for one expert in charge of the evaluation of identified expected results, output and
indicators for the ENI CBC MED Programme 2014-2020
Public notice
Regione Autonoma della Sardegna
Joint Managing Authority of the ENPI CBC Mediterranean Sea Basin Programme
Operational Management Unit
Call approved by JMC on 14.08.2014 and by the JMA official act No. 1527/163 of 07.08.2014
Art. 1. Background
The main features and strategic framework of the “ENI CBC Mediterranean Sea Basin Programme 20142020”, currently under preparation within the framework of the European Neigbourhood Instrument –
Cross Border Cooperation component, will be set in the Joint Operational Programme (JOP), expected to be
approved by 14 countries1 (Portugal, France, Italy, Malta, Greece, Cyprus, Algeria, Tunisia, Egypt, Jordan,
Palestine, Israel, Lebanon, Spain).
The ENI CBC MED Programme, which will replace the “ENPI CBC MED 2007-2013” in the next programming
period, must aim to strengthen cooperation by means of actions conducive to integrated territorial
development linked to the Union’s cohesion policy priorities, also fostering complementarities and
synergies with other initiatives ongoing in the area. Thus, a precise description of how the planned actions
will lead to results and which target groups are expected to deliver the projects is required.
The Joint Programming Committee (JPC) is the body responsible to define and approve the Joint
Operational Programme, while the future Joint Monitoring Committee (JMC) will steer its strategic
implementation. In particular, the JMC will review the results as achieved by the implemented projects. It
will follow the Programme implementation and progress towards its priorities using objectively verifiable
indicators and related target values. The JMC will also examine all issues affecting the Programme
Expected results, outputs and objectively verifiable indicators are therefore crucial to assess the overall
performance of the identified objectives and priorities of the Joint Operational Programme (JOP) and
design corrective measures as the case maybe.
Background information on the Programming Process
The preliminary EU programming documents for the period 2014-2020 call for a stronger thematic focus for
CBC programmes. They also require to deliver a clear cross border contribution. The need for a more
focused approach to thematic/sectoral priorities within programmes should both increase impact and
overall efficiency and reduce the currently high levels of failed applications for funding.
The ENI CBC MED Programme at this stage of the consultation process has identified two overarching
Promote economic and social development
Address common challenges in environment
Four thematic objectives completed the bulk of the new strategy agreed among the JPC members:
1.A Business and SMEs development
1.B Support to education, research, technological development and innovation
1.C Promotion of social inclusion and fight against poverty
Environmental protection, climate change adaptation and mitigation
Eligible Countries / regions are Portugal: Algarve ; France: Corse, Languedoc-Roussillon, Provence-Alpes-Côte d’Azur ; Italy:
Basilicata, Calabria, Campania, Lazio, Liguria, Puglia, Sardegna, Sicilia, Toscana; Malta: the whole country; Greece: Anatoliki
Makedonia - Thraki, Kentriki Makedonia, Thessalia, Ipeiros, Ionia Nisia, Dytiki Ellada, Sterea Ellada, Peloponnisos, Attiki, Voreio
Aigaio, Notio Aigaio, Kriti; Cyprus: the whole country; Algeria: Tlemcen, Ain Temouchent, Oran, Mostaganem, Chlef, Tipaza, Alger,
Boumerdes, Tizi Ouzou, Bejaia, Jijel, Skika, Annaba, El Tarf; Tunisia: Madanin, Qabis, Safaqis, Al Mahdiyah, Al Munastir, Susah,
Nabul, Bin Arous, Tunis, Al Arianah, Banzart, Bajah, Juridubah; Egypt: Marsa Matruh, Al-Iskandaryah, Al Buhayrah, Kafr ash Shaykh,
Ad Daqahliyah, Dumyat, Ash Sharquiyah, Al Isma’iliyah, Bur Sa’id; Jordan: Irbid, Al-Balga, Madaba, Al-Karak, Al-Tafilah, AlAqaba;Palestine: the whole of the country; Israel: the whole of the country; Lebanon: the whole of the country
In addition to these 4 thematic objectives, 11 priorities have been provisionally adopted during the JPC held
in Aqaba in May 2014. Further to the meeting held in Brussels in July 2014, the overall provisional strategic
framework is reported in Annex 1.
