The Case Against Congress

advertisement

The Case Against Congress

Congress is inefficient

 Bicameralism

 Decentralization of

Congress spreads power

 So many power centers make it difficult to complete tasks

 Proponents need many victories; opponents just one

 Excessive electioneering and fundraising

 Partisanship is inefficient

Congress is unrepresentive

Represents narrow geographical interests instead of nat’l interest

Tip O’ Neill’s claim that “all politics is local”

 Criticism that Congress is club for white, protestant male lawyers

 Older members generally get chairmanships (seniority)

 Unequal representation (Alaska = California)

 An un-elected staff

 Lack of 3 rd party representation

Congress is unethical

Numerous scandals

Excessive/unethical fundraising

PAC influence

Junkets (paid trips by interest groups)

Logrolling

Lobbying by family members of Congress (not subject to ethical restrictions as congressional members themselves)

Corporate hiring of family members (Wendy Gramm on

Enron board of Directors; wife of TX senator Phil Gramm)

Lobbying by former members of Congress (“revolving door”)

Congress is irresponsible

Diffusion of power allows members to push blame off on someone else

(people like their congressmen; but not Congress)

Diffusion of power results in “watered down” bills

“Spending Bias” – Members receive voter approval for “earmarks” but not cutting federal spending

Ex. – Gramm-Rudman-Hollings bill (mid 1980’s)

– Called for mandatory gradual budget reductions leading to balanced budget in 1991

If Congress could not meet reduction; cuts were to kick in

Mechanism to save Congress from itself

– Congress avoided law by extending deadlines and excluding certain types of spending from bill limits

“Pay as you go” system in place in early 90’s, but expired in 2002 and not renewed

Congress delegates excessive power to Executive branch

 Due to diffusion, Congress writes broadly worded laws and have bureaucracy fill in the holes

(criticism that laws made by un-elected officials)

 Excessive delegation in area of war powers

Download