Pollution Using Reverse Engineering NOAA Design Challenge Author: Anthony Williams, Williamsport High School, Washington County Public Schools Background Information Subject: Identify the course the unit will be implemented in. Grade Band: Identify the appropriate grade band for the lesson. Duration: Identify the time frame for the unit. Overview: Provide a concise summary of what students will learn in the lesson. It explains the unit’s focus, connection to content, and real world connection. Biology, Environmental Science, and/or Technology Education 9-12 5-7 days Students will conduct field studies to analyze Bay health and differentiate between point and nonpoint solution. Students then analyze existing strategies to reduce nonpoint solution and develop creative and innovative improvements to established designs. It is important to note that for this lesson, students will need to take a field trip to a watershed to collect water samples or water samples will need to be available to them for testing. Follow your school’s procedure for organizing field trips. Organization Posing Challenge: National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration(NOAA) Challenge Title: NOAA Design Challenge Challenge Description: Challenge: State the real-world challenge students will develop solutions for. The purpose of the NOAA Design Challenge is for students to research and design the most effective strategy for preventing or removing nonpoint source pollution from the water of the Bay or the streams that flow into it. Award: Finalists will present to the Chesapeake Bay Program Management Board who will select the winning team. The names of the winning team will be displayed on a NOAA Chesapeake Bay Interpretive Buoy System (CBIBS) buoy. Page 1 of 26 Innovating Solutions to Nonpoint Source Pollution Using Reverse Engineering NOAA Design Challenge Background Information Nonpoint source pollution occurs when rain runs off farmland, city streets, construction sites, and suburban lawns, roofs and driveways and enters our waterways. This runoff often contains harmful substances such as toxics, excess nutrients and sediments. It is called nonpoint source pollution because it does not come from a single source, or point, such as a sewage treatment plant or an industrial discharge pipe. Background Information: Identify information or resources that will help teachers understand and facilitate the challenge. Students will first need to develop an understanding of the Chesapeake Bay and the nutrients, sediments, and toxics issues in the Bay and its watershed. This understanding will be developed, in part, by students exploring data from NOAA CBIBS, the National Estuarine Research Reserve System, and Maryland Eyes on the Bay monitoring platforms. Students will then localize that knowledge by exploring nearby sources of point and nonpoint source pollutants entering the Bay or their local waterway and ground truthing that assessment through the hands-on collection of data. Students will also explore existing strategies for removing and/or preventing nutrients, sediment and toxics from entering the Bay. After developing an understanding of the excess nutrient, sediment and toxics problem and existing strategies for addressing these problems, students will apply what they have learned to the design of a technology that will remove or prevent these pollutants from impacting the Chesapeake Bay system. In addition, students could consider the cost effectiveness and community impact of their proposed solution. STEM Specialist Connection: Describe how a STEM Specialist may be used to enhance the learning experience. STEM Specialist may be found at http://www.thestemnet.com/ STEM Specialists can be used to provide feedback to students proposed design solutions. Page 2 of 26 Innovating Solutions to Nonpoint Source Pollution Using Reverse Engineering NOAA Design Challenge Background Information A variety of indicators are used to assess the health of the Chesapeake Bay. Enduring Understanding: Technological solutions can reduce impacts of human activities on natural Identify discrete facts or skills to focus on larger concepts, principles, or processes. They are systems. transferable - applicable to new situations within or Engineers analyze designs to identify shortcomings and opportunities for beyond the subject. innovation. 