During the programming exercise, the key steps of the Project Cycle Management have been followed
aiming at identifying the main challenges and problems, medium term needs, objectives, expected results,
indicators, external conditions and mitigation measures.
Art. 2. Invitation
The Joint Managing Authority hereby calls for applications from natural persons with a view to recruit one
expert supporting the JPC in the identification of the most realistic expected results, indicative outputs and
indicators. Interested candidates are invited to apply in accordance with the provisions of this call.
Art. 3. Description of the assignment
As programming is now entering in its crucial phase, the purpose of this evaluation of the expected results,
outputs and their indicators - in their preliminary version introduced to the JPC in July 2014 (Annex 1) - will
be to accompany the drafting process and ensure that the Programme developed responds as well as
possible to the current needs and challenges in the region, and lives up to the European Commission’s
requirements in full.
All expected results shall be described as measurable goals including measurement unit and target values in
their indicators. Outputs shall be considered as the possible indicative deliverables produced by applicants
within the timeframe of project implementation.
Each indicator must be specific to the results/output it is supposed to measure; Measurable (either
quantitatively or qualitatively); Available at an acceptable cost; Relevant to the information needs of
managers; Time-bound so that it is known when it can be expected the objective/target to be achieved.
Performance indicators and any other indicators might be considered in order to improve the overall
quality of the monitoring process.
The expert will support the JPC in the identification of the most realistic expected results, indicative outputs
and indicators. He/she will assess whether the best possible combination of priorities and expected results
has been identified or whether an alternative mix would be better in order to increase the impact.
The expert shall consider the quality of the indicators and the timely availability of key data in order to
monitor and review the Programme implementation based on the identified set of indicators.
This will involve:
Reviewing drafts of programme documents to map existing knowledge (e.g. preliminary draft of the
JOP, sector/thematic analysis, input provided by the JPC members and JMA/JTS, relevant studies etc.);
Providing concrete recommendations for improvement on the expected results and indicative outputs
by reviewing and assessing both their relevance and consistency with the identified objectives;
Providing a realistic estimation of target values2 and baselines for the indicators as the case may be
and verify their measurability at reasonable costs;
The financial allocation to the ENI CBC MED Programme is not yet available although it is estimated around 200 million.
Moreover, no decision on the allocation per objective has been decided yet. Therefore, the estimation of target values and
baselines will be finally considered by the expert once the allocation among general objectives and priorities is decided by the JPC.
Specifying alternative formulation(s) of the concerned indicator(s) whenever relevant;
Reporting on statistical data availability / source of verification in the Programme area at the most
appropriate territorial level;
Delivering a concise risk analysis and identifying possible mitigation measures for each thematic
Producing an evaluation report of the JOP strategy.
Structure of the evaluation
The evaluation report must reflect the following general structure and indicative number of pages:
Executive summary of conclusions and recommendations (2-3 pages);
Methodology - outlining the expert approach including a description of original research undertaken
and sources of data and information (2-3 pages);
Summary of the main strengths and deficiencies of the JOP strategy (5-10 pages):
Overall consistency of the intervention logic;
How the indicative expected outputs will contribute to results;
The relevance and clarity of the proposed programme indicators;
Challenges and needs in relation to relevant Programmes / Initiatives in the Mediterranean
Recommendations on possible improvements clearly graded according to their importance (in terms of
usefulness) (2-3 pages);
Risk analysis and mitigation measures to be considered for the implementation of the thematic
objectives and to be included in the JOP (4-12 pages).
