Chiral Sulfoxides: A Whirlwind Tour Literature Presentation Scott Jarvis April 27th, 2010 Characteristics of Sulfoxides Sulfoxides have high optical stability, in general the racemization of sulfoxides only occurs at an appreciable rate at 200oC except Benzyl and allyl sulfoxides whose racemization occurs at lower temperatures, 130150oC and 50-70oC respectively. Sulfoxides are accessible in both enantiomeric forms The large stereoelectronic differences between the three types of substituents (oxygen, electron lone pair, and two alkyl or aryl groups) at the sulfinyl sulfur allow the creation of a well defined chiral environment around the sulfur atom, therefore they are efficient as carriers of chiral information O S Methods to Prepare Chiral Sulfoxides Oxidative methods ◦ ◦ ◦ ◦ ◦ Nucleophilic substitution methods ◦ ◦ ◦ ◦ ◦ Diastereoselective Modified sharpless oxidation Salen oxidation Chiral oxaziridines Chiral epoxides Andersen Methodology (menthol) Aminosulfites (ephedrine, aminoindane) Sulfites (lactate derivative, sugars) Evans auxillary Oppolzer’s Sulfinylsultam Combination ◦ Thiosulfinate approach(tert-Butyl-SO-R) Diastereoselective Oxidation The oxidation of sulfur can be directed by a coordinating atom such as N or O or straight steric bulk NMe 2 O O NMe 2 AcOH S H N NaBO 3 78% de S O H N H2O2 H S O DCM N O O S 90%, 100% de N O O OH O Br F H O Br F H S DMD N DCM O Synthesis, 1992, 555 Tet. Lett., 1993, 7877 H O OH OH O S Quant., 100% de N O O OH Diastereoselective Oxidation R R R O O : S R' : R O O R O O R O O R R O O : R' S Chirality of sulfoxide comes from the anomeric effect O up to 100% de chirality independant of reagent (NaIO4, MCPBA, Oxone all give same compound) Chem. Comm., 1998. 2763 Modified Sharpless Oxidation Mostly relies on steric bulk to gain the selectivity R1 O R O O O H O Ti O O O O RL S : [Ti] RS Bull. Soc. Chim. Fr., 1996, 1109 Synlett, 1996, 404 (Kagan) R2 Yield (%) Phenyl p-Tolyl p-anisyl o-anisyl o-nitrophenyl Me Me Me Me Me 81 77 73 72 51 ee (%) (R) 91.2 95.6 92.1 89.3 75.0 Phenyl p-Tolyl p-Tolyl o-anisyl benzyl n-octyl CH=CH2 Et n-butyl phenyl Me Me 58 68 70 64 72 69 55.4 78.1 25.0 6.2 90.3 70.7 Modified Sharpless Oxidation Other diols have been used in place of DET OH OH OH OH OH OH OH OH OH OH Uemura’s Binol Version Ar Solvent Method Yield (%) ee (%) (R) p-tolyl CCl4 A 65 84 p-tolyl CCl4 B 67 93 p-tolyl CCl4 Ba 64 88 p-tolyl CCl4 C 44 96 p-tolyl p-tolyl p-tolyl p-tolyl p-tolyl p-tolyl p-tolyl p-tolyl CHCl3 DCM DCE Toluene o-xylene cumene THF Diethyl ether A A A A A A A A 74 84 86 66 88 86 46 32 23 16 25 72 61 57 72 57 Ph Ph CCl4 Toluene A A 80 86 65 63 2-Napthyl CCl4 A 73 51 p-BrC6H4 CCl4 A 62 68 n-octyl CCl4 B 64 69 JOC, 1993, 4529 O Ar S Me Ar Method A: under Ar peroxide in toluene Method B: under Air, peroxide in water Method C: Half as much catalyst Note a: under Argon S Me Modified Sharpless Oxidation H-Bonding under specific conditions can also give good selectivity (but very sensitive). O N O Ti(OiPr)4/(S,S)-DET/H2O O O S N N S N H iPr2NEt Cumene Peroxide N N H NH is