Creeping Flows Steven A. Jones BIEN 501 Wednesday, March 21, 2007 Start on Slide 53 Louisiana Tech University Ruston, LA 71272 Slide 1 Creeping Flows Major Learning Objectives: 1. Compare viscous flows to nonviscous flows. 2. Derive the complete solution for creeping flow around a sphere (Stokes’ flow). 3. Relate the solution to the force on the sphere. Louisiana Tech University Ruston, LA 71272 Slide 2 Creeping Flows Minor Learning Objectives: 1. Examine qualitative inertial and viscous effects. 2. Show how symmetry simplifies the equations. 3. Show how creeping and nonviscous flows simplify the momentum equations. 4. Give the origin of the Reynolds number. 5. Use the Reynolds number to distinguish creeping and nonviscous flows. 6. Apply non-slip boundary conditions at a wall and incident flow boundary conditions at . Louisiana Tech University Ruston, LA 71272 Slide 3 Creeping Flows Minor Learning Objectives (continued): 7. Use the equations for conservation of mass and conservation of momentum in spherical coordinates. 8. Use the stream function to satisfy continuity. 9. Eliminate the pressure term from the momentum equations by (a) taking the curl and (b) using a sort of Gaussian elimination. 10. Rewrite the momentum equations in terms of the stream function. 11. Rewrite the boundary conditions in terms of the stream function. 12. Deduce information about the form of the solution from the boundary conditions. Louisiana Tech University Ruston, LA 71272 Slide 4 Important Concepts • • • • • Flow Rate Cross-sectional average velocity Shear Stress (wall shear stress) Force caused by shear stress (drag) Pressure loss Louisiana Tech University Ruston, LA 71272 Slide 5 Creeping Flows Minor Learning Objectives (continued): 13. Discuss the relationship between boundary conditions and the assumption of separability. 14. Reduce the partial differential equation to an ordinary differential equation, based on the assumed shape of the solution. 15. Recognize and solve the equidimensional equation. 16. Translate the solution for the stream function into the solution for the velocity components.. 17. Obtain the pressure from the velocity components. 18. Obtain the drag on the sphere from the stress components (viscous and pressure). Louisiana Tech University Ruston, LA 71272 Slide 6 Creeping vs. Nonviscous Flows Creeping Flows Nonviscous Flows Viscosity goes to (Low Reynolds Number) Viscosity goes to zero (High Reynolds Number) Left hand side of the momentum equation is not important. Left hand side of the momentum equation is important. Left hand side of the momentum equation is zero. Right hand side of the momentum equation includes pressure only. Friction is more important than inertia. Inertia is more important than friction. Louisiana Tech University Ruston, LA 71272 Slide 7 Creeping vs. Nonviscous Flows Creeping Flow Solutions Nonviscous Flow Solutions Use the partial differential equations. Apply transform, similarity, or separation of variables solution. Use flow potential, complex numbers. Use no-slip condition. Use “no normal velocity.” Use stream functions for conservation of mass. Use velocity potential for conservation of mass. In both cases, we will assume incompressible flow. Louisiana Tech University Ruston, LA 71272 Slide 8 Flow around a Sphere Creeping Flow Nonviscous Flow Velocity Larger velocity near the sphere is an inertial effect. Louisiana Tech University Ruston, LA 71272 Slide 9 Flow around a Sphere A more general case Incident velocity is approached far from the sphere. Increased velocity as a result of inertia terms. Shear region near the sphere caused by viscosity and no-slip. Louisiana Tech University Ruston, LA 71272 Slide 10 Stokes Flow: The Geometry Use Standard Spherical Coordinates, (r, , and f) r v v e 3 f Far from the sphere (large r) the velocity is uniform in the rightward direction. e3 is the Cartesian (rectangular) unit vector. It does not correspond to the spherical unit vectors. Louisiana Tech University Ruston, LA 71272 Slide 11 The Objective 1. Obtain the velocity field around the sphere. 2. Use this velocity field to determine pressure and drag at the sphere surface. 