1. How is the health of an aquatic ecosystem defined? Essential Questions: 2. What factors impact the health of an aquatic ecosystem? Identify several open-ended questions to provoke 3. How is watershed health linked to the health of an aquatic ecosystem? inquiry about the core ideas for the lesson. They are 4. How can the health of an aquatic ecosystem be maintained or restored? grade-level appropriate questions that prompt 5. How does a design brief aid in solution development? intellectual exploration of a topic. 6. How does reverse engineering connect to scientific innovations? Students will be able to: assess Bay health. Student Outcomes: Identify the transferable knowledge and skills that differentiate between point and nonpoint source pollution. students should understand and be able to do when evaluate existing technologies and strategies designed to reduce nonpoint the lesson is completed. Outcomes must align with source pollution. but not limited to Maryland State Curriculum and/or national standards. develop a design brief describing proposed improvements to established solutions. Audience: ☒Peers ☒Experts / Product, Process, Action, Performance, etc.: Practitioners Students will use reverse engineering to assess existing Identify what students will produce to ☒Teacher(s) technologies and strategies to reduce nonpoint source pollution demonstrate that they have met the challenge, and develop an engineering design brief to outline a plan to ☐School learned content, and employed 21st century improve upon established solutions. Community skills. Additionally, identify the audience they will present what they have produced to. ☐Online Community ☐Other______ Page 3 of 26 Innovating Solutions to Nonpoint Source Pollution Using Reverse Engineering NOAA Design Challenge Background Information Next Generation Science Standards: HS. Human Sustainability HS-ESS3-4 Evaluate or refine a technological solution that reduces impacts of human activities on natural systems. HS. Engineering Design HS.ETS1-3 Evaluate a solution to a complex real-world problem based on prioritized criteria and trade-offs that account for a range of constraints, including cost, safety, reliability, and aesthetics as well as possible social, cultural, and environmental impacts. Standards Addressed in the Unit: Identify the Maryland State Curriculum Standards addressed in the unit. Common Core Reading in Science and Technical Subjects: RST.11-12.7 Integrate and evaluate multiple sources of information presented in diverse formats and media in order to address a question or solve a problem. RST.11-12.9 Synthesize information from a range of sources into a coherent understanding of a process, phenomenon, or concept, resolving conflicting information when possible. Common Core Writing in Science and Technical Subjects: WHST.11-12.2 Write informative/explanatory texts, including the narration of historical events, scientific procedures/experiments, or technical processes. Suggested Websites: Suggested Materials and Resources: Identify materials needed to complete the unit. This includes but is not limited to websites, equipment, PowerPoints, rubrics, worksheets, and answer keys. Resources Chesapeake Bay Program – good general information about the Bay and its stressors Governor’s Explore and Restore Your Schoolshed initiative Governor’s Stream Restoration Challenge Monitoring NOAA Chesapeake Bay Interpretive Buoy System GLOBE Program (Global Learning and Observation to Benefit the Environment) – Page 4 of 26 Innovating Solutions to Nonpoint Source Pollution Using Reverse Engineering NOAA Design Challenge Background Information classroom learning activities related to water quality investigations, including a lesson on practicing hydrology testing protocols, recommended before using in the field. NERRS System Wide Monitoring Program Eyes on the Bay Maryland StreamHealth Funding Chesapeake Bay Trust: mini-grant program -- funding to help support projects Examples of Existing Technologies Floating wetland: o http://www.biohabitats.com/projects/baltimore-healthy-harbor/ o http://www.healthyharborbaltimore.org/whats-happening-now/inner-harborliving-laboratory Algae Scrubber: o http://www.chesapeakequarterly.net/V08N1/main1/ o http://naldc.nal.usda.gov/download/49823/PDF Woodchips: o Bioreactor chips away at nitrogen running off farm fields o Mid-Shore Riverkeepers - Agricultural Outreach and Remediation o On-farm treatment of dairy soiled water using aerobic woodchip filters o Filter Media for Nutrient Removal in Natural Systems and Built Environments: II – Design and Application Challenges Bioretention and Forests (using plants to manage and filter rainwater runoff): o Rain gardens, Rainscapes and Rainscaping o Forests as water filters and Forest buffers Wetlands: o http://chesapeakebay.noaa.gov/wetlands o