Chapter 3 Functional and Conflict Theories of Education

advertisement
Chapter 3
Functional and Conflict Theories
of Education
Functionalist Theory
Process of stratification:
Occupational structure  demands for specific
performance  training/education fills demands
Needs of society  determine behavior  rewards
individuals
Critique
• Acquisition of new skills occur w/in
job categories
• Ed level changed in excess
• More/better education not necessarily
more productive
Critique:
Professionalization of Occupations
• Ed quality little effect on productivity
• Set ed requirement (licensing laws) 
tactic to raise prestige/autonomy
• Reality  learning retained only in
small part
• Ed goals achieved with a minimum of
learning
Social Mobility**
Education  Occupational Success
Social Origins  major intervening
variable
Independent of educational credentials
Social Mobility
Variables
• Race/ethnicity
• Class
• Skin color
• Name
• Accent
• Style of dress
• Manners
• Conversational ability
Business (tech industry)
Elite
• Upper and middle class
• White
• Male
• Straight
• Prestigious universities
**Ascribed group  prime basis for selection
Education**
Mark of membership in a particular group 
not skills or achievement
Conflict Theory
• Status groups**  associated groups
sharing common cultures/sub-cultures:
share a sense of status equality based
on participation in common culture
** a fundamental senses of identity:
others can not participate comfortably
Status Group Characteristics
• Style of language
• Taste of clothing/decor
• Manners
• Conversational topics
• Opinions
• Values
• Preferences in sports, media, arts
**Exclusion
Normatively legitimated exclusion based on:
• Class  lifestyle
• Power position
• Cultural conditions; geography, ethnicity, religion,
education
Struggle for Advantage
• Elite select new members from their status
group i.e. “fits in”
• Lower level employees who are indoctrinated
to respect superiority
• Struggle; wealth, power, prestige
**Education as a Status Culture
Main activity is to teach status culture:
vocabulary, inflection, dress, aesthetic
tastes, values and manners
(i.e. create and process “products” that
reflect the culture of the institution)
Education:**
Mechanism of Occupational Placement
Screening device:
Elite  socialized to the dominant
culture
Employees  attitude of respect
**Schools produce distinctive personality
types
Empirical Support
• Distinctions among status groups; class
and ethnicity
• Status groups occupy different
occupational positions
i.e. Wall Street  Ivy League
w/distinctive personality type  upper
class values/manners
Download