3. From the pressure and drag, determine the force on the sphere as a function of the sphere’s velocity, or equivalently the sphere’s velocity as a function of the applied force (e.g. gravity, centrifuge, electric field). Louisiana Tech University Ruston, LA 71272 Slide 12 Some Applications 1. What electric field is required to move a charged particle in electrophoresis? 2. What g force is required to centrifuge cells in a given amount of time. 3. What is the effect of gravity on the movement of a monocyte in blood? 4. How does sedimentation vary with the size of the sediment particles? 5. How rapidly do enzyme-coated beads move in a bioreactor? Louisiana Tech University Ruston, LA 71272 Slide 13 Symmetry of the Geometry r f The flow will be symmetric with respect to f. Louisiana Tech University Ruston, LA 71272 Slide 14 Components of the Incident Flow Component of incident velocity in the radial direction, v cos r f Incident Velocity v v e 3 Component of incident velocity in the - direction, v sin Louisiana Tech University Ruston, LA 71272 Slide 15 Creeping Momentum Equation To see how creeping flow simplifies the momentum equation, begin with the equation in the following form (Assume a Newtonian fluid): v r rv v P 2 m D t For small v, 2nd term on the left is small. It is on the order of v2. (v appears in the right hand term, but only as a first power). v r P 2 m D t Louisiana Tech University Ruston, LA 71272 Slide 17 Convective Term in Spherical Coordinates Louisiana Tech University Ruston, LA 71272 Slide 18 Reynolds Number The Reynolds number describes the relative importance of the inertial terms to the viscous terms and can be deduced from a simple dimensional argument. rv v goes like rV 2 L , where V is a characteri stic velocity and L is a characteri stic length. m D goes like mV 2 L . (It may rV 2 mV 2v 2 , help to think of a typical term m 2 ). The ratio is x L L rVL or . It is this ratio, rather than m or velocity alone, that m determines which terms are dominant. Louisiana Tech University Ruston, LA 71272 Slide 19 Reynolds Number Different notations are used to express the Reynolds number. The most typical of these are Re or Nr. Also, viscosity may be expressed as kinematic ( ) or dynamic (m) viscosity, so the Reynolds number may be rVL Re or Re m VL In the case of creeping flow around a sphere, we use v for the characteristic velocity, and we use the sphere diameter as the characteristic length scale. Thus, ru D Re m Louisiana Tech University Ruston, LA 71272 Slide 20 Boundary Conditions (B.C.s) for Creeping Flow around a Sphere v 0 for r R v v e 3 for r There is symmetry about the f axis. Thus (a) nothing depends on f, and (b) there is no f velocity. Louisiana Tech University Ruston, LA 71272 v r v r r , v v r , vf 0 Slide 22 Summary of Equations to be Solved We must solve conservation of mass and conservation of momentum, subject to the specified boundary conditions. Conservation of mass in spherical coordinates is: v 0 Which takes the following form in spherical coordinates (Table 3.1): 1 1 1 2 rvf 0 r r v r v sin r r 2 r r sin r sin f Or 1 1 2 r r v r v sin 0 When v 0 & 0 r f r 2 r r sin f Louisiana Tech University Ruston, LA 71272 Slide 23 Summary of Equations (Momentum) Because there is symmetry in f, we only worry about the radial and circumferential components of momentum. P τ 0 (Incompressible, Newtonian Fluid) Which takes the following form in spherical coordinates (Table 3.4): Radial Azimuthal Where H Louisiana Tech University Ruston, LA 71272 p 2 2 v 2 m Hvr 2 vr 2 2 v cot 0 r r r r v 1 p v m Hv r 2 2 0 r r sin 1 2 1 r sin r 2 r r r sin Slide 24 Simplified Differential Equations Yikes! You mean we need to solve these three partial differential equations!!? Conservation of Mass 1 1 2 r r v r v sin 0 r 2 r r r sin Conservation of Radial Momentum 1 v vr 2 p 1 2 v 2 m 2 r2 r sin v v cot 0 2 r 2 2 r r r r r sin r r r Conservation of Azimuthal Momentum 1 v v vr v 1 p 1 m 2 r2 sin r r 2 sin 2 r r r r sin Louisiana Tech University Ruston, LA 71272 0 Slide 25 Comments 1 1 2 r r v r v sin 0 r 2 r r r sin 1 v p m 2 r2 r r r r r vr 1 sin r sin 2 v 2 2 v v cot 0 2 r 2 2 r r r 1 v v vr v 1 p 1 m 2 r2 sin r r 2 sin 2 r r r r sin 0 Three equations, one first order, two second order. Three unknowns ( vr , v and P ). Two independent variables ( r and ). Equations are linear (there is a solution). Louisiana Tech University Ruston, LA 71272 Slide 26 Stream Function Approach We will use a stream function approach to solve these equations. The stream function is a differential form that automatically solves the conservation of mass equation and reduces the problem from one with 3 variables to one with two variables. Louisiana Tech University Ruston, LA 71272 Slide 27 Stream Function (Cartesian) Cartesian coordinates, the two-dimensional continuity equation is: u v 0 x y If we define a stream function, y, such that: u y x, y y , v y x, y x 0 Then the two-dimensional continuity equation becomes: u v y x y x y Louisiana Tech University Ruston, LA 71272 y y y 2y 2y 0 xy yx Slide 28 Summary of the Procedure 1. Use a stream function to satisfy conservation of mass. a. Form of y is known for spherical coordinates. b. Gives 2 equations (r and momentum) and 2 unknowns (y and pressure). c. Need to write B.C.s in terms of the stream function. 2. Obtain the momentum equation in terms of velocity. 3. Rewrite the momentum equation in terms of y. 4. Eliminate pressure from the two equations (gives 1 equation (momentum) and 1 unknown, namely y). 5. Use B.C.s to deduce a form for y (equivalently, assume a separable solution). Louisiana Tech University Ruston, LA 71272 Slide 29 Procedure (Continued) 6. Substitute the assumed form for y back into the momentum equation to obtain an ordinary differential equation. 7. Solve the equation for the radial dependence of y. 8. Insert the radial dependence back into the form for y to obtain the complete expression for y. 9. Use the definition of the stream function to obtain the radial and tangential velocity components from y. 10. Use the radial and tangential velocity components in the momentum equation (written in terms of velocities, not in terms of y) to obtain pressure. Louisiana Tech University Ruston, LA 71272 Slide 30 Procedure (Continued) 11. Integrate the e3 component of both types of forces (pressure and viscous stresses) over the surface of the sphere to obtain the drag force on the sphere. Louisiana Tech University Ruston, LA 71272 Slide 31 Stream Function Recall the following form for conservation of mass: 1 1 2 rv sin 0 r r v r 2 r r r sin Slide 22 If we define a function y(r,) as: 1 y 1 y vr 2 , v r sin r sin r then the equation of continuity is automatically satisfied. We have combined 2 unknowns into 1 and eliminated 1 equation. Note that other forms work for rectangular and cylindrical coordinates. Louisiana Tech University Ruston, LA 71272 Slide 32 Exercise With: 1 1 2 rv sin 0 r r v r 2 r r r sin 1 y 1 y vr 2 , v r sin r sin r Rewrite the first term in terms of y. Louisiana Tech University Ruston, LA 71272 Slide 33 Exercise With: 1 1 2 rv sin 0 r r v r 2 r r r sin 1 y 1 y vr 2 , v r sin r sin r Rewrite the second term in terms of y. Louisiana Tech University Ruston, LA 71272 Slide 34 Momentum Eq. in Terms of y 1 y 1 y , v Use v r 2 r sin r sin r and conservation of mass is satisfied (procedure step 1). Substitute these expressions into the steady flow momentum equation (Slide 23) to obtain a partial differential equation for y from the momentum equation (procedure step 2): 2 sin 1 r 2 r 2 sin y 0 2 Louisiana Tech University Ruston, LA 71272 Slide 35 Elimination of Pressure The final equation on the last slide required several steps. The first was the elimination of pressure in the momentum equations. The second was substitution of the form for the stream function into the result. The details will not be shown here, but we will show how pressure can be eliminated from the momentum equations. We have: p m v 0 We take the curl of this equation to obtain: p m v Louisiana Tech University Ruston, LA 71272 Slide 36 Elimination of Pressure But it is known that the curl of the gradient of any scalar field is zero (Exercise A.9.1-1). In rectangular coordinates: e1 p x1 p x1 e2 x2 p x2 e3 x3 p x3 2 p 2 p 2 p 2 p 2 p 2 p e1 e 2 e3 0 x1x2 x2 x1 x2 x3 x3x2 x1x3 x3x1 Louisiana Tech University Ruston, LA 71272 Slide 37 Elimination of Pressure Alternatively: v ijk vk ei x j p p p e k , p k xk xk p p ijk xk So, for example, the e1 component is: 1 jk x j x j p xk e1 123 x2 x2 Louisiana