http://water.epa.gov/type/wetlands/index.cfm o http://www.fws.gov/chesapeakebay/wetlands.htm o http://estuaries.noaa.gov/ Page 5 of 26 Innovating Solutions to Nonpoint Source Pollution Using Reverse Engineering NOAA Design Challenge Background Information Materials (rubrics, worksheets, PowerPoints, answer keys, etc.): Chesapeake Bay Note Sheet Presentation Rubric Explanatory Writing Rubric Point and Nonpoint Source Pollution homework Design Brief Page 6 of 26 Innovating Solutions to Nonpoint Source Pollution Using Reverse Engineering NOAA Design Challenge Lesson 1 of 2 Lesson Overview: Students conduct research and engage in field studies to develop and understanding of Bay health. Duration: 2-3 days Learning Experience 5E Component Identify the 5E component addressed for the learning experience. The 5E model is not linear. Details ☐Extension Preparation: Write the following questions on the board: How is the health of an aquatic ecosystem defined? What factors impact the health of an aquatic ecosystem? How is watershed health linked to the health of an aquatic ecosystem? How can the health of an aquatic ecosystem be maintained or restored? ☐Evaluation Divide the class into teams of four – five students. ☒Engagement ☐Exploration ☐Explanation Facilitation of Learning Experience: As students enter the class, have them sit in their assigned teams. Each team will brainstorm answers to the questions written on the board relying solely on their collective prior knowledge. Teams will record answers to the questions. Allow approximately five minutes for brainstorming. Have each team share their answers. Facilitate class discussion as teams reveal their responses. Do not confirm correct answers or provide guidance for incorrect answers. Students will conduct research to obtain in depth answers to questions. Transition: Inform students that they will work in their teams to conduct research to obtain in-depth answers to the questions on the board. Science and Engineering Practices ☒Asking questions (for science) and defining problems (for engineering) ☐Developing and using models ☐Planning and carrying out investigations ☐Analyzing and interpreting data ☐Using mathematics and computational thinking ☐Constructing explanations (for science) and designing solutions (for engineering) ☐Engaging in argument from evidence ☐Obtaining, evaluating, and communicating information Page 7 of 26 Innovating Solutions to Nonpoint Source Pollution Using Reverse Engineering NOAA Design Challenge Learning Experience 5E Component Identify the 5E component addressed for the learning experience. The 5E model is not linear. ☐Engagement ☒Exploration ☐Explanation ☐Extension ☐Evaluation Details Science and Engineering Practices Materials: Students will need access to computers or mobile devices to conduct research. Chesapeake Bay Note Sheet Presentation Rubric Explanatory Writing Rubric ☒Asking questions (for science) and defining problems (for engineering) Preparation: Prepare copies of the Chesapeake Bay Note Sheet for each student or have note sheet available for students to access electronically. Provide each student with a copy of the presentation rubric. ☐Planning and carrying out investigations Facilitation of Learning Experience: In teams, students will conduct research to answer the questions from the engagement portion of the lesson. Student teams will prepare a creative presentation to share the information collected and conclusions they made regarding the health of the Bay with the class. ☐Using mathematics and computational thinking As students present, capture key points for each question on the board. After student presentations, address any misconceptions. Transition: Inform students that they will take a trip to their local watershed to assess the health of the watershed. Provide students with an overview of the tests they will conduct and an overview of how to prepare for a field study for them to review. ☐Developing and using models ☒Analyzing and interpreting data ☒Constructing explanations (for science) and designing solutions (for engineering) ☐Engaging in argument from evidence ☒Obtaining, evaluating, and communicating information Page 8 of 26 Innovating Solutions to Nonpoint Source Pollution Using Reverse Engineering NOAA Design Challenge Learning Experience 5E Component Identify the 5E component addressed for the learning experience. The 5E model is not linear. Details Science and Engineering Practices * If the class is unable to a take a field trip. Inform the class that they will assess the health of the Chesapeake Bay using Bay monitoring