It is expected that the evaluation report will be easy to read, illustrative and well structured. The expert is
not systematically required to provide scientific research and the quality of the evaluation will be assessed
based on its usefulness.
Relevant sources of material for the evaluations to be carried out should include:
European Commission papers on indicators for monitoring and evaluation;
Output indicators identified by INTERACT and their consideration whenever relevant;
Indicators concerning any complementary or synergic initiative at EU and Mediterranean level;
Programming Process 2014-2020: Fiches developed by INTERACT;
Europe 2020: A Strategy for smart, sustainable and inclusive growth;
Thematic evaluations or studies undertaken on relevant fields of intervention;
ESPON studies and particularly the Territorial Evidence Pack;
Evaluations studies that might be relevant and currently being carried out at national level;
ENPI CBC MED - JOP Programme 2007-2013;
Logical Frameworks concerning the 95 approved projects under the current ENPI CBC MED
Programme 2007-2013;
ENPI CBC MED Programme website(
Please note that this list is non-exhaustive and further material could be relevant.
Statistical data shall be taken into account any time they are deemed relevant to the objectives of the
assignment. The material to be considered will be mapped as the first stage of the evaluation.
Art 4. Methodology and Timeframe
The expert must select the methodology (mapping, literature review, interviews, focus groups, peer
reviews, workshops etc.) that he/she considers most appropriate for answering the requirements of these
Terms of Reference (ToRs). The chosen methodology needs to be adaptable to changes in the regulations
and decisions that are likely to occur throughout the drafting process.
The evaluation must consist of desk research as well as interviews with key stakeholders and experts. Its
implementation must interlink with the work of the programming bodies and the expert must plan to
participate in relevant meetings.
The expert may request statistical, technical, administrative, financial and other relevant information from
the Programme Joint Managing Authority (JMA) and is encouraged to make comparison with
previous/ongoing relevant initiatives.
The expert is required to submit electronically any draft or provisional materials produced as part of the
evaluation and requested by the Programme. He/she will be invited to present to the JPC the main
outcomes of the work performed including recommendations. Progresses in completing the tasks assigned
and described in this ToRs shall be timely reviewed upon request of the JPC and/or the JMA.
Travels in the Programme cooperation area may be foreseen for the fulfilment of the tasks foreseen by the
The indicative timeframe for completing the above mentioned tasks could be estimated in about 30
working days within the two months following the signature of the contract.
Art. 5. Selection and award criteria
To ensure the independence of the evaluation, the candidates who have been direct beneficiaries of the
programme (grant recipients) will not be considered. All candidates must declare that they have not been
involved in the implementation of ENPI CBC MED projects including their technical assistance.
The following eligibility requirements must be satisfied:
citizenship of a Member State of the European Union, a country that is a beneficiary of the ENPI
Regulation, a country that is a beneficiary of an Instrument for Pre-Accession Assistance (IPA), a
Member State of the European Economic Area or a country that is eligible according to articles 8 and 9
of the Regulation (EU) No 236/2014 laying down common rules and procedures for the
implementation of the Union's instruments for financing external action;
possession of civil and political rights;
absence of sanctions under penal law or of ongoing penal procedures;
never having been deprived nor laid off from public administration and having been deprived from a
position in the public administration for having obtained it by supplying false or absolutely invalid
The following qualifications must necessarily be fulfilled:
have a level of education corresponding to completed university studies attested by a degree;
be computer literate;
have an advanced command3 of English (understanding, speaking, writing); excellent report writing
skills is a must;
have good French reading skills4;
Have minimum 5 years of professional experience in the evaluation of public policies and/or in drafting
monitoring/evaluation studies at Programme level;
Have minimum 5 years of professional experience in international cooperation and/or EU-funded
cooperation programmes, involving Mediterranean Partner Countries5.
Professional experience in the identification, analysis and collection of indicators;
Ability to gather information, elaborate findings and provide recommendations with reference to the
elaboration of evaluation reports.
