Unit 6: Forensic Anatomy: Fingerprints Fingerprint evidence is one of the most positive investigative means of identifying people. Dactyloscopy The study of fingerprints Historically William Herschel—required Indians to put their fingerprints on contracts, and also as a means of identifying prisoners Henry Faulds—claimed that fingerprints did not change over time and that they could be classified for identification Alphonse Bertillon—proposed body measurements as a means of identification; termed anthropometry Francis Galton—developed a primary classification scheme based on loops, arches and whorls. Edward Richard Henry—in collaboration with Galton instituted a numerical classification system Juan Vucetich—developed a fingerprint classification based on Galton’s that is used in Spanish-speaking countries Chapter 4 Fundamental Principles of Fingerprints A fingerprint is an individual characteristic. (formed before birth) A fingerprint will remain unchanged during an individual’s lifetime.(different even on identical twins) Fingerprints have general characteristic ridge patterns that permit them to be systematically classified. Chapter 4 Principles of fingerprints 1. fingerprints are unique 2. Fingerprints do not change with age Fingerprints displace unique patterns Chapter 4 Al Copone : tried to hid his fingerprints by dissolving his finger tips in acid. Chapter 4 Ridge Characteristics Minutiae—characteristics of ridge patterns Chapter 4 Ridge ending Short ridge Dot or fragment Bifurcation Double bifurcation Trifurcation Bridge Island Enclosure Spur Basic structures of fingerprints Examples of ridge characteristics used in point-by-point comparisons: Bifurcation: The point at which one ridge forks out into two separate ridges Ridge ending: The point at which a ridge ends Short ridge: A small, short ridge which looks similar to an island Enclosure: An area completely enclosed by ridges Fingerprint Minutiae Chapter 4 Structure of the skin Fingerprints Have General Ridge Patterns That Permit Them to be Systematically Classified: Loops, Whorls & Arches Left Loop Loop - one or more ridges enters one side, curves and exits same side Radial Loop - opens towards the thumb Ulnar loop - opens towards the little finger Right Loop Loop A loop must have one or more ridges entering and exiting from the same side. Loops must have one delta. Types Radial—opens toward the thumb Ulnar—opens toward the “pinky” (little finger) Which type of loop is this, if it is on the right hand? Left hand? Chapter 4 Whorls Whorl - forms a revolution around the center Plain Whorl - one or more ridges form a complete revolution around the center; have two or more deltas Central Pocket Loop - variation of the plain whorl; some ridges tend to form a loop pattern which recurves and surrounds a whorl in the center Double Loop (twinned loop) - another type of whorl; two separate loop formations surround each other Whorl A plain or central pocket whorl has at least one ridge that makes a complete circuit. A double loop is made of two loops. An accidental is a pattern not covered by other categories. Whorls have at least two deltas and a core. Types Chapter 4 Plain Central Pocket Double Loop Accidental Arch Arch - one or more ridges enters one side, rise to a wave, and exits the opposite side Plain Arch - smooth curved wave in the center; exits smoothly on the opposite side Tented Arch - variation of plain arch in which the ridges at the center are thrust upward in a more abrupt manner Arch Arches cont. All fingerprints can be classified into three general groups: loops (6065%), whorls (30-35%) and arches (5%). These form the basis for all tenfinger classification systems currently in use. Tented Arch Arch An arch has friction ridges that enter on one side of the finger and cross to the other side while rising upward in the middle. They do NOT have type lines, deltas, or cores. Types Plain Tented Chapter 4 Primary Classification The Henry—FBI Classification Each finger is given a point value based on whorl patterns right Chapter 4 left Primary Classification Assign the number of points for each finger that has a whorl and substitute into the equation: right index right ring left thumb left left middle little + 1 right thumb right middle right little left index left ring = +1 That number is your primary classification number Chapter 4 Comparison There are no legal requirements in the United States on the number of points. Generally, criminal courts will accept 8 to 12 points of similarity. Chapter 4 Methods of detecting fingerprints: The method used depends on the type of print and the type of surface the print is found on 1. Light enhanced: used oblique lighting or a laser to see hidden prints 2. Powder: black is still the most common 3. Iodine fuming: oldest development used on porous material ex paper Chapter 4 4. Ninhydrin: used on porous surfaces, can be used for developing prints as old as 15yrs. Development is sprayed on and develops overnight 5. Physical developers: ex silver nitrate, used on surfaces that had previously been wet 6. Superglue fuming: cyanoacrulate fumes, preserves the print Chapter 4 Laser Light Without