websites. ☐Engagement ☒Exploration ☐Explanation ☐Extension Field Study: Students will participate in a field study to assess the health of a local watershed. Resources to facilitate biological assessment, chemical water quality testing, and stream corridor assessment are listed below. Use these resources to facilitate watershed studies and adhere to your school system’s field trip policy. Students will need time to analyze collected data. ☐Evaluation Maryland Streams (Teaching Resources) – Maryland Department of Natural Resources: http://dnr.state.md.us/cin/explorerestoreschoolshed/teacher_resources. asp Bridging the Watershed – Alice Ferguson Foundation: http://fergusonfoundation.org/bridging-the-watershed/ http://www.nps.gov/asis/forteachers/upload/watershed-watchdogslesson-plan.pdf Watershed Watchdogs – Monitoring Costal Bay Health through Bioinventory and Monitoring http://www.nps.gov/asis/forteachers/upload/watershed-watchdogslesson-plan.pdf Students will use collected data to write an explanatory text describing the health of the watershed they assessed and the implications of their findings on overall Bay health. Use the Explanatory Writing Rubric to evaluate student ☒Asking questions (for science) and defining problems (for engineering) ☐Developing and using models ☒Planning and carrying out investigations ☒Analyzing and interpreting data ☐Using mathematics and computational thinking ☒Constructing explanations (for science) and designing solutions (for engineering) ☐Engaging in argument from evidence ☒Obtaining, evaluating, and communicating information Page 9 of 26 Innovating Solutions to Nonpoint Source Pollution Using Reverse Engineering NOAA Design Challenge Learning Experience 5E Component Identify the 5E component addressed for the learning experience. The 5E model is not linear. Details Science and Engineering Practices work. Alternative Learning Experience: In the event that an in person field study cannot be conducted, students can use Bay monitoring sites to collect data regarding Bay health. Sites that can help facilitate studies include: Chesapeake Bay Interpretive Buoy System – Data in the Classroom http://buoybay.noaa.gov/investigations/data-classroom Eyes on the Bay http://mddnr.chesapeakebay.net/eyesonthebay/ National Estuarine Research Reserve System System-Wide Monitoring Program http://nerrs.noaa.gov/RCDefault.aspx?ID=18 Maryland Stream Health http://www.streamhealth.maryland.gov/map.asp Chesapeake Bay Report Card (2013) http://ian.umces.edu/pdfs/ian_report_card_447.pdf Integration & Application Network http://ian.umces.edu/ecocheck/report-cards/chesapeakebay/2013/summaries/ Have students analyze key indicators of Bay health (dissolved oxygen, nitrogen, phosphorus, etc.) over time. Students will write an explanatory text describing how and why Bay health has changed over the years. Use the Explanatory Writing Rubric to evaluate student work. Transition: Ask students what did their studies reveal about how pollution impacts the Page 10 of 26 Innovating Solutions to Nonpoint Source Pollution Using Reverse Engineering NOAA Design Challenge Learning Experience 5E Component Identify the 5E component addressed for the learning experience. The 5E model is not linear. Details Science and Engineering Practices health of the Bay? Engage students in discussion around the question. Inform students that for homework, they will review point and nonpoint source pollution and their impacts on Bay health. Provide each student with a copy of the homework assignment to complete. Page 11 of 26 Innovating Solutions to Nonpoint Source Pollution Using Reverse Engineering NOAA Design Challenge Lesson 2 of 2 Lesson Overview: Students will use reverse engineering and the engineering design process to improve upon existing solutions to reduce nonpoint source pollution. Duration: 3-4 days Learning Experience 5E Component Identify the 5E component addressed for the learning experience. The 5E model is not linear. ☒Engagement ☐Exploration ☐Explanation ☐Extension ☐Evaluation Details Preparation: Draw a Venn diagram on the board labeling one side point pollution and the other nonpoint source pollution. Facilitation of Learning Experience: Briefly review point and nonpoint source pollution by calling students to the board to complete the Venn diagram using information from their homework assignment (additional class time may need to be allocated to review point and nonpoint source pollution if students did not complete the homework assignment.) Confirm correct answers and provide guidance for incorrect answers. Engage the class in a brief discussion