Tech University Ruston, LA 71272 e i p 132 x3 x3 p x3 x3 p e1 x2 p e1 0 x2 Slide 38 Exercise: Elimination of Pressure One can think of the elimination of pressure as being equivalent to doing a Gaussian elimination type of operation on the pressure term. This view can be easily illustrated in rectangular coordinates: 2 vx 2 vx p 0 m 2 2 x momentum x y x 2vy 2vy p 0 m 2 2 y momentum x y y Take of the first equation and of the second and subtract. y x Louisiana Tech University Ruston, LA 71272 Slide 39 Elimination of Pressure This view can be easily illustrated in rectangular coordinates: 3v x 3v x 2 p 0 m 3 x momentum 2 yx y yx 3v y 3v y 2 p y momentum 0 m 3 2 x xy x y 3v y 3v y 3v x 3v x 0 m 3 m 3 2 2 y xy yx x 3v x 3v x 3v y 3v y i.e., 3 3 2 2 y yx xy x Louisiana Tech University Ruston, LA 71272 0 E2 Slide 40 Exercise: 4th order equation With: vx y x, y y , vy y x, y x 0 What is the momentum equation: 3vx 3vx 3v y 3v y 3 3 2 2 yx xy x y 0 in terms of y? Louisiana Tech University Ruston, LA 71272 Slide 41 Exercise: 4th order equation Answer: 4y 4y 4y 4y 4 2 2 2 2 4 y x x y x y 0 or 2 2 2 y 0 x y 2 Louisiana Tech University Ruston, LA 71272 2 Slide 42 Elimination of Pressure Fortunately, the book has already done all of this work for us, and has provided the momentum equation in terms of the stream function in spherical coordinates (Table 2.4.2-1). For vf=0: 2 1 y , E 2y 2 E 2y E y 2 2 t r sin r, r sin 1 y y cos sin E 4y r r Admittedly this still looks nasty. However, when we remember that we have already eliminated all of the left-hand terms, the result for the stream function is relatively simple. Louisiana Tech University Ruston, LA 71272 Slide 43 Momentum in terms of y If: 2 1 y , E 2y 2 E 2y y 1 y 4 E y 2 2 cos sin E y t r sin r, r sin r r How does this simplify for our problem? Recall: Steady state Low Reynolds number Louisiana Tech University Ruston, LA 71272 Slide 44 Stream Function, Creeping Flow When the unsteady (left-hand side) terms are eliminated: sin 1 2 . 2 r sin r E 4y 0, where E 2 2 sin 1 Thus 2 2 y 0. r sin r This equation was given on slide 35. Louisiana Tech University Ruston, LA 71272 Slide 45 Boundary Conditions in Terms of y From v 0 at r R, vr 0 at r R and 1 y v r sin r 1 y vr 2 r sin Exercise: Write these boundary conditions in terms of y. Louisiana Tech University Ruston, LA 71272 Slide 46 Boundary Conditions in Terms of y From 1 y 1 y v 0 at r R v 0 at r R, r 2 r sin r sin r y y and must be zero for all at r=R. Thus, y r must be constant along the curve r=R. But since it’s constant of integration is arbitrary, we can take it to be zero at that boundary. I.e. y 0 at r R Louisiana Tech University Ruston, LA 71272 Slide 47 Question Consider the following curves. Along which of these curves must velocity change with position? Louisiana Tech University Ruston, LA 71272 Slide 48 Comment A key to understanding the previous result is that we are talking about the surface of the sphere, where r is fixed. 1 y y Because vr 0, 2 0. And so because 0 r sin for all , y must be constant along that curve. y does not change as changes. Louisiana Tech University Ruston, LA 71272 As r changes, however, we move off of the curve r=R, so y can change. Slide 49 Boundary Conditions in Terms of y 1 y y 2 , v r r sin From v r 2 r sin At r , vr v cos e 3 Thus, as r , (See Slide 14) y v cos r 2 sin e 3 v r 2 cos sin e 3 Thus, in contrast to the surface of the sphere, y will change with far from the sphere. Louisiana Tech University Ruston, LA 71272 Slide 50 Boundary Conditions in Terms of y 1 y y 2 , v r r sin From v r 2 r sin y r 0 y 2 2 d v r r sin d r v cos sin d 0 0 1 2 r v sin 2 g r 2 which suggests the -dependence of the solution. y f r v sin 2 Louisiana Tech University Ruston, LA 71272 Slide 51 Comment on Separability For a separable solution we assume that the functional form of y is the product of one factor that depends only on r and another that depends only on . y r, R r Whenever the boundary conditions can be written in this form, it will be possible to find a solution that can be written in this form. Since the equations are linear, the solution will be unique. Therefore, the final solution must be written in this form. Louisiana Tech University Ruston, LA 71272 