Chemical Treatment Latent Prints Latent fingerprints are those that are not visible to the naked eye. These prints consist of the natural secretions of human skin and require development for them to become visible. Most secretions come from three glands: Eccrine—largely water with both inorganic (ammonia, chlorides, metal ions, phosphates) and organic compounds (amino acids, lactic acids, urea, sugars). Most important for fingerprints. Apocrine—secrete pheromones and other organic materials. Sebaceous—secrete fatty or greasy substances. Chapter 4 Developing Latent Prints Developing a print requires substances that interact with secretions that cause the print to stand out against its background. It may be necessary to attempt more than one technique, done in a particular order so as not to destroy the print. Powders—adhere to both water and fatty deposits. Choose a color to contrast the background. Iodine—fumes react with oils and fats to produce a temporary yellow brown reaction. Chapter 4 Developing Latent Prints Ninhydrin—reacts with amino acids to produce a purple color. Silver nitrate—reacts with chloride to form silver chloride, a material which turns gray when exposed to light. Cyanoacrylate—“super glue” fumes react with water and other fingerprint constituents to form a hard, whitish deposit. In modern labs and criminal investigations, lasers and alternative light sources are used to view latent fingerprints. These were first used by the FBI in 1978. Since lasers can damage the retina of the eye, special precautions must be taken. Chapter 4 First thing to do after visualizing a fingerprint First photograph the print, then you can lift it Chapter 4 Iodine Fingerprint Chapter 4 Ninhydrin Fingerprint Chapter 4 The Super Glue Method of developing latent fingerprints Cyanoacrylate Fingerprints Other Prints Ears—shape, length and width Voice—electronic pulses measured on a spectrograph Foot—size of foot and toes; friction ridges on the foot Shoes—can be compared and identified by type of shoe, brand, size, year of purchase, and wear pattern. Chapter 4 Other Prints Footprints are taken at birth as a means of identification of infants. Chapter 4 Other Prints Lips—display several common patterns Chapter 4 Short vertical lines Short horizontal lines Crosshatching Branching grooves A More Recent Crime A bank robber was startled by an alarm just as the teller handed her the money. She grabbed it and in her haste to get away, ran smack dab into a glass door. Nevertheless, she recovered and got away. Subsequent examination of the door revealed a red lipstick imprint of the perpetrator’s mouth. Later police picked up a suspect, but needed evidence to link her to the robbery. http://www.hbo.com/autopsy/episode/episode_6_the_telltale_imprint.html Lip Prints Lip prints are different and can be used to identify suspects. There are several general patterns: Lip Prints What happened? Of several suspects, one was identified by matching his lip print to that on the bank door. The lipstick used by the suspect could also have been compared to the residue on the door. How? Chromatography of Lipsticks Thin layer chromatograph (TLC) can be used to separate the components of a lipstick. The chromatograms can then be compared for a match. Other Prints Teeth—bite marks are unique and can be used to identify suspects. These imprints were placed in gum and could be matched to crime scene evidence. Chapter 4 Visible prints Print left behind by either leaving the ridge impression or removing dust in a pattern defined by your print A fingerprint embedded in soft material is called a plastic print Chapter 4 Other Prints The blood vessel patterns in the eye may be unique to individuals. They are used today for various security purposes. Chapter 4 : Human Remains “There is a brief but very informative biography of an individual contained within the skeleton, if you know how to read it…” —Clyde Snow, Forensic Anthropologist Forensic anthropologists apply standard scientific techniques developed in physical anthropology to identify human remains, and to assist in the detection of crime. Forensic anthropologists frequently work in conjunction with forensic pathologists, odontologists, and homicide investigators to identify a decedent, the manner of death, and/or the postmortem interval. In addition to assisting in locating and recovering suspicious remains, forensic anthropologists work to suggest the age, sex, ancestry, stature, and unique features of a decedent from the skeleton. forensic anthropologists The identification of skeletal, badly decomposed, or otherwise unidentified human remains is important for both legal and humanitarian reasons. Forensic anthropologists frequently work in conjunction with forensic pathologists, odontologists, and homicide investigators to identify a decedent, the manner of death, and/or the postmortem interval. , forensic anthropologists work to suggest the age, sex, ancestry, stature, and unique features of a decedent from the skeleton. The Pathologist Determines the time of death. This can be done most accurately if the body is found within the first 24 hours of death Uses certain