directing Tet. Asymm., 2000, 3819 O 92% yield (94% ee) Salen Oxidation Typically thought of for chiral epoxidation of olefins but with modifications they are useful for sulfide oxidations. R Cat R N Cl N Fe O O Ph Ph Catalyst JACS, 2007, 8940. S Cat (2 mol%) aq H 2O2 (1.5) O S O O S H 2O, 3h, 20o C ee of Yield Yield sulfoxide (sulfoxide) (sulfone) (%) none 4 0 1 30 2 2 25 3 4 R1 p-MePh R2 ee of Yield Yield sulfoxide (sulfoxide) (Sulfone) (S) (%) Me 91 9 96 10 ( R ) p-MeOPh Me 92 8 95 2 10 ( S ) p-ClPh Me 76 24 94 89 5 88 ( S ) o-ClPh Me 97 <1 96 92 8 96 ( S ) o-MeOPh Me 99 <1 95 Ph Et 78 22 81 1 (R, R): R = H PhCH2 Me 93 7 87 2 (R, R): R = Me n-C8H17 Me 82 18 89 3 (R, S): R = H n-C12H25 Me 82 18 94 4 (R, S): R = Me c-C6H11 91 9 88 Me Other Metal Catalyzed Oxidations X OH N 1: X = NO 2 2: X = t-Bu HO VO(acac)2 1 mol % 1 1.5 mol % H2O2 R S R' R R R' R R' O S VO(acac) 2/2 S H2O2 (30%) R' Yield ee (%) Ph Me 94 70 Ph iPr 64 62 Ph N-C10H21 77 53 p-NO2Ph Me 55 63 t-Bu Bn 91 65 ACIE, 1995, 2640 Synlett, 1998, 1327 S R R' R R' Yield Ph p-Tolyl p-Cl-Ph H H H 84 79 87 p-MeO-Ph o-Br-Ph o-NO2-Ph t-Bu H H H H 60 81 75 67 44 (cis) Ph Me S S O ee (%) (cis) 85 77 64 57 64 62 46 68 12 37 (trans) (trans) Chiral Oxaziridine Oxidations L O N O S O O O Tet., 1988, 5703 JACS, 1989, 5964 JACS, 1988, 8477 JOC, 1992, 7274 Tet. Asymm., 1992, 629. R RT Cl Cl N S O O2 Cl Cl N S O2 S N O SO2 ($50/g) O Oxaziridine L S R Large R Yield (%) ee (%) p-Tolyl H 95 >95 p-Tolyl Ph 74 88 2-Napthyl H 84 94 t-Butyl H 84 94 t-Butyl Ph 80 94 n-octyl H 60 45 Cl Cl N O Top view SO2 Looking down the pocket between Ph and camphor Cl Cl N O Top view SO2 Looking down the pocket between Ph and camphor Chiral Peroxides H OBn HO O Bn O O OH O S S 25% ee -20oC S Ti(OiPr) 4 Peroxide O S O O S -20oC O Peroxide = Yield Tet., 1997, 185 JOC, 1998, 3423 79% (20% ee) 21% 16% (75% ee) 84% OH Summary of Oxidative Methods In general the oxidative methods require a large steric difference between the two sulfide substituents (ie: Ph vs Me) H-bonding can give selectivity despite a lack of large steric differences in some cases, though conditions are sensitive and difficult to optimize The oxaziridine oxidation works if the ‘small’ substituent is a methylene (or equally small such as vinyl) and the ‘large’ is phenyl or tert-butyl If the molecule is already chiral, diastereoselective oxidation can occur which depending on which isomer is desired could be an aid or a detriment Andersen’s Nucleophilic Method Oldest method, other secondary carbinols have been used also Limited to Di-aryl or aryl/alkyl sulfoxides. For the synthesis of dialkyl sulfoxides, the required menthyl alkanesulfinate esters cannot be prepared enantiomerically pure at sulfur (they cannot be crystallized, since they’re oils). Ar O S Cl O O OH S O Ar O S Ar Major Menthol Separated by crystallization, cannot by column O O Tet. Lett., 1962, 93 JACS, 1992, 5977 JOC, 1984, 4070 S O RM Ar R S "High ee's" Ar Aminosulfite Pioneered by Wudl and Lee using ephedrine as a chiral auxillary (1973), modified by Snyder and