Version Space Method Learning Algorithm: Candidate-Elimination



Initialize G, the set of maximally general hypotheses, to contain one element: the null
description (all features are variables).
Initialize S, the set of maximally specific hypotheses, to contain one element: the first
positive example.
Accept a new training example.
o If the example is positive:
1. Generalize all the specific models to match the positive example, but
ensure the following:
 The new specific models involve minimal changes.
 Each new specific model is a specialization of some general
model.
 No new specific model is a generalization of some other specific
model.
2. Prune away all the general models that fail to match the positive example.
o If the example is negative:
1. Specialize all general models to prevent match with the negative example,
but ensure the following:
 The new general models involve minimal changes.
 Each new general model is a generalization of some specific
model.
 No new general model is a specialization of some other general
model.
2. Prune away all the specific models that match the negative example.
o If S and G are both singleton sets, then:
 if they are identical, output their value and halt.
 if they are different, the training cases were inconsistent. Output this result
and halt.
 else continue accepting new training examples.
The algorithm stops when:
1. It runs out of data.
2. The number of hypotheses remaining is:
o 0 - no consistent description for the data in the language.
o 1 - answer (version space converges).
o 2+ - all descriptions in the language are implicitly included.
Advantages of the version space method:


Can describe all the possible hypotheses in the language consistent with the data.
Fast (close to linear).
Disadvantages of the version space method:


Inconsistent data (noise) may cause the target concept to be pruned.
Learning disjunctive concepts is challenging.
Learning the concept of "Japanese Economy Car"
Features: (Country of Origin, Manufacturer, Color, Decade, Type )
Origin
Japan
Japan
Japan
USA
Japan
Manufacturer
Honda
Toyota
Toyota
Chrysler
Honda
Color
Blue
Green
Blue
Red
White
Decade
1980
1970
1990
1980
1980
Type
Economy
Sports
Economy
Economy
Economy
Example Type
Positive
Negative
Positive
Negative
Positive
Solution:
1. Positive Example: (Japan, Honda, Blue, 1980, Economy)
Initialize G to a singleton set that includes
everything.
Initialize S to a singleton set that includes
the first positive example.
G = { (?, ?, ?, ?, ?) }
S = { (Japan, Honda, Blue, 1980, Economy) }
These models represent the most general and the most specific heuristics one might learn.
The actual heuristic to be learned, "Japanese Economy Car", probably lies between them
somewhere within the version space.
2. Negative Example: (Japan, Toyota, Green, 1970, Sports)
Specialize G to exclude the negative
example.
G = { (?, Honda, ?, ?, ?),
(?, ?, Blue, ?, ?),
(?, ?, ?, 1980, ?),
(?, ?, ?, ?, Economy) }
S = { (Japan, Honda, Blue, 1980, Economy) }
Refinement occurs by generalizing S or specializing G, until the heuristic hopefully converges to
one that works well.
3. Positive Example: (Japan, Toyota, Blue, 1990, Economy)
Prune G to exclude descriptions
inconsistent with the positive example.
Generalize S to include the positive
example.
G = { (?, ?, Blue, ?, ?),
(?, ?, ?, ?, Economy) }
S = { (Japan, ?, Blue, ?, Economy) }
4. Negative Example: (USA, Chrysler, Red, 1980, Economy)
Specialize G to exclude the negative
example (but stay consistent with S)
G = { (?, ?, Blue, ?, ?),
(Japan, ?, ?, ?, Economy) }
S = { (Japan, ?, Blue, ?, Economy) }
5. Positive Example: (Japan, Honda, White, 1980, Economy)
Prune G to exclude descriptions
inconsistent with positive example.
Generalize S to include positive example.
G and S are singleton sets and S = G.
Converged.
No more data, so algorithm stops.
G = { (Japan, ?, ?, ?, Economy) }
S = { (Japan, ?, ?, ?, Economy) }
Problem 2: Learning the concept of "Japanese Economy Car" (continued)
Features: ( Origin, Manufacturer, Color, Decade, Type )
Origin
Japan
Japan
Japan
USA
Japan
Japan
Japan
Manufacturer
Honda
Toyota
Toyota
Chrysler
Honda
Toyota
Honda
Color
Blue
Green
Blue
Red
White
Green
Red
Decade
1980
1970
1990
1980
1980
1980
1990
Type
Economy
Sports
Economy
Economy
Economy
Economy
Economy
Example Type
Positive
Negative
Positive
Negative
Positive
Positive
Negative
Solution: Suppose now we have two more examples:
6. Positive Example: (Japan, Toyota, Green, 1980, Economy)
New example is consistent with versionspace, so no change is made.
G = { (Japan, ?, ?, ?, Economy) }
S = { (Japan, ?, ?, ?, Economy) }
7. Negative Example: (Japan, Honda, Red, 1990, Economy)
Example is inconsistent with the versionspace.
G cannot be specialized.
S cannot be generalized.
The version space collapses.
Conclusion: No conjunctive hypothesis is consistent with the data set.
Reference:
E. Rich, K. Knight, "Artificial Intelligence", McGraw Hill, Second Edition
http://www2.cs.uregina.ca/~hamilton/courses/831/notes/ml/vspace/3_vspace.html