07Appendix.qxd
6/7/08
2:46 PM
Page 115
Appendi x A
Case Study
Grading
Template
Evaluated by:
Case Title:
Author/Team #:
Signature:
Date:
Grade (out of 60 marks) (See separate evaluation rubric)
Please rate the following categories out of 10, where 1 poor, 10 excellent
Presentation Criteria:
Total Value Key Issues:
Clear identification of
key symptoms of core
problem(s)
Score
Comments
/10
(Continued)
NEL
115
07Appendix.qxd
6/7/08
2:46 PM
Page 116
Power’s Case Study Anaylsis and Writers’ Handbook
Presentation Criteria:
Total Value Analysis:
Qualitative and
quantitative analysis
Ability to build ideas
Evaluation of Alternative
Solutions and
Recommendations:
Realism and practicality
of solutions
Strategic orientation
and focus
Logical tie-in to analysis
Justification of
recommendations
Implementation of
Action Plan:
Consideration of cost and
control issues
Time frame and possible
obstacles
Handling of Questions:
Ability to defend position
Convincing, consistent with
presentation
Ability to answer questions
Smoothness and balance
of group (if team-based)
Presentation Form/Style:
Presentation style/
communication skills
Creativity, professionalism
Use of exhibits and time
Score
Comments
/10
/10
/10
/10
/10
TOTAL
116
NEL