Benson (AlMe3, prevents racemisation). O HO NHMe O S 1.2 equiv SOCl2, Et3N O S NMe O NMe 9:1 DCM, 0oC, 24h Ephedrine 1) Crystallize (70% yield) 2) RM, Toluene -40oC (50-94% yield) O R S R'MgX R' >99% ee JACS, 1973, 6349 Tet. Lett., 1991, 5885 RT 5h Al O O N S R O AlMe3 DCM RT 30min HO N S R Kagan’s Sulfite Suitable for dialkyl, alkyl aryl, and diaryl sulfoxides giving enantiopure sulfoxides however tedious purifications (auxiliary derived from lactate). H HO Ph Ph SOCl2/Et 3N H -40oC DCM OH O Ph Ph S O H 9:1 O O H O S O Ph Ph Ph Ph S O O R 2M OH O R1 S R2 R "100% ee" H O Ph Ph S R1M O O H Ph Ph HO R JOC, 1991, 5991 (Kagan) O S O R2M R1 O S R2 "100% ee" Evan’s Auxiliary It was found that EWG’s on the N facilitate N-S cleavage, so Evan’s auxiliary was a logical step. Nucleophilic displacement occurs with inversion of configuration at the sulfur, and N-Sulfinyloxazolidinones are at least 2 orders of magnitude more reactive than Anderson’s menthyl sulfinate. O HN O O n-BuLi Ar ArSOCl Bn O O S N O Ar Major O LiN O R Bn S N Bn R = Me, tBu, Ph JACS, 1992, 5977 O O mCPBA O S N O Bn Bn O R S S Ph O Minor O R O O S N Bn Minor O R O S N O Bn Major Evan’s Auxiliary R1 O R1 O S N O Bn -78oC THF R1 S R2 p-Tol p-Tol p-Tol p-Tol p-Tol Ph t-Bu Bn n-octyl Me n-Bu O R2MgX R2 O R Me Et i-Pr t-Bu Bn Me Me Me Me t-Bu t-Bu O S N 1 Yield (%) 90 90 91 88 86 87 78 82 78 92 91 ee (%) 99 98 97 97 99 90 93 91 100 100 100 ROLi, ROH O o -78 C R1 O S OR Bn Et 2NMgBr JACS, 1992, 5977 o -78 C R1 O S NEt2 Oppolzer’s Sulfinylsultam Yields: 83-97%, ee’s 96 to >99% but only p-tolyl used for sulfinylsultam R The Sultam can be recovered and reused (recovered yields >90%) R = Alkyl, Bn, vinyl, allyl, alkyne, heteroaryl O DMAP, p-TolSOCl N NH S O2 Tet. Lett., 1997, 2825. rt S O2 S RM Ar R O S Ar Combination Approach to Chiral Sulfoxides LG's R O S R'MgX LG R O S X X X = OCH3 Br Cl X R' O P O O R R S O O P O Ti(OiPr)4 R-BINOL Water TBHP O S R O O P O R = Me >98% ee = Et 91% ee = Ph 94% ee R'MgX R O S Me Me R1 n-octyl n-decyl Me Me Me Me Et Et Ph Ph n-octadecyl cyclohexyl t-Bu (E)-2-styril n-octyl p-tolyl methyl p-tolyl Yield (%) ee (%) 54 46 >98% >98% 49 50 15 43 40 36 60 42 >98% 9 >98% >98% R' 91 94 94 Summary of Nucleophilic Methods All nucleophilic methods use chiral auxiliaries that are available enantiopure and cheap. Diaryl sulfoxides can be made using: Anderson method, Kagan’s sulfite method, or Oppolzer’s method Aryl/alkyl sulfoxides can be made using any of the methods Di-alkyl sulfoxides or alkyl aryl sulfoxides can be made enantiopure using Evan’s auxillary, Snyder/Lee’s method, the ephedrine method or Kagan’s sulfite Of all the methods, Kagan’s method is the most versatile but least used since it is so tedious for the crystallizations. Evan’s auxiliary method is easy, and versatile giving aryl/alkyl and alkyl/alkyl sulfoxides. Uses of sulfoxides Drug candidates/Natural product synthesis Ligands in Catalysis ◦ Hydrogenation ◦ Cyclo-additions (DA) ◦ C-C bond formation (Enone addition) Chiral Auxillaries (Main use) Chiral reagents ◦ NADH analog