indicators such as algor, livor and rigor mortis. Rigor Mortis The rigidity of skeletal muscles after death. Temperature of body Stiffness of body Approximate Time Since Death •Warm •Not stiff •Not dead more than 3 hrs •Warm •Stiff •Dead between 3 and 8 hrs •Cold •Stiff •Dead 8 to 30 hours •Cold •Not stiff •Dead more than 30 hours Livor Mortis Livor mortis is the settling of blood, resulting in a reddish or purplish color pattern. Lividity can indicate the position of the body after death. When lividity becomes fixed, then the distribution of the pattern will not change even if the body’s position is altered. Lividity usually becomes fixed between 10 and 15 hours after death. Algor Mortis Algor mortis is the cooling rate of the body after death. At a crime scene, the body temperature is obtained through: Rectal temperature Liver temperature Glaister equation: 98.4°F - internal temperature/1.5 = hours elapsed since death Generally the body cools 1 to 12 degrees Fahrenheit until it reaches the surrounding temperature Effects that Influence Algor Mortis Temperature of the surrounding environment Type of clothing on the body Wetness of the clothing Air movement Layers of clothing Size of the individual Forensic Anthropology The identification of skeletal, badly decomposed, or otherwise unidentified human remains is important for both legal and humanitarian reasons. Forensic Anthropology A forensic anthropologist may provide basic identification information of skeletonized or badly decomposed remains. From a whole bone or part of a bone, the scientist may be able to determine: An age range Sex Race Approximate height Cause of death, disease, or anomaly Osteology Study of bones 206 bones in an adult human Function of bones: Provides structure and rigidity Protects soft tissue and organs Serves as an attachment for muscles Produces blood cells Serves as a storage area for minerals Can detoxify the body by removing heavy metals and other foreign elements from the blood AGE: Osteologist have developed methods to determine an individual’s age at the time of death by the skeletal remains. Age Determination Most accurate estimations from: Teeth Epiphyses or growth plates Pubic symphysis Cranial sutures: the three major cranial sutures appear as distinct lines in youth and gradually close from the inside out. Investigators always use an age range because of the variation in people and how they age.The investigator does not want to eliminate any possibilities for identification. Age Determination Using Cranial Sutures Sagittal suture Sagittal suture completely closed Males—26 or older Female—29 or older Sagittal suture is complete open Male—less than 32 Female—less than 35 Complete closure of all three major sutures Male—over 35 Female—over 50 Lambodial Coronal Age Determination Using Basilar Suture Basilar Suture Technically known as the synchondrosis sphenooccipitalis, closes in females as young as 14 and in males as young as 16. If the suture is open, the individual is generally considered 18 or younger. Age Determination Using Epiphysis Stage of Union of Medial Clavicle Male Female 21 or younger 20 or younger Non-union with separate epiphysis 16-21 17-20 Partial union 17-30 17-33 21 or older 20 or older Non-union without separate epiphysis Complete union Age Determination Using Epiphysis Stage of Union of the Iliac Crest Male Female 16 or younger 11 or younger Non-union with separate epiphysis 13-19 14-15 Partial union 14-23 14-23 17 or older 18 or older Non-union without separate epiphysis Complete union Cranial development in children ages 0-5 years of age The calvarium is much larger in relation to the face and mandible at this stage in life The teeth are very important indicators of age in children this young because developmental patterns are well known. Dental development in children ages 0-5 years of age The stage of dental development seen here is approximately in the fifth year of life. The deciduous teeth are becoming more spaced, the first and second deciduous molars are fully erupted, and you can see the sixth COMPARISON OF A 5 YEAR AND A NEONATAL SKULL AGE DIFFERENCES Examples of skeletal development in young adults, ages 18-23. Examples of skeletal development in older adults, ages 60-70+ Examples of skeletal development in older adults, ages 60-70+ COLLAPESED VERTEBRA BODY COMPARISON OF A 5 YEAR OLD SKULL AND THAT OF A 60+ YEAR OLD SEX: Another determination that must be made is the sex of the individual. Often, skeletons are found after there has been too much deterioration to determine the sex of the individual. DETERMINING SEX BASED ON SKULL CHARACTERISTICS DETERMINING SEX FROM THE FEMUR: Gender Differences in Bones The pelvis of the female is wider. Males have a narrow subpubic angle (A) and a narrow pubic body (B). Male Female Sub Pubic Angle Gender Differences The ribcage and shoulders of males are generally wider and larger than that of females. In addition, about one person in twenty has an extra rib. This is more common in males than in females. Gender Differences In males the index finger is sometimes shorter than the third finger. In females, the first finger is sometimes longer