FOOD PACKAGING FSTC 311 – Fall 2015 Factors that affect package design Packaging Design Objectives • • Specific to the particular product or brand Must: a) b) c) d) e) f) Feature the unique attributes of the product Strengthen the aesthetic appeal and the value of the product Maintain uniformity within the brand’s family of products Strengthen differentiation between product varieties and lines Develop distinctive packaging forms that are categoryappropriate Use new materials and develop innovative structures to reduce costs, be more environmentally friendly, or increase functionality Design Objectives 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. Who is the consumer? What environment will the product compete in? What price point will the product be set at? What are the production costs? What is the time frame from design to market? What distribution methods are planned? Packaging Strategy – Objectives 1-3 Who is the consumer? 1. ▫ ▫ ▫ ▫ Children The elderly Health-conscious Immunity deficient Packaging Strategy 2. ▫ What environment will the product compete in? “Mom and Pop” store vs. hypermarket. Packaging Strategy 3. ▫ What price point will the product be set at? Luxury vs. regular use. Packaging Strategy What are the production costs? 4. ▫ Materials, etc. What distribution methods are planned? 5. ▫ Marketing campaign, international, etc. Primary Packaging Design Objective To accomplish the marketer’s strategy objective • (i.e., sell the product) creatively. Breaking through the visual clutter of the competition is key! Packaging Design Principles Attention Grabbers Symbolism of Color Yellow is the fastest color the brain processes, and therefore is usually a good attention getter. Symbolism of Color • Blue, Red, White and Grey = Stability, Power, Trustworthiness, Conservatism http://www.princetonol.com/groups/iad/lessons/middle/color2.htm The red is stimulating and intense, and makes the product visually dominate the category http://www.poundland.co.uk/product-range/a-z/200g-ritz-crackers-2-for-1/ Symbolism of Color • Yellow, Brown, Orange, Green = Nature, earthiness, warmth http://www.princetonol.com/groups/iad/lessons/middle/color2.htm White communicates purity, freshness, cleanliness Color of choice in dairy category Symbolism of Color • Black= elegance, sophistication, luxury, wealth Black was not used in snack food packaging until mid-1980s http://www.theimpulsivebuy.com/wordpress/2005/02/01/terra-potpourri-potatochips/ Symbols and Graphics Characters support brand communication, promote product attributes, and become the embodiment of the brand’s personality. Symbols and Icons Simple graphic diagrams or elaborate layouts http://www.nytimes.com/2007/04/27/technology/27amazon.html?_r=1 Physical Structure and Shape For many products, the physical configuration embodies the brand’s visual identity. http://www.freedigitalphotos.net/image/s_cocacola1.jpg Properties of the ideal package • Sanitary • Easily printed or labeled • Non-toxic • Easily opened/closed • Transparent • • Light-weight • Tamper-proof • Easily disposable • Compatible with food • Protective against light • • • Impermeable to gases and odors Resistant to mechanical and thermal damage Compatible with highspeed filling machinery Environmentally friendly Packaging Strategy Consumers gravitate toward product and packaging innovation that is playful while also making the product easier to use. Packaging Strategy • Feature the unique attributes of the product (e.g., highly nutritious, great new taste) Packaging Strategy • Strengthen the aesthetic appeal and the value of the product (e.g., added benefits through packaging design) Packaging Strategy • Maintain uniformity within the brand’s family of product (e.g., do not want to make a very different product so that consumers do not recognize the brand) Packaging Strategy • Strengthen differentiation between product varieties and lines (e.g., new colors, new graphics). How to break through the visual clutter of the competition? Packaging Strategy • Use new materials and develop innovative structures to reduce costs, be more environmentally friendly, or increase functionality. http://blog.esko.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/05/Innovative-egg-carton-packaging.jpg The choice of the material and design must be based on: 1. 2. 3. 4. Food composition and its physical state (i.e., solid, liquid, powder). Knowledge of the various deteriorative reactions that might occur. Intended storage conditions (including the time of storage). Socioeconomic situation of the anticipated customer. Packaging Materials Activity What two basic materials are used for egg cartons? Plastic and styrofoam Recycled cardboard Let’s critique this design http://b.fastcompany.net/multisite_files/codesign/imagecache/slideshow_large/slide s/friss-biotojas-20.jpg FOOD PACKAGING TECHNOLOGY MODIFIED ATMOSPHERE PACKAGING Deliberately changes the atmosphere around the food product for the purpose of extending shelf life. http://www.thantawan.com/images/domes_Active%20breathable.jpg Current methods 1. Using vacuum to remove the normal atmosphere http://guelphmercury.blogs.com/fuel/2009/03/usingcarbon-monoxide-to-extend-shelf-life.html 2. Adding a defined gas mixture (the optimum composition of this mixture is highly dependent on the particular food product) Factors to consider when deciding to implement a MAP process for a product 1. 2. 