The following qualifications will be considered as assets:
Professional experience in the identification, analysis and collection of indicators at Mediterranean
Professional experience in the EU Cross Border Cooperation programmes;
Advanced command6 of French and/or Arabic (understanding, speaking);
Candidates shall possess the requested qualifications and experiences by the deadline for the submission
of applications. Please note that possession of all the requirements must clearly result from the
documents submitted by candidates (Request for participation and Curriculum Vitae).
Before signing the contract, the selected candidate may be requested to present supporting documents
(i.e., copy of university degree, certificates of working experience, etc.). The JMA may not sign the contract
with the expert who will not be able to certify the declarations contained Request for participation and in
the CV.
Art. 6. Selection procedure
A dedicated evaluation commission, established by the JMA, will check the formal regularity of the
submitted applications and will exclude the applicants who do not satisfy the necessary requirements
foreseen in article 5 of this call.
Candidates satisfying all the necessary requirements will be included in a short list, from which one expert
will be selected according to the following criteria, listed by importance:
Higher number of years of relevant professional experience;
Higher number of years of professional experience in the identification, analysis and collection of
indicators at Mediterranean level;
At least corresponding to the C1 level of the Common European Framework of Reference for Languages (See the self assessment
grid at:
At least corresponding to the B2 level of the Common European Framework of Reference for Languages (See the self assessment
grid at:
Algeria, Tunisia, Egypt, Jordan, Palestine, Israel, Lebanon.
At least corresponding to the C1 level of the Common European Framework of Reference for Languages (See the self assessment
grid at:
Higher number of years of professional experience in the EU Cross Border Cooperation programmes;
Advanced command7 of French (understanding, speaking);
Advanced command8 of Arabic (understanding, speaking).
In case of equal qualifications, priority will be given to the youngest candidate.
Art. 7. Validity of the short list
The short list of experts, constituted on the basis of the present call, will be valid for 3 years after its
Art. 8. Application procedure
Under penalty of exclusion, interested candidates shall submit the following documents, completed in
English and duly dated and signed:
Request for participation. Under penalty of exclusion, it must be hand written signed; the format
(Attachment A), available on the Programme website:, must be used (other
formats will not be considered);
A copy of a valid Identification Document shall be attached to the application.
A Curriculum Vitae9 dated and signed shall also be attached to the Request for participation, according to
the European format (Attachment B) available on the Programme website:
Under penalty of exclusion, applications shall be sent by 8 September 2014 by certified mail with return
receipt, private-courier service or delivered by hand by the same date (hand delivery is possible in the
following hours - excluding public holidays: Monday to Friday, from 10.00 to 13.00; Tuesday and
Wednesday, from 16.00 to 18.00) to the following address:
Regione Autonoma della Sardegna – Presidenza
Autorità di Gestione Comune del Programma “ENPI CBC Bacino del Mediterraneo”
Via Bacaredda 184 - 09127 Cagliari (Italy).
Applications sent or delivered by hand after the above-mentioned deadline will not be taken into
consideration. The postmark or the postal office’s or private courier’s accompanying note (or, in case of
hand delivery, the receipt provided by the JMA) are considered proof of postage date.
In any case, under penalty of exclusion, applications duly sent within the set deadline of 8 September 2014
shall be received by the JMA no later than 15 September 2014.
The JMA cannot be in any case held responsible for possible late delivery or loss of applications. Applicants
shall thus take all measures to ensure the fulfilment of the deadline for receipt by the JMA.
Under penalty of exclusion, the request for participation shall arrive in a closed envelope together with the
attachments. The sealed envelope containing the request shall indicate outwards the following wording:
“Evaluation of the ENI CBC MED Programme Strategy 2014-2020
Call for expression of interest
At least corresponding to the C1 level of the Common European Framework of Reference for Languages (See the self assessment
grid at:
At least corresponding to the C1 level of the Common European Framework of Reference for Languages (See the self assessment
grid at:
The description of prior experiences and qualifications provided in the Request for participation shall be compliant with what is
stated in the CV; the latter will be used as supporting document to confirm what is stated in the Request for participation.