Sulfoxides in Drugs Sulfoxides have a reputation for being potentially metabolically unstable - and they can go either way, being oxidized up to sulfones or reduced back to the parent sulfide. Sulfoxides have a strange character for drugs, because that oxygen atom is about as close to a naked O-minus as you're going to find in physiological conditions. The tetrahedral geometry of the sulfur means that this electronegative group is held is a very specific orientation relative to the other parts of your molecule (usually positive for binding to a target). Also, of course they're chiral. That can either be a bug or a feature, depending on your project and on your view of the world Examples of Drugs and Natural Products HO O S O O NH2 O N O S N H Armodafinil (analeptic, stimulant) H H H N Esomeprazole (Proton pump inhibitor ulcers/acid reflux) OH Fulvestrant (Estrogen hormone treatment) O H O OH O O Podolactone D S O S O CH3 CF3 F F Sulfoxides as Ligands for Metals Generally metals bind through the oxygen of the sulfoxide, however the soft metals of the Pt group (Ru, Rh, Os, Ir) can also bind through the sulfur depending on the other ligands of the metal. According to the model of Davies sulfoxide coordination through O induces a decrease in the S=O bond order while the opposite occurs for coordination through S. Therefore, the bond length of the S-O lengthens for oxygen coordinated complexes and decreases for sulfur coordinated complexes. The difference in bond length can be observed by IR (thus one can determine the mode of bonding), with the typical IR frequencies for SO being 1080-1150 for DMSO-S and 890-95- for DMSO-O. The binding mode also affects the 1H NMR, with coordination through O induces small downfield shifts (max 0.5ppm) and coordination through S induces larger downfield shifts (0.5-1.1ppm). Chem. Rev., 2004, 4203 Catalytic Hydrogenation First work was by James and coworkers in 1976 using (+)-methyl p-tolyl sulfoxide with disappointing results. Followed up by McMillan in 1977 using a diastereomic mixture of sulfoxides which gave low ee’s. McMillan's Ligands HO H S O O H S O O HO OH O HO H O S O bdios J. Mol. Catal., 1976, 439 Can. J. Chem., 1977, 3927 H S ddios O O Ligand HO H2 (40 PSI), 55oC (49%yield) OH O (25.2% ee) Catalytic Hydrogenation Ligand Preparation S O S OH OH A OH B NH2 H2O2 NH2 S O S-Bn-Cysteinol O OH Temp (oC) Ir, Ligand B R JOC, 2000, 3010 HCO2H R 60 40 20 NH2 Conversion ee (%) (%) 99 38 57 65 67 80 O OH Ir, Ligand B R HCO2H R at 60oC OH OH OH Cl 82% 73% ee 99% 65% ee JOC, 2000, 3010 O 99% 52% ee OH 99% 79% ee OH OH 99% 70% ee 95% 65% ee OH 98% 55% ee Chiral Lewis Acid Catalyst for Diels-Alder Though not sulfoxides, the bis(sulfinyl)imidoamidine shown below gave moderate to excellent diastereoselectivity and enantioselectivity. O + n R O N Cu(SbF6)2 Ligand n R 65-96% yield 32-98% ee 94-98% de O O DCM -78oC O N O R = H, CH3, Ph, CO2Et, Acrolein O S N N N O S Ligand prepared in 3 steps JACS, 2001, 1539 Chiral Lewis Acid for Hetero-D.A. O O O 5 mol % Ligand 5 mol % Cu(TfO)2 MS 4A DCM RT