about the impacts of nonpoint source pollution on Bay health. Transition: Students will work in teams assigned earlier in the lesson to evaluate existing technologies and strategies designed to prevent or reduce nonpoint source pollution. Science and Engineering Practices ☐Asking questions (for science) and defining problems (for engineering) ☐Developing and using models ☐Planning and carrying out investigations ☐Analyzing and interpreting data ☐Using mathematics and computational thinking ☐Constructing explanations (for science) and Page 12 of 26 Innovating Solutions to Nonpoint Source Pollution Using Reverse Engineering NOAA Design Challenge Learning Experience 5E Component Identify the 5E component addressed for the learning experience. The 5E model is not linear. Details Science and Engineering Practices designing solutions (for engineering) ☐Engaging in argument from evidence ☒Obtaining, evaluating, and communicating information ☐Engagement ☐Exploration ☐Explanation ☐Extension ☒Evaluation Materials: Design Brief Worksheet Engineering Design Process PowerPoint Engineering Design Process Overview Engineering Design Process Planning Guide ☒Asking questions (for science) and defining problems (for engineering) Preparation: For this learning experience, students will use reverse engineering to innovate solutions to an existing problem. Students will develop design briefs and propose solutions to the problem. If students are not familiar with the engineering design process, you can use the Engineering Design Process PowerPoint, Overview, and Planning Guide to review concepts with students. ☒Planning and carrying out investigations Students will need copies of the design brief worksheet and access to the internet to conduct research. ☒Developing and using models ☒Analyzing and interpreting data ☒Using mathematics and Facilitation of Learning Experience: Page 13 of 26 Innovating Solutions to Nonpoint Source Pollution Using Reverse Engineering NOAA Design Challenge Learning Experience 5E Component Identify the 5E component addressed for the learning experience. The 5E model is not linear. Details Inform students that they will work in teams to evaluate existing technological solutions to reduce nonpoint source pollution from the Bay. Students will then develop a plan to improve their assigned strategy. This is known as reverse engineering, the process of analyzing the workings of a technological solution and/or strategy in detail with the intent to understand its function and purpose. Engineers use information gathered to construct new and improved products and/or strategies. Assign each team an existing strategy (see below). Team 1: Floating wetland: o http://www.biohabitats.com/projects/baltimore-healthy-harbor/ o http://www.healthyharborbaltimore.org/whats-happening-now/innerharbor-living-laboratory o http://www.conbio.org/images/content_about_scb/FloatingWetlandsArticle .pdf Team 2: Algae Scrubber: o http://www.chesapeakequarterly.net/V08N1/main1/ o http://naldc.nal.usda.gov/download/49823/PDF Team 3: Woodchips: o Bioreactor chips away at nitrogen running off farm fields o Mid-Shore Riverkeepers - Agricultural Outreach and Remediation o On-farm treatment of dairy soiled water using aerobic woodchip filters o Filter Media for Nutrient Removal in Natural Systems and Built Environments: II – Design and Application Challenges Team 4: Bioretention and Forests (using plants to manage and filter rainwater runoff): o Rain gardens, Rainscapes and Rainscaping o Forests as water filters and Forest buffers Science and Engineering Practices computational thinking ☒Constructing explanations (for science) and designing solutions (for engineering) ☐Engaging in argument from evidence ☒Obtaining, evaluating, and communicating information Page 14 of 26 Innovating Solutions to Nonpoint Source Pollution Using Reverse Engineering NOAA Design Challenge Learning Experience 5E Component Identify the 5E component addressed for the learning experience. The 5E model is not linear. Details Science and Engineering Practices More than one team can be assigned to a strategy. Teams must apply scientific knowledge and engineering design practices to improve their assigned strategy. Provide each team a copy of the design brief worksheet or have it available for students to access electronically. Allow student time to conduct research, brainstorm solutions, and complete their design brief. ☐Engagement ☐Exploration Preparation: If time allows, students should present their design briefs to STEM Specialists to receive feedback and modify their designs. STEM Specialists can be