than the third finger. This is not often used as an indicator of gender as there are many exceptions. Is this a male or female hand according to the above rule? RACE: Determining the race of a skeleton can be very difficult. It is based on the common characteristics of individual races rather than on hard fast rules. Because race can be a very important factor to identify the individual it is usually considered. Generally, the most important bone for race determination is the skull. The following table gives you an idea of the type of criteria used by scientist. CHARACTERISTICS FOR DETERMINING RACE Characteristic Cranial Form Mongoloid American Indian Caucasoid Polynesian Negroid broad medium-broad medium highly variable long high,globular medium-low sloping front high,roundeq medium highly variable Nose Form medium medium Nasal Bone Size small med/ large large medium med/small Incisor Form shoveled shoveled blade blade blade Orbital Form round Rhomboid rhomboid rhomboid round Mandible robust robust medium robust rocker form gracile oblique angle moderate moderate prominent moderate reduced Soggital Outline Chin Projection narrow medium broad Race Characteristics Caucasoids—have a long, narrow nasal aperture, a triangular palate, oval orbits, narrow zygomatic arches and narrow mandibles. Negroids—have a wide nasal aperture, a rectangular palate, square orbits, and more pronounced zygomatic arches. The long bones are longer, have less curvature and greater density. Mongoloids—have a more rounded nasal aperture, a parabolic palate, rounded orbits, wide zygomatic arches and more pointed mandibles. What differences do you notice between these three skulls? Can you determine race? RACE DETERMINATION NEGROID: AMERICAN INDIAN: CAUCASIAN SKULL Retention of the metopic suture is generally a caucasoid trait STATURE: Stature refers to a person’s height. By measuring the length, density and width of bones, osteologist can make a fairly good estimate of an individual’s stature. Often estimations are made with just a single bone. However, the fewer the bones, the less exact is the guess. Estimation of Height The height of a person can be calculated by using the length of certain long bones, including the femur, tibia, humerus, and radius. Below are the equations to determine average measurements for both male and female. (All measurements are in centimeters) Male Female femur x 2.23 + 69.08 tibia x 2.39 + 81.68 humerus x 2.97 + 73.57 radius x 3.65 + 80.40 femur x 2.21 +61.41 tibia x 2.53 + 72.57 humerus x 3.14 + 64.97 radius x 3.87 + 73.50 Odontology The identity of an individual can be determined by comparing a person’s teeth to their dental records. Unusual features including the number and types of teeth and fillings, the spacing of the teeth, and/or special dental work (bridges, false teeth, root canals) help to make a positive identification. Odontology and Identification Teeth are often used for body identification because: They are the hardest substances in the body They are unique to the individual X-rays are a good record of teeth DISEASES AND ABMORMALITY ANALYSIS Further work may be needed to identify the skeletal remains. Thus osteologist look for more unique qualities about the bones. This would include bone disease, or damage PHOTO 1. SHOWS ARTHRITIS PHOTO 2 SHOWS PERIDONTAL DISEASE PHOTO 3 SHOWS DENTURES PHOTO 4 SHOWS HEALED FRACTURE SURGICAL RECONSTRUCTION The surgical reconstruction of the face is very distinctive and provided a solid identification GUNSHOT WOUNDS Carnivores: This is a full view of the damaged femur. Notice how the ends seem to be the preferred part of the bone Teeth can leave many different types of markings on bones. Here are two examples of the marks that a canine tooth can leave. Canines create holes which go through to the marrow (a), or impressions like this one (b). Habitual, strenuous activity Ball and socket joints present a special risk because they allow greater mobility thereby increasing the risk of injury to the soft tissues and bone. The head of the humerus and glenoid cavity shown in this photograph were in complete contact for many years prior to this individual's death. The surfaces are smooth and shiny, indicating that the joint capsule and cartilage had worn away, allowing bone on bone contact in the cavity. Skeletal information Know difference between axial and appendicular skeleton Know that the hyoid bone is crushed during strangulation Know about fontanels Know the types of vertebrae ( cervical-7, thoracic -12, lumbar-5, sacrum, coccyx) Know the different types of fractures of bones Skeletal information Difference between male and female pelvis: 1 female heavier and rougher bones Pubic arch greater than 90 female less 90 male Male pelvis narrow and deep Cavity of male pelvis smaller than female Facial Restoration After determining the sex, age, and race of an individual, facial features can be built upon a skull to assist in identification. Erasers are used to make tissue depths at various points on the skull. Clay is used to build around these markers and facial features are molded. The Body Farm The nickname of a two and a half acre research