Slide 52 Comment on Separability In our case, the boundary condition at r=R is: y R, R R 0 and the boundary condition at r is: 1 2 y , v r 2 sin 2 Both of these forms can be written as a function of r multiplied by a function of . (For r=R we take R(r)=0). The conclusion that the dependence like sin2 is reached because these two boundary conditions must hold for all . A similar statement about the r-dependence cannot be reached. I.e. we only know about two distinct r locations. Louisiana Tech University Ruston, LA 71272 Slide 53 Separability Again, at r=R: y R, R R 0 and at r : y , v r 2 sin 2 1 2 For a separable solution, we look for a form: y R, R R Because the -dependence holds for all , but the rdependence does not, we must write: y r , Louisiana Tech University Ruston, LA 71272 1 f r v r 2 sin 2 2 Slide 54 Momentum Equation The momentum equation: 0 P 2 m D is 2 equations with 3 unknowns (P, vr and v). We have used the stream function to get 2 equations and 2 unknowns (P and y). We then used these two equations to eliminate P. Louisiana Tech University Ruston, LA 71272 Slide 55 Substitute Back into Momentum With y f r v sin 2 2 sin 1 r 2 r 2 sin y 0 2 4 (slide 45) becomes: 2 d f 4 d f 8 df 8 f 2 3 4 0 4 2 dr r dr r dr r Note the use of total derivatives. Louisiana Tech University Ruston, LA 71272 Slide 56 Exercise: Substitute y f r v sin 2 into 2 sin 1 2 sin 1 2 2 2 2 y 0 r sin r r sin r Louisiana Tech University Ruston, LA 71272 Slide 57 Exercise: Substitute 2 sin 1 2 f r v sin 2 2 r sin r 2 2 f r sin 1 sin 2 v sin f r 2 2 r r sin 2 2 f r sin 2sin cos v sin f r 2 2 r r sin 2 2 f r sin cos v sin 2 f r 2 2 r r 2 2 f r sin 2 v sin 2 2 f r 2 r r Louisiana Tech University Ruston, LA 71272 Slide 58 Exercise: So we now need 2 sin 1 2 2 f r sin 2 v 2 2 2 2 f r sin 2 r r sin r r 4 2 2 2 f r f r f r 2sin 2sin sin 1 2 2 v sin 2 f r sin 4 2 2 2 4 r r r r sin r r 4 2 2 f r f r f r 2 cos sin 2sin cos 2 v sin 2sin 2 f r 4 2 2 r r r sin r sin 2 4 f r 2 f r sin 2 f r cos 2 v sin 2sin 2 2sin 2 f r 1 4 2 2 2 r r r r sin Louisiana Tech University Ruston, LA 71272 Slide 59 Substitute Back into Momentum The student should recognize the differential equation as an equidimensional equation for which: 4 2 d f df 2 d f r 4r 8r 8f 0 4 2 dr dr dr 4 f r ar n Substitution of this form back into the equation yields: A f r Br Cr 2 Dr 4 with r 1 3 1 A v R 3 , B v R, C v , D 0 4 4 2 Louisiana Tech University Ruston, LA 71272 Slide 60 Equidimensional Equation The details are like this: 2 n d 4 ar n dar n 2 d ar n r 4 r 8 r 8 ar 0 4 2 dr dr dr r 4 n n 1n 2 n 3ar n 4 4r 2 n n 1ar n 2 8r n ar n 1 8ar n 4 divide by ar n n n 1n 2n 3 4n n 1 8n 8 0 This is a 4th order polynomial, i.e. there are 4 possible values for n which happen to turn out to be -1, 1, 2 and 4. Louisiana Tech University Ruston, LA 71272 Slide 61 Solution for Velocity Components Once the boundary conditions are evaluated, the solution is: 3 vr 3 R 1R 1 cos v 2 r 2 r 3 v 3 R 1R 1 sin v 4 r 4 r Louisiana Tech University Ruston, LA 71272 Slide 62 Pressure To obtain pressure, we return to the momentum equation: P 2 m D This form was 2 equations with 3 unknowns, but now vr and v have been determined. Once the forms for these two velocity components are substituted into this equation, one obtains: P cos 3mv R 3 r r P 3 sin mv R 2 2 r Integrate to get P. Louisiana Tech University Ruston, LA 71272 Slide 63 Pressure The result of this exercise is: 3 cos P P0 rgr cos mv R 2 2 r Louisiana Tech University Ruston, LA 71272 Slide 64 Force To obtain force on the sphere, we must remember that force is caused by both the pressure and the viscous stress. F3 R 2 2 T 0 0 rr cos Tr sin r R sin d df Used to get the z3 component. z3 is the direction the sphere is moving relative to the fluid. Louisiana Tech University Ruston, LA 71272 Slide 65 Potential Flow Potential flow derives from the viscous part of the momentum equation. m v 0 If we write: v f Then the viscous part of the momentum equation will automatically be zero. Louisiana Tech University Ruston, LA 71272 Slide 66 Potential Flow The continuity equation: v 0 Becomes: f 2f 0 Therefore potential flow reduces to finding solutions to Laplace’s equation. Louisiana Tech University Ruston, LA 71272 Slide 67