found at www.theSTEMnet.com. Send invitations to Specialists at least two weeks in advance. ☐Explanation ☐Extension ☒Evaluation Facilitation of Learning Experience: Students will present their design brief to the class or STEM Specialists. Students can modify their designs based on feedback. Collect and review student design briefs. Students can submit their design briefs to STEMChallenge@MBRT.org. Submissions must include the school, teacher name, and name of students. All students who submit solutions will be acknowledged by the Maryland Business Roundtable for Education (MBRT). Finalists will have the opportunity to present their design solutions to the Chesapeake Bay Program Management Board who will select ☐Asking questions (for science) and defining problems (for engineering) ☐Developing and using models ☐Planning and carrying out investigations ☐Analyzing and interpreting data ☐Using mathematics and computational thinking ☐Constructing explanations (for Page 15 of 26 Innovating Solutions to Nonpoint Source Pollution Using Reverse Engineering NOAA Design Challenge Learning Experience 5E Component Identify the 5E component addressed for the learning experience. The 5E model is not linear. Details Science and Engineering Practices science) and designing solutions (for engineering) ☐Engaging in argument from evidence ☒Obtaining, evaluating, and communicating information Page 16 of 26 Chesapeake Bay Note Sheet Name: Name of Team Members: Date: Class: Directions: Work with your team members to conduct research to answer the questions in the table. Use the table below to capture notes and site sources. Consult several reputable sources. Suggested sources include: Chesapeake Bay Program: www.chesapeakebay.net Eyes on the Bay: mddnr.chesapeakebay.net/eyesonthebay Maryland Stream Health: http://www.streamhealth.maryland.gov Chesapeake Bay Interpretive Buoy System: buoybay.noaa.gov Healthy Watersheds: http://water.epa.gov/polwaste/nps/watershed/index.cfm Questions How is the health of an aquatic ecosystem defined? Justify your answer with several supporting facts. Notes Source Chesapeake Bay Note Sheet Questions Notes Factor What factors impact the health of an aquatic ecosystem? Identify several factors and the positive and negative effects for each identified factor Source Impact (Positive and Negative) Chesapeake Bay Note Sheet Questions How is watershed health linked to the health of an aquatic ecosystem? Justify your answer with several supporting facts. Notes Source Chesapeake Bay Note Sheet Questions How can the health of an aquatic ecosystem be maintained or restored? Notes Maintaining the Health Restoring the Health of an Aquatic of an Aquatic Ecosystem Ecosystem Source Chesapeake Bay Note Sheet Questions Is the Chesapeake Bay Healthy? Justify your answer with several supporting facts. Notes Source Point and NonPoint Pollution Name: Date: Class: 1. Complete the venn diagram below comparing and contrasting point and nonpoint source pollution. Point Pollution Nonpoint Pollution Point and NonPoint Pollution 2. Summarize how nonpoint source pollution impacts the health of the Chesapeake Bay. Design Brief Reducing Nonpoint Source Pollution in the Bay Overview: Engineers work in teams to improve and refine solutions to existing problems for clients. For this learning experience, your client is the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA). Your team has been charged to evaluate an existing technological solution to reduce nonpoint source pollution from the Bay and then develop a plan to improve your assigned solution. You will submit your solutions to NOAA. Directions: Complete the table below to develop your written plan to reduce nonpoint source pollution in the Chesapeake Bay. Client Designers Insert the name of all of team members. Problem Statement Describe the problem you are addressing. Making something better, faster, cheaper, or more efficient should be a part of your problem statement. NOAA Design Statement Describe what your team will improve to your assigned technological solution. Explain why your improvement will help to better reduce nonpoint source pollution in the Bay. Constraints Identify limitations of your design. Constraints can include economic, environmental, social, political, ethical, health, safety, etc. Proposed Solution Describe your team’s proposed solution. Your team should brainstorm multiple ideas and analyze the pros and cons for each solution before selecting one. Include technical sketches and other resources to support your proposed solution. References Cite all sources used for this project.