The declarations contained in the application are subject to controls, as per D.P.R 445/2000 and successive
modifications and integrations. On top of the penal sanctions foreseen by article 76 of D.P.R n. 445 of
28.12.2000 in case of false declarations, if the controls reveal that the content of the declarations is false,
the concerned person will be deprived from the benefits possibly acquired.
Art. 9. Contract and Payment arrangements
The selected candidate will be offered a short-term temporary contract under Italian legislation.
Estimated value of the contract is 15.000,00 euro (gross salary including VAT, other taxes and pension
contributions to be paid by both the expert and the contracting Administration).
The contract will be on a fixed price basis. Payment will be made on delivery of the final evaluation report.
Travel and accommodation costs, where applicable, will be reimbursed according to the rules applicable to
the staff of the contracting Administration.
The awarding of a contract does not create in any case a public service relation with the Autonomous
Region of Sardinia.
In the execution of its tasks, the collaborator is bound to professional secrecy and shall abstain from
treating issues in which himself/herself, his/her relatives or his/her relatives in law have an interest.
For the entire duration of his/her mandate, it is forbidden to the collaborator to be engaged in any other
mandate or consultancy which may put him/her in a situation of conflict of interest. The failure in observing
these obligations or the occurrence, during the execution of his/her mandate, of reasons of incompatibility
or conditions of conflict of interest will determine the end of the mandate itself. The collaborator is subject
to the incompatibility provisions foreseen by article 53 of the D.Lgs. 165/2001. He/she is also bound to
observe the conduct obligations foreseen by the Conduct Code of the Autonomous Region of Sardinia
approved by deliberation of the Regional Government No. 3/7 of 31 January 2014.
At the moment of signing the contract, the collaborator shall provide a specific declaration attesting the
absence of any cause of incompatibility or conflict of interest in relation to the mandate he/she is going to
receive, in accordance with the provisions mentioned above.
Art 10. Personal data treatment
Personal data submitted by the applicants will be only used for the participation to the present call and for
the possible signature of a contract with the Joint Managing Authority, according to the Italian law in force
(Legislative Decree N. 196/2003).
Art. 11 Publication of the call and results of the selection
This notice is edited in English and published on the official website of the Programme and on the website of the Autonomous Region of Sardinia in the section « Servizi al
cittadino – Concorsi e selezioni » .
An extract in French of the notice is also available on the above mentioned websites.
The results of the procedure will be approved by act of the Head of the Operational Management Unit of
the JMA and will be published on these two websites.
Art. 12 Various and final provisions
The contract for carrying out the evaluation will be awarded as soon as possible hereafter and the
successful expert must be ready to start work immediately.
He/she is required to observe confidentiality when dealing with information and data made available for
evaluation purposes. Failure to observe confidentiality will lead to the immediate termination of the
contract without compensation.
All products delivered during the execution of the contract are intended as the sole property of the ENPI
CBC Med Programme. All data generated during the evaluation must be made freely available to all
interested parties involved in the Programme.
The JMA reserves the right to modify, extend, suspend entirely or partially or revoke this call. The
participation in the selection procedure involves the implicit and unconditional acceptance of the
provisions of this call.
[email protected], Tel. (+39)0706062443 – (+39)0706062309, Fax +39 070 400359, or
visit the website of the Programme ( ).
Art.13 Person in charge of the procedure
The person in charge of the competition procedure, as per this Announcement, is the officer Maria
Giovanna Pinna – Operational and Mangament Unit of the Joint Managing Authority .
The Director of the Operational Management Unit
Anna Paola Mura

List of manuals - Regione Autonoma della Sardegna