3. The food itself The packaging material (structure and equipment) The gas mixture and the volume of gas required Selection of the gas or mixture of gases The keystone of the process There are three main gases used in MAP: Nitrogen, carbon dioxide and oxygen http://2.bp.blogspot.com/-XB6wPbI-hzE/T5Bee-feq4I/AAAAAAAAANw/v4Nt9mCRRo/s1600/Atmosfera_modificada.png Carbon dioxide It can be bacteriostatic and fungistatic Highly soluble in water and fats, so can cause package shrinkage Directly inhibits the growth of bacteria and mold. However, because it dissolves in products with high fat and water content, it may cause the package to shrink around the product, and may add an acidic taste. Nitrogen Mainly used to replace oxygen. An inert, odorless gas which is not soluble in water or fats, etc. Does not dissolve in water and fats, and thus does not inhibit the growth of microorganisms. It is, however, and excellent "filler" gas used to prevent the collapse of the package and provide mechanical protection for fragile products. It displaces oxygen, thereby preventing or delaying oxidative reactions, such as fat rancidity, in foods. Displacing oxygen also indirectly retards the growth of aerobic microorganisms, which thrive in oxygen. Oxygen Usually avoided, but required in some cases (e.g. to keep meat red, avoid anaerobes in seafood) Used a) b) in only a limited way. In fresh vegetables, oxygen permeable films are used to prevent the "suffocation" of the gases that vegetables produce naturally when respiring. In fresh fish, oxygen prevents the growth of anaerobic bacteria—some of the deadliest bacteria, such as Clostridium botulinum, grow without oxygen! Oxygen In some cases, oxygen is used to improve the appearance of foods; red meat would not be red without exposure to oxygen. Successful MAP http://www.soxal.com/image/photoelement/pj/map33242.gif http://www.chandraassociates.com/images/Slide3.JPG Aseptic packaging Aseptic = sterile Aseptic packaging = sterile packaging Aseptic package One which has been sterilized prior to filling with sterilized food Shelf stable product > 6 months at room temperature http://www.mediacrayon.com/wp-content/uploads/2011/07/purepak2.jpg General Aseptic processing layout HEPA filter maintains positive air pressure UHT Raw product Packaging materials Commercially sterilized product Product sterilization Package filling Pre-sterilized containers with hermetic seals Package manufacture Or Assembly Packaging sterilization Filled in an atmosphere free of microorganisms Package Hermetic sealing Aseptic cartons Made of three basic materials that together result in a very efficient, safe, and light-weight package Each material provides a specific function http://i01.i.aliimg.com/img/pb/778/429/370/370429778_194.jpg Aseptic cartons Paper (75%) – strength and stiffness Polyethylene (20%) – barrier to microorganisms, heat seal Aluminum foil (5%) – keeps air out, light, and off-flavors http://www.milkunleashed.com/images/aseptic-milk-packaging-layers.gif Tetra Pak (Canada) Aseptic cartons and recycling http://www.tetrapak.com/publishingimages/materials_aseptic_carton.jpg Question a) b) c) In terms of source reduction through minimal use of packaging materials, a typical single-serve aseptic package (“drink box”) is the best package because of its: 97%/3% packaging-to-product ratio (by weight) 97%/3% product-to-packaging ratio (by weight) 65%/35% product-to-packaging ratio (by weight) Question a) b) c) d) Design of a package for aseptic processing requires excellent oxygen barrier high moisture barrier high temperature resistance and low oxygen barrier use of aluminum foil (always) http://jhamjhamrunner.files.wordpress.com/2012/10/1.jpg Question a) b) c) d) Design of a package for aseptic processing requires excellent oxygen barrier high moisture barrier high temperature resistance and low oxygen barrier use of aluminum foil (always) http://jhamjhamrunner.files.wordpress.com/2012/10/1.jpg Microwavable packaging Has seen some leaner years but now it is increasing 58% of microwavable foods are frozen foods Package characteristics In most cases, the package should be of a microwave-transparent material. Transparent materials absorb the microwaves They do not heat up Paper has some moisture and it heats up – negligible Best – plastics (LDPE, HDPE, PP, PET) Less common - glass transparent reflective absorbent Geometry More uniform heating with rounded corners Oval or circular shapes reduce corner heating The more surface area openly exposed to microwave energy, the more evenly the product will heat. Optimal configuration: annulus or doughnut Microwavable packaging design For Exam What are the basic functions of packaging? Justify the choice of a package (and material) for a particular food product Advantages Aspects of microwavable package design Food ‘map’ Remember the lab activities Packaging of one material over the other Matrix MAP and aseptic packages Example As a packager of fresh meat, you must choose between the following two atmospheres for the inside of the package: (1) 60% oxygen + 20% carbon dioxide + 20% nitrogen, or (2) vacuum packaging. List one advantage and one disadvantage for each option. Answer (1) 60% oxygen + 20% carbon dioxide + 20% nitrogen 1. 2. 1. Advantages: The high oxygen atmosphere favors the formation of oxymyoglobin, which gives the nice red color to fresh meat. The presence of nitrogen helps prevent the collapse of the package Disadvantage: Interaction of oxygen with lipids may produce undesirable flavor changes due to oxidation 1. 2. (2) Vacuum packaging: Advantages: Prevents rancidity due to oxidation of lipids (lack of oxygen) Prevents the growth of aerobic microorganisms and extends shelf life of the meat Disadvantage: May induce growth of anaerobes such as C. botulinum and some pathogens (safety) Microwavable packaging design D = dp/1.5 for a frozen product D = 2-2.5 dp; cylindrical container Cooked peas dp = D= Microwavable packaging design D = dp/1.5 for a frozen product D = 2-2.5 dp; cylindrical container Ham dp = D=