facility in Tennessee developed in 1980 by Bill Bass where bodies are placed in various conditions and allowed to decompose. Its main purpose is to observe and understand the processes and timetable of postmortem decay. Over the years it has helped to improve the ability to determine "time since death" in murder cases. Hic locus est ubi mortui viveuntes docent. This is the place where the dead teach the living. Facial Reconstruction When skeletal remains are found, and the victim remains unidentified after traditional means of identification fail, investigators may call upon the forensic artist to utilize the three-dimensional facial reconstruction technique Subject, age 4 yrs. Mother, age 4 yrs Subject, age 11 yrs. Mother, age 11 yrs Subject, age12 yrs, sisters ages 14 and 22 yrs Mother, age 14 yrs Parents ages 22 yrs Subject aged to 22 yrs Life Photo age 22 yrs Death Photo Computer Sketch Sketch from Body Life Photo Three-dimensional Facial Reconstruction Three-dimensional facial reconstruction technique The three-dimensional process is initiated by placing the skull on a workable stand, where the skull can easily be tilted and turned in all directions By utilizing proper tissue depth data can be used to determine race, gender, and age Artificial eyes are placed in the skull’s eye sockets, centered and at the proper depth three-dimensional facial reconstruction technique Information such as geographic location of where the deceased lived, his or her lifestyle, and the various information provided to the artist by the Forensic Anthropologist and other professionals, is heavily relied upon when completing the reconstruction. Hair is accomplished by means of a wig, or by applying clay to represent hair. Various items (props), such as glasses, clothing, hats, etc. may be applied to better accentuate the features of the individual three-dimensional facial reconstruction technique The tissue markers are glued directly onto the skull. Clay will be systematically applied directly on the skull, following the skull's contours; paying strict attention to the applied tissue markers Various measurements are made, and logged, to determine nose thickness/length, mouth thickness/width, and eye placement three-dimensional facial reconstruction technique Upon completion, the sculpture is photographed. All procedures are documented and working notes collected. When executed properly, this technique is proven to have a high success rate. Unidentified White Male The victim was discovered on February 15, 2002 in Hillsborough County, Florida. Estimated Date of Death is 5 or 6 months prior to the discovery of the body. Skeletal remains used for reconstruction purposes Unidentified White Male Estimated age: 55 - 65 years old Approximate Height and Weight: 5'8"; weight unknown Distinguishing Characteristics: Brown hair. Evidence of old (healed) facial trauma near the right eye. Dentals: All teeth missing well prior to death. Clothing: Tattered white plastic pants with elastic waistband, dark pin-striped men's suit jacket, and a "Faded Glory" brand, entirely tattered t-shirt. Unidentified White Female The victim was discovered on December 6, 1995 in Jacksonville, Onslow County, North Carolina. State of remains: Skeletal. Estimated Date of Death: Less than 2 years prior to discovery. The department has not ruled the death a homicide because there was little evidence. Unidentified White Female Vital Statistics Estimated age: 32 - 38 years old Approximate Height and Weight: 5'6" Distinguishing Characteristics: Hair may have been brown. Dentals: Expensive and extensive dental work. Tooth 19 had a root canal and had been cut for a crown, the crown was missing. She had protruding teeth. Clothing: Around her remains, investigators found two New York Transit Authority tokens, two keys with a partially burned key tag, a pair of broken glasses and several coins. The clothing found was a pair of white Nike tennis shoes, size 9; black Lee jeans and a red sweatshirt. Near the body was a thin 18 k gold necklace, two gold bangle bracelets and two gold hoop earrings. Instructions for Facial Reconstruction Lab After you have completed your facial reconstruction, your group will need to turn in a report with photograph of face if possible with the following information: Identify your missing person Include case history Include vital statistics See next page for example Unidentified Black Female The victim was discovered on December 16, 1999 in Tampa, Hillsborough County, Florida. Estimated Date of Death: Several years + Skeletal remains Remains consist of skull/jawbone only Vital Statistics Estimated age: 20 - 40 years old Other: Voodoo materials located. Case History On December 16, 1999 the skeletal remains of a black female was located in a public storage facility in Tampa. Remains consist of skull/jawbone only. According to The Department of Anthropology at the University of South Florida, "the mandibular molar displays some enamel crown wear suggesting a diet not typical of modern Americans, perhaps with more grit than is customarily found today in this country. " Read Forensics true crime scene investigation pg 71-76 Jesus