H O CO2Et 81% yield 98% ee 99:1 endo:exo Ligand O S N JACS, 2001, 3830 O N S Diethylzinc Addition to Benzaldehyde O Ligand OH Et2Zn Toluene 0oC Ligands HO O S 35% ee Tet. Asymm., 1993, 727 JOC, 2002, 1346 HO O S 45% ee Fe S O NH O S O 80% ee Enone Addition [Rh(C2H4)2Cl] 2 Ligand O O PhB(OH)2 40oC Ph Ligands S S O O 99% yield 98% ee (R) JACS, 2010, 4552 JACS, 2008, 2172 ACIE, 2009, 2768 S S S O O 98% yield >99% ee (S) S O O 96% yield 98% ee (R) Ligand Preparation 1) n-BuLi, -78oC S S O 2) O S O 96% yield 98% ee O O O O O Cl 99% yield 97% ee O 45% yield enantiopure S O F 97% yield 97% ee S O O 97% yield 96% ee 95% yield 95% ee O O O 90% yield 96% ee O O 87% yield 97% ee O O O 93% yield 92% ee 98% yield 92% ee JACS, 2010, 4552 98% yield 94% ee 95% yield 93% ee 87% yield 94% ee 97% yield 98% ee 75% yield >99% ee Sulfoxides as Chiral Auxilliaries “The reduction of beta-ketosulfoxides has been the most extensively investigated and used reaction involving the asymmetric induction of chiral sulfoxides.” Either stereoisomer can be obtained from the same beta-ketosulfoxide depending on the presence or absence of a lewis acid (ie: ZnCl2). Sulfoxides are cleaved under ‘mild conditions’. O S DIBAL O S Tetrahedron, 2006, 5559 Synth. Commun., 2000, 4467. OH O DIBAL ZnCl2 O S OH There are few examples of gamma-ketosulfoxides being reduced selectively O S R O i-Bu DIBAL O S R Al i-Bu THF O O R OH S R = Ph: 93%, de = 90% Me: 96%, de = 96% Et: 92%, de = 92% S Perkin Trans. 1, 2000, 3143 Tet., 2001, 8469 O O DIBAL S O OH 96% 94% de Unconjugated Addition Reactions Sulfoxides have the ability to stabilize a negative charge on an adjacent carbon Deprotonation of the alpha carbon of the sulfoxide requires a strong base (ie: LiNH2, LDA, n-BuLi, LiHMDS, etc.) High stereoselectivity usually requires steric hindrance in the vicinity of the alpha carbon and the use of an electrophile with a bulky group. If optically active sulfoxides give a poor diastereoselectivity the presence of another function such as an ester, sulfide or amide which can have a chelating effect in the transition state can improve the selectivity. O S 1) LDA R O S 2) R2'CO OH R' R' O S R' R' R R syn OH anti R = TMS, R' = Me, 88%, 96:4 syn/anti R = SiMePh2, R' = Me, 73%, >98:2 syn/anti R = CH2TMS, R' = Me, 93%, 73/27 syn/anti R = CH2TMS, R' = (CH2)5, 88%, 84/16 syn/anti JOC, 2000, 469 N R R' O S R'HN LDA H R THF O S R = R' = Ph, 87%, 68% de R = Ph, R' = 2MeO-C6H4, 82%, 62% de R = 4-MeO-C6H4, R' = Ph, 92%, 84% de R = t-Bu, R' = 2-MeO-C6H4, 92%, >99% de Cl O S OH 1) LDA 2) O S Cl 82% O KOtBu S O S H O 3:1 93% yield of two isomers Tet, 2006, 5559 O H O A combination of the chemistry of oxidation and alkylation can be useful for synthesis, such as that shown below which was used for a drug candidate program. N S N N Ti(Oi-Pr)4 D-DET O S N LDA N I O Cl O 71% yield 98-99% ee N O S NH >99% ee Chem. Rev., 2003, 3651 N Cl O N N O S Conjugated Addition (Michael Addition) R 1) LDA 2) O S R TMS H O O S O 3) Electrophile O R O O E TMS LDA Yield (%) de (%) MeI 21 >96 Me MeI 59 >96 Ph MeI 75 >96 Ph BnBr 74 >96 Ph i-PrCHO 90 >96 Ph PhCHO 98 >96 O O S Electrophile S S O O Tet, 2007, 5559 JOC, 2000, 1758 OL, 2001, 29 O O O 71% O 0% Conjugate Addition to Vinyl Sulfoxides Vinyl sulfoxides can act as Michael acceptors for a variety of nucleophiles (cuprates, enolates, malonates, amines, thiols, etc.) and due to the chirality can induce chirality at the beta-carbon, but at least creates diastereomers which can be separated with standard techniques. O O O R S R' Cl LDA THF O O O S R R' Cl R, R' = BnCH 2 , Me, H 86-91% yield 99% de O O P O O S O O P O O S O S O O Tet. Asymm., 2005, 665 Tet. Lett., 2002, 3061 O 91% 89:11 dr Sulfoxides as Chiral Auxillaries for D.A. “The sulfinyl group as, equally, become one of the most interesting chiral inductors in asymmetrics Diels-Alder reactions, due to: (a) its ability to differentiate between diastereotopics faces of neighboring double bonds, (b) the ease of chemical transformations in to different functional groups including its clean removal under mild conditions and (c) the existence of several efficient methods that allow the preparation of enantiomerically pure sulfoxides.” The substituents and lewis acid used to catalyze the reaction have a strong influence on which product is formed. O O S CN O CN S(O)p-Tol DCM PhI(OAc) 2 O O O O 37% Tet., 2006, 5559 S(O)p-Tol CN 28% OH O HO O O S 60% yield 97% ee O O O O O S CN O O CN O CN DCM PhI(OAc)2 SO O O 71% 92% ee Chem. Eur. J., 2000, 288 O O 21% 88% ee Chiral Reagents (NADH analog) A chiral NADH polymer supported reagent was prepared and shown to enantioselectively reduce the activated carbonyl shown below to an alcohol, and this reagent could be recycled using 1-propyl-1,4,dihydronicotinamide. O S O S O S N N O O O Heterocycles, 1998, 261 N Polymer O O S N Polymer OH O 2.5 Mg(ClO4)2 ACN/Benzene 12 hours RT O 100% yield >96% ee O S N Polymer Pummerer Reaction (can be used for cleavage of a sulfoxide) Sulfoxides with an alpha Hydrogen when reacted with an activating group (ie: Ac2O, TFAA, TMSOTf, etc.) rearrange to give alpha substituted sulfides. This reaction allows the conversion of a sulfoxide to a carbonyl, or can transfer the sulfoxide chirality to the alpha carbon creating a chiral sulfide. O R O S R' R O S O O O R' R O S O O O R R' O S R' H O O O O O R O S O R' R O S Nu R' R S R' R S R' Nu Nu = OH, O-alkyl, O-aryl, O2CR, F, Cl, Br, SR, NR2 Strategic Applications of Named Reactions in Organic Synthesis, 2005, L. Kurti and B. Czako O S Ph Ac 2 O NaOAc 125 oC OTBS HO H OTBS HO then H 2O 37% RO O S H O S Ph OH RO O H H TFAA/TFA (3 equiv) OTMS O Ph S N H H 80 oC N O O 2hr 63% yield O S Ph H o -25 C to -5 C 90 min N O O H o O O OTBS RO TMSOTf (3 equiv) DCM O O S Ph O Ph N O O TBAF H THF -5 oC 20 min H H O N Raney-Ni H H N O O O O Some good reviews if interested ◦ ◦ ◦ ◦ ◦ Chem. Rev., 2010, ASAP (synthesis of sulfoxides) Chem. Rev., 2003, 3651 (synthesis of sulfoxides) Chem. Rev., 2004, 4203 (SO bonding to Pt metals) Tetrahedron, 2006, 5779 (as chiral auxilliaries) Chem. Rev., 2007, 5133 (asymmetric catalysis)